red-dead-singleplayer

[drifting star]

I only have 2

The crocodile and the fox

[hushed flare]

Most are herbivores so they can't attack back but I recommend either a bolt action or one explosive ammo

you can deadeye all 5 shots into legendary animals

[drifting star]

Ok wow there’s so much to do still

[hushed flare]

idk how people can be on a second playthrough and miss all this tbh

rushing story

[drifting star]

This is my first play through

I started a second one because I wanted to remember the story

Because I hadn’t played in a while

[hushed flare]

Even the legendary map Hosea gives is reliable

[drifting star]

But I’m getting 100% on my first

[hushed flare]

Unless it's the dumb legendary elk xd

[drifting star]

Is that after the bear?

[hushed flare]

Ye

I found like 5 in chapter 3 just using the map

No online stuff

The elks icon is very misplaced from the first clue tho

So that's probably one of the "harder" ones

But guides exist

[drifting star]

I’m gonna have a third play through and I use no online stuff and actually figure out where stuff is

[hushed flare]

The only dangerous legendary animals I can think of is the secret bullgator one, cougar and panther

[drifting star]

Yea the bull gator was hard

I found the cougar but ran away I think

[hushed flare]

a good tip is that one explosive ammo can one shot basically all legendary animals

[drifting star]

Actually maybe that was the cougar in that mission where u go to the mountains and find that guy

For Strauss

[hushed flare]

White or black

Black one is in new austin

[drifting star]

Don’t remember

I’m gonna do dreamcatchers cuz I’m gonna lose my mind tryna find this little bird

[hushed flare]

Dreamcatchers gives a decent reward also

it gives you this trinket basically that doubles ability to use bow

Use bow much much longer basically

[drifting star]

Oh so that will be helpful to do before the hunting stuff

[frigid cloud]

It'll drain your stamina less while charging the bow

[hushed flare]

I think there's a hawk trinket that also minuses bow stamina usage by 30%

Both combined don't even scratch my stamina really

[drifting star]

Do I need trinkets for 100%

They sound like exotics …

[frigid cloud]

No

[hushed flare]

Well they are good to have tho

[frigid cloud]

They might count for equipment idk

[hushed flare]

they do

[drifting star]

Ok that’s handy then

Cuz I need 4 more equipment

Might as well go grab some trinkets

[hushed flare]

Buck antler and pronghorn trinket(if John) are very necessary for hunting

At least buck antler is

[drifting star]

Ok I’ll look on the rdr2 map app thing

[sudden nymph]

Hye guys how do i get gold fast ive just started and i want to get the traders job?? can anyone help me

[drifting star]

Sounds like your on about rdo u will get more help if u ask in #rdo-chat because that’s about online not single player 🙂 (and btw idk anything about online so I can’t help u lol)

[civic nest]

I don't really see the use of the proghorn trinket. If it could be obtained as Arthur it would be very useful but as John you don't need to be carrying animals around

[hushed flare]

It is good for hunting requests ig if you accidentally find a perfect opposum or skunk and don't have proper hunting request yet

or beaver

[tidal glacier]

Today, I cried for the first time in years. I finished chapter 6 with max honor. Very beautiful game.

[hidden moss]

I'm nearly bout to finish chapter 6 for the second time. Jealous of people playing it for the first time

[tidal glacier]

Yeah playing as marston is just not the same

[hidden moss]

Indeed. I’m happy I never played rdr1 rdr2 was just beautiful. Now I understand rdr1 once i watched it.

[hushed flare]

Micah is a good guy tho

[hidden moss]

Oof. First time playing he wasn’t lol. Then after some time I realized he’s a survivor !

[dusty knoll]

I just started Chapter 6... and I'm not ready for the feels train... halp

[hidden moss]

😭

[dusty knoll]

There's a moment in Chapter 4 (if my memorys right) that really made the whole group / family click for me

It's when Jack returns and the group gets around the fire to celebrate

I shred a few tears thinking about the incoming storm

Are there any collect-a-thons that I should complete before the epilogue?

Dinosaur bones, cigarettes cards, etc?

[civic nest]

Item requests if you have any

[dusty knoll]

Yeah, I did item request, activities, camp upgrades

[civic nest]

You did the side missions about teaching the widow how to survive?

[dusty knoll]

I'm not there yet, but soon!

oohh wait

I did that!

Showed her how to skin a rabbit

[hushed flare]

do Micah's item request before finishing game

[sonic patrol]

i’m reading this and realizing that i probably should’ve collected stuff before finishing the game

i just consecutively did mission after mission

[west brook]

Same here

[arctic wren]

First playthrough I tried that. When the wolves came I shot them but that apparently spooked her, couldn’t try again

Then on my second playthrough I got to the one where you teach her to shoot

Apparently I was too close to her when i shot my gun

[hushed harbor]

on the second one i was attacked and killed by a cougar once

[hidden moss]

Guys

How do i talk

In red dead online

On pc

Like vc

[distant pilot]

not really the right channel for that but look into your audio settings, there should be the right key for that and make sure you have the right microphone selected

[hidden moss]

Ok ty

[distant pilot]

no worries

[last barn]

Yo i was trying to do that mission to but I accidentally aimed my gun at her and she ran away, I expected it to be available after a couple minute cool down but it never popped up again

[dusty knoll]

I almost did that by accident, I was chasing the rat and aimed at her.

She got spooked but I could end the chapter

[languid storm]

what if arthur didnt die in 1899 and in 1911 pinkertons come and say we got your family john if you kill arthur you can see

[somber grove]

lol dead eye saves the day i just got the white arbanian and a robeer tried stealing it lol

dead eye helped to kill him

[hidden moss]

u could whistle too

[somber grove]

ok but does it work on scared horse @hidden moss

lol i just watched recap of rdr 1 and now my rdr 2 is ruined i feal like killing jhon

[round hedge]

John would've killed Arthur

and that's about it

[somber grove]

how to know if a npc wants to rob my horse

[languid storm]

what if arthur didnt die and live with johns family then pinkertons come i think john arthur uncle (red harlow) and jack can kill all of pinkertons

[round hedge]

dude are you stupid

uncle is not red harlow

and jack was fucking 16

and they'd shoot Arthur dead for sure

either shoot him dead or arrest and execute him later

[hidden moss]

Agreed

if arthur was alive he would be on terminal tb phase

he wouldn't have the strength to fight

[hidden moss]

most of times a wounded lady asks you for a ride

if it's a weird and armed man near the snowy mountains

refuse to give him a ride

[frigid cloud]

Don't give anyone a ride

[round hedge]

if he was alive then he wouldn't have TB

that's the thing

[hidden moss]

wasn't beecher's hope some place warm and dry?

like doctor said

[round hedge]

that's not the point

if people are talking about him alive, it's not about him being sick

it's about him being fucking alive 🗿

[hidden moss]

yes,yes i get that

but arthur gets sick at the very beggining of the game

[round hedge]

that's why they think about him being alive and healthy

[hidden moss]

TB was terminal in those days. Warm and dry place wouldnt cure him or anything

yes but warm and dry would let you survive for at least 3 years

[civic nest]

Still not enough to make it to 1911

Besides John only buys Beecher's Hope 8 years after Arthur gets sick

[hidden moss]

what i don't understand is that arthur had a freaking hardcore tuberculosis

coughed like liters of blood

(not liters,but a lot of blood)

[civic nest]

Yes, that's the deal with tb

[hidden moss]

arthur died because he couldn't breathe right?

he sounded like a broken automobile

[civic nest]

That and the beaten he received from Micah

But even if he didn't fight Micah, he wouldn't have last much longer

[round hedge]

imagine getting beat to death by micah

[civic nest]

The only way of Arthur to make it to 1911 would be if he never got sick

[somber grove]

i know him very well he tried stealling my neawly tamed white arabian

[hidden moss]

lmao

tell me you didn't kill him

there's a way to make him run away

[somber grove]

lol i used dead eye and killed him

lamo

and when he fell i put a hole revolver bulletes in him

lol

[hidden moss]

if you call your horse while he's running away (whistle for your horse)

dude will fall off the horse and cuss you

[somber grove]

ok

ty

[hidden moss]

What chapter are you in?

[hasty totem]

lemme point out something

arhtur

arthur*

could have beated the fuck out of micah

and i mean it

the fuck out of micah

if he didnt have tuberculosis

[hidden moss]

hey uh

you maybe want to delete that

deoking here hasn't finished the game yet

[long verge]

It's a real shame to realize that The Bone Wars ended about 8 years before Red Dead 2 takes place, Getting caught between two rival Paleontologists as a Stranger mission would have been a delight, so much craziness

[somber grove]

2 lol

[hidden moss]

as a piece of advice...when you get to chapter 4

Don't trust nobody

[somber grove]

i dont understand what you mean??

pls elobrate

[hidden moss]

in chapter 4 there's a new town

[somber grove]

rhodes??

[hidden moss]

nah

[somber grove]

then

??

[hidden moss]

Saint Denis

[somber grove]

i went there for horse glith but it was patched 2 years ago sad life

[somber grove]

nobody means strangers??

[hidden moss]

yes

[somber grove]

y

[hidden moss]

city alleys are full of little kids

[civic nest]

The black arabian glitch? It still works

[somber grove]

no i am talking about the three house glith

where in 2018 all type of horses used to spawn

[civic nest]

Oh, I didn't know that one

[somber grove]

but it was pathed in 2018 only lol

[somber grove]

but how does that mateer ??

i don't understand

[hidden moss]

they will rob you

so don't trust kids lol

[somber grove]

lol

[somber grove]

they must be buying rdr 2 cd's with it

lol

btw @hidden moss do you play on ps4

[hidden moss]

yes

but my ps4 doesn't work, so i'm going to repair it i guess

[somber grove]

do i need psn mebership to plsy rdr online like gta 5

[civic nest]

Yes

[somber grove]

online*

[spring sluice]

yes

[somber grove]

f

[hidden moss]

just create a psn account

that's easy

then you'll have to buy play station plus

[spring sluice]

mhm

[somber grove]

i have one but my 12 month xpired last month

[hidden moss]

rip

[somber grove]

so i will have to buy new one i guess i will buy it when i end rdr 2 stoeymode

[hidden moss]

how is your honor meter

[somber grove]

how to see it

??

[hidden moss]

bruh

[frigid cloud]

Down dpad

[civic nest]

Down button

[somber grove]

ok

[hidden moss]

pls tell me you're not on the bad side of it

[somber grove]

lol i went fishing and dished a lot of fishes and let them go to incress honar

[hidden moss]

Easy way to get honor

but u can just shoot the KKK

[hidden moss]

also, try to greet people

help people

[somber grove]

i will cheack and tell tommarow

[somber grove]

i do the best so far was i helped guy by giving him my health cure potion and in valantine near gun shop he told me i chould buy any thing for free i bought a new rifele with it lol

btw will kiling witness reduce my honar

[somber grove]

btw how does honar affect gameplay

@hidden moss

[hidden moss]

if you kill innocent people, yes

your honor won't be affected if you kill enemies in mission

[hushed flare]

my "honar"

[hidden moss]

leave him be bruh

[hushed flare]

lol

[somber grove]

sry but english is not my first lang.

[somber grove]

can you pls answer my question i am curious

to know it

[hidden moss]

just told you man

if you kill innocent people, yes
your honor won't be affected if you kill enemies in mission

[somber grove]

no i mean like how does it change things for aurther

[hidden moss]

changes the ending

[somber grove]

ok

[hidden moss]

also changes arthur's lines in some missions

[somber grove]

oh

[hidden moss]

if you have low honor arthur is gonna sound cold,and angry

[drifting star]

Also u get discount in shops

If u have high honour that is

[somber grove]

man nice

[hidden moss]

if you have high honor

[somber grove]

i will try to maintain high hounar kill people and rob stagecouch and sell them and then give the money to cam to incress honar

[hidden moss]

you will also unlock some unique missions near the end of chapter 6

i you have high honor

[drifting star]

High honour is the best

[somber grove]

camp*

[drifting star]

U will get loads of honour in a chapter 6 mission

[somber grove]

ok

is there any best way to do it

[drifting star]

But if u go around Saint Denis and great people it goes up quick

[hidden moss]

greet*

[hushed flare]

Fishing is my preferred method of honor raise

[drifting star]

I think it’s every 3-4 people you greet you get honour

[drifting star]

Thank you lol

[hidden moss]

and also, don't kill people that annoys you

that a huge mistake i commited in my first playthrough

[drifting star]

I have lowest honour lol

[edgy plinth]

same

lmao

[hushed flare]

Sometimes I've been able to kill people when I antagonized back and they start shooting and I kill them and I don't lose honor

[edgy plinth]

yeah

[somber grove]

don't worry it also has some good sides low honar gives you more loot from people

[hushed flare]

It's like the only benefit

Level one low honor

[drifting star]

I have 2 different saves 1 high 1 low

[somber grove]

ty i will not make that mistake

[drifting star]

When I feel like I want to kill someone I just switch save

[hushed flare]

If someone shoots you you should shoot them back regardless of honor

Or just run to the sheriff and they shoot the pwrson

[drifting star]

I don’t think u lose honour if u shoot someone who shot u first

[hushed flare]

Sometimes you do tho

[drifting star]

Yeah I depends it’s about why they are shooting u

[somber grove]

bye gotta go for dinner

[hidden moss]

As the game progresses, there will be many encounters with strangers around the map, many of those encounters are traps and ambushes

be careful with that

[hushed flare]

I wonder why it's ok to shoot a bunch of lawman no honor loss but a group of like 6 people that aren't lawman? That's where we draw line

They spawn as red dots

[somber grove]

ok

one time i helped a odrescale escape jail and droped my honar by lot

[hidden moss]

lmao

never help prisioners or bounties

[drifting star]

Don’t think I’ve done that yet

[somber grove]

i thought he was one of us

[hidden moss]

in the setting put the name of speaker feature

[drifting star]

Oh sometimes I find prisoners that need their chain broken

[hidden moss]

you'll know who is speaking

[somber grove]

you get it randomly on a road where they are trying to free him an

[hushed flare]

You help prisoners to get the secret gold bar location then you take him to sherrif

[hidden moss]

LMAO

[somber grove]

lol

[drifting star]

Woah😳

[hushed flare]

Lmfao

Triple delete

[somber grove]

@hidden moss for whom was it lamo

[hidden moss]

i got a screen shot lol

[hushed flare]

xd

[drifting star]

Lucky

[hidden moss]

dutch... dont do it

i won't

don't worry

ok

[hushed flare]

[hidden moss]

talk about sex some other place lmao

[balmy palm]

Whos the worst character?

😐

[lost moss]

Micah

[lost moss]

No

[drifting star]

Strauss

[lost moss]

Arthur

[somber grove]

dutch

[balmy palm]

[drifting star]

😡

[lost moss]

[drifting star]

[hushed flare]

[void pond]

[lost moss]

[civic nest]

Molly

[balmy palm]

I dont even know who the fuck that is.

[civic nest]

Dutch's girlfriend, got shotgunned in the stomach

[balmy palm]

Oof?

[hushed flare]

Perhaps

Molly does like nothing in the game lmfao

[balmy palm]

HA, LAZY BITCH

[frigid cloud]

Dotch

[hushed flare]

Artaur

[hidden moss]

worth character is dutch

[civic nest]

If Dutch wasn't arguing with Molly all the time he could have come up with a better plan

[hushed flare]

Most complicated character

[hidden moss]

MiCaH iS jUsT a SuRvIvOr

[hushed flare]

Micah is good guy

[balmy palm]

Bad guy.

[hidden moss]

I felt Pearson’s was the worst character 🌚 coming from me cuz I’m vegan lol

[balmy palm]

He is literally an antagonist.

[hidden moss]

i'm a huge punch survivor black lung! huge punch a survivor! huge punch again lol

[hushed flare]

Secret ending if you go back for the money with lowest honor micah gives you special miracle tonic

[civic nest]

Pearson best character

[hidden moss]

CaMp CoOk

[hushed flare]

Pearson gives you Lote satchel so he's op

[hidden moss]

All those plants around and he need meat.

[hushed flare]

You guys forgot Micah gives you second holster and a free lancaster

[civic nest]

Mr Morgan bring me some materials and I'll be glad to do something nice to you!

[hushed flare]

creates black hole satchel

[dark seal]

You can get lancaster from Rhodes instead at the start

[hushed flare]

What if too lazy

[dark seal]

It's easy instead of doing all those missions

[hidden moss]

But let’s say a new player didnt know that. 🤷🏽‍♂️

Either way you gotta do the missions.

[frigid cloud]

You can have 2 Lancaster repeater

[hushed flare]

Dual wield

[dark seal]

You gotta point

[somber grove]

location??

[hushed flare]

behind shady belle

Random event

and you get a treasure map

[hidden moss]

@somber grove

[arctic wren]

I loved following the treasure maps

[hushed flare]

How did people even solve the poisonous trail one

[hidden moss]

there's a hidden gold bar in a burned abandoned town near horseshoe overlook camp (chapter 2 camp)

[hushed flare]

And it's worth less then the landmark of riches ofc

[hidden moss]

town is called limpany,and the gold bar is in a safe at sheriff's office

[hushed flare]

Limpany is like a 10 second walk lol

[hidden moss]

yes

[hushed flare]

I use that gold bar to buy fast travel

[arctic wren]

Shit I didn’t think of that

[hushed flare]

gold bars respawn as jim Milton also

[drifting star]

Are gold bars worth £500

[frigid cloud]

Yes

Gold ingot 300$
Gold nuggets 50$

[drifting star]

Alr thanks cuz i have some so might as well sell them then

Gonna get all the dreamcatchers tonight

[hidden moss]

Anybody played rdr2 and went back to rdr1 and realized how dumb John is 😭

[hidden moss]

Everything is dumbed down about John

They fucked up his epilogue look

by making look like Arthur reskin too

[round hedge]

it's it's character development you see

[hidden moss]

Exactly!

😂

It makes sense for epilogue John not being able to bring 5 words ok?

he's maturing!!!!

I literally was upset when I was John in rdr2

[round hedge]

how is it possible to enjoy RDR2 John

his writing is garbage

[hidden moss]

You can't enjoy RDR2 John

Writing is garbage

Epilogue look is Arthur reskin

When the game started I was like let me be John after chapter 2 I was like nah I like Arthur more

That's the point

they dumbed John's character

so most people can like Arthur

And on top of it all

they decided to make Real Epilogue John's look

then they scrapped them

and made epilogue John Arthur reskin

Ahhh I wonder how jack marston gone be. Maybe he’ll come out and say Arthur was more like a father to me in rdr3

And have Arthur traits. Orrrrrrr might be Micah son never know

Knowing Rockstar they will fucking do it

Even though Jack is literally John's son

and John took care of him more

Idk Arthur took em fishing lol

[hidden moss]

that's all?

Saved him !

yeahhhh

Arthur is Jack's father because uuhhhhh fishing uhhhhhh book uhhhhhh

😂

oh oh ohooh Jack wears Arthur jacket!!!!!! Even though they are not same

[round hedge]

jack looks identical to arthur in RDR2

and identical to john in RDR

so good question

[hidden moss]

Abiligal always gave Arthur that look like only we know the truth 🌚

[latent plover]

Jack drew a picture of Jack Arthur and Abigail, he knows the truth

[hidden moss]

My point !

John : Jack is John's son. John took care of Jack, John went into berzerk when he heard Jack got kidnapped, literally ran to Save Jack during O'driscoll ambush, Taught him how to do ranch work, taught him how to ride a horse, Killed 3 men to protect Jack getting harmed, Went to kill Lamaire gang to protect his son,wife and his job, built beecher's hope just for Jack and Abigail to stay in a place, Saved Rufus's life, Hunted Dutch, Bill, Javier just to save Jack and Abigail from custody, Taught Jack how to shoot a rifle, taught him how to herd, taught him how to hunt, saved Jack from bear attack, John protected Abigail and Jack from getting killed.

Yeah, John is a bad father smh

Every father that adopted a son would do that though. 🤷🏽‍♂️

Dutch adopted Arthur and John and look how that turnt out even all Dutch did

Jack is actually no one's son

My point lol.

[fathom karma]

Jack is the son of Abigail and Abigail

[hidden moss]

I didn’t see no sign of Abigail prego

[fathom karma]

she had some fun with herself and out popped Jack

[hidden moss]

Jack is an alien creature

[fathom karma]

Yes he is

[hidden moss]

to look like adorable kid

[fathom karma]

Preach

[crystal nova]

Does the lending a hand glitch still work

[frigid cloud]

No

[somber grove]

hey is there any way when aurther dies i can save his money for jhon

[hidden moss]

When you finish the final mission as John you get 20k I think anyway at the end so you’ll have enough as John

[somber grove]

oh ok

[near agate]

Father

Fake father

[drifting star]

There is a way if u go to the Aberdeen pig farm because the people that live in the house take your money and stuff then when u are John u go back to it and find the money but I’ve never done it so I can’t confirm that it works

[frigid cloud]

It does work

[hidden moss]

bruh, u already got to ending_

[untold ocean]

Add the final sacrifice

[hidden moss]

Jack is John's son. John took care of Jack, John went into berzerk when he heard Jack got kidnapped, literally ran to Save Jack during O'driscoll ambush, Taught him how to do ranch work, taught him how to ride a horse, Killed 3 men to protect Jack getting harmed, Went to kill Lamaire gang to protect his son,wife and his job, built beecher's hope just for Jack and Abigail to stay in a place, Saved Rufus's life, Hunted Dutch, Bill, Javier just to save Jack and Abigail from custody, Taught Jack how to shoot a rifle, taught him how to herd, taught him how to hunt, saved Jack from bear attack, John protected Abigail and Jack from getting killed, sacrificed his life so his family can live in peace without being chased.

here

[hidden moss]

Well he didn’t actually sacrifice his life 😂 he was going to get killed either way cuz jack and Abigail didn’t kill nor rob they was just part of the family.

[somber grove]

no just asking as my ending alredy got spoilled

lmao

[round hedge]

no, he did sacrifice himself

he could've just ran away with them

[hidden moss]

Either way he was gone get killed not the others.

[round hedge]

but having to run all the time is not a way to live life

[hidden moss]

Dutch did

😂

[round hedge]

so he just went like a Chad and opened the barn doors

and sacrificed himself so his family could live

which sadly didn't work so well since Abigail died 3 years later 😔

[hidden moss]

So looking forward to rdr3🌚

[round hedge]

he was getting hunted, but he could survive

RDR3 lol

won't exist

[hidden moss]

Lone walker vibe lol

[round hedge]

and if it does then it'll be awful because fuck the redemption title

we need another R

[hidden moss]

Lol jack as a avenger

Mostly everybody gone.

[round hedge]

Jack's life was cruel

losing his father and mother in a span of 3 years

Jesus

[hidden moss]

He watched everybody else die I think he grown mature at that age

[hidden moss]

rip

[hushed flare]

And then he becomes a godly gunslinger for some reason

After their deaths

[hidden moss]

He put down them books and picked up them guns

[steady vector]

And that is that. Arthur's gone 😢 What a character

Won't feel the same playing as John, but I suppose I should finish the story. Hopefully see Dutch and Micah meet their end. Fuckers

[drifting star]

The second part of the epilogue is very fun

[steady vector]

I've come this far so I should finish it

Btw does the white Arabian respawn for the epilogue? That's the horse I was riding as Arthur at the end

[drifting star]

Should do

I’m still using the type of horse u get in the first mission and I’ve finished the game 😂

[steady vector]

Lol

[hidden moss]

Play with mods

for Epilogue John

Epilogue John is a mess

[steady vector]

I saw a tip about the White Arabian being good so I grabbed it right at the beginning and used it the whole game

[hidden moss]

Install mods that fixes epilogue John

So your whole John experience gets better.

[steady vector]

What do you mean he's a mess?

[hidden moss]

He's Arthur reskin

in epilogue

[drifting star]

I would’ve tripped on a rock and killed it or summin lol

[hidden moss]

John's face pasted into Arthur's body

and they also bleached John's dark mustache

So John looks nothing like John.

oh also

John is broken

Sometimes nothing works

he doesn't look into his weapon

[drifting star]

I haven’t played rdr1 so John just looked normal for me

[hidden moss]

Just take a look at early screenshot epilogue john or npc John

you'll start to notice it.

I have a txt ready for it

come to

#red-dead-media

[steady vector]

Lol it's not that hard

If it's just John's appearance I don't rly care. I probably won't notice and i haven't played rdr1

[hidden moss]

nah,

Even his writting sucks

He doesn't act like npc or rdr1 John

[drifting star]

It doesn’t look too different

[hidden moss]

lmao

So mickey mouse gloves

disco pants

Arthur's body

bleached mustache

jetblack hair color

arthur's hair

lowered ears

thick neck

Arthur's animation

Arthur's vomit sound

They are noticeable as hell

also face expression

he looks like a psychopath

his dialogues sounds like he's learning how to speak new too

[steady vector]

You're rather passionate about this

[hidden moss]

As a fan of John

It really bothers me.

Imagine they ruin Arthur too

By making him sound like a dumbass

make his hair, body

of previous protagonist

in rdr3

[red helm]

Like 1/4th of the past 3 months of the conversations in this channel has been Desano talking about how they messed up John in the epilogue.

[hidden moss]

Also sometimes his face expression gets broken

[round hedge]

lmao

[red helm]

... and I'm only slightly exaggerating..

[round hedge]

nah it's just the amount of errors that rockstar managed to do

it's comically large

[red helm]

Rockstar is indeed the fail with all the cuts and errors they have done.

[steady vector]

I probably won't notice but we'll see

[round hedge]

they were rather passionate with fucking john's model tho

because what they did really isn't a lazy job done

it's a good job for a bad thing

[hidden moss]

They did it on purpose

[red helm]

Yeap, I do agree, they should have kept the RDR1 John for the Epilogue. But... oh well.

[golden storm]

just had my first greet greet antagonize its really good

[steady vector]

Well even if that fucks up the epilogue it's still a great game

[red helm]

Always fun times.

[steady vector]

Maybe they should've ended the game with Arthur's death

[red helm]

And just immediately jump into Free Roam John?

[steady vector]

Idk. It felt like an end

[round hedge]

he didn't play RDR

so yeah

[red helm]

I think it is neat that they did a story for how the Beecher's Hope ranch started up. They just didn't do that great of a job of it....

[round hedge]

beecher's hope story was so stupid to the point i'd rather it was kept a secret

it felt like Michael De Santa cowboy edition

[golden storm]

I like you. you have a kind face.
a kind I'd like to punch

[steady vector]

I would be fine if the game ended with Arthur and didn't let you back into free roam. But most people wouldn't and that's not how games are made

[round hedge]

RDR ended just like RDR2 did

[red helm]

That would break with the Theme of Rockstar games. They all have a "Free Roam" after you finish the Story Mode.

[round hedge]

it had a continuation

[drifting star]

The game would be boring without free roam at the end

[round hedge]

mafia II

[red helm]

... Or all of them I have played.

Unless they had a New Game+, that would work.

[drifting star]

I haven’t played any mafia so idk what u mean

[steady vector]

I don't have a console so I can't play RDR. Maybe I will someday

[drifting star]

I’m gonna play it once I 100% rdr2

[red helm]

RDR1 is quite fun, but different.

[drifting star]

Is it shorter then rdr2

[hidden moss]

Still more fun

[red helm]

Yes,

[round hedge]

it's more realistic storywise imo

rdr2 is cinematic

and RDR is like you're living the missions with nohn

John

[red helm]

Shorter story, only like 4 challenge series. I don't think there were any collectibles....

[hidden moss]

Also you don't feel like you're the savior too

John makes you feel like you're just a dude trying to do his own thing

[drifting star]

Well I’m still gonna play it cuz I’ve heard it’s good

[hidden moss]

Which is very immersive

[round hedge]

it's funny how John gets used by almost everyone

but they all end their part of the deal

and then you have the government

[hidden moss]

And if they don't

[red helm]

Definitely more Realistic. If you die(Not in a Mission), you actually have to load all the way back to a previous save, so you lose a bunch of time..

[hidden moss]

If someone don't pay their part of deal

John makes sure they pay

[hushed flare]

Loading saves is a cheat code to this game

[red helm]

Touching water = Super bad.

[steady vector]

Can you manual save whenever you want like RDR2?

[red helm]

Nope.

[hushed flare]

John loses every ounce of energy for touching water

[red helm]

There are special places you save, like houses/rooms you rent.

Even when you are on a horse, if you get into water = Instant death.

[steady vector]

I dislike it when games don't allow manual saves or easy ways to autosave

[hushed flare]

Makes the game much more less cheesy

[red helm]

Well... Not all water, There is some shallow, little ponds, that are fine... But...

[hushed flare]

Something bad happened and you saved 5 minutes ago? Never happened

Horse dies = reload save

[round hedge]

cores system made the game way too easy

change my mind

[hidden moss]

Agreed

U can literally take down 40 dude with knives

[hushed flare]

legend of the east satchel where you can carry 99 tonics

[red helm]

Actually, don't you have a Horse Card thingie, that you can just use to resummon your horse when it dies?

[round hedge]

yeah

[red helm]

-If- you bought it from a Store, or get it special...

[round hedge]

yep

[red helm]

I remember they gave you one of the best horses in the game on like the third mission. That Yellow chestnut one, and kind of being a little blahed about that.

I mean, it is good, but... I felt a bit annoyed, since you didn't have to earn it, It's just handed to you on a silver platter.

[steady vector]

Hardly ever used tonics tho. Arthur can take a lot of bullets

[frigid cloud]

Level 10 health

[round hedge]

RDR is much harder

WAAAY harder

compared to rdr2

[steady vector]

No I was level 6 or 7

[frigid cloud]

I know

[steady vector]

I never needed to replenish my stamina bar with items, and very rarely needed health items. Only dead eye

And near the end with Arthur I didn't need to use dead eye much anymore either

[round hedge]

RDR had infinito stamina

infinite

and barely any dead eye and health lol

[red helm]

Okay, I was trying to remember if RDR1 had stamina or not....

[round hedge]

only horses had

[steady vector]

If you run around a lot at the beginning of RDR2 stamina maxes out pretty quickly

[hidden moss]

John/Jack stopped running after running for a while

[red helm]

I remembered horses did. But running as John was such a waste of time, usually, I just couldn't remember if it was even a thing or not.

[steady vector]

I was still getting health points from fistfights and bow/knife kills with Arthur so I guess I didn't max health. Stamina and dead eye maxed out with normal gameplay quickly for me

I don't care to do the challenges to really max them out

[frigid cloud]

Bow is best for levelling up health

[untold raft]

Arthur or jhon?

For me arthur

[frigid cloud]

Don't know who's ‘Jhon’

[untold raft]

Marston

[red helm]

Can I choose secret third option: Mary-Beth?

[untold raft]

No

[frigid cloud]

Fourth secret option: Micah

[red helm]

Oh.... then I don't want to play...

[hidden moss]

*John

[red helm]

[untold raft]

[hidden moss]

*jim

[drifting star]

How many exotics are there

[frigid cloud]

5 list

180 items? Including orchids, plumes, eggs I think

[untold ocean]

can you dismembered Micah’s head with a shotgun?

[drifting star]

That’s gonna take me the rest of the year

[frigid cloud]

I did all in one day

[frigid cloud]

Nope

You can't even fire at his body

[red helm]

It's not to bad, if you look up where all the orchids are on the internet, and such.

[frigid cloud]

30 spoonbill plumes

[drifting star]

Is it any camping involved

Or is it like finding dreamcatchers, bones etc

[red helm]

Camping? Like to reset spawns? I mean, if you have to find more Egrets or something...

[frigid cloud]

Orchids do not move

So kinda

[drifting star]

Ok

[drifting star]

And I mean waiting for something to spawn yeah

[red helm]

Yeah, depends on how lucky you are with the birds. But all the orchids and eggs are fine, if you look up Locations.

[hushed flare]

Hunting requests < Duchess and other animals

[red helm]

Eggs was funny, I had like 80 by the time he asked for them.

[frigid cloud]

What were you doing with eggs

[red helm]

I was just always looting nests whenever I came across one.

[cold valley]

hi lol

[red helm]

Evening

[hidden moss]

G U D E B I N I N G

[steady vector]

The fact that I reached maximum honor by deciding to help John escape instead of going back for the money was so fitting

[uncut topaz]

Man the ice glaziers make some sketch noises

[hidden moss]

The birds absolutely suck for exotics. I've only ever found a reddish egret once in 2 game playthroughs

[hushed flare]

hunting requests

[drifting star]

I just got mauled by a legendary wolf lol

[dawn tiger]

did you try and pet it?

[drifting star]

Yes

Didn’t go well

[dawn tiger]

But still a good puppo, rip arthur tho XD At least you respawn

[drifting star]

🙏🙏🙏

[old crystal]

I have a theory

What if Dutch was a Pinkerton all along

[tender marsh]

dutch was daddy until he wasnt

[civic nest]

How so

[balmy palm]

JonDeeznuts.

[sturdy edge]

If I have RDO on steam, and im deciding to activate RDR2 keys on Rockstar Club directly, will I have to redownload the whole file ?

[vast grotto]

probably

[nova plume]

How the hell do you hunt the bull gator?

[hidden moss]

With explosive bullets

[nova plume]

I meant find its been 2 hours

[hidden moss]

It's around lakay. Google is better for that tbh

[drifting star]

Use eagle eye and find the clues

[red helm]

Are you in Chapter 6? If yes. it is just south of Lagras, west of Lakay. If you find the first clue, Make a Manual Save, he is Super dangerous.

If you are not in chapter 6, it won't appear yet.

[hidden moss]

Is it possible to find collectives/everything without having to google where they are. I dont wanna constantly stop playing just to look up some complex place

[red helm]

Well, of course, you could find everything without the internet.

Just do your own exploring.

[hidden moss]

True thats the best way man I can never get tired of exploring RDR 2

I wish Ambarino wasn't really empty

Or a side quest where you wipe out the Murfrees

I swear I memorized that roanoke ridge soundtrack

[nova plume]

Oh ok im in chap 4 ty for the help

[empty cave]

should i play rd1 first? im confused now because rd2 is before rd1

[round hedge]

nah, play RDR2

then 1

[empty cave]

okok

but why do you play as jonh on 1

[round hedge]

playing with badass john then wacky john isn't the good choice

[round hedge]

play the story

[empty cave]

lol

im on chapter 6

[round hedge]

john got caught after the government ordered the execution of all outlaws

so they got his family and made John work for them so he could redeem himself from his gang times actions

[empty cave]

isnt that the mission where you rescue him?

[round hedge]

wht

what

[empty cave]

theres a mission where you rescue john

from that prison

on a hot air ballon

[edgy plinth]

I finished my second play through about a week ago

[empty cave]

nice

max honour?

[round hedge]

rdr2 came later

nothing in it matters to RDR

so no

[empty cave]

oh okok

[hidden moss]

The mission where yo I try to find Lenny when ur drunk is pretty sus

[empty cave]

fr lol

its funny

[untold ocean]

And Edgar betrayed him

And pretty much for the timeline

Rdr2 came before the processor

if man has the special miracle tonics

he wouldn’t have died so quickly

fuck plot armor

[dire sentinel]

not only that

edgar ross killed john because he wanted that squirrel statue

[long iris]

i need

hhelp

ok spoiler time i will mark as spoiler

[dire sentinel]

you can't use spoilers here sadly

[long iris]

wat if i mark as spoiler

oh

shoot

where may i

[dire sentinel]

i mean you can't mark it

yeah

[long iris]

bc i need help but it's spoilery

ver bad

how do i do it

[empty cave]

say it then delete it maybe lol

[long iris]

o

ok then

warning to anyone who hasn't finished the game

[hushed flare]

No rules against spoilers

Btw

[untold ocean]

Arthur is hot

[hushed flare]

Micah death is the most emotional death btw I cried

[untold ocean]

that’s a spoiler

[hushed flare]

no

[dire sentinel]

bro, wtf i haven't completed the game

[untold ocean]

John’s model is fucked

[hushed flare]

John has a bad clipping issue

[long iris]

so this is my second playthrough of rdr2 and i accidentally started the last mission with arthur and halfway through i was like 'oh shoot i gotta do things first before r tur dies' so i tried to exit the game and go back in but it sent me right back where i was. so i tried exiting the real man way after i looked up how, but nothin happened, so killed myself and i didnt get the option to exit

[untold ocean]

Rockstar can eat my pussy, fuck them

[long iris]

am i doomed 2 death

am on ps4 btw

[untold ocean]

you forgot to save

YOU DUMMY

[hushed flare]

Lol

[long iris]

:(

i didnt knooow

[hushed flare]

This is why people's horses die cuz no save

[dire sentinel]

lmao

[long iris]

i never saved bc i never exited the game i just put my ps4 in rest mode

well shoot

am i doomed

[hushed flare]

Lmfaooo

[long iris]

don't laugh

i thought u would be nice

[hushed flare]

[dire sentinel]

[long iris]

so i

can't exit the final mission

[hushed flare]

You basically restart if no backup lol

[long iris]

wat

[hushed flare]

Or whatever your last save was

[long iris]

yes or noOo

[hushed flare]

Can you not fail the mission

[long iris]

i did

no exit button

[hushed flare]

Retry checkpoint

Oh wait

[long iris]

:,(

i wanted to do the last hamish mission before i died

[dire sentinel]

don't do the last hamish mission

save it for john

if u want

[long iris]

gRRRRRRR

i wanna be R TUR

well heck

am i just one big ol

dummy guy

[round hedge]

he killed him because John was the last one on the list

so yeah, Ross was an asshole

[long iris]

so i can't exit or i can pls someon

æ

[untold ocean]

Adding get all the recognition from john’s work

[somber grove]

dutch kills micha and jhon kills dutch

[civic nest]

Dude

[somber grove]

same here

[somber grove]

??

[civic nest]

Don't spoil him

[untold ocean]

Ignore him xd

[somber grove]

it is from rdr 1

[untold ocean]

we know

I want to tuck Micah

In a burning house

[somber grove]

lol dutch died in rdr 1 only

[untold ocean]

he commit cliff jumping

[somber grove]

yep

[civic nest]

The Micah part isn't

[untold ocean]

he had a plan

Horsea

is so pog omg!

[somber grove]

i think aurther and hosea where where backbone of the gang

what do you think

[untold ocean]

Yes

[somber grove]

oh sry

[civic nest]

Lol that's my horse's name

[untold ocean]

Hosea’s personality ressembles my grandfather’s

[somber grove]

oh nice

and after that jhon had just started to handle the gang they left him to die lol

[steady vector]

Why would you tag me saying that when I haven’t played those parts yet. I know spoilers are allowed but c’mon

[red helm]

Just tossing out spoilers like that is rather lame.

[round hedge]

they didn't exist in RDR lol

[steady vector]

Ah well

[round hedge]

it's basically Dutch was the leader and John was second in command, with Bill and Javier being the members

[steady vector]

If anyone’s here rn can John shave anywhere at Beecher hope? (RDR2)

[round hedge]

bill and Javier went insane with Dutch when he lost hope in humanity and saw that his practices wouldn't change how the government progressed

which Javier later on with Dutch planned to leave john to die

John gets shot and left to die, but he survived and left the gang completely to live in his ranch

[round hedge]

bathroom

[round hedge]

which Ross later gets hold of his family

[hidden moss]

I’m on my 3rd playthrough and I’m afraid I’m gonna get the bad ending lol, I have so much low honor in chapter 2

[mossy juniper]

I want to ride my horse but it keeps tumbling on small ass pebles

[hidden moss]

Although you do get a lot of good honor when you throw out Strauss in chapter 6

[mossy juniper]

Yep

[hidden moss]

Seriously, you ragdoll off you’re horse from the smallest things

[mossy juniper]

Yeah I barely touched a tree stump and I got thrown forward

[hushed flare]

Skill issues ^

[steady vector]

Chap 2? You have lots of time to increase your honour

I had really low honour for the first 2 or 3 chapters and then started trying to increase it. I reached max honour during the final mission. Didn’t know until afterwards it contributed to the ending

So which is the canon ending? Is it high honour on the mountain?

[echo fiber]

Is Rdr remastered actually a thing because my friend said they r making it

[steady vector]

I don’t believe that has been announced

But if they do ever remaster the first one put it on PC 🙏

[hidden moss]

One thing I hate about single player is the game constantly takes away my weapons when I get off my horse

[hushed flare]

Your in a town

Then

[long iris]

ahhhhhh

i beat rdr2 for the second time but i'm stillll rlly depressed about the ending

i mean arthur's

gaaaaah

brrrr

grrrr

[placid granite]

I feel ya

The pain still haunts me to this day

[indigo fog]

When Arthur gets robbed and thrown into the pit. Can I go back to the cabin and kill them without taking the money? Like will killing them mess up the time capsule

I want to transfer money to John

[round hedge]

yes

[indigo fog]

Yes it will mess up the time capsule or yes I can kill them without messing it up.

[round hedge]

yes you can kill them and leave the money

[indigo fog]

Thanks

[hidden moss]

Ive heard it is in development but they might only release it if the gta remastered trilogy does well

[hidden moss]

i just completed my second playthru

pain.

[hushed flare]

Micah is a good guy

[placid granite]

I’m doing my third run through for the endings

Gonna be a big oof

[hidden moss]

i wish you well

[long iris]

micah: 🐀

[hushed flare]

micah:

[hidden moss]

Micah: you can fight but you cant think

Arthur: you cant do either

tb to micah shooting 3 grays in 2 seconds

Backing up my boi

[rapid cosmos]

can i find the wolf horse that supposed to be great in the snow online? (i’m new)

[vagrant temple]

No. Horses are only buyable in stables.

[frigid cloud]

What's wolf horse

[rapid cosmos]

okay. thank you. been waiting in the wild for an hour.

[heady anvil]

totally havent been listening to see the fire in your eyes on loop for a while

[leaden storm]

Guys did the o'driscolls dissapeared after the epilogue?

I can't find any of them in new hanover

[frigid cloud]

Yes

Obviously after colm dies they flee

[leaden storm]

Oh

[safe hull]

bro im playing a missin and an emeny got knocked out and then he just respawned? in front of me

lul

he wouldnt attack or anything but the mission wouldnt continue unless i killed him

[drifting star]

I got all dreamcatchers and forgot to save so I have to get them all again now 😑

[frigid cloud]

Bro

[void pond]

bruh i save every dreamcather because of my ocd

[plucky comet]

I just found a secret easter egg

Ig

[rapid pewter]

Riding from Van Horn to BlackWater is actually easy

[marble juniper]

how do i get exploding bullets?

[swift pond]

craft bullets with animal fat

ducks and geese are best to hunt for the fat

[marble juniper]

where do i find the pamphlet

[frigid cloud]

Fence

[marble juniper]

yes but whats th pamphlet called

[frigid cloud]

Explosive rounds and explosive slugs for shotgun

[hidden moss]

When it took 2 explosive rounds for me to kill the legendary bullgator I figured I'd hate to fight it any other way

[steady vector]

There’s a story mission with Sadie right near the end of of Arthur’s story where you go to a farm and kill the last organized group of O’Driscolls IIRC

That is after Colm hangs. Maybe you can miss that mission idk

[leaden storm]

OHHH

now i remember lol

[hidden moss]

bruh im legit working so hard to get high honor before the end

[sage vessel]

Ah

[hidden moss]

already in guarma

[sage vessel]

is this like standard edition?

anyone here has the original videogame?

;')

[hidden moss]

ima speedrun guarma

[acoustic bay]

Ima speed run snow area

[marble juniper]

i couldnt find the explosive rounds but i found the explosive slugs

[frigid cloud]

You should have it already

Don't you get it at the start of chapter 2

[marble juniper]

idk tbh i didnt play this game for almost 2 months i forgot

[frigid cloud]

Check your satchel then

[steady vector]

Which game should I play next?

[civic nest]

There's this game called Red Dead Redemption 2. It's pretty good, like GTA with horses

[hidden moss]

Yeah I've heard about it

Should I get it, looks interesting

[frigid cloud]

no

Definitely not

[drifting star]

I’m so close to 100% now

I’m at 91

[civic nest]

Nice

What do you got left?

[frigid cloud]

You're not close enough

91% is far from 100%

[hushed flare]

The last 10% is the hardest part usually

[steady vector]

I mean after I finish that one lol

[drifting star]

Graves, fish, exotics, hunting requests, weapons, max health stamina and dead eye, challenges, legendary animals and recipes

[civic nest]

Hunting requests is the worst

[drifting star]

I’m getting weapons atm

[civic nest]

Although some of the things you mentioned are not required to 100%

[drifting star]

Says that’s what I need

On the total completion tab

Oh I have an unknown collectible to which I think is rock carvings

[civic nest]

I'm fairly sure recipes, legendary animals and fishes are not required

[drifting star]

Yeah they are

Not all the animals I don’t think tho

Only 5

Unless there are only 5…

[frigid cloud]

There are more than 5

[frigid cloud]

They are you need to catch all legendary fishes and do that guy's second quest

[drifting star]

What’s the hardest challenge out of the 9

[frigid cloud]

Herbalist 1

[hushed flare]

no no, sharpshooter 1

way too hard pls nerf

[frigid cloud]

yes

[drifting star]

I will do that first when I start doing challenges then

[frigid cloud]

Do easy ones

Like shooting 3 birds, picking up 6 yarrow's, skinning 3 deers

[drifting star]

Ok

Tbh

If I did the hard ones first

I would get bored and give up

[long iris]

augghgghggggg arthurrrrrrrrdd

brrrgger

[hidden moss]

is it just me or rdr1 is boring af

[hidden moss]

man I really tried to love the game

I just get bored after 30 mins

[void pond]

[hidden moss]

You're boring.

RDR1 is more fun than RDR2 will be.

[hidden moss]

what you say cant change what I think

and yes its boring

I'm glad you agreed that RDR2 is boring

I didn't

Yeah you did

[hidden moss]

I said that for rdr1

Alright, walk for 200 minutes and loot a dude for 20000 hours

in rdr2

so you say its boring cause the looting system is bad?

[hidden moss]

and nobody loots bodies in rdr2

its so easy to earn money in rdr2

Not only bodies too.

Exaggerated realism

in rdr2

realism matters

Fun matters too.