#red-dead-singleplayer
1 messages · Page 474 of 1
Everyone says the talk with Sister is better though
Jfc I didn't remember gambler 10 to be so hard
Look at that, I just had to complain about it to get it
How can i fix pixelated hair and clouds?
How many hours has everyone put into red dead 2 I’ve only put 90
I've lost count of how many times I've replayed it, so I would guess 400 hours
So our ROI of getting micah out of Strawberry is a $300 bill. NICE! He never pays up. HHmmmm Now there's no way to ever make it worth while. We never get to collect. Man if there's anything this game does is definitely build some frustration.
Nothing for Dutch......
Nothing for micah.
Nothing for Colm-kinda.
@hidden mossRight around 600 and in far too short of a time period.
@frigid cloudMaybe I forgot. Doing another run now and this $300 right off the bat is kinda rough. How much do you get from it? I completely forget. HAHAHA
u get 330$
And you get his holster. Ya $330 still doesn't make up for it for me.
So $30? Whew, that's pretty massive. HHHmmmmm
I mean $300 for the bounty we had and we get $30 back? Not for that scumbag. If it was triple then it might be worth it.
I thought game lowers you bounty after the mission
I waited several days now. I thought it did too after a bit. Like pretty quickly. Couple days but it was at least 5 or 6 days and it didn't budge. Wasn't a D/O either. Just a huge f'n bounty. Didn't get silver on the mission but apparently killed enough to blast to $300?! Pft wutev.
Yeah i got 90 hours in about 3 weeks
because of lockdown
I barely Got 15 hours on the game
"Potent Snake Oil". The easiest, cleanest, most legit way to make consistent halfway decent money every single day. Well aside from probably poker. However if you're doing a run through, main missions only, it really helps. Nice racket to be in. Although it's literally NOT main missions only then. That's a pretty tough task-main missions only. Nothing else.
Nice to see the weapon loadout's been adjusted......
Ahh so the Valentine hotel "Entertainment" leaves around 1:45 am. HHmmmmm wonder where they go.
Followed a woman from that little camp right next to the main strip in Val from Val to her camp.
She goes to her camp, sits at the fire and sobs. Shaking her head sobbing. Kinda dark and I never watched through the night or anything.
"I expect you'll betray me in the end..".
IRL, my cue to move on..
"Potent Miracle Tonic" the rich man's PVE and PVP cheese, making you immortal and making deadeye super spammable. And you can carry 99 of these with the right satchel
what actually happens when you die in rdr1
i respawned at some campsite and lost my master hunter progress
thought that was a bug
You simply die

Hi
Where do I find American gray fox
I searched for it online but it shows up a big area on the map and not the exact location
Because there's no exact location
Oh
Why does my health core drain over time even tho I don't get hit or do anything that damages the health
The outer ring is still full
Is that because my character is underweight?
Nah
Cores drain overtime
And will drain rapidly if poisoned or wearing a coat in desert for example
It's basically like a life core. Realism.
We all get tired. We all get hungry. We all are losing health and energy each second that passes for the most part.
Also weights will affect your cores a little. Fat = take more damage. Thin = take less damage. They both have a stamina trade off as well.
600+ hrs and I hasn't eaten bulrush before?? HAHAHA Loved that reaction.
Weird. The very first time I ever viewed the fast travel list I was given a massive list of places I had never even been near.
This run through it's just the few places I've been. Very strange.
guys i think i broke the horse fence
NIICE
i killed one of the guys and now the shop wont open back up
no its just that it wont open like its always closed
story
i have one more horse i have to sell for a challenge
Dam that's interesting. Well seems like there's a bug. Unless that's just what happens.
Can't be what happens if you need to sell the horse, right?
Well I guess there's always the stable rip offs. Everything is stolen to them.
Has anyone been able to secure an Ardennes in ch 2? I've seen a vid on how to see it immediately as it spawns but it's dead. Instantly drops dead every time.
WOAH charles is back???
nonononononono guys i think my game is broken
- charles and john just talked ab how sadie knows where micah is so pbviously chrles shouldnt be back
- horse fence is closed forever
oh itsa glitch?
How do I take wild horses to sell
Do I need to physically travel that long and sell it ?
Tame the horse and take it to horse fence
And also, you might bond with it which sells for more
Cleaning after a kill is so incredibly off it's crazy. It's so bad I could see it playing as a deterrent to the enjoy-ability of the game.
My buddy gutted a deer in the wild once. It took nowhere near the time they are making it take in game.
I also find it comical that I am getting clean kill after clean kill with regular arrows before I open any crafting requests. HAHAHAHA
@frigid cloudHow far would you bond? 2?
Like by actually driving the horse all the way back to the fence ?
Should i replay rdr2
I’ve finished it 3 days ago but i can barely remember anything from chapters 1-2
Oki
Says I have collected all cigarette cards, I cant send any mail at a post office, and the "post all sets" is unchecked
anyone know what may be the issue
Last playtrough i rushed a lot of things so ima play it slower now
Also what to do if the animals don't apper in the location where they are in the guides and vids on yt ?
I tried sleeping too
And went to some other place and then came back as well but still they are not there
They're not consistent locations meaning they won't be there always
Keep searching in that area
😂🤣
@gusty solarAbsofuckinglutely. I'm on my 2nd run and the first resulted in 4 restarts. This run is main story only as much as possible. Good guy. Then I'm gonna do main missions only bad guy. Then I' not decided on good or bad yet but gonna do a full game all achievements and stuff. There's so much to see and learn it's insane.
if I make john bald, will his hair grow back?
oh ok nice
quickly
I went baldy and became a lil worried
bald john is scary
Just chug those hair tonics
yeah mine looks like he came straight from chemo
bought 3 and drank 3
Nicee
One thing Red dead is the longest game that ever took me to beat a game
There's longer games out there than RDR2. I have beaten it few times in 3-4 days.
My brother tried to play all through the Witcher 3 but got too bored of how long he had to play
Never bothered with witcher myself. Heard good things about it but i don't think i will ever try it myself.
I took me 4 weeks to beat the game😂 but I have heard good things about the witcher
I was talking about red dead
I played like hell when i first bought the game
It took me 2-3 months
Still took me a good 4 days
damn
I cant wait to be at chapter 2 again
You really took your time huh?
I should too
I blast through the missions too quickly
Well i only played like 1/2 hours a day
Oh
Long term investment
Absolutely love this game tho so i dont mind
My first play through took 11 months
Damn
Now I didn't play non stop, but I wanted to enjoy the experience and make it last
can i get a oil wagon aa john and where
Finished my 2nd playthrough last night. Time to attempt tearing myself away from this game and play some others….. 🥲
Wish me luck 😂
Goodluck😄
Just have to expect nothing else will match the quality of RDR2
But still enjoy them for what they are ig
AC Unity is close. Great story, great graphics, and nice combat system. Worth replaying after finishing RDR2😄💖
I've played that recently. It's actually AC Syndicate I'm trying now. Not expecting it to be great, but it's the only AC I haven't played yet
is there a way to load a new game in rdr2 so u start again at 1% and then skip the entire story so u can play with john and the 20k dollars? i ask because i want a new clean satchel and i wanna explore anything again but i dont wanna play all the 6 chapters again
What is the hardest mission in yall opinion
The entire story makes up like 70% tho.
The first Rhodes mission on the train. Get the criminal without taking a single hit
Only did that once
Never got gold since
The guy with a knife?
Anderson or smthing i think
you need to be a dodging master
Ye xD Did it once, failed in my other 6 playthroughs
That’s my most difficult mission. Hard to get gold in
i know i already have 100% but i wanna start new from 70%
You gotta rush through the entire story then.
r
I've done it before. Only for my save data to get corrupt. 😭
yes
Also a long mission so if you fail the gold medal you have to replay 20+ minutes
But is a piece of cake on pc, you can bring out a revolver with hotkeys and slap him
im trhing to rob a train on bards crossing but the game is doing everything in its power to not have that happen
How close am i to the ending of epilouge 2? Im at the mission that john. Goes to blackwater with abigail
How close is that to the ending?
vro....
What…!
🤬
Not a new chapter the ending of the game
You said “just bought this game”
I assumed, you said braught
But i just asked how close i was dont spoil!
Ye. So im telling u to leave
Cus spoilers here
Saint Denis gets nuked at the end
😏 😏 😏
By the Spanish Armada
And the Ark of the Covenant is opened
Unleashing God's wrath
good ending
Mega high honour ending
slightly above neutral honour ending
Seeing a deer means good honor right ?
Arthur: "Like I said, I'll handle this"
John: "Alright then."
John keeps getting in the way no matter what. Nice!
John taking no shit
John's a derp. That's why he's in debt like a mofo.
Everyone calls him derp
RDR2 John is just wimpy dude bruh
Fuck
I thought i could smell swedish people from a mile away
Youre Scandinavian though
100%
No :]
WHAT
😏
🤬
Why tho
Hylke is very
Scandinavian-esque
Like 19th century
theres just something about you!
Danish?!?!?!?
No
And of course-the first "Sure, I'll pay ya later". HAHAHAHAHA They fall for it every time. For a bunch of tough wranglin, money making dudes they're pretty f'n pathetic when it comes to collecting.
is it just me or this kid from the first mission in saint denis looks like Jimmy Hopkins
when you fail to catch up with cleet
No
Left of that :)
i'm always nice to him, i wonder what happens if you're mean to him
i can't find any videos of what happens if you're mean
I killed him by accident he just respawns
No one has tried in the history of mankind
Mrbossforthewin 😂
Form the Netherlands btw
Close enough...!
Just about
that dude clickbaits like a "Boss"
Most of his vids are clickbait
i have a question... everytime i ride out of camp as arthur i lose some money
i cannot understand why
no lol
why do i have to donate money
literally no importance
Bc dutch has a plan
they just npc's for me
i do not care about their morale
Just count the times he says 1 more score or i have a plan
i remember it took me like 3 playthroughs to learn that you can customize guns
👏
Even though theres a specific mission that teaches you how to do that. 🥲
i have a lack of attention
lol
There isn't though lol
Sheep and goats.
You just buy a gun but ok
now i waste all of my money customizing guns
@hidden mossThat's awesome! I learned most of the game before I played. I watched streamers for so many hours and it ruined nothing and I still forgot a ton.
Like horses. I've got over 600 hrs and just a couple days ago learned that the best horse to have is probably the Ardennes and it appears to now be impossible to get. It spawns in dead. I saw a vid of it. Dude was standing there while a cougar was walking all around it's hooves. Like W O W! That's a good horse for sure. Not gonna win a race but you aren't getting knocked off nearly as much as any other horse when near a pred.
Homeless guy in Val isn't quite what he says. Def has problems, though.
why does people says that john's death was unexpected you can literally tell that he was gonna die as soon as he exits the barn.
bruh
nooooo!!!1
Your Welcome
a l i e n l a n g u a g e?
Its got to be in valentine again
well
how do you guys style the Trappers cloak?
you can't style it
Is it me or apolossa is girls favorite in the game
Is it?
dutch :(
Is rdr1 short compared to rdr2?
Just now dawned on me. It's too bad we didn't get to see the oil container blow sky high in "Pouring". That would have been pretty cool to use.
yeah
Do I download single player separate to online
has anyone been able to confirm if animal versus animal death leaves a perfect pelt?
No.
@ebon brambleNope. Same launch.
Oh so I just need to buy to play?
you can either buy combined or buy it seperate
You can buy online separately. If you buy the story game it comes with online automatically
Oh it’s because I bought separate and now I want to do story
yeah you'll have to buy story
I bought the game from epic and it has both OL and story. I had no idea they were sold separately. Weird. One price, $35 for me.
yeah rockstars sells it both combined and seperate
yeah
it's pretty short
it has less missions than GTA V
yet feels longer
Hm. I want to play it now since I like rdr2 so much
i wanna play the first one but i dont have a ps3 :'
Not quite. You can’t buy story separate without online
yeah forgot to mention that
it's completely different from RDR2 btw, way more cartoony
and I'll also say that it has more realistic peds damages that you'll enjoy
like making them unable to walk if you shoot both legs lol
Yoooo I liked that mission, knocking John off the wagon was my favorite moment
John: "Bear left here-" BONK
how many times did dutch left john to die lol
None, he was going to come back for him when they were ready, he just needed to have faith and money.
o f c o u r s e
He has a godamn plan
Okay I bought the story mode
It looked fun and I heard people saying it was good and i can rob trains
yeah it is better than online imo
Welcome to the gang!!
I think so someone said more interactive
Thanks 😌
You'll be crying by the end, G U A R A N T E E D!!!
@ebon bramble don't come into this server if you don't want spoilers lol
until you finish the game at least
Yeah, this is the place where we all sit down after finishing and cry for a bit. (and talk about it)
Wow the snow moves when I walk forward
Ikr
Its really cool
mud and stuff does that too
I'm an exeption because I watched a playthrough in the summer
so I know mostly what happens
When I tilted my left stick aurthor took one step.
wot?
thought you meant jack
Anyone knows some good place to find hungarian halfbreds?
Where did you find it when you've done 100%?
Eh wont lemme post a link here
Its fine I dmed them the link to horse locations
ah ok
I don't remember lol
"So I guess you won't rob with me the banking coach...?"
N O P E!
F micah. I'd never give that pos any of my time no matter how promising. Or i'd set him up, get him out of the way. I'm saying this even before we do anything with him. Once we saw his behavior in the Adler house it should have been over.
Micah is cool and so are his missions.
I never noticed that when the gang is riding out to the bank job, Hosea says “get ready, we’ll be living in a new tropical land”
What a coincidence
Micah's missions are probably the fun ones to play
Strawberry one is my personal no1.
I wonder how many people were still alive in the town
I came back and made sure there was none.
I thought they should have made that town abandoned like Colter after that mission
Considering Micah and Arthur killed everyone
Or make it overrun by a gang
That would be a cool idea, a whole town run by a gang
I'd love if big shootouts had more impact on towns. Like no law for some time, or no NPC's spawning in for some time.
There's town lockdowns when you commit massacres
Cool idea
Not very long lockdowns tho
I just want more public hangings
Since when can you look down the iron sights of guns?
Yup, but i mean more severe "lockdowns".
I never knew that was a thing
My 1500 bounty massacre shouldn't create a lockdown that lasts 1 in-game day
I personally would have liked to see a gigantic shootout between all the gangs in Saint Denis
3 way fight with Police, O’Driscolls, and the gang
stores close for you when you have 250$ bounty
The town should go on a long lockdown, where there is not much law or npcs spawning in. Plus Feds or Army replaces the cops/sheriffs.
Now that’s a cool idea
Definitely would have liked to see more Army representation in the game
Such a cool concept
Sort of like GTA 5
When you get more stars, the FBI comes and the Military
Imagine entire army groups start chasing you with cannons
So our share of the robbery with micah is only $300. HAHAHAHA F that. OMG It's so hard to play knowing we have to deal with such a scumbag.
That’s worth almost 10 grand today
How much did the gang get from the Saint Denis riverboat?
When you had a 10 grand bounty for getting him out of jail-not worth it. he owes so much more. He owes the fee for the bounty and the cost of break out. Far more than $300 if he's so precious-which he's not. He never showed he was even partially worth it. In fact neither did Dutch. Hosea and Trelawney both worth more than either.
The gang could have gone to Tahiti for 51,000 dollars
When do we get access to the river lure?? Anyone remember?
Can’t remember
Can’t you just buy it from the Bait Shop?
Nice how you get a bounty in Lemoyne and never set foot there.
Lol
@ember wharf OK. When do we get access to the bait shop does anyone remember?
No 
If all of them started shooting at the Pinkertons, could Hosea have ran in through the front door?
Chapter 2 I guess?

Milton should have been shot when he met Arty and Jack fishing.
but like it seems like Hosea could have ran easily
Shoot Milton, Hosea bolts through the bank door
Anyone at the end where Arthur dies?
All these people that should be blasted never get it seems. I mean all the shit talking Milton did then to see him legit murder just because. HAHAHA Like wow.
Because they would have a lot of Pinkertons on them
@amber halo lol
Murders the most harmless dude. F'n coward.
Like @amber halo said, Arthur could have just said “Jack close your eyes” and killed Milton
Fun fact-The Pinkerton security company is still in existence to this very day.
They are owned by Securitas
If you're talking about Hosea nah hes sneaky and could do any harm in any ways
Yeah
OH they bought them out? HAHAHA finally.
And they posted a cease and desist letter to Rockstar
“Ferb, I know what we’re gonna do today”
Hosea is sneaky but that's it. Just a planner-trickster. If you fall for it then bad on you. Not you, anyone.
I mean, i'm not very good either as i made armadillo into my lil playground...
Grays, braithwates didn't. Lol
HAHAHAHA nope.
Every time I get bored I go cause chaos at the manor
"Now it dont feel right? I coulda told you that-"
Grays and Braithwaites didn't really fall for much now did they?
Try armadillo, people there do not fight back
Armadillo is hilarious
You can shoot anyone there and there isn’t any law
The civilians don’t even care
GAWD Dutch is so stupid. Such a dreamer and he sold it hard to so many. He's way worse than a Hosea. He kills, too.
I just dress up as a serial killer and go have fun in armadillo sometimes.
And for some ungodly reason the saloon still serves drinks while there is a cholera outbreak
And we never see him get his. Unless he did in RDR. I never played.
only safe thing to drink
and herbert moon has a portrait of strange man in the store for whatever reason...
Isn't rdr2 the prequel to RDR?
I don’t get Herbert Moon
how dare you massacre a defenseless town
There’s like a secret to him but I don’t know it
He struck a deal with the Strange Man
Target Practice
Thats why theres a cholera outbreak
Gotta get better at aiming somehow
boredom i guess, plus i done bandit challenges there
He sorta looks like Trelawny
Bro imagine
That would be a crazy secret
Trelawny killed off a whole town
Shit my aiming is so ass. Always has been. IRL it's top notch. Gaming is awful. I blow through dead eye like crazy.
That is impossible to be true but it would make trelawny sort of a badass in a hilarious way
It looks VERY similar to Trelawny
Trelawney = success af though.
"He talke the whole way but never actually said a damned thing."
I love how he adresses Arthur with "dear boy" after every sentence
Got Sean, gave Arthur an amazing 5 minnute, no gunshots, no knifing, $180 grab. SICK!
Trelawny was more of a brain than dutch.
You have a gun irl?
Micah was kinda dripping in the bank mission
@frigid cloudI've shot irl. Lots.
Mine's ok, i still need my glasses and i fucking hate them
I need glasses now but still aim better than I need.
Then how do you explain the lack of an escape plan for the ferry heist?
That was micah bell plan
Trelawny didn't plan anything but ok
I mean the ferry heist in Chapter 4
they still got richer
You mean bank heist? 🤣
No
oh wait
Trelawney was pivotal in getting Sean. He planned the robbery of the coach in broad daylight on a well used road. Genius.
Question, if Micah and Dutch didn’t exist, who would you most expect to rat out the gang to the Pinkertons?
Bill
abigail
Trelawney = shit getting done.
Dutch = death and mayhem.
Micah = death and mayhem.
or molly
Nah bill is loyal enough to not rat out
@frigid cloud Yeah
Definetely not Javier
You remember that scene where Angelo Bronte says he'll pay the first man that kills Dutch? Bill looks around like he's considering it
Doubt that signifies anything
Can you blame him
Sure
I just think he wanted to see whether others wanted it or not
They took Strauss into custody and he never said anything to rat out the gang
WTH Happened to Seamus? I went to see him once ch 2 I think and he's got his head wrapped. We ever learn wth happened?
I think that means you shot him...
If you killed him..
Not multiple but a few only
I stabbed Seamus in the back as john started talking about how Seamus met Arthur
:laughing:
Yo can I get some help
Depends on what you need help with
@hollow oak What with
I bought some gold off the ps4 store just for a start and it’s not on my person in rdro can I get some help?
Are you sure the purchase registered?
No one.
They're an extremely loyal gang.
Lemme check
Like a family.
My Lord they added the M1899 to Singleplayer
Yeah
Why is M1899 superior?
That's odd. Maybe you should restart your game
A pistol
TY
Added with pc release iirc
Time to dual wield
I tried
Unlocked in chapter 4 and only available in saint denis gunsmith
Is there somewhere I would pick it up
No, you should have it the moment you buy it
Well damn
.
Yeah I’ll check
Yes
how?
The barber?
oh
Maybe you have to claim it through benefits menu
Not sure
All I get is the option for cuts/fades etc
Its parted to the right by default.
I can't think...
Yeah nothing here
Could have sworn I saw bounties either lessen or disappear completely in one of my plays. Not seeing it now. CH 2.
Anyone know if there's any real way to tell if we are dirty? I mean like a little bit, nothing too major bc that's pretty visible. I mean if you're not really looking it's not but easier than just a little.
Just go your horse and equip the outfit you are wearing. That leans your clothes and your person as well I believe
Don't think they go away on their own
Ahhh my fav place-Dewberry! Love that place. Well it looks sticky and humid af but other than that.
@steady vectorYa I guess not. I could have sworn it did once in a play that I started. Maybe I just got confused.
I’m waiting for him to wake up because I knocked him out
Is he gonna wake up
I’m getting concerned
😔
Actually I meant Rhodes, whatever the name of that camp is. An amazing place to have a camp.
I think I might have killed him
Clemens Point
It’s cool how they made him have Gray Hair
Yeah I saw that already
He’s still alive, just unconscious but why isn’t he waking up
@dense mauveThere ya go! Love that for a camp.
Hes alive, just in a coma
Well I did slam him in the head with the bolt action rifle
Yeah, it's also got to be my favourite camp
It's very serious!
"You ain't as tough and dense as all that"
Well, it sure would do the gang well. Heh!
Its fun to start fights near the factories in Saint Denis
Arthur vs 10 workers
Actually challenging
I thought I was the only one who knew about that
I kinda feel weird up here
I’m in snowy land
And it’s night
Strange feeling
How cold is it
I feel like I’ve unlocked new emotions
well it is fun until the law shows up
So far nobody’s bothered me
As long as Malloy here doesn’t wake up
I’m thinking about throwing him in the river
Throw a fire bottle on him and see if that wakes him up
Fire will help then
Bro bounty hunters came and shot him
They were shooting at me and one of the bullets hit him in the head

Youve inspired me to go up in the mountains
Measure the coldest possible temperature
Threw the body over a waterfall
It’s currently. 28 degrees
Bro this is weird
The snowy area at night is very strange
Sort of sad and happy at the same time
It's so f'n sick how you shoot something or someone and the wound shows in the proper spot. GOD so many things about this game are just amazing!
i just won 5 poker hands just learning how to play
Pokers pretty easy
ight
I think if I had to rank the card games
Its making groaning noises dawg
@late lightYa. Crazy! Then there's the cougars growl spamming like crazy until you go find the person trapped in a tree. HAHAHAHA so funny how accurate some things are and others are just so ridiculous.
- Poker
- Blackjack
- Five Finger Fillet
- Dominoes
I know those aren’t all card games
But just games in general
Never learnt how to play dominoes
Dominoes is like the simplest game ever
It’s just hard to win
Poker is fun to play at the saloons at night
Blackjack is fun but you never win much money
Pokers where you get serious money
My record for a table is $78
For reference, you start with $5.00
I never learned dom either. Did poker pretty hard for about 3 yrs. Played on line in 7500 player tourneys and did pretty well so I decided to invest.
$100 in.
A yr later $100 out. HAHAHAHA AA is a shit hand.
Just found Jenny's grave by accident
I found Dutch’s moms grave by accident
Then I realized everyone already knew about that
I wish you could make it always night
Poker at night in the Saint Denis saloon is cool
It’s like a movie
Guys
Honestly I wish RDR2 had a casino
Where can I find moose?
Everywhere above the giant “Ambarino” on the map
... so I have to go back to the ice?
Si
... fuck
Remind me; is it killed with a repeater or a rifle
Why do you need to kill moose
Rafle.
Rifle
Camp upgrades
Bolt Action or Springfield Express Ammo I recommend
I'm getting that fucking moneh income
gambling addiction less goo
That's where you're wrong
We hunting MANGOS
AND MAIDENS
PARADISE
At this point I could go to Tahiti by myself
Lie
LIE LIE LIE
DONT TELL HIM THE TRUTH, DAMNIT
Also, on another note
Do you think Milton lied about Micha
?*
And he just planted the idea into Arthur's head to break the gang apart?
It’s possible
Tucker aint looking so good....
If Milton lied about that, I think Micah would have killed Milton early on
Tell him the truth
Bro his choice
Dutch is a b1tch
We can agree that some of RDR2 is a meme goldmine tho, right?
So uhm...
For example; "I don't speak German neither. I'm here for moneh. Moneh"
It didnt go very well
You told him the truth didn't you
Regardless of what you do, make sure to go a bit west of there to find a treasure map, on a corpse in a old abandoned camp.
Guys what was the best mission for you??
That one missions, where you do those things for those one people, and then get some things.
-20 degrees centigrade
Shorts weather.
I want an RDR3 but I hope they make it well
Find the Panranmic Map... Or whatever it's called? @late light
Not sure how they would fit it into the timeline
Its a long way lef until we see even a teaser
Ive already done it
I’d sorta be down for a game about the O’Driscolls
On an earlier visit
Aight, cool.
Main character is Colm
Kieran 
Or Kieran
O'Driscolls are just a bunch of savages, unsure if that would be a good game.
Jack in !917+ would be WW1 and after... not cowboy stuff, so, meh...
They will figure something out
RDR3 would need to be a pre-pre-quel.
Uncle in his younger years
Chances are O'Driscoll's probably had some bad, nasty shit handed to them at some point maybe helping forge their animosity. I mean the Irish were legit seen as the lowest of the low on the low measuring tape.
"Mick"
@amber haloHAHAHA That "Slur" always cracked me up and still does. I'm Irish and I find it absolutely hilarious.
They could have Sadie in south america in RDR3
If they do a game set earlier, we can see how Colm and Dutch used to be friends and how that got ruined. And other things.
Thats a good one
RDR3 Should have nothing to do with the Van Der Linde gang
How Hosea and Dutch met
Civil War era!
boring
When rdr3
Bro
Is it comfirmed
R will write themselves into a corner with another prequel
can they even do more on dutchs gang tho
Next decade
It's odd, too because it's not even a f'n slur. Anyone know why they get called "Mick" as a slur?
I know it's just a lil trivia if you don't without looking it up.
But, yes, I agree with this, I'd like them to go to another gang as well. But, maybe 'cameo' some stuff. Like see Young Hosea, Black Belle, etc.
I don't recall seeing them in Red Dead Revolver XD
^
brug do you think they recycled CJ
yes
or Niko
RDR1 only had a few people you'd recognize. So...
I'd go Civil War era
Could be a feud where 1 fam meets the other just before the start of it all. Like 1 fam was the top dog gang then all of a sudden they crossed paths with another when they were kids or something.
oh god no
imagine playing as Sadie
Slavery DLC

sadie story would be good wym
South America during the 1800s was something else
^
she was ok as an NPC
but not protagonist worthy
Eh, Unsure about all the way to 1860's. the weapons would be weird. You Really want to Fire those civil war Musket's?
Someone's never seen The Good the Bad and The Ugly
i didnt say that XD
i mentioned it cuz u can make a great story and game in that era
Nope. and I know they had some jacket bullets then, but still, they were expensive and military only.... Eh. I'm just saying 1870's might be a tad better.
it was fun as fuck at least
Wild Bill got blasted in Deadwood XD
Yes
and yes, don't think Hollywood movies are 100% true.
which is where i'm at actually c:
WHAT
It looks a lot like Blackwater
Dont tell me you live in Deadwood
yep
its pretty nice c:
I think the saloon he was in burnt down
Then West Elizabeth
The town of Deadwood actually looks like Blackwater
North West
Which is why this Halloween I'm being John Marston
They looked at a lot of naturalist paintings to get inspiration
They must have done a shit load of research
i should challenge Wild Bill to a duel or something as Marston XD
I am in north of Ambarino
Carin Lake
Fight to the death
they are stupidly rare
I'd shoot without hesitation
and you have to get a 3 star one for pelts 
I wish i had pic permission
yep
Moose are stupid rare, and you need 4 perfect pelts for the Trapper....
Omfg i was thinking of elks this whole time
Try up near Roanoke
VERY rare animale
wait
4?
Los animales de Ambarino se llama...
wasn't it just 1
I can't point them on a map. But check north of Brandywine Drop, or on a ledge just south of it. Plus there is a spot west of The Loft that I have seen them at as well.
3 or 4, Indeed. Way more than 1.
Hey! any help with panther hunting? I've spent more than 3 hours and I haven't been able to find a single panther.
They don't spawn.
So for those that may not know: The alleged slur "Mick" is derived from all the Irish that were coming to America spamming the states with names like "McGrath-McGraw-McAll-McAny-McEverything". "Mick".
@quasi folioAbsolutely. There should be some very good vids on yt.
@quasi folioMy first several attempts nabbing a panther using those vids were successful. Potent pred bait, likely not even potent, in the right spot, works like crazy but it also grabs boars and other predatory stuff.
Are you looking for them between the Braithwaite Manor and Catfish Jacksons? the Forest where the Harryfen Down cabin is?
Use predator bait over there
Yeah, I've tried using potent predator bait, predator bait, using deers and boars.
Bait is kind of only helpful if they are already around. It doesn't make animals Spawn.
But I don't seem to get any panther to spawn. 😦
Not in my experience, at least.
"We'll be back on track soon" ugh. Only if. Man makes me wanna stay right where we are and not move. HAHAHAHA
Gawd I still haven't played any even remotely bad guy yet. Looking forward to the sick $$$
Can I send the video I'm using to hunt panthers here?
Just so you tell me if that's or not the right spot, everywhere I've read on the internet says it's around that place...
"micah told me of a place we can lie low". AAAahhhhhh I'm sure he did.
The problem with video's is the randomness of animal spawns. Just because it happened with that player, doesn't mean it is going to happen to you.
Every animal spawn has a % chance
@red helmThe panther is almost like clockwork. Probably better. It's amazing how often it spawns. Sometimes a little too early hahaha
Just the luck of the dice roll.
If i have a question to Ask on the game can i do it here ?
Nah, there is no 100%. I'm sure you just got lucky a few times.
Of course.
Grr how hard to find Robins
Ouf, Robins...
@red helm"100%". I pretty accurately said that.
I "Got lucky" repeatedly. More than 20 "Lucky" events. Man, I've got it. Heh.
You've seen 20 panthers?
I assume rifles are ok to kill panthers, right?
@red helmHad to. I kept killing it with the wrong stuff. HAHAHAHA Then I finally learned not to follow 3 yr old videos and the compendium.
Springfield, headshot. Use Deadeye to be sure.
The videos were accurate for getting it to spawn but not killing it. Kinda like the white Arabian. Every time I went there it was there.
@red helmPretty sure I used an improved, which kill just about anything. Headshot. I always kill my animals with heads.
So, where exactly is this spot that you "Always" find a Panther in?
OR You can use a poisoned arrow
Exactly? I don't know how to get the coordinates but lemme see if I can explain. Gotta look a sec.
I'm getting tilted with this game, like, for real I've spent more than 3 or 4 hours just to hunt a panther and I haven't even seen a single one.
I wouldn't know how to find coordinates anyway, but yeah a ballpark would be acceptable.
I wanted to complete the game as much as possible but if the game doesn't want me to complete it who am I to say otherwise xd
DAMMIT I don't have that area opened up yet.
It's south of the manor a little east I think. The very southern road as it makes a big turn/curve. There's an animal carcass inside the forest about 15' or so. Bait it then hide behind the big rock.
You aren't allowed, there are a few animals that tend to be a pain in the butt. Moose, Robin, etc, etc.
the panther is near the fork at catfish jacksons
Harryfen Downs cabin, north of Catfish downs?
aka the road at the peninsula under braithwaite manor
So far I've only had big trouble with panther
@red helmActually hang on a sec. I'll look up a vid myself and see if I can explain.
are you using your deadeye?
the rest of em were just spending some time around and maybe using a bait but it was doable.
you're just having trouble finding a perfect pelt right?
No, no, I'm having trouble to even find one panther.
the panther spawn gave me trouble too I think it's one of the crappier ones
fyi, you need a few panther pelts. for completionist purposes. Saddle, 2 trapper clothes. Maybe the Satchel, if you are Arthur. and don't forget there is a Plain Panther and a Florida Panther.
Just northwest of Catfich Jackson's. There's a spot in the woods off the road you'll see the carcass. BAM! Constantly get a spawn with the bait and you have to book it out of there quickly to either aid the spawn or for protection or both.
In fact i think my game is broken : i'm searching a panther for they refuse to spawn. I've searched on internet for where to find them and everyone says they are at the same place which is south of Rhodes and I still don't find any one even if I have reloaded the place a lot of times. Am I doing something wrong or is there a problem with my game?
North-West- of Catfish Jacksons? Hrm, I'll check there. I still need a second pelt for a trapper clothing item.
what do you mean by reloading
I think you might wanna sleep in a different area and come back
Read the last 20 some messages of chat. for help on where to find a Panther
Ya I had absolutely no problem with panther spawn but using the proper tool messed me up. Any time I ever needs perfcets again I'm always gonna use arrow first then climb the ladder for power. I mean an improved head shot to a grizzly does the job.
I fast travel to a city, sleep and then come back
I have found a bunch of Panthers, North-East- of Catfish Jacksons, however, so... eh, but yeah, I'll check over there, first.
HAHAHA our dog is yellow with a little white. Every time I pet her I see deer pelt. Funny.
...
So is there really no other way to get Ox hide outside of hitting up the Downes ranch?
I think there is other locations...
A wagon filled with tomatoes???? Off the side of the road no driver? Haven't seen that yet. Sheesh!
@elfin ocean sent in media...
@elfin oceanYa. There's one near.....SHIT! Hang on a sec I need to see if I can find it and remember. I have legit mem issues.
There's 2 small marshes, where the woman and man were slaughtered and the woman offed herself I think. It's south of the marshes if I remember correctly.
Right outside Rhodes?
Ya I think that's it. Almost certain.
@late light Outside Rhodes
Where ever that gruesome scene was, right near there.
Bunch of Ranches with Ox and Bulls. Plus I have also seen randomly on roads guys walking them around.
question for @everyone: Why do you think Dutch left John to die?
btw i always make thse questions whenever i think of something
pls don't get mad at me lol
He is an asshole
The same reason he left Arthur to die; cutting off loose ends
fyi, you can't ping everyone, also you shouldn't on large servers.
sorry
ok
I like throwing dynamite at them. it's funny :D.
i know lol
If you sit and watch, you get good honor
am i the only one that always shoots the feminist woman in saint denis?
she is so annoying, she'll never stop talking
you might be tbf
the best kind of kill
Just got a cool idea
I mean, I get what the Feminist lady is trying to do, but not quite the way to get it done....
Man Charles can really be a bit bossy at times. I mean Arthur tells him to come along and he starts telling Arthur where to go, "Get back on your horse", etc.
Oh! Congradulations on the rank up. Green!
Maybe the RDR3 can be about the legendary gunslingers BEFORE Black Belle and such. And the game can show the more real side of a Gunslinger and how it's nothing like the romantic books. Kinda like Unforgiven.
So are there people who had troubles finding a paanther and who found a solution here ?
I'm really starting to think my save is broken
they're not that hard to find
If you are having bad luck, they can be. more than once I've had people in here talking about many hours not seeing a Panther.
I'm literally trying for days
i must have good luck cuz i find animals people cant find pretyr easily
except the moose
Shit this score is a bit too....working, for me. Like the bummer music is so f'n bummer. Even some of the general, kinda uppity, gets me a little down. So well done. Then some of the music when a pack of wolves is chasing you. Almost like line dancing music. HAHAHAHA
I've gone weeks without a Moose. and frak those stupid Wood Peckers and Robins...
@muted sierraFound a great vid for the moose. By moonstone pond. Not sure if I have the vid still but it worked very well for me. Also Lake Isabella, like crazy. Almost exactly where the white arabian is/was.
Also if you use a bait to attract animals and then it attracts one and you kill it, does the bait still work then ?
oh, dont worry
i got my moose c:
If you're having troubles finding a panther, try this: go just west of the triangle-shape crossroad southeast of Braithwaite, put some potent predator bait and go back to the road and hide behind the large rock
I went back up to Isabella and did multiple loads looking for the arabian again and keep finding the moose.