red-dead-singleplayer

[gray wasp]

wowzers

cant fucking belive that when I shoot people they die, such detail

[summer garnet]

When you spam A while on a horse it moves omg still finding new things

[gray wasp]

*Owen Wilson wow

[summer garnet]

When you hold lt then press rt the gun shoots its like real life man

[gray wasp]

And of course, just like it was back in 1899, the stores have a never ending supply of C H E E S E

anyways

back to a compilation of Owen Wilson saying wow

(I'm not even joking)

[keen birch]

[gray wasp]

okay

thats the last straw

[gray wasp]

💥

ok]

problem solved

anyways

Guys

I need a list of obtainable hats on my desk by tomorrow

would be appreciated

actually

I can look shit up

[quartz charm]

[hidden moss]

did you know if you move the left stick/hold the w key arthur will walk

never noticed this until my fifty millionth playthrough

[copper ferry]

Yo, what's the fastest Large/Heavy horse?

[hidden moss]

your mum

[summer garnet]

shire/andrennes

have a nice day

[copper ferry]

thank you very much!! (we may have differing opinions on Micah but I still appreciate the help,)

[copper ferry]

huh, your mum didn't mention any voice acting roles as I blew her back out, last night

(next time, mentally weigh out the idea of fucking with some dude who runs around with a picture of some random literally flaming dude, with the whitest name available)

[hidden moss]

well aint you scary

big tough discord boy

[primal sierra]

where a can created tiket for show one guys hack

[hushed flare]

The piss colored names go brr

[quartz charm]

Micah bad

[hushed flare]

Best in the west bad Micah good

[quartz charm]

Micah bad

[hushed flare]

👻 ping

[quartz charm]

Spoiler

[hushed flare]

No rules against spoilers

[quartz charm]

“Too many spoilers tag”

[hushed flare]

[quartz charm]

When 100%? @hushed flare

[hushed flare]

Already done lmao

Red role succ tho

[quartz charm]

Red is color of blood

[hushed flare]

It's also the color of red painted trash

[quartz charm]

Never seen a trash painted red

[dusk mason]

is there any way to get online content into post-epilogue without using third party stuff?

[obsidian junco]

Is it normal that nvidia dlss makes my hair look pixelated?

[hidden moss]

Guys bill dies in chapter 2

[autumn verge]

Who

cares

[odd cape]

Can John whistle while riding?

Like an idle not the whistle for horse action

also why does sadies horse (in the epilogue) look so weird

it looks like a flesh horse

[obsidian crown]

Omfg a cougar attacked the second I was looking at my pocket watch

we can all agree cougars are a nightmare

[odd cape]

At least they aren’t wolves

[obsidian crown]

Good point

[civic nest]

Nah cougars are worse

And panthers are the worst even tho they are reskined cougars

[hidden moss]

Yeah they are terrible

In red dead 1 and 2

[lunar cedar]

Does anyone want to do online

I am bored

[night raven]

I knew something was wrong about her horse, and you’ve just told me what it is. Ew

[odd cape]

A pack of wolves I mean

Two or three is fine

But once I got ambushed by like 6

[civic nest]

Still better than one cougar

[steady vector]

Dead eye is your friend

[odd cape]

tru but they all stun locked me so I couldn’t even point my gun

[steady vector]

Yeah if you let them get that close you’re screwed

[steady vector]

Hey guys, I’m on my third playthrough and I have a bug I haven’t experienced before. In a chapter 3 mission with Trelawny called “friends in very low places” he takes you to rob a stagecoach. First you have to talk to the clerk in Rhodes (Alden), but he isn’t there. I’m stuck there waiting to talk to an NPC that won’t show up

[hidden moss]

bruh

[steady vector]

I’ve restarted the mission, restarted the game, forced a checkpoint retry. Nothing is working yet

[hidden moss]

thats weird

[steady vector]

It’s a story mission so I can’t continue without it

[night raven]

Quit the mission and see if Alden is in his booth, if he isn’t, go do something else for awhile, like hunting, and then come back and see if you can start the mission

[steady vector]

I just slept for two days and I have a different mission with Micah I just started. I think it’s the long one where Arthur gets captured by O’Driscolls. After this I’ll check for Alden in free roam

[hidden moss]

Tip for hunting legendary animals

Use a rolling block rifle

I shot the legendary elk ONCE and it started to bleed out

[gilded tide]

y’all know how to get the misourri fox trotter in chapter 3

[hidden moss]

No

[gilded tide]

?

[odd cape]

does anyone else dislike playing thru chapter 4

it’s really long and boring tbh

[glad brook]

Chapter 4 is one of the shortest chapters in the game.

[odd cape]

oh

im stupid

[earnest haven]

I hated the end because of Hosea and Lenny

[odd cape]

Some missions were good but others were a chore

[frigid cloud]

Instead use explosive rounds

[earnest haven]

I hated Bronte from the first time We meet him so I really hated meeting him and working for him

[steady vector]

Chapters 3 and 4 are not as good as 1,2,5, and 6 imo

[earnest haven]

Chapter 6 really broke my heart because of Dutch. He’s one of my favourite characters and his betrayals still hurt. But I still like him thanks to the epilogue

[steady vector]

I liked Dutch on my first playthrough. Now I don’t really like him anymore due to his actions towards the end

[earnest haven]

How many times you played through the story?

[steady vector]

I’m in the middle of my 3rd playthrough

[steady vector]

I passed about a week of time in the game and it’s working now

[hidden moss]

I feel

Depressed

Apparently you can skin the lion in the stranger mission ‘He's British of course’

And you also need the lions paw for a trinket

[frigid cloud]

if u don't get the trophy trinket is unobtainable

[hidden moss]

😔

Does this mean....100% completion is now unobtainable..?

[steady vector]

Nope. Nothing missable is required for 100%

[hidden moss]

What is missable tho

[jagged cave]

Legendary animal disappeared from horseback after accidentally starting a misssion&abandoning it

Can't find carcass anywhere

and the image of the animal still looks crossed

On the map

Means I can't hunt it again

I assume there's no solution

Huh

[vocal vine]

hello chat

[jagged cave]

It came back after switching horses

[hidden moss]

Any good places for hunting bears?

[night raven]

Great! I wasn’t sure if that would work, but it was the only thing I could think of

[wraith panther]

killing people with tomahawks is incredibly fun

[hidden moss]

Ok boooooaahs

Any good places for hunting bears?

Yeah

The legendary bear location

Besides that

[vocal vine]

i only have problems with that GODDAMN bear

[long wedge]

Anyone here use either Young Clean Arthur or John Marston Restoration Project?

[steady vector]

Yeah! Now I can continue and Sean will finally die 😂

[steady vector]

No. Why change Arthur’s look so drastically

[long wedge]

How about JMRP? @steady vector

I really installed YCA for some of the original Clothing

Since his look is fine

[hidden moss]

😔

Nobody knows any places to hunt bears?

[long wedge]

Black Bone Forest

And upper Big Valley

You can find black beard around Roanoke too

[eternal vigil]

Just check this map

[gray wasp]

I should spend some time just reading Arthur's journal, maybe when I get to chapter 4...

I'm going to try and get my first legendary fish today

[dawn ether]

guys i have this problem when playing this game

where whenever i see reverend swanson

or he shows up in a mission

anyone else have this problem?

whyd you delete

my question

[gray wasp]

I need somebody beside me to keep telling me "No, dont play RDO, progress in the story for once and actually do what you said you were going to do" XD

[dawn ether]

sorry i shit myself

[gray wasp]

wha-?

[night raven]

Just don’t play rdo until you beat story mode. That’s what I did

[wraith panther]

Smh, I came across a band of bandits with a tied up lawman, killed the bandits and threw a tomahawk axe into the lawman

and now I can't retrieve it

[wraith panther]

the story is absolutely terrific

[hidden moss]

Boahs..

Im going on a mission

To obtain every ciggy card!

[hushed flare]

good thing premium cig packs exist

[steady vector]

I’ve been chugging hair tonics like some maniac but Arthur’s beard is stuck at 7

I think I’ve been on level 7 for longer than it took to grow out to 7

[hidden moss]

No no

Im finding

Them

[gray wasp]

f

I love finding those

especially if its someone you've heard of in the game

[candid cliff]

Can anyone tell me where you hunt bears?

O guess I should be asking is it anywhere near horseshoes overlook

[past pasture]

couple of bears in north of strawberry near that wide and long plain flower and grass area

[candid cliff]

Thanks dude

[gray wasp]

oh goodness no, best bet is Tall Trees or Big Valley I think

but idk

I havent actually hunter bears

[candid cliff]

Only bear I've gotten so far is the legendary one

[gray wasp]

I should though for the compendium

[candid cliff]

Only knew where that was cos of the mission

[gray wasp]

What I need to find is some Ram's Head

[past pasture]

yeah but you cant go there in early time of the story

[gray wasp]

yeah I know

it sucks

[candid cliff]

Wait do you move again

[past pasture]

ive hunted so many bears XD

[gray wasp]

oh yeah

[candid cliff]

That would be a bummer

[gray wasp]

tons of times

[candid cliff]

Urghhh

[gray wasp]

like around 4-5 times

[candid cliff]

I like Horseshoe Overlook

[gray wasp]

i think

same

dont worry

the next camp is pretty good too

[candid cliff]

Phew

Do I keep the antlers and stuff I hung up

[gray wasp]

doesnt have the same views though

yes

[candid cliff]

Yay

[gray wasp]

you do

[candid cliff]

Is it good for hunting

Huntings like my main thing

[past pasture]

do camp upgrades XD

[gray wasp]

you keep everything you've bought/ crafted for the camp

[past pasture]

or that hunting competition sort of thing

[gray wasp]

the next camp you move will actually be good for fishing

[past pasture]

but i would suggest get that legend satchel asap XD

[candid cliff]

No idea how

[gray wasp]

eh, dont rush LOTE

it takes a lot of hunting

and you'd need the right weapons

[candid cliff]

I just got the Varmint rifle I think it's called

[past pasture]

go check camp upgrades... you will see satchel too

[gray wasp]

oh good, that thing's awesome

[candid cliff]

I know, I just don't know what I need

[past pasture]

thats what is amazing about this game... especially when youre new

[candid cliff]

And the ammo is super cheap

[frigid cloud]

Only bear you have hunted is legendary bear

[gray wasp]

you do know how to check which weapons will result in a perfect pelt right? @candid cliff

[gray wasp]

no...I havent

;-;

[past pasture]

you need the animal skins required and camp upgrades i guess

[candid cliff]

All I know is that the Varmint Rifle helps with small animals

[past pasture]

yeah

[gray wasp]

oh so, allow me to indulge you

[frigid cloud]

Use a rifle for the bear

[past pasture]

always study the animal and read stuff .. it helps

also dont forget to track them 😂

[gray wasp]

When you study an animal, and show its info, it will tell you which weapon you can use in order to get a perfect pelt

[past pasture]

yes

[candid cliff]

Ah ok

Shoot o gtg my dinner is ready

See you later guys

[frigid cloud]

To see an animal's quality and track it you have to study it furst

[past pasture]

why is there no seperate "spoilers" channel in this server ffs

i wanted to ask something lol ;_;

[gray wasp]

(what counts as "tracking" it though, just tracking the trail, or actually finding the animal?)

[frigid cloud]

Aim at the animal hold y or triangle to track or in eagle eye

[candid cliff]

Ohhh that's why some stuff doesn't tell me the quality

👋

[hidden moss]

I beat up somebody for a ciggy card...i feel really bad now

[past pasture]

it gives you the trail which helps find the animal...

[gray wasp]

you can do that?

[hidden moss]

Beat him up to explore the house

Not to obtain it

[past pasture]

like trail is basically tracking footprints or basically tracks of animal in real life

[gray wasp]

I know what it does, I want to know if JUST focusing on the trail is enough to update the compendium

[gray wasp]

whose house tho?

[hidden moss]

Some two people

Dunno them

[gray wasp]

hmm

[past pasture]

not really focusing.. if you just track it once thats enough for the compendium

[gray wasp]

well maybe tell me where they are, I would also like a free card

[gray wasp]

so I JUST have to track the trail, not actually like, find the animal?

[frigid cloud]

No just track

[past pasture]

yeah ... you need to study to get to know the animal and its pelt and stuff

[gray wasp]

ok

[past pasture]

for compendium's perspective... just track.. like aim on that animal or woth binos... just track and thats it

[gray wasp]

cool

that clears it up

[past pasture]

in compendium there - study, track, kill, skin

i think you should not give spoilers here

pls delete

[violet osprey]

I tried to use spoiler tags and got warned

Also, look at the desc of this chat pls

"Be cautious of spoilers"

[past pasture]

i was just saying this above... like the rdo community server has a seperate spoilers channel 🥲

[violet osprey]

Its not my fault bro

[past pasture]

ik lol.. im not blaming you 😂

[violet osprey]

But whatever ill delete it

[past pasture]

👍🏻

[candid cliff]

I collected a debt for strauss

I feel horrible

It was a nice polish or German man

[tulip goblet]

hey

[red helm]

Evening

[frigid cloud]

Evening

[night raven]

Afternoon

[autumn verge]

Fucking nice

I won it easily with only 30 minutes

lets go

[steady vector]

What do you think the best horse Arthur can get is

[red helm]

Without much work, the Perlino Andalusian.

[steady vector]

Better than Arabians or fox trotter?

[red helm]

But with tricks or a lot of trouble you can get the MFT and such.

[steady vector]

I’m counting the horses you can buy in chapter 4

[red helm]

Meh, Arabian has better speed, but it's 'bravery' is ugh..

[gray wasp]

You just missed a exclusive item that you can only find there my guy

[steady vector]

Arthur can get the black and white Arabians and the amber champagne fox trotter

[red helm]

Like I said, if you want to go through the trouble of getting the MFT, it's definitely better.

and Arabians are only better if you don't mind their bad bravery stats. Which I do count as a stat.

[civic nest]

What trouble?

You can buy one as Arthur

[steady vector]

Yeah you can buy the MFT in chapter 4

The Arabians are much prettier though

[red helm]

Wait, you can? I thought it wasn't buyable until the Epilogue?

Am I confusing it with the Turkoman?

[steady vector]

Both of those are available in stables at the start of chapter 4

Turkoman might be even earlier

[red helm]

Oh, huh, maybe I just wasn't paying attention to stables in my second play through... Or decided not to get them, since I was going to use them with John...

Well, Meh, then definitely either a Turko or MFT are best for Arthur. Foo to Arabian's, they are scardy-cats.

[steady vector]

Lol you really don’t like Arabians huh. I haven’t had much issue with them

[red helm]

I liked them at first. and like the Red chestnut one. But, just get tired of getting bucked so easily.

[steady vector]

MFT is available from the beginning of chap 4. It’s hiding out in the Scarlett meadows stable

I’ve never seen the red Arabian tbh. Didn’t do much with John other than the story

[red helm]

The red one is just northwest of Owanjila.

[steady vector]

Black Arabian is great as an all black horse

[red helm]

Sure, but we aren't talking about looks.

[civic nest]

In my experience, the MFTs, the Turkomans and the Arabians are equally cowardly

So pick the one you like the most

[red helm]

My Turko seemed to be pretty decent. but all horses have a chance to buck, just some have higher odds than others.

[hushed flare]

I use mft for looks tho

[faint fossil]

i thought you were talking about actual nationalities and i got so scared

[red helm]

Obviously, your choice for what horse to use is like 80% looks. REally. Stats is the rest.

[hushed flare]

I mean other then looks it's not a arabian

therefore it's better then arabian

[red helm]

lol. oopsie.. Yes, we are discussing horsies.

[hushed flare]

"turko"

[faint fossil]

ye i know now lmao

[past pasture]

I need money, MAHNEEY!!

[candid cliff]

I got the payment but I felt real bad about it

[faint fossil]

yeah

[past pasture]

ikr

[faint fossil]

i believe that's the point

[past pasture]

debt collecting are shit

[faint fossil]

and arthur probably feels that way too deep down

[red helm]

The Debt missions are mostly poopie, even when you are doing a Low Honor run.

[wraith panther]

from Mr. Downes?

[faint fossil]

no

[rugged cloud]

Who wants to play

[faint fossil]

from the dude from uhhh

[candid cliff]

I can't remember the name

[faint fossil]

slovania? something like that

he doesn't speak english right

[candid cliff]

Its the guy on the first one

[past pasture]

yeah

quick tip... theres a rare watch you can save for yourself 🌚

in that mission

[hushed flare]

reutlinger

[wraith panther]

the guy that you have to rob?

[hushed flare]

oh wait

[past pasture]

ya

[hushed flare]

u can only get one tho

[red helm]

The Reutlinger watch isn't a Debt mission.

[hushed flare]

from the boat mission

you get a gold watch I think from Mr wrobel

[wraith panther]

I killed him after taking the stuff

[past pasture]

wait a min... i might have consifed with names

leme check real quick

[red helm]

Don't blame you, there is a lot of people in the game, hard to keep track of all the names.

[past pasture]

yeah... its antiqute pocket watch

[candid cliff]

I was tempted

[past pasture]

from mr wrobel 😂

[candid cliff]

Save him from the sadness

In a grim kind of way

I saw hoping I could apologize

[past pasture]

why kill that poor lad? :/

[candid cliff]

I didn't end up doing it

I just went and killed a deer for food

And regretted working for the German guy

[past pasture]

😂

[candid cliff]

I have an addiction to helping my camp

[past pasture]

u mean strauss?

[candid cliff]

Yes

I thougtj he was called Strauss but couldn't remember

[candid cliff]

Especially with food

[past pasture]

oh lord you'll hate him more i guess

[candid cliff]

So far he seems like a pr*ck

[past pasture]

sounds all innocent but hes a bad 😂

[red helm]

Loan sharking, is indeed, not a good way of making money.

[candid cliff]

I knew he was bad, mainly cos he's a pr*ck

Also I stg I'm the only one who does anything in camp

[red helm]

Unsure why Dutch was okay with it, it's basically just robbing the poor, in a way.

[past pasture]

dont start with dutch

[candid cliff]

I think the only time I've seen someone working was replacing a wheel

[candid cliff]

Ahhh please no spoiler

I thought Dutch was good

[past pasture]

have you guys completed the story?

[red helm]

But, yeah... Dutch..

[candid cliff]

I'm on Chapter 2

[past pasture]

he is... in a way

[night tide]

What’s the best horse to get. My black dappled horse just died, mind you the one I spent more irl money on and I can’t get it back which is stupid so now I have to get some other horse. What’s the best one

[red helm]

I've played through twice, and been in this server for a year now.

[past pasture]

no ... im not giving any

[red helm]

Turkoman, MFT are best overall. But get a horse you think looks good, thats really the main thing.

[night tide]

What’s MFT stand for

[past pasture]

okay

[red helm]

Missouri Fox Trottor.

[night tide]

Thanks

[candid cliff]

My predictions for betrayals are: Micah, Bill, Strauss and John

[past pasture]

thats the coat right?

[red helm]

Also, make sure to craft a saddle from the Trapper, those give some increased stats as well.

[night tide]

Bet

[candid cliff]

Micah seems like a prck, bill is probably a prck I don't remember much about him, Strauss is a prck and John is probably a prck

[night tide]

😀

[candid cliff]

I don't trust none of my crew

[past pasture]

i always hate micah.... like from the first day i met him... he just talks like crazy

[candid cliff]

Lil b**ch Micah

[night tide]

I did the Micah mission last in chapter 2 or whatever it was in

[candid cliff]

I rescue you from a prison and you visit an ex partners house

[candid cliff]

I did it like mid way thru cos I just wanted to get it done

I think I've still got some missions left

[misty cliff]

Micah is cool

[night tide]

I finished the game once and doing it against so I’m biased

[past pasture]

you might be a fool 😂

[civic nest]

I started to hate Micah since that mission in Strawberry

[misty cliff]

Never denied that.

[past pasture]

i just dont vive with micah 😂

[candid cliff]

If I had the choice I'd shoot Micah

[civic nest]

Then I hated him less after the coach robbery

[candid cliff]

Also is having Bad Honour not good?

Cos I have like a darkish grey honour

[night tide]

Depends

If your all for money sure

[candid cliff]

Mainly cos I kill all the witnesses

[misty cliff]

It's bad if you want to get high honor outfits.

[night tide]

That too

But high honor also gets you discounts

[past pasture]

i would say get your honor up... you'll get discounts

[candid cliff]

My honour goes down when o loot bodies which sucks

[night tide]

Look this so what you should do

High honor for authur

Nvm

[past pasture]

ikr

[night tide]

Don’t rob places

[candid cliff]

I had like $700 but then I paid off my bounties

[night tide]

Now stagecoach robberies are fine

[candid cliff]

Now I have $300

[night tide]

They don’t decrease honor

When people ask you for help do it

Give the veterans money. Specifically Mickey and the guy in Rhodes

[past pasture]

greeting people increases honor

[candid cliff]

My honour wents down so much after I said sorry actually j can't help ride you back to town to a lady

[night tide]

Oh and when you walk into a saloon greet everyone

[candid cliff]

I just saved you from dying under a horse and you decrease my honour cos I'm not riding ages away

[night tide]

Every 3 greets increases honor

[candid cliff]

I am an avid greeter

[timber canopy]

fish and throw back the fish

[night tide]

One time I was riding to Valentine, saved a girl, and she asked me to go to take her to Vanhorn :-:

[candid cliff]

That's what happened to me except I was at the legendary bear spot

[past pasture]

whats bad in rhat?

[candid cliff]

And they asked to go to Annesburg or something

[night tide]

Well the thing was I had been riding back in forth grinding the white bison outfit

[past pasture]

go cinematic on waypoint the horse rides itself... then enjoy the convo 🤣

[night tide]

;-;

Never knew that

[past pasture]

which girl? O o

[candid cliff]

I don't know.her name

All I know is that b**ch decreased my honour by like 5%

[past pasture]

ive played twice and haven't met a girl like that 😂

[past pasture]

how come?

[candid cliff]

I accidentally say I'll take.hee home and then say I can't and she decrease my honour

Cos she was stuck under a horse

Worth it tho cos now I have a bear hat

[past pasture]

ohh... you had to lift the horse up

[candid cliff]

Yes

Oh sh*t it's late

Gtg

👋

[past pasture]

bye

[night tide]

Is the rattle snake vaquero the best saddle

[civic nest]

The best is the panther saddle I think

[hushed flare]

1% difference

[ember wind]

Ok I guess I was in the wrong chat
Why won't Pouring Forth Oil 1 trigger for me I did the 3 required missions

[civic nest]

Still I think is easier to hunt 1 panther than 10 snakes lol

[hidden moss]

Oh definitely

BANG in the head with a rolling block rifle

[knotty marten]

Replaying the story what kind of name is eagle flies like bruh

Whats next cat meows

[ember wind]

Why is the valentine gunsmith missing

[knotty marten]

Idk

Just leave town and come back or sleep something to make the game load

[ember wind]

He returned!

[odd cape]

5

[civic nest]

I don't understand why there is Eagle Flies and Rains Fall but then there is Paytah

Unless his name means something like that in Wapiti

[knotty marten]

Honestly who knows

[ember wind]

Why won't pouring forth oil 1 trigger

I did the bounty mission and the other 3 missions

[knotty marten]

Your game is obviously tweaking out just restart and if it doesnt show up google it to see if u missed anything

[ember wind]

Like restart as in quit and exit?

[knotty marten]

Close the application and reopen it

Remember to save

Honestly i feel bad for dutch his story is very sad all he did was hit his head and then it all went to hell

[wraith panther]

bruh children in St. Dennis are such fuckers

[knotty marten]

Yep

And you cant kill them

Because thats wrong but normal homicide sureee

[quiet gazelle]

Why tf is my john at his maximum weight

[knotty marten]

Cus he fat

[ember wind]

Didn't work. What are the prerequisites for Pouring Forth oil

[quiet gazelle]

But like how

[knotty marten]

Idk google it

[knotty marten]

You ate a lot

[quiet gazelle]

I havent even touched food though

[knotty marten]

Its not that difficult a concept

Idk he just is

Was ur Arthur max weight

[civic nest]

His hit in the head probably did nothing that wouldn't have happened without it anyway

Dutch already had shot an innocent woman in the face in Blackwater

[wraith panther]

you really lose ammo quickly with semi automatic pistols

[knotty marten]

That was a moment of weakness the hit he got in the head made his violent tendencies increase which leads to some violent or unneeded deaths like bronte being eaten and that old lady in guarma who held dutch by knifepoint

I researched it and i think when he hit his head in the trolley robbery he severed his corpus callosum which affects his judgment and overall sanity

[night tide]

Lol

[knotty marten]

And with hoseas death and micah whispering in his ear theres not many men that wouldn't go insane

But at least he had a moment of clarity at micahs death

So he's a sweet old man who hit his head too hard

[golden storm]

i think you just watched the video essay on that very topic but alrighty

[knotty marten]

I am a nerd

I did not actually

I googled and reddited it

[night tide]

Never liked dutch

[golden storm]

dang the 2 most accurate sites

[knotty marten]

And peiced it together

[golden storm]

dutch is old

[knotty marten]

Dutch is daddy

[golden storm]

[knotty marten]

I will always love that man

This fake line of code

Is my father figure

[night tide]

Charles>

[knotty marten]

Charles is too quiet

[night tide]

Exactly

[knotty marten]

But not a bad guy

[ember wind]

FINALLY the quest triggered

[gray wasp]

Hey uh

guys

so I found a place called Hanging Dog Ranch, and its full of enemies

what do I do

BEAR

what the fuck...

:0

[keen birch]

Read if people that like Arthur or John should be banned.

[sinful knot]

Uhhhh try moving the lever of the repeater and fire using the trigger

[glad brook]

Dynamite.

[sinful knot]

dynamite is only useful if theres a few enemies in one tight space

otherwise it'll kill a small amount for a decent sized gang at hanging dog

wont do much

[golden storm]

ok i just looked at this channel and saw "ill kill and smash a dog" and had said HUH then i realized i read that wrong

dang i do remember the first time i went to hanging dog, i wss explorung the map in chapter 2 and got barraded with enemies and forgot ab it until chapter 6 qnd epilouge

[gray wasp]

I just did it and-

Im slipping

idk

My aim is worse and such

I died once as well

[golden storm]

what chapter are you on

[gray wasp]

3

[golden storm]

ah

the 2nd worst chapter as i like to call it

[gray wasp]

why?

(spoilers are ok)

[golden storm]

idk its repetitive ig

[gray wasp]

hmm

idk

[golden storm]

its just steal from Braithwaites
steal from other guys

the mansion mission is fun though

[gray wasp]

BUt idk for some reason I had a hard time killing all the enemies and I dont know why

[golden storm]

and same with theone inside rhodes

yeah its hard when youre on story mode

[gray wasp]

The movement and aiming seems sluggish to me

compared to Online

[golden storm]

the 2nd chapter is my least favorite

2nd chapter vibes are great everything is so calm and nice but its idk i dont like it

[gray wasp]

DAYUM

OK

so

Micah just pulled a gun on me

and Arthur just said "Just name the place my friend..."

[golden storm]

what mission

[gray wasp]

NONE

[golden storm]

arthur micah duel

oh dang

[gray wasp]

It was in the camp!!!

[golden storm]

ibe never gotten that one

[gray wasp]

lmao

[golden storm]

and ive played the game twice

[gray wasp]

WTF

I LOST MY

LEGENDARY

ELK PELT

[golden storm]

lmao

its ok it spawns at the trapper

[smoky hornet]

you'll have some to craft with at the trapper but no monetary gain

[gray wasp]

thats not what I needed it for though!!!

UGH

[golden storm]

i want the elk jacket but i dont wanna get wolf pelts

[gray wasp]

I needed it to craft a satchel

[golden storm]

i hate hunting so much

[gray wasp]

and now its gone

damn it

[golden storm]

whar satchel

[gray wasp]

idk

Tonic I think

[golden storm]

letend of east?

ah

[smoky hornet]

I love it honestly

the tedium makes sense IMO but I can see why you dislike it

[golden storm]

dont worry you csn buy all of them without pelts after story

ueah i hate that killing a deer in the head gives you a poor like 80% of the time

[little remnant]

if it was for a satchel, then it wasn’t a legendary pelt

so you’re fine

[gray wasp]

yeah ok im playing online, this is a bit tedious

I'll try and play more story tomorrow

;-;

Just, I'd like to play more story, but I just cant

[little remnant]

I’ve been doing my completionist run of the story and as fun as it is it definitely drags on a bit when you’re doing literally everything

[gray wasp]

yeah

and the thing is

I WANT to do everything

[glad brook]

Exactly. Throw dynamite first then start shooting.

[smoky hornet]

the andalusian is really underrated IMO

[gray wasp]

ikr???

I love mine

Named it Morgan

after Morgan Yu

[little remnant]

for me it ended up on my horse after the mission

[elfin sand]

have you all finished the main story mission

[gray wasp]

nope

Hey guys, how close can you get to New Austin before that sniper kills you? Can go go right up to the state line or does he kill you before that?

[zealous pollen]

Anybody bounty hunting on playstation? Hmu

[gray wasp]

Go to roles and give your self both the Bounty Hunter and PS4 roles

then you'll unlock a channel specifically for looking for a game

[zealous pollen]

Ohh ok thanks

[gray wasp]

np

[red helm]

There is a river south of Tall Trees, I always forget the name of it. But once you pass it, that is when the Sniper starts firing at you.

[gray wasp]

Upper Montana?

[odd cape]

I thought those were the names English people gave him

fuck

meant to reply to someone

[gray wasp]

lol

[red helm]

Probably, it comes down from a little lake on the west part of Tall Trees, and curves to the east, then ends by Thief's Landing.

[gray wasp]

Idk

oh

lemme think

Its not the Upper Montana

HMMM

[red helm]

But, anyway, you'll know when the Sniper starts shotting at you, because there will be No enemies at all around, and still shots are firing at you. Plus, it isn't just a Instant Kill, or wasn't for me. I survived some hits. More like 30%-50% per shot.

[gray wasp]

oh yeah

I've seen people survive a hit

but

even if you have like, level 4 fortification, he WILL one shot you after a couple hits

pretty sure

[red helm]

But, yeah, if you are trying to get all the way to like Armadillo, Forget it. Without some sort of glitchy trick.

[gray wasp]

yeah

thats not my goal

I just want to explore as much as I can there without death

[ember wind]

Is Micah a racist

[gray wasp]

yes

100%

[ember wind]

Ah ok

[gray wasp]

was it not obvious?

[ember wind]

I assumed he is

[red helm]

Really is no point "exploring" anything in the Blackwater/Tall Tree/etc areas, as Arthur. Just Leave it until you are John, just trust me.

[gray wasp]

;-;

nothing

nothing significant enough for him to write in his journal?

[red helm]

As soon as you enter those areas, packs of 5-6 Lawmen will just spawn out of nowhere, and if you manage to lose them, another pack will just spawn in...

[gray wasp]

yep

I know

Pinkertons too

[red helm]

So, really, going around for the POints of Interest, and such... Just... why bother..

[little remnant]

I was just on the river between the two states and they hunted me there too

so there isn’t much leniency

[gray wasp]

My main goal is to put as much in my journal as I can as Arthur, so if there are any plants or animals over there that I can study and pick, please tell moi

[red helm]

There is one plant around Blackwater, Prairie Poppy(?) you may be able to get lucky and pick one... otherwise, Just... meh

[gray wasp]

ooooh

damn

ok

thats gonna cut it close

[red helm]

I've seen a patch northwest of the town, a ways off...

[gray wasp]

aight

I'll get to it tomorrow

its a shame that you cant go to New Austin, I really like the feel of it

well-

not New Austin really

Thieves Landing is what I think looks really nice

that area

[red helm]

Yes, it's just dumb you can't go thereas Arthur. they should've just cut it entirely.

[civic nest]

You can get the New Austin plants as Arthur using certain exploits, but is hard as hell

[gray wasp]

I know, I;m not going to try and get them

any NA animals I can study without being sniped at?

[little remnant]

you can probably pull out some binoculars and study some

[civic nest]

I think if you do the Angelo Bronte mission glitch you can inspect animals

[gray wasp]

:l

but like

[red helm]

I mean, there really isn't anything special in the Blackwater areas. Animal Wise and no way you can see all the way to New Austin from there.

[civic nest]

Or at least hunt the legendary ones

[gray wasp]

without glitches

[little remnant]

you were supposed to be able to go to new Austin as Arthur but they changed it before the game released

[gray wasp]

S T U P I D

[little remnant]

it makes sense considering what he was a part of over there

[gray wasp]

but likle

He didnt do anything in New Austin

[little remnant]

a massacre in one of the more civilized cities wouldn’t be treated lightly

well yeah but how else is he supposed to get there

[civic nest]

They could have made it like late chapter 6 with random Pinkerton patrols

[gray wasp]

ye

[red helm]

A super Sniper shooting at him from miles away makes more sense, realistically....

[civic nest]

Of course

Who am I to question Rockstar's attention to detail and realism

Does anyone know if Caliga Hall has modelled interiors?

[little remnant]

as far as I’m aware it does not

[gilded tide]

can you get the misourri fox trotter early…. like chapter three? asked this question like 7 times just tryna cover all users lol

[little remnant]

you can buy a fox trotter from the scarlett meadows stable but it’s an amber one

well it was either buy it or there was some glitch but I’m not a big horse guy

it is possible

[steady vector]

You can get it as soon as chapter 4 starts to just play the story for a bit

You’ll have to buy it for like $950 I think

[hushed flare]

"wHy nOt juSt gEt AraBiAn tHo"

[civic nest]

White arabian best horse bro

I know because it's the only one I've ever had

[crimson bronze]

Arabian Farming for Money.

[hushed flare]

chad

[crimson bronze]

Hell, there's two additional wild coats out and about ever since the moonshiners update.

[hushed flare]

yeah it's the best horse because I've seen 9283829 reddit posts on it and found a video about best horses from 3 years ago

[crimson bronze]

I'm depressed that the top 3 horses from RDR1 all suck ass in 2

Also in my personal opinion since there is no 'meta' to chase in RDR2's Single Player, Literally just use what you like best.

If you like the look of say for example...Ah...American Paint or something?

Use it to your heart's content, literally nothing is going to stop you from doing so.

[past pasture]

arabian are fast and have best stats.. but they are not brave enough.. it will drop you if near predators or when the firing starts 🤣

[past pasture]

there are total 5 coats... 3 wild and 2 buyable from stables

[crimson bronze]

I know this, I'm more saying for optimal profit from Arabian Farming, get the wild ones and sell them off.

[past pasture]

oh yeah.. thats good

but after doing the treasure findings.. i dont think you'll need to farm horses to earn moeny for a long time...

[steady vector]

I much prefer fighting on foot than on horseback, so as long as I can dismount before the Arabian bucks me it’s all good

[gray wasp]

Where do you even find wild Arabians?

[summer garnet]

uhhh white arabian near lake isabella?

that striped one near calumet ravine

[gray wasp]

No, not what I mean

That’s only ONE Arabian

[summer garnet]

Warped brindle arabian near calumet ravine
Red chestnut south west of owanjila

only 3 sadly

[crimson bronze]

Basically what Grape Said, Around Owanjila for the red chestnut and then around Wapiti for the Warped Brindle

[hushed flare]

rdr2 players using meta horse, wide auto aim, meta revolvers and rifles, while also spamming tonics and biggame

[hidden moss]

is there a workaround with the headless zombie bug in undead nightmare

i have the 360 goty version and apparently im fucked and that i shouldve gotten it digitally

[hidden moss]

thing is though

blackwaters in west elizabeth

not new austin

and you can already explore like half of west elizabeth as arthur

[summer garnet]

Exactly we can just move from tall trees to avoid law

to new austin

[hidden moss]

Is it weird that I like shooting peoples heads off in rdr2

[vagrant temple]

Psychopath

Confirmed

[hidden moss]

Lol

Aren’t we all these days

[wraith panther]

I prefer mowing them down with tomahawks

bro

dual wielding a tomahawk and a M1899 would be epic

[heady anchor]

[hidden moss]

I highly doubt they’d allow that 😂

[mild hawk]

knowing rockstar

yeah

[wraith panther]

it'd be epic though

[hidden moss]

wha was ur reaction when arthur morgan died

and what was ur ending

[wraith panther]

he dies?

jk I know, but haven't gotten that far

[hidden moss]

lol

[quartz dove]

I did the last mission of the game with tomahawks only lmao it was so fun

[wraith panther]

someone just coming at you ignoring all the bullets being shot at them and slicing everybody up with an axe

that'd be terrifying

[hidden moss]

Jason Vorhees

[wraith panther]

true

it IS terrifying then

[quartz dove]

Lol

Where are you at in the story very suspicious

[misty cliff]

Dual wield semi autos with unlimited explosive ammo.

I think i'm gonna have some fun at saint denis market.

[quartz dove]

Peace was never an option

[misty cliff]

Violence solves overpopulation.

[quartz dove]

Agreed

Do you know how I get the console role

On this server

[misty cliff]

And then John comes home like nothing to teach Jack right from wrong after murdering 30 people.

[quartz dove]

Lol

Ofc

[frigid cloud]

#roles

[misty cliff]

#roles

[quartz dove]

Cool thanks

[wraith panther]

Chapter 4

[wraith panther]

m o d s

and you?

[quartz dove]

I’ve finished it three times lol

Right now I’m in the middle of a challenge where I only used a sawed off and bow the whole game

The Charles smith challenge

Imma make a few YouTube vids about it

[wraith panther]

nice

is it going well?

[quartz dove]

Yeah I’m on chapter 2 and so far it’s been fun

The train robbery mission in chapter one doesn’t let you bring the sawed off or bow tho

So I had to knife only

[dense mauve]

Did you make your Arthur look like him, too?

that would be awesome

[native pier]

Does anyone use throwing knives in a non meme way? How and why because in stealth it breaks it as soon as you throw by standing up ruining the benefits of the throwing knife in the first place xD

[wraith panther]

why use throwing knives when you can use tomahawks

[native pier]

Same question then but with tomahawks. When firearms exist

[civic nest]

They're useful if you don't want to get the law's attention

[native pier]

? @civic nest how so. Just because of noise?

[civic nest]

Yes

[quartz dove]

I tried my best to make Arthur look like him

I made an outfit as close as I could and I’m chugging hair tonics every chance I get

[dense mauve]

I see

[quartz dove]

Agreed

Ye that would be sick

[wraith panther]

get a wife in rdr2

[hidden moss]

with a lasso

and they say romance is dead

[wraith panther]

some may call it kidnapping, I call it love

[hidden moss]

a man of culture

some may call it a cry for help i call it a safe word

[quartz dove]

“You’ve got a fine way with the women amigo” -Javier

[wraith panther]

safe word that can't be heard

[hidden moss]

some may call it looting

i call it an unofficial prenup

[wraith panther]

some may call it murder

I call it termination of unused assets

[willow vortex]

where are rdr2 asave files?, like progress saved

[wraith panther]

do any core mechanics change in the epilogue?

[dusk mason]

can't swim

[frigid cloud]

Use your horse

[jade adder]

hi can anyone help me?

pleaseee

[marsh relic]

What's up?

[jade adder]

i just got rdr2 right

i used to play on friends pc before but we fell apart

[wraith panther]

wait are you not able to swim in the epilogue?

[jade adder]

abyways

[frigid cloud]

John can't

[jade adder]

anyways

[wraith panther]

wtf

he spent a few months living next to a sea

[frigid cloud]

Any deep water you're dead

[marsh relic]

Lol

[wraith panther]

breh

[jade adder]

i got a copy of the save files and now when i post them into the game save file location and replace the previous ones nothing..... still game starts at the starting

can anyone help me

like why is it not working

[snow basalt]

I know nothing about that. Sorry.

[jade adder]

i had a lot of progress

ok is there anyone i can @ who can help?

[snow basalt]

You could play through again. Now that you know a bit about the game, you can maybe get things you possibly missed.

[jade adder]

nooooo i spend 5 hours in chapter 2 just getting a foxtrotter

i was really attached to that

[snow basalt]

What chapter were you on?

[jade adder]

there must be a way

i was on 3

starting of 3

[snow basalt]

That's not too far in.

[frigid cloud]

Maybe obtaining a mft again could take a while

[snow basalt]

Are they hard to get in story?

I never really messed with that. If the horse looks okay, I'll take it.

[frigid cloud]

Easy in epilogue but early on in chapter 2 with a frustrating glitch you can

[jade adder]

yes in chptr 2 its very hard

[snow basalt]

Ah.

[jade adder]

i dont think its a glitch

like there is a mission to take guide the horse so its photo can be taken

[frigid cloud]

More of a trick

[jade adder]

well after the mission you can just track it

i failed so many times and each try took like a loooong time

[snow basalt]

I literally had that one horse you're supposed to sell when you go hunting with Hosea. I liked the horse and I kept it. I don't know about how difficult it is to get horses.

[willow vortex]

thats a diff mission man

well if anyone knows a fix then tell me ill wait

[unkempt latch]

you talking about the one for the legendary bear?

[snow basalt]

Si.

[gray wasp]

Hey guys

[unkempt latch]

wassup

[gray wasp]

What do I do with say... a 17LBS sturgeon?

[unkempt latch]

how do i get level roles?

is it discord level or ingame

[gray wasp]

Do I sell it or is there another use for it?

[unkempt latch]

what if legendary pelts you can bring legendary animals to a trapper who can make clothing or other cosmetics with it,m he will also pay

[gray wasp]

What

It’s not legendary

And it doesn’t have a pelt

It’s a FISH

and I need answers if I should sell it or not because I’m afraid something will happen to it

[unkempt latch]

i mean

if it isnt legendary

you can sell or cook it

its notgonna give a shit tonne so it doesnt really matter

[crimson bronze]

John is never meant to swim due to RDR1 in that, he could never swim there either due to fear of sequence breaking the game I.E. Getting to Mexico or West Elizabeth early by swimming across rivers.

[frigid cloud]

Sell it

[gray wasp]

Ok cool, hopefully it gives me a bit

[frigid cloud]

You can always catch another

[gray wasp]

That’s true

But

17lbs dude

17!

[unkempt latch]

use normal measurements

how many kg's

[gray wasp]

YO

19LBS catfish!!!

HOLY CRAP

I am the fishing master

[hidden moss]

Fart

[verbal portal]

I just killed the legendary bear with Hosea in that chapter 2 mission.

But now it’s gone and I have to track/hunt it again?

Bruh

[frigid cloud]

That's weird

[frigid cloud]

You killed the bear during the mission right?

[verbal portal]

Yes

With the tomahawk ax

[hidden moss]

my hud just totally disappeared

the minimal disappeared, my health disappeared, and everything else in the hud is gone

nvm it came back, all i had to do was fail the mission lol

[civic nest]

How weird. You're not supposed to be able to kill the bear during the mission

If you somehow did it then the game just didn't count it

[hushed flare]

Can't kill the bear

[long wedge]

You can kill it

[night raven]

I think they meant when you get the option to stay back and hunt it

[long wedge]

If you choose the option to stay hunting

[civic nest]

Oh that

[long wedge]

It’s impossible otherwise

[civic nest]

That's not part of the mission I think

[long wedge]

Nah it’s not

There’s 3 bears that are unkillable in the whole story

[hushed flare]

Bars

[nova igloo]

@long wedge If you're going to tag someone, maybe don't delete it?

[long wedge]

Whoops, meant to delete above,

Anywho

Where do I send the achievements?

[hushed flare]

oh no it's red name

[nova igloo]

Instructions are in #roles

[long wedge]

Sweet thanks

[steady vector]

Yes you can kill the bear during the mission (I’ve done it) but it doesn’t count and the bear just respawns afterwards

[candid cliff]

My horse just died

Is there anyway to get it back

[past pasture]

how?

[candid cliff]

It got caught next to a train

[past pasture]

horse retriever works most of the times

[candid cliff]

There was only a saddly

[past pasture]

only time it doesnt work is when your horse get burnt

which one was it?

[hushed flare]

if it was an Arabian then it was optimal death

[candid cliff]

It was a black horse I got from a mission I think

Really big

[hushed flare]

black shire F

[candid cliff]

Yep that's it

Can I get it back with horse insurance thing

[hushed flare]

There's like 3 horses in the game u can't get again and that's one of them

[candid cliff]

FUCK

I mean, dang

[hushed flare]

Save reload?

[steady vector]

Revive the horse?

[hushed flare]

if it's just a saddle it can't be revived

[past pasture]

with horse retriever

[hushed flare]

horse retriever

[past pasture]

but i think he's in early chap 2 and dont have it

[candid cliff]

No save 😭

[hushed flare]

[candid cliff]

It died like 10 mins ago btw

[past pasture]

OOF

[candid cliff]

I'm gonna rob a store out of anger

[hushed flare]

Rob a train

And the passengers

[candid cliff]

It died during a train robbery 😭

[hushed flare]

bruh

[candid cliff]

Off to rob the valentine store

I'll still be able to shop there right?

[steady vector]

Not immediately but yes

[candid cliff]

Kk

After like a day?

[hushed flare]

Robbing the doctor secret buisness

[candid cliff]

Is the doctor the one with that locked room

[hushed flare]

ye

[candid cliff]

I'll rob them

[hushed flare]

Have to discover side business first

[candid cliff]

Just did

[hushed flare]

k

[steady vector]

You get like $100 and a schofield from that iirc

Dual Schofields are awesome

[past pasture]

good luck 🌚

[past pasture]

the damn sound of it ❤️

[hushed flare]

Good replacement for the upcoming dual lemats

[candid cliff]

Do I have to go in holding my gun?

Cos I can't pull it out

[hushed flare]

Focus on shopkeeper then aim weapon

[past pasture]

dont killl the doc

XD

[steady vector]

Yep I dual schofields until I can buy lemats and dual wield those

[past pasture]

yeah

you can buy lemat from saint denis gun shop

after the party XD

[hushed flare]

not many people even know lemat and Evans exist because they are in a specific gunshop after a specific mission

[steady vector]

I just started chapter 4 again and checked but lemats are still locked

I’ve never tried the Evans tbh

[hushed flare]

Evans is a similar repeater to Lancaster but 26 bullets

And probably best sounding repeater imo

[gray wasp]

Ok you guys didn’t tell me how hard it was to get to Blackwater as Arthur

I could barely get past the river

[hushed flare]

get to new Austin as arthur

[gray wasp]

It’s upsetting because I really like the Blackwater area

[steady vector]

Good story mode gun I guess cause you can insta reload with deadeye