red-dead-singleplayer

[golden storm]

I believe it will

in like 10 15 years

I would like to see dutchs past

[round hedge]

RDR1 is a good western game

RDR2 might be more realistic but it's definitely focused in the east part

[golden storm]

why is epilouge jack so depressed lol

he's the worst

[vestal sail]

They actually had cars in RDR1. In the intro you see one being lifted via crane into Blackwater, and later in the game the feds use them. RDR1 took place in 1911 so it's not exactly a far fetched idea to have them in RDR2.

[narrow jetty]

one of the only thing I think RDR1 did better than RDR2 is John's ride to mexico compared to Arthurs ride back from Guarma

I just think Far Away is a much better song than Unshaken

they said "epilogue jack"

I think that means RDR2 epilogue

[frigid cloud]

Rdr1 doesn't have epilogue?

[narrow jetty]

Not formally

wait have you finished it

I haven't but I've watched multiple so I might as well have lol

I just entered mexico

[frigid cloud]

I've watched it but can't play on my own

[frigid cloud]

What can you do as arthur in new austin

[hidden moss]

You can get sniped

[frigid cloud]

ok

I know you do get sniped but what could you do if you were able to freeroam freely

[hidden moss]

If you cross the border from West Elizabeth to New Austin, you immediately get killtriggered and if you make it past that there is a sniper

Are you through with the story?

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[hidden moss]

So you know you turn to Johnboy in the epilouge

[frigid cloud]

I know you can go there freely as john

[hidden moss]

SO

So

sry

didnt mean for the caps

You could do exactly what John can do but you get sniped immediately

[frigid cloud]

I'm asking what could you do as arthur if you were able to freeroam

[hidden moss]

.

[frigid cloud]

I know.

As of activities

[hidden moss]

there you go

[vast grotto]

use mods to become god and find out for yourself

or just disable the NA sniper with it

[frigid cloud]

Are there any rare hats

[hidden moss]

I mean IF the sniper would be turned off, you probably still couldn't talk to the free roam event NPCs bcs the right voice lines just dont exist

I dont think so

OH

yes

the bolero hat

which is like a sombero

[vast grotto]

arthur still has unique drawings of the POI's in new austin so there's that

[frigid cloud]

Collecting all 30 dinosaur bones and completing the mission is also interesting

[round hedge]

nothing

new austin is empty

it'd been better if they didn't add it to the game honestly, it feels so rushed

[red helm]

I think they should've closed the map off from the river just south of Beecher's Hope.

[round hedge]

great plains was enough tbh

[red helm]

Had Tall Tree's, and the Black Water Regions be the Southern most border.

[round hedge]

should've just been the great plains part

and that's it

since john never goes to new austin

doesn't make sense for it to be in the main game

[red helm]

There is some stuff to do there, But, it's just not 'Canon' for him to go there, since in RDR1 he talks about never being there.

[frigid cloud]

If you kill del lobos outside of flaco Hernandezs cabin does that count as new gang del lobos discovered

[worthy pelican]

Could anybody help me with issues I've been having?

[frigid cloud]

From long distance maybe

[frigid cloud]

What is it?

[worthy pelican]

EVerytime I hop on I get Error FFFF and I have no idea how to fix it

I've looked at so many sites

[frigid cloud]

Online?

[worthy pelican]

and I have no idea

SIngle player

[frigid cloud]

Huh

Weird

[worthy pelican]

I can't even get on at all

[frigid cloud]

Sadly I don't know

Sorry

[worthy pelican]

Alright

[olive mango]

I just finished the first fishing mission. I saw there was a baitshop near Lemoyne. Do I always have basic bait and I need to buy better bait for bigger fish? I would eventually find out but just looking to get a quick answer

[frigid cloud]

Yes

Swamp, lake, river lures should work for fairly large fishes

[red helm]

You'll want the special lures for the Legendary fish. Lagras has the good Fishing shop.

[frigid cloud]

buy every bait and lure

[brisk arrow]

IM SO SAD NOW

[frigid cloud]

Me catching the legendary bluegill with Kieran for unique dialogue

[brisk arrow]

IM FINNA CRY

[frigid cloud]

y

[brisk arrow]

HAVE YOU FINISHED THE STORY

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[brisk arrow]

JUST WATCHED SEAN GET HIS FACE BLOWN IN

[frigid cloud]

Ouch

[mellow dawn]

Guys I had a problem with cigarette stamps, I have 144 in the compendium, but when I go to deliver them I only see 9 collections, instead of 12. Do you know what I can do or does not affect? (I received the reward but what I want is 100%)

[brisk arrow]

it was so unexpected

[mellow dawn]

help :(

[brisk arrow]

He was like "what is there to suspect"and BAM

[frigid cloud]

You're probably missing a few cards

Check from your satchel

[mellow dawn]

I have everything

[frigid cloud]

In your progress menu does it say cigarette cards are completed?

[mellow dawn]

Yes, 144/144
But in the task menu it appears that it delivers only 9/12 collections

[red helm]

Did you maybe accidently sale some to the Fence at some point?

Because the 144/144 is just all time, so...

[frigid cloud]

Jeez I really mistyped cards lol

[frigid cloud]

Isn't it 144/144 when you collect them all once?

[red helm]

Oh, right, yeah, I was thinking when viewing in the Compendium...

[hidden moss]

How can I be good again in Red Dead 2? so do good deeds.

[hushed flare]

Mailing all 144 cards vs Selling all 144 cards to fence

.

[barren comet]

if your arthur do camp jobs

[hidden moss]

" If your Arthur " can I also be someone else ?

[frigid cloud]

Uh

[frigid cloud]

Spoilers so I wouldn't question any further

But for high honor, greet, do camp chores

[hidden moss]

You indeed said yes xD but thanks for the help. Appreciate it!

[frigid cloud]

First time playing?

[hidden moss]

Yes I'm at Chapter 2

[frigid cloud]

ah well you're guaranteed to get spoiled here

[hidden moss]

That's not a big problem for me. Sometimes I spoiler my self too. I don't know why I just can't wait

[frigid cloud]

Ok good

[hidden moss]

Are all the Yellow points story missions?

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[hidden moss]

On the map

[frigid cloud]

White missions are side missions

That isn't required to continue the story

[hidden moss]

Sus

Alright

[frigid cloud]

But there's a few that's related to Arthur so they're not all stranger mission

[hidden moss]

Okay thanks

[mighty pecan]

SHUT UP IT WAS ONE TIME

[hushed flare]

I wouldn't be surprised if you didn't again

Next you sell all the orchids and exotic plumes to trapper instead of giving it to algernon

[mighty pecan]

LEAVE ME ALONE

[hushed flare]

jeez

[frigid cloud]

When rockstar includes online trophies for platinum trophy

[mighty pecan]

FR ITS SO ANNOYING

[hushed flare]

reach level 50 while trying not to die from boredom

[frigid cloud]

fr

Be mvp 3 times is the most annoying probably

And level 50

[hidden moss]

No way I surrendered and had to pay $ 400

[worldly bobcat]

What’s the hired gun kit?

[frigid cloud]

#rdo-chat

They really need to separate online trophies from sp trophies and platinum

[mighty pecan]

^

[slim mural]

scamazed lmfao

[frigid cloud]

Never surrender

[round hedge]

lmao

[hidden moss]

Nvm i just robbed the bank in valentine and got 2,900.

[severe anvil]

whats the difference between the bar outside the health and energy and the one inside

[worldly turret]

inside is core, that drains over time and sorta acts like your stomach, heart and brain since food help keeps those full, outside is general health/stamina and such

[sturdy kite]

Actually you can get it from uhhhh Micah mission

[sturdy kite]

How is it a story mode mission orrr

[hidden moss]

Yes

You steal the gold and yeah that's it

[sturdy kite]

What chapter

[vagrant temple]

Core is how fast you regenerate health. Outside ring is how much health you have.

[hidden moss]

2

Chapter 2

[covert lintel]

This game is gorgeous

[hidden moss]

Yes Read dead is a beautiful and brutal game @covert lintel

How i like it

And the graphics are amazing

[dawn geyser]

And the Gore too

[hidden moss]

Yes

Yes yes

[hushed flare]

I liked the game so much I 100% it

[main coral]

artur morhan

[sharp gulch]

guys help everyone still tells me to come looking for jack even though i already got him back rockstar please fix your game

[hidden moss]

same, instead of everyone telling me to wear warmer clothes, now its just everyone telling me to find jack...

[sharp gulch]

you'd think they'd remember after having that big party but apparently all that alcohol made them forget jack is here

[hidden moss]

mfw jack

[sturdy kite]

Guys what's the max weight you can get?

For horses

[cyan cipher]

it might be the same as your character can get

idk i always let my horse starve lol

[sturdy kite]

Just buy tons of food and feed him every 20 mins

It'll really change your horse experience

Trust me

Thing is i have the black shire and i want to see it overweight

So he's a tank

Buttt

[cyan cipher]

imagine obese white arabian

[sturdy kite]

Imagine obese black shire, he'll be fucking huge

[cyan cipher]

i never really rode shires other than when i stole them in a desperate getaway

i think i might buy one next time i play though

[sharp gulch]

why

[sturdy kite]

.

[sharp gulch]

how so

[sturdy kite]

Faster horse

Better stamina

[sharp gulch]

you can upgrade your horse?

all food seems to do is fill the cores

cause the cores are always full anyway

[sharp gulch]

pls just tell me how i get a faster horse by feeding it when all it does is fill the cores

[hidden moss]

just get lvl 4 bonding

don't even have to feed the horse after that

[sharp gulch]

probably one of these guys who drain their horses stamina core by riding too long with empty horse stamina

[hidden moss]

nah, what i meant was u could pat the horse while riding which refills the stamina bar..

i dont think that reduces core, i might be wrong..

[sharp gulch]

i wasnt talking about you

[hidden moss]

oh ok my bad..

[sharp gulch]

it's all good, calm down

[hidden moss]

got the black arabian from saint denis yesterday, its available during that random encounter..

where the couple gets robbed and the woman gets shot

[sharp gulch]

not sure i encountered that

i think that's part of the beauty of this game that no two people have the same playthrough

[severe anvil]

should i hogtie a random prisoner encounter or something

[sturdy kite]

bruh

[sturdy kite]

I meant this

You run faster And lose less stamina

I was just trying to be nice

[sharp gulch]

yeah but this is just a basic mechanic of the game

not really a secret

[sturdy kite]

Then why did you ask me to explain it to you...?

[sharp gulch]

i just wasn't sure if that's what you meant

[severe anvil]

if you sell all of your pocket watches will you not be able to tell the time anymore

[slim mural]

u can

[severe anvil]

ah ok thanks

[hidden moss]

it happens at midnight, around 12am-2 am, two common spots for the encounter is near the mayor's house and near the church

[main coral]

dutct vanderikde

[sharp gulch]

does your arthur actually have good weight? my arthur is always underweight

[severe anvil]

can you sell weapons in stores

[sharp gulch]

no

not to my knowledge

[hidden moss]

mine has average, once i got him to perfect weight

then it was always average

[little roost]

it's difficult to keep at perfect weight so I just kinda try to keep it at average

[sharp gulch]

i can't really be bothered to eat enough as arthur

it doesn't really do much

[cyan cipher]

got a point

all the weight system does is change core stuff

but other than that it does nothing except visuals

[hidden moss]

is there a difference in the stamina ?

[main coral]

teburclosis

[cyan cipher]

if youre underweight* it makes your health decrease faster and your stamina decrease slower

and vice versa

also yes sickness does affect cores but thats disabled in* epilogue

[rain ridge]

No puedo hablar inglés i have lumbago 😡

[main coral]

no puedes hablar ingels yo tampoco becuase I have teburclosis l

[versed barn]

I have both

[main coral]

its him

lumbago

leave uncle alone

[rain ridge]

@main coral dont worry i have a plan…. Lets go to TAHITI

[main coral]

oh man I'm ready to become a mango farmer

[versed barn]

Only food source in tahiti

[main coral]

we got Pearson

[versed barn]

Nvm

Lol

Arthur coughed all over me that's how I got tuberculosis

[main coral]

I actually just stared another play through and I'm about to go collect debt from downs

[severe anvil]

is it possible to eat multiple foods at the same time

[main coral]

if you can fit it all in your mouth then sure

[versed barn]

[main coral]

[versed barn]

I never go to camp so he should be dead homefully

Hopefully*

[rain ridge]

I fucking said I HAVE A FUCKING PLAN

[versed barn]

Leaves

[rain ridge]

😡

[main coral]

have you completely lost faith in me Arthur

[rain ridge]

Only i need money

[versed barn]

I completed story 2 times

[rain ridge]

To T A H I T I

[main coral]

I just stared my second playthrough

[versed barn]

That's all I hear from dutch

We need more money
I got a plan

[rain ridge]

I would have completed it if my progress has not been erased

[versed barn]

Rip

[rain ridge]

[versed barn]

I had a year between both play throughs

[main coral]

spoiler Arthur and dutch kiss amd uncle marries Jack

[severe anvil]

is there a way to manually check your honor meter/bar

[versed barn]

Down on dpad if on console

[severe anvil]

pc?

[versed barn]

?

[severe anvil]

ah wait ok

[rain ridge]

But i had a plan i use tricks and glitches to return my progress

[main coral]

or just cut the story short and marry dutch

[rain ridge]

I cant Susan kill Molly but…. If…. I got a plan why we don’t open a portal to the underworld and bring a talisman capable of reviving the dead?

[main coral]

kill Susan

[rain ridge]

Susan is already dead. Micah killed her

[main coral]

oh yeah

[hushed flare]

oh yeah

[main coral]

dknt mind if I do

[hushed flare]

[main coral]

[rain ridge]

What do you want im planning 😡

[main coral]

maybe lose ditch in the heist aswell

[frigid cloud]

Rdr2's loading is definitely faster though on console compared to GTA v on PS4

[severe anvil]

can you sell worn out weapons

[tawdry moon]

no

[vagrant temple]

You can just clean them?

[frigid cloud]

No you can't

It says this gun is worn and can't be cleaned any further

[boreal goblet]

So what happens if you kill a legendary animal, then die before you skin it?

Cause I just got killed by a cougar before I could skin it

Never mind

It stayed where I killed it

[hidden moss]

after chapter 6, what happens next??

[frigid cloud]

Chapter 7

[hidden moss]

how many chapters?

[frigid cloud]

No I'm just jk after chapter 6 epilogue comes

Epilogue has 2 parts

[hidden moss]

thanks

[frigid cloud]

No problem

[random plinth]

How hard is zoologist

Hmm , flirting with getting rdr platinum

Nah ,I am console peasant

Plus mods bad

Maybe

[hidden moss]

Mods are good.

A mod that fixes epilogue John

A mod that adds online content to story mode

a mod that adds more activity

a mod that adds npc clothes for Arthur/John

facts

[red pond]

what is the best revolver of the game in your opinion ?

[hidden moss]

Navy Revolver or Lemat for me

[red pond]

Said that because i just realized that i always use the same revolver with ace engraved on it..

[frigid cloud]

It isn't.

[red pond]

Can i find Navy on gunstore ?

[frigid cloud]

You just study every animal

Except parakeet and Guarma animals

[frigid cloud]

No it's not in sp

[hidden moss]

i think online

Oh man John with mods looks awesome

I wish Rockstar at least kept Epilogue John at 1.00

[red pond]

Ah ok, i never play online

[hidden moss]

Shame Rockstar downgraded his 1.00 look

i use the disc so still got 1.00 john..

his eyes aren't robotic either.. looks natural

[frigid cloud]

Lucky

I had digital

[hidden moss]

Smaller gloves and pants

[frigid cloud]

So can't downgrade

[hidden moss]

his npc facial hair

[hidden moss]

yep that too

His shoulders look closer to npc

in 1.00

Also his npc facial hair or dark mustache

only issue with 1.00 is that my john sometimes has arthur's tb body..

like he becomes extremely underweight

Yeah that sucks

but I think save and reload fixes the issue

Also in 1.00

When John wears his cowboy outfit

There isn't any blur

unlike in later updates

[frigid cloud]

What are other benefits for playing on 1.00

[hidden moss]

Better ambient occlusion, no blur, Useful bugs like St denis horse and Going to new austin as Arthur

Unlimited gold bar

Saddles don't teleport to rooftop at beecher's hope

also faster loading

Better graphics, more lively towns, camp requests work properly

[frigid cloud]

And

[hidden moss]

beard grows properly

U can reach to lvl 10 beard as John in 1.00

the Valentine General Store still has the 3 laterns on at night which are off in the latest patch. Also the lighting seems a bit better but I might be wrong on this one.

[frigid cloud]

now it only gets to 7 without tonics

[hidden moss]

yea

Also beard quality looks better on 1.00

[frigid cloud]

Is it also longer on 1.00

[hidden moss]

I think so

[frigid cloud]

Latest patch seems a bit shorter

[hidden moss]

I think they are same

It just u can reach to lvl 10 as John

and beard and hair grows properly

[random plinth]

@red pond you can't get the navy on single player, but you can get le mat, fun weapon

Epilogue John is sloppy made,compared to rdr1 and rdr2 pre epilogue

[hidden moss]

then they decide to downgrade him

with updates

[random plinth]

They just changed skins and voice on Arthur

"no one is going to know"
"How are they gonna know"

[hidden moss]

They did even give Arthur's vomit sound to John

lmao

[random plinth]

😂

[hidden moss]

yea, thats sad..

boah didn't even get his own vomit sound

So much for Rockstar's love for John lol

[manic marlin]

We all know arthur and john are the same guy smh

[random plinth]

Mark my words

Maybe in 10 years from now when rdr3 releases

[hidden moss]

Arthur will look like main protagonist

in epilogue

[manic marlin]

rdr3 will be about jack hitting puberty

[random plinth]

They gonna remaster both 1 & 2 and slap the trilogy in the then current graphics

Rdr 3 ain't about Jack

He won't even exist

[manic marlin]

it might be

[random plinth]

Rdr is a game about the wild west

[manic marlin]

do you know what jack does after the events of rdr1?

[random plinth]

What exactly are we gonna do with Jack in 1920?go to WW1 or meet the Mafia

[hidden moss]

became a writer or died in ww1

[hidden moss]

yea

[manic marlin]

He either became a writer, or sold his likeness to a writer

[random plinth]

Rdr 3 is going to be the glory days of the gang ,
Rdr 2 is the decay and rdr1 is the death of it

[manic marlin]

In Franklins house in gta there is a book titled "Red Dead Redemption" and it's written by Jack M.

[random plinth]

Food for thought

[manic marlin]

interesting idea

[summer lily]

doing bad actions as arthur doesn’t feel right

[random plinth]

Same

[summer lily]

imagine red dead 3 is before red dead 2 and the final mission is the blackwater ferry job

[random plinth]

Payed it twice , both times I finished high honor.
Although,I gotta tell, on my second playthrough, I was kind of a bad boy until you know,what Arthur learns about,then went full honor

[summer lily]

my honor was half until he got yaknow

[random plinth]

Felt much more like redemption

[summer lily]

oh what

[frigid cloud]

When Micah shot Arthur in the head:

Hmm I wonder if you could have low honor during the last ride and be honorable by helping john and getting high honor ending

[random plinth]

Yikes

There are 4 different endings

[frigid cloud]

Bro I know it isn't my first time playing

[random plinth]

😂

Sorry

But the ending you describe also ends with a headshot

[frigid cloud]

Yes

But what I wonder is

You could barely have low honor and 1 bar away from high honor then help john to be honorable

[random plinth]

True

[hidden moss]

If it is raining

then it's low honor

however

if u have you are one bar away

and help John

[random plinth]

You can also go really low honor near the end , then kick Strauss out and get a big honor +

[hidden moss]

and get to neutral or enough to be honorable

Try to die

which changes the ending

entirely

[random plinth]

Kicking Strauss out AND helping the extorted people, gives enough I think to reach it to neutral

[golden storm]

does that mean arthur is jim milton too?
and john is tacitus kilgore?

[frigid cloud]

y tf does Algernon call John James?

[golden storm]

idk who that is yet

I explored new austin it is really cool

I wish more things happened in it though

[frigid cloud]

Infamous exotic quest giver lol

[golden storm]

oh ok

[frigid cloud]

You should check on him sometime

[random plinth]

Nice hat and revolver

[frigid cloud]

Indeed

Even though I never used it

[random plinth]

I just slap his revolver on the off hand just for the looks of the grip

[frigid cloud]

I had lote hat on

While doing it

I swear in one of his cutscenes when john turned into the mirror his clothing was glitching out

[random plinth]

A lot of things glitch out

[frigid cloud]

It was like I was playing with colorblind mode on

Pretty much what happened is his clothes turned into purple and pink

[random plinth]

I had the perfect shot of John and guess what glitched

His thumb in the holster

[hushed flare]

John and his clipping issues

[round hedge]

perfect shot and epilogue John will never be in the same sentence lmao

[hushed flare]

dead son morgab

[ashen quarry]

Hi I'm new here.

Hi I'm new here.

[frigid cloud]

Nice

For what

Oh

For next role?

[random plinth]

True

[frigid cloud]

Damn outlaw role and color looks good ngl

I'll be bandit soon

[latent plover]

Does bill have a condition? Or is he naturally dumb?

[frigid cloud]

I wonder if it has pic and gif perms

Outlaw and old desperado look best

The colors

[vagrant temple]

Not canonically

Just speculation and theories

[shy mulch]

dude wants a piece of kieran's ass

[frigid cloud]

🤢

[latent plover]

True

Mary Beth wants that too

[frigid cloud]

She wants Arthur's

[random plinth]

Bill likes roosters

Most likely when he was under custody by Ross, I bet he told Jack more than he should

Ross was Milton's second

Pinkertons tracked the gang for years

So it's logical they had a file on each member, along with testimonies from known accomplishes aka rats

[frigid cloud]

I love how you fail for killing the colonel favours in the meeting with Monroe and rains fall

[severe anvil]

are there such things as uh encounters which affects the main storyline

[hidden moss]

how do you duel random npcs with an Xbox?

[summer loom]

i don’t believe so, i’ve never encountered one

[frigid cloud]

On Xbox?

[summer loom]

it’s the same as everything else

right?

[hidden moss]

Yes

[frigid cloud]

Can't think of any, but there are a few random encounters stranger asking Arthur why did he kill all those people after a few mission but don't think that affects any storyline

[frigid cloud]

You push the rt slightly and press it fully when the bar is full and it'll be a headshot guaranteed

[hidden moss]

no, how do you tell the npc to duel you

[frigid cloud]

O

There are random events

In valentine, van horn saloons when you enter the saloon someone will often bump into you and will challenge you to duel

[hidden moss]

O

[frigid cloud]

And there are one in valentine where one guy cheats in a duel then you can challenge him as well

[hidden moss]

All of em are just events

that cannot be repeated sadly.

i searched in Google I think you press r1 + r2 slightly and ur character will say a unique line

thanks :)

[round hedge]

because they are a family

and Abigail clearly didn't care about her past life anymore and joked about it with John

so she probably told him

yeah I'm sure he doesn't listen 24/7 everyday

for 4 years

it's 4 years

they obviously told him

he literally is almost always together with his family in epilogue

you're blind

not his fault

every night he's with his family

in the camp

mto Camp

not

the fireplace

no he's most normally playing something

they obviously had conversations with him like a normal human

[random plinth]

Ross did a favor to John I guess

Climate change is real

[shy mulch]

So I can brutally murder O'Driscolls no problem but if I steal the fish hanging off their camp I lose honor

man the setpieces are weird it must have spawned some innocent dude's fish drying inches away from a camp

[fathom yew]

Ok guys

Arthurd more gone has reached Tahiti

Why am I attacked by Mexicans ?

[hidden moss]

lads, they say agent milton enters the camp in clemens point, which mission is that?

chapter 3

i guess

right?

[hushed flare]

No in chapter 9

[heady anchor]

No it’s chapter 8.

It leads into chapter 9.

That’s why they abandoned their camp in Tahiti.

[hidden moss]

what

[sturdy kite]

hey boys, about Arthur's medicine made by rainfall

Does it restore him to his previous state in physique or is he still a bit worse in stats?

[frigid cloud]

Don't think so

Didn't he give just plants?

[sinful knot]

yes he is lol

he reads books there and you can have interactions with Jack and Abigail at the fireplace inside

[main coral]

jhon mraston

[brisk arrow]

Im pissed

I fought all the gunslingers to get their revolvers and a pistol that were "rare and powerful" and my pistols are already better i hope i can upgrade them cause damn they suck

[hushed flare]

They are cool guns tho

I personally don't like cattleman's with long barrel

[frigid cloud]

Get Tahiti revolver

1 level away from bandit

Uh

[versed barn]

I know

[brisk arrow]

Can you upgrade the gunslinger weapons

[brisk arrow]

Tahiti revolver

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[brisk arrow]

Where?

[frigid cloud]

Complete duchesses and other animals quest

Then you get a Tahiti revolver and a hat

[brisk arrow]

Is it that good

[frigid cloud]

Its a long quest

[brisk arrow]

Cause what i mainly run with is the m1899's

[frigid cloud]

You collect like 150+ items

[frigid cloud]

Never used it so can't say anything

It's just for looks I guess

[brisk arrow]

I mean i pray i can upgrade the gunslinger weapons though

[cyan cipher]

you cant upgrade them i dont think

personally id go with calloways scholfield revolver and the treasure scholfield revolver

[frigid cloud]

Otis' miller revolver you mean?

[hushed flare]

treasure Schofield

[hushed harbor]

[brisk arrow]

Guys

How long do you stay in cuba

[frigid cloud]

Your first time playing?

[brisk arrow]

Yes it is first time in cuba

How long does it last i dont really wanna be here lol

Or more or less when do i get my stuff back

[old pond]

I think there are like 4 or 5 missions

[mighty pecan]

Not long

[brisk arrow]

I hope not

[mighty pecan]

I mean I’ve completed the game i know it doesn’t last long

[brisk arrow]

I HAVE TO WALK EVERYWHERE WTF

[mighty pecan]

LMAO

YEAH

HOW DOES YOUR HORSE LITERALLY APPEAR ON AN ISLAND

[brisk arrow]

I mean id assume cuban rebels would have horses

[hushed flare]

Whistling for horse vs Setting up camp for horse

[old pond]

Youre not on Cuba, you're on guarma

[brisk arrow]

Guarma same thing

[frigid cloud]

Max 40-50 minutes

[brisk arrow]

That was a crisp slap im being intterogated

[frigid cloud]

Who else sold all their cigarette cards

[mighty pecan]

Dutch has red face in Guarma

[old pond]

Btw if you want to complete the compodium there are a couple of animals that can only be found there

[mighty pecan]

LITERALLY STOP

[brisk arrow]

😩

[frigid cloud]

[mighty pecan]

😭😭

[old pond]

But they don't count towards the trophies

[brisk arrow]

Also

I cant find bison

Like i looked for 4 in game days straight i was pissed

[frigid cloud]

What you need bison for

[old pond]

I always find them near train tracks at emerald station

[brisk arrow]

Provisions satchel

I wanna carry more stuff and make large amounts of special amm9

[frigid cloud]

You cant get it in chapter 6

[brisk arrow]

Ammo*

.......

[frigid cloud]

Unless you bought the upgrades you need already

[brisk arrow]

This island is chapter 5

[frigid cloud]

If you didn't the opportunity is gone for good

I'd say just wait till later on

[brisk arrow]

[frigid cloud]

It'll be easier to get it

Way easier no doubt

[brisk arrow]

Man i dont want this game to end

Is there a new game plus?

[frigid cloud]

It doesn't end after chapter 6 dw

[old pond]

Nope

But there is still plenty to do

[brisk arrow]

Will i be able to continue with the people arthur interacted with

Cause i need to tell the guy i killed the gunslingets

[jolly dragon]

Yes

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[brisk arrow]

Nicr

[frigid cloud]

You can do them whenever you want to

[brisk arrow]

Nice*

[jolly dragon]

You can even go to that inbred pig farm in the epilogue too

[frigid cloud]

You got spoilers or?

[mighty pecan]

JOHN GETS RAPED TOO??

[jolly dragon]

yea....

[mighty pecan]

😔

[brisk arrow]

Ooooooo

[frigid cloud]

Don't they just rob you and leave you

[brisk arrow]

I know

[jolly dragon]

The pig farm does that, but the swamp house odes a lil more

[brisk arrow]

And then the incest pig farm

[frigid cloud]

Well my john got raped on purpose

[mighty pecan]

I think thats just called sex

[frigid cloud]

And ended up with no food

[frigid cloud]

So he's gay?

[jolly dragon]

If you talk to Bill in chapter 3 he also talks about the Swamp house, and says he was a victim

[mighty pecan]

possibly

[mighty pecan]

Bill? More like gay.

[frigid cloud]

I mean Arthur could do it too so dont think thats canon

[mighty pecan]

idk arthur seemed a lil fruity to me

ngl

[summer loom]

the red dotty line i get around valentine; towns in lockdown right? like 50 mfs came after me for a 50$ bounty

[mighty pecan]

yes i believe so

[summer loom]

thanks

[brisk arrow]

Broooooo

[frigid cloud]

Dont towns go on a lockdown after 250$ bounty?

[brisk arrow]

They go on lockdown whenever shit goes down bounty doesnt matter

[frigid cloud]

Who else is going to sell their orchids to trapper

[brisk arrow]

If you shoot like 2 cops they can

[mighty pecan]

😐

[frigid cloud]

Heh

[frigid cloud]

When you sell all the meat and plants before herbalist 10

[mighty pecan]

I will annihilate you.

[frigid cloud]

When you miss one herb and stuck at 42/43

[brisk arrow]

YAY WE ARE LEAVING CUBA

wait

Can i rob town banks by myseld

Myself*

[frigid cloud]

No

[brisk arrow]

So when the story is over no more robbing banks....

[frigid cloud]

Only stores, npcs and tip offs given by Alden for stage coach robberies

[brisk arrow]

UGHHHHH

[dreamy yew]

There’s always trains

[frigid cloud]

Right I forgot to mention

[latent plover]

There’s always a goddamn train!

[dreamy yew]

Lol

[brisk arrow]

Its weird to me

That a game this good has to end

[dreamy yew]

Facts

[brisk arrow]

If only red dead 3 comes out

[dreamy yew]

I will there be one?

[frigid cloud]

It'll never come out

[brisk arrow]

I know

But maybe....

Just maybe it will happen

[frigid cloud]

Nah no maybe's

[brisk arrow]

LET ME DREAM

[dreamy yew]

Imagine rdr3 was even further into the past: a story of how the gang got together

[frigid cloud]

We know it already don't we

[dreamy yew]

The last mission would be the ferry job

Back in black water

[brisk arrow]

Wair

Is it ever possible to get the money in blackwater

[frigid cloud]

No

[dreamy yew]

Isn’t there some of it?

Like

[brisk arrow]

You cant even go into black water lol

[frigid cloud]

He hasn't finished it yet btw

[dreamy yew]

O

[brisk arrow]

...

[frigid cloud]

Are you out of Guarma

[dreamy yew]

He’s in guarma?

[old pond]

Do you really want to know now or just wait and find out yourself?

[frigid cloud]

I'm ready if he does want to know now.

[dreamy yew]

Yeah

[hidden moss]

he's offline..

[frigid cloud]

But it'll involve way more spoilers than the money so yeah

[dreamy yew]

I wish I can replay the game without knowledge of the story

Like an actual fresh start

[old pond]

I always think that, but then I realize that if that were possible I probably wouldn't have even started red dead cause I could just play one game again and again

[frigid cloud]

He'll definitely get spoiled next time he goes on this channel

[dreamy yew]

There should be a role in which it shows if you completed the story

[frigid cloud]

Unnecessary tbh

If you don't want spoilers avoid this server

[dreamy yew]

Perhaps

[hidden moss]

yea best thing is to avoid searching anything about the game, until you finish it..

[dreamy yew]

What was your guys’ favorite chapter?

[hidden moss]

3

[old pond]

2

[dreamy yew]

Nice

[frigid cloud]

Epilogue 1

[dreamy yew]

Alright

Mine is 3

3 or 5

[old pond]

Interesting choice

[brisk arrow]

Im back

[dreamy yew]

Who’s your favorite character in the gang?

Besides Arthur

[frigid cloud]

Micah

[hidden moss]

nice

[dreamy yew]

Interesting

I thought Micah was fine until

U know

[brisk arrow]

I now how it ends sadly

[dreamy yew]

Oh

[hidden moss]

hes a good feller

[frigid cloud]

You looked up I bet

[brisk arrow]

No

Ive known for awhile n9w

Now*

Just acted like i havent

I new how it ended but not anything else

[frigid cloud]

Chapter 6 ending?

Or the story

[brisk arrow]

Chapter 6

I already know im gonna cry still

[frigid cloud]

Ok

Do you know what happens next

[brisk arrow]

No

I know yoy play as john

And get arthurs stuff in part 2

[frigid cloud]

You can stop Arthur from dying btw

It's the rarest ending

[hidden moss]

neutral honor ending

[frigid cloud]

Have lowest honor and finish chapter 6.

[dreamy yew]

💀

[brisk arrow]

I have neutral honor

Im in the grey

[frigid cloud]

Huh uh

[brisk arrow]

So is arthur gonna live👀

[frigid cloud]

Yes

He'll cure himself

[brisk arrow]

YESSSSSSSSSSSSSS

OMG

IM GONNA FUCKING CRY

[frigid cloud]

Dude didn't think you'd get that excited

[brisk arrow]

Cause john is so dull

[frigid cloud]

I'm sorry but I was just joking

[hidden moss]

...

[brisk arrow]

.......

[dreamy yew]

💀💀💀

[frigid cloud]

But no

In reality he dies either way

[old pond]

I'd avoid low honor tho

[brisk arrow]

There is multiple endings though

Im like close to white mid greyish

[dreamy yew]

Low honor ending is kinda more realistic tho

[frigid cloud]

Yes do this and get high honor

[old pond]

Yes but also much more painful

[hidden moss]

yea, going for the money fits perfectly in low honor

[dreamy yew]

Yeah

[dreamy yew]

No I’m talking about

If u help John

[old pond]

It kind of does but it is just stupid in Arthur's Situation

[dreamy yew]

Yeah

[brisk arrow]

Wait wait

[dreamy yew]

?

[brisk arrow]

Is it possible at all

To play as arthur after the epilouge

[frigid cloud]

No

[brisk arrow]

Broooo

John is so fucking boring

[frigid cloud]

You're stuck with John

Forever

[dreamy yew]

Lmao

Rdr1 🌚

[brisk arrow]

Rdr1 was okay

Wair

[frigid cloud]

Rdr2 is before rdr1 btw if you didn't know

[dreamy yew]

I haven’t played it but I know what happens

[brisk arrow]

I did

Cause john does a swiss cheese cosplay

[solar sierra]

Swiss cheese cosplay? Wot

[prime estuary]

rdr1

[dreamy yew]

LMFAOO

I just found out what he means

[hidden moss]

ohh

ok lmao

[old pond]

Oh fuck I think I get it too

And I don't like it

[dreamy yew]

Dang

[frigid cloud]

Lots of cattle rustlers

[solar sierra]

I wish undead nightmare 2 would be a thing

[brisk arrow]

My mans does a SWISS CHEESE cosplay og

[hidden moss]

Arthur does covid19 cosplay

[brisk arrow]

Stop im gonna fuckinf cry

[frigid cloud]

Do you know all the endings

[dreamy yew]

Dutch’s chest

[brisk arrow]

I know you can stab micah i think

Idk

Just tell me its fine

Arthur fr fr dont look right withought his beard

[frigid cloud]

Get 10 level beard

Its ridiculously long

[brisk arrow]

I like length 4

[frigid cloud]

You sure

[old pond]

It's probably better not to tell

[brisk arrow]

Yes

[frigid cloud]

Yep that's what I thought

[brisk arrow]

Actually ill jusy find out

[frigid cloud]

Oh no

[brisk arrow]

Cause thats what bisk thinks

[frigid cloud]

Dont look up

[brisk arrow]

Thered nothing there

I aint even got teburculosis yet

[frigid cloud]

You shall soon

[brisk arrow]

Arthurs face dont look too goof

Good*

[frigid cloud]

Are you in lakay?

Or what missions you have right now

[brisk arrow]

Im runnign around a little

Do i get to keep jim boys revolver

Just turned in the photos and stuff

[frigid cloud]

Did you get it already

[brisk arrow]

No

He hasnt given it

Oh im now hunting his old friend

[frigid cloud]

If you get it as arthur yes it'll carry over

[brisk arrow]

No i mean do i get it at all

So ima assume yeah

[frigid cloud]

Yes

[brisk arrow]

Nice

[frigid cloud]

He'll give it to you eventually

[brisk arrow]

I antagonized one man in van horn and now the npcs are fighting me and eachother

So callaway doesnt give you his revolver

[abstract sphinx]

Oof

You get it

by killing him

[brisk arrow]

You take it in a duel

[abstract sphinx]

ye

[brisk arrow]

I like it one of my favorites when it comes to the gunslingers

[abstract sphinx]

Best pistols in my opinion are the M1899 and the Mauser

best revolvers in my opinion? Double action and micahs

[brisk arrow]

Yeah i mainly use m 1899

[abstract sphinx]

Fast reload and fire rate

[brisk arrow]

Got them in duel and maxed them out

Dual*

[abstract sphinx]

same

[frigid cloud]

I love how O'Driscolls have Irish accents and they pronounce colomo O'Driscoll which corrects Sean

[brisk arrow]

Rip sean

Ima turn on cheats head to annesburg and start my entourage of murder

[abstract sphinx]

Well, I'll be going now, enjoy fellers

[frigid cloud]

Bye

When you discard all herbs you've collected for herbalist 7

Still cowboy

[hidden moss]

Do u meet again mary linton after u go to the theatre in saint denis with her

[frigid cloud]

No

You don't ever see her again

[mighty pecan]

Good

I hate mary linton

[frigid cloud]

y

[mighty pecan]

she only talks to arthur when she needs something

She’s manipulative

[frigid cloud]

When you do her missions anyway because for a trophy

[mighty pecan]

i wouldnt have done that mission if it didnt have that

[frigid cloud]

fr her mission in chapter 4 is so long

I mean she wanted to run off with him again but Arthur stayed loyal to dutch and didn't leave the gang but he regrets in chapter 6

[mighty pecan]

he cant regret it if he’s dead

[frigid cloud]

I mean they would run off someplace dry so tb would slow down a bit

[frigid cloud]

No before his death

He let his love go because of the gang and he definitely regrets in chapter 6 because of Dutch's actions

[mighty pecan]

not necessarily because of the gang, more because he didn’t think he was a good man in the first place and that he’s an outlaw

[frigid cloud]

He wasn't a good man anyway

So makes sense

He also said he doesn't have money but that was probably an excuse

[mighty pecan]

Okay if he said that then he’s lying because my arthur was WEALTHY AS FUCK

[frigid cloud]

Apparently to everyone in gang they're poor and don't have one cent

[mighty pecan]

Not Micah he donated $25 :0

[frigid cloud]

Richest and kindest man

[mighty pecan]

I remember that encounter happened for me right after i donated a $300 gold bar

kinda slackin there micah

[frigid cloud]

Me doing every treasure map and donating everything to the camp

[mighty pecan]

I WAS GONNA BUY THINGS FOR CAMP AND I LEFT FOR LIKE 2 MINUTES AND IT WENT FROM $350 TO $0 LIKE DUTCH

DUTCH YOU THIEF

[frigid cloud]

Must've gone to the hidden chest

[mighty pecan]

Or gone to more fucking CIGARS

man has so many fancy cigars

[frigid cloud]

When you give him a pipe but never uses it

[mighty pecan]

LMAO FR

Also where did jacks fucking comic i gave him go

Never saw it once

Little shit

[frigid cloud]

Gave it to hosea

[mighty pecan]

[frigid cloud]

And you give 5$ to Abigail to get new clothes for jack but he still wears the same clothes after

[mighty pecan]

Jack has no drip

yk who does?

UNCLE

uncle has all the drip

[frigid cloud]

After completing cigarette cards quest as arthur next day in ledger Arthur donated 10000+ cigarette packs

[mighty pecan]

I fr thought you were gonna bring up the fence thing again

I was gonna get the shotgun

[frigid cloud]

Who knows.

I still might

[mighty pecan]

[frigid cloud]

Next google will tell you to do gambler 8 and quit the game without saving

[mighty pecan]

OH MY GOD SHUT UP

IM STILL STUCK ON GAMBLER 8

IM LOSING MY MIND

[frigid cloud]

Get lucky.

[mighty pecan]

It’s been 3 days.

[frigid cloud]

Jeez

I do it in one day

I did it like three times

First time was hella short 1 hour and a half then 4 hours and 4 hours again

[mighty pecan]

You’re just blessed by the red dead gods or sum

[frigid cloud]

Rdr2 speedruns are so inconsistent

Due to hunting requests and gambler challenges

[mighty pecan]

BRUH a speedrun of rdr2 would just result in death from sitting for too long

[frigid cloud]

World record is 35 hours

For 100%

[hidden moss]

I just use save editor to skip gambler 8 and 9

[mighty pecan]

what

uway

come back

how

[hidden moss]

Save editor is a program

[mighty pecan]

[mighty pecan]

I HAVE A DUCKING PS4

[hidden moss]

Lucky for you

u need a laptop

however u need save wizard which costs 60$

[mighty pecan]

guess who broke their laptop

[frigid cloud]

Rather get lucky then spend 60$

[hidden moss]

yeah

[mighty pecan]

It’s such a stupid challenge

[hidden moss]

I'm on pc

so i don't have to pay for save wizard

[frigid cloud]

Lucky

I swear someone in here they did it in 30 minutes or sumthing

Luckiest man alive

[mighty pecan]

Then there’s me with 3 days

[hidden moss]

U are more fucked

once gambler 9 comes

[frigid cloud]

Gambler 9 is worse

Cause you actually have to do something

If you don't know how to play you're fucked basically

[mighty pecan]

I HAVE FINSINED THE GAME TWICE I KNOW HOW TO PLAY

wait i forgot what 9 is

oh shit

[hidden moss]

Win 3 domino without losing

[mighty pecan]

oh easy i did that for the other domino one as well

[frigid cloud]

No

3 domino GAMES

Not ROUNDS

[mighty pecan]

.

what

do you want me to kill myself.

[frigid cloud]

Meaning you have to hit 60 3 times in a row without losing

[mighty pecan]

I DONT KNOW HOW TO ACTUALLY PLAY IT OH SHIT

[frigid cloud]

Once I tried it

Arthur drew every tile possible

[mighty pecan]

I’m playing as John maybe he’s better

[frigid cloud]

I completed it as John and opponent drew lots of tiles so it was fairly quick like 30-40 minutes

[mighty pecan]

It’s sad that we think 30-40 mind is quick

[hidden moss]

Arthur Marston is better 😳

Who said u were playing as John in epilogue

[mighty pecan]

fax doe

aight im going to bed bois goodnight

[frigid cloud]

Gn

[hidden moss]

good night

[sage falcon]

why are store doors barricaded and wont let me enter

it has a "closed" sign on it

it says there open on the map

[severe anvil]

can you play rdr2 offline

[frigid cloud]

Bro that's what singeplayer is for

[severe relic]

Why did you leave us behind dad

[sage falcon]

I beat ur mom to many times and the law was getting suspicious

[severe relic]

oh

[severe anvil]

i uh read some things online that u cant, wanted to check if you can already today

[frigid cloud]

??

[severe anvil]

ok