red-dead-singleplayer

[rose thistle]

there is a kid among us

[hidden moss]

Sus

[mild hawk]

sussy

[rose thistle]

@glass vapor

[mild hawk]

[golden vector]

online user rates drop to 0%

[glass vapor]

WHAT

[rose thistle]

GETOUTOFMYHEADGETOUTOFMYHEAD

@glass vapor

[glass vapor]

oke

[rose thistle]

@glass vapor

@glass vapor

[frigid cloud]

When you join a server just for emojis

[mild hawk]

okay

[glass vapor]

come in the corner

[golden vector]

📮

[mild hawk]

peternity

[rose thistle]

pedo

[mild hawk]

:

:

.,

yeha

[summer garnet]

wajajan 697 is pog

[hidden moss]

Almost every server I joined is for emotes

[mild hawk]

same

[rose thistle]

yeah him too

[rose thistle]

join mine too

[mild hawk]

i am incredibly anti social

[rose thistle]

very pog emojis

[frigid cloud]

Inv in dms

[mild hawk]

i cant even speak in a discord server without feeling like ass

[rose thistle]

[golden vector]

wonder why that is huh

[frigid cloud]

Or

[summer garnet]

same

[hidden moss]

Ok?

[glass vapor]

@rose thistle u must be rich

[golden vector]

📮🚘

amog

ys

[hidden moss]

Ok?

Ok.

[frigid cloud]

ok

[summer garnet]

ok

[golden vector]

⛔

[summer garnet]

ok

[mild hawk]

🚖

[rose thistle]

no

I'm poor

sub to me so I become rich

[golden vector]

to when the participant in the crew preforms suspicious and untrustworthy actions

[glass vapor]

i did

before this

[mild hawk]

dang quarantine

that's -1 subscriber

you have got to delete your channel

too much

[rose thistle]

lmao

idk what I'll do now

@wise condorroll I lost a sub

[golden vector]

gameroll was banned here

[mild hawk]

good for him

[rose thistle]

good

[golden vector]

lol

he joined another rdr server though 😔

annoying asf

[rose thistle]

yeah

he harassed melodic

and therefore melodic nearly killed himself

[frigid cloud]

I remember that

[summer garnet]

damn

[rose thistle]

over a video type that melodic originally created and did better

[frigid cloud]

Saw his community post as well

He hearts every comment

[mild hawk]

not to mention that gameroll most likely lies about his age and life just so people can ""respect him""

[rose thistle]

Gameroll is most likely 15

[mild hawk]

man says that he's 30 years old and has a wife and child yet all he cares about is his ego

and youtube subscribers

:/

[rose thistle]

wife and child?

[summer garnet]

almost everyone who is 14 does that

[rose thistle]

what person would marry and fuck with him?

and the poor kid

[summer garnet]

that is an excelent question

[golden vector]

more like cares if his youtube subscribers still give a shit and less of actually enjoying their own things

[mild hawk]

he is mistaking himself for his father most likely

[rose thistle]

he's gonna be

[mild hawk]

,

[golden vector]

he already is lol

i’m going to rejoin the other server he’s in just to see if he’s arguing still 24/7 over something subjective

[summer garnet]

i think i saw him comment on another yt channel

[hidden moss]

lmao

GameRoll ptsd

[hasty totem]

i need help

money or help john.

[frigid cloud]

Muneh

[hasty totem]

and why is arthur coughing to much.

[golden vector]

money

[echo iris]

who yall talking about

[mild hawk]

oh god

[echo iris]

on yt

[frigid cloud]

You've played the game or??

[hasty totem]

they are going to a mountain rn.

no

first time

[frigid cloud]

Still you should know what happens to him

[mild hawk]

lowest honor + money ending = best ending

[hasty totem]

ezz bruh

watch arthur killing pinkertons

[frigid cloud]

He's sick if you didn't notice @hasty totem

He has tuberculosis

[hasty totem]

then he’ll be in epilogue with john

[mild hawk]

yeah

[hasty totem]

ye lemme go kill the pinkertons brb

wait

omg im fighting

the micah guy

isnt he my bsf?

[mild hawk]

that fast?

ok

legit

[hasty totem]

wdym?

[frigid cloud]

Fr how fast

[hidden moss]

damn from killing pinkertons to micah in 10 sec

[hasty totem]

i got to a cliff

[mild hawk]

i see your plan here

[hasty totem]

wdym.

it was a cliff

[mild hawk]

yeah

[hasty totem]

and arthur

the main character

talked with john , i skipped that

[hidden moss]

micha is bsf

[frigid cloud]

Arthur will take a special miracle tonic

[hasty totem]

cool

alright

dont interrupt

me

im fighting

micah

brb

[hidden moss]

bruh

[frigid cloud]

How you're typing then

[hidden moss]

now he's at game credits

[frigid cloud]

Fast asf boi

[mild hawk]

he just got 100% rn

real professional

[rose thistle]

one mf is begging for a 4$ steam game in dm

saying its just 4$

I blocked and reported to modmail

[summer garnet]

if its just 4$ he can buy it himself

[rose thistle]

istg

[summer garnet]

lamfoa std

eat meats

[hidden moss]

Guys

My Arthur is cumming everywhere

how do i stop it

[summer garnet]

eat oleander i tried works 100%

[hidden moss]

std lmao..

ty

Arthur needs to fuck John ok?

[summer garnet]

eat common bulrush or oleander these things work super good against these

[hidden moss]

I don't want my boah to get horny everytime

[summer garnet]

np

[umbral zealot]

GUYS

I killed the legendary rat on top of a mountain

[hidden moss]

good

[golden vector]

trolled

[hidden moss]

skin it

[summer garnet]

nah bro thas a side affect he will be cured

[umbral zealot]

Damn says I cant skin micah

[golden vector]

🦷

[summer garnet]

np hope your arthur gets well soon

[golden vector]

hope you get cured soon!! 🥰🥰🥰☺️

[hidden moss]

u need to jerk off 200 times on Artur

he get shelead

like that

ok?

u need to jerk harder

200 per day

2000 per month

20000 per year

[summer garnet]

bro you need to white knight arthur and say that epilouge john just looks okay to you itll work trust me

[umbral zealot]

Guys

Did you know that

[hidden moss]

Arthur cums

[umbral zealot]

Arthur and john aim differently

[hidden moss]

yes

Arthur cums

John piss

[summer garnet]

why would i troll you friend?

[hidden moss]

different aim man

[umbral zealot]

Oh and your online charecter shits

[summer garnet]

nah he cums with one ball closed

[umbral zealot]

What

Dino bone quest sucks

[frigid cloud]

Nothing compared to hunting requests

[umbral zealot]

Not really

[frigid cloud]

Nah.

[umbral zealot]

Some of the requests are pretty convenient since you can just go to the store in San denis

[frigid cloud]

wat

[umbral zealot]

Unless its requests like tilly or dutch

[frigid cloud]

I was talking about the stuff required for 100%

[umbral zealot]

Dutches is fun to do since you get to kill a bear

[umbral zealot]

Oh

Yeah

[summer garnet]

bro then you havent tried out gambler challenge 8

[umbral zealot]

Speaking of gambling

I'm thinking about robbing the secret gambling room

[summer garnet]

np bro anytime

[frigid cloud]

For real

[summer garnet]

pls help me i have been doing this for 2 weeks and i only got 1 pls help plsplsplsplspsl

[umbral zealot]

LENNEH!

[frigid cloud]

It's luck based you just need to get lucky

No trick

[summer garnet]

ill pray ig thanks

[hidden moss]

Guys stop modding single player, RDR2 is already a perfect game with a perfect story with perfect gameplay with perfect cosmetics and zero flaws and zero issues or bugs, and it's ruining Rockstar's vision for red dead online since people will stop playing RDO and play Single player instead, then Rockstar will lose money and not be able to give us more online updates to make their perfect game even more perfect. r*'s level of quality and polish has never been achieved. they have changed our lives and the gaming world with their amazing storytelling. a character like arthur morgan will never come again, to the gaming world, leaving us gamers depressed. however some times in life you have to get a bittersweet ending. Roger Clark is the best actor ever and Arthur Morgan is the best character ever and RDR2 is the greatest game ever with zero flaws and Red Dead Online is the best multiplayer experience ever made and I love Rockstar games for their incredible work on the epilogue and I will continue to buy gold bars for Red Dead Online to fund Rockstar's development of Red Dead Online because without my gold bar purchases they will go bankrupt and die. R's level of quality and polish has never been achieved. they have changed our lives and the gaming world with their amazing storytelling. a character like arthur morgan will never come again, to the gaming world, leaving us gamers depressed. however some times in life you have to get a bittersweet ending. they have big cocks and big balls btw. Roger Clark is the best actor ever and Arthur Morgan is the best character ever and RDR2 is the greatest game ever with zero flaws and Red Dead Online is the best multiplayer experience ever made and I love Rockstar games for their incredible work on the epilogue and I will continue to buy gold bars for Red Dead Online to fund Rockstar's development of Red Dead Online because without my gold bar purchases they will go bankrupt and die. they have big cocks and big balls btw.,

U..U s--s--hh--ared opin-ion!?!??!!

omfg

Roger should block

you

“IT WAS PERFORMANCE CAPTUREEEEEEEE”

[hidden moss]

EXACATLY

Didn't know who you were 2 seconds ago. I couldn't care less.

Roger Clark

ahh

yeah I was making fun of that

Didn't know who you were 2 seconds ago. I couldn't care less.

he made a tweet like this

Was it a response to someone saying he was just a voice actor

[summer garnet]

u have twitter?

[hidden moss]

nah

[hidden moss]

Nah some dude shared his opinion about politics

Roger straight up blocked him

Lmao

[hasty totem]

guys…….

[hidden moss]

what’s up Jim Milton

[hasty totem]

arthur died….

[mild hawk]

nice!

[golden vector]

good

[hasty totem]

pussy destroyer

i was jk

i completed

red dead 2 times

[summer garnet]

good

[spark shard]

Yall think hair tonic affects pubes

[vale ledge]

Yes

[hidden moss]

A question I never thought I would hear 😂

Singleplayer> Multiplayer

Facts

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[hidden moss]

wtf

[hidden moss]

Im going say this one last time has anyone extracted the rdr1 audio awcs and had them playable in openiv and if so what program did u use too extract them from the iso snd from the rpfs i know for a fact GuiCORLEONEx794 managed to do it but i just for the 25th time that i have extracted them and the whole game files i get an error when opening them? Anyone know how i would stop the nuevo pariso outfit from getting removed from my wardrobe i got in into the wardrobe with bob ross' all items mod and when im wearing it out of nowhere i see that the outfit literally gets removed from the wardrobe and john no literally as im playing the outfit goes poof does anyone have an issue with loading 6.0 maps with 7.0 map editor Mainly the armadillo prosperous map ive tried like 20 times and get the same error this also happens with a couple other maps as well u sure because if it was then how is he in the wardrobe because with mp outfit changer the outfit resets to what it was so it must be modded sp content do u know why whenever i try to extract the rdr1 audio files i get this error in open iv gui said somehow he was able to extract them from the awc files but it wont let me Sad thing is that not just the horses coats visual looks are swapped but ratchel has old boys stats and old boy has ratchels but with ymt editing we could just maybe compare the two and whatever controls the restrictions we could remove from old boys ymt how exactly did u merge JMRP With Weebletron's NPC Closet I tried everything i could and only the model's were changed the textures were still the original textures i can send u my shop_items.ymt and could u do it for me please does anyone think that I don't own the game even though I have been seen playing it with this same discord account And at the time he said that I was playing the game I've merged so many times I don't even know how many times lol Stupid Merging And with the Catalogs, u need to be 100 percent correct if even a single line is one letter to the right of it the game won't read the file and that's caused me to do that 3 times in the past two days darn catalogs u want to compare the mods one with the vanilla one and then open up the offline one and then like if a change when u compare it is on say line 4455 you go to that line in the offline one and then copy the hash thats different just the 0xrandomnumbers part not any unk member then go to offline one then between <drawable> and </drawable> and to note some times it will have a name of an asset or a random hash in between them but that being said copy the hash that was changed over that and then repeat this till u did it all I think somehow by editing the catalog file you can get the (No Buckle) No OffHand In your wardrobe i don't know who tho whyem did it somehow actually the catalog from jmrp is WhyEm's it has the no buckle option i just don't know how he added it i might be able to find out by comparing a catalog file without it and the one with it and see what's missing from the one that doesn't have it and add whatever is missing to the catalog file that doesn't have it that should work

[frigid cloud]

Essay channel

[hidden moss]

Ughhh 4 hours in on gambler 8, still 1 more blackjack win with 5 cards to go

I hate R*

We should have gotten the ability to cheat😅

[uncut topaz]

Is it possible with rampage trainer to add the preorder neckpiece on pc?

[hushed flare]

or just nerf gambler 8-9-10

[hidden moss]

Ye lol

Atleast I alr got 2, should be done in about 80 hours ;p

[hidden moss]

[hidden moss]

Nope just got the last one😄🎉

Now gambler 9

[frigid cloud]

Worst

I prefer gambler 8 over 9 ngl

[hidden moss]

Nah, you can leave if you’re about to lose, then rejoin. It’ll still count as wins in a row

It’s pretty easy

[frigid cloud]

Don't like it regardless

It killed my hope for 100% cause I was bad at it

[hidden moss]

xD I like domino’s, so I’m good there😄

Haha

[frigid cloud]

Good for you

10 is shorter and piece of cake

[hidden moss]

Fr 10 took me like 5 mins whereas 9 took me bout 2 hours. Nice improvement

I think I'm alright at dominos, but the AI is sometimes OP at it

[frigid cloud]

I'll never understand dominoes

I hope rdr3 won't have the most complicated mini games ever

And that's as if it ever comes out

[vagrant temple]

This ^

[hidden moss]

I had to learn how to play all fives from a YouTube vid. Eventually got the hang of it

[vagrant temple]

I think I sorta understand it but I always lose

[hidden moss]

I had to play against tilly, Mary Beth and Abigail to have a better chance. Hosea is OP

Same with the guys at emerald station

[icy light]

I just shoot them if I don’t win

Easy as that

[hushed flare]

Can't wait for the challenge "win 5 times in a row while doubling down in blackjack"

[frigid cloud]

Blackjack is always rigged during 2 and 8

[hushed flare]

Or hunt a bear using only your breath to kill him

Blackjack is rigged definitely

I get blackjacks in gambler 8 when I'm trying to get 5 cards

[round hedge]

won't even be made

[hasty totem]

it will

[round hedge]

proof

[hasty totem]

my guy

this is rockstaf

rockstar

[round hedge]

exactly why it won't release

[hasty totem]

not Naughtydogs

[round hedge]

naughty dogs cared more about joel than rockstar cared about john 🗿

and rockstar is just milking their online modes for quick bucks

there won't be any RDR3

[frigid cloud]

Exactly

It wont

[hidden moss]

Would be hard to improve on rdr2 ngl

[sleek gazelle]

I want to sell my legendary ram to the trapper
But the trapper isn’t allowing me to do anything
If I save the game and reload it will be gone
I did it before

any body

How do I get my trapper to work
Without losing my pelt

[frigid cloud]

I don't think it will be gone

It goes to the trapper anyway I think

[round hedge]

make the gameplay less annoying

[hidden moss]

i understand

[round hedge]

that would be a great improvement

[hidden moss]

Make the challenges less dependent on luck too

[frigid cloud]

Lol

Ain't happening

[hidden moss]

One can wish

[frigid cloud]

Or just make it 45 challenges

[hidden moss]

that person who made the gambler challenges has a special place in hell

[hushed flare]

The last 3 gambler challengers were made by satan

[hidden moss]

10 was fine imo

10 was easy..

[hushed flare]

Well that's cheesable

[hidden moss]

but 8th one...

god..

4 painful days..

[hushed flare]

ok but why was gambler 6 so easy

[hidden moss]

9 took me longer I think than 8

Poker challenges were just a breeze

[hushed flare]

Most challenge difficulty pacings are weird

[frigid cloud]

Same

[hushed flare]

Master hunter is like "kill 5 cougars without a gun" then it goes to "kill an opposum while it's laying on ground"

[frigid cloud]

Everybody gangsta till 8th

[hushed flare]

8 is easy just get lucky

[frigid cloud]

Exactly.

[hidden moss]

The RNG gods were not on my side during 8

[frigid cloud]

Horseman 9 hurts to fail

[hushed flare]

when npcs hit 3 times and win

[hidden moss]

I cant do horseman 9 I dont think till I reach the epilogue

[frigid cloud]

You can

It's just a lot harder

[hushed flare]

when your doing a horse race challenge and you see a random encounter

[hidden moss]

especially as arthur

[frigid cloud]

[hidden moss]

I tried. Pinkertons fucked me up fast lol

if u dont make the jump across the bridge

[frigid cloud]

Special health cure

[hushed flare]

potent

is better

[frigid cloud]

Probably

Don't bother to craft it that often

[hidden moss]

I might just wait till epilogue. Knock that challenge out and then the last hunting request

[hushed flare]

I hardly see a difference between level 2 and 3 tonics

[frigid cloud]

Just do that it's easier

[hidden moss]

Yeaa

[hushed flare]

All I know is I have 4 special health cures and like 13 special snake oil im never gonna use in a real scenario

[hidden moss]

Only time I really bother crafting tonics is for herbalist

craft and use

[hushed flare]

Special horse reviver is probably the most useful imo

[hidden moss]

Definitely

[frigid cloud]

You barely pick up any plant in herb 10

[hushed flare]

Herb 9

Herb 11

[frigid cloud]

I guess it's a useful time to cook lots of minty big game

[hidden moss]

I have to do herb 7? Or whatever the one is where you have to craft special tonics that require 6x of 3 plants

Pain

[hushed flare]

I have 99 cooked big game and 50 something minty big game save me

[frigid cloud]

I have to try dat challenge with just killing murfrees

And looting them

[hushed flare]

murfrees are a ginseng farm

[frigid cloud]

I wonder what happens if you complete the last thing for 100% in a mission replay

[hushed flare]

completing American venom as last thing for 100%

[frigid cloud]

Impossible I think

Or not

Do you have to finish the story to place the squirrel?

[hushed flare]

idk

but I thought you would still get that camp place

Logically you should be able to

[hidden moss]

Probs just have to get as far as getting Beechers Hope

[hushed flare]

There's always those people who do everything with Arthur and then do John's role as finishing the quest

[hidden moss]

That will be me probs

[hushed flare]

I wish we could get more stagecoach robberies

[frigid cloud]

Seeing Arthur for 102829282 hours and seeing john for 4 hours

[hushed flare]

I was so confused when I never got more

[dark seal]

Is the Lancaster or Litchfield repeater better

[frigid cloud]

Lancaster

[dark seal]

Thanks

[hushed flare]

Evans repeater users be like

[haughty dome]

Litchfield is garbage

[hushed flare]

Carbine repeater users

[frigid cloud]

26 bullets with dead eye spam

[leaden bone]

So Horseman 9 is ride from Van Horn to Blackwater in less than 17 minutes without touching water, don't you have to touch water when crossing the Elizabeth river or whatever it's called?

[hushed flare]

I use Evans for the sound

[frigid cloud]

Use the bridge

[hushed flare]

There's also a spiral I think

I never used the bridge jump

[leaden bone]

I'm not talking about the huge river that feeds into Flat Iron lake

[hushed flare]

And I did it with an ardennes

[leaden bone]

I'm talking about the small river that comes down from Tall Trees or somewhere in there

[frigid cloud]

Use the owanjila dam then

[leaden bone]

Dam I didn't think about that

Thanks.

[frigid cloud]

I used that as arthur

Risky doe

Doesn't work if you have an arabian

[hushed flare]

average Arabian user vs average Shire enjoyer

[leaden bone]

I would assume that Horseman 8 is easy because Alligators exist

[frigid cloud]

When you fail the gold medal on house building mission

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[hushed flare]

Boars are predators also

[frigid cloud]

Foxes as well

[hushed flare]

Wait wbat

[leaden bone]

Barely

[hushed flare]

Foxes

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[leaden bone]

How are Foxes predators

[frigid cloud]

They do count

Idk

[hushed flare]

what's next eastern wild turkey is a predator

[leaden bone]

They run as soon as you set foot anywhere near them

[hushed flare]

Black bears be like:

[hidden moss]

Foxes go after chickens and shit

[leaden bone]

Same with Boars

[hushed flare]

black bears refuse to fight humans

[frigid cloud]

It counted for my master hunter 7 challenge too so I guess I'll consider it as a predator

[leaden bone]

Guess Rockstar didn't specify "Predators to humans"

[hidden moss]

When you just want the trophy to get attacked by grizzly bears but you only find lame beta black bears

[hushed flare]

Maybe those birds that take rabbits and snakes is a predator

[frigid cloud]

That trophy is cancer

[leaden bone]

Just go to Big Valley

Plenty of Grizzlies there

[hidden moss]

I havent found any there ngl

[hushed flare]

Go to grizzlies east for grizzlies

[leaden bone]

Keep checking the northern part

[hidden moss]

I think I usually go around moonstone pond or whatever

Yea I'll have to do that

[frigid cloud]

Use that bear inside a cabin

[hidden moss]

Killed him

[leaden bone]

There's a small cave out in the forest a ways into the northern bit of Big Valley, I've had good luck finding bears just a little bit west from there

[frigid cloud]

It's only one time but

ok

I wonder if legendary bear counts for it

[hidden moss]

I actually took a photo of that I think

[leaden bone]

Probably

[hushed flare]

Bear = bear

[hidden moss]

I hope so. I got attacked by legendary bear

Does it show in statistics?

[hushed flare]

I feel like legendary bear would kill too fast or have too much health tho

[hidden moss]

I remember surviving it. But I think it took more shots in the struggle

[frigid cloud]

Wish we were able to kill any of the bears encountered in missions

[hushed flare]

When you use a carbine to hunt a legendary bear

[hidden moss]

Madlad

[hushed flare]

I wanted to kill that bear in aftermath of genesis

[leaden bone]

Like the one bear in the epilogue mission

I forget it's name but it's in RDR1 too

[hushed flare]

I guess they needed that bear alive in rdr2 so it can be a thing in rdr

Plus it also explains why it took like 50 revolver shots and never died

[leaden bone]

They wouldn't have to include it

Since RDR1 took place entirely in New Austin

[frigid cloud]

In the hunting mission with Charles there's a bear as well but not killable

[leaden bone]

It isn't killable?

[hushed flare]

after math of genesis

[frigid cloud]

No

[leaden bone]

Damn

[frigid cloud]

It runs away after a few shots

[hushed flare]

I wonder why we couldn't kill it like wtf

[frigid cloud]

Like any other bears in missions

[hushed flare]

Ok but that boar in hamish is invincible

[leaden bone]

Yeah

[frigid cloud]

So is the wolf

It feels like you're not even shooting at it

[hushed flare]

Who's idea was to make the American venom sniper invincible until a certain point

[leaden bone]

Well the boar is invincible because Hamish has to die

[hushed flare]

#lineargaming

[frigid cloud]

So we lose health by the time we get close to him to kill him

[hushed flare]

My John after emptying like 20 express bolt action rounds into the boar "that thing had a hide of iron"

[leaden bone]

Stalinium Boar

[hushed flare]

Didn't deadeye repeaters used to shoot faster

[frigid cloud]

Lote outfit+overweight+facial hair level 10 during American venom

[hushed flare]

Level 10 hair

Red overweight

[frigid cloud]

Survivalist 10 catch all the fishes
Horseman 10 break every wild horse breed
Herbalist 10 season every meat

9 and 10 should've been changed

9 felt more like a final challenge

[leaden bone]

Wait so how do I find my achievements from the Social club

Steam user over here

[frigid cloud]

Idk

[leaden bone]

Nevermind I found it

[frigid cloud]

Good

[hushed flare]

10 seems more like a master hunter challenge since half the animal meats u most likely don't have

And since you picked all the herbs you should have the seasoning already

[frigid cloud]

My seasoning was ready even doe I never planned to have it ready

Not being able to catch largemouth bass

[loud plover]

used three express rounds from a springfield to take it down

[hushed flare]

Deadeye exists

[plush warren]

do you lose all of your horses if you complete story

[mighty pecan]

yes but not in a way you’d expect

[plush warren]

[rich horizon]

I want someone to make a mod where every horse is replaced with the regalia from final fantasy 15

[hidden moss]

Hi😄 So I walked up to Hosea & John with the wagon with moonshine, and it started Advertising, the new American art - 2

I didn’t start 1 yet by talking to Abigail, will I still get a 100% for missions now? Cus 1 got skipped😄

[frigid cloud]

It wasn't a mission anyway

You just can go to the wagon

[hidden moss]

Alright thanks💖

[frigid cloud]

When you talk to her no mission name comes up so I don't think so

You probably will get 100% for missions

[hidden moss]

I reloaded save just in case xD The save did get named after mission 1

But no medals

So it prob doesn’t count

Lmao theres people who replays the game just for medals

[hidden moss]

Oh, I do that too after im done with 100%, to get all golf

Gold

thats dumb I will replay the game just bc its a masterpiece not for medals

what are you gonna do with medals

sell them as gold

?

Same, I’m on my 7th replay. Doesn’t mean it’s not fun to try a full gold run😄

It’s just fun to do

Like anything you do for the game

if I play that game for the 999th time I will probably still cry at arthurs death

Everyone does xD well except for the Arthur haters

Do they even exist?

Ye. Lilith (the admin)

wtf

Just search their name with Arthur as message

And be shocked😄

ok but why

[hidden moss]

Do this & u will see, a lot xD

Lilith — 08/05/2021
if arthur wasn't an hugely wanted outlaw and murderer all his life to the point where he's on a kill on sight in lower west elizabeth, feeling bad for his character would've been better
Lilith — 08/05/2021
arthur's character is just bad guy turned good from life altering shit
Lilith — 08/05/2021
character writing wise, micah > arthur for sure
Lilith — 08/01/2021
arthur sticker
Lilith — 07/29/2021
i cried when arthur died too, happy tears and joy everywhere
Lilith — 07/29/2021
because arthur a bitch

😄

:(

:(

:(

:(

micah suc coc

but arthur suc a miracle tonic

[frigid cloud]

Nothing's wrong with that

But gold medals are 🤢

[keen ice]

hi

[round hedge]

What are you gonna do when you finish the replay, play it again until you're fucking bored of the missions?

[keen ice]

Is anyone playing with me rdr2 online

[round hedge]

lmaooooooo

[frigid cloud]

I never cried to Arthur's death

[abstract wasp]

I laughed

[frigid cloud]

Good

[hushed flare]

I cried on Arthur's death

Because Micah killed him so I cried of happiness

[frigid cloud]

I cried when Micah died

[hushed flare]

emotional

[frigid cloud]

Or I didn't actually

Don't remember

Probably no

[hushed flare]

rdr2 players be like "omg Arthur death so emotional I cried the Pacific ocean and I cried myself to sleep for 7 whole days and 24 hours straight man this game is so good bro this is my 82782th playthrough I'm still finding new things like how your horse can go backwards if you press RB twice"

[frigid cloud]

Wtf

[narrow jetty]

I'm just surprised at how many people don't know that if someone steals your horse, just whistle and your horse will buck them off

Also you can chokeslam people

In combat

[hushed flare]

I let people steal my horse because of that

whistle to make person get off horse

[narrow jetty]

Also, I know the game doesn't directly come out and say this, but it's pretty heavily implied that before John, the pinkertons/FBI were using Micah for what they ultimately used John for in RDR1

[hushed flare]

Let Pinkerton's kill Micah because yes

[frigid cloud]

Use Micah for wat

[narrow jetty]

Before John killed Micah, the the pinkertons seemingly had no idea where John was. It was only after he killed Micah, they eventually figured out it was him and here we are

[spiral cliff]

Does anyone know how to recreate the elegant suit in the single player

[narrow jetty]

"Revenge is a fools game" and "run and don't look back" hit different when you realize that not only did John look back, he did it out of revenge

Two of Arthur's signature catchphrases are just foreshadowing John's fate

Holy shit I just realized that

[hushed flare]

John got 20k atleast

Practically selling your soul

[hidden moss]

Use mods.

[narrow jetty]

Wow I can't believe I didn't realize before that both of Arthur's signature phrases are literally just tools used to foreshadow John's fate lol

I know I just said that but like it just hit me like a ton of bricks lol

[hidden moss]

Which taken by RDR1 dialogues

And RDR1 John's character.

[narrow jetty]

Well don't look back is

[hidden moss]

Taken by RDR1 And John Marston

[rain sorrel]

When you realize Arthur and hosea probably were there with John and dutch when dutch died

[narrow jetty]

Revenge is a fools game is from RDR2

[hidden moss]

Real John Marston's charcater

Fucking John Marston in RDR2

Poorly written

do not say epilogue John is John at all.

[narrow jetty]

He's not supposed to be the same guy in rdr2 that he was in rdr1

Even in the epilougue

[hidden moss]

Yup

RDR1 John said to Abraham

that

[narrow jetty]

That's not a bad thing lol

[hidden moss]

It is a bad thing

Didn't he say to abraham?

That he's Dutch's most trusted henchman?

and smartest of all?

and very arrogant?

agressive?

But in RDR2 all he does stay in camp

John was a bitch in the epilogue. The whole epilogue was just sucking Arthur's cock and John getting roasted by uncle. I feel like 1899 had RDR John as reference, and epilogue John had 1899 John as reference. People say "character development", then tell me how John went from a little socially awkward bitch who can't get over Arthur's death in the epilogue, to the guy he was in rdr1

[narrow jetty]

I mean, in rdr2 it's mentioned multiple times that John is Dutch's favorite between him and Arthur

[hidden moss]

Still he's not same character.

There isn't any aggression, arrogance or intelligence in RDR2 John

[narrow jetty]

Because RDR2 John is a little shitbag and again that's BY DESIGN lol

American Venom hardened him

That's the way I justify it

Lol

[hidden moss]

Nah

He still acts like a weird mfer in epilogue

and he looks like Arthur reskin in epilogue

[narrow jetty]

Rob Wiethoff actually talked about this

He said that when they were making rdr1 they kept on stressing to him that he was basically the baddest motherfucker on the planet And had to present himself as such. That's now how they told him to act in rdr2

[hidden moss]

They give attributes of RDR1 John to Arthur Morgan

If anything RDR2 John should've acted slighty like RDR1 John

Jim milton the goat

[narrow jetty]

I was just gonna say Arthur is kinda what you would think RDR1 John would be back in the gang

[hidden moss]

Yeah

Now

His epilogue look

He's Arthur reskin

[narrow jetty]

Is to be fair John is also pretty awkward in red dead 1

[hidden moss]

Not really

[narrow jetty]

Not nearly as much but still

He's like very quiet

[hidden moss]

Epilogue John's dialogues are so goofy and childish

[narrow jetty]

Honestly he kind of reminds me of Charles

[hidden moss]

A difference between not talkative and awkward.

[narrow jetty]

Yeah hes like a serious quiet bad-ass and red dead one but in red dead 2 hes like a super goofy loudmouth and borderline obnoxious lol

[hidden moss]

Npc John was okay

and still had some attributes of RDR1 John

Epilogue John is just weird

Arthur reskin and childish goofy dialogues

[narrow jetty]

Yeah like when you heard sheep with John in chapter 2, that reminds me more of RDR1 John

[hidden moss]

Also they put pitch in John's voice

Rob sounds closer to RDR1 John

but

In rdr2 there is a pitch in John's voice

Sometimes you can hear John's rdr1 voice

It would be cool if they only use pitch for Npc John

and stopped using it for epilogue

so Epilogue John's voice would be same as RDR1

at least it would be one good thing about Epilogue John

[narrow jetty]

I think that mostly has to do with the fact that when they 1st started doing the motion capture again, it was only 3 years after the original red dead

The epilogue was done much later

[hidden moss]

Nah

Epilogue was being in made

with rest of stuff

There is shit tons of beta stuff for epilogue John

and mods really restored them all

and guess what

they are working really fine

[narrow jetty]

You can literally hear John's voice get more raspy and animated as the game goes on.

Like go ahead and listen to him when you 1st rescue him in the mountains

Sounds a lot more like RDR1 John

[mighty pecan]

^

[hidden moss]

Like i said

[narrow jetty]

His voice is way less raspy and his voice is deeper

[hidden moss]

U can sometimes hear it

They put lots of pitch into John's voice

U can take a look in game files

[narrow jetty]

Here's the best way to describe this lol

Compare "I never thought I'd say this, but it's good to see you Arthur Morgan" with "YOU RUN LIKE A HEIFER MOOO"

[hidden moss]

I'm not trying to say Npc John dialogues sucks

[narrow jetty]

Yeah I get what you're saying though lol

[hidden moss]

I already said that

Some attributes from RDR1 John mentioned is not in RDR2

It's sort of like recton

*retcon

But we both can agree that epilogue John is not John

[narrow jetty]

Yeah lol

I do get what you're saying. It's not character development if hes more like red dead 1 John in the beginning of red dead 2 than he is in the epilogue

[hidden moss]

Yeah

Npc John has some RDR1 John attributes

with his dialogues

however they didn't give more to him

like missions and stuff

The game mostly focused on other stuff

than showing Npc John becoming RDR1 John

Then they forgot that John has matured and grow up

then they made a mess called epilogue John

[narrow jetty]

I will say I do kind of like the fact that they didn't overstate NPC John too much and made him just another member of the gang

It would have felt kind of forced if they tried to focus too much on him

[hidden moss]

Like i said

He should've gotten a bit more screentime

about his development

of charcater

[rich horizon]

can I board a train by jumping on it when it goes through a tunnel?

like you do in the opening

[hidden moss]

Probably. Worth a shot

[rich horizon]

also what's a good way to get money?

[red helm]

Exploring buildings out in the wilderness can yield a lot of stuff, random jewelry and such you can fence.

[hidden moss]

Treasure hunting probs one of the best ways

[frigid cloud]

Or wait till chapter 3 bank robbery

Or just get the end of the game and get 20k

And train robberies

[red helm]

Bringing stolen wagon's to Seamus is easy and consistant money. If you don't care about High Honor.

[hidden moss]

Jack hall gang treasure will net you a nice $1k

[frigid cloud]

40$

[red helm]

Didn't say it was a lot, just easy.

[frigid cloud]

True you never did

[red helm]

Train Robberies = A lot, but difficult.

[frigid cloud]

And higher bounties

[red helm]

Treasure maps = Easy and a lot, but one time only.

[frigid cloud]

Selling horses don't give much

[hidden moss]

One time usually enough

[red helm]

Yeah, selling horses is rather disappointing.

[hidden moss]

I think most of the 7k I have rn is mostly from treasures and just selling jewellery

[hasty totem]

btw if u wanna go good hunt in Red 2 Go in middle of rhoades and valentine

its a whole wilderness

and theres bambis

ez hunt

[frigid cloud]

Maybe selling 4 bonding level white Arabian gives a lot

[hasty totem]

i have 3

[red helm]

Make money hunting? Gator's is pretty the most efficient hunting...

[hasty totem]

no wait

isnt

im om that bond

where u hold square

and u move ur left joystick

and it goes left right

[frigid cloud]

Level 4 I think

[hasty totem]

k

[red helm]

Yeah, taming the Arabians would be the only ones worth bothering with. That I have seen.

[hidden moss]

Never realised how dirty a horse could get until I got the white arabian

[red helm]

Indeed, and some horses tend to whine about being dirty more than others, too.

[frigid cloud]

White shire

Dirt is barely noticeable on black horses

[hushed flare]

brown horses

[frigid cloud]

Or that yeah

[hushed flare]

dead horses can't get dirty either

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[red helm]

We need undead horses.

[hidden moss]

The horses from undead nightmare were pretty cool

[red helm]

Yeap, To bad rockstar is the lame and we probably well never get anything like that for RDR2.

[frigid cloud]

The dream of every players:
Hit 3 times and still end up with 14

Odds are 00000.1%

[red helm]

Never tell me the odds.

[frigid cloud]

Fine

How hard is it to get gold medals on every mission

I imagine it'd take a lot of time cause if you fail you replay

[hidden moss]

Fuck you

no content for you

-Rockstar

[red helm]

Yeap, that's pretty much Rockstar's policy for us.

[hidden moss]

They have so many potential for story mode

Better epilogue John

More guns

more horses

more stable

[red helm]

On all missions? Ouf, don't even want to think about that.

[hidden moss]

more quests

[frigid cloud]

Probably not worth the effort

[red helm]

There are a handful that are just -wtf- non-sense.

Mostly the ones that are timed.

[frigid cloud]

I hated whenever there was like don't take any damage during the shootout

[hushed flare]

deadeye every kill moment

[frigid cloud]

Ikr fr

[hushed flare]

I kept failing on take no damage from wolves

[frigid cloud]

That's so bs

I did it on a replay

[hushed flare]

Sawed off shotgun is wack

[frigid cloud]

With Litchfield

[hushed flare]

Bolt action rifle

• auto aim

[frigid cloud]

Don't think I had any bullets on other guns so I chose Litchfield

[warm gate]

Ayo can someone help me get money in like lvl 7 and have the bounty role

And like 129 dollars

[frigid cloud]

#rdo-chat

[fierce cave]

Apparently pirate sword doesnt work on alligator

[shy mulch]

average sword fan versus the chad axe thrower

[main dune]

hi

[hidden moss]

Hello

What's the fastest way of getting money after finishing rdr2?

[frigid cloud]

Dude

You get 20k when you finish it

[hidden moss]

ya ik

but i want more

[frigid cloud]

Treasures if you haven't done them

[hidden moss]

idk why

[frigid cloud]

And gold bars at a few places

[hidden moss]

Oh ok

Can I do heists

[frigid cloud]

Train robberies

Stagecoach robberies tip off from Alden and hector

[hidden moss]

oh ok

Ok thank you

[dire sentinel]

rdr2 update??

[sturdy patrol]

Huh

[frigid cloud]

Probably fixing online bugs

#patch-notes

[dire sentinel]

i thought so

[olive mango]

I dont understand for a side quest I needed a perfect squirrel carcass and shot a 3 star squirrel and damaged it and it became a 2 star. Even after I picked up the 2 star squirrel it says that it IS a perfect squirrel carcass. Why?

[hidden moss]

Buck trinket

[olive mango]

You're some kind of genius I see.

Haha ty so much. Was getting frustrated crafting small game arrows and looking for squirrels

[hidden moss]

I didn't understand your message but I tried to guess it

But buck trinket can increase your chance to turn quality higher

for example

u got 2 star animal

there is a slight chance it will make it 3 star

[olive mango]

I was lucky here then. As of now I only have 5 trinkets/talismans and the buck was one of them. It clearly showed 2 stars so I guess you just have to check the satchel to see if it gets labeled a "perfect pelt". Thanks man I wouldn't have thought to look at trinket attributes for a while

[hidden moss]

Np

good luck with your hunting request.

[frigid cloud]

What weapon did you use

[fierce cave]

Did hosea get the chicken he was stealing

[olive mango]

I believe I hit it with a regular sized arrow

[red pond]

Hi everyone, is it possible to see the strange man portrait on cabin with John if we didn't get there as Arthur ?

Btw Bayou Nwa is hek of fuckin scary by night.

[frigid cloud]

You need small game arrows

[hushed flare]

You do need small game arrows

[frigid cloud]

Eh idk y I even said probably

[hushed flare]

it quite literally says you need small game arrows in the description of animal

[frigid cloud]

Yep

[olive mango]

Yeah that wasn't even my question at all. I was asking why a 2 star animal showed up as perfect pelt and the other guy answered it was the buck trinket. I know small game arrows are needed

[frigid cloud]

Oh yeah he's right then

[golden storm]

I was carrying a perfect alligator pelt then arthur went sicko mode and I lost it

the greatest sadness of his sickness

[hushed flare]

Alligators are everywhere

In the swamp

[golden storm]

I know I almost never get a perfect lol

[hushed flare]

wrong weapon?

or just unlucky

[frigid cloud]

I bet first one

Using a shotgun

Alligator skinning animation

[golden storm]

unlucky

[frigid cloud]

What gun are you using

[golden storm]

when you forget to switch your double barrel to your Springfield its annoying too

usually springfeild

its my go to rifle

[frigid cloud]

Should work then

[golden storm]

I'm just unlucky

if uncle doesn't die from lumbago in rd1 I'm gonna sue rockstar

don't tell me if so though

[frigid cloud]

Y u ask then?

[golden storm]

I'm just stating it

[hushed flare]

Rufus dies from lumbago

[golden storm]

HAHAH

I know he goes missing

[frigid cloud]

Rufus gets lumbago because he couldn't take a shit

[golden storm]

bc I looked up something ab him and it said at the top: "Rufus ghost" and I was like WHAT THE HECK WHY SPOIL

gonna leave the internet forever lol

micah killed rufus

[frigid cloud]

That's cain

[hidden moss]

That’s just a theory. I like to think Cain left when the gang fell apart. He’s having fun with another family now, or was. Might have died of old age💖

[golden storm]

oh micah def ate cain

I think micah was the snake that bit rufus

[blissful tundra]

I have a question after I get off that one island and get back to shady bell will I get all my stuff back

[frigid cloud]

Yes

Horse, money, guns

[round hedge]

Micah himself said he got rid of the dog lol

[blissful tundra]

Can the bow be used to take out people silently

[shy mulch]

kinda

if ur trying to bow a camp they'll aggro since they're so close i think

You cooould aggro the camp, run away, then come back and the AI stops working

[golden storm]

me when the housebuilding theme is on spotify

the youtube one is better though honestly

[red helm]

If you shot them from behind it does work, but it has to literally be from behind. and they have to be alone, if someone is right by them, they'll hear it and alert.

[blissful tundra]

Yea I found that out the hard way lol

[red helm]

Their sneaky sneaky mechanics are very poor, unfortunately.

[torn kiln]

o thought it got taken down and deleted

[vast elk]

Whats a lumbago?

[tiny berry]

a gift and a curse

does the lost new yorker near strawberry have any purpose in the game, such as special item drops, a reward for returning him, etc.

normally i wouldn't care about stuff like this but when attempting a 100% file with every item in the game i want to be as careful as possible, one missed item and I go back a few hours

[civic nest]

Hey, new here

I wanted to ask, has someone found too a grave of a ton of workers died 1878 I think, in Roanoke Ridge near the frontier with Lemoyne? If so, is there any more lore for it?

I searched on YouTube but there no one appears to know if there is more to it

[hidden moss]

If you kill him you can loot a letter written to him from his ex girlfriend where she’s talking about how he ran off with another guy when he was teaching at Princeton.

[tiny berry]

thank you, glad i waited for a responce

response*

dang, I've Been had

[hidden moss]

welcome

[knotty sigil]

what makes the reason trelawny isnt a strange man? beside the reason that john recognise trelawny but he didnt for strange man

[jolly dragon]

Trelawny is a normal person with a family, whom he protects in Saint Denis. I’m pretty sure the Strange Man doesn’t have loved ones or significant others if he’s an otherworldly being.

[little roost]

ok so I know this is probably something that people are already doing but I just wanted to say. my new sidearm setup is John's Cattlemen with a sawed off. it gives me easy access to a shotgun for quick kills and I still have my revolver if you haven't tried this yet you should

[hexed orchid]

I don’t know if people have already came up with something like this but I was thinking that maybe the strange man is like a metaphor of johns sins catching up with him

[hidden moss]

he killed cain

rufus never existed

it was all in johns head

anyways when do the credits start

after arthur dies of after john kills micah

[summer garnet]

after john kills micah

[hushed flare]

"Arthur dies of after"

[hidden moss]

my fingers have lumbago

its very serious

[hushed flare]

Lower finger pain

[hidden moss]

whats the best way to kill micah

[hushed flare]

Don't kill him

[hushed flare]

Micah joins your side and everyone is happy

[hidden moss]

i hate micah

he bullied uncle

[hidden moss]

Where’d he say that? Never heard it

Nahhhh, Cain is happy & alive💖 Even Micah wouldn’t be so bad to kill a dog

[hidden moss]

What to do after epilogue

[knotty sigil]

get all the gold in the game

get all the point of interest

play around with graphical mod

[ancient rose]

uninstall and find something new 🙂

😛

[placid inlet]

You could go achievement hunting 🌞

[hidden moss]

Anyone want to join my hitman group

[summer garnet]

play the story again

[summer garnet]

he kicked cain once so i beg to differ

[golden storm]

explore new austin then play rd1 also get 100%

[hidden moss]

Finish legendary hunts etc

[lavish acorn]

hey guys, does anybody know whether it´s possible to rebuy unique knifes and tomahawks from the fence after losing them in a fight. they don´t respawn in the satchel unlike revolvers and shotguns, do they?

[mighty pecan]

You can buy the tomahawks but im not so sure about the unique knives

[lavish acorn]

Maybe it isn´t even possible to lose them because one can`t throw them. Thanks for reply

and the knifes that are throwable aren´t unique

[knotty sigil]

can i just go to the rock and loot the gold owned by this Bennett Brothers

or do i need to go to their house first?

[frigid cloud]

You need to craft unique throwing knives, tomahawks

[lavish acorn]

Yeah, but what if I accidentally throw my viking hatchet away that I found somewhere on the map,? Will it be lost or is it possible to rebuy it from the fence?I Heard some people saying it's possible.

[civic nest]

In every treasure hunt you need the maps first to be able to collect the treasure, except Otis Miller's revolver

I just bumped into it while exploring New Austin lol

[latent plover]

Sadie Adler in South America or Charles in Canada dlc would be nice

[knotty sigil]

oh thankyou

[shy mulch]

in booty shorts

[hidden moss]

Heard its lost forever. May be possible to reclaim the weapons from where you got them from but not sure. Just make sure you get them back after throwing them

[hushed flare]

Have you tried using your horse

I thought that was supposed to store everything

[hidden moss]

I dont think the horse stores throwables

lumbago plan tahiti rat

[hushed flare]

Micah rat plan Tahiti lumbago muneh insist

[shy mulch]

GO ON VAMINOS

[lavish acorn]

I'm pretty Sure that one can't reclaim the throwables from what they came from. Might be the best to store them in the satchel and avoid using to prevent losing

[lavish acorn]

Only the guns can be retrieved on horse after losing them- not throwables,I guess
Btw. Please change Nickname

[frigid cloud]

What's wrong with Micah fan

[hidden moss]

Xd

He is a micah fan

So yk

[frigid cloud]

Know what

[hidden moss]

Its strange

[kindred leaf]

Is the honor level important? I kept robbing trains soo my honor has hit rock bottom

[hidden moss]

Who tf likes micah

[frigid cloud]

What chapter are you in

[kindred leaf]

Ehem 2 i just started lol

[frigid cloud]

Ah well honor doesn't matter much now but try keeping it high

It plays a significant role later on

[kindred leaf]

Oh alrighty thanks

[lavish acorn]

But in the first Chapters you really Don't have to care about. Go on robbing trains

[round hedge]

jesus Christ did you play the game with your eyes closed

[hollow comet]

i finished the epilogue

im bored

i went to explore the desert

I massacred armadillo

then went to look for tumbleweed where i made my repeater better

[hollow comet]

micha murdered a child

*micah

and btw, where is the kkk

[strange smelt]

Tonight I returned to camp and Dutch was throwing a party for Sean's arrival I think...it was so awesome.... Arthur even sang❤️

[hollow comet]

lol

sean

havent heard that name in a long time

@strange smelt didnt you make arthur sing?

[strange smelt]

Yessss

Ring dang doo and some diddly diddle or something❤️🥺

[hollow comet]

I love arthur

hes so nice

but hosea

oh hosea

😦

[strange smelt]

What about Hosea?

[hollow comet]

nothing…

[green rock]

Can I have help?

I need help

[hollow comet]

sure!

[strange smelt]

Arthur and Hosea are my favourite

[hollow comet]

with what

[green rock]

I have no clue where to go. My markers for mission have disappeared from the map

[hollow comet]

arthur, hosea, sadie, charles and john

[hollow comet]

what mission is it?

i mean

what part are you on

[strange smelt]

I like Javier too but idk about Sadie...I'm only in chapter 2

[green rock]

Idk lol

😭😭

[hollow comet]

…

[green rock]

It’s not like there’s parts

I’m just going around and doing the random missions

[strange smelt]

How many hrs have you accumulated

[green rock]

Chapter 2

[strange smelt]

Where did you go to accept the mission

[green rock]

Accept what mission

[strange smelt]

Or is it a bounty

[green rock]

I’m just confused on where to go

Shouldn’t I have like markers on the map

For missions

[strange smelt]

Go to the yellow circle for missions

[green rock]

Nothing like that

My map is very empty

It doesn’t have the initials for characters for the missions

[strange smelt]

Idk...bug?

Try reinstalling the game

[hollow comet]

what was the last mission you completed

[strange smelt]

But you can complete missions in any order in a chapter right?

[hollow comet]

normally

but theres a mission thats not around the camp

its in the northt

*north