#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 470 of 1

autumn verge
#

that makes me sad

#

he fucking died

kindred leaf
#

Does no one know the solution to what i posted?

steady vector
#

You didn’t get to him fast enough and give him medicine

autumn verge
#

fuck

steady vector
#

Sometimes I think there isn’t enough time even if you try

civic nest
#

Have you tried getting another one?

kindred jackal
#

You always find dead mfs on horses in great plains lol

#

Just lasso them off

kindred leaf
#

I m also gonna try to have another save where I sell all 4 and hunt all 4 in one go I’ll do that tmr

golden storm
#

where is Arthur's grave

#

I've looked it up and all I see is mysterious hill honw

steep epoch
#

it's above the hobbit hole

#

just climb the hill behind it and there will be a rocky ledge

#

it'll be more visible if you died with high honor

golden storm
#

ok

#

I did

steep epoch
#

k

#

there'll be flowers there

golden storm
#

I like your username

steep epoch
#

to make it clearer

#

thanks

winter turtle
#

guys help

#

Help

#

Help

pale urchin
#

anyone know the best settings to run rdr2 at 4k on a gtx 1080?

sinful knot
night raven
true wave
#

arthur comparing session! GO!

twilit tendon
#

What’s the best horse in the game besides white Arabian

night raven
#

I like the black Arabian

twilit tendon
twilit tendon
hushed flare
twilit tendon
hushed flare
#

its so cowardly

#

overrated horse

twilit tendon
#

I Exchange my ultimate edition horse for it wtf

hushed flare
#

Have you seen how many people overrate it and still praise it even though the horse is small af AND IT BUCKS YOU OVER SNAKES

twilit tendon
#

They told me it’s the faster and the best

hushed flare
#

and the speed isn't the fastest btw lmao

#

Missouri has one more speed stat but speed doesn't make the biggest difference

twilit tendon
hushed flare
#

Bravery stat

#

War horse

#

I think work horses have a bit of bravery also

twilit tendon
#

I’m still at chapter 3 till then I’ll keep on it

hushed flare
#

All I can say is a stopped being a rose gray main when I hunted snakes and got bucked off when I wasn't even next to the snake for 10 seconds

twilit tendon
#

What’s better the ultimate edition horses or white Arabian

hushed flare
#

I think they are both coward horses

twilit tendon
#

🐿️

#

F

#

What was the 100 bucks for

hushed flare
#

You can tell your horses coward stat when it runs away at certain points when you dismount

hushed flare
#

Ultimate edition is widely not said worth it tho

twilit tendon
#

Will that be fixed if I got to boned 4?

hushed flare
#

but I think the features are like the cores drain less faster, more money from gang missions, 4 new trinkets, 1 extra gang hideout, 2 free trinkets u get as soon as chapter 2 begins

#

And the free horse, free weapons but i forgot the rest

twilit tendon
#

Btw I still don’t know why do I get for the 100 dollars besides the horses

#

What else can I do with it or get

hushed flare
twilit tendon
void pond
#

ultimate is like a collector edition

twilit tendon
#

What

hushed flare
#

Special has all the story mode stuff as ultimate edition

#

But ultimate edition has online shit

void pond
#

only bonus missions, trinket, outfit, etc

hushed flare
#

That I don't know about

void pond
#

yea

#

you also get bonuses in rdo

twilit tendon
#

That don’t worth an extra 40 dollars

winter turtle
#

What is all the fishes in red dead

#

I need help

void pond
#

since steam price for rdr2 and rdo is not far and u are interested in bonus mission sure get ultimate

#

if ur only play rdr2 no

#

ultimate not worth

winter turtle
#

I caught ultimate for 40 on Xbox

twilit tendon
#

Wait you have to pay to get rdo?

void pond
#

yep

twilit tendon
#

Even tho you need ps plus to play it

void pond
#

unless u buy ultimate

twilit tendon
void pond
#

i havent play online on ps tho

twilit tendon
#

F

hushed flare
#

From my memory special/ultimate gives these story mode stuff

1 extra mission or companion activity thats a bank robbery
Extra gang hideout for del lobos at twin rocks
Free guns which is volcanic pistol, pump shotgun, and varmint. Pump and Varmint are very useful early game
Good early game horse though it's a coward it is better then the shire and the Tennessee walker
One extra outfit and weapon equipment. Both do nothing gameplay wise but looks
4 new trinkets to be found and 2 unlocked as soon as chapter 2 starts
Cash bonuses and Core bonuses that can be toggled in settings. Kinda feels like cheating since money and cores are already easy enough but it's a feature
Discounts for camp upgrades

#

oo that's long

void pond
#

yep those are the bonuses

hushed flare
#

And then ultimate gives online for free or something with bonuses

void pond
#

i bought ultimate since the price is not far from buying base game + online

hushed flare
#

I got ultimate cuz it was on sale

#

And knowing the price difference from 60$ to 100$

void pond
#

same

hushed flare
#

Though I hardly played online

winter turtle
#

xboxhhvcfgbbb

#

Yes

twilit tendon
#

Hell yea

winter turtle
#

If you have ultramarathons

hushed flare
winter turtle
#

Ultimate

hushed flare
#

Not like money is easy enough to obtain anyway

#

chapter 3 gives you way too much money

winter turtle
#

lmao ultramarathons

twilit tendon
hushed flare
#

Ultramarathons nice auto correct

void pond
#

yea ur rich after a missions in chapter 3

twilit tendon
void pond
#

also u can do treasure hunt if u want extra money

hushed flare
void pond
#

selling goldbars

winter turtle
#

Not epilogue rich though 😎

hushed flare
#

Epilogue YeeHawSmile

twilit tendon
#

I tried to do a small robbery but I failed because I killed all the people are we didn’t get where did they hide it

twilit tendon
hushed flare
#

train robberys are probably the only reliable money making way if criminal playstyle

twilit tendon
hushed flare
#

good bars

void pond
#

yea if u do some treasure hunt

#

there are many guides in youtube

#

if you are interested

twilit tendon
hushed flare
#

Special editon probably looks like best buy unless u really want that online stuff

twilit tendon
#

Good

#

Good

#

Wtf

hushed flare
#

Bad

twilit tendon
#

Gold

winter turtle
#

Opinions on Birb?

#

Anyone

hushed flare
#

Which birbSoyoureCowboy

steady vector
#

The mission that starts with Dutch in Guarma is fun. But no game should ever keep you locked in a mission for that long without a chance to save and quit. You can’t save until you reunite the gang and fend off the immediate Pinkerton ambush. And before that you have to do everything involving the escape from Guarma

winter turtle
#

What why was that deleted

steady vector
winter turtle
#

Why is no one talking

#

Micah fan

#

Doctor

#

Where are you

hushed flare
#

dead chat

winter turtle
#

yes

night raven
winter turtle
#

retro123

night raven
winter turtle
#

what are all the fishes in red dead

#

I need sum help identifying

night raven
#

I'm not a good person to ask for this. Try red dead wikipedia or something. you could also plug fish into the rdo compendium channel

winter turtle
#

alright

#

I’m stuck on survivalist 10 so that’s why I’ll try that

night raven
#

Ah yeah good luck.

#

You can search the rdo compendium channel for each fish once you know what they are

#

good luck dude

quiet gazelle
#

I hate abigail

#

If john is in trouble then she can save him herself

#

Like fuck off dumb twat smh

loud anvil
quiet gazelle
#

Maybe annoying is the word

loud anvil
#

Yep

quiet gazelle
#

Got back from guarma and all she says "thEy goT joHn"

#

Like good for you smh

loud anvil
#

She cares about him

quiet gazelle
#

Well i dont

#

She can get him herself smh

#

Well i do but

#

Fuckin annoyin

loud anvil
#

😆

red helm
#

Abigail is indeed annoying, she just rollercoasters caring about John and hating him.

steady vector
#

Or maybe John getting captured was the wake up call she needed to realize she does care about him

#

Although she does leave and then come back later in the epilogue so yeah. Rollercoaster

red helm
#

But as soon as she gets him back it just seems like they go back to the same old. It's just never enough for her.

loud anvil
#

John gave her a beautiful house & a ranch so she wouldn't ask more

red helm
#

He gets a job as a ranch hand, but then he defends said ranch, and she gets all pissed and leaves him. Like, umm, should he have hid under the bed while the ranch burned down? What did she expect him to do?

#

They finally get Beecher's Hope, and still, she is all grumbling and such, seemed like she was only happy for like 5 whole minutes.

steady vector
#

Yeah I’m not sure what to think about that part. It’s definitely in John’s nature to defend the ranch and it makes the ranch owner like him more. But he knew Abigail hated it, so what’s more important.

quiet gazelle
#

Is it true the whole gang drilled abigail

red helm
#

It's not like John went out and started trouble with the Laramie gang. That would've been entirely different, but... like, wtf....

steady vector
steady vector
red helm
steady vector
quiet gazelle
#

I would enjoy free roaming as john if he actually looked like john and not jarthur margston.

red helm
quiet gazelle
#

Cus boy oh boy cant get across a river in peace

red helm
#

The can't swim thing is just non-sense from RDR1.

steady vector
quiet gazelle
#

Damn

#

So

#

Uncle hit first

steady vector
#

Probably yea 😅

quiet gazelle
#

They called him the one shot kid YeeHawSmile

steady vector
#

Lol

#

I’m going to bed. See you guys later

red helm
round hedge
steady vector
gusty spear
#

anyone here attempt the 100%? if so, how did you track challenges?

hushed flare
winter turtle
#

micah bruh he’s only a good evil man that’s it

#

Fenton’s much better

civic nest
#

Fenton killed his mother

#

He's mean

#

But he does know how to pour drinks

#

So he's forgiven

winter turtle
#

True

true wave
#

I hate Micah with a passion

tiny mango
#

aye lads, anyone know why my games not loading?

#

first scene of sp and its been loading for about 5m

winter turtle
#

If I use cheats on my game but save before I do it can I reload that save that cheats haven’t been used on it and I’ll still get achievements?

hidden moss
#

I got a story of my play through of RD2.
So I was at the point where I had a mission with Sadie in Saint Denis. I had met Sonny on my way to SD. I decided to enter his home and regretted it. So then after I woke up I continued towards Saint Denis. Then all of the sudden I faint, was taken to the doctor, and was then diagnosed with the disease.

summer garnet
hidden moss
#

Yes, first time around I did

#

It made it hurt worse cause I totally forgot about the guy I beat up for five bucks

winter turtle
#

Aww I miss hamish

hidden moss
#

Same

lilac charm
#

suck me fucken nuts mate

gusty solar
#

O h

amber halo
#

Anyone ever start chasing down a timber rattlesnake then see it's trail suddenly go red to find it dead? 3 star! Weird. It was alive then it just died.

hidden moss
amber halo
#

@hidden mossYa. HAHAHA The weirdest stuff sometimes. It was on it's way down a pretty steep edge which dropped off maybe 5 feet or so to the ground when it died. Threw it on the horse to seel it for the hell of it to someone, fast trave......(O U C H! Woops. HAHAHA

hidden moss
#

where was arthur morgan born?

#

dunno

amber halo
#

OK here's a few things I have noticed when it comes to time of day:
From Horse Shoe, when I woke up in the am the fastest I can check the time is always 6:11.
From Val hotel it is always 6:01.
Just woke in in Beecher's and it's 6:20.
This is pressing the pause button or down on the D as quickly as possible.
I can't remember if I checked the eastern parts of the map or not yet but I'm actually considering making a list of all of this.
At first I thought they were paying attention to time zones but 6:20 is extremely weird and it's west of Val and HS.
Well at least I think those were the times. Either way it's always after 6 am. I think I have had it exactly on the dot at 6 one time.

hidden moss
#

deluxe bath in van hornsadart

languid perch
#

midnight's gun or flaco's gun guys

quartz charm
amber halo
#

FBM. I'm still on the lookout for Anastasia.

mild hawk
summer garnet
#

oh postal dude

tiny mango
#

How long will the main story take?

vagrant temple
tiny mango
#

Ok thank you, google said 60 hours but I thought that was far fetched

vagrant temple
#

It depends on what you do

#

Lots of side activities

#

20 hours is pretty low even for main story

tiny mango
#

When do the side quests become available?

vagrant temple
#

In chapter 2

tiny mango
#

Sick as

#

thank you

vagrant temple
#

Np

tiny mango
#

does the game auto save?

hidden moss
#

Does anyone have any ideas to change the game up a little bit. I finnished my first playthrough about a month ago and wanted something different

vagrant temple
shrewd yoke
#

Where's the second bounty?

lament storm
#

So, what happens when you try to go to New Austin as Arthur? Heard it is inaccessible, but how? Tons of lawmen on your ass, or what happens?

kindred jackal
#

you get instakilled by invisible snipers

#

the moment you cross the lower montana river

lament storm
#

well that's cheap.. I can understand Guarma being like that, since one is not supposed to get there legitimately, but to New Austin, one can.. Oh well.

kindred jackal
#

yeah

#

it was meant to be accessible as Morgan, but cut out

#

theres voice lines, journal entries and everything for it in the files

lament storm
#

oh yeah. Shame.

#

Thanks for the info

steady vector
true wave
shy mulch
#

My hate for Micah varied chapter to chapter

#

After Strawberry? Fuck him. During 3-5? Disagree with him but tolerate him. 6? Fuck him.

kindred jackal
#

he feels kinda one dimensional and artificial

summer garnet
#

i like how all this started with 3 words

hexed ridge
#

He’s not one dimensional or artificial

#

He has considerable backstory and some of his actions are morally gray

vague edge
#

I liked Micah at the start before finding John with the wolves

hexed ridge
#

I liked Micah up until chapter 6

#

His massacre in strawberry was questionable but it showed him as really bad ass who would kill anyone who got in his way

#

Wasn’t till he started betraying the gang I started disliking him

arctic harbor
hexed ridge
#

Well he always seemed kinda crazy, but in a good way. If he was crazy but also crazily loyal he woulda been great

arctic harbor
#

Well hes no Trevor Philips imao

hexed ridge
#

Well yeah ig that’s what I thought of him at first

#

Trevor Phillips

#

Except as time went on it became clear he has no loyalty

#

I think his character up until ch 6 was up to interpretation which made him a well written character

#

If he was the obvious bad guy from the start, then he would be “one dimensional”

gray wasp
#

A

arctic harbor
arctic harbor
gray wasp
#

C

arctic harbor
hexed ridge
#

There’s also even more subtle details

gray wasp
#

E

arctic harbor
hexed ridge
#

Like how he doesn’t hang out with camp members

gray wasp
#

G

arctic harbor
gray wasp
#

I

hexed ridge
#

And acts like an outcast in camp besides playing five finger filet

arctic harbor
gray wasp
#

K

arctic harbor
arctic harbor
gray wasp
#

M

arctic harbor
gray wasp
#

O

arctic harbor
gray wasp
#

Q

arctic harbor
gray wasp
#

S

arctic harbor
gray wasp
#

U

arctic harbor
gray wasp
#

W

arctic harbor
gray wasp
#

Y

arctic harbor
gray wasp
#

👏

native thunder
#

Lmao

arctic harbor
#

congratulations

gray wasp
#

God what are we 3 years old?

arctic harbor
gray wasp
#

LMFAO

#

yeah

hidden moss
#

just came across the tree king for the first time

#

GO AWAY!

glad brook
#

Micah Bell.

kindred jackal
#

mocks the player, racist, hates women, kills jacks dog because he hates dogs now and points his skull engraved pistol at you

#

the last one is more of an obvious way signal hes the bad guy but the rest is just done to create artificial hatred because they know it would work on most audiences

hushed flare
#

simply looking at horse had to give bad guy vibes

kindred jackal
#

well yeah his horse is the low honor one from RDR1

vestal sail
#

Oddly enough Micah jokes about hating other White people so I wonder if he's just being mean to the nonwhites in the camp just for shits and giggles

arctic harbor
kindred jackal
#

micah bell sigma grindset

#

hate ALL races

#

including your own

hidden moss
#

i mean

#

there is a cut voice line

#

where micah says the infamous funny black word

kindred jackal
#

interesting...

young dragon
#

He does say a couple of racist slurs

weary scaffold
#

He even hates bill

#

Why do you keep calling me bill?

grizzled sapphire
#

Cuz all enclave soldiers are named Bill, obviously.

weary scaffold
#

It was a king of the hill reference just imagine bill form red dead redemption doing the same thing bill did in that one ep of king of the hill s3 lol

summer garnet
hidden moss
kindred jackal
hidden moss
arctic harbor
true wave
#

y'all know the Aberdeens?

summer garnet
#

yes

true wave
#

So, I tried to enter their house

#

in chapter 2

hushed flare
#

Aberdeen's = Arthur's bank

true wave
#

and returned in chapter 4 ish

#

and I can't find them there

summer garnet
true wave
#

like, they're gone off the map or something

#

is that supposed to happen?

summer garnet
true wave
#

ye

summer garnet
#

i think its scripted as chap 4 takes place after like 2 months after chap 2 so they up and left or they despawned after not interacting with them for a long time

true wave
#

oh that makes sense now

kindred jackal
#

guess its just a missable thing

#

they prolly didnt move since you can visit them as Marston in the epilogue

arctic harbor
true wave
#

oh ok thanks

arctic harbor
#

So which chapter are you in currently?

gray wasp
#

hey

#

I found the tomb

#

so thanks to whoever showed the picture of where is was

kind sun
#

ok so where do you get the legend of the east outfit, I just finished all the challenges!?!

hidden moss
#

wardrobe

kind sun
#

back at Beecher's Hope?

hidden moss
#

yea

frigid cloud
#

Any wardrobe

hidden moss
#

there's like 2 tho

#

outside beecher's

kind sun
#

I didn't know that, where do I do that? general store?

frigid cloud
#

No

#

Saloons>rent a room or a hotel

kind sun
#

ahhh ok

#

been playing this game for years, shit I still don't know

hidden moss
#

or at the tailor

#

there's a backroom

kind sun
#

while I have this knowledgable crew here

#

I am at the end, and I have a few questions hopefully you can help me with... obviously the 15th legendary fish can't be caught

#

so the compendium will never be 100%... correct?

frigid cloud
#

It will

#

It will be in your compendium

kind sun
#

really? when you get everything else?

frigid cloud
#

I thought you had to catch the fish for it to count towards the compendium but you don't have to apparently

#

Just discover its location and it's fine

kind sun
#

where is it?

hidden moss
#

you did the legendary fisher side mission?

kind sun
#

I think?

hidden moss
#

like the last part, where u gotta go to new austin with him

kind sun
#

I do not remember, I stretched the game out for three years

#

so I don't remember some of it (it was also during a time my mom passed, so some of that time is blurry)

#

I am showing in my log, a legendary fish, fisher of fish task

#

all 14 fish are checked off

frigid cloud
#

Did you mail them and meet the fisherman

kind sun
#

I mailed them, but not sure if I was ever prompted to meet the fisherman

frigid cloud
#

ah

#

You get a letter from him

#

I forgor

#

You collect the letter from him and you're able to meet him

kind sun
#

I don't see any letters from him?

hidden moss
#

i think you should check the satchel

kind sun
#

just did

#

ahh it's in invitations

frigid cloud
#

You read it and it's available

hidden moss
#

i think it should pop up right after u view it

kind sun
#

you guys are amazing

#

it also says I am missing hunting requests

#

in total completion, but I finished it and went to Hobbs' house

#

does it not finish until I put the thing she gives me in the house?

frigid cloud
#

No

#

You have to place the squirrel in Beecher's hope

kind sun
#

that's what I mean

frigid cloud
#

o

kind sun
#

sorry can I do that without triggering the last mission

frigid cloud
#

What mission

kind sun
#

I am trying to finish everything before I go get Micah

frigid cloud
#

Nop

#

Not possible

#

You have to finish the story to be able to place the squirrel

#

Kinda lame

kind sun
#

ok, I have two more questions..

#

I didn't get the trinket from Rain Falls, am I screwed?

frigid cloud
#

It's missable

#

So

#

You are

kind sun
#

so I am one short of finishing everything? fuck...

frigid cloud
#

u just want it in the compendium?

kind sun
#

yes

frigid cloud
#

hmm

#

This may work replay the mission you get that trinket

hushed flare
hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

Yes he just wanted it in compendium

kind sun
#

oh! what about the cleaver in the compendium?

hidden moss
#

u can buy it

kind sun
#

it says I have 1 of 1

#

but doesn't show up, I know it's a glitch

kind sun
#

any advice?

steep epoch
#

you probably threw your cleaver and didn't pick it up.

kind sun
#

no it says i have 1 of 1

#

I read it's a glitch

steep epoch
kind sun
#

neither

#

but when I go to try and purchase it, it says I have 1 of 1

steep epoch
#

are you playing online or story?

kind sun
#

story

steep epoch
#

go to the grizzlies, to the big clearing in the mountains.

#

go to the O'driscoll hideout near Pronghorn Ranch.

#

there's a cleaver in there on a railing/wall ledge.

kind sun
#

oh ok cool

#

also, I have almost to full dead eye core, I mean the smallest amount away

#

how can I max that out?

steep epoch
#

if it's not there, close the game and open it again.

steep epoch
#

I think that's what Val. Root is for.

kind sun
#

nevermind I reached maximum!

steep epoch
#

k cool.

kind sun
#

thank you!!!!

#

I am literally the cleaver, micah's revolver, and putting the squirrel thing up in Beecher's from 100% compendium and game completion

steep epoch
#

you don't need all of those for 100% completion achievement.

kind sun
#

no I know

steep epoch
#

k.

kind sun
#

but to finish the compendium

steep epoch
#

yeahh.

#

I never can finish it all the way, I always forget one snake and a bird or two on Guarma.

kind sun
#

I glitched back and got them yesterday

#

and one of the snakes supposedly in Guarma is in the regular map

steep epoch
#

you wasted 2-3 hours glitching back there???

kind sun
#

I got to the end, I had to

#

I wasn't going to finish this without going all the way

steep epoch
kind sun
#

west of blackwater? I think?

steep epoch
#

near the thieves place. I always mix it up with thieves landing from SoT.

kind sun
#

yes! sorry

#

I am going to play GTA 5 next, I haven't played a GTA since Vice City

#

so I need to go to Hanging Dog ranch to get the cleaver? do you remember where it is?

#

railing inside the house?

golden storm
#

as arthur it takes 3 though

#

took me 5 in total as arthur bc of deaths

kind sun
#

@steep token I redid jim milton rides again and got the cleaver, but doesn't show up in the compendium.. do you think if I just went there in a non-mission capacity, I could get it

#

@steep token cleared the ranch, saved, then reloaded.. still not there

steep token
#

You’re pinging the wrong person pal

frigid cloud
#

When there's too many dutches in the server

hearty hill
#

Wait how do u go back to guarma

#

There’s a glitch?

hidden moss
#

yes

golden storm
#

yes

hearty hill
#

Well what is it

golden storm
#

you go back to guarma lulhaw

hearty hill
#

That took u a rlly lomg time to type

golden storm
#

no but actually you go to manzaita falls and cross water and then drink glitch up

#

ik i put too many emotes the first time

hearty hill
#

How would u get back

hidden moss
#

die

#

only way

golden storm
hidden moss
#

or reload save

golden storm
#

reload the save

hearty hill
golden storm
#

if you die you spawn in guarma

hearty hill
#

Oh

#

I see

hidden moss
hearty hill
#

I’m going to be honest

#

Idk how to reload save

golden storm
#

acutally no you can close and reopen the gsme to get back

hearty hill
golden storm
hearty hill
#

Anytime my horse dies I just close amd reopen so she’s back to life

hearty hill
golden storm
#

save the game

hearty hill
#

LMAO I SOUND SO CLUELESS I PROMIS IK HOW TO PLAY

#

I just never do any saving stuff cuz it does that automatically

hearty hill
#

How

golden storm
#

go to story

#

go to save

hidden moss
#

its just manual save from the menu

golden storm
#

save

hearty hill
#

Ahhhhh

#

Thank u for helping my dumb ass

golden storm
#

do you play on console

hearty hill
#

Yeah PlayStation

golden storm
#

ok good it worked for me

hearty hill
#

Greattt

#

I’ll try it out tmr

golden storm
#

look up how to get to guamra as john and if should show a video but its gonna say how to get a canoe in the desc so click on it, then go to another video that says how to fet to guarma in that description

hearty hill
#

Tysmmm for the help I’ll definitely do that

golden storm
#

idk if im allowed to post links but i have the video

hearty hill
#

I just hope this doesn’t corrupt my game or get me banned or smth lol

golden storm
#

look in media

golden storm
hearty hill
#

Last question

#

U can go and come back any time or once u go u can’t go back again

golden storm
#

you can go back

hearty hill
#

Yay

golden storm
#

it took me an hour

hidden moss
#

you can go anytime, but its best to get everything in one go

hearty hill
#

I’ll try to do that

#

I heard someone say that when u go the island is filled with snipers

golden storm
#

the city part yes

hearty hill
#

So I’ll try to watch out for that as well

hidden moss
#

u can disable that too, by replaying a mission

golden storm
#

just dont go in the red

hearty hill
#

LOL SORRY IM ASKING SO MANY QUESTIONS

golden storm
#

yiure good

hidden moss
#

bareknuckle friendships

#

dont play the whole thing

#

once u get off the train, fail the mission and cancel it

hearty hill
#

Oh okayyy

hidden moss
#

disables the snipers for some reason..

golden storm
#

helpful for me as well

#

BUT

hidden moss
#

but dont mess with the lawmen

golden storm
#

the snipers come bsck if you get wanted in the xity

hidden moss
#

cuz it renables the snipers

hearty hill
#

Duly noted

golden storm
hidden moss
frigid cloud
#

Swim

hidden moss
#

i cant even get past thieves landing.

hearty hill
#

With Arthur I couldn’t even get to blackwater

frigid cloud
#

Wagon till thieves landing then swim and hope for the best ig

golden storm
hearty hill
#

Okay anyway thanks for all the help

#

Gotta bounce

hidden moss
#

oh damn, so basically go around the whole map..

golden storm
#

ill put a link in media its quite neat

#

yes it took 3 hours my final attempt, 5 in total

unborn iron
#

I'm on the last train heist

red helm
#

Money, money, money!

hidden moss
#

Im mentally preparing myself

#

For this fricking horse challenge

#

Strawberry to Saint Denis

#

WITHOUT TOUCHING WATER

#

I HAVE A PLAN

frigid cloud
#

That's easy

hidden moss
#

Im too good for this

#

Easy

#

Ok uh

#

7 enemies

#

Gotta trample them

red helm
#

Those place to place Horse challenges are not that difficult, just get to a Train Track as quickly as you can, and follow it as far as you can.

#

Then obviously, you just have to avoid trains, if they come, but that is usually rather rare. But, it is better than having to dodge people on the roads. Or go through forests and such.

hushed flare
#

rain isn't water in horse challenges btw

hidden moss
#

Now i have van horn to blackwater lol thats easy

hushed flare
#

Without touching water

#

And there's a river of water

autumn verge
#

I went back to valentine, Somehow the O'Driscolls are back

hushed flare
#

Which character

autumn verge
#

I overheard them saying "It better not be that cowboy that come by"

hushed flare
#

O'Driscolls should be dead after you help sadie

autumn verge
#

It was really something now that they can come back

hushed flare
#

Laramie gang is lame, no maxim gun at hanging dog ranch anymore

hidden moss
#

Maybe like they are the last few that are scattered around

#

Bc i encountered some i believe yesterday

red helm
#

Indeed, if you are past the Epilogue, and heard some O'Driscolls, that would be interesting.

autumn verge
#

If you go to little creek river, You can find the last remaining base of the O'Driscolls.

hushed flare
#

in epilogue they don't exist tho

red helm
#

I'm terrible with the river names, which one is that?

hushed flare
#

I think it's the one in new hanover

autumn verge
#

@red helmfar from strawberry

#

its that long river

hushed flare
#

Oh shit west Elizabeth?

autumn verge
#

yes

#

the top of west elizabeth

red helm
#

Far from Strawberry isn't super helpful.... In Tall Trees?

autumn verge
#

you will find a large ranch house

hushed flare
#

o Driscoll's moving to new Austin

autumn verge
#

full of O'Driscolls and the ones that you see from the horseman apocalypse

#

mission

hidden moss
#

My poor Starlight lol she gonna be destroyed after this

autumn verge
#

I think its a fair treat to kill all of them after what they done to kerien

red helm
#

Because that turned into a Laramie Gang hideout in the Epilogue...

autumn verge
#

I am still playing arthur morgan

hidden moss
#

sick man

autumn verge
#

Yeah I did check that it became a laramie gang

#

mostly through videos

red helm
#

Err... just reread the convo, why were we assuming you meant in the end game? Meh...

hidden moss
#

Help

#

How do i get to blackwater

#

Theres water

#

Help

#

Please

autumn verge
#

Oh yeah john cannot swim

#

welp

red helm
hidden moss
#

I need it for the challenge

#

lol

hidden moss
#

no

#

theres a broken bridge

#

its better that way

red helm
# hidden moss Theres water

OR there is a broken bridge, closer to Blackwater. BUT, you need a Big horse, and still, you can fall and it'll kill your horse and screw up the challenge.

#

The Owanjila Bridge is further, but easier.

hidden moss
#

but its cooler

#

A white arabian isnt that big so that sucks

#

Still

#

I have 17 minutes

red helm
#

Arabian's will Fail the Broken bridge way. 100%. Don't even bother.

#

You'll need a Shire, or Ardennes

hidden moss
#

Buell mightve worked

#

If i didnt lose him

red helm
#

Eh, Buell isn't quite....

hidden moss
#

Quite?

red helm
#

Big enough

hidden moss
#

Oh

red helm
#

He might do it. but... eh

hidden moss
#

50/50 chance of messing it up

red helm
#

Just do the Owanjila, it's not that much longer.

hidden moss
#

Yeah

red helm
#

If you were doing the challenge, As Arthur, the Broken Bridge method would be advised. But, otherwise..

hidden moss
#

How would that make a difference?

red helm
#

Ouf,going through that areas as Arthur is a Mega-Bitch....

autumn verge
#

Bounty hunters?

hidden moss
#

Is he going to place “LENNNNYYYYY” on the bridge and walk on that?

#

Welp

red helm
#

Groups of Lawmen, spawning around you, just where ever. Plus, the usual Predator's.... It's awful.

hidden moss
#

Byebye

#

Ima go do this challenge

red helm
#

Good luck

hidden moss
#

When u pause

#

Does that still count as using time

red helm
#

I would assume not. But not 100% sure there.

hidden moss
#

Alr

#

Bc i had to come off

#

Ima go back on tho

#

Soon

hushed flare
#

Horsemen 10

red helm
#

Last time I was doing Horsemen 10, Kentucky Saddlers were all over the place, it was pretty funny, and ridiculous.

hushed flare
#

Kentucky saddlers and morgans

gray wasp
summer blaze
#

Yea, it ties in nicely to RDR1

#

I got mad as a kid playing it, assuming a badass outlaw who’s been on the run for so long, who can kill with so much speed and damage would at least understand how to do a doggy paddle

#

I had the game of the year edition with the map and a poster of Bonnie Mcfarlane, I wanted to swim to mexico-John couldn’t swim ):

rustic shadow
#

does anyone know where the blue estate boss hat is?

hushed flare
#

Then pick up hat

rustic shadow
#

ye ye deez nuts

hushed flare
rustic shadow
#

but fr where is it it’s not in any of the tailors

#

or any trappers

hushed flare
#

outfit maybe

paper kelp
#

The master hunter challenge is so hard my dude

#

Cougars like never ever spawn

hushed flare
#

Gambler challenges

paper kelp
#

Yes but you see I want the cougar cloak thing and it’s a pain

#

How do I find more cougars

golden storm
#

i insulted micah and he pushed me ive never wanted to hit circle more

civic nest
paper kelp
#

I am there it took 3 hours to spawn another one and I almost died to it cause my horse is stupid

civic nest
#

You have to wait 3 in-game days for animals to respawn

#

And cougars spawn only one at once

paper kelp
#

That’s dumb

civic nest
#

So the best way to do it is sleeping for three days

paper kelp
#

Does it still respawn if your sleeping in the area it respawns in

civic nest
#

Yes

paper kelp
#

That’s good thanks

#

“You’re already at a campsite”
No I’m in the middle of nowhere it’s not letting me sleep

#

When I touch make a camp cowboykekw

golden storm
#

GUYS SWANSON WAS BY MICAH AND I ACCIDENTALLY ANTAGONIZED HIM I FEEL SO BAD IM CRYING

paper kelp
#

How dare you

golden storm
#

i reloaded the save

paper kelp
#

Poor reverend

golden storm
#

it is at the end of chapter 4 too when hes gettint his life back together :(((

paper kelp
#

What he say when you antagonize him

#

I wanna know

golden storm
#

i dotn remember it was something ab blood

paper kelp
#

How dare

#

All for antagonizing micah though

#

Maybe he’ll leave if you do it enough

#

I have no idea where my Micah is though he’s not at camp

hidden moss
#

Best revolver?

#

I think the top 2 candidates are the Schofield and Double Action

paper kelp
#

Double action

#

I feel like every o Driscoll I kill has a schofield revolver

#

Depends on what you mean best as in

night raven
hidden moss
red helm
paper kelp
#

What happens during the quest a fork in the road if you aren’t walking on the street and instead climb on top of buildings to get to sadies mission

quiet gazelle
#

Missions starts on the roof

paper kelp
#

Really and the guy just so happens to be on the roof also and drags you off magically

quiet gazelle
#

No

#

First he rapes arthur

#

Then drags him off the roof

#

👍 👨

paper kelp
#

Ooh so that’s how he got sick
Gotcha ArthurSip

quiet gazelle
#

The more you learn boah

#

YeeHawSmile 🤠

#

Also

#

That suit micah wears for the saint denis robbery

#

Damn fine

true wave
quiet gazelle
paper kelp
true wave
#

me?

paper kelp
#

Yes 🎉

quiet gazelle
true wave
#

I don't

paper kelp
#

dont what

hidden moss
#

👀🍿

true wave
#

I don't do the thing to Arthur

golden storm
#

dang arthur really has the confidence to say hi to EVERYONE on the street i could never

true wave
#

I do that lol

quiet gazelle
#

Arthur got raped by a dude outside of saint denis

#

Homie was limping

golden storm
#

bills best friend?

hidden moss
quiet gazelle
#

Homies hole was sore lololol

golden storm
hidden moss
#

Hey some might 😂

true wave
hidden moss
#

The teachers atleast 🥱

true wave
golden storm
#

eww i dont wanna be a teachers pet

#

saying hello to teachers is weird unless they say it first

paper kelp
#

Also my horse has eyelashes

golden storm
#

uncles horse has a mustache

#

as john at least

paper kelp
#

Wiat it does?

hidden moss
#

Most teachers need a good conversation they have to deal with bad kids all day

paper kelp
#

Yea but when you conversation with a teacher it’s weird because their oLd

golden storm
#

true ^^

hidden moss
#

Only weird if you make it weird

paper kelp
#

Maybe or maybe not

#

What the heck do you talk to a teacher about

#

Maths?

night raven
paper kelp
#

All my teachers are old

#

Do animals despawn after you’re attacked by them

#

Because I got mauled by a cougar

steady vector
#

Sometimes they do and sometimes they don’t it seems

#

And I think it’s different between story and online

#

If you get killed in Online you respawn nearby and whatever killed you (excluding another player) will probably still be there. In story that’s not the case

steady vector
kind sun
#

ok, so I am almost done... the compendium only has two items left.. micah's revolver (which I will get in the last misison) and THIS FUCKING CLEAVER

#

I have tried everything, I've played this game on and off for three years, I have to get this to 100%

#

PLEASE help me

paper kelp
kind sun
#

oh no, I have to play the epilogue finale to get it

#

that's not the issue - it's the cleaver

paper kelp
#

Idk what the cleaver is

kind sun
#

I have 1 of 1 when I try to buy it from the fence

#

but it's not in my compendium

paper kelp
#

Did you use it

kind sun
#

I replayed the Jim Milton blah blah mission Ep 1 to get it - doesnt go in the compendium

paper kelp
#

But did you use it outside of that

#

If it’s an item use it

kind sun
#

I can't pull it up

paper kelp
#

Maybe you gotta use it in order for it to be tasked as done

kind sun
#

not in my weapons, not even in my stock back at Beecher's Hope

paper kelp
#

Well I dunno man

#

Maybe it’s a glitch

#

I finally finished the kill 5 cougars with a bow

#

Is the lure and kill predator and herbivore supposed to be at the same time or can I lure a predator and kill it then lure a herbivore and kill it

night raven
#

It’s probably separately

red helm
paper kelp
#

Okay good

kind sun
#

anyone else know about the cleaver

#

I am gonna be so pissed if I fall one short after all this time

native vector
#

I miss playing rdr2

wary meteor
#

i didn't buy the cleaver but it did say its throwable, check your weapon wheel where the throwing knives and dynamite is maybe? if not you might have to buy a new one, I'm guessing you can buy another since it's throwable but again just a guess

#

@kind sun

paper kelp
#

Maybe you threw it and didn’t pick it uppp? I don’t know

native vector
#

Fun fact in epilouge you just directly buy the satchel of the east

round hedge
#

we know

#

and it looks ugly

native vector
#

Well

paper kelp
#

The what of the what

native vector
#

Cheese 🧀

native vector
paper kelp
#

I got a satchel in the epilogue that has unlimited storage space

#

I don’t know how

native vector
#

Has anyone finished rdr2 more than twice because I sure have

paper kelp
#

I got it a week ago so like once I guess

native vector
#

You finished it in a Week!

wary meteor
#

I just got to chapter 3, been spending a lot of time online tho since I really like open world games with character creation

paper kelp
#

Well more of a week and a half but yes

native vector
#

Thats still impressive

paper kelp
#

I played it nonstop lol

native vector
#

I've got 80 percent of the game completed

paper kelp
native vector
#

I only started hunting in my 2nd play trough

#

Chapter 3 was my favourite chapter

#

6 is just plain sad

paper kelp
#

I liked 1 2 and 3

native vector
#

Those were the best chapters

#

I personally didn't like chapter 1

paper kelp
#

Yep

#

Ooh I loved it

#

It’s so snowy

native vector
#

2 was so cool

paper kelp
#

I love snow

native vector
#

Shooting up valentine

#

Something I still do in epilouge

native vector
red helm
paper kelp
#

If you redo the mission in chapter 1 the o Driscoll one if you don’t get off your horse you can knock down Lenny and Javier infinitely and it’s funny

native vector
#

I'm still curious how gow4 won game of the year 2018
I liked the game yes but when you complete the story there's not much you can do

#

Lennyyyy

#

I named my black arabian good boah

kind sun
red helm
kind sun
#

it's not in the compendium, I can't use it, I can't buy one

native vector
#

It's sold at a fence I think

red helm
#

Purposely ramming my horse into Micah's horse is fun times.

native vector
night raven
#

You don't get to keep Micah's revolver if you replay the mission and pick it up right?

paper kelp
#

If you do the graveyard mission with John when he’s getting off his horse you can run full speed at him and fling him off of it and he will get up like nothing happened it’s hilarious

native vector
red helm
native vector
paper kelp
native vector
night raven
#

fuck! I missed it the first time and I have to go back if i want it.

native vector
native vector
night raven
#

It's a schofeild isn't it?

red helm
native vector
paper kelp
#

Best emoji change my mind ArthurSip

native vector
#

This is best emoji

wary meteor
red helm
kind sun
#

it is a bug

native vector
#

Go back there where u killed him

#

Ull find it

kind sun
#

I am at the last mission in the epilogue

paper kelp
#

Can you pick up his body

native vector
#

It's just a double action which look cool

paper kelp
#

If so I wanna bury him in guarma

red helm
native vector
#

Yess

night raven
native vector
#

U can

#

I fed him to aligators

red helm
native vector
#

Yeah

#

U need to go back there

#

After tehe mission

paper kelp
#

Put him in the oil hole by horseshoe, rats spawn there a lot

native vector
#

His family

#

Family reunion

paper kelp
#

Yep

native vector
#

His dad is horrible too

paper kelp
#

What I thought of replaying is that

native vector
#

Props to rockstar for making on e of the best games ever

night raven
paper kelp
#

“There’s talk of hanging him”
Dutch says “there’s talk of hanging him” to John but no second thought to go get micah nope

native vector
#

Well

#

Dutch hit his head

#

In chapter 4 in trolley station incident

red helm
native vector
#

That messed up his brain

paper kelp
#

I did a whole lot worse

native vector
paper kelp
#

He collided into me into a cliff

native vector
#

It's a Schofield

paper kelp
#

I think rocks > trolleys

native vector
red helm
night raven
#

Maybe I'll just bring Micha's body with me wherever I go and just parade him around until i find a good spot to dump him

native vector
#

Lawman go brrr

#

I want Brontes hat tbh

#

It look bouge

paper kelp
#

I wish they’d put the online clothes in story because what I see is it looks so cool

#

I want snake chaps

night raven
native vector
#

Best legendary hunter set?

night raven
#

I also want to shoot up saint denis dressed as bronte

native vector
#

Lmao

#

Gta 6 will be so cool

night raven
#

The vest is the best

red helm
#

Well, at least you can break up the Trapper sets, and change each piece.

night raven
#

Yeah.

#

I just use arthur's hat and john's hat for everything

red helm
#

Would suck if you had to wear all the items of a outfit, or not at all.

#

Ghost Bison hat = Best hat.

night raven
#

I wish the marauder set had a coat

native vector
#

If you wear arthur hat in epilouge my respect for you goes 📈 📈

night raven
#

I sometimes do, but i love john's also

native vector
#

True

#

But Arthur's hat is just diff

#

Name one thing you hate about replaying a mission

hushed flare
night raven
hushed flare
hushed flare
red helm
native vector
#

Oh you play rdr2 name every character

hushed flare
#

copier jk

kind sun
#

I can't post the link but if you google rdr2 cleaver glitch it's there

red helm
hushed flare
kind sun
#

is there a mission where you can roam and go to a fence and buy it?

#

early on?

glad brook
#

Durtch.

hushed flare
red helm
hushed flare
#

stranger #18273838

night raven
kind sun
#

I mean that I can replay?

red helm
#

I don't think you actually buy from Seamus in that mission, though.

night raven
kind sun
#

Jim Milton rides again

hushed flare
#

Cleaver is hatchet budget edition

kind sun
#

but it doesn't add to the compendium

red helm
#

There is a mission in Chapter 4, for Brother Dorkus, where you break out those 2 Spanish slaves... Do not remember the name.

kind sun
#

so I will be short one item

hushed flare
#

"Dorkus"stroke

red helm
#

Whatever his name is...

hushed flare
#

Dorkins

#

I still call sister cahedron or something sister cauldron thoSoyoureCowboy

red helm
#

But the slaves are in the Saint Denis Fence building, so you might be able to buy from it, during the mission.

#

Sister Cauldron da Witch lady.

kind sun
#

let me try and I will report back

#

thanks!

night raven
#

Good luck! Let’s see that red name soon

kind sun
#

what's the red name mean?

night raven
#

You got the Best In The West Achievement for 100%. I assume that’s what you’re shooting for

kind sun
#

I just wanted to get 100% compendium

civic nest
hushed flare
#

Red names be like:

night raven
hushed flare
#

the red names fan vs the level names chad

kind sun
#

so I am at the fence, but can't ask to buy anyting.. anywhere to steal it from?

night raven
#

Is there one on the shelves like in some stores?

hushed flare
#

Unlock fence

red helm
#

Meh, Yeah, I could get the red name too, but, nah, I'd rather have my level name, so Not even going to go through the hassle of getting the role title.

hushed flare
#

Same

red helm
hushed flare
#

I already have 100% but I prefer level name

night raven
#

I finally reached level 9 in roles

#

Almost to the light blue name gang

red helm
#

One more for the Eww Blue role.

#

Oh, wait no, Green is 10.

night raven
#

It’s better than yellow though

red helm
#

20 is Eww Blue.

hushed flare
#

level up

#

damn

red helm
#

Yes, Yellow is just plain Eww.

kind sun
#

i can't believe I spent 3 years on this game and I can't get 100%

red helm
#

Talk more!