#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 441 of 1

void pond
#

pearson in rhodes

hidden moss
#

Swanson?

#

What happened to him?

void pond
#

probably moved

#

not coming back

#

u can meet rain falls tho

hidden moss
#

That’s good

void pond
#

i think u can meet him in annesburg

nimble dew
#

So Hamish just died and I have to take his Horse how could I not :( I'd feel like shit leaving it behind

void pond
#

if i remember

#

and bonus, charlotte at her house

hidden moss
#

How do I get that money from the gun slinger book

#

What happened to Mary Linton?

void pond
#

u can see her in credit scene

#

but not ingame

vagrant temple
hidden moss
vagrant temple
#

Mary is a manipulator

hidden moss
#

Agreed

vagrant temple
#

She has like 3 missions

hidden moss
#

2

vagrant temple
#

2?

void pond
#

2 missions and 3 letter

vagrant temple
#

Ah okay

#

I haven’t played the 2nd one

#

Only the first one

sinful knot
#

Ive deleted it and reinstalled it over 7 times cause of PC problems

vagrant temple
#

Bro… 🤦‍♂️

golden storm
#

you can't play any online games without ps plus

#

oh

dusk marten
void pond
#

does ultimate edition on steam include online?

dusk marten
vagrant temple
dusk marten
#

i had online, then i bought story

#

Online sux

vagrant temple
#

RDO is just buyable in a standalone listing

#

Any RDR2 edition has RDO

void pond
#

yea, i watch my friends play rdo

#

many griefer

dusk marten
#

At least better than gtao frank

void pond
#

especially in saint denis

dusk marten
#

Thats why i moved to rhodescowboy_pleading

hidden moss
vagrant temple
dusk marten
hidden moss
void pond
#

man i wish they make blackwater dlc

#

and also rdr1 remaster for console and pc

#

but probably wont

#

:/

sinful knot
#

You know its just gonna be filled with arthur mentions and of course how could we forget arthur marston cringe

void pond
#

i just want to play rdr1 in current gen

sinful knot
#

BUT it would also be good for the modding community if they made it on current RAGE engine

#

it'd just be copy and paste to get a car into RDR2, the one ross drives

arctic wren
#

If I could create a god he’d be the god of circumcisions

#

Wrong server sorry

hidden moss
#

Come give a fellow red dead streamer a follow on twitch i would appreciate it so much. I’m a small streamer with only 15 followers. My goal is to touch 50

thorny spindle
#

How to not dislike Micah Bell?

hushed flare
thorny spindle
#

:/

hushed flare
#

oMg miCah baD, hE do BaD

sinful knot
#

Omg he kill person bad bad bad!!

thorny spindle
#

Can't wait to pop him later on

hushed flare
#

Don't shoot Micah's hat off for the good ending

thorny spindle
#

oke

hidden moss
#

House building sim with music

#

There’s a little bird

hidden moss
balmy palm
#

Hour later.... nothing

low aspen
#

Silence

severe anvil
#

so what happens if you dont detonate or detonate early the dynamite in black belle's swamp

hidden moss
#

detonate you kill 2-3 bounty hunters at once, don't detonate, you have to kill them using your gun.

high pier
#

Story has to have online clothing

dusk marten
latent lantern
#

hello guys. There is a mod where you can create events in single player, and I don't remember what it is called. If anyone knows about the mod please lemme know, thank you

hidden moss
#

whats the best way to make a good amount of money?

#

Treasure hunting

#

i already did that

#

Then robbing trains and selling jewellery to fences ig

hidden moss
#

mk

#

thanks

spiral cliff
#

Try and get the gold bars as well?

hidden moss
#

no

#

well i was

void pond
#

kinda pointless tbh

#

unless u want to do the aberdeen trick

hidden moss
#

i finished american venom then restarted the game

#

the challenge ones?

void pond
#

did u know the aberdeen trick

#

well 20k is already good amount of money

#

well i guess im cheap af

#

i wanted rdr 1 first tho

#

the remaster version

#

yea i heard their script is a mess

#

it is like making a new whole games

#

welp

hidden moss
#

Lmao

#

They could've made an another option where you bribe the witness

#

Some dumbasses defend that "BUT BUT ARTHUR IS BIG AND TOUGH!!! IT MAKES NO SENSE FOR HIM TO BRIBE!!!"

#

Arthur might be big

#

but he ain't dumb enough to beat up a dude in front of everyone just because that dude witnessed Arthur doing crime

#

Arthur could bribe him/her

drifting star
#

Hello for 100% completion do I need to mail the fish as well or just catch them?

hidden moss
#

Probably have to mail them

frigid cloud
#

You catch them and mail them

hidden moss
#

RDR1 John would put 200 bullets in Micah before he could do anything

#

Actually rockstar has said Arthur’s the best gunslinger in the gang

hidden moss
#

But in 1911

#

I doubt Arthur would win against John

#

In 1911 he dead dead

hidden moss
#

Maybe in fistfight Arthur can beat up John

#

But it would be kinda challenging

#

since RDR1 John is packing muscles

#

Micah in rdr2 barely even beat sick arthur

#

My jack shoots everything

#

Well, in my first play through I went for the money and Micah still struggled

#

Don’t be mean I thought John would get it

#

W h a t

sharp gulch
#

i find it very offensive that the red dead online logo is used for rdr2 on the rockstar launcher

hidden moss
#

err mister

sharp gulch
#

and the game is called red dead online

#

instead of red dead redemption 2

hidden moss
#

There’s a version you can buy that’s only rdo

#

fuck

sharp gulch
#

i know

hidden moss
#

RDR2 is dying without content

sharp gulch
#

just rockstar taking the easy way out again

hidden moss
#

I wish Rockstar restored Cut content with each updates

#

and fix epilogue John

#

with updats

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

Well I still haven’t completed my first play through full

#

That's why i'm playing with mods

#

Yeah

#

Yes

#

Horses are scared of predators

#

Because pain

#

and see you as potential predators

sharp gulch
hidden moss
#

Oh

hidden moss
sharp gulch
#

oh

hidden moss
#

yo sinker

#

do you play with mods?

sharp gulch
#

sometimes but not really, no

hidden moss
#

I'm full mods with this game

#

adds more stuff to it

#

I love the rdr1 drunk physics

#

Same

#

I like the brutal shoots

#

I wish they kept that RDR1 drunk animations

#

I play with the cheat

#

RDR1 has stuff that RDR2 don't

#

I like walking as Jack getting shit up dramatically

#

Shot*

#

Atmopshere, Combat, Arcade/Immersive gameplay, Weapon system

#

they made it fun

#

Rdr2 has mini games

#

Like five finger filet and dominoes

#

RDR1 does it too

#

and more than rdr2 tbh

#

Yeah

#

I wish they didn't cut liar's dice from rdr2

#

I ride horses irl

#

I love horses bro

#

Why Rockstar cut Liar's dice in rdr2

#

I cried when I died

#

Better than dominoes

#

Mine*

#

I had my Arabian since chapter 2 his name was Sam :((

#

Lmao

#

I have a Arabian irl-

#

His name is also Sam

#

White

#

Like my rdr horse

#

Yeah!!

#

He’s pretty old

#

I don’t ride him anymore

#

Since he’s a old Noah

#

Boah*

#

No idea you just know pretty much

#

When they don’t run around anymore and look tired asf

#

Lmaoo

#

Isn’t Dutch’s horse a Arabian?

#

Lmao

#

So it’s fake like him?

#

I like it

#

He rid well

#

But then he got shit

#

Shot*

#

I cried

#

I slashed Micah the fuck up and I’m happy

#

I feel like realistically Micah should’ve killed arthur there

#

Yes

#

Loud big boy so scary

#

One time irl I was riding a horse and we both fell down a hill

#

Luckily I landed on top of it

#

Don’t worry it’s okay

#

That’s what you’d think

#

It was a small hill though

#

It’s easy

#

Just swing your leg over

#

That’s why I like Arabians

#

They smol

#

I’m also shirt

#

Short*

#

I’m 5’7

#

Because they use those big motherfuckers

#

I like small horse

#

How old are you?

#

I’m also 14

#

You’ll get taller

#

Like a big boah

#

My moms 5’1

#

I’m as tall as my dad

#

Damn

#

I’m supposed to be 6’3 when I’m older

#

I have a wingspan of a person that’s 5’9

#

Not full body

#

But like same as them

#

Fair enough

#

I love the name

#

Yes

#

My John just got his wife back

#

Idk if I’m close to completing epilogue

#

I only wear John or Arthur’s hat

#

Or*

#

From where?

#

I never saw that

#

You mean his 1899 hat?

#

You can get that?

#

Can I mission replay?

#

Fuck

#

I don’t even have a save from epilogue 1

#

Im at school

#

I’m about to go home doe

#

Because I threw up

#

It’s like 8 am where I am

#

Yes

#

Sadly

waxen plaza
#

What

hidden moss
#

Micah is such a great character

#

Like I’ve never hated a video game character

#

But Micah

drifting star
hidden moss
#

I hope I get to light him up

#

Stand-off type shit

#

Nope

#

I’m excited

#

John Jim VS Rat boy

#

I love how John was like “I’ll never go to Mexico”

#

I like riding the dialogue is great

#

I feel Ike 100% this game will be fun

#

Well luckily I have no life

#

Yea

waxen plaza
#

Are they ?

#

Because I miss

hidden moss
#

I like a challenge

waxen plaza
#

Don't lie

hidden moss
#

I had to take a break from rdr a few weeks ago for my metal well being lmaooo

hidden moss
#

The best feeling is the feeling that’s hardest to get

balmy palm
hidden moss
#

Yes

balmy palm
#

Gotta make sure your metal is well, and been

hidden moss
#

The metal of my guns

balmy palm
#

No. Rockstar

#

Lmao

hidden moss
#

There balls get smaller

#

Who?

#

I haven’t done that yet

#

Can I do it in epilogue?

balmy palm
#

Damn it. I didnt get buell and I did the mission >:(

distant minnow
#

just like irl

#

and (only wild) horses will roll in dust and dirt to keep away flies

frigid cloud
#

Just no

#

Not fun

distant minnow
hidden moss
#

Great

distant minnow
#

I'm already at chapter 2 and finished the new south and arcadia for amateurs

#

I mean 3

#

Chapter 3

#

WHAT

frigid cloud
#

Lol

hidden moss
#

Do I have to get all gold medals?

frigid cloud
#

No

distant minnow
#

goddamn

hidden moss
#

Where

distant minnow
#

who could possibly need that many orchids

frigid cloud
#

Also hunting requests YeeHawAinsley

distant minnow
#

hunting is more fun

frigid cloud
#

Gives you a cool squirrel statue

distant minnow
#

like the loggers in cumberland and the wolves

hidden moss
#

WHERE DO I GET THE TAHITI GUN

frigid cloud
#

Complete all 5 lists

distant minnow
#

lol

frigid cloud
#

Buy lote satchel from a fence first before starting out

#

At least that jawbone knife is cool

#

‘It's art’

distant minnow
#

monster

distant pilot
#

I hope your horse trips

jolly valve
#

AYO

round hedge
#

imo his writing is terrible, only memorable thing he has is a huge props to Peter for acting as him

jolly valve
#

🚨🚨🚔

hushed flare
#

Bruh

hidden moss
#

I love Micah as a character but hate him as a person

vagrant temple
round hedge
#

fair

hidden moss
#

Does black water become accessible after the story? With out a bounty?

lost moss
#

Play through the story and find out rcthumbsup

hidden moss
#

It looks cool

lost moss
#

What

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

Just with john

#

I wanna explore so bad

#

Ah

hidden moss
#

Yeah and all around new austin

round hedge
#

new austin is fucking awful tho

#

and a massive plothole since john was never supposed to go there

hidden moss
#

It does feel pretty empty ngl

#

Oh

#

Alright

#

I really appreciated rdr2 the 2nd time around since I explored a hell of a lot more

#

Oh rlly and I don’t wanna use John so

hushed flare
#

Sometimes I prefer blackwater over saint denissadness

hidden moss
#

I love black water

round hedge
#

blackwater went from a dark and empty town from RDR to a colorful and filled with a lot of people town

#

mfs changed everything from it 🗿

hidden moss
#

Am I close? Abigail and John just got engaged

#

Next mission is called “American Venom”

oak quartz
#

Yes you are:)

hidden moss
#

Yay!

#

I love your profile banner

oak quartz
#

Oh god 😭

#

it was originally a joke but i cant be bothered to change it now

hidden moss
#

Agh shit, then to kill Micah I’ll write after the mission

turbid parcel
#

how do i get my horse back im stuck with a tenesee walker

oak quartz
#

How so? In story mode you’ll need to buy a new horse or if you have a better horse you’ll go to the stable and make it your main horse by putting the saddle on it

turbid parcel
#

it must of died then....

oak quartz
#

Aw, yea you’ll need to purchase a new horse from one of the stables

turbid parcel
#

which is the best stable?

pure stirrup
#

When can I see bounties be hung?

#

The one in valentine for example, the swan gurl

narrow jetty
#

I think the discrepancies between epilogue John's personality and look versus RDR1 John's personality and look is the single biggest case for an RDR1 remake

#

not a remaster, a remake

frigid cloud
hidden moss
narrow jetty
#

As a standalone character, I actually really like epilogue john, I just don't llike that he is presented as John Marston if that makes any sense

hidden moss
#

yeah

#

He doesn't look like John or act like John

#

he's a different character if you pretend

narrow jetty
#

Epiloge John is actually really likable it is own way, hes just not John Marston

hidden moss
#

yeah

#

“Hello scar face” has one eye

#

This man really missed all his shots

narrow jetty
#

Epilogue John is is very animated, goofy, awkward, but in an endearing and almost innocent way, RDR1 John is a silent badass that will put a bullet in ya if you fall out of line

hidden moss
#

Except he doesn't get more screentime tbh

narrow jetty
#

I actually really liked how John was presented as NPC. You could tell that he was rdr1 John but a lot less developed and more innocent

#

What I expected though was for him to eventually turn into the guy we saw in RDR1

hidden moss
#

agreed

#

Each chapter John turning into RDR1 John

#

Holy shit it’s the plan man

#

would be pog

pure stirrup
#

Can i see the bounties i catch hang?

hidden moss
#

What do I do?

#

Who do I shoot?

hidden moss
#

Do I shoot micah?

ashen forum
#

No.... Spoilers.

hidden moss
#

Or will Dutch shoot me

hidden moss
#

Oh shit nvm

#

Hey shit on kid

narrow jetty
#

Not having John's daughters death in the epilogue is a massive missed opportunity imo. That was literally the perfect excuse for John turning into the hardened man we saw in RDR1

hidden moss
#

Brb

narrow jetty
#

Arthur's son dying is what hardened him

hidden moss
#

Holy hell I just shot micah like 6 times

#

but I think John's daughter borns after RDR2 story

#

Ohhh that’s a lot of cash

narrow jetty
#

Yeah but I'm saying that makes no sense.. Arthur even talked about how his son's death is what hardened him. They could have done the same thing with John's daughter and used her death to explain how John became the hardened guy he was in rdr1

hidden moss
#

How much?

hidden moss
#

There are so many retcons happened in rdr2 tbh

#

How much money was that?

narrow jetty
#

And it makes even more sense as it would draw even more of a parallel between Arthur and John

hidden moss
#

I wish Epilogue John did have proper dialogues

#

instead of "you have a small neck"

#

I don't except epilogue John to be creative and talk well like RDR1 John

#

but he should definitely have better dialogues than npc John

#

Damn that was a amazing ass game

#

Time for all the side missions I guess

#

@narrow jetty Imo Sadie and Charles should die at american venom as well too tbh

#

I agree

#

They both got shot tf up

#

I don’t know how micah missed all those shots

#

It would make sense for Arthur's dialogue as well

#

"Revenge is a fool's game"

#

And during revenge Sadie and Charles pay for it

#

What do I do now I’ve completed epilogue?

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

Wait

#

What happens if I go to the old camps

hidden moss
#

The Pinkertons found micah?

#

I think Arthur got the tuberculosis when that guy that owed money to the crew coughed blood on his face

hidden moss
#

That dude covered his mouth

#

during tommy fight

hidden moss
#

Robbing homestead with Javier when Arthur moves it makes sense

#

No man could kill Arthur so God had to send a weird virus😤 😤

#

He probably coughed because of dust

#

Arthur solos goku

#

Arthur solos the whole anime universe

#

John needed a whole army and sacrifice to get himself killed

#

Can I get that open vest John has on?

hidden moss
#

or if you are on ps4

#

you can use save wizard

hidden moss
#

I’m on ps5

#

oof

#

U can't then

#

Fuck

hidden moss
#

This is why John Marston mods are so important

hidden moss
#

and never played online

#

I want johns rdr2 hat

hidden moss
#

No white stitch

#

and brim was bigger

#

I mean the gamblers hat

#

ah

#

John's rdr1 outfit is so beautiul

#

*beautiful

#

My John looks kinda like rdr1 John

#

My John looks like real RDR1 John thanks to mods

#

Is Mary Beth a writer now?

#

Be careful talking about mods is risky 👀

#

If you talk about how to install mods

#

then it is risky

#

Rufus survived!!

#

I'm just discussing it

#

people be saying "I want jhon from rdr1 and also I want a mod that turns rdr2 to rdr1" bro just buy rdr1 at this point samsungskull

#

W h a t

#

I just wanna look like the sexy cowboy man

hidden moss
#

We want epilogue John to be fixed

#

🤷‍♂️

hidden moss
#

They downgraded him with each updates

#

turned him into Arthur reskin

#

Arthur Marstin

#

Marston*

#

yup

#

Next play through I’m going full low honor

narrow jetty
#

Also, I don't know if anyone else has picked up on this, but you notice how John is like a lot more distant and cold with Jack in RDR1 than RDR2?

#

Epilogue I mean

hidden moss
#

Yeah

#

That could just be John though

hidden moss
#

arthur a good man in the cut scenes

hidden moss
#

Also he's trying to teach Jack

#

Ima go with John with low honor

#

how to live on his own

#

I love good honor arthur

#

Since I know what happens

#

Btw Arthur getting shot is more realistic

#

yeah

#

Micah would’ve shot him more than likely

#

I had full max honor going back for money for my first play through

narrow jetty
#

Like Imagine this, what if John's daughter died while Jack was looking after her, like she was playing in the water and Jack was supposed to be watching her but he was reading a book. She drowned and John loses his shit, blames Jack, basically tears into him deep, and it becomes this whole family drama that has to be slowly worked out, and that could explain John being more hardened in RDR1 and maybe a little more, idk, less friendly with Jack

hidden moss
narrow jetty
#

I'm flattered lol

hidden moss
#

I love it

frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

to make John even hardened

frigid cloud
#

True

hidden moss
#

I’m making my John in epilogue save who he can and be like a vigilante because he’s lost everyone he’s cared for mostly

#

Batman lmaoooo

#

John Jim Batman Milton

narrow jetty
hidden moss
#

Is John and Abigail standing where there graves are

frigid cloud
#

No

hidden moss
#

I have 20k now o-o

golden storm
#

I know who javier is now

hidden moss
#

I guess having his family taken by the government and being forced to do their dirty work is probs what hardened him a bit

hidden moss
golden storm
#

they didn't even mention his daughter in rdr2 though

hidden moss
#

Even more so in rdr1 tho

hidden moss
#

Bro uncle is sleeping where he dies wtf

frigid cloud
#

Tahiti needs more than 20k apparently

hidden moss
#

I’m the going back for the money the money box had 46k in it

frigid cloud
#

Yes

hidden moss
#

How much is Tahiti

frigid cloud
#

10282292720822928201810282$ according to dutch

hidden moss
#

I tried to glitch to guarma before chapter 5 to explore it more but fell off a cliff on the way there stroke

#

Where do I change in this house

frigid cloud
#

I returned Guarma as John

golden storm
#

Kentucky saddler is a bad horse

narrow jetty
golden storm
hidden moss
#

Arent there still invisible snipers in guarma if you're john?

frigid cloud
#

There is

hidden moss
#

Pain

#

Can I head canon that Sadie and Charles died?

#

Was kinda nice getting new austin animals on the way as arthur

golden storm
#

they're dead now so ig

hidden moss
#

I love johns western coat

golden storm
#

you can go to new austin as arthur?

hidden moss
#

If I go to tumbleweed or armadillo will I get shot at as Arthur?

frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

Murdered

hidden moss
#

Awh

#

That’s annoying

#

I was travelling around the outside of new Austin to get to guarma

#

Meh I’ll be able to as John right?

frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

Can I get to Mexico?

#

Yes

frigid cloud
#

Not properly textured but yeah

hidden moss
#

But theres nothing there

hidden moss
#

Is there anything cool there?

#

Wait

golden storm
#

you were supposed to go to mexico

frigid cloud
#

New austin hasn't got any uses other than 100% stuff tbf

hidden moss
#

Do I need the Guarma shit for 100%

frigid cloud
#

No

hidden moss
#

Thank god

golden storm
#

I love new austin

#

no new austin slander

frigid cloud
#

Only 50 animals studied for 100%

hidden moss
#

Why does my John look like John Wick

frigid cloud
#

You don't need it for any trophies either

hidden moss
#

I kinda just wanna get the guarma animals to fill in the compendium. But those snakes are horrible

narrow jetty
#

Also by the way, They could have used my fanfiction up there of John's daughter drowning because Jack was reading instead of watching her as a way to explain why John gives Jack such a hard time about reading books in RDR1

#

lol

fair cypress
#

Wow same people still in this chat 10 hrs later

frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

You’re a genius

narrow jetty
#

Alright I'll shut up about it now just wanted to get that out there lol

hidden moss
#

I could only have 1 snake spawn and that was it. No matter how many times I reloaded the game lol

#

Anyone else not like the high neckerchief?

round hedge
narrow jetty
#

I mean that's a pretty rough draft lol

round hedge
#

a man wouldn't change his personality completely by that imo

narrow jetty
#

Arthur did

round hedge
#

it should've been worked on during the chapters and specifically epilogue

#

to make him more RDR

narrow jetty
#

Arthur's sons death is what made him a hardened criminal

#

he said that

hidden moss
#

Jack always looks so scared

round hedge
#

Jack feels inferior to his father

#

that's why

hidden moss
#

I think the government taking John's family was enough hardening ig

narrow jetty
#

Losing a fucking kid can absolutely change a person

hidden moss
#

Epilogue could've been more brutal tbh

hidden moss
round hedge
narrow jetty
#

If there's one thing that can that's it

hidden moss
#

Charles, Sadie, His daughter death

#

His family getting taken

narrow jetty
#

especially when you trusted your other kid to watch her

hidden moss
#

John slowly getting more savage and agressive with each missions of epilogue

#

Seeing your ex father figure kill himself

round hedge
hidden moss
#

Like slowly starting epilogue with John happy then at the end of game

round hedge
#

which were forgotten

#

in RDR2

hidden moss
#

John is angry and like rdr1 John

#

Yea epilogue ended off a bit too happily maybe

round hedge
#

John matured nothing from getting away from the gang

#

literally nothing

hidden moss
#

I agree

narrow jetty
#

I'm not necessarily saying that has to be the only thing but I feel like the epilogue should have done something like that maybe plus other things to explain John becoming more hardened and cold

round hedge
#

that's the main issue

hidden moss
#

Time to walk out the barn dramatically

narrow jetty
#

The epilogue is way to happy imo

hidden moss
#

John could've been slightly angry at beginning of epilogue

round hedge
#

i have no problem with NPC John acting immature (should've been wise and badass tho)

#

but epilogue?

#

it needed to be RDR John

hidden moss
#

after more stuff happening

#

in epilogue

#

John needs to act like RDR1 John

round hedge
#

RDR John personality style

hidden moss
#

at the end of the game

#

It feels so dark that the epilogue ends off with a happy note when you know what happens to john in rdr1

#

You can do your own thing after epilogue and make him bad

#

I’m making him fuck everything up

#

There's difference between being cold and hardened

fierce cave
#

Hi

random dagger
#

Mg eh did you guys do horseman challenge 9 mine is bugged It doesn’t let me do it

round hedge
#

John was basically one of the guys in charge of the gang in RDR, that's something only a wise person can do

#

and he also said he was never less intimidating

hidden moss
#

I'm waiting till epilogue for horseman 9 tbh

round hedge
#

which means he always had those quick insults

#

like, see him talking to anyone he dislikes

#

he replies with an insult or irony quickly af

#

while in epilogue he can barely speak normally 🗿

hidden moss
#

In canon shouldn’t I only use johns cattlemen?

fierce cave
round hedge
#

it's... art....

narrow jetty
#

I think borderline survivors guilt about what happened with Arthur, plus his daughter drowning, plus Sadie and Charles dying on that mountain are enough to explain John becoming the man he was in RDR1

#

a man who has seen some shit

hidden moss
round hedge
frigid cloud
round hedge
#

not john's

fierce cave
#

Oh

hidden moss
#

Why can’t I shower :((

frigid cloud
round hedge
hidden moss
#

I dont think I'd glitch back to guarma for a while tbh lol that death on the way really put me off. Wasted so much time

round hedge
#

but rockstar completely forgot what character development is

golden storm
round hedge
#

and made him pathetic in epilogue

hidden moss
#

Can I not take off the offhand holster?

fierce cave
random dagger
hidden moss
#

I feel like “I wanna be your slave” fits red dead redemption as a song

fierce cave
#

I have no idea how i did it

hidden moss
#

Time it next time

random dagger
#

K

frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

Is Jack scared of john?

#

Sorta

round hedge
#

he feels inferior

#

like i said

hidden moss
#

John is just a stern father

random dagger
hidden moss
#

John is gonna beat up Jack

random dagger
#

I’m pretty sure it’s time

hidden moss
#

that's why

#

I feel bad for Jack he looks so scared

round hedge
#

Jack wants to make his father happy

hidden moss
#

Jack is scared of epilogue John

#

Trash bag gloves

narrow jetty
# round hedge and made him pathetic in epilogue

I think the epilogue should have been used to also do that as well. It should have been a lot less happy, They should have made John's daughters death a big part of it, and they also should have had Sadie and Charles die on the mountain

hidden moss
#

Do y’all like John or Arthur’s Satchel

#

Jack is only like 12 in the epilogue after all

round hedge
hidden moss
round hedge
#

they both suck

frigid cloud
round hedge
#

john's satchel is too big

#

and arthur's is boring

random dagger
hidden moss
#

Can you take off the satchel

round hedge
#

rather have no satchel

hidden moss
#

I havent even paid attention to satchels lol

round hedge
#

without mods

#

no

hidden moss
#

I don't mind John's satchel

#

i like it

frigid cloud
#

Y tf john started using a satchel after authur gave him one anyway makes no sense

random dagger
#

Right

hidden moss
#

Where is Arthur’s graves

#

Grave*

frigid cloud
#

Look up

round hedge
#

bruh

fierce cave
narrow jetty
#

Also John's RDR1 hat should have been Arthurs hat, yeah it would have made everything predictable but it already was so who cares

fallow echo
#

hello

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

John's hat should be different

#

Remember John is a man of his own

#

I dont talk about him much but I think about him prayge

fallow echo
#

How can I find the legendary bear if I already lost to it once

hidden moss
#

like Arthur

#

Go back to the same location

hidden moss
fallow echo
#

its not there tho

round hedge
fierce cave
#

Are rdr1 and rdr2 connected in any way? I havent played rdr1

narrow jetty
#

I get John doesn't like talking about Arthur, and maybe this is a hot take but I always thought that felt like a kind of forced excuse to explain why he isn't mentioned in RDR1

hidden moss
round hedge
frigid cloud
#

Jack remembers authur lol

round hedge
#

although it has a lot of plotholes

#

or changes that don't make much sense

round hedge
#

he should just

#

stop talking about him

#

he mentions him to everyone in epilogue

hidden moss
frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

he saved my life before he passed

#

Theres not much to say about Arthur tbh. He died 12 years before rdr1

round hedge
hidden moss
narrow jetty
#

See but that doesn't make a whole lot of sense though. It just feels like they had to make John not like to talk about Arthur for some reason just to explain why he isn't mentioned in RDR1

frigid cloud
narrow jetty
#

It feels kinda forced and unnatural

hidden moss
#

Should I do the hamish mission?

#

There was probably not much reason for john to bring up Arthur tho

round hedge
#

and not be like

#

"i don't like talking i think about him!"

fierce cave
round hedge
#

it's a new century and he still thinks about Arthur

#

that's kinda gay

hidden moss
#

John already barely talked bout him in epilogue. 4 years on, theres even less reason to bring him up imo

round hedge
frigid cloud
#

Your buddy did this to me, authur and I won - Micah

round hedge
#

talked to his fmaily

#

talked to micah

hidden moss
narrow jetty
#

See I don't agree, I don't see why he had to stop talking about Arthur, I'd argue that it actually wouldn't make a lot of sense other than to fill the plot hole of him not being mentioned in RDR1

round hedge
#

thinked about him in epilogue 1

hidden moss
round hedge
#

yeah

#

he mentions arthur to everyone

fierce cave
#

Does anyone have a good name for a female brown mustang

round hedge
#

it's like his damn husband died

#

not a friend

#

but a fucking husband by the way he talks about him

south dome
#

Hello

sinful knot
fierce cave
#

She has a stripe down her back but im not sure if thats unique

narrow jetty
#

More than all other gang members

#

Arthur and John were the first two other than Dutch and Hosea

round hedge
#

remember all the things he said

#

think about him all the time

sinful knot
round hedge
#

dutch killed himself in front of him and he never talked about him ever again to his family

#

and he was his father shortly

fallow echo
#

How can I get the legendary bear to spawn if I already died to it once in the mission with hosea? I tried to redo the mission and as soon as I selected the stay button it just cut me out from the mission

narrow jetty
#

I will say thought the whole "I don't talk about him much, but I think about him" thing sounds kinda funny when you've spent game days just finishing Arthur's stranger missions and constantly talking about him lol

frigid cloud
fallow echo
#

I tried

south dome
#

I've had this game for 3 years but Im always anxious about playing it I always restart after I reach valentine ._.

fallow echo
narrow jetty
#

unless you want it spoiled

hidden moss
#

Yea treat it like a YouTube comment thread

south dome
#

I thought maybe finding someone to talk to while playing will give me some courage

hidden moss
#

Why anxious

south dome
#

Idk

round hedge
#

John killed Bill, Javier and Dutch which he clearly didn't want to, moved on and never talked about them

hidden moss
#

I almost hit someone

#

This guy says he ships arthur and Dutch

narrow jetty
round hedge
#

Arthur died, always mentioning and thinking about him after 8 fucking years

south dome
fierce cave
round hedge
#

and possibly 12 if RDR gets a remake

hidden moss
#

Stressful ig

hidden moss
round hedge
hidden moss
#

Arthur X Sadie?

#

arthur x micah

narrow jetty
#

That might have gone over well in Lemoyne

fierce cave
narrow jetty
sinful knot
#

Im glad that didnt make it into final

hidden moss
#

Javier X Bill

round hedge
#

Arthur x Lemoyne rapist 😳

hidden moss
#

Bill X Phil

hidden moss
#

I tried to leave the rapist on the train tracks but the train never came cuz it was getting robbed up ahead smh

hidden moss
#

Sadie X Jake

frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

I know

frigid cloud
#

o nvm then

#

Yeah I forgot you're an online player as well

narrow jetty
#

Like Dutch said, that area is fulll of papists and rapists

south dome
#

Is it normal to be anxious while playing it thonkhaw

hidden moss
frigid cloud
#

No

hidden moss
#

No

#

like he lets any1 in..

frigid cloud
narrow jetty
hidden moss
#

If you get anxious playing rdr2, definitely steer clear from subnautica. That's anxiety inducing

sinful knot
hidden moss
#

Me too

#

Wait

south dome
#

Maybe cuz I'm comfortable with smaller screens and I play rdr2 in a freaking theatre

hidden moss
#

I never helped the brathewait girl I forgot

#

Rip

narrow jetty
frigid cloud
#

Uncle gives you clothing if you do his companion quest

hidden moss
#

u can sketch her tho..

round hedge
hidden moss
#

Badass empowered women when its forced in is bad

round hedge
#

she goes from crying widow to badass empowered woman by just changing clothing

narrow jetty
#

I don't think it's forced with Sadie

round hedge
#

it definitely is

narrow jetty
#

She lost everything

sinful knot
hidden moss
#

I think it is

narrow jetty
#

Her home, her husband, everything

round hedge
#

RDR2 is about revenge being bad

#

but Sadie takes revenge

hidden moss
#

Sadie knew how to shoot

round hedge
#

and

#

nothing happens

narrow jetty
#

She's filled with vengance

round hedge
#

she kills them all and lives a bounty hunting life

#

that's it

frigid cloud
#

Who tf lives up in the mountains anyway

round hedge
#

no consequences

narrow jetty
south dome
#

I don't understand anything been said here feels like aliens are talking 👁👄👁

sinful knot
#

the development is WAY too fast with sadie

narrow jetty
#

I agree with that

hidden moss
frigid cloud
hidden moss
round hedge
hidden moss
#

Yea all of a sudden shes some brave hotheaded character

round hedge
#

how did she handle with the stress and fear of getting shot

#

when she NEVER

sinful knot
round hedge
#

went into a shootout

hidden moss
narrow jetty
#

AND YOU LOSE HONOR FOR IT

#

FOR CHOOSING NOT TO SEEK REVENGE YOU LOSE HONOR

frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

All well and good if she didnt have to drag other gang members into trouble like during colm o Driscolls hanging

narrow jetty
#

IN A GAME WHERE THE ENTIRE POINT IS REVENGE IS BAD

frigid cloud
#

She should've died in American venom

sinful knot
#

When she shot the odriscolls at colm's hanging that scene is just so damn unrealistic, she doesnt even cock the hammer once and fires multiple shots while screaming cringe

hidden moss
#

Y’all think Lenny would of sided with Arthur?

#

It was so cringy

sinful knot
#

She nagged Arthur to help with colm's hanging

narrow jetty
hidden moss
#

Yea I understand the reason but it shouldnt really have happened

sinful knot
#

Reasonable

frigid cloud
#

She was crying in chapter 1-2 and changed in 3-4 suddenly

hidden moss
#

They didn’t let her

#

She did it herself

fierce cave
frigid cloud
#

Sided with dotch

hidden moss
#

Captured or dead in rdr1

narrow jetty
#

They didn't let her. She did it herself and Dutch immediately was like alright lets go

hidden moss
frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

Yes

#

I don’t blame Javier

frigid cloud
#

Oh nvm

round hedge
#

if john kills him, he actually has a tear in his eye

#

despite spiting in him

hidden moss
#

I never kill my Mexican boah

round hedge
#

John never wanted to kill his old friends

#

even when Javier was clearly an asshole in RDR

hidden moss
#

Y’all think Arthur was scared to die at the end?

south dome
#

.

hidden moss
#

Yes he even says so

frigid cloud
#

You don't actually have to kill anyone
Capture Javier
Let that other guy kill bill
Let Dutch jump off of the cliff

round hedge
sinful knot
hidden moss
#

I mean when he was fighting micah

#

nah

#

but before, i guess yes

#

He knew it was the end already

sinful knot
narrow jetty
round hedge
#

Arthur - sister I'm scared of dying
John - walks out of his barn to his own death like a Chad and manages to take out a few soldiers

sinful knot
hidden moss
#

Its scarier when you're getting killed by something you cant control I suppose

round hedge
#

and kill Fordham if you shoot him during it

sinful knot
#

running everywhere without getting shot a single time

frigid cloud
#

Uncle died protecting the ranch like a chad

hidden moss
#

Arthur had a good bit of time to reflect on his impending death. But john had like none

narrow jetty
#

It actually takes a lot of balls for a man to say "I'm afraid" in the 1800's

#

that was a big deal back then

round hedge
hidden moss
#

Pretty much

#

John just had to protect his family

sinful knot
#

John didnt say a word, he already knew he was gonna die eventually protecting his family

narrow jetty
#

I think John always knew in the back of his mind that somehow, someway, they'd get him

hidden moss
#

Most likely

round hedge
#

RDR is driven by his philosophy

#

it's literally the exact same thing

#

people don't forget, nothing gets forgiven

#

explains RDR story perfectly

sinful knot
round hedge
#

you sir, are a fish!!!!!

sinful knot
#

fish on the line!! im talking!!!

hidden moss
#

Outta the damn way

sinful knot
#

John had a lot of badass combat lines in the first game

round hedge
#

This ain't looking bueno

sinful knot
#

"You can stick that badge up your ass"

narrow jetty
#

The underlying theme of both Red Dead Redemptions is how revenge is an idiots game, it's literally what caused thr gang to implode. Revenge on the braithawaits, revenge on Bronte, revenge on cornwall

#

And John's revenge on Micah is what sealed his fate

sinful knot
hidden moss
#

They showed edgar ross at micah's body at the end. I feel like that was the motive to really go after john

#

Why emphasise it otherwise

narrow jetty
#

Maybe they would have eventually found him, MAYBE, but John going after Micah and killing their mole, leaded them directly to him where he was the only one they could really use

sinful knot
round hedge
#

Micah was retconned

sinful knot
#

Sure in the credits they show ross and fordham finding Micah's body and asking around for who killed him, but its not said that was the cause of RDR1

narrow jetty
hidden moss
#

I think its strongly implying it was the cause

#

There wouldnt be much reason to show it otherwise

#

Has to tie in somehow

narrow jetty
#

So many people try and go this "gotcha" thing whenever you point out that John killing Micah was what sealed his fate and it's so annoying. That's clearly what the game was implying even if you could make the case that they might have eventually found him

sinful knot
#

See they make people think Micah was the cause

#

but he isnt

hidden moss
#

Idk how it lead back to john either but that seems to be the case regardless

round hedge
#

imagine retconning Micah to make John being caught a revenge = bad story

#

definitely rockstar

sinful knot
#

They make people think Micah is the cause, but he really isn't. How else did they find his real name?

narrow jetty
hidden moss
#

Consider it a plothole ig

round hedge
sinful knot
hidden moss
#

Yea suppose so

narrow jetty
#

I'm not saying that they wouldn't have eventually found John, I'm saying that the reason why they used John to kill the rest of the gang members was because he killed Micah, the guy they were using before him

#

Maybe they would have

round hedge
#

a plothole should be the fact that the government still worked with micah for 8 years

narrow jetty
#

But John killing Micah guranteed it

round hedge
#

and had no problem with him killing thousands

#

with his gang

hidden moss
#

Once they figured that john was killing past gang members, why not leverage john to kill a few more

round hedge
#

specially Ross

#

who hates outlaws

#

now that doesn't make any sense

sinful knot
#

They never go after Sadie for getting revenge, yet its bad for John to?

#

Doesnt make sense

#

different braithwaite

golden storm
#

I dont like molly

narrow jetty
#

If John had never killed Micah, they might have eventually found him, but they wouldn't have kidnapped John's family and used him to do their dirty work

round hedge
#

another person named braithwaite

sinful knot
#

she runs back into the fire after they burn down the manor

round hedge
#

thars it

round hedge
#

it's literally RDR

narrow jetty
round hedge
sinful knot
#

bruh its a different person named braithwaite, more than one person has the same name

round hedge
#

because he was in the van der Linde gang maybe?

#

a gang full of outlaws

#

who robbed a lot of banks

#

people

#

i wonder why they caught him

narrow jetty
hollow comet
#

after

#

in

#

in

#

in

#

wait

round hedge
hollow comet
#

is this a trick question?

round hedge
#

RDR

narrow jetty
#

If John DIDN'T kill Micah, the plot for RDR would be WAY different

round hedge
#

that's it

hollow comet
#

oh then idr

#

c

round hedge
#

the plot for RDR is literally without Micah

hollow comet
round hedge
#

and he still got caught lmao

golden storm
#

I would kidnap micah and drag him behind my horse and then burn him

sinful knot
hollow comet
#

or he'd die

round hedge
#

yeah they are pretty much

#

ngl

hidden moss
#

Theyd just see that john has a family regardless and leverage that against him ig

hollow comet
#

no, don't you ever wonder what would have happened if arthur was on the ferry?

round hedge
#

both RDR and RDR2 gang stories are different

#

so yeah