#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 433 of 1

faint thistle
#

Yep, sheep are easy

frigid cloud
#

Lasso or repeater

faint thistle
#

You can usually rustle up a hide and book it before things go wrong

#

Go at night for less witnesses and make sure you know the right fence to hop

candid niche
#

yeah

hushed flare
#

Usually a bandana works since everyone besides lawman don't know who you are when reporting the crime

faint thistle
#

Also, good news for you here

#

Most of the witnesses for sheep rustling will book it away from emerald ranch

#

Since it has no law to report you

#

Usually you can hogtie them pretty fast

hushed flare
#

I just run usually

faint thistle
#

The investigation phase lasts for like 30 seconds tho

frigid cloud
#

If you fire at air does that stop witnesses

candid niche
#

that would be easy but volcanic pistols also work

hushed flare
#

never helped me

faint thistle
#

If you stop the witness you get much less downtime

hushed flare
#

How I stop witnesses is tackle and threaten twice

faint thistle
hushed flare
#

shooting in the air in a townpepw

faint thistle
hushed flare
faint thistle
#

Tackle and 2 threats is about the same time personally

hushed flare
#

Normally I run now

faint thistle
#

Also lassoing the witness has it ready for someone stumbling onto me

hushed flare
#

Even if I'm reported for murder I don't get bounties

faint thistle
#

The Saint Denis bridge is usually a clusterfuck

candid niche
#

yeah

frigid cloud
#

Hogtie = 20 seconds waste

hushed flare
#

Strawberry bridge is fast horse riders worst nightmare

faint thistle
#

Tbh my first witnesses gets the hogtie

candid niche
#

oh my god that is how I lost like 3 horses that bridge sucks

faint thistle
#

The second onwards gets a bullet in the head

faint thistle
hushed flare
#

Witnesses on horseback

faint thistle
#

*pre-lasso'd witnesses

#

Tbh witnesses on horseback can be rammed with your own horse

#

Usually you can take out either them or their mount for no honor loss

#

Anyone find other ways to keep your hands clean murdering

candid niche
#

anyone else kinda disapointed with john

hushed flare
#

I like to run into people's horses for no reason

#

fun

#

Even though I gave John and my horse another concussion

faint thistle
#
  1. shallow pond hogtie drop
  2. ram them with horses (only if they're on horseback too)
#

Any other options?

hushed flare
#

Ramming horses with horses like gtabigbrain

candid niche
#

drop then from the really high bridge over the water

faint thistle
#

If you get a bulky horse you can take em down easily

frigid cloud
#

Don't cause any trouble at all

faint thistle
#

Also, you can shoot their boats

hushed flare
frigid cloud
hushed flare
#

Or kill a whole cow for a good looking hat

faint thistle
candid niche
#

YES you understand

hushed flare
#

I stole so many random wagons in bandit

faint thistle
#

I was extremely pissed off at the consecutive tomahawk one

frigid cloud
#

Using mission replays to not lose honor for first bandit challenge

faint thistle
#

4 kills right, but first kill wont count so the odriscoll camp kept me one short

hushed flare
#

Did u use deadeye

faint thistle
#

Tried to aggro passerbys with hold ups

#

First dude ran like a bitch, second one gave me money

frigid cloud
hushed flare
hushed flare
faint thistle
#

I've never not been shot in the face over 3 playthroughs robbing people

faint thistle
#

But first kill wont count usually

hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

It starts after you pick up the tomahawk

faint thistle
#

Its effectively 5 kills

frigid cloud
#

You have to kill 5

#

Yes

#

Basically

faint thistle
#

The issue was me tryna turn travelers into red dot enemies

hushed flare
#

i did it without the ancient tomahawk

#

But I had 9 tomahawks so

faint thistle
#

And they refused to shoot me

frigid cloud
candid niche
#

having to kill a predator and prey at the same time frame made me really mad

faint thistle
#

Yepp, found a lawman

hushed flare
faint thistle
#

Desperate times

frigid cloud
#

I wonder if you have tomahawk in replays

faint thistle
#

Wish I did it then

faint thistle
#

Homestead robbery gear and such

frigid cloud
#

Better than cougar one anyway

faint thistle
#

You can carry over a pump action shotgun and lancaster repeater into the John rescue mission on the snow

candid niche
#

yeah true just fusterating

faint thistle
#

Makes wolf hunt way easier

frigid cloud
#

I did it in a replay

faint thistle
#

But your sawed off wont keep

#

Have to restart cuz dumbass javier wont let me leave without a sawed off

#

Literally every shotgun on my horse but that one smh

frigid cloud
#

Wolves are invincible at a far distance so regardless of your weapon choice in a replay you'll have to get close either way

faint thistle
#

The extra shots are welcome tho

#

2 sawed off shells vs 3 wolves

candid niche
#

the best loadout for hunting in my opinion is one sawn-off, one volcanic pistol, a bow, and the bolt action rifle.

faint thistle
#

I'd argue bow, varmint rifle, and throwing knives

frigid cloud
#

when you can drink a dead eye tonic where dead eye isn't unlocked lol

faint thistle
#

Covers all niches on a technical level, but you're prying that springfield from my cold, dead hands

candid niche
#

well the bow can be a varmint rifle and throwing knives damage pelts and hides

frigid cloud
#

Bow is op

#

Use it in every shootout in chapter 1

#

And your health will be high in chapter 2

faint thistle
#

Raises your stamina too

#

Bow cant handle moderate game iirc

#

Small game arrows cant clean kill rabbits right?

candid niche
#

no no no volcanic pistols are op in my opinion they are the best gun in the game

faint thistle
#

They're fun af as sidearms go

#

Ammo pool is eh

candid niche
#

oh yeah you are right about that

frigid cloud
#

That hunting with charles was so annoying for 3rd time

#

Stamina kept running out

faint thistle
#

Oh for bows

#

Why not use the springfield?

frigid cloud
#

No I wasn't in a replay

candid niche
#

slow reload and around the same power

frigid cloud
#

Just casual playthrough

candid niche
#

it is also modeled after a badass rifle

faint thistle
#

Varmint rifle is my go to riding weapon

#

Its great for algernon's plumes

frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

RDR1 John

faint thistle
#

And can headshot humans

frigid cloud
#

Loot isn't dependant on its quality

faint thistle
#

Yeah, just personal preference

#

I like snagging rabbits, muskrats, badgers, and raccoons on the sly

frigid cloud
#

What's the hardest thing to craft

candid niche
#

yeah i can see why you like it

faint thistle
#

Talisman or tonic?

frigid cloud
#

Clothing from trappers

faint thistle
#

Repeaters are too stronk for hunting

#

Oof, I wanna say anything involving moose

frigid cloud
faint thistle
#

I deadass didnt know they existed till my current (3rd) playthrough

#

Yeah, but usually those game get the lasso for me

frigid cloud
#

Except foxes

faint thistle
#

Varmint rifles are super accurate too

candid niche
#

yeah

frigid cloud
#

RDO compendium says black bear is lassoable

candid niche
#

wow

faint thistle
#

I hunted two rabbits, stumbled onto an odriscoll camp, and left with spare rounds in the mag

candid niche
#

ima try when i get home

frigid cloud
#

an animal goes extinct when you need them

candid niche
#

right

faint thistle
#

Yes

#

Fucking horseman 10 took me longer than the whole gambler line and herb 9 combined

frigid cloud
#

Fr me too

candid niche
#

i only finished the master hunter

faint thistle
#

Bandit is a lot of fun tbh

#

I'd recommend that

frigid cloud
#

American paint, Hungarian halfbred nokota and appaloosa

faint thistle
#

Treasure hunter gets you good gold and deadeye bonus

faint thistle
candid niche
#

i am already a natural bandit

faint thistle
#

Halfbreeds are a bitch to find

#

Wish thoroughbreeds counted

candid niche
#

i killed a whole town for a horse

frigid cloud
#

Herb 9 was fun till you realized you're missing something

faint thistle
#

I tried the wagon glitch

candid niche
#

and have max bounty in every region

frigid cloud
#

Fuck bounty hunters

faint thistle
#

Got shot in the head by God while picking ferview

candid niche
#

HELL YEAH

frigid cloud
#

If you can see Arthur's head so can the sniper

faint thistle
candid niche
#

no

faint thistle
#

I managed the wagon

candid niche
#

a tenesse walker

faint thistle
#

Picking the plant panned the cam into his hat

candid niche
#

i was desprite

frigid cloud
#

Wagon doesn't seem to work on console idk

#

Or I just failed

#

Camera always zooms in and Arthur's head is seeable

faint thistle
#

You gotta finaggle camera setting

#

Remove the auto head tracking, pump FOV

#

Otherwise you get recentered and domed

#

I got to macfarlene's ranch easily. It was the plant picking that ended me.

faint thistle
frigid cloud
#

1.00 players be like: cowboykekw

faint thistle
#

Pretty annoyed that they'd patch that but not a challenge oversight

#

Ffs just lower it to like 30 herbs or smtn

hushed flare
#

38 herbs

#

or make the 5 herbs in new Austin non exclusive to new austin

round hedge
#

John would win in a gun fight

#

not in a fistfight tho

golden vector
frigid cloud
#

He still gets a shot or two I think

mighty pecan
#

hello kids

hidden moss
hidden moss
near berry
#

GJGJF

crimson bronze
#

Arthur, After John's healed he's still seen as a sloppy shot.

#

Remember, John let his guns rest for about 4 years.

hidden moss
#

Everyone likes to ignore RDR1 John

#

and focus on epilogue John

#

so they can make Arthur look in comparison

#

RDR1 John is literally famous

#

and fast as fuck with his gun

#

Also take it to consider that he literally did most of shit alone

crimson bronze
#

Yes, but, When it's specified as "After John Healed" Your narrowing it down fairly hard to the very start of RDR1 where John is healed up by the spleen shot, John doesn't hit his stride again until meeting Landon Ricketts.

hidden moss
#

I believe John was still great with his gun

#

before landon

#

Landon was just a huge boost to his gunslinging skill

#

But remember

#

Epilogue John is trash

#

Arthur reskin and poorly written

hushed flare
#

Epilogue John and it's clipping issue

neat mural
#

I hate you

hushed flare
#

Y lol

neat mural
#

If you are a micah fan

hushed flare
#

problem?troll

neat mural
#

You will burnt in hell

hushed flare
#

I said problem?troll

crimson bronze
#

I mean, Micah's got a good sense of fashion; and he's a skilled gunslinger.

late pine
#

Hi Guys

neat mural
#

Because of your micah i literally cried when arthur died

hushed flare
#

I cried of happiness cuz of what Micah accomplished on Arthur's deathplantRoyale

crimson bronze
#

And atleast is a well acted villain.

neat mural
#

I just came here to see who the f is micah fan

hushed flare
#

There's like 4

crimson bronze
#

So, props to Peter Blomquist

hushed flare
#

4 Micah fans

neat mural
#

They shouldnt have killed arthur

hushed flare
#

at least with a # in their name

neat mural
#

Most loved character in the gaming history

crimson bronze
#

As sad as Arthur's death was, John's death in RDR1 more or less set the precedent.

neat mural
#

Just completed the story line today

hidden moss
#

who ghost pinged me?

neat mural
#

Btw i have a question

#

The stroy says its 78% completed but there are no missions noe

hidden moss
#

I lost my respect for Arthur

#

after roger clark incident

#

but I won't go down further.

late pine
#

Except from Arthur or John who would be your favourite Van Der Linde Gang Member?

neat mural
#

Hosea

#

Prolly

crimson bronze
#

Side Missions and what not, gotta find some unique weapons too.

hushed flare
neat mural
hushed flare
crimson bronze
#

Honestly, I like most of the van der Linde members, Even Bill.

neat mural
#

I hated dutch when he just walked away when arthur was in trouble

#

Same when john was

crimson bronze
#

Oh yeah, except Dutch, Fuck that bastard.

late pine
#

Anyone on Xbox?

neat mural
#

I liked sean too

#

He was loyal

late pine
hushed flare
late pine
crimson bronze
#

Hell, if anything, I really like the depth that Bill was given, in RDR1 he was just a spiteful, mean son of a bitch.

hushed flare
late pine
hidden moss
frigid cloud
hushed flare
#

true

#

at least in chapter 2-3

mighty pecan
frigid cloud
#

ok

hidden moss
#

Like angry mob who hadn't eaten for a while

#

and found their victims

golden storm
#

what is undead nightmare and where does it fit canonically

hidden moss
#

And it fits to John's nightmare at beecher's hope

frigid cloud
#

After john returns to the ranch in main story

golden storm
#

should I play rdr1 or that one first

#

me trying to figure out what town the first scene is in during rdr1

frigid cloud
#

Blackwater

#

I think

#

Been a while since I've watched the first scene

golden storm
#

not blackwater

#

there's no trains there

frigid cloud
#

There is in rdr1

fervent flame
#

in 1911 it was more modern

frigid cloud
#

It's so different than rdr2 trust me

fervent flame
#

in 1907 its still developing

golden storm
#

oh true didn't think ab that

#

bc before 1899 it was a trading post

hidden moss
#

So

#

West elizabeth and new austin is at 1899

#

now 1907

#

real 1907 looks closer to RDR1 MAP

#

Also real John Epilogue John ntoo

#

Rockstar was lazy with epilogue

golden storm
#

yeah they def should've changed more stuff to the landscape

hidden moss
#

and epilogue John

golden storm
#

bill just shot john I'm confused

hidden moss
#

Looks like modders are taking care of it

tight nacelle
golden storm
#

it took me 3 hours

#

wait bonnie macfarlane

#

I got a letter to her in rdr2

hushed flare
#

ye

#

can't post it I don't think

#

And I think you can get the letter in 1899thunk

golden storm
#

idk I was john at the time

round hedge
round hedge
golden storm
#

wait where is tumbleweed in rdr1

crimson bronze
#

Same place as it is in RDR2.

#

It's just become a rundown shithole occupied by Treasure Hunters i.e. Miners.

golden storm
#

oh that's why it's not on the map

dire sentinel
#

the pose he does in the rdr1 cover art with the sawed-off shotgun would’ve fit better with micah instead of abel

hidden moss
#

No sadie or Charles

dire sentinel
#

it makes no sense tbh, john struggles to fight micah after fighting an army

hidden moss
#

Just John going rampage all alone

frigid cloud
#

I think I saw a video of it

hidden moss
#

tbh

#

It just Rockstar went full lazy on epilogue and John

#

If you tell me Epilogue John and Epilogue is fine

#

then u are wrong

dire sentinel
#

imo john should’ve done the rdr1 pose while killing micah that was wounded & crawling away after a duel with john. then john would throw the shotgun onto the ground, turn around and then a camera would zoom in on his face and give us the “RDR2” title card with the whole background turning red. kinda like how jack killed ross

round hedge
#

ok that seems pog

#

way better than the cartoony ass ending

#

with micah walking away after getting shot

hasty totem
#

hi guys

#

i need help

#

so my data save thingys

#

when i load it

#

it says it got damaged

#

any way to fix this shit?

hushed flare
#

If it's corrupted I'm pretty sure there isn't any fix

hasty totem
#

wth

#

why

hushed flare
#

Corrupted files don't heal easy that's all I can say

hasty totem
#

well can u get them back?

#

@hushed flare

hushed flare
#

So u have no backup saves

hasty totem
#

i do

hushed flare
#

Hopefully u can use it then

hasty totem
#

how

#

teach me

hushed flare
#

Cuz backup

#

I don't play PC so I'm kind of inexperienced

hasty totem
#

im ps4

hushed flare
#

You have a role saying PC

hasty totem
#

ye

#

and ps4

#

i play both

hushed flare
#

ok

hasty totem
#

so

#

tell

#

me what do i do

#

to get them back

twilit swallow
#

GOOGLE is your best friend i always say

hushed flare
#

sometimes

#

when you Google your symptoms and apparently you have type 5 cancer

hasty totem
#

dude

#

wtf

#

tell me

#

yall are so weird

hushed flare
#

I dont know bropepw

#

I've had corrupted files on other games and stuff and there was no fix so I don't think rdr2 would be any different

hasty totem
#

i have backup files

#

does those help

hushed flare
#

probably but I have no experience on how to put them in

hasty totem
#

oh

hidden moss
#

Well kiddo

hasty totem
#

all those things i had

hidden moss
#

If ur save got corrupted on

#

pc

hasty totem
#

:(

hidden moss
#

is ur save corrupted on

#

pc?

hasty totem
#

no

#

i dont play on ps

#

pc*

#

only on ps4

hidden moss
#

Real chads would play it on pc with mods

hasty totem
#

dude

#

i had so many things

twilit swallow
hidden moss
#

that's all i can say

#

next time just create 2 save files

#

so one of em get corrupted

#

u can switch to another

hasty totem
#

i created 2

#

my guy

hidden moss
#

what happened to both?

hasty totem
#

capoof

#

curropted

#

curropted

hidden moss
#

ah shit

hasty totem
#

hold up

#

the back up

#

ez

hidden moss
#

nice

glossy belfry
#

are the rdr2 cutscenes in-engine?

#

for some reason they look so much better than actual gameplay, at least in my case

hidden moss
#

Is there a timer on gambler challenge 9 or something?

#

I was on 2 win streak then had to do something

#

Came back to see my progress gone

frigid cloud
#

Doesn't it say ‘in a row’

#

Meaning if you quit the game or reload you won't keep any streak

hidden moss
#

balls

dusty knoll
#

Are there camp upgrades past chapter 3? 😮

frigid cloud
#

You can buy camp upgrades till chapter 4

#

After chapter 4 no

#

Not anymore

dusty knoll
#

Thanks!

vagrant temple
#

Just well optimized

hidden moss
#

Which one is single player?

#

Is it story mode

#

Or online

hidden moss
frigid cloud
#

Oh

hidden moss
#

Maybe it counts as wiping your strrak

frigid cloud
#

Idk then

#

Wouldn't think so

#

Only quitting the game or actually losing wipes your streak

hidden moss
#

Just have to do this all over again yeshoney

frigid cloud
#

Yes I know how it is

#

I lost when I won 2 in a row

#

Its painful

hidden moss
#

Make sure that if you think you're about to lose a game, leave the table. Streak will remain intact

fervent flame
#

youve just reminded me i was going for all trophies/100% completion and that i have to do the squirrel statue

hidden moss
#

Lol I was actually doing the hunting requests today. Have to wait till the epilogue to get the last bunch tho

fervent flame
#

is it new austin animals?

hidden moss
#

Nah its just cuz the woman you send the animals to goes on vacation after the 4th hunting request. Becomes available again in the epilogue

vast grotto
#

bl

hidden moss
#

Yea it sucks. I had all the animals ready for the final hunting request but now I have to wait lol

red helm
#

Indeed, Rockstar and their non-sense. One of Several things Arthur can't do.

frigid cloud
#

Then you can put the squirrel

#

Shame animals don't carry over

#

Otherwise it'd be so much easier

#

You'd collect them as arthur then post them as john immediately

#

If you really tried you could do dino bones and herbalist 9&10 as arthur

red helm
#

Who wants to go through that irritating hassle, though?

frigid cloud
#

Yes, exactly lol

#

That's why 1.00 version for console and pc mods are best

hushed harbor
#

do mods not work w the most recent version of the game or smth, why specify 1.00

frigid cloud
#

John Marston looks better in epilogue

#

Angelo Bronte mission helps with new austin

#

And limpany gold bar

#

And that's the only version you can downgrade to

hushed harbor
#

does it work on pc the same as ps4 to downgrade

frigid cloud
#

I'm not on pc but my guessing no

hushed harbor
#

i imagine one could use mods on pc to disable the new austin sniper

fervent flame
rocky oasis
#

uhm i have a problem... i think i just killed clay and he isnt there anymore. Is there any other way to sell horses or will he appear again? cause i want to do the challenges and you have to deliver him 5 stolen horses...

hidden moss
#

Why did you kill him?

#

For shit and giggles?

frigid cloud
rocky oasis
#

I
inadvertently punched him

hidden moss
#

Damn

#

I accidentally punched Mickey in my 2nd playthrough

#

Really pissed me off

rocky oasis
#

xD

hidden moss
#

When i came back he's there and i donated money and said nothing

#

blood money

#

It's like he forgot who Arthur is

hidden moss
rocky oasis
frigid cloud
#

Maybe quit the game

#

And restart

red helm
frigid cloud
#

When I tried to redo 100% I got stuck on gambler 7 cause valentine saloon wouldn't open

rocky oasis
frigid cloud
#

I can see bartender inside

#

I did that caloway mission

red helm
frigid cloud
round hedge
#

that's why

rocky oasis
frigid cloud
#

Nice lol

red helm
#

Cool

hidden moss
#

Better lighting

#

Just Cause 3's lighting made me feel wet

#

I managed to get naked John

#

with save editing

#

and saved it too

#

lmao

#

Now John can go around and beat people

#

while naked

#

That's it? I got John in pajamas killing half the population of Blackwater

hidden moss
#

while John is in nudes

#

I also have John Marston mods

#

so real John Marston naked

#

He just woke up with a boner on his pants after a sleep with Abigail and blows up Fort Mercer

golden storm
#

wait how do you make him naked

hidden moss
#

Glitches or mods

frigid cloud
#

Doesn't work anymore

#

Only 1.00

hidden moss
#

Been having a lot of fun hunting lately

loud forum
hidden moss
#

haha yeah

#

I got those trinkets today

frigid cloud
#

Try hunting requests guys cowboykekw

loud forum
#

sad that my computer broke n I can't play anymore until 2022

frigid cloud
#

Jesus

hidden moss
#

Rip

loud forum
#

yeah been saving for that

#

inflation sucks

loud forum
#

uhh

#

someone pinged me with a gif link?

hidden moss
#

Idk

#

Maybe they sent a inflation gif

loud forum
#

bruh I hate that kink(no kink shaming)

rocky oasis
#

Is it possible to make the 90 challanges after arthur dies? Cause i wondered why the exploration challanges are not available

#

the others are possible but the exp. challange...

#

its greyed out

keen birchBOT
lofty valve
#

What’s the mission in chapter 2 that you get $3k

round hedge
#

chapter 3

lofty valve
#

My bad I meant 3

#

I still haven’t gotten to it what’s the name

native thunder
#

"Sodom? Back to Gomorrah" should be the valentine bank robbery i think

verbal portal
#

Does Sadie ever mention something about Micah burning her house

lofty valve
#

1 mission away

fast sable
#

For PC, is there a mod that automatically collect the loot like in other games?

#

Also, with only 6 hours of playtime and currently in chapter 2, the NPC interactions, especially with your gang, are phenomenal. It feels so lively.

somber grove
#

so like what should i do of him

#

ok ty

somber grove
wary crag
#

abigail or sadie

#

what is better

#

if you can have on as a wife who would you have

sturdy patrol
wary crag
#

same

sturdy patrol
#

But sadie is quite neat

wary crag
#

what about this

#

arthur morgan or john marston

fast sable
#

Is there a way to loot faster?

wary crag
#

no shut up

#

jk

#

idk

feral cedar
#

people sleep on Mary istg

short canyon
#

Whats the fastest way to get my honor up? I'm tired of everyone in camp looking down on me lol

vast grotto
#

just, help people i guess

short canyon
#

There's only so many chorse 😭

vast grotto
#

before anyone says "greet people" that's not the fastest way

short canyon
#

Yeah I tried that for a bit and stopped lol

vast grotto
#

just travel around the world for awhile and look for random events

#

in chapter 6 you get a 1.5x multiplier for any honor actions you do

#

good and bad.

short canyon
#

hmm good to know so I can get the high honor ending

vast grotto
#

if you follow through with the "money lending and other sins" mission branch you won't have to worry about getting your honor up

short canyon
#

I'll make sure to keep that in mind

leaden sorrel
#

Hello

dusty knoll
#

I have an issue when I want to trade with the Trapper 😦

#

Let's say I want him to craft a saddle or a suit part, he doesn't recognize that I have the animal pelts in my inventory

vast grotto
#

you have to sell the parts to him first

dusty knoll
#

Let's say I have 10x Perfect Snake pelts

#

Ahhh!! that's why!!

#

Very much appreciated ^^

scenic pagoda
#

i just wrote a little story about what i think happened in blackwater

gritty hazel
#

Anyone PS4 looking to help me

#

getting money and everything else

fervent flame
obsidian crown
#

Does anyone know where wild American paints spawn?

fervent flame
#

if you have the compendium done, check there

obsidian crown
#

"Can be found in the wild"

#

Not really helping

hidden moss
#

i bet there was gonna be stranger missions in gaurma

frigid cloud
glossy marsh
#

hey guys arthur gets coughed on my mr downes in the money lending quest and for some reason the cutscene lasts longer and ends with arthur toucjhing his fce it is suggested several times mr downes is sick with something

#

just wanted to know if its nothing seriouis

heady anchor
#

Nah he’s fine.

sage mica
#

ye its nothing

frigid cloud
severe anvil
#

damn

#

if you leave pronghorn and return back after a while there's a cutscene

#

just went to saint denis and back with my horse and uh cutscene yes

loud plover
severe anvil
#

no with the woman

hidden moss
#

They say Arthur because he can swim

#

lol

#

I mean you play as Arthur in epilogue too

#

Except he can't swim

severe anvil
#

what

hidden moss
#

yeah

#

you play as Arthur in epilogue

severe anvil
#

how

hidden moss
#

with jetblack hair

severe anvil
#

you cant swim?

hidden moss
#

yea

#

Epilogue Arthur can't swim

#

and has jetblack hair

severe anvil
#

never really swam

loud plover
severe anvil
#

at all

loud plover
frigid cloud
#

I wonder if Sadie knows John can't swim

hidden moss
#

and call it off John Marston

#

They were so lazy

#

that they gave John

#

Arthur's vomit sound

loud plover
hidden moss
#

I'm glad there are mods to fix epilogue John

loud plover
hidden moss
#

Chad mods just fixed him

#

made his outfits look accurate RDR1 outfits

#

Also they fixed most of stuff too

#

bringing back his 1.00 stuff

vagrant temple
#

hahahahaha

frigid cloud
#

Rdr3 jack finds a cure for lumbago and tuberculosis and revives both uncle and arthur

glossy belfry
hidden moss
#

then everything is gonna be aight

#

for John

glossy belfry
#

also can you use jmrp without having the custom clothes at the fence?

hidden moss
#

yeah

#

Just remove catalog_sp.ymt

glossy belfry
#

i wish they just added more hairstyles instead of replacing them

hidden moss
#

I'd like that

faint thistle
#

Some of the skips in rdr2 are stupid funny

#

Like having to set the wagon on fire to break the pickpocket's AI

#

Or tossing a molotov into the river to skip the walking sequence

frigid cloud
#

What

#

What walking sequence

rocky oasis
#

Is it possible to make the 90 challanges after arthur dies? Cause i wondered why the exploration challanges are not available
the others are possible but the exp. challange...
its greyed out

frigid cloud
#

Yes, they just unlock when you do the one that's before it

#

They'll all be grayed out till you do the previous one

rocky oasis
#

ah thanks very much

frigid cloud
#

No problem

severe anvil
#

i pity gavin's friend a lot seen him in lots of places

#

where is gavin

vast grotto
#

not in the game

#

just kill him and end his misery

severe anvil
#

oh ok

#

will do

frigid cloud
#

Wont he respawn

frigid cloud
severe anvil
#

ok well i guess ill do it when i see him again

faint thistle
#

Hey?

frigid cloud
#

Hi

faint thistle
#

Does the Ties That Bind stranger mission reset?

#

Hello Baran

frigid cloud
#

Hi

faint thistle
#

100% completion pain

#

Hbu

frigid cloud
#

Probably not sure

#

I did it as arthur still had it when I switched to john

frigid cloud
faint thistle
#

I got all 5 posters, but they wont spawn in their camp

#

Then I reloaded and their side story is now out of the mission log

#

No clue wtf happened

frigid cloud
#

Weird

faint thistle
#

Can anyone help me out?

#

Will I be able to access that mission as John?

red pond
#

Can i craft stuff with big fishes ? Just fish one but dunno what to do with it ...exept eat it lol

latent plover
loud plover
#

bros i just started RDR2 again as arthur
now i found a dinosaur bone before meeting Deborah Mcguiness
i then went to her and cant find the bone location paper in my satchel

did it automatically got delivered to deborah after i met her ?

#

pls help

whole dawn
#

someone told me I can get a bolt action in a mission while recusing sean. i don't want to watch a video to avoid spoilers, can someone tell me how I can get it?

frigid cloud
#

No clue

hidden moss
#

So

#

when u first kill the guys with the knife

#

after that

#

u will see 2 guy

#

one of em has bolt action rifle

#

u must kill him first

#

then he drops it

#

I think that's how it is though

#

I don't remember much.

frigid cloud
whole dawn
loud plover
slate badger
#

soo

#

why can I buy the entire garments sets at the trapper even if I don't have the requirements for them?

lean hedge
#

Hey mister

#

that's a fine animal you got there

candid niche
#

can someone tellme were to find bulls?

stiff echo
#

Doing gambler 8

#

Please pray for me

hidden moss
#

Did the “aren’t u cold” bug fixed?

#

Haven’t heard anyone say it at camp, and I talked to literally everyone😄

candid niche
#

uh maybe

#

i dunno

hidden moss
#

Even Abigail didn’t call me a fool😄

frigid cloud
#

It's not in 1.00

#

And latest patch yes

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

About time😄

frigid cloud
#

Gang members don't talk about it anymore

hidden moss
frigid cloud
#

So it's completely removed instead of fixing it

hidden moss
#

So annoying

#

Haha, well better then before ig😄

#

Kinda lazy tho

frigid cloud
#

Exactly

#

Yep

#

No photo mode in 1.00 either I think

hidden moss
#

Missed that too xD

#

And tbh. I feel like latest patch looks better then 1.0

#

It’s more vibrant

#

Always thought 1.0 would look better. But not really ig

#

The horse glitch was nice tho ;p

loud plover
# candid niche can someone tellme were to find bulls?

u can find them at emerald ranch and a place north west to it called carmody dell
plus u find oxes over there too so dont get triggered if bull doesnt spawn
ARE U LOOKING FOR BULL SHOTGUN CHAPS, I LOVE EM
(BTW R U A METALHEAD, GREAT mee too)

hidden moss
#

same with epilogue John too

#

also annoying bugs don't exist in 1.00

frigid cloud
#

I'd only ever downgrade for new Austin as arthur, gold bar and epilogue john and no bugs

severe anvil
#

hey why is sadie having cold

#

is it related to uh

#

y'know

frigid cloud
#

wat

severe anvil
#

in the epilogue

#

i heard her uh

hushed flare
#

Huh

frigid cloud
#

Wut

hushed flare
severe anvil
#

wait ok im trying to find the right work

#

word

#

she has a runny nose is it related to arthurs

hidden moss
#

What?

#

Sadie's epilogue look is same as main story

#

.

severe anvil
#

ok well

#

nvm then thanks anyway

hidden moss
knotty sigil
#

why does the ufo didnt spawn for me the one in mount shann, ive gone there at 2 am but nothing is there, should i sleep much further away? cuz i kinda sleep quite close to it

hushed flare
#

Wrong area or you've already seen the ufo

#

UFO comes between 12 and 4 am

#

In a specific spot

knotty sigil
#

maybe ill wait till 4

lofty valve
#

on the chapter 3 valentine robbery, i cant loot the last box, even though the circle area is still there

#

is that normal or do i gotta restart the mission

loud plover
worn sentinel
#

Is Undead Nightmare canon?

round hedge
#

no

loud plover
#

lemme tell yall a sad story

#

some weeks ago

#

i updated my RDR2 on ps4

#

then i found out some RDR Online update
i created a account

#

only to find out dat i was on a 2-3 day trial by PS4

#

sed

#

cant subscribe

solar goblet
#

When in the mountains other than changing Arthur's outfit for the cold. is there anything else i should do. like anything for my horse?

frigid cloud
#

No

solar goblet
#

Alright thankyou!

main coral
#

micah married arthur

frigid cloud
#

Hax

mighty pecan
frigid cloud
#

🤢

#

Micah needs mary-beth

hidden moss
#

Hot

#

Yeah i agree.

#

They are pretty powerful in Chapter 2

#

They have alot of damage

summer garnet
hidden moss
#

I prefer calling The Ranch Chapter "Chapter 4"

shy mulch
#

I dunno if this is a known bug or not but for anyone attempting challenges that involve combat you can aggro a camp, run away a fair distance, and if you come back the AI will break.

fast sable
#

Does RDR2 use the same map as RDR?

native thunder
#

no?

hidden moss
#

No

#

RDR1 has New Austin and Mexico

#

New Austin is in RDR2 but not Mexico

native thunder
#

unless you mean if NA and WE is the same

hidden moss
#

Wait no

#

I got the question wrong

hidden moss
shy mulch
#

I think some areas were loosely translated

#

There's like a video comparing roughly the same locations, the out of bound areas in RDR do show some land.

fast sable
#

Is there a way to loot bodies faster? I'm kinda tired running to each of them and hold E

hidden moss
fast sable
#

@hidden moss Which one? could you provide the link to that?

shy mulch
#

Maybe kick them into an awkward place so u can fast loot em

hidden moss
#

ModDB or just search RDR2 loot mod

hidden moss
hidden moss
shy mulch
#

Well they still gotta crack a few things

hidden moss
#

More mods came out

#

🤷‍♂️

#

John epilogue fix, Red dead online content for story mode

shy mulch
#

maybe in a few years we'll get witcher 3 tier mods

hidden moss
#

Npc clothes and guns

hidden moss
#

We are just waiting for custom model and awc support

shy mulch
#

nah more nitpicks

hidden moss
#

goddamn openiv don't give us custom model support and awc support

shy mulch
#

Arthur Marston just reminds me of how much people bitched about Geralt being inaccurate

hidden moss
#

so modders are trying their best

hidden moss
#

Arthur Marston is not John Marston at all though

#

Nothing accurate about it

shy mulch
#

It's no offense I'm just saying there are gonna be some rlly niche mods in the future and I will be lookin forward to em

hidden moss
#

I dont care about people saying "OMG VANILLA EPILOGUE JOHN IS FINE STOP NITPICKING!!!"

#

We have mods

#

and we are already making lots of shit about it

dire sentinel
#

console tho sadpepohaw

hidden moss
hidden moss
fast sable
#

When hunting for a deer, the game said use a "rifle" for a clean kill. What rifle do I need to use? Bolt or what?

hidden moss
#

Springfield

#

You just need to headshot a deer with a bow

fast sable
#

That explains it

#

I use a Bolt Action and headshot a deer and the quality went from three stars to one

shy mulch
#

Yea I thought hunting was a lot more complicated initially I used to just shoot deer in the neck with a bow in my first few hours

#

I never really use the organ system or whatever it's called it's all headshots from here

fast sable
#

So here's how I understand hunting:

Small - Varmint Rifle
Medium - Springfield or Lasso or Bow
Big - Bolt Action

#

@hidden moss Can I hunt with a rolling block rifle?

shy mulch
#

Hmmm I think smaller game call for small game arrows

hidden moss
hidden moss
fast sable
#

Yeah, and that

#

How about a rolling block?

#

Can I use that?

hidden moss
#

Big - Poison knifes

shy mulch
#

rolling block is a bit inconsistent for predators

fast sable
#

I see

shy mulch
#

I dunno I took my scope off using the bug but a cougar coming at me survived a headshot from that shit

hidden moss
#

Your John experience ruined

fast sable
#

Also is there a way to get rid of a gun?

hidden moss
#

😄

fast sable
#

I'm carrying like 10 weapons on my horse 😂

round hedge
shy mulch
#

You could go to a weapon locker and stow it away

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

At camp

#

Or Hotel

fast sable
#

I'm currently in my first playthrough and already spent like 30% of it hunting 😂

hidden moss
#

He spent 4 hours hunting

shy mulch
#

I've been fishing lately, it's so relaxing

round hedge
shy mulch
#

Also Survivalist 10 is like 75% done

hidden moss
#

It took him 2 hours to shoot a legendary moose because he wants it to be a perfect skin

shy mulch
#

So did he just stalk it

hidden moss
#

Too bad i never told him that Legendary Animals dosen't require perfect skin

shy mulch
#

I know moose horns can suck for regular ones

hidden moss
#

So he's stuck in Chapter 3

hidden moss
fast sable
#

Ngl. After sometime playing GTA Online and probably spend like 90% of time grinding, I find that RDR2 is more fun and relaxing

shy mulch
#

Well that game isn't as immersive and I don't even like using the term immersive

fast sable
#

They messed up by making an online game more fun playing solo 😂

shy mulch
#

Oh and you're playing Online too? Man hope the degens didn't randomly kill you

fast sable
#

I don’t play RDR2 online. I do play GTA Online

shy mulch
#

Really sad how they encourage that oppressor bs lol

#

or just annoying pvp in general

fast sable
#

Already uninstalled GTA V so there’s that

autumn iron
#

i was playing rdr2 a few days ago and randomly went to online and my ps plus ran out 10 minutes in because it just turned 12 am, so thats nice

hidden moss
#

It's a warning

boreal goblet
#

The john proposing cutscene will forever be my favorite cutscene in epilogue

native thunder
#

one of my fav epilogue cutscenes is the one where it shows john shoveling manure.

hidden moss
#

John is only RDR1 and Npc one

#

Idk who is that guy at epilogue

native thunder
#

ah yea

#

john morgan, sorry

fast sable
#

Both of my pistol has a spade and heart symbol. What do they mean?

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

So epilogue vanilla dude seems to be fake and not canon

native thunder
fast sable
#

First and second?

native thunder
#

you get those symbols when you get 2 copies of the same gun

#

like dual schofields, cattleman, etc.

fast sable
#

Oh I see now

#

Thanks for the explaination

#

Is there a way to discard a gun?

#

I seem to pick up a worn gun

round hedge
#

discard it completely, no

#

but you can put it away with the weapon locker

shy mulch
#

oh boy they're talking about the strange man's face now

#

Is the Melodic dude on this server I wanna ask why he's arguing so much about faces got damn

indigo fog
#

“When I’m gone, the’ll just find another monster”

shy mulch
#

the next monster is why arthur's cock isn't rendered in game and why I need to argue with folks on youtube about it

round hedge
#

it's the fact that john's cock was downgrades

#

his NPC has a bigger crouch 🗿

knotty sigil
#

is it possible to trigger pagan ritual?

hidden moss
#

I just noticed

#

During the mission where the gang leaves Horsehoe Overlook

#

Javier is wearing the same duster coat he has in RDR1

summer garnet
main coral
#

outlaw

#

pew

loud plover
unreal gate
#

Should i sell the black horse that the old man gave me in camp?

#

The horses name is shire

#

Keep or sell?

frigid cloud
#

Keep

#

It's rare

#

You can't find it anywhere else

elder raven
#

hey guys, it is cool if ask for some help regarding getting 100% completion here from time to time? For example, i find the Exotics quite troublesome

frigid cloud
elder raven
frigid cloud
#

Yes

elder raven
#

nice

#

you know, i was very really close, i had a 93.7% save, but then my ps4 had some issues and i had to reinstall the software, losing everything

#

don't matter to me. i'll try to get it again, i am currently on 68%, almost finishing chapter 6

severe anvil
#

damn

#

i pity you

frigid cloud
#

Did you have an autosave

elder raven
# severe anvil i pity you

thanks lol, sad, i know, but i think instead of like, it saddening me, it gave me a big motivation boost, actually

elder raven
#

well i mean i did

#

but lost it

frigid cloud
#

Rip maybe you could recover it from PS4 cloud servers or sumthing

elder raven
#

i looked there, it wasn't there

frigid cloud
#

Damn.

elder raven
#

i don't mind a lot. I would quit but then i remembered Arthur, and i want to honor him the best i can, and i think that would be if i was to 100% the game

#

so i am just not quitting. oh and i learned from my mistakes and saved the files to my usb, just in case 😂

frigid cloud
#

I have overwritten my 91.4% save but got an autosave 84.1% from PS4 cloud servers

elder raven
#

ah i see

#

but you got the 100% regardless

frigid cloud
#

Yep

elder raven
#

which was the most troublesome for you to do? @frigid cloud

#

out of the requirements for 100%?

frigid cloud
#

Hunting requests and gambler challenges

elder raven
#

not exotics?

#

i am currently on gambler challenge 9

#

and i find exotics and hunting requests the worst imo

frigid cloud
#

Exotics was fine

inner storm
#

I’m so pissed

#

OH MY GOD ITS NOT EVEN CHAPTER 2

#

I FUCKING CANT

#

I LOADED IT UP AND ITS CHAPTER 1

#

THE BEGINNING

#

NO SAVES

#

WHERE ARE ALL MY SAVES

#

WTFFFFFFFFFFFFF

#

I’m gonna go cry

elder raven
#

sorry about that

inner storm
#

I was literally in chapter 4

#

What the hell

elder raven
inner storm
#

I hate chapter 1

#

So much

elder raven
inner storm
#

Like can’t there be a way to skip it

elder raven
#

nah

frigid cloud
elder raven
inner storm
#

What happened to my saves though

#

Omg my life sucks

#

How long would you say it takes to complete chapter 1

#

And chapter 2

#

Could I do it in one day

elder raven
#

just skip all the cutscenes

inner storm
#

Both chapters?

elder raven
#

yeah for sure

#

chapter 1 doesn't even take 4 hours for sure

#

2-3 at most

#

and chapter 2, not sure

inner storm
#

How long would it take for chapter 2 though

#

Just so the missions and nothing else

#

And skip cutscenes

elder raven
#

idk, my guess is 12 hours at most

#

@frigid cloud also did you get Legend of the West trophy? The platinum?

inner storm
#

12 HOURS?!

#

THE FUCK

#

I DO NOT HAVE THAT TIME

#

AHHH

frigid cloud
inner storm
#

I am in tears right now

frigid cloud
#

Don't play anymore doe

inner storm
#

MY SAVES SAID

elder raven
inner storm
#

“Bye bish”

elder raven
#

okay then 2 days for you to complete the two chapters

inner storm
#

This shit is fucking insane

elder raven
#

hey i know how you feel

#

but don't give up on it

inner storm
#

I had everything

#

All ammo typed maxed out

hidden moss
#

I think I prolonged chapter 2 by like 10 more hours just to keep micah in jail prayge

inner storm
#

All trapper gear

#

Golden health cores