red-dead-singleplayer

[steady vector]

Just finished rdr1, and I didn’t know Uncle and Abigail’s deaths were coming. Anyone know how Abigail dies or is it all speculation?

[rustic karma]

I don't think it was ever confirmed

I've always just heard it being chalked up to sadness

Don't know if that meant suicide or just deterioration

[little remnant]

or since it’s just a lady on her farm alone (other than her little bitch son), could’ve been attacked

easy prey

[rustic karma]

Dont talk about me boi like that

[worthy fjord]

I heard she died because she was sick

[little remnant]

she spontaneously exploded, very tragic death

[hidden moss]

she died cuz she was sick, simple as that.

[rustic karma]

Doesn't seem like anything in red dead can be described as "simple as that"

Always room for discourse

[hidden moss]

hm i c ur point.

[rustic karma]

But sickness is very plausible, could have been the remnants for the cholera outbreak

Or one of the many diseases that ran rampant during that time

[worthy fjord]

Some guy on YouTube said she died from Tuberculosis

But I don’t think it was an Arthur joke because he uploaded it 9 years ago

I’ll send it in community content

[hidden moss]

9yrs.

[rustic karma]

If it was tb, Arthur could have very well been responsible, grieving and depression leads to not taking care of oneself which can cause the dormant tb to spread

Tb can chill undetected for years if you have a good lifestyle

[hidden moss]

true.

[ebon tulip]

Yeah but Arthur had a good lifestyle with lots of exercise

[rustic karma]

Not really

He was injured in chapter 3

And is in a gunfight every other day

Plus he had to deal with the gang falling apart

[ebon tulip]

I think it was, grief, stress and too much work that caused Abigail to die

From a storytelling perspective it makes the most sense

[worthy fjord]

Jack helped out with the ranch

[ebon tulip]

We don’t know when she died

And a young boy can’t do as much as John

[ebon tulip]

That’s true

But I don’t think he’s actually getting shot every other day besides when he gets shot in cutscenes

[rustic karma]

Not shot

But he is in gunfights

Also, never noticed that bill got shot during the rhodes gunfight

[drifting vapor]

1914 according to the rdr Fandom page

[ebon tulip]

Oh ok

So it could be literally anything

[rustic karma]

Pretty much

[worthy fjord]

Yes

[rustic karma]

Uncle could have spread his lumbago

[worthy fjord]

Could be it’s very contagious

And deadly

[rustic karma]

Thats what I hear

[oblique rose]

Uncle would of been the best gunslinger if it wasn’t for his lumbago

[zealous skiff]

I know that a majority of people here mainly play red dead 2 but I was wondering if you any of you guys have the first red dead for Xbox. Looking to play online.

[rustic karma]

I wish, I had it on my 360 but I have no idea where that is

Been thinking of getting psnow to play it on my ps4 or pc

[zealous skiff]

I guess it would be cheaper in the long run. If you did that.

[rustic karma]

True, only 10 bucks and I can beat it in under a month

Or just get the free trial and speedrun that shit

[distant minnow]

hello is this imposter?

imposter from amon gus?

[little remnant]

only works if you have super good internet though

100mbps at LEAST

[vagrant temple]

This ^

[rustic karma]

I believe you can download psnow games on a Playstation

Then you don't need as good of internet

[little remnant]

only ps4 games

ps3 games must be emulated because ps4s and ps5 never got backwards compatibility

[rustic karma]

Ah I see

Might just emulate it then

[distant minnow]

red demption

red emption

red red emption

[civic nest]

dead emption

[rustic karma]

Re ea reemption

[civic nest]

Red a mption

[distant minnow]

Red Dead Redemption 2 from EA

Because we ain't giving you a damn thing on Christmas, you need to pay for the Christmas Pass

I swear if they do that and overprice the pass I might quit

[distant minnow]

Red tion

Red on

Re on

reon

ren dad renmntionp

[rustic karma]

Is the Christmas pass gonna start right after the holloween one or is there one in between?

[distant minnow]

It's a prediction

it might not be real

I think they're gonna do a christmas pass

Rockstar likes to overprice things

[rustic karma]

Wasn't there one last year?

[distant minnow]

was there? I dunno because I'm relatively new

i am a lowly Rank 20

rank 5 in trader

[rustic karma]

I played during that time but not much, and I didn't buy the passes

[distant minnow]

there SHOULD be some outlaw passes and maybe a turkey day thing

To be honest I don't think there will be any turkeys alive during thanksgiving in red dead online

People will killem all to have a virtual thanksgiving

but the good thing is the attention will be focused on those and not on important animals like deer elk bison bear etc

[vagrant temple]

I doubt they’ll do a Christmas pass

Though I wish they did

[distant minnow]

I think they will

[vagrant temple]

It’d be a first

[distant minnow]

They SHOULD give a few bits of cash and gold to players on the 25th

[vagrant temple]

It’s Rockstar. Don’t set expectations

[rustic karma]

Cripps making me kill them all for resupply missions

[distant minnow]

h

[distant minnow]

I don't even want a christmas pass

I just want snow

[vagrant temple]

Oh yeah well that’s a given

We always get snow

[distant minnow]

I know

Around when does it start

It's my first winter

I bought a nice white coat in anticipation

[vagrant temple]

Week of Christmas

[distant minnow]

And when does it end

[rustic karma]

Thats so bullshit

[vagrant temple]

The week of Christmas

[rustic karma]

it should be all of December

[distant minnow]

that sucks

that is bullcrap

damn you rockstar

[vagrant temple]

I agree but that’s how it was done in the past 2 years

[distant minnow]

it should be all of December all January part of February

and maybe in northern states should extend to March a little

[vagrant temple]

People always complain about the snow lol

[rustic karma]

What

[vagrant temple]

It’s fun for like 2 days then people start complaining

Happens every year

[rustic karma]

Saint denis is so cool with the snow

And it gives cold weather outfits a week to shine

[vagrant temple]

Mhm

[hidden moss]

When is Saint Denis snowy?

[rustic karma]

Christmas week

[hidden moss]

rdr2 happy ending
arthur: strauss go send micah or someone i aint going to collect a debt this time im busy
mary: is it too late for us arthur
arthur: nah it isnt let's go now
credits

[rustic karma]

I agree but Mary can fuck off

Charles and Arthur passionately make out as the screen fades to black

[chilly spruce]

I cant find the Le Tresor Des Morts in the chapel in Saint Denis, any idea how to get it?

[unique garnet]

I wish we could camp in the snow in online.

[unique garnet]

You already got the note in the tunnel by the water? The gold is in the cemetary

[chilly spruce]

No

How do i get that?

[unique garnet]

You know Le Tresor Morts is a pre order only map right?

[chilly spruce]

Oh, didnt know that

[unique garnet]

If you can start it, you gotta go to the jail in Limpany and loot the first map.

[autumn verge]

Is Rdr being snowy?

I remember everything

Was very snowy

It was

it reminded me something personal

Heh, I guess past things can never be let go do they?

Shit I didn't take a screenshot when it was around that time

[crystal sierra]

can horses get cold in snowy areas?

[rustic karma]

Not that I know of

[autumn verge]

No

Horses are steriods on snowy places

Look at the White Arabian horse for example, Lived through snow for it's entire life

[sinful knot]

When you think about it arthurs blue shirt holds a great meaning in greek literature. If we go as far to look at most known greek mythology gods, the mythical god, zeus is usually portrayed with a white robe. While going back to the roots of white, we realize that it is a color!!! 1!1! If we return back to arthur and his beautiful shirt we realize that it is blue, also a color. The details into this game are crazy. I found out about this when I was looking at the horses testicles and then realized that the game has horses, and also realized about the greek meaning behind Arthur's shirt. The details in this game never cease to amaze me. Rockstar has outdone themselves. Truly the best game ever. Details!!!!!!!

[hidden moss]

[civic nest]

Omg 53 years later and we still find new things

[mild hawk]

This game never fails to impress me.!!!1.!

the details in this game are outstanding!

marvelous!

also, if you look at arthur while he whistles, he opens his mouth, and when i saw that, it reminded me of how God opened his mouth to breathe. Which also means that arthur is god! Who would have thought? the hidden details in this game make my penis fully erect. Bless Rockstar!

[eternal bear]

kinky

[night raven]

What in the cinnamon toast fuck have I just read?

[knotty marten]

Everyone in this channel be like

[brazen trellis]

Any advice to some quick money in the game

[graceful glacier]

gold bar in Limpany

[brazen trellis]

In offline mode

[graceful glacier]

yes. In Limpany is a gold bar you can sell for $500

what chapter are you in?

[brazen trellis]

1

[hidden moss]

Use your initiative

[brazen trellis]

Ok

[hidden moss]

What are your ideas for getting money quick, so far?

[graceful glacier]

Won't be able to do anything till you're in Chapter 2. Once you're in your new camp, Limpany is right underneath. In one of the buildings, under a desk (I think) is a lockbox with a gold bar.

[brazen trellis]

Ok

[hidden moss]

My eyes sting after crying from chapter 6

[sinful knot]

Steal a boat from an NPC and go out of the map to Tahiti, the money and mangoes are there

[hidden moss]

Lol

[hidden moss]

This is just the good ending

[rustic karma]

I find it hilarious that with all the money the gang collected, they could have easily gone to Tahiti

Hell, even with just arthurs take from the valentine heist, they could have gone

[civic nest]

I think Dutch didn't really want to go to Tahiti or another place, he really wanted to keep fighting the modern world

[dire stump]

yes

[gilded tide]

is the dark bay turkoman the best horse?

i think it’s easily one of the best,

[unique garnet]

It's a great horse, I like to buy one for John.

[gilded tide]

ah i like to use it in chapter 3

or just pick it up in chapter 3 and use it the rest of the game haha

[rustic karma]

Might have to check it out, I've only used Arabians and the starter horse

[gilded tide]

lol you can get one in chapter three during horse flesh for dinner. you can get either the best turkoman (dark bay), black arabian, or white arabian by doing a glitch

[rustic karma]

Damn i just beat that mission a few hours ago on my current playthrough

I'll know for next time tho

[languid perch]

is the tiger striped horse worth it?

[languid perch]

okay then

[unique garnet]

I see.. was going to say isn't the dark bay only purchasable in blackwater?

[languid perch]

can i buy a dark bay turkoman somewhere?

blackwater?

[turbid ore]

yeah you can buy it in blackwater

something around $900 or something

[languid perch]

worth it?

or should i go for

the tiger mustang

[crimson bronze]

Really just depends on your personal tastes.

[languid perch]

honestly the turkoman looks so beautiful

it can even compare with buell

mustang is meh

but its unique

[turbid ore]

i guess you can buy it

[tawny nimbus]

same

[turbid ore]

its stats are pretty good

[tawny nimbus]

everytime dutch said WE JUST NEED MORE MONEEY i was so confused

[turbid ore]

lol

[tawny nimbus]

fucking faith

[lament dock]

anyone here hate the lenny and author gets drunk mission

[turbid ore]

well it was quite a goofy mission and finding lenny was pretty hard so i will say that its not one of my favourite missions

but i dont hate it though

[hidden moss]

slander

[languid perch]

thats a war crime that you just did there my friend

[turbid ore]

lol

[languid perch]

can you burn down towns in rdr2?

i wanna raid armadillo

and burn everything down

[placid inlet]

nay

[misty cliff]

you can kill people there and cause some towns to go on lockdowns.

also any shop you'll enter and mess it up, it's gonna look shot up and destroyed for some time afterwards.

[naive glen]

i finished the game like 5 months ago idk

[dense lodge]

i just beat story mode i am now sad

[placid inlet]

have some tissue

[hidden moss]

how do trapper outfits work again

[dense lodge]

how do you mean

[hidden moss]

the individual pieces require me to get the ingredients but i can buy the full outfit without any of the required materials or money

doesnt take away any money when i do it

whats up with that

[dense lodge]

no you buy the outfit when you have everything and then it puts it in your outfits

[hidden moss]

im confused

it lets me buy the whole outfit and checks all the individual pieces like i own them

[dense lodge]

your outfit menu

[hidden moss]

even though i don t have the materials

[dense lodge]

can you buy the outfit or not

[hidden moss]

ye

despite not having any of the required materials

[dense lodge]

weird

click on it

[hidden moss]

i can buy the whole outfit but not any of the individual pieces

[dense lodge]

idk

[hidden moss]

like i cant buy the boots or gloves alone

really weird ngl

[dense lodge]

hunting the white bison sucked

try hunting a big white animal in a snowstorm

[wet hull]

Aussie rdr2 dlc would be hella sick

[fast ravine]

Any dlc would be sick

[wet hull]

just what would it be about

sadly rockstar just wants money

[fast ravine]

They could easy move 10-20m units of dlc content

Graphics can hold up for next 3-4 years

[wet hull]

but i don't get why they dont wanna do dlc

it would be phenomenal

[dense lodge]

do you think a rd surval game could work

[fast ravine]

Weird innit. They could make anything and we could easily buy it

[wet hull]

yes

[wet hull]

im gonna get trilogy tho

[fast ravine]

I guess

[wet hull]

honestly hyped

[fast ravine]

I’ve already preordered it

[wet hull]

at least its gta

[fast ravine]

Played all of them like 15 years ago

So be nice to play them again

[wet hull]

I've played all but 2,3

[fast ravine]

3 and Vice city was nice

San Andreas was meh but would give it a go again

[dense lodge]

who remembers metal gear survive

[wet hull]

me

[little remnant]

I haven’t heard anything about 3 ever so I’m looking forward to trying it out

[fast ravine]

3 was mind blowing for 2001

[wet hull]

yes 💯

[fast ravine]

Imagine in high school and playing it

Mind blown

[wet hull]

u wanna continue in #general cuz this chat is about red dead

[fast ravine]

Yeah

[dense lodge]

was it any good

[wet hull]

haven't played

[dense lodge]

good

rn im watching cowboy bebop

did you play mgs5

tpp

[rocky nest]

With the legendaries do you have to use the exact weapon it asks for for a clean kill

[dense lodge]

idk

i think its just what they want you to use

[rocky nest]

i dont have poison arrow yet, i’ll try a rifle to the head n see what happens

[little remnant]

not really since they don’t have pelt qualities, but don’t go overboard with explosive rounds of anything or else it’ll fuck it up

wait this is singleplayer

nvm dude Nuke that mf you’ll be fine

[vivid relic]

Not hyped for the trilogy

No idea why this server is just about red dead redemption 2

[hidden moss]

rdo horse armour dlc

jack marston dlc

[fast ravine]

I wanna ride a war wagon

[wet hull]

the harder they fall soundtrack fits so well with red dead

[gray wasp]

Missed opportunity for R* to add Nintendo playing cards in RDR2 (Nintendo started in 1889 making playing cards)

I know they would need permission

but they had the assets

[civic nest]

I doubt there would be Nintendo cards in the US by that time considering Nintendo is a Japanese company

Unless they also added some Japanese immigrant or something

[vivid relic]

yup

[gray wasp]

idk, in the story it would have been a extra 10 years of the cards circulating

Think they would have made it to america by then?

[glad brook]

Would be pretty out of place tbh.

[native thunder]

new camp activity with gang members comparing their cards like children lmao

[civic nest]

I don't even know how big Nintendo was at the time. Maybe it didn't even expanded throughout all Japan

And by that time it doesn't make much sense to import cards all the way from Japan when there was probably card manufactures in the US

[gray wasp]

true

Still its an interesting fact nonetheless

Nintendo is 130+ years old

[raw quiver]

Really?

Damn

[gray wasp]

yep

made in around 1889

[raw quiver]

That's pretty Interesting to Know,What were they doing before

[gray wasp]

Before what?

[raw quiver]

Oh no No nvm

I was Refering to the switch

[crimson bronze]

They made playing cards, then switched to toys, they didn't start getting into anything related to video games until the very very late 1970's

[gray wasp]

because videogames didnt exist until 100 years later

(89 to be presice)

[dark stratus]

Only real ogs played rdr2 in 500 BCE

[normal elk]

Lol

A choose your own adventure book animation

With pictures*

[burnt swan]

Anyone has an idea why my honor level wont change?

[rustic karma]

it takes quite a few deeds to get it up

or down

fewer deeds to go down tho

[burnt swan]

i already played the game 2 times and i know when it should change but it just wont

[oblique rose]

Bro I enter story mode and my horse is on the floor dead

[burnt swan]

hasnt changed since the beginning(chapter 4 now)

[normal elk]

Oof

[oblique rose]

I mean if you have good honor then you can shoot up a town without consequences

[rustic karma]

what chapter are you in?

[normal elk]

John has the most annoying voice,

Like

[oblique rose]

He is also aggressive

[normal elk]

Worse then dying AM over there

[rustic karma]

objectively wrong, this is not up for debate

[burnt swan]

i just killed 70 people in saint denis and it didnt change a thing

[placid inlet]

aw i like his voice

[oblique rose]

“Get out of the way you long streak of piss“

[normal elk]

"It's art!"

[oblique rose]

But it is art

[normal elk]

But srs where does John keep his 10 packs he smokes every day?

[oblique rose]

In his satchel

[normal elk]

He just BURNS though em

Like crazy

Sounds like he has been doing that for 5 yeara

His voice is pure gravel

[rustic karma]

they are life affirming ciggies

[normal elk]

Annoys the fuck outta me,

Mhm

John's graveliness should have been applied to the ciggie card guy at the trainstation

cause seriously I think there has to be a hole somewhere at beechers hope the size of a grave full of ciggie butts

Even dying Arthur didnt sound nearly as bad

And he was older, also smoked, and had tb

Like j e s u s

Jhionm milarstion

[distant minnow]

Red Dead Logic: Arthur/John can keep many meters of rope, an almost unlimited amount of tonics and food, and a lantern in his satchel, but can't put a jug of moonshine in it

Also for some reason: Arthur/John can keep raw meat/fish in his satchel for days and it doesn't go bad

But if he gets shot by the Tumbleweed Sheriff for some reason he dies

[rustic karma]

i would love to have a realism mode with proportionate carrying abilities

but rockstar

[distant minnow]

Imagine a run of red dead where you can only use a Morgan horse, cattleman revolver, and carbine repeater

No tonics

Food yes

And permadeath

[normal elk]

Carbine isnt bad, and the cattle is good

Permadeath is dumb

[distant minnow]

they are the starter weapons

[normal elk]

I know

[distant minnow]

it's realistic

[normal elk]

....

Isnt fun to die?

[rocky nest]

It uninstalls the game and you cant play again

[distant minnow]

One other thing how can Arthur get killed every which way and respawn but can't respawn after he dies of TB

[normal elk]

Did anyone have fun when Arthur died?

He doesnt respawn?

It just goes back?

[distant minnow]

...so he revives.

[rustic karma]

water too

[distant minnow]

he is still dead.

[normal elk]

Rewind the tape

He is fine now

[distant minnow]

that does not make sense

[normal elk]

ITS A GAME

[distant minnow]

yes i know but like'

[rustic karma]

with my luck i would get hit by lightning

[normal elk]

we are overthinking this

[rocky nest]

Woodpeckers… they actually up in trees or what?

[distant minnow]

i think you can get hit by lightning

[rustic karma]

but maybe a chapter based perma, like TLOU2

[normal elk]

Huh

Maybe!

[distant minnow]

or just guarma perma

[rustic karma]

i did in CTA a couple days ago

[distant minnow]

guarma perma with only knife

and fists

[normal elk]

Anyone read oracle or sunset in purgatory?

[distant minnow]

what

[normal elk]

Both kinda fix it stories

Is just groundhog day

Cept

In sunset's case from the wolves in colter to beechers hope,

[distant minnow]

you aren't making sense

i haven't read any of those two books

[normal elk]

Is a "every time you die you are back on the mountian in 1899"

Kinda thinng

Is interesting

[distant minnow]

let's just chalk it up to video game logic or arthur gets knocked unconscious and doesnt actually stop living

or is seriously injured

[normal elk]

Mhm,

Video game logic

[distant minnow]

the second theory makes more sense

[normal elk]

They are good reads tho!

On Ao3

[distant minnow]

sure

[languid perch]

he goes into a human hibernation

and then in rdr1 he searches for john but doesnt find him

[distant minnow]

no he gets knocked unconscious

or seriously injured

there are many explanations

[languid perch]

yeah but to keep it real he wouldn't stop breathing if he got knocked unconcious

[distant minnow]

yes

he wouldnt

so he doesnt

thats why he respawns

he recovers

[languid perch]

yes

[gray wasp]

lemme just recover from breaking all the bones in my body and being shot at a hundred times real quick

[distant minnow]

idk

Miracle Tonic ™️

he might have a secret miracle tonic that he buys when we are not playing as him

[gray wasp]

dude...in my game Arthur is currently literally laying at the botton of a lake, with every bone in his body broken and riddled with bullets, how tf does he survive that?

[distant minnow]

Miracle Tonic ™️

[gray wasp]

but the hell is he going to take it

[placid inlet]

it’s bc he is a lovely guy : )

[gray wasp]

That makes...0 sense

[distant minnow]

human bodies float

[placid inlet]

[distant minnow]

use the last remaining strength to drink miracle tonic

or just open the miracle tonic in the water and drink it all

[gray wasp]

not for long

[distant minnow]

Fard

Shid n fard

he farts to the top of the water? what do you want me to tell you

he might...drift to shore?

[gray wasp]

Listen, there are many ways to die in this game in where it's impossible to recover

[distant minnow]

get stuck on a rock

[distant minnow]

example

[gray wasp]

Being set on fire in New Austin

0 water

[distant minnow]

Miracle Tonic

he can still take a miracle tonic in new austin

[gray wasp]

that is the stupidest fucking excuse I've ever heard

ok then

[placid inlet]

[gray wasp]

falling off a cliff, it kills him instantly

[distant minnow]

I am right

[gray wasp]

no time to take a tonic

[placid inlet]

video games not making 100% sense? scandalous

[distant minnow]

No time to use deadeye either

At all

Deadeye should not be possible

But arthur and john are just that fast

So yes there is time to take a tonic

[gray wasp]

you cant use deadeye or tonics while falling

[distant minnow]

you cant but he probably can do fast movements with his hands and arms while falling

face it miracle tonic is the reason arthur was alive

[gray wasp]

I don't see miracle tonics or deadeye helping with the TB

[distant minnow]

miracle tonics are not to heal sickness only direct injuries

like bullet wounds, knife wounds, claw slashes and falls

[gray wasp]

[distant minnow]

you know the maker of the miracle tonic could be the strange man

or francis sinclair

[worthy fjord]

I think it was the bounty target

I forgot his name

But he’s the first bounty target in valentine

[distant minnow]

yeah the fake miracle tonic maker

that one killed people

[distant minnow]

@gray wasp why do you think everyone in the ingame world (npc's) have no scars or seem to be affected by any ailment at all (other than Mickey and Buell's owner)

[gray wasp]

That'so fucking inaccurate, there are dozens and dozens of NPC's that have scares

[distant minnow]

scares

yes

scars

no

[worthy fjord]

Everyone makes spelling mistakes

It’s fine

[distant minnow]

i have never seen an npc with scars

except for john as an npc

and the two previously mentioned

[gray wasp]

Are you blind

Arthur has scars

wth

You can tell by his facial hair

[worthy fjord]

If you go and get the money in the last mission you can stab Micahs eye

[distant minnow]

1 arthur is not an npc 2 where

[worthy fjord]

And in the epilogue he’ll have a scar

[distant minnow]

Right cause he didnt have the miracle tonic

[gray wasp]

On the left of his chin

Its easy to spot on facial hair stage 3

[rustic karma]

most of the gang has scars

[gray wasp]

Yeah he's just being wrong

So, SO many people have scars and shit

[distant minnow]

only ones i have seen are dutch micah in the epilogue john and maybe arthur if @gray wasp is right

[worthy fjord]

They are right

[rustic karma]

arthur definitely does

[distant minnow]

he never mentions it

[rustic karma]

you can see it really well with a level 3 chin hair

[gray wasp]

THANK YOU

[worthy fjord]

He doesn’t have to mention it🤦‍♂️

[gray wasp]

yeah its obvious

[distant minnow]

its a game... why are you getting so worked up

like

[worthy fjord]

I’ll send a screenshot in #red-dead-media

[gray wasp]

dude you started this, I'm just finishing it by proving you wrong

[distant minnow]

sure i guess i am wrong but then answer me this how can arthur revive from all that and die from tb

without reviving

[rustic karma]

alot of npcs have smallpox scars

[gray wasp]

just look at the Murfree's

those guys are like another species of scarred

[distant minnow]

they don't have the Miracle Tonic

🤣

[worthy fjord]

[gray wasp]

Ok then

riddle me this

[distant minnow]

what if you can only get miracle tonic when you play as someone like arthur can only get miracle tonic when you play as him same as john

because they gain some awareness or whatever

[gray wasp]

there are so many holes in that

[worthy fjord]

You can buy them from the dotctor

[rustic karma]

the valentine sheriff is covered in scars, too

[worthy fjord]

Doctor

[gray wasp]

Tyeah

[distant minnow]

there is also a Ufo

in the game

and a robot sitting on a mountain

[worthy fjord]

Yes and?

[gray wasp]

what the fuck does that have to do with anything

[gray wasp]

and the robot is actually a normal thing, you'd know that if you payed some goddamn attention

[rocky nest]

Does the ufo have scars

[distant minnow]

ufo is kind of magic

[distant minnow]

Check 🤣

[gray wasp]

No it fucking isnt

maybe to the people back then it seemed like magic

but its just technology

[distant minnow]

but what is it powered by

[worthy fjord]

Electricity?

[distant minnow]

also hallow's eve call to arms

the satanic circle thing

that is magic

[worthy fjord]

Bro they aren’t canon to the story

[gray wasp]

^^^

[worthy fjord]

It’s just for fun

[vapid knoll]

how did this go from scars to magic

[distant minnow]

Discord

[worthy fjord]

Idk

[worthy fjord]

It’s just for Halloween and the whole call to arms thing isn’t canon

[distant minnow]

ok

[placid inlet]

[distant minnow]

if it isnt magic and it isnt miracle tonic how did arthur survive getting hit by all those bullets being mauled by a legendary bear and more

[rustic karma]

i dont think anything online is

[gray wasp]

Main character thats why

[distant minnow]

but then why does arthur not respawn after ch6 death

[worthy fjord]

Yes

[distant minnow]

when he can respawn from every other death

[placid inlet]

it’s bc otherwise the game would be over too quickly LOL it’s a video game

[worthy fjord]

Do you want to die instantly because you got shot once?

[rustic karma]

because plot armor and storytelling

[placid inlet]

a damn video game 💀💀💀

[worthy fjord]

That wouldn’t be fun

[distant minnow]

i am pretty sure it is just not to the gang's story

[gray wasp]

Main character priveleges expired

[distant minnow]

yes but that's still a plothole

[rustic karma]

well considering its been 1898 for the past 3 years, i dont think so

[gray wasp]

And the UFO and satanic magic isnt?

[worthy fjord]

No it’s just a way to end a story

[distant minnow]

although there is a possibility that every time arthur dies he creates a separate universe where he hasn't died yet and that's how he survives

[placid inlet]

hahahahaha

[distant minnow]

time loop

idk

[worthy fjord]

Tacitus are you trolling or are you serious?

[distant minnow]

i am spitballing ideas

[hidden moss]

in other words he's trolling.

[distant minnow]

battery acid

[distant minnow]

i am throwing possibilities

[normal elk]

And a squirrel that is called "art" that looks like John

[civic nest]

That squirrel is John

[rustic karma]

Vudu john

[civic nest]

After dying in 1911 he went back in time reincarnated as a squirrel, got hunted by past John, sent to the taxidermist and became a statue

[rustic karma]

and shaky was behind it all

[crystal sierra]

Are there any side quests you can only do with Arthur and not after Chapter 6?

[civic nest]

The ones with Charlotte, the widow at Roanoke Ridge

[crystal sierra]

Ok thanks

[unique garnet]

Which is really funny since Arthur in most player's cases mail the first set of animals

[rustic karma]

the downes family missions

[hidden moss]

Respawn is ridiculous

Upon death, the player should be presented with their saves they can load

[hidden moss]

Yes.

[civic nest]

What if the last save was 3 hours ago?

Besides, you can manually load a save if you want

[rustic karma]

I really wish there was a difficulty level, there is no reason to do the challenges accept for 100%

[placid inlet]

i hate the challenges with a burning passion

[glad brook]

Cool bandalers tho.

[placid inlet]

that's true

[worthy fjord]

What challenge are you doing now?

[worthy fjord]

Who doesn’t?

[placid inlet]

nerds

[rustic karma]

Gambler, I've done it a couple times before and its just so tedious

[worthy fjord]

Rip

It took me 5 hours to finish gambler 8

[glad brook]

Video game logic.

Your thinking about it too hard.

[hidden moss]

Your fault. Also, there is the autosave feature

[hidden moss]

The challenges unlock reinforced equipment.

[rustic karma]

Its just not worth the time investment

[hidden moss]

Have you heard of recreation?

[night tide]

wdym

[burnt swan]

hey u guys know the farther near valentine building a house?

So i met him in chapter 3 and gave him some money and he told me to give it back but i returned a little bit too late and the house is already sold

u know how i can revisit him and get my money back?

[night tide]

Cant

[turbid ore]

he just ripped you

[night tide]

that $ is gone

lol

[turbid ore]

lol

[burnt swan]

😦

[night tide]

sorry bout that

[turbid ore]

[hidden moss]

[night tide]

I don't think you can find him after that either

[burnt swan]

actually i dont care cuz i got enough money but i just wanted to take a look

[turbid ore]

well if you saved the game before that then you can get it back

[night tide]

Yah

[hidden moss]

Is there any way to not be as sad from arthurs death

[rustic karma]

Uhh

Like micha ig

[eternal bear]

u cant skip the depressive episodes following Arthur's death

unles you're a pyschopath who likes Micah

[gray wasp]

Yes it's called drugs

[eternal bear]

hop in RDO, that's before the current events of RDR2 and Arthur's alive somewhere

[misty cliff]

Micah is cool

Best character ever

[turbid ore]

try the bad ending, i felt like its a little less sad

[hidden moss]

Idk if I have the heart to see Arthur get spat on, the passing out and his death again

And seeing my horse die at the end

It pissed me off so much I left 1 guy left just to punch them to death

[calm crow]

Bruh

My sister thought dutch was a butler

Bc of the Way he is dressed

[hidden moss]

Low honor endings aren't sad because Arthur had it coming

[dusk wyvern]

Why did I load in game and my whole inventory, guns tonics and all had just disapeared?

Ya still it's all gone

[hidden moss]

Bug

Reload

[dusk wyvern]

I did

[dusk wyvern]

I reloaded and restarted my PC, there is nothing on my horse. I tried loading a save didnt work either.

[hidden moss]

weird

maybe you accidentally removed every item you have by a mod menu??

mod menus usually have that option

[dusk wyvern]

Yup probably did thay

that

Actually maybe it was because I was playing as a wolf then left the game

[hidden moss]

LOL

Next time, don't cheat

[ornate cloud]

are there unlockables for low honor?

like outfit or something?

[random aurora]

just a belt buckle as far as i know

[frigid cloud]

No

[placid inlet]

story missions

oh wait this is singleplayer

in that case...... only bad things

and a bad conscience

[crystal sierra]

Hey, i just came back from the Island in the chapter 5, when I whistle my horse it says he's lost, will I find him?

[frigid cloud]

Eventually, yes.

[crystal sierra]

I have to look for it all over the country?

besides his assignment rank was level 4

Ho hes back

[rocky nest]

dunno if its the same but you can usually get your horse to respawn at any stable if you leave it behind somewhere

[ornate cloud]

a what?

[random aurora]

a buckle dont know if it is just for online or storymode as well

[ornate cloud]

as far as cosmetics go from what i see on a video

the gambler suit that you can buy looks slightly different for both honnors

[placid inlet]

oh yeah, it's blue for high honor and red for low honor

[gray wasp]

Wait what? Actually?

So Markiplier was just an idiot then?

[frigid cloud]

I don't know who that is

And what he does

But you do get your horse back after you return to camp in chapter 5

[gilded tide]

nope you can buy it and then get it in chap three as well

[gray wasp]

Markiplier? A youtuber? He played RDR2 when it first came out, but never finished the game like a coward?

[frigid cloud]

Lol

Where did he stop?

[gray wasp]

Seriously he stopped right at Epilouge

[gilded tide]

wow

[gray wasp]

he got like 5 min as John

and then turned off the stream

[unique garnet]

which stable?

[frigid cloud]

Blackwater stable which unlocks in epilogue

[gilded tide]

wait i thought you were saying you can buy it in black water?

[unique garnet]

yea thats what i thought

[unique garnet]

right, u said u can get in chapt 3? im asking where

[gilded tide]

oh through horse flesh for dinner

[unique garnet]

youtuber Matthew haynes did the same thing

then never finished

[gray wasp]

Its always a shame when they dont finish

[glad brook]

Not like they missed out on much.

[gray wasp]

lol

Well

they missed the house building mission

and killing the legendary rat

[ornate cloud]

a guide to grow beard to max lvl?

i cant find anything real

[jovial shuttle]

E

[frigid cloud]

Hair tonics

[placid vine]

How do you get the brown fringed shotgun chaps?

Need them for a custom outfit

[muted violet]

Can anyone help with a glitch I got?

I'm in the epilogue rn and I can't focus on Abigail to propose on the boat

If I press Left trigger nothing happens

[loud forum]

yeah man rdr1 sounds worth it

[hidden moss]

its fun af

[loud forum]

unfortunately I can't afford a PS3

need to fix my Xbox 360

[hidden moss]

you could probably find a free emulator tbh

[loud forum]

wish they'd make a port to pc to make life easier loll

[hidden moss]

there is a port

just illegal

lol

[loud forum]

yeah but honestly I would feel bad not paying for an amazing game

even if it is from a multi billion dollar company I wouldn't pirate rdr2 even if I was forced to

[hidden moss]

rockstar made gta 5, they have more money thrn they know what to do with

but i will still buy games when i can

[loud forum]

yeah but wouldn't feel right getting a masterpiece for free tbh

[hidden moss]

i guess

but still

always an option lol

[loud forum]

yeah

[hidden moss]

just its a great game

[loud forum]

I used to pirate games before I bought them to make sure I liked em first

rdr2 can't be pirated tho, too risky and too heavy

steam still helps with their compression and faster download speeds

[hidden moss]

me and steam refund department are bffs at this point tbh

i play a game for like 2.9 hours to figure out if i like it

[loud forum]

"hey Julia, it's me again, Dave. I'd like to refund this again lol"

[hidden moss]

lmao

honestly tho

[loud forum]

yeah I feel like I refund too much

I didn't refund batman Arkham knight because I accidentally left it open overnight and couldn't refund it

[hidden moss]

oof

[loud forum]

now it just sits there, waste of money

[hidden moss]

its a great game tho

[loud forum]

At least I bought in a promotion

[hidden moss]

you should try playing it

[loud forum]

yeah not my style tho

The open world feeling wasn't right

[hidden moss]

too empty?

[loud forum]

It felt like even when I wasn't on a mission I had to do mission stuff

[loud forum]

yeah

[hidden moss]

rdr1 is like that tbh

[loud forum]

only criminals to beat and the combat system is a bit slow

[hidden moss]

but its also a smaller map

sp not so empty

[loud forum]

but rdr1 has at least some npcs and a great story from what I've seen

[hidden moss]

it does

[loud forum]

But batman felt empty and not fun y'know

[hidden moss]

and it also has fast travel

[hidden moss]

i guess

i heard its like spiderman ps4 but more empty

[loud forum]

yeah

spiderman PS4 seems fun until you realize you can't commit crimes because you're the good guy

[hidden moss]

eh they make it fun

the combat is really good

[loud forum]

The nice thing about open world games is how you can commit heinous crimes and not get any type of real consequence

[hidden moss]

and you can always beat up bad guys

[loud forum]

oh

well can't say anything about that, never had a ps4

Sad thing is heroes don't kill so I don't assume there's blood or detailed gore like in rdr2?

[hidden moss]

not really

theres some in cutscenes

but not that u can cause

[loud forum]

sorry if I sound like a madman but my favorite pastime in rdr2 is to dismember people tbh

[hidden moss]

lmao

aight im gonna go take a nap or smth

gotta wait for rdr to load

so like

[loud forum]

cya

[hidden moss]

8 years

cya

[loud forum]

ok one thing

it really bothers me the stereotype

my rdr2 loads in like 32 seconds

[hidden moss]

i meant the download lol

[loud forum]

oh

[hidden moss]

lol

[loud forum]

well gn

[hidden moss]

gn

[dusk wyvern]

It's my game, and how was that cheating I was just messing around

[little remnant]

no such thing as cheating in a singleplayer game

[vivid relic]

Ye true

[wary hazel]

I have anxiety to spend money

I have like 20k

And got all shit

[hidden moss]

yep been there.

[turbid ore]

Exactly

[hidden moss]

To be fair, Low honor kinda makes sense for me especially for an outlaw who spends their lifestyle that causes ordinary people to suffer from their actions (ex: robbing, killing, etc). Arthur tried to change but he was aware that he cannot fight whole old habits he maintain for the last 20 years along with his gang, although He did care about his gang and his family and redeemed his sins (ex: absolving debt, helping a soldier to escape, rescued Abigail).

The players have a lot of opportunities to change Arthur from a low honor man to a high honor man with various missions and events before the last train robberies mission.

The vibe of Arthur last ride is different depending on honour

[wary hazel]

no

[languid perch]

low honor gives a silver filter

with some eerie music along with the song

high honor is gold

with calming music

[hidden moss]

not just the music.

[languid perch]

oh yeah and the voices are different

[hidden moss]

John only caring for himself: ROSS WHERE THE FUCK IS MY FAMILY GIVE ME MY FAMILY
meanwhile john orphaned tons of people and killed atleast 700 people in his life

[hidden moss]

Canon is low honor until diagnosis

[lament dock]

anyone know what to do if you get the shotgun from the cabin

and its just clean

[wraith panther]

I think that's a lot of people's favourite past time

[wraith panther]

Go and dismember people

[loud forum]

tbh I can see why

[lament dock]

No its like

[loud forum]

realistic kills

[lament dock]

They say to clean it. But all the sudden its clean

[loud forum]

well can't you just go on?

the game should understand it's clean

[lament dock]

I cant. I cant move

[loud forum]

oh uh

[wraith panther]

It'd be pretty epic if you could shoot someone in the chest and the chest just evaporates

[wraith panther]

Restart game maybe

Or suicide if you can

[loud forum]

bruh what

the server deleted my message

[wraith panther]

Noice

[loud forum]

Can't we use the discord spoilers?

[lament dock]

nope didnt work

[wraith panther]

Apparently not

[wraith panther]

Oof

Maybe try saving your game and then restarting it

[loud forum]

well this reminds me of the time I got stuck on a mission because I couldn't get on the fortified train cabin

that one where you have to shoot the doors to scare the people, don't remember the name but it was a heist

[wraith panther]

What chapter?

[loud forum]

3?

if I remember correctly chapter 3 or the end of chapter 2

a train heist where you have to blow up a door

[lament dock]

i cant

[wraith panther]

Oh yeah that one

[wraith panther]

Wtf

[lament dock]

you know when you enter the O'rdricol cabin after killing them

[loud forum]

oh you mean when you slaughter the o Driscoll camp?

[wraith panther]

I went there when she was alone

[loud forum]

yeah when I went on that mission I got glitched too

only way was to leave the game and rejoin, had to redo the entire mission

this also reminds me of the chapter 4/5 train heist(where John falls off) my game crashed at the end 😭

[lament dock]

bruh

really

I just did that lol

[loud forum]

only thing that worked for me

I also installed a trainer to kill myself if it happened again and it really helped

maybe try installing native trainer or Red Dead Trainer, then use the kill yourself thing?

[lament dock]

i did that. I suicide myself

[loud forum]

shit man, didn't work?

[lament dock]

nope

[loud forum]

so you're softlocked?

[lament dock]

yeah

[loud forum]

uhh

I never saw this glitch?

try contacting rockstar on the bug report site

[worn skiff]

I need a suggestion

[loud forum]

?

[worn skiff]

I am thinking to buy red dead redemption 2 story should I buy because I already have online

[hidden moss]

Clean it anyway

[lament dock]

wow thanks it totally worked

[hidden moss]

Cool

[loud forum]

yeah it's amazing

no spoilers - it has an amazing story and you can do whatever tf you feel like

[worn skiff]

Oh oki then I will buy on steam sale

[worn skiff]

I already played story bro

But on my friends account

[loud forum]

Doesn't rdr online come with single player?

[worn skiff]

But not explore story too much

[worn skiff]

Nope

[loud forum]

my single player came with online for some reason

[worn skiff]

Then you should be lucky

Because I only bought rdr online in 5$

[loud forum]

probably a processing error or something else happened because I bought the normal edition

[worn skiff]

You bought standard bro that's why it have both

I bought only red dead online stand alone edition

[loud forum]

oh

I thought only ultimate edition had both

[worn skiff]

No bro

[loud forum]

sorry I'm kinda new to rockstar standards lol

[worn skiff]

Oh I can understand

But I wanted to buy from steam standard edition

[loud forum]

I don't really understand how to buy a standalone version - I bought standard because I thought I couldn't buy just single player

but either way every penny was worth it

[worn skiff]

But I played story in my friends account but did not explore too much I only played story mission due to time limit and friends account also

[worn skiff]

Standard edition come with both story and online while red dead standalone come with only online

You can search red dead online both in epic or steam

[loud forum]

that's rather confusing

[worn skiff]

Yeah little bit

And you know online is cheap then standard

It’s 10$ on sale in steam and in epic it’s 4$ on sale

While standard is 30$ at sale on steam

[loud forum]

yeah

[worn skiff]

I bought on December 2020 when red dead online released

As a stand-alone

Then I bought it in 5$

[loud forum]

oh

can you at least install that mod that makes private sessions?

redm?

[worn skiff]

Their are some glitches that you can make private session

But search yt

You will find video on it

[loud forum]

the only reason why I don't like playing online is griefers

[worn skiff]

Yeah same

[hidden moss]

Hi guys can u find all animals with arthur in rdr2

And I mean only with arthur

[loud forum]

probably

some guy did 90.1% with a healthy Arthur so you most likely can

[hidden moss]

But like the red part

[lament dock]

where can i find lenny when im fully drunk

[hidden moss]

Which arthur cant enter

[loud forum]

oh, blackwater?

[hidden moss]

In heaven :D

[hidden moss]

Yes

[loud forum]

yeah you can't, there's invisible snipers and you're wanted there

[hidden moss]

So the animals that live there

U cant find them?

[loud forum]

if you can somehow disable the snipers then yes

if you can't, there's no way you can hunt there

@hidden moss plus there's some op lawmen there

they appear from everywhere if you enter blackwater

[hidden moss]

F

[loud forum]

teleported there once got killed within 10 seconds

[hidden moss]

Lmao

[loud forum]

was gonna recommend mods but I see you're a ps player

sad

but either way you can hunt almost everything outside blackwater

it's a giant desert and you can only go there on the end of epilogue 1

[hidden moss]

F

No you cant

Snipers kill you if you go past the Montana river

[lament dock]

Author's a chad

He managed to suck some venom and not die

Only Tuberculosis will kill him

sadly

anyone know what to do when you cant manually save for no readson

[hidden moss]

He spat it out

[lament dock]

also anyone know why i cant save

I was wanted but i paid the bounty

[torn wedge]

Can someone help me please

I cant get past the barn scene in the beginning

It’s saying hold L2 I’m doing it nothing happens tho

[hidden moss]

I doubt it

[lament dock]

Can someome help me? I was wanted and i payed the bounty right? I cant manually save no more

[hidden moss]

cant help never been there.

did ya try restarting the game?

[lament dock]

But

ill lost all my progress

[pine laurel]

Try go in and out of the meny. I've had similar situations and then it helped to just pause the game and go back after a while

[normal elk]

I remember there was a mission, that you could leave without it failing you. I dont remember what mission but I remember the guy talking about how at that point the sniper was disabled and you could walk into new austin

[hidden moss]

There was a bug allowing you to to travel there, yeah

[ornate cloud]

bruh

why did my glorious beard just disappeared?

im clean shaved for no reason, why?

wtf

i put so much effort into making my beard and now its gone for no reason?

[knotty marten]

Kekw

[hidden moss]

What is a beard’s favorite nuts? Mustachios.

[ornate cloud]

bruh wtf my beard

i was at lvl 7

cmoon

[languid perch]

just drink hair tonics

then sleep

then drink hair tonic

repear

its easy

[ornate cloud]

ok so

i went into my clothing and it seems its a glitch of some sorts

my beard was saved on 1 of my outfits

another one had my beard as well but shorter?

wtf is that glitch even

its not like growing this beard is easy

[languid perch]

another glitch changed my outfit

im in epilogue and i was wearing john's hobo grey full sleeve

then it reverted to the cowboy outfit

[hidden moss]

Bug. Reload

[ornate cloud]

i did

the whole game

and it didnt fix

also selpt

went bathing

still no fix

[sage vessel]