red-dead-singleplayer

[ashen quarry]

HI

[hushed flare]

Causing massacres in valentine or saint denis👎 vs Causing massacres in annesburg

[opaque rampart]

how do you make NPC Wars

like in those videos

[hushed flare]

I think those are mods if I'm not wrong

[opaque aurora]

😩

[halcyon dove]

i find it funny how arthur is outraged by one dollar for whiskey, meanwhile he has about 900 dollars in his back pocket

[hidden moss]

Anybody got an account for rdr2, story mode

Willing to share

[vast elk]

?

Lol hes gone

[severe anvil]

how do i disable the compass

and uh where i dont have to press alt to be able to see the icons

nvm got it thanks anyway

[hidden moss]

@pastel creek u Norwegian?

[dusky cedar]

Dude

my message keeps being deleted

why cant you post spoilers

fine

!SPOILER ALERT!

is there any way I can get arthurs money as john?

[hidden moss]

Yes.

[dusky cedar]

how

[hidden moss]

Go to Aberdeen pig ranch

Then

talk with twins

sit with em

Drink that poison

and lose all ur money

[dusky cedar]

ok

[hidden moss]

but don't go to aberdeen ranch

After u done it

Come back as John

[dusky cedar]

but

[hidden moss]

and you'll see place is empty

Money don't disappear

[dusky cedar]

Im aleready in the epilouge

[hidden moss]

Rip then

[dusky cedar]

and I never went there as athur

[hidden moss]

Oof

Well

Finish american venom

[frigid cloud]

Do treasures

And american venom

[hearty ledge]

Why would you do that

[hidden moss]

If u want to keep Arthur's money for John

[hearty ledge]

You’ll get like 20 grand when you finish the epilogue

[hidden moss]

Some dude is asking how to keep Arthur's money for John.

I know u get 20k

Shit I know more stuff than u do at this point

Game burned me out

I'm still disappointed about RDR2 cut content

especially Real OG Epilogue John content.

[sick lintel]

I had 5 mil, went to Aberdeen before the last chapter 6 mission, played epilogue untilll part 2, came back and now John is the richest man in the west

[hidden moss]

Arthur Marston is rich

[sick lintel]

Yes

Well

I technical has

4.9 mil due to well

Guns

Ammo

[sick lintel]

Etc

[sick lintel]

Arthur and John was the richest boahs in the west

[hidden moss]

Who is John?

You're playing as Arthur Marston in epilogue

[sick lintel]

Yeah

[gritty hatch]

what y’all talking bout

[hidden moss]

Arthur Marston do be stealing Arthur Morgan's body though

[hidden moss]

Making fun on Epilogue John's look

[gritty hatch]

lol

[sick lintel]

I wish Arthur lived tbh

[gritty hatch]

[mighty pecan]

Said every rdr2 player to exist

[sick lintel]

Yes

Yknow what would make the best ending

[unborn iron]

Did molly snitched?

[sick lintel]

No

[unborn iron]

huh?

[sick lintel]

She was drunk asf and was mad

Bassicly

[unborn iron]

Why mad?

[sick lintel]

She was drunk and mad

Something about Dutch

[unborn iron]

Something?

[sick lintel]

It was Micah who rated

[gritty hatch]

Nice pfp

[unborn iron]

Huh

Excuse me

Micah rated?

wat

[sick lintel]

Micah ratted out the gang when they got back from the carribean

[unborn iron]

Nice banner

[sick lintel]

On the last mission

[gritty hatch]

thx

[sick lintel]

On the last mission Milton says that Micah ratted

[unborn iron]

Milton maybe lied

[sick lintel]

No

I’ve played the game 3 times fully

I know he didint

[unborn iron]

Me too nub
I'm on chapter 4 for the third time

[sick lintel]

Sad

Im in epilogue part 2

[unborn iron]

Yes

Cool

[hidden moss]

Not me

I just like to play as John

[sick lintel]

And John Is the richest bOaH with 4.9 mil

[mighty pecan]

I hate playing as John its so boring

[hidden moss]

Rockstar did John dirty tbh

[sick lintel]

How?

[mighty pecan]

If i wasnt doing 100% completion i would lose my mind

[hidden moss]

His epilogue look

also his writting in epilogue

Why the fuck Epilogue John's dialogues sounds like he learns how to speak new?

Or look like Arthur reskin.

[sick lintel]

Yknow what surprising

How Arthur and John survive so many fatal shots

Hell

[hidden moss]

Epilogue John's vomit

fucking has Arthur's vomit sound

[mighty pecan]

thats just rockstar being lazy tbh

[sick lintel]

John almost got shot in his heart in the last mission of chapter 6

[hidden moss]

Rockstar went full lazy on epilogue and John

John looks like Arthur 2.0

and written like shit

[sick lintel]

Arthur survives a shotgun shell TWICE in his left shoulder

It takes more the. 10 bullets to kill John

Etc

Like dead ass, in rdr 1

[mighty pecan]

I mean i dont wanna be one of those people who complain about the smallest thing in a game where the details are amazing but John is literally Arthur 2.0. EVERYTHING he does

[sick lintel]

John takes more then 19 shots before he dies

Hell even when he takes those shots

[hidden moss]

[sick lintel]

It takes him a little before he dies

[hidden moss]

John looks like Arthur 2.0

and doesn't act like real John

[sick lintel]

John and Arthur might was Brel be the 1800 version of super man

[hidden moss]

Some goofy arthur 2.0

[gritty hatch]

[sick lintel]

Everyone else and John to their male horse: your okay boy

[gritty hatch]

[sick lintel]

Arthur Morgan: YoUr OkAy BoAh

[gritty hatch]

I told Arthur Morgan to say

boi

[sick lintel]

Arthur Morgan in 2021: fucking god

arthue Morgan should’ve been dead a couple missions before the final chapter 6 mission

But he lives thanks to the German family

[gritty hatch]

cum

[unborn iron]

um

Wat?

bruh

[gritty hatch]

[sick lintel]

[unborn iron]

I think you bark rules

[gritty hatch]

no

what I do

:(

[unborn iron]

Stop barking

I will tell your owner

[gritty hatch]

???

[sick lintel]

Cat finna be shot

[gritty hatch]

Cat big sad

[sick lintel]

Micahs thoughts every time he sees Arthur

[gritty hatch]

jelly beans

[sick lintel]

S h o o t h I m

They did Arthur dirty tbh when he has low honor

[gritty hatch]

Click the emoji

j e l l y b e a n s

pls snipe

Dsng y’all don’t got dank memes

[sick lintel]

[gritty hatch]

gimme the cash

[sick lintel]

[gritty hatch]

[sick lintel]

no u

[gritty hatch]

a

[sick lintel]

[gritty hatch]

gimme gold bars

[sick lintel]

[gritty hatch]

Gimme cash

[sick lintel]

No

[gritty hatch]

yes

[sick lintel]

No

[gritty hatch]

Ima call backup

[sick lintel]

[gritty hatch]

The army

gimme

da

cash

[sick lintel]

[gritty hatch]

BoaH

Gimme the cash bOaH

[sick lintel]

[gritty hatch]

[sick lintel]

[golden vector]

[latent plover]

[fierce cave]

im in a cutscene and i just saw the stagecoach go at least 10 feet in the air while im just casually talking to john

[sick lintel]

Lol

Well I saw Pearson’s stew pot in the air before lol

[frigid cloud]

When Seamus makes money from cigarette cards

[hidden moss]

Does anyone know if the glided cage tuxedo glitch still work?

[trim scroll]

Is rdr1 worth it to play after RDR2? Just finished my first play through and I wanna know

I’ve never played rdr1

[summer loom]

bro, i’m doing the fishing mission with the veteran that lost his leg. This fish is impossible to catch 😭

[summer loom]

yes, very much worth it

[trim scroll]

Is this your first play through?

[summer loom]

no, just the first time doing the fish one

i figured it out tho, literally press the button once and as soon as you hook it it skips to the cut scene

[modern minnow]

agree

[frigid cloud]

No

[golden storm]

I bead red dead redemption!!!!!

[frigid cloud]

First game or second

[wraith panther]

True, but that‘s later

[golden storm]

second

[frigid cloud]

nice

[golden storm]

where is everyone else though

[frigid cloud]

Who?

[golden storm]

wait nvm they're in the credits

[plush warren]

i had the game and never started story 😎

[frigid cloud]

ok

[random plinth]

Heretic

[hidden moss]

Gambler challenge 8 is driving me crazy

[boreal goblet]

Which one is that?

[frigid cloud]

Hit 3 times and win against dealer 3 times

[mighty pecan]

Hello

[frigid cloud]

In blackjack

Hi

[sage falcon]

how come when i take a screenshot with windows key+prt sc it takes a screenshot of my character back in time like 10 minutes?

[latent plover]

It’s ridiculous that this is even a challenge

It’s so long

[frigid cloud]

And luck based

[mighty pecan]

Im stuck on it rn im dying

[hushed flare]

man

then get luckier ez

[mighty pecan]

slowly loads shotgun

[hushed flare]

Shoot it at the dealer not me

[mighty pecan]

[steady vector]

Trying to focus on the story in this game is impossible. I have to do every side activity/mission I see in case it’s gone later 😄

[mighty pecan]

ADHD be like

[hushed flare]

when your going to yellow D but then you see a white ? A mile away

[steady vector]

I’m already terrible at finding time for the story in open world games, and when the world is this good and as interactive as it is....

I’m 45% of the way through the story in 70 hours. Lol

[frigid cloud]

When you take 2 months to complete the story

[frigid cloud]

How many hours do you play per day

[mighty pecan]

hmm maybe like 9 or 10 depends on the day

[frigid cloud]

and still didn't get it?

[mighty pecan]

MAN SHUT UP ALREADY

[frigid cloud]

Woah that's mighty unlucky

[frigid cloud]

What lol

[mighty pecan]

[dusky hare]

That's the fun of it all. Just get lost in the game and the world itself.

Do what you want to do, when you want to....it's not a race, nor should you ever feel like it is. If you do, then you're only robbing yourself of the experience.

[loud plover]

Hello Boahs n Gurls

[frigid cloud]

Get lucky then

Are you playing blackjack 10 hours straight

[mighty pecan]

I will murder you with explosive rounds

[mighty pecan]

If i did that I’d have killed myself by now. No, i do maybe a couple or a few hours of it then i do other shit

[hushed flare]

I just commited to gambler 8 in van horn and I completed the entire challenge in 1-2 hours though it probably was just luck

[mighty pecan]

I’ve been doing it in Van horn the whole time not just because people say its best its so i can shoot up the whole town when i get mad

[frigid cloud]

Do it in blackwater

[mighty pecan]

yeah no thanks

[hushed flare]

Lmao

Usually my strategy is if I get a too high number or i lose i leave table and go back in instantly. Speeds it up but that's about it

[mighty pecan]

THEY TAKE FOREVER TO SET UP

[frigid cloud]

When gambler 4 doesn't include tumbleweed and blackwater

[mighty pecan]

or maybe im just impatient

[mighty pecan]

I barely ever go to tumbleweed ngl

[frigid cloud]

Sit in first place which is closest to the dealer so he gives you cards first and if you get high cards leave and rejoin

[mighty pecan]

yeah i do that but im still impatient

[frigid cloud]

It has poker

The saloon in tumbleweed

[mighty pecan]

I hate poker

[frigid cloud]

Meanwhile blackwater has both

Blackjack and poker

[mighty pecan]

I love blackjack but hate poker with a passion

but gambler 8 is kinda making me hate blackjack too

[frigid cloud]

Just go all in and skip

[mighty pecan]

I do that so much with John cause he has so much money

[frigid cloud]

Blackjack is simpler to me but a lot of rng is involved

[mighty pecan]

later skaters i gotta return to the real world

[frigid cloud]

Bye

[latent plover]

Why there instead of other locations?

[frigid cloud]

So he'd get a big bounty

[latent plover]

Oh right lol I thought blackwater had an advantage when playing blackjack

[frigid cloud]

Nah

But it's an alternative location that no one goes to I believe

[latent plover]

I prefer van horn

It’s cheaper there

I think blackwater is 10 cents buy in

I mean that’s the minimum you have to bet each time

I think

And for gambler 8 you probably go through about 10000 hands

[frigid cloud]

I like van horns dealer's accent

Blackwater also has dominoes only missing five finger fillet

[crimson bronze]

You're also forgetting the Rhodes Parlor House has Blackjack too

[frigid cloud]

Micah's outfit in online when

Me choking an Arthur morgan outfit player with it

[steady vector]

Man these horses go through hay fast

You’d think someone else could carry these hay bales over some of the time

[green pine]

lol

[golden storm]

how long does it take for lawmen to go away when you're in the red circle and they're searching

[frigid cloud]

Probably random, not sure

They could find you immediately or be blind all of a sudden and don't see you at all

[golden storm]

ok cool im hanging in the tumbleweed jail with a thousand dollar bounty waiting for the cops to leave so I can escape lol

[frigid cloud]

One time I escaped from blackwater and 1500$ bounty hiding in some tents and they didn't see me at all

[golden storm]

yeah they aren't seeing me at all

there's literally a pile of bodies I made (probably 50 something)

I saved before though so I won't have to pay the thousand

[summer loom]

bro, i hogtied an o driscoll, stowed him and rode into town. Just got a 10$ bounty for kidnapping, i thought you could turn in criminals?

[latent plover]

A long time

[frigid cloud]

They're not exactly criminals.

You can turn in random prisoners that asks for your help in freemode

[vestal sail]

Depends. If they find nothing (corpses, etc) then they will give up and leave fairly quick. However, if they were just chasing you, or if they were just called in to the area and the first thing they find is bodies, then it will take extremely long.

[latent plover]

^

[vestal sail]

Your role says you are on PC, you know there are mods that can fix that.

[hidden moss]

I'm already using mods 🤷‍♂️

I'm just making fun of Epilogue John lol

[frigid cloud]

Message could not be loaded

What is the message

[vestal sail]

He was talking about Epilogue John being a reskinned Arthur.

[sinful knot]

Yes it is

[frigid cloud]

He's right though

[vestal sail]

They have mods out there that fixes that issue.

[sturdy frost]

John Marston Restoration Project.

[sinful knot]

yea we know

[frigid cloud]

Yes I'm sure

[sturdy frost]

but i do have a question for y'all, doesn't matter if you're using PC or console but do you experience that your saved custom outfits doesn't save? I've had these problems recently. I'm on PC btw.

[hidden moss]

I had that bug

It's impossible to fix it

I think

There is no solution

[sturdy frost]

like, when i load into the game my saved custom outfits aren't in my wardrobe.

oh, okay.

[vestal sail]

Anyone see the mod that was just released that adds Mexico under New Austin on the map? It's a simple mod because it only edits map textures without actually editing the world itself.

[sturdy frost]

yeah, i think I'm gonna download it.

[vestal sail]

It looks awesome in game.

[sturdy frost]

really?

[vestal sail]

Yeah

I can't wait until a mod that adds a fully functional Mexico to the game is released.

[sturdy frost]

that would be awesome.

[boreal goblet]

If that mod gets made im buying it on pc

[vestal sail]

Separate bounty system, exclusive lawmen and civilian NPCs, activities and towns to visit.

[sturdy frost]

is it just me or should rockstar just make a remake on the first red dead redemption instead of GTA 6?

[vestal sail]

Yeah would be cool

[boreal goblet]

True

[sturdy frost]

i mean, i would love to play the first game on PC with new graphics etc.

[sinful knot]

you can use xenia to play it on PC without vsync

[sturdy kite]

How do I keep Micah's hat after stealing it

[sturdy frost]

you can't.

[sturdy frost]

how do i do it?

[sinful knot]

just search up how to download xenia

[sturdy frost]

i've never used xenia before so i don't know how it works.

okay.

[sturdy kite]

Yeah it doesn't let me save it

[sturdy frost]

well, john, you can't save it, you can't keep it.

[sturdy kite]

I wanted it for my Josey Wales outfit :(

Saf

Sad

[sturdy frost]

now that sucks but you could either get the legend of the east outfit or craft a big valley hat on the trapper shop.

[sturdy kite]

Is the big valley hat the same?

[sturdy frost]

i don't know the name though.

well, no, not exactly but it sure is similar to the one micah use.

[sturdy kite]

Yea

[sturdy frost]

@sinful knot when i open the program it says nothing, it's just a white screen if you know what i mean.

[sinful knot]

yes thats cause you need to download rdr1

[sturdy frost]

where do i download it?

[frigid cloud]

Legend of the east outfit hat is a similar to Micah's but it's not the same

[vestal sail]

I gave myself Micah's horse on my 100% save. I never ride Baylock but I like to pretend I took it from him along with his revolver after American Venom.

[sturdy kite]

How'd ya get it

[vestal sail]

Save editor.

[sturdy kite]

Oookay

[vestal sail]

I also gave myself Old Boy, I use him as my main horse.

[sturdy kite]

It's a PC thing right

[vestal sail]

You can get it on PS4 if you have Save Wizard + Save Editor.

[sturdy kite]

Save wizard?

[vestal sail]

It's paid software that decrypts save files so they can be modified in a save editor, then encrypts them back.

[sturdy kite]

Oh okay

[vestal sail]

Just put your safe file on a flash drive, put it in your PC, use save wizard to decrypt the file, modify it as you please with a save editor, then decrypt it back so you can actually use it on PS4.

Save wizard does cost $50 though, but there's no other way to actually decrypt/encrypt save files yet and there isn't a cracked version of save wizard out either.

[fierce cave]

I won the race against dutch back to camp but didnt go directly on the objective

[red helm]

The line on the road? That's just 'advice' the mission gives, you can ignore that.

[mighty pecan]

I shoved Dutch into bushes to get ahead as one should

[red helm]

He deserves it.

[mighty pecan]

^

[red helm]

Though, he isn't that difficult to win against, even with a mid-range horse.

[mighty pecan]

yeah the count be slackin

[frigid cloud]

Dude

I had every gold medal requirement completed in that mission

I fucking ran into a tree just on the last stretch

[red helm]

D'oh!

[mighty pecan]

HAHAHHA YOU FINALLY MADE A MISTAKE

HAHAHAHHA

GET REKT

NOOB

ME > YOU

[frigid cloud]

Not as bad as selling all cigarette cards to a fence

Noob

Me > you

[candid walrus]

[mighty pecan]

.

get out

[red helm]

Yeah, how can you not know you had to send the cards to that dude? Epically epic failage.

[mighty pecan]

A BLOG TOLD ME TO

[frigid cloud]

Noob

[mighty pecan]

shut

[red helm]

Oh! A blog told you. Well then....

[frigid cloud]

At least it was my own mistake

[mighty pecan]

noob

[frigid cloud]

Instead of some blog telling me to run into a tree on purpose

[red helm]

I'm going to write a blog, telling people to sale everything they own to fences.

[mighty pecan]

How about i tell you to run into a tree

[frigid cloud]

No

[mighty pecan]

yes

[frigid cloud]

Nah.

[mighty pecan]

yes

[frigid cloud]

No

[mighty pecan]

yes

[frigid cloud]

How about a blog tells you to sell all your cigarette cards to a fence

Oh right it did already. Lol

[red helm]

I'm going to assume the Blog said to send all the sets to the guy, and Then to sale the extra's to the fence, but you missed one of those steps....

But, anyway..... failage

[frigid cloud]

If he did big noob

Next time that blog will be telling him to kill 5 cougars but don't skin them

[red helm]

Perhaps.

[mighty pecan]

It said to go to saint denis for the cards and jog up to the fence down the street

[mighty pecan]

[red helm]

Huh, seriously, no step about actually mailing them?

[mighty pecan]

Nope. Found out by actually looking at the log

[frigid cloud]

Btw a tip for that cougar challenge hit them with poisoned arrows but when it falls down execute it next :troll:

[red helm]

wow, okay that blogger is a idiot then.

[mighty pecan]

Poison Arrow? Oh man i love that song

[mighty pecan]

Ikr

[frigid cloud]

Song? Wtf

[mighty pecan]

yeah its a really good song by ABC

[frigid cloud]

ok

Definitely not off topic

[mighty pecan]

[frigid cloud]

Heh

If you execute it with knife it doesn't count for the challenge that's why I told you to do it

[mighty pecan]

WHAT

WHY NOT

[red helm]

I wasn't going to say that.

[frigid cloud]

I'd feel bad tbh

Finding another 5 cougars again

[red helm]

Yeah, not mean at all.

[mighty pecan]

I spent 5k on the cards TWICE and it took 2 hours.

😐

[frigid cloud]

5k jesus

[red helm]

$5000?

[frigid cloud]

Max 1k for me

[mighty pecan]

yes

[frigid cloud]

Or 500$

[red helm]

Yeah, couple hundred...

[vestal sail]

If you have max honor it will cut that amount in half.

[mighty pecan]

ok

[frigid cloud]

Me with lowest honor

[vestal sail]

On my Arthur save I got all cards simply by robbing trains over and over again.

[red helm]

I got most of them from exploring, with Arthur, then at the end of Chapter 6, I got to Highest honor, bought up all the clothing, got all the cards and guns. Because I didn't know about the pig farm trick and messed that up. so whatever.

Was that or just throw like $12k in the campfire.

[frigid cloud]

I watched a sharpshooter challenges speedrun he used poisoned arrows to disarm 3 enemy

[red helm]

Ha, nice.

[frigid cloud]

Collecting cigarette cards gives great dead eye xp as well

[vestal sail]

It took a long time but my Chapter 2 Arthur save has 38k, with all clothing purchased and crafted, all guns bought and found (Using save editor I made every gun available to purchase at the start of Chapter 1 so I wouldn't have to wait to unlock them later).

[frigid cloud]

Impressive

[vestal sail]

Made all that money from robbing trains and valuables.

[red helm]

Cool, Yeah, I'm sure I could've had a lot more money, but I kind of didn't really care after awhile, since I was going to lose it all anyway.

I'm in the Epilogue now, I did all 3 of the endings I didn't see in my first play through.

[vestal sail]

Yeah if I ever care to progress that save I can always use the pig farm trick

I have all the point of interests sketched as Arthur, including ones in New Austin (used mod to disable invisible sniper). I also did dino bones as Arthur as well.

[frigid cloud]

How is farming simulator

My biggest wish in rdr2 is to do dino bones quest as Arthur

[red helm]

Stupid invisible sniper.

[frigid cloud]

I need to see dat cutscene myself

[red helm]

Feeding chickens and cleaning up the poo is the bestest part of the game.

[vast grotto]

just do NEW_AUSTIN_SNIPER=off

[vestal sail]

It's pretty cool to see Arthur instead.

[fierce cave]

Should i use the schofield or double action

[frigid cloud]

When a cowboy game goes to shit shovelling from robbing trains, gunslinging

[red helm]

Schofield

But, try out every weapon you find, and pick whatever you like best.

[vestal sail]

I use duel Cattlemans as Arthur, like in the promotional screechshots and trailer.

[latent plover]

Im sure there’s a vid of that

[frigid cloud]

Yes there is

[red helm]

A lot of this game is preference.

[frigid cloud]

Arthur stole John's pose in one of trailers or gameplay I forgot

[vestal sail]

Yeah

It showed him killing a wolf in that pose I think.

[frigid cloud]

John Jim.

[obsidian crown]

Does John keep Arthur's valuables in epilogue?

[frigid cloud]

I donttt think so

[red helm]

No, Only unique stuff.

[obsidian crown]

damn

[frigid cloud]

Treasure maps

For example

[obsidian crown]

Then what's the point of Arthur giving him the satchel

Ok well there is a point

[frigid cloud]

His journal

[obsidian crown]

Good point

Is the emerald a unique item?

[red helm]

Probably, I don't remember if I saw it in there or not.

[candid walrus]

You could say so. There is only one in the game. But it's worth $25 (or $50? idk) lmao.

[obsidian crown]

50$

[frigid cloud]

All meats, provisions definitely don't rot in 8 years

[obsidian crown]

Yep they do not rot at all

My keyboard hates me man

[red helm]

Mmm, 8 year old can's of peaches.

[candid walrus]

Mmm, delicious.

[frigid cloud]

Damn that was a fast edit

[obsidian crown]

Mmm, 8 year old assorted biscuits that aren't at all stale

Just like grandma used to make

[candid walrus]

lol

[frigid cloud]

If Arthur gave his satchel to john why he uses his own satchel

[obsidian crown]

Because unlike the meat of course the satchel rotted

[red helm]

Rockstar logic.

[wraith panther]

He didn't want a dead man's satchel

[frigid cloud]

Even more questionable, if you had lote satchel equipped does Arthur's reappear in the cutscene in final mission?

[wraith panther]

Final Mission of the game?

[frigid cloud]

No chapter 6

[wraith panther]

Ah ok

[obsidian crown]

Even more questionable, how does the satchel fit like 5 hats

And meats and a freaking METEOR PIECE

[candid walrus]

👀

[obsidian crown]

bigger than a woman's purse dude

[frigid cloud]

Don't his saddle bags do?

[red helm]

5 hats you question, but not 99 can's of beans?

[obsidian crown]

Normal satchel

[frigid cloud]

Arthur's satchel can keep literally anything

You'd think Arthur's satchel wouldn't keep legendary catfish

[shy mulch]

selective immersion

[frigid cloud]

Who else buys 99 hair tonic as soon as they get lote satchel

[shy mulch]

me, i need that max level beard boah

[frigid cloud]

Damn

I'm obsessed with Arthur & John facial hair level 10

Dude I'm still cowboy

Need to talk more

[red helm]

I've yet to bother going past 7 beard/hair...

[shy mulch]

did anyone ever try to go non violent in the story before realizing rockstar railroads u into killing

[frigid cloud]

Van horn fence trick

[shy mulch]

i rember at the ass end of chapter 2 I tried disarming the thugs holding john and strauss hostage lol

[red helm]

Some of the missions are way to difficult, Your allies are way to lame for that challenge. unfortunately.

[obsidian crown]

Especially sniper ones

[shy mulch]

Man I just try to clean up after my gang during killing spree sections

[red helm]

Your allies either don't survive long enough, or take way to long to actually kill all the enemies... etc, etc.

[shy mulch]

Like Micah taught me that missions can cost me a fat bounty

[halcyon dove]

oh oarthur

[frigid cloud]

Rdr2 pacifist when

[frigid cloud]

Bandit 5 moment

[shy mulch]

I would have rlly liked more pacifist shit it's so badass to just shoot guns out of folks hands

[red helm]

Plus, occasionally you 'Have to' kill someone.

[shy mulch]

or more nonlethal weapons

[frigid cloud]

Laramie gang leader

[red helm]

Fassar, and some others, yeah.

[frigid cloud]

Including Micah too

Saddest moment ever

[summer lily]

john and abigail so cute

[frigid cloud]

You could just shot Micah once and deactivate dead eye he still dies

[summer lily]

bro

do you like micah

[frigid cloud]

Anything wrong with that?

[summer lily]

it’s a valid opinion just not one i agree with

his character is amazing, because i hate him

if i hate a character it’s usually because their build of the character is amazing

and the voice acting etc

[frigid cloud]

He's a good guy, he stopped a bad gang that does bad things

Everyone should thank him instead

[hidden moss]

I never grew my beard as John or Arthur

Since i have mods

I keep my John at lvl 1 or lvl 2

since i have stubble mod

but for Arthur I always do lvl 2 beard

[red helm]

People are allowed to like villains.

[summer lily]

villains yes micah no

[summer lily]

well

arthur is a good guy in a bad situation

[frigid cloud]

He never was good

He killed and robbed a lot of people

Suddenly he changes after he learns hes dying

[summer lily]

He’s a good guy with a bad judgement

is dutch a good guy in your opinion?

[frigid cloud]

No

[summer lily]

atleast arthur changed in a good way

[frigid cloud]

I like everyone in gang

[round hedge]

good guy?

lmao

ruined families over loan sharks that he didn't need to accept

[summer lily]

yea a morally good person

[round hedge]

and shot a bunch of people

[summer lily]

he never wanted to do the loan sharks

he’s the only person who good do it

[round hedge]

then why did he do them without complaining?

[summer lily]

he did the right thing in HIS mind

[round hedge]

it's a whole gang, they could've done it for him

all it took was a no

[summer lily]

he literally said cant you do anyone else

[round hedge]

he's one of the gang leaders, why couldn't he ORDER it?

[jolly dragon]

I remember arthur complaining a couple times

[frigid cloud]

All chapter 2 debt missions includes beating up

[summer lily]

and strauss said, and i quote “They don’t have the same factor of fear you have” (not exactly word to word somet along those lines)

arthur did whats right to the people he knew

and he realised those people were bad people

[round hedge]

and that was ruining lives

[summer lily]

and then became ‘good’ in our eyes

but he did the right thing in his eyes

[round hedge]

for me he was always a piece of shit outlaw guy

and died like one

that's it

[slim mural]

he kicked strauss when he realized too

[summer lily]

That’s the great thing about arthur

you choose who you want him to be

[frigid cloud]

If you did bad deeds in 90% of your live then tried to be a good guy in 10% would you be considered a good guy?

[round hedge]

getting shot in the face by Micah

[summer lily]

he redeemed himself

[round hedge]

how so

[summer lily]

it really depends how you play as arthur

he legit (well i did) paid the debtors and absolved the debts

[round hedge]

how exactly is giving a bit of money for a family he made lose a husband/dad

[summer lily]

he paid the debtors what they owed

[round hedge]

and made the woman go into prostitution

so she could survive

[summer lily]

He didn’t make one of the families do that

[summer lily]

and he paid a price for that

[round hedge]

that's still not redeeming imo

that's just fixing 20% of the shit he made

[summer lily]

i never said that was redeeming it

i was gonna say everything he did in chapter 6 redeeming himself (other than if you did differently)

[round hedge]

cowboy jesus redeeming himself 😫 😫

[summer lily]

he is jesus

damn abigail when she realises the ring is used

[frigid cloud]

oh yeah let's beat him up and kill him then help his wife and kid

[summer lily]

he ain’t even know who’s it was

[summer lily]

didn’t mean to kill him and didn’t know he killed him, if he knew he killed him at the time he wouldn’t have paid them back

they only found out chapters after

[round hedge]

beating a sick guy who wouldn't fight back

[summer lily]

i didn’t beat him

[round hedge]

oh yeah definitely wouldn't have killed him

[summer lily]

i just threatened

the entire time

it worked

[round hedge]

and then he throws him into the fence

[summer lily]

bro he didn’t break his back on the fence

[round hedge]

the game canonically makes Arthur beat him

[frigid cloud]

Me shooting him in the face

[round hedge]

no matter the choice

[summer lily]

LOL

he didn’t beat him he threw him at a fence at most

and that wouldn’t have hurt him even if thomas had TB

[round hedge]

then why does Thomas have bruises in the cutscene huh

[frigid cloud]

But Strauss tells Arthur he's died

[slim mural]

strauss told him to beat some sense into the debtors when they don't pay their debt

[summer lily]

that’s if you decided to beat him

didn’t have bruises for me

[round hedge]

aka canon

[summer lily]

no you could just threaten the entire time

[round hedge]

beating still canon

[summer lily]

we are having an argument on wether or not a character is deemed a good person when you literally choose what you do as him

[summer lily]

not really if you don’t beat him

lol

[umbral zealot]

Hey so guys

I've been trying to catch this damn white Arabian by lake Isabella any tips?

[round hedge]

imagine wanting such a wacky horse

[frigid cloud]

Lasso it

Fr

[umbral zealot]

No I'm asking where to go

[frigid cloud]

Roam around and you'll find it eventually

I don't know exact

[summer lily]

doing american venom rn

[frigid cloud]

And you can't saddle up till you do the hunting mission with hosea @umbral zealot

[round hedge]

should've been as bland as Jack's revenge

rockstar retconning Micah for a revenge = bad plot

but makes the mission epic

[frigid cloud]

If john didn't go for revenge rdr1 would have never happened that's why he went for it

[umbral zealot]

Dude I'm in chapter 3

[frigid cloud]

ok then lasso it

[round hedge]

RDR didn't have a revenge and they still went after him

[frigid cloud]

And break it

[umbral zealot]

I just want a cool lookin horse

[round hedge]

so yeah

[umbral zealot]

What's best time of day?

So I can see in the mountains

[round hedge]

remember, Nate John's or whatever his name is didn't want any more outlaws in new austin

so the FBI went after them

[umbral zealot]

"Super agents"

[round hedge]

which never had Micah or any other character from RDR2

[frigid cloud]

If they were to remaster rdr would they change the story and update it as well as graphical update

[umbral zealot]

Can I track the horse down with my eagle eye?

[round hedge]

why would they change the story for retcons added in RDR2?

it's not RDR fault that the writers decided to put a shitload of characters lol

but having John get caught up because of his past is more appealing than revenge = bad IMO

gives more impact with his "people don't forget, nothing gets forgiven" phrase

[frigid cloud]

Ah yes true

Did Mr geddes secretly knew john and his family were in van der linde gang

[round hedge]

who?

oh, that fat guy

probably not

which doesn't make much sense since everyone knows Marston in RDR lol

[frigid cloud]

Dickens seems to know

But probably didn't tell anything to the boss

[round hedge]

Dickens only found John's excuses stupid

which makes me sad since RDR Marston would never give wacky excuses

[frigid cloud]

They wouldn't give him a chance if he told he used to be in van der linde gang probably

[lofty valve]

I only have $300 and I have a $160 bounty (first $75 because auto run is dumb and ran into a lawmen jail cart at the side of the road) and the rest from freeing Micah from the jail and killing half the town, should I pay it off rn? Or what should I do cause I don’t want half my money taken away right away

[round hedge]

no

[round hedge]

John in RDR was very clever and always had quick answers or insults for whatever question they had

I'm sure he'd have better things to say than what Rockstar decided him to be in epilogue

[lofty valve]

I shouldn’t pay at all?

[round hedge]

nope

[lofty valve]

Then what

Can’t even go places without getting killed now

[round hedge]

then waste your money

[lofty valve]

N getting money taken

[frigid cloud]

Go where

[round hedge]

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[lofty valve]

Certain areas where there’s red

[frigid cloud]

Where are you trying to go for what

[lofty valve]

I had something in black water and the river/border that separates newhanov and the place where strawberry is

since I just freed Micah from jail

[frigid cloud]

Do you have that mission where you save sean

[lofty valve]

Nah I’m still new into the game I just freed Micah

[frigid cloud]

huh

[lofty valve]

I just freed Micah from getting lynched in strawberry

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[candid walrus]

Nice

[round hedge]

now you just got the impossible to remove offhand holster

hope you have a PC

[lofty valve]

lmao console

[round hedge]

yep you're fucked

[lofty valve]

how come

[round hedge]

you'll never be able to remove that ugly holster

hope you don't mind your coat constantly clipping with the satchel lol

[lofty valve]

lmao

[frigid cloud]

What happens if you swap the holster with challenge ones

[lofty valve]

I’ll get used to it

Anyways

basically don’t pay for bounty no matter what right

[round hedge]

wait until chapter 3

[lofty valve]

cause these mfs won’t even let me travel without tryna kill me

Okay

[round hedge]

you'll get like

3k from a robbery

[lofty valve]

I only have $300 when tf am I gotta get more money

[frigid cloud]

3000$

[round hedge]

gold bars too

[frigid cloud]

Get the gold bar in limpany it should help early on

[round hedge]

there's one next to the camp

[lofty valve]

I have the

Javier escuella shit in black water

But If I go there mfs gonna try to kill be

[lofty valve]

Where

[round hedge]

YouTube

[latent plover]

YouTube

[lofty valve]

Okay

[frigid cloud]

YouTube

Damn i missed it

[lofty valve]

imma try going back to the camp but I’ll probably get killed before I get there lmao

[frigid cloud]

Try to go to that mission from bard's crossing instead of from blackwater

[lofty valve]

nvm I can cross the red border without getting a wanted level and 10 people after me right away

that’s what happened last time n mfs took another $20 from me smh

was it worth it that I got the ultimate version of the game I mean it was for $35

[round hedge]

if it was for 35 dollars then yes

if it was extra 35

then no

ultimate edition is garbage

[frigid cloud]

I think I got it when it was 66% off

[hidden moss]

Except for that sexy black hunting jacket

[round hedge]

exactly

[hushed flare]

Black classic frock coat better

[round hedge]

all coats suck in the game

[lofty valve]

I got it for 65% off

[round hedge]

imagine having 7 coats for sale only

[hidden moss]

Story mode lacks clothing

[round hedge]

even GTA V had more 🗿

[hidden moss]

They also didn't make clothing and looks seperate for John and Arthur too

[round hedge]

GTA V had better customization than RDR2 for protagonists lol

[hidden moss]

Not even hairstyle option for John exclusive

[lofty valve]

Bruh i accidentally took out my gun in the sherif n them mfs told me to leave then I diffused it n then left and I really got a $5 bounty 😑 why is this game so damn annoying

I diffused and left and I get bounty and arrested lmao

[round hedge]

get used to it, the wanted system sucks

[shy mulch]

i keep seeing red scarfs in sp is that like an item from one of the fences like i keep hearing

[frigid cloud]

Fr I don't like any coats

[lofty valve]

Lmao

[round hedge]

one of the downgrades compared to RDR lol

[hidden moss]

No

[shy mulch]

lame

[round hedge]

it's from a mod

[shy mulch]

not lame

[round hedge]

Hosea's scarf

[shy mulch]

🏃‍♂️

[hidden moss]

Dort is probably pc user

[shy mulch]

oh i suppose i should add that as a role

[round hedge]

not sure which mod, but should be NPC clothing

or any other clothing that has npc outfits

[hidden moss]

Yeah it is npc clothing

[round hedge]

clothing mod*

[hidden moss]

Npc clothing adds npc clothes

[round hedge]

no shit

[hidden moss]

Most of em works well for John and Arthur

[shy mulch]

bout to make arthur look fresh

[hidden moss]

So Rockstar went too lazy on clothing options for John and Arthur

[round hedge]

JMRP has the purple CP 1 scarf

[hidden moss]

and mods proves it

[lofty valve]

bruh do I lose my bounty hunter shit because I got arrested by the sheriff

[round hedge]

no, you lose your money

[lofty valve]

I go back into the sherif and they told me to leave

I lost $4 and then I can’t see the bounty hunter shit anymore

And mfs presses me to leave

[hidden moss]

There is a glitch to get arrested and serve your time without losing any money

[round hedge]

then that's a W

[shy mulch]

R is honestly tripping for gating off mods so much folks have to do so much work just to make em work in game compared to something like Skyrim or TW3 which have ridiculous amounts of mods all for specific shit

honestly cant wait for someone to fix clipping issues on clothes

[hushed flare]

Wish we had mods on console

[shy mulch]

ie. hunting jacket tassles

[hushed flare]

I literally want a PC just so I can mod

[hidden moss]

Imagine if JMRP was a mod for consoles too 😳

[hushed flare]

it should xd

[shy mulch]

well wait a bit longer pardner maybe GPU stock will get better in 2022

[hidden moss]

JMRP and Rockstar reverting John to 1.00 version

then everyone wouldn't mind John

[round hedge]

1.00 version is pretty yikes tho

[frigid cloud]

Maybe 1.00 version is close to modding

For console

[hidden moss]

Nah

Save wizard or save editing

[round hedge]

nah 1.00 john is pretty bad

[hidden moss]

is close to modding for ps4

[round hedge]

it's Arthur Marston still

[hidden moss]

Still decent than current version

[frigid cloud]

I meant free

[lofty valve]

When do you actually start getting proper money in RDR2

[frigid cloud]

I want 1.00 so I can go into new Austin as arthur even though there's nothing to do and infinite gold bar

[lofty valve]

I only have $300 lmao

[round hedge]

chapter 3 i think

[frigid cloud]

End of chapter 2

[lofty valve]

Seems far asf

[round hedge]

you can grind gold bars too

[lofty valve]

How long does it take to get to chapter 3

[frigid cloud]

Chapter 2 is long

[lofty valve]

Well fuck

How i check what chapter I’m on

[frigid cloud]

Progress

Story

[lofty valve]

Okay

[shy mulch]

you should clean up the ch 2 side quests then move on to main quests

[lofty valve]

I’m on chapter 2

[round hedge]

oh btw @lofty valve

[lofty valve]

Yes

[round hedge]

there are 2 missable clothing in chapter 2

an ugly ass denim scout Jacket

and spurs

[hidden moss]

and spurs?

Nah,

[lofty valve]

What are spurs

[round hedge]

if you want to get them

[hidden moss]

U can actually get spurs at chp3 too

[shy mulch]

you mean the dutch spurs

[frigid cloud]

Spurs doable in 3 as well

[round hedge]

yeah

[round hedge]

ah nice

[shy mulch]

yea you can

[lofty valve]

what’s Dutch Spurs

[mighty pecan]

hello

[shy mulch]

uhhh vaquero rider or smth

I forgot what fetch quest it was

[frigid cloud]

Hello average person that sells cig- I mean hi welcome

[mighty pecan]

so original as always

[round hedge]

bruh

imagine not enabling links

[lofty valve]

clothing is important? Other than hot/cold clothes

[round hedge]

no

but in case you want it lol

[shy mulch]

temps are weird most of the time

[frigid cloud]

Strawberry is cold apparently

[lofty valve]

I have the ultimate edition so it gave some clothes

[shy mulch]

the regions you expect to be cold can be over 70c

[lofty valve]

Yea it is

[shy mulch]

aka annesburg and van horn

[round hedge]

ngl

it's realistic

but i hate the temperature system

[frigid cloud]

I guess it's close to a mountain so fair enough

[round hedge]

along the weight

[shy mulch]

i suppose

[frigid cloud]

How to gain weight so quickly

[round hedge]

I'd easily disable both

[shy mulch]

thing is i never rlly have to take off winter clothes that much

[round hedge]

eat a meal in saloon, drink, eat a meal, drink, eat

[frigid cloud]

I imagine having 99 big game meat then doing van horn fence trick

[shy mulch]

maybe it's bc my cores are always golden or that the temps never get that hot or cold unless i'm in the deep grizzlies lmao

[hidden moss]

Rockstar is weird with their decision sometimes

If u just decide to take a look cut content

you'll start to think this game is in half development.

[frigid cloud]

Is there any chance to see the cut content for rdr1

[hidden moss]

Well sorta

It's hard as fuck though

Idk how u can check cut content for rdr1

[frigid cloud]

Maybe another reason why they don't release it on pc

[hidden moss]

RDR1 coding was spaghetti

And his child RDR2 is spaghetti in codes and files too.

[worn sentinel]

Anyone think Arthur and Sadie’s interactions with one another is just hilarious

[hushed flare]

no

[frigid cloud]

Wut

[hushed flare]

interacting with Micah is hilarious tho

[frigid cloud]

Cowpoke.

[hushed flare]

Yes

[mighty pecan]

Interacting with Sean was hilarious for me as an irish person

[hushed flare]

it's colom o driscoll

[mighty pecan]

‘Colom’

[frigid cloud]

He's right actually

[hushed flare]

Colem o dirscoll

[frigid cloud]

O'Driscolls pronounce it that way

[hushed flare]

Dirscoll

[shy mulch]

mrs. assler

[worn sentinel]

“God damn sons of bitches” hilarious line from Micah

[mighty pecan]

I mean the entirety of the gang seems to be from North Dublin only

[worn sentinel]

Lenny and Arthur are like brothers in some ways

[frigid cloud]

O'Driscolls have an intense irish accent in freemode but in missions they're so normal

[worn sentinel]

Yea there kind of a weak gang

With a dry ass personality

[mighty pecan]

😐

[worn sentinel]

What?

IMO from my experience

[mighty pecan]

😐

[frigid cloud]

When you get the item Sean wanted in chapter 2 but it's chapter 4

And they meet up in hell again hey Arter can I have my Kentucky bourbon

[rugged parrot]

Jesus Christ, this game is literally just walking simulator

[hidden moss]

You and I experience the game very different😄

[rugged parrot]

It's so boring being forced to walk forced to go a certain pace for the first hour of the game

Is the whole game like this? I almost fell asleep walking down the hill to the bandit camp on one of the first missions

If so I'm not interested

@hidden moss j don't play fortnite and I never will

[hidden moss]

Wha… you got impatient with that little walk?

[rugged parrot]

I haven't played cod for months

[hidden moss]

Ye, RDR2 is pretty slow ig, I mean story can be rushed, but it’s supposed to be taken slow imo

[rugged parrot]

I play sea of thieves, cyberpunk, and battlefield 4

[frigid cloud]

Has cyberpunk improved any bit

[rugged parrot]

Well they've done literally hundreds of bug fixes

[hidden moss]

Isn’t cyberpunk?

[rugged parrot]

If you think cyberpunk isn't story based you're delusional

[round hedge]

no

[round hedge]

the first chapter is insanely boring

can't blame you for that

[frigid cloud]

Arthur:M'lady
Sadie:what is this shit

Very hilarious

[rugged parrot]

I don't get what those games not being story based has to do with anything anyway, I'm just saying, the first part of the game is extremely boring

[rugged parrot]

Agreed

[round hedge]

it's the main part why i never replay

[frigid cloud]

Lol same

[round hedge]

and chapter 2 being the second reason

[hidden moss]

Lmao I honestly love it. Riding with dutch & the gang, hunting with charles

[round hedge]

since i already know the missions and still find the boring

[hidden moss]

It’s great

[rugged parrot]

There was nothing interesting that happened so far and I'm at the part where you go hunting

[round hedge]

just hearing about it makes me want to sleep

[lofty valve]

Bruh they needa have an option to let Jamie shoot himself I accidentally shot him for the 2nd time lmao

[frigid cloud]

Nah boring shit

[round hedge]

i'd even say RDR2 first missions are more boring than RDR

[hushed flare]

Let Jamie shoot himself

[hidden moss]

Ig I like slow games, I usually don’t go full speed with horse either, just slowly getting to where I wanna go

[round hedge]

RDR2 is way too much slow

[frigid cloud]

That long ride to horseshoe overlook and your speed is capped