Because you've done almost everything already
#red-dead-singleplayer
hidden moss
hidden moss
how many parts does the epilogue have
wary hazel
2
hidden moss
thats a lot less then i imagined
is part 2 a lot longer then part 1 or is it around the same
wary hazel
np
dusky latch
rob the bank ( not sure if u can )
peak vigil
mild hawk
okay
gilded tide
does anyone else like playing low honour more then high honour
because technically they’re both canon
and i just love doing a massacre in valentine
or saint denis
fierce cave
found a bug where arthurs belt and offhand holster are just gone
wary hazel
go to ur wardrobe and select a gun belt
wary hazel
ikr
gilded tide
yes but i hate getting bounty
i’m specifically playing a low honour 1500$ bounty playthrough this time lmao
wary hazel
lol
wary hazel
yes
sweet forum
is it possible to get the legend of the east outfit as Arthur because you can't get those herbs in new austin
civic nest
Yes you can but getting the herbs is crazy difficult
frigid cloud
I wouldn't bother, ridiculously difficult.
hidden moss
I wouldn't bother, ridiculously difficult.
What's so difficult about it?
frigid cloud
Wagon method is mad difficult
hidden moss
Wagon method is mad difficult
What's wagon method
civic nest
Even making it to New Austin is hard
civic nest
What's wagon method
You basically drive a wagon that leaves your head covered to prevent the sniper from killing you
gleaming whale
bruh
civic nest
What
gleaming whale
bruh
night tide
Just found out Micah killed jacks dog, never knew
hidden moss
that bastard.
civic nest
: Remember when you were calling for your dog and he never came back? It was me, Jack. I took him to the nearest river and drown him and then put him in Pearson's stew!
placid inlet
wary hazel
wary hazel
is it possible to get the legend of the east outfit as Arthur because you can't ...
yes
cheat
then save
placid inlet
legend of the east outfit kinda ugly : (
wary hazel
truth
civic nest
then save
You can't save after using cheats
Besides there is no invulnerability cheat to go pass the sniper lol
tawdry moon
Shotgun coat is 10/10
dire sentinel
legend of the east outfit kinda ugly : (
a bit, yeah. the main reason i wanted lote was because of the vest
tawdry moon
Can't find anything which is as good as this
dire sentinel
but that dragged me into chasing 100% completion
placid inlet
oh yeah the vest is awesome
like i do like the individual items of clothing but together its all a big meh
frigid cloud
Nah, all.
hidden moss
Just found out Micah killed jacks dog, never knew
Proof?
hidden moss
Shotgun coat is 10/10
Which one?
hidden moss
For the posionus trail map do u need all maps to get the gold?
, how can you know where the gold is if you don't find all the maps? Only the final map tells you where it is and you need all the ones before it for that,
hidden moss
So you're ruining the game balance
You may as well just spawn in 5000 dollars if you're going to look up the treasure locations
Arthur wouldn't be able to just look it up so why should you
night tide
Arthur wouldn't be able to just look it up so why should you
Irl person vs a dude in game chill out
@fervent crown don’t worry I looked them up too. And yes you need all maps
hidden moss
He says it
I thought he just says that the dog isn't coming back
night tide
Meaning he killed it
fervent crown
I will kill Arthur if it comes to it
hidden moss
It's not confirmed
fervent crown
Ez
hidden moss
It's possible he just beat/scared the dog away
night tide
It's not confirmed
“Heavily implied” it might not be confirmed, but he definitely killed it
hidden moss
"not confirmed" "definitely"
night tide
If the dog ran away Micah wouldn’t care anyways
hidden moss
Yeah
gleaming whale
greet everyone in saint denis
frigid cloud
don't be a prick in-game
hidden moss
How do u get Honor level up
Be honorable
Don't be dishonorable
Anyway, why do you want to become honorable?
night tide
How do u get Honor level up
Greet everyone you see. Every 3 greets increases honor
Donate money
Help people that ask you to take you places
silk hull
Chapter 6 is making me real sad =(
hidden moss
Do you not realise
If you're honorable you make less money but you get discounts.
If you're dishonorable you get lots of money but no discounts
It doesn't matter either way, there are more important reasons for being honorable or not
fervent crown
Ok I will continue to kills dogs and other animals
misty cliff
Nice
night tide
Do you not realise
Wapiti why are you always so derogatory
hidden moss
Ok I will continue to kills dogs and other animals
No that's ridiculous
tacit plover
It doesn't matter either way, there are more important reasons for being honorab...
That depends on if you’re in the original story or the epilogue
If you’re in the epilogue , honor doesn’t really matter
Fu
hidden moss
In ch 1-6 you must be dishonorable until a fork in the road and then be honorable. In the epilogue you must be honorable
tacit plover
Why do you have to be honorable in epilogue
hidden moss
Because John quit the life of crime
hidden moss
In 1907 John is laying low as a farmer with his family
hidden moss
Arthur is an honorable character
No, Arthur is dishonorable in every mission before a fork in the road
night tide
Not true
tacit plover
No, Arthur is dishonorable in every mission before a fork in the road
That’s false
hidden moss
Proof?
tacit plover
The mission where Arthur frees the slaves from the Saint Denis fence and gets the Nun’s cross back are before fitr
wary hazel
The dishonor talk with gang members also
night tide
The mission where Arthur frees the slaves from the Saint Denis fence and gets th...
Exactly lmao
Arthur is literally the most honorable man in the gang other than Charles
Saying that John is honorable because he has a farm is useless
Pablo Escobar had a whole zoo lmao
tacit plover
Abigail had to leave John and take Jack with her just for him to stop doing dishonorable things
hidden moss
The mission where Arthur frees the slaves from the Saint Denis fence and gets th...
At that point he knows he is sick and is starting to see things differently. Also, when I say he was dishonorable, that doesn't mean he was a piece of shit for no reason. He would obviously help the nun to get the cross back. But he was a thief, killer, liar etc.
tacit plover
At that point he knows he is sick and is starting to see things differently. Als...
Those missions were in Chapter 4
hidden moss
Saying that John is honorable because he has a farm is useless
John is honorable because he needs to be. He left crime and just became a farmer
tacit plover
He got diagnosed in Fork in the road
night tide
Arthur was honorable and he didn’t need to be
hidden moss
Those missions were in Chapter 4
Doesn't matter due to what I just said
He was an outlaw but he didn't choose every evil option he had available to him
night tide
Also John was a “thief, killer, liar, ect” too lmao what’s your point. They’re all gang members
@wary hazel gets to decide
wary hazel
They don't believe In heaven.
hidden moss
Also John was a “thief, killer, liar, ect” too lmao what’s your point. They’re a...
he left crime
The epilogue is in 1907
night tide
Because he was forced too
hidden moss
Read.
night tide
His whole gang was killed off or disbanded what you want him to do run solo?
hidden moss
He left to take care of his family
misty cliff
Nope, my John became a serial killer
hidden moss
That doesn't matter
night tide
It does
hidden moss
He had to leave crime to take care of his family anyway
tacit plover
“leave crime”
tacit plover
Because murder is incredibly lawful, isn’t it?
hidden moss
That's an exception
night tide
Who took John son fishing again, I can’t remember
misty cliff
Left crime and then eliminated the saint denis populace
night tide
…
night tide
Left crime and then eliminated the saint denis populace
But I guess that’s also an exception, why? Well that’s also an exception
misty cliff
My john as a whole is an exception.
night tide
The whole epilogue is an exception
misty cliff
He is the most wholesome person ever, even more than Micah Bell
night tide
Facts
misty cliff
The whole epilogue is an exception
It is, unfortunately. It's something else.
hidden moss
If John was a criminl in 1907 then why does Abigail get mad at him for doing tiny crime actions
hidden moss
How do i find player online please help?
night tide
It is, unfortunately. It's something else.
That something else is an exception
night tide
How do i find player online please help?
Are you in story mode rn?
hidden moss
@night tide online but i see no one
fervent crown
Press r1 on the loading screen
hidden moss
@fervent crown me?
tacit plover
If John was a criminl in 1907 then why does Abigail get mad at him for doing tin...
Meaning that John kept doing things that made him, Abigail, and jack have to keep moving
night tide
<@700836863551864869> online but i see no one
There might just be no one rn lol, try restarting just in case. I don’t play a lot of online
fervent crown
Ye
misty cliff
John's life was so cool 'till abigail moved in again.
night tide
If John was a criminl in 1907 then why does Abigail get mad at him for doing tin...
Maybe because Abigail is literally the biggest softy in the game and was always against violence?
That’s literally her character
tacit plover
Maybe because Abigail is literally the biggest softy in the game and was always ...
She killed Agent Milton
night tide
That’s the only time I’ve seen her use actual violence
night tide
I might be wrong but I think she’s overall peaceful char
candid walrus
She killed Milton?
Yep
fervent crown
Does the levictuis Cornwall guy die?
night tide
Either way John is dishonorable and Arthur is honorable can’t tell me dif
candid walrus
Yes
fervent crown
Good
night tide
Does the levictuis Cornwall guy die?
Have you not played story mode…
fervent crown
I just started again
night tide
Oh ok
fervent crown
Cuz I quit in 2018
hidden moss
@fervent crown wdym loading screen
night tide
That’s exactly what i did
tacit plover
I might be wrong but I think she’s overall peaceful char
The entire reason she was apprehended by Milton was that she was charged with murder
fervent crown
When it says start storymode
night tide
The entire reason she was apprehended by Milton was that she was charged with mu...
All of the gang was
The murder was just an overall
fervent crown
Like press X to load in
hidden moss
@fervent crown i don't get thati just load in to online
tacit plover
All of the gang was
Then why wasn’t tilly apprehended alongside Abigail?
fervent crown
Idk search on reddit or gogle
night tide
Then why wasn’t tilly apprehended alongside Abigail?
Good point
misty cliff
Either way John is dishonorable and Arthur is honorable can’t tell me dif
Both of them in my hands are quite sunshines and rainbows.
hidden moss
@fervent crown no is just u Know where to find Ppl to play with?
fervent crown
Not many people play online tbh
night tide
Online is dead
fervent crown
If they do they all half way across the map
night tide
Rockstar will never do anything with it
Also I think it’s just that no one really wants to play it when story is awesome
tacit plover
🪦 Here lies RDO
fervent crown
Yep
hidden moss
@fervent crown oh so theres no body
fervent crown
Rip 2019-2019
hidden moss
Like no server
fervent crown
Its empty
zenith patrol
I was just about to ask if the people are toxic or not on online but it seems like that wouldn't even be a problem if they were (I got the game like today)
fervent crown
Like actually empty
hidden moss
Bruh
night tide
it’s because you can do so much in story mode
fervent crown
Yep
misty cliff
I was just about to ask if the people are toxic or not on online but it seems li...
They are extremely toxic.
night tide
Vs GTA where story is sort of held back, and online is do whatever
fervent crown
I love rdr2 over than gta5
misty cliff
Avoid Online imo
night tide
That’s why GTA online is always full
night tide
Horses>
zenith patrol
They are extremely toxic.
Ow not very good news considering my race and gender
zenith patrol
Btw anyone know why my horses keep going in circles when I try to go straight?
misty cliff
sorry but horses in rdr2 are complete dumbasses. Irl they are sweet but in the game they are just moronic
fervent crown
In game they are autistic
gilded tide
They are autistic
don’t use autistic as an insult wtf
fervent crown
K
native sphinx
Anyone had a weird crash after 15 minutes of playtime PC
?
I looked it up and tried many of things to no avail
gilded tide
Anyone had a weird crash after 15 minutes of playtime PC
re install the game
restart your pc
reset your wifi
native sphinx
re install the game
tried/:
native sphinx
Yeah Epic
native sphinx
lmao
gilded tide
hmmm
native sphinx
Nah I tried everything man
native sphinx
tried to revalidate
native sphinx
yeah I did
gilded tide
that’s weire
native sphinx
I tried a lot of weird internal PC editing shit too
gilded tide
do you get an error code
native sphinx
tried lower graphics
gilded tide
you could always google the error code
native sphinx
no just crashes/:
native sphinx
no its okay
native sphinx
and the game was running for a week no probs
native sphinx
even when im only playing singleplayer?
gilded tide
can’t have high expectations with rockstar
gilded tide
even when im only playing singleplayer?
i’m pretty sure yeah
probably need servers to run singleplayer too lmao
gilded tide
damn tho that sucks, i have no idea :(
native sphinx
anyways thanks for the help
gilded tide
game should’ve ended on my last boy
frigid cloud
And?
gilded tide
And?
?
it’s pretty cool that the first and last job were both trains
and how the game starts in that snowy ass environment
and ends in it
eternal bear
why didnt arthur used a horse reviver, god damn it i spent a grand on that horse
gleaming whale
for plot
gilded tide
And what next after game ends on my last boy
what man?
what are you trying to say bro
i have no idea what you’re saying baran
eternal bear
shouldve used a special tonic then arthur couldve kicked micah's arse
no brainer, it didnt had to end that way 
calm crow
Bruh
Pls help me
I wanna increase my honor with cheat codes
But it always says “you do not meet the prerequisites to unlock this cheat.”
south coral
You have to purchase certain newspapers to unlock some. Different ones become available after story missions I believe
frigid cloud
But it always says “you do not meet the prerequisites to unlock this cheat.”
Purchase a newspaper after completing ‘Urban Pleasures’ in chapter 4
limber path
Sorry if it's a dumb question but where do I go hunting?
Im at the camo hut they don't have enough food
frigid cloud
Animal's loot is dependant on its quality, if higher quality=more meat
steady vector
Trying to do a story only playthrough is to hard. Here I am hanging out in camp for half an hour and then gallivanting around to fulfill the camp requests that I haven’t done before.
proven cedar
I wanna increase my honor with cheat codes
I just run around saint denis saying hi to everyone cuz i been killing so much my honor bar is almost as low as it can go😂
hidden moss
Surprisingly I've never done a high honor playthrough
autumn verge
I'll miss Reverend
hidden moss
Strauss is a bitch I was happy to be able to kick him out
proven cedar
Ong I haven’t even got to that part yet but im already excited
floral island
i dont really like kicking strausse out
people blame him for arthur's illness, but arthur knew what he was getting himself into (ofc he didnt know he would get sick, but he knew there would be risks)
glad brook
Well he kicked Strauss out because he went for poor hardworking desperate people the same type of people the gang were supposed to be fighting for.
floral island
thats the way it is, outlaws wouldve done anything to survive.
i mean, throughout the entire story you rob hardworking people, or even sometimes kill them.
strausse was no different to any other gang member
rich jetty
silk hull
Eagle flies is gonna be ok, right, guys? 😭
floral island
Lmao i love arthur
dont we all
rich jetty
Arthur= Hotti
mild hawk
negative
fly high, my friend 
rich jetty
Eagle flies <:cowboy_sob:609505440920895524> fly high, my friend <:cowboy_sad:60...
is pc rdr2 good
proven cedar
U can mod it so I assume it is
rich jetty
ok
jovial orchid
is pc rdr2 good
yess
jovial orchid
Arthur= Hotti
arthur is amazing and hot
silk hull
is pc rdr2 good
I love it, but then again I don't have a point of reference since I never really was a console player lol
proven cedar
troll face paint on arthur is currently the best mod made
Someone needs to make a mod that turns dutch into squidward or sumthn😂
mild hawk
unfortunately modders can only edit textures due to openiv devs being fucking cucks and not releasing the custom model support for rdr2
proven cedar
Rip
Im sure they’ll find a way eventually. Not like R* pays any attention to rdr2 and rdo theyre to busy rereleasing gta5 for the 15th time and calling it a “remaster” or whatever
ancient adder
i picked up the guy who got killed by the prostitute in valentine but now i cant drop it? i want to report her to the sheriff
rich jetty
heh
proven cedar
Anyone else get a black Arabian right after the valentine robbery?
hidden moss
i did.
silk hull
Hell yeah Sadie! we don't need Dutch! You and Arthur will get married, and have lots of babies, at least until Arthur dies in a few weeks...🤔 maybe having lots of babies isn't the best idea
glad brook
i picked up the guy who got killed by the prostitute in valentine but now i cant...
Beat her up.
Then you could report her.
true plaza
So I'd like to collect a good portion of what's required before I trigger Dutchesses and Other Animals, bc once I do, the plumes become scarce af, but I'd rather not grind it all out right now. If I dont start the first initial mission, will I still be able to start it after Chapter 4 or will I miss the boat on it(no pun)?
civic nest
You can start it even in the epilogue
But you can't grind all the stuff the guy wants before starting the mission
gilded tide
how come there are only 5 states
like
i’m not american
so i don’t know how many states there were in 1899
but i know for a fact there weren’t fucking five
true plaza
You can start it even in the epilogue
Why not? Do the plumes/gator eggs you're already carrying not count?
civic nest
Idk about birbs but the orchids stop spawning when you get close to the amount he asks for
true plaza
how come there are only 5 states
It doesn't take place in the entire country. Just a good portion of the Southwest
true plaza
Idk about birbs but the orchids stop spawning when you get close to the amount h...
Tbh I didnt even know you could collect the orchids early, I was just gonna get a headstart on the eggs/plumes
rancid flame
Hey! Sorry if this is the wrong place to ask, but is there some way to get a gang member as a follower in this game?
Only been playing for a few hours
true plaza
Hey! Sorry if this is the wrong place to ask, but is there some way to get a gan...
Unfortunately not outside of a mission
civic nest
I think you can by glitching the game by bringing an enemy to camp or something like that
I'm not sure how is done
languid mortar
Hey! Sorry if this is the wrong place to ask, but is there some way to get a gan...
Only via glitches, and it's weird and jank. Basically bring an enemy to camp then die before you get reset and then set up a personal camp as soon as you can
gilded tide
Hey! Sorry if this is the wrong place to ask, but is there some way to get a gan...
no worries, but if this is your first playthrough i’d highly recommend not being in any reddits or discord’s because you’ll get the game spoiled :|
gilded tide
Rest in peace, Arthur. Despite everything, you were a good boah
😭😭😭
just started the epilogue?
or done the game yet
autumn verge
Damn Sadie looks quite a monster
silk hull
Now it's just John and what's her face and that boi, whatever his name was. and our trusty wagon horse, Floppy
autumn verge
I looted the fat man with the bread that Sadie wanted to kill
in the chapter 6 mission widow with her
He has a letter
Letter to Tom from Colm
Wow this was
a sad letter
silk hull
just started the epilogue?
Yeah just started that part, looks like John is an honest hard working boah now, despite the fact that he's still lying through his teeth lol
ancient adder
do legendary animals respawn?
autumn verge
No
autumn verge
In story mode yes?
ancient adder
Yes
autumn verge
then nope
silk hull
If I didn't go get the money in the cave at the last camp as Arthur, can I go back and get it as John?
autumn verge
You'll get the money from the cave once you finish America venom
ancient adder
how much money is it?
autumn verge
Enough to buy you everything
The last mission for you to do free roam is My Last Boy
The last if not two more missions will be Dutch
I see a lot of people still stuck to chapter 2
cattle pussys
ancient adder
Enough to buy you everything
is that what the whole "gang's share" thing was?
normal elk
No, we dont know if Micah went back for the money, but you do recive a lot of money. All the money that was stashed in blackwater
normal elk
We can assume he did cause he never shut up about going back to blackwater for the money
wary hazel
The last mission for you to do free roam is My Last Boy
No
fluid cypress
damn
I’m in chapter 5 and just learned that u can’t do camp chores and a lot of shit from now on
i feel bad I ddint experience those things before
digital flicker
always keep your honor level high .d
marsh valley
Mine is at rock bottom
It's not my fault
Trains are just too much fun to rob
I'll turn it around before the end
I want my revenge to be worth something
digital flicker
Dont forget that this will affect the story.
hidden moss
yep.
normal elk
It's not my fault
It is your fault tho,
wary hazel
Im in chap 3 and i have max honor
hidden moss
good.
frigid cloud
Cheats
normal elk
No,
wary hazel
no
normal elk
It's completely possible
frigid cloud
Really, how?
wary hazel
I free roam too much
normal elk
"Hello mister!"
hidden moss
lmao.
normal elk
Like 500 times
frigid cloud
Jeez
wary hazel
Even i saw gavin friend
steady vector
Even i saw gavin friend
I swear it seems he follows you around sometimes
wary hazel
Lol
steady vector
See him in town several times and out in the wild a few times as well in the same playthrough
wary hazel
We are gavin
normal elk
I thought that your pfp was dead eyed hug guy, with a cowboy hat
Was wrong
DEAR GOD
frigid cloud
steady vector
Mine?
wary hazel
Huggy wuggy is best
tawdry citrus
You sir are a fish
normal elk
Wat
hidden moss
Hi guys, im new to RDR2 what should I do first in order to make money?
normal elk
Why are you copy pasting
Dude just go out there, it's open world, you see that bird? Shoot it
You see that house? Rob it
Whatever works
Also story missions
thorn drift
What about just getting roles ranked up xD
normal elk
Hi guys, im new to RDR2 what should I do first in order to make money?
Asking in every chat isnt a good way to get help, just makes you look like an asshole
normal elk
Pc
thorn drift
Trying to find someone to posse up with, I'm surprised it's not cross platform yet
marsh valley
It is your fault tho,
Naaah of course it's not! I... it's Micah's influence i swear.
...isn't because it's just fun to kill and rob
Finally in Chapter 4
I'm excited to get my chaotic hands on the LeMat
Well, two of em preferably
normal elk
Lemat = good
marsh valley
I just wish it could fire incendiary shot...
normal elk
Navy = ? Cause it's not in story
marsh valley
Yeah idk about any of that navy nonsense
How can you beat a shotgun revolver?
You can't. Plus you can be the Man in Black from Westworld
I certainly have the hat for it
normal elk
Nice
marsh valley
I'm sad it's too hot now to wear my panther skin
Moving to the swamps apparently comes with that trade off
But I got some nice crimson drip from the Gucci store in Saint Denis, so it ain't all bad
I also got pickpocketed for $300 and came away with an additional $400
wary hazel
if u wanna wear ur panther skin just lurk around in NW or WE north part
and ambarino
lemoyne sucks
wary hazel
what guns
marsh valley
LeMat
I'm thinking blackened steel and gold, pearl handle, engraved with gold
For that opulent but brutal look
wary hazel
i have my schofield on black steel
marsh valley
I got the Semiauto early
Robbed the old woman for it
wary hazel
theres only 2 of them lol
marsh valley
I hate Micah's guts
But 12 really is better than 6
And 18 is better than 9
Dual wielding is where it's at for sure
wary hazel
its good for fire rate
marsh valley
One robbing with Sean
The other doing that robbery before I did it with Sean
wary hazel
and badass
marsh valley
Oh man
marsh valley
Schofield is nice and accurate at least
marsh valley
One thing I'd wish I'd known sooner: your stats get a permanent boost for getting full sets of challenge gear
That's really nice to have
wary hazel
basically
it allows u to carry more ammo to
if u have a upgraded gunbelt u can carry 300 ammo for revolver and pistol
but if u do unlock all the reinforcement stuff u will carry like 400
marsh valley
More explosive shot too
Which is what I truly care about
Being able to have two LeMats full of explosive bullets
Partial to the bandit stuff myself
marsh valley
I mainly use it to blow safes open
marsh valley
And when I'm feeling like switching it up
When I truly want to inspire some fear
And don't want to use my Auto Five
That shotgun is an engine of destruction
marsh valley
I rob em at Wallace Station
Already have a $1500 bounty in West Elizabeth, and its on a bridge so the law has some trouble
wary hazel
u want some good tips?
marsh valley
The semiauto is a godsend in train robberies
wary hazel
to not get bounty
marsh valley
Tight corridors and confined spaces
Eh not really
I keep my heat high out there so I have somewhere to terrorize with impunity
Where I can throw down with eight bounty hunters at a time
I really need to do more stagecoach robberies tho
wary hazel
how do u escape the law on bard crossin
wary hazel
u jump down?
marsh valley
I shoot em until they give up when I rip and run
wary hazel
damn
marsh valley
Eventually they'll run out of men
wary hazel
batman
marsh valley
And I like the fight
I purposely got a silver medal in Blessed Are the Peacemakers cause dammit
They took me prisoner and tortured me, I was gonna kill em all
marsh valley
I did not escape unseen
I shot everyone between me and freedom
Hell, I fired off some shells in the air to get their attention
wary hazel
lol
marsh valley
I introduced those boys to my special moonshine buckshot
Must've liked it cause they kept screaming, I assume for more of the stuff
Those O'Driscolls, drunks the lot of em
wary hazel
they are bad
and
virgin
i was raiding hanging dog ranch rn
and
a damn odriscoll
marsh valley
Colm is sort of an incel tbh
wary hazel
i spammed my shotgun on him
marsh valley
Thing I can't figure is why in the mission where they give you a minigun
The medal requirement says "get headshots, be accurate"
Bitch you just handed me a minigun! I'm going to waste ammo and shoot everything that moves into Swiss cheese!
wary hazel
xd
wary hazel
which
wary hazel
blackwater mission?
hidden moss
yes.
wary hazel
that mission might me in
rdr3 last mission?
idk
we dont even know a glimpse of the game
wary hazel
oh
marsh valley
Yeah
I'm not donating that
The gang can have one of my many gold bars instead
Ain't as if I'm hurting for cash
Shoot I should just donate all the gold we can leave the US right now
Go farm some mangoes
wary hazel
u wish
marsh valley
sigh
If only
It'll never be enough for Dutch, even if I handed over every dime I had
marsh valley
I doubt he'd kill me
But Micah would sure as hell smother me in my sleep
Take the cash and run
marsh valley
I spend every moment he's in my sight winding him up
Antagonizing him
Nobody in camp cares
wary hazel
i lost honor for antagonizing him
marsh valley
Come chapter 6, our battle will be legendary
wary hazel
dumb game
wary hazel
lol
wary hazel
Xd
marsh valley
wary hazel
ima go
jagged cave
If Pinkertons don't know where the blackwater money is hidden
Dutch could have just send one of the girls to bring it piece by piece every night ?
Carrying the chest would be suspicious ofc, and we know how Karen is good at hiding stuff under her skirt
Plus didn't Abigail was able to slip away in saint Denis job because Pinkertons didn't know she was a member of the gang ?
jagged cave
Since they know what Hosea looks like they must have assumed that Abigail is accomplice then
But in my blackwater theory there won't be any known person with one of the girls
hushed sinew
yeah like sadie, they don't know her
jagged cave
and dutch not trusting them isn't a good excuse to me
hushed sinew
right, like if he really wanted to he could get the money
jagged cave
The worst thing could happen is they steal the money and runaway
Better than robbing a city bank
hushed sinew
I don't get why they never ever even go close to blackwater but after the bank job in Saint denis they still come back several times
jagged cave
I'd rather have b.water money stolen than to risk my gang's future
hushed sinew
plain stupid 😩
silk hull
Is there a way to spawn things like animals? or do you need a mod for that?
I just wanted to spawn a few dogs lol
hushed sinew
i think u need some heavy modding for that lol
silk hull
Hecc
silk hull
I'm trying really hard to like them, but I HATE John and Abigails relationship. They're constantly bickering and it is soooo annoying 
floral island
i cant be the only one that forever thought bessie was hosea's horse??
ive played this game 5 times and always thought bessie was his horse 
frigid cloud
Well, I didn't.
sinful knot
I'm trying *really* hard to like them, but I HATE John and Abigails relationship...
not a relationship without arguing
silk hull
My message it poofed
rip message, you will be missed
😭
Well since discord ate my message, all I was trying to say was that abigail doesn't even seem like she tries to be a little understanding. She wants John to change and that's that, like over night.
Which, when you've been raised most of your life to do one thing, change over night ain't happening
sinful knot
Well since discord ate my message, all I was trying to say was that abigail does...
She was never a smart person
Micah's killing didnt provoke the events of RDR1
it was the loan either way
tacit plover
it was the loan either way
Yes and no
fervent crown
What's the best horse in the game?
floral island
Depends what for
lament dock
Would the van der linde gang be good mercenaries?
mint linden
What's the best horse in the game?
IMO the Arabian horse breed
jagged cave
was it the blackwater money dutch kept hidden in the cave ?
mint linden
Two separate chests, that was all the money they collected after the massacre
floral island
A bit of the money in the chest was also the money the gang got over the years, like all the robberies.
A dialogue is heard during chapter 2 that Arthur tells Sean all the gangs earnings get put into a chest in a safe location
fervent crown
The black Arabian in Saint Denis can you only get it once?
Or multiple times because mine died
tacit plover
Is the money John gets at the end the gang’s earnings or the blackwater ferry money? Or both?
frigid cloud
The black Arabian in Saint Denis can you only get it once?
Not sure, you can check the stables of course
fervent crown
How much do they cost?
wary hazel
was it the blackwater money dutch kept hidden in the cave ?
no
thats gang share money
savings
frigid cloud
How much do they cost?
Don't remember, like I said check the stables
hearty dune
Hello. I just got myself rdr2 for xbox s. I played thru the rdr2 back when it released on PS4. But it was like playing on an airplane lol. Dat noisy ps4 haha.
Well. I dont remember too much, is there a way to transport more meat and pelts? Right now I am having 2 bear skins. One on my horse, and one on me. And I have to run all the way to valentine. On foot :o
frigid cloud
More meat by upgrading your satchel
And temporary horse to carry one more large pelt
tacit plover
What’s the maximum amount of non-large pelts (ex. deer pelt) that you can put on one horse?
hearty dune
And temporary horse to carry one more large pelt
Thanks
frigid cloud
Multiple pelts, I don't know the exact amount
hearty dune
Can I get like a horse cart to store more things on?
frigid cloud
Nope
tacit plover
You can’t store pelts on stagecoaches or carts
wary hazel
What’s the maximum amount of non-large pelts (ex. deer pelt) that you can put on...
infinite
hearty dune
Too bad about the animals. I dont like leaving the bear carcas. It is food.🥲
rocky nest
Do pearsons camp upgrades do anything? Or just visual?
tacit plover
Just visual
rocky nest
ty
gilded tide
Now it's just John and what's her face and that boi, whatever his name was. and ...
lmfao
“what’s her face”
gilded tide
Do pearsons camp upgrades do anything? Or just visual?
wdym camp upgrades
like leather working tools?
hearty dune
So. How often does the train come on the railroads? I put a women abductor on the tracks. 😅
gilded tide
Both of my black Arabians just got killed
which version of the game do you play on
also how did you get them
because there’s like four different ways to get it free
tacit plover
Do you get a side mission marker that tells you when you can go visit charlotte in the epilogue or can you just go to willard’s rest at any time?
frigid cloud
No, only in chapter 6 but it'll appear on your map
tacit plover
No, only in chapter 6 but it'll appear on your map
The wiki says that you are able to visit charlotte in the epilogue
frigid cloud
Also possible
fervent crown
What is the epilogue?
fervent crown
U play as John as a prequel to rdr1?
hidden moss
yep.
fervent crown
Ok
wary oasis
What is the epilogue?
"noun
noun: epilogue; plural noun: epilogues; noun: epilog; plural noun: epilogs
a section or speech at the end of a book or play that serves as a comment on or a conclusion to what has happened."
You get to keep playing so Jack Marston has abandonment issues
Cause even after he got revenge dad didn't stay on the ranch
timid fulcrum
is arthur's original haircut right parted or left parted ?
graceful glacier
gilded tide
is arthur's original haircut right parted or left parted ?
bald
wary oasis
Bald yeah
gilded tide
Bald yeah
yeag
😂
can you go to the black water stables
as arthur
and get the misourri fox trotter
wary oasis
You can try
Or mod
I don't think it'll allow you in the stables though, have to try...
gilded tide
damn lol
silk hull
Anyone know what the hecc you're supposed to do during Sadie's 2nd mission playing as John, with the guys down in the canyon? am I just supposed to kill them or what?
I've replayed the mission twice and she just sits behind the rock
marsh valley
Bad News: I bugged the Fundraiser mission by getting a bounty so I had to go back at least ten hours to a save where I hadn't caused trouble in Saint Denis
Good News: I can replay my favorite missions of chapter 3
I'm not happy
But this is the price I pay for trying to get 100% completion
I guess I'll just redo half of Bandit and all of Sharpshooter and the rock carvings mission aaaaaaaaa
To quote Arthur Morgan: "I wanna die"
tacit plover
But this is the price I pay for trying to get 100% completion
Technically, by the game’s rules, you don’t need to do fundraiser to get 100% completion
marsh valley
Well… I want my name on the building
This is the price I pay for insulting a cop who was beating on an innocent black man
And then earning the ire of the whole Saint Denis police force
tacit plover
Like dunkey in his rdr2 video where the entire Saint Denis saloon was filled with the bodies of police?
marsh valley
Nah I ran
I didn’t feel like staying to fight
Kinda pointless in the city
I’d do it in Strawberry, in Valentine, but not Saint Denis
Hell I’d even do it in Rhodes
But not when I get made every three blocks
tacit plover
Why not Saint Denis?
marsh valley
I don’t feel like racking up a $1500 bounty
Already have that issue in West Elizabeth cause I wouldn’t stop knocking over trains
Cause once I start killing I don’t stop for nothing
tacit plover
Same
tacit plover
hidden moss
Bad News: I bugged the Fundraiser mission by getting a bounty so I had to go bac...
Just save regularly
hidden moss
This is the price I pay for insulting a cop who was beating on an innocent black...
Of what relevance is the man's race?
marsh valley
Describing the scene
And why I insulted the man
Which earned the ire of all the boys in blue
I wasn't shocked
This is Lemoyne after all
hidden moss
The Saint Denis police are very annoying
marsh valley
Theyre fucking everywhere bro
Impossible to just beat someone up in this town
Altho
The other day in Valentine I tried instigating a bout of fisticuffs
And he and his three buddies all drew iron
and I went "y'know, nah. I'm good this time I don't need to murder all three of these fools"
misty cliff
I'm just glad there is no SWAT in 1907.
marsh valley
Same
But they make up for it in numbers
We bandits are the special forces of the old west
misty cliff
I'd say Bureau, Pinkertons or Marshalls were the government's spec ops of the old west.
And in worst cases, military.
marsh valley
True enough
But at least in this game, the Van der Linde gang fits that bill as well
Less men, but much better shooters
O'Driscolls and the others die by the dozens
misty cliff
Opposite of O'driscolls
marsh valley
I'd say we're about as well equipped as the military, or I am anyhow
The Browning Auto-5 is an engine of pure destruction
misty cliff
And double FN Brownings 1900 with chewing tabacco
marsh valley
I'm further back from getting the LeMat now
I'm itching to get my mitts on a pair of those
misty cliff
i kinda wish police forces progressed with their armaments, but they all still cary cattlemans and some old carbine repeaters
misty cliff
marshalls spawn with semi auto sometimes
marsh valley
Ah
Upside of going back 7 hours of gameplay is I get to burn that manor again
And kill the O'Driscolls in Blessed Are the Peacemakers
misty cliff
I go terminator on the saint denis police every few hours out of boredom.
marsh valley
I'm much better at this game now that I have a PC copy
marsh valley
Precision aiming is great
I don't even mod
But the game kinda has that Max Payne 3 precision shooting to it
And it's nice not to have to rely on the autolock
misty cliff
i'd mod epilogue john marston so he looks like he was supposed to, feels off playing as him.
unique garnet
And it's nice not to have to rely on the autolock
srsly, the game is kind of boring on console for that reason
unique garnet
left trigger... right trigger.. repeat
marsh valley
Yeah you have less precision
It's having a whole hand and an input on a flat surface versus a thumb and a much less precise input
I still beat it twice on Xbone tho
split ivy
I'm trying to get Gold on BATPM right now. Why is Micha such a good shot I can only kill 2 of the lawmem holding Bill? I wish they'd go back to letting us get Gold in pieces. 😤
marsh valley
I'm just having more fun committing crimes now
And realizing that if you just keep killing the law during a train robbery, they stop coming
It's lovely
Wallace Station is such a horrible spot for them
misty cliff
i still have fun committing mass murder anyway. I bet it's funnier on pc
marsh valley
The bridge there makes it hard for them to board and the passengers to escape
Cause I shake everyone down before focusing on the safes
Anyone else keep finding unlootable watches in those?
misty cliff
hardly ever rob trains myself but yeah i often find those
marsh valley
Okay it's not just me
misty cliff
either that or just some ammo
marsh valley
I have train robbery in my future but that's because I'm redoing half the Bandit challenges
I need that sweet extra stat boost
I wish the game explained that a little better
That if you get sets of challenge gear it yields the next level of your stats
I'm only finding this out on playthrough 3
misty cliff
I used to love bandit equipment too, but it doesn't fit with my current outfits.
split ivy
I've tried robbing trains a couple of times, it's almost not worth it due to the bounty. Even with a mask.
marsh valley
See I racked up a bounty in WE
And I'm just never paying it
There's very little there worth your time
misty cliff
i basically run with 1500 bounty everywhere
marsh valley
Aside from some hunting
I try to keep my crimes contained to the state where I'm already wanted dead or alive
Strawberry isn't fun anyhow, there's not a bar
So every time I knock off a train, I head to Wallace Station
Sometimes I rob the shop there just for kicks
That guy's shop is just too enticing a target, I've robbed him 5-6 times by now
tacit plover
Is there a stats section where you can check how many and what crimes you’ve committed, like in rdr1?
hidden moss
3 star moose bugged out and disappeared
I should've just lassoed her straight away instead of tracking to track her
wary oasis
I'm finding it so hard in EP2 to find a Moose
Used to find them as Arthur before quite often
hidden moss
A lot of the "rare" animals aren't really that rare
wary oasis
Well Moose are...
hidden moss
I've seen 3 in like 1 week, all by accident
marsh valley
herbert moon is the best guy to rob
"i'M hErBeRt MoOn, I'vE jUsT bEeN rObBeD!"
misty cliff
You can't kill Herbert Moooooooon
marsh valley
If I could go to new Austin I wouldn’t bother with his ass
I’d go find a perfect Gila monster skin
I wish I could do that in the main game… those gloves are fire
misty cliff
Huh, i oftentimes hang around Armadillo
It's my playground since there is no law(amazing)
marsh valley
After this I want to play RDR1 again
But leave lots of things unfinished so I can play as Jack
misty cliff
Enjoy your fishing kid, while you still can.
misty cliff
ironic
marsh valley
Now? I’m thinking I’ll spend some time robbing stages
Whet my appetite and finish more bandit before I start going after bigger targets. Trains.
I’m taking out five and taking every dime
I need to find more truly evil people
So I can feed them to alligators
Nobody but that slave catcher has been worthy of such a fate
marsh valley
Well
Nobody I could set on fire and feed to the gators
then feed the remains to the bayou fish
marsh valley
In 1 or 2?
misty cliff
But you can burn them alive
crimson bronze
That doesn't add up.
Javier's probably John's age at the oldest.
Bill? I could believe Bill being close to 50 in RDR1 atleast.
calm crow
In 1 or 2?
2
calm crow
Javier's probably John's age at the oldest.
No bc he was born in 1850
crimson bronze
That sounds like a gigantic asspull.
crimson bronze
I don't believe it is.
hidden moss
More like 29
hidden moss
Hmm
tacit plover
How the hell do they expect me to do a 9 minute dry dash when it keeps fucking raining
misty cliff
sad times
crimson bronze
How the hell do they expect me to do a 9 minute dry dash when it keeps fucking r...
Raining won't count against you, You just can't cross the waterways.
tacit plover
It gave me the notification when I started for Valentine to Rhodes but didn’t give me a notification when I left Strawberry
crimson bronze
I genuinely didn't even know that Valentine to Rhodes had a 'dry-run' condition since the challenge never states such a clause when you get it.
marsh valley
Anyone know how often Alden will give me stage coach robberies?
hidden moss
When he gets info, he'll tell you
hidden moss
I genuinely didn't even know that Valentine to Rhodes had a 'dry-run' condition ...
Right. So then why does the SD to Strawberry state it specifically, I wonder...
crimson bronze
Strawberry and Saint Denis, along with Van Horn to Blackwater
Mainly to make it more 'diffcuilt'
marsh valley
Time to harass Cornwall’s refinery so I can do some sharpshooter challenges
Like long sniper shot and hatchet from 80 feet
crimson bronze
Strawberry to Saint Denis actually isn't awfully hard.
Just ride the rail tracks from Riggs Station to Saint Denis
tacit plover
Van horn to blackwater sounds impossible
wary oasis
Its not
crimson bronze
Van horn to blackwater sounds impossible
It is possible, just need to take a special route of sorts.
graceful glacier
It's not easy, for sure.
tacit plover
What’s the time limit
graceful glacier
good vids on Youtube for best route
tacit plover
That’s only 3 or 5 minutes above Strawberry to Saint Denis
mint linden
I genuinely didn't even know that Valentine to Rhodes had a 'dry-run' condition ...
Wait till youre on horsemen challenge 9
hidden moss
That’s only 3 or 5 minutes above Strawberry to Saint Denis
And only slightly a longer journey
crimson bronze
Wait till youre on horsemen challenge 9
I finished all the challenges, so I already know the pain
hidden moss
Legendary Sockeye salmon is stupid
I go to the fish maps marker, nothing. To the maps marker, nothing. I go to specific spot from looking up online, instant bite
wary oasis
That one took about an hour for me
tacit plover
Do you have to get all the legendary fish for 100% completion?
As in “Best in the west”
floral island
any tips for fishing legendary fish?
tacit plover
Also, who counts as an enemy for horseman 7
wary oasis
If you want to do it normally just read the compendium and fish as per that
wary oasis
Also, who counts as an enemy for horseman 7
Find seven enemies, kill them and don't dismount
Like a gang HQ or something
hidden moss
Enemies are your enemy
Actually
Does it count as enemy if you antagonise someone and they start shooting you?
wary oasis
"Enemies"
crimson bronze
I mean, you can rack up a bounty and wait for bounty hunters to approach you.
graceful glacier
<@!412004556801572864> why not
I mean, you can do what you want, but shooting rando npc's won't count for the challenge.
tacit plover
I mean, you can rack up a bounty and wait for bounty hunters to approach you.
That would take too much time and definitely too much money
graceful glacier
just go to one of the known hideouts and don't get off your horse while you kill everyone.
I do think the kkk guys count.
wary oasis
They have to be marked as enemies on the map...
tacit plover
Hanging Dog Ranch will still have Laramie gang members in it after “Jim Milton Rides, Again?” right?
wary oasis
So a gang HQ like Shady Belle would work
graceful glacier
GTA Series Videos on YouTube has a video for every single challenge if you're ever having trouble.
marsh valley
Welp I just shot up Valentine again
All so I could shoot three men's hats off in deadeye
craggy fern
i ahve n issue where i cant spin my revlover anymore
wary oasis
Reload the game