red-dead-singleplayer

[round hedge]

reason

although swept back with pomade has the accurate color

[balmy palm]

Maybe he just had dirty ass hair?

[round hedge]

no

[hushed flare]

Right parted is the most accurate John i think

[round hedge]

he just had realistic hair

[round hedge]

nah

it looks terrible

[hushed flare]

There's no other way tho

[round hedge]

all arthur hairs on him look terrible tho

but i'd say the middle parted level 4-5 (WITH A HAT) looks pretty accurate to RDR

[hushed flare]

This is for console noobs without John restoration mods

[round hedge]

aside from the black color

i hate the right parted model because of his forehead bangs

they look awful

[spring sluice]

Ive been wondering why the pinkertons went after john in rdr1

I think it's because he escaped sisika on that one mission?

[round hedge]

it was the FBI

and no, everything from RDR2 is retconned

specially micah

he got caught because nate johns ordered them to get rid of all outlaws

and they went for John because the government knew he was one of Dutch's gang members

basically, he was caught because the government didn't forget his past actions during the gang

[hushed flare]

Micah death

Was John's rediscovery

[round hedge]

yeah, that's the RDR2 part

RDR and RDR2 pretty much have different stories lol

for how he got caught

[hushed flare]

At least they connect

[round hedge]

but i like the RDR more

[round hedge]

eeeeh not much

could've been done better

[spring sluice]

Yea but on one mission in rdr2 they didnt know who he was and he said he was "rip van wrinkle"

[hushed flare]

Not like they didn't make rdr2 after rdr or anything

[spring sluice]

but yea i remember in the ending they were investigating who killed micah

[hushed flare]

I think they know ever since John got of siskia

[spring sluice]

yea im saying

[round hedge]

RDR reason for why john got caught: "people don't forget, nothing gets forgiven"

RDR2 reason: revenge = bad

that's it shortly

[spring sluice]

so like once he escaped he was put on the records of escaped criminals

and thats why they went after him

[hushed flare]

Government didn't forget, society didn't forgive basically

[round hedge]

yeah

[round hedge]

Government didn't forget, his actions weren't forgiven

[spring sluice]

yea

[hushed flare]

Also since he was basically the most dangerous one after Arthur died

[spring sluice]

yes

[round hedge]

arthur's death was sad but jesus christ, john's death still hits me like a truck

[spring sluice]

they never forgot he escaped

[round hedge]

it was way too fucking tragic

[hushed flare]

If the player was controlling either of them then Pinkerton's and law wouldn't exist

[spring sluice]

in my first run I was killed by micah execution style

[round hedge]

micah's death was terrible

cartoony villain death 🗿

[spring sluice]

i put all bullets in his head and he still shrugged it off...

[round hedge]

you guys can disagree, but if i could change the ending

[hushed flare]

Probably the most lazy part about Micah's death

[round hedge]

i'd have both charles and sadie die during the mission since the game wants to force that revenge is bad

and instead of an epic music like american venom, a sad one would've been better

[spring sluice]

ye

[round hedge]

like blackwater OSTs from RDR

[hushed flare]

How do you get a sawed off directly in your skull and just be like eh whatever time to die

[round hedge]

and instead of dutch appearing or whatever, it'd be just john being a massive badass and beating the shit out of micah

like RDR

[hushed flare]

But to be fair I think it took like an entire century for John to die when he got shot like 50 times

[spring sluice]

you mean decade?

[hushed flare]

The barn at Beecher's hope

[round hedge]

and instead of that weak shootout with micah and john, imagine if it was john being a massive chad and making micah get trapped in that cabin

then using the RDR shotgun pose to shoot him

[hushed flare]

Open doors, gets shot 50 times, takes like 20 years to die

[round hedge]

and going back with the "RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2" screen

like RDR

[hushed flare]

micah death was the most emotional I cried change my mind

[round hedge]

micah's death was cringe and possibly the worst death i've ever seen change my mind

[spring sluice]

The death that shocked me most was shaun's

[round hedge]

seans

[spring sluice]

didnt expect it

[hushed flare]

Arthurs death was the most cringe change my mind

[round hedge]

📠

[spring sluice]

Hosea

didnt even get a chance

[round hedge]

sean was only made to die for plot

same for lenny

hosea was just

eeeeehhh

he died

that's it

[spring sluice]

bru

[supple stag]

Yo

[hushed flare]

Lenny and Kieran's death were just fillers

[supple stag]

Im new here

[hushed flare]

Like

[spring sluice]

he was an old man and they did him dirty

[hushed flare]

What are you gonna look at, Sadie Adler stuff

[hidden moss]

nice

[round hedge]

yeah true

[supple stag]

And then there is Arthur's death

[spring sluice]

that would be hot

[hushed flare]

Arthur death = filler

[round hedge]

saw it from miles away

[hidden moss]

or arthur and john stuff

[round hedge]

arthur's death just sucked balls, i'd rather have it being a mystery the entire game

[hushed flare]

The players should know that ever since Arthur gets TB diagnosed then they should know he dies

[round hedge]

than it being obvious

[round hedge]

arthur should've changed without a disease

john changed because of his family

arthur should have something like that

[supple stag]

Yeah, he had tb he was gonna die soon, i literally predicted that he either dies from tb, pinkertons, or micah, plus rdr1 protagonist is John, what happened to Arthur? He is dead

[round hedge]

yeah exactly

but since a lot of people never played RDR

[hushed flare]

Blue alive damnation game when

[round hedge]

it'd been better if his death was hidden from the public

John had his redemption without needing any sickness

[hushed flare]

No rules against spoilers in this server so if you go and look on stuff about red dead on purpose your probably gonna be spoiled

[supple stag]

Well in Arthur's defence, he had a line where he told John that he has a family and needs to start making money, plus he also said "we were not the ones who changed" meaning Dutch did becaise of Micah filling his ego

[round hedge]

i meant during the story

like, john's death was a complete surprise

and shocking af

and arthur's was way too obvious since the start

[hushed flare]

John's plot armor ran out

[round hedge]

mf needed an army

just to be put down

[hushed flare]

All John had to do was drink potent miracle tonic

[round hedge]

rdr2 was made after RDR, nothing in RDR is because of arthur

change my mind

[hushed flare]

Deadeye🦍

[round hedge]

tbh i think john could've easily killed everyone in there if he didn't want to sacrifice himself

not easily actually, but he could

[supple stag]

In online, me and my friend kill people in the saloon in saint denis and a whole army came busting threw the door and we mowed them down, we are G O D

[round hedge]

low budget john marston

[supple stag]

I did it with myself too, and i still murked them

[hushed flare]

Could have just hid behind cover because apparently that makes you almost invincible from everything Infront of you

[round hedge]

i don't care much about arthur's death anymore, but john's still hits like a truck

[round hedge]

he could've used the second floor of the barn if he wanted to kill them all

john taking all those bullets and still surviving

what a badass

[hushed flare]

Was there even windows in the second floor

[round hedge]

yeah i think so

don't remember correctly

hold on

[hushed flare]

And you said Micah was bad death because he took like 5 revolver bullets to the head and survived

[round hedge]

the thing is

[hushed flare]

Bias gang

[round hedge]

he walked away like a cartoon

and went

"guess i'll die lmao"

[supple stag]

Well the reason why it was so sad was because he was about to throw it all away, quit this gang, because of Dutch's ego filled by Micah, so what was left to live for was himself, that is not enough for him, more likely he was going to fix it with john, that is what was sad about Arthur

[round hedge]

@hushed flare

there is a window in the barn

[hidden moss]

Arthur’s had a warning, John had a feeling of safety but then it was really unexpected.

[round hedge]

#red-dead-media

[hidden moss]

As soon as you know he had TB you knew he would die.

[round hedge]

the forced revenge = bad plot

[hidden moss]

Not really forced revenge.

[supple stag]

Meanwhile we waiting on rdr3

[hidden moss]

I don’t think we need RDR3

I think Van Der Linde gang story is over, maybe if they made a new gang or something.

[hushed flare]

rdr remaster or fixed epilogue john

[round hedge]

remaster

[hidden moss]

The epilogue should have been longer tbh.

[hushed flare]

if a rdr remaster happened I wouldn't be surprised if they fucked up john

[round hedge]

as long as there are no changes in john's story or model

[hidden moss]

John was so bad in rdr2.

[round hedge]

RDR John model only needs improved textures

[hushed flare]

I think the game was slightly rushed

[supple stag]

We still dont know what happened to Sadie Adler, as far as i know, it was left on a cliffhanger because in rdr1 SADIE WAS NO WHERE TO BE SEEN where the hell did she go?

[hidden moss]

Slightly rushed?

[round hedge]

true

[hidden moss]

It took like 9 years bro

[hushed flare]

Meh

[round hedge]

i can't look at RDR John and EP john

[hidden moss]

Well,

[round hedge]

and say it's the same person

[hidden moss]

It’s said a girl out near where she went died in a bounty hunt

[round hedge]

john killed her 😎

[hidden moss]

Idk where the source is, but apparently she died there.

Jack is the only one confirmed to be alive.

[supple stag]

Really?

[hushed flare]

Sadie and Charles went somewhere else

It's even shown in the credits

[hidden moss]

One thing I hate about like, people who hate Micah,

[frigid cloud]

Pinkertons captured Sadie and hanged her and killed Charles in rdr1

[hidden moss]

Is they really underestimate him.

[supple stag]

INSERT MARSTON GANG AND LET THERE BE RDR3

[hushed flare]

Micah is good wdym

Smh

[hidden moss]

They say he loses to everyone just cuz he rated.

Ratted*

I will say right here, he is definitely top 3 best gunslingers in the gang.

[hushed flare]

Micah is a good gun with 2 revolvers u have to give him that

[hidden moss]

Fr.

[hushed flare]

Im sometimes convinced Micah has his own deadeye

[hidden moss]

Guy shot like 4 people in the head within seconds

Without even aiming properly

[hidden moss]

I love Micah

[hushed flare]

Micah gets like no bloom with double actions mind you (American venom)

[hidden moss]

He is the good guy in a way

He was funny asf tho ngl

[hushed flare]

I feel like Micah would have killed John in American venom if Sadie didn't do anythjng

[supple stag]

You know what Rockstar should do? They should have, in there next anniversary, a event where specific roles can party

[hidden moss]

He would have

[frigid cloud]

Of course

[hidden moss]

Ez

[frigid cloud]

If dutch or sadie didn't show up

He'd be dead for sure

[hushed flare]

I shot Micah before Sadie did anything but took the bullet because plot armor smh

[hidden moss]

Micah is way better than RDR2 John with guns.

[round hedge]

I don't like Micah, not because he's a bad guy, but because his writing wasn't that good IMO

[hidden moss]

Cap

[round hedge]

it's just your average villain that hates everyone and everything

but his Actor did a great job

[hidden moss]

He had an amazing backstory, great lines,

[hushed flare]

I think Micah knows the deadeye trick of not having to reload guns when you go into deadeye

[round hedge]

into making him have an actual personality

[hidden moss]

He was badass

And I loved his personality

[round hedge]

if micah had a different actor

i think he'd suck

a lot

[hidden moss]

Deadeye isn’t an actual thing.

It’s just there to show they are good gunslingers.

[round hedge]

because it's peter who makes micah an actual interesting person, his writing is way too basic and cliche

[supple stag]

What if a crossover happened in both of Rockstar's both game franchises?

[hushed flare]

But you can't just reload 12 bullets in half a second only deadeye can do that

[hidden moss]

Ayo?

[round hedge]

they made everyone good looking in RDR2

[hidden moss]

okay but..

[round hedge]

for some reason

[hidden moss]

Pregnant Micah

🥵

[hushed flare]

True

Micah x Arthur

[hidden moss]

Pregnant Micah 😩😩

[hidden moss]

Do you want me to put a bullet in ur head right here? Right now?

walks towards you

[hushed flare]

Can't be killed with plot armor

[hidden moss]

😩😏

[hidden moss]

Tbh

Imagine if

[supple stag]

Meanwhile in arthur's house, arthur x sadie

[hidden moss]

John’s honor mattered

Like in American venom

[hushed flare]

Man it should have

[hidden moss]

Imagine there was a non canon ending where Micah caps John and Dutch

[supple stag]

[hidden moss]

then kills sadie

[hushed flare]

there's no reason to have high honor in epilogue

[round hedge]

the perfect way to have john's honor matter in RDR

would be about ross fate

[hushed flare]

play as micah

[round hedge]

if he had high honor, he wouldn't be praised

and instead everyone would hate him because of him killing John

[hidden moss]

I wouldn’t be complaining

I’d love to do that

[round hedge]

while bad honor he'd get the normal ending, full of medals

and retired peacefully

[hidden moss]

Did you guys get high honour death or low honour?

[round hedge]

low honor is my favourite

but i got both

[hidden moss]

Low honour makes more sense.

[hushed flare]

Imagine shooting someone that destroyed all the remaining van der linde members without scratching smh

[frigid cloud]

Low in first playthrough

[round hedge]

true

[frigid cloud]

And returned to money

[hidden moss]

Like, Micah is REALLY dishonourable.

[round hedge]

micah wouldn't leave arthur alive to have a peaceful death at all

[hidden moss]

He would not leave arthur to die peacefully.

[hushed flare]

True

[hidden moss]

Yeah

[hushed flare]

I liked Micah shooting Arthur or stabbing him in the back more

Seems more Micah ey

[hidden moss]

It’s more of a revenge plot for John.

Beluga

Pablo the discord mod

[frigid cloud]

When Charles finds Arthur with a knife on the back

[hidden moss]

Okay but, imagine the pain Dutch felt

For low honour go with John

When he walks away, and hears that gunshot

No LMAO

[hushed flare]

Pablo or Lester

[hidden moss]

Pablo

[frigid cloud]

Best sheriff

[hidden moss]

he’s more powerful

[hushed flare]

Damn

[hidden moss]

Okay but,

Who would win in a gun fight,

Micah or Arthur

[hushed flare]

deadeye

[hidden moss]

No plot armour.

[hushed flare]

k

[fickle ravine]

[hushed flare]

well depending on what guns they are using then probably arthur

[frigid cloud]

Micah disarms authur and he wins

[humble lotus]

white

[hushed flare]

if we had an actual duel with Micah

not just getting pinned down to a box

[hidden moss]

ever notice that

In the chapter 6 stand off,

Micah draws his revolver first, but Arthur still draws faster

[frigid cloud]

I did

Everyone did eventually

[hidden moss]

I love that

And how

[frigid cloud]

Micah's getting old that's it

[hidden moss]

When using dead eye, Arthur has a clock ticking in the background

[hushed flare]

dude have you seen how fast Arthur and John can pull there weapons out using RT to aim

[hidden moss]

Meaning the time he has left to live,

[round hedge]

imagine RDR John draw agains't micah lmao

[hidden moss]

But with John he doesn’t.

[wraith panther]

you what

[hidden moss]

Micah would probably win

in a draw

[wraith panther]

That's for his remaining life?

[round hedge]

definitely not, john draws quick af

even quicker than arthur

[hushed flare]

have you guys ever drawn guns using RT or while aiming

[hidden moss]

Just my opinion

[round hedge]

yeah

[hushed flare]

They draw an entire shotgun in half a second

[hidden moss]

I hit RT then LT

[hidden moss]

Yes

[round hedge]

watch a video of john drawing, he's quick af

it takes like

0.2 second for him to draw a revolver

completely

[hushed flare]

I have a whole clip of me doing it xd

Why I recorded it? Idk

Micah is hottest

Change my mind

[round hedge]

because it's fun

imagine reloading a single action revolver in 1 second

definitely jogn

john

[hushed flare]

#red-dead-media

[hidden moss]

Just watched the scene where he shoots the 3 Mexicans,

Vs Micah shooting those Grays,

And John took about 2 seconds to shoot the 3 Grays,

[round hedge]

he didn't have a reason to shoot fast tho

[hidden moss]

and John took like 3 to shoot all of the Mexicans

[round hedge]

both are pretty different

[hidden moss]

Ig

[round hedge]

john wasn't in any danger at all, while micah was in a shootout

[hidden moss]

Micah will do anything for his own survival,

Much like a rat.

People say Micah "avenged" Sean

No he didn’t.

He saved himself.

and,

The stuff Micah says is deep

Like his quotes are making you see the real world.

[hushed flare]

It was easier for Micah to shoot everyone as the other 2 liked Sean and had feelings

[hidden moss]

Yeah.

[hushed flare]

Micah didnt care so he killed 3 people while the other 2 didn't even know what was going on

[hidden moss]

You gotta kill to eat, that’s how this country is.

There are winners, and losers, nothing else besides.

I agree with him ngl

[hushed flare]

I'm pretty sure Micah ratted just so he can take a little bit more money sadly

[hidden moss]

He will do anything so he can survive.

That or immunity ig

[hushed flare]

Tbf people will shoot you over slightly bumping into them so eh

In 1899 apparently

[hidden moss]

Tbf.. most of the gang treated Micah like shit.

I know he did the same back, but still.

People be shooting at john cuz he antagonised them and said they had a small neck

He didn’t have any bond with any of them besides Dutch.

[hushed flare]

Micah didn't really have a reason to care for the gang if everyone hated him all the way back in chapter 2

[hidden moss]

LMAO

Micah was pretty much unlikeable. He would go out of his way to insult the gang

[round hedge]

main reason why john has the epilogue neck size

[hidden moss]

Strauss: I'm-
Arthur: leaving.

[hidden moss]

He also sexually harasses all of the women.

In dialogue at camp.

[hushed flare]

ye

[round hedge]

why have women in a gang when you can't bang them 🗿

[hidden moss]

The women do like..

Nothing

Except Sadie

[odd creek]

Lol

[round hedge]

sadie plot armor

massive plot armor

[hidden moss]

And Abigail

[odd creek]

I rember that quote, one of the only f bombs in the entire story

[hidden moss]

b o a h

[sinful knot]

3 whores in camp yet arthur doesnt wanna do shit

[hidden moss]

Sean the only one who got laid

Oh I didn’t know I was talkin' to a LADY

[round hedge]

Do you want me to take out a gun a blow a fucking hole in your head, right here, right now

[hidden moss]

I mean everyone got laid by Abigail.

[lost moss]

What the fuck

[round hedge]

you want that? you want that?

[hidden moss]

Well true

[round hedge]

what a fucking badass quote

[hushed flare]

Mary Beth is a pickpocketer, I forgot what Abigail does, Tilly helped with one companion activity and does work, Susan runs the camp practically and can use a gun

[round hedge]

horny

[odd creek]

Perhaps

[hushed flare]

Most of their roles go away in chapter 6 at most

[sinful knot]

John's most badass line

[night python]

Micah: Im not a monster miss

Mary beth: Of course you are not

Mary beth: You are not that interesting

[hidden moss]

Ain’t that a nice way to talk to a lady?

shakes chest

[odd creek]

explodes Mary Beth 5 seconds later

[round hedge]

even archer got scared lmao

[frigid cloud]

He breathes so heavily like bru

[round hedge]

he heard that and thought

[hidden moss]

That time Micah flirted was the only time he seemed nervous.

[hushed flare]

Archer

[round hedge]

"yep i'll be in beechers hope assault you fucker"

[night python]

It would have been funny if you could ask her to dance and she said yes after that

[hidden moss]

Like he was stuttering and he actually looked like he meant it

[round hedge]

is it archer

[hidden moss]

Charles throwing micah on his ass. Respect

[round hedge]

archer fordham

[frigid cloud]

Lmao

[round hedge]

something like that

[hidden moss]

That actually happened to me

[hushed flare]

oh

[hidden moss]

Literally right after Micah asked her she asked me to dance

[sinful knot]

"Mr marston i ask you to calm down"

[night python]

Right after micah flirted with her?

[round hedge]

mf really just went to kill john because of that

fr

[hushed flare]

They know how lethal John was so of course archer would be scared

[odd creek]

Bruh why don’t they make it so you can dismember Micah at the Mountain

[hushed flare]

And also plot armor

[round hedge]

people have said in years that archer didn't go to kill john

when that mf is legit in front of him

[hidden moss]

Giving micah to the skinner brothers would be nice

[hushed flare]

kek or cringe

[sinful knot]

Arthur shoots nobody in cutscenes but John will be quick to shoot those mexican soldiers in the head for Luisa

[hushed flare]

I'm surprised Arthur didn't start shooting after Micah shot grim shaw infront of the entire gang

Maybe there's some weird reason but i don't know everything about the story

[frigid cloud]

We would've entered dead eye and tag Micah and everyone else

[hushed flare]

Have to make rdr happen somehow

[wraith panther]

Just murders the entire Gang save for him and John with 2 revolvers.

[frigid cloud]

Maybe only Micah then

[night python]

Dutch: It will take more than a prehistoric to scare you surely

Arthur: I just want to see you meet your match when it comes to an ancient alligator with a big mouth Dutch

[hushed flare]

legendary alligator

[night python]

And then Dutch goes and calls Arthur a comedian

[hushed flare]

Like dutch wouldn't crap himself

[frigid cloud]

I imagine dutch shooting author if he shot Micah in that standoff

[hidden moss]

Plus cleet and joe

[night python]

Micah shoots grimshaw

[hushed flare]

I wouldn't be surprised if bill started shooting

[night python]

Dutch: Who is betraying me?

[hidden moss]

Ig they just froze from shock

[hushed flare]

damn I wonder who killed grimshaw, must be the wind

[frigid cloud]

Authur to Tilly: Dutch has a soft spot for her

[night python]

If im not mistaken i think dutch and grimshaw were together at some point

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[hushed flare]

More like had a soft spot

[night python]

Before the story

[night python]

Makes it even worse

He trusted someone who joined 6 months ago more than a girl that he was with in the past

[hidden moss]

Dominatrix

[hushed flare]

I raised someone for 20 years but this other person fills my ego so even if he kills a old gang member then I still trust him until 1907

[hidden moss]

Micah saved Dutch's life. You're gonna think highly of someone for that

[frigid cloud]

You can see dutch on map after he goes to save john in train job

[wraith panther]

Micah only joined 6 months ago?

[night python]

Arthur did múltiple times as well

[night python]

Yeah

[wraith panther]

yo wtf

[hushed flare]

He despawns right

[night python]

He mentions twice i think

[frigid cloud]

Idk but you can see white dot which says dutch

[wraith panther]

Dutch is pretty fucked

[hushed flare]

when John isn't a dot on the minimap

[frigid cloud]

🗿

[hidden moss]

That knock to the head during the trolley station robbery did its damage

[night python]

Does this trolley go to tahiti?!

[frigid cloud]

Does this boat go to Tahiti

[hushed flare]

when you donate 10000 to camp funds and we still need more money

Smh Tahiti must be expensive

[frigid cloud]

Donates 10101019272937392730182022810272927$

Still not enough

[hushed flare]

I think we are trying to buy earth

not go to tahiti

[frigid cloud]

Makes sense

So dutch can get rid of the law

[hushed flare]

[frigid cloud]

Then make the earth Tahiti

[hushed flare]

Buy the law to delete it

[hidden moss]

1 mor scor orthurr

[frigid cloud]

oh orthur

[night python]

We need noise arthur

[hushed flare]

Mary oh Arthur linton

[night python]

One more big score

[hushed flare]

I think blowing up a bridge and then robbing the train that has the money to fix it was kind of smart

[night python]

Every single time mary said a word: oH aOrThUr

[hushed flare]

And also killing colm

[frigid cloud]

Killing colm definitely

[hidden moss]

yOu rUinEd mAh LiFe

[hushed flare]

Have those "for sale" houses been used yet

In online or story

[sinful knot]

"I like a strong woman, but not that strong"-John

[hidden moss]

A few more like her, there wont even be a world left

[night python]

Didnt John call abigail a man at some point?

[sinful knot]

Yeah in a chp2 interaction

[chrome roost]

ah oops sry

[balmy palm]

I've only ever played rdr2 on ps5. Is pc better?

[sinful knot]

PC doesnt lock your framerate at 30

and yes cause of JMRP

[civic nest]

Fucking finally, I found the goddamn turkey

[balmy palm]

._. So... they didn't update rdr2 for ps5 OR ANYTHING?

[sinful knot]

Nope

[civic nest]

I got zoologist and skin deep now

[balmy palm]

:( man......

They NEED TO, the ps5 can take it.

[round hedge]

no

it's rockstar

why would they care about RDR2 💀

[balmy palm]

Why would they make anything better?

[round hedge]

they only care about downgrades

not upgrades

[balmy palm]

Downgrades people, downgrades.

[round hedge]

they rather downgrade the graphics or john

than upgrade for ps5

exactly

[balmy palm]

True true.

Its the money maker.

People using micro transactions makes it even better for them online.

[golden storm]

do I have to do all the gold medals to 100% rd2

[frigid cloud]

Nope

Only for gold rush trophy but that's 70 gold medals of course

Gold medals 🤢 anyway

[golden storm]

ok I will not do them all gold

that sounds like a waste of time lol

[frigid cloud]

Exactly

It is a waste of time

You just need to do the things in progress menu

[balmy palm]

Is there a tutorial for all gang locations?

I want to 100% kill all gangs.

[hidden moss]

Can just find a guide online

[golden storm]

I'm glad most of the gang hideouts are found in story lol

I think I only need to find 2 more del lobos, all the skinner locations, and probably another laramie location

[balmy palm]

._. Cant find some, some closer to armadillo. John only

I think.. 🤔

[golden storm]

Fort mercer and something breech

gaptooth breech

[balmy palm]

So they must look like Mike Tyson!! XD

[hidden moss]

I just finished the mission where eagle flies dies.. it really sucks how it happened. Dutch left me lmao

It feels like I’m getting close to the end of this

[golden storm]

I'm pretty sure that's the second to last mission

[hidden moss]

Oh god

I’m nervous

[golden storm]

dont be

[hidden moss]

I don’t see any of this going well

[golden storm]

I had trouble with that eagle flies mission actually

[hushed flare]

My last son is BS to get a gold medal in

[hidden moss]

“Our Best Selves” well, I’ll write after the mission.

[hushed flare]

Good mission

[golden storm]

oh nvm our best selves isn't the last one

[hushed flare]

Micah saves Arthur and everyone is happy

[golden storm]

then arthur leaves with mary

[hushed flare]

[golden storm]

tobi you're on the second to last mission now

[hushed flare]

no there's like 5 more

more actually

[golden storm]

no I looked it up

[hushed flare]

I forgor 💀

[golden storm]

our best selves is the last train rob mission

then it's rdr

then ep

[hushed flare]

you forgot epilogue missions

Ye

[golden storm]

I mean in the story >:(

[hushed flare]

That is the story bruv

[golden storm]

still

I just killed tophat stranger in rdr1

[frigid cloud]

Our best selves is easier

Red dead redemption is a little annoying

[golden storm]

yeah its a lot different from rd2

[frigid cloud]

Whats a lot different

I was talking about the mission

Not the first game

[golden storm]

OHH

ok

[hidden moss]

Wait, johns dead? But I thought we played as him in the first game..

[round hedge]

prequel

[hushed flare]

REACH ABIGAIL AND SADIE WITHIN 1MINUTE

[round hedge]

that's easy lol

[hushed flare]

get 7 headshots in a carcano rifle

[frigid cloud]

Not in replay

[round hedge]

that sucks

[hushed flare]

Deadeye

[round hedge]

oh.

[hidden moss]

The missions not over?

[hushed flare]

how I completed it was just spamming moonshine

Moonshije doesn't count to using health items

[frigid cloud]

Using the main street to run could be doable with high health

[golden storm]

it transfers into the last mission in chapter 6

[hushed flare]

Level 8 health cores sadly

[frigid cloud]

Didn't know that lol so I did it legitimately

[hidden moss]

Agh, shot

Should I focus on this?

And then text after it?

[frigid cloud]

Up to u

[hushed flare]

I want to use my level 10 cores in replay 😔

[hidden moss]

Alright I’ll text when I need to

[hushed flare]

guys what is the best seasoned big game meat

[frigid cloud]

I wonder if moonshine still works for not using any health items

[hushed flare]

it does

[frigid cloud]

I wish I knew that

[hushed flare]

Idk why but moonshine counts to not using health items and health cure does i think

Maybe cuz it removes a bit of health core or an oversight

better then hiding behind cover to refill a smidge of health

[hidden moss]

My honors max- is that good?

[frigid cloud]

Yes

Perfect

[golden storm]

yes good

wait how did you max your honor

[frigid cloud]

Strauss' missions

[golden storm]

true you get a lot of honor from those last 3 Strauss missions

[hidden moss]

I helped mrs downs, Strauss, and Charlotte

[frigid cloud]

nice

[hushed flare]

I like low honor ending more

imo

it feels more character for Micah to shoot arthur

[lost moss]

I was so sad when Arthur got shot in the head by Micah and Dutch walks away

[hushed flare]

I cried of happiness because I was happy what Micah accomplished

[lost moss]

You have the most money on your self in this server

[hidden moss]

I guess good thing I have high honor

Ima go now before I get spoiled more

[frigid cloud]

Bye

[hushed flare]

I have a 1500 bounty in this server from trolling

[frigid cloud]

Come back after the final mission

[hidden moss]

Wait wait

[lost moss]

How

[hidden moss]

Micahs a fucking Ray

Rat**

[hushed flare]

good rat

[golden storm]

bad rat

[hidden moss]

Fuck that guy but I’ll be back after the mission

[hushed flare]

[golden storm]

did you not expect it tho tbh

[frigid cloud]

Epilogue enjoyers soon

[hushed flare]

Only epilogue enjoyers can get level 10 deadeye

[golden storm]

basic story mode fans:
epilouge enjoyers:

[hidden moss]

Ima write a paragraph after this mission

This is sad asf abigails crying

[frigid cloud]

Lol

[golden storm]

I hope my girlfriend sadie adler is in rd1

[frigid cloud]

First time playing?

[hidden moss]

The music 😭 I’ll be back

[golden storm]

yes

she's in mexico according to where she said she wanted to go so its possible

[frigid cloud]

I'm sure she's in the first game

Do u want to know she's in the first game or not

[golden storm]

I bet not lol

[frigid cloud]

Or just find out on your own

Ok

[hidden moss]

Why am I crying

[frigid cloud]

y

[hidden moss]

The music

Ahhh shit I’m at camp brb

[frigid cloud]

Good

I love how you can run into the caves without john saying we have to go authur

[hidden moss]

Holy shit

Miss grimshaw

Time to fuck people up

[red helm]

Before going into the caves, you can turn and see Micah/etc, and aim at them, BUT you can not shot at them... Grr.

[frigid cloud]

Throw dynamite

[red helm]

Oh.. Dynamite. Didn't think of that.... Yeah, I was doing that a bunch of times to see all the ending... Oh well.

[frigid cloud]

They have a lot of health they get back up after the explosion

[hidden moss]

My horse wtf

[frigid cloud]

Next...

[red helm]

:( Worst part of the game...

[hidden moss]

Oh shit

Big choice..

Uh

Uh

[frigid cloud]

Buell actually looks better than I thought

[hidden moss]

Ima go for the money… to try to get it to John

[golden storm]

no go with john

[frigid cloud]

Doesn't matter

[hidden moss]

I just went for the money

Awe he put his hat on him

Oh shit the music

Brb

[frigid cloud]

I hope I didn't force Buell to flee

[golden storm]

I haveng seen that ending but the John one is the sunset ending

[frigid cloud]

In my save

[frigid cloud]

Too late now

[golden storm]

mhm

[red helm]

I used Buell for quite awhile in the Epilogue, but just got a Dark bay(?) Turkoman.. going to compare once I get it to 4th bond.

[golden storm]

I'm almost done with rd1 chapter one

[frigid cloud]

I didn't find buell looking good so I never took it

[red helm]

Not the biggest fan of Buell's looks, so, eh... Hard to beat his stats though.

[golden storm]

who is buelll

[red helm]

Unique horse you get from the Veteran's side mission.

[golden storm]

oh I haven't done that one yet

[frigid cloud]

And trophy from giant boar

[golden storm]

ik its good though

[hidden moss]

42 thousand?! And that’s not enough to leave earlier?

[golden storm]

he had a plan ig

[red helm]

Dutch is a greedy ding dong.

[hidden moss]

Oh shit

Micah just stabbed me brb again

[frigid cloud]

Authur vs Micha

[latent plover]

If everyone had a little faith then the gang would be in Tahiti

[golden storm]

can't believe micah is going to save arthur and bring him to mary

[frigid cloud]

He's unbelievably buffed in that ending

Atleast you get to slice his eye

[hidden moss]

Damn I fucked his eye up

Just bit his ass

Oh there’s Dutch

He can’t kill me and I got tb lmao

[frigid cloud]

Plot armor

[hidden moss]

Wait

Dutch knows?

He looks sad

[frigid cloud]

Knows what

[hidden moss]

Micah was the rat

The music omg

Wait

No

[frigid cloud]

Probably believed in the end

[hidden moss]

That’s how he dies..?

Wow..

[frigid cloud]

who

Authur?

[hidden moss]

Arthur

[red helm]

Good times...

[frigid cloud]

There are 4 different endings

[hidden moss]

Looking up at the sunset in the camp

Is there one where I win?

[frigid cloud]

No

He dies either way

[hidden moss]

Wait, I play as John now?

Sick

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[red helm]

Yeap, he always dies.

[hidden moss]

That sucks

[frigid cloud]

Farming simulator time

[hidden moss]

Why is John so buff

[red helm]

Milk dem cows!

[hidden moss]

Bruh

They just moved us on instantly

I’m emotionally scared

[red helm]

Tip, don't get in a accident with your wagon.

[hidden moss]

Ew John with a beard

[frigid cloud]

Best way to hide the scars

[hidden moss]

I like the scars

Bruh

I’m broke now

[frigid cloud]

You'll get a lot of money at the end

[hidden moss]

Like gta?

[frigid cloud]

I'd not worry

Yes

[red helm]

Yeah, just concentrate on missions for awhile.

[hushed flare]

brutally murders horse and a guy

More importantly, don't run into a wagon with a horse

[hidden moss]

Am I wearing the jacket from chapter one?

[frigid cloud]

yes

[red helm]

Just one guy?

[frigid cloud]

Lancaster repeater
Kill counts 192720372038398

[hushed flare]

No I meant the entire population of saint denis

[hidden moss]

Jim Milton

[frigid cloud]

John Jim

[golden storm]

I always wonder what happens after the mission fails in the game universe

[hidden moss]

How long are the missions in epilogue?

[red helm]

I was giving him a hint for mission objective, odd ball.

[hushed flare]

#1 favorite weapon in most people's compendium probably

[frigid cloud]

Like 7-8 in first epilogue probably

[hidden moss]

My favorite was the Schofield

[golden storm]

short, you can finish epilouge entirely in like 2-3 hours

[frigid cloud]

Gold medals be like
Feed a horse
Milk the cows in 10 seconds

[hushed flare]

I used duel lemats so much it became my #1 favorite from compendium

[hidden moss]

Does the honor matter as John?

[frigid cloud]

No

[hushed flare]

Complete mission with 90% accuracy
Complete mission in 2 minutes
Complete without health items
Complete with only side arms

[red helm]

Not really, but high honor still gives a store discount, so, whatever.

[frigid cloud]

Other than that max honor gives you 50% discount

[hidden moss]

Alright

[frigid cloud]

In every shop

[hidden moss]

I hope we can find Micah and kill him.. or is that in rdr1?

[hushed flare]

You get so much money that honor discount stops to matter as john

[red helm]

Low honor, better loot from humans. Your call.

[frigid cloud]

Not in rdr1

[hushed flare]

I wish low honor had more benefits then more loot from bodies

[frigid cloud]

He's not even in rdr1

[hushed flare]

No reason to become dishonorable unless your lazy or just have a bunch of money

[red helm]

Me too. High honor gets way more benefits.

[golden storm]

how many benefits from high

[latent plover]

Lazy?

[frigid cloud]

I already had low honor from massacring armadillo

[red helm]

Should've had low honor outfits and such.

[hidden moss]

I’d assume since he’s not in rdr1 we kill him or rockstar just be rockstar and leave a loose end

[hushed flare]

Only dishonor benefits I can name is
Lvl1 more loot from bodies and different dialogue for only Arthur it seems
Lvl5 gives a new deadeye sound and it's more noticeable on Arthur but John gets a bit of extra bass

[frigid cloud]

You will definitely get spoilers if you keep asking

[hushed flare]

Ikr

[golden storm]

epilouge gold medal: birth the cow in under 10 seconds

[hushed flare]

birth the foal in 5 seconds

[frigid cloud]

Gold medal
Beat jack in the race

[red helm]

Yeah, Horse, not cow.

[hushed flare]

yes

[frigid cloud]

Feed a horse

[golden storm]

Beat jack

[hushed flare]

Gold medal
Take no damage in the shootout

[golden storm]

he deserves it imo

[hushed flare]

If only jack wasn't such a glitchy dialogue

[red helm]

Yeap, Jack is a little jerk most of the time.

[frigid cloud]

Beat up the leader without taking any hit and in 25 seconds

[golden storm]

my goodness how many missions are in rd1 chapter 1 geez

[frigid cloud]

Not as bad as Anderson in chapter 3

[hushed flare]

You can grapple then press left joystick to put him on the ground and that usually beats anyone

Unless it's plot armor Micah and tommy

[golden storm]

can you get Milton's hat

[hushed flare]

Derby hat

[red helm]

I was talking to Jack about John's dad, and out of no where Jack got mad and I had to hit the Defuse option... Jack was like "Why are you staring at me like that".

[frigid cloud]

Don't think so

[hushed flare]

I think Milton uses a weird derby hat

[golden storm]

I want a top hat actially

[hushed flare]

Stovehat

[golden storm]

😐

[hushed flare]

I said stovehat

[golden storm]

idc ab hat names

[red helm]

Might be at the Tailor in Saint Denis?

[golden storm]

I've never been to the tailor lmao

[hushed flare]

Tailor sells like 6 top hat varients but I don't think any of them are black and black or black and white

Tailors are cool

[frigid cloud]

You have

In that mission with trelawny

[hushed flare]

fine night of word I still can't spell

Mission

[golden storm]

oh wait yeah I remember

[frigid cloud]

Fine night of the debauchery

[golden storm]

the boat mission

[frigid cloud]

Or something

[golden storm]

great mission

[red helm]

You probably couldn't shop through the catalog in that mission, though.

[frigid cloud]

He's been there

[hushed flare]

Fine night of doucheaberry I always thought

[golden storm]

I want fancier clothing

[frigid cloud]

Lol

[hushed flare]

Classic frock coat black is a start

[red helm]

But, yeah, you had to go in, during the mission, but...

[hushed flare]

Or the shotgun coat from gambler outfit

[golden storm]

I also want dutches outfit it's nice

[hushed flare]

I want his vest

[golden storm]

rdr3 where Dutch is the protagonist and he rounds up the gang

[red helm]

You can get it in Online, but, frig that non-sense.

[hushed flare]

His vest is the best

[golden storm]

lol like I'll play online

[frigid cloud]

Not anymore

[red helm]

Could..

[golden storm]

what happens if you kill alden

[frigid cloud]

Authurs outfit for 52 gold bars 🗿

Such bs

[red helm]

Yeah, Online is just a grindfest ugh.

[hushed flare]

All important npcs respawn

[golden storm]

are alden and his friend in strawberry in a relationship

[hushed flare]

wtf

[hidden moss]

Johns is the same price

[frigid cloud]

Yeah

Unfortunately

Probably will be on discount but still no

[hushed flare]

when John's outfit in online is more accurate then the one in story mode

[frigid cloud]

Fr

[lost moss]

Imagine not getting the outfits when they first came out in outlaw pass 2 🤮

[hushed flare]

rockstar and take two

[lost moss]

Kinda mad that they added those

I wanted them to be exclusive to outlaw pass 2

[hidden moss]

I have both from the outlaw pass

[lost moss]

Same

[hidden moss]

along with the union stuff

[frigid cloud]

Not everyone was playing it since day one

[lost moss]

I didn’t get the first outlaw pass

[hidden moss]

Oh, I’ve maxed all of them

[lost moss]

I completed it but didn’t get enough gold to buy it

And from then on I have been dedicated to competing and buying every single pass they add

[hushed flare]

I did online for like 4 days then dropped it

[golden storm]

wait im confused on why the government made John go to new austin in rd1

[hushed flare]

Call to arms looks like a fun mode though

[frigid cloud]

To hunt down Bill and javier

[golden storm]

ohh cool cool

wait javier

[hushed flare]

javier

Yes

[golden storm]

I didnt know he was in this

[hushed flare]

havier

[red helm]

Blackmailing him. He had to hunt down his old gang, or they were going to Jail him and they were holding his Wife and Kid hostage. Basically.

[golden storm]

I want to go back to my family and see uncle

ohhh cool cool cool

[hidden moss]

I loved Javier until he sided with Dutch

[frigid cloud]

Where was uncle

[red helm]

Javier is in 1 mission, for like 2 minutes. I actually forgot about him, until someone reminded me, some months back, on here.

[hidden moss]

Where

Now I’m curious

[golden storm]

Javier didn't sire with dutch?

WAIT no thats charles

[hidden moss]

He did

[hushed flare]

Sire

[golden storm]

whos javier

[hidden moss]

He stood with Dutch

The Mexican hot boy

[red helm]

I honestly don't remember specifically, at the end of the Mexico missions.

[golden storm]

wait I don't remember this dude

[hidden moss]

The one guy that wears a blue jacket always

And plays with knives

[frigid cloud]

Charles

[hushed flare]

lol

[golden storm]

what mission was he in

[hidden moss]

A lot of them

[red helm]

Remember in Chapter 1(RDR2) when you were saving John up on the mountain, from the Wolves? Javier was the guy you were with.

[frigid cloud]

In first mission literally

[hushed flare]

I wonder why Pinkerton's didn't make John hunt sadie and charles

[golden storm]

oh I thought that was dutch

[hidden moss]

Bruh

[frigid cloud]

Bro u use Charles' horse in first mission

[hidden moss]

They look the same bro no difference

[golden storm]

bc Charles was in Canada and sadie was a bounty hunter and maybe in mexico

[red helm]

Javier plays such a small part in RDR2 as well, it's kind of sad.

[frigid cloud]

Do companion requests & activities with him

[hushed flare]

I can literally only remember like 2 missions Javier was in that was with you and it's like companion activity and trelawny mission

[golden storm]

also whats up with homesteads

it said there's like 8

but there's only one mission I could find

[red helm]

He is in Guarma with you guys, but he gets shot immediately and you go and rescue him, so again, you barely see him.

[golden storm]

wait I thought that was charles

[frigid cloud]

Then you save him with dutch

[hushed flare]

guarma map expansion

[red helm]

Charles doesn't go to Guarma.

[frigid cloud]

Charles makes a distraction for others to escape

[hushed flare]

I like how everyone that went to guarma with Arthur became your enimies

[hidden moss]

Mango farm simulator

[golden storm]

as soon as dutch said there was a rat in chapter 4 I was like ok it's micah

[frigid cloud]

Did anyone talk about rat in chapter 4?

[hidden moss]

Same but then molly

[golden storm]

although the spoilers I saw never did I see that dutch was the villain so that was a suprise

[frigid cloud]

Molly wasn't a rat lol

[golden storm]

same same

[red helm]

I was suspecting Abigail for awhile

[golden storm]

she claimed to be

[frigid cloud]

No she was just drunk

[golden storm]

ywah

[frigid cloud]

And if you listened to Milton she didn't talk

[golden storm]

yeah ik she didn't rat

[frigid cloud]

o

[hushed flare]

so according to Milton Micah wasn't a rat till after they got of guarma

[golden storm]

oh def not true

[hushed flare]

Micah is good guy confirmed

[golden storm]

he was a rat from blackwater at least

[frigid cloud]

No

[hushed flare]

why would Micah wait all this time if he was a rat from the beginning anyway

[frigid cloud]

Dutch was too reckless I guess in chapter 4

[golden storm]

micah planned the whole job in blackwater

[red helm]

Good and Evil are just a point of view. These things are not always Black and White. There is lots of shades of grays.

[hushed flare]

What I hate about most Micah haters how they immediately say "Micah bad, he do bad" without proof or question

[golden storm]

rdr3 play as Dutch final mission is the ferry job I hope

[hushed flare]

Blackwater ferry job would have been a cool first mission

Then the normal colter stuff would happen

[golden storm]

yeah just like prolouge in gta5

[frigid cloud]

178000$ heist

[hushed flare]

I don't think Arthur was in the ferry job so maybe you play as micah

[golden storm]

or john

you get shot

[frigid cloud]

Then push john to the water

[golden storm]

I like how that's the big bank in Yankton and it only had 178000 dollars

[hushed flare]

biggest city

[golden storm]

Mexico expansion when

[frigid cloud]

Never

[hushed flare]

I wanted to go inside sisika

And fort wallace

[golden storm]

your mom expansion when

[golden storm]

you go inside fort wallace

[hushed flare]

IN F R E E R O A M

[golden storm]

I'm sure you can with hacks or glitches

[frigid cloud]

console

[golden storm]

glitches

[frigid cloud]

Don't say it

[golden storm]

actually it's probably very easy to spawn a hot air balloon in pc rdr2 since it's already a thing lol

but also you can tp to it probably

1783

mhm look it up

[hidden moss]

can we all agree that dutch also let hosea die

[frigid cloud]

No

[hushed flare]

Level 30+ saying why you shouldn't say mods or glitches or you will be banned:

[hidden moss]

dutch let hosea die

[golden storm]

no

[hidden moss]

yes

[hushed flare]

Your mom let Hosea die

[frigid cloud]

I did lol

When was it invented?

[hidden moss]

arthur was a child to dutch

[golden storm]

john was a child to dutch

[lost moss]

When was what invented

[hidden moss]

shit dutch is the main Villain

[golden storm]

yeah he picked him up at age 8

[hidden moss]

not even micah

[frigid cloud]

John is doubtful in chapter 2 already

[hidden moss]

Milton said if dutch came out of the bank he would let hosea live

[frigid cloud]

Authur should've dead eyed everyone

[hushed flare]

Micah fed dutch ego and dutch went weird mode and betrayed people he knew for 20 years the end

[golden storm]

also dutch had a brain injury