#red-dead-singleplayer
1 messages · Page 494 of 1
sell wild araaabianas
I’m going to do a platinum run but I don’t know which trophies are missable
Can anyone help?
hit up treasures and gold locations
i already got black arabian, shud i keep or sell the white one
Keep
so you have 2 black arabian
About to say you can just stable and equip the saddle
Arabians are pretty overated, you should get a turkoman
Saying Arabians are overrated is a normie position to take
W as you should
Meanwhile Arabians will always get lots more votes in horse poles then other horses and there's still 9999 posts a day on "hOw to Get wHiTe ArABiAn"
horse poles??? there are horse poles?????
Hey how many "rare" weapons are there?
I got the rare shotgun anf the rolling block so far.
Auto correct from polls to poles
I never knew there was the rare shotgun, only the rolling block. news to me
Now they're pretty good for racing, and they look nice, but really they're scared of everything and is why I like the turkoman better.
Since the Turk is still a pretty fast horse, and also good with contact
I mean does elite handling actually make a difference 
I really can't tell
The better horses have standard handling anyway
The arabian I had for about a couple of hours before I got the Turkoman had elite handling, but my Turk I have now has normal or whatever it is
I haven't noticed a difference
"Handling is essentially what class the horse is; Standard is often the most common, featuring average speed and stamina cores, Race means the horse is faster, but can get worn out quicker, Heavy is slow, steady and trustworthy, and the Elite class gives you a high stamina core with medium speed." @hushed flare
i like turkomans but for riding they are sooooo stiff
Just in case one bites the dust
Speaking of which make sure u have horse reviver and medicine on u at all times
I lost the black raven shire cu, of being an idiot
And not restocking
or just get a horse better then arabian
👍
I'm fine with that since it's great under fire and its pretty fast
To each their own
I just dislike the size of arabians
Feel to small
Black raven one is gorgeous
Lemme search it
thoroughbred best
I had the Black Dappled throughbred but it died and it wasn't my fault
still pissed about it
reverse black dappled?
thoroughbred fans on their way to claim there free special edition thoroughbred every playthrough
lol
its really a cool horse
Which ever one you get with the special edition
ya that one
I prefer keeping the tenesse walker from chap 1 so the end really hits hard
But honestly I have a gold turko man mixed with white and I love it rn
true
Also to be clear we all have played the game through right
I have
No need for spoiler warnings
I'm on my second play through chapter 4 rn
im on third playthrough
I had the game reached chapter 3 them got a fake spoiler
about to do Our best selves
And i was like well no point playing the game and i looked up a story summary
:P
So technically im on my first play through chapter 4
who ruined the experience for you
L
me
U guys know that one video where he hangs all the bad guys
its treason then
I got that recommended
Can you hang people in rd2
imagine thinking there’s no point in playing the game because of a spoiler
For some reason my brain tjought oh so ur a traitor and then thought no point playing the game
Im dumb mate
? like in saint denis
Lol
yes i did
Did anyone else wait til like chapter 4 to go to Saint Denis
I rode near it, the swamp area mainly
but I was like, you know, lets just go there when the mission needs me too
anyone 100% the game here?
I did first play through I think
cap
I finished it in 2019
Reached there escaping the cops in the first train robbery
then didnt play rd2 til last moth since I got it on my xbox
With sean charles and john
I went for Jacky boy
jack is ugly in rdr1
I got rd2 on ps4 in 2019, finished it, and never played again. But now I downloaded it last month on my xbox
facts
Quick question
What are molasses used for irl
Its a geography question i have to answer and im too lazy to look it up
huh
Homework
I think syrup
Mhm
something like that
Need one more
I explored most of the map in chapter 2. Getting to Saint Denis to the first time was one of my favourite parts
Also at first I thought Van Horn was a ghost town lol
ik man but m in chp 2,
Np
Oh well when your able to get one you should buy it
Also I would switch to the Thoroughbred you can buy in Valentine @willow vortex
Van Horn is super boring. Mainly that whole side other than Saint Denis
ok i have it
Van Horn sure turns into a ghost town once i roll through there.
The horse?
Also you know how hard it is when an NPC is being a jerk but you cant do anything because you want high honor
yes i think
Yeah, gotta keep up the honor untill i unlock the extra outfits
that too, but as Johnny i can finally commit crimes against humanity.
I just punch him and run away
Doesn't make me lose honor
the game is so vast for just on e playthrough
And besides you lose so little honor you can get it back in like 5 mins vía saying hi to NPCS
yes
then after fishing you try to return to camp and you get attacked by outlaws on the way
Thats what I say
Arthur is definitely better with high honor it fits his character
John is better low honor
sense it fits his character better
Author 🗿
Can anyone tell me the best hair level for og Marston in rdr2 on ps4
I am confused if it is 5 or 6 or 7
middle parted 4 or 5 with hat, right parted 5 with overshirt to spread it without hat
Ah thanks
i think 6 without hat middle parted and prob 5 with hat, plus pomade
which makes his hair browner
Idk I just go with the longest hair tbh
Depends on the what fashion you wanna wear
I think long hair on 6 is the best
Longest lvl 7, right parted faded.
hey i found a thorough bred in forest shud i keep or nah?
Is it good
i never understood sheriff malloy's "secret"
is that he killed his lover?
is that is very "dark secret?"
that means you missed it, oof.
its a missable item, only found in a story mission
in chapter 3
You don't use shotguns that much since you are more likeable to use the revolver on any situation. But its always nice to have a shotgun
Guess you could say that 
Maxim gun meta
yeah just stash that on there
OMFG
GUYS
I JUST
got a school assignment
on fashion from 1901
its PERFECT
Epic win
i only use a shotgun when an npc horse crashes into my horse :)
Well thats your fault 90% of the times
no
well actually yes
idk why i get mad if it's my fault lmao

i don't care about losing honour when that happens
i do all types of satanic things to those npc's
history!
That makes sense
I’m taking modern euro history, so naturally we just started a unit on George Washington’s mistreatment of the Iroquois Native Americans
It doesn’t make sense
help my mom gave me a shirt and it says "cornwall" on the shirt
Burn it
lol
Epic winning
We also have a long term sub so that may be why our unit is weird
imagine dying to a coward and to tuberculosis 
Holy shit there's a camp event where Mrs Downes shows up and pays Strauss the rest of the debt
Did not know this Till now
Micah Belle trolls me once again 😭
also, imagine dying as leaving your barn and getting shot up by a 80 year old goverment agent 
Did anyone else know about this lmao
yes
YouTube exists
lol
Well shit lol
Wait why though doesn't arthur collect the rest after the valentine bank robbery?
You just managed to spoil an entire franchise in two discord messages while still being really vague about it
no
They can’t pay bc Thomas died
I specifically remember Mrs Doenes handing arthur money though lol
Remember when he was like "I'll keep her in black on your behalf"
"Ah ms Downes thank you for your punctuality etc etc
Ah you've encountered the Mandela effect
we just need more goddamn money
cuz that doesnt actually happen
loved that quote
Lmfao
WAIT WTF
yeah
she hands him the money
it's memory error aka Mandela effect
That's why he says thank you
going blank
yeah
OK yall are trippin lol
Did u know monopoly man has no monocle
no arthur
He literally says thank you and puts the money in his pocket
tell dutch to go f*ck himself
Never
trolled 2 hard
jesus
epic gaslight
Bruh
kill @hushed flare
Don't fuck with my head like that lmao
But Monopoly man has no monocle still
I stay using my Pump Action 24/7
Thought I was going nuts
lmao
Lmfao
Yeah I know that one lmao
y'all whats your favourite soundtrack from rdr2
Good ole Lancaster and Pumpaction. Sometimes I'll use duel Volcano pistols. Or I'll use a Lancaster, Springfield, and duel shot guns
The one where your building the house any day
Probably either the disaster or Jim Milton Rides Again
Thats the way hits hard
One of them is the annesburg wanted theme that sounds like our best selves
a m e r i c a n v e n o m
how is that a question
American venom became repetitive music for me
same
There's this wanted theme that pops up sometimes that isn't the traditional wanted theme. It has like a piano
its always in my mind
Don't know what it is though
Ambarino?
Nah. It kinda sounds like the music at fort wallace when dutch leaves arthur
Got that same piano
our best selves is really good man
Well haven't played that mission in a fat minute so idk
It's like a steady piano dun dun dun dun dun dun
Ambarino combat music is the creepiest. Quite fitting.
Ah yes the classic "music that goes like Doo Doo Doo Doo" 
Epic way to find songs u like on yt

But the wanted songs should have been much more intense.
no
Yeah the wanted theme default is kinda underwhelming tbh
it gives good vibe

And New Austin should have had unique ambient soundtracks.
Annesburg has best wanted theme imo
It does.
Best town to massacre cuz of the difficulty also
Question: Who was the worst one?, Micah Bell (Killed arthur) or Edgar ross (Killed john)
rip
i recently had a situation where guards literally swarmed me in annesburg, killed like 40 of them all around me.
Edgar Ross, i personally absolutely hate him.
I also wish Arthur had his own signature theme. John has that signature tune you hear in American venom and other songs involving John, Sadie has her own. Arthur has never had that defining theme
That makes you think of him
Outlaws from the west
And John's The Shootist/American Venom
That's the more the van Der linde gang theme though
Fits Arthur Morgan
average armadillo massacrer noob
vs average valentine/saint denis massacrer fan
vs average annesburg massacrer enthusiast 
Yup and outlaws from the west
Like you know how when you save John in the beginning from the wolves you hear American venom for like a split second?
no
hardest one tho
i just like to massacre the entire town of blackwater in rdr2 epilogue
Easiest one where law spawns is either Strawberry or Tumbleweed
bruh, there is no cover in annesburg
guards and police come from every single way
American Venom is the most tragic mission in both games tbh
Blackwater swarms with marshalls after you kill off the police department, so i'd say it's pretty hard too, but unlike annesburg it has a lot of good cover.
There's that one high point where you kill Pinkerton's with dutch u can use
And also some lawmen carry carcano rifles so that's nice
bridge
Unlike other towns where you can camp on a roof the entire time this one is harder to do
wait wtf
or camp in saint denis police dept
Building camping
lmfao
imagine watching sadie's a$$ for 5 minutes then getting punched by jealous bill williamson
I mean once i had a day long shootout in game but left the console on for 3 days
then screen goes black and u were kicked from camp
forever...
so only one day then
One in-game day
48 mins
No 3 days in game was the one in saint denis pd
Bill's got no time for woman.
1 day long is the one where i left my console on for too long
bill is gay
you could cook eggs on it.
did u try it
Nope, probably would taste like shit
no he is not
me on my way to eat breakfast with console cooked Sunnyside up
legendary bear 2.0
bill is allende's boyfriend though
no
yes
bill is gay
Micah is chad
of course
delete this shit
Micah is god
its the truth
lol

lol
loL
bru
bru
edit to bruh when
bru
bruH
no i just say "bru"
k
alr y'all tripping
k
shut noob
Mods watching the edit logs rn
i'm afraid i can't let you do that.
what if i...
ping....
t h e o w n e r
ah there is no owner 😭
@keen birch
can i swear in this server? @keen birch
ah yes, then i get banned because of swearing
but he can't answer my damn question rn
thank u bot
Been thinkin' about this. The entire story of RD2 is basically just one big foreshadow of American Venom
What are Arthur's two signature sayings?
"Run, and don't look back" and "Revenge is a fools game"
yes
Those two quotes basically sum up the entirety of the downfall of the gang. Dutch's lust for revenge
Which seals John's fate
It's all one big forshadowing of John's fate
Well it kinda is a recurring theme in the series
John takes revenge for Arthur by killing Micah, which gets the feds on him and results in his death. Then Jack takes revenge for John by killing Agent Ross...
Going back and killing Micah was the worst thing John ever did. All of the progress and development he made of escaping that life, all of the sacrifices, Abigail leaving him and John building her a house to show that he's changed. Everything they did, Arthur did, was pissed away for what?
Revenge
Empty revenge
not empty
the tragedy of the whole story
Yeah given how Micah lived he would have likely gotten caught and hung for his crimes eventually
What did it do? It changed nothing. DIdn't bring Arthur back, and it in fact made it easier for the feds to eventually find John
they found john like one week after he killed micah lmao
Yeah but it looks like they waited a couple years to kidnap his family lol
Yeah even the newspapers talk about it being John that killed by Micah lol
for whatever reason
I have a theory as to why they waited
they wanted to plan it right
they waited like a good 3-4 years though
Not really. It mentions that he was betrayed by his own gang
Ironic
like it was a while
then again we don't know how long it took them to actually find John
Also we don't know how much time it took them to find John
they was planning and they finally got to a conclusion: "lets kidnap marstons family and force marston to kill his friends and mentor"
we only know what we saw in the credits
"after that we give him his family back and we raid him 2 days after"
And the most fucked up thing is they were using Micah to track down the rest of the gang before John killed him
Why do you think Micah was like join us John
he was gunna turn him over to the pinkertons
if that would happen micah would have gotten killed right after he gave john and dutch to pinkertons
I think Ross had already spent years trying to find Dutch, Bill, and Javier, and failed. After having no real leads, they finally turned to Marston
yeah just like they did with John
Well they only turned to Marston because Micah was dead
they were using Micah
john also took a while to find them
javier was a coward, i think he was running away when john was trying to find him
if i remember right
once they found out John killed him he was the closest lead to a remaining gang member they had
so they chose him
During those 4 years of John at his ranch I feel as if Ross was in the midst of finding Dutch, Bill, and Javier. After coming to no conclusions they decided to use John to do their dirty work.
They likely kept John around as plan B if they couldn't catch them themselves
So glad they changed him in the second game.
If arthur hadn't confronted Downes what would the plot of RDR1 be
John would have had to go after Arthur
Damn
That was like Javiers thing in the first game. Instead of fighting he would use his charms to get away. It even worked on John.
phisically
So Thomas Downes is responsible for RDR1 and Chapter 3 and Beyond
no
leopold strauss is
and dutch
and micah
Nah the gang is
The gang were the ones lending money to desperate people
All comes back to them
leopold enjoyed doing that
So they took his family, possibly arrested him as well, and put him in Sisika until they decided to give him the deal that would supposedly allow him to get his family back. So Ross and Fordham traveled with John from Saint Denis to Blackwater via Ferry so John could get on that train to Armadillo so John could get Bill first. This explains why John arrived on a Ferry in the beginning of RDR1.
it was so satisfying to kick him out of camp
you can actually find strauss riding away from camp
i think it's a glitch but it happened to me
i had max honor, i threw a molotove at him
and i lost half of my honour
I remember I kicked him out of camp during a low honor playthrough and I was so pissed when my honor went from max dishonor to almost High honor lmao
Some people say that John was returning from hunting Sadie or Charles
Yeah I heard that too
yeah, you could have just massacred an entire town
to have low honor again
I did lol
I massacred that camp with the people with like deformities
I forget the name
rip 99% of town population
OHH
butcher's creek?
i think?
i dont remember
Or rob trains
I'm doing a high honor playthrough where I help a lot of people when I journey
Yeah its that stranger mission with the posined water
yeah and then blow up the passenger train wagons lmao
that makes you lose a lot of honor
pov: arthur morgan has a playstation ❤️
he gets arrested
Nope
He gets hanged later on when taken by the Bureau
In rdr2 or 1
1
Oh then i do not care
oh you mean 2
Yes
Lenny's death was anticlimactic i feel like they just wanted to get rid of lenny
Hosea was just sad tho
ofc they wanted to
why do you think they got rid of sean
heart
Make it quick and painless you evil bastard
okay
They really do not give a damn about where a person is shot
Yeah
if it dies is what matters
So sad i mean at least sean got it in the head
someone has crow spawn for me?
tbh it was awkward
I forgot that lenny died so when i saw it im like the fuck wait what ok i guess
generic pain sound and drops to the ground
I need crow
Sean was funny tho
what
just look at sky
I found raven
or kill some animal and leave it on a open ground
This is why you die
But no crow
they will come eat the carcass
I’ll try
lmao
But are they crows or ravens?
both
I need crow
crows are a bit rarer
Crows and Ravens are different
Does it matter just kill something
After 15 h only crow left
Satisfy your bloodlust
I have good spot
Spawned 3 in 15 min
Whit quest
the small bridge in roanoke?
I think
High honor human
I was there after 2 min first spawn and then a fucking npc in my arrow
And second one I shot my bow
I shot a horse instead of an odriscoll once i will never live it down
Wich one?
Calloways so i cant drop it because its like the best revolver in game
Oke
Oke
I've killed over 100 horses
Get over it 
Idk why but I use two pistol all the time lol
Yoooo I got a question about a mission
Tell
Honor, Amongst Thieves
One of the optional missions that you can unlock by helping Captain Monroe during the mission Archaeology for Beginners
double M1899 plus chewing tabacco
?
Same
submachine gun before it was popular
I accidentally hit decline, do I gotta go back and naturally get that mission?
Oke
You'll have to restart the mission
What if I already had completed it?
Then there's no way to get it I think
Damn so I gotta get to a natural spot before doing Archaeology for Beginners


U want to search for Dino bones and u said now to the woman?
Archaeology for Beginners is the Rains Fall mission in chapter 6
Nah you're all good
But one of the optional missions in order to do Lending a Hand comes out of that, and I just fucked up and missed it
That sad
So I believe I'm just gonna have to cut my losses, continue my journey to getting platinum, and when Lending a Hand is the last trophy I need, I will load the closest save I had
Sounds like the best option
I entered a legendary animal territory but it said there was too much activity to hunt it, what do I do?
Ok thanks
Go a good distance away, and come back to it. "Hopefully" it will reset the area.
Or just leave and come back
If what I said didn't work, then yeah, try the camp/sleep trick.
Hi I just started red dead redomption 2 but there are things I do not understand well (I am a big noob) so sorry I have a lot of questions.. such as health, energy, composure, I do not really understand the difference between the interior (so by example the heart for health or the lightning for energy) and the round border, the gauge, I know that there are toners that are used to fill the round border ... Also for the horse, how we give it energy (by letting it rest) and where we can find a brush for the horse (because I saw the brush icon)
Also for hunting, is there a good way to kill bears or other dangerous animals, because I have a hard time ... And for hunting you just have to have a bait and put it in the right area and wait to be able to hunt an animal? Or do something else have to be done? I also received the map with areas for certain animals, but I have no idea where it is.
Also for the missions currently I am at the very beginning, I have been in the next town, done some mission, and the group talk about returning to black water, but for the moment there is no mission like that, just small mission, this is normal?
Also in the camp in the notebook where we can improve the camp, I can't buy the improvements on the right page like I can improve the meds but not the food.
Sorry to have asked so many questions
I'd recommend playing the story missions, You'll unlock things based on how far you've came.
You can give health/energy to the horse vía feeding him
You will get the brush during a mission story dw about it
There are many methods for hunting. But for big animals you will later have the correct weapons to hunt them. As for the best weapon its the bow which you get on the 3rd mission of the game.
You can find animals vía the drawings arthur makes of them in the map. But do take into account they can take some time to find.
Basically play the story. Everything will unlock with dew time
You will get better weapons and better overall as you progress on the game
Also dw we all been in that point 
That's the problem, I find more the missions of history, there are only small missions, like going hunting or going to look for debts
@lofty marlin First question, the differance, the Interior is the Core, the better that is the faster you regenerate the outside, which is actually your Hit Points, Or Stamina/Dead Eye.
Do small missions too. They are both important and sometimes unlock main story missions
Everything is important to do and you gotta put it with exploring the world
But how do you feed your horse? And Yeah I know normally I received the brush, but I can't find it, neither in my bag nor that of the horse
Get close to the horse and interact with it. You will be able to brush him fred him etc
Is your profile picture a scene from Twilight Zone?
So to hunt you need a bait, the right area for each animal and wait
No need for a bait
Normally you can find them by yourself or using dead eye
@lofty marlin When hunting, make sure to Study Each animal you see, then you will see a button for "Info" that will tell you how to get a "Clean Kill" if you use the right type of weapon it says for the clean kill, you shouldn't harm the pelt. But, Obviously, the animal has to start at a certain Pelt quality in the first place. Try to only bother with 3 star animals.
Yeah, Baits don't do much, they can help, but meh... Just look around for a animal, then go from there.
Oh okk so we can upgrade the core with the toning
Right, if you just do into the woods, put down and bait and stand there. You aren't going to get much of anywhere.
You can uograde dead eye health energy vía doing stuff
Like hunting cooking meat running etc
Sort of, Red core is BAD, you need to heal it. and Gold is very good.
Also constantly eat
N stuff
Because arthur actually needs to eat every once in a while
Well... Constantly, no... but...
Yes every once a while
Like once every 1 hour irl if you want at the start of the game
Yeah i eat in the campement
Good enough
I try not to let either me nor my horse's cores go lower than 75ish%, usually.
And so for the animal map that I was given, is it shown where exactly on the map?
legendary one? It's a rough map of, almost, all of them, yes.
Whats the easiest challenges to complete to get a full set of reinforced equipment? (holster, gun belt, bandolier, off hand holster)
Technically Explorer. But, only if you look up, online, all the maps and treasure locations
Otherwise, depending on what chapter you are in. Maybe Weapon Expert or Sharpshooter?
I already did that one on my last playthrough, I was thinking of trying sharpshooter
Yeah, that of the legendary animals ... But I can't see where the map is right in the map of the game
You have to go to your satchel and find it in there.
It's an actual map that Arthur has to examine.
@lofty marlin Did we answer all the questions you wanted answered? Also, feel free to ask more, anytime. It's the main reason for this channel.
Keeping arthur normal weight is so annoying but i dont wanna keep buying food
Ouf, the weight system is whack.
I remember you can be a bounty hunter in this game, anyone know how to do this?
also is there a honor level requirement? im kinda in the red side atm cuz of main story missions lol
Bounty Hunter is a Online role.
ooh
U can bounty hunt in story but doesnt pay well
is it only for players via players or can you do player vs npc hunts?
Just pick up bounty posters from sherrif's offices. You don't get the title of bounty hunter, but you can hunt bounties
Its only player vs npc
is it well thought out or u just get a marker and you head there?
Unless someone has a super high bounty but that rarely happens
Indeed, there is a couple Bounties for each town. But nothing like the Online thing.
i was thinkin of tryin out RDO after i finish the story this is def interesting
Only legendary bounties are well thought out
does it pay well? i heard money is an issue in RDO
Other ones are get there lasso a guy bring him to cops
Bounty hunting in rdo is only good for gold
Money it gives is pocket change
Money, Money, Money.
Ok
well gold = $500 in single player, is pretty much better than any money bills lol
i dont mind gold 😛
If only money could be exchanged for gold and vice versa
Collector would become the king
ahh
Does every mission optional and unmissable need completed in a single playthrough to attain 100% completion?
Like I missed one optional mission, and I have a save file behind it available, but I did so much shit since then like Rock Carvings, Dino Bones, Hunting Requests, and such. And I'm afraid that it will set me all the way back and total completion wouldnt stay
ask this guy: @frigid cloud, he knows everything
Would appreciate it fr, this shit is irritating
Eat food at the saloon twice a day.
Not needed. You can replay any mission you completed
Optional missions don't really have a Gold medal
Alright cool, so I can still get 100% and then go back to get the one mission I need to complete for Lending a Hand after the playthrough that I am on
Yeah. Although Gold Medals are not necesary for the in game 100%
Only for the steam/ps4 trophy
Right, cool cool, thank you!
Anytime! 
So I went back to Adler ranch in Chapter 2. I found a bird. An odd bird because it's in the grizzlies. In very thick snow. The bird was a Western Tanager Songbird perched on a fence near the Barn. Any thoughts?
Did you hunt it?
And analyze it
I just studied it. It flew away before I could do anything else.
Tanager's aren't all that rare, no.
Full Compendium you want to Study, Track, Kill and Skin/Pluck. Obviously you can don't need to track birds, however, but, plucking, though.
But, again, don't worry, Tanager's are all over, there is a couple different color's, but you only need one type, for the compendium.
Quick Tip
Focus on that once you finish the game
Or mix it with exploration
Else you will go completly insane
I was the opposite, I try to multi-task and do a few things at the same time. Work on a challenge or a side mission, while looking out for pelts I may need for the trapper, while exploring, etc.
I just did like 30% of the collectables and the needed stuff for 100% completion by complete accident vía exploration and points of interest on the online map
Yeap, I got a bunch of the bones and dream catchers and such while exploring and doing story missions during the normal game.
I got like 4 of them
And the rest found them with the online map because im not wasting 500 hours of my life for bones
Ouf, yeap, I got like 7 bones and 6 Dream catchers or something, but they were one of the last things I did before finishing 100%. Some of the Bones were just in some crazy spots.
Either you randomly blind luck into finding it, or I don't know...
I got only 1 dream catcher because i focused mroe on story
Specially because there are missions that last like
2 hours
Its not a single mission that lasts long but rather a series of them where you cannot go do something else from how much you are bond to them
A lot of the Catchers I would find because I noticed my controller would vibrate when I was near one, which either meant Catcher or Point of Interest.
Yeah thats the best part
Also if any of you are having problems by finding dinosaur bones Even if you know you ar ein the correct location just use the dead eye, it will show you with yellow stuff
Yellow Bubbly swirl. But you have to be semi-close.
Not like Orchids, where you can be really far away.
Or Legendary Animal Clues.
Ye
Although its the same stuff that legendary animal clues have
So look for that
Same with the dreamcatchers I think but your con troller actually bibrates when you come any close to it
You know
it bothers me a lot
Jack has like blondish hair
I hope that's just one of many genes that came from grandfathers or grandmothers
Only man that has blonde is Arthur
So I can cross Javier, Dutch and Micah.
Eh its one of the many theories of whos the father of Jack
Normally people point Javier
But Arthur is the 2nd most possible
Whos the first
Javier
It would be like basically. The game says John is the father of Jack, fans theorize its either Javier or Arthur
Yeah its weird tbh. In rdr 1 I think his hair is Brown
I just went to do the fisherman mission
Looking at his hair
Awfully a lot blonde
I only did it to get the gold medal
but goddamn
Yeah its just
Weird
Then again there is no direct answer to who it is. Its just theories and opinions for the most part
And what's terribly confusing is when we get to the RDR 1 he is a lot like a mexican
Yee, thats why its discussed a lot
Yes
youre right
he does look a lot like Javier but as an adult
My main question is where could Abagail inherits be
Basically the theories for each one go like this
- Javier because of how Jack looks on rdr 1
- Arthur because of something he wrote on his journal
Thats a really quick summary though
Nobody knows tbh. Normally those stuff are not touched at all during the games or by people
Its just one of those Minor details for the character
so there's a theory that Abigail died of TB right
that got me thinking
what if she got it from Arthur
It can lie dormant for years
Tb is only given vía contact with blood
Besides
It got Arthur in like
6 months
yeah but that doesn't happen with everyone
some people show symptoms in months, takes others years
How old is Jack Marston before Abigail died?
Like
Given before TB
15
Before john died he is 15
If you want a real scale you can say like
40 minimum and 70 really pushing
The older the age the worst the immune system fails yes?
Yes I Belive
My one quarrel with the story is Arthur's TB progressed at an unrealistically fast rate
fu
even with all that was going on it still typically takes at least like a year to die from TB
sometimes more
You said yourself its different
The story takes place over like 3 months
Arthur didn't start really showing symptoms until probably a month before he died
You can say btw 3 months and 7 months top
Does lumbago spread
Uncle didn' ñt have Lumbago
Lol
It was just an excuse to be lazy
And do nothing around
I just don't get how he went from a subtle cough here and there to falling of his horse almost dying from TB in the span of like a week
all felt to fast lol
and like his face changes instantly
Aye man he started coughing on like chapter 3
Its from way earlier than people expect
tuberculosis isn't such a fast progressive disease
it varies
Sometimes you show symptoms within a few months, or it could take years
all depends
Man
like even 5-10
Also I love the high honor go with John ending but lets face it it's way to perfect
If Arthur did kept his guard up, killed micah and logically he couldn't carry the money with him
The realistic ending is Micah shooting Arthur in the face
low honor ending is more realistic tbh
not every “realistic” ending has to be so blunt
just because something is good doesn’t mean it’s unrealistic
plus come on it’s a western you need a cool stand-off
yeah but like
lets think logically
why would Micah not kill Arthur
in any scenario
and why did Arthur not kill Micah
Does the honorable ending have a more honorable version of Micah or some shit? lol
he tried
still failed ripbozo
depending on the ending you get, Dutch steps on his foot or Micah just gets the better of him lol
Idk
Between the start and early chapter 4 there is not even a month
quick question just finished chapter 4 what happen to the girls? it was only abigial who went with us for the heist, i guess their still back at saint denis probably moving to a new place?
sigh why cant i use spoil tags lol
Since Hosea mentions that it is May and the letter you get from the mayor is dated May too
They stayed back in the camp
They won't bring the girls to any hesit except if they are part of the plan
Which they weren't
gotcha, during the scene dutch said something about going back to camp but
i think the guys who are after them was already there?
"if anything goes wrong, we meet back at the camp"
or they'll get caught tryin to go back to camp which is why they went to the boat instead?
They couldn't go to the camp because they knew they would be followed and killed
So took a boat instead
I guess itsj ust a loophole to the plot?
cuz out of everything, they pretty much ditch the camp to start a new life wherever the boat took em lol
Just keep playing the game. Know that they couldn't go back to the camp because they would be followed and killed. The first thing that dutch had an idea was going to a boat. Then chapter 5 takes place
Not sure if this is too spoilery but will we be reunited? (with the girls)
You will see
👍
If you want spoilers, just ask. I'm sure everyone else here has done the story missions.
just reached chapter 5 so i wana keep it as spoilerless as possible lol
Ik but its just best to expirience it
was just curious about this side thing with the girls
Rather than get spoiled
^^
Has more of an impact in the end

Its fine!

That was not their plan. Dutch knew they couldn't get to camp because the city was full of Pinkertons at the moment, it was impossible to get out given that they would be patrolling every exit. They go on the boat, wait a few weeks somewhere far and then come back, or at least that was the plan
ahhh idk how i forgot this part
makes alot of sense now lol
Ye, i gave a shitty explanation too. So sorry for that too :P
You ever wondered
its very possible John had to kill Charles, Sadie and the rest of the living gang members before RDR1
Perhaps, though if Charles went to Canada and Sadie went to South America, those two would've been tricky. And why would they have cared about Mary-Beth, Tilly and Pearson?
That's why he was stepping off a boat in the opening cutscene
maybe he was returning from south america/canada
Ferry from Saint Denis/Sisika.
Was it confirmed
I know saint denis and sisika werent a thing when rdr1 was being developed but then again neither was charles
Don’t forget my boy Josiah
does it ever say where the ferry was from
Also considering he went all the way to mexico for javier they probably could have had him go there as well
Indeed, it's hard to say about the members that didn't exist, so, we can just speculate.
Yeah its easier to just believe John probably killed/captured them right before RDR1 starts
hence why theyre never mentioned
My guess is that the Pinkertons didn't know about them. Milton didn't know John when he first met the band and he has been with them since forever
Charles was only with them for like 6 months and Sadie like 5 seconds
In a newspaper article it is mentioned that the only gang members wanted are John, Dutch, Bill, Javier and Micah
They didnt really know about Sadie because she was a very new member who generally laid low until chapter 6 or so.
but what about charles and the rest
what list
bc john is mentioned there lol
The ones without bounties on their heads, or can lead them to the ones with bounties, probably aren't worth bothering with.
I suppose
And then Mary Beth, Tilly, Karen, Pearson, and Josiah don’t really do anything major so it’s hard for the agents to know their identity
The wanted list
i don't think the FBI wanted Javier anyway since he was outside their jurisdiction but John got him anyway bc he was also a former member and knew about the whereabouts of Bill
Fun fact people theorize that the start of rdr 1 (john getting out of the boat) is him returning from killing Both Sadie and Charles
There probably wasn't a way to identify Charles since he had no relatives or friends before joining the gang
I know
thats what i was getting at lol
is it ever confirmed where the boat was coming from
I know
So its just food for thought really
but in either games does it ever say where the boat was coming from
Right, just people theorizing, so...
No
Still is fun tbh, gets a little confusing at time but still fun 
I doubt it. and they probably just did the boat scene because it looked neat. "Showing Off neat Graphics".
Yeah to pay homage to gta 4 probably
Most likely
and that piano score
Indeed, this too.
Is it wrong that John Marston on rdr 1 makes me remember some stuff to Niko Belic
Like the fact that he doesn't hide what he does to anyone. Not Even his own family
Honestly michael de santa reminds me of john
michaels like if john was born in the modern generation
both have a bullet time ability both left their lives of crime for their family
etc
The overall relationship of michael and amanda reminds me to Mary and Arthur
both are snarky
But if they actually got toghether in the end
Tried to is a better word since they never trully left it
Yeah and they both betrayed their gang
well
john was left for dead
michael left his mate for dead
John was left for dead and michael faked his death to protect his family
Although I could be getting some stuff wrong since its been ages since I played gta 5 story mode
oh yeah and both are strong armed by the fbi
Also both are forced
lol
Yeah and it was trevor that was meant to take the hit
but brad walked in his way
michael and the fbi wanted trevor dead lol
It was just all went wrong for mostly everyone because Michael's fake death comes to bother him later on the game lmao
micah lmao
the whole game wouldnt have happened if michael didnt say you forget a thousand things everyday
All for a catchy line he stole from a movie
even trevor roasts him for it lol
Who wouldn't tbh 
Oh poor Dave
Also while rewinding my memories about the game i reminded that Franklin was just dragged into the situation
And only stayed because "aye we friends"
he saw the big game with michael
it was mostly for the heist cuts
even says one score with him he made more money than he ever did hustling