red-dead-singleplayer

[civic nest]

What are you trying to get?

[hushed flare]

Level Up

[night raven]

There’s got to be a way somehow. You can’t use it or anything?

[hushed flare]

CMON 10 more XP wtf

[red helm]

Talkie talkie

[kind sun]

I am at the end of the game, the cleaver is in my compendium, I can't use it, I try to buy and it says I have 1 of 1

it's a known bug

[hushed flare]

Last message before level 30?

YES

[red helm]

Yay!!!

[civic nest]

I got it too

[hushed flare]

life is restored

[kind sun]

trying to get to 100% I have Micah's revolver left which I will get at the end and this

[red helm]

No more Eww Blue for you.

[hushed flare]

I'm now dirt orange

[kind sun]

what did you do @civic nest

[night raven]

I was in the middle of replying to you telling you to wait a little bit until the minute clock ticks over and gives you your points when it swapped you

[hushed flare]

I already thought a minute went by

[red helm]

it's Prestigious... atleast.

[civic nest]

I was only able to complete the compendium. Somehow I didn't have it in there

[hushed flare]

Now time to be stuck in this color for the next 2 and a half years

[civic nest]

In the mission Jim Milton Rides Again you can pick up one

[kind sun]

I did

but it won't count iut

it

I just replayed it

[red helm]

Tell me about it, I got this color in like April, or March or something...

[hushed flare]

infinite reaper in level 50 somehow

[red helm]

He Nitro'd. It's double XP

[hushed flare]

smh

Cheater

[civic nest]

You can't keep the weapons you acquire replaying missions

[hushed flare]

this server p2w

[red helm]

Indeed.

[night raven]

But you get the compendium info

[kind sun]

I know, but it doesn't show in the compendium

not for the cleaver

[red helm]

You do not, BUT you get the Compednium info.

[night raven]

You’re supposed to though, that’s the issue

[civic nest]

That's weird, it worked when I did it

[kind sun]

yes, I replayed to get the Owl Trinket in the compendium

[hushed flare]

Oh damn infinite left wtf

[night raven]

@kind sun I assume you’ve tried reloading a save?

[civic nest]

Oh I remember now, I think I only got the info when I killed someone with it

[kind sun]

tried everything

[red helm]

Got banned.

[kind sun]

let me try that @civic nest

[hushed flare]

Same fate as John the bear hunter I feel like

[kind sun]

because right now, it's not even in my freaking wheel

[night raven]

Do both a throw and a melee just to be safe

[civic nest]

I got it with a throw

To the head

[red helm]

We actually don't know what the reason was. His DM's were off, and the banning happened while he was asleep. Plus the Mods wouldn't tell anyone else the reason... So.... Mystery.

[kind sun]

gotta break into Hanging Dog ranch again!

[night raven]

Throwable kills a really satisfying. Especially from range

[native vector]

Ikrr

[hushed flare]

not telling reason is weird

[red helm]

Indeed.....

[night raven]

He’s too powerful for his own good…

[hushed flare]

Time to get level 60 then get banned in sleep

[red helm]

The way to go.

[hushed flare]

test xp message

[kind sun]

is there an FAQ on how to change colors?

[night raven]

Gtg. Hope you’re all still allowed on the server when I get back. G’night y’all

[hushed flare]

15 whole xp

[night raven]

Check #roles

G’night

[red helm]

Nightie nightmare

[hushed flare]

undead nightmare nightmare edition

[native vector]

What do you think rdr3 will be like

[hushed flare]

Should be on a new gang

[native vector]

Will it be jack starting a gang or will we play as dutch/hosea

[native vector]

Thats what I want

[hushed flare]

Play as Micah in rdr3 best

[native vector]

Yes

I will throw him cliffs

[kind sun]

IT DID IT!!!

THANK YOU! @civic nest

[civic nest]

U welcome

[native vector]

Did what?

[kind sun]

throwing the cleaver in jim milton rides again, puts in the compendium if you have the glitch

what's y'alls favorite weapon to use? in battle (not counting long range rifles)

[round hedge]

schofield

because it is slightly accurate

[civic nest]

I always use Lancaster and Schofield revolvers or 1899 pistols depending on which chapter I am

Although I started using now one Schofield and one hand shotgun

[kind sun]

ok, @civic nest, my sensei... where do I go get Micah's gun?

I finished the epilogue

[civic nest]

Just return to where you killed Micah. His corpse should still be there along with his gun

[molten mauve]

yo guys, how do you toggle sprint on the pc keyboiard?

like not holding the sprint button

[lean sparrow]

Does anyone here know the strange man youtuber

[winter turtle]

yes

[hidden moss]

Horse challenges are annoying sometimes

yes

[arctic harbor]

Not sometime, everytime

[summer garnet]

i mean the valintine to rhodes one was fun the rest are just bad

[hidden moss]

dragging the person 3300 feet was fun too

[arctic harbor]

Lol

[jagged cave]

The gang is constantly changing places and no one knows their location, so how do letters arrive at camps ?

[hidden moss]

strauss picks up mail from the nearby post office.

also under a fake name

[main fable]

Im gonna ask a weird question

But just gimme an interesting answer

What would be the most interesting way Arthur can get a brain injury? Like idk falling off of a huge cliff, shot by rolling block rifle, etc

[rapid robin]

Falls off horse, to get run over by another horse, to get kick in the head by his horse...

[kind sun]

what is the best way to see if I have finished all the stranger missions and random encounters

[hidden moss]

there isn't any checklist for that in the game.

only 10 stranger missions for 100%

doesn't tell the total though

[summer garnet]

there isnt really anyhting for that plus you only need a few random encouters and 10 stranger missions for 100%

[kind sun]

yeah. I figured, but I am just trying to see if I finished everything before I stop playing the game

I am looking at rdr maps

I know some side missions you get letters and such, so just trying to reverse engineer what I have/and haven't completed by what I have, don't have, etc.

for example, I thought I'd finished the random encounter with the prostitute who I am supposed to help remove the man from her room

accidentally came across it yesterday

at the second to last mission to get Micah

[hidden moss]

take her to the sheriff, you will get some money and honor

[kind sun]

I thought I hadn't completed Brothers and Sisters, One and All, but I am going through my missions and just realized I did.. stuff like that..

for example, I am not sure if I did "The Wisdom of the Elders" with Obediah Hinton...

is there a way to check that? does he give you something to show you finished the mission... For example, I did the manzanita post thing where I took the newspaper clipping from the man... years ago... forgot about it... kept going back to get it and couldn't - realized it's because I already had it... make sense?

I wish there was a way to look for stuff in your satchel as a way to see if you have completed certain asks

[arctic harbor]

Parkour..

[wispy ether]

I got the game back today after January 2019, forgot all the controls and accidentally stabbed the Valentine sheriff

[hidden moss]

free nevada hat though

[wispy ether]

I guess

I mean indid get shot and killed

[hidden moss]

oh..

[summer garnet]

getting bucked by 2 horses standing close to eachother, parkour with horse

[neon copper]

i need help

i killed the legendary buck and i put it on my horse, i didnt skin it just the carcass then i died to bounty hunters, the trapper doesnt have the skin and i cant craft the trinket i need help how do i get the pelt and the things required for the trinket

[summer garnet]

i think the legendary animal will spawn in a few days again so just sleep for a few days then go to the location

or relaod your save

[neon copper]

i reloaded my save, didnt help

ill just wait

i hope it doesnt affect 100% completetion

[summer garnet]

you can hunt other legendaries so dw

you need only 5 for 100% and there are 16

[hidden moss]

Are hunting legendary animals worth it for a casual player

[summer garnet]

yes, you can make really good clothing peices with them

[wary oasis]

There no trains in the Epilogue?

[wary oasis]

Yeah, clothes and achievements and challenges

[hidden moss]

why not

[wary oasis]

Not seen any since CH6...

[hidden moss]

strange.

[wary oasis]

Yep

In pt2 and non spawn

If I buy a ticket it just loops back to station

Maybe bug...

[low night]

There should be

[wary oasis]

Lol there is a reddit post suggesting there are two trains stuck on Annesburg and you need to move one to get it working again ha

[hidden moss]

Oh yeah i didnt think about that

[sonic saffron]

uh- question..

is there a way to get stuff back after escaping the uh.. chapter 6 island thing?

like horses n guns?

ive only just arrived back to the mainland so..

[hidden moss]

yes

you get everything back

[sonic saffron]

okay cool

was just worried cause i have like 1.6k ive earned by running around lol

[gray wasp]

I love this game

I saw an Bald Eagle snatch a rock bass out of a river and fly away

just like in real life

[kindred jackal]

weird thing i noticed is if you dont retrieve your guns when you escape from being kidnapped by the driscoll boys, it tells you the camp replaces your weapons for you

like damn those mfs got the customisation right and everything from my old guns

[gray wasp]

but why wouldn't you get ur guns back, seems like a dumb move

[kindred jackal]

i didnt notice the first time

[gray wasp]

when I get to that part I'll get them back

[kindred jackal]

it didnt tell me or anything

[gray wasp]

How did you not notice the yellow gun icon...

[kindred jackal]

yeah but

thats everywhere in the game

[gray wasp]

true

[kindred jackal]

i thought it would just be a gun someone dropped

[gray wasp]

but it was YELLOW

yellow = bro get da fuk over there

[kindred jackal]

guess im lucky the gangsters are kind enough to spend all that money replacing my shit

[gray wasp]

Lol

I went to Sean's party

was nice

Arthur's been underwheight for a while so now hes back to average

Im going to try and do the story now

I also did a home robbery with Charles, and after I did it Arthur started coughing, like seriously coughing ;-;

poor boy

[vague edge]

Sean's party is great

Jack's party is one of the best parts in the game I'd say though

[gray wasp]

I'll never skip a party, Javier's music is something great

just feels so nice

[glass smelt]

Easily

[gray wasp]

makes me wish I hung around the camp more

[vague edge]

Same

And to be honest I liked Javier

[gray wasp]

but in my game, Arthur's like that one uncle who shows up now and then and gives you money for your birthday

[vague edge]

He was on eof the most loyal guys in the camp

[gray wasp]

oh yeah definitly

I would have paid for more Arthur/Hosea moments. Who knows, maybe I'll get them...

[vague edge]

That's why I'm saying they should have Red Dead 3 with either Dutch or Hosea as the playable character

[golden storm]

i heard dutch is in rdr1 i havent finisjed it yet though

i hope we go to tahiti and hes just chillin there

[gray wasp]

Lol

still need Tahiti DLC

[vague edge]

An alternate ending

If Arthur had left Micah in Strawberry

[dense mauve]

I'd imagine that wouldn't go down well with Dutch

[glass smelt]

Tahiti and Australia DLC

[gray wasp]

"Its for the greater good, Dutch"

[vague edge]

I mean it probably wouldn't, but at least Hosea would be alive

[gray wasp]

TBH other gang members would go and free hm

[vague edge]

More than likely

[gray wasp]

so you're screwed anyways

[dense mauve]

And Arthur would now be seen as a selfish bastard

[glass smelt]

While freeing Micah shoot him in the head when no one's watching and blame it on the popo

[gray wasp]

lol Arthur is just a omnipotent being who can see the future and everyone else is like "Go free MIcah!" "Go see Downes!" and Arthur is just trying his best to stop bad thngs from happening

[vague edge]

I don't really get it though, Dutch has pretty much raised Arthur yet Micah had only been with the gang for a few months

Why would he even have that much trust

[gray wasp]

We already discussed this, no?

[glass smelt]

Dutch is gone in the head, guy lost it in the end

[vague edge]

I mean true but it's just weird to me

[dense mauve]

Micah knows that Dutch loves recognition, and therefore uses that to his advantage.

[glass smelt]

Micah was too good for Dutch, made everything seem so perfect and Dutch beleived Micah blindly

[gray wasp]

Micah's a yes man, so him agreeing with Dutch at every turn makes Dutch trust him

[vague edge]

Yeah that's fair

[gray wasp]

He turned his back on his family and went with Micah

[vague edge]

Well i don't exactly think he turned his back tbh, think it was more when Hosea actually died

[glass smelt]

Yep he let Abigail die and left with the boys

[vague edge]

Dutch needed someone to turn his back to and Micah seemed the perfect choice

[hearty hill]

Micah was a master manipulator

[gray wasp]

Everything would have been find if Dutch just listened to Hosea instead of Micah

Hosea's plan was better imo

[dense mauve]

But he eventually didn't have a Hosea to listen to

[hearty hill]

Sometimes I think it was after hoseas death dutch was grieving and wasn’t in a good state of mind so Micah could have easily manipulated him into trusting Micah above all gang members

[dense mauve]

It became even easier for him when Arthur got TB

[hearty hill]

Cuz ppl consider Dutch as like a silver tongued con man so how does the manipulator become the manipulatee

[gray wasp]

Dutch is a showman as well, he likes the big dramatic things like train robbing and trying to fool 2 feuding families.

(this is late)

[lean sparrow]

Does anyone know the strange man youtuber

[gray wasp]

yes

[dense mauve]

My favourite RDR2 youtuber

[lean sparrow]

What is the horse he is using

[hearty hill]

Yeah I’m in their server lol

[lean sparrow]

What horse does he use

[hearty hill]

Not too mention all his famous speeches to the gang are written beforehand

U can find notes in one of the camps of his speech

[lean sparrow]

Do you know the name of his horse he uses in his video

[hearty hill]

I’m not rlly sure

Hasn’t he used different horses in different videos

I doubt he’s kept the same horse for every single video

Unless he has then idk

[dense mauve]

Yeah, it would help if you could say what video you're referring to

[hearty hill]

If u can get a picture of the horse maybe I can help identify it @lean sparrow

[gray wasp]

YEs I found speech notes

its actually a missable item

only in chapter 2

[wary oasis]

Might as well just do the game 100%. Monies worth...

Latest patch notes out for update today?

Doesn't look like it...

[gusty solar]

So this is the end huh

Holy shit

[frigid cloud]

How to remove achievement roles

[hushed flare]

[frigid cloud]

Looks neat

I like outlaw role color

[hushed flare]

Now time to be stuck in this color for the next 5 months

[gusty solar]

Im just going to visit arthurs grave and restart ig 🧍🏼

[gray wasp]

well if you havent before, finish the story

but I assume you have

[gusty solar]

Im restarting

[gray wasp]

does anyone know how to get screenshots from Xbox to my Ipad and/or Chromebook?

I want y'all to rate my custom outfit

[hidden moss]

new level pog

[night raven]

@kind sun did you ever figure out the thing with the cleaver?

[raven locust]

If you download the Xbox app on your iPad you might be able to save the screenshots from there

[native thunder]

rjeusjiwwk @hushed flare

U beat me lol

[terse heart]

Red dead so good

I have to beat it every week

[amber halo]

19lb 4 oz sturgeon baby! Nice.

[kind sun]

I did! you just have to use it on someone!

[hidden moss]

What challenges are easiest

Besides treasure and horse

[frigid cloud]

Bandit, sharpshooter

[vague edge]

Gambler

[obsidian crown]

Why do I not have any other type of bullets in my m1899 pistol??

Like there is no other bullet icon, only regular

[frigid cloud]

Bug I think

I never saw that

[obsidian crown]

So just gotta relaunch the game?

[hidden moss]

yes

[civic nest]

If you have a coach and save the game, is still there when you load it again?

[hidden moss]

nope

gone

[weary scaffold]

I wish Mac was given a character model

[hushed flare]

Slow

[hidden moss]

Sharpshooter is annoying rn bc whenever i get on a train theres never any birds to kill

[frigid cloud]

Eventually there will be

[hidden moss]

go to emerald ranch

get on top of train

shoot bird

And im always wanted lol

[hushed flare]

Put on bandana

and I think shooting will make you instant wanted if in a town

[frigid cloud]

preferably do it at emerald station

[hidden moss]

Doesnt it have to be moving tho

Which is annoying

[hushed flare]

Ye

[hidden moss]

get a train from valentine

[hushed flare]

but deadeye exists

[hidden moss]

go to emerald

get out

get top of train

[hushed flare]

take a train get out and when train moves jump on with horse

[hidden moss]

yes

Get horse to follow to jump onto when finished?

[frigid cloud]

You can just jump off

Anything works

[gray wasp]

ok thanks.

i'll try that

[arctic wren]

I always do that after the Billy midnight mission

[hidden moss]

Uh oh

Last horse challenge

Oof

[hidden moss]

I just saw so many birds

But the train isnt moving

I found out why

I killed the driver

Also

Tip for anyone that robs trains

Use a bow to kill the guard at the back

I got one

But then the law came

Hmm RDR2 can be weird sometimes. I completed “The ties that bind us” story line as Arthur, it’s still in the journal.

Now playing as John, and they’re back again, first mission🤷

Lol

[hidden moss]

This is too annoying

My horse doesnt follow when i use train but it usually does

[gray wasp]

So we're doing a WW1 style auction

and reapeating rifles are a option

yay or nay?

(have $45000 to bid)

[hexed ridge]

I wish ww1 games were in the game

It would be cool if they unlocked in the epilogue or something

We need more guns r*

What are y’all rocking for sidearms

I have dual schofields and I like them

[civic nest]

A schofield and a sawed off shotgun

[wary oasis]

Yeah you can play it as both John and Arthur. I did

Think it's a bug

[hexed ridge]

If navys were in story mode I’d definitely be rocking 2 of those

Just for the gorgeous long barrel and clean sound

[gray wasp]

NEVER MIND

AUCTIONS SUCK

People bidding 31000 on PIGEONS

[hidden moss]

hey, can wee rob a bank in solo version ?

[gray wasp]

We got tanks and thats it

[wary oasis]

It's in missions

As in single player?

[hidden moss]

yes but I finish the game, and I was wanting to rob a bank

[frigid cloud]

On your own no. Only in missions

[hidden moss]

Playing rdr2 and eating doritos is the best

At the same time tho

[wary oasis]

Nope you can only rob people, shops and trains/coaches etc in SP. Rest is done via missions, there is an extra one in the ultimate and special editions btw.

[hidden moss]

Imagine the chapter 4 bank robbery but with only one person 💀

[hidden moss]

ok, and in online we can ?

[frigid cloud]

Nop

[wary oasis]

Would have probably been cleaner...

Should have just let Dutch do it

[frigid cloud]

You cant rob people, shops, trains in rdo

[hidden moss]

I guess it's possible

Maybe but 100% harder

Bc the distraction would be harder to pull off

[wary oasis]

Would have been fine since Arthur has deadeye lol

[hidden moss]

Without dead eye tho

[hidden moss]

no, I try a 1000$ bounty in saint denis and I din't die

[wary oasis]

Plenty of snake oil and ciggies and it would have been fine as one player

[hidden moss]

Fair enough 🤣🤣

[wary oasis]

Maybe fine with duck and cover

[hidden moss]

Thing is

A whole gang managed to only just survive

Well

Most

But yk what i mean

Trying to survive by yourself would be nearly impossible

[wary oasis]

Yeah the story way would be hard but you could easily kill that many on your own with deadeye and cover

[hidden moss]

Chewing tobacco makes it possible

Lol

[wary oasis]

Snake oil is good

[hidden moss]

I prefer tobacco

U can hold more

[frigid cloud]

Chewing tobacco slightly damages the core so I don't like it

[frigid cloud]

Lote satchel bro

you can hold 99 of everything

[wary oasis]

Chew on a little salmon....

Or shot a little whisky lol

So we can't rob shops, people or trains in RDO?

[frigid cloud]

No

[wary oasis]

Sucks

[hidden moss]

Bruh thats sad

[wary oasis]

I'm at EP2 first play through and at 440 hours

Not touched RDO yet

I think it'll be good but I know it's missing some good stuff from SP

[hidden moss]

Yeah

[gray wasp]

👀

omfg

not everything right?

[hushed flare]

Except watches for some reason

[gray wasp]

lol what?

[hushed flare]

Idk why you can only carry 5 watches for every satchel

and 1 pocket watch

[frigid cloud]

No

[gray wasp]

because Arthur doesnt have much time... ;-;

[hushed flare]

Me when john

[gray wasp]

John doesnt really either

just a couple years more

[hushed flare]

better then no years

[gray wasp]

true lol

[hushed flare]

Yeah but lote satchel carrying 99 is super high

99 of most valuables and sellable things

99 of all food and tonics

[gray wasp]

wow now I can have 99 of Jimmy Brooke's pen

[hushed flare]

if u can obtain that much

[gray wasp]

lmao

Time manipulation GO!

[hushed flare]

Mods

[gray wasp]

Xbox

sadly

Mods in this game are pretty nice

but imagine 99 gold bars

[hushed flare]

Fixed John mod

[frigid cloud]

Possible

[gray wasp]

oh WHAT

how?

[hushed flare]

Glitches.exe

[gray wasp]

oh

[hushed flare]

I think there is only like 26 findable gold bars tho

And then there's a few ingots that have the same icon as gold bars

[gray wasp]

still like $13000+

[hushed flare]

Not like epilogue gives 20k

[gray wasp]

lol

[native thunder]

is it possible to even get ingots?

I only remember the mission where the German guy gives u one and that's it

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[hidden moss]

Arent bars and ingots the same thing?

Or do i play too much Minecraft

[native thunder]

how?

bar give 500, ingot 300 iirc

[frigid cloud]

There's a gold ingot in na

[frigid cloud]

Yes you do

[gray wasp]

lol

[hidden moss]

u talking about the infinite glitch?

where we kick the ingot out of the loot box

and pick it up again and again

[native thunder]

love ur name lol. "oh, a toy boat!"

[hushed flare]

#1 Micah fan

[gray wasp]

Oh ItS a Toy BoAt!!!

I cant wait for that mission

[native thunder]

I am genius with poker up the ayse

[frigid cloud]

No

[gray wasp]

YESH

I love him

[native thunder]

#1 person with outlaw role too :))))

[gray wasp]

Dragic #1 NPC

[frigid cloud]

I told there was a gold ingot in na that's it

[hushed flare]

Treasure hunt

gives a useless trinket and a ingot I think

[frigid cloud]

Most useless probably

[kindred jackal]

finally

another member of the orange club

[supple trout]

[feral haven]

is it possible to inspect the devils cave (show up on map and journal). Or is my game broken?

I have the "devil" in my journal, but does the cave show up on the map?

[civic nest]

You can enter, yes

The map changes to show the cave when you're in it

[hidden moss]

Outlaws to the end

[eager kindle]

I need some help, can someone help me with it :c

[hidden moss]

Bruh

I just got back on

I lost my progress from challenges

Bruh

Whyy

[eager kindle]

i';m trying to find some horses, like arabian or andalusian and whenever i am on the spot, they are not there :c

idk if i'm doing anything wrong

can anyone help me

or give me some tips

[hidden moss]

Where u going exactly?

[eager kindle]

roanoke valley for andalusian

or lake isabella for arabian

[hidden moss]

Just keep circling round it

Big circles

I think i found mine near a cabin

[eager kindle]

i was circling around it about 3hrs yesterday for arabian

nothing :x

so i guess i keep going

thank u c:

[civic nest]

The andalusian is just east of a waterdrop in Roanoke Ridge, but I don't remember exactly which one. You can get there from a path that comes from the south

And arabians, if you're not getting lucky in Lake Isabella, try west of Owanjila

[terse heart]

Guys

I did the trixk

Tricj

Trixk

Trick

Where man steal horse

And you whistle and horse buck him off

[eager kindle]

yeah and its not there :c

[eager kindle]

thank u!

does it matter if im horseback or not? idk if i should be on feet, or if i can horse ride.

[golden storm]

i need to rob 5 coaches in a day but also the disingenuous men or wharever closed down can i just find coaches whrrever

[hidden moss]

Yeah i think

Ima go destroy the Saint Denis population

Bc im so angry

[tulip goblet]

i love just going on a killing spree in like saint denis or something

[golden storm]

also why doesnt it say i havent max health stamina and dead eye when i have

[native thunder]

wdym

where would it say u have max

[civic nest]

You have to complete all challenges and buy all reinforced gear to max them

[native thunder]

^^

[golden storm]

ohh like trinkets

[autumn verge]

shit I broke my load

I am really mad that online takes place first and story mode happens in the second part

I don't get it at all

There will be more gunslingers by that time

And I am for damn sure in the middle of john Marston storyline rdr1 all the gunslingers are gone or killed by pinkertons

[hexed ridge]

?

[hidden moss]

John and Landon were the last

[hexed ridge]

whats wrong with online taking place first

[hidden moss]

Honestly

online taking place 1st

would be better

Imagine RDR2 story line ends

then online starts

and expecting to see most of gang

But yeah

I'm pretty sure RDR2 online is not canon

or at least semi canon

[hexed ridge]

it could be canon

I dont see why not

[autumn verge]

It doesn't fit for me and for damn sure goes the same with GTA 5

[hexed ridge]

Obviously some parts like Sean chilling in random places handing out missions isnt very canon but the leclarke story might as well

[autumn verge]

I see rockstar milking it with these "end high future vehicles" they got

[hexed ridge]

none of that in online

The stories are pretty self-contained too

[steep epoch]

Online takes place years before the gang arrives. However, some of them came from the area, if you remember. Such as Micha, Joe, Cleet, Sean and a couple others.

[hexed ridge]

only sean cleet joe and trewlawny

it takes place the year prior

i hope when they finish the online story they have it tie into the main story in some way that would be cool

[steep epoch]

no Micha did, if you remember "he had business" in the area.

also Sadie

Sadie and Jake.

live up in the mountains.

[autumn verge]

Her jakey

[hexed ridge]

i dont rmember micah?

is he a stranger mission?

[autumn verge]

no

His partners are

[steep epoch]

he says he's from the area in the stage coach mission.

[autumn verge]

crazy

[steep epoch]

in the campaign that is. not Online.

[hidden moss]

True but I would probably find more value just playing the story again

[wary oasis]

I found value in doing pretty much everything I could

[autumn verge]

ayo I got a item called base poison

I got 20 of them in my quick draw club rdo

its an unreleased item

[red helm]

Yum

[frigid cloud]

Dude

That outlaw role color looks fancy

[red helm]

Talk more and you'll get there, eventually.

[frigid cloud]

I shall

Have to remove achievement roles too

[red helm]

Best in the West role is for Noobs... 😉

[hidden moss]

old desperado looks cool

[frigid cloud]

ye it's boring now

I wonder if I can dm Alden to remove them

Or just leave and rejoin

[frigid cloud]

Gunslinger and outlaw colors neat

[red helm]

I remember someone saying you can change your roles on your own. Don't know how though.

[chilly rune]

just lost a legendary animal because i skinned it in front of the trapper and he became a witness to some bullshit and then i was killed by bounty hunters

[red helm]

That sounds odd...

[autumn verge]

sounds like harriet's ancestors alright

[hushed flare]

U can leave and rejoin then do >level up in bot commands to remove noob achievement roles

[autumn verge]

Ok who fucking cares about bot roles

it doesnt value shit

[hushed flare]

color

and ur pee color

[autumn verge]

Im not going say its yellowish

but

its somewhere between transparent, and the color of water

mhm

You know the thing about blue and water is that

they don't mix

and that's just the horizon lighting

Its not blue, Because if we took a bottle of water, There's no color

Either that

or the naked human eye is bullshit to everyone else

@hushed flareYou get what Im saying

[glad brook]

Pee color lmaooooooo.

[gray wasp]

Lmao what did it say he witnessed?

[true wave]

can I save an npc who will get killed by their horse?

and if so, does that raise my honor?

[wanton bison]

probably gonna start a new playthrough

actually you know what

im gonna start one right now

I keep telling myself to 100% the game instead of starting a new playthrough

but its too late now

fuck I regret it now

[true wave]

pfft

mood

I started one as I started my main profile

so if you're gonna do a restart, I suggest you do one as you do another one

[hidden moss]

100% sucks xD Im at 94% now

I’ll prob restart soon too

All the small tasks to get to 100% suck

[wanton bison]

"ill just 100% next time"

-what Ive told myself EVERY SINGLE playthrough

[hidden moss]

Ye xD tbh I usually go back cus I miss Arthur, maybe it is possible to get 100% if we could just play as Arthur completely😄

John is cool, just feels odd playing

[wanton bison]

honestly ch1 is so underrated

yes its short but its just cool to be in the snow, figuratively and literally

I wish ambarino had more content

[hidden moss]

I love chap 1. I don’t get why ppl just load a chap 2 save when restarting

[devout hemlock]

ono

[hidden moss]

It’s amazing to get that “first time starting” feeling back😄

[devout hemlock]

my arthur coofed

uh oh

[kindred jackal]

Yeah idk why people do that in games, use saves to skip intro sections

[wanton bison]

I do see a point to it

[hidden moss]

Well it’s part of the story though

[kindred jackal]

If you care enough about the experience start from the beginning

[hidden moss]

Why skip it

[wanton bison]

it saves an hour and a half of whats basically a long cutscene with some tutorial

[kindred jackal]

People who get turned off by how boring games are at the beginning end up missing out on so much good stuff

[wanton bison]

agreed

[kindred jackal]

How many people have done that with both RDR games and GTA 4

think of the great games they missed out on because they were impatient...

[wanton bison]

if rockstar ever does rdr3 I think it should be set around the blackwater massacre

and you play as one of the calender boys

[hidden moss]

Tbh I’m hoping for a new map. Just something different

[olive mango]

What are your guys feelings about playing in first person? Is it fun or is it unnecessarily difficult and clunky?

[hidden moss]

Let’s go with Charles to Canada

[wanton bison]

sometimes cool

and Im pretty sure you walk faster while in fps

[kindred jackal]

Not this again lol

[true wave]

ouch yeah, I had to pause my game and rethink so many things

(by that I mean I played yoshi's island on the SNES)

[kindred jackal]

"This is where the fun begins"

[hushed flare]

Only use when I'm using a scoped gun, playing cards or examining thing

[devout hemlock]

It was a light coof

did far worse coofs irl

[true wave]

same

I'm coofing irl rn lol

[devout hemlock]

arthur will be fine 🤠

[true wave]

though, it's been 3 weeks

[kindred jackal]

I have coughing fits most mornings anyways

[true wave]

I should get that checked out...

Ultimate, go to the doctor pls

I'm concerned

[kindred jackal]

Eh I think coughing is pretty normal, I've been doing it daily all my life

[devout hemlock]

I cough a lot in the winter

[true wave]

It's summer where I live

[devout hemlock]

I feel fine otherwise

[hushed flare]

Rdr2 fans when they cough 3 times:

[kindred jackal]

(gets tuba coloured sis)

[devout hemlock]

I mean back in early 2020 some classmates told me to go to the hospital for coughing a bit

[true wave]

lmfaooo

but that shit not fun

[hushed flare]

dramatic rdr2 fans then

[true wave]

...

I feel like I'm talking to a jojo fan rn

[kindred jackal]

Imagine you die from Tuberculosis in real life then when everything goes black you see "You can now play as John Marston"

[hushed flare]

luigi

[true wave]

You can now play as luigi

[kindred jackal]

Wouldn't complain tho

[steep epoch]

Vault-Boy playing RDR2 visible confusion

[kindred jackal]

getting to live a second life AND it's the legend of the west

[hushed flare]

Special health cure vs Tub color sis

[devout hemlock]

idk really hard to choose a new profile pic

[steep epoch]

Fallout's 👌

[true wave]

fallout 4 is gold

[kindred jackal]

I remember people freaking out about the RDR1 newspaper article which says "tobacco cures tuberculosis"

[true wave]

76 is a dumpster fire

I'm sorry

[steep epoch]

Fallout New Vegas is just

[devout hemlock]

Not a massive fallout fan

[kindred jackal]

imagine you smoke 100 ciggies and Morgan just instantly cures himself lmao

[true wave]

^

[devout hemlock]

only played the fourth a few times

[true wave]

I wish

[true wave]

4 is good though

[kindred jackal]

I've always preferred Skyrim personally, although when it comes to open worlds I prefer 2008 - 2018 Rockstar mostly

[true wave]

same

Skyrim's great especially the mods

[hushed flare]

Legend of the east satchel owners with 99 chewing tobacco, 198 cigarettes, and 99 cigars

[kindred jackal]

smokes every single one and dies from choking on all the smoke

[devout hemlock]

-takes 100 horse medicines and cures tb-

secret ending

[kindred jackal]

takes horse medicines and its ketamine

[true wave]

that's what I thought lol

[kindred jackal]

Red Dead Redemption 2 mission 67: Arthur does fucking ket and wakes up 6 days later in New Austin

[true wave]

Hey, you! You're finally awake

[kindred jackal]

Oh no

[true wave]

if you know, you know

[steep epoch]

you have commited crimes against Lemoyne and her people

[true wave]

Stop, in the name of the law!

lol

[round hedge]

after playing RDR2 i realized that john coughs an awful lot at camps in RDR

the attention to detail to make john have tb

incredible isn't it

[steady vector]

Damn these murfree brood ambushes are vicious

At least they have good loot

[true wave]

Does John have tb?

[quiet gazelle]

No tf

You rlly trust some dood wit a pfp like that

Ofc he doesnt have TB

[true wave]

I haven't played the OG rdr

[quiet gazelle]

Niether did i but

No he does not have TB

He has a gigantic cock

[pseudo tapir]

same but i know the story

[true wave]

I don;t

we going in blind

[round hedge]

said the guy with a "dark killer" username and wrench pfp

[round hedge]

no, i was joking

he does cough a lot at camps tho

[quiet gazelle]

Total chad shit smh

"Sulkii"

Smh

[round hedge]

oh no i can't show my face 😭 what if they find me ugly

wrench be like

[quiet gazelle]

Least the game was alright smh

[round hedge]

is alright a nickname for garbage

[quiet gazelle]

Wd2 was probably better than the first one and legion

[round hedge]

🤣

[quiet gazelle]

[steady vector]

I love chapter 6 Arthur

[chilly rune]

disturbing the peace

[low night]

Any tips for finding a Moose for zoologist?

[steady vector]

Absolving debts and helping Mrs. Downes feels good

[true wave]

yes

[smoky hornet]

despite not being a horror game can we agree this game can be quite scary at times

[steady vector]

I’ve heard about some scary locations and side quests but I haven’t found them yet

[devout hemlock]

never really felt scared but there are some really messed up things

[true wave]

Sonny

He scarred me

[devout hemlock]

like the serial killer and micah bell

hella messed up

[steady vector]

Getting ambushed in the middle of the night by animals or people can be a jump scare but I’ve learned to stay alert and ready all the time

Always ride with a gun in your hand

[true wave]

and that one woman in the swamps

[devout hemlock]

and the murfrees

and the skinners

[true wave]

scared the living daylights outta me

[devout hemlock]

micah said during a stage coach robbery that he was given a tip by someone and then he died in a "boating accident" the next day to cover his tracks

[keen birch]

By reading this message, you agree to our terms that Arthur Morgan sucks.
Thank you for your time!

[kindred jackal]

I consent and agree to this

[shell elm]

Excuse me what the frick

[shell elm]

If you want to get scared more easily, you should play in first person. Those damn alligators can be seriously frightening at night

[sinful knot]

Whoever said this is a fucking chad

[steady vector]

Alligators can be quite scary if you aren’t looking out for them lol. I don’t like first person much in any game, so I won’t choose it over 3rd person

[kindred jackal]

Arthur Morgan fangirl accounts on Instagram got me on suicide watch 💀

[hushed flare]

Micah bell fangirl accounts where

[round hedge]

fun fact

that woman is Charles with white textured

textures

[true wave]

blep

[kindred jackal]

Naw legit just came across an account where someone is role-playing as Arthurs wife or something jesus

[true wave]

🤮

[devout hemlock]

darn alligator snapping turtles take a single kick to kill?

kicked it once and is sadly moaned and died

turtles are supposed to be strong

[gray wasp]

Well

One good head stomp...

You ever played Mario?

[paper kelp]

How are you supposed to lure a herbivore, kill it and lure a predator and kill it within a time limit. Every place I go is either full of predators or full of herbivores nothing in between

Also I’ve tried so many times I wasted all my money on bait

[paper kelp]

I’ve also tried the heartlands plains but I either get a deer and can’t find a fox in time or I get a fox but there’s no gosh darn deer around. What do I do

[glad brook]

Get good.

[red helm]

There is no time limit, you just can not kill anything else between the two.

Last time I did it, I wandered around until I found a Black bear. Put on a Cover Scent. Got close-ish to the Bear, put down the bait, moved away, waited for the bear to go get the bait. Blam. Then I found a Deer, Cover Scent, go close-ish, put down bait, moved away, wait for it to go to the bait, blam, challenge done.

[median swift]

Hi

Is there a bug with the horsemen lasso drag challenge?

I've tried it so many times and when I start to drag ppl it shows that x amount of feet done

But as soon as they die on the way and lasso gets off it resets the counter to zero

The guides I've seen tell that it doesn't matter if the person is alive or dead and the challenge can be done with multiple ppl

Anyone can help me with this ?

[glad brook]

Trot dont go full speed. That'll kill them.

[median swift]

What is trot

[glad brook]

Sorta like running but not really.

It's like jogging for horses.

[median swift]

Oh ok 👍🏻

[frigid cloud]

aight

[median swift]

Also which is the best horse to buy in the game apart from the white arabian?

Earlier I had the most expensive horse from the saint Denis stable but it died during a fight with the bounty hunters

:(

[glad brook]

Not sure. I use any.

[median swift]

👍🏻

Any way to get permanent gold cores or it's just temporary?

[frigid cloud]

Temporary

[dire stump]

whose better to play as Arthur Morgan or John Marston?

[dire stump]

Misouri foxtrotter

[frigid cloud]

If he's early on that won't work

[dire stump]

yar but its still a good horse from the stable in uhhhhh near Strawberry I think near the border of one of the states in the wilderness (not the one in Blackwater)

[frigid cloud]

Scarlet meadows stables

[dire stump]

also the female one has better stats then the male one I noticed

[frigid cloud]

If you want silver dapple pinto you'll wait for epilogue 2

[dire stump]

yeah that one I forgot the name

[dire stump]

but the gold version (forgot the name of the coat) has better stats

[summer garnet]

Its amber champagne but you didnt ask so

[frigid cloud]

noice

[dire stump]

yeah thats the one!!!!

[dire stump]

thats the horse I use but I havent played in like a month so I forgot

[median swift]

I've finished the game 😅

Just doing the challenges nd other stuff now

So which one should I get ?

@dire stump

@frigid cloud

[median swift]

Anyone !?

[hidden moss]

use a fox trotter

[median swift]

Where can I get it

[summer wharf]

I'm getting some weird lighting effects like a glow on the outline of the characters on horses when the camera moves... anyone know what the issue is? All ultra settings.

[hidden moss]

there's a stable in lemoyne, scarlett meadow area, not sure

[median swift]

Blackwater or saint Denis

Oh

[hidden moss]

oh ok nvm

go to blackwater stables

[median swift]

?

[hidden moss]

there's one

[median swift]

Ok 👍🏻

That's the best one ?

[hidden moss]

yea its the same one, just a different coat.

[median swift]

Oh ok

Does coat color make any difference?@hidden moss

[hidden moss]

no

[median swift]

Also how do u study the birds that are flying?

[median swift]

👍🏻

[dense mauve]

Binoculars

[median swift]

The study button is greyed out @dense mauve

@hidden moss I'm also doing the it's art trophy thing 😀

First 2 done

[hidden moss]

oh

there's 4 more hiding places i think

[median swift]

Oh

I heard there's 5 hunting request

And then u get the statue

And u find it 6 times

[hidden moss]

oh wait, you didn't get the statue yet?

[median swift]

I'm waiting to get the 3rd hunting request

[median swift]

No not yet

[hidden moss]

oh ok, i thought u were talking about finding it 2 times.

[median swift]

Nah 😅

[hidden moss]

goodluck

[median swift]

Too much grinding in 2 days 🤣

[median swift]

😀

Thanks

[hidden moss]

yea it does take a while..

[median swift]

Mhm

How u did it ?

Any tips ?

I'm following the gta series videos guide

[hidden moss]

just craft small arrows and get a varmint rifle.

thats pretty much it

[median swift]

Yeah I've those

[hidden moss]

yea the rest basically depends on the animal spawn rate

[median swift]

Oh :(

@hidden moss are u doing other troph rn ?

Like the zoologist

[hidden moss]

nah, haven't played in awhile..

[median swift]

Or the 100% compendium

[hidden moss]

maybe i might go for zoologist

[median swift]

Ah I see 👍🏻

[hidden moss]

i was doing gold rush last time i played.. but gave up..

[median swift]

I'm trying to do it too along with hunting request

[quiet gazelle]

Huh

[hidden moss]

btw if u want an amber champagne fox trotter, go to this stable #red-dead-media

[quiet gazelle]

Micah bell could be a hell of a protagonist

[median swift]

What

[hidden moss]

the other coat

[median swift]

@hidden moss I just checked and I have 101 animals to study and skin to get the zoologist 😂🤣

[wispy ether]

Yeah...

[hidden moss]

damn..

[median swift]

😂😂

I'm not able to find the oriole

:(

Any place to find oriole ?

I'm at Riggs station

Can't find them flying here

[quiet gazelle]

A what

Tf is an oriole

[median swift]

It's a bird @quiet gazelle

In rdr2

@hidden moss finished 3rd and 4th request 😀

But idk why I can't mail the 4th request items in the post office

:(

[quiet gazelle]

This old twat rains fall rlly crying over some dumb shit called a chanupa tf smh

[kindred jackal]

LMFAO

MFs these days getting upset when they crackpipe getting stolen

[dire stump]

the amber champane Misouri foxtrotter female

[gray wasp]

LMFAO

[low night]

Fort Brennand

[gray wasp]

HEy guys

there are Canadian Geese in this game!

Im being represented!

But

I do have a question

Why does the lantern suck so badly?

It barely even works, its even worse on horseback

[low night]

Yeah it sucks

The electric one is even worse

[gray wasp]

Lol you would think it would be better

I'm glad its not just me

[gray wasp]

So...

Is there not something across the water, west of Bluewater Marsh/ Saint Denis?

Like, land or smth?

(or not west, um... to the right on the map is what I mean, idk if the map's Up, Down, Left, and right = North, South, East, West.)

hopefully you know what I mean

[low night]

Sisika but that's it

[amber halo]

Might anyone happen to know how to get icons to stay on the map?
I see ducks in many areas and several other animals. I want to put ducks on mine and I have found multiple groups of them that don't register on the main map. I have no idea how this is done.
I'm pretty sure I see it done with anything you study but other than that I still see a lot of the animals in a lot of the places but I'd like to know if there's a structure I can do to make them appear when I find them, after studying.

[low night]

[solemn saddle]

Bro u good?

[gray wasp]

what the fuck

I guess hes mad that he missed the sale? (unlike me HAHA)

RDR2 was 50% off with Xbox Lve Gold

[gray wasp]

whats that?

[low night]

You'll see

Where are you in the story

[gray wasp]

Chapter 2, havent done John's mission yet

Im stuck in school

its horrible

but the pain will end soon

but ye

I dont have the Rolling Block yet, thats basically where I am.

[median swift]

Hi

Any way to make the bow crosshair bigger ?

I'm having a terrible time with bow kills and the aim and tracking of it on controller is plain garbage

It never follows the target and never shows up the show info/study prompt unless I'm like 5 cm away from it

[amber halo]

@median swiftIf I pump the aim assist I target anything in sight. Even on minimal assist it's pretty aggressive.
I use controller on pc.

[median swift]

Wdym @amber halo

Like on the rifle it will track so good I don't even have to move my analogue stick

But on the bow it will just STAY there

And the dot is so tiny I need to put my face deep in the screen

[gray wasp]

(where did these 2 red dots on my hand come from?)

wait nvm theres 4

[frigid cloud]

wut

[gray wasp]

idk

[frigid cloud]

Feels better without red name

[gray wasp]

just some pointless dots on my hand?

[frigid cloud]

Someone best delete this

[frigid cloud]

I don't understand

Irl or rdr2

[gray wasp]

irl

just 4 red dots

[frigid cloud]

not sure

[gray wasp]

hmmm

probably nothing

if they start to irritate me or smth I'll look it up

[amber halo]

HAHAHA I just heard the best sound from an ai I just aggro'd for nothing on a mt top. Dam! His shot hit the water and was so cool.

[median swift]

Any way to make the dot bigger on the bow when aiming ?

[low night]

Check accessibility settings

[gray wasp]

Anyone know what trinkets are good? (they might just all suck but I want them anyways)

[median swift]

Not there

AAAAAAA how does this guy get perfect carcass of the waxwing if he shoots them with a repeater

And it shows 2 stars

And when he puts it in the satchel it shows up as perfect carcass

[frigid cloud]

Owl feather trinket perhaps

But only way to get is in chapter 6

[gray wasp]

shiyt

From Rains Fall?

[frigid cloud]

yes

[gray wasp]

ok cool I remember things

[frigid cloud]

Also finishing Hamish's missions will leave you with a giant boar you can take the trophy and make a trinket out of it

[gray wasp]

welp idk who Hamish is but I'll probably find out

that guy from the Hunger Games?

(wait no thats Haymitch)

right?

[low night]

Buck trinket

[frigid cloud]

Buck trinket is useless in latest patch

It never worked for me

[low night]

It's better to just use small game arrows

[median swift]

Oh

How does it work

I liked all the legendary animals except the panther

[low night]

There's a chance good carcasses become perfect ones

[median swift]

Oh

What's the chance it becomes perfect

[low night]

Idk but it seems low

[median swift]

Oh

[low night]

I'd guess like 10%

[median swift]

:/

I need to get a perfect ceder waxwing carcass for the art exhibition

They are always flying and the bow doesn't lock on them

[frigid cloud]

Try on foot and free aim with dead eye

[median swift]

I do it on foot only

What's free aim

[frigid cloud]

And I skinned a 1 star grizzly bear and it was good

[hidden moss]

niicee

[median swift]

It got sent I was missing the skunk carcass
I had perfect skunk pelts but I didn't know it needed the carcass

[median swift]

Any tips ?@hidden moss

[frigid cloud]

Try on horseback

[hidden moss]

yeea horseback helps