#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages Ā· Page 525 of 1

fringe hatch
#

How many hours you got?

#

500?

#

1k?

steady vector
#

šŸ¤·ā€ā™‚ļø

fringe hatch
#

I think?

steady vector
#

I know what happens and I have no desire to play as John when I could restart and have Arthur again

bronze pumice
fringe hatch
steady vector
fringe hatch
bronze pumice
#

I still find new things occasionally.

fringe hatch
#

Still playing as John is cool. Having farming activities is very cool

bronze pumice
#

I never do any farming or even go to the ranch.

marsh valley
#

Does the Lemoyne raider bounty expire at some point?

#

Or is it just not spawning for me?

marsh valley
bronze pumice
#

I haven't been to the ranch in real life months, so yeah.

hidden moss
#

I think I have a bug

#

My player menu says I'm 3% overweight but my Arthur looks fine if not underweight

steady vector
#

Arthur doesnā€™t look much heavier until youā€™re close to max weight. Even then itā€™s hard to tell if you have a beard and wear a jacket

hidden moss
#

3% is close to the upper bound of average. After 3.75, you're overweight

#

And I've seen "average" weight Arthur with a lot of neck fat

bronze pumice
#

I stay at 7.5%.

#

As much as I can.

hidden moss
#

But here I am, almost overweight and Arthur has no neck fat at all he looks underweight

#

Weird

bronze pumice
#

It's honestly hard to maintain, but without it he dies too easily.

hidden moss
hidden moss
bronze pumice
#

I know from experience, whenever his weight gets even a percent lower I die. With it at 7.5%, I almost never die.

#

Plus, the extra health buys you more time to take a tonic.

hidden moss
#

Get better at gunfighting

marsh valley
#

Okay now I'm just lashing out at every blindly loyal dog in this camp

#

Williamson mainly, running around and calling us all traitors

#

But I don't hate Bill
I'm just disappointed in him

#

I am always happy for Swanson tho

#

He turns a bad hand of cards around and makes it out

hidden moss
#

Found a crashed mail wagon

#

Lots of cool letters to read

marsh valley
#

Time to kill that legendary gator

#

Also that wagon was a good read

#

I now have a really hard choice to make

#

Bear claw belt buckle or gator tooth bracelet?

#

I'm keeping the raven claw compass since it was such a pain to get and looks nice

hidden moss
#

gator tooth one

marsh valley
#

Damn
I can't wear it with a coat

#

So I don't wear it then smh

#

Oh well

#

I've broken even on my honor level
From very low

#

If I keep pushing I might die a good man

hidden moss
#

Nice

marsh valley
#

Fuck the camp
Fuck the gang
Fuck Micah and Williamson and Dutch
I taught Charlotte how to skin a rabbit now I'm gonna go hang out with Hamish

#

I will be riding Buell into the final battle I think

vague silo
#

you guys still playing this shitty game??? graphics is fine but the story mode is shit and nonreplayable worthy, there's not much you can do after playing 40hours...but RDO is quite better and grindable game

hidden moss
#

rdo is online ffs

marsh valley
#

....why would I want more grind?

#

are you nuts?

#

I play RDR2 for power fantasy and to shoot fun guns

hidden moss
#

Give me one flaw in the game

vague silo
hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Re: only 40 hours

#

I dunno what you're doing

#

I'm in hour 200 and only now am I in chapter 6

hidden moss
#

I have 1000 hours completely accidentally. I only completed the game 2 or 3 times

marsh valley
#

Tfw Micah says he'll take Jack fishing
Great now he wants to kill the kid, a chaser after killing the dog

vague silo
hidden moss
#

both are diff

hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Nah I got into challenges and hunting

hidden moss
#

I've never wandered around and admired the scenery

hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Because turns out those give bonus stats

hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Better stats = better gameplay

hidden moss
#

exactly

marsh valley
#

More deadeye to shoot Pinkertons with

#

Plus... how can you play without getting that Panther cloak? Seriously now!

#

It's so comfy looking!

hidden moss
#

doesn't do any side quests
"There's nothing to do in this game!!!"

marsh valley
#

Wish I'd known bounties vanish in chapter 6

#

I'd have done em all in 4 to get my honor up

hidden moss
#

sad

marsh valley
#

Ah well

#

John can do em for me

#

I'm in too deep to go back now

hidden moss
#

yea i was gonna say that

marsh valley
#

Altho I didn't ensure John would get an extra mission

#

Anthony Foreman was just too big a risk to leave breathing

#

Plus
Fuck that guy
He kidnapped Tilly

hidden moss
#

nah i let that dude go

#

cuz tilly insisted

marsh valley
#

She did, she did....
But that low honor Arthur doesn't like leaving loose ends

hidden moss
#

fair reason

hidden moss
hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Lmao I didn't know that

#

I just threatened him at gunpoint

#

But yeah after sorta understanding all that gang did to Tilly....
I stuck that motherfucker like a pig, and I'd do it again and pay for the pleasure

frigid cloud
#

what's canon, you let him go or execute him?

marsh valley
#

Execute him
Make him vulture food

#

But then again my canon is Arthur only shaping up post diagnosis

hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Then going after Micah and Dutch in the end with righteous fury

#

All the shit that snake makes me put up with, you bet your ass I'm going to put him on borrowed time

hidden moss
#

Saved my game after jumping off 5he train and a split second before I got wanted

#

When the cops found me I just reload

marsh valley
#

One eyed gunslingers live slightly longer than the luckiest TB patients

hidden moss
#

Challenge progress saved but no blunty

proven cedar
#

Anyone else think john looks really stupid running around at the very beginning of the epilogue

#

He looks like a mobile game character

marsh valley
#

Here's a question

#

I kept the Whittemore suit

#

And the color is determined by honor

#

So... if my honor goes into the positives, will it turn blue?

#

If it does... I'll have to buy a new hat to match it

hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Hehehe

#

It gets stored on your horse if you have an outfit slot free for storage, but you wont find it there

#

So you hit up a wardrobe and add a hat to it, it becomes a custom outfit, and you keep it

#

...think I just answered my own question there

hidden moss
#

Wow

marsh valley
#

It's a neat trick, keeping the suit
Goes nicely with the watch you win from poker too

#

Which... sure its a bauble but I like checking the time on my solid gold watch

#

Tomorrow I need to do some fishing and meet n greets
Get that honor within the threshold where I start getting good guy cutscenes

#

Cause I dont wanna call Strauss a parasite

#

I want to say "we're bad men, but those people? They weren't. Now get out."

hidden moss
hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Yeah Iā€™m just trying to make sure of it

hidden moss
#

My friend had reddish Gray honor, and it went to white after all the debts

marsh valley
#

I want to be in the good honor zone before I go and do that

hidden moss
#

I never knew they were that impactful

marsh valley
#

Iā€™m currently at gray

hidden moss
#

I had max honor from chapter 4 lol

marsh valley
#

And yeah itā€™s the Reutlinger

hidden moss
#

Yeah I heard of a way to make it your personal watch

#

How do you do it?

marsh valley
#

Easy just equip it

#

Go into your kit, watches, equip the one you want

hidden moss
#

Oh it just stays in your satchel after the heist?

marsh valley
#

Yeah if you didnā€™t sell it

#

Which why would you

#

155 is easy money to make no reason to sell a unique watch

hidden moss
#

I quite like the platinum pocket watch

marsh valley
#

I used one till I had the Reutlinger

#

Nice, but every other bounty Hunter I meet has one

#

This, nobodyā€™s got this. Let alone outlaws or law enforcement.

hidden moss
#

I just sell or donate all my valuables though

#

It's nice using the real pocket watch but sometimes it takes too long so I just press down on d pad to bring up the time on my hud

marsh valley
#

I mean yeah
But I kinda like checking the time manually, especially in situations like right before we went into Bronteā€™s manor or hit the bank. Just a little something to play with really

#

Itā€™s like using the in game camera to take pictures instead of photo mode and screenshotting

hidden moss
#

Right

#

I used to like taking photos with the camera but they just go to social club and I can't really do much with them

marsh valley
#

I really love photomode tho

#

Being able to move the camera around is great for getting that perfect screenshot

#

I donā€™t use social club at all tbh

hidden moss
#

to make money dutch

marsh valley
#

Iā€™m actually going to start antagonizing Dutch

#

Fed up with his shit

#

My low honor Arthur was kind of a monster but heā€™s trying to change now. Whatā€™s Dutchā€™s excuse for carrying on like this?

hidden moss
#

yea I recently gave a necklace to Tilly

#

where can you find that story book Jack requested

#

Explore the states

#

I'm sure you realise that you won't find a book in a bush in the forest, so you'll need to search cabins and shacks across America

outer tiger
#

Whats the best horse in sp?

hidden moss
#

Just look at all the different breeds and see which of them suit your needs

outer tiger
#

Can i find them in stable places?

severe relic
crystal sierra
#

How do i mark an X on an enemy while i'm in Dead Eye ?

#

Because i can do it in online with the paint in black card but I can't find how to do it in story mode

wise wolf
#

Press r1

#

During deadeye

wise wolf
rocky nest
#

Its automatic early in story mode, changes later

#

automatic is actually pretty good for hunting

hidden moss
#

No

#

Automatic is terrible for hunting

#

Because, when I drag it over to the heart and lungs, it will paint a target on some non-fatal area on the animal

hidden moss
crystal sierra
#

Like, when you stop the dead eye it shoot every bullet you've marked

rocky nest
#

Aim for the head while its automatic, obviously

crystal sierra
#

On ps4 and ps5 ? šŸ¤”

rocky nest
#

(talking about hunting)

crystal sierra
#

Ho

crystal sierra
hidden moss
hidden moss
crystal sierra
#

But

#

When i do this it just shoot

#

While i'm in dead eye

hidden moss
#

Keep an eye on the top left corner of the screen, helpful information shows up there @crystal sierra

crystal sierra
#

Ok i'll try that

hidden moss
#

So you aim, then tap R1 to mark a target where you aimed, and you can mark as many targets as you have cartridges in your magazine

crystal sierra
#

Thanks

hidden moss
#

Np

hidden moss
gray wasp
#

Oh my god I can't wait until I unlock that deadeye perk where when you fire, you stay in deadeye

hidden moss
#

Mhmm

#

I'm about to do pouring fourth oil iv

#

I haven't done a story mission in several in-game months I reckon

gray wasp
#

Ikr

#

Arthur is the best at procrastinating

hidden moss
#

I've been doing all my side quests because I foolishly let a bunch of them rack up in my tasks log

#

Now all my challenges require me to use something I haven't unlocked yet

gray wasp
#

???

#

explain?

hidden moss
#

E.g. sell 5 horses to the horse fence

crystal sierra
hidden moss
# crystal sierra Yes

Cool. I know very little french. A mon avis, RDR2 est le mieux jeux video šŸ˜ƒ

crystal sierra
#

I don't know if it is the best but it is objectively one of the best

hidden moss
#

Mhmm

rocky nest
#

Are you early in the story @crystal sierra

gray wasp
#

well then just move up the story

crystal sierra
hidden moss
#

Ayo does anyone know how I can get my honor up? Iā€™m on Chapter 3 so Iā€™m still new to the game? Which itā€™s half way there but still close the the gray side kittcry

#

go to st denis

#

u'll find a lotta ppl to greet there

#

donate cash or jewelry to the camp

#

throwing fish back in the water

#

pay off ur bounty

#

Okay thanks and do stranger missions help too? Iā€™ll check out Sent Denis today and try

#

do camp chores

#

etc

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

Okay thanks lol

hidden moss
#

I want him to be a honorable character so Iā€™m trying to get his honor up more

pastel timber
#

Missions

frigid cloud
#

that's in chapter 6

pastel timber
#

Oh

#

I thought hes / she is at chpt 6

hidden moss
#

Iā€™m in Chapter 3

silk stratus
#

Cool

hidden moss
#

Yep which I just started 2 days ago but wow the game is becoming fun on some parts

wise wolf
tawdry citrus
#

By the time I was in chapter 4 I went from lowest honor to Max honor very quickly

long kite
#

Should I hang cleet?

proven cedar
#

Damn the house building song a vibe

hidden moss
#

@hidden moss

normal elk
#

Dude,

#

He tried in the end

hidden moss
#

The guys in chapter 3 haha

normal elk
#

Yaknow?

hidden moss
#

Sure

normal elk
#

He wasnt a good person by any means

#

But he did what he could with the time he had left

hidden moss
#

Indeed

normal elk
#

Ignoring the shooty bang bang missions, cause yaknow it's hard to feel bad for getting rid of an enemy you have been taught your entire life is bad

#

Sees it as protecting his family, as dysfunctional as it is

#

Doesnt mean it's okay

#

But, it's like. the only thing he has

#

The gang I mean

#

It's been established that he would kill whoever is in the way of his "family"

#

was never a good person, and he knew it.

#

But he attempted to make a change

#

Even if he survived somehow, he wouldnt know what to do, the gang was his everything.

#

Sorry for the spam

#

It was all he knew

hidden moss
#

I think he was still honorable even if he was bad still because he tried so I want to make him honorable just because thatā€™s I see him

long kite
#

Why did Dutch save John in the epilogue?

hidden moss
long kite
#

Mentally

#

Especially in rdr1 (havenā€™t played it)

hidden moss
#

he hit his head in a mission, and without his best friend, hosea, he's crazy.

long kite
#

or whatever you call those things

hidden moss
long kite
#

Yeah that?

hidden moss
#

mhm

long kite
#

Goddamn, kinda sad to see such a strong man just crumble like that

#

and lose it

#

The game does a good job at slowly showing his downfall

hidden moss
#

you see it clearly. in chapter 1, dutch was a completely different man.

long kite
#

Fr

#

Is he in the first game a lot?

hidden moss
#

he rescued sadie, though, in the later chapters, he only cared about loyalty, and himself.

hidden moss
#

he gets killed.

spring spear
#

im gonna be honest

hidden moss
#

(sorry for the spoiler)

long kite
#

Yeah heard that

spring spear
#

if i see a stadia player here

long kite
#

dw already knew

spring spear
#

wrong chat

long kite
#

or is their like a goal he has, Iā€™m not gonna play it for a while cuz I canā€™t

hidden moss
long kite
hidden moss
#

rdr3

#

coming soon

long kite
#

Confirmed?

hidden moss
#

i think it'll be another prequel.

hidden moss
long kite
rocky nest
#

He saved micah from sadie in my book

#

Hope itā€™s a brand new story in next rdr

gleaming citrus
#

Rdr3 already?

#

Dawg rockstar will work on anything else but Gta 6

long kite
#

What is there to do in rdr2 when u finish the epilogue

tacit plover
#

Anyone know a good place to find a wild Appoloosa

gleaming citrus
#

You could finish the stranger missions

long kite
#

Is red dead online any good?

gleaming citrus
#

Yeah itā€™s pretty good

long kite
#

Any main character appearances?

gleaming citrus
#

I used to hate it but itā€™s actually pretty good

long kite
#

Like for missions n shit

gleaming citrus
long kite
#

Isnā€™t Sean dead

gleaming citrus
#

There might be more but I forgot

gleaming citrus
long kite
#

Ohh

#

aight that makes sense

gleaming citrus
#

Sadie still has her husband

long kite
#

Iā€™m assuming my character is a mindless guy/girl that dosent speak a word

gleaming citrus
#

Yup lmao

long kite
#

Great

#

Is the first game on the same level as the 2nd?

#

like storytelling wise

gleaming citrus
#

Wdym

hidden moss
#

He was clear

#

He asked this:

#

Is rdr storytelling as good as rdr2 storytelling

marsh valley
#

Iā€™d say yes. Sure the story is simpler but all the meat is still there.

#

1 inspired all of 2

#

Every call back, reference, and little detail of Dutchā€™s fall is all leading up to meeting him again in 1

#

Also YouTube comment section be like ā€œnooooooo Arthur would never get revenge the wholesome save John ending is the canon one!ā€
Me: But I shall stand unshaken. Fuck Micah. Revenge is all thatā€™s left.

cold parcel
#

(Spoiler alert of RDR1) I actually like how John's little speech to Bonnie is a little similar to Arthurs speech to the nun. They both talked about how they have lived horrible lives, talked about their sons and parents.

marsh valley
#

Moments like that are great

tawny nimbus
#

just had the weirdest conversation in camp

#

sometimes

#

game messes up

#

and places lines where they shouldnt be

cold parcel
#

"How you doing Ms Ardler?"
"It's like a nightma-"
"OkAY, I'Ll cAtcH yA LAter Then."
"Alright Arthur"

tawny nimbus
#

had one with abigal just now

#

"How are you doing Arthur?"
" How are you Abigail?"
" Fine"
"Ok i'll catch ya later then"

marsh valley
#

Well be glad itā€™s that and not Bill Billiamson coming over to call you a traitor

#

Or Javier asking where the loyalty went

cold parcel
#

The only odd conversation I had was actually scripted. It was when Sean returned to camp and we had a party with the bois. I went over to the campfire to chill with John and Bill came in to talk about some weird shit, it was something about an animal and I remember just being like "Tf is this man talking about?", I look over to John and he has that same wtf face.

marsh valley
#

ā€œFellersā€¦ is it weird for two men to share a whiskey??ā€

#

ā€œBill wtf are you on about now?ā€

cold parcel
marsh valley
#

Or was he talking about how much he admired Kieranā€™s nuts

cold parcel
#

Lmao

marsh valley
#

It could be anything with Bill

cold parcel
#

I remember in Clemens point, Bill was bullying Kieran and Arthurs comment to this was: "You two would be an great couple"

marsh valley
#

ā€œBill, you look confused, like someone just asked you where the sun goes at nightā€ javier

cold parcel
#

Poor Kieran, his nuts almost got taken off by Bill.

marsh valley
#

Kieran Duffy didnā€™t deserve any of this

#

He just wanted to work with horses

cold parcel
#

Yep.

marsh valley
#

I need to go visit his grave still

#

ā€¦.I kinda forgot after it happened

#

When does he get taken anyhow?

cold parcel
#

He probably was taking an piss or something.

marsh valley
#

Iā€™m just wondering if they had to make him squeal to find the camp

cold parcel
#

It's also strange how easily they got to him.

#

Probs Micahs doing.

marsh valley
#

I figure he rode off for a bit by himself and thatā€™s how

#

ā€¦there is that

cold parcel
#

But some of the gang members wouldn't even let Kieran go off by himself.

marsh valley
#

Iā€™m starting to think Micah has been setting us up as early as the end of chapter 2

cold parcel
#

I feel like Micah set everything up after what happened in guarma.

marsh valley
#

First itā€™s the bad campsite
Then itā€™s the Oā€™Driscolls kidnapping Arthur
Then the bank job goes tits up but that one could go either way

#

But Dutch feels like for someone this is all going to plan, and maybe heā€™s right. Micahā€™s plan

#

Thin the heard and then grab the Blackwater money
He asks Dutch in chapter 3 if he can just go grab it and we can all leave
Heā€™d have taken it and run

cold parcel
#

I find it hilarious we get more money with Bill in the valentine robbery.

marsh valley
#

Could be that when the Pinkertons caught up with him at the end of 5, heā€™d already been talking to em. Just this time they got his balls in a vice.

#

And heā€™s certainly working with them in the epilogue

cold parcel
#

They could have sent Sadie to get that Blackwater muneh, but then again I feel like Dutch thinks she will report some shit to the pinkertons.

marsh valley
#

Dutch is paranoid anyhow

cold parcel
#

Uncle should have been the leader.

marsh valley
#

For real

cold parcel
#

They would be in Tahete in no time.

#

Taheeteeee

marsh valley
#

Lazy pos has a lot of wisdom given all heā€™s survived

#

But really

#

Arthur shouldā€™ve cast his vote with Hosea over Bronte. That was the moment.

cold parcel
#

Yep.

#

That was the moment where Dutch lost it.

marsh valley
#

Cause if Micah didnā€™t call those Pinkertons himself then killing Bronte and letting time pass after the trolley station sure as hell did bring em

cold parcel
#

Yeah.

#

Dutch starts to lose faith in John because he took his advice to be with his family.

marsh valley
#

Thereā€™s still a nonzero chance it was Micahā€™s doing though. If indeed Dutchā€™s crazed bloodhound instinct for traitors is right

#

But he could equally just be nuts

cold parcel
#

Yeah.

#

Too bad Hosea decided to get killed, Dutch just went more and more insane when he died.

marsh valley
#

Goddamn Dutch

#

For not seeing like Hosea did that Arthur was next in line to be the lieutenant, the second in command

#

But no no
He needs a yes man to enable his disease more than a smart gun

#

Iā€™m just done with Dutch rn in campaign run 3

cold parcel
#

Same.

#

It's trippy to really see how Dutch turned out in RDR1

marsh valley
#

Iā€™m antagonizing and calling his ass out whenever I can from here on out

#

He gets to join the Antagonize List with Micah and Bill

#

Although with Bill Iā€™m just disappointed. He follows like a blind dog. At least Javier has made his informed choice.

cold parcel
#

I love Dutch, and I only antagonise him when I'm in a pissed off mood.

marsh valley
#

I did it when he gave some pretty speech about how weā€™ll make it

#

When weā€™ve lost four guns in half as many months

cold parcel
#

You gotta do it when he screams at Grimshaw in Beaver Hollow.

marsh valley
#

And now live in caves with Micah giving all the advice
He can shut his mouth

#

Loyalty meant nothing to Dutch

#

ā€œAll them yearsā€

#

Oh oh

#

Iā€™d also add to my list of dirt on Micah

#

Heā€™s trying to float the rumor John has turned as early as Chapter 4

#

Now that could be internal politicking but maybe notā€¦

#

Why does he need to cast blame about a rat that early hmm?

#

Either heā€™s trying to ladder climb orā€¦. Because heā€™s trying to cover his own snitching ass

cold parcel
#

The only time when I actually believed one of Micah's lies was when Sean died. Arthur was screaming at Bill and Micah, and Micah just says "Some things go wrong, you're screaming because we tried to look for a score like you and Hosea" or something like that.

#

That was the only time I was like "Huh, maybe we are insane"

marsh valley
#

He is right about that kinda

#

But Arthur is raw and grieving right then trying to pin this on somebody

#

If itā€™s his faultā€¦ Sean was like an annoying little brother to him

#

I love how in the low honor journal Arthur remarks how he only realized how much he loved the kid when he died

hidden moss
#

Deadeye is bad

hidden moss
#

I've seen this theory somewhere

#

Micah woilve worked better as simply the camp scumbag

marsh valley
#

Yeah I dunno if it tracks tho

#

Which is probably why they cut it

#

Also wtf I love deadeye now that I can shoot forever in it

#

Free aim with just the right amount of slow time to make me feel like Iā€™m playing Wild West Max Payne which since the combat engine comes from it Iā€™d say is accurate

calm crow
#

Okay, so this is probably a stupid question and Iā€™m probably just trying to be deluded by my own thoughts since I love Javier Escuella with all my heart, but what actually happens to him once you hand him over to Edgar Ross. Of course, I just captured him instead of killing him, so Iā€™m assuming because John didnā€™t kill him Edgar did. And if thatā€™s the case I really wish it didnā€™t give me the option to capture him as Iā€™d much rather John kill him than Edgar. I donā€™t see any reason as to why theyā€™d keep him alive so I guess Iā€™ve just answered my own question, but since Iā€™ve just typed this all out Iā€™m gonna post it anyway and see what other people have to say about it šŸ™‚

marsh valley
#

Probably hung by the neck or killed by firing squad

#

I donā€™t see a universe where they let him live

hidden moss
#

Hanger

#

Hanged

marsh valley
#

Potato potato

gleaming citrus
calm crow
#

I just love Javier just as much as i love Charles

#

Call me weird

#

Or whatever

tawny nimbus
marsh valley
#

It breaks my heart when he starts seeing me as the opposition in chapter 6 I totally get it

calm crow
#

But i always loved him ever since he rescued John

tawny nimbus
calm crow
#

I mean

marsh valley
#

Wellā€¦ he didnā€™t see Dutch strangle an old woman

calm crow
#

You couldnā€™t blame him

tawny nimbus
marsh valley
#

Then againā€¦ he was there at Blackwater

#

Wasnā€™t he?

tawny nimbus
#

there is a voice line

#

where he says

marsh valley
#

During the ferry job?

tawny nimbus
#

love is the most important thing and that dutch did all that in blackwater for love

#

where he sits at the campfire in shady belle

marsh valley
#

If he was willing to stand for that I doubt heā€™d change his mind over that old woman

#

Speaking of did Dutch just leave that gold on her body?

tawny nimbus
#

yes

#

he did

marsh valley
#

And pocket it for himself?

#

Motherfucker!

#

See this is how you know heā€™s got a bad concussion

#

That trolley crash is almost as responsible for the gangā€™s downfall as Arthur voting with Dutch to hit Bronte

calm crow
#

I think the reason he changed so much in rdr1 was bc he really relied on the gang. Cuz think about it, John got a family, Arthur got a goal, Pearson has a career, Mary beth and tilly has dreams, Micah still got Dutch. But Javier got nothing. He dosenā€™t have a family. Javier deep down still got a good heart, but without the gang he got nothing

marsh valley
#

Micah doesnā€™t really have Dutch tho

#

Dutch only teamed up again to get the Blackwater money
Then kill Micah

#

ā€œWhy are you here Dutch?!ā€
ā€œSame reason as you I supposeā€¦ā€
Shoots Micah

calm crow
#

But Micah and Bill both made their own gangs

marsh valley
#

Very true yeah

#

Javier just gets pressganged into being an assassin for the dictatorship

calm crow
#

Right when i Saw Javier in rdr1 i could see he was a man who has nothing

hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Hell of it is

#

Itā€™s his own fault

#

Javier backed the wrong side there at the end

#

She did pull that knife after Dutch started closing in for the kill. He was killing her no matter what.

hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Correct

#

But long term isnā€™t needed

hidden moss
#

Dutch was always crazy

#

He just never let the mask slip

marsh valley
#

Short term bumps to impulsiveness and aggression do matter tho

hidden moss
#

Until he shot Heidi mccourt

marsh valley
#

Itā€™s why he drops the act and goes after Bronte

#

All full of fire and rage

#

His thinking is impaired by a concussion

calm crow
marsh valley
#

And past thatā€¦ well the damage is all psychological in Guarma and after.

marsh valley
calm crow
marsh valley
#

But yeah Dutchā€™s concussion was really just the trigger for a much bigger break. His actions after the ferry job and the failed bank job, then Guarma when he does a whole Colonel Kurtz bitā€¦ right off the deep end.

#

I dunno I think everyone could tell Micah only cared for his own survival mostly. If Javier couldnā€™t itā€™s on him.

calm crow
#

Ehhh idk

#

But anyway

#

Did you know that Javier in rdr2 is 49 years Old

marsh valley
#

Yeah that I donā€™t believe for a second

#

Iā€™d buy heā€™s that old in 1 but not 2

#

Hosea is 55 and looks eons older

calm crow
#

Well it is a known fact that he was born in 1850

#

And that would make him 49

#

And he is 61 in rdr1

hidden moss
#

Javier is more like 29

marsh valley
#

Yeah no I donā€™t buy that for a fucking second

#

No way

calm crow
#

But math has confirmed it

marsh valley
#

61 year old Javier is not giving 40 year old Marston the slip in Mexico

#

No way in hell

#

Either the official documents have his age wrong or Rockstar did a dumb

#

Thereā€™s just no way he looks that good and is still an active killer at 60

calm crow
#

John in rdr1 is 38

marsh valley
#

Yup

calm crow
#

And is 26 in rdr2

calm crow
long kite
#

Dutch looks like a ps1 character in red dead 1

marsh valley
#

Bullshit. I declare this non canon.

long kite
#

Is red dead revolver any good?

marsh valley
#

Cause a whole fuckton of people died by 60 back then

calm crow
hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Because at 60 your body is hurting. Knees go bad. Muscles weaken. Joints ache. All the fighting Javier has done itā€™d catch up with him like it did with Hosea

#

Iā€™d buy heā€™s Johnā€™s age but not older than that and still actively killing

long kite
#

What age is Javier in red dead 1

calm crow
long kite
#

Why did the government/Edgar even cut their deal with John and hunt him down

hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Maybe maybe not

#

But that just trips me out

#

Given Hosea looked dead at 55

#

I think he had lung cancerā€¦

hidden moss
#

Absolutely

marsh valley
#

Iā€™m taking the Ginseng just like he told me to

#

Maybe itā€™ll help

hidden moss
#

I think Hosea's hair was just always gray

marsh valley
#

it wonā€™t

hidden moss
#

Or went that way early

#

He looks very good

marsh valley
#

Hosea is the real father of the gang

calm crow
#

Is it weird that i never really hated milton?

marsh valley
#

Milton is a man of convictions. Heā€™s cruel by necessity.

#

Ross enjoys it tho

calm crow
#

If you think about it, he is one of the good guys catching a gang of killers and robbers

marsh valley
#

Meanwhile Rossā€™ second in 1
I liked that guy
He didnā€™t show up to kill John. He objected.

#

Man thought they made a deal and wouldnā€™t help Ross to go back on it

hidden moss
#

Yeah he was cool

marsh valley
#

I will be killing Javier myself if I go back to RDR1

#

Better that way. Instead of giving him to the hangman

calm crow
#

Itā€™s like you are forced to pull the trigger

marsh valley
#

You could just tie him and wash your hands of the whole thing

#

But thatā€™s impersonal and cruel. His bloodā€™ll still be on your hands, so do it yourself yknow?

calm crow
#

And the Line Where Javier Said ā€œI hope you and your wife and your children rot in hell.ā€ Really made me sad

marsh valley
#

Well
Back to the game

#

Soon Iā€™ll be collecting Buell

calm crow
#

You mean Bill?

marsh valley
#

He and I can ride right to the grave

#

I mean Buell

#

The horse

calm crow
#

Ohhhh

marsh valley
#

Hard to mix em up

#

Buell is definitely smarter than Bill

#

Easy

calm crow
#

I rather get the arabian White horse

marsh valley
#

ā€¦and also a horse but itā€™s harder to tell on that count

#

I kinda want a horse like that
But I want to help Buell reunite with Hamish

#

And that boah is a beast of a horse

unique garnet
marsh valley
#

Buell and I shall ride to the pearly gates and meet Hamish and Lenny and Hosea and Sean and Kieran, and have us all a big old party

marsh valley
#

Plus it means heā€™s Johnā€™s age in 2

#

Which makes sense

mint linden
#

Wasn't John 36 by the end of 2?

calm crow
#

He was born in 1850

#

And the game takes place in 1911

marsh valley
#

Imo thatā€™s just dumb retconning

#

I know of nobody but Agent 47 who is still that good at fighting and killing past 60

#

And being dumb retconning I will choose the truth according to RDR1

hidden moss
#

hey partners

#

also, dutch in the first game was damn impressive, and he was never young in the games

marsh valley
#

True enough tho I think he died at about Hoseaā€™s age so that makes sense

tacit plover
hidden moss
#

Do the gold medal requirements stack?

marsh valley
#

I love his voice cracks in RDR1

#

ā€œIs that yeeeew Jaaaahn?ā€

marsh valley
#

Maybeā€¦

#

When the Bureau comes looking for Rossā€™ killer itā€™s him who finds Jackā€¦ and makes it go away

#

Cause he sorta owes John a tiny bit. If the man has a conscience maybe I can see it.

#

Make the bad thing he did to a bad man justā€¦ never reach the ears of government. Or say it was someone else.

tacit plover
marsh valley
#

Yup. But he did the job didnā€™t he? Killed who they told him to. Archer is also the one thanking him for it.

#

Archer respected that if he respected anything about John

#

Maybe thatā€™s enough to buy Jack a blind eye. Maybe not. Iā€™ve always wondered what happens to that kid

unique garnet
#

according to the red dead wiki

marsh valley
#

That makes much more sense

torpid kindle
#

Yeah, iā€™ve read that javier was 38 in rdr1 and 26 in rdr2

calm crow
unique garnet
#

I'll pm u since i cant posts URLs here

tawny nimbus
#

hard making a pre quel

tacit plover
lean sparrow
#

How do i complete sharpshooter 7

tawny nimbus
tawny nimbus
tacit plover
tawny nimbus
#

what im trying to say

#

its hard making a pre quel to a game

#

and details like this

worldly orchid
tawny nimbus
#

slip sometimes

lean sparrow
#

Deadeye

worldly orchid
#

@lean sparrow go to fort Riggs and snipe

marsh valley
#

I'm painfully feeling Hosea's absence here at camp

worldly orchid
#

Its not that hard tbh

marsh valley
#

Watching Jack by the fire with the Reverend

tawny nimbus
#

yea its sad

#

if i had to change 1 death it would be hosea's

marsh valley
#

I like the low honor turned high at the end thematically
You're waking up and taking responsibility for your actions at the end along with Swanson
Sure your health is declining while he's getting better, but your minds are clear

hidden moss
lean sparrow
#

Anyone know some good outfits for john

hidden moss
#

Trapper outfits are all fantastic

worldly orchid
frigid cloud
marsh valley
#

Micah mocks me for falling behind and "not having the lungs for this"
Meanwhile I've pushed so far ahead with the repeating shotgun that the game is telling me to double back

worldly orchid
frigid cloud
#

dead eye is allowed

#

iirc

worldly orchid
#

Idk, he told me it wasnt

#

I lol

frigid cloud
#

@lean sparrow you can use dead eye

marsh valley
#

Moments when you're glad you packed a LeMat: when the big wolf is three feet away in the middle of a charge

lean sparrow
#

But i found a way

#

If you use poison arrow and shoot them in the legs

#

They will kneel and there pistol will disarm

frigid cloud
#

i think you're talking about sharpshooter 8 instead of 7

marsh valley
#

I love hunting with Hamish so much now that I'm a master hunter

#

Unlike fishing I'm good at this

worldly orchid
#

Bow > anything in hunting

hidden moss
#

A rifle is superior, because it deals more damage

worldly orchid
#

In terms of pelts I mean sorry

hidden moss
#

With a bow, there is a higher chance of merely wounding the animal, causing superfluous pain

#

Same thing applies for pelts

#

Every animal has two possible weapons for perfect pelt, except for the varmints or small game. E.g. deer are reg arrows or riflr

worldly orchid
#

Yea varmint is the only 1 I agree with

#

The sound it makes oof

#

But also the damage depends on ammo

#

U could easily take down a grizzly with explosive arrow

#

Same with other weapons i suppose, but I like bow better because u can do stealth kills

marsh valley
#

Hamish just helped me get some perfect wolves

#

Which I used to add another skull to the camp

worldly orchid
#

Nice

worldly orchid
marsh valley
#

3rd

#

The one where I figured out challenges give you more core

worldly orchid
#

Ok good, u know how bad it gets

marsh valley
#

So I did a bunch

#

Master Hunter baby

#

Those three rabbits drove me insane enough to enjoy hunting

#

But I got a sweet cloak out of it which is keeping my sick body warm

worldly orchid
#

Have u tried museum challenges?

#

Those are on a whole other level

marsh valley
#

which

worldly orchid
#

The ones where u have to collect perfect animal carcases

marsh valley
#

Oh... the request board

worldly orchid
#

And send to mail

#

Yea, thats hard af

marsh valley
#

I swear this game knows what I'm looking for

worldly orchid
#

It won't let u send them individually

marsh valley
#

"Kill a possom playing possom"
Aight bet I've seen 20

#

Then

#

None

worldly orchid
#

Lol

marsh valley
#

Try finding a bull moose

#

I got a perfect one first try but it was hell to find

worldly orchid
#

I figured out north of owanjila lake is perfect place to hunt

worldly orchid
marsh valley
#

I went to that lake with the gang treasure

#

Near Colter

worldly orchid
#

I had to look on YouTube to find 1 in colter

#

Lmao yes

marsh valley
#

Yeah that one didn't work for me

#

But the frozen lake did

tacit plover
#

And taking notes

worldly orchid
#

Lol fr

marsh valley
#

I just wish I could get a Hila Monster as Arthur
Screw Legend of the East I just want the panther gloves

worldly orchid
#

I wished they added this hunting system to gta

worldly orchid
tacit plover
tacit plover
marsh valley
#

it is too sad

#

There is no way to find the drip

#

But hey at least I kept the casino boat suit

worldly orchid
#

Or rdr3 with Charles as main character

#

Or a spin off

#

Charles and sadie deserve their own game

tacit plover
hidden moss
#

Second playthrough.

gilded tide
#

wdym

hidden moss
#

Iā€™m doing aā€¦

#

Second playthrough?

gilded tide
#

ah ok

hidden moss
#

Itā€™s pleasant to see Dutch before he lost it.

#

Before that bastard Micah fed him those moralsā€¦

gilded tide
#

he was written so well though

#

red dead devs were amazing tbh

#

in the story writing aspect

worldly orchid
#

I feel like Dutch was loosing it before blackwater

#

They say he killed a woman

#

During the heist

worldly orchid
marsh valley
#

Yeah Hosea was the only person keeping him in check

#

He refuses to let Arthur take on that role

hidden moss
#

Have hookers always been in red dead??

hidden moss
marsh valley
#

Found Trelawny's family by accident

#

Huh

#

Well that's where he goes then

hidden moss
#

Where?

wary oasis
#

They have a house in Saint Denis

hidden moss
#

Dang I didnā€™t know

marsh valley
#

Yup interesting huh

#

Itā€™s in the same block as the doctor

hidden moss
tacit plover
worldly orchid
marsh valley
#

Buell and I are heartbroken
But the boar is dead

hidden moss
marsh valley
#

He is now my main horse

#

I will do right by Hamish

#

And go kill more boars in his honor

#

Dutch is shoving me around
This is new
I'm used to Micah doing it but not Dutch when I'm just refusing to sugarcoat it for him

#

Wow Murfree ambushes are unfair
Yeah just instakill me with a knife why dont you

hidden moss
#

Knives are lethal weapons

tacit plover
hidden moss
#

That's why they kill you

marsh valley
#

Yeah just usually I get slashed and a chance to kill the guy but nah

#

He was right on top of me

#

Itā€™s nice having Buell. Heā€™s a good horse. And by taking him Iā€™ve reached high honor. Time to make some things right.

frosty geode
spice forum
#

Spoiler free but man that was awesome

marsh valley
#

Oooh my hatred for Micah is reaching a boil now

#

Sorry John but I intend to hit that fucker instead of going with ya

fading adder
#

Anyone know that mine thats got like 2 guards?

tacit plover
#

Went to Cattail Pond to get an Appaloosa, got an American Paint instead

#

Iā€™ll take what I can get, I suppose

loud grove
#

imagine not wearing arthur hat during american venom

#

thats all folks

marsh valley
#

I found a man stalking Charlotte Balfour

#

His tent had handcuffs and pictures of naked women

#

After he admitting to having spied on her and was considering going back to watch further, I took his head off with the LeMat.

#

Game thought that was mighty dishonorable of me. Guess what game I donā€™t care, I will sleep soundly at night knowing Charlotte gets to as well.

#

My honor might be through the roof now, but I'm still a killer

hidden moss
deep jackal
#

Is this a rockstar owned server?

drifting vapor
candid pasture
deep jackal
#

Ohhhhhh ok

marsh valley
#

Time to see Colm swing

#

Like I had to swing to escape his cellar

hidden moss
#

I feel like i kept forgetting about colm, took me way too long to know who he was when i looked him right in the face

marsh valley
#

I remembered him well after the mission where he kidnapped Arthur

#

I was so shocked by that turn of events

hidden moss
#

fair enough, that was one hell of a mission

marsh valley
#

sigh the game won't let me toss a tiny fire bottle in micah's direction

#

Yeah I love that mission

#

Only reason I scored Silver was I killed every O'Driscoll I could find

#

Instead of sneaking out

hidden moss
#

i think only because what happened to sean right after mission to mission got my interest more, but i need to try them again

#

no one can alert others you are sneaking if theres no one alive to see you sneak

marsh valley
#

Exactly

#

But I assume they meant no trace

#

And my moonshine buckshot sure as hell left traces on those boys

hidden moss
#

wsg ya'll

marsh valley
#

looking for night folk

#

not finding any

winged pendant
#

When collecting companion items, do you need to speak with them to trigger them or can you just collect them and bring them back to them without triggering anything?

tepid ginkgo
#

Iā€™m fairly sure you donā€™t have to trigger anything

winged pendant
#

And is there any time limit when it comes to what chapters the items are available during?

tepid ginkgo
#

I believe so.

marsh valley
#

Yeah there's some for jack in chapter 2

#

a thimble for abigail

tepid ginkgo
#

Iā€™m just taking a guess Iā€™m comparing it to the gold you can find throughout the chapters

winged pendant
#

Alright thanks

tepid ginkgo
#

Sure thing

winged pendant
#

Oh, one more thing, do the companion item quests count towards the 100% completion?

tepid ginkgo
#

Iā€™m assuming so. Given itā€™s quests, think stranger missions

drifting vapor
#

Whoops read it wrong

tepid ginkgo
#

I just thought gold when they said it

winged pendant
#

Damn

#

I got a lot of stuff to do lol

tepid ginkgo
#

I never finished it entirely. You mean the story right?

winged pendant
#

No Iā€™m going for the platinum trophy

tepid ginkgo
#

In that case Iā€™m pretty sure they count

autumn verge
hidden moss
#

Ayo I wanted to ask what chapter does Arthur start showing symptoms of tuberculosis? Just got to chapter 4 LEOKEK

void pond
#

i think he start coughing mid chapter 3

#

and he started hard coughing at the end of chapter 4

#

to be specific, in the missions where bronte involved

hidden moss
#

Ooooh okay thanksā€™

marsh valley
#

I've hit minimum weight in game

#

Tuberculosis is no good

#

I just can't keep the weight on

hidden moss
#

same with me

tepid ginkgo
#

I think Arthur has the weight of a fetus at this point

hidden moss
#

though ive already completed rdr2

tepid ginkgo
#

Iā€™ve done it 3 times now

hidden moss
#

im gonna do another playthrough

tepid ginkgo
#

Gain your honor by fishing and just letting them back in

#

In that last chapter you get a load more honor than you usually do

chrome gale
#

i cant stop playing rdr2

tepid ginkgo
#

and thatā€™s perfectly normal

frigid cloud
tepid ginkgo
#

Take it from them I dunno

void pond
hidden moss
#

I don't know why but I played the story so many times and after 2 weeks of finishing it I already want to replay it again.

lean sparrow
#

Can anyone help on dm

hidden moss
#

Sharpshooter 8 completed

#

Relatively easy

hidden moss
lean sparrow
hidden moss
#

What I did was

#

In valentine i just kept pointing my gun at a specific farmer and when he would draw his weapon, dead eye and shoot the gun

hearty ledge
#

howdy cowpokes

hidden moss
plush ruin
#

if anyone needs me to make them an online or story outfit drop me a DM throughout the day and i'll make some as soon as im free

gray wasp
#

Fuck

#

I forgot

#

someone here told me important info a couple days ago

#

and I forgot it

#

shit...

long kite
gray wasp
#

Wait wtf

#

I have a New Austin animal studied in my conpendium?

#

H O W

#

I haven't used any glitches

long kite
#

Join us John, Join us!!

gray wasp
#

Just that Dutch also knew that

long kite
gray wasp
#

and only came so he could kill Micah

#

yeah

#

So basically Micah was bullshitting until the end

long kite
#

I wonder where dutch went when he walked down the mountain

gray wasp
#

Same here

#

I wish there was like

#

a comic series

#

about what Dutch did during that time jump between games

long kite
#

its scary how fucked up he looks in rdr1 compared to rdr2

gray wasp
#

Yeah

#

he's not even wearing proper clothes anymore tbh

long kite
#

lol fr

gray wasp
#

just r e d

#

no style lol

long kite
#

I'd like to see a game about arthur in his teenage years, leading up to the blackwater massacre

#

I just like prequels I guess

gray wasp
#

Same

#

I feel like we have too little info

#

on those days

long kite
#

factss

gray wasp
#

just scraps of paper really

#

and Arthur's Journal

long kite
#

have you read the journal?

gray wasp
#

Not much tbh

#

just the occasional peek

long kite
#

yeah neither have I

#

not all the way through

gray wasp
#

I'll give it a read-through when I finish Chapter 6

#

as John

long kite
#

idk what to do, I've just finished my first walkthrough

gray wasp
#

John probably read the entire thing between those years after the gang split

long kite
#

yeah i agree

#

im probably gonna make a new save

gray wasp
long kite
#

for a high honor run

long kite
#

might play uncharted 4, havent played that game myself yet

gray wasp
#

Once you do the challenges, nothing much is stopping you from going for a 100%

long kite
#

true that

gray wasp
#

But really what I'd do is go back to a different game that you were playing before you got RDR2, and haven't played in a while because of that.

#

I haven't played Overwatch in months lol

hidden moss
#

Can we talk about spoilers here?

gray wasp
#

Well...

#

yes

#

but I'd not recommend it if there's a new player in the room

hidden moss
#

Ok thanks

viral dagger
#

Is it me or anyone else is also experiencing excessive rainfall ?

dense mauve
#

Me too

gray wasp
#

"Whole world's changin', even I see that now. Our time... has pretty much passed. They don't want folk like us no more. It's their rules or be damned with you. No more outlaws, no more killers. Now it's us being hunted... oh, and they ain't stopping. We went and made our choices a long time ago, so... I guess we gotta pay for our sins."
-Arthur Morgan

hidden moss
#

šŸ˜”

gray wasp
#

There really isn't a accurate way to describe that man, at least no quick ones...

#

But he deserves a long description

indigo flax
#

Soooooo, I have a question. I bought rdr online a while ago and now i bought redemption 2. I have online installed but not rdr2, They are both the exact same size and I now have the option to play story when i open online, is there anything to worry about not having rdr2 downloaded as a game?

hidden moss
#

Yes

#

The game won't run

#

Lmao

#

Try pressing the story button

fluid cypress
#

lol what

#

both are not the same size tho

hidden moss
sage vessel
hidden moss
fluid cypress
#

doesnā€™t make sense

#

on ps4 the whole thing is 150gb

gray wasp
#

REALLY

sage vessel
#

i mean how is the game in playstation

#

is it good or bad

fluid cypress
#

so like both are 70 each?

fluid cypress
sage vessel
#

what makes it so good

fluid cypress
#

I didnā€™t find any problems

#

lol

#

thatā€™s all

sage vessel
#

how

hidden moss
#

Rdo by itself is up to 123 gb

sage vessel
#

how did you not find any problems

#

thats impossible

fluid cypress
#

bruh I just didnā€™t I mean thereā€™s like maybe 2 glitches

#

Iā€™ve encountered over 8 months

hidden moss
sage vessel
fluid cypress
#

Both were mission related

fluid cypress
sage vessel
#

ps4 pro has 4k aswell

fluid cypress
#

yep

#

hdr also but thatā€™s useless

#

cuz hdr sucks in rdr2

#

i donā€™t use it

sage vessel
#

hdr?

#

oh yeah

fluid cypress
#

ye

sage vessel
#

im gonna pretend that i know what you are talking about

fluid cypress
#

bruh

#

hdr

#

high dynamic range

#

Increases the range of colors displayed

sage vessel
#

yeah

fluid cypress
#

Basically a more variety/range of colors are seen on hdr screens

sage vessel
#

4K too

fluid cypress
#

But the material itself should have hdr capability

#

most games hdr works well u see a big difference and itā€™s way better with it on

#

But rdr2 welp

sage vessel
#

non-hdr is bad

fluid cypress
#

thereā€™s a difference yeah but it makes it more dull

#

Just does the opposite

viral dagger
sage vessel
#

4k hdr is gā­• ā­• d

fluid cypress
#

Yes

#

In most cases

#

4k is always good

sage vessel
#

so you get 240 fps on 1080p and 60 fps in 4k

#

hmm what about 8k

fluid cypress
#

actually rdr2 doesnā€™t have native 4k on ps4 itā€™s checkered, native 4k is only Xbox even tho ps4 pro can run it

sage vessel
#

yeah i know

fluid cypress
#

like half of the pixels are 4k in checkered pattern when the screen is in heavy motion and when thereā€™s less itā€™s the whole thing

sage vessel
fluid cypress
fluid cypress
#

But rdr2 has no 8k support for ps5

sage vessel
#

oh wow rdr2 can work on ps5 too

fluid cypress
#

Yep

sage vessel
fluid cypress
#

Itā€™s full 4k over there unfortunately no 60fps

sage vessel
#

sometimes it could be locked to 30 fps

fluid cypress
#

it is

#

always locked

sage vessel
#

it sucks

fluid cypress
#

nah

#

i like it feels cinematic

#

but some other games

#

feels bad

#

for rdr2 itā€™s good

#

tbh games on ps4 should have an option for 60fps with 1080p

#

itā€™s not impossible like god of war has it on 1440p

neat rain
#

Idk the difference between 60 FPS and 30 FPS

fluid cypress
#

jk

#

There some games thay have 60fps on ps4 pro

#

but only ps4 pro so

#

you should check

#

if u have pc then thatā€™s best to see the difference

frigid cloud
gray wasp
#

yeah, but it runs suprisingly well on console as well

#

I'm fine with it