red-dead-singleplayer

[hushed flare]

Same. I usually walk around the streets instead of full sprint madman

[hidden moss]

Te

Ye

[frigid cloud]

Walking in rhodes vs walking in saint denis

[hidden moss]

I prefer Rhodes

[rugged parrot]

I just hope the game isn't a favor simulator, go do this for someone, go save this guy, go deliver this, oh no Billy Joe got kidnapped by bandits go kill them

Is it?

[hidden moss]

Saint denis is cool, but idk, not a city person😄

[frigid cloud]

It kinda is

[rugged parrot]

Save me

[hidden moss]

Not really favor. More kinda… do this

[round hedge]

saint denis has the worst NPCs i've ever seen

people praise for how rockstar npcs are

but saint denis is just absolutely garbage

[wicked swift]

visually saint denis looks better but overall id prob say rhodes

[rugged parrot]

I was never interested in the game at all but my friend told me to get it, tbh I will play it a few more hours and see how it is but I'm not really interested that's the problem

[floral goblet]

black water and rhodes r so pretty

[round hedge]

RDR2 is cool but there are many slow paced things that are really unecessary

opening cabinets taking 5 seconds

jesus

[rugged parrot]

I know I'm just saying I'll play it again in a few days and hopefully it peaks my interest

[round hedge]

looting taking 2 seconds

[frigid cloud]

Tying up someone takes fucking 10-15 seconds

[rugged parrot]

Exactly that's another thing that made it boring, I had to loot a bunch of shit and it took forever they tried way too hard to make it immersive that's the impression I got

[round hedge]

jesus christ don't even tell me about that

[hushed flare]

Annoying thing about rdr2 also is when you accidentally pick up a body

[hidden moss]

Just replayed singleplayer knowing all of the secrets and shortcut

[round hedge]

and the constant need of dead eye

[hushed flare]

Takes till next century to pick it up then drop it

[hidden moss]

OR A HAT

[round hedge]

like, it's almost impossible to shoot without the fucking dead eye

[hushed flare]

When you pick up the wrong hat:

[round hedge]

it was just a mechanic to make it easier in RDR

but in RDR2 it's a fucking must

since you gotta wait 2-3 seconds for each shot to be accurate

[hidden moss]

Unless you have the Navy Revolver on Online

Arthur picks up a semi-auto shotgun like he has never seen a gun before

[round hedge]

i easily don't consider RDR2 as my favourite open world because of all the realistic shit they decided to add

most of the times it's just painful or boring to have them

and not fun at all

my opinion of course

[rugged parrot]

My favorite open world game is breath of the wild

[hidden moss]

So do i

[frigid cloud]

If you play online and return to story every animation is way slower

[hidden moss]

True

Thankfully i finished Singleplayer before Online

[rugged parrot]

Online looks like shit too I checked it out the graphics are terrible

[hidden moss]

So i can Clint Eastwood all the way to lvl. 50

[frigid cloud]

I returned for 100%

[rugged parrot]

Max graphics on PC

[round hedge]

i dropped RDR2 already

couldn't bother to play it anymore

[hidden moss]

Just tie the hand and call it a day

[hidden moss]

You got bored out of Chapter 1?

But the entire game is worth it

[round hedge]

no, i finished the game

[hidden moss]

Oh

[round hedge]

and never played it again

[hidden moss]

Just 100% it

[round hedge]

definitely not

boring as fuck

with useless achiviements

achviements

idk how to spell

it

[frigid cloud]

Dude the amount of things you have to do for 100% is insane

[hidden moss]

Gotta agree with Sulkii

I finished it once and everything is empty with repeating voice lines in Beecher's Hope

I did 100% with this game

[floral goblet]

Micah fan😥

[round hedge]

why not

[hidden moss]

Deal With It

[frigid cloud]

I'll correct you achievements

[hidden moss]

Because he can 🤷‍♂️

[round hedge]

thank you chad

[frigid cloud]

No problem anytime

[round hedge]

i'd install the game again to play with JMRP

but overall rdr2 is boring now

[frigid cloud]

For example grin and bear it lol

[round hedge]

everything was awesome in my first playthrough

[hidden moss]

Replay it

I did that too

[round hedge]

but now most of it is boring

[frigid cloud]

Survive 18 bear attacks and kill the bear

[hidden moss]

And yes Chapter 1 is horrible

[round hedge]

nah i'll just start from epilogue with a save game

[rugged parrot]

See at least my complaints are being justified

Chapter 1 sucks

[frigid cloud]

I need to keep a save in each chapter

[hidden moss]

I have that feel when i beat it but when i came back it still feels the same. Except Beecher's Hope

I still have the voice lines in my mind because it's repeated

[frigid cloud]

I still have sheeps and goats so I'ma get John's revolver next I think

[rugged parrot]

Cyberpunk has never bored me and I'm not done the game yet so I'll complete it before this game

[hidden moss]

Man

JMRP really makes Epilogue better

I just noticed

with other John Marston mods

[round hedge]

yeah, the other open world games aren't as detailed

[hidden moss]

John looks derpy asf in stranger mission cutscenes

[round hedge]

but they are way more enjoyable to play

watch dogs 2, a game i loved playing

[hidden moss]

I'd really like it if they kept it in both fun and immersion

[round hedge]

stirt was meh

story

but the gameplay

oh boy

awesome

[hidden moss]

I really like Watch dog 2 gameplay too

I also like map design

[rugged parrot]

Watch Dogs 2 is one of the best games I've ever played I didn't even finish the story I just did PvP

[hidden moss]

I also encountered Dutch riding The Count after saving me from jail and followed him and he just sits there staring.

[hidden moss]

So did i

I fucking loved it's songs and parkour and story

But i never finished it

[hushed flare]

I assume watch dogs is where you watch dogs

[frigid cloud]

I'm not sure tbh

What it is about

[rugged parrot]

You're a hacker man and you hack stuff somehow on a mobile phone and you're basically a vigilante

[hidden moss]

Yeah

[frigid cloud]

I prefer shit shovelling in epilogue

[hidden moss]

Who tf milks cows normally

I just pull both sticks down

Good for speedrun tactics

[lofty valve]

if I turn my self into sherif so I gotta pay my bounty amount of fines

[frigid cloud]

I think pushing right stick down then left and repeating is faster but not necessarily sure

[hidden moss]

yes

However if you turn yourself

[lofty valve]

I’m not boutta pay $160 in fines fuck that

I only have 300

[hidden moss]

Micky sucks 🙂

and save and load before Arthur/John comes out of door

u don't have to pay for money

[frigid cloud]

You don't have to pay your bounty off

[hidden moss]

Just turn yourself

then wait for cutscene to end

[frigid cloud]

It can stay

[hidden moss]

then save and load before John/Arthur comes out of the door.

[lofty valve]

I’ll Google it

[hidden moss]

That way your bounty will be erased

also u will keep ur money

Idk if they patched this

but when i tried it

it worked

[lofty valve]

I don’t like doing glitches but their law system is so shit

[hidden moss]

Law system is a huge downgrade

Law system was better in RDR1

[lofty valve]

Rockstar is just making games to do glitches

[hidden moss]

Ngl most of things that was in rdr1 was downgraded as hell in RDR2

[lofty valve]

Gta online you can’t go far easily without glitches same with Rdr now ig

[hidden moss]

One of downgrade is John

[lofty valve]

Imagine Rdr1 gameplay but RDR2 graphics

[hidden moss]

God I like that

Some things from RDR1 should've been kept in rdr2

RDR1 LAW SYSTEM

Weapon system

I'd rather have rifle holster instead off hand holster

[frigid cloud]

Is rdr1 100% easier

[hidden moss]

yeah

more fun

[floral goblet]

Isnt there zombies in one of the games

[frigid cloud]

When you collect flowers, orchids, plants, herbs in rdr2

[hidden moss]

Undead Nightmare

And you have to do these all stuff while playing as Arthur Marston

[frigid cloud]

Not necessarily, you can do it as arthur morgan as well

[hidden moss]

But some people save them

for epilogue

[frigid cloud]

You just need the lote satchel so makes sense

[floral goblet]

seems fun not a fan of the graphics tho lol

[hidden moss]

I don't get people hating on RDR1 graphics tbh

Graphics are awesome for it's time

[hushed harbor]

i wonder what rdr2 would look like if the environment was as muted as rdr1

[hidden moss]

If only RDR2 had Rdr1 atmosphere and setting

[frigid cloud]

How is the hunting in rdr1

[hidden moss]

Simple

And enjoyable tbh

[floral goblet]

definitely good for it’s time

[hidden moss]

U shoot em

[frigid cloud]

How many animals are there

[hidden moss]

Not much

I don't remember but i think like 10-12

animals

[hidden moss]

I agree. RDR2 has lack of western spaghetti feel

It's more like a dark ass game similar to GTA 4

[frigid cloud]

Damn they really improved the animals with rdr2

[hidden moss]

I wish Rockstar had not cut Bobcat animal from RDR2

[frigid cloud]

When you kill uncle with no hesitation but ties Abigail and jack up

[hidden moss]

There would be one more animal in RDR2 then

[hidden moss]

I really like some of RDR1 stuff than RDR2

Also the final battle with Micah and Arthur in the mountains has alot of resemblance to Jimmy Vs. Gary in Bully

Atmosphere, John, Gameplay

Oh

I also like clothes in rdr1

Me too

[frigid cloud]

Except Arthur loses

[floral goblet]

I want to show off my outfits

[hidden moss]

Even though most of outfits in RDR1 are cowboy outfit with another pieces in it

[hidden moss]

True true and Micah has more HP

Rdr2 outfits are just randomizer

[frigid cloud]

Micah is superior in general

[floral goblet]

HUH

[hushed harbor]

thematically for the game and its story, it makes sense

[frigid cloud]

Wut

[hidden moss]

Yeah

Meh

Don't care about atmosphere and setting

I just want a cool ass duel with Micah in the Epilouge

I only care about gameplay and epilogue John

So do i

The fuck is Rockstar's problem with epilogue John

why couldn't they keep him in 1.00 version

if they were too lazy to fix him

Epilouge was abandoned and rushed

[hidden moss]

yeah

So many lost potential and cut content for epilogue sadlyt

So did Guarma

[hushed harbor]

i think they made him look more like arthur for the people that miss him after the story

[hidden moss]

Cut content in Rockstar Games makes me feel like i got ripped off

[frigid cloud]

Fr

[hidden moss]

Bad excuse.

[hidden moss]

That's John Fucking Marston

So just some people could remember Arthur

why would they ruin one of most iconic character of gaming?

Arthur's gone. He's dead

[frigid cloud]

If you want to see Arthur have a save in each chapter then

[hidden moss]

John was literally iconic for it's time

If he dies, he dies

and it would be awesome if John looked like John in epilogue

Acted like Jonh

John Marston is John Marston

instead of some goofy and arthur reskin in epilogue

[hushed harbor]

or save edit so that u play as arthur in the epilogue

[hidden moss]

Also he's derpy asf

[hidden moss]

God epilogue John's dialogues

makes me go

"YOU HAVE A SMALL NECK"

"YOU LOOK LIKE YOU LIKE TO EAT!"

[boreal goblet]

I don't see what's wrong with it?

[hidden moss]

Good god

What the hell

[hidden moss]

Everything.

That's not the John Marston i know

Also his greets sucks too

"SIR!"

"OH PARTNER!"

Almost as if he's gonna run to people and attack em

like what the hell

[frigid cloud]

Arthur's outta the damn way is better

[boreal goblet]

Should've chose someone else or made him more like john

[hidden moss]

That pisses me off and made me don't touch the square button

Npc John acted like RDR1 John

At least he acted more closer to RDR1 John

and Npc John at least had decent dialogue

[boreal goblet]

Can't even tip your hat... Smh

[hidden moss]

Man

Epilogue John doesn't look into revolver/pistol

when aiming

just aim then go photo mode

he looks somewhere else

I have shit tons stuff that is wrong with epilogue John

Also when you encountered that mexican guy that challenges gunslingers John says "I'm no gunslinger but sure" and beats him and made him be ashamed himself that he lost to a random dude. And for Arthur he told the guy he's a gunslinger and beats him and the guy still acts fine and competitive.

Weird shit

Almost as if Rockstar wanted to downgrade John as much as possible

So people like Arthur more

No hate to Arthur

I just hate what they did to John

[boreal goblet]

Yeah they made John act like a jerk so you like Arthur more

[hidden moss]

Not even a jerk

They made him act like a dumbass and childish

and goofy

This makes me want to play as Epilouge Jack in RDR1 all over again

also made him look like Arthur reskin in epilogue

just to add some heat to fire

[frigid cloud]

When you can't take a bath in Beecher's hope

[boreal goblet]

They don't have enough water in the tub ig

[hidden moss]

GOOD FUCKING LORD

THIS STRESSED ME OUT

And also you change your clothes there to add a salt to the wound

[hushed harbor]

make people like Arthur more
dont even give a cheat that lets you swap between john and arthur in the epilogue
hmm

[hidden moss]

Beecher Hope is most buggiest place in RDR2

I agree

Saddle teleports to rooftop

[boreal goblet]

Or at least a cheat to make john swim

[hidden moss]

Sometimes John's family disappears

or flying at air

[frigid cloud]

What is that?

[hidden moss]

Abigail don't react to John after crashing near her

[hidden moss]

If you take off your horse saddle at beecher's hope

Saddle will teleport to rooftop

[frigid cloud]

WTF

[hidden moss]

in 1.00

Thankfully they have the same barn opening animation

That bug didn't occur

John: How's Jack?
Abigail: He's... Jack

Hearing this for the 400th time

Really made the Epilouge rushed asf

I'd rather not have epilogue at that point tbh

[boreal goblet]

At least they fixed the people saying your cold glitch

[hidden moss]

"What people have we become"

[hidden moss]

I started playing on 1.0 today. It’s amazing. Nobody told me I’m to cold, and I got rose grey Arabian & gold turkoman in chap 2 xD

[hidden moss]

and better looking John

[frigid cloud]

How did you downgrade exactly

[boreal goblet]

What subtitles glitch

[hidden moss]

Also sometimes in epilogue

[hidden moss]

That’s in 1.0? I thought that was only alpha

[hidden moss]

Nah

[boreal goblet]

Oh

[hidden moss]

I bought the DISC for it. Had to start new save

In 1.00 John looked slightly looked different

decent

Alpha/Beta John looked like John though

[frigid cloud]

I SWEAR in replays it says stranger instead of Sadie when Sadies talking

[hidden moss]

Or pre-release John

Uncle 2

Sometimes in epilogue

[frigid cloud]

Yup also dat lmao

[hidden moss]

U'll see Uncle 2

[frigid cloud]

Lawman 1,2,3,4 moment

[hidden moss]

Ah alr, nice😄 so far 1.0 had been great, only annoying thing is the map is laggy, the icons move weird xD

[frigid cloud]

I want 1.00 for limpany and new austin

[hidden moss]

(1.00 John vs Current John)
1.00 John:
-Npc Facial hair
-Better Facial Expression
-His body looks more like John's
-His ranch pants and gloves were small

Current version John:
-Bleached Mustache
-Broken Facial Expression
-His body looks more like Arthur's body
-His ranch pants and gloves got oversized
@hidden moss

here

[hidden moss]

Indeed

[hidden moss]

Yeee I can’t wait for NA, getting to chap 4 sooner then usual ;p

[hidden moss]

Nice👌

Also @frigid cloud what’s with Limpany?

[frigid cloud]

Infinite gold bar

[hidden moss]

yeah

Limpany has gold bar glitch in 1.00

Oooh xD nah I don’t wanna do that, I like the grind in rdr ;p

There is another glitch for infinite gold

in current patch

but it takes more time than 1.00 limpany bug

I just noticed

Another glitch for unlimited gold bar is on new patch

The new versions of the game is more lighter

Yeah

New version of the game has more bleached graphics

Felt like i was playing a mod

Didn’t r* fix the lightning in 1.0.9?

[hidden moss]

they did

but still not same as 1.00 graphics

I think they only updated the graphics for frame rate fixes

Like seriously

I'm fine with the game

Also there is another bug with mission

Motherhood blur

When John wears his cowboy outfit

John looks blurry as fuck

In 1.00 that bug didn't occur

[summer lily]

what’s limpany

[frigid cloud]

Oh shit let's go im bandit

Next outlaw

[hidden moss]

The burned down small village

Close to horseshoe overlook

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[hidden moss]

I wish there was a way to go to NA in chap 2, without the wagon😄 Chap 4 camp is alright, but 2/3 are def the best

And I spent a lot of time in camp xD def now that nobody telling I’m cold all the time

[frigid cloud]

Early on limpany could get you 15000$ without lote satchel i reckon

[hidden moss]

Nice. I already collected the gold bar tho, so prob can’t do it anyway

[frigid cloud]

Maybe it respawns then you can do it

[hidden moss]

I’ll check, would be nice to upgrade camp instantly😄

[frigid cloud]

Donating 1 million to the camp early on?!

Dutch

Let's go to Tahiti

[hidden moss]

Lmao. Imagine if that triggered a secret early ending ;p

Micah in jail

Gang in Tahiti

Im still hoping on a secret alternative ending lol. After 7 playthroughs you’d think you’d give up, but everytime you find something new, or an opportunity to do something different, the hope is back ;p

We need an alternative ending. I want Arthur to work on Johns ranch

[frigid cloud]

Maybe

[barren comet]

dutch still be like; WE NEED MONEY OR WE ARE DEAD. JUST 1 MORE SCORE

[boreal goblet]

Why don't they allow you to replay stranger missions

So stupid

[hidden moss]

I agree

Also you have to stick with default Arthur

And big bearded John

[lofty valve]

I bought the ultimate RDR2 shit so I can get the volcanic pistol for free but how do I buy the second one for free

Cause it says it’s already owned

I wanna dual wield 2 volcanic pistols

[frigid cloud]

Nah I got Arthur to level 10 beard in chapter 2 and stopped playing

[boreal goblet]

So you have a second holster?

[lofty valve]

Yea

I got it from rescuing Micah

[frigid cloud]

Buy it again

[lofty valve]

Can’t

It says owned

[frigid cloud]

It should say buy secondary

[lofty valve]

Nope

Buy button disabled

Owned label on it

[frigid cloud]

Do you have it already

[lofty valve]

Yes

I wanna dual wield 2 of them

[frigid cloud]

Huh

Weird

Maybe you need to save and reload or quit the game and start playing again idk

[lofty valve]

#red-dead-media

[hidden moss]

Finally completing the gambling challenges is a blessing

[mighty pecan]

Nerd why are you never not in this chat

[lofty valve]

Bruh why is the de spawn so fucking high

I was just tryna get a horse n I hog tie him n I turn around and the fucking horse de spawned after 2 seconds of not looking at it

[hushed harbor]

horse apparition

[native thunder]

probably ran off tbh

[frigid cloud]

I want to be.

[shy mulch]

nah the horse despawn is real

[latent plover]

Yeah what’s up with that

I wanna take a bounty hunters horse but as soon as it runs over a hill it despawns

[shy mulch]

thats how you complete horseman 10 you ride around someplace like the heartlands to despawn qnd respawn horses

R engine weird

it's probably how they keep the game relatively optimized

[latent plover]

For horseman 10 there’s specific places where certain horses spawn

[shy mulch]

then there's hunting for hhb as arthur lol

[frigid cloud]

Me using big valley for every horse

[shy mulch]

I finally found one near Emerald Ranch

[frigid cloud]

Yeah I know that one is pain the ass to find

But same I found one near emerald ranch

[latent plover]

I think I just googled the location(s)

[shy mulch]

Whoops, all Morgans and Saddlers

When you see a massive herd spawn and it's all Morgans lol

[frigid cloud]

Lol

[shy mulch]

the funny part of horseman 10 is looking at all the low poly horses when u use binoculars

[latent plover]

Sometimes you’ll find a npc riding a nokota or thoroughbred but it’s so rare it seems like a pointless detail

[shy mulch]

if only they rode an MFT

boah gettin robbed

[wary oasis]

When starting out in the epilogue do you keep all Arthur's stuff like gold, belongings and guns etc?

I know you don't keep horses

[frigid cloud]

When you sell all birds to the trapper instead of posting them at a post office

[frigid cloud]

Gold bars don't carry over

Guns do

[wary oasis]

I have 15 lol

[frigid cloud]

Pretty much unique stuff

[golden storm]

I like how either greeting or antagonizing uncle as John is always antagonizing him

[frigid cloud]

Apparently gold bars aren't unique but ok game

[wary oasis]

Gold bars do respawn in certain areas I'm sure

[hidden moss]

SPOILER: Hello, I have a question to the Singleolayer Mode of RDR2. I couldnt find any answers in the FAQ. My question is, is there any chance to get the money im the epilouge back?

[frigid cloud]

Arthur's money to john you mean?

[hidden moss]

Yup

[dusky hare]

So, I'm playing through story mode again, and I'm at the Pour Forth Oil #4, where you actually do the train job.

It seems as if something is broken. I have tried the mission 6 times, and all 6 times the train gets there before I can. The dialogue isn't even completed on the ride over. And 4 of those 6 times I hauled ass to get there and still wasn't fast enough.

Is this a known issue that maybe got broken in one of the updates? I've played through the story around 8 times, and NEVER had an issue with this.

[frigid cloud]

In chapter 6 go to that Aberdeen pig farm let the couple rob you but don't return when you're in epilogue return as john retrieve your money from behind the paint on the wall

Or picture idk what's it called

If you're already in epilogue this doesn't work unfortunately

[wary oasis]

Time to go sell 15 bars of gold...

[hidden moss]

And when i collect every treasure with arthur but dont sell it are the treasures still in my Inventory?

[wary oasis]

Then shopping spree...

[frigid cloud]

Yes I think so

[hidden moss]

Soo that i understand: I can collect every treasure as arthur and can sell IT as John in the epilouge?

[hidden moss]

No.

Every shit u got as Arthur will not be carried to John.

Except some items though

Like unique ones

Ahh okay now i understand. Thank you verry much ^-^

If u want to keep Arthur's money

sell all valuables that except unique ones

then do the aberdeen bug

Do it before final mission of chp6

[golden storm]

how do yall make so much money as Arthur I think I had like 300 dollars as him lol

[hidden moss]

U get more money as story progress

Honestly not a big fan of getting shit tons of money from missions

[golden storm]

I mightve spent it all idk

[hidden moss]

They should've made activites unlimited like in rdr1

Unlimited bounty hunting

stagecoach robbery unlimited

[golden storm]

yeah that would've been fun

[hidden moss]

I love RDR2

Are treasuremaps unice items?

I just hate that fact there are cut content and lost potential

[hidden moss]

Yeah

[golden storm]

maybe in whatever game is next in the rd series

[hidden moss]

Treasure maps carry over

[golden storm]

is red dead revolver worth 15 dollars whoever has played it

[hidden moss]

Alright thank you very much. I think i have a Plan lol:)

[hidden moss]

Yeah, It's a good game

If u don't mind the graphics ofc.

[golden storm]

no I love old game graphics

so tell me why arthur can fit wood and a literal tent in his pocket but the second I want more than 4 guns in my pockets the game refuses

[frigid cloud]

When GTA online players play rdr2: uhh why can't I carry all my guns uh this is weird where are cars

[wary oasis]

And 20 bars of gold with 20 different types of herbs and a coffee cup..

[golden storm]

but no I can't harvest all of the animal parts

[wary oasis]

Because you have about ten boar teeth in there

[frigid cloud]

Upgrade your satchel then

[golden storm]

how

[frigid cloud]

Go to any fence

And buy every satchel

If you're in epilogue ^

If you're still as arthur you need to craft it from Pearson

[golden storm]

ok

does Rhodes have rules or is that just a myth

HAAHAHAH IT DOESNT

[frigid cloud]

wut rules

[golden storm]

laws

you can kill everyone and nobody cares

[fierce cave]

Can you just keep buying gun belts from the trapper to increase your ammo capacity?

Im stuck at a max of 150 pistol ammo

[golden storm]

I keep forgetting john can't swim

[hidden moss]

Arthur Marston can't swim

[dark seal]

John can't swim?

[vestal sail]

Arthur Marston? Ever since I downloaded the proper mods he went from that to John Marston.

[hidden moss]

He's a meme now

[vestal sail]

I noticed in recent patches they lowered John's ears a bit, for no good reason.

[hidden moss]

Nah

[vestal sail]

It's quite noticeable.

[hidden moss]

John's ears in vanilla

was always low

even in 1.00

[vestal sail]

You sure? I have screenshots of the models.

[hidden moss]

yes.

1.00 John was same as current version John

Nothing changed about John's head

or face

Only his mustache got bleached

and shoulders looks like Arthur

If you're talking about that beta John's right ear or left ear in John's pov

is bigger than his other ear

Npc and Rdr1 John has the same thing

[vestal sail]

Okay I see

Did you get 1.0 fitment? It fixes his shoulders.

[hidden moss]

I have all mods for it

This man ran up to me and shot me, I just ran away and I still got wanted 🧍‍♂️

[vestal sail]

Time to shoot up the town.

[shy mulch]

st denis?

[hidden moss]

Annesburg

[shy mulch]

some lemoyne rats assaulted me on the street yet im a kidnapper for hogtying them and leaving em to rot

[hidden moss]

I didn’t even fight back, the guy just shot me

[shy mulch]

literally chose the nonviolent route theyre lucky i didnt off their heads

[hidden moss]

So then after I got wanted I just shot up the place

[shy mulch]

can't be worse than van horn tbh

literally got shot at because two drunks dueled each other and the whole town turned into a free for all

[vestal sail]

I like to use mods to spawn in a Maxim gun in Van Horn and just mow down the whole town.

[shy mulch]

lol i wanna shrink the whole town and step on em

is there like a mass shrink option for the trainer

[vestal sail]

With mods you can make yourself bigger to where they seem smaller...

[shy mulch]

isn't it the other way around too

I swear I saw a tiny arthur

[vestal sail]

Try spawning in a Maxim gun at one end of the town and fire a few shots, then try to survive.

I killed like 30 - 40 guys in just a minute or two in Van Horn with the Maxim Gun.

It's a fast way to lose honor though lol

[wary oasis]

Do all the trappers sell/craft the same stuff?

Not one does anything unique..

[hidden moss]

They sell same shit

[wary oasis]

Taa

Unlike stores have most of the same stuff plus some random extras...

[latent plover]

How did Mary know where Arthur was buried?

[plain edge]

Does honor affect the ending you pick? Like,if I were to have good honor,but I pick the bad honor ending,would it change the normal outcome?

[latent plover]

Yes

4 outcomes

Good good

Bad good

Bad bad

Good bad

[round hedge]

yes

1.00 John is the same Arthur Marston we have today, but with a few changes

like the correct mustache texture, better facial expressions, and fixed gloves and pants

but other than that, same old Arthur Marston

[round hedge]

no, it doesn't change anything in the story, all deaths will still have the same ending

but they will change a few dialogues that aren't important

[wary oasis]

Are all the trapper quests still available in the EP?

[plain edge]

Ah,ok. Bc I’m on my 4th play through,and I’ve done high honor for the other 3,and figured I’d do low honor this time

[round hedge]

wdym

the trapper outfits?

if so

yeah

[wary oasis]

Yeah like I can complete all the Trapper as JM?

[hidden moss]

Yes.

[wary oasis]

Taa

[trim scroll]

I’m trying to make a decision. I just finished my first play through of RDR2, should I go straight to rdr1, or do a second play through of RDR2 and then do rdr1?

[random plinth]

Depends

Have you played 1 before?

[mighty pecan]

If you’re not going for 100% completion or anything like that definitely play rdr1

[trim scroll]

Never played 1

[mighty pecan]

My PS3 is broke so i can’t play it

[lofty valve]

Which mission is it in the end of chapter 2 that you get $3k?

[round hedge]

RDR

don't let epilogue John be your only memory of him

btw, rdr John is literally 0% like epilogue John so you might have fun playing it

[vestal sail]

RDR John is waaaaaay more savage than RDR2 John.

[signal timber]

Anybody any idea why I'm not getting perfect rat carcasses in the elysium cave even though I'm using small game arrows?

Just keeps giving me poor carcasses again and again ...

It's tedious ...

[round hedge]

he's honestly more savage than Arthur too

RDR John legit would scare my soul away

[vestal sail]

He's got epic insults too. "I bet your pa wish he pulled out."

Ties up enemy
"Normally, I bet you usually pay someone to tie you up."

[vestal sail]

Arthur has some good cut lines though.
"Just shoot yourself in the head and save me the trouble!"

[hidden moss]

I hope RDR1 John is people's memory

Because fuck epilogue John

[frigid cloud]

I think they're mangy meaning always 1 star

So rather use that saloon random encounter where saloon is overran with rats

Or fort Riggs

[golden storm]

I like epilouge john

[hidden moss]

Wtf

[frigid cloud]

Epilogue

[hidden moss]

At what percent will the story end

[golden storm]

ohhh not epilouge post epilouge I mean

100

82 completion I believe

[hidden moss]

Ah you like main story John?

[golden storm]

no after the epilouge story (like after the ranch is done and Abigail and Jack are there

[signal timber]

Really?

[frigid cloud]

Yup study them and it'll say mangy

[signal timber]

I didnt know that meant you couldn't get a perfect carcass

Will try fort riggs ...

[signal timber]

Oh and thanks ...

[frigid cloud]

No problem

[tawdry moon]

"Maybe I'll keep her in black, on your behalf"
Never understood this line. Can anyone explain?

[mighty pecan]

I think it means in black as in funeral clothes

saying theyre gonna die basically

[paper stream]

hello, so is there a way to access your ingame photos in a folder cause am tired of uploading to social club and downloading from there

[steady vector]

I just did the mission where you rob the building next to the saint denis post office with Dutch and Lenny, and afterwards it changed my dead eye to always stay on if I shoot without marking a target. I never mark targets, I activate and then shoot ASAP after lining up a headshot. Now dead eye stays active after I shoot (since I don’t mark targets) and dead eye gets wasted because it stays active. I’m guessing there is no way to reset to how it was before?

[red helm]

You'll have to manually turn it off yourself.

But, indeed, there is no way to revert your Dead Eye back to previous levels.

... That I am aware of...

[steady vector]

All right thanks. I wish they left dead eye as it is instead of changing how it works multiple times

[red helm]

I like the marking method, it quite helps when you are hunting, for head shots.

Me?

Oh, okay then.

[steady vector]

Never thought of that, I’ll try it for groups of animals

[red helm]

Yeah, it's good to know exactly if you got the head, or accidentally hit the neck, etc.

[steady vector]

I’m guessing the changes to dead eye make it progressively easier for controller players, and weren’t intended for keyboard /mouse players (such as myself)

[wary oasis]

Any way to stop weapons spawning on your back when you start missions? half the time I get the varmint rifle when I need to kill off a load of enemies...

[red helm]

Ahh, right, Yes, It's better for Controllers, of course.

[steady vector]

Yeah?

[red helm]

Eh, unfortunatelly, you have to pay attention to your gun load outs before you start a mission.

[wary oasis]

Remove the varmint and put back in store?

[red helm]

Were you not using the Varmint before you started the mission?

[frigid cloud]

When you go hunting rabbits before the mission

[round hedge]

no, but they'll always get in your back when you leave your horse near the mission start

so if you select the ones you want and leave the horse before getting close to the mission

[frigid cloud]

I like the ability to stay in dead eye after firing but without that manual tag is still as good

[round hedge]

they won't be randomly selected

[red helm]

Yeah, having choices isn't a bad thing.

[mighty pecan]

@frigid cloud i was collecting a perfect rabbit pelt to post to the person today and i went to the fucking butcher.

[frigid cloud]

The ability I mentioned mostly helps with so you don't have to activate it after each bullet

[frigid cloud]

[mighty pecan]

Am i actually mentally deficient

[frigid cloud]

Are you joking or not

[mighty pecan]

I’m not.

I’d been playing for 14 hours straight i got sloppy

[frigid cloud]

Makes sense

You'll skin the next one probably

[mighty pecan]

😐

[hidden moss]

Good thing rabbits are absolutely everywhere

[wary oasis]

Thanks will try that

[round hedge]

if that doesn't work

then just leave your horse

and change the weapons

then get in the mission without getting on the horse

[red helm]

Perhaps take a few breaks every now and then?

[frigid cloud]

When you say that they stop spawning

Either they're 1-2 star or never spawn

[mighty pecan]

haha no

[hidden moss]

Sounds like my kind of luck

[mighty pecan]

how do you know how many stars the carcass is

[frigid cloud]

You study it first

Otherwise no way

[mighty pecan]

okay

[frigid cloud]

Or get lucky and it's 3 star

Actually

[red helm]

Indeed, you should be studying every new animal you see, and then you can see how many stars they have.

[frigid cloud]

When you kill an unstudied animal it'll show its quality

Next time I think

[mighty pecan]

I’ve been playing for so long and i feel like a complete noob

[frigid cloud]

Noob

[mighty pecan]

ok nerd

[frigid cloud]

🤓

Herbalist 9 speedrun enjoyer

[red helm]

I think you still have to study? I'm unsure, I always make sure to, for Compendium completion.

[latent plover]

How tf did Mary find Arthur’s grave?

[frigid cloud]

Not sure exactly but saw it in a video where bear is unstudied and still sees its quality

[hidden moss]

Must've been Charles

[red helm]

I wondered that as well... How does Charles know how to get in Touch with her?

[latent plover]

They don’t know each other yeah

[frigid cloud]

Or she found it coincidentally

[red helm]

She was just wandering around Ambarino?

[frigid cloud]

But no way

Lol nah

[hidden moss]

Weird how Arthur and Micah fought near the Widow's home

[red helm]

She owns that little Hobbit shire home right next to it?

[frigid cloud]

I'm confused

[hidden moss]

So do i

[red helm]

Ha... Rockstar logic...

[latent plover]

Definitely not

[red helm]

Ha, yeap, I'm just tossing out random non-sense.

[hidden moss]

Maybe john told mary but who knows

Or word got around somehow

[hidden moss]

Maybe. Since John has the picture of them together

Horrible in Online

The automatic point deadeye

I agree

But it's great for headshots and Lancaster

[frigid cloud]

Maybe it's cut content and john was supposed to meet mary and tell where the grave is

[hidden moss]

Yea maybe it's just implied john wrote to her at some point after meeting up with charles

I fucking hate cut-content in Rockstar games

[frigid cloud]

I got Dutch's outfit in online but quit playing after that

[hidden moss]

Hero

I just realized. Arthur originally owns John's Range Gloves

[shy mulch]

does anyone know what would cause arthurs nose and the skin under his eyes to turn dark

oh also his lips are black

[tepid rose]

Where are u in the story?

[shy mulch]

i dont have tb

[tepid rose]

Did u recently have a brawl?

[shy mulch]

i dunno did arthur fall on his face or smth he looks like a raccoon

[tepid rose]

Well that def might be bruises

[frigid cloud]

What chapter are you in

[shy mulch]

3

here i'll just post a screenie

[tepid rose]

Yeah falling on the face does give a person bruises

[shy mulch]

alright lemme try to sleep this off or something lol

maybe i'll get that max beard too

[tepid rose]

Anyone know if the mission "Visiting Hours" can be skipped? i just started "That's Murfree Country" and since it sets up chapter 6, i thought "Visiting hours" would be skipped and sadie does the mission on her own

[frigid cloud]

No it cant

You'll have to do it either way

[tepid rose]

Oh okay good

Thank you

[frigid cloud]

Probably her mission will spawn after setting up the camp

[hidden moss]

What is the meaning of the wolf ?

It shows up sometimes

Mostly when Arthur is coughing

[frigid cloud]

You have low honor meaning coyote will show up

If high honor instead a buck will show up

[hidden moss]

How do I get more honor

[frigid cloud]

Did you do strauss mission in camp

[latent plover]

Do good deeds

Say hello to everyone you see

[frigid cloud]

Debtor missions give a lot of honor

[hidden moss]

I'm at the end of the main story anyways I think. 57%

67%

[frigid cloud]

What missions are left

[hidden moss]

I don't know, where can I see ?

[frigid cloud]

Open your map

And you can see every mission you have

[hidden moss]

I'm in the middle of one rn so I can't

[frigid cloud]

Ok

What are you doing in that mission

[hidden moss]

Helping saddie with killing some dudes

In a huge camp

[latent plover]

Yeah if you haven’t done the debt missions do them

[hidden moss]

Will the honor affect the ending?

[latent plover]

Tbh I’d just continue playing as you are and see what ending you get

[hidden moss]

Okay

[latent plover]

I think it’s better that way, my first time I didn’t realise honour made a difference. But I’m glad I didn’t know, kinda felt more natural to get an ending that I created by the way I played the game

If that makes sense

Unless you really want a specific kind of ending

Btw you’ll find spoilers here eventually

[frigid cloud]

Me neither

I always was a dick so you can guess the ending

[latent plover]

Same

If someone said “get lost” etc when I said hi to them, I’d antagonise and then end up killing them

[hidden moss]

Rockstar is Rockstar, they make a good game. Then fuck it up with updates

and also don't fix their bullshit

ahh yas lovely, the pain im feeling is great with the game

[main coral]

pinkleton

[stiff aurora]

same

after finishing rd i dont even care abt johns honor lol

[runic depot]

im a psychopath on rd

[hidden moss]

This ending.. I'm nearly crying

[lofty valve]

RDR2 auto run be having you think you'll be at the place but you'll be at a random ass location standing still with a $50 bounty increase and less money than what you started with

[hidden moss]

Why do i have to work now ? I'm John now

[glossy lotus]

lol

that was my thoughts when I finished it, like why am I play farming sim

[hidden moss]

Fr..

[glossy lotus]

The missions pick up, its just John living a different life to get away from the pinkertons

[hidden moss]

What happens after that?

[main coral]

John marries uncle

[glossy lotus]

It'll be better to do it without spoilers trust me

[hidden moss]

Okay but I have to know one thing; will i be able to buy weapons again and get the money i left in the mine? @glossy lotus

[round hedge]

He's living a different life because of his family, not pinkertons

[glossy lotus]

He's also trying to evade them

Hence why he changed his name

[round hedge]

he didn't give a shit about anyone from the gang anymore or law, only pinkertons

[glossy lotus]

But the story will pick up again

[round hedge]

huge fucking retcon fr

Jim Milton was so unnecessary

why not just keep it Marston 🗿

[glossy lotus]

Lol

Rip Van Winkle was unecessary

[hidden moss]

I just want to be a cowboy again XD.. i didn't want to to farm missions

[glossy lotus]

fr and its like a whole hour or more of them

[round hedge]

true but at least it made sense

[lofty valve]

yo sulkii

[round hedge]

while jim Milton is stupid

[lofty valve]

when is it that you get a 3k robbery

[round hedge]

since everyone calls him Marston in RDR, no reason to hide

[glossy lotus]

Jim Milton was one of the agents too lol

[round hedge]

somewhere at the start in chapter 3

[lofty valve]

oh

[mighty pecan]

I second this

[round hedge]

only milton, not jim

[lofty valve]

i just started chapter 3 nice

chapter 2 was long as shit

[round hedge]

might take a few missions

but eventually you'll have it

[lofty valve]

auto run got me killed like 5 times lmao

nice

i have 1.2k at the start of chapter 3 so i should be good

[hidden moss]

Uhh damn imma just skip them missions

[mighty pecan]

Don’t look in this chat much if you’re only on chapter 3 theres a ton of spoilers in here

[round hedge]

epilogue is hella boring without john acting like RDR

[lofty valve]

okay

[fierce marsh]

so i just found a white arabian, got attacked by wolves, shot them, arabian was nowhere to be found, camped and slept until next morning, nothing, left the general area, (still in the grizzlies tho) camped until morning again, and still cant find it. any help?

[round hedge]

go away and leave that wacky arabian behind

[near berry]

haha sussy baka

[fierce marsh]

😐

[mighty pecan]

Lake Isabella is a big place. Don’t run at full pace, crouch and go fast like that. Go into eagle vision for tracks

or just leave and come back after a while

[fierce marsh]

alright

[hidden moss]

Is it worth doing the Stranger Missions as John?

[stiff aurora]

yes

if only ur trying to achieve 100 percent completion

[hidden moss]

I want too, and looked fun playing as John as i wanted to feel more close to him by doing the quests ig

Oh links are getting deleted ?

[plush warren]

i just started story like 5 days ago

im on chapter 4

[hidden moss]

take ur time plz

[plush warren]

no

rdr2 speed run

😎

[hidden moss]

I finished it 4 hours ago it's so good

Enough to make a man cry

[solemn tusk]

Is anybody a moonshiner? I wanted to try some missions before I purchase it.

[round hedge]

if you wanna speedrun

skip most missions you can in chapter 6

[plush warren]

sean is my favorite character and he died

i hope lenny and javier survive tbh

and hosea

[vagrant temple]

Try asking in #pc-lfg

[hidden moss]

damn idk if i want to replay the game again or stay in epilogue hm

hm

[round hedge]

didnt you play RDR lol

[plush warren]

no

[main coral]

van dr lind

[plush warren]

i only had rdr2 to troll my brother online

[subtle torrent]

yo

[vagrant temple]

Right? I wish there was more after the epilogue

[hidden moss]

i loaded a save with everything not done, but it feels so weird to play as john

[vagrant temple]

Just a bunch of small missions would’ve been great

[vagrant temple]

Ah okay

Yeah two chapters and the story ends

It’s the biggest letdown of rockstar games. No more story after it’s done

[hidden moss]

it was my second play through, but i got the game done fully on second

minus epilogue

[vagrant temple]

A large variety of infinite missions would go so far in a Rockstar game

[hidden moss]

wat do i do that the story ended idk

[vagrant temple]

Just kinda loses steam after the main story is complete

[hidden moss]

miss what's his name

[vagrant temple]

Arthur?

[hidden moss]

yes

[vagrant temple]

How’d you forget Arthur’s name 🤦‍♂️

[hidden moss]

i didnt lol

[pliant tree]

nah bro it's tacitus kilgore

[hidden moss]

i am wanting to play it again through the mainstory, and do comp but i just finished the main story, so im kind of like

idk in pain

[vagrant temple]

I will never understand how Arthur came up with that alias

[pliant tree]

ArThEr CaLaHaN

[vagrant temple]

Why not just John Smith?

[pliant tree]

idk

[vagrant temple]

Like seriously. Wtf is Tacitus Kilgore

[pliant tree]

probably too easy

[vagrant temple]

That could be right

Easy to misspell and hard to look up

[pliant tree]

i mean rip van winkle wouldn't be hard to spell lol

[hushed flare]

Jim milton

[pliant tree]

let's see jim milton nope no address for that name here

[distant crescent]

Well rdr1 exists

[frigid cloud]

Btw does anyone know why Algernon calls John James

[little roost]

yeah I'm about to finish my second playthrough but I'm not going to do the epilouge I'm just going to delete the save I have for my second playthrough and go back and play on my main one ad john

[somber grove]

where do i scrub my horse is there any place

[random plinth]

Use the brush or take it for a swim

[somber grove]

ok ty

and can you pls tell how does the double horse system work

@random plinth

and can i give the horse to the camp

[mighty pecan]

You can’t do that, if you hitch a horse you wanted to give, it would just show up as a temporary horse symbol

[faint thistle]

@somber grove you can buy something that doubles as a stae upgrade tho

But you cant donate a horse

[hidden moss]

LENNY!!!

[glossy marsh]

hey i need some help i killed legendary bear and now i have his pelt but im still in early game and have not unlocked saint dennis so what do i do with the pelt

[paper stream]

when i try to upload photos to social club it just says alert and doesnt upload, anyone know a fix?

[hidden moss]

Can find a trapper in a few locations to give it to. Like beside riggs station and northwest of strawberry

[glossy marsh]

no i diead

i cant get the hide back

[shy mulch]

Check the trapper the game accounts for losing Legendary pelts by automatically sending them to the trapper.

[glossy marsh]

damn

then i cant sell it

[shy mulch]

so what, you can still craft the legendary garments

[glossy marsh]

yeah

[wary oasis]

The game accounts for lost stuff or bugs pretty well

I lost the Ornate Dagger and then found it to buy at the fence

[heavy cedar]

Red dead has the best story of anuhame hands down you can't change my mind

[fierce cave]

shit

i feel like

an awful person

i hit a dog in rhodes when it ran in front of my horse

[cobalt kindle]

is it dead

[fierce cave]

no

but i still feel bad

because i hit a dog

[hidden moss]

RDR1

[glossy marsh]

damn

[glossy marsh]

the ending realyy got to me

[faint thistle]

Do cutscenes count for mission time?

[frigid cloud]

Gold medals?

Yeah, but there are a few exceptions I noticed

Mostly you need to skip cutscenes for gold medals

[faint thistle]

Thank you

I'm in pain on the gold rush

[umbral zealot]

Hello my boys

I finnaly caught that white arabian

[faint thistle]

Whats the goddamn plan?

Oh grats

Wolves are a pain in the ass there

[umbral zealot]

THE PLAN IS MONEY

[faint thistle]

Very skittish horses + stunlock

[umbral zealot]

And collecting the best guns in the game from the gunslingers

[faint thistle]

The prettiest for sure

[hidden moss]

A LOT OF NOISE?

[faint thistle]

Ironically they're usually worse than their normal counterparts

[umbral zealot]

Yes but they look good

[faint thistle]

Micah's is one of the few unique guns with much better damage

Oh def my favorites as well

Partial to flaco and granger pair

[umbral zealot]

Ok

So if they where to get into a fight who would win

John or Arthur

[hidden moss]

jack

[faint thistle]

Well, he did live

[umbral zealot]

Rdr1 john and chapter 2 rdr2 arthur

[faint thistle]

TB or no TB?

[umbral zealot]

No tb

[hidden moss]

no tb

[umbral zealot]

And john after he has healed

[faint thistle]

Betting on Arthur tbh

[umbral zealot]

Both of them have full loadouts

[faint thistle]

He's a fucking dark souls boss

[umbral zealot]

What?

Omg that reminds me

[faint thistle]

His HP pool is chunky

[umbral zealot]

Remember in chapter 3 where you race dutch

[faint thistle]

I dont even need to take cover

[umbral zealot]

I was about to beat him but then I smashed into a tree a few feet from the camp

He then won

[faint thistle]

Relatable

I've never not had that bullshit happen

You can play it in your favor tho, with a bulky horse most npcs crashing into you will rocket off course while your steed tanks it

(Or the tried and true pushing them off the road. Dutch's baby Arabian ain't got shit on a Turkoman)

[frigid cloud]

Oof relatable

[latent plover]

A tiresome one

[hidden moss]

i got 25 golds, 45 more to go..

[frigid cloud]

Noice

I finished it in epilogue

[hidden moss]

need to do 2 more hunting requests and then ill get the 100% too..

its annoying, cuz the animals barely spawn

[faint thistle]

Oof, what animal you need?

May be able to lend a hand with all the memorized spawns stuck in my head

[frigid cloud]

I'll assume list 4 and 5

[hushed flare]

I found all the birds after woodpecker on accident looking for a robin

[faint thistle]

Oh, those fuckers

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[hushed flare]

I swear I find like 50000 perfect cardinals before a robin

[frigid cloud]

you know a bounty you do in that fort near van horn

That location should have some birds

[hushed flare]

I tried that spot

[frigid cloud]

How was it

[hushed flare]

It's where I found the robin but it took a few in-game days

[faint thistle]

Clemens point has toads

Its kind of like a private game reserve

[hushed flare]

I found every other bird except roboins at the fort

[frigid cloud]

Me going to new Austin to get a desert toad

Toads and bullfrogs are easy to find anyway

[faint thistle]

Which birds other than robins do you need?

Also, do the hunting challenges need to be done after unlocking or can you just turn in carcasses

[frigid cloud]

No you need to get the poster in valentine station

And you can only do them consecutively

[faint thistle]

So you cant just turn in a carcass in your satchel?

Oof

[frigid cloud]

Nope

[faint thistle]

Somedays I hate design rdr2 philosophy

[frigid cloud]

You need to have that list active for it

[faint thistle]

Even rdr1 let you do challenges out of order

[frigid cloud]

And you can only post it when you have all the animals you need

Unfortunately

[faint thistle]

I'll be honest

I'm 3 playthroughs in and just discovered the hunting requests an hour ago

[candid niche]

anyone know where to find sheep in the wild or are they like bulls were they are only at farms/ranchs?

[frigid cloud]

Emerald ranch

[faint thistle]

You can find em near rams and elk usually

But emerald ranch is by far the easiest

Also there's a farmer near the heartlands with a bunch of goats penned up

You dont lose honor gutting his private pen

[candid niche]

oh ok thanks

[faint thistle]

Np

Hunting challenge?

[candid niche]

no trapping

[faint thistle]

Oof

[frigid cloud]

It's easy to get perfect pelt anyway

Or hide whatever