#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 478 of 1

hidden moss
#

John had lots of experience and training by landon rickett.

eager pasture
#

no

vagrant temple
#

RDR1 is a sequel mate

hidden moss
#

RDR2 is retcon

misty cliff
#

He was in a gang for fifteen years. Sure he did.

native thunder
#

Arthur and John have been robbing for like 10+ years .

ebon bramble
#

Okay thanks

vagrant temple
hidden moss
#

?

vagrant temple
#

As in prequel Sadie

native thunder
#

sadie is not as trained or experienced as John or Arthur. therefore she should not be glorified with plot armor as much as she does . her husband dying doesn't give her 10+ years of shooting experience

native thunder
#

it's not sexism, it's just that she's not trained

hidden moss
#

Logic does not work

native thunder
#

unless treedemolisher just can't handle sadie not being simped for

misty cliff
vagrant temple
eager pasture
misty cliff
#

But wild animals do not shoot back.

hidden moss
frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

1899 Sadie isn't

native thunder
#

oh yea 1907 is alright. but 1899 sadie is not. pretty sure we were talking abt her killing o driscoll's

vagrant temple
#

I haven’t played the game in a long time

eager pasture
native thunder
#

tbh game never says she can't handle recoil. so ignore that

vagrant temple
native thunder
#

lol

summer garnet
#

i think he meant charlotte

frigid cloud
native thunder
#

but yea, I'm not saying sadie is bad bcs she's female. im saying she's not as good as the other men in the gang who have been shooting for 10+ years

vagrant temple
#

Some of you must think she’s a defenseless kitchen wife pre prologue I swear.

native thunder
#

I mean, she throws bottles at micah

vagrant temple
#

I think Sadie is written well

vagrant temple
native thunder
#

in the prologue

summer garnet
#

and misses completely

vagrant temple
native thunder
#

micah could've just shot her lmao

eager pasture
#

guys guys guys, let's not waste our time on why sadie cannot be a good gunslinger like the rest of the game in 1899, let's waste our time on who is the best gunslinger (spoilers, it's not micah)

native thunder
#

it means she wasn't exactly trained for that situation in 1899

misty cliff
hidden moss
#

Red Harlow > Landon Ricketts > 1911 John

native thunder
#

Charles with his bow lmao

#

does harlow even exist

vagrant temple
native thunder
#

isn't he just a myrh

#

myth

vagrant temple
#

Arthur is kind of a sheep the whole game

eager pasture
vagrant temple
native thunder
#

Arthur shouldn't have been influenced that much tbh

vagrant temple
#

He doesn’t think for himself until the end

eager pasture
#

dutch does go very crazy in the end

summer garnet
#

I felt like hosea was more of a father to arthur than dutch

vagrant temple
#

Hosea is my favorite character

#

Only one with any sense

eager pasture
#

i am just so split on dutch

#

i don't think he's inherently bad, he just sees himself as the messiah of his own ideology. The martyr against civilization

summer garnet
#

he became like the people he hated imo

eager pasture
summer garnet
#

This is some English teacher level shit right here

#

but true

eager pasture
#

I mean you hear it, when Dutch calls himself a "concerned citizen" in chapter six or so. Wasn't he the one recruiting the gang, trying to leave citizenhood?

eager pasture
#

But i can't say, if i can love dutch as a character.. Or at least love to hate him

ember wharf
#

I don’t get why people hated him, I thought he was cool

#

I personally think Dutch would have helped the gang but Micah was the devil on his shoulder

steep epoch
#

Remember when Charles said he was scared the way things were heading (in chapter 2) and said he doesn't want to end up in a cave, it goes against everything Dutch believes in. coughs in chapter 6

eager pasture
ember wharf
#

How would you guys rank the gang members

eager pasture
#

by morality?

#

or by how much we like them?

eager pasture
#

wheres that tier list?

#

oh found it

ember wharf
midnight elm
#

how fly

ember wharf
#

Most of you would probably put Micah at the bottom

#

Personally Molly is dead last for me

ebon bramble
#

Rip my horse died and I had no reviver so I put it down 😦

vagrant temple
#

🥺

ember wharf
#

One time my horse was dying in a field

#

So I ran all the way to Valentine on foot

#

Bought horse reviver

#

And ran all the way back

ebon bramble
#

It’s sad because I just modded it to the max and spent like 100

ember wharf
#

Sometimes if my horse is dying I’ll turn on cheats

frigid cloud
#

Should've bought some horse revivers

ember wharf
#

Then the game doesn’t save

frigid cloud
#

That's not efficient imo

#

You can just quit the game

#

And load back in

ember wharf
#

No it’s not efficient at all

ebon bramble
#

I did that but I still saved

ember wharf
ebon bramble
#

It worked sometimes but I guess it didn’t this time

ember wharf
#

Not after

ebon bramble
#

Yea I put it down first to see what happened then I quit

ember wharf
#

Or just idk buy some reviver

#

Sometimes I don’t have reviver and I feel bad that it’s suffering

ebon bramble
#

Also why in the events with the white dot ⚪️ do I accidentally walk into them and then they run off

ember wharf
#

So I shoot it in the head

#

Like they do on farms

#

One time I missed with a fire bottle and accidentally killed one

smoky hornet
#

this game is scarier than many horror games

austere escarp
#

xd

raw ore
#

i have an yt link in my "about me"

true wave
#

The way the gator just rushed toward the boat and jumped

austere escarp
#

I played that mission alone, at night

high wasp
#

yeah same

true wave
#

I screamed at 11 pm almost waking up my parents

high wasp
#

shit was scary

true wave
#

Also, that time Arthur gets kidnapped by the o’driscolls

#

I was terrified

high wasp
#

the way his vision was blurry and he was hung upside down

round hedge
#

and leaves with no scratches

#

in a cutscene

high wasp
austere escarp
#

yeah both missions where hell scary (in the context that both of them I played them like at 12 am and I'm eleven)

smoky hornet
#

just roanoke ridge

#

and the bayou

#

and tall trees

#

those 3 places

high wasp
#

i played them late but the arua of the missions were just scary

austere escarp
#

yeah

smoky hornet
#

i swear roanoke at least is haunted in some way

austere escarp
#

I think I read there is an easter egg of a ghost

late light
#

Yes

#

In the Bayou

#

A woman

true wave
#

I saw that one

austere escarp
#

I think there's one in Roanoke Ridge too

smoky hornet
#

roanoke's got the pentagram

high wasp
#

and tall trees is just scary

smoky hornet
#

there's also a connection between butcher creek and the braithwaite's secret

#

if the strange man vids are correct

misty cliff
#

Undead Nightmare in RDR2.

#

now that would be something

#

but of course online is what makes the most buck

paper kelp
#

I don’t know I honestly dislike online

high wasp
#

same

gray wasp
frigid cloud
#

Y

gray wasp
#

idk

#

demons

native thunder
#

yep

gray wasp
#

do be spook tho

native thunder
#

everything on the east has a certain horror element to it

#

like the swamps and roanoke

gray wasp
#

yep

austere escarp
paper kelp
#

Guys is there a legendary rat

#

I know you kill one in the epilogue but you can’t skin it for some reason

frigid cloud
gray wasp
late light
#

Sad

#

Legendary possum

cedar quiver
#

Hey so after leaning the denim jacket is missable can somebody tell me all the stuff that’s missable in terms of clothes?

hidden moss
ember wharf
#

I wish it was more RDR2 oriented

#

It’s full of mini games

paper kelp
#

Yea and its grindy

#

Like I would gladly grind if it was rdr2 oriented like you said

#

Some missions have trelawny and Sean but its not much

cedar quiver
#

Also I don’t wear spurs.

hidden moss
cedar quiver
#

Ok then.

hidden moss
#

I recommend checking out missable items in rdr2 wiki though.

#

There are so many

cedar quiver
#

Playing the epilogue for the second time.

#

After that I’m doing a new game again.

hidden moss
ember wharf
#

There are probably a ton of people that don’t know about the gun in New Austin

cedar quiver
#

Red Harlow’s Scorpion gun?

cedar quiver
#

Maybe the steam deck can play it.

hidden moss
cedar quiver
#

Any vanilla ponchos though?

#

Even technically?

round hedge
#

no

solar rivet
#

I have a very serious question

#

Does the bandana or mask do literally anything or is it just looks

hushed flare
gray wasp
hushed flare
#

Committing crimes with bandana still effective kind of

round hedge
#

it has a mechanic but it's bad enough to work only for looks

random oasis
#

I have 5349 dollars

solar rivet
#

And what are you gonna do with it

random oasis
#

Idk

#

I have good guns

#

And my camp is goof

#

Good*

#

And my clothes are good

hidden moss
#

Atleast that’s how I see it, kinda makes sense. They also change clothes for the valentine bank robbery

hidden moss
ember wharf
#

Bruh who robs stores

#

You get like $20

true wave
#

beginners?

hidden moss
#

what to do when uncle wont give me my mission?

ember wharf
true wave
#

yeah

ember wharf
#

Not really worth the risk

true wave
#

it's not

hidden moss
quiet gazelle
hidden moss
vagrant temple
hidden moss
#

wait nvm it appeared

hidden moss
#

because the game is soo boring once you beat it

vagrant temple
#

I have the guide for RDR2

#

I really need to find the time to do everything in the game

#

Because the guide has it all

#

Even though I don’t need to I want to do everything

autumn verge
#

Who is annabelle

#

And is she just a girl?

hidden moss
#

Then gave up

#

Too much work

autumn verge
#

This is bullshit

#

I have another fucking problem

#

RDR2.exe warning on a windows 7 alert

#

how the fuck do I fix this

#

Is it something to do with the compatibility in steam?

#

The internet hates

#

me

#

the fucking internet hates

#

me

paper kelp
pine dirge
#

so I'm looking to craft the Trophy Buck outfit and two of the items list the Legendary Fox Pelt as requirements... are there multiple legendary foxes to hunt? I've already killed one near Rhodes

candid walrus
#

Nope, only one legendary fox. When you kill + skin it you automatically get the number of pelts you need for crafting anything.

pine dirge
#

so I've already crafted the gloves and I'm trying to craft the moccasins... so you're telling me I have enough of the fox pelt(s) to craft it still?

candid walrus
#

Mhm

pine dirge
#

as well as the buck vest (which I'm just now seeing needs the leg. buck pelt as well)?

#

hmmmm ok

quick geyser
#

what something fun to do I completed the epilogue

pine dirge
#

rob a train?

#

I had high honor and just went fuck it, I'll rob a train

glad brook
#

Go hunting.

#

Stuff like that you may have missed during your first playthrough.

vagrant temple
#

It’s impressive

candid walrus
#

Yep

quick geyser
#

i wrote almost all those things down

#

but on the top of my list is to fish for all of the legendary fish

red helm
cedar quiver
#

Where can I post my Arthur Morgan?

round lotus
#

is it about fashion or the character in general

amber halo
#

"...You will now remain in dead eye when you fire your weapon if you have not tagged a target"
That sounds like a nerf to me. So I have to turn D.E. on then off for every shot?

night raven
#

itI's essentially used for when you miss a tag or so you can turn and fire at something outside of your fov

red helm
#

You can look at it as a nerf, in one regard, However, you can look at it as better in another regard. It's debateable.

night raven
#

it also lets you shoot things like thrown dynamite out of the air in deadeye, since you can't target it.

#

I wonder if you can shoot down a throwing knife

red helm
#

Indeed, it's better for moving targets and those sorts of things. But if you just use dead eye to head shot one or two guys, and nothing else.....

#

Varsatility.

night raven
#

yeah

#

it just makes it easier to shoot things that you can't tag

#

like locks

#

I really struggle with those

#

well now im curious if you can shoot knives and stuff out of the air. This is the only reason i regret quitting reddit because it's the only place where i could get an answer to that specific of a question

round lotus
#

I think its better if you want to do tricks or something like that using throwables like dynamite

cedar quiver
quiet gazelle
#

Im so fucking pissed

#

This damn train finished off rachel

#

Where am i finna get a seal brown thoroughbred

#

I cant

#

Smh

#

Im not reloading the game bc i aint loosing my perfect panther pelt

amber halo
#

"Take care of business or scurry off...?"

If I were a smart outlaw I'd say scurry tf out of there, let them think anything they want-TOO MUCH IS GOING ON!

Get tf out and you may have plenty of time later. It's that simple. Hehehe only in imagination land I guess.

#

HAHAHA Wading through dark green, zero visibility, neck high swamp waters teaming with gators at 9PM.
My kinda party. Some people do this shit still I think. Crazy!!

late light
#

The great horse menace

#

Locomotives.

#

Donni have you played through the game once already?

amber halo
#

WTH?!?! Doing the gator mission and I'm dying. HAHAHA First time I ever did it, knowing nothing about it, I passed it easy. Not now. Weird.

late light
#

E

#

Are you rescuing the fisherman?

#

Or did you just run into an alligator

quiet gazelle
#

The closest thing i have to rachel now is the dark bay turkoman or seal brown warmblood 😞

amber halo
#

Dutch all ignorant af about the savagery of some people. HAHAHA loser!

sterile sky
#

Finally finished the story
God john is so sexy

lilac prism
#

The first thing I bought after completing the very final game mission was a shave for John’s beard then I bought the rose gray Arabian horse

late light
#

Bald John

#

Less gooo

#

Bald Arthur, even better

amber halo
#

OMG John was also hit in the face with a gun! Just realized that! HAHAHAHA

late light
#

He has taken so much abuse

amber halo
#

he def has.

#

So that's weird. I'm at the swamp about to go to Bronte's and the bait shop is inaccessible. I play the mission but reload to check something and now the bait shop is open. Weird glitches. HHmmmm So I wonder what other stuff we can do that with. Although about now all glitches have pretty much gotten removed or don't matter.

#

And why we don't serve Bronte up alive is just baffling. Makes no sense to me.

#

I tripped on a chair with Bronte on my back so he dies? Just double checked on my vid.
YEP! Don't trip on the chair trying to put Dutch in front of you when you exit the mansion with Bronte. HAHAHAHAHA Stupid.

summer garnet
amber halo
#

I still wanna find a way for the Ardennes early.

quiet gazelle
#

Some bounty hunters ride a bay roan ardennes

amber halo
#

It's weird how they make it look like Dutch crossed some boundary when he fed a DEAD Bronte to the alligators. I expected him to do it when he was alive. I think it's pretty weak to do it after. I mean if I'm in his position? Pft! He goes in alive.

#

@quiet gazelleWHAAAAT?!?! Any idea where? When? Like ch 2??

quiet gazelle
#

Any time

#

Like

#

Just get it up

#

And then

#

Soon enough a bounty hunter will ride a bay roan arden

amber halo
#

OK just start studying them all then? There's a bunch that cross the Dakota pretty often.

quiet gazelle
#

Or buy it for 140

amber halo
#

I'll def take that neg honor. I'll waste 4 hours of saying "Excuse me" to build it back up. Fine with me. Then I'll trot into cougar country and laugh at the thing while I pull out my pump action to make it's f'n head disappear!

#

@quiet gazelle Buy it on ch 2??

#

In*

quiet gazelle
#

Yeah

#

Scarlett meadows stable

#

Or build your bounty up and nick the horse from a bounty hunter

amber halo
#

No shit?!??! HAHAHA well then that's it. Def gonna use that. Just wondering if they're as brave around wolves as cougars.

quiet gazelle
#

Yes they are

amber halo
#

W O W!!!! TYVM

quiet gazelle
#

Also quick tip

amber halo
#

$140 is nothing.

quiet gazelle
#

Do not hunt with race horses brov

#

Or arabians

#

Nono

amber halo
#

Hell no. Race horses are trash. Well if you can keep them going then turn around they are really good but good f'n luck keeping them going.

lilac prism
quiet gazelle
#

They are way too skittish

lilac prism
#

My beloved Rose Gray Arabian is what I use for everything

amber halo
#

Like we're way past the wolves or a bear and it starts stopping. Like really RS?? Come on!

quiet gazelle
#

I tried hunting on a thoroughbred

#

Stopped, bucked me off infront of the panther

amber halo
#

Ya you can pull it off but man it's a pain and a gamble. I can't stand how they start stopping after they've left the preds in their dust.

lilac prism
#

I’m used to the skittishness of the Arabian but I’ve never tried hunting with it

amber halo
#

HAHAHA Then just left you to deal with it. AAhhhh gotta love em.

quiet gazelle
#

I got the red chestnut thoroughbred with cheats

#

Tried to stable it

#

Broke my game

amber halo
#

You can usually just run past the wolves if the timming is right but it rarely is. I had a white one once and after the one race the pack came and she stomped tf out of a wolf and kept me on the whole time. I was like DAM LEVEL 6 BOND YO!!!!

quiet gazelle
#

I got 1mil in this save

amber halo
#

So do they monitor story mode games??

#

Like I guess they have anti cheats in story??

lilac prism
#

Not really

amber halo
#

OK well I wonder how their game broke then.

quiet gazelle
#

No but the red chestnut is only for rdo

amber halo
#

AAAHhhhh so it whacked the code. Dam hell of a cheat.

quiet gazelle
#

Yes

amber halo
#

@quiet gazelleHAHAHAHA Legit using the horse to hunt them. Too good! I see it gets stressed af but it just deals with it. That's top notch. I like how these other "War Horses" freak just like the Arabians. I used the one you steal from the guy who owes the debt and it bucked me first sign of something funky.

late light
#

I got the special edition or something

#

When it came out

#

Where my war horse at?!?! 🤬

quiet gazelle
#

The iron grey is only for pre order

quiet gazelle
amber halo
#

Holy shit. So that mission at Bronte's was 5 hours!
We clear the house and put him into the boat in probably 1 hour maybe? Tops? So the swamp trip must be 2 hours each way from Lagras to his house.
OK disregard. I just mapped it and hadn't known this yet.
We go from Lagras to Bronte's then from there to Shady. Pretty dam cool mapping it afterward like that.

plucky comet
#

Hm

amber halo
#

Another weird thing I just noticed. The 2 overly sophisticated men trying to prove their worth to the woman in front of the gen store in Val were arguing and the one said "People have tried to drowned him..."
"Drowned". I'd imagine these characters wouldn't mess that word up and the subs state it properly as "Drown". Interesting. So much shit it's crazy!!!

#

Takes me about 13 mins to take a bath and in that time the guy walking into the Val hotel when I buy the bath (as early as possible after spending the night) doesn't make it to the end of the hall by the time I get out. HAHAHA Weird stuff.

#

"What about the money in Blackwater?"

"Forget that-it's gone"

Kinda calls for insta 3 cylinders to the head to me. JS.

amber halo
#

"A shifty, no good, killer on the run from the law".
Y E P!

obsidian crown
#

omg I can't find a silver earring anywhere

amber halo
#

No idea here. GL

quiet gazelle
#

Good luck on the campaign

#

After chapter 4 the kiddy outlaw happy gang life shit ends

amber halo
#

Who you talkin to @quiet gazelle

hidden moss
#

May i stand unshaken

#

onlyyyyy

#

i miss the crash of worlds

hexed orchid
#

My favorite pastime in red dead is massacring the del lobos I'll never forget the day they killed my horse outside of tumbleweed

gray wasp
#

Who's ready for another day of not playing RDR2 because my dad's banned me from entering his house ever again?

#

(Im very tired)

#

but I could try and steal my own xbox

#

what do you guys think?

late light
gray wasp
#

Its a long story

#

but basically I got in trouble and my dictator father blew it out of proportion

#

and I may have yelled around 7 years worth of pent-up anger at him

dense mauve
#

If you're banned from entering his house, where are you now?

jaunty flume
#

Who can give me RDR2 to use /gameshare on XBOX please let me play my acc got hack and i just start game

#

So I dont mind restarting but i just bought it on my hacked acc

gray wasp
dense mauve
#

I see

gray wasp
#

Is it theft if the item I want to take is technically mine? Because imo if you gift someone an item, it becomes the gifted person's property

dense mauve
#

Probably is theft unless you get consent

gray wasp
#

consent from whom exactly?

#

my father?

#

thats hilarious.

dense mauve
#

I don't know

gray wasp
#

*sigh

#

well It'll probably work out

#

I'd apologize for what I said to him, but that would be a lie

languid perch
#

i have a confusion

#

im doing the master hunter challenge

#

im in challenge #6 right now

#

and it says ive killed 1 cougar with a bow and skinned 2 cougars

#

im confused

#

do i have to skin only three cougars and i can kill the other four with a bow?

native thunder
#

@languid perch yes. basically the challenge is kill 5 cougars with a bow, and skin 5 Cougars. since u skinned 2 Cougars, u only have to skin 3 more, but still have to kill 4

languid perch
#

hm okay thank you

#

btw got any good cougar spawns?

#

im dying out here lmao

#

i waited 20 minutes and got only 1

quiet gazelle
#

Theres a good one

#

Around braithwate manor

#

Not even 1 minute and a cougar had already gone for me

amber halo
#

"Look out another boat on the right"
Turn to my right I see an ocean, turn to another right I see an ocean, turn to another right I see a mountain....
"Hey I've got a plan" nothing happens.

TF with this mission??

languid perch
quiet gazelle
#

No

#

A place near there

#

Like

languid perch
#

thats depressing

quiet gazelle
#

Bottomish of the map

hidden moss
#

sad

languid perch
#

many yt vids have comments saying the beach near annesburg has alot

#

hm

#

so i should go to the annesburg beaches?

#

just run around there and ill eventually find one?

#

thank you

misty cliff
#

micah is a good guy

hidden moss
#

Dude’s the best

misty cliff
#

people who didn't pay attention to rdr2 story. Clearly he is cool and good throughout the game

hidden moss
#

Cool & average more, but still a good guy

amber halo
#

Wow that island mission is broken af. Dam I didn't realize it was this bad.

misty cliff
#

yeah

amber halo
#

The island attacking mission.

amber halo
#

Ya

hidden moss
#

What’s broken with it?

amber halo
#

Wonder how many times I'm gonna have to do it before it works

#

Well there's no aim of any kind with anything and the cannon just stopped firing, no direction or instruction for anything, no wewapon switching, just left trigger and shoot.

hidden moss
#

Ah prob just reboot ur game

amber halo
#

Cannon just stopped firing and I'm sitting there trying to fire right now. Wonder how long it's gonna stay like that.

hidden moss
#

How is he pathetic? He’s awesome

late light
#

Who?

hidden moss
late light
#

Bro

#

🤬

smoky hornet
#

what horses have you mainly used during your playthrough(s)?

hidden moss
amber halo
#

OK there we go. Just all died so maybe I an fire the f'n thing this time. Maybe it's bc I hit the boat with my first 4 shots. just freaked the game out.

dense mauve
smoky hornet
#

I ended my first playthrough with a golden turkoman, currently using the perlino andalusian for my second, and plan to use the chestnut arabian for the third

hidden moss
#

He just surviving, he’s a great man. Pick your battles

dense mauve
amber halo
#

The only thing good about micah is when he capped that roofed sniper in Rhodes in about 1/1162nd of a second.

hidden moss
dense mauve
#

Not sure if you can call him a good man

hidden moss
#

Called him a great man, he knows how to fight, to survive, to get out on top

#

Brutal sure

amber halo
#

AAAhhhh ok. All I needed to do was reload but never got the prompt. I def hit the button though. I hit them all.

hidden moss
#

Great man nonetheless

dense mauve
#

If you think Micah is a great man, I dread on what you think is a bad man

hidden moss
#

There are no bad man

#

There’s bad choices

#

Ppl aren’t bad nor good

#

Choices are

#

They define you momentarily

smoky hornet
#

???

hidden moss
#

God killed thousands, he’s seen as a great man isn’t he

dense mauve
#

No

hidden moss
#

But that’s my point ^^ good/bad ppl don’t exist. It’s just choices that ppl see from different perspectives

smoky hornet
#

I'm not a religious guy so I can't really have a say on whether he's good or bad

smoky hornet
#

no

amber halo
#

I thought I was right about something. Characters say "Fella" subs tell us "Feller".

vagrant temple
#

Wrong chat but I am sorta

smoky hornet
#

you wouldn't wanna be in their presence

#

god dammit jim milton

vagrant temple
#

The last season?

hidden moss
vagrant temple
#

I haven’t watched past the 1st season but I know what happens

#

The last season was terrible

misty cliff
#

micah was a realistic outlaw, unlike arthur.

vagrant temple
#

The writers are absolute trash without source material

smoky hornet
hidden moss
#

Simple truth is ppl are complicated

vagrant temple
#

I think they’ve proven that

hidden moss
vagrant temple
#

It’s just the lack of source material

hidden moss
#

It’s all a matter of perspective, consequences of other ppls choices

smoky hornet
#

reminder we're meant to be talking about yee haw: sad edition the sequel here

vagrant temple
#

The last season was completely freestyle writing

misty cliff
#

why concern yourself with nonsensical good and bad, just go for it and have fun

vagrant temple
#

Also let’s talk in #general @hidden moss

smoky hornet
#

how's fenton

hidden moss
#

Every action, every choice has consequences

#

It’s that easy

dense mauve
hidden moss
#

You can’t please everyone

dense mauve
#

Yes

hidden moss
#

So don’t worry about such stuff

#

😂

amber halo
#

Gotta love micah's, well I'd say beer belly but in his case, PUNK belly.

misty cliff
#

deviant art

#

probably

amber halo
#

micah's asking about Blackwater again on the boat ride back to Lemoyne???
See? Some of this stuff is just HUH? Especially after you get to play a few times and really catch some stuff.
Just as they were leaving Dutch said that money is gone.
Weird.

hidden moss
#

one of the newspapers in de story mode says that Arthur Morgan died by Pinkerton raid but that is a lie

amber halo
#

Dutch on the ride back INTO Lemoyne "Anyone disagree? Anyone?"

Everyone breaks eye contact with him.
Whew.

#

@hidden mossHa! Media. Gotta love it.
"Propaganda is the most powerful weapon in war". Can't remember who said it but they did and they are right.

frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

yeah that can be

amber halo
#

Making that ride down to Shady from Van Horn rn after the return....GAWD that song!!!
Hits my f'n heart hard!!!
Turn on cinemativ and listen. Whew.

hidden moss
gray wasp
#

Why does the game want to go fishing so much?

#

I fished with Jack, then with Hosea and Dutch, then with Kieran

hidden moss
#

lol

#

fishing is fun :/

amber halo
#

I'm thinking if anyone with half a brain just heard Dutch say the exact same thing he said before they left the country, about getting more money and leaving, they would have either just stayed on that boat and taken it somewhere else or gone back to that hell hole in Guarma and started doing their own thing.

Dude legit just repeated himself as if the massive failure didn't even happen. That's it-it's over. It's literally international now. Nowhere to run to. Gotta split up.

#

No irs to report income to at that point.

#

You could easily change your identity back then.

late light
#

Öne more plan Arthur

amber halo
#

Gov income tax doesn't come back for about another 12 yrs. Long time to make a new person.

gray wasp
#

Dutch is like a broken record

amber halo
#

Ya

gray wasp
#

keeps saying the same thing, wth no actual progress

amber halo
#

Yep. Talks a lot.

gray wasp
#

He's just a showman

amber halo
#

Like a politician. HAHAHA

#

EXACTLY like a politician.

gray wasp
#

tbh he would make a great politician

amber halo
#

Sgreed

#

Agreed*

gray wasp
#

Strauss would maybe be his campaign manager

#

idk

hidden moss
#

strauss is shit

gray wasp
#

Indeed he is

amber halo
#

I'm thibking Hosea.

gray wasp
#

maybe

amber halo
#

Hosea can set up a great show.

gray wasp
#

yeah

amber halo
#

Strauss could fund it

gray wasp
#

sad we didnt get to see enough of what Hosea was good at

amber halo
#

Ya Hosea was awesome!

gray wasp
#

R* MORE HOSEA

amber halo
#

^^^^^^^^^^^^^

gray wasp
#

He didn't deserve the death he got, didnt even have any last words

#

just died

amber halo
#

Hell no. F'n Milton takes out one of the physically weakest, UNARMED. F'n scumbag.

hidden moss
gray wasp
amber halo
#

HAHAHAHAHAHA

gray wasp
amber halo
#

I'd have to say Milton giving micah a run

hidden moss
#

hosea had a bounty on his head and he was a dangerous criminal in the eyes of the law though

amber halo
#

Milton thought he was a badass. I kinda wish he got his another way but it was still good.

#

Ya but Hosea was still very wesk and unarmed.

gray wasp
#

SADIE GET THE DYNABOW WE'RE GOING HUNTING FOR A COUPLE OF BOWLER HAT-WEARING SNAKES

amber halo
#

weak*

hidden moss
#

he just shot hosea to intimidate the gang, in order to force dutch to surrender

#

he just caused a massive shootout instead

amber halo
#

True.

#

He shoots him then gets tf out of Dodge! HAHAHAHA Punk

hidden moss
#

milton was a coward

gray wasp
#

Hosea deserved to rest away on some land out west like the original plan was. Like a conman's retirement

amber halo
#

F'n coward af. At least micah would stick around for the shootout and be pretty productive.

gray wasp
amber halo
#

HAHAHA exactly.

gray wasp
#

Like I totally though he died then

#

but APPARENTLY NOT

amber halo
#

Ya they move and 10 seconds later BAM

hidden moss
#

"i shall hunt you to the end of the earth and the end of times"

#

arthur exits barn

#

milton: ah shit

amber halo
#

Already can't wait for my next play through.

gray wasp
#

"This idiots really starting to irritate me..."
one of the scariest Arthur lines imo

hidden moss
#

runs away

hidden moss
gray wasp
#

to kill EVERYONE

hidden moss
#

how the hell did he slip away that fast

gray wasp
#

idfk

hidden moss
#

even arthur is asking himself that

#

during the shootout arthur keeps saying "where's milton?"

#

or things related with milton

gray wasp
#

Where's Milton? Arhtur asked calmly.

amber halo
#

All the chances they had to blow Milton away. So mant times they just should have glanced around and said, "Really?"

BAM BAM BAM BAM BAM-repeat 70 times.

hidden moss
gray wasp
#

Just that one scene of Arthur charging out of that barn was so badass

#

I'll never forget it

hidden moss
#

as arthur exits the barn all the pinkertons turn around like "ah shit"

#

lol

gray wasp
#

I just want a sequence of Arthur tearing through enemies, slowly advancing to the main guy he needs to kill. (like that Darth Vader scene from Rogue One)

hidden moss
#

did y'all know that milton had a wife and a little kid?

gray wasp
#

Oh good now I get to end his bloodline!

hidden moss
#

arthur made a mistake in riding to camp at the end

#

the pinkertons followed him lol

gray wasp
#

did they? that confirmed?

#

idk

hidden moss
#

i mean

#

before going his separete ways he did not kill all of them

#

the rest of them were in van horn

amber halo
#

Ha! Here I was thinking you didn't get a neg honor for stealing that horse to ride back to Shady after Guarma but it pops up after the song. F me!!!

frigid cloud
#

I wouldn't worry

amber halo
#

Nah

gray wasp
#

(wtf why is one of the challenges on that moonshineing mission 85% accuracy?!)

#

I cant do that!

gray wasp
#

;-;

amber halo
#

It's just funny it takes that long to pop up. I can see that confusing tf out of people.

gray wasp
amber halo
#

HAHAHAHAHA

hidden moss
#

until i found a horse

#

shitty horse

frigid cloud
#

Also you need to kill 5 grays while escaping and there's only 5 grays but Sean is faster than you and kill them before you can

amber halo
#

Horse is amazing looking though. SHIT!!

hidden moss
#

but a transport at leats

frigid cloud
gray wasp
#

oh wait

amber halo
#

It's so hard. You really have to know where they're ocming from to steal them from the others sometimes.

frigid cloud
gray wasp
#

that brings up a questopm

frigid cloud
ember wharf
#

I found Saint Denis by mistake

frigid cloud
#

ah nvm

#

I just realized

gray wasp
#

the moonshine one in chapter 3

frigid cloud
#

With hosea?

gray wasp
#

no

#

with the deputy

#

and Dutch

frigid cloud
#

ok

gray wasp
#

I wish I knew the challenges ahead of time

frigid cloud
#

That one's complicated yeah

#

you cant take damage, have to get 10 headshots or smth and high accuracy

gray wasp
#

NO DAMAGE?!?!?

#

WHAT THJE FUCK

#

JEEZ

#

I'm never gonna 100% this game

hidden moss
#

the very first time i played the game i was pushing micah's horse all the time, because in a youtuber's video he pushed micah's horse and micah said: "Oof", i pushed micah's horse so many times waiting for him to say oof

#

his horse died

#

and i failed the mission lol

frigid cloud
gray wasp
#

you have to do shit like that 70 times...

#

*pain

#

there are 210 challenges minimum

#

because some have 4

amber halo
#

So I get those yellow sparkly things that pop up when you're investigating something but I'm not getting any tips or clues from them. It's when you get back to Shady from Guarma.
Is there supposed to be a clue prompt or am I just supposed to basically put it together that shit went down?

civic nest
gray wasp
civic nest
#

If you want I can check which missions I chose to get gold and send you the list

gray wasp
#

wait

#

what

civic nest
gray wasp
#

do you not have to do all of them?

compact wing
#

isn't 70 the number of all missions?

gray wasp
#

yeah isnt it?

civic nest
#

No, it's 100+

compact wing
#

i thought there were only 70 missions

gray wasp
#

WHAT

#

YES

compact wing
gray wasp
#

WHOOOOOOOOO

compact wing
#

does the side ones count?

gray wasp
#

I CAN SKIP SOME

#

TYSM

civic nest
compact wing
#

you saved my life

gray wasp
#

so you can skip around 30 missions to get gold

#

nice

civic nest
#

Yes

gray wasp
#

NICE

compact wing
#

but there're still 70 fucking missions to play

gray wasp
#

yeah

#

I'll do them last

#

save the pain for when my skill has improved

civic nest
#

I just started another save and did the story from the start knowing what to do in each mission to get gold

frigid cloud
#

@gray wasp gold medals aren't needed for 100%

gray wasp
#

Hey guys I forgot to say, I'm actually gettin-

#

really?

frigid cloud
#

yes

gray wasp
#

but-

#

that...

frigid cloud
#

For 100% you just need to do what the game tells you to

civic nest
#

They're needed for platinum tho

frigid cloud
#

I said 100% but yes

gray wasp
amber halo
#

Is the Hungarian Halfbred as badass as the Ardennes when it comes to wolves and cougars?

frigid cloud
gray wasp
#

so...

#

I dont have to do it?

frigid cloud
#

No

#

Gold medals aren't required for 100% completion

gray wasp
#

you sure?

#

ok

#

cool

frigid cloud
gray wasp
#

anyways I'm getting close to completing the Zoologist achievement

frigid cloud
#

nice

gray wasp
#

well...close is a strong word

#

Im making good progress

#

Do legendary animals/fish count?

frigid cloud
#

No

gray wasp
#

Ohthankgod

#

imagine if Guarma animals were required

#

that would be so unfortunate

frigid cloud
#

still possible but more difficult

gray wasp
#

I'll try to get them in anyways, for the journal

frigid cloud
#

Luckily rockstar knew players would miss them

gray wasp
#

Good on ya R*

#

There is a issue with getting the Zoologist thing though

#

and that issue is called: small birds

#

I've tried to use the binocs, but I dont know where to look specifically in trees

#

I missed a woodpecker that way

compact wing
gray wasp
#

;-;

#

the pain...

#

the incoming pain...

compact wing
#

be a goddamn man

#

as arthur said

gray wasp
#

I only have like 3 golds

compact wing
#

I've got something like 15

#

but i've never tried to get more

gray wasp
#

they're so fucking difficult though

amber halo
#

Frustrating how they string together like 6 missions leaving Guarma. Just go go go go go go. Like why even make rest a part of the game then since a bunch of stuff is always gonna push us with zero sleep.
Said it before. Really feels like a ocmpletely different team toward the end.

gray wasp
gusty solar
gray wasp
#

When it comes to it, you guys are totally helping me with "It's Art"

amber halo
#

@amber haloYa. All the missions there were basically just war style stuff. I guess that's kinda cool bc it's another facet of style but......nah. Not this game. Then the constant pressure when you get back, move instantly, get attacked, repeat.
I guess it's also a good way to produce mounting pressures. "Stand Unshaken" meh.

hidden moss
#

guarma chapter was soo boring in my opinion

#

you basically kill the entire island

#

+alberto fussar

amber halo
#

Ya. Stupid.

#

So just got rid of the Pinkertons with the gatling....let's see if I get to loot 40 of them now. I doubt it.

#

From what I've seen the first time we really visually see Arthur looking different is when he peeks through the doors in the Lakay ambush. His face is all blotchy and pale and he has a pretty hard coughing afterward.

amber halo
#

@frigid cloudJust counted them, too. 31...and there's one leaving I can see on the map during a cut scene. Wow never checked that before. He's just free to trot off like nothing while we sit there and....ugghh......"PLAN" with Dutch.

#

Never knew they'd show up like that on the map during a cut scene.

hidden moss
#

i just realized that there is actually pinkertons patrolling van horn

#

they attacked me

amber halo
#

Shit there's 2 of them on the map and they aren't moving.

#

SHIT!!!! Couldn't chase them!

hidden moss
#

shoot em down

hushed flare
#

:tompog:

amber halo
#

70% accuracy with the gatling?
I've seen lots of tutorials about lots of different things and, oddly, they are never staring into blinding light like I am. I'm guessing there's some missions where you literally need to adjust lighting to get the gold on.

frigid cloud
#

But I've done it on first try

hushed flare
#

70% with Gatling is just using Gatling like a semi auto

amber halo
#

It looks like headlights pointed at your face. Not the tutorials though.

#

"Dead Eye ambush" whatever tf that is. I always panic when my D.E. just keeps ticking away and I can't figure out how to use it during some of those things.

hushed flare
#

uh skill issues

frigid cloud
#

^

#

When Arthur kicks the door=dead eye ambush @amber halo

amber halo
#

@frigid cloudOK. Still don't really know what that means though. Just start marking then pull the trigger? I think I always pull the trigger early or something. I need to record it some time or something.

#

Anyone know if the fast travel map is no longer used in Lakay? Not finding it in the shack and I'm guessing it's gone now.

frigid cloud
#

Tag 2-3 enemies and fire away

#

Or just don't use tagging

wide pivot
#

Can you unlock the dudes buying stolen horses before Sean’s death?

amber halo
#

@wide pivotYa. Way before.

#

@wide pivotWell I'm pretty sure anyway.

#

I can't believe the f'n horse fence only gives $10.40 for that amazing looking black/white Hungarian Half that you yoink from Van Horn getting back from Guarma.

gray wasp
#

wait

#

hol up

#

I heard someone say earlier that they fought Pinkertons by Van Horn

#

at some point in the game do Pinkertons show up around places other than the Blackwater area?

#

I've only fought them near Onjiawa or whatever its called

#

The combat in this game gets super monotonous, yet I still enjoy it for some reason. I just remember running from the law into a dead end in the start of the mountains, I took cover and fought off as many as I could. I love those situations where you either kill them all or die. unfortunatly I was met with the latter, but I;d totally get into that situation again.

hidden moss
gray wasp
#

No lol

#

Saw a playthrough up until end of Chapter 6

#

So I know that end of the story

hidden moss
#

Ah ok, well then u know the story

#

They appear around van horn after killing Cornwall

gray wasp
#

Oh alright

#

makes sense

hidden moss
#

Patrols are posted all over there then

gray wasp
#

ok

#

(Are there any animals ***near *** the New Austin area that Arthur can study without being sniped in one-hit?

#

Like, not actually in New Austin

#

but close

#

I wanna get as much done with Arthur as possible

hidden moss
#

Hmm, maybe pronghorns… but can’t remember for sure if those were close to blackwater

gray wasp
#

Like, regular Pronghorns

#

the ones all over the Heartlands?

#

or different ones?

hidden moss
#

Nah I think they’re different

#

In NA atleast

#

But not sure about close to blackwater tbh

#

You could always go to NA with Arthur

round hedge
#

and get shot automatically because they punish you for trespassing

hidden moss
#

Nope

#

There’s a mission U can use

#

To explore whole of NA

gray wasp
#

Even if your health is fortified

hidden moss
#

Nope

#

Not in mission

terse heart
#

I wish you could store one large mask on your character

hidden moss
#

I can DM you the link, it’s kinda a glitch, not allowed here

civic nest
#

That glitch was patched

hidden moss
#

The new method too?

gray wasp
#

Well, guys

#

just tell me where the death barrier is

civic nest
#

I guess you're referring to the Angelo Bronte mission

gray wasp
#

or where you start to get shot

hidden moss
#

Where you go during the mission? With John riding with you?

hidden moss
terse heart
#

It sucks how desperate they are to restrict you from blackwater and new Austin as Arthur

civic nest
hidden moss
#

2 weeks ago someone on vid said it did

gray wasp
#

Pin the location where the sniper starts to shoot at you on a map, and then message it to me in the media channel, so that I know where to stop

hidden moss
#

Looks like it does still work

gray wasp
amber halo
#

So we can fast travel TO Lakay but not FROM Lakay. HHmmmm

hidden moss
#

why didn't john just surrendered as soon as he exited the barn :/

#

or did he just wanted to die

ember wharf
#

Side note but remember that underrated mission where the gang fights off enemies inside a burning barn

gray wasp
#

Yes

hidden moss
#

Hi . I have a Problem. ever happen that Steam Just Starts Red dead online? I want to start rdr2 offline and cannot anymore. I am using scripthook mods

dusk mason
#

Are there any singleplayer sombreros you can save? trying to get the del lobo look going

hidden moss
#

It Always start this Rockstar Launcher sayingi dont man rd online

smoky hornet
#

for my next playthrough I may try to go a route where I'm not a millionare the whole game, I'll trigger the aberdeen pig farm encounter after the Valentine bank robbery (I'll try to avoid getting many items before then) so I'm more encouraged to perform robberies and actually use the butchers for money and not just the trapper

amber halo
#

"We don't take kindly to outsiders around here"

"Well we don't take kindly to those that don't take kindly."

smoky hornet
#

"This is murfree land!"

"No."

#

"Die!"

"No but with a shotgun."

gray wasp
smoky hornet
#

what if the murfree brood was just short on jelly beans and was looking for Fenton so he could give them jelly beans

#

speaking of

#

Fenton was really underdeveloped he could've had more of an arc

#

Rip Van Winkle aswell

gray wasp
#

Imagine that you had the option to defuse OR Greet.
Rancher or smth: "You get off my land"
Arthur Callahan "HEY THERE PARTNER"

smoky hornet
#

no no no

#

you play as Tacitus Kilgore

gray wasp
#

I just think its so comedic to run at someone while also yelling hello to them

smoky hornet
#

it is

#

more serious question: Which is scarier? Bayou or Roanoke?

gray wasp
#

Welcome to the gang, we have:
Aiden O'Malley
Rip Van Winkle
Fenton
A fucking Rat
and more!

smoky hornet
#

roanoke for me

#

roanoke's atmosphere is generally more gim/somber while having the looming threat of the murfrees

#

plus there's tons of anomalies in roanoke

#

the bayou is also terrifying

#

with pleasance and the night folk

gray wasp
#

But the fucking Nite folk

smoky hornet
#

and the goddamn crocodiles

#

the night folk are more paranormal/eerier but the murfree are just straight up terrifying

gray wasp
#

Aw shit

smoky hornet
#

you've also got butcher's creek in roanoke

gray wasp
#

thats a good one

#

Just...

#

both, both are bad

#

But you could easily turn Roanoke into a horror game, just remove 3rd person, your guns, and your horse.

ember wharf
#

I remember the first time I got access to the repeater

#

Now I don’t even use repeaters

gray wasp
#

Lancaster superiority

smoky hornet
#

i prefer repeaters cause I basically just go for headshots and prefer fire rate in that ragard

#

regard*

#

probably about 80-90% of my kills throughout my first playthrough were one shots

ember wharf
#

Bolt Action rifle is all I use now

#

And the bow because it’s fun

smoky hornet
#

the bow IS fun

ember wharf
#

I like the Bolt Action rifle because it’s LOUD

gray wasp
#

I can't really hit headshots in rapid succsession, it screws me over in RDO

smoky hornet
#

I'm on pc so no auto aim

amber halo
#

"It's ok, it's ok. You're safe"
As he hugs her and gives her a nice fresh breath of "Die in a yr or so".

smoky hornet
#

i still haven't done jack shit in rdo

ember wharf
#

The Evans Repeater is OP

#

I wish fire worked like how it did in the barn mission

#

It just keeps burning

gray wasp
#

ye

ember wharf
#

And the building starts getting destroyed

#

I guess that’s too advanced for this decade

smoky hornet
#

it'd be possible to fuck up a lot of the game in that regard

#

it wouuldn't make sense to jsut have buildings reappear and if you just burn down full towns a lot of the game's features are gone

ember wharf
#

It would be so sick

#

If you could destroy buildings

#

Bro I don’t even care about that

#

JUST LET US SPAWN IN CANNONS

smoky hornet
#

plus you'd probably kill mickey

#

and the town dogs

#

mickey is great

#

and if you kill dogs in this game you might aswell be renamed to Micah Bell

gray wasp
#

what if its an accident

smoky hornet
gray wasp
#

yeah

#

I havent done that btw was just wondering, I always say hi to de good bois

smoky hornet
#

the only dogs I justify in killing are those mangy dogs in butcher's creek

night raven
gray wasp
#

dont tell him anything

#

let him discover Arthur dies and then maybe he'll try to be better

smoky hornet
gray wasp
#

like you're supposed to

smoky hornet
#

everywhere else I'm very polite

amber halo
#

When you rescue the chick from the...whatever they are, in the cave (Murfree) do you get any extra honor when you decline payment from her mother?
I think you get honor either way but anyone know if it's like more points?

hidden vine
gray wasp
hidden vine
#

he doesnt seem super clickbaity

#

HE IS SUPER CLICKBAITY

gray wasp
#

he does to me

#

OH LMAO

#

I KNEW IT

#

I KNEW HE WAS BULLSHITTING

#

I havent even watched his videos and I just knew

#

just the way they look

hidden vine
smoky hornet
#

he's the absolute worst

gray wasp
#

HAHA!

#

*victory

amber halo
#

FTW just talks about everything in detail. I haven't seen anything clickbait yet but a grip of peep complain that he is. I think bc he titled one video something along the lines of finding a cure for Arthur.

smoky hornet
hidden vine
amber halo
#

Other than that, which really wasn't clickbait, he's pretty good and explains a lot and does a lot of research trying stuff.

gray wasp
smoky hornet
#

and if you want in depth videos you can go to Strange Man

#

whose editing and production quality is superb

gray wasp
#

love him

amber halo
#

Videos are videos. People create videos. Simple enough to me.
I have several mini tutorials saved in my bookmarks-he has the most. I only like pertinent info, he delivers that mostly. If not I'd not have anything from him. Plain and simple.

ember wharf
#

You have discovered MrBossFTW

#

His content SUCKS

hidden vine
#

i remeber seeing a 27 sec vid yesterday which showed letting jamie die in a mission and in the comments someone sayes "mrbossftw made a 11 min vid on this"

gray wasp
#

:l

#

IMagine making a 10+min long video when a 30sec clip will do

amber halo
#

The scene with Molly on her exit arguing with Dutch really is incredible. Fantastic scene till grimeshow comes into it.

smoky hornet
#

he acts like a fortnite youtuber (nothing against fortnite I really enjoyed the early seasons, just the communty surrounding it is something) speaking about games with generally mature themes

#

honestly scrap that

#

he's just a shitty CC

hidden vine
#

lmao

#

thats agreeable

gray wasp
#

but yeah u right

amber halo
#

Arthur really looked like shit even before his passout cough. Pretty much before they got to Lakay I'm guessing is when he started "Feeling bad". I noticed it far before then. Head tilts and turns a bit to the right when he's standing straight looking straight ahead.

hidden moss
#

And the first cough was a dead giveaway tbh

amber halo
#

Ya.

gray wasp
amber halo
#

100%

gray wasp
#

For me, his first cough was after raiding Chez Porter

hidden moss
smoky hornet
#

i didn't do much free roaming in chapter 6 because I'd rather have my experience fit the urgency of those final moments so I didn't get to see the effect of Arthur's TB nearly as much as others did

gray wasp
hidden moss
amber halo
#

It's weird. I always use D.E. a tiny bit to line up head shots and never EVER get the correct amount of head shots for the objectives. I've literally gotten nothing of what looked like only head shots for every shot-NOPE! Like just now with the Murfree's. All of them were hs's. I aim no where else. HAHAHAHA

smoky hornet
hidden moss
#

Ah, tbh veteran questline is better with John

#

Don’t wanna lose Buell

smoky hornet
#

this playthrough i'm gonna release my horse into the wild before that final mission

#

I don't want em to die

hidden moss
#

Doesn’t work

smoky hornet
#

perlino andalusian

hidden moss
#

I mean in a way I suppose

#

But they’ll still be gone

smoky hornet
#

yeah ik

#

just so that it doesn't have to die in a technical sense

#

idk though

#

cause the final ride would be much more impactful with my main horse

hidden moss
#

Would be fun if we could release them, and later found a horde of mixed horses by the ones Arthur left behind

#

Imagine Turkoman & Buell mix

frigid cloud
gray wasp
#

better with arthur

hidden moss
#

Only as a late visit

#

Right?

#

She was dead for me first time I played