red-dead-singleplayer

[civic nest]

I think you can only sell them to a fence, which is what you're supposed to do

Check if in the trinkets menu of the fence, the legendary animals parts are in white instead of gray

[kindred leaf]

Hi there i have a question abt the game after i have obtained the trophy for getting 70 gold medals do i still need any more for another trophy?

[red helm]

Gold medals for a mission, themselves, don't do anything, no. Nor Silver medals, for that matter.

[modern minnow]

[kindred leaf]

Ah ok i m relieved to hear that i don’t need any more

[red helm]

Nope, unless you want to brag about them or some such.

[kindred jackal]

unless you mean the PS3 version, which is like lower than 720p

[red helm]

They made the graphics look like that on purpose, for it to have a gritty, wild west feeling.

[kindred jackal]

exactly, most games these days have lost the grit

they instead go for ultra-vibrance and way too much bloom

[misty cliff]

You could make that feeling with modern graphics but for some reason you rarely see it.

Real life ain't all that colorful as some people think.

[kindred jackal]

yeah, older games with less vibrant graphics somehow hit closer to real life for me

roaming around in GTA IV and Red Dead Redemption make me feel like im in places ive actually been IRL

[misty cliff]

Indeed. Even if never was in the US. However roaming ambarino during snowstorms hits pretty close to home for me. Same with games that had rainy or grey atmosphere.

Also, RDR soundtrack is superior to RDR2 one.

[kindred jackal]

yes

[red helm]

RDR had a great soundtrack, especially the ambient/background music.

[misty cliff]

RDR2 soundtrack felt way too monotonous, besides american venom.

[kindred jackal]

yeah, the ambient music being my biggest gripe

it felt more like a generic triple A adventure game

[misty cliff]

Also, music when cops 'r after you should've been way more intense especially with a high bounty.

[red helm]

Yes, agreed there, some nail biting, white knuckle chase music.

There are a bunch of Western movies, with the Criminals, and the Law Posse after them, and chase music playing. So, bit of a missed opportunity.

[misty cliff]

yeah

[untold ocean]

YOOOO, in the mission ‘revenge is a dish best eaten’ you can loot bronte while he is knocked out

Waaaaaaaaaa

didn’t know that

[frigid cloud]

You can also get his Mauser pistol

[quartz charm]

Oof I missed the item requests trophy... I guess I'll have to start a new save

[hushed flare]

Those type of item requests where you get like 1 chapter to do them

[quartz charm]

yeah... pain

[visual ember]

Should I get rdr singleplayer?

I might just wait until a sale

[quartz charm]

yes

[kindred jackal]

right wtf

second time my animal hides have just disappeared from my horse

[quartz charm]

happened to me way too many times

[kindred jackal]

just one day without a glitch in this game

[opal geode]

lmao why everyone hating the soundtrack

it literally won best soundtrack in goty awards

and I think its really good

better than the first one idk but i didnt have anything to criticise in the 2nd one

[kindred jackal]

its not a bad soundtrack

no no no

very good, no doubts about that, just personally I believe the 1st was better in many regards

[hidden moss]

I think that happens when you do a mission, where you either need to put something on the back of the horse, or someone needs a ride on the back of your horse

That’s usually when it happens to me anyway

I wish online trophies were separate cause I would love to platinum this game since I dont play online

[wary oasis]

I thought they were?

[frigid cloud]

No

They're not

You have todo them if you want the platinum trophy

[wary oasis]

Not sure this is Steam?

[opal geode]

i think they arent that hard

[wary oasis]

Maybe PSN

[frigid cloud]

Platinum only psn yeah I think

[opal geode]

if ur a plat grinder its do able i think

[frigid cloud]

Or xbox too

[wary oasis]

I play on PC

[frigid cloud]

So it's separated for u

[opal geode]

steam achievements

[wary oasis]

Yeh

[opal geode]

@wary oasis

[frigid cloud]

Lucky

[opal geode]

i saw the trophy reqs for plat for online and they dont look that hard

think rockstar went kind with us

one off the achievements for gta5 was getting level 100 in online

[wary oasis]

Guess it's the Legend of the West for PSN?

[dire raven]

the only soundtrack music i dont like is the fast travel music

[wary oasis]

Yeah wears out quick

That's The Way it Is ♥️

[opal geode]

tbh i wouldnt mind having an odriscoll backstory in the next red dead game

[quartz charm]

same, but i'll get them anyway, just takes a while

[opal geode]

the mission where sean dies was so stupid

arthur and the rest were talking about how they betray both sides to get loot

while they were the only ones talking

and being watched by every god damn person

and then when they spill everything then they figured something wasnt right by then it was to late

you dont say these things out loud especially not in the town were everyone is a gray

[dense vale]

i think the point was that it meant for them to have been talking in a quieter manner

though i do understand your reasoning behind "where everyone is a gray"

[hidden moss]

anybody like the phrase howdy

[opal geode]

is this some sort off glitch

why was one of the braithwaites i was shootin speaking spanish

thought they were american english

i could be wrong tho

[civic nest]

Most probably a glitch

[vivid moat]

I just had to re live Arthur death scene again😭 now I'm dying on the inside

[winter turtle]

Hosea

[hidden moss]

Fr

He literally died in the most realistic way but in a dumb way

[hushed flare]

Sniper should have shot Arthur

[winter turtle]

Ok Micah fan

[hidden moss]

Inb4 should've shot micah

I was almost late

[vivid moat]

Nah bro Micha

[hushed flare]

Micah is good

[opal geode]

yeah bro i hate michael

[feral spoke]

Micah is the biggest duchebag in the game

[vivid moat]

I wish you had the option to save him from strawberry or not id leave him to swing

[quiet gazelle]

Micah is one hell of a gunslinger though

The only reason i kinda like him lol

[opal geode]

yeah i kinda liked micahs mission

and thought he was a badass

but i hated him tho

[quiet gazelle]

Lol

Ive gotten used to antagonizing him every time i see him around camp

[hushed flare]

He was such a gunslinger he would of killed John in American venom

If Sadie never helped

[quiet gazelle]

I gotta agree on that even if you're probably joking lol

[opal geode]

nah micah was a pain holy shit

needed sadie and dutch to kill that guy

[opal geode]

i think my game softlocked

nvm

had to reload my game for the third time lol

[hidden moss]

happened to me when i was trying buy camp upgrades and someone bumped into me.

i couldn't move

[opal geode]

lmfao these kids wouldve regretted living if they knew i had 5k in my satchel

[opal geode]

had to ask the bartender for whiskey

and when i pressed square arthur sits there waiting

and the bartender doesnt do anything

[hidden moss]

Micah is a great villain

[willow vortex]

shey guys

[amber halo]

Got my first pack of wolves with manual paint dead eye, all head shots (4) all ruined with express rounds and they were a good distance. Should have switched to the f'n improved. DAMMIT! Wow had so much more time to place my shots it's not funny.

[summer garnet]

imagine if the sniper shot hit seans shotgun tho

[kindred jackal]

I liked the way he died, for once it was realistic yes

A character just dies unexpectedly, I always wondered why characters never die like anyone else would, no climatic bleed out or last words or poetically achieving something

Just killed

[opal geode]

yeah the way he died I don’t have a problem with

but the fact it was very preventable

like theyre the only mean looking mfs speaking in a town full of grays

talking about how they was the ones that set the tobacco fields on fire

thats like talking to your buddy how to rob a bank inside the bank

infront off the bank teller

[opal geode]

I also like that teaches you how life can be unexpected af and that you should be more around your loved once every time you can

because anything can happen outta nowhere

like nobody expected seans head to blow up

in that situation

we just thought okay we gonna do something for the grays again and trick them get the gold and leave

[willow vortex]

guys pls help me

i got the viking axe and helment

then i went to get the rare shotgun

while i wore the helmet i swtiched to a dead guys hat and now i cant find my helmet

i restarted and its not coming

its not on my horse too

wdid

[hidden moss]

Idk

Maybe check your wardrobe

In camp

[golden storm]

what are those thingies that turn your cores gold

ik there's at least one for health

[willow vortex]

guys

im getting a free gun frm gunstire

which do i get

pls tell me fast

[frigid cloud]

Ammo, food, health I think

Wait

I misread

[willow vortex]

im on chp2

[willow vortex]

shud i get volcanic pistol?

or varmint or sprongfield rifle

[frigid cloud]

Do u have special/ultimate edition

@willow vortex

[willow vortex]

idk

idts

[opal geode]

@willow vortex thats ultimate edition lol

you can get all of em for free

[summer garnet]

the 5$ food in saloons and seasoning big game meat

[frigid cloud]

I think it's that guy who u save and he gives you a chance to buy a gun

[opal geode]

no

hes talking about something else

in a special edition of red dead you get the volcanic pistol varmint rifle and the other one for free

if you just get it from the gun smith

[frigid cloud]

Bro I know

[opal geode]

brother if he was in chapter 2 why would he only ask about those 3 weapons

also do you even unlock volcanic pistol in c2

or varmint rifle

[frigid cloud]

You do

With Ultimate edition or not

[opal geode]

why do you say i think its the guy you saved

and when i explained its not

you say “i know”

[frigid cloud]

Cause every gun's price is 0$ when he lets you buy a gun

And don't forget he also mentioned Springfield rifle which is not free with ultimate edition

[opal geode]

oh sorry then you must be right ig

i kinda forgot what the third weapon was since im far now but the moment i read varmint and volcanic i thought it was the special edition

so i kinda assumed the third one he mentioned was also included

[willow vortex]

WHT, how

[amber halo]

2nd pack of wolves met since manual dead eye, all head shots with improved, 1 perfect! Hell yes. Can't believe how much better manual is. LOVE IT!!

[hearty valley]

I just got the game, do you need to bring 5 different carcesses from 5 different animal? or can you bring 5 deer carcasses? it's for the satchel

[willow vortex]

HO TO GET PERFECT ALLIGATOR SKIN

[frigid cloud]

Any carcasses work

[frigid cloud]

Rifle+aim to the head

[keen birch]

By reading this message, you officially acknowledge Arthur Morgan sucks. Thank you for your time!

[hidden moss]

alright

[sharp gulch]

Rename yourself to Micah bell

[willow vortex]

AND WOLF?

[frigid cloud]

Same with wolf as well

[turbid ore]

what's wrong with this thing

[frigid cloud]

What an amazing bot!

[amber halo]

@willow vortexImproved arrow? Seems to be working for almost anything even remotely big. I get grizzlies and wolves and bison with them.

[frigid cloud]

Improved arrow is an alternative I guess

[amber halo]

So I hear the howl from wolfie. Jump on a rock to try height advantage, no wolves show. HHHmmmmmm the rock was close too so it wasn't like I was running for a few seconds or anything. I heard they can't attack you on a big enough rock and, in my case, they didn't even show.

@frigid cloud I didn't even see you had replied but ya there seems to be several methods for most people I guess.

[worldly shore]

Hello There !
I'm wondering if in the multi of RDR2 we can do all the campaign but at two player.
Someone can tell me ?

[frigid cloud]

You should go and kill them on horseback next time

[amber halo]

@frigid cloud The wolves?

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[amber halo]

That was the first time I ever tried getting onto a rock. Almost all my wolf kills are from horseback, not really much of a chance to get on foot. Last 2 packs were on horse, not sure how many before that but wuite a few.

quite* heh

I just imagine I have a better chance on foot. I just wanna hunt them for once. I did it once. Found them by chance and got one of em. Loved it hahahaha

I never have a better chance on foot but it seems I would. Actually the horse is pretty brave so I think I just need to calm her a bit.
She killed a wolf once and stomped another which was badass.

[opal geode]

you dont need to talk in caps it makes you look stupid lmfao

btw if you obliberate an animals pelt with a shotgun the carcass will suck ass cuz theres a big fat bullet hole in it

but if you use a bow and arrow or a varmint rifle and shoot in the head the pelt wont damage and you get 3 stars

[amber halo]

I got a perfect grizzly pelt once with 2 explosive shots to the head. That made me think it was all just a luck thing.

[opal geode]

i think bears are just different

cuz theyre thicc af

also you dont skin the head parts off animals

so idk might be both luck and just the game mechanics

[willow vortex]

GUYS

oops

pls check #red-dead-media

[potent orbit]

does anyone know if the canoe counts for survivalist 5 as of caught 2 fish now and it hasn't counted wondering if its glitched?

dw i got an actual boat and it worked

[summer garnet]

@hidden moss im very sorry for ping but i just wanted to ask that does the JMRP mod have the longarm holster from rdr1

[hidden moss]

nah

it's not in game files longarm holster

it wouldn't work well with rdr2 weapon system neither too

[summer garnet]

oh ok thanks

[hearty valley]

Is there more gunsmith customization that can be unlocked (through story or other gunsmiths)? The ones on valentine kinda lack some colors and stuff

[summer garnet]

There will be new guns if you progress the story but no new gun customizations im afraid

[kindred leaf]

Lmaoo i was too lazy to collect the cigarettes cards so i went to the general store or fence in Van Gogh trading post and bought about $1000 worth of them and finish collecting all of the card sets

I have 7.5 k left so idm

[opal geode]

when i find premium cigs i smoke some and grab it

it gives you a card

so later when i have to buy i dont have to buy much

[shy mulch]

tfw you're trying to get all the cig cards but it's the 2nd half of chapter 5

[hidden moss]

I deadass just finished the story 10 times

Going for 100%

84% for now

Gambler is too hard

[unborn rock]

Can i share my twitch ch

[sonic sequoia]

Is there a mod, that shows the collectibles on the in-game map on PC? I don't like switching between real world and virtual world

[vague edge]

Bruh that's just cheating and lazy

[frigid cloud]

No

Thats self promoting

[unborn rock]

Ahhh

Sorry

[frigid cloud]

Delete it if possible

[sonic sequoia]

I think most people won't look for 200 collectibles without a guide. I just like to not switch between worlds that's not immersive

[frigid cloud]

u wanted a mod though not guide

[sonic sequoia]

Yeah. Because guides are IRL. ..

An irl map or ingame map are the same as cheating is concerned. One is just more immersive

[vague edge]

That's the whole fun of it though, why need a mod or guide when you can go and LOOK for them

[sonic sequoia]

What if they are behind tree number 65384828 on square inch number 2039582929385820475829?

Without a guide that's not doable if you want to play other games

I guess I can do the but cigarettes thing. It's technically not cheating. If you have the money...

Buy cigarettes*

[quiet gazelle]

Old boy is one handsome ass horse

Wish all the gang horses were available

[hidden moss]

the gang horses can be temporarily obtained through a mission glitch

[red helm]

Indeed, the Tumbleweed Stable should just have some random chance to have any of the gang horses available any time you check it.

[hidden moss]

replay 'horsemen, apocalypses' and they spawn at beechers hope.

[red helm]

Or, maybe they should let us change the color of the coats on the horse. Like they let us change the color of the tail hair and head hair.

[quiet gazelle]

Totally agree

[quiet gazelle]

Bet, ima try it

[red helm]

The last time I was at Beecher's, Charles was there chilling out. That was cool, But, unfortunately, I didn't want to hang out for to long, because I was on the last step of the Squirrel Statue.

[hidden moss]

yea i got that bug too..

[red helm]

His horse was no where to be seen, however.

[hidden moss]

charles was there after american venom for some reason..

he was talking about building the house

[red helm]

Nice little bug. To bad I've never seen Sadie there. That would be interesting.

[red helm]

He was just chatting with Abigail about chores or... something.

[hidden moss]

Replaying story again

Lol

hmm, for me he was at the fireplace outside the house, crafting arrows or something

then i greet him, he says something about completing the house, but its already built

i thought he visited us or something lol

[red helm]

He was in the house with Abigail, then wandered out to the camp fire, for me... But, like I said, I really wanted to finish the Squirrel thing, so, didn't stay long.

[hidden moss]

In my first playthrough I thought Arthur and Sadie might end up together

[red helm]

In my first play through, I really thought I was going to end up playing -as- Sadie before chapter 6 ended....

[hidden moss]

really weird how the squirrel got on top of a mountain

[red helm]

Ouf, Yeah, How the heck did Abigail get up there?

[misty cliff]

Rampaging as Marston in tumbleweed makes a good backstory as to how it ended up as a ghost town.

[hidden moss]

Lol

Nice

[hidden moss]

that sheriff is the most powerful one ig

1 shot death

Fr

[misty cliff]

Yup, insane too, and annoying as hell

[hidden moss]

Don’t fw tumbleweed

Van horn is the best place to rampage in my opinion

[woeful niche]

agreed

[misty cliff]

Saint Denis here.

[red helm]

lol, yeah, that would be funny. But, the townsfolk do talk about the fact that the train not having a stop there being really bad for business. Plus, John shouldn't have been down there in RDR2 at all.... But, anyway...

[hidden moss]

they all eventually start killing each other in the end, lol

[misty cliff]

Yup, to be honest he still went there with sadie adler so a lil plot hole there

[hidden moss]

I went into new Austin and avoided the law and bounty hunters but then I started getting sniped from somewhere

And I died

No clue how

[red helm]

Indeed, that mission with Sadie should not have happened either.

[hidden moss]

they should have let arthur into new austin tbh

[red helm]

Invisible Sniper. Rockstar Bullcrap non-sense.

[hidden moss]

just blocked blackwater

Yea

there's even voicelines for him in new austin

[misty cliff]

Overall, they messed up the epilogue john in different ways but i gotta deal with it since my pc will never run Red Dead.

[red helm]

The Dakota River, south of Beecher's/Tall Tree/Blackwater, should've just been flooded/uncrossable, and all of that area southwest of there completely cut from RDR2.

[misty cliff]

I mean armadillo is nice because no law.

New Austin should have had actual content. Ambarino mountains too.

[hidden moss]

just a bunch of sick people who won't even fight back though..

[misty cliff]

That's the best part

[red helm]

I mean, It's neat to see with the improved graphics, and all, but, Canon wise. Makes no sense...

[misty cliff]

You can pretend he never went there when playing in RDR. Not the only thing that's a plot hole, just the thing with prequels...

[red helm]

Yeap, yeap

[lost ferry]

Qui peux me lancer des missions de chasseur de prime pour moi est un pote on a besoin d’or

Sur play

[red helm]

English only, sorry.

[quiet gazelle]

Woah so bill does keep brown jack musty

I brushed him

And no difference

[frigid cloud]

It looks cool either way imo

[quiet gazelle]

Hell yeah

Idk if this happens to everyone but everytime i make my way to blackwater i stumble upon some dead dude covered in arrows in a wagon

And the horse that drives the wagon is a white roan nokota for some extra context

[native thunder]

it's a random event, but shouldn't be happening more than once

i don't know, story mode is kinda broken due to online patches. like all the campfires where you can talk to npc's are permanent

[frigid cloud]

Skinner brothers fault of course

[hearty valley]

Went hunting nonstop for 7hrs, finally got legend of the east satchel

[hushed flare]

Legend of the east satchel is basically easy mode

After getting it

[idle sorrel]

I call it the bottomless inventory

[hushed flare]

Pocket blackhole

What does John see when he opens Arthur's legend of the east satchel

[idle sorrel]

Was thinking about getting legend of the east outfit

I’m scared at the same time

[hushed flare]

90 challenges

Gamblers challenge set shouldn't exist

[hidden moss]

It sucks doing them, however completing them is one of the best feelings you can get in RDR2😄

[hushed flare]

Getting legend of the east outfit legit was good

[potent orbit]

@hidden moss yeah i just finished them the other day

[hushed flare]

Win blackjack 3 times with 3 hits or more

[hidden moss]

I don’t use mods/cheats in RDR, Can’t imagine it’s more fun with them

[potent orbit]

i got quite lucky that on took me about 45 mins

[hushed flare]

I would like to mess with PC mods but I'm a console noob

[hidden moss]

Same😄

[hidden moss]

Lol nice, took me 3 hours ;)

[potent orbit]

same im on xbox

[hidden moss]

So you’re very lucky😄

[hushed flare]

I got my 3 wins in like 2 hours

and gambler 9 I was lucky

actually getting 3 wins in a row instead of cheesing it

[hidden moss]

I actually like the Domino’s challenge. It’s relaxing after all the other stuff

[hushed flare]

At least dominos I can actually play the game kind of

[potent orbit]

but dominoes took about 4-5 hours as i didnt know you could leave plus i ended up watching irl domino strat guides to do it lol

[hushed flare]

blackjack = press a simulator

[hidden moss]

Haha ye😄

[potent orbit]

poker was super easy as you can just replay a couple missions and its done

[hidden moss]

Ah xD Ye I enjoy Dominos in real life as well, so that was prob best gambler challenge for me

[hidden moss]

I just went all in a few times, got it in like 10 mins

[hushed flare]

flat neck station

[hidden moss]

Ye

[potent orbit]

yep and water boat robbery

[hearty valley]

I only wanted the satches for the looks, didn't know there's benefits lol

[hidden moss]

Tbh I regret getting the legend satchel

99 items is to much

I thought it’d be like 20 for everything

But 99 just feels like cheating

The grind is completely gone. You just grind once and your good

For the rest of the game

[hushed flare]

I mean at least I can carry 99 cheese wedges

Xddd

[hidden moss]

True ;p but I miss the hunting & herb gathering etc. Rn it’s just cus I can

Not cus I need to anymore

[hearty valley]

I kinda want to mod my game so I can have 20 items limit

[hidden moss]

Oof if I played on PC, that’d be the only mod I’d use😄

[hushed flare]

John restore mod

[hidden moss]

Didn’t play RDR1, so John looks fine for me

RDR2 John is my first John xD

[hushed flare]

John has a weird clipping issue tho

[hidden moss]

He does?

Haven’t noticed that yet

[hushed flare]

yeah I've seen his hand go through his satchel and his hair go through some hats

[hidden moss]

Only glitch I know is the scout jacket. Which sucks cus it looks awesome

Ah

[hushed flare]

also when you crouch your gun belt just casually clips through his leg

[hidden moss]

Oh ye I did notice that😄

[hidden moss]

How is the texture glitch for scout jacket even still here tbh

It’s been forever

[hushed flare]

I mean it took rockstar like 6 months to remove all weather related dialogue fix the cold bug so kind of not suprised

[hidden moss]

@hushed flare Yh I’ve had the same issue

True xD but the jacket been there so much longer

[hushed flare]

and then rockstar fixes limpany gold bar glitch in 0.00001 seconds

[hidden moss]

Ye😅

Seems legit

[potent orbit]

they fix all these money glitches instantly but wont fix game breaking glitches in their games lol like there's a glitch in gta 4 thats been around since 2008 which makes it so you cant complete the final mission above 60 fps this makes it so on anything apart from 360, ps3 or pc you cant complete the game

[hushed flare]

seems legit

[potent orbit]

i literally played through the whole game on series x just to realise this

[kindred jackal]

You literally crouch and half his gear sinks into his body

Sometimes I prefer playing games on console, specifically Rockstars titles, but honestly I can never go back to RDR2 on my PS4 for John alone

[amber halo]

First time I ever literally chased down a wolf, 4 more show up, pick them all off with bow and, again, manual paint with D.E., and I get a negative honor? F ME!! HAHAHA

[worthy pelican]

My honor doesn’t go up anymore :/ I finished the game tho so is that why?

[wary oasis]

You should be able to max it out by CH6

[quartz charm]

I'm having a hard time killing cougars with the bow

they don't spawn much

[red helm]

Wander around Roanoke Ridge, west of Annesburg, and Blackbone Forest, west of Strawberry(north of lake Owanjilla). Lots of Cougar's around there. Also Tall Tree's and western New Austin if you are John.

[quartz charm]

Thank you! Trying rn

[lost ferry]

what is the best role to take first

[hushed flare]

red dead singleplayer

[loud forum]

yooo

apparently the mexico mod made progress

[hidden moss]

does anyone think that they will make a rdr1 remake anytime soon

[strange dragon]

Prolly not since the code is fucked

That’s why it ain’t on pc

[trail compass]

Can I get both gunslinger ebony grip and the hero pearl grip? I got to a high honour and got the black one for some reason, and I can't seem to get the white

[quartz charm]

I wish but probably not

[strange dragon]

The hero pearl grip is only available on a cattleman while the low honor one is available on a doubled action

[trail compass]

Ah ok, that makes sense. So I can get both though?

[strange dragon]

Yeah cuz I got both

[trail compass]

Awesome

[strange dragon]

I got both while having high honor I think but I don’t remember

[trail compass]

Idk why I got the gunslinger ebony one because my honour hasn't fallen below half way

[strange dragon]

Ok that exactly happened to me I remember now but ig just take it

It’s weird

[trail compass]

I'm not complaining I guess XD Free stuff is free stuff

[strange dragon]

Yep

[quick geyser]

I don’t know what I should buy with all this money I completed the epilogue

[opaque aurora]

may i

stand unshaken

amid

amidst a crash of worlds

[round hedge]

they won't remake the game

[hidden moss]

They are remaking the original gta games , they also said that that if those were successful they would make a rdr remake

[round hedge]

they are REMASTERING, not remaking

[trail compass]

Hmm my cattleman still doesn't have the hero pearl grip

[narrow jetty]

Listened to "God's gunna cut you down" by Johnny Cash today and realized it like EXACTLY describes the RDR1 story

"He said John go do my will (The FBI making John kill his former gang members). Go and tell that long tongue liar (Javier) go and tell the midnight rider (Bill), tell the rambler the gambler the back biter(Dutch) sooner or later God''ll cut ya down"

"You can run on for a long time you can run on for a long time you can run on for a long time, sooner or later God'll cut ya down" (John can run from his past all he wants, but sooner or later, he'll be cut down"

[quick geyser]

Is there a way to rob a train with getting the law?

or is that impossible

[quartz charm]

try in new Austin

to avoid witnesses

[silent raft]

there’s a perfect way and it’s been legit unlimited money for me until i wanted to raise honor, but what you do. take certain steps. first, you buy train tickets to riggs station, then you hop on top and run to the front of the train via roof of train. (take a moonshine before this in case you get shot at) then take control of conductor, steer it to the middle of the huge bridge, get off the conductor, clear lawmen on train and then any other lawmen that will come by will run under the bridge for some reason and can’t get on the train. you can do whatever after that point, a lot of the time my horse would fall off the tracks and try to follow me so i’d hitch it before you get on the roof

[silent raft]

i’ve been doing the same thing for the past two years it’s amazing

[quartz charm]

Any tips to find to dinosaur bones without looking for the exact locations online?

[trail compass]

All the story events are beginning to be like: "This person wants to talk to you", so I go say hi to them, and then a different character immediately interrupts and takes me on a mission

[quartz charm]

[hidden moss]

crap, yeah ur right i always mix those 2 up

[amber halo]

So I can't remember who here said that they get a height advantage against wolves by jumping on a rock but I have done it 3 times now and every time they disappear on my map but I hear them barking, they get quiet so I jump down, hear them bark then jump back up, not on map. HAHAHAHA
So from what I am seeing there is no getting an advantage from a rock. Wish I had the game you have.
They did once chase npc's while I was on the rock and that was funny. F'n npc's never bothered to thank me but I'm sure I'd have gotten an honor knock had I not saved them.

[frigid cloud]

They were already close to me when I climbed and stood on the rock so I guess wait till they're close @amber halo

[opal geode]

is there a way to hide your accessories

for weapons

can you unequip them atleast

kinda dont like how they look

they can look cool but doesnt fit with the clothing styles i like

[marble spire]

u do have an advan over panthers and cougars on rocks

start a new game and hunt for LOTE satchel

get 100 story gold medals

[opal geode]

whats a lote satchel

why is every gun smith owner a dickhead lmfao

[amber halo]

I've actually hunted a wolf once. There were 2 frolicking like dogs. Never saw them there again. Hit them from a rock no where near them. Weird. I think it was some kind of glitch.

[opal geode]

me making the gunsmith rich af:
gunsmith: really no reason for it to be taking this long

how do you get that

sorry i was customising weapons and not paying attention

[hidden moss]

Is there a way to only have 1 holster?

Bruh

I want 1 not 2

Or just never save micah

He deserves jail anyways😉

[opal geode]

okay i have just upgraded every weapon i have

spent like 1.2k

funny right

[hidden moss]

Rdr2 is too easy

"Mission skips"

[opal geode]

its for the casuals

you dont have to

my uncle is mid 30s his gaming skill got worse

so its there for them

yeah my uncle

[hidden moss]

Imaging skipping american venom

My friend says u get better at gaming as u age

[opal geode]

only sigma males dont dual wield

because you get that ability from micah

[amber halo]

Horse alerted agitation from across cat tail so I take a peek with the binoc's. F'n grizzly over there and it she was hitched. Hmmmm didn't think that could really happen when they were hitched. Maybe it's just a cool way of letting you know a good opportunity to hunt is available. Pretty badass though.

[hidden moss]

Joe is the Worst character

And joe was in like 3 missions

[opal geode]

im in the mood for treasure hunting

[hidden moss]

Easily one of my fav videogame characters

[hidden moss]

Omfg anyone rememebr how buggy treasure hunting was in rdo beta?

[opal geode]

rdo was boring

so idk

[hidden moss]

Sometimes the treasure wasnt even there

[opal geode]

do they show where everyone is on the map now?

[hidden moss]

OGs remember Rdo Beta

[opal geode]

bcs it feels like im the only mf on the map sometimes

i remember rdo beta

but not the treasure hunts

i remember being hyped af

but it wasnt ready yet

still isnt

[hidden moss]

Whats the worst rdr2 port

PS4 xbox or PC

[opal geode]

probably pc

[hidden moss]

Yeah console versions are always better on Rockstar games

[opal geode]

lets see

jack hall map 1

[hidden moss]

GTA 5 is boring nowadays

[opal geode]

@hidden moss thats not what he means by ports

[hidden moss]

Its still good tho

[opal geode]

obv the pc version is better

first months of the pc port and alot of people had complaints of the game crashing

and rockstar launcher made it almost impossible to play it for some

[hidden moss]

Prob cuz their PC is from the stone age

[opal geode]

one year later im watching a youtuber play it on pc

and his game crashed twice

and he was pretty early

i just watch lets plays sometimes

[leaden storm]

Guys

How do you find the carolina parakeet

I've been searching for a straight 5 hours and haven't found any of em

sup cuz

Bayou Nwa

[hidden moss]

Nah

Well sometimes i watch streams

Idk

Hold F to revive chat

OK

My shitty PS4 cant read disccc

I wanna play rdr2

Why

When

Me will folow

And watch u pley

What game will u play?

1 or 2?

How am i supposed to know?

You didnt say "Red Dead Redemption 2"

And i know

Well u can still discuss rdr1 right?

But mainly rdr2

[quartz charm]

John’s drawing skills are out of this world

[hidden moss]

He draws like me lel

[opal geode]

im guessing jack hall map 1 is close to that plague barn

[quartz charm]

[hidden moss]

Herding missions in rdr1 make me wanna throw my controller at the wall

[opal geode]

yall dont like herding

that what cowboys do tho

[hidden moss]

Its just complicated for some reason

[hidden moss]

But Arthur isnt a cowboy

Hes a gunslinger

Stop shooting them you damn lunatic!

REVIVE CHAT REVIVE CHAT

[quartz charm]

Completing the compendium is driving me crazy

[hidden moss]

What yall think is the worst chapter

For me is Epilogue Part 1

Some missions in chapter 4 bore me

[quartz charm]

Do I have to do the Guarma glitch to study the parrots ??? Or I can study them if I replay the missions there?

@hidden moss any clue partner?

[summer garnet]

you have to do the guarma glitch to study them

[hidden moss]

Chapter 5 was rushed

[quartz charm]

Alright then, thanks! @summer garnet

[summer garnet]

epilouge was rushed

[hidden moss]

Colm o driscoll is dum

[hidden moss]

Yeah u can beat it in 2 hrs

Chapter 2
rest of chapters

[opal geode]

chapter 3 > 2

[hidden moss]

True

Especially when u burn down the farm

[hidden moss]

yep the guarma glitch is the only option

[quartz charm]

That’s crazy because I didn’t remember having the possibility to explore when I was doing the guarma missions back then. So glitching is the only option. Nice rockstar…

[hidden moss]

you could explore, once u finish helping hercule save those workers

after helping him, don't go to dutch

i tried getting back to saint denis, and the whole game was kinda broken for me after that

like horses weren't there in the stables, nothing works in the mainland in chapter 5

[quartz charm]

[hidden moss]

they added the damn invisible sniper in guarma too -_-

[opal geode]

i just heared some unique ambient music

kinda creaped me out

[quartz charm]

Yeah I tried once, it’s pain. Can’t do anything outside the jungle

[hidden moss]

there's one way to disable it, once the sniper starts shooting, go to progress and replay 'bare knuckle friendships' and fail the mission then cancel it.

tried it a while ago, still works ig

[quartz charm]

That’s pog!! I’ll try tonight

So first, I have to do the glitch, then I do this?

[hidden moss]

yes first get to guarma

once the sniper starts shooting

[hidden moss]

then do this

[quartz charm]

Will do!

Is the Boa constrictor there?

[hidden moss]

only found a red tailed boa once, is that the one?

[quartz charm]

I don’t think so

[severe sequoia]

who here wants to help me kill micah that dirty fucking rat

[summer garnet]

micah 🐐

[hidden moss]

Why do u love him?

[severe sequoia]

why do you love him

he literally caused the downfall of the gang

[summer garnet]

Hes written well

[severe sequoia]

he is not

[hidden moss]

He's a whole ass (in French accent)

[severe sequoia]

micah manipulated dutch

[summer garnet]

[summer garnet]

then ask the mods why they hate arthur

[severe sequoia]

i doubt they hate arhtur

arthur*

arthur actually cared about the gang

[elfin anchor]

If you hate somone in a game it just means that it’s very well written

[misty cliff]

I always liked Micah for some reason.

[opal geode]

uhm there was a treasure map apparently

in that burnt town south of valentine

i missed it came back but it despawned

is it something i should worry about

for 100% completion

for exploration challenges

[opal geode]

oh okay its some sort off special edition

[jagged cave]

Are male horses bigger ?

[severe sequoia]

Actually yes.

honestly online compared to single player

single player is better in more aspects

[hidden moss]

Except John's outfit

Online has better John's outfit than singleplayer

[severe sequoia]

mods exist

[hidden moss]

I knowq

I was just mocking about that Rockstar gave Online John's actual better version of cowboy

what Rockstar did to him

lol

[severe sequoia]

I hate his hair in rdr 2.

[frigid cloud]

Today got Pearsons quest as soon as I loaded in

[hidden moss]

Shit everything is wrong about him in epilogue

Hair color

hair

headshape

facial hair

body

outfits

[severe sequoia]

I hate playing as john.

[hidden moss]

yeah

they really messed him up

[severe sequoia]

I actually enjoy arthur as a character.

[hidden moss]

Well mods fixed Epilogue John

look

but they can't fix his character sadly

Shame Rockstar didn't take a look at RDR1 John's words about young John

[severe sequoia]

Honestly I don't know how some people likes michah.

[hidden moss]

Due to voice actor

Voice actor is cool guy

[severe sequoia]

but his character is pathetic

[hidden moss]

yeah

[severe sequoia]

and is a rat

[hidden moss]

Well not really a big fan of Arthur

His voice actor

well

It's complicated

[severe sequoia]

a lot of people actually loves arthur and his voice actor

[hidden moss]

yeah

But some people don't

His voice actor is too political and too agressive

when you have different opinion

[severe sequoia]

I agree with him

[hidden moss]

Sure

your choice man

I don't support him or his enemies

I'm against politics

[severe sequoia]

politics is what makes the world go around

[hidden moss]

And what makes people more agressive and closed minded

I just stay away from it

anyway it's off topic

[severe sequoia]

you cant hate his character due to his real life actor

kind of stupid if you do

[hidden moss]

I hate his character too tbh

but it's opinion.

[severe sequoia]

you are in the 0.01 percent of people that hates his character

[hidden moss]

Alright?

[frigid cloud]

When you say you dont like Arthur:

[hidden moss]

I'll get attacked probably

[severe sequoia]

you very much will

arthur is our boy

[hidden moss]

Send me death threats?

Lol

Oh boy I'll be sent death threats

like they did to peter blomquist

[severe sequoia]

what

[hidden moss]

yeah

Peter Blomquist got death threats by Arthur fans

I have my reasons bro

I used to like Arthur until community got toxic

[severe sequoia]

you cant hate him because of the community but whatever

[summer garnet]

fr? damn

[hidden moss]

yeah

[hidden moss]

They attack any people who prefer John over Arthur as well

[trail compass]

Why is it that literally every time I get a wanted level, the game spawns a wagon in front of me

[upper fox]

They also attack people that say that rdr2 isnt perfect

[severe sequoia]

john is a legit racoon

[quartz charm]

You’re the best! It’s working!!

[opal geode]

how tf you gonna hate arthur for what the community did lmao

[summer garnet]

i think theres a saying ''Stop plucking the petals, go for the head''

[hidden moss]

👍

[golden storm]

I spent 5 hours getting to guarma as Arthur without the snipers, then I got wanted and died and the snipers respawned

literally I was there for 10 minutes

[misty cliff]

Arthur is way overrated. I even like Micah more.

[hidden moss]

Watch out you'll get death threats and insults like Peter Blomquist and they will tell you to stop playing the game if you dislike Arthur

[misty cliff]

I know. But when people send hate, you know you're doing something good.

[hidden moss]

yeah

Or you're just stating your opinion

Without causing harm to no one

[misty cliff]

Yup. Arthur also imo makes no sense. If he was invented back when they made the first RDR, he would make sense but since he wasn't, there's just too many plot holes. Wish they just made you play as someone that had already existed, it would make sense imo.

[hidden moss]

RDR2 is a huge retcon

[misty cliff]

Also don't get me started on epilogue John, both his looks and the way he acts. He acts right and like himself in 1899 and 1911 but in 1907 he feels like a different person.

[hidden moss]

Too goofy

in epilogue

[misty cliff]

And he lost his mean and witty way with words and that "orthur saved ma life moar than once!!!".

[hidden moss]

That line came out of nowhere

[misty cliff]

literally

[hidden moss]

ikr, especially on the last mission

I still don't get it

John should've forgotten about Arthur tbh

like rest of people

it doesn't make sense how he went from like he is in 1907

to hardened badass john marston in rdr1

[misty cliff]

He also should've killed micah bell with his iconic shotgun pose.

[hidden moss]

yeah

Sadie and Charles should've died there

[misty cliff]

Agreed

[hidden moss]

Ost should've been darker

[misty cliff]

and more western ish

[hidden moss]

while John's iconic song plays but way darker and cruel

[misty cliff]

american venom but more rdr1 ish

[hidden moss]

and John starts to act like he is in RDR1

[hidden moss]

yeah

[misty cliff]

RDR2 ost wasn't intense enough especially when you are wanted. GtA and RDR had that proper feel when you are wanted by cops but in RDR2 it feels to quiet.

[hidden moss]

yeah

Also ambient ost is dull imo

[misty cliff]

Too dull, doesn't feel very western imo.

There's but few good ost's. Very few.

[hidden moss]

yeah

[misty cliff]

I actually figured out how to make john look at leas a bit better on console without mods.

[hidden moss]

Pencil mustache?

[misty cliff]

Swept back hair level 6 pomaded since it has his og hair color
pencil level 1
regular beard level 1
dundreary or whatever they're called level 1

[hidden moss]

ah

Reverting to 1.00

gives more stuff

but u are on digital i believe

[misty cliff]

indeed. unfortunately i have digital copy

[hidden moss]

But on 1.00

You can go with natural mustache and chops

lvl 2

[misty cliff]

yeah

[hidden moss]

and dandready sideburn lvl 2

it sometimes looks dark enough t

[misty cliff]

really wish they fixed him but they only seem to care about online.

[hidden moss]

yeah

[misty cliff]

also remade winchester repeater. Make lancaster all iron metal and rosewood varnish

[hidden moss]

nice

[potent orbit]

if i reload my save will plants such as yarrow respawn in areas ive picked them

[trail compass]

Dutch's sanity: 📉

[kindred jackal]

ARTHUR SAVED HIS LIFE!!!!!

MORE THAN ONCE!!!!!!

[hidden moss]

Need an expert on v1.00

Anyone?

[frigid cloud]

Not me

Unfortunately

[hidden moss]

I know some

what do u want

Need semi auto shotgun early in chapter 2, since mama Watson's is always broken in v1.00

[hidden moss]

U can't get semi shotgun from anywhere else

Can u glitch through house?

The only person that carries a semi auto is Hosea

Couldnt get his though

Try to trigger gang glitch

which they will follow

then try if Hosea drops his gun

Yeah, but unfortunately it doesn't work with his semi auto

oof

[hidden moss]

Lantern glitch? Yeah

[hidden moss]

So I didn't understand this watson one

is house locked?

No

Lemme explain

The semi auto at mama watson in v1.00 chapter 2 is always a broken gun that doesn't get fixed with gun oil

oh

have u tried gunsmith?

Same as double action in chapter 2

ahh

wait

[hidden moss]

Yeah it doesn't work in gunsmith

that sucks

I guess only u can do

is to buy it

Any method to spawn Mauser in chapter 4?

I know about Bronte's

Need another one

[obtuse holly]

hi guys

I'm new here

[hidden moss]

Haven't found anything

[hidden moss]

Bronte goons maybe?

In events u can get bronte goons attack you

In v1.00 they either use knives or revolvers

I might do the save with cheats glitch this time when I do the Bronte in chapter 4

Save myself the hassle

alright

[obtuse holly]

does red dead online also get weekly update

[hidden moss]

This is singleplayer chat

[obtuse holly]

oh sorry

@hidden moss is there any chat dedicated to playstation users

I'm new here btw

[hidden moss]

#ps-lfg

[steady vector]

So I just started a new story play through, but the auto save feature seems tied to my first save. Can I use auto save on my new game without overwriting my original game? (this is PC)

[hidden moss]

You can't

except loading that auto save file

and saving it

then go on with ur new playthrough

[steady vector]

But that would delete my original save file right

[hidden moss]

Dude

U saying u don't have any manual saves?

[steady vector]

No no

I have 2. One for my first game and one for this save

I’m saying the auto save feature seems locked to your first game

Not a huge deal, I’ll just have to remember to manual save more often

[hidden moss]

U should do manual save

if u don't want to lose ur save

[steady vector]

Yeah I try to remember saving before and after every mission

And during free roam if I’ve been out for awhile

It’s easy to forget though

[lethal estuary]

Will I grow to hate Bill Williamson, Javier Escuella, and Dutch Van Der Linde in RDR2?

[turbid ore]

no

at least not in the start

[hidden moss]

RDR1 will do it for you

[turbid ore]

yeah ik

they're like the main villians

[hidden moss]

yeah

[turbid ore]

i haven't played it but i have an idea

rdr2 was good

i'll play rdr1 some time later. maybe when the remaster comes out, if it comes out

[lethal estuary]

An Red Dead Redemption Remaster is like a Grand Theft Auto Remaster Trilogy, people will spread rumors but it won’t happen.

I don’t believe rumors.

[turbid ore]

makes sense

[quiet gazelle]

Aquaman dies

[gusty solar]

Damn

I think i just finished the game

[turbid ore]

where are you in the game?

[gusty solar]

Mr morgan just passed

[steady vector]

You’ve still got two chapters left

[turbid ore]

yeah epilogue 1 and 2

[gusty solar]

O h

[severe sequoia]

spoiler it

not everyone completed the story yet

[hidden moss]

It’s been 2 years

[severe sequoia]

Do I really need to get a moderator?

[hidden moss]

What

it’s been 2 years and she wasn’t trying to spoil it for newbies like it said in the rules

why are you calling a mod?

[severe sequoia]

Still is a major spoiler in the ending.

[hidden moss]

Again. It’s been 2 years since this game has been released

[severe sequoia]

@nova igloo Ume spoiled the ending of RDR 2.

[hidden moss]

Spoilers are fine

[severe sequoia]

It's not.

[hidden moss]

lol he actually pinged a mod

[severe sequoia]

For new players it's really not.

[hidden moss]

none of em are new players

They talking about finishing the game 💀

[severe sequoia]

are you fucking stupid

new players would see that shit and know it's a spoiler dumbass

[hidden moss]

dude

Maybe calm your self?

[nova igloo]

Read the rules, this isn't a spoiler free server

[void pond]

[hidden moss]

It said spoilers are acceptable aslong it doesn’t spoil it for a new player on purpose

[nova igloo]

Unless the dude purposely spoiled it for someone, it's fine. Looking at the discussion, looks like it came up organically so he didn't do it with the intent of spoiling for someone

[gusty solar]

The description of the chat literally says be cautious for spoiler

I mean

[hidden moss]

yeah

[nova igloo]

Yeah you're good

[hidden moss]

Ume did nothing wrong

[gusty solar]

Phew

[hidden moss]

that guy is weird

Dude went crazy when I literally read the rule 4 minutes ago

Minimod

[gusty solar]

Maybe he didn’t finish it or smth

Lmao

[hidden moss]

dude tried to suck up to the higher authorities

[nova igloo]

The first line in this channel's description is "be cautious of spoilers" and is both bold and underlined lol

Plus rule 11

[gusty solar]

Ikr?

[gusty solar]

Its a she btw lel

[hidden moss]

Sorry

I will right They if i don’t know gender next time

[gusty solar]

You couldnt really tell so dw

[misty cliff]

@EmperorAuryx#0746 People that join this server should know what they signed up for. Most people completed the story years ago.

hah

i think he left

[gusty solar]

I think he got kicked

[misty cliff]

I can see why.

[oblique rose]

i just scrolled up

Currently replaying red-dead 2 so i can just vibe in chapter 2

have to do chapter 1 tho

[gusty solar]

Damn

[hidden moss]

Haha relatable

Chapter 3 was my fav

Rhodes and the heartlands where the best exploration I had in ages

[gusty solar]

With the 2 families right?

[hidden moss]

The snowy area was great with cool Easter eggs but that’s it

yep Braithwates and the Grays

We end up killing em both 😂

[strange dragon]

Red dead online >>>>>>>> Rdr2 story mode

[hidden moss]

ur funny

nice joke

[strange dragon]

Nah I’m serious rdr2 sm is shit

[strange dragon]

Also you’re*

[oblique rose]

Online is only fun with friends

[gusty solar]

Bruh

[hidden moss]

Apologies good sir, it seems you have legitimately ended my entire career path and future with thye amazing sense of grammatical correction, please allow me to step down my lord.

[gusty solar]

Its a server chat, not a spelling contest

[hidden moss]

Profusely

[oblique rose]

Im being almost one shotted by odriscolls wtf

Why is Arthur so weak in chapter 1

[strange dragon]

Funny joke

[hidden moss]

winter blizzard

[gusty solar]

Why do you think that storymode is bad?

[oblique rose]

Story mode is superior

I wish you could play atleast with 1 other person in story mode tho imagine how fun that would be

[hidden moss]

Funny joke. *

[oblique rose]

Kinda like some of the far cry games

[hidden moss]

Yeah I like the bull sharks in far cry 3

[strange dragon]

Is this really a question right now lmao

[gusty solar]

Yes

Tell me

[strange dragon]

Number one Arthur is a shit character

[gusty solar]

Mhm

[strange dragon]

The story is dumb and filled with plot holes

[hidden moss]

What

[strange dragon]

The gameplay is shit

[gusty solar]

I mean its a prequel

[hidden moss]

Even tho you can only do half the shit you can do in online?

idiot

you realise storymode was way more content

[strange dragon]

Way more content = a long dumb story and stupid side missions

[willow vortex]

guys

i threw axe no a guy

[gusty solar]

Well everyone can have an opinion of

[willow vortex]

and prompt to pick it up not coming

[hidden moss]

its bugged, don't think you can pick it up

[willow vortex]

wht now

tht axe is only 1 in the whole game

do i relaunch?

[hidden moss]

yea do that

[oblique rose]

Just buy another axe

[hidden moss]

I prefer the legend of the east over a mute

[oblique rose]

is Arthur the legend of the east?

[hidden moss]

Yeah

And john is the legend of the west

in the first game

[oblique rose]

Ah, that explains it

Am i the only one who didnt know sadie is the lady in the barn in chapter 1

[gusty solar]

Ehhh I finally realised in the last chapter

[oblique rose]

How long is chapter 1 again

[hidden moss]

meh 2 hours

[gusty solar]

2 hours

[hidden moss]

if ur quick about it

[oblique rose]

I just wanna chill in horshoe as big buff healthy Arthur

[hidden moss]

Fr

[oblique rose]

Not rescuing micah tho

[hidden moss]

I like chapter 3 because it’s buff healthy Arthur with a nice lake for fishing and swimming

[hidden moss]

We can get the off hand in other ways

[hidden moss]

those are collectible hatchets, he's talking about

i think

Yeha

[gusty solar]

Buff arthur 😿

[oblique rose]

oh

[hidden moss]

Viking Axe and ancient tomahawk

[oblique rose]

fat John is like skinny Arthur

You respawn with those

[hidden moss]

🤣

[oblique rose]

why does rescuing John take such a long time

[oblique rose]

I Also like the lake, but i like being near valentine

[hidden moss]

that’s true, but I don’t feel like staying after butchering the town

Reverend Swanson sees ghosts in the swamp in chapter 4

we get to see it too

[wraith panther]

how do you butcher the town?

[oblique rose]

As long as it isnt beaver hollow its aight

[wraith panther]

everyone runs away, and then law enforcement comes

[oblique rose]

The cornwall mission

oh

I shot everyone on sight

[hidden moss]

You still murder countless of people

in that soil

[wraith panther]

pew pew