red-dead-singleplayer

[gray wasp]

So when I did the Shady Belle mission with Lenny, I got a Bolt-action out of it, and somehow I also got a Springfield, which I recently learned SUCKS

so where did the Springfield come from

[amber halo]

Any of you having problems with "Favored Sons" or have you had issues with it? Now my f'n plunger won't show up. I can't help but think this is just a prelude to all the shit that's gonna happen. I just re-launched the f'n game, too!

[round hedge]

yeah

you know those night missions from macfarlane's ranch in RDR?

something like that would've been cool

[amber halo]

You guys get the recent update to the game? You know if it was W-11 related? Guessing it was.

Speaking of Favored Sons I bet cordite smells pretty dam fantastic.

[gray wasp]

?

No

idk

[native thunder]

no idea where the Springfield came from

u might've had it before I guess

[burnt estuary]

u get to wear a badge

sexy cop arthur

[gray wasp]

lmao

imagine if he gets arrested

that would be akward

[hushed flare]

running over people in Rhodes without a bounty

[amber halo]

OK well after all that it ay not be a glitch. It has something to do with alcohol only working on dead eye sure sometimes after you've been diagnosed. Well brandy at least. I have had other foods that still work on the cores though even when the 0pop up says you don't need as much as you normally do. In fact I've always thought that pop up was stupid bc it ALWAYS fills the cores back up but this is the first time it hasn't for me.

[gray wasp]

Your wrong actually

I did that and they shot me

I was in Caliga Hall

oh wait

I should have specified

I ran someone over with my horse near Caliga Hall, and the Grays started to shoot me

[amber halo]

GOLY SHIT! This scared tf outta me. On Favored Son's I bumped into Dutch's horse-well Dutch ran into me, and insta-dead. HAHAHA First for everything I guess.

[hushed flare]

Strong horse

[amber halo]

^^^^^^^^^^^^

[night raven]

I just learned about the slide kick you do when you hit melee on a horse

Would have been useful

[amber halo]

HOLY SHIT! I just noticed the tutorial I'm following for Favored Son's-GOLD is using a bolt action. HAHAHAHA That's insane.

[amber halo]

Yep. That's one of the many reasons I research such a massive game like this prior to playing.
Have you figured out how to aim to either side or is it just whoever is closest on that side?

[night raven]

Like auto aiming on a horse?

I think you just move the camera to what die you want to and

Hit aim

[gray wasp]

Hey guys

on a scale of 1-10

how scary is it when you hear a panther yowl, but you dont see it

[smoky hornet]

15

I might install mods

[hushed flare]

With auto aim it's more like a 2

[gray wasp]

but like

you dont know where it is

[hushed flare]

Auto aim does tho

[gray wasp]

tbh that would be kinda scarier

just locks on to nothing

[hushed flare]

Except I use free aim

[gray wasp]

so

what would free aim rank?

[hushed flare]

Probably like an 8

since horse free aiming is hard enough

[smoky hornet]

I'm on PC so free aim

depends

on horse back

like a 6

alone in the woods

like a 15

[gray wasp]

How about alone, at night, in the middle of the woods?

and your horse just suddenly BOLTS

just YEETS out of there

(but actually why are y'all so scared of panthers? do they one-shot you or smth?)

I havent actually interacted with one yet

[solar rivet]

Hey question who’s the random woman in the credits

When Charles is leaving

[hushed flare]

ikr who is that

[solar rivet]

Wym?

[hushed flare]

Haven't had a panther one shot me except the black legendary one

But even if you have a brave horse you can still be bucked off easily

[gray wasp]

dang

[hushed flare]

I've been able to somewhat withstand the legendary one but I had to use potent health cure before hand

[gray wasp]

In front of a certain someones grave?

[solar rivet]

No

It wasn’t that scene

[gray wasp]

OH

OK

idk then

[hushed flare]

Sadie I think

[solar rivet]

In a dress and short hair? Just seems odd

[gray wasp]

Abagail?

[hushed flare]

Abigail doesn't leave tho lmfaoo

[gray wasp]

idek

asking the wrooong person

[solar rivet]

Lmao

[hushed flare]

it's Sadie but tied up hair and dress I'm guessing

Since Sadie somehow resists a stab wound in the stomach cuz plot armor op

[solar rivet]

I’m surprised she lived

[hushed flare]

She should have died

[solar rivet]

It was like a lung or liver stab

[hushed flare]

power of miracle tonic prob

[solar rivet]

Probably hair tonic

[hushed flare]

[solar rivet]

[amber halo]

"Get 35 Head Shots-FAILED"
Uhh huhh. Right. BC Arthur Morgan has shit for aim. He must bc everything I shot at was head, TARGETED! Hehe

[hushed flare]

gold medal accuracy checks when you miss one shot even though it said "70% accuracy":
"Doesn't count chief"

[copper ferry]

Hey, is there a single player mod that lets me beat up Micah in camp for good Karma?

[hushed flare]

also what is this

[hushed flare]

Micah good

[copper ferry]

plz no

just.... no

[solar rivet]

Mary at Arthur’s grave, gtfo hoe lmao

[hushed flare]

How did Mary find Arthur grave xd

[solar rivet]

Cuz she’s a Pinkerton plot twist

[copper ferry]

It's heavily implied Micah kills Cain and that alone makes want to download an sp mod that lets me shoot him outright

[hushed flare]

:0

[solar rivet]

Mary was against him all along?

[copper ferry]

Doesn't Arthur talk with the people in camp about Mary?

[hushed flare]

Play as Micah mod 🥺

[copper ferry]

NO, I want to KILL or MAIM Micah

[amber halo]

I can't cook a catfish. I am currently carrying 1 flaky fish, 1 plain ven, 2 plain pork. Aren't I supposed to be able to cook that thing with such a limited amount of stuff I'm carrying? I'm pretty sure it doesn't yield flaky either and has a completely different inv spot like gritty fish or something.
Jesus over 800 hrs and still not a f'n clue!!!

[amber halo]

Maaaah you just think you do.

[copper ferry]

I legitimately hate people who abuse or are implied to abuse animals

[native thunder]

Qwerty I'm outlaw now <33

[frigid cloud]

Everyone's outlaw 😠

[amber halo]

Def hard not to. He's a whole diff kind of p.o.s.

[gray wasp]

its ok fellow bandit

[frigid cloud]

[copper ferry]

Like, all his other behaviors I can understand/excuse (I keep in mind the harshness of the era,) but hurting Cain is truly unforgiveable.

[amber halo]

OOhhh there's little I can excuse even with the harshness. I mean he wasn't trying to CATCH Sadie when he burned her house down to settle her down. Not at all.

Hey I've heard that breaded and fried catfish is f'n amazing but I can't remember if I've had it. Is it worth it? Looks vile from the outside but I've heard that for many yrs now.

[gray wasp]

IRL?

or-

lol

[solar rivet]

Question

[gray wasp]

Answer

[solar rivet]

What do I do with all the money at the end of the game lmao

[native thunder]

nothing

[solar rivet]

Seems a lil pointless then

[frigid cloud]

Spending spree with high honor discount

[gray wasp]

Buy all the weapons you dont already have

buy all the phamphlets from a fench

idk

worlds your oyster

make sure you dont cut yourself on the shell though

[round hedge]

gets shot by a fucking sniper and the other a knife to the stomach

both survive

sixteen times the detail

[gray wasp]

(damn thats a good metaphor I should remember that one)

[round hedge]

buy horse

kill horse

buy another one

until you go broke

[frigid cloud]

Buy rose gray arabian 🤓

[round hedge]

🤓

[amber halo]

HAHAHAHA OMG the shit has really come out to fuck around today hasn't it. Now I can't fast travel from the same spot I tried to a second ago. Maybe that's my p0unishment for pausing during a prep for FT then loading up.
Ph ya, horse is out of range now, too. HAHAHAHAHA WT actual?!?!
WHAT?? OK somehow the horse DID hear me and came to the rescue.

We trying to make RDR f'm DBD now??? Add more shit and completely fuck up what's already there in the process??? Jesus. That's why I WAIT several yrs to buy a f'n game.

[native thunder]

.

[amber halo]

HEEEEEEYYY FT works again. You know because.....

[solar rivet]

Is it possible to catch the catfish by the penitentiary

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[solar rivet]

How

You get hosed with bullets soon as you get close

[frigid cloud]

I didn't

[solar rivet]

When did you catch it then

[frigid cloud]

In epilogue

[solar rivet]

That’s not possible

[frigid cloud]

I've had no issues while getting to the island

[solar rivet]

And another issue how tf are you supposed to bring it back on a tiny boat

[frigid cloud]

You put it in your satchel

[gray wasp]

No

no...

NO

dont tell me theres a fish by SISIKA?!

[hushed flare]

Eh

Just don't get spotted

[civic nest]

It's not hard to catch

The guards won't see you unless you get too close to the prison

[autumn verge]

I found a dear in the swamps

[hoary blaze]

Central union railroad role?

[vocal hemlock]

they are very common around

[autumn verge]

I though it was my honorable power

[jagged cave]

"Bison ?! Why did you kill the bison ?!" quote had potential to be meme next to lumbago imo

Missed opportunity

[red helm]

Perhaps.

[autumn verge]

no?

[round hedge]

no

[kindred jackal]

Charles having a hissy fit would not make a good meme unfortunately

[glad brook]

Yeah. No thank you.

Only uncle please.

[mild hawk]

or none because the joke is just overrused

[civic nest]

I got to hunt a fugitive with my name lol

He also has my same height

It physically hurts me each time John butchers the pronunciation

[night raven]

Do bounty posters list the target’s height?

[civic nest]

This one does at least

[night raven]

I never noticed that

I wish you could put the posters and pictures you got somewhere .

It’d be cool to do in the epilogue

[autumn verge]

Can Arthur say the n-word

[obsidian stone]

yes

[autumn verge]

nice!

[obsidian stone]

👍🏿

[untold ocean]

one more big score

[autumn verge]

Or sell white Arabians horses

[untold ocean]

what the fuck Dutch

[autumn verge]

So

Arthur's bag

can fit

40 bottles

Maps

food

Plants, Some horns and claws and small carcass

While I had my bag, Which is a tactical bag can only fit a medium size steak worth, Only two sizes of worth of bottles and a knife

this is bs

[night raven]

You forget the concept of the wormhole satchel, or bag of holding

But I love it when games explain that stuff

[autumn verge]

Oh blackjack

some shit it is

[civic nest]

Don't doubt of Pearson's mastery of pocket dimension satchel

[night raven]

Yes

[autumn verge]

Winning with three hits in black jack is going take too fucking long

Welp shit

10 dollars and 76 cents at my black jack

datfaq

[autumn verge]

Fuck

its 11 19

[gilded tide]

how can i get the mft early

like chapter two early

without doing all the albert shit, it’s just too tedious for me

[red helm]

That challenge took me something like 4 and a half hours.

[civic nest]

Mft?

[little remnant]

can you elaborate

[tacit marsh]

Is it possible to lose a gun? I was playing with the Springfield rifle and it just disappeared during a mission. Maybe that's why?

I went to my horse and it wasn't there either

[night raven]

You’re locked to certain guns during missions

[haughty scroll]

Hey so uh

For the It's Art achivement

Do I need to go to John's house after I nab the statue?

[little remnant]

yeah i think he puts it on the mantle

[haughty scroll]

Whoops I guess not, I need to find the statues

Well I'll c y'all when I get this achivement

[leaden bone]

So I'm encountering a bug with herbalist 9

I've literally picked every single herb in the game

I thought I had done it, so I opened a mod menu (In singleplayer, I don't mod in online) and spawned in every herb (Turning off autosave) to see which one I had missed (Its stuck at 42/43)

I grabbed every single herb, it didn't update.

[little remnant]

do you have the one from the exotics quest?

dumb question actually theres multiple isnt there

i know you specifically have to PICK them, not just get them from npcs or anything so that could be one reason

[leaden bone]

Yeah, I literally picked all of the orchids

After getting herbalist 9

The only thing I can think of that could be the problem

Is that I picked all 5 Queen's Orchids before I got Herbalist 9

Like there are none left

But even then, I spawned in one and picked it, and nothing got updated.

[little remnant]

yeah picking ANY herb before you get the challenge will make it not count

[leaden bone]

Exactly, but this should make it count.

Yet it doesn't.

[little remnant]

its weird ive heard people complain about 42/43 all the time but normally theyre still missing SOMETHING

[leaden bone]

Yeah no I spawned in ALL of the herbs and picked them ALL and its still at 42/43

There's even 2 herbs that aren't in the game normally that I picked and those did nothing

[little remnant]

i think if you go to the challenge entry (dont know how to get there on pc) it should tell you which one youre missing

[leaden bone]

It doesn't.

It's actually the only challenge where you have to do everything of a certain thing that doesn't

[little remnant]

strange

[leaden bone]

Break all horse breeds, yeah it shows you the horses you've broken in

Every single other one shows you which one you're missing

I'm just super confused at this point

And if there's limited Orchids why did Rockstar even let you pick them before getting to Herbalist 9, or why did they make the orchids even count at all?

[little remnant]

how far along algernons quest are you

im reading that it can cause problems with the challenge a lot

supposedly his stuff will spawn a few extra things that you need to pick for the challenge (for some reason unknown to god himself)

[leaden bone]

Just the first quest

[little remnant]

thats probably it then

[leaden bone]

With the Egret plumes and LoTN Orchids

[little remnant]

proceed with his missions

[leaden bone]

Agh christ....

Algernon's missions are literally the thing I dread the most about RDR2

[tacit marsh]

No I know that. But it disappeared completely. Like even after the mission it wasn't on my horse. Even as John it wasn't there. (I was close to the end of the game when it disappeared)

[leaden bone]

Thanks for your help

[little remnant]

no problem

honestly its helpful to know before i start doing herbalist stuff, i was just online troubleshooting

[leaden bone]

Ah

Well and it kinda pisses me off too

Shouldn't Herbalist 9 be Herbalist 10

[little remnant]

i hate collection quests honestly

The rock faces, fossils, legendary fish

super annoying

[leaden bone]

It gets boring after a while

[little remnant]

dont even get me started on the cigarette cards

[leaden bone]

It's just the same quest, but the goal and the positions are different

What even is Herbalist 10

Season and cook all 11 types of meat

That one is super easy

Compared to Herbalist 9

[little remnant]

herbalist 9: Traverse the entire southeast of america gathering plants, including dangerous regions.
herbalist 10: haha do a little bit of cooking :^)

[leaden bone]

@little remnant Yeah so after doing a bit of research, Algernon's quest-line does interfere with Herbalist 9 a lot. Turns out that no more orchids of a specific species will spawn until you have completed that quest with that orchid species from Algernon. Oh, and also spawning them in doesn't count either (That's why it didn't update for me)

So yeah looks like I'm SoL.

[glad brook]

Could have been a dead NPCs gun you might've picked up.

[quartz charm]

Getting 75 gold medals is really hard

Goddamn

[frigid cloud]

[untold raft]

[quartz charm]

[amber halo]

Holy shit! Anyone know if that's legit? They really started creating laws against fireworks prior to 1900??
If so then---W O W!!!!

[dusky schooner]

why man cigarette cards is ez

just spam buy the premium cigarrette

[golden storm]

i love how i can shoot a lawman in the head 5 times and he'll still get up but if i shoot one bounty in the hand they automatically die

[frigid cloud]

Scripted probably

[fierce cave]

I shot a lawman in the back and got charged with vandalism

[gilded tide]

fox trotter

[gilded tide]

fox trotter

missouri fox trotter

[late light]

Guys its time for the last mission with Arthur

In gonna complete it with good honour for the first time

[gilded tide]

good honour?

wdym

what does good join our do

honour

[little remnant]

changes the ending

[gilded tide]

didn’t know that

[little remnant]

surprising

it’s kinda common knowledge

[late light]

Dang

Its hard to tell sarcasm apart sometimes

How long are you into the game @gilded tide

[gilded tide]

? i’ve been done for a while

im on another playthrougu rn

[late light]

So you didnt know the honour effects the ending even though youve completed it?

I mean i didnt either

🙂

[civic nest]

Idk if there is one

The closest is the black arabian or a black Morgan

[hidden moss]

there are pure black horses near horshoe overlook i think, awful race

but i think there is

[haughty scroll]

Finally got the It's Art achievement

[round hedge]

chapter 2 with black shire

[haughty scroll]

Took me nearly two months

[gilded tide]

how to get the missouri fox trotter in chapter two

[wanton bison]

you cant

[hidden moss]

that sounds racist out of context lmao

pure black, awful race

lmfao

[wanton bison]

not unlocked until chapter 3

[civic nest]

I came across that Mexican that challenges you to shoot bottles and when I beat him he started shooting at me lol

That never happened before

[night raven]

There’s a few different encounters where that happens I believe. I’ve only seen the one near Rhodes

[gray wasp]

Wait what

He's so easy to beat, and he's never shot me

hes like an ATM

[night raven]

I lost to him in the bird segment

[gray wasp]

wow

imagine

sorry

I use deadeye for like 3/4 birds so

[civic nest]

It's hard without using dead eye

[gray wasp]

its easier

[gray wasp]

well...

I have aim assist so

its a bit easier

But its fun to absolutely destroy him

I've made $40 off of him

[night raven]

It was a long time ago when I had shitty weapons and was running low on deadeye

[gray wasp]

oh

thats reasonable

and to be fair

most people encounter him at the start of the game

so

same boat

[night raven]

Yeah. I could totally beat him now

[gray wasp]

IMagine trying to do it with a 0 condition Cattleman

XD

[night raven]

A toy boat, if you will

[gray wasp]

You

you sir

are the best

[night raven]

[gray wasp]

But yeah once you get a reapeater, he becomes a money machine

$20 a pop

[night raven]

I’ve gotta revisit lemoyne more

I’m in the epilogue now

[gray wasp]

I want to spend more time in West Elizabeth, seems like a nice place

but

Y'know

Tall Trees are off-limits

[frigid cloud]

West Elizabeth theme

[night raven]

Tall trees is really weird

But it’s pretty

[gray wasp]

(the wanted theme?)

[frigid cloud]

No

[gray wasp]

how so?

[night raven]

You get murdered by a gang a lot

[frigid cloud]

When you ride in west Elizabeth not wanted theme

[gray wasp]

:l

[night raven]

The gang is really mean, and gangs go

[gray wasp]

I didnt know each state had a different riding theme

WAIT

hold up

[frigid cloud]

Not riding

[night raven]

I never noticed it

[frigid cloud]

When you're in that state I guess

[gray wasp]

whats the gang for West Elizabeth?

[night raven]

O’driscolls are the official one I think

[gray wasp]

hmmm

[night raven]

There’s about one for each state

[gray wasp]

yeah

exept ambarino

I think

[night raven]

The Del Lobos are in Ambarino for a little bit, but not enough to be significant

[gray wasp]

Lol?!

[frigid cloud]

yep

[gray wasp]

When?

Why

[night raven]

Ambarino doesn’t need a gang to kill you

[gray wasp]

LMAO thats true

[night raven]

Flaco Hernandez

[gray wasp]

wait really?

[frigid cloud]

yes

[gray wasp]

is it enough to put them in the compendium?

[night raven]

Yeah I think so

[frigid cloud]

You can get del lobos in gang compendium early on as arthur by just killing one of them

[gray wasp]

:D

YES

I'll go do that

when I can

[night raven]

It’s the only way I got them in there before the epilogue

[gray wasp]

So I just have to kill one of them, while looking for Flaco?

[frigid cloud]

[gray wasp]

pog

tysm

[night raven]

You’ll have to kill more than one while you’re there, but only one is needed for the compendium

[gray wasp]

(Feel free to DM me anything else interesting I can put in the compendium BTW)

[night raven]

Don’t forget the animals in guarma

[frigid cloud]

And owl feather trinket

[gray wasp]

D;

Thats going to be hard

Stealth in this game isnt optimal

[night raven]

Get the legendary buck trinket too

[gray wasp]

how

I might have already

but how

[night raven]

Kill the legendary buck and skin it

You get an antler

[gray wasp]

OH yeah I've totally done that

[frigid cloud]

stealth is optional, you just don't kill any of them so if you get spotted use health cures but don't kill anyone

[gray wasp]

:l

but

like

I still have to pick up the items

they'll shoot me when I do

I'll try tho

(when I get to that part lmao, still in chapter 3)

Markiplier was able to get it though so I'm sure I can as well

[frigid cloud]

I guess try to sneak in first at least get the items silently

[night raven]

He played RDR2?

[gray wasp]

yes

but guess what

[night raven]

Awesome

[gray wasp]

He said he would finish the game

and he DIDNT >:l

He stopped at Epilouge

smh

but yeah, if you can power through 9 hour long streams, I'd reccomend watching it

[frigid cloud]

If you're already in epilogue y not just finish it

[heavy cloud]

Hi! I started playing 2 days ago and pretty much all I’ve been doing is hunting. I’m leveling up slowly and I don’t mind, I like playing to have fun. Do you have any suggestions of what I should and so tips for the game. Thank you😊

[round hedge]

uninstall the game

[tame hedge]

No u

[round hedge]

already did

[civic nest]

Craft the legend of the east satchel if you don't have it

[round hedge]

[gray wasp]

kinda sus ngl (god I hate that, omfg I hate saying that)

[light dawn]

How do I even discord?

[gusty solar]

How do discord

[civic nest]

How discord

[gray wasp]

Why Discord

[tacit marsh]

I lost a gun. I think. I lost the Springfield rifle. I was doing a mission when I got shot and it just disappeared. After the mission I checked my horse and it wasn't there. I even checked the weapons locker and it wasn't there either. What happened?

[gray wasp]

idk

Purchase a new one?

[pure compass]

wish i always saved before a mission, felt like doing the opposite of what i did! damn

[solar trench]

shit

[keen birch]

Read if you suck.
Receive this message if Arthur Morgan sucks.

[gray wasp]

No. you dont get to say these things, bot or no

*sigh

anyways

hey guys

how do I get arrested lmao

[jagged cave]

Is the woman Trelawny distracts while we rob the car same woman that sings "I'd rather live in saint Denis" in the theater?

[hidden moss]

This legendary channel catfish

Ive been fishing for about 30 minutes now but no luck

😔

[civic nest]

You can't catch it, it's cut content sadly

[hidden moss]

Oh that sucks

[civic nest]

Damn Rockstar spends a whole year putting black bars in cutscenes but can't finish missions

[hidden moss]

It would be an epic catch

Its also going to bug me by showing on the map

[sinful knot]

They most likely are finished cutscenes

The reason why some content might not make it to the final product is either cause the developer doesn't think it would belong in the final version, it might not work, etc

[hidden moss]

It does

[sinful knot]

can be lots of reasons

[hidden moss]

Maybe they are working on it 🤔

Probably working on size

Since it would be massive but also could easily pull you

[red helm]

If it pulled that guy in, like it did, probably best to leave it be.

[hidden moss]

😔 but im addicted to fishing now

[red helm]

The end of the Legendary Fish missions was a tad disappointing. They give you that cool fishing lure, but... you're done, so... umm... whee?

[hidden moss]

Theres no point in fishing after getting all legendary fish

[civic nest]

I guess it comes in handy if you haven't completed survivalist 10, but the only advantage it gives is not having to change the lure

[red helm]

Yup, slightly helpful, if you didn't know about Survivalist 10, before doing all the legendary fish. But, otherwise, whee.

[gray wasp]

hold up, whats survivalist 10?

[civic nest]

Fish every type of fish

[gray wasp]

WHAT

every single fish?

;-;

[civic nest]

Yep

Good thing is you can do it with legendary fishes

[gray wasp]

I still have to go to Lagras and get the special lures...

so I cant

its on my to-do list

but uh

what does it mean by "type" of fish

Like, is it specific or not? (like how a Rock Bass and a largemouth Bass are different fish, but are both Bass)

[civic nest]

It is specific

[gray wasp]

goddammit

[civic nest]

You have to catch every fish in the compendium

[gray wasp]

GODDAMMIT

Even if you caught them before unlocking the challenge?

[civic nest]

But for example if you catch the legendary muskie it counts as if you caught a regular muskie

[civic nest]

Yep

[gray wasp]

thats so dumb

[night raven]

It makes them grindy and nearly impossible to do naturally

[gray wasp]

so. dumb.

[mental shoal]

Hello there fellas!, question, is there a way to increase your Honor with a mod ? I don't want to use a cheat, it doesn't let you save

[gray wasp]

I hate both the gold medals, and the challenges

too complicate

[night raven]

It makes it grindy and almost impossible to do them naturally

[gray wasp]

yeah

;-;

[night raven]

If there is an RDR3, challenges should be able to be done in any order

[red helm]

Just a FYI, Survivalist 9 is catch a fish over 19 lbs.

[night raven]

Also, bring back nightwatch and add an arm wrestle minigame

[night raven]

A few of the legendaries fit that

[red helm]

Or is it over 18?... either way, whatever.

[night raven]

Like the pike

[red helm]

Yeah, but if you've caught all of them, beforehand...

[night raven]

Yeah

Being forced to do challenges in order sucks

I’m still going to do them, but it’s lame

[red helm]

Yeah. and if you don't do Herbalist 9, while doing the Exotic missions... Ouf.

[night raven]

There was no reason to be forced to do them in order either

[red helm]

Rockstar and their non-sense.

[night raven]

Even if we couldn’t see the next challenge until we did the first, we should be able to fufill the requirements for the later challenges

[red helm]

Retro active challenges, would be nice.

Or, baring that, at least partly done. Like when you get to Horseman 10, If you've already tamed some of the horse breeds, those would be counted already.

[night raven]

Yeah. Challenge two for master hunter would have been completed long before I finished number one

Just because I was doing horseman one

[little remnant]

just go into town and greet literally everybody you see, your honor will go up super fast

[mental shoal]

Thank you, I think I'll need to do it a few times

[narrow jetty]

I just said this in general but I'll say it here because I'm flabbergasted

So I'm in single player

Right

And I run into the back of a horse, it kicks me, and a random NPC just pulls out a gun and starts shooting it

Never seen that before

[little remnant]

there’s a guy who straight up shoots his horse in the side of the skull if you beat him in a race

literally immediately shot him in return

[misty cliff]

Does he?

Never saw that happen.

[red helm]

Yeap, I shot that guy too. Jerk.

[little remnant]

you have to run into him a second time after beating him

[narrow jetty]

Yeah that's a random event

[misty cliff]

Besides i shouldn't talk considering the amount of horses i killed.

[narrow jetty]

But this wasn't that it was just like a glitch

A horse kicked me and a random npc started shooting it.

[red helm]

Indeed, sounds like a weird glitchy thing to me. Funny, though.

[narrow jetty]

Because the way it was shooting the horse was as if it was in a gun fight

[misty cliff]

I never bothered to race with him. Always shotgunned the dude in the head just because.

Either that or i declined.

[little remnant]

2nd Degree Murder

[red helm]

Bad idea, you get really nice stuff

[misty cliff]

What would i get

[red helm]

Quicker bonding with All horses. Passive stat boost to all horses...

[misty cliff]

Well, let's hope i run into him in my new playthrough.

[red helm]

There are a couple random encounters. One is a Black lady south of Rhodes, that races to Catfish Jacksons.

[misty cliff]

i only ever saw her once

in 2018

[red helm]

Whelp, you've been missing out.

[misty cliff]

Probably. Still, i'm a happy Buell owner.

[red helm]

Would be a Buell with +1-2 more Speed, if you'd been doing those races.

[misty cliff]

Yeah. I'm not complaining tho.

[quartz charm]

Anyone got 75 gold medals here?

[civic nest]

Only someone with incredible skill and patience could have such a thing

[red helm]

I started working on that after finishing the 100%, up to like 20, but was a bit burnt out, and I'm just... grr and sigh right now.

[quartz charm]

It’s super hard … @civic nest

[red helm]

Also, it's 70 Gold Medals for the trophy.

[civic nest]

Start a new save. That way you won't suffer from burnout

[quartz charm]

Do you think it adds up? Or you only have to do it on one save only?

[red helm]

Pick and choose, only try ones a few times, then move on to another. Try to avoid ones with Timed, they tend to be the "hardest", but remember that Cutscenes count on timed...

Yes it has to be on one save.

[quartz charm]

There’s a lot of timed ones…

[civic nest]

All on one save

[kindred jackal]

Cutscenes should not count for time, that's so dumb tbh

[civic nest]

I think for some missions they count but for others it doesn't

It's so weird

[kindred jackal]

You shouldn't be pushed to skip cutscenes in a story game imo, even if it's just for challenges

[hushed flare]

Meanwhile the accuracy challenges are pretty bs because it could say 80% accuracy but you miss one shot and you fail

[civic nest]

That mission of chapter one with the wolves is the worst. You need 80% accuracy, no damage and you only get a sawed off so you have to let the wolves get close

Also no dead eye

[glad brook]

Literally the easiest mission to get gold on.

I got it the first time I played.

[gray wasp]

wtf...

[civic nest]

I swear I played it like 10 times and never got gold in it

Maybe I'm just built different lol

[little remnant]

im doing my completionist run of RDR2 rn and it’s actually hell

[copper ferry]

Can I get a Machete in Chapter 3?

I'm just checking because when I wiped out Beaver Hollow and I only came across a single Murfree with a knife.

I haven't gone for the Night Folk yet, I just figured I'd ask before going to waste my time.

[true spade]

imagine

[civic nest]

I think you can only get the machete in that chapter 5 mission onwards

Or at least I couldn't get one before in all my playthroughs

[copper ferry]

I was about to say, I see it's buyable from the Fence at Emerald Ranch.

When I looked on the RDR2 wiki, it says that the Night Folk have them, and that you can get one during the mission to save Sean.

[kindred jackal]

Yes you can get one in that chapter 2 mission

dropped by the dude trying to kill Charles

[little remnant]

I got mine clearing out Beaver Hollow

[steady vector]

You guys know where a good place to buy RDR1 for Xbox 360 is?

[little remnant]

the internet 👍

[vagrant temple]

eBay? Craigslist?

I mean 🤷‍♂️

[steady vector]

Does it hold up well after playing the second one?

Obviously that’s subjective but what’s the general consensus?

[little remnant]

yeah

for the time that game was insane too, the graphics are even still pretty decent

[steady vector]

How about the undead nightmare thing

[vagrant temple]

It’s obviously dated but still plays very well

[steady vector]

Is it worth getting game of the year edition for that?

Price probably wouldn’t be much different actually

[vagrant temple]

Undead Nightmare is one of those rare quality DLCs

100% recommend

[little remnant]

it’s because Undead Nightmare could be a standalone game

[vagrant temple]

Mhm

[steady vector]

Alright I’ll get the GotY edition then. Thanks

[quiet gazelle]

I have a very wierd question

Can you shoot up arthurs grave by any chance

Like

Its an actual question

Aint trolling

[fringe shoal]

"You're the Hosea to my Dutch"

[civic nest]

I guess so

[glad brook]

Rockstar originally intended for it to be a stand alone game I think.

[gilded tide]

sure, i’m down for chapter three. how get in chapter three.

[wanton bison]

do the mission "the sheep and the goats"

thats the final mission of chapter 2

then do the mission right after that one

[hidden moss]

theres also a hardcore mode and a few extra dlc in goty

[hidden moss]

its still up on the xbox marketplace btw if thats more your thing

main con of goty however is that it requires disc switching for multiplayer

[steady vector]

I didn’t even know there was multiplayer in the 1st game

[hidden moss]

well there is lol

and it could be argued that its better than rdo which is an easy debate considering how hit or miss rdo is

i guess they never miss huh

personally i dont wanna buy live gold so idc

[little remnant]

RDR1 multiplayer was kinda fun but really not that great

[hidden moss]

ye

i imagine it being fun with friends

but not so much otherwise

like gta 4 mp

[steady vector]

Well I’m not getting it for the multiplayer. Might check it out though

[hidden moss]

still thinking of getting gold just for all the mp achievements

1 has a whopping 91 achievements

most of them mp as you could guess

[steady vector]

RDO is fun but the friend I was playing with didn’t like it for long, and if I’m playing on my own then story mode is much better

[hidden moss]

ye

[little remnant]

I’m tired of games having MP achievements

[steady vector]

I can imagine it being quite fun with a group

[hidden moss]

same

1 has more mp achievements than 2 😂

[little remnant]

to be fair I think RDR1 launched with it

[steady vector]

I’m so glad I don’t care about achievements lol

[hidden moss]

how

[gilded tide]

and then

[hidden moss]

my gamerscore boosts my ego

[wanton bison]

go to the stables in lemoyne

near emerald ranch

[hidden moss]

ye but thing is

theres also more mp achievements

than story achievements

in 1

lmfao

[little remnant]

RDR1 has the lamest MP achievement ever

The rockstar one you can only get by killing another person who has the achievement

[steady vector]

If it’s easy to get then I’ll go for it but I don’t waste time with achievements

[hidden moss]

it had one that referenced lady gaga lol

[hidden moss]

fair im sorta the same

im not gonna 100% the game for that achievement

[hidden moss]

tbf a lot of mp games have that but i agree

[gilded tide]

and then

[wanton bison]

buy the horse

from the stable

[gilded tide]

which

[hidden moss]

the stable

in lemoyne

[gilded tide]

which horse

[hidden moss]

near emerald ranch

[gilded tide]

which horse lol

[hidden moss]

whatever you want

[gilded tide]

aight

then what

[hidden moss]

kill it

[gilded tide]

ok

then?

[hidden moss]

idk

throw a fire bottle at it

[gilded tide]

lmao?

[hidden moss]

volatile dynamite

horses have dismemberment too btw

[gilded tide]

kill it and then do what

[hidden moss]

idk

revive it and kill it again

[gilded tide]

bro so you’re telling me to buy a horse and then kill it?

[hidden moss]

yes

[gilded tide]

which horse

[hidden moss]

idk what you want me to tell you

ride it?

[gilded tide]

i was asking how to get the mft….

[hidden moss]

the what

[gilded tide]

misourri fox trotter

[hidden moss]

buy that horse

then

at that stable

[little remnant]

you play the story and it’ll unlock

[gilded tide]

you fucking can’t

[little remnant]

that’s it that’s how you get it

[gilded tide]

in the epilogue

i want to get it before

how is this so hard to understand lmfao

[little remnant]

too bad

[gilded tide]

i know that you can

[hidden moss]

you could use a trainer

too bad you're on playstation

[gilded tide]

omfg

[stoic arrow]

Can u get back to the tropical island as John marstin?

[hidden moss]

no he cant swim

[stoic arrow]

Huh how bout Mexico?

[hidden moss]

jump the border

[little remnant]

if you just look it up there’s guides for it lol

[gilded tide]

i can’t find any that aren’t patched. the albert mason one is just practically too hard as wel

well

[gilded tide]

which horse bro

[little remnant]

then you’re out of luck man

sometimes you have to cut your losses and carry on

[steady vector]

If you’re just looking for a good horse you can get early then grab the white Arabian

[little remnant]

White Arabian supreme

[steady vector]

I always get it at the beginning and use it for most of the game tbh

[spring sluice]

dont the horse die at the end

[hidden moss]

cool but about the matter of uh

finding it

[spring sluice]

bro

[hidden moss]

thats why you find/buy it again 😂

[spring sluice]

it's the most obvious place

it's in the name

[hidden moss]

oh yeah

so youre telling me

to go to the middle east and kidnap a white arab to use as my mount

[spring sluice]

no the location is in it's name

thats the biggest hint

[steady vector]

It’s very easy to find

[hidden moss]

yeah

in saudi arabia

duh

[spring sluice]

yea he knows where it is

[hidden moss]

ye

also in the uae

was the uae even a thing back then

[gilded tide]

it’s a troll man

100% it’s a troll

[hidden moss]

what

me?

[gilded tide]

“2 blocked messages” the troll is angry

[spring sluice]

he seems normal

[little remnant]

he just made a joke lol?

[hidden moss]

yeah lmfao

[spring sluice]

i think theyre both trolling

[little remnant]

it’s fine if you’re mad you can’t get the MFT early but chill out a bit

[gilded tide]

ayyo they just keep acting like this “buy a horse then kill it” “go to saudi arabia” like tf??

[hidden moss]

bro im sorry i cant actually help you

calm tf down lmao

you seemed to play along when i told you to buy a horse

[little remnant]

all very obvious jokes ?

not really trolling you just got goofed on

[gilded tide]

okay then 🤷‍♂️

[obsidian stone]

that's a pretty funny joke too

lol

[odd gale]

I just caught a gigantic smallmouth bass on the quest where you go fishing with Kieran. When I caught it, the game said it was 5lbs but I have to stow it on my horse because it’s so huge. It seems to be counted as just a normal smallmouth bass because in my inventory it says I have 6 of them

[little remnant]

Bigmouth Bass

[hidden moss]

you find the mft in missouri

btw

@gilded tide

[little remnant]

I’ve been catching some massive fish recently

like 20 pounds

[odd gale]

The fish I have looks 20lbs but the game thinks otherwise

Must be some kind of error

[gilded tide]

..

[hidden moss]

you can change the measurement system in the settings

if its displaying kg

[odd gale]

It’s not

[pearl parcel]

guys can i ask a question here

[odd gale]

It said the fish was 5 lbs when I have to carry it with both hands

[little remnant]

yes

[pearl parcel]

okay so

i did the veteran mission

and i completed it

he said take my horse

i got ontop of it

then click on camp option by accident

i cant find him now

can i still use him?

[hidden moss]

this is why jahn is better than arturd

[hidden moss]

whistle

see what horse comes

[pearl parcel]

i still have my main horse

[hidden moss]

shit idk then

[pearl parcel]

ffs

[hidden moss]

try to use eagle vision to find it?

or reload a save

[pearl parcel]

it went to a completly different place

[pearl parcel]

did that

couldnt

[little remnant]

no icon anywhere? normally your temporary horse is just shown on the map

could also check stables

[pearl parcel]

yeah i did

[little remnant]

if not you better reload the game

[pearl parcel]

it was another horse

[pearl parcel]

i did

mann

[little remnant]

no I mean to before you finished the mission

[pearl parcel]

i was only able to load once

and it was already completed there

i hope i dont lose it

i really hope i dont

its a 5 stat horse

mine is 3

[hidden moss]

you shouldve saddled it

[quiet gazelle]

Lolol

No buell

🥲

I cant speak since ive never finished the hamish missions

[rustic shadow]

whatt kind of breed is boadacia

[hidden moss]

your mum

[rustic shadow]

uhhh

[civic nest]

Horse

[rustic shadow]

😳

[hidden moss]

im bored

jahn >>> arturd change my mind

[little remnant]

Arthur: gets stupid disease
John: gets shot like a 100 times and still stands for a bit
pretty obvious who the chad is here…

[hidden moss]

especially when jahn even took down 1/3rd of ross's firing squad along with him in his dying moments

[little remnant]

to be fair arthur killed a lot of Pinkertons during all of their raids though so I don’t know if it’s the best comparison

John also has the cooler hat

[hidden moss]

yeah but john does it right before he dies

just to flex on the government he has a quicker trigger finger than them

[little remnant]

it’s probably the hat

[hidden moss]

the real best protag

is jack

[civic nest]

No, it's Uncle

[little remnant]

Red Harlow you mean

[civic nest]

Same guy

[hushed flare]

Best protagonist micah

😍

[gilded tide]

[quiet gazelle]

Liver chestnut hungarian

Accordin to some pc files

[rustic shadow]

thanks but does it spawn anywhere?

[quiet gazelle]

You can spawn it in wit mods

I think

But i see ur on ps4

So ig no

[hidden moss]

hey so in the mission u do with hosea on chapter 2 (hunting a bear) when you buy the horse you want the old one disappears (not the black one you sell) Is there any way to ''save it''

[civic nest]

You can just stable it instead of selling it I think

[jagged cave]

An npc made a comment about beaver carcass on my horse, then I decided to greet him and Arthur actually responded according to what he said

Details man

[civic nest]

I didn't know about that one

It also happens when you ride an expensive horse or when you have "ugly" clothes

[gray wasp]

Hey so uh...

this game is actually one of the first games that I really want to 100%

so dont be suprised if I ask for a lot of help from time to time

[hidden moss]

im gonna 100% rdr1 just bc you dont need to gold medal all of the missions

unlike 2

[gray wasp]

yeah

[hidden moss]

id try for 2 if not for that

[gray wasp]

its horrible

[hidden moss]

but thats offputting enough already

so im gonna 100% 1 instead

[gray wasp]

just the whole "challenge" shit is so horribly wrong

[hidden moss]

yeah they fucked up legend of the east

[civic nest]

You don't need to in 2

[hidden moss]

outfit doesnt even look that good too

[civic nest]

Not even for the trophy

[hidden moss]

legend of the west outfit was cool enough

and worth it

[hidden moss]

fr?

[civic nest]

Yeah

Gold medals are only for the trophy and even then you only need 70

Out of like 110 missions

[hidden moss]

i know we're only horsing around but i really like jack as a protagonist tbh even tho he doesnt get enough screen time

[hidden moss]

ye nah fuck that

[civic nest]

Still, you don't need a single gold medal for 100%

[gray wasp]

pog

but

didnt someone else say the opposite?

(someone who also had Best in the West)

[civic nest]

If they did then they're wrong

My 100% save has less than 10 gold medals I think

[gray wasp]

lol

good to know

that reduces my stress about it by like 35%

[civic nest]

The worst about doing 100% is the collectibles. Dinosaur bones and orchids specially

But they're relatively easy if you follow a guide

[gray wasp]

yoo

y'know that river thats west of van horn?

[civic nest]

Yes

[gray wasp]

theres a dino bone there, and I have no freaking idea how anyone would have found it

its so obscure

[civic nest]

If it is the one I'm thinking then it is one of the few I found on my own lol

[gray wasp]

wow

[civic nest]

I was just using eagle eye and saw the yellow bubbles

[gray wasp]

The one in the Oil Derrick was easy

wait

you can use eagle eye?

[civic nest]

Yes

[gray wasp]

I never use eagle eye tho

:P

[civic nest]

It's really useful for a lot of things

[gray wasp]

huh

I even have the trinket that makes you able to use it for longer

yet I never use it

[civic nest]

I use it a lot lol

[gray wasp]

the problem with using it to find bones and such is that if you arent using a guide, I guess its its completely luck based

right place, right time scenario

[civic nest]

Yeah

[gray wasp]

ooh

I have a idea

[civic nest]

And even if you use eagle eye it only works if you're close

[gray wasp]

a simple quality of life change

What if finding bones and orchids worked the same way as treasure maps?

you get a vibrating signal

(in the controller and stuff)

idk how it works on PC

and the closer you are, the stronger and faster it is

that would make it a lot easier

[civic nest]

Do treasure maps work like that?

[gray wasp]

In RDO they do

[civic nest]

Ah, I still have to try online

[gray wasp]

I wouldn't if you want to keep your sanity

lol

but yeah if they worked like that, I'm sure everyone would appreciate it

[civic nest]

The controller would go crazy in the bayou if it worked like that lol

You can spot orchids easily with eagle eye

[gray wasp]

oh really?

Ive found like 2

[civic nest]

Well, "easily", if you know where to look

[gray wasp]

:l

didnt know they were common in the bayou

(I use the term "common" loosely)

[civic nest]

Yeah there is tons of them

But the tricky part is finding the ones you need

[gray wasp]

how many in total are there in the game?

[gray wasp]

you need them? for what?

[civic nest]

Like 20 or 25

[gray wasp]

ah

[civic nest]

The Algernon Wasp mission

Which is required for 100%

[gray wasp]

the w h a t

what kinda name is A l g e r n o n?

somebody must have hated their child

[civic nest]

I'm fairly sure is an artistic name lol

Anyway, that mission is a pain in the ass

But at least pays well

At the end of all the mission you end up with like $700, a unique revolver and a hat

[gray wasp]

oh ok

can I do it as Arthur? (that will always be my first question)

[civic nest]

Yes you can

But do it with a tutorial if you don't want to lose your sanity

It should be available after chapter 4's mission in which you go to the party

[gray wasp]

hmmmm

uh oh

sanity is at stake?

jeez how hard is this thing?

[civic nest]

Not hard but you'll spend hours picking up flowers

[gray wasp]

f

you said there was only 25!

[civic nest]

And if you don't know where to find them, welp

[civic nest]

Only 25 types

[gray wasp]

oh

OH.

[civic nest]

I think I've miscalculated, they must be between 15 and 20 types

But that's not important, he'll ask several of each type

[gray wasp]

oh

but do you need all types for 100%

thats the question

[civic nest]

You need to complete the mission

[gray wasp]

yeaaaah?

[civic nest]

Yeah, and he'll eventually ask for some of each type

Plus some feathers and gator eggs

[gray wasp]

oh

uh

so

we might have a problem with that then

I may have...found and sold a bunch of gator eggs, not knowing why they existed

[civic nest]

Don't worry, I'm sure they respawn

[summer garnet]

Can we just appreciate how arthur has 2 legs in this game my god the realism

[civic nest]

If you press X Arthur runs, it's been 3 years and we still discover things it's crazy