red-dead-singleplayer

[round hedge]

gambler challenge isn't even fun

it's just stressful

[summer garnet]

and time consuming too

[hidden moss]

ikr, takes so damn long

I wish you could gamble much more

Much much more

[summer garnet]

i used to like dominos when i played it with my friends thanks to rdr2 i hate it now

[gray wasp]

I dont gamble, but on the topic of minigames: I AM THE KING OF 5 FINGER FILLET!!!!!!!!!

[ancient python]

Black jack is alright

[hidden moss]

when i got a zero or 6, the npc just blocks it.. then gotta draw like 15 tiles

its like he knows

[summer garnet]

its pain when you have to do 3 hits and win somehow

[ancient python]

True

[summer garnet]

the first round is pretty easy

[gray wasp]

IM shit at poker though because Idk anything about lol or what cards are better, or how to play at all

Ive never done it before

[amber halo]

HAHAHA fishing ai with mpc's is pretty jacked. Funny though. Standing on the pier fishing. Pearson walks up, starts fishing and just stares at me asking if there's something I need. Silly af but kinda funny how he just stares.

[gray wasp]

Time to save Sean and move on with the story! (as soon as I finish Bandit 2 because I can.)

[amber halo]

OK now the 2nd time I've seen micah interact with a woman. About as gross as the first. Hmpf

[gray wasp]

Micah's just a horrible person to everyone, this shouldn't suprise you.

[amber halo]

Anyone know if there's a fishing glitch? I know the big one's you have to stow on the horse but if I don't cook like multiple 5 pounders do they despawn on load? Mine did.

[gray wasp]

idk, my version of fishing is with GUN or HORSE

I dont have a fishing rod yet

idk if you can get one early

[amber halo]

You can get one but I already opened it too.

[gray wasp]

opened it?

[amber halo]

Caught a nice 16 pounder yesterday. Great fight, too. Love the fishing interaction for the bigguns.

[gray wasp]

(opened it?)

[amber halo]

Ya I had a rod before I opened the mission and all the other achievemnts and bigger baits came after.

[gray wasp]

ok

where can I get a rod then?

[amber halo]

I snagged one off a guy standing on Dakota right by valentine camp. If you go near him, see if he tells you to move, don't, when he attacks he drops it. Beat his ass take his rod no neg honor.

[gray wasp]

really?

I dont think thats intended

but ok

[amber halo]

NPC's all over use them but you have to snag it from them. I had no idea it worked that way. Well it does on pc.

[gray wasp]

does it break anything in the game later on?

by getting a rod early

[amber halo]

Ya you can get like cheese bait from Hosea I think after you guys go hunting for the bear. If I'm remembering correctly.

[gray wasp]

interesting...

[amber halo]

It might be breaking my ability to carry around 40 pounds of fish. HAHAHA have to test some more.

[gray wasp]

actually, this brings up another question

I've found that a lot of guns and clothes are locked and I cant buy them.

[amber halo]

I may know. Prolly not bc I still know very little.

Oh ya a shit ton of guns are locked rn. Early on.

They open quick.

[gray wasp]

ok, ok good to know. ( I can look up the specifics, thanks.)

[faint yacht]

Progress through chapter 2 story

[amber halo]

There's some really op guns to get EASY from side raids on enemy camps you find. REALLY nice. I'm in late ch 3 and still using it. Couldn't believe it was available that early.

[gray wasp]

ok

Lol IM probably making a mistake using Billy Midnight's Pistol then, I just think it looks cool.

[faint yacht]

I use it just cause it looks cool on cutscene holsters

[hidden moss]

Do you prefer Linear story mode or Red ded type

[gray wasp]

Red Dead type

I like freedom

[amber halo]

I meant to say late ch 4

[gray wasp]

I use Midnight's Pistol and Granger's revolver, but I might switch back my my own custom revolver. (solid gold, silver engravings, very fancy)

[hidden moss]

Same But i would Rather have less but longer storys

[gray wasp]

I guess

thng about this game is that the story shouldnt always be your primary goal

theres so much to do outside of it

you can finish the story in like 13 hours

EZ

[hidden moss]

Sure About that?

[gray wasp]

thats the WR so...yeah I suppose

you should do other things than the story

stranger missions, hunting, fishing, just wandering around.

they put so much into this world, you can't not explore

[amber halo]

I've had to retsrat like 4 or 5 times now before I even really knew wth I was doing. Now that I have an idea of how to do just the most basic other than linear I'm finishing this run with mostly linear then starting another one where I'm not gonna fret honor as much as I have been knowing how hard I was breaking my back to pin it but it's not even pinnable until the 5th and 6th.

[hidden moss]

First source that come up on Google says 40-50 hours for mainstory

[gray wasp]

Wait what

can you not spoiler things?

[hidden moss]

?

[gray wasp]

???

you cant put the spoiler thing over text

I was just-

nvm

*sigh

[muted sierra]

If I were to describe the mission "A Quiet Time" it'd be "Spongebob and Patrick at Goofy Goober's 2004 colorized"

[round hedge]

eeeehhh

not sure RDR2 missions have freedom

[hidden moss]

He means between

[gray wasp]

yeah I mean actually in the world

you can do whatever

you're only limited by your skill, and the developers ideas.

anyways

can you replay any mission if you beat the story?

I though you caould at anytime, but it only shows recent ones

[round hedge]

leave the track to get to the place slightly quicker

• mission failed *

[gray wasp]

OK NEVER MIND I RELATE

I was chasing Jamie, and instead of going through the sheep I went around a tree, and it FAILED THE MISSION with Jamie RIGHT THERE, like 10 meters away. I had to re-start the whole mission, including talking to the chelonians. (I wasn't so polite the second time...)

chelonianism is a scam anyways

they just get money off of charity and then commit suicide

Oh

I didnt get a chance to say this yesterday

but Arthur stops/cant focus on a possum if they're playing dead

which I find interesting

[hidden moss]

im almost to best in the west i have 83 percent done

[gray wasp]

damn

[hidden moss]

im doing gold medals now

[gray wasp]

What counts toward progression anyways? I'm at twenty-something and Idek what I did

I've just studied animals and picked flowers and shit tbh, with a bit of story and gunslinging on the side

[hidden moss]

idk a acheviment

[frigid cloud]

Progress and total completion

[hidden moss]

that too

[frigid cloud]

Still too far

[hidden moss]

?

[gray wasp]

also Im an idiot

shooting snakes before studying them

[hidden moss]

y

[quasi folio]

Hey! Does anything happen if I keep for a long time pelts on my horse?

[frigid cloud]

they rot eventually I think

[gray wasp]

because they snakes? with poison? so my first reaction is screaming and shooting.

[quasi folio]

I got a lot of pelts right now on my horse but I'm not sure about if they rot or not, I know carcasses do, but about pelts I have no clue if they may despawn or something if I keep them there for long.

[hidden moss]

yes they rot but its only if you have the animal

i think

for a long time

[quasi folio]

what do you mean by having the animal? The carcass? I only got pelts

[hidden moss]

yes the carcass rots

[quasi folio]

Carcass (the animal body) do rot with time, yeah. But my question its if pelts do too.

[hidden moss]

i dont think so

so ur good

[gray wasp]

Pelts are fine yeah

[quasi folio]

Alright, thanks.

[frigid cloud]

What u need so many pelts for? @quasi folio

[hidden moss]

spirt is the pelt god i guess

[hushed flare]

traper

[gray wasp]

Hey guys...what are my chances at successfully hunting a legendary wolf? 'cause I found its area...

I have a bow, a reapeater, and a varmint rifle. (+ my pistols)

like, does it matter what I use, or does it have to be perfect?

[hidden moss]

Just fucking shoot with ur best gun

Legendary animals don't have quality

[night raven]

If it’s legendary, you can’t ruin the pelt. Hit it as hard as you can with something high caliber

[amber halo]

HAHAHAHA can't believe I just saw grime show shove another woman. She makes me sick. Well her personality does.

[hidden moss]

wastin my time

[gray wasp]

Very good info. if I say, charge it guns blazing, will it fight or run away? (I assume fight because its a predator)

[hidden moss]

unload every shotgun you have

perfect quality

[gray wasp]

uh oh

we have a problem then

I dont have a shotgun on me or my horse

they're all in my locker

I'd have to ride all the way back to Valentine

would dual pistols be enough?

• Deadeye

It would be a total of 18-16 hits. (if I hit most of my shots)

[frigid cloud]

Bro don't stress about it

Use any guns and tag in dead eye

[hidden moss]

you can always reload using deadeye, so using anything you got now is fine..

[gray wasp]

WHAT.

I still dont know how to stop tagging people in deadeye, I end up wasting 2-3 shots on someones arm

is it supposed to be like that?

[spring sluice]

I don't think they'd be tagged if you didn't manually tagged them

[frigid cloud]

Automatic tagging

It'll change later on

[frigid cloud]

You can activate dead eye to reload your gun

[gray wasp]

when? how do you even unlock that stuff like revealing fatal points?

[hidden moss]

yes, if you go out of deadeye and activate it again, it reloads your guns for you

[gray wasp]

thats neat

thanks

[frigid cloud]

Manual tagging in chapter 2

[gray wasp]

im in chapter 3 tho

[frigid cloud]

And in chapter 4 being able to stay in dead eye after firing, in chapter 6 you get the ability to see fatal points

[gray wasp]

*2

[frigid cloud]

Well you gotta do a certain mission

[gray wasp]

I've done all the missions up until saving Sean

[hidden moss]

oh ok

then u r about to get manual tagging

on the train job

[gray wasp]

alright

[frigid cloud]

Gotta do the train heist to unlock it

[gray wasp]

train heist?\

OOOOH THAT TRAIN

wait so when does Chaptee 2 end?

[frigid cloud]

Soon

[gray wasp]

awww...

[hidden moss]

next chapter got the same vibe though

[gray wasp]

still I'll miss the view

and being close to Valentine was nice

[gray wasp]

so when I unlock it, what button does it?

Left Trigger?

[amber halo]

Does the horse fence team go bye bye?? Can't find them now.

[gray wasp]

The what?

[amber halo]

My bad.

"Horse Fence".

[gray wasp]

I still dont get it

A fence for horses?

or a literal fence

[amber halo]

Those 2 guys that buy stolen horses and give us more for stolen than a stable would but less than if they were legit horses.

[gray wasp]

oh them

I forgot about them

[amber halo]

They no longer appear on my map nor the map index.

[gray wasp]

uhh

idk

[frigid cloud]

R1

[gray wasp]

OH

the right button

ok ok

lots of controls to remember

thanks you guys for helping me out with so much the past couple days

[hidden moss]

not sure what's the button on xbox..

oh nvm..

[gray wasp]

yeah

L1 and R1 + right and left button

L2 + L1 = right and left trigger

[night raven]

It’ll probably attack you. Just use a sniper and hit it in the face

[gray wasp]

Lol i dont have a sniper yet

I have a varmint rifle with a short scope

thats the best thing I have atm

[night raven]

Use that, but use explosive ammo or other advanced ammo. If you’ve got improved arrows with your bow, try that. If you’re in a pickle, use a sawn off shotgun or use a metric ton of improved ammo on your pistols

[gray wasp]

Alright

GAME PLAN!!!!

1. buy explosive ammo

[amber halo]

OK I just found them. Maybe they were never in the index but I remembered the spot. Whew.

[gray wasp]

2. go back to the area

3. find the damn thing

4, remember that I didnt bring a shotgun

5. go all the way back

6. get a shotgun

[night raven]

Good luck my dude

[gray wasp]

7. go back AGAIN

8. MURDER

[night raven]

Great plan

[hidden moss]

make sure you got the pamphlets

[hushed flare]

Explosive shotgun ammo 👎
Explosive revolver ammo

[gray wasp]

......pamphlets?

[amber halo]

OMG most I've ever gotten for a horse. HAHAHA Dam! Well I know a quick and easy way to make some good cash when I do a bad guy run.

Ya "Pamphlets" it will be under "Documents" in your satchel I think.

[hushed flare]

Lemat revolvers are good at filling both the revolver and the sawed off category

[amber halo]

Crafting recipe's and stuff.

[hidden moss]

yes, once you have the pamphlets, then you can craft explosive ammo

buy it at the fence

[gray wasp]

and where would get that? (cant buy it?)

oh

ok thanks

alright I'll try and remember my plan 'cause Im away dong work until 2:30

i gtg now

Thaaaanks

[native vector]

Explosive rounds for repeaters and rifles are just different

I use them when hunting for legendary animals

[hushed flare]

I mean sniper rifles even carcano can one shot in the chest and if it's express you can even shoot the shoulder or leg

I never saw the practicality of explosive ammo besides one shotting legendary animals and unlocking train safes quick af

[native vector]

Using explosive rounds on a npc is useless

[solar trench]

boys can you help me with the gambler challenges ?

[gray wasp]

no I suck

mainly because I've never played any of them irl or otherwise

[solar trench]

dude i've never played any gambling games

[gray wasp]

example: in poker I folded when I had an amazing hand

[hidden moss]

idek poker, all i did was go all in and win somehow..

[solar trench]

i come to the gambler 5 with pure luck

but the gambler 5 is domino

i dont know how to play it

no body plays domino in my country

[gray wasp]

lol do you also not like reading the guide?

[solar trench]

so i did not play too

[hidden moss]

nah, didn't bother

[gray wasp]

I need to practice poker

at a train station or smth

or in the camp

[gray wasp]

lol same! its too complicated, even for a avid reader like me

too much information

but I have a basic idea on how it works

[hidden moss]

i was just really lazy..

[gray wasp]

although I was wondering if you can bluff NPC's into folding

[hidden moss]

dominos (draw game) is just connecting the tiles with the same number right? until you're done with all the tiles

[gray wasp]

yeah I think so

its like Uno with blocks

lol

[hidden moss]

yea i guess so, except there's no +4 or skips..

all of those challenges feel rigged, except the finger fillet and poker i guess..

[gray wasp]

I wouldnt know...

[gray wasp]

FFF is so easy though, especially on controller'

its just A B (reapeat action until the sun explodes)

Arthur just stabs at the speed of sound

[hidden moss]

yea, feel kinda bad for the npc

gets like 5 points with multiple injuries, while mpc just gets 12 while performing moves..

[gray wasp]

Ha ha yeah. for a semi-realistic game, FFF feels surreal

I feel bad for Lenny.

its the only minigame Im good at ;-;

but practice makes perfect

[hushed flare]

Npc seeing Arthur/John do this in finger fillet

[gray wasp]

Arthur is also incredibly more fit than me, and he's what, 36?

[hushed flare]

Depends if ur underweight or not

[gray wasp]

Still I can only sprint for like 30sec

Arthur's endurance is just insane

even when underweight

compared to an irl human, Arthur's on another level

(probably because back then you had to walk/ride horses everywhere)

and also the life of an outlaw is one that requires lots of stamina

[sacred thistle]

Uncle outlived almost every single Van Der Linde member, guess sometimes you just need lumbago

[frigid cloud]

No

It's lumbago luck

[sacred thistle]

Yes, Baran.
My use of "need lumbago" was intended to be in a satire tone, almost being used ironically in hint to Uncle's tendency to procrastinate and him generally being overweight.

[frigid cloud]

Thanks for that

I misunderstood

[gray wasp]

yeah satire and sarcasm are very hard to detect in text

thats why I use air quotes or italics to emphasize

[gray wasp]

it is kind of strange how the physically worst member of the gang outlasted almost everyone else.

[night raven]

Well he didn’t really fight or anything so he didn’t put himself in danger.

[gray wasp]

there was that one time...

and that other time...

[night raven]

But he was oldest next to hosea most likely so he would have died at some point

[gray wasp]

and that about it

[night raven]

The thing with the wagon?

[gray wasp]

(Hosea deserved better!)

[night raven]

Oh yeah definitely

[gray wasp]

not sure

[night raven]

I think Sean had it worse though

[gray wasp]

Hosea deserved retirement on some land out west, becoming one of those grandfathers who always tell stories about when they were young. ;-;

Dutch and Hosea: Ying and Yan

[frigid cloud]

"Hosea sucks" is incoming

[gray wasp]

from whom?

[hushed flare]

Gaius be like

[shy mulch]

average hosea sucks fan:

[ruby pewter]

dude

[gray wasp]

but why would people hate on Hosea? He's nice to everybody, made good calls, and if Dutch actually listened to him, maybe people woudl still be alive.

[ruby pewter]

playing RDR2 with mouse+keyboard is SO wonky

[gray wasp]

thats why its preferable on console

its 1st person is still wonky though

[shy mulch]

rockstar got keyboard mfs playing twister with their hands

[gray wasp]

LMAO

true

evenon console its a bit much

[shy mulch]

at the same time i'd rather aim my guns with mouse

[gray wasp]

the auto aim on console is pretty amazing though

so it makes up for it

[kindred jackal]

gunplay on PC is ass ngl

mostly attributed to RDR2s annoying combat

[shy mulch]

thats bc their mouse handling is horrible

and yea the enemies do have annoying ass animations lol

I would swap to controller if they supported Gyro for everything

not just the steam controller

[gray wasp]

lol i was reminded of how they wave up and down in a hilarious fashion

like reapeatedly ducking

sometimes if you just stop and look you see how funny it is

and the thing is that its not that bad a strategy

but still, deadeye is a thing

[shy mulch]

I use it too much

[gray wasp]

same

its not that hard to maintain now though

coffee and cooked stringy meat do just fine

[shy mulch]

makes me wonder if big game is overkill for chapter 5+

[ruby pewter]

well ive offically hit max negative honor

what happens now

[shy mulch]

since his ailment makes him cough his lungs out after eating a bit

you keep it that way until you get an outfit

I think for the fancy suit you get later on it turns your vest and tie red or smth

[gray wasp]

oh ye I remember hearing about that

[hidden moss]

yea low honor changes outfits and dialogues

[shy mulch]

I think you get a different gun grip too

[hidden moss]

for the bank robbery and the boat heist

[hidden moss]

yea

[gray wasp]

I'm going for high honour for my first playthrough

then on my next I'll just be commiting crimes wherever I go

[gray wasp]

one more hour, then I go home and can play

I copied my legendary Wolf game plan so I remember it

if I do this correctly it will be my first legendary animal

[ruby pewter]

this is supposed to be a high-action cowboy shooting game

and im here picking flowers for the last hour for challenges

great concept rockstar

fuckign fantastic

[gray wasp]

LOL

[hushed flare]

You should have a different deadeye sound but johns is less noticable

[gray wasp]

Well you're doing it by choice so its your own fault if it seems boring

[hushed flare]

Picking flowers and herbs for special horse reviver tho

[gray wasp]

So if you rob a store, (mask on) does the shopkeeper become a witness?

or do I have to hogtie them?

[ruby pewter]

nah

rob the store with ur mask and dip out as fast as possible

youll be fine

[gray wasp]

alright

so thats what went wrong

I robbed the fence in Saint Denis and I tried to hogtie him

[ruby pewter]

hell nah

[gray wasp]

one other thing

y'know how sometimes npc's have different reactions to being robbed? (some will give you money, some wont, others will just shoot you)

in the case of the 2nd one, does shooting your gun in the air help...convince them?

[glad brook]

Maybe. But shooting your gun will also alert everyone nearby.

[gray wasp]

yeah

its situational

[gray wasp]

tbh why wouldnt you give money in this scenario, you could DIE

[glad brook]

It was a common thing during that time period.

[gray wasp]

lol people were just plain thougher back then

technology has made us weak tbh

but the pros mostly outweigh the cons

[silent lotus]

where can i buy a horse?

[gray wasp]

any stable, or steal one

[frigid cloud]

Stables

Or tame a wild horse

[silent lotus]

ok, thanks

[gray wasp]

Theft, Stables, or natrual friendship

those are your options

you should already have a horse though, either the starting one or a temporary one.

did you just start the game?

whatever, you got your answer

does anyone know a good horse that is easy to obtain? I have a andalusian or whatever the name is rn.

[shy mulch]

you can get a white arabian

its hanging around the left road of lake isabella

[hidden moss]

there's a white arabian in the wild and black arabian in saint denis you can steal in an encounter

[lost ferry]

Gas is better to buy prestigious merchant or bounty hunter

[frigid cloud]

#rdo-chat

[gray wasp]

hey when starting ur game do you guy also get long loading times?

like a minute or two?

[frigid cloud]

Don't remember

[low finch]

yeah

like a minute

[round hedge]

you better just go without anything

since masks and bandanas are just for style

[gusty solar]

this game has brought me misery

[hushed flare]

No they make it so witnesses don't know who you are but lawmen can see straight through for some reason

[round hedge]

exactly

that's just plain useless

[hushed flare]

Still style

if I'm gonna commit a massacre I will wear it

[round hedge]

not losing honor or gaining with masks would be pretty pog

shooting a whole town and staying with positive honor

[hidden moss]

but but this would ruin the game ok???

No fun allowed..

[shy mulch]

hey mister

behind you m'am

max honor

[hidden moss]

throws fish

+Honor

[shy mulch]

pov: you commit mass genocide but you go fishing and greet people afterwards

[kindred jackal]

I loaded the game up on an old save, got ambushed by the italian mafa in san denis (couldnt fight back or i'd have a fucking wanted level), then had bounty hunters come up on me when i slept at my camp, then couldnt set up camp again because apparently i committed a crime

legit all i wanted to do was check a few things out on a chapter 4 save but instead got hit with all that

[hidden moss]

fr

[ruby pewter]

theres too many stranger encounters in this game
i just staright up ignore them now

[hidden moss]

and boom you just missed missable item

RDR2 has unholy amount of missable items

it's irritating

[frigid cloud]

What's the rarest missable item

[ruby pewter]

fml

maybe they will reoccur

[hidden moss]

I really don't remember

there are so many missable items

like holy siht

[true wave]

I'm totally not sadge thanks to this fucking game

[ruby pewter]

wtf

i put up a camp and a cutscene played where 2 murphy bloods came up and told me to never camp here again

lmao

[true wave]

"bunch of kin fucking bastards"

-Arthur Morgan 1899

[hidden moss]

heard there's this hat, called liberty hat which is only available on a random npc in 2 missions

[frigid cloud]

Maybe scout jacket

[uncut topaz]

Susan really just came up to me in camp and slapped me upside the head, called me revolting and made me wash myself.......

[shy mulch]

change ur outfit on ur horse often

bam, no baths needed

[hybrid igloo]

You know, I've been wondering...

Are Fussar's men the Cuban Army, the Guarman Army, or some Guarman militia?

[glad brook]

Until you actually do all those stranger missions and the game suddenly feels so lonely.

I don't understand why there are so little bounty hunter missions. Wack.

[hidden moss]

Prob the little gold shield in braithewait manor. Only available during the mission you burn down the mansion

It sells for 0 dollar tho😄

[ruby pewter]

is horizon zero dawn gameplay similar to rdr 2

[hidden moss]

Both have robots🤷

[ruby pewter]

how do i check how many hours ive played on rockstar version

i wanna see how many hours of my life ive wasted

[steady vector]

What if it wasn't a waste

[hushed flare]

when a chicken feather sells more then a shield made out of gold

[hidden moss]

I mean using just the compass, i didnt word that very well

No i think it was someone else

[red helm]

Yeap, that Shield probably gets my vote. But there is also a lot of random letters and notes on rand-oh strangers. Like I just hogtied a random dude in Van Horn to kidnap him and put on the train tracks nearby(For whatever bandit challenge that is), but I looted him of course, and he had a letter on him...

[hushed flare]

Except with the letters I'm pretty sure can be get at any time if you loot and kill enough random people

and the letters in story missions are pretty obvious dunno how you can miss them

[red helm]

Yeap, so not 'Missable" really, but eh... suppose if you never bother to kill/loot those people.

[hushed flare]

well I drag random people with lassos for no reason and loot them and sometimes get a letter and I'm in epilogue 2 on a 100% save

[red helm]

Like, I don't know if that one letter was specific to a person in Van Horn, or if it is just a chance to find it from any Stranger in the world...

[hushed flare]

I think some letters are in specific types of people

Letter to Jacob can only be found on(quoting wiki) "rich blackwater townsfolk"

[red helm]

Exactly, what if you never bother to kill the townsfolk in Rhodes or some other town?

[hushed flare]

not like the letters have any requirement

i want to find all books in rdr2

[red helm]

The only good book is the one written by Lewis Lupont.

[lilac iron]

arthur morgan once said

[red helm]

"You, sir, are a fish." ?

[lilac iron]

😅

[red helm]

Ha, ha.. Sorry, go on.

[lilac iron]

no i said that for people to tell me what arthur once said

its ok

[red helm]

Oh, you were just 'fishing' for quotes?

I thought you were going to say more stuff.

[lilac iron]

yeh, just for a bit of fun

[red helm]

Why are you a sad person @lilac iron ?

[lilac iron]

im going through a rough patch

[red helm]

Aww, well, I hope it gets better, soon.

[lilac iron]

arthur once said " you're my favourite parasite..... No, ringworms my favourite parasite, you're my second favourite parasite..... I lied, ringworms, then rats with the plague, then you. "

[lilac iron]

and thank u

[red helm]

That's a good one. It's been several months since I went into the Epilogue, so I can't remember to many good Arthur quotes. Fooie.

[lilac iron]

oh wow, im addicted to it. well i completed the game for the first time in January, that took my 112 hours, i kinda rushed it. Then i played it agian, took my 200 hours, i took my time. Now im trying to 100% the compendium and the story of course

but ive spent along time online aswell

[red helm]

I've been playing over the past year and a half, went through twice, but just got 100% a few weeks ago. Though, never done Online, because I just don't want to deal with Griefers and such. Life is to short.

[lilac iron]

oh, i kinda enjoy online. i rarely run into griefers but R* just need to add better updates

[shy mulch]

Seems a bit friendlier than GTA Online from observation

[lilac iron]

im just making money to make different outfits every now and then

[red helm]

Online seems, sort of okay, but still... eh.

[shy mulch]

Until R adds flying horses with maxim guns

im not responsible for online relapsing into GTA Online tier bullshit if that ever happens

[ruby pewter]

YES

[hushed flare]

Arthur Morgan once said: "micah cute"

[ruby pewter]

herbalist 6 completeddddddddd

[hushed flare]

[shy mulch]

Dutch once said JESUS MICAH IS THAT A TRAP

[red helm]

Yes, flying horses with people shoting explosive rounds and what not. This will not surprise me in the least.

[hushed flare]

Flying unicorn horse with 2 cannons attached to it

[red helm]

Nice. Get ready for some yuckiness, though.

[shy mulch]

How about armored Wagons with a built in cannon

[ruby pewter]

herba7 aint too bad

craft 5 special tonics

[shy mulch]

better yet you can command a ship like the one in Guarma and if it explodes it'll be like the Halifax explosion

[red helm]

Yeah, long as you know where some Yarrow's are.

[hushed flare]

War wagon but replacing the maxim with a cannon

Arabian mk2 when

[shy mulch]

ill just counter with my crocodile hat

buck that boi off

[hushed flare]

I'll just counter that by not playing online

[shy mulch]

TRUE

[ruby pewter]

18 yarrow fml

[lilac iron]

does anyone know good gold making schemes in rdo?

[shy mulch]

lol you can probably get a bunch in the heartlands

[hushed flare]

#red-dead-singleplayer

[shy mulch]

yarrow that is

[hushed flare]

Getting gold in the heartlands in rdo

[red helm]

Grinding and Patiences, but yes, this is Single player room, so....

[lilac iron]

oh right, im so sorry

[shy mulch]

how else are we gonna get to tahiti

[red helm]

No worries.

[hushed flare]

buy a horse that costs 46 gold bars

[ruby pewter]

18 currant, 18 yarrow, 18 burdock root....rockstar wants to see its players in pain

[hushed flare]

That's how

[shy mulch]

and make it fly

[lilac iron]

arthur once said " Is this trolley going to tahiti? "

[hushed flare]

Arthur once said "Micah is good guy"

[red helm]

Herb 9 is the only lame Herbalist challenge, really. Unless it was retroactive, and/or you didn't need to get the New Austin/Blackwater herbs.

[hushed flare]

Nerfing herb 9 down to 38 would be nice

[vagrant temple]

If only we could get something like that

Finally something to use gold on

[hybrid igloo]

Ah, are you a Micah fan unironically?

[ruby pewter]

i searched for 1 hour ALL over the great plains looking for burdock root before i realized only next to train tracks and water.........

[hushed flare]

Sort of yes

[shy mulch]

the river near horseshoe overlook is good for burdock root

[hybrid igloo]

Lol. You wanna know something?

[red helm]

Roanoke Ridge, great place for thoes.

[hushed flare]

Micah is good

[vagrant temple]

Use #rdo-compendium

[hybrid igloo]

I'm kind of a rare Sadie hater.

[hushed flare]

ok

[shy mulch]

how could you hate Mrs. Assler

[red helm]

Sadie is cool, but I can see how there are people that can dislike her.

[ruby pewter]

YOOOOOOOOOOOOO

wtf

❤️

[hushed flare]

lol what

[ruby pewter]

it shows where all plants are in the map

[hushed flare]

ye

[hybrid igloo]

Tell me about it.

[hushed flare]

also burdock root is like everywhere

[shy mulch]

Makes me wonder if ppl dislike her character as a good thing or if she is poorly written

[ruby pewter]

nah ur thinkign of wild carrot and common bulruck

[shy mulch]

I can understand the former because revenge just leads to more bloodshed

[hushed flare]

I mean how tf do you go from being a poor widow to becoming some next level gunslinging

Weird character development

Idk if rdo counts

[shy mulch]

That hot air baloon shit was dumb as hell

The instructor died because she couldn't keep that revenge scheme in her pants

[hushed flare]

fricken Sadie over here trying to attack an army by herself

[hybrid igloo]

Exactly.

[hushed flare]

I wonder how Sadie didn't die in American venom

[shy mulch]

but she is caked up

[hybrid igloo]

Plot armor.

[shy mulch]

second biggest ass next to uncle's lumbago cheeks

[hushed flare]

Bs armor

[hybrid igloo]

Nearly every gang member has it.

(Except for poor Hosea)

(And Lenny)

[kindred jackal]

and micah

and bill

and javier

and dutch

[shy mulch]

and

[hybrid igloo]

And Arthur

[kindred jackal]

and john

and abigail

[hybrid igloo]

And Karen

[kindred jackal]

everyones plot armor wears off eventually

[hushed flare]

arturd all he had to do was drink potent miracle tonic

[hushed flare]

Not if you have 99 potent miracle tonics

[hybrid igloo]

True.

[kindred jackal]

except Jack

motherfucker kept livin

[shy mulch]

I was sad as hell with Hosea

[hushed flare]

So I just got 26 times by all sides? health cure should fix these wounds

[shy mulch]

Hell I was sad when I was doing a quest with Hosea and some asshole ran him over with a wagon

[hybrid igloo]

For me, it's both.

DON'T BASH ME.

[shy mulch]

I can see it

[kindred jackal]

i dont see her as a "well written" character as such

and she does annoying stuff

i think RDR2 introduced so many new characters that it didnt have time to develop many of them

[hushed flare]

Revenge for the sake of revenge

[shy mulch]

to me it just feels like the rash decisions characters make are so poorly written it's mind boggling

[kindred jackal]

aside from Arthur, Dutch and John, but even John got the short end of the stick

[hushed flare]

Arthur Marston*

[hybrid igloo]

She does.

[kindred jackal]

i think they should have had the gang be a lot smaller

[hushed flare]

I feel like 3 of the deaths in rdr2 were just fillers

[kindred jackal]

yeah i didnt really care for Lenny or Hosea dying

[hybrid igloo]

Also,

[hushed flare]

Wouldn't feel like a "gang" with like 5 people tho

[hybrid igloo]

How did Sadie not get killed in the Hanging Dog Ranch raid?

[kindred jackal]

not 5 but

[hushed flare]

Even though every other gang has like 50000 members

[kindred jackal]

still smaller

[shy mulch]

I'll argue about Hosea he was the voice of reason in camp and I like listening to his dialogue especially when it involves the old days

He's one of the characters I wouldn't mind a prequel/DLC for but I know it'll never happen

[kindred jackal]

i think Micah made a good point about how they took so many people under their wing

[hybrid igloo]

True.

[kindred jackal]

you could have removed all the girls who do nothing like Mary Beth and Tilly and nothing would really change...

[hushed flare]

Everyone looked like they did there part though like mary beth being good pickpocketer and stuff but that all goes to waste like a chapter later

[hybrid igloo]

Dude, the entire gang went after Favours' regiment and won.

[hybrid igloo]

Mary Beth is just a novelist.

And Tilly is just... Tilly.

[hushed flare]

I forgot what Tilly did tbh

[hybrid igloo]

Same.

[shy mulch]

she had two run ins with that gang of hers she used to be in

or whatever

[kindred jackal]

Arthur, John, Dutch, Bill, Javier, Hosea, Micah, Grimshaw and one or two others would have been enough imo

[shy mulch]

I mean I guess it resolved itself but got damn I forgot about it in Ch.4

Charles I would put on that list

[hybrid igloo]

The Foremans?

[shy mulch]

Yea, I felt kinda badass fending off that Foreman guy from Tilly

I think they did that scene really well but all we got was a one off quest for it

[hybrid igloo]

Also, how did Bill not get absolutely destroyed by the Guarman Army?

He was like the dumbest person there.

[shy mulch]

He probably has some army training of his own

[ruby pewter]

@vagrant temple compendium saving my life rn, thank you baby ❤️

[shy mulch]

Or he sucked off some Guarma boys

But was Bill not at the makeshift camp the whole time in Ch.5? I think it was him and Micah guarding the place.

[hybrid igloo]

True.

He was in the army.

[shy mulch]

discharged for being a power bottom or something

[kindred jackal]

mf had the thickest type of plot armor:

returning character from the sequel

[hybrid igloo]

I also don't like how Sadie does something and nobody talks about it but when Dutch or Micah does something they don't hear the end of it for a month.

[shy mulch]

I think Bill is dumb but in the heat of combat he could probably handle himself

Same reason why he survived the Grey setup

[lilac iron]

who is ur fav characters and why?

[kindred jackal]

Bill had a notable instinct for survival

[kindred jackal]

John and Dutch

[shy mulch]

Still got captured for some reason lol

Bill being the punching bag is always funny

[lilac iron]

my favs are arthur, sadie and uncle cuz lumbago

nooooo

[hushed flare]

Micah and Micah

[lilac iron]

its not

[ruby pewter]

Is RDO better than trying to 100% story mode?

[kindred jackal]

both are a grind

[lilac iron]

•_•

[kindred jackal]

story mode is just a grind with the full tools of the game at your disposal

[shy mulch]

i'm on the exotics grind right now

[hushed flare]

Exotics is easy

[hybrid igloo]

Sadie is a rambo.

[shy mulch]

I need that pimp hat boah

[hybrid igloo]

I'm gonna team up with the O'Driscolls against her.

[kindred jackal]

John and Dutch for me because they're the best written IMO

[hybrid igloo]

Sadie will realize rage and revenge isn't the only thing that causes rampage.

[shy mulch]

I need like 15 more gator eggs and 20 spoonbill plumes and I'll be picking a bunch of flowers the rest of the way

[hushed flare]

Gator eggs are pretty easy

[shy mulch]

what confused me were the lady slipper orchids

that shit made me do the mining camp quest

[hybrid igloo]

I could take Sadie alone.

[lilac iron]

do u actually like micah? @hushed flare

[shy mulch]

I'd take Sadie alone if you catch ma drift

[hybrid igloo]

Without any of my friends in the Regulators or the O'Driscolls to help me.

[hushed flare]

Micah is good bro

[lilac iron]

why

[shy mulch]

Micah is the villain that starts making too much sense

[hushed flare]

Because villain.exe

[shy mulch]

That's why I respect him

[hushed flare]

And also the fact that Micah would have killed John in American venom if Sadie didn't step in

[lilac iron]

that is true

[hushed flare]

Micah can somehow reload both revolvers instantly which is good evidence he has deadeye

[kindred jackal]

Micah is pretty cool imo

well

[lilac iron]

i guess he is a walking beast in his leather duster

[kindred jackal]

his outfit is cool, sometimes hes funny (intentionally or not) and his voice is cool

[shy mulch]

Man Uncle probably even has deadeye

[hushed flare]

Uncle shooting 3 rounds from a double barrel shotgun be like

[lilac iron]

uncle is the best just being honest

[shy mulch]

Except his Lumbago debuff makes his deadeye core drain twice as fast

[potent orbit]

finally just got 100 percent completion after going for it on and off since the start of 2019

[lilac iron]

congrats

[hushed flare]

2 years

[ruby pewter]

if you had to choose to commit to grinding one

which would it be

[shy mulch]

story

[kindred jackal]

prolly story mode

[lilac iron]

story

[shy mulch]

you meet a lot of cool folks

[ruby pewter]

why is that?

[kindred jackal]

at least i can play as John Marston and not some voiceless character who looks like clay

[hushed flare]

online you would have to deal with some carcano cuck on a horse griefing you

[kindred jackal]

and story mode doesnt limit your access to features

[hushed flare]

Bolt action Barry also

Explosive ammo Eric

[shy mulch]

Oh man don't get me started on how Rockstar makes online chars

[kindred jackal]

grinding in online has no endgame or rewards

[shy mulch]

I understand silent protagonists but ever since GTA V they're a bunch of duds

At least in IV they used to SPEAK

[lilac iron]

yeah there will always be that 1 person on rdo on there racing horse with a rolling shotgun

[kindred jackal]

both GTA Online and Red Dead Online have awful wax looking characters who all look the same

[shy mulch]

Yea it's just not the same, no personality

[kindred jackal]

like the fucking detail on characters like Michael Townley and Arthur Morgan

then the ugly fucking online monsters

[lilac iron]

where story u can meet just a random person washed up on a beach giving u a letter to bonnie

or someone i cant remember

[kindred jackal]

i wonder who thats meant to be

possibly one of her brothers since she said all of them died except one who was in new york

[lilac iron]

i only play online just to make outfits

ive made alot

[kindred jackal]

that used to be me with GTAO lol

[shy mulch]

is it me or do the meme outfits make them even more awkward in cutscenes

[kindred jackal]

but in RDO its such a grind for everything, you cant even have fun with your friends like GTAO at least

[lilac iron]

sadies bounty hunter outfit, micahs outfit, arthurs gunslinger, dutch, arthurs guarma outfit ect.

[hushed flare]

Rdo players after making their female dress in all black

[kindred jackal]

and males

the rank 100+ sweats dressed in all black and the role clothing items

[shy mulch]

I like the opulent looking mfs

[wanton bison]

the only good thing about rdo is that my character looks like mario

[hybrid igloo]

I make the U.S. Army outfits.

And the Guarman Army outfits.

[wanton bison]

im so fcking mad that you cant use online outfits in singleplayer

[shy mulch]

The people making accurate outfits and people making wacky outfits are all better than the edgelords lol

Those are the folks you wanna team up with

[lilac iron]

where are u guys from? u dont have to say ofc

[shy mulch]

murica

[wanton bison]

honestly I dont want rdr3 yet

I want rdr1 remastered

[kindred jackal]

the only outfits i've made are Super Mario and Trevor from GTA

[shy mulch]

don't worry it'll be a while

[kindred jackal]

pretty funny

[lilac iron]

is that in America?

[shy mulch]

yeah it's the 51st state

[night raven]

California

[shy mulch]

Murica, North America

[lilac iron]

oh wow cool

[night raven]

East of Maine

[shy mulch]

wtf catgirl from california

Yea I think it was for something over a century ago

[lilac iron]

im just from England

[shy mulch]

A gang of hicks blowing up their battleship

[lilac iron]

nothing special

[shy mulch]

maybe there was some self awareness when they were writing ch. 5

[wanton bison]

ambarino just creeps me out

the worst thing is finding another person

[lilac iron]

arthur once said " OUT OF THE DAAAAMN WAY "

[wanton bison]

and getting out

ghost train, vampire, nite folk

makes sense

[lilac iron]

arthur once said " To the bar sènõr "

[wanton bison]

but ambarino is on a whole nother level

[shy mulch]

GET OUTTA HERE VAMANOS

-Arthur

[hybrid igloo]

Abandoned town too.

[lilac iron]

VAMOS VAMOS

[wanton bison]

I think its partly due to the eerie music

in ambarino

the whistling in the background

[shy mulch]

are people ever in the wapiti location

[wanton bison]

and when you revisit colter as john you hear voices

[lilac iron]

lemoyne in the dark is scary ngl

[shy mulch]

the red area

[lilac iron]

dark swamps

[wanton bison]

at least there are other humans

in ambarino your all alone

only at night

[lilac iron]

what time is it for u guys?

[shy mulch]

I'd rather be in Lemoyne at night than anywhere near Van Hornesburg at night

That monster experiment man

[wanton bison]

oh shit

im in grizzlies

and I just heard a rumbling noise

[lilac iron]

wheres the time machine guy?

[wanton bison]

one of the side quests

Im not sure where its located

[slim steeple]

A little to the north of Strawberry

[lilac iron]

what about the guy who built the robot?

[lilac iron]

oh thank u

[slim steeple]

In Saint Denis at the lake

You're welcome

[lilac iron]

the lake in saint denis?

[slim steeple]

Yes

[lilac iron]

the one with the rc boat?

[slim steeple]

Yes

[lilac iron]

ah ok

ty

[slim steeple]

He invites you to his lab but it has to be night to activate the mission at his lab

[wanton bison]

in ambarino your only friend is a sniper rifle

[lilac iron]

what about the ufo?

[slim steeple]

I'm not completely sure.

[ruby pewter]

i was hunting herbs just east of braithwait manor when i saw a black guy corpse washed up on the beach. he had a terrifying spiked collar around his neck and was in shakles. his note was to his cousin in canada in which he was gonan meetup, be finally free and start an education...was kinda sad tbh

[slim steeple]

I saw the location once but I forgot

[lilac iron]

yeah it is

[lilac iron]

its ok

is there other interesting things in story?, i have completed story, just never really focus on exploring which is what im doing now

[slim steeple]

There is a painting at window rock of sculptures that leads you to get three gold bars

[lilac iron]

ooooo

[wanton bison]

what do you guys think the most underrated chapter is

[kindred jackal]

UFO is one of those things Rockstar loves lol

[wanton bison]

1 is underrated tbh

[lilac iron]

ch1

[slim steeple]

Chapter 1 probably

[night raven]

I love the first three and 5

[kindred jackal]

literally get 100% in GTA V and a ufo appears at mount chilliad...nothing else except a t shirt and the achievement

not sure what the UFO is about in RDR2 tho, that seems even more out of place lol

[static rover]

whats the recommended graphics settings?

[slim steeple]

It was a reference to a cult in real life that killed themselves to go to an alien planet

[kindred jackal]

idk depends on your specs

[lilac iron]

pablo!

[static rover]

i have a 3060

RTX

I7

16 ram

[kindred jackal]

well still i wouldnt know

[static rover]

144 hz screen

[kindred jackal]

youll have to do some research

[lilac iron]

sounds like u got a nice setup there pablo

[static rover]

yes

[lilac iron]

does anyone know where the kkk pop up

[kindred jackal]

Random places all over

Pretty sure it's mostly near Rhodes and Strawberry tho

[glad brook]

Lemoyne.

[slim steeple]

Yeah, that's where I saw them first

[lilac iron]

just randomly in lemoyne

[slim steeple]

Well, there are four spawn points

[lilac iron]

what about this guy who test animals? makes creatures or something

in van horn?

[slim steeple]

I'm not familiar with that one. There is a house near Van Horn though where you can climb through the window on the second floor

[lilac iron]

im not sure what it is, just i saw someone say something about the guy making creatures

[slim steeple]

It's where the mission where you steal the dynamite with Bill starts

Yeah, I'm not sure if I've seen it. I don't think I have

[lilac iron]

its ok

where are u from batguy? u dont have to say

im from England

[slim steeple]

The US

[lilac iron]

oh nice

do u guys over there really think that the uk is really posh

[slim steeple]

I don't know what that even means. You'd have to elaborate

[lilac iron]

u don't know what posh is?

[kindred jackal]

Believe me, no

[lilac iron]

maybe its a British thing

[slim steeple]

No, I've heard it before though

[ruby pewter]

herb challenges grindy as hell

are any others worse?

[lilac iron]

well posh means, rich and acts really snobby

[slim steeple]

Oh, then no

[kindred jackal]

I don't know anyone here who is any of that

Well in the UK, I don't live in England itself

[lilac iron]

what do u think about the uk

[kindred jackal]

Although I feel like Scotland can't be that different from whatever goes on down south

[slim steeple]

Well, it doesn't depend on the place, it depends on the people. I have wanted to go see England though

[lilac iron]

how do u think we are over here

do u think we are polite or rude

[slim steeple]

Well, like in the US, it just depends on mental state and such. You seem pretty nice, I don't really judge a place before I've been there.

[lilac iron]

is england one of the places u want to go

[slim steeple]

Gtg sorry

[lilac iron]

oh no problem

[night dust]

Hey can someone help me with this problem im having in singleplayer

I cant get this text off my screen, and john will not speak

i fixed it nvm

[quartz charm]

I say it now and I’ll say it again. RDR2 is magnificent. Probably the greatest game ever made to this day

[night dust]

Man Im so glad I got this game again

[night dust]

YES

[ruby pewter]

nah

[night dust]

I can play this over and over

[ruby pewter]

witcher 3 is better than rdr2

[night dust]

this is my second play through cause I sold my xbox

[night dust]

If I had the ability to I would hit you rn bro

Just a tap

You r wrong

[quartz charm]

Maybe you should stop doing weed partner

[night dust]

That weed really messed up your brain

Youre very very wrong

rdr2 is the best game out rn imo

for singleplayer at least

i dont rlly care about online

[kindred jackal]

Witcher 3?

Could have at least said the first RDR...

or GTA IV imo

[ruby pewter]

like i love rdr2 as well

but its not my opinion its objective FACT

witcher 3 is the better game

[night dust]

No it isnt

[kindred jackal]

I mean

I can't call any game one of the best of all time

It's subjective

[ruby pewter]

Metacritic.com Witcher 3 has 9.4 and RDR2 has 8.5

[night dust]

Hey @ruby pewter dont dm me, what you just sent is wrong

we do not care

[kindred jackal]

A lot of people really don't like RDR2, a lot of people do

[night dust]

metacritic? imagine listing to someone elses opinion lol

[kindred jackal]

Exactly, opinions

If you think RDR2 is one of the best games ever, or Witcher 3 or idk fuckin Roblox, that is 100 percent fine

[night dust]

ok no but factually

rdr2 is #1

[kindred jackal]

but everyone likes and dislikes stuff

Not factually, my friend bought it and only played it for about 13 minutes, played some online and never touched it again, safe to say for him it wasn't number 1 at all

[night dust]

no factually its #1

your friend is wrong

I am right

[kindred jackal]

Okay whatever lol

[night dust]

anyone who disagrees w me is wrong

[kindred jackal]

I see what you're doing here

Well played

[night dust]

i am right

[kindred jackal]

Uh huh

and the moon is made of cheese

[ruby pewter]

anyways W3 is the better game but both are fantastic

u guys ever tried W3 DLC?

[kindred jackal]

I think this whole thing is an elaborate joke anyways

[ruby pewter]

what do u mean

check ur dms

[kindred jackal]

Anyways

[ruby pewter]

honestly

rockstar really fucked up with the herb color pallet here

apart from a select few, its IMPOSSIBLY hard to tell herbs apart from one another until ur standing on it

my horse is lying on the ground about to die

can i run to a stable real quick or will he dissapear

[kindred jackal]

Yes

[ruby pewter]

yes hell disaapear?

or yes I can run and come back?

[kindred jackal]

He won't disappear

I've done it a few times myself

[ruby pewter]

ah

thanks bud

[weary scaffold]

I hope we get Rdr3 have it be about jack in the year 1916 or have it be about a new gang takeing place in the 1850s have it take place in a deferent part of the USA and one of the dlcs can be about going to the map of the frist 2 red dead redemption games with a new story. and undead nightmare 2 or something deferent like fighting vampires

[hybrid igloo]

Me too.

The United States doesn't officially enter the war until 1917.

[ruby pewter]

i think RDR3 around the civil war would be so cool

[hybrid igloo]

Yes.

It would.

[ruby pewter]

or maybe just a couple years before, have it be arthurs dad who is a slavery abolitionist

[weary scaffold]

Kinda like the good and the bad and the ugly

[olive mango]

If I sell the gold jointed bracelet (used to craft alligator talisman) to the fence will it be available for me to use in crafting or will it be gone?

[night raven]

I figure it'll be available, sort of like with the trapper or pearson, but I'm not sure

[night dust]

Can someone help me with this story mission is fucking glitched and its pissing me off

[night raven]

Let's hear it

[night dust]

WHY DOES IT KEEP DELETING MY MESSAGE

I DONT WANNA SPOIL THE FUCKING GAME

[shy mulch]

just say it

[night raven]

spolier tag it?

[night dust]

ANY TIME I SHOOT A GUARD SAVING LEOPOLD AND JOHN IT INSTANT FAILS ME

[night dust]

I DID AND IT CAUSES IT TO BE DELETED

and I dont wanna skip this shit I hate skipping checkpoints

[quartz charm]

[glad brook]

Just restart the mission smh.

[night dust]

I dont wanna go through that sheep shit again dude

That shit is annoying as fuck

Im about to uninstall this shit game

ye nvm i just alt F4'd and uninstalled lol

[raven locust]

That’s a bit of a over reaction to a mission glitching

[night dust]

Nah, tired of game

[glad brook]

A second ago you were praising it for being the best game ever lmao.

[shy mulch]

so, did you use the deadeye marking feature

just checking

[night dust]

Yes

[night dust]

I take all of that back, shite game

good on first playthrough, horrid game now

[shy mulch]

okay, I have no idea

[night raven]

Try disarming the guards instead?

[shy mulch]

you can't

they magically get new guns, ur supposed to kill them all

[night raven]

What message does it give when it fails you @night dust ?

[night dust]

leopold and john died, failed

[shy mulch]

I know it would be cool to disarm them all but the game railroads you into killing

[night dust]

Even when i shoot the guard in the face

A bullet to the skull doesnt kill these bastards apparently

uninstalled already anyway, 0/10

[glad brook]

I've disarmed some guys before. But they pull out their sidearms.

And you cant disarm them after that. Only two handed weapons.

[night dust]

ye i dont care anymore lol

uninstalled

[raven locust]

Your loss

[night dust]

nah

[shy mulch]

Disarming is jank in this game anyway

[night dust]

mods fix that

I dont have any installed but ive seen some good ones

[shy mulch]

And if u were replaying then you prolly aren't missing out much

[night raven]

I don't really remember the mission where you save john and strauss, what was the name?

[shy mulch]

When you replay a Rockstar game the tedium and jank is a lot more noticeable

A Strange Kindness, last mission of Ch 2

[round hedge]

it's weird

we could easily disarm enemies in RDR

[night dust]

The Sheep and the Goats

[round hedge]

wonder why they changed that

[shy mulch]

ah crap it was sheep and the goats

[night dust]

yea