red-dead-singleplayer

[sinful knot]

injured/dead probably

[golden storm]

I think all rockstar games are in the same universe

[hidden moss]

Epilogue john an alien

[hollow comet]

no they're not

[narrow jetty]

Maybe, but it would have been different. The whole plot for RDR wouldn't have happened. They wouldn't have kidnapped John's family and made him kill Javier, Bill, and Dutch because they were using Micah for that. After Micah died, they needed someone else, which is why they used John

[golden storm]

franklin is cjs son though

[round hedge]

dude

[hollow comet]

new york doesn't exist in gta

[round hedge]

that's literally RDR

[sinful knot]

bruh LOL

[round hedge]

Micah didn't exist

and he got caught lmaooo

[pure stirrup]

When can i see the enne anne swan bounty hang?

[sinful knot]

Micah wouldnt affect anything in RDR

[round hedge]

Jesus Christ

[hollow comet]

what would have happened if they had never found sadie

[narrow jetty]

Holy shit I'm talking about in the context of the prequel lmao

[round hedge]

the context of RDR already explains what happened

[narrow jetty]

The prequel explains the events of RDR1 and how they took place

[round hedge]

and RDR2 completely retcons it

yes

[sinful knot]

RDR2 is full of retcons

[keen birch]

Read if Arthur, Lenny, Hosea and John sucks.

[round hedge]

it's easier to think this way than try to make sense

[hollow comet]

i think jack is a victim of incest

[sinful knot]

What

[narrow jetty]

Not necessarily lmao, RDR2 canonically explains the events that led up to RDR1,

[hollow comet]

I don't like dutch

[round hedge]

RDR reason for John getting caught: I did bad shit in the gang and they caught my family because of it

[hidden moss]

Dutch is intriguing ngl

[hollow comet]

Why can't I murder pearson?

in rhodes

[round hedge]

RDR2 reason: haha revenge made me get caught

[hollow comet]

bad

[sinful knot]

see everybody shits on rdr1 for its graphics when it had a way better soundtrack than rdr2

[hollow comet]

they should remaster rdr

[sinful knot]

they literally reused an la noire theme for one of rdr2's wanted theme

[hidden moss]

Rdr1 still holds up well today I reckon

[sinful knot]

LOL

[narrow jetty]

I mean this is still true in RDR2, it's just more detailed

[golden storm]

would Sean have stuck with dutch or been with Arthur in chapter 6

[round hedge]

RDR graphics still look gorgeous

[hollow comet]

yes they should

[round hedge]

you mean completely different

[hidden moss]

Rdr1 and 2 both had outstanding soundtracks but idk if I can pick one

[narrow jetty]

Yeah RDR graphics are amazing even now

[sinful knot]

rdr sunsets are way more gorgeous than the second game's

[hollow comet]

can't and shouldn't isn't the same

[round hedge]

RDR goes from "people don't forget, nothing gets forgiven" to "revenge = bad" plot

[hollow comet]

its not revenge thats bad

its dutch

[narrow jetty]

No, they still caught John because he did bad things in a gang, RDR2 just elaborates and goes into the specifics lol

[sinful knot]

in rdr2 the soundtrack doesnt even come close to rdr1

[hollow comet]

his type of revenge is killing the richest man in america

killing off a big family

yes fuck rdr1

never played it but fuck it

[sinful knot]

RDR2 is full of retcons bruh

[hidden moss]

I havent played rdr1 in a good long time

[hollow comet]

they should remaster it with rdr2 graphics

[sinful knot]

rdr1 has way better ragdolls than rdr2

[hidden moss]

Kinda miss it

[hollow comet]

and better storyline

to explain blackwater

anybody else wanted more of guarma

[narrow jetty]

Kinda depends on what you like, The RDR1 music is more western and energetic, rdr2's music is more like a dark drama

[sinful knot]

Jesus you've never played a single game in 2008-2010 have you

[hollow comet]

?

[hidden moss]

Rdr1s drunk physics were fun

[sinful knot]

Sure

and yet you praise rdr2

what

[hollow comet]

fuck gta 5

remaster it!

wait nvm

[hidden moss]

Idk why they got rid of those fun ragdoll physics from gta iv and rdr1

[sinful knot]

rdr1 had better combat themes, and what does rdr2 have? "thicc widow badass revenge bad"

is literally it

[round hedge]

soundtracks definitely not

[narrow jetty]

Both RDR1 and RDR2 are incredible can we stop fighting lol

[hidden moss]

Idk rdr2 had an unreal soundtrack

[sinful knot]

i dont believe you've played rdr1 or IV before

[narrow jetty]

RDR2's soundtrack was also fantastic

[round hedge]

tfw when you gotta change the first game for the second to make sense

[round hedge]

combat and most missions soundtracks were boring

[sinful knot]

and ofc this was after you bought rdr2

[round hedge]

alongside the ambient OST

[hidden moss]

I think I prefer the rdr2 soundtrack but are just so good

[hollow comet]

I have played a ton of rockstar games

ranging from gta v to rdr2

[sinful knot]

sure...

[round hedge]

walking in RDR2 is so boring because of the bland music

there's no charm into it

[sinful knot]

rdr1 had way better soundtracks, ambient and combat

[hollow comet]

you're so boring

boom

[round hedge]

walking in new austin in RDR tho

[hidden moss]

Most of what I remember from rdr1 is deadmans gun, the main theme and the outlaws return

[sinful knot]

ah i havent? let me show you some screenshots

[hollow comet]

roasted

[round hedge]

the OST 🤌

[hollow comet]

get rekt

yeah yeah you're right

[sinful knot]

Ive literally played it before and took screenshots

[hollow comet]

true

yeah thats a good point

[narrow jetty]

Well it depends on what you like, RDR1 is more acardey and spaghetti western, rdr2 is more realistic and raw

[hidden moss]

I think the mission soundtracks in rdr2 were better but I'd give the ambient stuff to rdr1

[round hedge]

what

[sinful knot]

and so have i shared screenshots here

want me to share them again?

[narrow jetty]

RDR2 is more like a simulation, RDR1 is more like a game

[hollow comet]

stop leave me alone you're supposed to ignore me

[sinful knot]

rdr2 fanboys

[hidden moss]

Ehh I liked it

[hollow comet]

yeah, thats true

you're not wrong

yeash

true

[narrow jetty]

ok RDR1's storyline is amazing wtf

[hollow comet]

not wrong

i agree with that

[hidden moss]

I think the sheer amount of detail in rdr2 really made me appreciate it a lot

[round hedge]

at least RDR storyline doesn't get confused midway like RDR2

[sinful knot]

and you can literally do the same thing with rdr2, let me just get arthur sick and shoot him in the head

[hollow comet]

good point, good point

[narrow jetty]

both RDR2 and RDR1 have amazing stories that complement each other perfectly

[hollow comet]

thats not wrong

yeah, thats good

[hidden moss]

That's just oversimplifiying it tbh

[hollow comet]

you're right

[round hedge]

Nate Johns wanted to get rid of all outlaws

[hollow comet]

how many balls can a camel stick in its mouth

[round hedge]

and that included dutch

[hollow comet]

yeah

[round hedge]

Ross just didn't say that because he enjoys messing with John

[hollow comet]

thats true

[round hedge]

since he has his family hostage

[hollow comet]

exactly!

[pure stirrup]

Where does pearson have his store? Rhodes?

[hollow comet]

true true

[narrow jetty]

yep rhodes

[pure stirrup]

Alr thanks

[sinful knot]

@hidden moss You really think everybody here likes rdr2?

bruh

And about emulator, emulators dont lock at 30fps

thats the difference

meanwhile console is always at 30fps or lower

How long has it since you've gotten an emulator

there is more than one emulator

not just one

[hidden moss]

Branjer has ultra good pc though

[sinful knot]

[hidden moss]

Even me with gtx 1060

can handle RDR1

Emulators are getting better

[sinful knot]

I have an RTX 2080 super, it does pretty well on xenia

thats the point

you have zero knowledge about emulators

so why are you talking

You act like you've used one before

God thats a good one

Then why are you talking is my question

[keen birch]

Unless you actually own the game for that system, don't talk about emulation as it's technically piracy.

[sinful knot]

"Oh i havent driven a car before but i know about them"

Desano plays emulator also

Does it run decent tho?

[summer garnet]

ok

[sinful knot]

ok??

[high pier]

what

petition to add Caps into the game

[keen birch]

Arthur found Lenny in hell where they went.

[sinful knot]

So do the people that have xenia can have "privllages" to talk, thats my final input on it, move on

[high pier]

not flat ones

[hidden moss]

Deep

[hollow comet]

lenny was in heaven

[high pier]

i need to complete my british service outfit

but i dont have a cap

[round hedge]

no he was in hell

[high pier]

and they arent in single player

[round hedge]

all of them were

[hollow comet]

no he was in heaven

nope

nope

nope

[sinful knot]

all of the gang were in hell

[high pier]

sean is in heaven

[hollow comet]

bla bla bla bla bla bla bla bla

@sinful knot abigail and jack?

[hidden moss]

Most of gang members are in hell

[hollow comet]

smh

[round hedge]

oh you mean useless character #4

[hollow comet]

smh

smh

smh

[summer garnet]

dutch micha bill and javier an the calandar bros

[high pier]

no i mean relevant character #4

[sinful knot]

Most of them are, jack didnt even kill anyone while in the gang

[round hedge]

so relevant he only had like 3 mission

missions

before dying

[high pier]

he killed the lizard

[round hedge]

and wasn't important in the story until he fucking died

[high pier]

what about kieran

[hidden moss]

Sean was great all the same tbh

[high pier]

i cant even remember any of his missions

even if he had one

[hidden moss]

Kieran might be expection tbh

[round hedge]

Sean, Kieran and Lenny

the useless trio

[sinful knot]

Yea bro was so important with barely any screentime with only arthur thinking about him after his head was popped

[hidden moss]

Gotta appreciate Kieran for saving Arthur's life

[hollow comet]

Most useless characters in rdr2 gang
5. Tilly
4. Sean
3. The irish girl
2. Kieran

1. The pastor

or priest or whatever

[sinful knot]

literally all he did

[round hedge]

fax

[sinful knot]

mostly useless

[hidden moss]

Most gang members is so fucking useless tbh

they get like 1-2 screentime

Useless sure but I still liked him just based on personality

[summer garnet]

holy shit forgot abt molly lamo

[hollow comet]

the only useful females are the fat chick and sadie

[sinful knot]

"I saved your life arthur" then isnt important in the story until he gets killed

[high pier]

most useless characters 5 abigail 4 john 3 arthur 2 dutch 1 micah

[round hedge]

stay salty

[high pier]

arthur sucks

[sinful knot]

number 2 should be sean

[hollow comet]

bro is he joking?

[round hedge]

the writers wanted to add so many characters but forgot about them midway

[summer garnet]

i mean his name is literally sean

[round hedge]

and only remembered they existed when they wanted to kill them lol

[hollow comet]

abigal's usefulness was carrying john's sperm and providing him a reason to live

[sinful knot]

sean only becomes important after he dies

[hidden moss]

There was maybe too many gang members, it's hard to build up a connection with em all

[high pier]

so does jesus

[round hedge]

well

[hidden moss]

Sean was never mentioned after his death though

lmao

[round hedge]

he's not wrong

[high pier]

he was

[hollow comet]

whenever a gang member died, its like they were erased from everyone's memory

[hidden moss]

only 2-3 times

And never again

[summer garnet]

he was briefly mentioned in battle of shady belle but thats it

[sinful knot]

only a few times and then forgotten about like every other death in the gang

[high pier]

sean is hesus

jesuahd

hes jus

[round hedge]

and then there's Arthur that john couldn't forget after a while decade 🗿

[high pier]

jesus

[round hedge]

*whole

[high pier]

gtg adio

[hidden moss]

Feel like arthur shouldve talked bout hosea more since he knew him for like 20 years

[hollow comet]

john and arthur had gay sex

[sinful knot]

rdr1 had a gritty feeling to it while rdr2 has cowboy jesus

[hollow comet]

the cowboy outfit is the ugliest outfit ive ever seen

the saint denis with a white hat is amazing

[summer garnet]

fr

[sinful knot]

with arthur marston yeah

trash bag gloves

[hollow comet]

arthur marston?

who the fuck is arthur marston

[round hedge]

it completely sucks in RDR2

[sinful knot]

long story

[round hedge]

it's not even close to RDR

[summer garnet]

jarthur morgston

[hollow comet]

oh they had gay sex so they became one

[round hedge]

cowboy outfit in RDR2 barely manages to be a cosplay

[sinful knot]

basically arthur reskin you play as in the epilogue

[summer garnet]

and too tight west

[hollow comet]

okay

btw why did i have to redo marco dragic mission

i hated it

[sinful knot]

his belt is bigger than his vest which creates a little void on the side

[round hedge]

tell me one outfit from epilogue that looks good

epilogue exclusive

[hidden moss]

Whenever I talk to my dad bout rdr2, he mentions the one thing he hated was the first Marko dragic mission with the boats

[round hedge]

only thing that looks good is the western coat 🗿

[sinful knot]

rdr1 duster is hot

[hidden moss]

her husband got literally killed by some drunk guys

[round hedge]

true

[sinful knot]

yeah

[round hedge]

oh yeah, my dog died

[summer garnet]

winter cowboy

[round hedge]

time to learn how to shoot professionally out of nowhere

[hidden moss]

Yellow ranch gloves but u need mods to obtain it

Wasnt there a hat in rdr1 that would give you immunity from police?

[round hedge]

looks like shit

[hollow comet]

I have a few complaints about arthur or john

• holsters aren't to the left and to the right
• how the fuck do they carry arrows?
  -There are 20 revolvers in the horse's saddle bags
• johns scars are disgusting
• their faces are always dirty

[hidden moss]

Ah

[sinful knot]

arthur marston's cowboy outfit with the western coat

[hidden moss]

That was fun

[summer garnet]

wait i meant western coat shit

[hidden moss]

bro compared literally a dog to a human life

[round hedge]

yeah because it's just as stupid

[sinful knot]

johns scars are badass, and ofc their faces will be dirty its not like they had skin care products in the 1800s

[hidden moss]

im done arguing ill just agree with u dumb mfs

[round hedge]

wouldn't mind Sadie becoming good if it actually had proper development

[hidden moss]

Ye we should’ve had a quiver for arrows

That’d look so cool

[round hedge]

instead of changing clothes = skills

[round hedge]

there was one

[sinful knot]

damn u killed him

[hidden moss]

There was :o

[round hedge]

but it was removed

[hidden moss]

Whyy

[round hedge]

yeah there's a mod that restores it

[hidden moss]

Console player here :/

[round hedge]

bow is a stupid weapon in RDR2 which doesn't make sense

[hidden moss]

Also horse holster

[summer garnet]

same

[round hedge]

change my mind

[hidden moss]

man

Ditto

[sinful knot]

explosive arrows

[hidden moss]

I'd prefer RDR1 weapon system

Without need of that dumbass horse

Infinite pockets

[sinful knot]

i loved the ragdolls in rdr1

[hidden moss]

Give me rifle holster, no off hand holster

The ragdolls were great in it ngl

[summer garnet]

tomohawks they dont even reach thier target half the time

[sinful knot]

Gonna whip out my explosive bow in 1899

[round hedge]

imagine ripping a skull in half with a tomahawk tho

should've been a thing in the vanilla game 😔

[hidden moss]

The ragdolls were just more fun then

[sinful knot]

the wonders of the euphoria engine

GTA IV basically has the same effect

[hidden moss]

I love using the bow tho😄

So much fun

[hidden moss]

he didnt, he compared his dog dying to a woman seeing his husband getting killed and she being kidnapped in a basement will the guys that killed him get drunk in her house

[sinful knot]

Humans arent any smarter than animals??

[summer garnet]

why do you need bow when youre shooting everything you see lamo

[round hedge]

Sadie had no experience at shooting while getting shot at

[hidden moss]

Fun. Poison arrows + bow + stealth killing

[round hedge]

but is suddenly as good as outlaws

[hidden moss]

It’s awesome😄

[round hedge]

that were shooting since 20 years ago

the realism is incredible innit

[hidden moss]

xD

I got tired of the bow from those hunting requests

[sinful knot]

yeah purple gun wraps in 1898 also

realistic

[summer garnet]

and then tried to make her too badass

[hidden moss]

bro she literally says she used to go hunting while her husband did house work

[hidden moss]

I also wondered about their farm, like it’s snowy there. What did they farm, horses?

[round hedge]

getting shot at is a whole different thing

but nah, let's make her be as skilled as Arthur and John

[hidden moss]

Unless shes hunting o driscolls, it ain't the same

[round hedge]

because her husband died of course

[sinful knot]

mhm boo hoo husband die

[hidden moss]

Sadie was able to take on 3 lemoyne raiders with a knife in shady belle. Or something like that. Makes sense

[sinful knot]

not every widow in the 1800s went crazy and turned into a gunslinger

[summer garnet]

because her husband dies she gets 100% more accury and more plot armour makes sense

[round hedge]

HER BUSBAND DIED!

[hidden moss]

yup

[round hedge]

SHE'S NOW SKILLED

SHUT UP IT'S REALSITIC

[sinful knot]

Which is unrealistic killing 3 armed odriscolls with one single knife

how tf is that even possible

[hidden moss]

Yea its mad

Dead husbands be giving you some mad skills

[round hedge]

Sadie do be getting that isekai plot armor

[golden storm]

what outfit combo can make me look fancy

[summer garnet]

NO DUDE ITS REALISM YOU WONT UNDERSTAND

[round hedge]

gonna become gay and marry a guy

so if someone kills him

I'll become as skilled as John Marston

[sinful knot]

REALISM THE ARMED ODRISCOLLS IMMEDIATELY GOT BONERS FROM SADIE AND DROPPED THEIR WEAPONS

[hidden moss]

You'll develop deadeye

[round hedge]

ill develop irl plot armor

[hidden moss]

Sulkii has plot armor in irl

[round hedge]

me on my way to become irl protagonist

[sinful knot]

anyways im gonna grab a bowl of lasagna

[hidden moss]

Avoid being epilogue protagonist

[sinful knot]

so is all the other women in the camp 🤷

especially karen

[summer garnet]

damn im just stuck with boiled rice ik u ddidnt ask but still

[hidden moss]

Karen fucked sean as soon as he was rescued

[sinful knot]

how do we know the women in camp havent fucked a man once, they clearly knew what they were doing in the tent

lol

[round hedge]

why would a 1800s gang keep women in the gang

for anything other than sex

[sinful knot]

lets get some women and put them to work

nobody in 1800

[round hedge]

women were basically considered useless during those times

[hidden moss]

Fuck people who need fucking

[summer garnet]

FEED PEOPLE NEED FEEDING

[round hedge]

and only for breeding

[sinful knot]

women didnt even have rights

[round hedge]

and Karen certainly looked like a whore in an early gang artwork

[sinful knot]

yep

karen has for sure fucked a dude before

no doubt

[summer garnet]

yeppers

[round hedge]

massive badonkers

[frigid cloud]

Sean

[sinful knot]

giant personalities

[spring sluice]

Ik Abigail was most definitely

[hidden moss]

sean and Karen did the deed in jhons tent

[frigid cloud]

Miss grimshaw tried to force her into prostitution again so definitely

[spring sluice]

Wait what

During that bank robbery mission

[summer garnet]

i mean she was a hooker before she joined the gang

[spring sluice]

Who

[frigid cloud]

Does that explain John's daughter then?

[upper fox]

goddamn the mods in this server dont like jokes

[summer garnet]

yes

[frigid cloud]

ah okay

Good to know

[summer garnet]

basically every discord mod

[mighty pecan]

hello people

[summer garnet]

hi

[spring sluice]

hello

[upper fox]

got muted for 1 day for posting two pictures in the wrong channel

[mighty pecan]

[frigid cloud]

Tahiti rat lumbago insist meme gets deleted

[hidden moss]

Mods only like jokes if you're a discord kitten egirl telling the jokes

[summer garnet]

i got muted for 6 hours cus i wasnt saying rdr2 here

[mighty pecan]

I wonder why

[frigid cloud]

y

[hidden moss]

W

[sinful knot]

we cook a lot during weekends, steak, mac n cheese, salmon etc

[summer garnet]

[upper fox]

i posted a meme about rockstar milking gta online then a mod told me to post in another channel and then i responded wih the i dont think i will meme

[summer garnet]

oh yea i did see that

[upper fox]

then boom muted for 6 hours then i joined with a alt said you cant escape and then boom alt banned and mute extended to 24 hours

[frigid cloud]

Surprised you didn't get banned for having an alt

[vestal sail]

I was just googling the solution to this problem and sadly there is none other than starting a new save or loading an older one before the Epilogue. One less thing you can do at Beecher's Hope..

[keen birch]

it's people just trying to downplay their warns or mutes so they can make staff look dumb af
I see it happens here as well.

[summer garnet]

why does he run like arthur in the property more reason for my arthur took johns skin headcanon

[upper fox]

keep dreaming

its never gonna happen

[summer garnet]

yep

[vestal sail]

Yeah his walking/running animations are Arthur's at Beecher's but outside of it he uses his own unique ones.

[upper fox]

hi mod did u miss me

[summer garnet]

yE sAd LiFe

[vestal sail]

I know.

[upper fox]

[frigid cloud]

I miss that old quote feature

[vestal sail]

I hope a mod fixes this specific issue soon.

[hidden moss]

Well

[hidden moss]

Hi how are
Would you like to Play RDR

John Marston animation mod

gives John's animation to beecher's hope

so no more Arthur's animation

guys check this out

[sinful knot]

John's rdr walk

and idle

[upper fox]

angrier face, walk animations, carry animations, weapon point animations etc.

definitly one of the top mods

[vestal sail]

Yeah I've seen that mod.

[hidden moss]

bruh can anyone tell me why can't i send a link??

[frigid cloud]

Only in #general-media and #red-dead-media

[vestal sail]

It's a bit buggy but once the bugs are fixed perhaps I will get it.

[hidden moss]

thank you

[sinful knot]

so far the new updates dont have bugs

[hidden moss]

Rest in peace stylish cat

he got banned

[upper fox]

branjer or desano do one of guys know where the equipment section is of all item menu mod?

[vestal sail]

Uhhh like holsters, bandoliers, etc?

[upper fox]

yes

[hidden moss]

just go to cltohes

[vestal sail]

If I recall it's just under clothing

[hidden moss]

and u will find it

[upper fox]

found it thanks

[hidden moss]

Next weapon equipment mod is gonna be awesome

It makes John's equipment look closer to RDR1 now

[sinful knot]

i stopped using that mod

[upper fox]

the one from Eki?

[hidden moss]

yeah

[sinful knot]

yeah

[upper fox]

awesome

[sinful knot]

ekis bandoiler is awesome

[hidden moss]

I have a picture

#red-dead-media

[vestal sail]

I just use JMRP

[upper fox]

I saw it it looked awesome

[hidden moss]

Eki gave it to me for test

It will be released soon

[upper fox]

cool

[vestal sail]

Is that just a texture mod for the regular one?

[hidden moss]

?

[vestal sail]

The bandolier

[hidden moss]

John's bandolier is retexture of upgraded bandolier

[vestal sail]

Ah okay

Will likely get that once it's released

[hidden moss]

Yeah it's good

It makes equipment look closer to RDR1 John's equipment

[vestal sail]

I really like the latest release of JMRP

[hidden moss]

nice

did u install 1.00 fitment?

It gives John's 1.00 body

[vestal sail]

Yes

[hidden moss]

nice

[upper fox]

i really like the open rancher vest idk why

[vestal sail]

He no longer has Arthur's shoulders

[vestal sail]

Same

[hidden moss]

I'm wearing cowboy outfit

too addicting

[vestal sail]

I wear the cowboy outfit with RDR1 duster coat

[upper fox]

i really like all of john's outfits

[vestal sail]

Am I the only one that really likes his Chapter 2 - 6 clothing? Like the one with the buckskin vest and shotgun coat?

[upper fox]

john's npc clothes are great

[hidden moss]

no

Rockstar was about to give us OG John and his gang clothes for epilogue

then they said fuck it

and gave us Arthur reskin

[upper fox]

i hate it how john got worse over updates

[hidden moss]

john's face in rd2 epilogue looks like a sak of meat

[vestal sail]

The latest JMRP update adds his NPC shirt and his shotgun coat outfit looks identical to his NPC one.

I actually enjoy playing as John now

before on PS4 it was meh

[hidden moss]

JMRP added his npc clothes for epilogue

like entirely fixed epilogue John

[upper fox]

r* fucked up with epilogue john and thats how people prefer arthur over john

[hidden moss]

I’ve decided my head canon john will be based on someone else’s theory that Jack saw his sister die and that made john hardened. And his song is “The Man Comes Around”- Johnny Cash

I know it’s most likely how it not went but, I like it-

[vestal sail]

My head canon is that Arthur left his hair, shoulders, ears, and face in his satchel once he gave it to John.

[hidden moss]

spoiler

[hidden moss]

John Morgan

do y'all think john deserved death at the end of red dead 1?

[hidden moss]

In a non bias prospective yes

[knotty sigil]

yes

because he knows that it is risky

[hidden moss]

He knew the risk

[knotty sigil]

he always knew the government will never be that kind, theres always a catch

[hidden moss]

Well he grew up around the gang. Was the only life he knew

[knotty sigil]

dutch also told him that before he jump off the cliff

[hidden moss]

I think everyone who died deserved it

Some more than others I suppose

They were criminals that were murderers

[hidden moss]

even arthur morgan?

[hidden moss]

Yes

[vestal sail]

He should have left Beecher's once he reunited with his family.

[hidden moss]

In a non bias stand point

lol yea

We play as bad guys in the entirety of red dead

and john has like 20 k in his pocket

[vestal sail]

John never was the smartest, even Arthur says that.

[hidden moss]

can't even buy a blanket to jack

He didn’t even buy the furniture

Maybe if Jack wouldn’t be so intimidated he would

[knotty sigil]

the smartest of them all probably is javier

or trelawny because he just keeps disappearing

lmao

[hidden moss]

Javier is hot

[vestal sail]

Trelawny or arguably Micah

Hosea too

[hidden moss]

Micah was the smartest

Of all the members of the van der linde band, who was the one who most deserved death? (aside from micah lol)

[knotty sigil]

dutch

[hidden moss]

Dutch

[vestal sail]

Bill at the end of RDR1

[hidden moss]

I think it's more wisdom than intelligence for most characters

[knotty sigil]

he manipulated both gang with arthur and with those in rdr1

[hidden moss]

In the prospective of the law micah didn’t deserve it as much

[hidden moss]

dude just killed a family and a little girl lol

Everyone’s so quick to hate on Micah because they’re looking at it from the gangs POV

[hidden moss]

Sounds normal

No hes genuinely a detestable character

[knotty sigil]

no micah also deserved to die no argue

[hidden moss]

From any perspective

Yeah he’s a count

Cunt*

But he’s a great character because you hate him

Hes a great villain no doubt

[hidden moss]

peter blomquist acting was awesome

[summer garnet]

he killed tons of law men and a little girl

[keen birch]

[hidden moss]

So did Javier

[summer garnet]

ok and?

[vestal sail]

When he mocked Arthur's sickness I really started to hate him.

[hidden moss]

uh

[vestal sail]

I tried to dynamite his feet

[hidden moss]

When he said “black lung” I hated him

I loved seeing charles throwing him on his ass

[frigid cloud]

Micah's greetings are best such as : cowpoke

[hidden moss]

What side quests should I do now that I’ve finished epilogue?

[vestal sail]

At the beginning I always assumed it was a friendly rivalry between the both

[hidden moss]

i liked micah at the beggining of the game, i thought he was funny and badass

[frigid cloud]

Hamish's to get Buell

[hidden moss]

I WAS MISTAKING

[upper fox]

evelyn miller side quest

[vestal sail]

Visit Charlotte

[hidden moss]

Oki

[summer garnet]

that american inferno burnt out one

[hidden moss]

Do them all

[hidden moss]

Who?

[keen birch]

Always get Buell before end of Chapter 6.

[vestal sail]

I have Buell as John

[summer garnet]

lets just ignore

[hidden moss]

What if I go and kill Charolette

[upper fox]

did you even pay attention to the story of rdr2 lol

[hidden moss]

@lost moss U got back from Gulag

[frigid cloud]

Evelyn miller in chapter 4

[hidden moss]

Yes-

Ohhhh

Bug brain

[frigid cloud]

You can

[upper fox]

clearly you didnt

[lost moss]

I luckily did

[hidden moss]

I completely forgot bout Evelyn Miller until I replayed the game

[hidden moss]

I just remembered I have a horrible memory

[lost moss]

It was a accidental ban

[hidden moss]

Isn’t he the mayor?

[summer garnet]

no the author

[hidden moss]

Bro

I’m kinda slow

Dutch likes books by him

References him a lot

[hidden moss]

ah

[frigid cloud]

John mentions him as well

[summer garnet]

that dutch always adores and reads his books

[hidden moss]

How do I get the money from that gun slinger book?

[frigid cloud]

What money

[hidden moss]

Oh yea I still have to finish that

The share the author promised us

[frigid cloud]

o you don't get any

[hidden moss]

So he lied to us

Weirdly enough no prompt shows up for the last part of that mission for me

don't judge me but...sometimes i can't believe that people cries at the end of rdr2,cus i think it's just a videogame

lol

[hidden moss]

I cried when my horse died

And during Arthur’s last ride

[summer garnet]

thats very judgable

[hidden moss]

I didn’t cry when Arthur died though because I thought it would happen

You're not really seeing the bigger picture if ya downplay it as "just a game"

The what?

There’s panthers?

[frigid cloud]

Cougars too bro

[hidden moss]

I use that saddle all the time but havent even looked at the effects

[summer garnet]

i was stoned asf i didnt think arthur would die but was only able to find out when micha mentioned him

[hidden moss]

Trying to track cougars and panthers sucks

Should I finish the side quest before going on the challenge shit

[frigid cloud]

Master hunter 6 sucks because of cougars

[hidden moss]

Yea but the panther usually finds you before you find it

[summer garnet]

just check south of pronghorn ranch theres a common cougar spawn

[hidden moss]

Where can I find him?

[summer garnet]

point

[frigid cloud]

Ocreaghs run

[summer garnet]

ocreaghs run grizzlies east

[hidden moss]

Where did the natives go?

[frigid cloud]

Moved on

[summer garnet]

they went to canada

[hidden moss]

some random guy in a youtube comment section told me that i wasn't a human being because i went for the money lol

[hidden moss]

I found em south of Rhodes. I just mean trying to track a panther to 100% that compendium entry for them

[hidden moss]

I went for the money my first time

Because I thought John would get it

It was bad ass as hell

[frigid cloud]

Isn't that cougar??

[hidden moss]

Sliced micah the fuck go

yeah well my first time i had low honor

and micah stabbed me in the ass

Cougars and panthers always just find me first

No I’m at valentine and I’m On my way!

Damn

[frigid cloud]

You get to catch legendary fish

[hidden moss]

I should visit charolette after

I wanna kill her but I love her

[frigid cloud]

And Marybeth

[hidden moss]

Just 3 more legendary fish

Where are Mary Beth and tiy?

Tilly**

[frigid cloud]

And rains fall

Tilly in saint denis

[hidden moss]

Tilly is in saint Denis I think

[frigid cloud]

Near the tailor

[hidden moss]

rain falls is at annesburg station

Good memories

I made johns rdr1 cover outfit-

The one with the bandolier

spoilers:

LOL

k

i won't

For what game?

nah

[summer garnet]

yes cougar sorry

[hidden moss]

What game?

it's if you meet rain falls

You gotta expect to get spoiled here lol

[frigid cloud]

Are y'all talking about rdr1 or I'm missing something

[hidden moss]

Dude listening to “Dead Mans Gun” is so beautiful while riding

Outstanding song

[summer garnet]

i meant cougar sorry

[hidden moss]

Sure yea I'm ok with finding both haha

I need to find Arthur’s grace

Grave*

Ik where to find em...

Can I find Mary Linton?

[frigid cloud]

No

[hidden moss]

For I can shoot her

Just tracking them I mean

[frigid cloud]

But she appears in the credits

[hidden moss]

Is difficult cuz they charge me beforehand

[summer garnet]

is it in cumberland forest or grizzlies?

[frigid cloud]

You can rob him

[hidden moss]

Does he know it’s you?

Mary's missions were kinda boring imo

[frigid cloud]

Of course

[hidden moss]

What does he say?

[frigid cloud]

He recognizes you

And talks about others

[hidden moss]

Oh I meant when you rob him

[frigid cloud]

What d hell joun

[hidden moss]

anyone noticed that if you meet rain falls in epilogue he has alzheimer's??

Jokingly?

I don't have the heart to rob him lmao

Pearson’s such a loveable guy

[frigid cloud]

You can find gang's photo in his store too btw

[hidden moss]

Felt a bit bad when arthur was kinda cold towards him at the start

[knotty sigil]

no uncle lumbago is 😩

[hidden moss]

I feel like he’d give good hugs

[frigid cloud]

Chapter 1 everyone gets roasted by authur

[hidden moss]

True that

There’s a old guy with no leg

Is that him?

That's mickey isnt it

(Talking about hamish

[frigid cloud]

Or veteran in rhodes

Oh yeah hes

[hidden moss]

i once donated like 2 deers and 2 rabits to camp... 2 days later pearson told me: We'Re GoNnA nEeD mOrE FoOd Mr MoRgAn.

[frigid cloud]

Greet him

[hidden moss]

I already love this guy

[summer garnet]

but he begs for food every 2 hours

[hidden moss]

I never gave food

Y’all

[frigid cloud]

Get lote satchel

[hidden moss]

My Johns hair kinda looks like his

That’s a beautiful horse

[hidden moss]

i donated food throughout the whole game until pearson left the camp

Wait I have this type of horse in online

i once asked myself if i could donate dog or horse meat...

so i shot a few dogs and horses

Not Golden but the same breed

[frigid cloud]

Nice

[hidden moss]

I’d his questions like fun?

[summer garnet]

i wish you could adds to the REALISM

[hidden moss]

you could skin horses in red dead 1

Adult Jack looks like Javier sorta like a mix of him and John

so i thought...

lol

[soft flame]

How to catch legendary catfish

[hidden moss]

Is Jack’s johns son confirmed?

[summer garnet]

ye cus of the bread and moustace

[frigid cloud]

You can't.

Uncatchable

[soft flame]

Wtf

[hidden moss]

maybe not john's biological son but john was his father

he raised him like ass but he became better

Jack’s intimated and it’s sad

[frigid cloud]

John didn't give a shit about jack till chapter 3 end

[summer garnet]

get all special river lures in lagras then search up legedary fish locations boom you can complete ez 1 hour

[frigid cloud]

HE SAid legendary catfish

[round hedge]

yes

[hidden moss]

He means the canal one

[soft flame]

Ive got all the other fish, just the catfish eludes me

[round hedge]

jack is exactly like John

so yeah he's his son

[frigid cloud]

Catfish is uncatchable

Don't bother

[summer garnet]

ye its cathcable go ahead

[hidden moss]

You can’t catch the canal one

[frigid cloud]

No it's not

[hidden moss]

antisocial and dumb,but also a badass when adult?

Just did the hamish mission

I love him so far

Yes

Very beautiful horse

can't you just kill hamish and take buell?

Lol

What’s the best gun for hunting legendary bear?

[frigid cloud]

No

Gotta wait till the end

[hidden moss]

Who the hell would do that

[summer garnet]

i mean its 200 pounds you would need a tow truck

[frigid cloud]

Anything

[summer garnet]

rifle or dynamite

[frigid cloud]

Stand on a rock and shoot it with anything you think that's powerful

[hidden moss]

I wanna get the pelt for the jacket

[frigid cloud]

And also legendary animals don't spawn till you inspect the clues

[soft flame]

Rolling block rifle

[hidden moss]

What about Carcano?

[frigid cloud]

cap

[hidden moss]

Blasphemy

[frigid cloud]

Like I said doesn't matter

Use anything

Repeater or rifle

Or shotgun

[hidden moss]

Does it give anything good?

Is it the same one arthur hunted with Hosea?

[soft flame]

That works too

[frigid cloud]

You can craft a hat with it

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[hidden moss]

This man is panning for gold

Ima hunt the bear

No-

[soft flame]

Yea

[frigid cloud]

gets attacked by the bear immediately

[hidden moss]

Where do I look?

[frigid cloud]

Inspect all the clues

With eagle eye

Otherwise it won't spawn

[hidden moss]

I see a clue-

[summer garnet]

o creaghs run again

[frigid cloud]

Inspect it

[soft flame]

Go to the area where it is in the map, and use eagle eye, find the clues, and then u find the bear, kill it before it kills you

[hidden moss]

I’m scared

[frigid cloud]

You'll be fine

[hidden moss]

Explosive bullets help

[summer garnet]

YOULL BE ALRIGHT BOAH

[frigid cloud]

Legendaries are a piece of cake

[hidden moss]

Swear the legendary moose took like two explosive rifle bullets for me

That

Was

Easy

[soft flame]

I just used highly velocity bullets for all

[frigid cloud]

Express more damage

[hidden moss]

That was the easiest kill of my life

[frigid cloud]

High velocity for longer range

[hidden moss]

Express my go to

Explosive is for those real special ones

[soft flame]

legendary animals are no more difficult than regular ones

[hidden moss]

So do o go to the trapper?

[frigid cloud]

You overthinked it

[hidden moss]

They're a lot stronger usually

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[soft flame]

@hidden moss yea just sell the pelt to the trapper

[hidden moss]

Legendary moose is a true beast

[summer garnet]

yes sell it then craf the garment of your choice

[frigid cloud]

And you're able to craft the hat and jack

I forgot where was it but it's called bear hunter

[soft flame]

I still haven’t gotten the money from legendary fish and its been days since I mailed it

[frigid cloud]

Dragging a bear to the trapper?

[hidden moss]

Bruh

My horse just died from a little fall

[summer garnet]

reload save to get the horse back

[frigid cloud]

Well that's why you need to have horse revivers

Huh it already died so that wouldn't matter

^

[round hedge]

John isn't dumb lol

[hidden moss]

Abigail would disagree

[frigid cloud]

She's lame

[hidden moss]

Made it to the trapper

Most people sees epilogue John only smh

Bro

If they ever played RDR1

[hushed flare]

z

[hidden moss]

The trapper just made me wanted for trespassing

I’m confused

[hushed flare]

6 hour slow mode in red dead media lol

Rip those people who want to send a bunch of pics at once

[summer garnet]

bruh moment

[hidden moss]

I’m gonna cry

[hushed flare]

ok

[hidden moss]

I just made a camp now my pelts gone

[hushed flare]

Micah death was the saddest

legendary pelts?

[hidden moss]

You sure?

[hushed flare]

I thought only legendary pelts do that tho

o

[hidden moss]

I swear this Murfree guy is annoying

Ow

[hushed flare]

Murfree horses look like zombies

[hidden moss]

Wish they got Micah

[summer garnet]

you cant even heal or change them

[hidden moss]

We should scalp micah

[summer garnet]

my horse just slows down when im abt to get ambushed

[hushed flare]

go to beaver hollow before or after chapter 6 for a suprise

beaver hollow is actually my local plant farm

[hidden moss]

I have to kill a bison for the coat

[hushed flare]

Murfrees drop ginseng, violet snowdrop, yarrow, currant from what I've seen

[summer garnet]

why do they keep plants in thier pockets

[hidden moss]

How do I find the legendary panther? I want the cloak

[summer garnet]

you have to do master hunter challenges

[hidden moss]

Murfrees helped me get burdock root for herb 7

And what do I do for that

How do I check my progress?

[frigid cloud]

Master hunter 6

[summer garnet]

my brain is fried rn

[hidden moss]

Master hunter?

[hushed flare]

Well they can't exactly use money

[frigid cloud]

Or like 3

[hushed flare]

Same with skinners

[hidden moss]

Was master hunter 6 killing the cougars with a bow?

I have to get 3 rabbits

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[hushed flare]

Same with nitefolk

[summer garnet]

for 9 just go to lone mule stead for the opposum

[hidden moss]

heartlands are the best place for rabbits

Ah yea I just kept going to the area around the trapper near strawberry

[frigid cloud]

Skin 3 perfect rabbits

[hidden moss]

Great spawn area

Wait the hamish mission. Here

Another Question for everyone: what do you think was the most badass moment of arthur morgan and/or John Marston?

John pointing that shotgun at the guy in the barn

[frigid cloud]

His death authur Morgan

[hidden moss]

And for Arthur walking up to the mansion

That was my thought top lol

Too

[summer garnet]

that part in magician of sport where he interrogates a bounty hunter after killing one of them

[hidden moss]

Or Arthur walking back for the money

Never liked that ending tbh

[hushed flare]

I liked go back for the money high honor

[hidden moss]

Yeah because Micah becomes Scarface pt 2

Felt better helping john get to safety

[hushed flare]

Both low honor endings feel like what Micah would do

[hidden moss]

he was just furious that's why he acted badass

Arthur dying on a mountain when the sun rises hits diff

But Arthur looking up at beaver hollow

[hushed flare]

Arthur getting stabbed in the back literally hits diff

Lololoo

[summer garnet]

yessir

[hidden moss]

his face when it happens tho

[hushed flare]

painful death

[hidden moss]

Damn you..

Glad I never experienced those endings for myself lol

[frigid cloud]

I did

[hidden moss]

DamN us BOTH

AgHhh

[hushed flare]

death

[hidden moss]

pew

Not much of a redemption lmao

Micah got mad at that line

[hushed flare]

Go back for the money was basically revenge

[hidden moss]

i think the low honor endings are also redemption, You help john as a act of redemption but you also pay for your sins

But Arthur doesnt change his ways

[hushed flare]

I wonder why John and Arthur couldn't have just went for the money

[hidden moss]

Low honor is more realistic

John had to get away from pinkertons ig

[hidden moss]

"i head down there im dead in five minutes" john said

[summer garnet]

everyday rdr2 chat hating arthur marstan and being philosophical abt the last ending

[hidden moss]

john was injured he could barely use a gun

[frigid cloud]

Imagine Micah had a sawed off shotgun instead of a revolver in low honor ending

[hidden moss]

Honestly the worst is seeing nitpicking bout epilogue john

I wish Micah blew Arthur’s head off

Yes I’m fishing

I will

[frigid cloud]

I left him like a dumbass

[hidden moss]

Legendary fish

[frigid cloud]

I hope i didn't flee it in my 100% save

[hidden moss]

Legendary fish just makes my thumb sore

[frigid cloud]

Might have an older save who knows

Lol

[summer garnet]

buell is better than racheal change my mind

[hidden moss]

BRO IS HAMISH OKAY

Man just got dragged

[hushed flare]

Racheal🦍

[hidden moss]

My Rachel got hit by a train

...

What?

Who spoiled what?

[frigid cloud]

Nothing

[sinful knot]

Nothing

[hidden moss]

nothing

go away

[sinful knot]

We were just talkin about the weather

[summer garnet]

nothing

[frigid cloud]

It was the wind

[hidden moss]

Oki

dead

[summer garnet]

hes near clemes point

[frigid cloud]

Doesn't he appear after fishing with kieran

Close to legendary bluegill

[sinful knot]

it should be near catfish jacksons when you go fishing with kieran

[hushed flare]

John swims with naked man

[summer garnet]

i pulled an all nighter ik u didnt ask but still

[hidden moss]

Didnt know you could find him outside the mission

arthur and john doesnt have a penis tho

[sinful knot]

rockstar always makes nude parts

[hushed flare]

bruh

[summer garnet]

bruh

[hushed flare]

What are you doing in photo mode @hidden moss

[hidden moss]

Ig that's why Abigail stayed with him

[hushed flare]

you guys do weird things in photo mode

you can still do it

Smh

pause menu

[hidden moss]

howw

You can't check penis without mods tbh

[hushed flare]

easy

lmfao

[summer garnet]

i tried it but it just stops at his pants

[hidden moss]

I remember watching a boundary break vid where they examined Arthur in the bath. He had no peen

However John's cock is certainly bigger than Arthur's

[hidden moss]

If u wear pants

that's considered as cock

Npc John's cock is bigger

My thumbs sore

I got him

[hushed flare]

stroke

[hidden moss]

Whose?

[hushed flare]

WTF