red-dead-singleplayer

[lament dock]

anyone know th elocation to the lady that got stuck by her horse

ugggghh

I had to the lenny mission again

[ornate cloud]

bro

wtf is wron with this game

my horse just disappeared now

and got replaced by some cheap one

wtf

[grizzled sapphire]

Micah shaves Arthur randomly in his sleep. That's why everyone hates him so much.

[ornate cloud]

aight reloaded a save and my turkoman was back

wtf is going on with this game and its random ass glitches

bruh

[lament dock]

wow ok. Thanks game. i got the option to skip getting the double barreled shotgun from the cabin becuase i was softblocked and now i cant save my game anymore

[hidden moss]

Your horse died

Wdym

[hidden moss]

Not much

[hidden moss]

Horse death is not a glitch

[lament dock]

Im so tired

[ornate cloud]

@hidden moss i fixed it any way

it was a glitch

my horse was relaced by a cheap one for some reason

[lament dock]

I got a question. What happens if you die frequently and got the option to skip checkpoint

[stiff coyote]

I have a small problem, when in free roam i decide to grab someone with a gun and then press f to hit him with the item, artuhr ends up shooting the npc instead of hitting anyone knows the reason why?

[rustic karma]

Get yourself a drink and look up a guide

Its tedious and boring as hell

[placid inlet]

that's good advice

i have like 2 challenges left. gonna do shots beforehand

[hidden moss]

good idea.

i played for 9 hours strait for that gun.

then deleted the game 1 week later.

it wasnt worth it.

those dinosaur bones challenges were fun tbh i enjoyed that.

[ornate cloud]

you load after the QTE

[hidden moss]

cuz the weapon ya get afterwards was pretty sick.

[glad brook]

That's what happens when your horse dies.

[ornate cloud]

i had to do it for the cart pumping mission

it was impossible somehow

[lament dock]

wymqte

[hidden moss]

quick time event ig.

[lament dock]

well its during a missio

its when you killed the O driscols in the cabin and get the shotgun

[hidden moss]

I just got so lucky 💀

[hidden moss]

What is F used for in other contexts?

Played my first game of blackjack, doubled down and won

It happened AGAIN 💀💀💀

Lucky

My luck ran out

:(

NEVERMIND!

I doubled down at 18 and got 2!

[stiff coyote]

to attack, in mele fights you can use lmb or f to punch

[hidden moss]

Lets go!!

I did gambler 2 FINALLY

Ha gambler 3 is easy

[worthy fjord]

It’s just a warmup for gambler 8

[hidden moss]

I spent 3 hours straight destroying micah at it, think I'll be fine

[worthy fjord]

You won’t

It’s worse

I spent 5 hours trying to beat it

[hidden moss]

Ok

What have you gotta do

[worthy fjord]

You basically have to hit 3 times or more in blackjack

And win against the dealer

[civic nest]

Yeah that one's the worst, it's just pure luck

[worthy fjord]

Yes

[civic nest]

Even if you manage to hit 3 times, sometimes the dealer still wins

[hidden moss]

true its just pure fkn luck.

[rustic karma]

Doing gambler 4 rn and just bust out 2 guys with one hand

[worthy fjord]

I’m doing herbalist 9 and I only need 12 herbs

[hidden moss]

[hidden moss]

Herbalist suck

So does sharpshooter

The hat one is so STUPID

I dunno how to do it

[civic nest]

It's fun tho

[hidden moss]

Thats just you

[stiff coyote]

so anyone know what the issue may be?

[civic nest]

Go to Saint Denis to that place behind the tailor

Plenty of people with hats

[ornate cloud]

what is the best sadle + stirups for the Turkoman horse? or is the Panther sadle the best sadle in SP?

[hidden moss]

I always kill them, its not a people issue its a weapon issue

[civic nest]

Do you have the level of dead eye in which you can shoot without marking?

[hidden moss]

Yeah

Y

[civic nest]

Just making sure

[stiff coyote]

anyone? Has the same problem as me on PC?

[civic nest]

Try to aim to the wings of the hats (is that how they're called?)

[hidden moss]

I get what you mean but thats still hard to do

Bc of how thin they usually are its hard to hit them unless ur below or above them

[dusk wyvern]

Writers for Dutch: WE WILL SURVIVE!!! All we need is one more score. We will be free. We are close. WE JUST NEED MUN-EH!!! Repeat aproxamitly 7,384 times througout story mode

Oh woops I fogot

LETS RIDE!

[ornate cloud]

to tahiti and beyound

[hidden moss]

[hidden moss]

Idk then

Maybe your bindings are messed up

[ornate cloud]

tahiti calls us boys

[worthy fjord]

We need munneyh!

One last score

And we’ll become mango farmers in Tahiti

[little remnant]

RDR2 fans preparing to use the same unfunny jokes for the 7842nd time

[worthy fjord]

Yes

[ornate cloud]

harvessting mangoes

but we need money

lots of money

[little remnant]

mfw boah plan mangos faith lumbago

[worthy fjord]

Yes rdr2 humor

[native kiln]

Arthur standing back looking at a lot of cash he just put in the camp funds:👁👄👁 this isn’t enough Dutch?..

[little remnant]

humor is supposed to be funny

[jagged cave]

Why did you kill the bison ?!

[little remnant]

this one is underused I want to see more Charles bison posting

[worthy fjord]

Is that the hunting mission with charles quote?

[jagged cave]

Yeah think it has meme potential to it

[ornate cloud]

how is uncle supposed to harvest mangoes with his lumbago

interestingly he never objected that

[worthy fjord]

He’ll be left behind

[ornate cloud]

well no

[worthy fjord]

The gang has had it with the old man

[stiff coyote]

could be, ill check that

[jagged cave]

The most useless gang member?

[leaden tree]

Ehh fucking Uncle

[placid inlet]

yes but we love him

[eternal bear]

Uncle's a laugh, hell ill keep him even if he's useless

[placid inlet]

plus he sees through micah and dutch's bullshit<3

[leaden tree]

Ye

[placid inlet]

other than that swanson is pretty bad in the first few chapters lmao

does nada but heroin

[leaden tree]

He's just an old crackhead

look into his bible to find out why

[placid inlet]

yeeep

im glad he gets better tho lol

[ebon tulip]

In terms of doing the least for the gang? I’d say Reverend

[lament dock]

Anyone got the shotgun from the cabin and it is already cleaned?

[oblique rose]

bro my Arthur ragdolled and hes stuck on the ground he wont Get up

[rustic karma]

Arthur needs life alert

[chilly spruce]

Is there any reason why the horse wont come to you or follow you when u whistle?

[rustic karma]

Is it too far away?

[chilly spruce]

No

It was in range

[rustic karma]

Well seems you just have a stupid horse, friend

[chilly spruce]

Ah, ill throw her in water and get a new one then

[rustic karma]

Seems the best course of action to me

[chilly spruce]

What horse should i get?

[rustic karma]

Hmm

Depends

What chapter are you in

[chilly spruce]

4

Got here not long ago

[heavy barn]

Wrangle the white arabian😪

[chilly spruce]

Will it come to me when i whistle?

[rustic karma]

Not me killing mine an hour ago

[chilly spruce]

And what is its location?

[heavy barn]

Ahh sboot🤣

[placid inlet]

[leaden tree]

On my 3rd save I have beautiful black Arabian Horse with white long tail and (this hair on neck i forgor how its named)

[placid inlet]

mane?

[rustic karma]

Around lake Isabella

[chilly spruce]

Ty

[leaden tree]

Yes! Mane!

[heavy barn]

Its pretty popular you can find thd locations on youtube but its up in the mountains

[placid inlet]

[leaden tree]

not for everyone, I fucking reloaded my game 3 times, did 7 circles around the fucking lake, did 2 missions, came back and what? NO HORSES

[rustic karma]

Every time I go up there to get the bison its there

[leaden tree]

I fucking did everything and what? NO HORSES

[chilly spruce]

Does it spawn only once?

[rustic karma]

Yep once

[leaden tree]

Dont troll him

[chilly spruce]

Ah, then i might have missed mine when i went to kill bison

[leaden tree]

It spawns a lot

[rustic karma]

Oh I thought you could only get once per playthrough

[leaden tree]

On my 4 other saves everytime I go there even if I tamed 3 already there always is one

[placid inlet]

well yes but i assume if u miss it u can go back and try again

like its not gone for good

[leaden tree]

Man

Grizzlies works for me like anti-brainer

Like if im in Grizzlies my brain just poof and I fucking jump with my horse around mountains and fight wolfs with knife

[hidden moss]

You need to long whistle for a follow. If they're not coming when you whistle then there may be an obstacle

[rustic karma]

I must have misunderstood, you should be able to go back and get it even if you have been up there already

[chilly spruce]

Did it multiple times

It didnt even move from its place

[hidden moss]

Bug

[chilly spruce]

Prob

[chilly spruce]

Ty

[leaden tree]

Even at the border of the wistle range when I do one quick whistle she comes

Guys, favourite/best easter egg?

[hidden moss]

I don't know too many

But off the top of my head I really like the Michael one

[leaden tree]

May You remember me which one is that?

[hidden moss]

Have you tried Eagle eye

[misty cliff]

Not an easter egg but i love pagan ritual site as well as native burial grounds. I love the butcher's creek stranger missions too.

[leaden tree]

Yes

[leaden tree]

Ahh this, oke

[hidden moss]

Buell or white arabian

[red helm]

Buell, he is a tad less of a scaredy cat.

[hidden moss]

Alr

Thanks

Also any idea where to find that weirdo vampire?

[red helm]

Look for the clues around the marketplace in Saint Denis.

[hidden moss]

Thanks

[red helm]

I think... I never actually got around to looking for that.

[autumn verge]

There is nothing I can do other doing gold rush

[hidden moss]

Im aiming high

Going for 100%

[red helm]

Gold Rush is rather ugh

100% is fun, Other than Exotics, Hunting Requests and Gambler 8.

[hidden moss]

Ahem sharpshooter challenges ahem

Wait how many exotics are there

[red helm]

Too many.

Exotics wouldn't have been to bad if he didn't ask for so many items per mission.

[hidden moss]

That sounds awful

No thanks i will save that for last (a few years from now)

[red helm]

There is like 6-7 total.

[hidden moss]

Missions?

[red helm]

Yeap.

[hidden moss]

Whats gambler 8 again?

[red helm]

Win 3 times with at least 3 hits.

at Blackjack.

[hidden moss]

Blackjack? Ohhh yeahhhh booooaaahh

[placid inlet]

hmmmm i finished all the gambler challenges but i remember like none of them so at this point im thinking maybe it was a fever dream

[red helm]

Yeah, that sound about right, you basically just sit there and hit as many times as you can without busting, and then pray you actually win with 3 hits, if you get that many.

[hidden moss]

I did that once but didnt have the challenge

Pretty sure it was 4+3 at the start, hit once and got 2, hit again got 6, hit again got 3 and again got 1

Somehow won

[vivid relic]

Then go to the church in saint denis at 12 am

[autumn verge]

Why the fuck does this happen to me

Having a black tattoo lines all over Arthur

[red helm]

Nice. I know I've seen the darn Dealer win with 6 cards before.

[autumn verge]

I put extra clean shave on Arthur

and lord and behold the black lines are gone

[ember wind]

Perlino Andalusian or Dark Bay Turkoman

[red helm]

Yes....

Turko's have a bit better stats. But, really, up to you, 80% of horse choice is your preference.

[ornate cloud]

is there any way of turning off tap button twice to swith the weapon to another

thats so annoying

[red helm]

Hrm, don't think I have had a problem with that. Are you on PC?

[ornate cloud]

yeah

[red helm]

Okay, yeah, I play on the PS and don't have a problem with it....

[autumn verge]

Colm dies

rip

What a hard music that goes

[hidden moss]

Its literally impossible to get to Saint Denis now 💀💀💀

Theres always like 11-14 bounty hunters

[autumn verge]

Just spam deadeye if you can't beat em all

with normal speed

[knotty marten]

Popular opinion:

[ember wind]

Buell or Perlino Andalusian

[rustic karma]

Buell

Buell is best horse without a doubt

[ember wind]

Also why do the Murfree Broods look like Neanderthals

[hidden moss]

is there a easy place to get gambler 7?

[placid inlet]

isnt it just beating ppl in each location?

[hidden moss]

oh no gambler 8 win 3 hands of blackjack with 3 hits or more

gambler 6 is winning in each location

[autumn verge]

datfaq is that

[ember wind]

Neanderthals, ya know our predecessors

[placid inlet]

ah i think i did gambler 8 in van horn

but it's not easy to get it anywhere, it's literally just dependent on luck

[ember wind]

Why isnt the perlino andalisian respawning

Nvm

[rustic karma]

Just spent 3 hours on it and made 0 progress

[hidden moss]

yeah I'm in van horn the town is so hostile no idea why already lost $300 for getting beat up and shot

almost won one hand but i got a push

[rustic karma]

Same

[placid inlet]

oh no

[rustic karma]

My first hand was a 3 hit push

[hidden moss]

so why is van horn so hostile?

[rustic karma]

No idea, I go to rhodes

Every trip I've taken to van horn ends in a bloodbath

[placid inlet]

rhodes is probably a better place to go for blackjack lol

van horn is just angry all the time

[hidden moss]

yeah i just walked into the bar greeted someone and got punched in the back of the head then the whole bar decided to join in

maybe it's the honor level system

[autumn verge]

For the pussies who cannot fight, Just fucking shoot them all

Sick of tired of hearing the story of how I went and greet on van whore people

[rustic karma]

Some people care about honor and shooting up an entire down does some damage to that

[autumn verge]

You can get your honor up by just greeting people in saint denis or valentine

[hidden moss]

how can i pull a gun out when i'm on the floor getting kicked a bunch of times and dying without being able to get up

[autumn verge]

Welp redo it again

[hidden moss]

well if it happens again i'll try that

[placid inlet]

damn ur real tough

[autumn verge]

Remember to use uhhh mint game

[rustic karma]

Orrrr just go to rhodes and avoid having to fight or pick mint or greet people

[placid inlet]

[autumn verge]

I can lose honor by throwing explosives and killing fishes

just wonderful

[opal flint]

Does anyone know how to fix brightness/contrast or whatever? Like the game looks amazing when not in full screen, but as soon as I full screen it, it looks pretty bad

Is it the game or my bad monitor

[hidden moss]

Yes, why wouldn't you?

[autumn verge]

Cunt game

[placid inlet]

[rustic karma]

Your logic and morals are a tad off...

[ember wind]

Can I call buell the Epona of rdr2

[placid inlet]

omg<3

cute

[rustic karma]

Theoretically, I suppose you could

[placid inlet]

this gonna make me call my next horse in online epona

[clear pier]

is a black arabian or white arabian horse better

[civic nest]

Black

But white is free

[clear pier]

ehh money is irrelevant in singleplayer

[civic nest]

Then get the black one, or the rose grey bay

[rustic karma]

Thats not what I'm hearing from Dutch

[clear pier]

LMAo

[rustic karma]

Money=Tahiti

[clear pier]

fr

"we just need some money, and we can make a new life"

me sitting on a billion dollars

[placid inlet]

[hidden moss]

I kind of wish there was a chapter where the gang got enough money to leave and then at the end of that chapter they lost all their money so they had to go back to Saint Denis Valentine wherever

[rustic karma]

Dutch, we could have gone to Tahiti with $15.25

If only you did your research

[placid inlet]

dutch is kinda an idiot

no offense to my daddy

i mean what

[hidden moss]

He is very much so in idiot well okay

[rustic karma]

He is so stupid

Ligit based his ideologies on a rich man that tries to act poor

[hidden moss]

Well actually the only thing he did wrong was listening to Micah the countless acts of murder and robbery are minor crimes

[placid inlet]

the problem is that he thinks hes smart tho with his books nd shit 😫

[mental drift]

im trying to stream red dead 2 over a discord call, the audio goes through but the stream is black, anyone know of a fix?

[rustic karma]

Lenny calls him out on it too and he turns into a pissbaby

[placid inlet]

yeah i mean as soon as anyone criticizes him he becomes a dickhead

man is not even smart enough to realize micah is just telling him what he wants to hear

[hidden moss]

For anyone who has completed the entire game what is your favorite mission

Also what is the saddest death that and what is the best death

[placid inlet]

fav mission gotta be a quiet time

[rustic karma]

Its between the oil field one, the tobacco one, and the Braithwaite manner burning

[placid inlet]

best death was micah<3 saddest obvi arthur, and hosea imo

[rustic karma]

Saddest death was probably big L

It was such a shock

[placid inlet]

[candid pasture]

[hidden moss]

Best death is 100% Micah saddest death is a three-way tie between Hosea Arthur and Lenny for me

My favorite Mission has to be American Venom for obvious reasons

[rustic karma]

I must make a confession: I didn't find arthurs dead that sad

I love him to death tho

[placid inlet]

american venom is goooood

[hidden moss]

😱

[placid inlet]

its so satisfying finally seeing that asshole die

and LOL i always think im over it but then i replay the last arthur mission and im just like

[hidden moss]

Micah is a bitch and racist

[placid inlet]

hes one of the few villains that you can just completely hate lol

no redeeming qualities at all

[hidden moss]

I wanted to kill him more then I wanted to kill Agent Ross

Hosea Lenny and Arthur should have survived and Micah should have died before the end of Arthur's story

[ember wind]

Wait does Micah hate Lenny

And Charles

And Javier

[rustic karma]

Yeah, most villans I can relate to, not micha

[hidden moss]

Yes it's been clear multiple times he's a racist to every single one of them@ember wind

[ember wind]

Oh

[placid inlet]

yeah he literally told charles to go fetch him food... lmfao

charles my king threw him on the floor tho like the legend he is

[hidden moss]

I wish we would have been able to keep the little bastard in jail

[ember wind]

Charles and Hosea are the most humble and laid back members of the gang

And Uncle I think

[placid inlet]

theres also an interaction where micah tells javier to fuck off back to mexico and javier just says "why dont you fuck off back to hell" LMFAO

gottemmmm

[candid pasture]

rekt

[ember wind]

Micah is an awesome villian, Peter Blomquist's acting and Rockstar's writing makes him so hateable and it's amazing

[placid inlet]

oh yeah peter blomquist is crazy talented

[ember wind]

It's sad he got sent threats for portraying Micah

[hidden moss]

I'm on my about 10th playthrough of the story and I'm at the blessed are the Meek and not going to do it yet the little bastard can rot in jail

[placid inlet]

hahaha relatable

and wait did he really get threats

its bullshit when ppl cant separate an actor from a character

[ember wind]

Well Blomquist looks like Micah

But ye I agree

[candid pasture]

he definitely does oh my god

[hidden moss]

Yeah he got threats and I remember someone not the actual actor who played Colm O'driscoll who is named Colm o'driscoll also got threats

[placid inlet]

oh yeah, they used his likeness afaik, no?

for the performance capture

[ember wind]

Yep

[hidden moss]

lumbago

👀

I feel like in single player I'm a God at Poker

[rustic karma]

I hate that people do that

[placid inlet]

reminds me of when ppl sent threats to the actor who played joffrey in game of thrones and he quit acting lmao

not cool

[candid pasture]

did sg message anyone else or was it just me lmao

[placid inlet]

[hidden moss]

He's a good soldier

[hidden moss]

Micah is a shallow villain with no motives. He's a cartoon antagonist who is evil in every way.

[placid inlet]

welp

his motive is staying alive ig

[hidden moss]

He disrespects every gang member except Dutch which is entirely unnecessary

He's also too homicidal

[sinful knot]

you can also say one dimensional man

was just there to make the gang fall apart

[hidden moss]

Yeah

I feel like Rockstar went all out with Red Dead Redemption 2 story because Dan Houser was leaving Rockstar at the time

And they wanted to have a good story

After he left so it would stick

[sinful knot]

and it flopped on it's ass

What were they thinking, seriously

After playing the first game for a while, it just takes those 2010 memories out

But here's my take

It should've been more focused on a few gang members including John, Arthur, Dutch, Bill etc

just leave Micah out

[hidden moss]

First of all you're wrong it didn't flop it's actually better than most of their stories

Second of all it was necessary

[sinful knot]

and it didnt even win goty bruh

If they wanted to make a story more centered on the gang's fall and why John is fighting Dutch, Bill and Javier in 1911

You should very well focus on fewer characters instead of 3 women doing laundry work

infact the main ones

[hidden moss]

What main women from what I remember Karen and Tillie aren't main members of the gang

[sinful knot]

I mean main characters

[hidden moss]

And while it didn't win game of the year it's still possibly their best story

[sinful knot]

John, Arthur, Bill Dutch etc

[hidden moss]

It wins game of the decade

[sinful knot]

They should've focused on them and a few others more

instead they make them the useless fucking clowns

[hidden moss]

So the game of the decade has a worst story then any other Rockstar game Red Dead Redemption 2 won game of the decade what other Rockstar game has won that

[rustic karma]

And Laura Bailey for playing Abby

[sinful knot]

And you really think it won "game of the decade" fr?

should stop taking fans words so seriously

[hidden moss]

Rdr2 has the best story of any game let alone any rockstar game

[sinful knot]

I agree

Arthurs blue shirt holds a wonderful greek meaning that is it's a color

blue is a color

[ember wind]

I got Buell! I wish you could keep Hamish's hat tho

[glad brook]

Saying it has the best story of any game is saying too much but I agree its Rockstars best story.

[hidden moss]

Name a better game story

[placid inlet]

i mean it's subjective really

[hidden moss]

Nope

[glad brook]

Every gang member actually feels like a living breathing person they're so well written. Except maybe Micah but the whole point is to hate on him I guess.

[glad brook]

What do you think you'll get out of hating on rdr2 every chance you get?

You got nothing better to do?

[sinful knot]

You are correct on that one

But i'm pointing out it's flaws

[glad brook]

Most of what you point out are nitpicks.

[hidden moss]

Such as?

[sinful knot]

You see my current messages clear as day but you have trouble reading my past messages

[glad brook]

Like Arthur grunting before he dies being annoying or some dumb f*.

[sinful knot]

Why are you making up shit i didnt even say

wasnt even here until now

[glad brook]

.

[sinful knot]

My man

That was almost a MONTH ago

you're going back to the past

also it wasnt related to story flaws

[hidden moss]

Well I wasn't necessarily taking his words into account I was more or less taking the news in to account then again the news can be wrong I found something that said it was Game of the decade so that's why I said that

For her words I don't really give a s***

Or*

[ornate cloud]

in batman arkham games you can see parts of the map of the next game, so can you see parts of rdr2 map in rdr1?
excluding the rdr1 original map that was recreated in rdr2
?

[candid pasture]

there was hints of rdr2 in gta

[sinful knot]

well in RDR it's just empty landscape which I doubt is part of RDR2's map

prob cause 2 wasnt thought of yet

or it's locations

[hidden moss]

What hints?

[candid pasture]

one of the missions called “ daddies little girl “ there’s a bike rental guy with a red dead shirt on

[hidden moss]

I live in the present

[ornate cloud]

is there screenshots? i mean when you turn from black watter to the rdr2 part its just desert?

[sinful knot]

there was a vid about it

[candid pasture]

rockstar is very creative when it comes to easter eggs to their next games

[sinful knot]

but yeah it is just empty terrain in rdr

[ornate cloud]

yeah i wana see it lol

im interested in these type of things i dunno

welp i found a vid but cant post links

[hidden moss]

Name a better game story than rdr2

[candid pasture]

last of us part 2 and god of war

[hidden moss]

Both very shallow

[ornate cloud]

witcher franchise, cyberpunk
they are neck to neck in story telling and characters

[rustic karma]

Thank you

[candid pasture]

[hidden moss]

not wrong

[rustic karma]

How?

[candid pasture]

if you’ve actually read everything in god of war and got into like every detail of it god of war has an amazing story with great characters one of my favorites

[hidden moss]

take ashes to mountain
Encounter hurdles
Jump over them

Get attacked
Hunt down attacker to exact revenge

[rustic karma]

If I follow that horrible logic then rdr2 is:

gang get in trouble
gang run
gang fight each other
micha die

Summarizing the game by a couple main plot points is idiotic

[normal elk]

LOL

[hidden moss]

God of war has a boring story and the only great thing about it is gameplay

[normal elk]

just steal Micah's revolver as Arthur and kill him with it

[rustic karma]

Red dead was great, tlou 2 was great, GoW 2018, the witcher was great, and cyberpunk was great, all for different reasons. Each had their own flaws, too

But none of them were shallow in the slightest

[sinful knot]

bro summarized the whole game in one message

[rustic karma]

Sure on the very surface level but it was so much more then that

[sinful knot]

Gang gets out of snow
Gang moves to new place cause pinkertons give them a warning
Gang gets involved in a feud, Jack taken, has to move again to find him
Gang gets him back and plans saint denis bank robbery
Goes wrong and ends up killing 2 of the gang members

I can summarize these chapters easily

its just not good storytelling

[rustic karma]

I wouldn't say that

[sinful knot]

Well tbh i'll put it a different way

From chapter 2 onward it's pretty much all their fault

Getting involved in the family business and ending up losing one of their own

[rustic karma]

The plot that you summarized is the base plot but imo the side plots really made this game shine

And I love the physiological side of the characters

[sinful knot]

The base and side plots just don't sit well with me

Why get yourself deeper into shit?

all could've been prevented

[rustic karma]

Because Dutch

[sinful knot]

especially chp3

[rustic karma]

Understanding dutch's character really makes you understand why he did what he did

[sinful knot]

When his whole philosophy fell apart, he began to spiral into doing horrible things believing he was going into the right direction with what he was doing

And in the end Arthur eventually paid for this

Sure he doubted Dutch a couple of times here and there but followed through with it

[hidden moss]

He only followed through with it because he needed to stay loyal to make sure John and his family got out

[rustic karma]

He is a narcissist obsessed with evylen millers work, which, in theory might be good and all but we see firsthand that it just doesn't work. And evylen is a fraud and knows it. So a flawed man following a flawed man. Then the loss of hosea caused him to fall deeper into his unaddressed mental health issues. And it doesn't help if on top off all that, you have a group if people that feed into your ego constantly, giving him a sense of never being able to be wrong. That's why I think he continued to make the same mistakes over and over. Whenever he fucked up, everyone was just like "its ok, you'll come up with another plan"

So thats how I explain the repeated actions of the gang

Not bad storytelling but great characters

[sinful knot]

Exactly

He heavily relies on Hosea

[hidden moss]

Once Hosea died everything went downhill from there

Micah was able to get into his ear more than he was before Hosea died

[sinful knot]

They made it like that, he relied on someone only in the second for Dutch's collapse also

Then from there he started going into the wrong path thinking he was right

[sinful knot]

John could've left before it all went downhill

[rustic karma]

He didn't have anyone he trusted to tell him otherwise

[sinful knot]

now that i think about it

[sinful knot]

yeah another hole

This game just has so many plot holes is all

[rustic karma]

Such a long story is bound too

[sinful knot]

They never show how, they only talk

[rustic karma]

Care to explain, I don't see how

[sinful knot]

Okay so

[hidden moss]

I mean Arthur tried Dutch just didn't listen

[sinful knot]

He relies heavily on Hosea (someone who didn’t even exist in RDR1) and retcons Dutch’s downfall being around Hosea dying.

It's more of a retcon than a hole

[rustic karma]

I don't think introducing a character is necessary a retcon but I see where you are coming from

His sole purpose was to break Dutch when he died

[sinful knot]

A lot of these characters have only purposes and no real reason to be there

for example Micah

[rustic karma]

Oh

I thought you mean Mary Beth or something

Micha is an interesting take

Do tell

[sinful knot]

As before he was only there to help the gang's downfall, or be it

[hidden moss]

Micah is a rat and that's the only reason to help the games downfall

Gang

[rustic karma]

I know I won't be able to convince you otherwise but just because a character isn't in the sequel, they aren't invalidated as a character

If they were ignored and only came up when they were relevant to the plot, then yes

But they were built up

Some weren't, but most were

Like keiran, love him, but he wasn't needed

[vivid relic]

Anyone wanna voice chat while playing games ?

[sinful knot]

Kieran was ignored mostly

wasn't used for much and they killed him off

This is also where the companion system couldve came into play

hanging out with them could've built their relationship

[rustic karma]

But on the other hand, hosea was build up, we understand the relationship that Dutch has with him, we get backstory, and form a bond with him. When he died, Dutch and hosea were growing apart a bit, you could see it in the way they interacted. I think that broke Dutch more, kinda like how ellie's separation with joel when he died caused her so much grief. Both characters never got the conclusion they needed to have a healthy grieving process

Hence causing both of their insanity

[vivid relic]

No one then lol

[dusk wyvern]

Any cart or anything where you can put people?

[vivid relic]

Huh

[dusk wyvern]

Like is there a wagon or cart in singleplayer where you can stow people

Instead of just on your horse

[vivid relic]

Ohhhhhhhh

No

I mean

Just find a cart

With a. Horse

With open space

And put people in ig

[hidden moss]

Nope. Dutch's downfall began when Heidi McCourt got shot.

[rustic karma]

Dutch was doomed from the start

[fathom ice]

dem

[rustic karma]

He hid behind a facade, when he killed Heidi, his illusion faltered, when hosea died he gave it up

[sinful knot]

Charisma

Making dumb people see the good in the world

[languid perch]

whose heidi

[rustic karma]

The girl that Dutch killed on the boat in blackwater

[hidden moss]

yeah right.

[hidden moss]

i can't believe gambler 8 is taking this damn long

[rustic karma]

I just gave up for the day

[hidden moss]

5 have been a push and won 2 the pain when a push happens that much

[hidden moss]

I don't think he died

[lament dock]

after finishing the gunslinger quest, what should i do next?

[hidden moss]

Play the game

Free roam lol

[languid perch]

burn down armadillo

[summer garnet]

Welcome to RNG

[worthy fjord]

I just encountered the feral naked man in the forest of Roanoke Ridge and I can see his penis

[hidden moss]

[rocky nest]

Amazing enjoy

[hidden moss]

The what?

😆😆😆😆

[shy plume]

food

[summer garnet]

🗿

[amber halo]

So, 4 people, undetected in Blackwater, tracking bounty hunters, can't get the "Blackwater Money". Heh.

[foggy grove]

its in a bank

[rocky nest]

do you ever get the ability to summon backup or something like that?

[dense lodge]

God Micha is a dick

[chilly spruce]

The law in saint denis is so dumb, i hit a cop with a door while leaving the saloon and they give me a bounty

[misty cliff]

Micah is cool

[stiff coyote]

hello, i know i asked someone yesterday about this but i still had not fixed this issue - the issue in which when arthur holds an npc while holding an firearm and i want to hit the npc by presisng f, but instead of the animation of hitting the npc happening, arthur kills the npc. I am playing on PC and when i played on PS4 i did not have such problem, if there is anyone who knows how to fix this i would be greatfull cause i cant find anything about that on the internet

[hidden moss]

At the end of chapter 6 who would Hosea Lenny Sean and Molly O'Shea side with Dutch and Micah or John and Arthur

If they were still alive obviously

If the gang had still gone downhill even though Hosea was still alive the gang probably wouldn't go downhill if Hosea was still alive but what would happen if it had who would Hosea side with along with Lenny Molly O'Shea and Sean

[ornate cloud]

i just remembered the complaints back in 2017

that rdr2 was too survival focused and that aspect was supposedly annoying to many

"i have to feed mycharacter all the time" and whats not

lol

😄

[chilly spruce]

How do i make my satchel carry 99 items of the same thing?

[chilly spruce]

They wouldve joined john and arthur

[hidden moss]

This is good

[hidden moss]

That's not dumb. It's assault.

[chilly spruce]

How

[hidden moss]

Because you hit someone with a door

[chilly spruce]

Thats stupid

[ornate cloud]

you cant

theres legend of the east satchel

but you cant really sore 99 of every item

[hidden moss]

I forgot to mention Kieran

[chilly spruce]

Well it wasnt every but some was

[ornate cloud]

valuables and things like throwable weapons are limited

[chilly spruce]

How do i get it?

[ornate cloud]

you craft it with Pierson

you have to craft all satchels first

by hunting and skinning various animals

than you craft the legend of the east one

[chilly spruce]

Reinforced satchels or like all all

In my first playthrough i bought a satchel like that from fence and i didnt need to craft anything

[ornate cloud]

what

?

you can buy satchels from the fence?

[chilly spruce]

I got it at that time

[ornate cloud]

i never heard of satchels being sold at any fence

[hidden moss]

Play the game. Everything is said to you through the help tips in the top left, and from character dialogue, and there's a help section that you can read from the pause menu.

[chilly spruce]

Mk

[hidden moss]

None of the fences sell satchels

[patent cobalt]

They do during the epilogue

[hidden moss]

Oh that's right my mistake

[ornate cloud]

what kind of satchels they even sell

ive never seen it

bruh its true...

the fences to sell satchels

yeah but at that point its not really doing anything other than compendum completition

its important to have the legend satchel as Arthur

[hidden moss]

Yeah

You spend the vast majority of the time in which you play rdr2 with arthur

[rocky nest]

Love the rhodes mail guy

[hidden moss]

Why

[worthy fjord]

He’s a discouraged man

[worthy fjord]

Yeah before the epilogue, the only way to get satchels is to get some material for Pearson and he’ll make the satchel for you

[hidden moss]

Yes

[tacit plover]

I’d say do it during the main story since you essentially get the satchels for free, but considering how much money you get at the end of the epilogue, you might as well just complete the epilogue and buy the satchels

[night tide]

So I was talking with the vampire in Saint denis, and I antagonized him right? Thinking it would be an easy kill with my double barrel. It wasn’t, dude tried to punch, I dodged and was about to bring his head down and shoot him but he punched me again and I died. Is there any way I can use an auto save to go back before this? I slept twice before and google says rd2 auto saves when you sleep

[civic nest]

It autosaves when you die too

So unless you manually saved beforehand, you can't find him again

[worldly spade]

How many chapters are there total?

[worldly spade]

I heard this but what does this mean? Is this a euphemism?

[candid cliff]

Yo a vampire

How do I find it

[civic nest]

8

[candid cliff]

I'm in chapter 4. Sadly I'd seen spoiler sbefore I started

[civic nest]

You have to find 5 hidden messages written in walls, that will form a pentagram. Then you go to the middle of the pentagram at midnight and you'll see an X in the minimap indicating a body, and there you have it

[candid cliff]

Do I get anything from killing them?

[civic nest]

An unique knife

[candid cliff]

Ooo

Only unique knife I have is a civil war knife

I got it in a bounty hunter mission

[civic nest]

First time I was in that fort where the knife is I didn't know how to go to the basement lol

Spent like half an hour exploring and couldn't find the entrance

[candid cliff]

Same. I ran around for five mins before noticing the ladder

F

[pastel owl]

I finished the game 4 times, the last was 100% and i just started a new story, anyone got any tips of things to do once you finish that?

[candid cliff]

Bruh

Trying to hide spoilers and message deleted

[night tide]

Can you find the vampire as John?

[pastel owl]

Oh Damn sorry i wont mentiob anything

[pastel owl]

I think so

[night tide]

Even if you found it as Arthur?

[candid cliff]

You've finished 4 times

[night tide]

Because I really want that knife lol

[candid cliff]

I've been playing for like a month and havent finished

[night tide]

How can you endure such pain

[pastel owl]

Idk i jjust do it in the weekends

I try finish with good honor so that it wont be as bad

[night tide]

Like finish it in a day?

[pastel owl]

2 days

[frigid cloud]

No

[night tide]

Damn

Oh you just do mission straight

[pastel owl]

Yeah

I just got ps+ so i started playing rdr online

But its kinda wierd

[candid cliff]

RDO is so hard to start out in

I've got most of my money cos I helped a dude do Moonshine stuff

[pastel owl]

Idk so far ive just been hunting

[candid cliff]

Quick advice: get the enable 2fa bonus

[pastel owl]

You wanna play together some time?

[night tide]

Once I finish with John I’ll start doing online

[pastel owl]

What part are you on

[candid cliff]

#rdo-chat

[pastel owl]

Eplilogue 1 or 2

[candid cliff]

Maybe

Can you not use Arthur at all after finishing

[night tide]

Just finished the dynamite stage coach with Micah and bill

[pastel owl]

Oh your still playing as arthur?

[night tide]

And finished all of the things with rains fall already, atleast I think the fort is the last one, I didn’t focus on them when I last played

[night tide]

Yah I’m taking it super slow, trying to postpone his death lol

[candid cliff]

I'm in Chapter 4. Early Chapter 4 tho

[pastel owl]

Lol

[candid cliff]

I heard I get to kick out Strauss so I'm excited

Hate that b*tch

[night tide]

It’s nice

Very nice

But make sure you do all his missions

[hidden moss]

Just reload

[night tide]

Wow super helpful👍👍

[hidden moss]

It would be spoiler if I told you

[candid cliff]

I'm also trying to raise my honour, some woman lowered my honour cos I said I can't take her to Saint Annesburg

[night tide]

Yah make sure you always take people when they need help

Also make sure you greet everyone you see

Every 3 greets increases honor

[candid cliff]

I greet people a lot

[fathom ice]

yeah greeting is good for honor

[hidden moss]

No problem.

[night tide]

So is saving people from getting robbed in Saint denis

[candid cliff]

I was on the hunt for a legendary bear and I accidentally accepted then said I couldn't help

So she got angry at me

[night tide]

Tough

Also never help people that are being taken to jail in the jail wagon

Decreases honor by a good bit

[candid cliff]

Oh ok

[hidden moss]

Happened to me. I offered to help but she said she lives in annesburg. I don't know where that is so I decline and I get honor loss

Ridiculous

[candid cliff]

I shoot escaped prisoners

[night tide]

Don’t do that

[candid cliff]

I've never even been there aswell

[night tide]

Take them to the sheriff

You get money

[candid cliff]

Ok

[hidden moss]

I got reported for kidnapping

You only get 5-10 dollars anyway

[night tide]

Still worth it

I’ve never been reported for kidnapping

[candid cliff]

My main way of making money is just story missions

[night tide]

Start hunting and get perfect pelts

[candid cliff]

I do hunting

Mainly donate to trapper and stuff

Gotta get that White Bison hat

But I'm so far from its location

[night tide]

I have the fit and wear it when I’m hunting actually lol

It’s nice

But the outfit is kinda overrated

[candid cliff]

I want it to go with a sheep poncho thing

I'm making a black and white outfit

With my black and white guns, like Yin and Yang

[night tide]

I have black and white volcano pistols

But good and white schoffields. They’re so nice you should try gold and white with weapons

[misty cliff]

I remember when i made all my weapons all black with silver barrels and engravings. Looked amazing but now i just make them like RDR1 guns.

[candid cliff]

Volcano pistols 😳

[night tide]

They’re my favorite pistols

Second to schoffields

Idk how to spell it

[candid cliff]

My black Schofield is full black and my white Scofield has gold engravings

[night tide]

Oh also

When you see the automatic pistols

[hidden moss]

whats the best rifle for yall?

[night tide]

The ones that look super dumb, don’t get it

They suck

[night tide]

Bolt Action

[candid cliff]

I only have Springfield and bolt

[night tide]

By far the best rifle

[hidden moss]

to me bolt action its so fookin op.

[misty cliff]

semi auto is not good

get m1899 instead

also better than mauser

[night tide]

The aim is a little funky with the M1 but it makes up for it

[misty cliff]

I stick to lancaster with long arms

[candid cliff]

I bought a bunch of stuff from the fence in Saint Denis

Some recipes

[misty cliff]

and pump action

[night tide]

I just unlocked the Linchfield

[candid cliff]

Poison Arrows are they good?

[night tide]

And I use the semi auto shotgun

[night tide]

Never used em

[candid cliff]

Well they were Hella expensive recipe

[native thunder]

no need to use poison arrows unless you want to see npc suffer for fun ig

[misty cliff]

semi auto shotgun is amazing but accuracy goes down quick over time.

[candid cliff]

Are they good in hunting at least?

[native thunder]

no practical use for them like dynamite and fire bottles

[misty cliff]

hence why i use pump, it also has an amazing sound.

[night tide]

True, you gotta clean it a lot and make sure you’re using slugs

[native thunder]

think so

however i think you have to hit a bit more precise with poison arrows instead of normal rifle bullets

[night tide]

I don’t see the point with the poison arrows

[native thunder]

cuz there is none lol

[night tide]

I can just kill some one with a reg any day

[native thunder]

yep

[pastel owl]

I use them on bears

[candid cliff]

Maybe they are for bears

Oh lol

[fathom ice]

lmao

[night tide]

Who’s hunting bears with bow and arrow

[pastel owl]

Because a normal arrow would take multiple shots

[night tide]

That’s terrifying

[pastel owl]

Poison arroe

[native thunder]

yea thats the only tjme where its slightly reasonable

[pastel owl]

I hit and run

[night tide]

I’m taking out the shotty

[pastel owl]

Than i kill ir with a knife

[native thunder]

or u could just shoot it with a gun lol

[night tide]

Very brave

[pastel owl]

Yeah but like if its a legendary bear

[night tide]

Have y’all done the stranger mission where the hunter lost his friend with in the grizzlies?

[candid cliff]

Nope

[pastel owl]

It will take more than 1 bullet

[night tide]

Do it

[candid cliff]

I don't do many stranger missions

[native thunder]

does the bear even die

[night tide]

It’s sad and scary

[candid cliff]

So they pay well

[night tide]

Stranger missions increase honor too

[native thunder]

im not sure if it glitched for me but it was invincible for me lol

[pastel owl]

Yes but it will kill me if i dont run before the poison kicks in

[candid cliff]

I went back and killd it

[pastel owl]

Their health is just rigged

[candid cliff]

Hunting is so fun

[pastel owl]

I love fishing

[night tide]

Fishing is awesome

[candid cliff]

I've killed countless animals and gotten perfect pelts so many time. Yet I can't get a f**king perfect squirrel

[native thunder]

just go on ur horse with varmint and aim assist and do drive bys on innocent rabbits, that's fun hunting

[pastel owl]

I found a spot where you can fish and set the fish free but theyy fsll on land and then i pick them up

[candid cliff]

That's what I do 🤭

[fathom ice]

where is that

[night tide]

Ive used dynamite on a bird before

[hidden moss]

What's the point of that?

[pastel owl]

If i told you id have tk kill you

[native thunder]

youll find squirrels eventually, look in the heartlands area and the grizzlies mountains, just have bow and small game arrows ready and aim assist

[candid cliff]

[fathom ice]

[night tide]

Yes only game arrows will get a perfect pelt

[native thunder]

theyre pretty abundant

[pastel owl]

I get honor for letting the fish go and also replenish my cores with food

[candid cliff]

Do you have to use small game, does varmint wirk

[native thunder]

varmint messes up the pelt

[candid cliff]

Pain

[night tide]

I was doing the hunger requests, and I saw “perfect cardinal” and decided I’m not doing it

[native thunder]

small game is the only thing

[hidden moss]

You're cheating

[eternal bear]

the mission when u fish with kieran

[fathom ice]

his goals are beyond are understanding

[eternal bear]

u can go into the water with the young lad and you'll see something remarkable

[fathom ice]

the naked guy?

[eternal bear]

aye

[fathom ice]

[eternal bear]

[tacit plover]

I spooked the civil war veteran in Rhodes by fighting some dude near him. Will I be unable to encounter him again?

[nocturne spindle]

I've done it before, but the water is too thicc to be able to fully see the New World

[chilly spruce]

Is it possible to kill legendary animals in new austin as arthur?

[eternal bear]

i saw the New World

nice touche by R*

[nocturne spindle]

Only if you do the Angelo Bronte glitch on 1.00

[eternal bear]

its big if u know what i mean

[hidden moss]

How can I get 2 carcano rifles I have one with a scope I wanna get another one to do a glitch and get the scope off

[chilly spruce]

Without glitches theres no way?

[nocturne spindle]

Nope, since you can't really collect the pelts with a wagon

[worthy fjord]

You can't buy 2 carcanos but I think you can buy 1 and take another carcano from an npc

[hidden moss]

Any idea where I can get another one

[frigid cloud]

Find an npc that carries carcano rifle

[stoic arrow]

[violet ledge]

What gun are you using?

[worthy fjord]

For the squirrel, you need to use a bow with small game arrows

[worthy fjord]

no not really

[worthy fjord]

varmint only works with animals like rabbit, racoon, opossum, turtle...

[chilly spruce]

What do i do with rock statue?

[candid cliff]

Just got my first 2 perfect boar pelts and died cos I didn't want to kill a police dog

[worthy fjord]

what rock statue? From where did you get it?

[chilly spruce]

Got it by collecting rock carvings

After i collected them i sent them by mail and got it as a reward

[opal flint]

anyone know how to fix washed out colors on story

[hidden moss]

Heard of self defense?

[candid cliff]

It was a doggy

And it made my honour worse

[hidden moss]

Doesn't matter

[candid cliff]

I'll shoot it next time I guess

I also made the mistake of surrender to bounty hunters

Cost me $300

[hidden moss]

Spend all money, then surrender. Pays bounty for free

[candid cliff]

I was gonna dead eye them all but took to long to count them

I was gonna wait till last second

[chilly spruce]

Where does that dude who gives u a quest to collect rock carvings live?

[nocturne spindle]

Near Strawberry

[chilly spruce]

That much i remember myself

[nocturne spindle]

It was a shack near near Owanjila

[chilly spruce]

Ty

[hidden moss]

Just explore the states

[nocturne spindle]

That wouldn've taken too long...

[hidden moss]

Nab

Nah

I found him naturally

[chilly spruce]

Where can i find silver chain bracelet and abalone shell fragment?

[hidden moss]

Abalone shell fragment is in a house in Rhodes north of the main road

You should try to naturally find the silver chain bracelet

[chilly spruce]

Kk ty

[long walrus]

Anyone got trade to sell ill help ps4 and xbox

[candid pasture]

this is a red dead single player channel

[hidden moss]

this aint an lfg channel.

[hidden moss]

That sentence makes no sense.

Trade isn't a noun; it can't be sold.

yea right.

[nocturne spindle]

Bruh true

[rustic karma]

I got the bracelet from killing the sister at the pig farm

[rustic karma]

Horseman 9 as Arthur has proven to be a tad more challenging then I expected

[hidden moss]

What did you expect?

[rustic karma]

I didn't think they would drain my health that fast

And I didn't make a great route, overestimated my horse

[hidden moss]

I wanna ask a general question about story

There's gonna be spoilers

I've not finished the game yet

But with Arthur I was on max honor

And I got the Arthur Mountain death

Where Micah doesn't shoot Arthur

But that just doesn't seem natural

Micah would kill arthur no matter what

So... By your opinion, what do you think is the more Natural ending of mountain death?

Micah Shooting Arthur or Arthur dying naturally.

[rustic karma]

I think micha shooting Arthur makes the most sense to me but I also hate giving micha that satisfaction so I prefer the TB ending

[hidden moss]

That's the same eay I feel

So I guess I'm sticking with TB ending

But If RDR2 were a TV show or something, I would definitely prefer the Shooting scene

[hidden moss]

High honor ending because Arthur performed redemption

[hidden moss]

Didn't think of that

Thanks for sharing your opinion

Yk that weirdo in a shack and u get a weapon from him

If u kill him

We killed each other at the exact same time so do i not get the weapon

Broo noo

I lost my double sided hatchet too

God sake

[rocky nest]

can you disarm the old timer gunslingers youre trying to get stories from?

[frigid cloud]

Yes.

[sinful knot]

except calloway

[rocky nest]

Damn, didnt realise. Already killed 3

[hidden moss]

They deserve to die

Because first and foremost, they all attack you first

[gilded tide]

can you turn in ethan watson for 500?

or is it impossible

[gilded tide]

it’s the best to unarm for easy honour

[vestal sail]

No, if you disarm them they either pull out another gun and kill themselves or attack you with it, and it cannot be shot out.

There's no real reason to disarm them unless you want a challenge I suppose.

[gilded tide]

… i didn’t say don’t kill them i said unarm them for easy honour

you can either kill straight away, no honour

unarm then kill

easy honour

[rocky nest]

ah ok, if they end up dead either way im not too worried

[chilly spruce]

Is there anything interesting to explore in guarma?

[gilded tide]

nope

[worthy fjord]

New birds and snakes

And iguanas I guess

[vestal sail]

Oh well yeah that works too I suppose

I personally play the game with low honor all the way until Arthur gets diagnosed, then I do the optional honor missions until he gets positive honor.

It makes the most sense IMO

[hidden moss]

Damn that does

[worthy lance]

We just need one. more. Score.

[static rover]

which graphics api should i use?

[worthy lance]

What

[static rover]

]

[worthy lance]

No

[hidden moss]

Yes

[hidden moss]

That's completely right

[unique garnet]

I've had better experience with Vulcan

[unique garnet]

ur on console, the question does not apply to you

[worthy lance]

Oh oki

My bad

[chilly spruce]

Like?

[hidden moss]

The island

[chilly spruce]

Which is full of guards and u can barely go anywhere

[tacit plover]

Saint Denis Guarma stinks!

[chilly spruce]

Both sucks

[rustic karma]

Hot take, Saint denis is the best town

[chilly spruce]

No it sucks, too much people

And too much law

[hidden moss]

was gambler 10 suppost to be one of the harder ones got it first try

[rustic karma]

10 is dominos, right?

[hidden moss]

no that's 9

10 is win 3 hands of poker in a row

[rustic karma]

Oh yeah, I just go all in and usually they fold

[hidden moss]

10 should of been on the first ones kinda disappointing

[rustic karma]

The people are great, it gives me so much serotonin bc they are so nice to you, they just hate it when you are on your horse. And the nights there are amazing

[hidden moss]

Sounds easy

[worthy fjord]

I prefer blackwater, it’s like saint denis but smaller and less crowded

[chilly spruce]

^

[hidden moss]

Awful people, awful buildings, awful pollution, awful concrete, awful law and order

definitely blackwater has more room

saint denis to many buildings and you really can't go around the town in creative ways

[worthy fjord]

But I do agree that at night saint denis is amazing

[rustic karma]

For me its probably: saint denis, blackwater, strawberry, valentine, armadillo, van horn, annesburg, tumbleweed, rhodes, and then lagras

I don't think I forgot any

Oh and Colter

Kinda

[worthy fjord]

Colter is an abandoned mining town, it doesn’t have any stores or shops

So I wouldn’t count it

[rustic karma]

Nature-wise, Laramie ranch and brandywine drop are my favorites

Lake Isabella is a runner up

[hidden moss]

no mcfarlane ranch?

[night tide]

cleet and joe look like straight trailer park trash