#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 527 of 1

marsh valley
#

As Arthur

#

But no matter
Stuff for later

#

If I go back to RDR1 I wanna try and leave a lot for Jack

#

Have some reason to keep playing

#

I'm leaving so much gold behind in chapter 6
20 bars from various treasure hunts
All of it for the Marstons now

#

$10,000

#

I found a UFO once

tacit plover
#

Is that from the end of the main game?

marsh valley
#

Yup

#

One of the two endings
The one I'll be going after once I've decided I've fucked around enough

red helm
#

That's what I did in my second play through, as much as I could as Arthur.

tacit plover
#

I took him alive as Arthur just because, went to the Saint Denis jail in the epilogue, and he was still there

red helm
#

Funny, hang the poor bastitch already.

tidal relic
#

my current outfit's in the fashion thread, anyone wants to see

red helm
#

Vertical stripes, how sliming.

marsh valley
#

Execution by… gator!

#

My favorite method of disposal

tidal relic
marsh valley
#

Love that pinstripe

#

But… I’m always won over by the Whittemore

#

I’m so happy you can keep that suit with the glitch

boreal smelt
#

Do you get red dead online with ultimate edition

marsh valley
#

I think so, I’ve got it

boreal smelt
#

Nice

#

I just got it lol

gray wasp
#

I just had a 6-hour power outage... sadcat

rain herald
#

Is arthur sining to himself while riding normal?

gray wasp
#

Awwwww is he?

#

That's awesome

rain herald
#

I can dm you a quick recording if you would like @gray wasp

gray wasp
#

Sure why not? As long as I don't get doxxed or anything lol

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

rain herald
#

How the hell would listening to a recording get you doxxed?!

gray wasp
#

IDFK

#

I'm an idiot

#

don't question my methods

rain herald
#

Ill question them all i want >:]

gray wasp
#

...

tidal relic
#

I'm doing the Professor sidequest rn, and I'm at the point where I have to bring in a bounty to use as a test subject for the chair

#

Arthur's being such a dick describing the way he's gonna die, and I love it

gray wasp
#

Ikr

#

So mean...

#

lol

marsh valley
#

Debating on going after all the dinosaur bones
If only to drag out the ending

#

Imma find some of em

hidden moss
rain herald
#

Just came out of the camp when it happened

sinful knot
gray wasp
#

And there is from being painfully electrocuted?

#

At least a gunshot is quick...

sinful knot
#

you get to enjoy a finale of pain

#

for one last time

rotund ermine
#

ran into a guy sifting for gold, waited around until he found a nugget and immediately murked him lol

#

i love how detailed this game is, i was almost expecting him to just loop dialogue while sifting

#

now i have gold 😎

marsh valley
#

Nice

#

But have you ever found a man who fell off his horse and had a pocket full of gold teeth?

#

No clue where he found em

rotund ermine
#

he was just savin' them for later

#

don't worry about it

#

i'm just impressed that the guy found gold and arthur had unique dialogue for robbing it from him, i waited around for a minute or so

rotund ermine
#

oh shit i found the jack hall gang map just by exploring

#

i was really expecting to have to look it up

floral umbra
rotund ermine
#

where the fuck is the second one 😩

floral umbra
#

Idk

marsh valley
#

Accidentally lost two honor levels cause I shot some flaming buckshot at some bounty hunters and killed their horses

#

Guess I have to get that back up

#

Somehow

#

Probably talking to people in Saint Denis

#

But hey I found the Mount Shann UFO, back to dinosaur bones for a while

tidal relic
#

I was in, I think Rhodes, some guy was showing off his new gun to his friend and accidentally shot him

#

I didn't know that could happen

marsh valley
#

Yeah funny stuff

#

I got arrested in Valentine because my horse lagged into a collision with a man, and in the subsequent fight he punched Buell
Buell killed his ass dead with one kick, knocked me into the mud, and suddenly the law is there...

#

I'm just too sick with TB to care
Fine, arrest me and take $15, your funeral being that close to me

#

Literally came to this town for a bath, rest, meal, and some horse care

marsh valley
#

21/22 bones at last

marsh valley
#

Time for My Last Boy
Real close to the ending now

#

I'll need to hunt after this, finish stocking up on moonshine shot and explosive shot

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

That battle really lives in my head rent free

#

It's one of the best fights of the game imo

fringe maple
#

Yea.

#

Sad part of is...well

#

Eagle Flies flies

marsh valley
#

Saved Arthur and therefore John

#

And Abigail

#

And Jack

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

Really owe that man

fringe maple
#

Honestly, kinda sad seeing Rains Fall in the epilogue

#

How he basically turned insane

marsh valley
#

He's a broken man

#

And Dutch made him this way, the bastard

#

Yet another white man using him and his people for their own gain

fringe maple
#

Honestly, kinda mad because I was like still in Chapter 2 before I got spoiled the game

marsh valley
#

All the shit Dutch does, that takes the cake

fringe maple
#

I was having the time of my life too

marsh valley
#

I got spoiled about the tuberculosis

#

But that didn't matter

fringe maple
#

fully

marsh valley
#

It's about the journey not the destination

fringe maple
#

Yeah

marsh valley
#

I watched the ending over my roommate's shoulder

#

Still bawled like a child finishing it myself

fringe maple
#

I usually took a break during the Rhodes chapter

#

I went hunting

marsh valley
#

That's what I did this run

fringe maple
#

and got mauled by the Nightfolk

marsh valley
#

I did Master Hunter in chapter 3

fringe maple
#

fun times

marsh valley
#

Panther skin

#

Hell yeah

fringe maple
#

Honestly doing my 2nd playthrough

#

on chapter 6

#

and I don't wanna continue

#

I don't have the soul

marsh valley
#

I continue on out of spite

#

Micah shall pay

fringe maple
#

I might get on my other account on xbox

marsh valley
#

And since I turned around my honor I can make him pay!

fringe maple
#

played my 3rd and a half playthrough

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

Low Honor saving John is iconic imo

#

"Damn you!"
"DAMN US BOTH!"

#

Felt right somehow

fringe maple
#

proceeds to cope and seethe as he shoots Arthur

marsh valley
#

As will reverting to old habits and charging down that hill

#

The money doesn't matter
Vengeance does

fringe maple
#

bit off topic

marsh valley
#

Besides, this way John will escape easy, as I will be making a huge noisy distraction

fringe maple
#

but the mission where Kieran looks like a French King in 1799

#

and the O'Driscolls attack

#

I gotta say

marsh valley
#

Oh... Horsemen Apocalypses

fringe maple
#

their ost is pretty epic

marsh valley
#

One of my all time favorites

fringe maple
#

ngl

marsh valley
#

I got to put the LeMat to the test

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

And turns out it's a rifle

#

In revolver clothing

#

Cause I sniped so many of em

fringe maple
#

I might had to chug some rum

#

but that's fine

marsh valley
#

Game should have explained to me it's fine to drink and take chewing tobacco
That they don't count as health items

fringe maple
#

Gotta say it's when Sadie gets her plot development rolling

marsh valley
#

Guarma Rum hits different after you been drinking it on Guarma itself

fringe maple
#

Loved that mission with the Gatling Cannon

marsh valley
#

For sure

#

Guarma is painfully short

#

BUT

#

It has some of the coolest moments of the series

marsh valley
#

Short, sweet, and full of turn of the century warfare

#

I didn't expect that when I bought Cowboy Simulator

fringe maple
#

I mean it's also kinda set the political influence that the US had on Cuba and the surrounding islands during the Spanish-American War

#

also

marsh valley
#

And you can read about that in the papers as early as chapter 2!

fringe maple
#

Haitian Men together stronk

marsh valley
#

Yes they are

#

I really love the newspapers

#

They give so much flavor

#

"Chinese exclusion act upheld"
"Spanish American war ending in record time"

#

Plus reading about the heists

fringe maple
#

Yeah, especially the newspaper scrap Arthoor has about the first heist

marsh valley
#

Yeah... been a long time since the gang did the robin hood gig

#

"We've turned into a bunch of killers, I mean it!"

#

Hosea saw it

fringe maple
#

head to St. Denis and give some money to the beggars (though they just acting)

marsh valley
#

What a tenuous position he held
The questioner who never got on Dutch's bad side, probably because of seniority
When Arthur tries that, Dutch shuts him down and calls him a traitor

#

I like the Rhodes veteran actually

#

He's a decent sort

fringe maple
#

I mean

marsh valley
#

Wrong side of the war but a good guy

fringe maple
#

kinda biased as I am a Southerner myself

marsh valley
#

Texas here

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

But I'm not one to buy into the Lost Cause

#

Like

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

That statue in Saint Denis of General Quincy
I laughed hard when I saw the word coward on the statue of "The hero who defended the South in the War of Northern Aggression"

#

Like first
War of Southern Treachery get it right
Second
He's Nathan Bedford Forrest, thus the coward bit

#

Ahhh

#

If only Arthur had voted with Hosea

#

Maybe we'd all be in Tahiti

fringe maple
#

pretty funny

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

Apparently if you go to the battlefield in the rain you get confirmation he was a coward

#

Retreated when it got hairy, let his men get slaughtered

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

The ghosts tell you

#

Oh man that line

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

That mission is also great

fringe maple
#

the Ghost Train

#

in Saint Denis

#

not saint denis

marsh valley
#

never found that but I think I heard the swamp ghost once

fringe maple
#

I mean Scarlett Meadows

fringe maple
#

honestly

#

it can go die in a hole

marsh valley
#

I did find two UFOs tho

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

First one was entirely an accident

#

Second, I went looking

#

Aliens exist who knew

fringe maple
#

Third one I think is in the Heartlands

#

or I think it was a rumor

#

idk

#

saw a video on it.

marsh valley
#

Only two I know of

#

Some shack full of skeletons

#

And Mount Shann

#

Night Folk are cool but scary

fringe maple
#

by accident too

#

I was like

#

the hell

marsh valley
#

I went looking so I could do the Night Folk Stranger Mission

#

helping some guy evict em from his house
using bullets
Never met him before

fringe maple
#

I then proceeded to do my ancient ritual of feeding them to the gators

marsh valley
#

Ah

#

I fed the slave catcher to the gators

marsh valley
#

And the Saint Denis Eugenics guy

fringe maple
#

the guy you help find the flintlock and watch?

marsh valley
#

Dunno, but I found poetic justice in that kill

#

Yeah him

fringe maple
#

Oh yeah

marsh valley
#

He spent his life hogtying people and tossing em on a horse going somewhere unpleasant

#

I just recreated the experience for him

#

Lit his ass up with a fire bottle while the gator ate him alive

#

Kicked the remains into the swamp for the fish

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

Gator somehow was fine

fringe maple
#

honestly

#

thinking of returning to online

marsh valley
#

Never got into that

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

Always seemed like the boiled spinach next to the prime rib that is story mode

sudden halo
#

guys what's the most expensive (selling) and best horse to use for?

fringe maple
#

but this is singleplayer so

fringe maple
#

probably the Arabian idk.

marsh valley
#

Idk but Buell is the best horse imo

sudden halo
#

white arabian?

fringe maple
#

yeah I mean

#

you can find it in the wild

#

in the snow

sudden halo
#

yeah

#

white arabian is actually my main horse

marsh valley
#

I appreciate having a horse with level 9 stats

#

Just like me

sudden halo
#

I've been thinking of just farming selling horses

fringe maple
#

I had to legit buy a 3rd horse

#

one died during my trek to save Sean

#

died falling down two feet cliff

marsh valley
#

My first horse Sleipnir got run over by a train

#

Very sad indeed...

fringe maple
#

second i named Quint II got legit bullied by a wagon

sudden halo
#

lol

fringe maple
#

and the one I got during the rhodes one I called after my brother

#

hasn't died since

marsh valley
#

Buell killed a man the last time I went into town

fringe maple
#

and I'm proud

sudden halo
#

my first horse ran into a wagon, and I didn't have any horse reviers

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

Boah

#

But yeah

fringe maple
#

what what

#

oh my god

#

I forgot that buell is a boy

marsh valley
#

I got in a fight
He laid hands on Buell
And the kick knocked us both into the mud
He died

fringe maple
#

the name and looks had decieved me

marsh valley
#

I just got arrested cause I couldn't be bothered to escape or shoot up the town
Trying to be better than that

#

Yuh Buell has big old balls

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

Afraid of nothing but snakes

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

See I'd have done that but I didn't get what I came to town for so I got arrested

#

Legit I just needed a shave, a bath, a meal, some sleep, and horse food

tidal relic
#

Re: horses, my personal mount is a dark-chocolate Shire named Minerva

marsh valley
#

Last horse was named Dolores

#

She's stabled now

#

And gets to live

#

While Buell and I shall go out in a blaze of glory

tidal relic
#

I have another one named Titania

fringe maple
#

I need to do the Veteran Mission

stoic swallow
#

anyone still play collector?

fringe maple
#

and find Charlotte

marsh valley
#

You should do both of those

tawdry moon
#

Baby arthur

fringe maple
tawdry moon
#

Horse name

marsh valley
#

Chapter 6 is so depressing

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

And Hamish and Charlotte make it a little brighter

fringe maple
#

Compared to 2

marsh valley
#

Arthur makes friends outside the gang

tidal relic
#

Should I kill or spare Anthony Foreman

fringe maple
#

Honestly, when I first loaded up the game

stoic swallow
#

hmm well rockstar decrease the sell price @fringe maple

marsh valley
#

People who care, right there at the end of his life

fringe maple
#

I was very suprised with the graphics

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

It's... very nice
Hamish met this Arthur when he was still an awful man, and his friendship helped him become better

fringe maple
#

Kill is more satisfaction

marsh valley
#

Yeah I killed that asshole

#

They abused Tilly, and I love Tilly

tidal relic
#

Same

fringe maple
#

The three girls are epic

marsh valley
#

Poor Karen...

tidal relic
#

She reminds me of Lisa from Saved by the Bell

fringe maple
#

Karen, Mary-Beth, and Tilly

marsh valley
#

She just... vanishes

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

Probably so

#

Either that or she's further east/west

tidal relic
#

Alrighty then, killing it is~

marsh valley
#

And either still a drunk or has her act together

fringe maple
#

Honestly, her alcoholism took her over

marsh valley
#

It really did

#

Swanson is also a high point of 6

#

Come back from hell... and Swanson is okay

fringe maple
#

I'm glad Tilly and Mary-Beth made it out

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

I was annoyed by it

fringe maple
#

Ngl, thinking of buying RDR1

marsh valley
#

Game tryna get me to play poker against my wishes

#

I'm debating on playing it next

#

Leaving plenty for Jack to do

fringe maple
#

I mean

#

I want to know the rest of the story

#

and my main goal in gaming?

#

Get 100% in both games

#

(and beat Dark Souls if I ever get it)

marsh valley
#

Dark Souls is not something I'm going back to

#

I'm all for challenge and ball busting difficulty...... just not like that.....

fringe maple
#

man went through hell

#

then to heaven

#

then back to hell

#

then back to heavan

#

then back to hell

#

then finally, heavan.

marsh valley
#

God... this is just such a depressing mission

#

Dutch wound up Eagle Flies to see how he'd go

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

The pure heartbreak in Rains Fall's voice...

fringe maple
#

I even yelled at Dutch for leaving Arthur

marsh valley
#

Borrowing from Arthur's journal:
"That sight will stay with me until I die"

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

Hot take

#

Dutch is worse than Micah

#

Like that random Mexican dude I met said

#

Often those closest to us are the most cruel

fringe maple
#

Kinda sad seeing his people get gobbled up like on a Rich Man's platter.

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

Dutch claims these people are the last true Americans along with his gang... then he uses em up and throws em away

#

And gets all ornery finding out Arthur has been helping them "behind his back"

fringe maple
#

in his balls

#

and then Micah

#

in his balls

marsh valley
#

Micah comes first for damning us all

#

Then Dutch

#

Much as I hate our fearless leader, there's an order of operations to be followed

#

Rats before family

#

That, and he's been a right prick this whole game

fringe maple
#

As through all the missions I took a moment to take photos

marsh valley
#

I love photomode for that

fringe maple
#

hold on lemme get on social club real quick

marsh valley
#

Should make a compilation of em all sometime

fringe maple
#

I have like

#

3-8 already

marsh valley
#

I have so many screenshots

#

Maybe half are good, but I have 230 mb of em

#

Something I love about hanging out with Rains Fall is just how much he influences Arthur
"I saw a man who not so long ago I would have seen as pathetic and weak, and yet now... I see a strong man humbled by forces I scarcely comprehend"

#

And when he told him about his own son... damn...

#

Rains Fall also gives you a great trinket that almost nullifies your TB

#

If you do his mission with no bloodshed

#

from -20% to cores to -5%

fringe maple
#

thats cool.

marsh valley
#

Worth the effort for sure

fringe maple
marsh valley
#

I think I'm well on my way in that regard

#

76% so far

#

Thank god I can skip the Guarma animals

#

Well, reloaded a save

#

Realized I'm low on fire shot and explosive shot

#

And I need at least a full rack of one of those for this mission

fringe maple
#

well, probably gonna go to bed

#

and just to make sure

#

dutch does indeed

#

fucking suck

marsh valley
#

I love how Arthur

#

No matter his honor

#

Won't take a cent of the oil refinery money

oblique sand
#

damn ...

#

my game keeps crashing and idk why

#

its a gpu crash cause my amd controller pops up to tell me its an issue relating to that

#

happens relatively close after starting up the game, did a mission and then near the end it froze then closed

oblique sand
#

just changed api to directx to see if it will improve ... doesnt

#

lol it was working fine until now got like 5 hours or so clocked in

#

why is it just crashing every 10 minutes all of the sudden

hidden moss
#

hey

#

anyone think that Dutch hit his head when the ship went down and that’s what caused him to turn crazy and ruthless

marsh valley
#

Trolley station robbery

hidden moss
#

oh yeah true

marsh valley
#

You can chalk most of Dutch’s batshit insane decisions in 4 and 5 to him being concussed. Increased impulsiveness, rage, trouble thinking, the signs are all there.

hidden moss
#

you can see the face of regret on him when arthur dies with high honour you can see that he regrets what he did

#

because him hosea raised arthur, i bet if hosea was still alive it wouldn’t have went down that way

marsh valley
#

Hosea was the only one who could doubt Dutch without him ignoring it

hidden moss
#

yea and dutch listened to hosea

#

also i wish it was a option to not help micah out of strawberry

#

Not only did dutch care about the money but i heard that he wanted to be close to his mother’s grave in black water that’s why he never left completely

willow linden
#

Hosea's death was basically the downfall for the gang

#

Shit went down real bad after that

hidden moss
#

exactly

#

i didn’t react that much to lennys death but when hosea died i was aboutta cry

willow linden
#

Yeah

marsh valley
#

I was shattered when Lenny died

hidden moss
#

during chapter 4 and 5 they killed of quite a bit of the gang members and if they didn’t kill them most of em got injured

marsh valley
#

Another of Arthur's proteges dead

#

First Sean, then Lenny

#

And just like that

willow linden
#

I still hate dutch for believing in a snake he found 6 months ago over someone he raised.

marsh valley
#

The Van der Linde gang has no future in it

hidden moss
#

i never liked sean tbh no hate on him

languid mortar
#

wasn't micah in the gang for a year

marsh valley
#

By the end yeah

#

He and Charles are still the newest

languid mortar
#

I want to shoot Micah

hidden moss
#

all of us do

#

at least i think

marsh valley
#

Dutch buys Micah's talk tho cause he's a Yes Man
And Dutch's mental illness requires mindless followers

marsh valley
#

Except... Micah has his own plans

languid mortar
#

y'all ever heard of Micah's backstory?

willow linden
#

Nope

marsh valley
#

His own brother says if Micah is within 50 miles

#

He'll come find him

#

Break his neck

hidden moss
#

also is it just me or does any one else ship arthur and sadie

marsh valley
#

So Micah can apologize to God on both their accounts

languid mortar
hidden moss
#

ight guys i gtg but nice talking to you

willow linden
#

Arthur's final mission hit like a bitch

marsh valley
#

"When I had daughters, I vowed to protect them, to keep them safe from the evils of the world, I begged God for strength, if only he would help me to atone for all I'd done"
I'm paraphrasing but Micah's brother is an okay guy now

willow linden
#

Fr

hidden moss
#

cya

marsh valley
#

I don't ship Arthur and Sadie

#

I ship Arthur and Charlotte

languid mortar
#

Who is Charlotte again

marsh valley
#

Charlotte Balfour
The widow up near Marko's lab

#

North of Annesburg

languid mortar
#

oh

willow linden
#

Yeah

marsh valley
#

You teach her to survive on the land

#

And she makes it

#

For Chapter 6 that's really happy

hidden moss
#

what were their names

#

them rhodes couple

languid mortar
#

i still ship arthur and sadie but I dont think the relationship would've been like saide and her husband

marsh valley
#

uhh

#

Penelope and

hidden moss
#

we and claire

marsh valley
#

....

hidden moss
#

yeaaa

#

penelope

marsh valley
#

Whats his name

hidden moss
#

weau

languid mortar
#

beau?

marsh valley
#

Beau yeah!

#

Good kids

#

Hope they made off well in Boston

willow linden
#

God chapter 6 was depressing, just looking at Arthur's pale ass skin was depressing enough for me ngl.

languid mortar
#

I used to think Beau died in the sean death mission

marsh valley
#

At least you can make some friends

#

Hamish being one of em

#

I loved that man

#

He and Arthur talking late into the night is such a good scene

hidden moss
#

rip him

marsh valley
#

Given Arthur is losing friends by the dozen

languid mortar
#

I heard some dialogue from Arthur which I must've thought was about Beau

hidden moss
#

i forgot

marsh valley
#

Both at the end of their lives

hidden moss
#

what happened to rain falls

#

where did he go

marsh valley
#

Crazy sorta

languid mortar
hidden moss
#

to?

marsh valley
#

Broken and wandering

hidden moss
#

canada was it?

languid mortar
#

I think?

hidden moss
#

heard he went to canada

marsh valley
#

His tribe made it there, but he's in America in 1907

willow linden
#

Rain Falls was a nice guy

marsh valley
#

His son's death has broken him

hidden moss
#

yea yea

marsh valley
#

Sucha nice man

#

One of the people who I credit redeeming my low honor Arthur

hidden moss
languid mortar
#

I constantly fantasize about a scenario in which (most) of the gang from ch2 lives happily ever after

hidden moss
#

:)

languid mortar
#

I can't believe I care about these guys so much

marsh valley
#

Gives Arthur medicine and a chance to air some of his feelings
About his dead lover and son for example

#

I feel bad for whoever skipped that mission

languid mortar
#

you can skip it?

marsh valley
#

It gives such insight into Arthur, why he's such a cold and sour man

willow linden
#

I feel bad for whoever went the wrong way during Arthur's last ride triggering the dialogue and music to stop.

marsh valley
#

He's been hardened by pain, and the TB has split that shell open

#

I once heard some guy missed the ride to Shady Belle

#

Cause he walked and found the gang in Lakay

#

Which...

#

That's like missing the Mexico bit in RDR1

languid mortar
#

I remember ploughing through ch6 missions

#

because after guarma I was just nonstop doing missions

marsh valley
#

I've tried to pace myself

#

Do all the fun stuff Arthur can

languid mortar
#

didn't quite know what else to do

#

and was too absorbed into the story

marsh valley
#

Try and see some camp scenes

#

I hunt, fish, make ammo

#

Gather herbs

#

Do challenges

willow linden
#

Beaver Hollow was legit the most depressing campsite tbh

marsh valley
#

Yall seen that fan video of Dutch returning to Beaver's Hollow?

#

Where he's slowly losing it?

willow linden
#

Dk but I returned to beaver hollow as John and it was full of bandits

marsh valley
#

Makes sense

#

If yall want a link I got one

#

That video is canon for me

willow linden
#

Tbh after everything Dutch did, I don't feel bad for the dude one bit.

marsh valley
#

Especially after he gets Eagle Flies killed

#

The members of the gang with souls left won't touch a cent of that money

willow linden
#

He literally teared the whole gang up by listening to the rat

#

Though it's ironic how Dutch dies at the bottom of a mountain and Arthur dies on top of it.

marsh valley
#

Depending on your ending

#

My Arthur will be going back for revenge

#

He just snaps and charges down the hill, come what may
Money isn't the goal, Micah is

willow linden
#

There's only high honor Arthur in my book

marsh valley
#

I will leave him crippled, a permanently wounded predator struggling along for the rest of his life

#

Knowing he's slower now, less accurate, less perceptive

#

That one day
He'll miss

willow linden
#

Man if only Arthur bit Micah

marsh valley
#

For a man who sees all of life as surviving and dying
That's hell

willow linden
#

He would've gotten TB and died the death he deserved

marsh valley
#

Besides, this ending makes more sense to me
If you're dead and John is running, it's better to create a massive distraction
Lead the Pinkertons the wrong way

#

Nobody will be following him, they'll all be coming for me

willow linden
#

Help John makes more sense to me since chapter 6 was all about saving what's left.

marsh valley
#

Fair enough

#

I've just done both Help John endings

#

And for a low honor Arthur who only went high in the last weeks of life

#

The violent end and confrontation with Micah makes the most sense

#

That a violent man would snap and revert to old habits there at the end

willow linden
#

Micah executing Arthur would've just pissed me off even more so I don't do low honor endings lmao

marsh valley
#

It felt deserved in mine

#

But Arthur didn't flinch

#

And that run
He was waiting in hell for Micah to join him

willow linden
#

Arthur accepted what he did

#

Micah denied

marsh valley
#

There's just something badass about being the damned gunslinger, and your final act is to do something good, even if you pay for it

#

But yeah other reason I'm going for the ending I am
I don't want Susan to lie there all alone...

#

She deserved far better

#

Although the low honor money ending has a great line to Dutch

#

"You let him damn us all Dutch!"

willow linden
#

High honor ending makes more sense to me since chapter 6 was all about Arthur's redemption and trying to do what's right with the time he have left, and I think being faced with the reality of your incoming death changes a person.

marsh valley
#

Which is why imo low honor to high honor is the canon way

#

After the diagnosis, Arthur changes

willow linden
#

Yeah

marsh valley
#

All the anger and rage makes no sense. He’s a dead man now.

#

However ending wise

#

Going for the money has the better music

#

I stand unshaken? No

#

I stand, unshaken!

willow linden
#

Nah help John had 'Red Dead Redemption' in it which is literally my favorite track

tidal relic
#

At this point is it even worth saying " spoilers pls"

marsh valley
#

Spoilers are allowed here so long as we ain’t trying to ruin the experience. Talking about em is allowed

#

If I read the rules right anyway

tidal relic
#

That's fair

#

I don't really know anything about the context anyway

willow linden
#

Though I love how Arthur just takes Micah's eye out in (go for the money high honor)

tidal relic
#

Well, guess I'm going for the money

#

I hate Micah

willow linden
#

Why are you even here if you haven't finished the game lmao

tidal relic
#

Cuz I can be?

#

I don't have anyone but myself to blame if I get spoiled

willow linden
#

So you don't mind spoilers?

tidal relic
#

Ehh, as long as it doesn't completely spell it out

#

So far all I know is Arthur's probably gonna die at the end

willow linden
#

What chapter you at?

marsh valley
tidal relic
#

since y'all talked about doing stuff as John

marsh valley
#

Like I’ll do this just to hear that line

tidal relic
marsh valley
#

it’d make sense why Micah missed

#

I do love how John is so full of shit for half of this game

tidal relic
#

Yeah

marsh valley
#

Then he gets humbled like that and figures out what he cares about

#

If you snoop around in the party

#

You hear him tell Abigail that “well uh… it’d be easier to keep him safe in my room”

#

And she asks if they’re going to be a family

#

Like yeah lemme just cry into my whiskey you have it so good Marston

#

Didn’t even have to go to Guarma with us

tidal relic
#

It's like losing Jack flips a switch and he's like "shit I have responsibilities to family now"

marsh valley
#

Nothing like that age old biological instinct

tidal relic
#

Yup

marsh valley
#

And that’s right when he starts questioning Dutch

tidal relic
#

As an uncle, it's pretty strong

marsh valley
#

Realizing it’s not like the old days he can’t play it fast and loose

willow linden
marsh valley
#

Yknow who I appreciate now?

#

Uncle

#

He’s lazy and nasty and inappropriate… but he’s had Dutch figured for a long time

tidal relic
#

Yeah, the way this scene is set up is giving me major vibes of like

marsh valley
#

“You just like playing American King with your round table of knights!”

#

And he dies defending the Marstons

tidal relic
#

You remember the scene in Tangled after "I See the Light" where Flynn gets bonked and the twin guys make it look like he's abandoning Rapunzel and she has that heartbreaking look on her face?

marsh valley
#

Didn’t see it but yeah?

tidal relic
#

there's a scene like that in pretty much every Disney/kids movie

#

Like, a big happy moment that drops off like an undertow of sudden inescapable tragedy

marsh valley
#

Yeah

#

Was that entering Saint Denis with the Chapter 4 title drop?

tidal relic
#

I'm thinking it was saving Jack

marsh valley
#

Yeah no you’re on the downturn now

tidal relic
#

Cuz now we're all happy and partying

marsh valley
#

But some of it is too forced. Karen is trashed

tidal relic
#

Is it worth continuing to make donations at this point?

marsh valley
#

Dutch is making loud proclamations to the boom of thunder and the oncoming rainstorm, and the mood shifts

#

Yes

#

Do it while you can

#

There won’t be much in the way of camp upgrading in future I’ll say

tidal relic
#

Huh

marsh valley
#

So buy your boat and explore now

tidal relic
#

Alrighty

marsh valley
#

I found some cool islands with Pirate Rum

#

Max stamina and I keep getting more…

#

Could save it for John or drink it, as the Wolf heart makes it impossible to get plastered these days

tidal relic
#

On a different note

#

One of my friends told me about a stranger interaction that ends with some... unfortunate implications for Arthur

#

didn't remember where it happened tho

marsh valley
#

Oh yeah

#

If a strange man invites you into his swamp house

#

Kill him

#

Don’t go in that door

#

The game will ding you but you’ll avoid being taken advantage of

hollow ravine
#

Yea I remember he knocks you out with a bat

marsh valley
#

No sir

#

Not happening. Fool me once Aberdeen Pig Farm

#

Were they cannibals? They had meat but no pigs…

hollow ravine
#

Oh the anberdans they take all your money

marsh valley
#

You can get it back tho

hollow ravine
#

Ik there was a glitch tho

#

You can get it as John if you leave it

marsh valley
#

You can use that as a bank yeah

#

Get robbed right at the end and just roll with it

#

But I'm leaving John 20 gold bars

#

10 grand

#

And more

#

My nice watch too...

#

I do so love the Reutlinger

tidal relic
marsh valley
#

Specific I just can't remember where exactly

hollow ravine
#

Me either

#

I think in the middle of the swamp?

tidal relic
#

Bayou Nwa, apparently

#

... guess I'm going swamping.

flint apex
#

does anybody know of a mod that makes bullets more lethal? like 2-3 shots can take my character out. i wanted to make my playthrough as realistic as possible

hollow ravine
#

The legendary gator is so annoying to find it’s tracks it literally took me 3hours

marsh valley
#

I found it easy

hollow ravine
#

I literally search the entire swamp to notice it did not spawn

marsh valley
#

The game be like that when it knows you're looking

#

So many ducks until I need to find some

jagged escarp
#

I think I missed the Strauss missions in chapter 6. Is there a certain point where you can't do them?

marsh valley
#

Dutch's favorite catchphrase isn't just "PLAN"
"It doesn't matter how we got here"

jagged escarp
#

Anybody know when exactly the cutoff is?

marsh valley
#

I'm actually not sure

jagged escarp
#

I did the mission where you save John from the chain gang and the Strauss icon disappeared

#

He's still in the camp but I can't interact outside of the general greet/antagonize options

#

I guess I could go back. The mission with John didn't take very long.

#

Nevermind. I slept and it came back

#

Hooray!

marsh valley
#

Oooooof

#

I just gave Colonel Favors the underbarrel of my LeMat cause I had switched to that mode before the cutscene

marsh valley
#

It's time
Red Dead Redemption

sonic pivot
#

im currently doing the first part of the duchesses and other animals mission, i have all the egret plumes and i need 13 more lady of the night orchids. does anyone have any tips forn where in the bayou they might spawn?

hidden moss
#

seek help from yt

sonic pivot
#

k

tacit badger
#

Dumb question but

#

Why do they have power lines in the game

#

Did they have electricity back then?

hidden moss
#

🤔

#

says 1906. telegraph wires maybe

marsh valley
#

I am... satisfied

#

John saved himself. I killed a lot of Pinkertons with my favorite guns, and Micah lost an eye. I call this a win.

#

So strange to be in West Elizabeth and not to be worried about bounty hunters... been a long time

hollow ravine
#

As John most of the missions are bounty hunting. but Arthur it was so hard just to find a poster

hidden moss
#

Which ending would be considered as decent (all of. Them are shit because Airth dies anyways and John is pretty much useless apart from him being a badass gunslinger)

#

@marsh valley 9 hours on red dead 2 😳

marsh valley
#

It's... been a long night

#

In the Epilogue now

#

I liked the high honor confrontation back at camp for Arthur

hidden moss
#

Damn... You serously have finished the game in one go 😂

marsh valley
#

Nah it took...

#

227 more hours before that

hidden moss
hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Nah I turned good

#

And yeah

hidden moss
#

I finshed mine took me 2 months

#

Stright

marsh valley
#

Third time playing took me about a month

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

But going with John

marsh valley
#

I played low then high

hidden moss
#

Rather then money with high honour

marsh valley
#

Turned good when I got sick

hollow ravine
#

I was trying to be high honor as John but it was so hard I had to keep killing

marsh valley
#

I had more fun sticking it to Micah tbh

hidden moss
#

Yeah but i would literally shotgun the doctor.

marsh valley
#

...yeah John is in for a bad time

#

I need that achievement

#

For having a super high bounty

#

But first I'll explore and hunt

#

Bounty Hunt

hollow ravine
marsh valley
#

Take a man from his son in Lemoyne as John

#

For true irony

icy cove
#

so i was trying to do the hunting quest. normally you can find the poster on post office walls but i dont see anything there apart from some paper about buying land which is unrelated. Is there any reason? i heard you need to do the mr black and mr white mission, but i already did and 92.7 percent done

marsh valley
#

Feed a confederate leader to a gator

hidden moss
#

Because of hosea... If he was alive he could've made things better for Arthur and joined his side with Dutch

marsh valley
#

Things never would have gone that far with Hosea

hollow ravine
#

Hosa might be dead but he is remembered

marsh valley
#

He'd have kept Dutch in check

#

Oh yeha

#

I felt his ghost in Beaver Hollow
His absence

hidden moss
#

Next time i know, when micah is in prison you can actually burn him alive i saw a video on YouTube and it explained it but it was from last year 👀

marsh valley
#

I just took his eye

#

I'm very happy

icy cove
#

when you set him on fire, he drops his pistol allowing you to grab it

hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Maybe I gave him TB too I bit him

icy cove
#

or when he dies he drops it

hidden moss
icy cove
#

you can also get his pistol in chapter 1 lol

hidden moss
#

Micah 👀

marsh valley
#

Hosea could get Dutch to question himself without being seen as subversive

hollow ravine
icy cove
#

yeah

marsh valley
#

Why tf do I want the rat's gun?

#

I have better ones

icy cove
#

because the stats are really good

hollow ravine
marsh valley
#

Better than my LeMats?

icy cove
#

yes

hollow ravine
#

His gun is useless anyway

marsh valley
#

A shot from one of those is like an angry cougar
Usually just kills you very dead

icy cove
#

i think so

marsh valley
#

His guns don't have a shotgun mode

#

Therefore they are stupid and lame

hidden moss
#

I will buy mod and spawn micah and kill him over again and again
By
Burning him alive
Feeding his to bear / crocs
Drowning him
Torturing him with my throwing knife
Hang him
Dislocate his bones slowly so he feels pain and dosnt die 😏

icy cove
#

fair

marsh valley
#

Ooh I got to give Pinkertons both LeMat underbarrels earlier

#

Felt real good

hidden moss
#

Micah = black lung (full stop)

marsh valley
#

He's dead inside

hollow ravine
icy cove
#

otis millers pistol is also good

hidden moss
#

I hate how the only insult he had on Arthur was "black lung" 😂

marsh valley
#

And cowpoke

hidden moss
icy cove
#

well arthur called micah cowpoke too

hidden moss
#

Exactly hes just stupid with some crazy luck

marsh valley
#

Micah had this weird tendency to taunt me about having trouble keeping up in a firefight
While I was so far ahead of him the game told me to double back

#

Everything in his path already dead

hollow ravine
#

Dutch keeps saying we need money when he got over 40,000 dollars

hidden moss
#

Morgan did also call him snake which i was satisfied the most at the end (snake = he hid in the shadows of Dutch and brain washed him)

marsh valley
#

I mean... I've been hiding away close to 20k myself

hidden moss
#

I got ny white coat Arabian horse

marsh valley
#

7k from ways and means
10k in gold

hidden moss
#

Had it for month still ride it

marsh valley
#

So uh
I could've paid for our boat trip

hidden moss
#

My bounty is 100k in Valentine 😎

#

Achievement

#

Always rob. And kill

hollow ravine
#

I had a glitch when me and my horse flue

random sedge
#

I think 1,5k is max isnt it?

hidden moss
#

Its like max

#

Yeah

#

But i still mess around in that town

hidden moss
#

Not 1.5

hollow ravine
#

My valentine hates me

hidden moss
#

I have around of 1k

random sedge
#

Im pretty sure 1.5k is max

hidden moss
#

Its a good town but i just like it because its more busy and that makes it more money because people use it alot

hollow ravine
hidden moss
#

Rip

hollow ravine
hidden moss
#

I robbed him many times

#

Especially one store in rodes

#

I destroyed him

#

And gun shop on sd

#

This guy greets me with gun rather then hello

#

And welcome 🤣

marsh valley
#

Oh

#

I didn't get to keep all the gold...

#

Damn you John Jim Milton you spent it all on whiskey didn't you?!

#

At least I had enough xp items to get John up to snuff...

floral umbra
marsh valley
#

Nah like its missing straight up as soon as i could check

#

I guess he kept some of the other stuff

#

At least the Reutlinger is still here

nocturne spindle
#

It sometimes doesn't show the gold, you need to find another gold bar to fix it @marsh valley

marsh valley
#

Welp

#

Does New Austin have a source?

#

Also I'm just now learning there was a Braithwait treasure I let burn in that manor
Kicking myself over that one

nocturne spindle
marsh valley
#

Yep

nocturne spindle
#

It's useless tbh

marsh valley
#

I mean yeah...

#

But it's a collectible... and I missed it...

nocturne spindle
#

You can't even sell it and it's stuck in your inventory

marsh valley
#

But like
I'd look at it and smile at the memories of burning that place down

nocturne spindle
marsh valley
#

Like how I look at my Reutlinger and smile at how we took Desmond Blythe for all he had on that riverboat

nocturne spindle
marsh valley
#

"You're right! Only an idiot would give a greaser a gun!"
Javier snickers

#

Good times...

nocturne spindle
#

"There's something I don't like about the pair of you"

#

"There's planty I don't like about you but I have the decency to keep my mouth shut"

marsh valley
#

"I expect we're to dress up as a bunch of dancing girls and can can off the side!"

#

"You can see his noble birth clearly in the... heavy brow from all the... inbreeding."

nocturne spindle
#

"Don't spend too much or your wife is going to kill me"

#

"To the bar señor"

marsh valley
#

God the voice crack on that last line killed me

nocturne spindle
marsh valley
#

I really don't get Abigail

#

In some of the Pronghorn ranch bits

#

Like there's little choice but to fight the Laramies
Unless she'd like John to be out of work

bronze pumice
#

I don't like her. She complains about literally everything.

marsh valley
#

I like her plenty, but in some cases I agree with John
Some men need beating

#

They have good chemistry tho

#

And she genuinely loves that fool

languid mortar
#

John Marston is a fool

#

But so is Abigail

#

and together they are lovers

light ledge
#

i have this problem in rdr2 on pc that whenever i walk or ride my horses in some places mostly small hills there is this weird glitched texture line below arthur or arthur's horse that is glitched out if i have time i will add a screenshot , can anyone help me ! . and btw my rdr2 is one ultra settings for the most part

merry leaf
#

.. I don't think this is the chat for troubleshooting stuff.

gray wasp
#

Hey when Arthur gets to Guarma, what happens to all the stuff in his satchel?

#

Should I sell all this stuff I'm keeping?

#

I still have Jimmy Brookes' pen, the Reutlinger Watch, and Catherine Braithwaith's Brooch (and more...)

outer tiger
#

umm, im at point where i got to farm. Dutch and Micah betrayed me and i don't have my bag anymore and lost all money. Whats gonna happen all after this? If gonna tell me just tag me!!!

frigid cloud
gray wasp
#

ok thank god

outer tiger
outer tiger
#

Idk but its big farm

languid mortar
#

so pronghorn

#

you're john right

#

@outer tiger

glad brook
#

Ranch.*

fluid cypress
#

u won’t get it back

jagged escarp
#

How do I get rid of the story imposed bounty in Annesburg?

#

The one after the prison thing with John

hidden moss
#

like that wanted dead or alive thing from annesburg to saint denis

light ledge
pure carbon
#

Who's Arthur?

gray wasp
#

Are you fucking joking

hidden moss
#

-388388383 sc to debt collector

pure carbon
#

Maybe

glad brook
#

@hidden moss

#

Who tf is livicous cornwall.

hidden moss
#

@glad brook

glad brook
#

@hidden moss @hidden moss

outer tiger
#

I will beat you up

gentle haven
#

I had a price on my head and I talked to the trapper, the hunters started to go after me and I tied the trapper

#

I don't know why I did it

#

but I'm afraid he won't sell to me anymore

hidden moss
#

he will dw

gentle haven
#

Thx

hidden moss
#

np

lean sparrow
#

Where can i buy bread bait

hidden moss
#

Bread is readily available

#

Arthur always has some on him

#

@lean sparrow

fluid cypress
#

Ur literally the one asking and I answered

#

If you have a problem with people responding just don’t talk

#

idiot

hidden moss
#

exactly

#

brudda

#

just ignore em

fluid cypress
#

ye I will

hidden moss
fluid cypress
frigid cloud
gray wasp
fluid cypress
#

unless u kill u them u have to wait for them to respawn

#

but they will u sell u after that

gray wasp
#

yeah

fluid cypress
#

tbh I was surprised to see the Rhodes gunsmith even after the whole kidnapping thing and he was jolly as ever

gray wasp
#

Must of had...

#

amnesia...

fluid cypress
#

Only told me to ‘stay out of trouble’ lol

fluid cypress
#

I should rob stuff more often I feel like I’m tryn too hard to be the good guy

#

Sometimes even restraining a little fun

gray wasp
#

the crime in this game is hard to resist

fluid cypress
#

ye but it’s kinda punishing aswell

gray wasp
#

yeah...

#

bounties are a bitch

fluid cypress
#

lol was in a fight cuz I bumped into a guy and I ended up getting a small bounty

#

….and that ended with my horse dead and 300 for my head

gray wasp
#

Once I ended up having "No Bounty"

#

idk

fluid cypress
#

Sometimes they tell you to move along

fluid cypress
outer tiger
#

16

fluid cypress
#

more like 9, based on how you reacted a dude tryna help out LMAO

outer tiger
#

Lol

fluid cypress
#

fr mans got so pressed cuz I answered what he asked

hidden moss
#

u lost already

gray wasp
fluid cypress
#

lol

#

he asked abt not having items in the epilogue

gray wasp
#

Could have told him about the $20,000...

#

whatever

#

¯_(ツ)_/¯

#

The threat was not needed

fluid cypress
#

still doesn’t mean he can go around acting like that

gray wasp
#

true

fluid cypress
#

unless he is 9 (which I think he is)

gray wasp
#

If he is, then how tf did he get here of all places...?

fluid cypress
#

dunno so many underaged accts lol

#

even on other platforms

gray wasp
#

F

fluid cypress
#

you’ll see abunch of kids on insta reels breaking the tos

gray wasp
#

:l

fluid cypress
#

ye it be like that

outer tiger
#

I wait

gray wasp
#

digging your own grave here pal

fluid cypress
fluid cypress
outer tiger
fluid cypress
#

he’s not right in the head

outer tiger
#

Haha

gray wasp
fluid cypress
#

I’m getting a seizure reading his msgs 🥴

outer tiger
#

U dont need to take everything so serious on the internet

#

😀

gray wasp
#

Well it's hard to identify things like sarcasm in text format, just saying...

fluid cypress
#

I’m still wondering what was his thought process when he sent that

outer tiger
#

Did i said sarcasm at anypoint

fluid cypress
#

didn’t seem like sarcasm one bit.

gray wasp
#

I know

lean sparrow
#

Why is it so hard to fish

outer tiger
#

I just mean u dont need to take things under your nails

gray wasp
#

I was just saying...

#

And my reasoning is the same with jokes

#

it's hard to tell sometimes if somebody is being serious