red-dead-singleplayer

[fluid cypress]

I jacked a coach

It had one horse

But damn

it flew

I finally figured out the weight thing

basically if you reach underweight there’s no hope

You can’t increase

If you’re average- you can play around with it now

keeps changing from avg- perfect and avg+

depending on even the smallest amount of food you eat

orrr my previous playthroughs were just bugged and now it’s ok

[brazen pier]

Well when arthur gets his tb it's impossible to change his weight as food doesn't have an affect on him but before that you can change it

[weak pawn]

Is the shotgun repeater and Lemat revolver worth it?

[hidden moss]

Definitely the shotgun

So you can blow peoples heads off

@weak pawn

[idle kraken]

Just started chapter 3 and finished first sheriff mission

Which side missions can I do? I’ve done the circus stuff

Micah still rotting

I’m fishing with Kieran atm

[nocturne hornet]

oh for f sake

I ran into an event at the boarder of Saint Denis, they shot at me while I was riding along, I shot back, law came and of course is now hunting me instead of the ones shooting at me first

Rockstar should fix that

[fluid cypress]

it’s funny that you think r* is gonna update anything for the single player at all

[weak pawn]

Thanks!

[nocturne hornet]

I know but it's still annoying af

[weak pawn]

Is the Lemat Revolver good

[fluid cypress]

Lemat is good but what’s the point if you have a shotgun with you also imo pump action is still the best even though you’re getting 5 rounds instead of 6 from the repeating it has more damage and accuracy

It takes 2 sometimes 3 shots to kill with repeating, atleast in free aim unless you’re very close up almost point blank

But with pump action 1 or 2 takes enemies down from some distance

also let’s not forget how cool pump action looks with black body dark varnish and silver/any light color engravings and frame details

[nocturne hornet]

F YES

I just unlocked the Mauser

well nto really but I got it from Brande

[weak pawn]

Makes sense

Might as wel just use a shotgun instead of a revolver with a gimmick

If I replay a mission is my progress in the game lost?

The alert says it’ll return me to this point

Does it mean I’ll be returned to my current progress or back to the mission I’m replaying?

[hidden moss]

Hey guys am I the only one who makes there Arthur have drip

[vagrant temple]

I keep the original outfits lol

Having Arthur/John fancy doesn’t fit them at all

[dull geyser]

Yes

John and arthur with dapper outfits kinda feel wrong

But those outfits on them are fire tho I just prefer rugged style on them

[hidden moss]

I prefer a mix between the two

Having them too fancy doesn't fit

[astral bone]

Too rugged would also give it away

[hidden moss]

Nah, Arthur is a rugged man

[fluid cypress]

I don’t think so it’s just a single mission replay but make a manual save just in case the game cannot override that by itself

I haven’t tried it so

[sly sandal]

no if you replay a mission it doesn't make you lose progress i think

but save just incase

[nocturne hornet]

Holy Shit

The Start of Chapter Five is really amazingly made

Spoiler for Chaptver Five btw:

oh lol

nvm

[dull geyser]

Lmao

[tidal cave]

so the graphics settings dont apply until you restart the game?

[primal knoll]

is it true if you liked rdr2 you also liked witcher 3

letting pc download it while im at work

[dull geyser]

I guess

I had fun while playing witcher 3

[nocturne hornet]

HOLY SHIT

Chapter 5 Is AMAZING

[fluid cypress]

enjoy it while you can

gets over real quick and no way to revisit

also it has some exclusive animals

and an actual beach

[nocturne hornet]

Em

Does anyone know where to Shave in the Chapter 5 Camp?

[light rune]

While trying to get the Arabian horse in the wild it managed to run away and now I can’t find it do I just need to leave the are?

[light rune]

There is no shave in camp but Dutch will soon point you to the next camp with a shaver

[nocturne hornet]

Alright

could've also just said no

[fluid cypress]

U can’t shave in guarma just look at Dutch lol

[nocturne hornet]

Im not in guarma anymore

Im already back

[fluid cypress]

everyone’s supposed to look like hobos

ah

I never tried

[nocturne hornet]

YESYESYES

[fluid cypress]

at lakay

[nocturne hornet]

Im finally in the mission in that I can unlock the Mauser

in shops

[fluid cypress]

noice

[nocturne hornet]

I already have one from before but duel wielding a mauser will be more than epic

[light rune]

?

[fluid cypress]

u could’ve got it from the gunslingers mission

nvm

[nocturne hornet]

Get an arabian from the event in Saint Denis

around Midnight

SOmeons wife gets shot

[fluid cypress]

ye it’s the best

[nocturne hornet]

The Husbands Horse is a black Arabian

just look it up on yt

"How to get Arabian for free in Saint Denis"

[fluid cypress]

tormenting a man who was having relationship problems just when his wife died then making his day worse by stealing his surely very expensive horse

[nocturne hornet]

Or you safe his wafe and steal the horse right away

just need to get away from the law

[fluid cypress]

I like to watch her die

[nocturne hornet]

yeah me too 🙂

[fluid cypress]

he goes to the swamps after that for some reason easier to rob without getting wanted

he also isn’t a witness if you leave him he’s just so done with the world

[nocturne hornet]

itm I have the White Arabian

the legendery one from Lake Isabella

[fluid cypress]

Arabians are too small for me

[nocturne hornet]

I like them

[light rune]

I’m trying to get it

[nocturne hornet]

anyways imma continue wwith mah mission now

[fluid cypress]

They look ridiculous when Arthur rides them with the gang everyone up and he’s down tiny

[dull geyser]

Yea

[nocturne hornet]

Its damn easy actually

[dull geyser]

I like the turks

[nocturne hornet]

just tame it like a normal horse

[fluid cypress]

i like the ultimate edition horse even if stats aren’t good idk why

[nocturne hornet]

but be more careful and like 5 times slower

[light rune]

I messed up and it kicked me off and ran away

[fluid cypress]

Lol hard part is to find it in all that snow

[light rune]

Can I just come back later

?

[nocturne hornet]

I think so

[fluid cypress]

Fast travel to like saint denis or something sleep there then come back

[light rune]

Ok

[dull geyser]

Just roam around there at like 2am

[fluid cypress]

It always respawns after a while unless you already have one

[light rune]

Ok

[fluid cypress]

also don’t fast travel to colter and go down to the lake from there I’ve noticed the horse just runs away the moment u come near that area go there from valentine

or strawberry

whatever’s easier in your opinion

[dull geyser]

I just lassoed the horse then I spammed calm until I manage to ride it

[fluid cypress]

That’s one way to do it but ppl say it’s harder and can go wrong in many ways

but it’s quicker than slow approach and calming the horse

idk never tried the lasso

Also I think I found a way to get unlimited elixir thing that gives u health xp

bob Crawford’s home seems to respawn it’s items so I can rob it again and again

i think

i robbed it once

Then robbed it again for the Hosea fence mission

Then robbed it once after the mission

Yet to try it again

[dull geyser]

Didn't know that

[nocturne hornet]

Chapter 6 BABY

YUHUHUHUU

Time to shave

[muted jetty]

no don't shave arthur during chapter 6

[prisma comet]

where on the map can i find people i can play blackjack with?

[nocturne hornet]

why?

I already did

[rocky oasis]

ja

[nocturne hornet]

Why not

[muted jetty]

he can protect others by having the bushy mustache

[nocturne hornet]

huh

tf

wdym

[nocturne hornet]

might just mention you so you get notified

[muted jetty]

it's like a mask for his face

to keep the gang safe

[nocturne hornet]

well shit

time to get Hair Tonic

[hidden moss]

damn that's nice to know I was about to shave 😭

[cobalt chasm]

after the guy coughed on me Mrs grimshaw immediately made me stick my face in the water barrel so every last person in that camp is going to die painfully now...

[fluid cypress]

Also he looks very sick and tired the beard helps hide it

[hidden moss]

About to start my second playthrough

[weak charm]

ayyo can shires be found in the wild?

[drifting vapor]

I dont think so. I think u can only steal them

[weak charm]

well i found one a while ago

friend told me it was a glitch

but idk seems too odd

[drifting vapor]

So I looked it up and the info there is conflicting too but some of the sites say they can be found in the wild

[nocturne hornet]

HOLY SHIT

flying in a hot air balloon is AMAZING

[cobalt chasm]

If I drop a weapon to pick up another one my first one will still be on my horse right?

[nocturne hornet]

If it's in a mission, yes

if not then I think also yes

[cobalt chasm]

lol

Found a pump action in a homestead mission and I just don't want to leave my lancaster or hunting rifle behind

[nocturne hornet]

Someone wanna call just cuz you're also bored?

Im in a self created vc

[frigid cloud]

it goes back to your horse

[fringe creek]

Yea ur horse has hella capacity

Also, I miss my mustang, Buckshot

He was a good boy

[willow vortex]

guys i need help

[nocturne hornet]

hm?

[willow vortex]

my john marston has a hat on him which cant be saved on its own, so i have to go to clothing locker, im at tumbleweed rn, and my camp is at beechers hope

is there any way i can save it without riding all the way ther

[celest sigil]

Anyone knows what is the secret achievement on xbox?

[nocturne hornet]

ok I cant help with that im not done with Chapter 6 Yet

someone wanna watch me finnish it?

[marsh valley]

Micah in Blessed are the Meek?: I showed him and I’ll show the rest of this town!
Five seconds later
Mission Failed Micah has died

[willow vortex]

ah

well its a cool hat

i posted its on #red-dead-media

its the hat of the sheriff in tumbleweed

[cobalt chasm]

hunting predators sucks

"hey, lets make the animals friggin TELEPORT right next to the player and move ridiculously fast, to the point even deadeye can't take them out before they're mauling arthers arm"

[marsh valley]

Fucking Micah keeps getting himself headshot
And the game calls this a loss...

[river nacelle]

Can I give an idea to add to online? This is it. So, you know how you have 4 horse stagecoaches that people ride in story and a replacement for fast travel? How come you don't have that for us in online? I think a lot of people would like who would rather have a 4-horse stagecoach in replacement for fast travel with the same spawning technique and for people who would really like to ride a 4-horse stagecoach in online as well. I hope you can think more into this idea. Thx! 😄

[willow vortex]

also what about my horses {MAJOR SPOILER} after well u know what john doesnt get his horses, any way to get them back?

[keen vapor]

Im stuck in camera mod whiout hud after pressing F6 what do i do

[nocturne hornet]

restart your game <_>

[keen vapor]

yes but it apen every time i press f6 is there a way to avoid that

[nocturne hornet]

Not press F6 xD

ok jk

Message the support and ask them about it

[cyan night]

When you get honor for paying money to the camp, does it matter how much you give? Meaning if you give $100 at once is that equal to giving $1 over and over again 100 times?

[river nacelle]

Where do you find the outlaw pass?

[hidden moss]

better ask that here #rdo-chat

[upbeat basin]

The high cap honor per donation is $24. So when you want to grind some honor you get a rhythm of donating the right amount

[river nacelle]

Thx

[hidden moss]

👍

[cobalt chasm]

I have a problem

spoiler text not allowed?

[cyan night]

Meaning donating $24 is better than 20 and 20 is better than 10, but anything above 24 isn't any better than 24?

[nocturne hornet]

no

[cobalt chasm]

SPOILER: I'm in rhodes trying to save the guy in the gun smith's basement. the gun smith is dead but I can't find a way down...

[nocturne hornet]

just say SPOILER in front of the message or smth

[upbeat basin]

Yes

[cyan night]

Anyone know if the special hats will respawn? Meaning if I found a special hat and put it on but then took it off and left it on the ground, is it gone or does it respawn? Or I guess I just thought of it, do I permanently keep it once I have tried it on once?

[nocturne hornet]

I really am way too cruel in RDR2

[upbeat basin]

Depends, if it is special (like the Civil War Hardee hat and others) it should stay in closet

[nocturne hornet]

I just helped someone out of a Bear Trap, Got the Reward (Ammunition) and just shot him in the head

🙂

[upbeat basin]

.

[cyan night]

I'm pretty sure I had a necklace in my inventory at one point but now I don't see it and wonder if I sold it to a fence. Is there a way to buy such things back? I might have had a mirror as well. Now I see some of those things would be asked for as camp requests. My future plan is to not sell basically any such items.

[tacit plover]

That’s not how you get down there

You have to hold the gunsmith at gun point as if you were starting a robbery and there will be a prompt to “Rob Basement”

[cobalt chasm]

Ah, well he seems to be alive again somehow, I’ll give it a shot

what

the

hell

[nocturne hornet]

well shit

I just wanted to get on my horse and I started choking some random guy and now the law is after me

rip

Saint Denis has way too many people

[cobalt chasm]

been there mate

[cyan night]

But you can farm honor by greeting someone every 2 seconds

[nocturne hornet]

I know

but its so many witnesses if you do like one accident

[cyan night]

That's true. That's why I go OCD and save it frequently

[nocturne hornet]

OCD?

[cyan night]

obsessive compulsive

[nocturne hornet]

alright

[cyan night]

I basically save the game manually whenever I encounter something new or accomplish something important just in case

Over the top I know

And I have 4-5 rotating save spots just in case

[nocturne hornet]

Hey do you know if you can "stack" Hair Tonics?

like buy 3, drink 3, buy 3 repeat

Yo @cyan night how often do I have to get honor for it to increase in my honor bar

and decrease

[cyan night]

I'm not sure to be honest. I've only been playing for about 11 days (but I have about 100 hours in - crazy) but it seems like little things like saying high add very, very little to the bar. Some things add more. And the opposite can be true too. It would be interesting to know how many donations/greetings are needed to "level up" on the honor meter but I don't know.

How far do you have to leave camp to cause the characters to reset? Specifically asking to try to get them to trigger new dialogue and item requests.

[fluid cypress]

There’s a legendary fish at sisika wtf?

[solid eagle]

do we have an idea for what caused Dutch to make some dumbass decisions in the story? I just finished arthurs story and im not sure why he walked away after all he did

[fluid cypress]

Some people believe it’s the tram mission where he hits his head i believe that’s stupid he was always like that just slowly showing his true colors

[solid eagle]

right, still cant believe he just watched micah shoot susan and didnt kill him on the spot

some shitty leadership

i hope ill be able to reunite with micah as john and finish this

[woven kindle]

I absolutely agree! I couldn't believe he would just sit there and let it happen. :/

[solid eagle]

yeah, my assumption is that in his eyes susan had already "betrayed" him by siding with arthur quietly for the past few weeks

well, time to write a thesis on this game

[fringe creek]

I kinda wish Arthur yelled at Dutch something like "What do you want me to do? Dress in drag and do the hula?"

[solid eagle]

arthur can make any phrase sound badass

damn my dumbass actually thought rdr1 has john as the main character lmao

never knew it was jack and he looked that similar at that age

[rugged path]

Can somebody help me, is it possible to find racing and heavy handling type horses in the wild? or are the all just standard?

[true wave]

can I not keep the civil war knife?

[true wave]

lol he can

[tidal cave]

man is this game heartbreaking

[hidden moss]

I have a question regarding the bolt action rifle

Can you get it somewhere in free roam?

Or do you have to buy it?

[true wave]

^

[tidal cave]

i think you get that in a mission in chapter 2 with john but i may be wrong

[tidal cave]

why did things have to be the way they are

[hidden moss]

what mission?

[tidal cave]

idk the name but the one where you get some sheep with john

i think thats the last one in chapter 2

[rugged path]

any1?

[candid walrus]

The Thoroughbred is a racing horse, the dapple gray and bay can be found in the wild

[rugged path]

but you can't find a mustang with racing handling or something?

[candid walrus]

Mustangs you can find in the wild. Not sure about their handling type. I'll check

Handling: Standard
Category: War / Work

[rugged path]

what does the categroy tells? and can you send me a link?

[candid walrus]

A link to the horse? If so, #red-dead-media

[rugged path]

Ow so a horse breed can only have one handling type?

[candid walrus]

Mhm

[rugged path]

or did i get that wrong?

[candid walrus]

No, you're right. Each horse can only have one handling type

[knotty slate]

What’s the best weapon to duel weld?

[glad brook]

Double actions revolvers.

[surreal pivot]

Shotguns

[cobalt chasm]

I got too many guns to know what to do with

What am I gunna do with 4 rifles

springfield screws with deadeye so I suppose I can ditch that one at least

still leaves the bolt action and two rolling blocks.

[red helm]

You can always put some in the weapon locker if you feel like your weapon wheel is to cluttered up.

[cobalt chasm]

It’s not so much clutter as it is I can only carry two at a time, so there’s no good way to test them back to back to see how they feel

Plus I don’t understand the difference between the rifles and the repeaters

[red helm]

Right, true. But, really, there is only tiny differences between the same weapons.

Rifles = High Damage, low reload and bad ammo capacity.
Repeaters = Medium damage, decent reload and high ammo capacity.

[cobalt chasm]

Hm, might stick to Lancaster than instead of any of the rifles. Maybe keep the rare rolling block rifle in case I need to snipe.

Or a shotgun if things get hairy up close

[red helm]

I prefer repeaters for Human hunting, and Rifles for Animal hunting.

[candid walrus]

I always keep one repeater, rifle, and shotgun handy

Then I just switch them out depending on what I'm going/where I'm going

[hidden moss]

Best revolver?

Imo it's either Schofield or the Lemester

[rocky oasis]

Help, i have a bug at the "The Noblest of Men and a Woman (RDR2 Gunslingers) " quest, ive done all 4 of them and i should return now to the saloon of valentine, but there is no questmarker in any way, and if i go there nothing happens. I think its a bug does someone know how to help?

[candid walrus]

What chapter are you in?

[cold sparrow]

I'm honestly using this to pretend I'm texting people right now, I'm in a very embarrassing situation right now 😭☠

Someone text me about sumthin🤦‍♂️

[limber lotus]

dope

[cold sparrow]

What is?

[limber lotus]

this is how you cope with embarrasing situations

or deal with

[cold sparrow]

Ik, don't tell any1 🤦‍♂️

[rocky oasis]

´2

[candid walrus]

That's why. You need to wait until Chapter 4. Then it'll show up

[rocky oasis]

ok thanks

[candid walrus]

Np

[primal knoll]

what do you guys think the best trapper clothes are

just discovered this, on my first playthrough i never even knew about this guy wtf

[candid walrus]

The beast of prey (?) outfit

[primal knoll]

i mean they all seem mostly the same

[candid walrus]

The one with the legendary alligator skin and the legendary panther skin

[primal knoll]

uhh

do you mean master hunter

ohh

nah i meant like the challenge items

that give you bonuses

[candid walrus]

ohh

lmao

makes sense

I like the bandit ones

Except for the bandolier, I don't like bandoliers

[worn lake]

Hi Guys I Have Draw Problem . I Can't Draw Weapon With Dead Eye . I Hold R2/RT But Arthur Just Shoot And Don't Use Dead Eye But With Mouse And Keyboard I Hold Left Click And Arthur Draw Weapon Without Any Problem . How To Fix With Controller.

[primal knoll]

i wonder how the fuck i just got a second holster

im on ch2 and obviously havent rescued micah

it just popped up outta nowhere after i killed some outlaws or something? idk

like i shot those ones who were shooting at the dad and sons building a house

[cobalt chasm]

the horse ai's ability to go from parkour master to tripping over absofreakinglutly nothing is astounding

or careening off the side of a cliff...

[tacit plover]

You can get them from doing challenges and then going to the trapper

That’s the only way I know of that lets you get a second holster before rescuing Micah

[cyan night]

Holy crap that was intense. I (intentionally for the achievement) got mauled by a grizzly but I didn't realize that simultaneously a bounty hunter was coming up on me so he was attacking me at the same time. No idea how I survived both.

[cobalt chasm]

me either I usually die to a single grizzly without so much as a quick time event

I mean I literally just did, found some dude tracking a "critter", he made the shot, big ol' grizzly came out of the shrubs and charged me instead of him

okay so apparently it takes 4 express bullets from the rare rolling block rifle to the head to kill the legendary grizzly

which is terrifying

or was

[mortal sonnet]

Woah

[mortal sonnet]

Uh doing challenges gives us bonuses?

[red helm]

You unlock a specific set at the trapper for each challenge, and after the 10th challenge, if you buy all of the set, you'll actually get a permanent plus to Health, Stamina or Dead Eye, getting it up to level 9 after the first, and then level 10 after finishing the second And third set.

[primal knoll]

ohh i see thank you, wonder which one i did

[red helm]

If you go to your Manu, then go to the Compendium, and then challenges, I think it shows which item comes from which challenge.

[primal knoll]

so without spoiling it

i got the killer clue #1

whereabouts should i go to get the next clue

[mortal sonnet]

There's a guide on YouTube

[void sluice]

either the brudge near wallace station or the tree near braithewaites

[cyan night]

So if I am buying fishing lures for the first time but I can already buy the "special" versions of them, is it just a waste to buy the regular versions? Or do the special ones only affect legendary fish?

[hidden moss]

does anyone know where to find the blanket appaloosa? i can’t find it anywhere

[void sluice]

heartlands

[lean sundial]

in the wild

[void sluice]

like sometimes it’s in the heartlands sometimes it’s in the rhoades area

[cobalt chasm]

Has ANYONE seen, Gavin!?

Does Gavin even exist?

[void sluice]

there’s a wagon with a dead body in it with a letter to gavins friend

presuming that’s gavin

[tidal cave]

how do i get honor fast

im in chapter 6 and i dont wanna miss the good ending

[cobalt chasm]

greet npcs

[primal knoll]

i gotchu

leopold strauss will give you a mission

its in like the south part of the map

you gotta collect debt

without spoiling too much, go there and absolve the debt but also give the bitch some money

its instant max honor

[tidal cave]

danke very much

[primal knoll]

np

btw you dont need that much honor

just >50%

[hidden moss]

Ye like u u got max low honor if u make honorable decisions during Strauss missions it would go to neutral

[worn lake]

Hi Guys I Have Draw Problem . I Can't Draw Weapon With Dead Eye . I Hold R2/RT But Arthur Just Shoot And Don't Use Dead Eye But With Mouse And Keyboard I Hold Left Click And Arthur Draw Weapon Without Any Problem . How To Fix With Controller.

Please Help Me!!!!!!

[primal knoll]

never used a controller but are you able to enter deadeye at all?

LT (hold) + RS - Activate Dead Eye while aiming

L2 (Hold) + R3 - Activate Dead Eye while aiming

[cobalt chasm]

I had to use another horse for a mission, which was fine apart from that specific horse being terrible. Got back to camp and did a quick whistle and when my horse came Arthur let out an excited "I'm back girl!"

God I love this game

[red helm]

Sometimes it is the little things that make things great, yes.

[primal knoll]

man first time i played this game i didnt hunt properly

just rode around on a horse and lasso'd shit

which was fine, but using binoculars to study/track the pelt rating is so much more fun

crouching and if you use scent lotion you can get really damn close

[tidal cave]

somewhat unrelated but imma say it. once i was doing the anthony foreman mission and i left my horse at camp. a bounty appeared so i took his horse and went to do that. that mf burned that horse and nearly killed me. thank god i didnt take my horse

[primal knoll]

bruh does hosea have tuberculosis

[tidal cave]

he does cough tho

im in chapter 6 now and i guess this is arthur's final chapter, can you never go to new austin as arthur?

[hidden moss]

I didn't complete the story

yes u cant go to new austin as arthur

i think theres a trick but that trick is a pain in the arse

[glad brook]

Complete it then come back.

[hidden moss]

lol

[marsh valley]

Gotta love it when I run across a rival gang doing a roadside jailbreak on a prison car, but shoot em dead before they free their comrade
Usually that's what I save fire bottles for... nothing like burning an O'Driscoll alive and screaming in his cage

[hidden moss]

I'm on like chapter 4

After burning down the lady's house

nice

[marsh valley]

That's such a good mission

[hidden moss]

that mission was so fun

[marsh valley]

I bring moonshine shot for that

So I assume it's made with their liquor cause I buy it in Rhodes

[hidden moss]

John died on it for me the first time

[marsh valley]

I'm part of the reason why that house burned

Micah kept dying in his prison break mission this run

Task failed successfully

[hidden moss]

Arthur Morgan

[glad brook]

Jim Milton.

[tidal cave]

anyone got this bug where sometimes you just try to calm the horse but it just goes on forever

[cobalt chasm]

SHAWN

NOOOO!!!

[hidden moss]

@tidal cave that almost happened to me online

I was trying to loot the saddle bag

[hidden moss]

Is it a wild horse

[tidal cave]

nope it was a mission one with the veteran

[hidden moss]

If it's a wild horse, mount it and tried not to buck it off until the horse got exhausted

[hidden moss]

Oh i see

Well, i never got the bug

Maybe try to slowly approach it while calming the horse

[hidden moss]

Singleplayer is good ngl

I can stay on chapter 2 forever

[tidal cave]

things i learnt for rdr2:
dutch had a goddamn plan

[waxen nest]

Hi I was wondering how you pick places to hunt

I can't make potent bait yet because I haven't unlocked fishing but I've got some herbivore bait from the store and wanted to know how to make the most of it

Also, how many carcasses can I stack on a horse?

[tidal cave]

i think just one but i maybe wrong

im in chap 6 now and got a Wanted DOA but i cant pay it off?

[cerulean mortar]

put the bait in the ground and stay back. Find some high ground from where you have a good look at the bait, and stay there without moving

[waxen nest]

Cool cool but as far as the actual location it's not real relevant?

[cerulean mortar]

some animal will appear

well try to put it in some open area, not where the animal could get blocked by trees or some stones

[waxen nest]

" it's over pronghorns, I have the high ground"

[cerulean mortar]

I almost never used bait in my playthroughs, ususally just look for animals arround. Although maybe I should have used it

most of the time the wrong animal appears, not the one u are searching for

[waxen nest]

Makes sense

I'm just trying to make some poker money and get acclimated to hunting for later

[cerulean mortar]

sounds like a plan

so its your first time playing the game?

[cerulean mortar]

The most convincing thing Ive found online is, that the guy that search for him is kind of crazy, and has split personalities. Gavin is his other self

he has a note on him if you loot him , that explains the back story I belive

[tidal cave]

itd be nice if rdr2 had a secret ending that if you donate like 10000 to camp you actually go to tahiti

[uneven coral]

excuse me i bought the 40 dollar version of the game of of the rockstar sight and im wondering if anyone knows how i get the rewards from when i bought it? idk if i should have came here with this question im just confused im new as i just bought it today

[nocturne hornet]

what is it with this wolf after like every 2 Missions

[nocturne hornet]

NOOOOO

My white arabian just died to a f*ing waterfall

SHIT

I cant get to the saddle

the water is dragging me away

is there a way I can fix this all?

[nocturne hornet]

Ok rip

its completely dead

just bought a new one

[weak charm]

Bruh that's depressing

[nocturne hornet]

yeah

[vivid fable]

hello

yo

[fluid cypress]

Wdym

is it like a dream sequence?

If it’s that it’s a coyote it represents your low honor

Kinda like a warning

that you’re choosing the dark path

[dull geyser]

Sadge

My turkoman died when I got ambushed by bronte's men in st denis

And I couldn't revive it cause it got ran over by a stage coach

[nocturne hornet]

I'm on the Dark Side of the Force

Lord URoRRuR’R’R

[nocturne hornet]

Is there a way, so that I can turn off this annoying af slow kill cam

[fluid cypress]

Dark side of the force is a pathway, to many abilities, some would consider unnatural

[rugged path]

Can someone help me, I just got a tip for a home robbery, but internet says a various things i can do. It also says i can go back to camp and ask a companion to join, but i can't seem to find this option.

It is about the pigfarm robbery

[iron grove]

Once you get the tip you’ll get a little White House icon with a dollar sign on it at camp, that’s where you can start the home robbery

You don’t get to actually choose who accompanies you unfortunately, it’s just like unlocking a little side mission

[rugged path]

mm, i did not see the icon yet...

maybe wait

[iron grove]

Did the tip come from some friendly Mexican guy camping near a train track

Cause I don’t recall a pig farm robbery but there is a stranger encounter there

[nocturne hornet]

Red Dead Redemption

LESS GO

I think it's the final one

[iron grove]

Wat?

[nocturne hornet]

Im in a mission called "Red Dead Redemption"

I mean my story is 72% Done but why would it be called "Red Dead Redemption" then

[iron grove]

Ohhh right

Enjoy!

[nocturne hornet]

Oh no

oh no

[rugged path]

No inmate, had to shoot his chains

[nocturne hornet]

oh for f sake

I just spent over 600 Dollar on a new horse and the story decides to kill it

f this shit

[dull geyser]

Lmao

[nocturne hornet]

Someone wanna watch me finnish the story?

join #927931372402798683

ok nvm its lagging mah game

[dull geyser]

I wanna watch but im outside rn

[nocturne hornet]

HOLY SHIT

Something epic just happened

ok nvm

[primal knoll]

youtu.be/P4ZdmuKP7Os

HAHA

[nocturne hornet]

I wish I could undo my last option in the story

I dont wanna play as fuqing John

[primal knoll]

first playthrough huh?

[nocturne hornet]

yeah

and I dont wanna fucking do it again

[primal knoll]

have you finished the epilogue tho

[nocturne hornet]

I hate this

epilogue?

[primal knoll]

give it time

trust me

yeah when you play as john theres like 25% more story

[tidal cave]

dutch has a plan

[dull geyser]

Lol

[tidal cave]

are you guys sure we cant donate like 10k to camp and unlock a secret ending?

[proud cipher]

Dutch: wE neEd mOrE MonEy

OnE mOre ScOre

[tidal cave]

i have a legit doubt

everytime i do a mission more than 50% goes to "gang share". when i look into the mission details menu it still says everyone's cut AND the gang share. but i never see this in the ledger or camp funds. why

[proud cipher]

rockstar forget maybe

[maiden sentinel]

It goes to Dutches stash out side the camp

For his Tahiti saving

[tidal cave]

then why do we always need ONE MORE SCORE

[proud cipher]

you know I heard this one guy theory it was pretty interesting

Dutch said that if he lived in a cave then they would just be low level criminals

and his tent was in the middle at horse overlook

and then at chapter 6 his tent was far from everyone and almost in the cave

[maiden sentinel]

That is interesting

[maiden sentinel]

He needs more Muneh for the mangos

[tidal cave]

lol i didnt even see dutch camp now im in chapter 6

i just wish rdr2 had a happy ending

[sly sandal]

that option is just for the ending of that mission, you play as john either eay

[proud cipher]

it does

[sly sandal]

eay*

way***

[proud cipher]

well

the epilogue does

[tidal cave]

red dead depression man

[proud cipher]

h a m i s h

[maiden sentinel]

Very accurate

[proud cipher]

HAMISH

[tidal cave]

i guess but arthur doesnt tho

[maiden sentinel]

Hamish 😭

[proud cipher]

bring back hamish

he didn’t deserve that

[sly sandal]

well rdr2 is technically John's story too

[maiden sentinel]

He coulda had so many cool stories

[sly sandal]

and John's story doesn't have a happy end

[proud cipher]

guarma seems rushed tbh

only like 2 missions

[sly sandal]

yeahh

[maiden sentinel]

It probably was

[sly sandal]

guarma was supposed to be explorable

[maiden sentinel]

Which is possible they wanted it to seem that way

[sly sandal]

then they removed it all

[tidal cave]

lol when i first played it i thought it was like fc3

[maiden sentinel]

They removed hours from the game

[sly sandal]

there were missions, strangers, treasure maps, other locations

[proud cipher]

why

[sly sandal]

though the island was smaller

[proud cipher]

why did they remove it

[sly sandal]

cause it wouldn't have really made sense in the story

atleast if they made it available after the story ends

would've been cool

idk tho

[proud cipher]

what to do after you finish the epilogue

I have 84% completion after finishing epilogue

[maiden sentinel]

Anything else you wanna do basically

Finish side missions

[proud cipher]

I don’t want to study 534 something animals

I did every side mission

before I finished the story

[maiden sentinel]

You don’t have to study animals for 100%

[sly sandal]

you don't need to study everything for 100%

[maiden sentinel]

Gotta do challenges

[sly sandal]

there's a list in the progression category

[proud cipher]

find the graves too?

[maiden sentinel]

And side missions you don’t have done

[proud cipher]

no I do

[sly sandal]

yeah it's super time consuming

[proud cipher]

it has a check mark

[sly sandal]

i only have 95% and I'm not gonna finish it

[maiden sentinel]

So exotics, bones, cigarette cards,

[sly sandal]

i just started playing online on christmas

been doing that since

[maiden sentinel]

Yeah you gotta visit the graves

As well

[proud cipher]

online is such a grind

you need so much gold

[sly sandal]

the last 2 stranger missions are so fucking annoying

takes ages

[proud cipher]

and if you don’t buy it

[tidal cave]

you said it for me

[proud cipher]

it takes you years

to get it

[maiden sentinel]

I managed to get 100% while my internet was dead because I didn’t have anything else to play

[sly sandal]

Nah

[proud cipher]

I’d rather just get a modder give me gold tbh

[sly sandal]

Once you get going it doesn't take long to get good gold

[proud cipher]

or do treasure map glitch

[sly sandal]

and plus you don't even need that much

for stuff

[proud cipher]

15 gold

when your getting like .10

a mission

[maiden sentinel]

I liked starting out and grinding for stuff

I done it for 2 accounts

[sly sandal]

i got bounty hunter with 10 gold and I'm getting close to 15 so i can get trader

bounty hunting gives you like 0.5 per legendary bounty

depends tho

[proud cipher]

what shouls I get first

[sly sandal]

on the difficulty

[maiden sentinel]

And if someone asked me to get on their account and grind it out for them I would

[hidden moss]

Me too.

[proud cipher]

I just started online but not really playing cuz so much grinding

[sly sandal]

bounty hunter is kinda good for starters tryna get gold

[tidal cave]

i kinda like online but i dont see the purpose of it unless you have friends to play with. id much rather play as arthur in valentine rather than online

[maiden sentinel]

Very true

[sly sandal]

Yeah

I have friends to play with

so it's fun

[maiden sentinel]

Currently looking for a specific horse in story mode

[proud cipher]

does tb slow Arthur down in free mode at all?

[maiden sentinel]

Nope

[proud cipher]

if that scientist guy didn’t die

[tidal cave]

i dont think so except that whenever he smokes or drinks he coughs

[proud cipher]

maybe he could of cured arthur

[tidal cave]

could he tho?

[sly sandal]

The only difference is when he has tb Arthur's underweight

you can't change that

[proud cipher]

but then he wanted to take over the world with robots so

[maiden sentinel]

Yeah he was more focused on the robot lol

[proud cipher]

why did the robot kill him

[tidal cave]

i feel like its dutch's fault. if he didnt keep stalling arthur couldve gone to tahiti and took some rest

[proud cipher]

it was Micah too

[maiden sentinel]

Ah yes the blessed Tahiti

[proud cipher]

he manipulated Dutch

and took advantage

[tidal cave]

i dont think its confirmed if the robot killed him

[maiden sentinel]

Micah just told Dutch what he wanted to hear

[tidal cave]

yes man i mean micah

[drifting vapor]

At the end of the day they were never gonna go to Tahiti imo

Even if everything had been successful

[tidal cave]

yea

[maiden sentinel]

Dutch was tired of Hosea and Arthur saying no and saying it wasn’t a good plan

[sly sandal]

funny how they could've gone to new austin or mexico by boat when coming back from guarma.. literally the perfect environment for Arthur's tb

[maiden sentinel]

Which Micah was like “let’s round up the men and go fuck it up”

[sly sandal]

then just send a letter or something to the rest of the gang

[drifting vapor]

Tbf Arthur agreed with Dutch more than hosea. Arthur just complained alot

[proud cipher]

is there anything to do past blackwater

[sly sandal]

yeah

[proud cipher]

like other stranger missions

[maiden sentinel]

Arthur agreed with Dutch because he was being loyal but knew it wasn’t a good idea

[sly sandal]

treasures, bounties, secrets

no strangers I don't think

[drifting vapor]

They didn't know where they were. Remember the Pinkerton are at shady Belle when they come back so if y send a letter there u screwed urself over again

[sly sandal]

i mean it wasn't that hard

[proud cipher]

I think anyone with a pea sized brain would’ve decoded that letter

[sly sandal]

yeah

[tidal cave]

anyone think r* gonna make a rdr2 story dlc?

[sly sandal]

no

[proud cipher]

nope

[tidal cave]

or a mexico expansion?

[sly sandal]

no

[proud cipher]

they didn’t with gta story

[maiden sentinel]

Probably not knowing rockstar

[proud cipher]

if it won’t make ‘em money

they won’t do it

[sly sandal]

or maybe for online but not singleplayer

[drifting vapor]

Of course which is why I kinda put the downfall of the gang on Arthur too

[maiden sentinel]

Even though it could make them good money

[tidal cave]

they at least did cayo perico tho

[drifting vapor]

I can't hate on bill and Javier when a few chapters earlier Arthur would've done the same thing

[tidal cave]

on the note of muneh - undead nightmare 2?

[maiden sentinel]

If Arthur and Hosea would have told Dutch Micah wasn’t good for the gang maybe Dutch would have listened more

And kicked Micah

[maiden sentinel]

I would love Undead Nightmare 2

[tidal cave]

they were saying just not hard enough

[sly sandal]

i mean the foundation for mexico in rdr2 is there
there's special music there, ambience, literal holes where the towns and buildings are supposed to be...
it's all probably already made too, all they would need is add some characters, missions, bounties etc for mexico and slap it in online.

for singleplayer it wouldn't make sense since John doesn't go there till rdr1

[maiden sentinel]

Yeah he had no reason at the time to go to Mexico

[sly sandal]

although online takes place in 1898 and there's no bridge to mexico in 1899 so... maybe not

[tidal cave]

theyd have to pull a doomsday heist

[sly sandal]

or they could make up a story that the bridge got blown up cause of heat between the two countries

[tidal cave]

i mean merge the time or move forward

[sly sandal]

tbh anything would work at that point

[sly sandal]

that'd be cool, but it could really only be available for one or two missions

not a whole area

[tidal cave]

yea people wouldnt fight the 'once in blue moon' content

[sly sandal]

yup

[void crow]

Hey guys I just started the story!

[tidal cave]

nice

[void crow]

It’s a very beautiful game!

[tidal cave]

indeed

itd be nice if the game alerted when you had stranger mission. i opened my map and saw a stranger mission. if ii hadnt i wouldve missed it

i mean like the ? ones

[proud cipher]

I hate npcs that have plot armor

like the final final mission

the sniper

so much plot armor

[tacit plover]

more plot armor than your average anime protagonist

[cyan night]

For the challenges that involve catching every type of fish or breaking every type of horse, does it count things you have already done prior to getting to those challenges? Or do you have to do them all again if you have already done that?

[tidal cave]

do you guys think the gang wouldve been fine if micah didnt join?

[primal knoll]

you guys ever come across that stranger who is eaten by wolves or something

and hes like help me help me

and you offer him medicine and he says in spanish "medicine?? im way past medicine!!"

thats what i did and he just dies

was i supposed to shoot him for good karma?

i dunno

you could also offer whiskey

[proud cipher]

loot him after he dies

and get minus honor

why can’t we loot dead people without having less honor

it’s dumb

and then when people shoot you first and you kill them

you lose honor

[tidal cave]

thats if you cause something that causes them to shoot

you can shoot and loot the damn odriscolls however you want

and the murfree broods

and the lemoyne raiders

[primal knoll]

was playin a lot of rdr2 last night, i get vivid dreams when i sleep, thought of this mission where u rob a bank with lenny and the law is chasing after you, but you get robbed by outlaws and you can choose to give the money or not give the money

few nights ago had the same dream where i just shot em but i got caught

last night i gave them the money and the law was like

oh u dont have the money

sorry wrong guy

[proud cipher]

the murfree broods annoying asf

[primal knoll]

they have decent loot tho

[proud cipher]

I never used food or tonics in story mode

all I ever used was health stuff

[tidal cave]

i kill them with the machete

[proud cipher]

never even used snake oil

[tidal cave]

with fortified health

[proud cipher]

can you use a potent health cure and become god for a little bit

and be immortal

[tidal cave]

i dont use them but always have everything stocked up

[tidal cave]

yea

[proud cipher]

lol

[tidal cave]

but take too much damage and itll go in a few seconds

[proud cipher]

oh

[tidal cave]

you guys use mods in rdr2?

[proud cipher]

no

[tidal cave]

im planning on using it on my second playthru

[proud cipher]

what kind of mods

[tidal cave]

like trainers and stuff or some script mods

i played gta 5 story -5%, with mods 95%

[tacit plover]

they have killed me with the machete

[tidal cave]

i saw em coming at me with a mechete once. so thats why i started killing them with machetes

[snow tree]

Yo guys Im trying to do the 100% rn and I did all the hunting requests you can do as Arthur, do all of the requests reset if I finish the game?

[tidal cave]

can you even catch the fish with hamish?

[lost pelican]

It's just for me that the game misses a lot of its magic in epilogue? I don't feel the same vibes with John

Still cool, but not fantastic like is with Arthur

[primal knoll]

did i just encoutner a prostitute?

"got any plans this evening?" she asks

yet my only two options were "decline" "reject" "rob"

da fuq rockstar

[tidal cave]

yea and i think reject gives you negative honor

[lost pelican]

Arthur doesn't like it and John is married hahaha

[tidal cave]

decline increase your honor

[lost pelican]

Don't antagonise prostitutes buddies

Antagonise the rats

Not literally the rats

[tidal cave]

now that you say it the first thing that comes to my mind is the eugenics supporter in saint denis. there is an officer just beside him but even if you beat the shit outta him no one cares

[lost pelican]

I shoot him one time and i got wanted, but not for beat or kidnapp him

[tidal cave]

and killing the kkk gives you positive honor

[lost pelican]

Indeed
People cares if you have a klan member in the horse back?

I never tried it

[cyan night]

Sorry I posted this already. For the challenges that involve catching every type of fish or breaking every type of horse, does it count things you have already done prior to getting to those challenges? Or do you have to do them all again if you have already done that?

Because if so, I'll just hold off on catching more fish/horses until I reach those challenges.

[lost pelican]

If you already did it will be counted

[primal knoll]

Sharpshooter 4 - Kill someone at 80 feet away with a tomahawk

?????????

how the fuck

[tidal cave]

lenny get the camera

trickshots maybe

anyone know about Isaac

[muted sierra]

The missions are giving me a gold medal even tho I did all of the requirments

[glad brook]

As it should.

[hidden moss]

Not hard

[cobalt chasm]

Game: Robbing trains can be extremely lucerative
The train: no freaking loot and 1 passenger to rob
The law: $1,200 bounty

And again I ask, what the hell is the point of wearing a mask if they can still tie bounties to me face while I'm wearing it

[primal knoll]

what the fuck

this is what i dont get about crimes in this game

3 o driscolls were talking shit in valentine, i 1v3 them with my fists

then i get arrested for unarmed assault

i didnt antagonize

just walked up and stared at em

maybe its because i was trying to see if i could carry their bodies to the sheriffs office?

[cobalt chasm]

yeah they don't like it when you pick up bodies

but again wearing the friggin mask should stop them from attaching the crimes to you

As it is, it's only purpose is letting you walk to a post officer to pay off your bounty without the law seeing you first

that and something you have to do in missions

[primal knoll]

i figure wearing a mask would be more reason to be reported than carrying someone who assaulted me to the sheriffs

yeah i just said fuck it and surrendered, was only $10 and didnt wanna raise it by killing lawmen

horse was stuck so couldnt run

also does changing clothes have any effect or is that heresay

[cobalt chasm]

The mask doesn't stop them from reporting you, it stops them from knowing who to report. Or at least, it should.

If you rob a bank and get into a shootout, wearing a mask won't make you invisible, but it should make it so they can't put a bounty on Arthur, because they don't know it's him.

[fluid cypress]

That is not a choice you play as John whatever happens

unfortunately

[cobalt chasm]

honestly, the mask, combined with the fact that self defense counts as murder, are my 2 biggest gripes with this game

[primal knoll]

quick question

so i picked up two side quests, the dinosuar one

and the rock carvings one

like, do they show up on my minimap or some shit at least?

how the hell am i gonna see rocks

[frigid cloud]

they glow in eagle eye

[primal knoll]

its mainly how they instantly recognize its arthur despite the mask

the cops i mean

[primal knoll]

damn thats it?

well im on my second playthrough and ive been using eagle eye every 10-20 seconds and looking around while riding my horse

so i guess it wont be too bad

is it a big glow like a legendary animal sign?

[frigid cloud]

yes

[primal knoll]

do gang camps respawn once you kill em

i dont wanna get to a point where i eradicated all the gangs

[tacit plover]

According to a discussion from the wiki, they respawn a few days after clearing them

[ebon roost]

Rdr is a rpg?

[arctic tinsel]

Not really

[drifting vapor]

Like the other guy said the people do respond there every few days but sadly u can only really raid the supplies once I've found

[primal knoll]

it can be for sure

@drifting vapor @tacit plover thanks guys

also i accidentally stabled my pack mule horse, is there any way to get him out?

used to take two horses hunting to carry more shit

[vivid fable]

bro i didnt knew the rdr2 is a prequel and i knew the endding of rdr1

whyyy

i need to play a game with another spoiler whyyy

i played rdr2 with knowing the ending and i need to play rdr1 arleady knowing what is gonnna happen whyy

[drifting vapor]

Hm so u want to have both of ur horses with u? I've never tried seeing if I could get another one out of stable to have 2 but try hitching the one horse in town and then walk over to the stable and get it out.

[primal knoll]

its way different dont worry

[drifting vapor]

No clue if it'll work as I've never tried it but I would think it might

[primal knoll]

yeah i usually hitch the other one in my camp

it works well for sure but i wanted to get like 3 horses lmao

didnt know if that was possible

anyway

you know how odriscolls have a hideout in the valentine doctor shop?

[drifting vapor]

Ya

[primal knoll]

i keep trying to just kill them and put my hands up against the sheriffs but they just shoot me

theyre not happy i killed gang members?

and it seems theres no escape from that room?

so i just have to shoot em

[vivid fable]

I think micah wasnt a rat

[drifting vapor]

Ya there's no escape besides out the front.

[vivid fable]

He had so many chances to sell gang to cops but he didnt

[drifting vapor]

I have tried using throwing knives tho to hurry out the front so that there's not as many cops to shoot

[primal knoll]

hmm alright

gonna get a fat bounty

and i dont have the ability to bribe hector and alden

id do that in ch3 and just make $150+ each time from also selling the stagecoach to emerald ranch

but rn im pretty poor (taking my time with the missions)

[drifting vapor]

Whenever there's a chance to make a good sum of money at one time through criminal deeds, rockstars automatically gonna try and give u a bounty

[drifting vapor]

He wasn't till at the end

[vivid fable]

I mean playing game knowing whats gonna happen is fricking sad, and sooilering myself the next part is just horrible

[drifting vapor]

He didn't want to sell the gang out at first

He wanted to get that blackwater money and run but Dutch didn't listen to him so he sold the gang out for freedom and to get the money

[vivid fable]

Wait

He became the rat in end of guarma didnt he?

[ivory oracle]

apparently right when they got back from Guarma

[vivid fable]

So there was a mission where they killed cornwall

[drifting vapor]

Ya ig being stranded on Guarma was the last straw for him

[ivory oracle]

yes and no it depends dutch shot him in the lower chest so he could be alive in a hospital

Or something

Or just dead

[vivid fable]

And where ross and the other guy (pinkertons) get away dutch told micah to go ged documents and he had easy chance to go to them but he didnt and he got the documents

[drifting vapor]

Nah its confirmed he died

[vivid fable]

Yeah

[ivory oracle]

alr cool

[vivid fable]

U get his revolver

He stays where he was shot

Can i send a link to a video with proof he wasnt a rat

[drifting vapor]

Sure I'll give it a watch. I dont think u can send links tho so put a space somewhere in the link so it'll send

[vivid fable]

Space

Ok

http s://youtu.be/An3TiutcWg4

Bro and how did the athur got tb

[drifting vapor]

From that sick charity guy spitting on him when Arthur was tryna get that loan back for Mr Strauss

[vivid fable]

What if you wont do that mission

[drifting vapor]

It's required

[vivid fable]

But other missions can be skipped

[drifting vapor]

Some can, that one can't

U can only go so far in the story before none other pop up

And I watched the video and got the gist of the ideas he was saying. It's a lot of thought but a lot of his ideas do have a counter point

Micah isn't gonna sell out Dutch and Arthur at the Cornwall meeting because he wants to know where the money is still

He doesn't just want freedom, freedom is just the backup plan

Also he brings up it'd be dumb to invite the Pinkerton to the top of the mountain in epilogue. No he was trying to collect Dutchs bounty

[vivid fable]

Micah is one of the best antagonists in games

[drifting vapor]

Oh no doubt I've said it before. Hes probably my favorite

[vivid fable]

My favorite antagonists are micah carver from twd s2 and joseph seed from fc5

Carver has micah in himself i dont know how to explain it

And joseph is just fantastic character

[reef dust]

Ah shit just joined this server and got spoiled in 5 seconds

[vivid fable]

Magic of spoilers

Very sorry

I got the same

Kraul i hope youll still enjoy the game like i did when i was spoiled

[vivid fable]

Still here?

[drifting vapor]

Tbf that line itself isn't much of a spoiler

[vivid fable]

The rest of it

[drifting vapor]

Micah is an arsehole from pretty much day 1

[vivid fable]

Do you know far cry t

5

[drifting vapor]

I've heard about it but I've never played it

[vivid fable]

It's super game

My favorite

The story

Do you know whats best in far cry series

You cant spoil yourself

You know you will kill main antagoinst

Also whats your fav character from rdr2

[fluid cypress]

Nahhh you still don’t know that he’ll be the main antagonist

i thought it was gon be Milton or Cornwall or something like that

[drifting vapor]

We never called him main

We just said antagonist

[fluid cypress]

we’ll still calling him an antagonist just basically says a lot of other things abt the twist itself

[drifting vapor]

Hmm that's tough

[fluid cypress]

Bill was quite and an asshole too imo and I expected him to do something cuz he was an antagonist in rdr1 aswell but welp

[vivid fable]

Main antagonist is gavin

[drifting vapor]

Gavin? Has anyone seen Gavin? GAVIN!

[vivid fable]

I enjoyed the fight with gavin

He is a iconic character from the story

[primal knoll]

are wild horses good for anything

[drifting vapor]

Being a hunting partner ig

And there are some wild horses that some people like

[vivid fable]

I had my arabian white horse sydney but she died cause of fird

Fire

[primal knoll]

you can tame em? damn

dont need a saddle for them to carry shit?

[drifting vapor]

Ya the white Arabian is a popular one

[drifting vapor]

U didnr know that? And I mean ride on ur main horse and then just put animal hides and stuff on the wild tamed horse

Ride it around a bit first so it becomes ur temporary horse tho

[vivid fable]

I dont know what tame means i am from poland can you explain the word

Like get horse to main horse?

[wary oasis]

(of an animal) not dangerous or frightened of people; domesticated.
"the fish are so tame you have to push them away"

Means they're relaxed around humans

[wary oasis]

Find it in the wild then tame it and put your saddle on it

[vivid fable]

Ahh

Okay

Also why was strauss kicked from gang because i was shocked what arthur has done, like i got to the leopod and boom arthur kicks him out

[wary oasis]

CH6?

[vivid fable]

What

[vagrant saffron]

They're asking if you're in chapter 6 of the game

[vivid fable]

I ended the game

Its been few weeks

[primal knoll]

bruh

is it possible for me to hide in the black water region at all as arthur

i killed like 50+ lawmen and have been duckin in the trees

only thing that made em stop for a while was when i hogtied a survivor and carried him

but then they just headshot me so i had to drop him lol

i forget how i got to this mission where u rescue sean

[hidden moss]

Is there anyway to get the dark bay Andalusian early in chapter 2, I know some breeds you can find on bounty hunters so I just want to see

[wary oasis]

I guess yes then lol?

[wary oasis]

Not without mods

There is the invisible sort of sniper that pissed everyone off in Guarma too.

[wary oasis]

That's in Chapter 2

[primal knoll]

yeah beat it last time

i remember sneaking in no problem first playthrough but i just died a few times

[wraith panther]

ngl saving people and immediately killing them is pretty lit

[cobalt chasm]

There's a few of the mini-interactions in this game I'm really not sure I understand the point of

[wary oasis]

I tried a couple of times, for the horseman 9 challenge and gave up until the epilogue.

[wary oasis]

What like?

[cobalt chasm]

In Saint Denis there's one where you see a cop knockout a criminal and the only thing you can really do to interact is antagonize the cop, which starts a brawl and sets all the law in the area on you, plus like $5 bounty for every cop you knockout

[wary oasis]

Some things are teasers and just plain random

Some just mini stories in the game

[wary oasis]

With reference to police brutality maybe

[cobalt chasm]

I suppose

But the "best" case for Arthur in that situation is to ignore it so I don't know that it highlights the issue particularly well

I can't just shoot every lawman in the town

[rugged path]

So i got the tip about the Aberdeem Pig Farm home robbery, but it does not show up on my map... Can someone explains how this works?

[wary oasis]

It's a stranger mission so you just need to go to it.

[rugged path]

but how do i know where it is?

[wary oasis]

It lies north of Pleasance and northeast of Lonnie's Shack, very close to the border with Roanoke Ridge

Check fandom

You won't see the name on the map until you've been to it...

Same with most shacks and cabins etc

[rugged path]

ow nvm i now have the option in the camp to rob it with S

[wary oasis]

Can't remember if it's a robbery mission

I just remember it being a stranger mission where you can also get money

[drifting vapor]

Different house

The pig farm if I recall right is southeast of emerald ranch

[wary oasis]

Yeah I don't think they're referring to the Pig Farm lol

[drifting vapor]

I mean they mentioned it by name

[wary oasis]

Yeah

[primal knoll]

man chewing tobacco literally makes you invincible

just genocided blackwater

[wary oasis]

Yeah but not for long

[primal knoll]

been like a half hour haha

[wary oasis]

lol