red-dead-singleplayer

[hidden moss]

Killing the entire san denis population tomorrow

[red helm]

Fragging Gambler Challenges.

[solid eagle]

got another morality question, just finished confronting jeremiah compton, the old ass slave catcher. Should i kill him and put him out of his misery or let him live?

[hidden moss]

Does every kill made by Dutch look vicious and awesome

Also, your call, choose your own morals partner

[solid eagle]

i would, just want to know your guys's opinions on this

and what you would do

[true wave]

hi

[flint umbra]

89/90 challenges, now I just have to tame 9 more wild horses

[hidden moss]

I usually kill bad ppl in game so kill him if u want

[flint umbra]

Kill him he deserves it, spare the others 😄

Got all 20 dreamcatchers, now just to finish the hunting requests and the last horseman challenge and I should be at 100%

[bronze pumice]

If you're trying to be a good guy, you should probably kill him quickly to put him out of his misery.

[flint umbra]

Oh, and Cigarette cards

97.6%

[solid eagle]

found a klans member and hes on the back of my horse rn, any ideas what his punishment should be? Im on the fence between eaten by pigs and steam train assault

[flint umbra]

Feed him to the legendary Bull Gator 😄

Pull a page out of Dutch's book

But Pig food sounds good for that one too

[maiden sentinel]

Eaten by pigs seems like it’ll be more brutal so I vote for that one

[flint umbra]

Or better yet, leave him as live bait for the legendary lion or cougar

That way, if you're after the cougar, he won't go after you first 😄

That's what I did on PS4 to get the legendary cougar pelt 3 years ago lol. I still haven't gone after the legendary cougar on PC though

Bait = 1 Klans member + potent predator bait. Lather Arthur in scent cover lotion and you're good to go 😄

[solid eagle]

i came to the middle ground and ran him over with the train first then let the pigs go munchy on him

unfortunate how it makes me wanted however

[hidden moss]

i just accidentally overwritten a save on red dead can i get it back? i’m on xbox

[heady ocean]

sorry don’t think you can

[hidden moss]

no way at all?

[heady ocean]

Sorry lad

nope

[sly sandal]

i believe you get honor if you do it lol

the game acknowledges thst he's a slaver

[solid eagle]

until i feed the dude to some pigs and a poor farmer witnesses it

[hidden moss]

Burn him

[hidden moss]

Big brain

Every time I c the kkk I usually blow them up or burn them and if any survived I’ll kill them all in dead eye and it’s quite fun too

[short garnet]

I bow to them

[hidden moss]

not cool bro

[short garnet]

What's not cool about it? So I should be judged by my beliefs while other people cry that they are judged?

[short garnet]

How's that, Bro?

[hidden moss]

u r deluded

i bought 10 arabians once so i would have no cash and i could get into the "poor cowboy" role

in a way

must get into the feel

hay guys does anyone know if i can keep the trapper outfits when i get john

you probably can

get in

just i dont want to lose them

[short garnet]

Spoiler alert

[hidden moss]

w

btw

Arthur goes to cuba

[hidden moss]

this channel allows spoilers though

so

[short garnet]

damn

[hidden moss]

im 90%sure

[sand plinth]

no..dutch

[short garnet]

fuck dutch

[hidden moss]

u trader

fuck him urself

why did u let him die

[sand plinth]

arthur Will be killed in epilogue 2

[hidden moss]

Does the companuin activities count to 100%

i wanna say no but i have no idea

[sand plinth]

John Will be broke in Last chapter 6 mission

HOSEA can stay a like a book in chapter 7. I wish

[hidden moss]

are you on lsd

i

what is going on

[sand plinth]

no, i just wanna know- lenny is send? Pls say to me!.+

[hidden moss]

Awesome

🤠

I wanna b a cowboy baby

[arctic wren]

Nah man in chapter 6 Arthur goes to Sisika and epilogue one is John working to gather people to get him out then epilogue two getting him out

And then the law leaves him alone cause they hanged someone in Arthur’s place

And they thought it was him

[hidden moss]

its so sad that archer fordham dies in rdr2 😔

very sad

[dull knoll]

It’s so sad Steve Jobs died of ligma

[hidden moss]

who the hell is steve jobs??

[gray wasp]

(dammit I can't post Gifs here)

[cursive loom]

Ligma Balls.

[hidden moss]

Embed fail

[cursive loom]

Lol

I hate how rockstar treats RDR2

They legit just released a whole new ass DLC for GTA but still nothing rlly exciting

Like add the online clothes into fucking story mode

[next kindle]

wont happen

gta is their main game and they dont have that

so why add it to the less popular game?

[spiral silo]

Or they should make red dead online how they made gta online

[earnest herald]

what, flying horses with 300 loaded rocket propelled missiles?

they can't make rdo like gtao without making it even shittier

[hidden moss]

Someone who has finished the game and still played dm me I tried to type here but it keeps removing my message

[tacit plover]

Server aren’t shut ding we Jeff why hand added one when it Greg

[normal elk]

Gibberish

Lenny send, you cant send people?

Im confused

[tacit plover]

If you cut them into small enough pieces they can fit in a box

[normal elk]

Well yeah

[tacit plover]

Or the box just has to be big enough

[glad brook]

Body?

[normal elk]

But this is jus gibberish to me

[tacit plover]

And then you can send them

[normal elk]

I dont

Understand what the original guy meant by "lenny is send?"

Explain please

[floral ice]

someone help i have an fps issue which i cant find a solution to

so basically i can run on like 100 fps for like 15 minutes but then for the rest of my session it runs on 20 fps

and the same thing repeats despite me restarting my laptop, redownloading the game and restarting the game

anyone experienced something similar?

could u provide a solution?

[hidden moss]

#pc-technical-stuff

[floral ice]

ohhh okay thanks imma ctrl v this there

[tacit plover]

He also said “HOSEA can stay a like a book in chapter 7. I wish” so I don’t think he’s trying to make sense

[normal elk]

Lol

[sterile nest]

bro the sensitivity on PS4 sucks

I have it on max and it’s feels slow

I mean it feels like ur playing Mario kart

But when you suppose to go right

it doesn’t go but just goes slow

so you have to try ur hardest to move it to ur right

[normal elk]

Dont play on console!

Pc is better for.... most things except stuff that needs an anolauge stick

Even then you can buy one

[hidden moss]

You just bad at Mario kart bro

You know you can drift in Mario kart for turns right

[loud forum]

How do I throw someone in combat

Like I've seen people do it in controller and have no idea how to throw someone away

(I know how to push someone away with W + D + R or W + A + R)

[wary pecan]

Anybody on single player wanna chat? Ps4 have a mic. Preferably people that have already completed the game

[foggy ocean]

im so sad rn. My horse just died after getting in a gunfight with some men on the road. he died instalty couldn't revive him. we had a level 4 bond.

[subtle finch]

Story = 👌

[tacit plover]

A similar thing happened to me once

I was ambushed by the Raiders

They had a Gatling Gun

They shot my horse

And then me

[wintry solar]

F

[mild igloo]

hey guys i am in chapter 4 rn

anything i should do before moving onto chapter 5

[loud forum]

Do many things

[tacit plover]

It was a max bond horse too

[wintry solar]

Mega sad

[gray wasp]

buy all the camp upgrades

[flint umbra]

One more horse and challenges are done 😄

After that, I just have to finish the hunting requests for 100%

[flint umbra]

Challenges completed 😄

[hidden moss]

I kinda feel bad cuz I literally came back to Beecher’s after killing like 20 people and 3 waves of bounty hunters+their horses and Jack saw me with blood on my hands

😔

[flint umbra]

You went hunting, it's OK

@tacit plover
No Horse Revivers left?!?

[tacit plover]

I instantly died from the gatling gun

[solid eagle]

anybody know how much warmth the legendary moose hunting jacket provides?

[dawn geyser]

Today I learnt that in "The Joys Of Civilization", you can wait till the bartender serves you instead of calling him over and over again

[true wave]

huh

noted

[flint umbra]

99.0%, 3 hunting requests left. I collected a few items for next 3 requests too, hopefully I get to finish it all tomorrow

[hidden moss]

@solid eagle max level like the bear, wolf, ram coats, sheep/panther poncho

there are almost no mid level warmth items, but with a low warmth coat/gloves and specific warm vests you get to mid warmth

low level is everything fancy

and it says "good in hot weather"

[peak wagon]

not working

[hidden moss]

specify plsz

[solid eagle]

alright, thank you.

[wintry estuary]

If you had to do a top 3 sidearms two of the three being sidearm and offhand sidearm what would they be in singleplayer

[hidden moss]

A train snatched my Fentons life (Fentons r wat I call black horses and ponies) 😭😭😭😭

[placid inlet]

rip fenton

[arctic wren]

Whenever my horse dies I just load the last auto save which is usually right before

Or the horse is about to die

Dont want to risk it

[hidden moss]

i did the hes british of course mission and did not take the lion paw can i do that mission again?

[hidden moss]

do i need the lion's paw to get 100% completion?

[frigid cloud]

no and no

[tacit plover]

Did that in my second playthrough

That was because I wanted to hear the dialogue between the bartender and the other guy

[abstract prism]

hi

#general-media

how do i get it to max stats

[tacit plover]

When you complete all challenge sets, you unlock the ability to go to level 10 for all stats

[abstract prism]

this is story mode

[tacit plover]

Yes

[raw pivot]

Im replaying stor mode

[prime jewel]

omagash

[drifting vapor]

I've played through the story multiple times and this kind of stuff is pretty much what I'm trying to do this time lmao just see if there's other ways to do the missions I never tried

[dawn geyser]

Pro tip for extra pizzazz

Wear a full civil war outfit while doing "Horsemens, Apocalypses" (or whatever the name was) to feel like you're defending an outpost back in the good ol 1864

[hidden moss]

How do I win a dominoes round without drawing?

[main nest]

@mild igloo Hunt the vampire in the alley

[hidden moss]

Something depressing just happened to me my batteries died mid mission and there’s no aa batteries left😭😭😭😭

Fun fact ivr completed story about 5 times

Or 4 maybe

[fresh forge]

I can get a free gun, which should I choose?

[haughty mirage]

do some research, and pick

there are plenty good ones

I recommend something like a bolt action or colt navy as a starter, save for shotguns later

Oh wait

Just realized

This is singleplayer channel lmfao

my mistake

[sterile nest]

but it’s broken wtf- the sensor is broken actual idiot

[hidden moss]

You have all the info right there. Use your initiative.

[glad brook]

@hidden moss best gun?

[hidden moss]

Well my first go to weapon whenever I start a new game is the Springfield rifle and it’s pretty good so I recommend that

[flint umbra]

OMG We found Gavin! 😄

Anyone know of any opossum spawn spots? I checked YT, scoured all of them and got nothing so far

[vocal tusk]

these gambler challenges are annoying

[flint umbra]

Just wait for Gambler 8

but I found Van Horn saloon good for low cards if you sit at a full table, second from the left of the dealer

[vocal tusk]

im on gambler 9 rn

8 took me a couple days

[flint umbra]

Me too. But 9 was easy. It frustrated me at first, but then I went to play against the one guy at emerald station

Took me about an hour to finish it

If he pulls ahead of you in points just stand up and sit back down, it doesn't reset the win counter

[vocal tusk]

ahh i didnt know it didnt reset. very nice

[hidden moss]

I cant believe died

😭 😭

I want to cry

[tawny nimbus]

god every single goddamn time i see clothing in RDO i just wish it was in story mode too

dressing up arthur or john like a tryhard would look very weird

but hell at least it would look badass

they should have had some sort of director mode ( like in gta 5 ) in story mode where u made ur own character then you could use the clothing in RDO for your character made in story mode

[wintry estuary]

If you had to do a top 3 sidearms two of the three being sidearm and offhand sidearm what would they be in singleplayer

[tawny nimbus]

alright so

i didnt understand what you just said

im gonna make a top 3

once for sidearm once for offhand

Sidearm ( Revolver Edition )
3. Cattleman Revolver ( Your usual go-to at the start of the game , solid if you can aim , just the gun for the player who just realised a gunsmith exists in chapter 3.)
2. Schofield Revolver ( Probably the most used revolver in the whole game , while it's fire rate is slow it's a cool looking revolver and the stats are not good but not bad at the same time , making it the revolver you could use for the whole game )

1. LeMat Revolver (Great damage with the alternate firing mode that can one shot at close to medium range , and with nine bullets the LeMat is probably the best sidearm in the whole game )

Offhand (Anything Edition lmao)
3. Any copy of your sidearm ( double the fun )
2. LeMat Revolver (18 bullets and 2 shotgun shots wtf)

1. Sawed Off ( Great at decapitating solid damage looks cool and rdr1 cover art )

couldnt fit what i wanted in 3 slots

but thats all ig

[flint umbra]

G'damn Partner! Took me 4+ hours to finish hunting request 3. Chipmunk and Opossum really gave me trouble

I got all the birds I need for the last 2 requests except for the Crow

[harsh nebula]

Holy crap it’s Walter H White!

[flint umbra]

You're Goddamn Right!

99% just those last 2 hunting requests left now

[harsh nebula]

Bro I loved Breaking Bad

[flint umbra]

My favorite 2 shows: 1. BrBa 2. Mr. Robot

[harsh nebula]

But uh I don’t suppose this is the correct channel nor server for Breaking Bad discussions

[flint umbra]

nah let's stick to RDR2

[harsh nebula]

Yes I suppose we shall

[vocal tusk]

i stumbled upon the wildlife art quest and i 100% regret it. getting those small bird carcasses are a pain

[harsh nebula]

I feel like it doesn’t really matter in the single player, in online I guess it’s more about your play style, the best weapon for PVP, aesthetics, whatever, but Singleplayer just… allows any weapon to be a viable option, the slow motion deadeye just makes any weapon OP

[flint umbra]

You need to complete it for 100%

that is literally the last thing I left on the to do list

[harsh nebula]

I’ll be honest with you, I tried to complete RDR2 100%, accidentally deleted my save file, got pissed, downloaded one from the internet and just gave up

I might try again some day

But not for a while

[flint umbra]

I've been at 99% for about 24 hours IRL now just waiting to complete it

It's not that difficult just time consuming...until you have to hunt a 3* chipmunk

Alvin really gave me some trouble there lol

Opossum, there's a spot near Riggs station, set up a camp, sleep til night time, save, then quit and reload until a perfect Opossum spawns under the trees

Make sure to make a legendary pronghorn trinket if you don't nab the chipmunk before the opossum though

[sudden halo]

Guys where do I find coyotes? I've only found 2 in erin fields but no perfect ones. and I need perfect pelts

[maiden sentinel]

Oh my god I’ve done the same thing. I had one at 99% and it got deleted so I had to completely start over. I didn’t play for a couple months because I was so mad

[harsh nebula]

Oof

Wasn’t at 99% I was at like 70 something

At 99% I would’ve almost if not broken my monitor

[wary oasis]

About to do American Venom, I've not explored NA apart from the only single player mission in NA as John, guess I'm not missing anything?

[harsh nebula]

No you’re not

[maiden sentinel]

Nah your not really missing anything

[wary oasis]

Not explored it yet, going to do it as next character after EP2

[red helm]

There is a bunch of things to do in New Austin, Just none of them really have much to do with the Story. Lots of Animals to Hunt, couple of Bounties in Tumbleweed, some Legendary animals, and things to explore, etc etc.

[wary oasis]

Yeah I know I've got a list of stuff to do in NA. It's just not canonical I guess

[red helm]

Indeed, if you want to be Canon, never go further than that River just north of Thief's Landing.

In Free Roam, at least.

[wary oasis]

Only went to do that one single mission

[wary oasis]

Why?

[red helm]

It is fun to explore out there, and it's pretty, but I would've just assumed they cut all of NA plus the MacFarland Ranch/Thief's Landing area. Since John says he's never been down there, in RDR1. and obviously all that 'invisible' Sniper non-sense and such if you try to go down there as Arthur.

Just remove all of it, and have a smaller game file.

[red helm]

Maybe he revived it.

[flint umbra]

I just need a crow and a cedar waxwing now

waxwings are tough to come by though

[gilded edge]

I just did the stranger quest where you have to subdue bertram

i feell horrible

[red helm]

If that Fort southwest of Van Horn hasn't been any luck, there is the area south of the Hanging Dog Ranch. and also the Painted Sky Ranch.

[wary shard]

Back to playin after like a year.

[hidden moss]

Awesome

[hidden moss]

After all these years we found him on discord

[spiral silo]

This server and game is kinda dead

There

I admitted it

Watch me get banned

[hidden moss]

My fav sidearm and off hand is the volcanic pistol and my fav 2 handed gun is bolt action rifle and pump action shotgun

[hidden moss]

That’s terrible I feel for u I completed the main missions and then the other day the game decided to bully me and put me back at the end of chapter 2

[flint umbra]

I tried about 5 locations. I got a few down but they were all 2 star even after I picked them up (yes I have the trinket) @red helm

[hidden moss]

Ikr

[flint umbra]

Brathwaite manor by the water, Fort Riggs, Bayou NWA, West of Emerald Ranch by the pond with ducks, MacFarlane's ranch

[hidden moss]

That sucks

[spiral silo]

Seriously kid steals his moms card for 111k worth of cash just to get back at me for killing Jim once

Him*

[flint umbra]

He didn't get back at you...he got back at his mom

[hidden moss]

Wtf that kid is a brat

[spiral silo]

Lol yeah

[hidden moss]

I hate kids except Jack

[spiral silo]

i didn’t even do it out of spite I did it cus he talked so much shit

[hidden moss]

Jack is the only child I like

[spiral silo]

So I said to deal it if you can’t take it (that’s what she said)

[spiral silo]

Jack Kyle?

[hidden moss]

Jack marston

[spiral silo]

Oh

He resembles to Carl grimes a bit

[hidden moss]

Idk who that is but ok

[spiral silo]

Nah that’s a sin

How old are you?

[hidden moss]

Aaaaaaahgggdfgfcrtrc

16

[spiral silo]

And you haven’t seen TWD

[hidden moss]

I just had a seizure

Na

[spiral silo]

Damn

It’s good

[weak pawn]

Can you rob banks outside of missions?

[hidden moss]

Idk

[spiral silo]

In red dead or gta?

Bc red dead you can’t do anything like that

Gta I don’t play anymore

[hidden moss]

That’s depressing

[hidden moss]

I still play gta v

[spiral silo]

Yeah they would make twice the money if they did the same things like they did from gta v

[hidden moss]

Yeah exactly

[spiral silo]

But rockstar games is filled with idiots XD

[hidden moss]

And Arthur or John would probably make twice or maybe triple the price compared to robbing a shop

Yeah

[maiden sentinel]

Oh definitely

[spiral silo]

Yeah

[hidden moss]

My fav place to rob is the van horn trader cuz npc never goes on there and I can make an easy quick $20

I hate how r* is treating rdo

[spiral silo]

I just use money cheat

[hidden moss]

I feel like they just don’t care about the rdo community

[spiral silo]

They don’t

They see gta online making money so they keep doing that

[hidden moss]

Yeah I’m mean they do add kinda shitty updates to rdo tbh

[maiden sentinel]

GTA makes more money than red dead does

But

[hidden moss]

And they add good updates for gtao

[maiden sentinel]

If they put good updates and decently regular ones

RDO would make good money

Especially with new players buying gold bars

[hidden moss]

Like y can’t r* add bank robberies or heists that’ll make the game cooler

And I do love both rdo and gtao I just wish there’s much more content in there cuz rdo does get boring sometimes

[weak pawn]

You can’t rob banks?

Sucks

[spiral silo]

Nope

[hidden moss]

Ikr

[flint umbra]

This is getting ridiculous lol still no luck with last 2 birds

[solid eagle]

if i die will any pelts on my horse be gone or will they jsut be stored on him but not visible anymore

i just bagged a leg. fox pelt and still need to find another animal pelt so not sure what precautions i need to tak

or will it just now be saved with the trapper since its a legendary pelt

[hidden moss]

That’s sad😭👏

[hidden moss]

I think the pelts will still b stored. On ur horse if u die

[flint umbra]

@oak crater No they won't I lost a bunch of pelts a few times

[hidden moss]

Well that sucks

[flint umbra]

Finally snuck up on a crow at Brathwaite manor, just the cedarwing left now

[hidden moss]

Wonderful

[red helm]

Depends what kills you. If you die to a human, they just take money. But if a animal kills you, you lose all your pelts/carcasses stored on your horse(Not your satchel), but no money loss.

[red helm]

When I was doing the Cedar Waxwing, a odd thing happened to me, I decided to just save all the carcasses, for the heck of it, and at some point I had like 20 of them, and after I checked my satchel for some other animal I just killed, I noticed that 3 of them just happened to be Perfect, though, I'm quite certain when I was picking up the carcasses they didn't say so, or obviously, I would've went over, got the Beaver and finished..... So, whatever, I didn't complain, bug or whatever happened.
Make sure to recheck your satchel, just in case, though.

[marsh valley]

The Bountiful Achievement is good fun

Just hanging out in the Loft killing lawmen and stacking the bodies like firewood

waiting for either more law or more bounty hunters to roll by

[hidden moss]

My cat just attacked me and my dog 😭😭

[marsh valley]

Is it worth it to do all the hunting requests and the exotics?

Or should I move on to RDR1?

[hidden moss]

Move on to RDR1

Or If you want to torture yourself choose the option 1.

[marsh valley]

I’m probably going to kill Javier
I’ve dragged a lot of men to the hangman’s noose in 2 as Marston. But sending Javier there… don’t feel right.

[hidden moss]

Well it's your decision. But if i get to choose, i would rather hear their opinions about the past further more.

Lasso him and then send him

[next tusk]

is it weird ive had rdr2 for a year and only played the online til this week

😶

[flint umbra]

FINALLY! Thank Baby Jesus! 😄

[hidden moss]

Nope the online isn’t anywhere near as good

At least in my opinion

[marsh valley]

It's hard to follow up on story mode

[next tusk]

i take it online is before the story

[hidden moss]

Yeah story mode is just unmatched, and rockstar don’t give a crap about online if they did it could be really good

[flint umbra]

From what I heard, RDO started a story, but never finished it 😄

[hidden moss]

I don’t think it said

[next tusk]

braithwaite manor is still standing in rdo

[hidden moss]

Then it should be before chapter 4

[next tusk]

so is bacchus bridge

[marsh valley]

RDO is before

[hidden moss]

Makes sense

how long should I wait to replay the story

rdo is in 1898

I finnished it about 5 months ago

its proved

I would be happy if they are working on Undead Nightmare 2 but yeah my hopes are gone.

[flint umbra]

Damnit. I got the perfect cedar wing but I forgot my perfect bever carcass was lost when I collided with an NPC lmfao

I forgot to pick it back up...whoopsie

Now I've done it, just have to wait for the letter to meet the lady and 100% run is completed

[next tusk]

ay do I help marston or go get the money

[flint umbra]

Abigail! 😡

[next tusk]

you right

[solid canopy]

yall im about to bawl my eyes out, im on chapter 6 and doing the fishing thing with Hamish but i dont know if im doing anything wrong but when i get the hook on the legendary fish thing it gets away so i need help

im about to quit ive done this about 10-15 times already

[hidden moss]

Na it starts before chapter 1 cuz Sadie and her ranch exists

[hidden moss]

oh right

[hidden moss]

So something similar happened to me so every time I use the fishing rod I just hold down the button that I yeet the hook in and the fish gets on the line but then I can’t reel it in so my stragerty is to press whatever button u yeet the hoook into the water not hold it tho and u should get it in no time maybe

[flint umbra]

100% done 😄

[hidden moss]

wwwooooookets gooooooo

Am proud of u 👍

Ur a true legend

[flint umbra]

Thx Partner! 😄

[hidden moss]

Np partner

[flint umbra]

Legend of the East! Erm...I mean West

Wild Wild West

Now if I start a new save I will stream it on twitch every weekend or so. 😄

[hidden moss]

Control the fish rather than reeling it but if you don't want the fish to get so far away, hold the reel button then let go, hold it again then let go hold it again(do it fast) to stop the fish from getting away until the fish was tired. If you want to get the fish faster and closer to your direction, control the fish downward while reeling it.

Idk about the PC controlls tho.

[hidden moss]

i couldnt find the mental strength to find all the dream catchers and dino bones

[atomic flame]

If you do everything in moderation it’s still fun

Say for instance I’d hunt a legendary animal / fish then I’d find a few dinosaur bones and then open cigarette packs

Then level up some stats or some shit

I’d you mix things up it can stay fun

[flint umbra]

Dream catchers were easy man

I just had a map pulled up on my right screen and followed the waypoints, marking each one

that part took me the least amount of time actually

Try finding the mental strength to keep going with hunting requests though! I was close to giving up at 99% at least 5 times today

Some items, even with guides when I needed them were excruciatingly long though. Cough hunting requests

I only started playing RDR2 again after I built my new PC last month, went from 46% to 100% in the last 3 weeks

Yes @atomic flame exactly that. Mix things up, always otherwise it becomes mega boring

[solid eagle]

do pelts disappear from my horse if i fast travel?

[placid inlet]

not in singleplayer

[next tusk]

do you get arthurs items back in epilogue

i had 22 gold bars

[native thunder]

nope

i think they respawn though so you have to find them again

[hidden moss]

Yes

Well the only things Ik of Arthur’s stuff John gets r his clothes weapons

nd his journal

So yesterday I was vibing on saint denis and I was gonna do the trelanny mission where u had it rob a ferry so I was almost there and I went up to trelanny on my Fenton (that’s what I call black horses and ponies) amd then I had this random npc just witness me apparently disturbing the piece which I’m pretty sure I’ve never did and the. I got the law on me

[placid inlet]

yeah you keep clothes weapons, and saddles as well

[next tusk]

so my gold is gone then?

[placid inlet]

yeah, sorry : (

[long yarrow]

My Dutch warm blood that I bought at the beginning of the game and has been with me all the way through play through of 6 months to the last couple missions was just shot and killed in an ambush by lemoyne raiders. I uninstalled the game and do not plan on finishing.

[steep lion]

just played rdr2 for the first time today

is the black arabian horse around st dennis theatre in chapter 2 still around or is it removed now

[old pond]

Pretty sure it's still around

[solid eagle]

what is with these saint denis lawmen holy shit, i try to help them catch a fleeing criminal and i get chokeholded

[weak pawn]

Is it possible to kill those little kids who steal your money?

In saint denis

[soft heath]

yeah

but it’s pretty hard @weak pawn

[weak pawn]

How do you do it?

[soft heath]

you can catch up to them im pretty sure

[weak pawn]

Afterwards though

[soft heath]

Edmund

wydm*

wdym*

[weak pawn]

After I catch up

It plays a cutscene

[soft heath]

I don’t think u can kill them

[weak pawn]

I’ve heard stories

Nvm thanks anyways

[soft heath]

all good bro

[hidden moss]

I wish, I really hate them

[weak pawn]

Same lmao

Just wanna throw a fire bomb or dynamite

[hidden moss]

Same man they really annoying

[hidden moss]

Well I hope u have a grand time playing it

[hidden moss]

Nice man enjoy the game

[hidden moss]

I did c someone kill those little shits o reddit and I tried it for my self but didn’t work also in the comments in that post someone did say they used a mod so idk

[hidden moss]

Same

Little punks

I hate them

We must eradicate all kids

Yes I love dark humour lol

[steep lion]

thanks i love the home-y feeling you get from the gang that we didnt have in rdr1

[hidden moss]

Yeah same

Fun fact I’ve played rdr2 before I played rdr1

Cuz I knew that rdr2 was a prequel to rdr1 so I played that first

[hidden moss]

I like how they all tough but once you saying something back they ran like a little bitch

[weak pawn]

LmAo that’s true

[hidden moss]

Fin fact rdr2 is my fav game I and I now love western after playing it

[opaque cove]

I had red dead online, then i tried to buy red dead singleplayer. I tybed in all my credit card information. Then it took me to a security wepside that didnt work. It said 404eror. But when i looked they still took my money and i didnt get fucking singleplayer

Can any one help

Can anyone help

They are not going to answar my emails

So what i do?

Do i just accept they stole all my money?

[iron grove]

I’d phone them

[steep lion]

got the arabian horse around the theatre in st dennis but i couldnt save the couple lmao

rdr2 is def gearing up to be the best game ive ever played seen so many comments about people wanting to play it again for the first time now i understand

the only criticism i have so far is i wish they wouldve added difficulty the enemies' ai is kinda just normal (or im just having post effect after recently finishing tlou2 on grounded+)

[marsh valley]

I started the art exhibit hunting quests

Super weird

Cause while I spent three hours stuck on the second quest, I just kept finding other birds on the list and bagging them early, so the hard part is gonna be the opossum and the rat and such

Maybe the beaver too I recall those being a pain

[steep lion]

did you buy it on steam or something? if u still dont have the game the bank can give you the money again to buy it

[opaque cove]

its only 8 euros i dont think the bank wanna do thats

but im kid so its a lot to me

i bought it in rockstar

[steep lion]

they will if u wanna

[hidden moss]

Well if ur trying download ot into pc then Idk any reliable sources cuz I’ve on,t played it on Xbox one but I’m getting scam vibes from them

[steep lion]

then i doubt u were scammed if u bought it from rockstar

is the transaction details in ur email or smthing

[opaque cove]

i didnt get scammed

its theyr security system that didnt work

so i couldnt complete it

so i didnt get the game

but it still took the money

[hidden moss]

Very rude much

That’s sucks so much

[steep lion]

yeah id tell ur bank abt it cause it might happen again with the card u used

[hidden moss]

Maybe try buying it if steam

[hidden moss]

My way of earning some more money during robberies in missions is to rob the ppl

[hidden moss]

I’m currently in a relaxing Choo Choo train ride

[severe belfry]

Rdr2 is a great blend of enemies that are easy but not too easy

It’s enough to feel like the terminator at times but you can also lose a whole bunch of health if you get jumped

[hidden moss]

Gonna play rdr2 for the first time in 1-2years

[golden vector]

nice

[hidden moss]

For the first time in just over a year

To be mostly exact a year and 2 months

God I was so cringe in the past

So I’m chapter 4 theres this mission where u Dutch and another fella go out to find Jules and get jumped by a gated and I’m wondering can u kill the gator

[tidal relic]

I don't think so, it's a legendary animal.

[hidden moss]

Ok

[golden vector]

you can only hunt it after completing the mission with charles and the murfree brood

[nocturne spindle]

Is there a way to kill the bear in "Aftermath of Genesis"?

[tacit plover]

Yes

I saw a video where someone killed it with an axe

[sly nest]

How do you catch up to Jamie everything I try he gets away

[hidden moss]

You can't really if you mean catch him but if you mean stay with him just keep pounding x or a

[sly nest]

Ok

[gilded prism]

what do you guys and galls think the best roles to get are?

I'm really stuck on which one to get

[frigid cloud]

#rdo-chat is the correct chat to ask this

[gentle acorn]

Hey all! Happy to join this server. Huge fan of rdr2. Got the game just recently. Steam autumn sale, this year.

Already did a playthrough. Although I am late in saying it, what a game!!

[gilded prism]

got to agree with that

[gentle acorn]

There are millions of things I didn't do in my 1st play. Just went by the main missions

[gilded prism]

you gotta do them gooood side quests

[gentle acorn]

For sure

[gilded prism]

soz gtg

[gentle acorn]

Ok. Take care now

[tacit plover]

Finally got an Appaloosa

Now I just need a nokota, a hungarian halfbred, and an American standardbred and I can kiss horseman goodbye

[sly sandal]

you can kill it afterwards but i suggest you bring a pump shotgun with slugs

[gilded prism]

yea good idea

[next tusk]

can you rob banks and trains after the epilogue?

[tacit plover]

Banks, no. Trains, yes.

[next tusk]

ah thank you

[tacit plover]

Nokota down

[wary oasis]

Bank robberies are part of the main story aren't they?

[spiral raptor]

yea

[marsh valley]

Bank robberies are always a special occasion

Not just a casual pastime
Which... I like.

Although I'd love to rob the Lemoyne National one last time and actually make it work

[tacit plover]

I managed to get lucky and got the standardbred and the half-bred in the same location

[wary oasis]

What does the mysterious writing in Blackwater actually mean? Just a hint/joke?

[gray iris]

Is it good when you already have all the best horses in chapter 2

[wary oasis]

[gray iris]

I mean I started to play the game back in 2019 I then completed the whole game but then my pc had a few problems back in March and I sent it to fix it 2 weeks ago and 2 days ago I got it back and started to play rdr2 again and now I went to look for the best horses and I have all of them now

[hidden moss]

Kind of impossible

[silk stratus]

Hello

Can you help me

[marsh valley]

Uh why me

and with what

[silk stratus]

Guns

[marsh valley]

Uh buy a LeMat
My final message to the world

[silk stratus]

Your gonna die ?

[marsh valley]

Nope

But there's my gun advice

[silk stratus]

lemat better than navy ?

[marsh valley]

Yes

[silk stratus]

Cool

[marsh valley]

1000% yes

Nine shots and a shotgun shell vs

Whatever the appeal of the Navy is

[silk stratus]

Man your a good person

[marsh valley]

Not particularly but you're welcome

Back to the hunting lists for me
Still struggling to get that perfect rat

And the game won't let me ship Micah to the taxidermist so I have to look

[maiden sentinel]

I went to the burned down town in the heartlands and found a few perfect rats when I was looking

[marsh valley]

I'm gonna try the civil war fort first

But I'll check there if I get desperate

Which I probably will be

Only good rats

Never perfect!

Not even with my damn trinket
Have mercy game.... please...

[dull knoll]

Gotta use small game arrows

[marsh valley]

Nah I'm using em
Headshots

I just keep finding good rats
And they never become perfect when I pick em up, which'll sometimes happen

[wary oasis]

Saint Denis has rats

Done the Buck Antler Trinket?

[marsh valley]

Yup
It's why I'm sad none of the good rats have become perfect yet

Also where
Cause I think I exhausted the barkeep's rat extermination

[wary oasis]

Go to Prinz & Co - Lots there

[quiet canopy]

Can I say a joke with a red dead spoiler?

[marsh valley]

The meat plant outside town? I just checked there I think, came up with nothing but stray doggos

[wary oasis]

Tagged you in #red-dead-media

[tacit plover]

What does that do

[wary oasis]

More chance of higher quality skins etc

[marsh valley]

Yeah its super good

Sometimes you get spared because rng smiles on you

All I need now I think is a Perfect Possum, Bat, Beaver, and Skunk

I've managed to nab almost every other bird and critter in the hunting requests

Jack Abigail and Uncle might wonder where I am
But I toil in these fields so I might bring art home to my family

After this, it'll be only challenges and exotics left, and I might just move onto rdr1 at that point

[wary oasis]

Possums are easy to find, if you go to the cave by Elysian pool there is a number of dead ones at the entrance which some are perfect. Skunks just are around here and there

Beavers are rich at Owanjula

[tacit plover]

Time for Bandit 5

“Amass a $250 bounty in one state”

This should be fun

[wary oasis]

Easy

[tacit plover]

It is

Which is why it will be fun

[wary oasis]

I've yet to do the Bountiful achievement of which will also be fun ha

[marsh valley]

Simple enough just break Micah out of jail

[red helm]

You found a Perfect Rat? Was about to tell you where I found 6...

[marsh valley]

Yup!

So I'm well on my way now
If I nab a possum real quick I'll be done with part 3 as well

I ended up shooting birds by a river for a couple hours and as a result I've nabbed them all early

[red helm]

Cool. Riggs train stations at night, or Eris Field for Opossums.

[marsh valley]

Might go looking for dreamcatchers in the meantime

Since that's another thing on the 100% completion list

[red helm]

Eris Field also for Skunks, fyi.

[marsh valley]

These challenges will be the death of me tho
Gambler and all that especially

[red helm]

Ouf, Gambler challenges is the suck.

[marsh valley]

Herbalist too

But I'm at least on part 6 or 7 of that

Only 30 challenges left

[red helm]

Herbalist isn't to bad, unless you are trying to do it as Arthur.

[marsh valley]

And then every fucking exotic

[tacit plover]

The description for bountiful says $250, so does that mean if I have over that it won’t give the achievement?

[marsh valley]

Bandit is something best done as Arthur

Also nah don't trip out about that Aiden

[red helm]

$250 or more.

[marsh valley]

1. Sheriff Gray likes you

2. I racked up like 1500 in Ambarino during the bit I just held out in the Loft against hunters, I got it anyway

...or did Sherriff Gray like Hoagie Macintosh? I can't recall.

I just felt bad doing Bountiful

Ruining John Marston's rep which I'd worked so hard to maintain
All that bounty hunting for honor and cash, and he ruined it in five days

[red helm]

Well, sure, but not like it's that hard to get it back, just walk around and say hi to a couple hundred people.

[marsh valley]

This is true, but yknow
I still felt bad enough to go back so it never happened

And I wouldn't find out if Abigail pulls a grimshaw and chews me out for blowing up locomotives

[red helm]

I 'cheated' when I did it, since I didn't want to pay all that money off. I loaded a manual save before I started the crime fest.

[hidden moss]

I heard a rumor of the kkk being in the game

[marsh valley]

Yup

[red helm]

No rumor. Definitely are.

[marsh valley]

And they're gems all of them

[hidden moss]

Lots of weird stuff in the game

[marsh valley]

You don't even gotta do anything

And they kill them selves

It's glorious

Just watch and they drop like flies

But uh
I help them along

Giving my dirty south a bad name
White robed motherfuckers, they're all yella underneath them robes

[red helm]

Yep, funny stuffs.

[hidden moss]

A lot of strange stuff that not related to the actual story are in the game

Interesting

Why

[marsh valley]

Flavor

In universe lore

Like Pleasance
The ghost town that all we know is they died of sickness

[red helm]

Easter eggs and random things are never a bad thing.

[marsh valley]

Just there to make this world feel lived in

Which is great

Finding a meteor yourself is just fun

[red helm]

That Meteor crater is really cool.

[marsh valley]

Yeah especially how a fragment killed everyone in a nearby house

[hidden moss]

I wonder why is the Easter eggs are only on story mode tho

[red helm]

Ha, yeap, the cabin next to it.

[marsh valley]

I only found that first

[red helm]

People in Online mode don't want to wander around exploring? I don't know.

[marsh valley]

Then I went "wait the paper mentioned a falling rock it couldn't have been far"
And lo and behold there it was

Idk online mode is kinda lame imo
But that's just me
Maybe one day I'll be desperate enough to jump into that

[hidden moss]

Lol

[red helm]

Online seems like it would be neat for a few hours, but then just grinding and being griefed, so, meh, nuts to that.

[hidden moss]

Guys the other day some folk invited me to his house and I think I got raped

[marsh valley]

Never trust swamp people man

If you deep in the bayou and some fucker asks you to come inside
Don't

[red helm]

Ouf... Sonny... Go back and get some revenge on him.

[marsh valley]

Shoot him and burn down his house

Some real degenerates in Lemoyne

But not as bad as in Tall Trees
Those Skinners disturb me something fierce

[hidden moss]

I felt really uncomfortable the moment I got raped even tho its just a game

[wary oasis]

If you leave him afterwards you can mess about with him each time you go near

[red helm]

Unpleasantness, game or not....

[hidden moss]

Anyways I already killed him so

[marsh valley]

Feed his ass to a gator!

It's my favorite method of execution

I almost did that to the Lemoyne Raider Chief, but I wanted to watch him swing instead

[hidden moss]

Guys am I the only who cried the moment lenny passed away

[red helm]

Lenneh!

[marsh valley]

He was our future
Along with Sean

[hidden moss]

Didn't really knew Sean to well tho

[marsh valley]

Lenny biting the dust really cements the end
All the new blood dead, leaving only the old guard

[red helm]

My second play through, I tried to shot the guy that kills Lenny, but they don't let you fire your gun, until afterwards. It's very lame.

[marsh valley]

I always liked Sean
He's an annoying little shit but somehow he grew on me

[hidden moss]

Yes unfortunately

[marsh valley]

That and in low honor Arthur's journal his note is so sad
"I only realized how much I loved that kid until after he was gone..."

[hidden moss]

The saddest moment of the game was the moment artur passed away
I actually cried for a while

[marsh valley]

Now then... where to find possum...

I only cried hard this time when Buell died

Which I knew I was making that happen
But still

[red helm]

Well, I knew the Arthur thing was coming, so could prepare for that. However, for me, the Horse dying cutscene was the saddest part.

[marsh valley]

He and Hamish and Arthur Can go hunting now

Oh yeah
The horse is an ugly cry moment

[maiden sentinel]

The horse made me ugly cry

[red helm]

Now that was rather unexpected. Poor Horsey.

[marsh valley]

Arthur takes precious time to comfort the animal as it dies...
"Thank you"

[maiden sentinel]

On my first play through I kept the same horse that you get from Sadie’s place the whole time

The rage I felt after I finished the game because it died

[red helm]

Yeah, I had the red Arabian, that I found and tamed back in chapter 2. the first time I played through the game.

[hidden moss]

Guys let's take a minute silence to honor of Arthur please. What a wonderful man

[marsh valley]

A real piece of work
Who maybe found some clarity at the end

I love playing the game low honor to high

[hidden moss]

Man u disturb the minute of silence

Thank you everyone. Now lets continue with our life

[red helm]

[maiden sentinel]

Man you guys make me wanna go play the story again

I might just do that

[hidden moss]

Go ahead and enjoy your self

[red helm]

I sort of want to start a Third play through, but.... meh, Kind of in the middle a few more trophies. Stupid Grin and Bear it. and still need to do the Zoologist and Skin deep...

[maiden sentinel]

I miss my black shire in story 😭

[marsh valley]

I'd say fuck it and do the whole game again

But I'm so close to 100%
Relatively speaking

[red helm]

After I finished the 100%, I kind of got a bit of burn out, especially after trying to do Gold Rush.

[maiden sentinel]

I wanna platinum mine. There’s an online trophy I would have to be lucky to get

[marsh valley]

Gold rush is kind of a bs achievement I won't lie

Some missions are just "oh do it in 90 seconds"

Or

[red helm]

Ugh, Online Trophies...

[tacit plover]

I’m never going to try to platinum

1: Online

[marsh valley]

"Get five headshots and 90% accuracy with the maxim gun"

Which cmon

[tacit plover]

🤮

2: Zoologist

[marsh valley]

I'm not gonna be accurate with a freakin minigun

[tacit plover]

3: Gold Rush

[red helm]

Indeed, there is a bunch that seem very easy, but then you play them and it's just "Oh, you played this 15 minute mission and failed it because of this 5 second thing, retry it".

[tacit plover]

I know right

[marsh valley]

I like ones with accuracy reps and such

Sidearm only

That stuff is good

Horsemen Apocalypses with super aim and two LeMats felt godly

But some requirements are just bullshit

[maiden sentinel]

I don’t mind zoologist trophy

Because I just play music and look for the animals and vibe

[red helm]

Horsemen Apocalypse was such a fun mission, I was really sad it was so easy to Gold.

[marsh valley]

thats part of why it's good

The gold medal is a nice reward if you just played right

No time limits or nothin

[red helm]

They needed more missions like that one. and less where you travel around for 5+ minutes... That was neat once or twice, but when you are trying for Gold Medals, very ugh.

[marsh valley]

Here's a criticism of old Seamus the wagon fence
Man won't take a wagon with an MG on the back
Like cmon dude
You're a lame fence if you cant take off the maxim gun, sell the wagon, and then sell the big gun

[red helm]

Indeed, you'd think he'd be able to sale that sort of thing quite quick.

[marsh valley]

But nah apparently not

He's just a bad fence then imo

Any clue on where I can find a perfect bat?

[maiden sentinel]

I used the cave in the Elysian pool

[marsh valley]

I came up empty in there

But maybe it was just too dark

[maiden sentinel]

Hmmm

I don’t know then

Some bats were always dead at the beginning of the cave for me and I found one there

[marsh valley]

Ah. Maybe I found those as Arthur

And none have died since in the past 8 years

[red helm]

Yes, in that cave, but it's random if they are there or not. It's in the middle part that is light up.

For the bats...

[marsh valley]

Wait two bats...

Both good

Darn

[red helm]

Fooie

[marsh valley]

Two more
Both good

Ahhh here we go

Lots of live ones

Gotcha

One perfect bat

Skunk possum and beaver next

[red helm]

Yay

[marsh valley]

All this so Abigail can hide my squirrel statue

[tacit plover]

I greeted Joaquin Arroyo while he was in the jail cell and he made a yo mama joke

[marsh valley]

Truly amazing

[red helm]

Abigail is such a twirp...

[marsh valley]

I found him and th other Cortez packed into the same jail cell

[red helm]

Nice.

[marsh valley]

I do love Abigail tho

She suffers no fools

[red helm]

She was sort of okay in early chapters, to Arthur, but just annoys me in the Epilogue, and then in RDR1.

[marsh valley]

I can't really be too mad at her in the epilogue

John is really struggling to turn himself around
Eight years after Arthur went and died for him

I'd leave his ass too

[maiden sentinel]

Yeah I had a very love hate relationship with Abigail in the epilogue

[gray iris]

I have them

[marsh valley]

Ultimately
She might annoy me
But the character of John loves her
And despite it all she does love him

Ain't that the dream in this life? Finding someone who'll love you despite your flaws?
I appreciate that at least in the story

[maiden sentinel]

Mhmm

[marsh valley]

Perfect beaver is gonna make me perfectly end my life

[red helm]

Owanjila Dam, west side of it.

[marsh valley]

I'm trying up near Roanoke for the moment since I'm here

I had luck here in the past

[maiden sentinel]

I always found beavers at night

[red helm]

Eh, over where the Legendary beaver was is sort of okay for normal ones, but the Owanjila lake is better.

[marsh valley]

I don't know if I have it in me to do the exotics

I joke about suicide over the hunting
But that's got nothing on the boredom of exotics

[red helm]

I was trying to do all the Exotics without online guides...

[marsh valley]

At least I kinda enjoy hunting specific things

[red helm]

The darn Orchids just got to annoying, however.

[marsh valley]

See

I wanna be a true gamer and find it all myself

But I'll be real I don't have the spare hours of life for that

[red helm]

I am pretty proud of myself for finding 6 dreamcatchers and 7 Dino Bones on my own. After looking those up, yikes, don't know how people were meant to find all of those on their own, without literally just combing the map.

[marsh valley]

I have no shame I used guides for all that stuff

[red helm]

Oh, and 5 Stone Carvings.

[marsh valley]

Bc yknow
I'd rather just spend an hour then see the time traveler as a kid

And get the good talisman
Than spend a couple days searching far and wide

I found a UFO on my own tho

[red helm]

Nice.

[marsh valley]

I knew about the location sure
But I didn't go looking when I found the house of dead people with the UFO showing up to take them to space

[red helm]

I really enjoy exploring, so, I mostly don't mind those sorts of things.

[marsh valley]

That just sorta happened

I wish I'd slowed my roll in story mode and explored more as Arthur

I did a lot but not everything

[tacit plover]

Same

[marsh valley]

Like I should've done most of the hunting

[tacit plover]

Just got bountiful

[marsh valley]

And then just gritted my teeth and done exotics

Niiice

Did you camp out somewhere and fight?

[tacit plover]

Nah

[marsh valley]

Or run the whole time?

[tacit plover]

I went to new Austin

Did a bounty

Slept twice

Did the other bounty

And slept again

[marsh valley]

You did a bounty... while being hunted by the sheriff for your bounty?

[red helm]

Yay.

[tacit plover]

Irony, I suppose.

[marsh valley]

...nice

[red helm]

I think while you are on a Bounty mission bounty hunters won't spawn?

[tacit plover]

But I didn’t have a bounty in new Austin

[marsh valley]

I'm happy i saved all the bounty hunting for John

It was kinda cool having him freelance in between working for Sadie

[tacit plover]

Just ambarino, lemoyne, new hanover, and west elizabeth

[marsh valley]

And I got to watch Mark Johnson swing as John Marston

Knowing this'll catch up to him in four years time

[maiden sentinel]

Beautiful

[tacit plover]

JM watched MJ hang

[red helm]

John Markson? Or Mark Johnson?

[marsh valley]

Yes

But yeah that felt very dark

[tacit plover]

Yet more irony

[marsh valley]

Same guy as John
Just John did the whole buy land thing better

Didn't live in a swamp

All that for $25

At least Mark didn't have to cross two states and one national border to go home and then get killed anyway

[maiden sentinel]

Very true

[red helm]

Poor John.

[marsh valley]

Poor Jack

[tacit plover]

Same destination, different journeys

[marsh valley]

I'm gonna try and avoid all RDR stranger missions as John

Except I Know You

I wanna run around as Jack
The last gasp of the old west

Doing nothing that will really matter except give that boy more experiences besides killing Edgar Ross

[red helm]

My experience with finishing RDR1 was a little bittersweet, since I had already completed all the side thingies, for the most part, before finishing it. Though, in comparison to RDR2, there is Far fewer things to do.

[marsh valley]

Maybe that's a good thing

But yeah I wanna leave Jack stuff

[red helm]

Like, there is only 4 sets of challenges.

Or so..

[marsh valley]

Damn that few?

[red helm]

4-5... unsure..

[marsh valley]

I dread heading to 1
They've nerfed my LeMat

[red helm]

Gambling doesn't have a set, you just kind of win in specific places...

[marsh valley]

Just a nine shot revolver in that game

[wary oasis]

trying my hardest to find a Derby High Hat...

[maiden sentinel]

I played through the first one with a friend and he wanted to all the quests before playing as Jack and I didn’t because I wanted to save that for Jack

So I really need to go back and play that one again like I wanted to

[marsh valley]

I've seen John do it all

But it occurred to me this run
That just like Arthur and John share quest dialogues
So do John and Jack

[tacit plover]

For some reason the game is having me do “The Ties That Bind Us” again despite already having done it as Arthur

[wary oasis]

Yes you can do it with both Artur and JM

[drifting vapor]

I want to know what would've happened had Arthur actually taken Milton's offer. Do yall think Milton would've actually left him alone or? Ofc it's all speculation since it's a game but still

[karmic relic]

LENNEH

[marsh valley]

Hell yeah perfect possom down

And Skunk

Now I mail the possom off and nab a beaver... and I'm done

I really like possums irl
They're just trash cats

[tacit plover]

It’s not that

I already did it with Arthur

[wary oasis]

Yep

Me too

You can do it with both

[marsh valley]

Hell no
Where d'you think Ross learned the old backstab?

[tacit plover]

Now it put me back to the start as John

[marsh valley]

Milton and Ross would've done Arthur just like Ross did John

[hidden moss]

It's a glitch, so the stranger mission started again as John even though we finished it as Arthur. Majority of players got the mission too, i was confused at first but i later learned it was a glitch.

So yeah, do it again.

[drifting vapor]

Ya I mean that's what I was thinking but then again if Arthur took off they'd have to find him which would be harder and they wouldn't have the same leverage they did john

[wary oasis]

And go visit them after the second missions at Stilt Shack

[marsh valley]

True enough. Fortunately for the gang, Arthur is too deep
"Nothing matters to me more than this gang. I'd kill for it, I'd happily die for it"
Hard to turn a man like that

[tacit plover]

[marsh valley]

Unlike the Legendary Rat

[drifting vapor]

Ofc. I just like to think of hypotheticals sometimes

[marsh valley]

I notice that Micah only picks on people he sees as weak, feeble

He used to dog Hosea a lot, every time Hosea coughed

From either his asthma or lung cancer

And then when Arthur gets ill... there it is

Real interesting pattern, says a lot about the man
He only goes after people who can't fight back

Or the weak, either one

[drifting vapor]

I think Bill threatened to attack him one time didn't he?

[marsh valley]

It's the age old "Arthur would've killed him if he'd been well"
And yeah

[wary oasis]

Anyone picked up the Derby High Hat recently?

[drifting vapor]

Or I might be mistaking it

[wary oasis]

Been looking for it for a while

[marsh valley]

He never picks on Charles after our man decks him

Or Javier once he punches him

(The knife bit was with Bill whoops)

I never really hate Bill

He's just a dumb dog, too loyal for his own good

The pitbull desperately trying to achieve love

[hidden moss]

Arthur has a flaw. Arthur is a smart man but he pretended to be deaf and fool for the sake of loyalty, that's for sure.

[tacit plover]

Hosea pointed a gun at Bill due to his laziness once

[marsh valley]

See I always saw Arthur's playing dumb act as both a not undermining Dutch thing
But also a way for him to get the drop on some people who underestimate him

[drifting vapor]

I dont hate Javier either. Idk if you've ever seen the speculation that Javier was still split between wanting to join sides with Dutch or arthur/John at the end as while he's over there, he never points his gun at them like the others do, rather in the air

[marsh valley]

...but it's also a way of self deprecation
Arthur doesn't see himself as a deep and thoughtful person, as a smart man
Even if his journal argues differently

[hidden moss]

Too bad, my boy Javier is blind and never really got his character development.

[marsh valley]

He just cant see himself as anything but a dumb brute, here to kill and keep the gang in line

Poor Javi
I dunno what I'm gonna do with him

I don't want to hand him over to Uncle Sam

But I also don't want to do him in myself

[hidden moss]

It's best to hand him over

[marsh valley]

Bill? I'll let circumstance deal with him

[drifting vapor]

I mean I also think it has to do with he knows if he does discuss with Dutch it'll fall on deaf ears

[hidden moss]

In my opinion

[drifting vapor]

Like he tells Charles, he knows their criminals, but Dutch would never ever take that as an answer

[marsh valley]

Yeah...

I appreciate Hosea more every time I play

"I don't do much thinking"
"Now I don't believe that for a second Arthur"

Especially this one camp encounter I had in 4 i think
He's telling Arthur to think for himself, knowing he's not always going to be there to talk Dutch off a cliff edge

[hidden moss]

Right? but i think he wanted to reach Dutch and talk about it but never really had a courage to say so.

It only happned in chapter 6

After chapter 6, i bawled ny eyes out and cried for 10 minutes straight.

[drifting vapor]

Ya,the end was truly sad

[marsh valley]

I actually got fed up this time in chapter 6

And started Antagonizing Dutch

Calling him on his shit

[hidden moss]

Same

[marsh valley]

"You let him damn us all"

then I antagonized Cleet and Joe at the same time, since they're worth about half an insult a piece

[hidden moss]

I antagonized Javier too even though he was my favourite character but he is acting like a douche

[marsh valley]

I went back and forth with him

And Bill

Sometimes trying to be nice

[hidden moss]

Even he insulted Charles! I was so disgusted when i saw it ingame.

[marsh valley]

"I know this is all hitting you hard Bill"
"Don't think you can sidle up to me Morgan"
"But like a kicked dog you're just too dumb to see it!"

[hidden moss]

I really like Arthur's insults

[marsh valley]

Chapter 6 is just so depressing
Can feel the ghost of Hosea haunting the camp

"Mister you have a kind face"
"...thanks?"
"The kind I'd like to PUNCH"

[drifting vapor]

It's a shame there is not enough gang bonding in the free roam of the story. I wish it was like gta and saints row where you could take some of thecgang members with you to do random things

[hidden moss]

Sometimes sarcastic or just brutal

[hidden moss]

Yep

[marsh valley]

I try to play John as only high honor in 2

Low honor is more suited to a man with nothing to lose
And John has everything to lose now

[hidden moss]

The only time i was enjoying gang members bonding, it was fishing with Kieran

[drifting vapor]

Luv what Arthur says when the naked swimming guy appears

"Is this why you love fishing here?"

[hidden moss]

How can i forgot about that

He has so many iconic lines to be fair

But i really like his sarcastic jokes

[marsh valley]

I also love fishing with Javier

Heck, I loved doing anything with Javier

He and Arthur were a good team

"Hey, you're right! Only an idiot would give a greaser a gun!"
Javier snickers

That and the home robbery with him in chapter 2 is also just classic

[drifting vapor]

Bit off topic but that reminds me, I was disappointed with the amount of house robberies. I figured there'd be more the way they featured it

[marsh valley]

Yeah I wish there'd been more

But you can rob the debtor at Catfish Jackson's early if you didn't know

I home robbed them from some tip I got

Then came right back and collected the debt next chapter. Guy even remembered me.

My favorite robbery tip has to be Willard's Rest tho
You show up, and find Charlotte Balfour the widow

Help her learn to survive
A couple missions later she offers you anything you want from her house...
And it's chapter 6 so I turn her down the money is meaningless now

Here's a question: what was going through Dutch's mind when he left Arthur to die in the refinery?

[drifting vapor]

So what I think is after that trolley crash where he hurt his head, Micah took advantage of him and started making him think Arthur was the real traitor. Dutch was just worried about making enough noise to escape so if the natives were distracting him he could leave. Arthur's trial would be a big distraction and he could just tell the gang at that point Arthur wasn't worth it or was a traitor.

Charles Sadie and John might try to break him out which could cause a good distraction for Dutch also who would end ties with them as well.

[tacit plover]

I was pissed the locked a BANK ROBBERY behind the “Ultimate” edition of the game

[drifting vapor]

Idk how I keep missing that mission. I've literally got ultimate and gotten the horse and stuff from it but haven't ever been able to find that mission although I've heard its not worth it anyway

[tacit plover]

It’s in chapter 4

[drifting vapor]

Must be because I never usually hang around the camp in chapter 4 really

[marsh valley]

If you do Horsemen Apocalypses you miss it

[marsh valley]

tbh
I bought Ultimate Edition on PC for regular price cause of that
Not worth, its a tiny mission

[drifting vapor]

Damn I'll have to pay attention to the camp next time I go through it

[marsh valley]

But it's Uncle and Charles so I mean I had fun

[drifting vapor]

Don't u get only paid like 60 bucks from it?

[marsh valley]

Just not a huge take
Rhodes is poor

Eh like a hundred I think

As we already knew, nobody in that town had more than $750

[drifting vapor]

Well wtf are the grays and Braithwaite keeping their money

[marsh valley]

As the horse fence says

[drifting vapor]

They don't have gold or a bank account

[marsh valley]

They're both basically broke

Two ailing families

And we're the dumb cowboys who fall for their trappings of former glory