Like: ‘oh look someone responded to my question I put up on a public chat for the purpose of getting an answer, time to respond with a violent threat!
#red-dead-singleplayer
fluid cypress
fluid cypress
I don’t see why I need to prove anything to you.
outer tiger
Or is yours balls even dropped yet?
gray wasp
Like: ‘oh look someone responded to my question I put up on a *public* chat for ...
like: "How fucking dare you answer me, I'm going to punch you for that-"
lol
fluid cypress
Maybe come back once you’ve learnt English in your elementary school 🥴
fluid cypress
like: "How fucking dare you answer me, I'm going to punch you for that-"
lmao
outer tiger
Guys, u are fun 11yr gay kids
outer tiger
Maybe come back once you’ve learnt English in your elementary school 🥴
Ummmm, im not american. Im finnish
I dont care if some words are wrong
Idm
Neekerit
fluid cypress
I’m still laughing at the ‘oh look! I got what I asked for time to write a threatening message with grammar that sounds like it came from a toddler!’
outer tiger
Hahahahahahh ur probably laughing
So fun😂😂😂😂
Omg hahahaha
I dont surprise if you tell me that u play fortnite with thay gay xbox kid and be on same facetime jerking like this🤏🍆
gray wasp
Hey, I'm a year younger than you and I'm acting wayyyy more civil and mature than you
ok
that's a bit much tbh
frigid cloud
outer tiger
fluid cypress
Hey, I'm a year younger than you and I'm acting wayyyy more civil and mature tha...
welp partner, looks we’re born in the same year 🙃
gray wasp
¯_(ツ)_/¯
frigid cloud
lzzzzzz he's muted
frigid cloud
bye
gray wasp
bye
fluid cypress
I have my exam tomorrow this what I’m doin
frigid cloud
he's muted, dw
hidden moss
troll gone for good
fluid cypress
ye
frigid cloud
I have my exam tomorrow this what I’m doin
you should study instead
frigid cloud
I know how it feels
gray wasp
yeah so I spent all day yesterday catching up
and guess what
the universe decided that that day was a good time for a 6-hour power outage...
icy cove
I need a bit of help, yesterday I was trying to do the hunter quest which usually has a poster on the wall for the Rhodes post office but it isn't there for me. I've completed the mr white and Mr black and I'm currently going for 100%, on 92.7 as of now.
Any ideas of how to fix this
tame widget
I need a bit of help, yesterday I was trying to do the hunter quest which usuall...
Hunter quest? You mean bounty?
icy cove
Nah, if you go to the completion tab, there something that says hunting challenge or something along those lines, the poster for that objective is on the post office in Rhodes usually
Or sometimes other offices
I think
It's the Ms L. Hobbs mission
lean sparrow
My hands are aching cuz of fishing
gray wasp
hanging in the wall
icy cove
Yeah but I finished the game already, do I need to do it In chapter 2?
gray wasp
Yeah but I finished the game already, do I need to do it In chapter 2?
No? It should still be there...
icy cove
It was there for me, saw some other people with that problem but they fixed it by doing mr whites and Mr blacks missions but I already did that
Wasnt!
Sorry
Lol
I checked saint Denis, Rhodes and valentine
frigid cloud
Do you? my mark went from a A to an F basically
I have no A or F, it's different here
lean sparrow
Where is the ignose gar fish
gray wasp
The Legendary one?
or just any old gar?
because you find the legendary Gar just north of Lakay...
hidden moss
Where is the ignose gar fish
Check the compendium
foggy grove
I have my exam tomorrow this what I’m doin
i dont revise i just believe in myself 
gray wasp
Have some goddamn faith
lean sparrow
because you find the legendary Gar just north of Lakay...
I only get the sturgeon
gray wasp
I only get the sturgeon
Are you using the Special Swamp Lure?
because that's the only way
fluid cypress
i dont revise i just believe in myself <:eybluescaredsmile:895666131753381909>
Only works for maths lol
I have maths
Still scared shitless
lean sparrow
Are you using the Special Swamp Lure?
Yes
jagged escarp
Legendary animals are a pain
lean sparrow
Oh wait special
gray wasp
Oh wait special
jagged escarp
Literally never spawn for me
lean sparrow
Are you using the Special Swamp Lure?
But im trying to get the normal one
gray wasp
Ohhhhhh
I was able to catch one on the train tracks to St. Denis, opposite of where you catch the Legendary Sturgeon I think
lean sparrow
I was able to catch one on the train tracks to St. Denis, opposite of where you ...
Can you show it on the map
gray wasp
Nope! 
lean sparrow
Ok
gray wasp
Go to #rdo-compendium, the locations are the same for Story mode as well
trust me I've done it
lean sparrow
Cant find it the list is too long
last orchid
Finally caught arabic horse (dunno how translate it to eng. maybe, it is right)
gray wasp
Arabian?
gray wasp
Finally caught arabic horse (dunno how translate it to eng. maybe, it is right)
the horse breed is Arabian I think
last orchid
the horse breed is Arabian I think
yeah, mistake
last orchid
so, i cant feel any difference between arabian hrs and my old hrs (stamina 3, speed 3)
fluid cypress
There’s a big difference dude Arabian’s stats are like 7 speed 5 stamina if I’m not wrong
last orchid
There’s a big difference dude Arabian’s stats are like 7 speed 5 stamina if I’m ...
"i cant feel" and "there isnt any difference" not same things
i dont know how i can describe it, but there is really a little or no difference for me
hidden moss
Same
gray wasp
It do be like that
lean sparrow
Go to <#722870280690597938> I've revealed the locations
Thanks man i got it first try
Appreciate it
gray wasp
Always welcome, I told you it works 
lean sparrow
What time does cougars spawn
icy cove
Yeah I really want to the master hunter, but I've seen one cougar early in in the game. They're the hardest animal to find it seems. Let alone 5 of them
lean sparrow
I cant complete the challenge where you need to kill 5 of them with bow
lean sparrow
Yup
icy cove
Hopefully the rest after that aren't as hard
I can't even do the last legendary animal because you need level 9 master hunter :((((
icy cove
Yeah kind of sucks considering the one me and Michael are on will take so long
I've seen like 3 cougars even after beating the game like 5 times
And I'm trying to 100% :(
I'm at 92.7 rn so not too far off but the remaining missions are either hard or take wayyyyyy too long
I've done dinosaur bones though. That mission is such a hassel
Doesn't take long, but just isn't interesting
gray wasp
I've done dinosaur bones though. That mission is such a hassel
ooooh I only know where a couple are, any info?
icy cove
I can send you a map of all of them
icy cove
Or atleast the one I used, but there's also a video that does really good and is more accurate
gray wasp
Oh ok
icy cove
I'll send the video because the picture doesn't show the ones in new austin
gray wasp
alright
gray wasp
I'll send the video because the picture doesn't show the ones in new austin
I'm in chapter 4 so that's irralevant
calm crow
I have just saved a game but what happens if i Press “overwrite”
gray wasp
only one way to find out!!! ¯_(ツ)_/¯
icy cove
If you overwrite the save you are currently playing, all it does is replace that save with the one your using right now. Which is just a more recent save
Basically replacing old data with new data if that makes sense
calm crow
Soooo i just save it once more?
last orchid
I've seen only one cougar ever
lemme guess, it was quest with cave and black cougar?
icy cove
Do let's say you saved 1 hour ago, if you overwrite that save, it just saves to where you currently are instead of the one hour ago
gray wasp
and also I don't count that one
icy cove
So yes you can overwrite your save as long as it's the same world
last orchid
It was white-
ah, mistake again. sure, it was white
calm crow
So yes you can overwrite your save as long as it's the same world
Wdym same world?
icy cove
Like the same save
gray wasp
So yes you can overwrite your save as long as it's the same world
(If I saved back in chapter 2, can I go back to that save without erasing weeks of progress?)
last orchid
btw i have seen cougar in west of grizzly mountains
icy cove
So if you want to do that, save the game on a different thing. Don't overwrite the save
So save in a clear space
calm crow
But as Long as i saved it im fine?
icy cove
Yeah you can go back and forth
icy cove
But as Long as i saved it im fine?
Yeah
icy cove
Yourwelcome, out of curiosity, why you wanna go back to chapter 2?
tawny nimbus
who else is fckin tired of hearing the woman outside the saint denis tailor saying LEMME VOTE LEMME VOTE every time they try to look cool
i get it
good interaction
but god damn its so repetitive all the time
icy cove
There's a lot of things like those repetitive people yelling. Reverend in strawberry, mayor in strawberry, that lady, pamphlet guy in Saint Denis, scientist in annesburg ect.
Kind of annoying but I don't notice it much anymore lol
dull knoll
Successfully filled out the animal compendium as Arthur. Only one I can’t get is Rufus
tawny nimbus
bruh
too badd you cant finish the game as arthur but it feels good knowing john finished his work
icy cove
I didn't even know Rufus was a option lol, also how did you get the animals that are in new austin?
dull knoll
I use glitches from the 1.0 version
icy cove
I still need like 70 more animals which Includes guarma but there's that one glitch to go there
dull knoll
That’s what I did
It’s impossible to search Guarma easily during the story
So frustrating
icy cove
Yeah
dull knoll
I didn’t know the pit trap was a thing
marsh valley
Fortunately, they’re not required for 100% completion
I wish I’d have been able to cook while in Guarma
icy cove
Yeah that's good it's just I'm a collector man ig lol
marsh valley
What’s the point of hunting if you can’t cook and craft?
I wanted to eat some wild pork…
dull knoll
I really just wanna finish the story missions and have it be immediately 100%, like that was the only thing holding me back
icy cove
Me neither haha
marsh valley
Not that I know of. Tried at the camp fire
icy cove
Walking to second run room brb
marsh valley
Cause I went hunting when I had the chance
dull knoll
It’s predetermined
You can’t
If you call your horse you get a message: “Your horse is not on the island”
Rockstar basically calling you an idiot
marsh valley
I really need to play all the stranger missions as Jack Marston
Be Jack the Lone Gunslinger
Angry with the outlaws, the police, the Bureau, and the Federal Government as a whole
The last gasp of the old west
icy cove
Someone just pulled a gun out their waist to show someone now the cops are here. Not very pog.
marsh valley
Wait uh…. Irl?
icy cove
I just want to go to a normal school that doesn't have people bringing guns like once a week
Yeah
Kind of cringe
marsh valley
Like that really happened… well shit you don’t live in Texas do ya?
icy cove
No Im in Kentucky sadge
icy cove
Lol yeah, kentucky is kind of hill Billy trash.
I don't think it's the state. Just the school I'm in
Doesn't happen to other hs
Much
But at my school like twice a month it happens
Doesn't sound good but honestly at this point I'm completely unphased to fights and shit like that since it's like every other day
tawny nimbus
nah bruh i bet that shit plastic
all jokes aside
thats not good
nobody knows??
or do they not care
icy cove
It probably is plastic but usually it's real but not loaded. They care, thats why cops are here but honestly not enough to prevent something like that
There is a reason my school is rated poorly
calm crow
If i activate a cheat will my game progress get lost?
icy cove
Save before you use cheats because you can't save while using them
Very important lol, I lost hours of progress due to that.
calm crow
Cant i just turn off the cheats, save, and enable the cheats?
icy cove
I'm not sure.
icy cove
No worries
fringe hatch
Imagine a Red Dead Redemption 3. With Jack reuniting with some of the old gang members. Like Charles and Sadie
In a different map ofc
fringe hatch
I don't know if they can make another completely different story with nothing related to the old games.
I mean Van Der Linde story has stayed in us
for 2 games now
I would say for Rockstar to use the imagination. They have potential
calm crow
Naah enough with the prerequel
icy cove
I don't think a third game Is a good idea but if they make it about before the blackwater events and then have blackwater be the last mission, it may be good
icy cove
I would prefer a prequel to rdr2 than a sequel to rdr2
fringe hatch
Naah enough with the prerequel
They could do a sequel to rdr 1
icy cove
Rdr1*
calm crow
I want to see the game continue as Charles
icy cove
I don't really care for Jack much personally
calm crow
Or Jack
icy cove
Charles is cool
calm crow
I want to see him in Canada with a family
icy cove
I just think the blackwater event sounds cool
Same
Love charles alot, my favorite character apart from arthur and John
marsh valley
I somehow want to see Jack Marston fighting in WWI
icy cove
That would be interesting
marsh valley
Maybe forced to join the French Foreign Legion after killing Ross
Cause he sure as hell wouldn’t fight for the US Army
Not after what they did to his dad
Most of the combat would be the same
Like think Guarma but for a whole campaign and in the French mud
icy cove
So do you think they should scrap the map and make a new one or have multiple maps so you can to like beechers hope?
Ect
marsh valley
Huh?
icy cove
Because I would want to see Jack up keeping beechers hope. Fulfilling Abigails dream
A little
marsh valley
I can’t decide if he’s fucked on that count or not
Cause he shot and killed an FBI agent in hot blood
So he might have to flee the country
lean sparrow
How do i complete gambler 5
marsh valley
Or… Agent Archer is the one who takes the case and lets it go cold
lean sparrow
What are the rules in dominoes
icy cove
Never got to it
marsh valley
He always thought Ross was a bit of a monster, and he didn’t show up to kill John with the rest
icy cove
Oh I have no idea how to play dominoes lol
marsh valley
John did his job and they stabbed him in the back
Maybe he’d hear of Jack and turn a blind eye to it all
Try to bury the case
If not, Jack could run off to Mexico I suppose
icy cove
Mexico would be interesting. Mexican government in the first game was really interesting so I wanna see how it would be for jack
tough plume
Oh I have no idea how to play dominoes lol
How it’s soo easy
icy cove
I just place the ones it let's me
tough plume
Exactly
icy cove
I assume you have to match the number
tough plume
Yup
icy cove
I'm practically a pro now
marsh valley
Well the people would probably love him, his father was a local hero and something of a revolutionary
tough plume
I'm practically a pro now
I know the feeling
icy cove
Yeah. Jack turns into the Mexican government lmaoo
uneven sierra
@ionic gull
ionic gull
<@561691933433397269>
hi
icy cove
Imagine if he was just the government haha
ionic gull
Hiya give yourself roles
🙂
marsh valley
I see Jack more as an anti government kind of guy somehow
ionic gull
done
marsh valley
Is that old cuss still alive in 1914?
hidden moss
What are the rules in dominoes
The game tells you
marsh valley
I just wish we knew conclusively what happened to Jack
icy cove
What if there was just a Landon Ricketts games. Bad ass gunslinger just demolishing fools lol
marsh valley
I know there’s a GTA Easter egg where he’s written a book
marsh valley
He’s got a lot of good material
Shoot, could publish a book off of Arthur’s journal alone
Then write about John
And more
Might have a career there if the government doesn’t get him first
icy cove
Idk if you agree. But i always thought it would be cool to write a book about rdr2 or maybe if Rockstar instead of making a game, made a book of the previous events leading up to rdr2
I don't like reading much, but would def read that
Arthur should have became a artist instead of a bad ass outlaw. His art is so good. John on the other hand is well.... ya know... a bit... bad in comparison
tawny nimbus
nothing makes me want to live more than the soundtrack of american venom
i dont fucking know why its a song made for some pixels rendered by techonology
but it sure as hell is one of my favourite songs of all time
tawny nimbus
most games i dont know how to play
robbing that river boat with trelawny and javier with strauss
fluid cypress
Ye I only play poker that’s it
tawny nimbus
i just randomly pressed buttons
fluid cypress
lol
wary oasis
most games i dont know how to play
Read the instructions
fluid cypress
I wish there was arm wrestling
Like in rdr1
That was
Fun
But can’t complain with how many side activities we got
wary oasis
I wish there was arm wrestling
There was in GTA San Andreas
fluid cypress
There was in GTA San Andreas
Dunno only played that like 10 years ago
tawny nimbus
probably wasnt as known in 1899 but what the fuck should i know
fluid cypress
Man I always wonder
How tf does Arthur wake up in 3hrs without an alarm clock
wtf
How can I learn this power
hidden moss
Dont udnderstand it
The help menu
tawny nimbus
thats it
fluid cypress
How lol
tawny nimbus
chad mindset
fluid cypress
I mean u can wake up whenever u want
In the game
Lol
Not 6am
Also in some missions they are like let’s wait till night or some shit
fluid cypress
Ye braithwaite manor
tawny nimbus
if you go at day
marsh valley
Arthur should have became a artist instead of a bad ass outlaw. His art is so go...
iM sOmEtHiNg oF a DrAfTsMaN mYsElF nOw
tawny nimbus
it just turns into night in the cutscene
tawny nimbus
iM sOmEtHiNg oF a DrAfTsMaN mYsElF nOw
HAHA yea true
marsh valley
John your art is awful this is why I marked all points of interest as Arthur
fluid cypress
Dunno I started it at sunset so it just blended into night
marsh valley
Can’t draw, can’t swim
hidden moss
How tf does Arthur wake up in 3hrs without an alarm clock
Napping when you're not very tired
marsh valley
Well he can herd
marsh valley
Ooooof
tacit plover
Which isn’t very impressive
fluid cypress
what can john do
Can’t herd, can’t swim, can’t draw
tawny nimbus
<a:marston_ded:760803405953499166>
oh you motherfu-
tacit plover
Buy it is something he can do
tacit plover
Can’t herd, can’t swim, can’t draw
He can herd now
tacit plover
Which was when he basically couldn’t do it at all
tawny nimbus
in chapter 6
if anyone knows
the interaction between jack john and micah
john plays with jack which is something he wouldnt do in the first chapters
tawny nimbus
and protects jack from micah
gentle haven
I have almost $1000, I have to urgently find a way to spend
marsh valley
“Micah said he’d take me fishing”
Don’t go with him Jackie he’ll kill you just like he killed Cain.
wary oasis
I have almost $1000, I have to urgently find a way to spend
I remember going into the EP with like $6k
marsh valley
Fucked me up that Micah killed the camp dog
tawny nimbus
Fucked me up that Micah killed the camp dog
yea
like killing animals? what did the animal do to you
marsh valley
But I took an eye from him, so maybe it’s fair
tawny nimbus
micah is the fucking animal
gentle haven
I remember going into the EP with like $6k
😨
tawny nimbus
im glad arthur fucked his eye up
marsh valley
“Your buddy Arthur did this to me!!!”
fluid cypress
I have almost $1000, I have to urgently find a way to spend
yeep
marsh valley
Oh yeah
fluid cypress
That’s what I did
marsh valley
Imagine Micah living with that for eight years
fluid cypress
Just bought a lot of outfits
marsh valley
Knowing his time surviving is now limited
tawny nimbus
yea
marsh valley
One eyed gunslingers don’t have a long shelf life
I figure that led to my Arthur living rent free in his head for every second of those eight years
tawny nimbus
with Dutch to your left , john to your right and sadie literally in front of you you know youre gonna die
upbeat basin
Hehe just finished 2nd playthrough yesterday
I "baptized" micah as john by shooting him in the head, balls, and each shoulder.
It was nice to see him die
marsh valley
Funny. He called me Slow Knife Morgan when I lost at five finger. My knife wasn’t so slow after all huh?
marsh valley
Quick enough to blind his fool ass
upbeat basin
Wait when is he half blinded
upbeat basin
Oh
marsh valley
Which wasn’t my concern at all. I’d have torched that whole sack if possible
upbeat basin
Ive only gotten high honor help john twice
marsh valley
I just wanted Micah
And to yell at Dutch
It’s not about the money, it’s about sending a message
Besides
Susan couldn’t lie there dead all alone…
fluid cypress
Anyone else feel like return for the money high honor was supposed to the canon ending? Cuz like in the epilogue Sadie sneaks up on him, Micah is skilled gunslinger so that wouldn’t rly work unless he was blind and then dutch shot him, again from the left so like everything’s going on the left side. Also I don’t rly remember that well but Micah’s character model after he’s dead always has a scar no matter what ending u choose. Also to top it off John doesn’t rly talk that much abt Arthur if Arthur didn’t choose to go for the money and go with John wouldn’t Arthur like mean a lot more to john?
marsh valley
The way Micah misses every shot he takes at John when the standoff breaks makes me buy it
Besides there’s a cycle then
fluid cypress
Ye
marsh valley
Arthur went back for revenge, died. John went back for revenge, died. Jack goes back for revenge, then what?
fluid cypress
But I still like the mountain ending better
tawny nimbus
Arthur went back for revenge, died. John went back for revenge, died. Jack goes ...
breaks the cycle
marsh valley
Mountain ending is more beautiful
But there’s something to knife fighting Micah in the middle of the burning camp that’s just satisfying
tawny nimbus
The way Micah misses every shot he takes at John when the standoff breaks makes ...
probably why he has like 50 men instead of his saying in the coach robbery optional mission in chapter 4 where he says 10 good men would be the best not 20 with women
fluid cypress
Arthur went back for revenge, died. John went back for revenge, died. Jack goes ...
Tbh if they do make a game following jack it wouldn’t rly be a western anymore
upbeat basin
Yeah they cant do a 3 from jack imo
marsh valley
probably why he has like 50 men instead of his saying in the coach robbery optio...
Cause he can’t cut it anymore and knows it. He’s living on borrowed time, it’s a miracle his “good friends” Joe and Cleet haven’t killed him in his sleep.
Because he’s weak
upbeat basin
And what would he redeem himself from is my thought
marsh valley
Injured
fluid cypress
It would go more closer to something like the mafia games
rain herald
Tbh if they do make a game following jack it wouldn’t rly be a western anymore
They could make it a game about the mafia if they do that
upbeat basin
Oh mb
fluid cypress
They could make it a game about the mafia if they do that
Welp u already have the mafia games set just over a decade after rdr1 if I’m not wrong and that’s a take two game soo
marsh valley
I just wish we got more on Jack. Knew where he’d end up
If I go back to RDR1 I gotta try hard to ignore every stranger
Leave Jack some Wild West adventure to enjoy
fluid cypress
Mafia isnt rockstar
Tbh I don’t see why take two would let rockstar make something in that timeline it’s basically the Mafia games and r* will nail em as usual (or maybe not) and mafia games would just become unknown
fluid cypress
I just wish we got more on Jack. Knew where he’d end up
Maybe a book could work for that
marsh valley
Yeah it’s just not likely we’d get the RDR writers doing a project like that if it didn’t come out at some point before this
fluid cypress
Yeah
marsh valley
Then again, we’re maybe getting an RDR remaster so nothing is impossible
rain herald
Tbh I don’t see why take two would let rockstar make something in that timeline ...
Im talking about mafias in general rockstar wouldnt need to even talk about making a game based off a mafia
marsh valley
Perhaps
fluid cypress
They could just keep the tradition and make another prequel
Or maybe a new story entirely set in the same universe but before rdr2
marsh valley
They could, and yet I dunno about that
People keep asking for more Van der Linde gang
And I almost want them to do something new
Maybe have us play as Uncle
Back when he was the “One Shot Kid”
rain herald
Or they could make a game around the odriscals
fluid cypress
Tbh we’ve seen the important stuff there’s nothing too much in the past except the ferry
marsh valley
I wouldn’t play that game on principle. Fuck Colm.
fluid cypress
Or they could make a game around the odriscals
Bruhh that wouldn’t rly work
People hate em
marsh valley
Yeah unless we go deeper into the past there’s not much Van der Linde gang left to tell about
fluid cypress
Ye
marsh valley
I want some old characters but not everyone
Which is why I wanna play as Young Uncle
Maybe get some insight into how he’s combat capable yet refuses to do anything but drink
fluid cypress
Maybe they could go all the way back and make a red dead revolver who knows
fluid cypress
Maybe get some insight into how he’s combat capable yet refuses to do anything b...
And say lumbago
marsh valley
Game ends in a doctor’s office as he receives the diagnosis
And is forced into early retirement
rain herald
People hate em
Why? Because theyre rival criminals?
marsh valley
Cause they got no souls
I wouldn’t wanna play as them cause they’re all monsters
Not murderers. Monsters.
Like what Bill becomes running his own gang
Rapists and women killers
fluid cypress
Why? Because theyre rival criminals?
Lol looks like you haven’t heard the tale of cold o’driscoll’s Twitter acc
slow bison
I finally finished everything! Its tedious but sure is worth it.
fluid cypress
Just based on that I don’t think people would like a game abt the o’driscolls
fluid cypress
I finally finished everything! Its tedious but sure is worth it.
100%? Damn
slow bison
@fluid cypress Yeh
fluid cypress
Tbh I ain’t bothered for a 100% cuz u won’t rly get a trophy/achievement unless u do online
and I haven’t touched online not even once
Not intending to
vagrant inlet
hey all, I;m looking for help to install some mods I like. Never done it before and rather not f up my game files etc ^^'
slow bison
@fluid cypress online is fun to be honest.
fluid cypress
Not interested I have no faith after gtao
slow bison
You can feel freedom in Online without the restriction of Story mode if ever that makes sense
fluid cypress
plus none of my frnds play online so I’m least bothered
I mean like one guy does
But that’s it
slow bison
The achivos for the OL is not as tedious compared to story. Its like OL was the non tedious version of the story.
marsh valley
…see I see the opposite
Doubling the prices of some guns. Adding level caps to buying em. All of that feels more restrictive than story mode
Where I could get a semiauto shotgun in chapter 2 and a Carcano in chapter 4
Besides
With no good story to carry me through gameplay, why do I want to just grind?
I can terrorize the npcs in free roam and not have Griefers
slow bison
@marsh valley well if you see it that way. But you did it anyway for the achievos
lean sparrow
I rode from van horn to black water in 13 minutes without touching water and i didnt get the challenge completed why
slow bison
I rode from van horn to black water in 13 minutes without touching water and i d...
Can be a wrong starting point, or you did cross any stream?
Could also be interrupted gallop?
crimson bronze
Yeah unless we go deeper into the past there’s not much Van der Linde gang left ...
I'd say Hosea would be interesting to do a story about, He himself states he was a very brutal bastard in his youth before meeting up with Dutch
hidden moss
Hosea is cold hearted
Just listen to what he says if you kill Crawford and his son, he just doesn't care
marsh valley
And yet, he cares deeply enough about his own
"My only regret in life is that I attained wisdom at such a price..."
He tries to teach that to the others
It worked on Arthur I'd say
muted prawn
So does anyone else think it’s weird that you can’t “buy” a working girl. I was shocked when I saw that wasn’t an option, especially being Rockstar and all. Yes, I know you can do the bath but not the same.
severe belfry
I haven’t touched online yet
I mean I only just got the game but from what I’ve seen the online is only fun with friends and most of my friends either don’t have an Xbox or don’t have rdo overall
The thing is the single player feels so alive and immersive
That I just don’t feel the need to play online at least for now
I can spend forever doing side quests
pale bridge
if i go into chapter 3 without doing some things in chapter 2 will i be able to do them again
i didnt get camp upgrades
will i miss out on any missions or sidequests
marsh valley
Yes
Stick around and you can do all sorts of stuff
There's a lot of small jobs like that
pale bridge
the last save i made was a couple days before
marsh valley
I'm glad Jim Milton Rides Again? has no time limit
Abigail can bitch and moan all she'd like, we helped Geddes, I got a bunch of new powerful weapons, and made at least $120 doing all this looting the house and the bodies
pale bridge
and idk if its worth redoing all of that progress
pale bridge
in chapter 3 can i still upgrade my camp?
marsh valley
Yes
fluid cypress
in chapter 3 can i still upgrade my camp?
I think u can upgrade till ch6
frigid cloud
chapter 4 is the last opportunity
frigid cloud
because you couldn't find the ledger
marsh valley
Yeah we basically starve
frigid cloud
can't upgrade in chapter 5 & 6
fluid cypress
Lol I never used to donate
fluid cypress
Only in my first play through but after ch 3 I stopped caring
marsh valley
I do, if only to outdo Micah whenever he brags
And to buy camp stuff
I miss a time when people sat around the fires on the skins I'd hunted and laughed and told stories
fluid cypress
Welp whatever I did all icons in camp stayed red and never seemed to stock so I just gave up
fluid cypress
I miss a time when people sat around the fires on the skins I'd hunted and laugh...
Don’t make me cry
Pls
marsh valley
They burned my cougar skin chest, ox rug, and boar skin table
All my trophies went up in flames
My skull collection too
Ram, gator, wolf, all gone
fluid cypress
All I’ll say is 
marsh valley
See I don't see it as abandoning him, just splitting up earlier
You make the big loud distraction
Be like that bomb hosea set off in Saint Denis
And Marston escapes
And you get to confront the men who destroyed the gang
fluid cypress
Kinda feels like abandoning, especially after he says ‘you want the money? Go for it I have a family’ or something
marsh valley
And yet every time it's offered up he goes right along
fluid cypress
haha lol
marsh valley
Always in the thick of it
fluid cypress
Ight I gtg
marsh valley
Arthur is sort of hypocritical
But cmon Micah deserves to get burned on this
He's a rat
hidden moss
I got like 3000 dollars so Im always throwing in 20-50 bucks in the box
I keep the supplies stocked up and all
crimson bronze
So does anyone else think it’s weird that you can’t “buy” a working girl. I was ...
In short, Arthur has a reason for it even if it's never explicitly stated, He's still pining for Mary and also doesn't want to make another family that will inevitably get killed or die in some unfortunate manner.
marsh valley
Pretty much
crimson bronze
For John it's because he's trying to stop being such a general degenerate and be a proper husband and father to Abigail and Jack Respectively.
marsh valley
And Jack either is sticking to his family’s moral code
Or he’s so far gone even the whores don’t want him
dull knoll
I’d like a Jack mod for rdr2 where you just play as child Jack
Throughout the entire game
calm crow
is it good to overwrite every time you complete a mission?
glad brook
Yes.
fluid cypress
is it good to overwrite every time you complete a mission?
Ye
Unless u want to play a mission/that particular time period again
Just create a new save if u want
But just save after every mission or atleast once before u close the game
marsh valley
Shit...
I think I just helped the kid Micah orphaned find his dog
Yknow that house he shoots up in Strawberry?
gray cargo
tried to stab a aligator
marsh valley
Definitely deserves it
So I’m taking the bounty to take that guy from his family
As John. This hits a bit different.
languid mortar
yeah
I had an idea last night
about what if rdr was a 3-part series
and the order was reversed
where our rdr1 would be the finale of this 3-part series
this alternate 3-part would have 1 be about the beginning of the end, ending somewhere near the blackwater massacre, 2, and 3 would be pretty much the same as our rdr2 and rdr1
brave ledge
how do i get horses that aren’t from store?
gleaming whale
tame
glad brook
And Jack either is sticking to his family’s moral code
Nope you should listen to some of things Jack tells them lmao.
dull knoll
As John. This hits a bit different.
I tried so hard to just spare him as Arthur
Mission fails if you try
marsh valley
Yeah
I wish the Panther skin wouldn’t prevent me from wearing the gator bracelet. I get it’s a coat but it clearly doesn’t reach the arms
marsh valley
Horrah I caught Lindsey whatever his name is
And I'm debating
Gator food?
Or a good old hanging?
Silly me I forgot John can't swim
So I just bought the Legend of the East satchel at a fence?
All that work youd have to do in the main game and you can pay 200 in the epilogue
Amazing
oblique sand
using the dx12 api seems to work better than vulkan ...
what are you guys' experiences
sinful knot
using the dx12 api seems to work better than vulkan ...
for sure it will
vulkan sucks
hidden moss
Are we allowed to say spoilers on here or so?
Just want to make sure so I don’t make anyone mad 
candid pasture
spoilers are allowed
unique garnet
using the dx12 api seems to work better than vulkan ...
IME Vulkan worked better
candid pasture
but if your purpose was to ruin someone else’s experience then that’s not allowed but other than that yes spoilers are allowed 
unique garnet
but i dont think im using dx12
hidden moss
Nah I don’t want to probably why I was asking lol but I did the chapter 4 quest before the Bank Rob in St Denis and I’m not ready 
Arthur looked so shocked when Dutch killed Bonte so it made me tear up a tiny bit because he’s getting sick 
fringe hatch
using the dx12 api seems to work better than vulkan ...
Vulkan doesnt work well for me. I cant fullscreen
But in terms of fps vulkan is better.
But uses more resources
boreal smelt
I just died with legendary animal pelt and it said I can go to trapper to get it by there’s nothing here
hidden moss
Killing Brontë was fine
hidden moss
I just died with legendary animal pelt and it said I can go to trapper to get it...
The trapper already has it.
arctic wren
American venom time
arctic wren
It has been done
boreal smelt
The trapper already has it.
So how do I get it back
hidden moss
So how do I get it back
Why do you want it back?
Are there any changes on the map in the epilog of rdr1?
I wouldn't expect much since it's like 3 years but there has to be something
boreal smelt
When I get my guns form my horse and I go check to see if I have them they aren’t there
last orchid
What's name of reserve save file?
main sparrow
vulkan sucks
if u have an amd card vulkan gives more fps
for nvidia dx12 is better
and for the ppl that cant fullscreen
try alt tabbing out of the game then coming back and setting it to fullscreen
brave ledge
are horses are to tame
fluid cypress
are horses are to tame
wht?
I’m assuming u mean hard, it actually depends
Some horses are easy to tame
Some (like the white Arabian) take like 20 minutes to calm and one wrong step, one movement faster than u should’ve done can just reset all ur progress and spook the horse
Also dont forget the time it will take to find certain horses
They only spawn in a specific area and can be hard to find
So yeah
Kinda hard
hidden moss
When I get my guns form my horse and I go check to see if I have them they aren’...
Send a video of this.
bronze pumice
Why do people slowly walk up to a wild horse to get it instead of just driving up to it on another horse and using the rope to grab it?
brave ledge
I’m assuming u mean hard, it actually depends
yea i meant this lol
brave ledge
Some (like the white Arabian) take like 20 minutes to calm and one wrong step, o...
ah that sucks
hidden moss
Why do people slowly walk up to a wild horse to get it instead of just driving u...
So they get it calmly instead of scaring it and doing the rodeo
brave ledge
what’s a good horse that’s fairly easy to find and tame
bronze pumice
So they get it calmly instead of scaring it and doing the rodeo
But then they spend minutes walking up to it slowly when you can get it in less than 30 seconds the other way.
hidden moss
Doesn't really matter tbh
bronze pumice
Is not falling off of it when it’s lashing out at you that hard?
hidden moss
For some people
bronze pumice
I’ve never struggled with it. I don’t even think I’ve ever fallen off.
hidden moss
Only time I ever did was in rdr1 when the camera went everywhere
After that it's easy as hell
bronze pumice
You mean in RDR2?
bronze pumice
That’s what I meant.
hidden moss
I know
frigid cloud
Why do people slowly walk up to a wild horse to get it instead of just driving u...
I agree, whole lot easier
hidden moss
Why do people slowly walk up to a wild horse to get it instead of just driving u...
Because the latter option is unethical
tacit plover
Do I need to do the rodeo for it to count as ‘breaking’ in horseman 10?
boreal smelt
Why won’t it let me use fence
hidden moss
How many missions do I have to do, to get out of Gurma or something I just started chapter 5
tacit plover
There’s 5 missions until you get out of Guarma
sly tundra
Does anyone know how to play RDR1 on PC? I can't find it anywhere?
hidden moss
Okay thanks!
boreal smelt
Can you use the fence with a bounty
hidden moss
I have no idea
tacit plover
Can you use the fence with a bounty
Probably
boreal smelt
Every time I go near him he locks
tacit plover
Every time I go near him he locks
What does the pop- up in the top left corner say when you go near him?
frigid cloud
you can't if you have over 250$ bounty
tacit plover
I just threw the hunter hatchet into a guy who procedure to fall into a waterfall
Now it’s under the water
I think it’s lost forever
hidden moss
Why won’t it let me use fence
It does
fringe maple
Does anyone know how to play RDR1 on PC? I can't find it anywhere?
There is no PC Version
hidden moss
you can't if you have over 250$ bounty
Untrue
frigid cloud
how?
hidden moss
I just did business with Seamus, with 325 dollar bounty
frigid cloud
i meant using shops
sly tundra
There is no PC Version
oh, that sucks
fringe maple
hopefully better than GTAs remake😅
oh yeah
that shit
I'm so glad the community didn't get it fly past them
because Rockstar probably would go back to milking GTAO
sly tundra
Yeah🤣
tacit plover
What exactly counts as “robbing” a coach?
hidden moss
welcomes
night tide
What exactly counts as “robbing” a coach?
Gotta rob the boxes in the back. Go to the ones parked in the towns and just walk to the back and rob it
Ones in Rhodes, Saint denis, valentine, ect
hidden moss
What exactly counts as “robbing” a coach?
A stagecoach has a strongbox in the back. Rob it to rob the coach
jagged escarp
Why do I have to hold X sometimes during cinematic view but others I don't?
Seems really inconsistent
hidden moss
Seems really inconsistent
It's not. You always must hold X during missions. You can let go in free roam.
jagged escarp
I guess I'm just misremembering. I haven't played in a while and finally am getting around to finishing
hidden moss
I guess I'm just misremembering. I haven't played in a while and finally am gett...
What's your profile picture?
jagged escarp
An eye
weary herald
Why do I have to hold X sometimes during cinematic view but others I don't?
In free roam you can let go but in missions you have to hold X
hidden moss
What is it from lol
jagged escarp
Desert Sessions album cover
hidden moss
Thanks
hidden moss
👍
hidden moss
Looks nice
jagged escarp
Looks nice
I can send you an image of it if you want.
chrome pond
My Dad played and I got a 90$ Bounty in Lemoyne and New Hanover...
Epilogue though, so paid
Thinking of starting a playthrough with him when I get back from college for Christmas
arctic wren
Some (like the white Arabian) take like 20 minutes to calm and one wrong step, o...
I mean I just run up to it, jump on, then just do the thing to not get bucked off
Takes like a minute
hidden moss
I mean I just run up to it, jump on, then just do the thing to not get bucked of...
That's unethical
arctic wren
I then feed and clean the horse and just stand and pet it to make up for that
fluid cypress
I mean I just run up to it, jump on, then just do the thing to not get bucked of...
Yeah sure try that with the Arabian it will bolt before u even get remotely close to it
Unless ur calming it afar every millisecond the horse just runs away
arctic wren
I just go up with my horse
Lasso it for a sec
Then let go and grab on
Usually works
There was the time that instead of throwing my lasso I threw a fire bottle
But that was an accident
fluid cypress
There was the time that instead of throwing my lasso I threw a fire bottle
LMAO
marsh valley
Man I’m relistening to the track that plays in the Arthur V Micah knife fight
Damn it’s so ghostly and ethereal
The two rivals finally duking it out in the fiery remains of the camp while ethereal angels wail
“You’re a snake!”
“A snake huh?! Then you’re a vulture Morgan!”
Call me Slow Knife Morgan one more time motherfucker I dare you. Take the other eye too.
autumn verge
Being over dramatic bud
marsh valley
Hardly, it’s the best ending
hidden moss
The best ending is high honor go with john
marsh valley
It’s got the other great view of the game
The cliff at night
I can’t decide if I prefer that or the burning camp
Both are very dramatic locations
misty smelt
how do u fix erro code 18
hidden moss
Anyone know why bountiful trophy won't unlock?
marsh valley
No idea
I wonder if Micah caught TB in my ending. Arthur bit his hand and drew blood, that’s surely enough.
But, so long as he doesn’t get beaten half to death or go to Lemoyne he could be just fine with it
final jetty
Guys
i did an oopsie
and i need help
or advice
i am junting a legtendary animal, i killed it and it fell in a lake
and i cant skin it
marsh valley
Get on the horse and try to bump it back to land
marsh valley
If it hasn’t sunk
final jetty
its under water
marsh valley
Hmmm
final jetty
xd
marsh valley
Do they respawn if you miss em?
marsh valley
Might have to reload
final jetty
i cant be bothered
marsh valley
Which animal?
final jetty
moose
tacit plover
I think I lost my hunter’s hatchet
marsh valley
I recall that one being good. I’d go back personally but it may not be worth it to ya
tacit plover
It went into the water
final jetty
yes
marsh valley
Hooray!
final jetty
noooooo
marsh valley
Skin for the skin god!
marsh valley
Get it back quick
final jetty
how?
tacit plover
Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for hatchets
marsh valley
Hooray the skin god has saved you
If only I was allowed to skin the Legendary Rat…
Micah’s head would go nicely over the fireplace I’m just sayin
tacit plover
I’ll try going back to where it first was
That worked for the Civil war knife
If it isn’t there, I’ll go to my weapon locker
marsh valley
Civil War knife and the Hardee hat are dope
But I prefer the dagger the Saint Denis vampire carries
lean sparrow
Can you pause the game while doing horseman 9
hidden moss
i am junting a legtendary animal, i killed it and it fell in a lake
Reload
tacit plover
But I prefer the dagger the Saint Denis vampire carries
What’s your favorite unique hat
Not including Arthur’s or John’s, obviously
marble horizon
How do I collect the auction money after the valentine thing
tawny nimbus
you cant i think
marsh valley
What’s your favorite unique hat
Scarlet Big Valley Hat
Cause it made Arthur look like the Man in Black from Westworld
With the hat and the LeMats and all
tacit plover
What can I do with a perfect goat and pig hide?
red helm
What can I do with a perfect goat and pig hide?
Bring perfect pelts to the Trapper, if you are interested in clothing. If you are still in early chapters, however, you may want to check out Pearson in the Gang Campground, you can upgrade some of the tents and such with pelts.
tacit plover
Bring perfect pelts to the Trapper, if you are interested in clothing. If you ar...
In EP2, so I’ll go to Trapper
red helm
Yeap, no upgrades you can do to the Ranch with pelts, unfortunately. Rather disappointing that they didn't do anything with that.
wary oasis
Is it a while before you can place the squirrel statue on the fireplace?
sudden halo
Guys, there's a fundraiser for the memorial hall thing in saint denis. should I loot their lootbox? and how much will I get?
I gave them 20 dollars but I can take how many money they have and be on the same honor
tacit plover
Yeap, no upgrades you can do to the Ranch with pelts, unfortunately. Rather disa...
Should I give perfect carcasses to the Trapper?
frigid cloud
Is it a while before you can place the squirrel statue on the fireplace?
after American venom which is the end...
marsh valley
I have new appreciation for Uncle
wary oasis
after American venom which is the end...
Thanks
marsh valley
Man had Dutch figured as early as Chapter 2
"You want to be king with your group of knights!"
"See boys, there he goes, the greatest man we know... and even he is lost..."
red helm
Should I give perfect carcasses to the Trapper?
Umm... Might be okay to give carcasses, but I was always paranoid and made sure to skin them and sold everything seperately, just in case.
marsh valley
For some critters like the panther I brought it to him
You get extra cash
And he makes some remarks too
icy cove
for some reason the hunter quest still hasnt appeared. ive checked every post office in the game
😦
red helm
I tend to find it outside the trolley station in Saint Denis.
icy cove
ill check it again
red helm
You're checking for a poster, right?
icy cove
yeah
red helm
Okay, making sure. It's not a mission marker or some such.
icy cove
unfortunately i dont see it
red helm
I think I remember it being on the outside part, next to a poster for a theatre.... I wonder if there is some other requirement to get it to show up.
red helm
That's the lame. Guess you need to be careful where you are throwing those unique weapons.
tacit plover
I’ll check my weapon locker before I give up all hope
icy cove
i see the theatre poster but not the hunter one, thanks for the help though
ill check out armadillo again
tacit plover
i see the theatre poster but not the hunter one, thanks for the help though
Where’d you go?
red helm
Hrm... Yes, others have talked about the Hunting Request poster not appearing for awhile, then it just being there later. So, perhaps there is something else required for it to be around..
icy cove
Where’d you go?
saint denis was the one i was just at, but ive checked every post office
icy cove
yeah i seen someone in a video get that one. didnt see that poster. just some random poster about buying land lol
so this website im on says there is one in armadillo but theres no post office. all i see is just 1 million posters of cholera. feel like im running pass it lol
frigid cloud
perhaps the quest is already active...
icy cove
if thats the case im gonna cry, ill check my documents
red helm
You can check your active missions.
red helm
😆 Have it already?
red helm
No worries. Huge tip, make sure to look up all the birds you need, before you need them, and get them first. Since when you need them, they are Way harder to find.
icy cove
ok thanks
red helm
Especially the Robin and Woodpecker....
frigid cloud
well thanks baran haha
np
hidden moss
No worries. Huge tip, make sure to look up all the birds you need, before you ne...
You don't need to cheat
wary oasis
Robin's easy to find in at Ringneck Creek
hidden moss
I did all the hunting requests without cheating up until Ms Hobbs went on vacation
Robins are elusive but possible to find, and woodpeckers are literally everywhere I've seen 10 or so
tacit plover
Unfortunately, the hunter’s hatchet was not in the weapons locker because the weapons locker only has guns
final jetty
guys from which point can i buy a mauser pistol
i just finished the part where you kill bronte
picked the gun up
and now i want to buy a secondary
wary oasis
CH4 I think
tacit plover
and now i want to buy a secondary
You can get one from Billy Midnight
wary oasis
Go to gunsmith in Saint Denis
final jetty
or no