#red-dead-singleplayer
1 messages · Page 535 of 1
And the Braithwaite gold is under the floorboard
After the manor burns down you can nab it
Well ya but it's only one gold bar isn't it?
Ye but that’s like 500 bucks
Not much for a,big plantation
Also I wonder how Charles knew where Arthur's body was
The Braithwaites especially haven't been doing too well with "the new labor laws"
Unless the help John ending isn't Canon
Idk actually
I think Charles is just a g and he looks everywhere
Probably just followed the corpses
But in my ending he found me back at camp
He must be. Cause thatd be weird that he would even know Arthur was dead
Dead eyes looking up at the sun
Well he knew it was coming, and surely a big bust like that one wouldn't be quiet
Ya that's y I would think that ending would be more Canon since Charles finds him but I also couldn't see them wanting Arthur to be seen that way
I'm sure when he heard the Pinkertons had come and scattered the gang at last he assumed the worst
The Pinkertons you mean?
I feel like the honourable help John ending is canon
I meant since Charles buries him
But Charles is like amazing at tracking
I do too but I'm just saying since somehow Charles buried him
I prefer honorable revenge
It makes sense why Micah missed every time he shot at John in the cutscene
And the fight... oh man that fight is just godly in high honor
Has that ethereal wailing in the music like in the Braithwaite manor fight
My first time through the story I somehow got the lucky ending of helping John and dying somewhat peacefully
I had low honor throughout most of it
I actually like low honor helping John
You know what's coming
You take the headshot like a champ
Arthur doesn't blink
Good point
And then Micah laughs like a maniac as he copes and seethes because you weren't salty or begging
The only one I hate is the stab ending, I feel it's such a crappy death for Arthur.
Yeah that one has a great line tho
"You let him damn us all Dutch!"
In high honor going back for the muneh to fight Micah makes sense
Sticking with John, you're a much bigger target for the Pinkertons
You split and make the biggest noise you can, John will make it
And Micah can pay for what he did to your family
And it fits the whole cycle of revenge that nobody escapes from
Arthur always said revenge is a fools game and a luxury he couldn’t afford
And yet he goes along with literally every revenge plan
Hell, he says yes to hitting Bronte
Colm
Sadie and the O'Driscoll's last stand
Every time
What Arthur portrays himself as and what he does r different
Arthur says that and does it anyway
Micah's betrayal I feel would send him right off the edge
Those aren’t really his revenges tho I feel like. Like going after bronte was all Dutch really arthur is just loyal to the gang
Maybe, but if he felt so strongly he'd be opposing them
He'd sit it out
I mean remember that Arthur tells Dutch had they just followed hosea plan in blackwater, they would've been fine. Yet throughout the story he always joins Dutch side even when hosea disagrees
Because loyalty
Arthur is a somewhat shitty person imo until his tb diagnosis
Look at it this way
In that ending
Arthur goes for revenge, he pays for it
Then John goes for revenge, later pays for it
Jack goes for revenge, and what happens next...?
It's a cycle is what I'm sayin
Also
I'm all on board with Arthur being low honor till the diagnosis
Have your fun then become a good boy
Yeah that’s what I mainly did
Imagine if instead of making a,typical rdr3 they made a spinoff that connected rdr and the gta styles through jack
Though I also headcanon hard that Arthur's fear is a lack of control
And violent situations are the only moments he feels like he has life by the reigns
So low honor makes a lot of sense as things go to hell
See I want to go further back and play as Hosea
Also I’d love to see what happens with Jack after he kills ross but also i hope the next red dead instalment is a compete new set of characters way earlier in the deep heart of the Wild West
I do too. I've always thought a gta5 style where we get Dutch hosea and someone else potentially Arthur as playable characters would be cool
Hosea is such a thoughtful man but
He has a heart of ice in many moments
Was a real bastard in his time
Did a lot of bad things
His only regret?
That he learned what he did at such a price
"Ain't childbirth the most beautiful miracle? It seems a woman can give birth to monkeys after all!"
Even he had to snap since she had kidnapped a child
Ye
The line I like most from that mission tho?
It's a repeat
And yeah a gta5 style character swap would be cool for red dead
"It doesn't matter how we got here!"
Every time something goes wrong, Dutch says something like that
Yea Dutch kinda crazy and seems like he makes it up as he goes along and talks all fancy
I should check on old Evelyn Miller
He seems to be having a rough time of it these days
Every time John opens that barn I get chills
Same damn animation
Arthur's a bit like him in that respect. Can't remember which mission it was in chapter 2 or 3, but Bill mentions how if Arthur does something wrong, it's no big deal but when someone else does, suddenly they r the camp idiot
Although a lot of those times Arthur is forced into a conflict because he was just around
Yeah in chapter 3, I think before the bank heist if I remember correctly
To be fair, Bill is a prize idiot
But sometimes even the prize idiot brings in a solid take
Valentine was all by the numbers too
Get in, hit the bank hard, get out
Everything we wished the Lemoyne National had been
I love how Arthur and sadie can somehow take out a whole town of Pinkerton in van horn yet we can't escape st Denis after the bank robbery besides by boat
Clearly we just didn’t try hard enough
Although then again
That was a small town with no law to speak of
Saint Denis had Pinkertons, Cops, and any citizen with a gun and money in that bank looking to help out
I mean if Charles outran them I don't see how the gang couldn't have
Too many people perhaps
That and upon first playing that I fully expected Charles would be at the end of a rope for pulling that stunt
Maybe. Idk I just love trying to think of what if it didn't have to be the ending it ended up being. I mean that gold plus the money already saved up couldve gotten them on a boat somewhere nice I'm sure
I think the plan should’ve been to hop a ship immediately after robbing the bank
See the point of divergence I see for that robbery not going to shit is going after Bronte
Two whole missions of delaying action
Maybe if they’d struck a day or two after the trolley station debacle the gang could have slipped away
Probably. I'm sure the killing of Bronte didn't help them hide from the Pinkerton too well
So it’s all on Arthur for voting to deal with Bronte
Well, he’s the lynchpin of that decision anyhow
What it did most for the Pinkertons was it bought them time to be ready
Ofc. Like I said earlier Arthur hates on Dutch plans but instead of voting for hosea, he always goes for Dutch
Maybe they had some strength there already
Maybe Bronte let em know
But wasting at least a couple days on Bronte sinks the ship
I think perhaps Milton caught hosea before the explosion also and let it happen so that he could trap the gang in there
Probably more likely it happened right after
He bought Abigail time to run after all
They only nabbed Hosea
Well
I think I've done almost all I care to in this game
Aside from some missing dreamcatchers, exotics, and whichever table game I havent played, along with 30 challenges, there isn't much left
I'll check on Mr. Miller and maybe go visit the graves, then call it done and hit the next one
Why do my guns get dirty so quick?
Is it something to do with where I travel or something?
when i press f on the train robbing mission, nothing happens when i try to break free and i die
anyone got solutions?
You probably always use them. Always carry enough gun oils to clean them up.
Aw shit. So I have to do the fish for 100%
Fish, exotics, one table game (idk) which, and 30 more challenges
And I'd be at 100%
I think I'm good with 95% for now.
Probably on purpose...
Well I may not get to play RDR1 now!
My console won’t boot
And I’m flat broke so
Wow. That really grinds my gears
Here I was all stoked to play RDR and a faulty power supply or something ruins the plan
Here’s the real question now
Am I desperate enough for something to do to wipe my save file and play RDR2 again?
Is RDR1 available for PC?
Nope I don’t think so
….I gotta do it man
There’s fuck all else to play in my RDR future
So here goes 300 hours and 95.8% completion. Watch it go.
I trade it all to be Mr. Morgan again.
Yikes
The strongest choices require the strongest of wills
And sacrificing my gameplay upon the altar shall set the clock back 8 years and resurrect all that we’ve lost
Still got 4.2% to go and it’ll probably take ya the same amount of time it took for the first 95.8% 😂
Oh you know it
Those exotics will be the death of me
But it’ll be faster this time around
Everything I did imma do better
I hated that I missed an animal in guarma on my first playthrough so I couldn’t 100%
I don’t think Guarma critters count for 100%
You just need to have studied some amount of all animals
I thought they did, I must have missed something else then
Unless you were trying for the full compendium
I was
Ahh
This time I’ll see if I can bug my way into New Austin
All for the Gila Monster skin
You know whatd be dope
An entire chapter dlc based on the gang in Blackwater
Meeting micah
Prologue
Although
I’d buy that shit
I kinda like never seeing how Blackwater goes down
Well arthur didn’t really
Having it left ambiguous is kinda fun
He wasn’t on the boat
All we know is Dutch killed a girl and she died bad
Yea
See I think Micah was snitching even then
But like we still wouldn’t know what was happening cause Arthur doesn’t even know
My theory for Micah is he intentionally found Dutch and wanted to try get his reward
Cause at micahs camp near strawberry there’s a wanted poster for Dutch
So there is…
And the Colm thing to me 100% felt like he was working with em
Tried to sell out Arthur
Yeah he was imo
Take his place as #3 in the gang
Milton claims Micah only snitched after guarma but I reckon he has been in talks with everyone since the start
1-4 Micah is firmly trying to break the pillars of the gang down
Yeah I dunno if we can take Milton on his word on that
That, and maybe he means they now have a tighter hold on him than before
Could be he’d been an informant but now he’s their inside man
Yeh could be
So satisfying
It’d have been dope if Arthur had bit off his trigger finger too but we can’t have everything
Human teeth can sever fingers. We’ve got the bite force
I’m just sad the papers don’t have Blind Eyed Micah
Yea just gotta have the actual will to do it
Some psychological thing
Same thing that stops us biting off our tongues n shit
Well in a fight to the death all bets are off
But maybe Arthur just didn’t fight like his life mattered
I mean he had been suffering from tb
If arthur was healthy Micah wouldn’t have stood a chance
he knew he was gonna die so i’m assuming he just gave up
That’s Micah’s thing actually
He preys on the weak
He taunts Swanson when he’s deep into his sickness and Hosea during his coughing fits, anyone he sees as weak in some way
Which becomes Arthur
lollll
I just wanna get an opinion from other people. I find it easier to explore the open world with John cause the main story is basically finished and the objective of the story is basically just to get your wife to come back to you. All of the little activities and sidequest feel more “in place” when you are not doing them in a life or death situation according to the story or if the story is about having to do something quickly.
Does that make sense?
Yea I agree
I prefer arthur as a character but definitely easier to get around as john
And there’s more to explore
yeah I agree too
When I do that as John a quiet voice in the back of my head says this is why Jack has abandonment issues
Like tall trees is probably my favourite place to explore based on random incidents purely cause the skinner brothers
They the most interesting gang imo
I start feeling guilty for being out in the world for weeks
it’s also nice having john finishing the side missions for arthur
Yea like the dinosaur one
But….
I want my Gila monster panther gloves…….
It makes me so sad Arthur never got to wear em
I like the time traveler side mission
He never got to experience the full death roll set despite making all of it except the gloves
Time traveler is very fun
I really wish rockstar would add some of the online customisation options to story
You can just see the gears in Arthur’s head turning as he tries to figure it out at the end
So I’ve heard you can get to New Austin during the mission for Angelo Bronte
Where you kill the grave robbers
Oh really?
Well, I’m going to try it and see
Good luck that’s a long ride
But… if I came home with a perfect Gila monster skin…
That’s all I want
And maybe Otis Miller’s revolver
Dutch: well you took your time
Hey when y’all explore different towns do you change your outfit to sort of blend in or is that just me
Nope
Like in st denis I’ll dress fancy
Ah. There’s the catch
omg yeah lol
Yea and if I go out hunting I’ll put on mostly trapper gear
Please dont spoil anything but do you get a fair amout of money with john by playing the story?
But the best suit is the Whittemore hands down
Yes
Thans
def
Plenty. I did bounty hunting that I left behind
You can actually get the suit
It’s secretly stored on your horse if there’s space
And from there you just need to save it as a custom thing. Add a hat and suddenly you keep your good suit.
I like most of em
The one with Mark Johnson hits close to home
I really like the hat you can make with the legendary bear skin
I made a really cool bounty Hunter outfit using the agency belt that glitches after the colm hanging mission
If you go shirtless with that thing you look like a caveman.
that’s the best look
Or the panther poncho
the bison one looks pretty cool too
I love the panther poncho
It looks so warm and cozy
But it’s hard to keep it on in chapter 4
Yeah it’s a west Elizabeth/ambarino based item imo
Horseshoe is probably my favourite camp
It’s the most nostalgic
Where I discovered I loved the game
I got rdr2 as a birthday present in 2018 and I had never heard of it before at all. I was debating to even play it I wasn’t that into cowboys or the Wild West but damn after the first mission I was hooked.
Yeah a very pleasant surprise
surprised it didn’t win GOTY
I have since yeah
It was harder to enjoy cause of the obvious decrease in graphics and shit but still a really good story
And a great game
he ded
It's truly much easier to do things as John. In a gameplay sense, he is a family man and has no true life or death struggles in his travels.. And never did, honestly.
The catch is the game punishes you for it
you don't want to draw anything you can find as Arthur
he literally draws like dogshit lmao
hard to read his writing, as well
nor does he say much.. he's rather non- introspective
Ngl I like restarting
The first fight I went hog wild
Almost died bc no health anymore but I charged in, tackled a man, and shot him right in the face
After blowing his buddies away before Micah or Dutch could draw
If I am wanted dead or alive and surrender to the police do I lose all my money? Or only the amount I have as a bounty?
I think you lose a bit ye
I kinda need help in optimizing the best settings for RDR2 on my PC.. I know most of the settings but I need an expert to ask about some things regarding performance
im gonna get it now, its on sale for like 12 bucks i recon it will be worth it. I trust rockstar
Definitely worth 12 bucks
yeah i recon
yeah the second one was just stunning, i have high hopes
i sure will
ill probably finnish gtav first because for some god forsaken reason i havent played it
I’d still buy it while it’s cheap
12 bucks? What an insult
But good bargain
They don't come together in pc?

Idk
I think they're supposed to be together, but I've had it for such a long time that I forgot
Yea, I remember buying it for Christmas 2 years ago
How is it? I haven't played online in forever
In relation to content i mean
I remember struggling to get gold
Well there is double money and xp on bounties and moonshiner
And getting killed real quick lol
Yea lol
Tbh I was being annoying at the time 
Thats 
Omg they can kill ur horse?
Yea but not permanent
Lol what
As long as you have insurance
Your horse comes back
Rockstar got horse necromancer on standby 🤣
You are a goose
No u


I need help
I just found some pig farm couple the brother and sister, so anyway I accidentally killed the brother but the sister killed me, I returned. To the house after I respawned but the guys body was gone and the sister was gone too, does she return?
Wait like did you sit down for dinner with them?
Nope, if u kill them they don't respawn
Absolutely 💯
Yea, but its so immersive
Specially with wildlife
A few weeks ago I found some Indians on the Mexico side of the river
But that's just detail
Not a spoiler btw
KKona
Hello guys

No I kinda just went upstair to check on her then came down pulled a gun then shot the guy then the lady stabbed me and I died
Erm did you lose all your money?
Cause you may have ruined a really cool/interesting interaction
So , I'm trying to make Arthur a good guy through out the whole story and even in the world of RDR but I like to harm people who don't give respect when I'm asking for a ride, so I tie them up and drag them on the ground while I ride my horse. will that effect Arthur's reputation? 
I mean no one is watching
I only lost about 18 bucks I still have 300
If you don’t kill them and sit down to dinner with them they drug you, rob you and dump you in a pit with another corpse
And then you can back and get sweet revenge
Bro. Ned and Peter ending up together was such a smart move for representation, and it’s so good that they’ve listened to Andrew Garfield who wanted Spider-Man to be bisexual
When u complete main story line, how many percent u will be at?
Probably like 50
For example in gta v, when u complete main story u are at 60%
Or less
And animals
But thats weird i am in half of chapter 2 and i am already at 20% 🤔
No one can give u an actual answer
Why?
It depends on how much you've done during the main storyline. Some people do more some do less
But u do all main story missions to complete the main story no?
You cant just skip a mission
Yes but I'm talking about outside of missions. No one usually does all the missions without accomplishing some other things
Or maybe if u have unlocked a mission which will finish a chapter and u have a few main story missions still active then technically u will skip them? @drifting vapor
U can't skip any actual storyline missions. Like I said no one usually just completes all the missions without doing other things. Hunting, side missions, activities etc will all change what percent u finish at
So even if i hunt some new animal not in mission or do some random event it will add some percentage?
Yes. It may not be a lot but it adds up and changes what u finish at
Aight thanks for answering
#red-dead-media love beechers hope
I’d take it slow and do all the side missions as they come up because some are only available for that specific chapter
how do i make wolf skin or any animal have poor palet
On purpose? Shot it anywhere but the head.
Is it worth to do it?
Because some side missions can be boring i know that from other games
when rescuing sean did anyone else just stop to watch charles' machete fight
The side missions are actually really entertaining.
Yeh defs worth it, sure some are more interesting than others but all are good fun
I managed to actually headshot the guy Charles was fighting once, it was pretty funny to see tbh.
i had every chance to headshot him, i just wanted to see how the fight panned out
Am bored in rdr2 whats something fun to do in free roam
Why?
Use the right weapon and shoot it in the head
I always have clean shaven Arthur, mainly because I like Hosea’s look
does anyone know something about save editor?
I have played the game since release and didnt know that the m1899 pistol was in the game..
i wonder if abigail would react if i antagonized jack in front of her
Probably not, but that would be funny.
If you target a animal, and study it, you'll then be able to get to look at info about it, which will tell you how to preform a Clean Kill. That shouldn't harm the animals pelt.
80% - 90% depends on how much missions u do
perfect alligator skin sells for $3.50 i believe?
bro yall know how everyone likes to talk about lenny and arthurs drunk scene but what about john, uncles and charles drunk scene? it makes me laugh very much yes
That is a good scene, if it didn't end so badly.
The LeMat is a god tier gun
No
You cannot convince me otherwise
And in black metal and gold with pearl handle and gold engraving, I disagree on it not looking good
I don’t care how good it looks
Shotgun revolver
Enough said
It’s so bad
It’s perhaps the best revolver
Sawed of shotgun duel wield with volcanic pistol
Better
More satisfying
Nah. Get two LeMats and you have enough
Your about to give me fatal lumbago
Think about it. You’ve now got 2 shotgun shells and 18 shots.
Even if you miss you can’t miss
Honestly I just hate the reload
Eh. That’s the other half of having two
One runs dry and I just swap to the second one
I have a mod that removes duel wield
If I haven’t bought time by then to reload the fight can’t be won
Lancaster is good while it lasts, the one Micah gives you
Or you can get it in Rhodes
But then the bolt action shows up
I love the bolt action
You can get it in chapter 2 early
Where
Go cattle rustling with uncle in chapter 4
The farmer has a Carcano rifle that isn’t worn
Ahh
I’ve completed the game but chapter 2 is my favourite
Volcanic is honestly so sexy
If you use it with sawed off in duel wield its so much fun
Also using 2 of them is a camp clearing machine
I just like my hard hitting wheelguns
Slugs
Semiauto shotgun is the best tho
An early semiauto in chapter 2 is godly tho
Watson cabin
😼
Cattleman revolver is a lot of fun to use ngl
I hate getting low scores on the first mission in the game
When I shoot most of em then charge in and break up the O’Driscolls from the cabin
And bronze. Game doesn’t reward having fun.
I’m going to be honest I don’t give a shit about game scores
Also I won’t be able to type for the next half hour because my dad wakes up for work and my lazy ass has to pretend to be asleep
rip
when donating to the camp, should it be $20 or $20.01? Not sure whats the minimum to hit the most honor bracket
go with 3000 just to play it safe (sarcasm)
20$ is the best in term of money efficiency
I mean the one cent makes a difference between getting medium amount of honour or high amount
well, 20$ is the cap for the max honor you can get each time you donate
for example
donating 20 $ = donating 100$
in terms for honors
well if you are short on money you can try fishing
kk thank you
also, are horses that are tamed and found in the wild considered stolen or stable purchased?
can confirm my dad has left for work
now time to play RDR2
Quick question, does anyone else check RDR2mods.com or Nexusmods.com
to see if new mods come out
every day
I hate when stuff like this happens
no game will be perfect tho
Are there some fences that buy items for more than others
Always sell to Saint Denis fence
he buys for way more than fence at Rhodes.
He is also right next to trapper so do a legendary animal on the way if you feel like it
or get ingredients for trinket
My Arthur has red eyes i dont know why I thought it was from no sleep but he it’s has not changed do any of you know why?
Thank you so much
Same price, the biggest draw is just his proximity to a trapper.
you... Have paid attention to the sell prices, right
gold watches are 10$, platinum are 12$
silver are 8$, no matter where you buy each of them
Will say 40% off a horse at Sant Denis with the honor and mayor discount IS a good deal though lol
You can get struck by lighting?
Guys what’s best way to get money after ending the epilogue?
Ik we start off with a huge amount but I mean when that starts to get low
I'm just needing the californian horned owl to get zoologist achievement
it can be see in the sky?
You can solve the treasure maps and get meteor fragments
Also some special items like tsantsa and female fertility statue makes a lot of money when sold
Hunt animals with huge pelts helps a lot if you get a perfect one
The bear pelt for example 7,50
You can sell stole wagons too
Some wagons worth like 50
@craggy sand train robberies can have ludicrous amounts of money from robbing the passengers and the safes that you need dynamite to open there's a lot of tutorials on YouTube to make sure you don't get a bounty and to make sure you get a passenger train with lots of people instead of a cargo train
How do I quickly get rid of premium cigarettes
Discard it or start to smoke frantically hahahaha
Ok
so i’m starting the story for the second time, and i did most of the game on story mode. any tips to make sure it’s not boring?
Explore, explore well
For sure you will find something that you didn't saw at first
i got everything done, map fully explored the only thing i missed were some of the challenges
will i still find more?
Yeah you will, trust me hahaha
Thanks for the tip lmao
Finding the story for the 2nd time (a year later) boring atm and its chapter 2
chapter 1 is so much fun tho ngl
How many hrs you got in rdr2?
So far 220hrs
Close to it, or much longer hahaha
haha yeah I wouldnt be surprised
I do hope rockstar make rdr3 with alot more free roam content but the game also makes you realise thats all you want, more free roam content.
Why do I have a prisoner who tried escaping in rhodes and and I cant turn him in?
Lmao
Someone was probably walking by and got spooked.
You can only fast travel from camp?
You can do it from both camps and campfires
So when i want to fast travel i just build a campfire?
Yes as long as you have horse
What chapter are you in?
Horseshoe overlook
You will need to do camp upgrades first
I just started
I just bought map for arthur
But what now?
Tagged you in #red-dead-media
Ok ty
Go find a camp fire
Does it matter if I explore NA as JM at all before American Venom?
Not same price
The guy at Rhodes buys gold bars for 300 whereas the guy at Saint Denis buys gold for 500
@atomic flame. Never knew.
I now have to save micah for fuck sake
From Strawberry?
How do you get the Cornwall oil wagon there’s too many people
Nvm but yeah thats what I thought
I mean hes saved but sitting back atm
Its the 2nd stage
Id rather leave him there
Yes conversations with NPCs is different
But story missions aren't too different, right?
When I start playing again I wanna start Arthur off with lowish honor, cause I feel like he wouldn't be the best guy
Ya ride, just FUCKING GUN IT
Try to get behind a hill so you dont get blown up
If all else fails
Steal the one in valentine
Get behind a hill so you dont get shot at and then blow up*
Just wait for them to get out.
Kill everyone, works everytime.
Or you could shoot near the wagon with an rifle from some hill and the horses should run away from the factory.
when will sadie ask me for the harmonica? I already have it and i did the mission with her a few hours ago when she spoke about it
She normally asks about in the mission where you go shopping with Sadie. But I believe she might ask in camp for it.
I think she actually asked for it in Horseshoe overlook. I don't know if she was supposed to ask for it that early,but she did ask for it on my third play through.
Simply not true.
No it is
I don't document photos of selling gold incase someone calls me out on it
Not bar
Gold Bar
sells for 300 at rhodes
500 at saint dneis
Nope
Never
No reason to sell at Rhodes anyhow
Did yall kill Jimmy Brooks?
Personally I do, I like to play Arthur as someone with anger issues, and who tends to get violent easily
That's how I see him tho lmao
I would kill him, but he has an fine pen.
You can’t loot it off his dead corpse?
I didn't get the pen when I tried to loot him.
anybody know if the principals vest provides warmth?
Does it matter if I explore NA as JM at all before American Venom?
No.
I doubt anything changes in NA after that mission.
Cheers
Someone mentioned something to me before that you can't play as canon if you go further south than Thieves Landing
That was me. and I was just being Nit Picky, since John says he has never been down there, in RDR1.
I feel like the epilogue was just rushed. Sadie and Charles just left so quick.
Yes you're right since RDR1 starter was Armadillo
John skinned Arthur's body and hair.
I'm about to do American Venom and I think Charles has gone already
Nah, Charles ain't leaving before that mission.
Yeah, you don't even really say good bye to them, technically, just see them in the credits enjoying the wedding, then gone.
Guess I'll find out
There should have been an side mission with the both of them.
Or at least a little mini-scene like you get with Tilly, Rains Fall and such, where you see them leave... Or some such.
Yeah, that would work aswell.
Like, Find Sadie in Blackwater about to catch a boat, or Charles in Valentine and he leaves in a wagon for Canada.
I also think Karen should have been mentioned in the end. It's pretty unknown what the hell she did, but maybe drank herself to death.
Tilly's letter she mails to you mentions what she thinks happens to Karen, but yeah, that's a vaguery.
Yeah.
It's just kind of lonely after American Venom.
You just got Abigail, Jack and Uncle.
... and Rufus. But, yes, compared to the Chapter 2-4 Gang Camps, it's rather boring to hang around Beecher's Hope.
Or upgrade stuff at all, That was a rather enjoyable mechanic they just kind of droped.
Mhm.
It would also be kind of cool if Pinkertons would show up when you're riding somewhere and ask questions like "Are you John Marston?"
Ha ha, that would be rather funny. "No, sir, I'm Jim Milton."
"Rip van Winkle!"
Answer depending on your honor.
Low honor would be Rip Van Winkle and high honor will be Jim.
It's also disappointing that we don't hear shit from Dutch after American Venom.
Same goes for Bill and Javier.
Sort of makes a bit of sense, I'm sure they took a bit of time to get their stuff set up. It was years later that RDR1's events happen.
Meh, I guess.
Bill's gang is hold up in Fort Mercer, and in the Epilogue it's a Del Lobo strong hold. So....
Yeah.
But I feel like we should hear atleast something from Dutch, because like John said, he's an colorful character.
If I remember correctly, that was followed by him saying something along the lines of “he may not be so colorful anymore”
Perhaps he takes a few to get started too, You kind of have to assume the 'Free Roam' stuff after American Venom doesn't really actually move time.
Or that was Sadie
Dutch and his plans.
Imagine his new gang in RDR1 going to rob the blackwater bank.
"One more bank, fellers!"
"One more Dutch.."
Ooh, it would be cool if you stayed around an gang camp for long, the Pinkertons would come to investigate the place.
And if they saw you, you either have to talk your way out or shoot your way out.
Well, that does happen in Chapter 5, when you get back to Shady Belle, after Guarma. a Bunch of Pinkertons show up.
Yes, there being random encounters with them, would be neat as well.
Pinkertons just are nonexistent after chapter 6.
I literally felt some funny feeling in chapter 6's last mission when Ross shouted "This is the Pinkertons, put your guns down, nOw"
It's like an badass feeling.
Pffft, Pinkertons, thinking they are cool. Like I can be scared of something with Pink in their name?
A bit, but it's certainly not scary though.
Grayertons... Eh, whatever.
Yes, but, money is kind of easy enough as it is. I actually think Train robbing should be harder... or something.
Agreed.
Sisika could have been used, because its just there in the epilogue.
Like, if you got arrested in Lemoyne and have an big bounty, you will end in Sisika.
There is a legendary fish on that island, but yeah, would be funny if you get to the $1000+ bounties, they toss you into Sisika, and is a difficult break out mission at that point.
Would be hilarious when you break out of there, you see Uncle with his boat waiting. "There you are boah!"
Yeap, yeap, or Abigail with a boat, all pissed.
I doubt Abigail would do it but I wouldn't be suprised if she did help.
It also would be nice to see the guy that we used an shield in Sisika as Arthur.
He would remember John and possibly shit his pants near him.
You're kind of limited on "Gang" allies, like Arthur had. So... It's Uncle, or..... Kind of would be funny if Jack was waiting there.
Jack and Rufus!
Rufus rowing the boat.
Hi
How long have y’all been playing for?
Couple of months.
Oh cool!
Evening. Almost 2 years, but rather sporaticly.
Oh wow
Just, like, laying in the street?
I got the zoologist trophy, i'm so happy 💕
And there only a few left animals to complete the skin trophy
Noice
I got 100% in my first playthrough
i'm really proud of myself for that one
I did use a guide for things that you have to do in certain missions
Anybody that has completed the game wanna chat? Preferably somebody that’s on ps4 and has a mic
Hello sir
Ok you gotta go
Everyone knows the best character is Josiah Trelawny
Pearson.
Second.
I'll hear u out tbh. Dk if ur serious but I could see having Micah as ur favorite
Micah's an asshole to everyone
licks dutches ass
betrays the gang
Kills Arthur depending on honour
Honestly dont get people who hate Bill and Javier.
Bill is funny and Javier is cool too
I think it's mainly due to their betrayal of Arthur
I just really really hate Micah
None of what you said here is wrong but he is a rather well built up character. His character was the perfect fulfillment of it imo
His only positive is his cool gun scene when sean dies
They weren't betraying crap to them Arthur and John were betraying the gang.
He wasn't the smartest, the strongest, the best shooter, but he was an opportunist and knew when to strike
Yes but with how much some people love Arthur, they dont see it that way
Yeah its silly.
I hope in rdr3, they add the ability to take members with u. Like if u were planning on going to a shootout and rdr3 took place before the events of rdr2, then you could pick the Callender Boys or if you were trying to be sneaky doing something you might pick hosea
RDR3 will be a while lmfao
Ofc lol I'm just saying when it does come out
RDR3 play as young dutch?
Yeah
Hopefully I won't have grankids to look after
That was what I was hoping. Perhaps gta5 style where we start as Dutch, then can switch to hosea and then Arthur possibly
I love Hosea
Me too
Hosea could brutally rape me and leave me in the streets & i'd still love him
So true. 🤭 🤭 🤭
I just got the thomas downes scene
Arthur and John didn’t betray them, it’s the gang that betrayed Arthur and John
Dutch left John and Arthur to die
And Micah made Dutch think they were traitors
Causing the whole gang to turn against them
dead serious. no cap
Understandable he is an amazing antagonist
I love him because of that one time he hits micah
It won’t let me do one of the Missions for strangers and Idk why it just keeps stopping for some reason
quick question, other than southeast of strawberry, where in the hell can i find chipmunks? those lil bastards are pissing me off trying to get a perfect carcass
Chipmunks are indeed annoying to find, try around Horsetooth Ridge, Eris Field, and other forests.
Cougars & Panthers are annoying as fuck also
finally found one after spending three in-game days by fort riggs. for those curious, found one within seconds at ringneck creek.
Getting a 200 buck bounty for saving micah is annoying af
Yeah
atleast you get a holster
off hand holster can be unlocked before that mission though
How much does read dead redemption story mode cost cause I got it on my ps4 but that broken so I want it on pc
About 60 dollars buuut it's going on sale (likely) on steam soon
Ok
Also, I ended up making a random mental justification for why theres not that many towns
I downloaded red dead online does that download red dead story or no is that separate
I ended up just thinking "it's a big country of course we don't see everything"
That's seperate
I can run it I run online 60 FPS cap
Ight good
I have a 2070 super, I5 9600K, 3.7 GHz & 16 GB Ram and sometimes my game goes below 30 fps on max settings
I sit at a confortable 50 to 60
but in strawberry & valentine my FPS goes bye bye
just get a ps5 damn
Phh... yeah just get a console with no customisation ability
also I have a PS5
Or rather very little
I enjoy modding in video games and having fun with shit like that
mmm
Fair enough
I am paying of a PS5 but I haven't tooken it out of the box
I'm going to leave it untouched and sell it when the time is right
or I might use it one day
Also the PS5 RDR2 runs at a capped 30 fps in 4K
Yo guys im in chapter 3 and ive realised how much stuff there is now unlocked outside the story
Would it be beneficial to stray away from the story
Cause i do feel like its been moving very fast
I always try and do a mix of everything to keep things less boring
Pump shotgun or Semi auto?
semi
Go to the old ladys cabin for a free semi in the cellar
Bruhhhh why am I killed by lawman from self defending
I prefer pump
but it's all down to personal preference
Pump, I’ve used pump for my entire RDO career
I’ve only had Pump for a while but I’ve been thinking to get a semi auto one for a while
Where abouts is that?
I might just get the free one and play with it for a while
Watsons cabin
Thanks
near little creek river and west of wallace station
Is it possible to get the same type of facial hair as Charles Chatoney in singleplayer?
does anyone know how to make windows stop automatically turning on real time protection?
its really getting annoying when i try to launch rdr2
If you go to the barber and play around with the certain styles and lentgths of certain parts of your beard then you could probably figure it out
Just go to your nearest barber and try some of the combinations
Guys if I start a new game in story mode will my old one by saved?
Hey guys quick question: I simply hate Mary (Arthur ex gf not Mary Beth), I hate everything about her, her manipulative speeches her act as the weak girl trying to get Arthur help her all the time. So I helped her with her brother since she told me her brother always liked Arthur but now she wants help with her father who hates Arthur.
It is my first playthrough and I wanna see and enjoy every content there is, but I really don't want to help her. Would I be missing a lot by rejecting her?
Without spoilers, there is a few minor things and moments that happen when the missions are completed however you won't be missing a ton
If you're the kind of person who likes to have every detail, complete every stranger mission etc. then I'd recommend completing it
It gives a few details about Arthur's past too, so if you want to learn about that then go for it
If you've saved it or auto save has, yes. To check go to the pause menu, story and click load game and if your previous save appears then it has, I'd recommend starting a new save to prevent overwriting for this playthrough.
I see, tbh yes I am that kinda person and I've been doing every stranger person quests but I want to reject her nonetheless just to give Arthur some dignity I dunno. But thanks for the reply, appreciated
No problem man, it's your choice to play the Arthur you want to be
Wooow i didnt know you get soo much money at the end
Yes, explore the world and enjoy it
I tried for a low honor Playthrough. But seriously.. Arthur just doesn't let you be an a**hole from the Guarma chapter onwards. 
That's kinda the point of the game though, Arthur is learning to be a good man
Of course
You can just reject it and be a killer anyway
I try
Never do the good option :)
I was at -240 points
But after the story changing moment, ugh I couldn't make a coughing arthur a jerk
Thanks partner you helped a lot
When games attempt some kind of good/bad system you usually end up feeling like you’re fighting against the game if you try to go bad
No problem
I always have a dishonorable save on hand
I have one in the mid game for Arthur right when I got a free gun encounter in Valentine, and I have a save where I know all the cheats for John
For wreaking havoc
Favorite thing last time was dressing in green, going into the fancy saloon in St. Denis, and throwing dynamite into it.
OUT, AM I?!
boom
While the other save is for bullying since I love Arthur’s lines
I play honorably otherwise, but I have two saves for utter mischief
Bully Arthur is fun af
Not the worst I’ve done with cheats
Yo guys, any suggestions on what to do with money
Do i need it for something, should i save it?
Most things in the game look relatively cheap
what chapter are you at
why do my guns disappear
Buy guns or something.
Share some of it to the camp.
Buy an boat with the ledger, and bam.
You and the boy's got an boat in camp.
All camp things are max
Buy an new horse then?
There really isn't much to do with money.
Buy some recipes.
Idek whay recipes do lol
I don't even use recipes, but there they are.
You can make an more better dynamite stick with recipes.
And better fire bottles.
I only have online but should I get story mode if get the money
you should
What to do with all of the money u get at the end? Can it even be spent?
If you do challenges related to herbalists or hunting or shit like that you can buy an off hand holster at the trapper
lmfao
I have the sharpshooter off holster and i've only done like 3 missions
Buy every gun. Every piece of clothing, get LOTE satchel & buy the max amount of items
Download the buyable properties mod
Or a few other mods.
Hey there I have a problem with a mission
I'm currently playing the mission An Honest Day's Labors
The after the cut scene there is no dialogue all the way to the canyon. I've played it before on the PS4 and I YouTubed it and there is dialogue. When we get to the part where you're meant to go down into the canyon and fight nothing happens. Sadie gets off her horse and crouches behind a rock. At this point, he's meant to talk about what they should do but nothing happens at all.
Source Reddit
I have the same issue
I would use mods, but I have updated my PS4 into the goddamn current version, 9.30
The only mod I'd think about using would be one that makes the Wanted system not trash.
What does it do
I don't know, just heard people mention that they exist, and change it a bit.
Why are some guns locked in the gunsmith?
Some just don't get unlocked until later chapters/missions. Rockstar logic.
hay
Train Robberies
Passenger trains, not cargo
does anyone know where to find a 3 star robben
Like, rob the passengers?
Yes
Train Robberies are a bunch, but can be dangerous+high bounties if you don't do them right. Easier is stealing wagons and selling them. But if you don't want any dishonor/etc at all, just go hunting Alligator, boars and such.
Thanks I’ll do that
How many chapters are in the game?
6 Chapters, then Epilogue Part 1 and 2.
Ok
Can I meet with every side character in epilogue?
Tilly, Mary Beth, Rain Falls and Pearson can be met outside of the main missions
gold bar treasure chests
Ok but I mean like Penelope, Charlotte, Sister, Downes
There is some people that Arthur met before the EP like Mickey etc
Not sure about any others, can't remember right now
Penelope and sister downs I never seen again after the last chapter
I haven’t tried to go back to Charlottes house
Sister and Downes I know as a fact that you can’t see
What
Just not doing tasks
Only explore world
Kill random people
Run away fron head hunters
Bank robbery
Etc
You can play as an outlaw
But if you don’t complete missions you won’t progress that far
You can’t rob banks in free roams
You can only rob trains
And individual people
What is roam
The open world
Yes
There are only certain homesteads you can rob
Break into cabins
I’d argue that’s quite inefficient
As there are only a set amount of cabins
its fun tho (:
and, tbh
i find fun to be very important while grinding
to prevent burnout
More fun than train robberies?
Even as low honor arthur I gotta be nice to my camp people
I don't know who in their right mind antagonizes little Jack
So
Here's a guess as to where they hid the Blackwater money
It's buried with Dutch's mother
It's why he mentioned he found out she was buried there
And it's the last place anybody would ever look
Cause nobody with decency would dig up his own mother and bury his riches with her
I know where Dutch hid the money.
Oh? You agree?
That actually makes a lot of sense
Do I install mods before story mode or after story mode?

