red-dead-singleplayer

[chilly bramble]

Just don’t know whether the spawn rate has changed or not

[cold parcel]

Didn't even know there's black Arabians around there.

[primal knoll]

nevermind

i placebo'd myself

the speed difference is pretty much negligible wtf

only noticeable difference is the handling

thats really disappointing

[west crane]

Every animal shows up as a paw

[cyan night]

Well I grinned and bore it. Done getting raped by grizzlies though, at least on purpose

[broken dragon]

guys

what is ur favorite outfit?

[glad brook]

The gunslinger.

[loud forum]

I fucking hate Bronte and his mafia men

like I just saved a person getting robbed and they started blasting me??

how I wish there was a mod to remove them

[glad brook]

That greasy son of a b**.

[loud forum]

I blow up the head of the person robbing the dude and what do I get as a thank you? A WANTED LEVEL

[lament dock]

why is fishing on the pc sucha hassle

[hidden moss]

Ik.

[spark bone]

Who wants to play amoogus

[hidden moss]

Molly is the worst character in rdr2

[tacit plover]

I can’t catch this legendary smallmouth for the life of me

[cyan night]

I just tried and got it first try. About 1pm sunny with special lake lure. Standing from southeast corner (but to the west of the little part of water at the most southeast corner that points south - hope that makes sense).

[spark bone]

Who wants to play Amoogus

[tacit plover]

I used special lake lure and I didn’t get it. It’s supposedly more active when raining, but I kept getting muskies. Mind showing a screenshot of your location on the map in #red-dead-media?

[spark bone]

Who wants to play amoogus

[spark bone]

Wait what fish

[tacit plover]

@cyan night I got it. Thanks

[opaque plume]

New to the game (I’m late ik), I just finished chapter 1 and I’m playing chapter 2. All I’m doing are these short little missions and they seem to go nowhere. After I finish them, does the game start to pick up or?

[candid pasture]

it gets better

[opaque plume]

Am I doing the right thing by doing these small missions?

[hidden moss]

Bruh i was reading the journal in Saint Dennis and a guy ran me over and he reported me for assault when he ran me over I didn't do anything to him 💀

[uncut berry]

She gives me gold digger vibes, despite not being so

[hidden moss]

Cops let me go tho thankfully had legendary fox on my horse

[opaque plume]

Are all chapters like chapter 2 where all you do is these small missions?

[tacit plover]

No

Survivalist 10 seems like Horseman 10, except even worse

[opaque plume]

Sorry what does that mean?

[opaque plume]

Oh Nevermind these missions pretty fun ngl

One last question

[tacit plover]

Since you’re just starting, it’s not something you should concern yourself with

[opaque plume]

I saw some stuff about an epilogue, should I have played that before chapter 1 (I don’t remember being able to play it).

Ok

[tacit plover]

The epilogue is after the main story

[untold sonnet]

Alright, for the past two days I have been having an issue with the mission where you go for a ride with Rains Fall. I am unable to complete it, because for no reason whatsoever, it just crashes during it. Different spot each time. Anyone else have this issue?

[opaque plume]

Sorry got the definition of it messed up

Oh and is the thing about black water or whatever explained more? And when do the pinkertons show up in chapter 2? thank you all a lot btw.

[untold sonnet]

Trust us, keep playing and shit really starts to pick up. Blackwater gets explained a bit more too

[opaque plume]

Bettt

[untold sonnet]

My best advice would be to look up as little as possible about the game. There are some HUGE spoilers you really don't want to know

[opaque plume]

Ok cool

[opaque plume]

I saw one but I think it’s fake could you confirm?

[tacit plover]

Uh oh

[untold sonnet]

What is it?

[opaque plume]

Something like jack killed Micah but that wouldn’t make sense so I assumed it wasn’t real

[tacit plover]

It’s fake

[opaque plume]

Ok thank you

[untold sonnet]

Oh yeah, there's this whole cutscene where Jack, the 4 year old, sneaks up and strangles Micah with a wire.

Of course it's fake, lol

[tacit plover]

[opaque plume]

Ok thank you guys

[opaque plume]

Oh sorry I mean john I forget the names

But there in the same gang so it has to be cap

[untold sonnet]

Ah, yeah. Be careful with what you see out there. Lots of people use mods and make fake scenarios or fan edits

[opaque plume]

Ok thanks a lot I can’t wait to finish it

[hidden moss]

cool the law will take you no mater what you've done if drunk

[fluid cypress]

Also remember not to skip the stranger missions (the white missions on the map) sometimes they can be chapter specific and if you move on with the story and not play some of them you won’t get a chance again. Imo some of them add a lot of depth to the protagonist

[fringe creek]

Also, take time between missions to roam about the map

You'll see lots of cool shit

[muted sierra]

I am 100% convinced parts of RDR2 were inspired by Lone Survivor

I mean they even low key use one of the soundtracks from the movie when you're in the mountains

[primal knoll]

man what th efuck is this shit

got my first white arabian horse, the fucker gets scared at every little thing and almost bucks me off

the speed difference is largely negligible

the only thing thats noticeable is the handling

i got scammed by all you folks who are posting in here about how its the goat horse, meanwhile i just miss my chapter 1 morgan

like i legit notice zero speed difference

[dull geyser]

Lmao

[civic nest]

Lol

[dull geyser]

I just choose a horse that looks cool for my arthur

[civic nest]

Whoever told you that hasn't been playing for long

[dull geyser]

Fr

[primal knoll]

dude everyone circlejerks about white arabian

"omg its the best horse you have to get it"

when i go to google and type "site:reddit.com rdr2 best horse" every single comment goes "white arabian hurr durr"

also as a side note, i finally completed legend of the east satchel 😄

im on chapter 2

its crazy how much shit i can carry now like wow

[dull geyser]

That's bs

Just pick a horse that you like

[tacit plover]

the day i get all of those pelts for satchel upgrades, in chapter 2, no less, is the day i die

[dull geyser]

Yea

[primal knoll]

ive been taking my t ime

the hardest one was by far the perfect cougar pelt

but i kind of cheated

i found a cougar, saved my progress, it was a 2 star

so then i reloaded until it was a 3 star

[tacit plover]

makes sense, since there aren't any in missions

[primal knoll]

took me like 45 mins to find the cougar in the first place

[dull geyser]

The moment you finished all the side activities it feels boring and you don't wanna continue the main story

[dull geyser]

I got attacked by a cougar 3 times when i was hunting a boar

[primal knoll]

i disagree heavily

well wdym by side activities

[dull geyser]

Like side quests

[primal knoll]

because theres so many side missions i havent found yet

like i hear people talk about this swamp bitch arthur pipes down

i havent met her yet

[dull geyser]

Lmao

[primal knoll]

also havent met the wolf photographer

but trying to find em via exploration instead of just looking em up

its a very fun way of playing

especially since im on my 2nd playthrough, and in my first all i did was bumrush the main storyline

i just wanna play as arthur as long as possible

dont think ill go past chapter 4 at this point 😄

[dull geyser]

Yea

That's the part I don't wanna see again

You can also get a nice horse in chapter 3 if you rob horses with john and javier

[primal knoll]

oh?

[dull geyser]

You can get the dark bay turkoman there if you bonded with it before you sell it to the horse fence

[hidden moss]

So I brought a saint denis lawman to the ranch and he acted like he was the one still with power lol

Acted like I didn't bring him up across the map tied up

[dull geyser]

Lmao

[primal knoll]

thats one of the things i dont like about the game

they coulda done so much more with hogtied people

one thing i was surprised about, however, is if you hogtie that aberdeen pig farm sister brother-fucking bitch

and u bring her to their mass grave that they initially dropped you in

and drop her there

theres some extra dialogue

which i thought was cool

but for the most part they really just dont care

[hidden moss]

He also put a bounty on me and he's in a dif state :|

Also sleeping lots makes john fat trying to grow his hair lol

[hidden moss]

He was saying some dialog

How he was surprised i Made it this far and saying I won't get away for doing this to a law man

[night sluice]

How do i get get better at fist fights 😔 am i just not timing things right or something

[tacit plover]

there's a better way to grow hair

[primal knoll]

press r when they punch

then they are stunned then you can hit f

if you already weakened em up, hit e to grapple

then you can choke or just keep beating em (careful cuz choking will make you wanted usually)

but yeah just hold r right before he punches

then he gets stunned and spam f

[fluid cypress]

Don’t just use the block simply

Instead use movement controls along with the block button that way you will dodge it left/right/backwards instead and then you can follow up with a counter and catch your opponent off balance

normal blocking you get a few hits if you go for more you can get screwed over but dodging you can pound the shit out of ppl

only thing is if you fail you’re getting the full damage of a punch

also if you wanna get out of a fight you can’t handle just pull up a gun usually they pussy out

[night sluice]

Thanks guys

[hidden moss]

Was drinking hair tunics

[night sluice]

Bit embarrassed i had to join the disc yo ask about getting better at fist fights lol but at least i wont get pounded now

[sly sandal]

or if you wanna knock em out fast you can pull out your gun and hit them across the face with it twice

i think it's the same button as punch

[fluid cypress]

But if you pull up a gun they might also pull up a gun or just run away

Not as satisfying as beating them to death imo

If it’s an asshole always make sure to kick them even after they’re downed so they die

[tacit plover]

that + killing the van horn fence owner then waiting until morning repeatedly

[glad brook]

And you'll most likely get the law on you.

[fluid cypress]

Nah they don’t get the law unless you fire first or do anything violent first

like if you verbally harass someone and they get physical you won’t be punished

Even if you kill them

[hidden moss]

you'll get the law on you for a fistfight too

it doesn't really matter which

you have to be weary and even just not give a shit at times

and sometimes yes you'll get away with assault

otherwise it's an assault level 4 which is 15$

yes I'm essentially ignoring the witness check

@fluid cypress Where does the motion part come into play? Can you knock someone down with melee with it?

I usually just do square > circle and get the counter animation

is there more than one?

[hidden moss]

This was early in the game's life cycle; check the dates, they're usually year one. Never use Reddit in particular, but what you do is your choice I guess.

Otherwise chief like, it is the best free horse and that is stat wise. If you find it negligible, I think you're underestimating the amount of distance you may have to run from cops. It will get scary. A good horse is a good friend and will save your ass. But sorry for the tl;dr. I am attached to Foxtrotters generally outside of main game. But what I'm saying about stats is that the game almost never lets enemies rubber bands or clips through terrain in conflict in free roam. You can do a lot with a good horse to evade the law and ride hard and loose.

[keen ledge]

I can't stop using the free horse you get if you have gold/ultimate edition of the game. I've used it since every playthrough ever since 2018 when I played on PS4.

[fluid cypress]

Same lmao best horse imo love how it looks plus u can get max speed and almost max acc with stirrups

Best this is it’s big unlike the puny Arabian and does not spook

[fluid cypress]

No you won’t, not as long you’re not the one who started the violence

For eg: you verbally harass someone till they get violent and start hitting you, you can go ahead and knock them out, stab them or blow their head and no one will report it

I’m not too sure abt shooting

But stabbing I’ve done a lot

I like to pick fights with the workers on the under construction port in black water, the part which has that nice ramp going into the water

Then I just fight them there

[fluid cypress]

Wdym I didnt understand

[fluid cypress]

Yeah that you can just do in any direction and the counter them, sometimes doesn’t work if you’re doing it in the direction of the attack

[hidden moss]

i see @fluid cypress

[dull geyser]

I just stare at them till they started to throw hands

But I guess antagonizing is a faster way to start a fight

[sly sandal]

Missouri Fox Trotter is the best imo

it's also a beautiful horse

doesn't look stupidly small and boring like the arabian

has comparable stats to it

[keen ledge]

They'll arrest you for shooting. Yesterday 3 O'Driscolls were harassing me. Told them to fuck off and they threw a punch. Knocked out 2 and the third started shooting me so I shot back. The law didn't react until I shot him.Valentine seems to be a very biased town

[dull geyser]

Sheesh

[fluid cypress]

Yes, I’ve noticed fighting o Driscolls will almost always get the law on you

With regular npcs it doesn’t

[lament dock]

cattleman or Double action

[dull geyser]

Cattleman

[young forum]

I can't buy Blackwater Ledger 64

It's not in my Newspapers

I am already in the Epilogue

[young forum]

I finally got to getting past my gamer's block on the Epilogue and now at John proposing to Abigail

[little wraith]

Hey guys I just started trying to hunt some legendary animals but not exactly sure how to do it. I’m in the correct area for one of them and I’ve been riding around the general area for about 20 minutes and can’t find a single clue lol

[young forum]

Jesus Christ John

Goddamn it
Don't go after Micah

[hidden moss]

Use eagle eye for you to find yellow particles then follow the trail.

[hidden moss]

There sadly are some special conditions for each animal

Some animals appear at night some at morning etc, some need clear weather some need fog and etc so it's a bit complicated.

dang, i should be hunting more legendary animals then. Thanks for the tip, btw.

Or that isn't true for singleplayer and is only for online?

Np if it's true!!

[little wraith]

This happens in single player or just in online?

[hidden moss]

I don't rly play single player but hopefully it's for both maybe Someone else can answer that

In my experience, I hunted legendary panther, i only followed the dung, trail and rotten carcass. There's no weather cycle or time schedule.

(Just 1 legendary animal btw which is the Panther.)

[young forum]

Now I can finally say I completed RDR2
God I hate this game
I won't be able to enjoy anymore games like this one so everything will be just a little bit disappointing unless it's a FromSoft gamee

[tacit plover]

Sounds like a curse

[glossy wolf]

Hey folks. I just have one question. How do I get my horse to graze at camp? For some reason this has been such a small and irritating problem for me.

[tacit plover]

Graze?

[glossy wolf]

Yeah, eat grass

[tacit plover]

"Hitch at hitching post, then lead, turn away from hitching post towards where other horses are grazing (don’t walk, just turn), release. Horse should wander away and graze."

[frigid cloud]

just online

[glossy wolf]

But how can you turn without moving?

[hidden moss]

Okay my bad then

how to always get a bleed out?

[cyan night]

Is there any purpose of buying newspapers? Does it trigger anything? Or is it just background info that some might find interesting? I bought one and "read it" kind of but didn't notice anything important.

[civic nest]

They may have hidden tips and cheats

[cyan night]

But they won't trigger secret side missions or something that would otherwise be locked, right?

[civic nest]

The cheats are not available unless you've bought the newspaper they're in

[drifting mountain]

I keep getting a texture bug on very specific parts in the game. -- When I play dominoes in camp and we go to the next round it bugs out and now as well after getting the cutscene returning to camp after you ask for money for the guy Strauss lend money to.

It's some low res random spot. @RDR media.

Actually, I don't think it's a texture bug. It seems that my screen is teleporting elsewhere on a specific part of the map.

[hidden moss]

how do i always get a bleed out

[hidden moss]

Shoot em

Its just luck

[iron nebula]

Try to shoot them in the neck

[hidden moss]

Like right in the neck

[marsh valley]

So I helped Appleseed Timber fend off some wolves

Then I robbed their payroll stagecoach

And sold the coach

Got a cool $175 all said and done. Not bad for an evening’s work

iirc Micah badmouths the Discouraged Men later but for me there’s nobody better usually. Although Hector’s jobs tend to be better than Alden’s.

[safe junco]

Okay so just started playing on PC ... really lost as to what I am doing. Anyone out there can help an old boy out?

[uncut berry]

lost as in?

[little wraith]

Like lost in the what to do in game? Or you can't get it to run properly? Or something else?

[digital smelt]

are guns meant to be gold in undead nightmare?

Just reloaded my save and my cattleman revolver and carbine repeater are gold now

[safe junco]

Lost in what need to do and how to doing it lol

[digital smelt]

how far into the game are you

are u still in the mountains?

[safe junco]

not far just did the hat mission

[digital smelt]

the hat mission?

[little wraith]

Yo can you get the elephant gun in single player or just online?

[marsh valley]

Prolly just online

Ahhh I’m back to Bandit 10

I love robbing trains

So much money from the safes and passengers and also a whole army of law to fight. Perfect.

I’m never going to be able to pay off my West Elizabeth bounty

And I might just leave my ambarino one

[red helm]

Having a $1500 bounty in every state is how real men play the game.

[hidden moss]

hat mission?

[hidden moss]

how to speed run a low honor play through

[muted sierra]

In RDR2 I got more low honor until Arthur gets sick

then I go high honor

[hidden moss]

it’s so hard to get high honor before he gets sick

[muted sierra]

no its not

[hidden moss]

playing the game normally

[muted sierra]

again, no its not

[hidden moss]

i felt like it was

[muted sierra]

I did it on my first playthrough

[hidden moss]

i only made it 3/4 up

[muted sierra]

That's still high honor

[red helm]

Once you figure out how the honor system works, it's pretty easy to move it around.

[hidden moss]

i got full honor first playthrough and it was pretty easy after TB but imo it was harder before TB

[muted sierra]

im pretty sure u cant do it before tb

[hidden moss]

that’s probably why lol

[red helm]

Yeah, you can only get to 70% before the Diagnosis.

[hidden moss]

ahh makes sense

[red helm]

Good or Bad, either way.

[hidden moss]

imagine going back for the money

what a horrible way to end the game

[muted sierra]

I wish someone would make a proper RDR2 game movie..ya know that's actually good :p

Ima try to eventually

[red helm]

I've done all 4 ways, I wanted to see all the endings.

[hidden moss]

high honor going with john feels super fulfilling

[red helm]

But I've only played through the game 2 times.

[muted sierra]

I play John the same way I play him in RDR1

same outfits, guns and horse too

[red helm]

Low honor/Help John is awful...

[hidden moss]

i’m a killing machine with john lmao

[muted sierra]

Fuck that XD

[hidden moss]

i kill random people for fun ngl

[muted sierra]

Also I was pretty happy to play as Marston again.

[hidden moss]

he’s huge

[muted sierra]

huge?

[hidden moss]

muscles

[muted sierra]

Oh. Not really lol

[hidden moss]

bruh

those lats

[red helm]

I was a bit disappointed being stuck as John, actually.. Not massively, but, eh... Played all that time on RDR1 as him, was hoping we'd be playing as someone else when the Epilogue finished, or something.

[muted sierra]

Well his player model in RDR2 is Arthur's body and head with John's face on it.

[muted sierra]

I was pretty happy to play as John. I prefer Arthur but Marston was still my boi

[red helm]

Again, certainly wasn't pissed or anything, but... eh...

[muted sierra]

I was so annoyed by all the disrespect given to John by these new RDR players who never played RDR1

[red helm]

I played RDR1 a bunch, several years ago, so..

[muted sierra]

I wasn't talking about you :>

[hidden moss]

never got past bill shooting me

[muted sierra]

bruuuuh

Also, in terms of writing, RDR2 gave John the 5 star treatment. Which I'm so happy about. I still prefer his 1911 self but RDR2 made John an even more incredible protagonist.

[red helm]

The first time I was playing and I was at the end of Chapter 6, I was getting the feeling It was going to switch us to playing as Sadie, in that mission where you rescue Abigail from the Pinkertons.

[muted sierra]

Nah

When Arthur actually died I was like "Well John...it's me and you again, buddy."

[red helm]

Like, Arthur put Abigail on Sadie's horse, and he said to go, for half a second, I thought Arthur was just going to ride off and the Camera was going to stay on the two ladies, and it was going to say something like "You are now controlling Sadie, ride to..."

[muted sierra]

Sadie's good character but not player protagonist worthy

Plus John is the main character of RDR2 anyway

[hidden moss]

yeah

she’s cool and all

but not john level

that’s like switching to Charles

he’s dope but nahhhh

[red helm]

Eh, certainly not perfect, but, would've been interesting. Let us play a Cowgirl in the end, and such. Plus she was on one of the game disc's.

[muted sierra]

Only Arthur was capable of overtaking John

[muted sierra]

Nothing compared to Marston

[hidden moss]

do you think there should be a rdr3

[muted sierra]

Yes but not about the Van Der Linde gang

[red helm]

We already got to play John a bunch on RDR1, so someone else would've been nice, and why not a lady?

[muted sierra]

Cuz Sadie's not worthy of that and John is the main character of RDR

[hidden moss]

idk I think there’s very little content for her

just bounty’s

[muted sierra]

yup

While Arthur is the central protagonist we play as, the main character of both RDR1 and RDR2 is John Marston.

So playing as Sadie would make no sense

[hidden moss]

yup

[muted sierra]

RDR3 has to have NOTHING to do with the Van Der Linde gang tho. The story is over.

[hidden moss]

rdr3 should be about jack

[muted sierra]

That's an even worse idea

[hidden moss]

there soooo much content dude

[muted sierra]

No there is not

[hidden moss]

just make it within a short 2-3 year span

[muted sierra]

Nope

[hidden moss]

why

[muted sierra]

The wild west is over by the time RDR1 is done. And Red Dead is a WILD west game.

[hidden moss]

it’s the last days of the west

[muted sierra]

No the west is over by the end of RDR1

[hidden moss]

nah dude jack looked a lot like he was living in the wild west in rdr1

[muted sierra]

Well he wasn't. That's just how the west looks in the U.S

WW1 had started and the days of the Wild West was over

[hidden moss]

true

[muted sierra]

Also narratively, there's nothing else to tell

[hidden moss]

i think they should just end the story here or come up with a completely new story

with nothing to do with arthur and john

[muted sierra]

Yes

I'd want a game set during the last days of the Civil War

[hidden moss]

new map, new stranger missions

[hidden moss]

a little to far back imo

[muted sierra]

Bruh, have you not seen The Good the Bad and the Ugly?

[hidden moss]

nah

[muted sierra]

or the Outlaw Josey Whales?

[hidden moss]

nah

[muted sierra]

You're a maniac

[hidden moss]

so old

those movies

[muted sierra]

And still so great

especially GBU

Without The Good the Bad and the Ugly, you don't have Red Dead Redemption

[hidden moss]

true

[muted sierra]

Good Bad Ugly is about 3 outlaws seeking a huge amount of treasure during the Civil War. It has both outlaw moments as well as them getting caught up in the war against their will.

And it's like 4 hours long

[hidden moss]

hell no

so long

[muted sierra]

The 4 hours is justified

It's incredibly well written

[hidden moss]

i might watch it

[muted sierra]

Do it

The closest movie to Red Dead Redemption 1 is Unforgiven

[hidden moss]

tbh i could care less about rdr3’a story and setting i just want fantastic gameplay

[muted sierra]

Bruh

RDR's story is incredibly important

This isn't GTAV

[hidden moss]

not to me lol

[muted sierra]

Then go play GTAV :p

[hidden moss]

i enjoy rdr2s gameplay tho

[muted sierra]

RD Redemption has always been narrative heavy

[hidden moss]

if you have a game with a fantastic story but trash gameplay it’s automatically trash

[muted sierra]

btw Joe, you do know what happens to John in RDR1 right?

[hidden moss]

but the other way around is fine

[hidden moss]

yeah

[muted sierra]

The Last of Us 2 wants to know your location

[hidden moss]

ok that is the exception to the rule LMAO

[muted sierra]

looool

[hidden moss]

that is fully a story game

idk

your right

[muted sierra]

Hehehe

TLAOU2's story was so shit compared to the artistic masterpiece of TLAOU1

Oh, Joe. May I show you a mod?

For RDR2?

[hidden moss]

sure

[glad brook]

Alotta people think that about rdr2 I'm not one of them ofcourse.

[muted sierra]

Those people are weird, lol

[glad brook]

I like slower paced games.

Guess people are just used to games like Call of Duty and the like.

[muted sierra]

I mean I love Modern Warfare 2019 but RDR2 is still legendary

[cyan night]

I just found a taxidermy ape/monkey. Seems kind of random.

[red helm]

In the game?

[cyan night]

Yeah. Just found it on youtube after I found it

[tidal nacelle]

I always assumed that it was heading to the taxidermist in strawberry.

[cyan night]

Probably

[red helm]

Where is it?

[tidal nacelle]

northeast of strawberry, where the bridges are. you can see it down the cliff side under one of bridges

[cyan night]

I tagged you in the media channel

[red helm]

Cool, yeah, maybe going to the Taxidermist, but.. random indeed.

[hidden moss]

Bounty hunters r annoying

like cmon why go looking for a guy with a 15$ bounty at 2 am

I'm just trying to hunt :|

[kindred jackal]

GTA V's narrative is very center-stage to the story mode actually

[young forum]

RDR2 has clunky gameplay though. Sometimes it feels like our character isn't even following the inputs.
-Presses R1 to go to Cover
-Proceeds to slow walk to cover even if I am pushing the left stick forward fully while pressing X
Even the fighting animations aren't that good compared to RDR1
RDR2 is a really good game but those fighting animations man

[hidden moss]

Gbu was pre good tho hella old but I remember watching it on Sunday when was a kid

[muted sierra]

I watched it a few years ago. It's an amazing movie

Also I watched Clint Eastwood's new movie last year in theaters, wohoo

[hidden moss]

I used to watch cowboy movies when I was younger had no choice really

either be bored or be entertained somewhat watching what parents where watching lol

[muted sierra]

I only like Western films that aren't really romanticized like most of Eastwood's

[young forum]

For some reason I only watched Godfather series, I think Toys 1, and Original and Prequel Star Wars movies when I was a kid
I wasn't what you'd call a diverse set of movie watching, I only got to watching Western Films recently

[muted sierra]

Which westerns you like?

[young forum]

Did Django (both versions) count?

Aside from that, Godless

I plan to watch Hell on Wheels next

[hidden moss]

bruh i shot a elk in the head it was a perfect elk with a rifle and it gave me a good pelt

[muted sierra]

DJang Unchained?

[true wave]

tombstone's good

one of my favorites

[muted sierra]

Cuz that one is great

[true wave]

judge me go ahead.

[dull geyser]

Tombstone is legendary

[muted sierra]

Unforgiven

[true wave]

val kilmer did good

I also really enjoyed the dollar trilogy

that shit is ICONIC

[muted sierra]

Fistful of Dollars is goodish to me

But Good bad Ugly is amazing

[true wave]

yesss

for a few dollars more is also really good

[muted sierra]

Yup

I love the in movie version of Good Bad Ugly's theme but I dont like the remade version. Aka the one that's used in media most

[true wave]

I agree

the OG is just better

[dull geyser]

3:10 to yuma was pretty good

[muted sierra]

The one the media uses a lot sounds to cheezy and such

[true wave]

I agree

[muted sierra]

the one in the movie sounds eerie like you're in the desert

[true wave]

just like the first few seconds or so

[muted sierra]

Have you seen Unforgiven?

[true wave]

I have not

I'll add that to my list

[candid pasture]

keep it red dead related

or move to #general

[muted sierra]

It's the closest movie to RDR1

[true wave]

my bad....

[muted sierra]

friend me plz :>

[true wave]

shoah!

we're friends now!

[marsh valley]

I like being Arthur because none of my violence will matter later on

For John, I feel like I can’t just go on a rampage

And rob fifteen trains in an hour

[hidden moss]

same

[marsh valley]

Idk why I like train robberies so much. Maybe they’re profitable but it’s also the corridor firefights and the early moments of robbing the passengers before they run off

[true wave]

I feel sad because Arthur clearly hates the killing

[hidden moss]

during shootouts with the police he could taunt them so it shows that he kinda likes it

[true wave]

then I'm confused

[marsh valley]

Idk in low honor he seems to take a sick pleasure in it

He feels guilty but he keeps doing it. Because violence gives him the feeling of power life is stripping away

[true wave]

fair

that explains things very well

[hidden moss]

well idk I love playing as low honor arthur

[marsh valley]

But then he confesses to someone that he’s not sure why he’s going off the rails

[true wave]

yep

[marsh valley]

I like to think violence is his coping mechanism

Nothing to make you feel powerful like sticking a shotgun in someone’s face and demanding their money

[true wave]

correct!

[marsh valley]

“Ma’am this Browing Auto Five will blow your face off, just give me your watch!”

[hidden moss]

lol

[marsh valley]

Now here’s a real question: does Arthur secretly want revenge? He follows most every plan that involves it…

[hidden moss]

eh well arthur's not perfect

so I guess

[marsh valley]

I like that he’s flawed

Potentially a hypocrite depending on playstyle

Preaching against vengeance then running after Micah Bell

I think I’m finally gonna get Algernon’s hat this run

If I can withstand completing the exotics

[true wave]

does he actually say that?

[marsh valley]

Nah but I wish he did

[true wave]

same here lol

[marsh valley]

I wish the guys Trelawny found had more coach robbery tips

Three a piece isn’t much

And like he says the odds of finding something good are low

Usually the most valuable thing on a stagecoach is the coach itself

[true wave]

uh huh

[hidden moss]

stage coach's sell for a nice amount

mainly just amo and tonics money but better then nothing

dude you don’t even need money lol

there are gold bars everywhere

[night sluice]

hey so when im hunting, is there a place to store the pelts i skin like in camp or is it always on my horse

[primal knoll]

hahahaha

[surreal pivot]

I'm pretty sure you can just store it on your horse

[primal knoll]

just did the mission where i find the guys "zebra"

so funny

cant wait to see what his "tiger" is (no spoilers 😄 )

[surreal pivot]

And then you can find it in your satchel

[primal knoll]

for big animals you can just leave em on your horse

[night sluice]

mkk thanks guys

oh also is the butchers the only place i can sell the animals i hunted or do i need to progress a bit more in the story

[surreal pivot]

You can sell them at the trapper

And then you can make clothing out of whatever you sold

[night sluice]

gotcha dont think ive unlocked a trapper yet but thanks again

[primal knoll]

HAHAHA

the cougar "tiger" ate the dog

[cyan night]

I've found an apparently good florida panther spawning location, but I'm having trouble "studying" him before he tries to gut me. Can't seem to kill me as easily as a cougar but much harder to spot it seems.

First one that jumped on me I got a perfect pelt but I stilll need to study one.

[hidden moss]

Use binoculars on a panther that spawns in the minute you detect it in eagle eye

there's really no other way but luck

you have a couple of locations that they can spawn in far away from you

[cyan night]

I actually got it right after I posted (always happened). I just had a buck with a messed up face charge me!! What?

[hidden moss]

but that's a 5% chance at any time in the area

so very hard to achieve

[cyan night]

I've been camping south of Braithwaite manor so I can ride in and knife kill horsemen. Doesn't seem to lead to a bounty. I just ride in and wait till they get mad then knife one and ride away into the apparent panther territory

[primal knoll]

HAHA

BRO

it was an actual lion

i did not expect that hahahaha

[hidden moss]

You can use your rifle too btw

it doesn't really matter which

[dull geyser]

Lmao I was convinced it was another dog but when I saw the dead cow lying on the ground

I was pretty excited cause I thought I could skin it

[night sluice]

just found saint denis and saw my first dead or alive bounty, is the payout the same here for dead or alive or is it like some games where its decreased if theyre dead

[dull geyser]

Yea I think capturing them alive gives higher payout

[night sluice]

Agh god dammit it didnt matter anyway, i accidentally one shot the guy

[primal knoll]

holy shit

i just got the piss scared outta me for the first and probably only time playing this game

was riding along and saw a lady crying in a swamp

approached her and these fuckin ghoul looking mofos pop up

was in the swamp near lagras

and i shot them all then a "witness" starts riding by and then says "oh youre gonna pay" and starts shooting at me hahahah

what the fuck

[night sluice]

man it sure was a big jump from going to classic western gun slingers to suddenly arrive in saint denis and have to up against gatling guns

love this game

hopefully i dont get jump scared too lol

ah sick, still got the full pay even though i killed my bounty

[dull geyser]

I got scared as well when they jumped me

They ambush me as well when I go to the swamps at night

[primal knoll]

i got a machete from the followup mission

pretty sick

[dull geyser]

Nice

[limpid rapids]

I like micah

[hidden moss]

i kinda like his outfit

but i still think hes a villain

and he should rot in hell

[limpid rapids]

Hes a really good character

And a perfect antagonist

I did American venom last night

It was so fun

[hidden moss]

yes

a very good one indeed

[hidden moss]

i wasted all my tonics on it lol

[limpid rapids]

Thats why we all hate him

[hidden moss]

i did 2 playthroughs and on both playthroughs i always run out of tonics

[limpid rapids]

I had no health tonics so i had to skip the checkpoint

[hidden moss]

i know

rockstar did a good job on the story

n the graphics

[limpid rapids]

To think of it now we got matrix demo

[hidden moss]

dang

i watched the whole credits

it took a while

but it was worth it

[limpid rapids]

I skipped it so my viewer wouldnt rot

Remember when dan houser was still in rockstar?

[hidden moss]

yeh

[limpid rapids]

GTA 6 got rebooted because he left

[hidden moss]

we aint getting it for another 20 years

god damn it

[limpid rapids]

But we will get rdr2 expanded and enhanced for ps6

[hidden moss]

lol

but i mean

it wont be that different

just better graphics

and better horse ball physics

[limpid rapids]

I hope it includes undead nightmare 2

[limpid rapids]

LMAO

[hidden moss]

i bet they'll make horse balls shrink 10 times more in the desert

idk, just a prediction

[limpid rapids]

I bet too

[hidden moss]

yeah been waitin for that

[limpid rapids]

Been waiting for that for 4 years 💀

[hidden moss]

lol

dang

[limpid rapids]

while rdr1 got it on its first october

[hidden moss]

is rdr2 gonna be 4 years old

[limpid rapids]

instead we got halloween pass

[limpid rapids]

Its already 2022

OH WAIT

[hidden moss]

damn

[limpid rapids]

OH FUCK

Its 5 years olr now

[hidden moss]

it is?

[limpid rapids]

About to in october i think

[hidden moss]

i thought they released it in 2018

[limpid rapids]

Yep

[hidden moss]

2022- 2018

[limpid rapids]

Count from 2022 to 2018

Its 5 years

[hidden moss]

= 4

[limpid rapids]

why do i get 5,

[hidden moss]

i dunno

lol

i searched on google

[limpid rapids]

Bruh

I counted on fingers

Jan 1 2018 to 2022

[hidden moss]

i hate alden

i hate that stupid voice everytime i get in a post office in rdo and story mode

and the character i hate the most in rdr2

is the rhodes general store cashier (the ones from chapter 2-6)

[limpid rapids]

alden is the post office

[hidden moss]

purely just because of that annoying voice everytime i need to buy clothes or food

[limpid rapids]

I did his mission once

He payed me 4 dollars

Like wtf am i gonna do with 4 dollars

Transfer it to gta?

4 dollars in 1899= 400 dollars in 2013

I think

[night sluice]

Why are some guns locked in the catalogue, do i need to find them naturally off an npc or something first?

[limpid rapids]

What is your level

[night sluice]

Oh uh idk

Ngl didnt realise there was levels in singleplayer

[hidden moss]

u can

[limpid rapids]

Bro i believe this is singlebplayer chat

[hidden moss]

u gotta get it through the story

or

you can just like

steal it off some npc who has one

[limpid rapids]

you can unlock some revolvers by entering the epilogue

Micahs for example

[hidden moss]

i didnt bother

i dont wanna see his ugly face again

[night sluice]

Mkk

And micahs a pain, shouldve just ignored him

[limpid rapids]

Should have left him to hang in strawberry

Even if bad honor

[hidden moss]

Why tf Charles spawned in. I thought he went to Canada.

I missed him tho

[fair sky]

Micah is a great antagonist

[dull geyser]

yep

[tribal ember]

kinda

but i think dutch is more of an antagonist

[glossy wolf]

I asked this question earlier, but didnt get a proper answer. How do I get my horse to graze/eat grass at camp? I've been trying litually everything (Yes, I read the reddit post, but it didnt work) Are there any solution for this?

[tribal ember]

wdym eating grass

the animation?

[glossy wolf]

Yeah

Im some kind of a roleplayer who likes to just blend in with the others..

[tribal ember]

idk i dont play rp

and ive never noticed abt that animation at all

[crimson lance]

The horses just sort of do it on their own, I don’t think there’s a way to force it.

[glossy wolf]

I've seen my horse do it a few times after a mission, but I have really never found a way to toggle it yet

[crimson lance]

Best bet to make sure they’re fed is just to feed them yourself.

[glossy wolf]

I know, I just want my horse to stick with the other horses at camp

[tribal ember]

when u stop ur horse at the camp, just put him at the side of other horses

[kind dew]

I dont think it will World

[glossy wolf]

It wont work, I've tried it before

[fluid cypress]

I’ve noticed when it’s hitched it eats shit from the ground

[kind dew]

Ugh

[fluid cypress]

i mean stuff

lol

[kind dew]

Oh

Lol

[dull geyser]

They just do that on their own

[night sluice]

is the bandana not enough to disguise myself when i start murdering so they dont know who i am, or am i gonna need to use a full mask

[fluid cypress]

Both do the same thing it’s just cosmetic beyond that

you only disguise yourself from normie civilians lawmen will recognize you no matter what

[crimson lance]

This ^

[fluid cypress]

You can also be wanted as an unknown suspect there’s a lot of stuff the mask mechanics the game doesn’t explain at all

[crimson lance]

It took me a while to understand that

[fluid cypress]

yeah

all the game says is ‘mask hide identity’

even the clothes you wear and everything comes to play when you’re an unknown suspect

[night sluice]

gotcha

thanks for the heads up

the game sure threw a lot of mechanics at me, takin me a min to really learn em

[fluid cypress]

just watch a vid there’s some on yt that explain it rly well to understand how clothes/beard plays a role in it and wht all things you can get away with, how to do it safely etc

bounties are a pain

[night sluice]

cheers man

and yea still gotta get 300 to pay off my west elizabeth bounty thanks to micah

kinda spent all my money on new clothes and guns lol

[hidden moss]

i just finished the story

im crying

[marsh valley]

did you blind old Micah Bell?

[night sluice]

do most items increase stats cos if they do how the heck do i check what stats they increase

[marsh valley]

Like what items?

The Ginseng elixers and all that?

[night sluice]

oh mb not items, like accessories and stuff

cos i was checking my horse out and apparently the saddle helps with regen and reduce drain but it didnt say it when i was looking at it in the stables

[dark scaffold]

is there anyway to get the white arabian in chapter 2

[cold parcel]

I'm not sure if it's available in chapter 2,but I there should be white Arabians in the mountains in the grizzlies. Atleast when I was there with John, there was an arabian.

[crimson lance]

Yeah go up to the Grizzlies near where the White Buffalo is

I’ve gotten it in Chapter 2.

[dark scaffold]

is there an exact point where?

ive recently started and a friend said to get a white arabian

[crimson lance]

I have found it on the northern shore of Lake Isabella

[dark scaffold]

ok thanks

[crimson lance]

You’ll have to capture it and break it so you can ride it though because it’s wild.

[dark scaffold]

wdym break it

[crimson lance]

You’ll have to approach it and calm it, then get up on its back and do the horse breaking mini game. Basically it bucks all over and you have to try to stay on top.

[dark scaffold]

oh ok

[crimson lance]

I’d practice with a few lower caliber wild horses in New Hanover to get the hang of it first.

[dark scaffold]

mama didnt raise a pussy

going in blind here

[crimson lance]

Lol ok man

It’s not hard once you get the hang of it though

[cold parcel]

Rdr1 horses were easier to break.

[crimson lance]

Much easier.

[cold parcel]

And horse's in RDR1 are chads.

[night sluice]

man why the heck is the hair lookin real bad, is my settings messed up

[cold parcel]

Arthur's hair or?

[night sluice]

my horse

[tribal ember]

which is yall favourite camp?

[cold parcel]

Horseshoe overlook.

And you can I guess modify the horses hair in stables I guess if that's what you meant, I dunno.

[tribal ember]

clements point much better ngl

[cold parcel]

It's aight.

I feel like shady belle was underrated.

[tribal ember]

kinda depressing

you had that feeling that everything was going bad

[cold parcel]

Still an nice mansion.

[tribal ember]

it felt kinda estranged of the other gang members

[cold parcel]

Yeah.

Also, Beaver Hollow was pretty much the point where you saw they were fucked.

Dutch being in an cave, the one thing Arthur mentioned about to Charles.

[tribal ember]

There is a theory that Dutch hits his head in the failed heist in Saint Denis, not in the bank robbery.

[cold parcel]

Yeah.

It would make sense, because in that mission after they get away from Saint Denis, it sounds like he turned crazy as soon as that.

[leaden sorrel]

Where is Dutch?

[chilly bramble]

I’m in chapter 2 rn , should I even bother trying to get a black Arabian in St Denis?

[chilly bramble]

It’s been so long trying to find it and I’m going to go crazy at this point

[chilly bramble]

I did actually get it once and I spent a lot of money to customise it and also sold my white Arabian cause I thought I would never use it again

But then it died 5 minutes later

[rare sigil]

I tamed the white Arabian and it slide down a cliff that was 2 millimeters long and it died. Will it respawn after a while?

[chilly bramble]

In story mode , I don’t think so

[rare sigil]

Great, are there any better ones that you don’t have to buy?

[chilly bramble]

idek myself , I’m quite new to RDR2

There is the black Arabian you can find in st Denis but from personal experience it’s way too hard

[rare sigil]

I’m gonna see if it respawns because I had it run away one time and it took a few days to respawn, no harm in trying

[chilly bramble]

Oh damn it can respawn?

My black Arabian died cause it left it on train racks and when I came back out it was long gone

[tribal ember]

just get the white one i the snow

[rare sigil]

I had some wolves scare it off and I did a few missions, then I came back and it was there again

[chilly bramble]

It’s good enough for the story mode right?

[rare sigil]

It’s one of the best horses in the game

[chilly bramble]

Well then , I’ll just have to get the white Arabian again

That’s going to be such a hassle lol

[rare sigil]

It’s the best wild horse as far as I know

[tribal ember]

its one of the best ones

[chilly bramble]

Yeah , had it for quite a while and it’s so fun to use

[tribal ember]

its not

and he is the most beauty

[rare sigil]

Do you know if it respawns after it dies?

[chilly bramble]

But I really hate having to ride it back all the way to Valentine so I can put it in the stable

[chilly bramble]

Took me ages to get it before but now that I know how to I’m sure it won’t be that hard

[tribal ember]

just get the sadle of your horse

[tribal ember]

you can revive him

[chilly bramble]

Oh my god I just realised I should’ve done that

[rare sigil]

I’m pretty sure you can only revive him if he’s on the ground moving, if he’s not moving you can’t revive him. I didn’t have reviver on me anyway

[tribal ember]

haha, i didnt want my other horse so i had to kill him

[chilly bramble]

When I first tamed it was taking him back and these wolves appeared out of nowhere and just ended up killing me and scaring off my horse

[tribal ember]

then you cant i guess, never happened to me

[chilly bramble]

Is there an on screen notification if your horse dies or is about to?

[rare sigil]

There wasn’t when mine died, maybe cause I have literally tamed him 2 minutes before it died

[chilly bramble]

Yeah , same here

[tribal ember]

nope

[chilly bramble]

Damn

Well I gotta go but it’s nice to see this discord server is really good

[cold parcel]

I remember an funny story with my temporary horse. I just got back to Clemens cove and I was like, where the fuck is that horse. Turns out the dude was just walking near Clemens cove's beach.

[chilly bramble]

Will definitely be back on jt agian

it*

[frigid cloud]

after 3 in-game days

[rare sigil]

Thank you

[chilly bramble]

Where will it respawn??

[rare sigil]

Can confirm, white Arabian respawns after death

[cold parcel]

Grizzlies.

[rare sigil]

Where you found it

Literally exact same spot

[frigid cloud]

^

[chilly bramble]

My black Arabian died and it’s been ages in game days , will it respawn at all?

I’m guessing not lol

[cold parcel]

Good question.

I think it will.

[chilly bramble]

Those words have lighten something up inside of me

I need that black Arabian lol

[cold parcel]

Good luck mah dear boah.

[chilly bramble]

Where would it respawn? At the place of its death or somewhere else?

[cold parcel]

Maybe near the barber?

I think I saw an video where an black arabian was near the hanging place in Saint denis.

Or try Tahiti.

[chilly bramble]

Oh well I got my black Arabian by stealing it , do you think I would find it there?

[cold parcel]

I think so.

[chilly bramble]

I’ll check the barber and maybe the place where my horse died

[cold parcel]

It's funny to see everyone getting the best horse in the game, meanwhile I'm using the horse I got from the O'driscoll's in the first mission.

[chilly bramble]

lol

I don’t know why but I just really want to get the best things in the game before I continue

But tbh that’s a really sad way to play the game

[cold parcel]

It's funny to also think that horse has survived everything with me, the weakest dude. Then the strongest of dudes die.

I did an train robbery with an Arabian, died.

Tennessee Walker was just an chad and kept pushing.

[chilly bramble]

Damn , Arabians just have a habit of dying I guess

[cold parcel]

Suicide squad.

[chilly bramble]

Damn , I don’t even have any money to take the stagecoach anymkre

Anymore*

Do you know any ways I can get some money in St Denis without getting a bounty?

[cold parcel]

Uhh.

[chilly bramble]

I guess I can still rob a store quickly

[cold parcel]

Well, I dunno, I always get an bounty from Saint Denis even tho I don't do anything.

[chilly bramble]

sigh the gunsmith is gonna get it again

[cold parcel]

Robbing the store risky.

[chilly bramble]

I don’t even know why he thinks he can pull a gun on Arthur of all people

[cold parcel]

Last time I tried robbing it in Saint Denis, I was caught.

[chilly bramble]

Whenever I get caught I just ride to the top of St Denis and hide somewhere

It’s quite a safe place to head if you have a bounty

[cold parcel]

Or shoot everyone.

[chilly bramble]

Would love to but I don’t really want to get my honour that low

However , can’t you increase it really quickly but just greeting a lot of people in St Denis?

[cold parcel]

Fun fact, I'm an honorable outlaw. I shoot everyone, but still have an good honor.

Yeah, you can.

Works with every place pretty much, but Saint Denis has more people.

[chilly bramble]

Alr

I should probably go now

Thanks for talking to me

[cold parcel]

Np.

[tidal nacelle]

can not get passed gambler 8

[uncut berry]

I robbed the gun smith in Saint Denis and I was able to outrun the law enforcement it’s that easy

[marsh valley]

So far I have Bandit, Explorer, Master Hunter, Weapons Expert, and Sharpshooter done.
Halfway done with horseman, Herbalist will be a pain, as is Gambler

Survivalist will just take time

[fringe creek]

How come the game asks you to use the long scope rifle on a black bear but tells u to use a regular rifle on the much larger grizzly?

[quartz root]

But with ammunition High Velocity or Express

[fringe creek]

ik but how come u can't use the long scope rifle on the grizzly?

[quartz root]

I mean you can still drop him one shot. I dont see problem here.

[fringe creek]

It's because I wanna make sure my pelts are perfect

[quartz root]

Yeah with Express ammo you will be fine

[cold parcel]

Just punch the mf.

[tacit plover]

Right now I’m on Survivalist 10

[arctic wren]

“Nothing I haven’t got” as I have every single cigarette card

[marsh valley]

Lmao

I'm finally playing poker for Gambler

So hopefully by the time I get to the riverboat I'll be the Master Gambler

[red helm]

Silly Gambler challenges.

[modest acorn]

Quick question for you feller’s. Just completed gambler 9 (thank god) and was on my way to Valentine to play poker for gambler 10. Im in chapter 2, haven’t done train robbery or free Micah(cuz he should rot) and Javier comes riding out of the woods to the road by the northern railroad tracks that lead to valentine. Says Bill got captured and was only a matter of time until they take him in for the bounty. We gotta rescue him. I’ve done 5 playthru’s and i have never seen this before in my life. Have you?

[red helm]

Wow, huh, nope, I do not recall seeing that encounter either. I hope you didn't decline?

[modest acorn]

No i accepted. Recorded it as well

[red helm]

Nice.

I've definitely had Javier come and pester me about Dutch wanted me to come back to the camp. Many, Many times...

[modest acorn]

Tho i missed the first part in recording cuz I accidentally turned the replay off. Got the whole rescue tho

[modest acorn]

Never had that one either

[red helm]

Cool, definitely post it in #red-dead-media

[modest acorn]

Alright i will in a bit

[red helm]

Okay, let me know.

[red helm]

It's just a Fast Travel back to the Gang Camp, Kind of more irritating than anything else.

[cold parcel]

I got that encounter. Pretty fun.

[modest acorn]

Ah. Well regardless, maybe im not spending enough time away from camp lol

[red helm]

Maybe, it was happening to me in Chapter 6, before the final mission. So, that may have had something to do with it.

[modest acorn]

Oh maybe

[red helm]

I was prolonging things as much as I could, though, doing side missions, challenges, etc.

[main compass]

Why does sadie's voice sound like she's struggling to sound like arthur lmao

[red helm]

It's a southern accent, quite a few people sound like that.

[fringe creek]

So, for some reason, the menu in my game says the peccary needs a rifle

[cyan night]

Can anyone tell me what triggers the "gangs" part of the progress in the game? Is it only when you meet one of them in a mission? Because I have met Odriscoll, Lemoyne, Murfee and Night Folk but progress only says 3 for me.

[fringe creek]

But every other source online says a repeater

[red helm]

Night Folk aren't a actual Gang.

[cyan night]

Oh. Gotcha I was going by the list of 10 here reddead.fandom.com/wiki/Gangs_in_Red_Dead_Redemption_2

[red helm]

Yes, that is slightly confusing.

[cyan night]

That answers that though. I know I'll meet them eventually just wanted to make sure it wasn't bugged

[red helm]

I don't remember which weapon I used for the Peccary pigs, but I think I just used what the in game info said, I don't remember having any problems getting perfects.. Is it not working out?

[fringe creek]

I got a perfect with the repeater

[red helm]

Then, sure, whatever works.

[fringe creek]

Tho when I went up to the carcass, I swore I saw 2 stars

but ig that's just me

[red helm]

Maybe the Buck Trinket went off.

I bet I did use a Springfield, and didn't check the info, since that is what the regular boars need...

[hidden moss]

Uh so I am looking for moose but I haven't found any but the legendary. I've looked in the areas where they are, haven't found any

[red helm]

Moose are one of the rarest animals, so you are not alone there...

[main compass]

i thought they were zombies first time i saw 'em 💀

[red helm]

Check online for their spawn points, but, rare... I've seen them up where the Legendary is. Down on a ledge under Brandywine Drop, that waterfall south of where the Legendary is. I've also seen them just west of "The Loft"... But, yeah.. Patience... and more Patience.

[red helm]

They are quite interesting. Have you done the side mission involving them yet?

[main compass]

there's a side mission about them?

[hidden moss]

I've literaly spent hours looking for the moose and yeah

[red helm]

It's at night, just north of Lakay.

[red helm]

It took me weeks to finally get a Moose Antler for the Camp Upgrades....

[hidden moss]

Yeah I don't know where to find them

Where did you find yours

[red helm]

I just said the places I've seen them. Also, I've heard people mention the two lakes by Coltor.

[hidden moss]

I've looked there but all I found were snow

[red helm]

Well, what part of rare is confusing you?

I mean, they do not show up very much, I've seen Panther's way more often than Moose.

[hidden moss]

Ik

[red helm]

Like, seriously, I've seen maybe 4 moose, ever, and about 8 panthers..

[hidden moss]

In the fine nights of debauchery mission wit trelawny, if you go during nighttime there is a xtra lil cutscene

[red helm]

Interesting.

[night sluice]

lol sitting on 600 and aint none of it going to camp just yet

[hidden moss]

Should I get the Delgado saddle or the upland saddle?

Nevermind forget that, I found one I like

[night sluice]

do i need to always be holding shift to drive this train or is there a way i can just make it go lol

[marsh valley]

Ugh I just got fucked by some Lemoyne Raiders
They ruined my perfect panther corpse. So now I gotta scrounge up another rare swampcat… that and I think I screwed up a coach robbery by knocking a guy out too soon so I never learned the location of the money

[marsh valley]

tfw you get another perfect panther then the game cucks you out of it by making it despawn with fast travel

[tacit plover]

not the worst thing that’s happened to me using fast travel

[dull geyser]

Lmao that's why I save after I got a 3 star pelt

[marsh valley]

No worries I have a new one

turns out bait isn't always a waste of time

[hidden moss]

how?

[marsh valley]

Lured me a new big kitty with some berries and fish

Also how what?

[hidden moss]

how did you die to lemoyne raiders?

[marsh valley]

Oh I didn't I slaughtered em like pigs

But they shot the body I had on my horse

[night sluice]

man clothes shopping really drains all the money out of you

[bold carbon]

Ikr

[marsh valley]

It vanished again!

This game hates me!

Fuck my whole ass life bro

RDR2 fails object permanence

[night sluice]

dude i just got like 600 after fencing some valuables and that gold bar

and then poof, clothes ate like 500

[marsh valley]

Really? Clothes are dirt cheap

Guns drain all my cash

Yo this is pog I go back to the autosave and there's my panther
Which is good, I don't have to ragesmoke a cigarette now

[night sluice]

for me its clothes cos i buy a lot of different colour

guns arent too bad cos its just once purchase and youre good

[dull geyser]

Sheesh

[marsh valley]

I like to customize

Add plenty of gold engraving and bits

[night sluice]

for me its more the fashion statement 😎

[dull geyser]

I just get outfits from the trapper

[night sluice]

arthur morgan looking like peaky blinders rn

[dull geyser]

But I spend big time on guns

Dapper look is fire

But I like the rugged look

[night sluice]

oh yeah i like to make sure my guns look clean and dangerous

i try to make it a decent mix

dapper and a bit rustic

[dull geyser]

Yea

[night sluice]

dapper coat but rustic hat

[dull geyser]

I got my schofield revolvers in all silver with black engravings

[night sluice]

i got 2 schofields, one silver and one gold
silver for all the ads and gold for the special targets

[red helm]

Super stupid that it does that, you make a camp fire so it automatically turns your large carcasses into meat... Dumb dumb rockstar logic.

[marsh valley]

Yeah especially bc I wanted to avoid damaging the carcass by fast traveling

[night sluice]

wait theres fast travel?

ah well i like riding around, enjoying the scenery

[red helm]

Yes, you have to do a few upgrades to your Gang Camp, then you can Fast Travel from either Arthur's Tent or your Campfire.

[night sluice]

ah makes sense

[dull geyser]

It's annoying when they ambush you I remember my horse died because of their gatling gun

[night sluice]

i probably should be upgrading camp huh, instead of spending literally like more than a thousand on clothing and guns lol

[red helm]

Most of the Gang Camp upgrades don't do diddly, but the Fast Travel upgrade can be helpful, at times.

[night sluice]

fair fair

and are you not able to get a perfect hunt with a bow or am i just bad even though im pretty sure i always hit the eye or something

[red helm]

Depends what animal you are hunting, make sure to study, then check the info, it will tell you what weapon to use for a 'Clean Kill', that is how you don't damage the pelt.

[dull geyser]

There are other kinds of arrows used for them

[night sluice]

OH

ok

yeah i should probably read up more on the info when i find new things

[red helm]

Reading is your friend.

[dull geyser]

Yeaa

[marsh valley]

I really like the hunting in this game

Especially for the big kitties

Those are terrifying

[night sluice]

do i get more opportunities to earn more gold bars later on in the story

oh and actually when or does the war vets building get finished in the story?

[dull geyser]

Yea you get insta killed if you didn't notice them

[marsh valley]

I manage to fend off their first hit usually

But that’s with full health and a health boost from the challenge gear

[dull geyser]

You can fend them off if you timing is good

[marsh valley]

Currently doing the satchel thing. Not fun but hey, it gives good bonuses

[dull geyser]

Yea

[marsh valley]

Big cats are just like wolves but more dangerous

[dull geyser]

I just roamed around the jungle till I see a red dot on my mini map

Getting a 3 star panther took me a multiple tries and it really is time consuming trying to spawn one lmao

[marsh valley]

I just made a save near Boulgers and kept reloading till I got it

[dull geyser]

Yea that's where they spawn

[marsh valley]

Big kitter

[dull geyser]

I tried baiting them but I only got 2 stars

So I just roamed at the woods until a 3 star spawns

[hidden moss]

@marsh valley what you think Mary would have done if she knew Arthur had TB

[marsh valley]

Probably stand by her decision

[hidden moss]

Wow

Cold hearted

[dull geyser]

Sheesh

Feel bad for our boah arthur

[marsh valley]

Idk what do you expect?
Her to go back to a dying man who won’t leave the gang?

Mary has always been a lost cause

[dull geyser]

Yep

[marsh valley]

Charlotte Balfour is the real missed chance…

[dull geyser]

She would've been a widow again if she came back to arthur

[dull geyser]

realized that when she kissed him on the cheek

[marsh valley]

…she’d be made a widow again too but damn…

I do love Charlotte

[dull geyser]

Yeaa

I even made sure her stalker dies so she wouldn't be bugged by that creep

[marsh valley]

Yes indeed