red-dead-singleplayer

[gilded tide]

update 1.00

i have disc version ps4

[night raven]

I started the veteran in chapter 6 and I’m in the epilogue and still need to finish it

[jade pendant]

Yeah but just don't do the final mission with him in ch 6

You'll lose buelle

[night raven]

Yeah : (

[frigid cloud]

Is complicated to explain, best look up a guide

[gilded tide]

know any vids? can’t find anything

[frigid cloud]

Sure

I will dm you

[hidden moss]

I hate it

[split ivy]

You do keep your gear and current horse, you just wear the default outfit. It was an update I think.

[hidden moss]

I wear animal hats on all my outfits

[night raven]

No I meant you don’t keep items and stuff that you pick up

During a mission you are replaying

[split ivy]

Oh, yeah. My b.

[night raven]

On a side note, am I the only one that thinks it’s lame that you can only use the Hero’s Pearl grip on the cattleman and the gunslinger ebony on the double action?

Those should be available on every gun

[split ivy]

I know right?

[night raven]

Like I sort of understand why ebony is only on the double action because it just feels bandit-y but still annoying

[hidden moss]

Pearl grip black volcanic pistol

😍

[sinful knot]

I just use a burled grip navy along with a snake carving and different varnish for story

[glad brook]

Turn off your wifi and download the game. That's it.

Not complicated at all tbh.

[tacit plover]

So I can only have 2 talismans active at once

[upbeat kiln]

So uh

I came to chapter 4

But im sad that a certain Irish died

[civic nest]

All of them are active, you just choose which ones are visible

[dusky latch]

spoilers are allowed as long as you dont intended to ruin the fun of other players

[upbeat kiln]

Oh kk

[rugged forge]

who loved the part when dutch shot micah and John killed him

[dusky latch]

everyone

oh shi

[jade pendant]

Just don't spoil the ending cause it ruins the fun the most

[nocturne spindle]

Wish you could have them all at the same time

[lament dock]

Is ti just me or im getting the weirdest of crashes

Like I had a crash where I died to an explosion during on of them moonshiner mission

[arctic wren]

Drive carefully and maybe crashes won’t happen smh

Maybe you should have your license revoked if you keep crashing?

[lament dock]

oh fuck you. That joke was good

[chilly spruce]

do i give the legendary fishes to that fisherman dude who asks you to send them to u?

[frigid cloud]

Yes

Mail them to him

[chilly spruce]

hes located near rhodes?

or somewhere else?

Found him

[pliant coral]

so

somebody here on chapter 3?

[chilly spruce]

I was there

How do i get the fish at sisika penintiary?

Do i just swim there with boat or theres some other way?

[frigid cloud]

With boat

[chilly spruce]

I get boat from van horn or somewhere else?

[dusky temple]

Question, can you get the cash from aberdeen pig farm?

[chilly spruce]

After they took it from u?

[dusky temple]

But i didnt put the money there as arthur.

[bright dawn]

story sounds cool but i feel like i'd play it once and never touch it again

[hidden moss]

alr.

i finished it twice only.

my first playthru was bad.

second one was almost perfect i had all the weapons etc.

[languid mortar]

I hate hunting for bisonn

[rocky nest]

why

[languid mortar]

i can never damn find any

i have been searching

all over new hanover

for this fabled fucking bison

[placid inlet]

sylvus and the curious case of the mission bison

[languid mortar]

im so fucking pissed

i try to look up some kind of fucking guide

and everythings like "if you wanna find bison:look here!"

"actually, look here!"

"no, that guide is wrong this one is right"

and I go to the bloody bison markers on the fucking map

and there ain't NOTHING

[placid inlet]

have u tried #rdo-compendium

[gilded tide]

you literally go on a mission with charles to kill bison…

[languid mortar]

HOLY UFCK

A BISON

BISON

OMG

[gilded tide]

why don’t you just you know

[languid mortar]

Also I arleady

did that mission

ages ago

[gilded tide]

go where you went with charles

[languid mortar]

I did

there wasnt nothing there

[gilded tide]

there wasn’t nothing?

[languid mortar]

idk cowboy speak or wahtever

[gilded tide]

so there was something?

[languid mortar]

but i found BISON

yes there were

rabbits

FINALLY

I got a perfect bison pelt

[placid inlet]

congrats

[rocky nest]

Just to the west of heartland overflow for bison

Think thats what its called

Between the lake and the heartland oilfield is where I found a good size herd

[hidden moss]

bruh i shot the double barrel shotgun off of a murfree's back while he was tied up

and it went off and blew his head to pieces

thats awesome.

thats y i like shotguns u know.

[rocky nest]

fuck this satchel kid mission

[hidden moss]

💀 he pisses me off

[sinful knot]

its easy

especially with one particular shortcut

[rocky nest]

The checkpointing is annoying

I broke the mission n got right around behind him and still couldnt catch him, gave up after that cba

[hybrid bramble]

yeah we got a stepback

oh oh bran

well

i must say arthur

wait

[hybrid bramble]

so you lost all your money

ha couldnt be me

[rocky nest]

see #red-dead-media

little punk

[hidden moss]

😩 oh my goodness that one pinkerton in the mission "Red Dead Redemption"

"Its Arthur Morgan!"

right before getting blown away

[chilly spruce]

If i caught legendary fish and lost it do i need to catch it again?

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[tacit plover]

Oh

[chilly spruce]

Where is hoseas grave located?

[candid pasture]

he can be found in the bayou next to lenny

[chilly spruce]

Ty

[tacit plover]

If I hogtie a US Army member in Archeology for Beginners, would it count as killing them

[chilly spruce]

No

On map it will show x but it doesnt count as killing

[safe iris]

I never knew John had a daughter and there's such little info on it
Wish they'd had more in the epilogue like if Abigail would be pregnant with her or something

[chilly spruce]

How do i get special river lure

?

[rustic karma]

Once you meet the fisherman, you can buy it from the lady in lagras

[ebon tulip]

Yeah but I think it was a different year

[lofty valve]

Lmfao

I sent a message with spoilers so people don’t get spoiled but it deleted it

[native thunder]

spoilers r allowed anyway

it's been 3 yrs since release lol

[lofty valve]

It’s more of trying to be a good person

Anyways so after you get back from the island place on chapter 5 I only have $450 so my $4,000 I had previous is all wasted now?

[native thunder]

u dont get ur money back automatically?

[lofty valve]

I have $450

I used to have 4,000 before I went into that place

I haven’t completed chapter 5 yet

[native thunder]

where r u rn

[lofty valve]

I just got back

I’m on

[chilly spruce]

Play a few missions and you will have it back

[lofty valve]

Van horn trading post

[lofty valve]

Okay good

[native thunder]

if u would just do some missions then it gives u back ur stuff

[chilly spruce]

I just noticed that Otis Millers revolver and Calloways revolver has same stats

[lofty valve]

I only use volcanic revolver

Since I got it for free

[chilly spruce]

I used 2 volcanic revolvers until epilogue

[lofty valve]

What’s epilogue

[chilly spruce]

Have u finished game atleast once?

[lofty valve]

Nah

Lmfao

[chilly spruce]

Ah

[lofty valve]

Well i accidentally read Arthur we dies in the end

That’s pretty sad

[chilly spruce]

Ye

[lofty valve]

I finally got a new tv so I can finish the game in peace

It was hell playing on a laptop screen for half 42% of the story

[oblique rose]

Oh damn

On a laptop?

That must of been hell

[split ivy]

Jeez.. I feel sorry for your eyes.. but I can't talk 😅

[hidden moss]

🕴🏾 me who was going to sell a stolen horse and found the ghost train easter egg

[stiff coyote]

Hey guys, i have a problem regarding mods

i am trying to get a mod for rdr2 but it doesnt work, the mod im trying to get is basic needs, just for now im plannign to get more.
so basicaly i installed scripthookrdr2.net and put it into game files, then i got a script folder (empty one) and put it in game folder as well, where i inserted the mods

hold on, this gave me an idea, wait ill see if it works

[night raven]

Well theyre both schofeilds

[stiff coyote]

okay it didnt work

so anybody who knows whati should do?

[gilded tide]

ima go back to 1.00

to get 30 limpany gold bars

get the misourri fox trotter through saint denis stables

great way to start off a new game with the best horse and 15,000 lol

[nocturne spindle]

I tried that in 1.00 but the gold bars never worked

[gilded tide]

once i was at a friend’s house when the game came out and i did it for him and it worked perfectly

it’s actually pretty easy lol

[nocturne spindle]

It always gave me 2 gold bars, nothing more

[gilded tide]

2 is still great

that’s 1000

after you get all the guns that you can at that point and all the accessories and all that

you’ll still have like 400$ lmao

for any misc costs

[nocturne spindle]

I always saved my money until I completed "My Last Boy" and did the Aberdeen Pig Farm Glitch

[gilded tide]

not a glitch

it’s completely legal

will never get patched

[nocturne spindle]

I doubt that

[gilded tide]

how so? someone steals your money, and just stores it

for 8 years

[nocturne spindle]

It might not get patched, bit I don't think that is is intended

[gilded tide]

and then someone collects it later

[gilded tide]

idk

[autumn verge]

What do I do with hamish's horse

[gilded tide]

?

fucking ride it?

lmao??

[autumn verge]

Even better option

I'll sell it

[nocturne spindle]

Bond to lvl4 and finish "Red Dead Redemption" with it

[gilded tide]

if you really want 20 bucks, go for it man

[autumn verge]

So

I should

[nocturne spindle]

No

It is a valuable horse, in sentimental value

[gilded tide]

my personal opinion is don’t

[autumn verge]

Damn

[gilded tide]

because buell has a lot of backstory

[autumn verge]

Im going

[gilded tide]

but

[autumn verge]

Ok fine

[gilded tide]

do whatever you want lmao

[autumn verge]

Ill ride his horse until his death

[nocturne spindle]

Good

[gilded tide]

sure

[nocturne spindle]

Hamish trusted you with his beloved Buell, don't sell him off

[autumn verge]

You're right

I shouldn't sell him

[hidden moss]

He's clearly called Buell.

[glad brook]

RIP Hamish horse. 😢 😢

[gilded tide]

boys

i’m about to do my last boy

need to gain some honour first of all because i want the honourable ending lmao

[gilded tide]

wait

what is the last mission tho

there’s like a 3 mission chain or smth

[civic nest]

The last two are chained, yeah

The second to last is called Our Best Selves

[night raven]

Yeah it’s Our Best Selves, then Red Dead Redemption, and then one more that might be called The Wheel

[hidden moss]

No

My last boy, our best selves, rdr, the wheel

[exotic night]

Good thing I had the game open all day. Don't need to launch it to resume playing haha. This server BS is... BS though.

[hidden moss]

Mine is running at all times as well

[languid mortar]

eagles

[exotic night]

Tonight was the first night I was going to play online (I got the game a few days ago and was working through single-player)

RIP

[languid mortar]

rdr2s ambient music is so lonely

but like

in a good way

[glad brook]

Yeah its beautiful af.

[split ivy]

Plus you can get so many screenshots...

Even on last gen consoles, it's beautiful.

[whole briar]

when do i unlock the m1899?

[civic nest]

Chapter 4

You can only buy it in the Saint Denis gunstore tho

[upbeat kiln]

Currently on chapter 4

Damm im singing cielito lindo with Javier

[languid mortar]

I am looking for

pigeons

[red helm]

I've seen Rock Pigeons on Bards Crossing.

[split ivy]

Anyone know where woodpeckers and or cardinals spawn?

[keen shell]

Hey does anyone have advice for perfect ram pelts? I’ve been using my rifle with express ammo, high velocity and normal.

[languid mortar]

try hitting the head?

anyone know a reliable pigeon spawnpoint

some place that i can definitely find a pigeon

or two

[civic nest]

There is a big railway bridge in New Hanover

Try there or the abandoned building next to the railways north of Shady Belle

[languid mortar]

noted

I'll try the bridge again

then i'll head down to the railways

[languid mortar]

I aint finding no pigeons in either of these places

[glad brook]

Try Saint Denis.

[languid mortar]

I just left saint denis when i asked

but i guess i'll try there again

[civic nest]

It's just hard to find them. It took me a while too

They spawn in cities too but I think it's harder to find them there

[keen shell]

I’ve only been hitting the head, straight on forehead but most I get is good.

[civic nest]

What gun are you using?

[split ivy]

And I find using Deadeye on the head or major body area tends to work.

[gray wasp]

I haven't played this game in over 3 days ;-;

I'm suffering

[civic nest]

It's been weeks since I last played, I have nothing else to do

I'd like to try RDO tho

[red helm]

I don't think I've played in at least a month. Got burnt out after completing the 100% trophy.

[gray wasp]

dang

well I still have lots to do as a new player so-

[red helm]

Most of the game is quite fun. There is just a couple of very irritating things....

[amber halo]

Holy shit. I had no idea RS actually took breaks FOR ANYTHING.

[slow bison]

Rockstar really is crazy with the amount of grind for the achievements

[hidden moss]

yea right.

[languid mortar]

I'm still

searching

for

pigeons

;-;

[hidden moss]

Is it large or massive?

Just use a bow. Improved or regular arrows depending on size.

[chilly spruce]

How do i take out all my horses out of stables?

[rocky nest]

I think i remember seeing rock pigeons around bards crossing (the huge rail bridge over the estuary) if they count @languid mortar

[lament dock]

god fucking dammnit. fishing is suppose to be a relaxing thing in rdr2. I cant catch something for shit

[rocky nest]

Got the right bait? Eagle vision lets you see the fish too if that helps

[lament dock]

reeling in makes me mad

[glad brook]

Fishing is good for you.

[rocky nest]

Yeah im not really a fan of the reeling in motion

[glad brook]

Heard about an option that let's it reel it in automatically but idk.

[lament dock]

where

[rocky nest]

Rockstar servers are down for me, cant figure out how to play offline

[lament dock]

reset router

[rocky nest]

It’s their end I think

[chilly spruce]

How do i get clean kill?

[rocky nest]

Study the animal (aim at it with binoculars and hold rb)

or can aim at it with unscoped weapon

It will tell you how to get a clean kill

[chilly spruce]

Those red kinda places on the animal?

[rocky nest]

Yeah, but use the weapon it tells you to when in the animal info

[chilly spruce]

Kk

[rocky nest]

which iirc is rb again once youve studied it

Dont forget you can use deadeye which makes it much much much easier

and eagle vision makes it a lot easier to find the animal in the first place, and doesnt consume deadeye time (which i wrongly assumed it did for ages)

[chilly spruce]

Ty for info

[rocky nest]

np

Can’t play an offline game singleplayer because their servers are down. This is annoying af

[shell fable]

yeaah it under maintainan

to many report that say cant be play rdr2

have some error

[misty cliff]

Maybe they are fixing epilogue John

prolly not

stupid me

[shell fable]

including me cant play

[oak hare]

hello

[misty cliff]

hello

[oak hare]

i just joined the server

[shell fable]

i already uninstall twice

damn

[misty cliff]

im loading a saved game rn

see if it works

[oak hare]

oh okay i see u guys got the same problem

xd

[misty cliff]

i think i loaded into the game

yeah i can play

[oak hare]

i cant even play the story mode anymore

[shell fable]

me too

[oak hare]

ye yesterday it was just the online mode

rip

[oak hare]

zzz how

[shell fable]

yeaa how

[oak hare]

the sad thing is i just bought and downloaded the game

[shell fable]

rockstar say it still under maintenance

[oak hare]

i was able to play last night the story mode and now nothing xd

ye well, guess it will take a while

since they couldnt fix it until now

[shell fable]

me last two day

[misty cliff]

i had weird messages pop up bot nothing besides

[oak hare]

so youre actually playing ?

on playstation i see

[misty cliff]

i am

[languid mortar]

I've been going back and forth to and from that fucking railwayy bridge and it's surroundings for ages now and I ain't seen no fucking pigeons

[rocky nest]

Look on the rocks in the river, and perched on the bridge itself. Best to look from quite far away with binos i find @languid mortar

[languid mortar]

saw something on the bridge from west eliz side with binocs

looked like it might've been a pigeon

but by the time i reached it it was long gone

cant believe

im doing all this for a fucking hat

this is worse than it was hutning eagles

im seeing birds of all types

ducks, sparrows, ravens, crows, waterfowls, and cardinals to name a few

but my only sign of pigeons

is a distant blurry bird flapping away before I get close enough to even properly see it without binoculars

[chilly spruce]

Am i the only one who can play atm?

[languid mortar]

no

[chilly spruce]

Oh nice

[languid mortar]

ive been spending hours

looking for pigeons

[chilly spruce]

Nice, im trying to find legendary pronghorn

[languid mortar]

why is it so hard to find a fucking PIGEON OR TWO

FUCK

that might've been a pigeon!

[chilly spruce]

Gl finding them

[languid mortar]

I just shot a bird

didnt know what it was

couldnt see

and i couldnt study it

i shot it but

it wasnt enough to kill it

Still. No. Pigeons.

[hidden moss]

keep lookin.

dont give up

[languid mortar]

[silk hull]

I shot a duck in the head with a shotgun

it got up and flew away

the duck was a god

[fathom ice]

dayum

[silk hull]

and now I live in fear of the day that duck god seeks it's revenge

[languid mortar]

im losing my mind

[silk hull]

Lost mine a long time ago

I gotta do this stupid mission all over again

Also gotta get a controller, playing with keyboard isn't impossible, but hecc some of the buttons are confusing lol.

[fathom ice]

i mostly see pigeons around saint denis

[silk hull]

Eat them

[languid mortar]

I just want

some pigeon feathers

please

red dead gods

please

please

[silk hull]

Ask nicely

[languid mortar]

i beg of you

[silk hull]

ask the pigeons

be like

hey gurl

[languid mortar]

give me two pigeons

PLEASE

[silk hull]

show me your feathers

[fathom ice]

ride around saint denis and shoot any bird you see if you cant study it xd

[silk hull]

😉

and the pigeons will be like "what the hell?"

and fly away

[languid mortar]

I ain't seen any birds in st denis

but

i guess

i'll check

[fathom ice]

damn

[languid mortar]

since this damn fucking bridge

has given me nothing

[silk hull]

gasp I came across a woman with ideas, a woman! with ideas?! in 1899!?!

[languid mortar]

aint finding no pigeons in st denis so far

let alone a single bird

[silk hull]

How/where do you learn to fish?

I've just been shooting them lmao

[chilly spruce]

Hosea teaches a bit

[languid mortar]

a mission has you fish

[chilly spruce]

What bait do i use in Elysian pool

[rocky nest]

You must become one with the pigeon

[languid mortar]

I just need some faith

i am like

legitimately upset at this point

hours of searchng for pigeons

with zero fucking luck

combined with a fucking failed robbery

have upseet me

[chilly spruce]

Do i need to complete some mission before catching Legendary Perch?

[rocky nest]

Try sleeping to reset the animal spawn if you havent already @languid mortar

[languid mortar]

i tried that a lot

[rocky nest]

You’re seeing birds sat on top of rocks right? Just the wrong ones?

[hidden moss]

Guys

Who is the Strange man

That John marston meets

In rdr

1

[ornate plinth]

Devil

Probably

[hidden moss]

And

Whats his point?

[ornate plinth]

Mystery

[languid mortar]

Nope

no birds at all

not on the rocks at least

I've encountered a lot of ducks on the ground

Saw a video showing a pigeon in annesburg

gonna take a gamble and haed all the way over there from Bard's Crossing

praying to the pigeon gods rn

🙏

[silk hull]

This freaking fox just took like 6 bullets from a shotgun! the animals in my game are gods apparently

I shot it in the head twice O_O

[rocky nest]

Rocks in the rivers is always my go to for smaller birds, but they’re usually barely visible without binoculars or scope

[languid mortar]

i've been scanning the river with binoculars for ages buddy

tfw your horse dont respond to the whistle

and you get a bounty

cause you killed a robber

[silk hull]

GASP I found a kitty!

[languid mortar]

cats are unimportant

[silk hull]

We can't pet the kitties T_T

[languid mortar]

they are mere distractions from the one true god:

Pigeons

[silk hull]

On a side note

I've pet every dog I've seen

Am I playing the game right?

The only god is that dang fox I had to shoot 7 times before it died lol

[languid mortar]

fox unimportant

does a fox give you a little trinket on your hat?

No?

ive arrived in annesburg

beginning pigeon search

[silk hull]

Casually hasn't been beyond the emerald ranch

[languid mortar]

im going to start crying

ive been searching

for literal hours

HOURS

and not a single fucking pigeon

not a single fucking one

and all I need are two

TWO!

[rocky nest]

I cant play at all

[languid mortar]

it's almost 1 am and i am no closer to finding pigeons than I was at 2 pm

I've been sarching

since 2 fucking pm

2 PM!

hahahahaha

[lofty valve]

Why are you searching for pigeons

[languid mortar]

an accessory

for the hat

[rocky nest]

maybe the pigeons are on the authentication server

[silk hull]

Damn it Dutch, just let the jail keep Micah, no one likes him anyway 😠

[lofty valve]

Oh I saw a pigeon earlier

They’re not that rare

[rocky nest]

I remember woodpecker taking me forever

[languid mortar]

WHERE

TLL ME

[lofty valve]

I’m jk

[languid mortar]

i mgo uenh fyufoctlthjfff

just two pigeons

PLEASE rdr2

[rocky nest]

You know what a pigeon looks like right?

[languid mortar]

Yes

kind of

but i've been thoroughly searching

going back and forth

aiming and inspecting every fucking bird

[silk hull]

I just brushed this horse and he's dirty again, what the hecc?

[languid mortar]

i know what a fucking pigeon looks like

[lament dock]

i cant play

wtf

[rocky nest]

Servers down

Rockstar down

This guy doesnt know what a pigeon looks like

bad day all round

😭

[languid mortar]

im going back

to bards crossing

why does the map lag

when i use it

but

normal rdr2 doesnt????

[fiery anchor]

Where can I find some cool guns ?

[silk hull]

Hey bois, how do you lead another horse while mounted on your horse?

[misty cliff]

at the gunstore

saint denis gunshop has the best stuff

[rocky nest]

You can mount the other horse and whistle for main horse to follow if thats any good @silk hull

[silk hull]

Thank

[chilly spruce]

How do i get large feathers?

[frigid cloud]

It says large feathers but it actually means flight feathers which you can get from any bird

[patent cobalt]

If I would lead enemies to camp/Beecher’s hope, what would happen?

[lament dock]

is it back

is the server back

[languid mortar]

back to sylveon searching

i mean

pigeon searching

where the fuck did sylveon come from

[hidden moss]

Is the server back

[plush ferry]

not for me

[languid mortar]

hell if i know ive had it on nonstop on the xbox for a week now

[glad brook]

Keep on looking I believe in you.

[hidden moss]

pain

pain

pain

pain

pain

[lament dock]

holy shit

wtf happened rockstar

[wary hazel]

What's wrong

[wide pivot]

the servers has been down for a while, dis sucks

[grizzled sapphire]

Uncle will sort them out 👍

[hidden moss]

the one shot kid they used to call him.

[silk hull]

Wonder if Rockstar will give us any compensation for being made to wait this long for their shitty server to stop being shitty?

[grizzled sapphire]

Does this really need to be discussed in the single player channel too? Smh

[silk hull]

Yes

R O C K S T A R. Fix your shit. Uncles Lumbago keeps crashing my game

[chilly spruce]

For me its working perfectly

[wide pivot]

well you’re on ps dipshit

[golden walrus]

Sure wouldn't spit on a few dollars or gold in RDO

[rustic karma]

no

[wide pivot]

maybe beans!

[rustic karma]

15% off level 5 coats

[sick maple]

[foggy grove]

still down?

[hidden moss]

yes.

[silk hull]

I pressed the wrong button and made the dog sad, and now I'm sad

[hidden moss]

[mossy apex]

@near trellis hey bbg

It’s master goose

[raw quiver]

Do all Gunsmiths Sell the Same weapons or?

[hidden moss]

only the st denis one got different guns.

[raw quiver]

Does it Also include The guns from the Other shops or?

[hidden moss]

yea it does.

[raw quiver]

Ah okay Thank you

[hidden moss]

(:

[raw quiver]

^^

[steady vector]

Rockstar launcher is glitched on PC right now? I was playing with mod files so I thought I messed it up

[unique garnet]

It's having connection issues. I could only get into offline mode

[steady vector]

Same. But the game can’t be played in offline mode right

[unique garnet]

ive never tried

[hidden moss]

how long for the server to go back up?

[silk hull]

You can play the story in offline

Or you could -_- now I'm getting timeouts

Quickly beginning to hate this game company. Not even wildcard is this bad

[supple trout]

Rockstar Service Status:
https://support.rockstargames.com/servicestatus

[unique garnet]

dunno, it's been like a day and a half already

when it comes to rockstar, it's best to eliminate expectation altogether

[silk hull]

I really wish there was an option to just leave Micah to rot in jail. I really don't wanna save him lol.

But how else is he supposed to be all primary antagonisty?

[steady vector]

Story would have a very different outcome

Arthur would still die from TB, but Dutch probably wouldn’t make as many poor decisions and the gang might stay together and escape.

[limber path]

How do I access the fence in emerald ranch?

I just did the mission that unlocks those but i can't find the person to sell it to

I've walked all around the ranch

[wide pivot]

have you done the quest with Hosea?

[limber path]

Yeah

It only says wait till morning

[wide pivot]

oh yeah that has happened to me too, have you been wanted recently?

[limber path]

Yeah

So i can't do it cause I'm wanted?

Like not wanted but i have a bounty on my head

[hidden moss]

Is there a fence icon on your map

[wide pivot]

it should still be possible. if you have created a disturbance, you may have to wait a few days.

[limber path]

Yeah i just checked that

It has a lock on it

Imma pay off my bounty to see if it does something

[hidden moss]

Nope

Bounty doesn't matter

Have you recently committed a crime

[limber path]

I think so

I haven't played the game in a few days

[wide pivot]

try and save and reload the game otherwise, it’s a glitch that occurs sometimes

[hidden moss]

Just come back later and Seamus will be available

[limber path]

Alright

[civic nest]

Or go to another fence

[wide pivot]

i think they’re in the early gameplay

[limber path]

Ayo

It worked

I just saved and loaded that save

[wide pivot]

sweet!

[limber path]

Thanks for the help

I got a lot of shit to sell

[misty cliff]

there is also a fence in saint denis, vanhorn and rhodes

just so yk

[limber path]

So i can afford my second Schofield

[misty cliff]

what chapter you in

[limber path]

Like second

I just arrived at horshoe overlook and did a few missions

[misty cliff]

you found the Schofield i assume

[limber path]

Nah

I did the medic backroom robbery

Or whatever its called

[hidden moss]

still down

nice rockstar

[misty cliff]

There is a Schofield there@limber path

did you pick it up

[limber path]

Yeah

[misty cliff]

nice

[limber path]

But i want another one

To dual wield

Also

My money went up from like 200 to 900

[misty cliff]

i suffered inside when i got the offhand holster

it looks bad

[limber path]

Yeah but it's really fun to use

[misty cliff]

well i guess, i wouldn't complain if the characters just pulled out the 2nd gun out of nowhere

also satchel should have been removable.

It breaks some of my outfits

[limber path]

I never take a good look at my outfit so i never see it

[misty cliff]

When i wear let's say a black suit, a worn out tan satchel is the last thing i'd wear along with it

[silk hull]

Damn it, this mission yeeted all my kills off my horse so now I gotta go hunting again

[limber path]

Wait

I can't buy a second schofield

Tf?

[misty cliff]

you can't

its locked

untill chapter 3

[limber path]

It says that i already own this gun

But there is no lock

[misty cliff]

the one you picked up

if you do not possess offhand holster you can only own one

after getting it you unlock Schofield in chapter e

3

[hidden moss]

Why would you want two?

You only have one holster

[limber path]

I have 2

[hidden moss]

Then buy a second one

[limber path]

I can't

It says i already own one

[hidden moss]

Are you sure you have an off hand holster

[limber path]

Don't i get it after freeing Micah?

[hidden moss]

Yes

[limber path]

Then i have it

Can I drop my other one?

[tacit plover]

I’m trying to get a perfect beaver pelt to craft one if the satchels, but whenever I see a beaver it’s always in the middle of the body of water

[hidden moss]

So?

[limber path]

It seems like i may be stupid

Turns out i already own 2 of them but i never realized

[rustic karma]

I go to the lake north of strawberry, there are usually boats and you can grab any beavers you kill from the boat if I'm not mistaken

[tacit plover]

That’s where I am

[hidden moss]

It clearly says owanjila

[rustic karma]

Yeah thats the one

Didn't know how to spell it but north of strawberry gets the job done

[neon oyster]

Is it possible to have 2 of your horses out of the stable at the same time or no?

[limber path]

Anyone got rifle recommendations?

[hidden moss]

Guys wouldnt it be good if the blackwater massacre was a dlc?

[limber path]

I don't think you can do that

[misty cliff]

i'd prefer an undead nightmare

[hidden moss]

why

[neon oyster]

they should totally make it a thing

[limber path]

Yeah

Would be really nice

[misty cliff]

atmosphere and the supernatural tone of the game, it'd be an icing on the cake

[hidden moss]

Yes

[tacit plover]

I killed a beaver, but then it sank down

[limber path]

Wait you can?

[neon oyster]

you can?

[misty cliff]

saving saint denis or valentine from undead.

[hidden moss]

That's what I said

[neon oyster]

how

[hidden moss]

yeah that would be good too but the blackwater massacre is important too

[rustic karma]

Yeah, only one can be saddled tho

[misty cliff]

why not have few dlcs

[hidden moss]

true

[misty cliff]

But now we can only dream

[neon oyster]

ok cuz i was wanting to have that for carrying more than 1 big pelt

[hidden moss]

You take one out, then walk back in and take another

[hidden moss]

how about a rdr1 remake?

for those who didnt played rdr1

[tacit plover]

We know a lot more of the game’s supernatural elements than we do about the Blackwater massacre

[misty cliff]

I'd buy that in a heartbeat

[hidden moss]

and ngl the gameplay of that game and the mechanics is not good

[hidden moss]

same

[rustic karma]

Its definitely a bit dated

[neon oyster]

ooooh never thought about doing that

[tacit plover]

That would be the superior dlc

[hidden moss]

bro the gta 4 gameplay is still better and gta 4 came out in 2008

[rustic karma]

And your point?

[hidden moss]

rdr1 came out in 2010

[limber path]

Anyone got a shotgun recommendation?

[hidden moss]

and still has worst gameplay than gta 4

[hidden moss]

pump action

[rustic karma]

Does it matter at this point, by today's standards both games have shit gameplay

[hidden moss]

yeah thats why they should make a remake

with better graphics, gameplay and mechanics

that game is 11 years old

nearly 12

[tacit plover]

I got the beaver

[hidden moss]

but its still one of the best games of that time

[hidden moss]

where does the beaver spawn again?

[tame flower]

Imagine we got a another zombie DLC for rdr2

And John finds a zombie Arthur

Or somethin

[sinful knot]

nah its better by a tiny bit

I loved gta 4's slippery cars but they get annoying

[tacit plover]

Owanjila

[hidden moss]

what makes it better?

[hidden moss]

okay thanks

[sinful knot]

no slippery ass vehicles

in GTA4 it was like you were riding a car with shitty tires

[hidden moss]

horse* 💀

[sinful knot]

wagons

[hidden moss]

oh yeah

but the horses and the wagons still feels weird

to drive

it feels like I'm drunk

[hidden moss]

Pump action

[limber path]

I got the semi automatic

I just went to the grandma and stole it from her

Like just before you said that i got the semi automatic

[hidden moss]

Is the lever action shotgun any good?

[hidden moss]

make RDR2 Single Player DRM-free !!!!!!

i can't play it because of servers are offline.... it's so epic fail from rockstar...

[crimson bronze]

Single Player? Yeah, Literally just use what you feel is best.

You find you like the Repeating Shotgun? Then use it.

[silk hull]

I have located a mountain and I am going to use it to hunt for neat and cool things

[hidden moss]

Absolutely not.

[silk hull]

I found many neat and cool things

[hidden moss]

But the shotguns are all about the same except for the coach gun which is really bad

[crimson bronze]

Again, it's single player, There's really no meta to even follow, there's nothing wrong with using what you like best.

[silk hull]

I wanna do a playthrough after I finish the story where Arthur does nothing but liberate horses from stage coaches and wagons

[graceful glacier]

I hate Angelo Bronte.

[silk hull]

I was just now years old when I realized you can stow more than 1 pelt on your horse

[hidden moss]

There is. The weapons have stats. The double barrelled shotgun only holds two shells a very slow reload. It's not viable.

[crimson bronze]

You can argue it all you want but it is ultimately single player, the combat is a lot slower in pace, you can easily auto reload a weapon through triggering deadeye.

[hidden moss]

That's no fun at all

[misty cliff]

pump action still rocks

double barrel is almost useless

[rustic karma]

Its single player, it doesn't matter in the slightest

I use a varmint rifle in story mode

[hidden moss]

servers are up

[crimson bronze]

Personally, no fun to me is chasing the meta of online in a mode where most weapons are on even grounding while also having NPCs that aren't as cheap as the revenue agents or other players you can face in online.

It's only a matter of opinion.

[glad brook]

Drive wagons just like you would with a horse.

Move the analog stick up while pressing x and stuff.

[glad brook]

Dang straight I prefer slower paced games.

[tacit plover]

Probably won’t get all the pelts for the satchels

Personally, I believe rather than being able to buy the satchels from the fence, Rockstar should’ve made it so you bought them from Pearson at the Rhodes General Store in the Epilogue

[smoky hornet]

hot take but I believe reverend swanson's goodbye is better than arthur's heart to heart with sister calderon

sister calderon's is more emotional in a direct sense but I feel swanson's is more impactful as he's actually seen all sides of arthur and lived through all of it, so his honesty hit hard to me

[worn hearth]

No shot he remembered half of it though

[dusky temple]

Can some access the store in RDO?

[last lily]

I just finished the campaign and omg

[silk hull]

Oh this stupid game just disconnected me from online in the middle of the tutorial thing and now I gotta do it all over again -_-

[slow bison]

achievement hunting in this game is tedious AF!

the game is super slow paced, then every challenge and achievements is so f'ing tedious!

the notion of 51 achievements in this game seem easy; but each achievements make you like grind AF worth like 10 achievements for each 1.

[placid inlet]

tbh i kinda like that

[silk hull]

I love how slow paced the game is

[placid inlet]

yeah : )

[hidden moss]

.

[jagged cave]

Is ardennes only courageous during intense gunfights ?

[hidden moss]

dunno.

[jagged cave]

Because even with lvl4 bound it's so skittish near predators

[lean sparrow]

Why does it say to pick one of each specie of herb but i already have every plant

And it says 38 out of 43

[frigid cloud]

Must be glitched.

[hidden moss]

def a glitch.

[lean sparrow]

Nvm i found out

[hidden moss]

(:

good for ya.

[chilly spruce]

Does it need to be a specific weather to fish at Elysian Pool?

[hidden moss]

never heard of that place tbh.

[tulip pebble]

Why would you fish at Elysian pool in story

It's poisoned

[arctic wren]

For the legendary fish

[tulip pebble]

Didn't realise there was one in Elysian pool

[tacit plover]

Poisoned fish

😋

[arctic wren]

Yeah I got it once I’m pretty sure

Arthur says he has no idea what it is, I think

I could be remembering something completely wrong tho

[chilly spruce]

Do i need some mission before trying to catch it?

[tulip pebble]

nO

You need a special lake lure though

[arctic wren]

Yeah legendary perch is in the Elysian pool

[chilly spruce]

I have it

[tulip pebble]

Oh have you started the side quest for the fish?

If not head up to flat iron lake and find a NPC there to talk to

[hidden moss]

either way, i d think weather rly affects fishing.

[chilly spruce]

I just asked if theres some mission for it u said no

[arctic wren]

You need all the special lures cause there’s different lures for different waters

[tulip pebble]

Yeah, i forgot my bad

I'm a mainly online player, which is why i questioned your fishing in the area in the first place

But google got me there

[hidden moss]

understandable.

(:

[raw quiver]

Hey what If you Mess up A stranger mission and it doesn't come up again? How do You fix That Or is there no way?

[hidden moss]

stranger missions will always show up even when ya mess it up.

i think u r referring to side missions.

if thats the case then u gotta reload the game.

thats y i keep the auto saves off ya know.

if i mess up i just turn off the power then reload the game and sort it out later.

[silk hull]

I really gotta get a controller. it's killing my shoulders to play on keyboard lol

[hidden moss]

then go get one.

[silk hull]

No, go get one for me 🤔

Don't really even know what to get lol. Last console I ever played was the PS2 lmao

I assume I need an xbox controller, since I have xbox live on my computer

[plush vessel]

How many times you finished the story-mode

[candid cliff]

Arthur just got diagnosed 😥

[plush vessel]

by who

[candid cliff]

Doctor

The disease

[plush vessel]

I remember this shit hurts me every time i remember it

[candid cliff]

I just saw some fox or some in the road

Isn't that an honour level thing

[plush vessel]

I don’t think so

[candid cliff]

I swear there is something about seeing a buck and a wolf

[plush vessel]

where do you see those wolf

[candid cliff]

Dreams and stuff

Arthur sleeps and sees a wolf sometimee

[languid mortar]

that's low honour

[chilly spruce]

It is

[candid cliff]

Dang

I've got to raise it then, I'm in n like slightly left grey honour

[chilly spruce]

Is it possible to catch legendary channel catfish?

[languid mortar]

I had a dream last night

[plush vessel]

arthur is dead

[languid mortar]

that I found a fucking pigeon

in rdr2

[plush vessel]

😂😂😂 where

[chilly spruce]

Wait u still didnt find it?

[languid mortar]

nope

ended up giving up for a while

[chilly spruce]

Thats sad

[languid mortar]

and messing around with the gang glitch

[chilly spruce]

Really really sad

[languid mortar]

and chearts

just cooling off

going back onto my main save

maybe now that it's been reloaded a pigeon will fucking spawn

[jagged cave]

Appearently low honor antagonise dialogues are way more savage

And funnier

[plush vessel]

what is the most thing that hurt you u rdr2

[languid mortar]

What?

[jagged cave]

can't wait to roast people now

[languid mortar]

ooh my god

i just saw

an unstudied bird iin annesburg

[chilly spruce]

Lets hope its a pigeon

[languid mortar]

i shot it dead

compendium updated

Band tailed pigeon

[chilly spruce]

Its the one u needed?

[languid mortar]

both pigeons give the same feather

but im amazed

i got it

I GOT IT

oh my god

[chilly spruce]

Congrats

[languid mortar]

I never thought the day would come

Now just to find one more.

[chilly spruce]

Is it possible to catch legendary channel catfish?

[languid mortar]

idk

i dont think so?

[tulip pebble]

Nope

PC players can spawn it in with a mod menu, but there's no way to get it naturally in the game

[chilly spruce]

Hmm ok

[languid mortar]

why does roanoke ridge is creepy?

[tulip pebble]

It's cursed 👍

[candid cliff]

How is it cursed? What's the lore?

[glad brook]

Arthur's ghost haunts it.

[candid cliff]

Cool

[glad brook]

Its actually just some hillbilly cannibalistic ritual crap.

[languid mortar]

Butcher Creek is kinda sad

with the story of Obediah

[candid cliff]

Oh😥

That would have been cool

[languid mortar]

i may have just

ran into another pigeon

and immediately lost it

NO

I lost another pigeon

shot two

both fell off the bridge and into the river

[silk hull]

😮 I got the fishing pole! time to stand on the riverbank for hours

[misty cliff]

kill thousands of people, go and throw some fish back into the water, greet people in saint denis, get high honor.

Easy

[hidden moss]

yea right.

[misty cliff]

arthur is a good man because he threw fish back.

[languid mortar]

Oh my god

oh my god

it's been

3,000 years

[misty cliff]

since what

[languid mortar]

since i started the pigeon hunt

[misty cliff]

good hunting

[languid mortar]

i honestly think

that the game

might've been glitched

I searched

for hours

from 2 pm to 1 am

and i ffound

NOTHING

i went back and forth everywheree

from bridge to annesburg to st denis to abandoned railway buildings just outside of st denis

but only

after i reload my save

do I come back to annesburg

find a pigeon

go to the railway bridge and hteres like

6 pigeons

can I just say photo taking kinda sucks

[hidden moss]

kinda.

I didn't even know there were pigeons in the game

[languid mortar]

lets say you have a lot of photos taken

[silk hull]

So

you can't skin horses

and I just shot a horse in the face for no reason

and now I feel bad

[languid mortar]

let's say it's 96 photos specifically

and you want to clear up photos

so you have to go into rockstar social club, have it load up

then go to a photo

go to options

delete it

then it deletes the photo

[silk hull]

Well, this is the wild west BOI and you know what we do in the wild west!?

[languid mortar]

goes into a loading scrreen for social club

[silk hull]

we eat those photos

for nourishment

[languid mortar]

then resets you back to the top

so it makes it imo really annoying

to clear out old photos

[silk hull]

You know

Rockstar is a multi-million dollar company

you would think they could have a network that doesn't force you out of the game every 10 minutes

[chilly spruce]

Where can i play blackjack?

[candid cliff]

I see the wolf again

[raw quiver]

Oh the Stranger mission I think Was a woman in a hut I did The bottle Shooting and and then I accidentally shot near her and it hasn't come up

I think That was The Only one

[languid mortar]

lmao i just came across an amazing encounter

[hidden moss]

Some tips for the dominos challenge?

Pls?

😭

[chilly spruce]

How the hell do i complete sharpshooter 8?

[steady vector]

Shoot ppl in the legs with poison arrows

[chilly spruce]

That will disharm them?

[raw quiver]

Which is?

[languid mortar]

Reginald

[hidden moss]

Sry blud I cannot recall this one.

[languid mortar]

in the valentine tavern

sometimes you can bump into someone

while entering