#red-dead-singleplayer
1 messages ¡ Page 508 of 1
Robbing trains is like the only thing worth to rob
Yeah
Yeah but 3000$ from valentine bank robbery is more then enough for a average playthrough
That's not that much really
well it's a shit ton for chapter 3
All camp upgrades unlocked and you still have much to spend
Unless you go on a shopping spree and loose all your money doing so like I did on my first playthrough.
Probably the best way to balance the game
Either dump it all in shopping or donate some to camp funds
What are mods like on rdr2
idk u should check
I don't got a pc

nothing
pretty underwhelming
its just cheat mods and cosmetic for the most part.
What about a mod menu
i think there is something like that
but ya nothing like gta hulk mod or crazy shit like that
Imagine sick arthur turning into hulk
It's not a game
Y
It's 3 games
does lastofus2 or rdr2 have better graphics
rdr2
rdr2
Rdr2 was called "game with the best graphics" by google
Or something
Idk their PC probably exploded when they tried to run rdr2 on max graphics
hey
how do I find Eagle Flies' mission? I talked to the chief and his son, they hired me for a job
but I don't know how to find him
Will show up on the map as a story mission if you agreed to help
thanks
I am experiencing a glitch in the sheeps and the goats mission where when i get to the wagon my game glitches so i cant pick up struaus does anyone know how to fix this P.S. i am on ps4 this is in story mode
rdr2 duh
Rdr2 runs pretty well on PC
Complete a mission or wait around for some time the mission will appear
i rode the opposite way and it popped up on the map, so maybe try that
that would be towards saint denis
How do i get into new austin as arthur with a carcass and which one should i use
how to i get an xbox flair?
You can just install a mod that disables out of bounds snipers
Im on xbox lmao
GET FUCKED
Cant discuss mods here either so
Buck or pronghorn
Buck âźď¸âźď¸đ¤
At least my game consoles game version wasnât released later
what?
Remember the Kieran screaming theory near shady Belle ?
Just reached chapter 4 and been hearing screams already
and Kieran is in the camp
It was a good idea but apparently it happens randomly
Welp, time to get more money by gambling
I gotta pay off the $200 bounty I got from a failed train robbery
i have a 1.5k bounty in strawberry valentine and saint denis 
Have you thought about how bills name is probably William Williamson
i probably should
I just want money, bounties increase wayyy too fast in story
I had $3000, I lost like $800+
How tf am I supposed to get rid of my money?
Dont
dont say it
I killed them already dont you dare say it
give it to camp spend it on ammo engravements
Dutch gay
He didnt give a shit about her lol
Thats not the point
What is?

Nah thatâs not THE PLAN
his name is Marion
Marion Williamson
Atleast i dont get hackers and modders in rdo
itâs on his discharge papers and he mentions it to Micah in a camp dialogue
chad me who is on pc but doesnt play online
pretty chad ngl
i rob trains all the time without bounties thereâs a strategy
well I didn't use it
PC players on their way to get doxxed by rdo/broadcasting your ip simulator
lol
lol
hey
howdy
I'm having a hard time getting my honour up, maybe I should just do the story...
I need money, and I'm a bit bored of trying to get a 3-star badger
I have 7 2-star ones
for fucks sake
Seems like youâre having fun lol
Trying to get 100% completion in chapter 2-3
go to that abandoned battlefield I forgot its name
I found my badgers sometimes in heartlands, riggs station, or theres a location that GTA series videos gives
^
no I'm fucking not I've wasted so much of my time
I am in PAIN
LOLLLL
W R O N G.
I told you that I'm just tryna get as far as I can as Arthur
so 100% completion attempt in chapter 6 then
deal with the "very sick" debuff
and weight loss
yes
I forgot the core drain rate but it's by more then 50% I think and also you lose weight way faster
Core lasting rate from 90 minutes to 75 minutes according to wiki

what does this means?
core drains faster
Your cores at full normally last 90 minutes
When your sick core drains faster
ooooooh
you can see how many minutes your core has left by looking at wellbeing
spam biscuits on Arthur and enjoy coughing asmr
;-;
wait
If you spam those things, does Arthur actually cough or-?
Eating 99 crackers to give Arthur a asthma attack
Arthur cough everytime after eating I think
;-;

;n;
No only if you eat more often than he can handle
force Arthur to the limits, go to colter in open collar union suit, bare feet, jeans
what is more than he can handle
Sometimes I used to eat... and cores never went up whenever Arthur was sick
Once he starts coughing
Maybe small core boosting foods aren't as good?
we should have a cheat to toggle tuberculosis to make the game harder
tbh, just deal with red cores and make Arthur look even more tired during ch 6. imagine exploring during ch6, it's just weird imo. I only did the ch6 exclusive missions and story everytime I hit ch6
incentive to explore drains out in ch6 for me
I mean yeah when you get the crazy debuff then why explore
hey
Chapter 4 is the exploring and Epilogue 2 exists
I had Arthur at max weight last time and I think he loses it all during story around Guarma and the beginning of chap 6. Not much you can do
I mean yeah you don't get much food on the island
It is possible to keep him above average weight when you have TB tho
perfect weight with tb
I usually go overweight because who needs stamina when horses exist
Go to a saloon and eat 6 meals in a row
I mean when you get higher stamina cores then stamina becomes easy to handle
One big game meat fills all 10 player calories also
Yeah just run around a bit to increase stamina at the beginning
I might run all the way to blackwater
I think I read somewhere that you can eat 3 items of food every 15 or 20 minutes and they all contribute to weight
I thought u needed to sleep to update weight
I buy lots of crackers, biscuits, and chocolate bars
Sometimes random load zones contribute
Sometimes my weight increased from making a campfire
and fast traveling updates weight
Lol
Jeez how long is it going to take for John to find Bill in rdr1 đ
After he wins a revolution
I just started helping the Mexican army guy to fight against the rebels
I had a feeling John might switch sides
is it possible to complete the Errand Boy achievement as John?
Only camp requests you can do as John are Charles' and uncle's so.. impossible unless you've done 3 as Arthur
charles is long gone
all of Act 1 and 2... lol
Ah well, uncle is still possible but you can't achieve it
I wasted 75% of all my provisions and wondered why arent the cores increasing
Why can't I do the little x on peopl with dead eye
All dead has been doing for the last 5 in game hours is just I can do one shot
It just slows down time
Which chapter are you in?
3
You have to paint the x's manually now, just press q im sorry if this is the answer you werent looking for
Ah ok
It's better that way anyway, you just have to get used to it
yessir
please stop
uninstall RDR2'
you dont deserve rdr2 if you think you can get 100% in chapter 2-3
Isn't it impossible anyways
Yeah, you have to be at least in chapter 4
dude he's just joking he's gotten 100% completion
Chapter 4 unlocks new austin and blackwater
i forgot
11
!!!!
someone please help me
I jhust got read dead
and when I exit out of full screen while playing on my laptop
a bunch of dead pixel stuff shows up
how do i fix tghisd?!?!?
Hey y'all out of curiosity any reason why I make 0 progress on fishing suddenly? I was fishing fine before the camp moved and suddenly the wheel doesn't rotate and no progress is made no matter how fast I rotate my PS4 joystick, no matter how I time the left joystick and R3 etc
Maybe find context first 
I got 100% on chapter 2.
i don't think so
Is there a specific time when camp activities show up
Not really
Gambler 8 moment
the hell just happened
I insulted someone, an entire bar started shooting me and I gained a 5$ bounty
sad
If I get all the health boosting trinkets and talismans and whatever else, will the entire circle be full like this 
No you have to get weapon equipment like holsters and gun belts and bandoliers to get lvl 10 health
I literally said âand whatever elseâ but ok
Best song in the game is the one that plays when riding back to shady belle after you return from gurma or however you spell it
Our best selves underrated
Battle of shady belle when riding with john tho
If you use a cheat, is your ability to get achievements/trophies permanently locked?
Why are you using cheats anyways
Fun?
Do you mean mods
PC?
Yeah
Idk then
Itâs probably just an issue with my pc
Most likely
I did that, the achievements weren't progressing like my best in the west achievement was stuck at 69% but in the game its 90 something
I mean the red role is bad anyways 
I would sky blue over that anyday
take*
i wish that the black water massacre was in a prologue like how gta5 did their prologue
no, letâs say you use a cheat and do a mission, the moment you get off the game itâll bring you back to before you did the mission
It disabled manua lsave and trophies
manual*
For money?
That would be quite interesting
or at least a dlc
But letâs be real
The world will end before Rockstar makes more story mode dlcs for games
is it at my camp or the town
Town
The World will end before rockstar makes undead nightmare for rdr 2 and red dead redemption 3 with micah protagonist
is it worth it to get the most expensive horse
so should i just donate my money to camp?
All of it.
no don't do that lol
Who would want that second one
Most people wouldnât complete it, because theyâd just kill themself over and over since theyâre playing as Micah
Sorry if it's been asked in here before, but do yall think the guess is correct that some people have said about the gangs old camp being on that small hill directly north of blackwater
Lol
Do yâall actually play online? I played it for like 5 months but itâs just so fucking annoying now.
is it me or does john's hat's name change
in the wardrobe it's called John's Classic Hat
but in the horse it's called John's Cowboy Hat
With friends its pretty fun
Thanks to this game I become really anxious when someone coughs in public transportation
JOHN
if rockstar makes story mode dlcs i will cry out of happiness
Iâd die from happiness
Reply if u hate Micah
Anyway, is there a specific time of day the stranger mission âHeâs British, Of Courseâ can be accessed
Because I know some stranger missions can only be done at a certain time
Is it just me or do i feel a bit of remorse for Mr Wrobel in the debt collecting quest
he just seemed like a nice guy
He weirdo
technically almost everyone that arthur went apeshit on over $50 debts were nice people but oh well
yeah but he seems do be doing fine, when you go there with sadie in the epilogue he is still living in that house
I accidentally took the wedding ring and he seemed so distraught
I had to restart, I couldnât do that
Silver MFT or Silver Turkoman
That depends
I mean Iâm cool with any horse if I have any connection
Horse I found that was attacked by the skinners? I take it in and nurture it and itâs my main horse for a long time
Was a shit horse when it came to stats
But still
Why is my Rose Gray Bay Arabian horse unusually brave
if they added two things to this game i wouldâve been so much happier
bank robberies
and duels
braveness doesnât exist wdym
Robbing a gunsmith seems like a bad idea
not really
if you have a tomahawk
itâs easy to rob
with no bounty no cops
But they have all the guns
Well thatâs dumb
Heâs got a wall of guns behind him that he doesnât use?
It really is
I guess theyâre locked in a case
what would he do with them
itâs 1899
itâs not like he has a maxim
Idk I feel like using a sawn off would be more effective at close range like that
Defend himself
So like should I get the turkoman or MFT
oh wait yeah youâre right
Just better gun choices
doesnât matter
get whatever you want
pick up a black arabian or an mft if you want speed a turkoman if you want health itâs red dead you can pick whatever you want as long as itâs not a morgan lol
Mft
Theyâre fast and have high health
Theyâre just not that strong but why would u need strength anyway
Theyâre more expensive tho
They donât have great acceleration though. But once you get up to top speed youâre really moving
Like the trains of horses
I recommend u donât by either
Save ur money and get the white Arabian for free
Itâs the fastest horse in the game I think
mft are the mvps
it's pretty much the best horse until chapter 4... or unless u get the black arabian from the random encounter
What random encounter
there's a street robbery in saint dennis where u can get a black arabian for free.. which otherwise cant be had until chapter 4 at the saint dennis stable
Oh what
I didnât know that
I had the black Arabian horse until I finished the game in chapter 6
I had tears in my eyes when he died
Yeah but it disappears when you die
Don't know what happens if you stable it before dying
ride to stable...
when u enter a stable, both ur main horse and temp horse follow u inside
Even if it is your main horse it still disappears
It's like the game knows you shouldn't have it
that's completely false, i just replayed story mode
got the black arabian for arthur in chapter 2
thatâs just a lie mate
the game doesnât know you shouldnât have it
the game doesnât give a shit
Idk what to tell you, that's what happened to me
fuck load mods if you want to as long as itâs story mode rockstar doesnât give a fuck
Twice
TWICE? your game bugged lmao
In different playthroughs
Two times I got that Arabian, two times it got replaced by a Tenesse Walker
The games trying to tell you something....
sure the horse didn't just actually die before you got it to a stable 
I completed RDR2!
have some tissues
if you could have an extra option in rdr2
when you approach dutch
an option appears, called: "BETRAY"
(the option is only available in chapter 6 logically but it would be funny if it was in the other chapters too)
would kinda fuck with the pacing
Iâm going to try to go to tumbleweed in chapter 4
good luck 
Hey guys, i want to create the original John (rdr1) anyone know a video on yt tutorial for it?
Mods
Sure! Search up something called Mods! That'll surely help you.
Now that I completed red dead should I get a trainer cuz I'm bored
And spawn grizzlies
Just get some mods
there's a lot of good ones
like bounties
duels
etc
catalog which is gonna be back soon
can get NPC clothing
Hey, does anybody know if I start the parakeet quest in the main game if I'm able to finish it in the epilogue?
I was able to get something that somewhat resembles him:
- Middle Parted 4 or 5 (right parted 5 with overshirt spread without hat)
- Try to get his weight at perfect or at least a bit above that
- For his cowboy outfit, switch out the cassimere shirt for a white everyday shirt/overshirt and his ranch pants for black striped town pants, and add black kneller rider spurs to give somewhat give that ranch pant illusion or whatever and for boots arthurs boots look more accurate
dont have any yt vid sorry
The mission where you kill the murfeys in the cave is terrifying
It is. Interestingly enough, I found all the gang hideouts well before I came across the story missions to clear them. At least for the O'driscolls, Micah mentions it on your second mission with him, for example.
How do i buy the fire bottles?
Is it possible to hold up an entire saloon?
Fence
Anyone else think that the epilogue could've utilized more of the expanded map in the story missions?
Like, they went through the trouble of recreating half the map of the original game but only utilized like 1/6 of it
Need help
Need to see Dutch in Rhodes but whenever I get near the mission icon it becomes locked
And when I go away it becomes unlocked
this is exactly why i want a pc
Help pls I wanna do his mission and it won't let me
person learns to wait 17 seconds (no way this happened!!!) (not clickbait)
By any chance, do u have a bounty on u? I know one time I had a bounty on me and while bounty hunters were tracking me I ran into rhodes and it messed up the rhodes missions for several days
I mean I left the Braithwaite house and I noticed on the map j saw bounty hunters
And yes in near every state I see on the map lol
One in strawberry bc of micah, one in valentine bc of Cornwall and Rhodes I'm not sure actually
Do I rlly have to pay it off
I mean I have the money it's just annoying
Ya what I'd reccomend doing is waiting several in game days and next time make sure there's absolutely no bounty hunters chasing u
Should I go to camp and just constantly sleep?
No u don't have to, u just gotta wait a day or 2 for rhodes to chil lout
I think the game only allows you to sleep through one day so I guess try it and see if it's cooled off after one day
Alr I might get these plants keiran needs for his horse and might see about getting that white arabian horse I think that's what its called
Alr
It's def an annoying feature
Well F me!!! Just nabbed the panther-EXTREMELY QUICKLY-Dropped it off to Pearson-NO PANTHER DROPPED OFF!
So I saved immediately after grabbing it. UUUuuuhhhhhhh well I did but I guess the game didn't like it. 1 cover scent, 1 potent bait and 1 panther GONE!!! HAHAHAHAHAHAH That's what I get for not spending an hour straight on it I guess.
calm down bro
You're fucking weird. Have a great Halloween!!!
Shut the fuck up thats why i fucked your mom and made your dad leave. Have a great Halloween!!!
calm down bro
im beating passive agressive with passive aggresive
Hey can somebody help me with a technical issue?
arthur must craft if from pearson... but if ur in the epilogue, it's at the fences
more or less, yea
Maybe?? I can try bc I had issues at first.
When you're playing as John. Fence has them all and I think you have ro buy them in order from top to bottom. It's very pricey unless you're good that way.
after chapter 6, u enter the epilogue.. u play as john then
or just complete epilouge
After ch 6. You have a massive fight where Dutch shows up and it's pretty clear that any play after will NOT be with Arthur.
TUBCALOSIS
HAHAHAHA "1 blocked message ------Show message" Love me some block action!!
man what are you on about
chill
go to #roles first lol
We're golden. My posting nothing in violation of any rules is def good to go. Thanks for your input-YOU ROCK!!
OK So I guess it was my bad?? I thought Pearson knew how to extract a pelt from a carcass. Is this not the case? Pretty sure trapper can, too, no? Anyone know?
what should i upgrade in my camp?
was more just about how erratic you sound, also I think giving Pearson a carcass doesnât skin it
I think you're right. I am pissed. If it came across that way then GOOD! I believe it did so my ability to transfer my frustration through text worked! No9 reason to calm shit, it's frustrating af! Nabbing the panther within like the first 3 tries is unheard of for me. But now the game is reloading me in the area I saved WITH the ca on the horse but no cat. Also no cat is spawning so I likely need to do the whole wait 2-3 days bs trick. Very frustrating.
Hello guy
"I give you mercy, you mistake it for weakness. Now I'm gonna show you strenght, and you may mistake it for brutality."
Are the bugs with the unholstering your weapons still in the game or the outfit bug
I am experiencing a glitch in the sheeps and the goats mission where when i get to the wagon my game glitches so i cant pick up struaus does anyone know how to fix this P.S. i am on ps4
I was walking around camp (in chaper 3) and Dutch says something along the lines of "You will betray me in the end, Arthur. You're the type." Like Dutch, isn't that a bit too much foreshadowing
First time I ever heard of it try restarting from a check point and if that doesnât work restart the game
so i cant die untill i get to the wagon but when i do die and reset or leave or checkpoint my game freezes ive done the mission over 60 times
Hold on Iâll start up my game and replay the mission if I havenât already
its in chapter 2
I can only assume itâs a glitch that rockstar wonât fix
And itâs a main story mission too
yeah i can barely play it
Iâm gonna be honest if this is true and I know rockstar wonât fix it Iâm just gonna stop playing RDR2
Online too if they donât give a shit about their game I wonât either
ok
settle down yter pfp
just found out i cant change my outfit without glitching
I just read his post dear lord the cringe
Thatâs something that happens from saving outfits too quickly that got me too at one point
oh
Yeah been a long time glitch
I mentioned it here
@inner scroll
@inner scroll Iâm at that point about to find out whatâs going on
i just checked my signal strength which is 59
I just did the part your glitching on I got through just fine but what is signal strength? I mean what are you referring too @inner scroll
Yeah just got through that part you were mentioning just fine and what are you referring to by signal strength
internet
hey can anyone whos familiar with the rdr2 story give me a bit of a recap from where i am?
havent played in 3 months
not a FULL recap just a little bit of what happened prior
Where are you in the story?
just got to the island out in the middle of no where, have no idea how i got here...
guarma
Oh bank robbery in Saint Denis went wrong, gang fled on a boat, boat sank and ended up in Guarma
ok thanks a bunch that jogged my memory
Mhm np
i just got back into playing and when i loaded into story i was like ???? island???? middle of no where???
haha
Do I get more plumes from clean kills ?
Noted
Played "house of borsodi's" theme from witcher 3 during shootout in the poker ship
Fits the situation so well
Setting is pretty much the same ; you're there to rob the place where rich people gather, you're posing a different personality, and your cover blows up and you fight guards to escape the place
You also have 3 companions with you
Geralt, elf girl, hobbit, borsodi's brother
Arthur, Javier, Strauss, Trelawny
Roger Clark should be getting a ton of work
Such a great performance
He slipped under the radar unfortunately
rdr2 players after literally anything: "So mUch deTaIL vEry appreciated gAme đ"
horse balls/shit: Extreme atttentioonnn to detailzz!
Can we appreciate the fact that if you press a the horse moves omg attention to detail is amazing
I think he's doing his own story narration audio stuff.
Nah f that-Let's get cyberpunked HAHAHAHAHAH Much better. HAHAHAHAHAHA Even better let's bounce all over the place with fortblech! AWESOME!!!!
Micah rat lumbago insist ynnel shoar munneh boah plan dutch villain đ¤Łđ¤Ł
i have no idea what i just read
I wish I didn't understand those words
Hes speaking the language of gods
Do you guys know whether itâ possible to keep the machete and the pirate sword at the same time or does the game forces you to drop one of them after picking up the other because Iâm a bit scared that Iâm going to loose my nice looking sword after buying the machete at the fence and not beeing able to get it again?
jesse, what the fuck you talkin about
Love headbutting saint Denis cops if Arthur says "what you're looking at boy"
I think that you can keep them at the same time if you get the pirate sword first and then buy the machete (don't steal it from enemies). If it gets lost, you should still be able to find it on your horse
Thank you sounds good
arthoor morgun
Impostor
hi
howdy now
Craft what?
Put it in #general-media
Oh yeah thatâs weird
Is the scout fire giving you the option to craft/cook?
You sure itâs the scout fire?
Go try the other fire
There should be a second campfire that has a bunch of chairs scattered around it
Weird
Must be a glitch
Or you have to upgrade the fire first
Thereâs a third fire then
Itâs little and it doesnât have chairs
I think itâs near the horses
Towards the exit to camp
You canât craft at the stew pot because thereâs stew there
There are technically 3 fires
The main one with the chairs, the stew fire, and the scout fire
Yay it worked!
Glad I could help
Yeah that should be it
There's a Lucas that contacted me. In DM. I can't respond unless we're "Friends".
Rdr1 needs some variety to the gameplay. Every mission turns into a shootout
Same with rdr2 75% of the missions turn into shootouts
Yeah I guess. The shooting mechanics are a lot more fun in the second game though.
"god damnit"
"hosea"
"HOSEA GOD DAMN IT KILL THOSE BASTARDS"
Oke
But itll cost 950 dollars
Nice
Finnally a horse to get back to the Arabic after I killed it the 8th time
And how long I have to walk for max bondage
?
Bro i play for 3 hours daily my horse is lucky if brush or feed it
Even if i feed my horse and care for it, it always bucks me off by the smallest snake nearby even if i calm it 
Arabian moment
Yeah, it actually is the white arabian 
Recently completed the story, gonna play through it again for grandmother to watch since she loves westerns. Ready for that good ole red dead depression
Damn, i hope you and your grandma enjoy the second playthru, Goodluck
SAME LOL
me looking up rdr2 ships to see how bad the bad side of the community is:
"oh god"
"O H G O D"
O H N O
I mean you searched for it now suffer
Arthur x Hosea
landon x john
guys i need help
I'm trying to do the Gambler 8 challenge on RDR2. I need to win in Blackjack with 3 or more cards

I did, but it didn't count
I canât do the first bandit challenge
Everyone I try to rob pulls a gun out on me
Maybe itâs because Iâm trying to rob people on horses
in my opinion that one random encounter in the Grizzlies with the Tucker guy is super sad
it's pretty much luck... hope for an ace and other low cards and just keep hitting
Rob some city folk or people without gunbelts. You can also try grabbing them and then robbing
That works for me
You have to ask for 3 or more cards
lol the look arthur gives at the table when he's at aberdeen pig farm
who is shipped?
If I get arrested is the money taken from me the same amount as my bounty or more?
80 percent of your bounty
11/10
Micah Destroys the gang 11/10 ship would reccomend
Micah is good guy right ? (:
Whatâs the most expensive/best thing you can get at the Rhodes general store? The snake bite guy is pfferigg bc
Offering*
Went with the Earl outfit
Micah x Dutch is superior đ
Have a perfect wolf pelt. Who do I give it to? Pearson or a trapper?
How much money have you got?
200$
Yeah give it to Pearson
Thanks!
Legend of the east satchel be like
Yeah I just restarted my playthrough today and everything I hunt is going to Pearson for awhile
i have only played on PS4 and was recently given a xbox by someone who moved. Is it basically the same experience or should I download it?
john x Jack
John Marston x Jim Milton x Rip van Winkle
the virgin john or the chad landon ricketts
the virgin john.
chad Ricketts
Tbh I named my extra social media accounts rip van Winkle in honor of that line in rdr2
Degenerates like you belong on a cross
^fallout new vegas reference so dont attack him mods
What the fuck man
jack isnt johns son tbh
jack is arthurs son, thats why arthur is a better father figure to jack than john
Arthur is Jack's son.
depends what you want to craft with it
Whereâs the proof that Jack is Arthurâs son?
Damn, spoilers đ

Hey guys, does anyone having micro stuttering with DX12 or Vulkan on ultra settings with RTX 3090 ?
i have 17k in story mode. what should i buy
Everything
Literally anything and everything
Arthur is just a better father figure (but really he only takes him on a fishing trip and treats him kindly like every other fan member) because he misses his own son, and John canât really relate to Jackâs life experiences at all
Ok
There's also the underlying concern that Jack might not actually be Johns kid 
Not sure if they ever nailed it in stone that John is definitely jacks father 
Nice pfp
events that led up to the events of rdr 1 and rdr2:
rdr2: dutch killing heidi mccourt
rdr1: john killing micah and him using his real name in bank records
jack and John look super similar + their hair texture is basically the same so itâs implied to hell and back that heâs the legitimate father
It still adds to why things between Jack and John aren't all buddy buddy, pretty sure it was the reason John left the gang for a year as well 
Ah, it's not exactly stated as a reason, but it would make sense if John had doubts about it that he'd seperate to prepare for the challenge of raising a kid, let alone one that might not be his 
I was spoilering it 
No and honestly it might be that if they ever want to do something with Jack in rdr3 it could possibly be Jack trying to figure out who could be his real father
Jack is a reskined John in rdr1. John is def his dad.
does it really matter who his father is, john raised him (at least from 6ish) so he is jacks father
Yup
Yes it does
Like you was someone elses child and some woman steals you from them
You will get depressed
Not sure how he'd do that tho. Not like they had DNA testing. .....and seeing as she was with the entire gang, idk how he'd figure that out
Even if john isnt the bio father, he is still is an adoptive father, which would still make him jacks father. And its not like any other paternal figures wanted to raise jack
Jack is Pearsonâs son, this is indisputable
^hafta wait and see what happens with Jacks hairline, and waistline in rdr3 đ
RDR3 is a pipe dream
hot take: i hope rdr3 has nothing to do with the gang, kinda like that mafia series, where you see some of the characters from the other games but its about completely new characters
yeah
but like
what would it even be
itâd be difficult to make it anything more than RDR2 with better graphics
maybe a revenant style game would be sick
Seems pretty obvious imo if they ever make an rdr3, it'll be about jack.
how
But I don't like speculation on that shit tbh. Waste of time
maybe but they put themselves in a pretty shitty spot for jack
yeah but its a good conversation starter, almost everyone has an opinion on it
you are right tho, its not good to create false expectations, it has killed many games
I wish rdr2 had NG+
probably never gonna do a 2nd playthrough because I suffered 100% walkthrough in my first
sorry for late answer, but I won a game with 4 cards and 21 points
and I didn't make progress on the challenge
That moment when you antagonize someone in Van Horn 
I should stop going there for Gambler 3
I did it anyways
so
does anyone know if I can complete Gambler 4 as Arthur?
I think it's "Win a hand of Poker in ever location"
there's only like 5 pokers and you only have to do 3
yes, you can
niiiice
Flatnek station, Valentine and Saint Denis
Ok cool
legend of the east as Arthur speedrun

I'm already 51% done the game lol
on Chapter 3
Why?
did someone here the Gambler 8?
Thereâs no need for this really. Itâs not a game where you collect tons of loot and gear that makes you more powerful. You could use the weapons given to you in the story and be fine.
I mean it's still Grindy af
challenges and weapon equipment
Outfits
Unlockable weapons
You donât have to do any of that
yeah
And? 100% was hard to get
Still grinding those fucking Perfect Badgers BTW
still havent found any
Its been 2 weeks
Fair enough
I found like 50 trying to get a oppossum lmao
I alternate my playthroughs. First Iâll do almost everything on the map, and next time Iâll stick to the story without deviating much
dammit
Me neither lol, they were just what we used
OH FUCK
sorry

wrong server

We're talking about chemistry on another server
lol
I'm also still trying to do Master Hunter
but finding Black Bears is kinda hard
especially when you forget that thats what the challenge is and get off-track
if I have 18 (J and 8) on blackjack and I ask for an extra card and it be a 2, I'll have 20. If the croupier burst with 25, is it supposed to count as a win in the Gambler 8?
because I did it 2 times and it didn't count
not as tedious as find 5 cougars and kill them with a bow
internet issue
there's a spot east of valentine that spawns grizzly bears, I think it counts for this challenge
yeah
I'd like black bears though because I need to fully enter them into the conpendium
I havent tracked them yet
I see
You haven't found a black bear wtf

Its always the one I forget
I'm just trying to complete the Gambler challenges but that Gambler 8 is driving me crazy
study the animal = tracking i thought
Just git lucky then
nope, have to actually track them
I have to won with 3 or more cards isn't it?
either the animal itself or the trail will do
because I think I already did it
Well I got 100% animal completion many times just fine by just studying and killing with correct weapon
at least 3?
There's a lot of luck based rdr2 challenges
can I send a print screen link here?
hunt 5 cougars and kill with bow except finding the cougars was the hardest part
Oh did I tell you guys about the time I won a double-down with $1? I literally yelled out "Luck is on my fucking side today!" (I then lost most of it, in ironic fashion)
idk I found that easy because I found all them by just doing other challenges and stuff
The problem was for me is that master hunter was one of my last challenge lists 
And I didn't want to do herbalist or gambler
or hunting requests
small brain
lol
win with 5 cards or more
I have to finish with at least 5 cards

fastest way to do the challenge is when you know you aren't gonna get 5 cards and pass you leave the table and come back, like when your on card 3 and the numbers like 17-19(sometimes you can get double 2's but super unlikely)
I did gambler 8 in like 2 hours I guess Iâm lucky
Same
Without any tricks or anything
One day I just did all 3 wins in one day lmao
lol
Win 3 whole domino games in a row
and then gambler 10 I thought was gonna be like "win 13 FFF while your controller is upside down and blindfolded"
But it's easy with replay missions
lmao gambler 10 was extremely easy
I cant play dominoes
I just replayed that boat mission
I dont know howwww
I'm trying since yesterday but I think I would have at least 1/3 now if I had read that like a human being
Yea I didnt know how to play until gambler 9 so I had to learn an entire game for a rdr2 challenge
all 3 and 5 are such bullshit
"win 3 hands of poker in a row..."
How did the boat mission help?
u play poker bru
because the boat mission makes it so ur guaranteed to win
Strauss cheats for you
I read that the Gambler 10 is easy to do because you can go to Flatnek Station and make all-wins until you complete
true but that costs a bit of money by spamming all in
How would that help lol
Ikr
Waste of money
it's win 3 pokers IN A ROW
But sometimes you need to flaunt and trick them
Idk if folding counts against the win 3 in a row
Oh did you mean Arthur folding or-?
Ye
I might be misreading some things
Oh ok
I was talking abotu everyone else folding exept for Arthur
I restarted a playthrough and I really want to do all the challenges this time
Also hunt all the legendaries
100% completion Speedrun
imagine if gambler 8 was in a row
pain
everyone would be stuck on 98.8% then 
That counts towards full completion?
Oh does anyone know when the Gunslinger mission line continues?
Yeah all of the challenges
I did them all a while back
I want to say itâs some time in to chapter 6
you can do the entire gunslinger mission in like chapter 4 I think lol
Chapter 4
dude in saloon
Oh yeah you canât max out your cores without doing them
sad
I still havenât finished them :/
Iâm doing herbalist no
Now*
I finished gambler bandit and explorer
how did you finish gambler before herbalist
I started with gambler
suffer first
I felt different
I started with the hardests too
But by the time gambler is completed I feel like sharpshooter and weapon expert would have been completed
But at least it's not left off like right before 100% completion
100% completation requires 100% compendium?
I still have 3 more stranger missions until I get 100% (night folk, rock carvings, bones)
No I donât think so
No
Because there are animals in guarma you can study
thank god
100% compendium requires skin of guarma animals too?
Yooooo Arthur can play piano???
Nice we got something in common for once!
This song should play when arthur dies change my mind
See you again
Perhaps
It was wrote when paul walker died so maybe
He means in like heaven when you die youll see him again
Bold of you to assume he's going to heaven
My arthur is
yep.
Yeah he did a lot of bad things
He tried, in the end though
Shoot fellas as need shootin, feed fellas as need feedin, and kill those that need killinh
we have to give him that
but we have to give him canonical credit for trying to turn it around...
And...he really did his best, it just wasn't enough.
I donât think Thomas Downes deserved to get beaten to death
And the lawmen he killed while robbing a bank
Realisticly he did kill alot
But what about when he killied the slave owner, or all the odriscolls, or SAVING JOHN
thats true, but the bad still outweights the good
but still see you again doesnt fit.
ofc.
No, arthur found good in him and did what he could
When he hurt Mr.Downes he helped Edith and saved her and gave her money and helped everyone survive
what abt the things he did before.
Arthur went to heaven as he found god essentally
And Micha went to hell change my mind
lenny should have never told dutch that micah was in jail
every saint has a past and every sinner a future
micah def went to hell.
he went to heaven 
John went to heaven
No. Arthur didn't ask for forgiveness or penance, he accepted what had happened, and decided that, instead of turning his life around, he'd try and save the others lives.
He killed sure but he killed micha so yk that helps allot
john went 6ft below the ground
arthur goes to hell in my opinion
same bruv.
Exactly my point went to heaven
Just because he killed Micah doesnt change where he goes in the afterlife
look how many cops arthur killed
and people who gets in his way or threatens his gang
Anyone Know a Good place To farm horses?
what.
Wdym?
I mean Like
Beachers hope

alr.
Oh yes lake isabella
Alright
White Arabian near lake isabella
Ah okay Thank you
Mustang?
I still havenât gotten the horse, Iâm using buel
The white arabina horse?
Yeah itâs pretty good
No, he went to hell, He didn't ask God for forgivness, and many of his past acts could not have been forgiven anyways. I understand that it's sad knowing that he must have gone to hell, but that's the way it is I'm afraid.
whats the real name of that horse
nvm ill just call it mustang
Arthur went to dine in the great hall of Sovngarde
he foreshadowed the way he wanted to be buried
Idk I never got the horse


