Why not both?
#red-dead-singleplayer
latent plover
hidden moss
When Sadie said “Thank ya arthur” I think I fell in love
hidden moss
Why not both?
Which one first
latent plover
Oh either I guess, no difference really
frigid cloud
You shouldn't lose honor for not helping sadie because Arthur always has said revenge's a fool game
latent plover
Nah
frigid cloud
For a trophy yes, you have to but for 100% no
latent plover
Sadie needs some throat lozenges for that croaky voice
frigid cloud
I haven't even done Mrs downes missions in chapter 6 yet they're available to replay
hidden moss
Dutch needs to hit puberty and stop having the voice cracks
latent plover
Also true
hidden moss
I haven't even done Mrs downes missions in chapter 6 yet they're available to re...
Have you done the missions?
hidden moss
Mine unlocked after killing Cornwall
frigid cloud
I didn't have had high honor that's why
hidden moss
Oh
hushed flare
2 free gold medals atleast
hushed flare
I think those are the only honor type missions if I'm not mistaken
frigid cloud
ye
hushed flare
Mrs downes
hidden moss
I feel like Dutch would like Pizza Hut
frigid cloud
If you have low honor they don't show up
latent plover
nosnawS
hushed flare
So time to rob 50 trains and kill all passengers then fish and throw back for an hour and I'm a saint
latent plover
Reversed Swanson
frigid cloud
Lmao
hushed flare
Resumed swanson
frigid cloud
In speedruns Arthur's honor: ❌ ❌
hushed flare
YouTube comments in rdr2 be like "WeLl actUaLly 1.50$ waS 527373738388383$ in todAys mOneY"
frigid cloud
No wonder why jack gets excited to get a dollar from micah
hushed flare
free money
latent plover
Leviticus Cornwall is Jeff bezos
hidden moss
I’m taking a break from the game for a sec for my mental health lmao
hushed flare
John becomes Jeff bezos in the epilogue
Arthur becomes bill gates after valentine bank robbery
latent plover
Isn’t it convenient how Milton teleports to safety? Outside the bank he vanishes instantly, the same outside the Lakay camp
hushed flare
cuz plot armor
hushed flare
When Arthur takes 2 shotgun blasts and 50 revolver wounds and drinks one moonshine and it's all healed
frigid cloud
In cutscenes characters: one shot and dead
Outside of cutscenes: can take 12938193710282383 bullets and still alive
fierce cave
hose
fierce cave
Hosea gets shot once and dies
hose
latent plover
I said whoever threw that paper, your moms a ho-sea
fierce cave
what if hosea got lumbago
frigid cloud
What john should fear: bullets
What he actually fears:water
fierce cave
his death caught me really off guard
hushed flare
In cutscenes characters: one shot and dead
Outside of cutscenes: can take 129381...
And then protagonist: eats can of beans and moonshine and all good
frigid cloud
hushed flare
When can the enemies call out Arthur and John for cheating
frigid cloud
Do ppl really eat bear meat and wolf meat?
It's big game meat so
hushed flare
Do ppl really eat bear meat and wolf meat?
Minty alligator meat op
Also gives you a free weight level if you sleep
frigid cloud
I think timber wolf gives less big game meat than gray wolf does
hushed flare
Alligators give like 5-6
hushed flare
Crustacean meat moment
fierce cave
where do you find possums
hushed flare
average big game meat fan vs average mutton/crustacean meat enjoyer 
latent plover
where do you find possums
You’re better off googling that so you can see locations on a map
hushed flare
where do you find possums
Riggs station at night
latent plover
But you’ll tend to hear them before you see them. They make a loud screech
fierce cave
i will capture one
latent plover
Wanted dead or alive
frigid cloud
But you’ll tend to hear them before you see them. They make a loud screech
Best way to know that they're in the area
hushed flare
When the opposum gets a wanted level
frigid cloud
I don't think many people knows that
fierce cave
🤠
latent plover
Best way to know that they're in the area
Yeah I must’ve missed so many of them before I knew that
hushed flare
Opposum for master hunter 9?
latent plover
Opossum playing possum
hushed flare
When the challenges go from "kill 5 cougars with a bow" and then the 2nd to last challenge is "kill a opposum playing dead"
frigid cloud
Maybe but I don't think so
hidden moss
Nope no one I just searched
frigid cloud
When the challenges go from "kill 5 cougars with a bow" and then the 2nd to last...
When people forget to skin them
hushed flare
Good thing there's 3 Micah fans
hushed flare
Micah is good guy
frigid cloud
^^
hidden moss
I just don’t like how he insults arthur and thinks he’s incharge
frigid cloud
He's in charge though
hushed flare
he's good at shooting
latent plover
Micah shoots about 10 bullets at John at point blank range: misses all of them
hushed flare
Micah is probably better at shooting then most YouTubers 
hushed flare
Micah shoots about 10 bullets at John at point blank range: misses all of them
Plot armor broooo
shhh
sinful knot
Micah shoots about 10 bullets at John at point blank range: misses all of them
Just like dutch misses all his shots on fussar
frigid cloud
Cause he's not a gunslinger
hushed flare
fussar has plot armor 2!!!
sinful knot
Cause he's not a gunslinger
The dude was duelwielding
latent plover
So much armour
hidden moss
Guys, my epilogue John looks broken. He has his 1899 hair with dark brown and fixed outfist
hushed flare
average modder
hidden moss
I want Arthur's hair back
Because Rockstar actually pulled metal gear solid
by giving us Arthur Marston
sinful knot
I know johns hair is brown but plz switch it back to jet black gui
hidden moss
instead of John Marston
hushed flare
When you get johns hair on arthur
hidden moss
Man, we are actually didn't notice it
but Rockstar actually pulled Kojima on us
Remember when MGS2 was about Snake when trailers came out?
But they gave us raiden?
Yeah
vast elk
Y cant we bring hogs on the horses back?
latent plover
Heavy
hidden moss
In RDR2 early screenshots we see John Marston
but in release we get Arthur Marston
Rockstar is a genius
hushed flare
bring bison on horseback when
latent plover
Are they that much heavier than a deer?
Yeah they’re heavy af
hushed flare
Fat boars
vast elk
Based
frigid cloud
Dutch improved gunslinging skills in 8 years then
hushed flare
How to bring a moose on horseback
sinful knot
Dutch improved gunslinging skills in 8 years then
all the other times hes a good shot in 1899, kills 3 guys in a matter of seconds at braithwaite manor but he cant kill fussar, one guy
vast elk
Plot armor
pure tusk
can u get legend of east outfit with arthur?
hidden moss
can u get legend of east outfit with arthur?
With bugs and glitches yes.
hushed flare
Micah when he can't hit John after firing all 12 shots with revolver at 5 feet away
pure tusk
With bugs and glitches yes.
what about the legend of the west or is it just in rdr1
frigid cloud
Drag a perfect moose from annesburg to tumbleweed in 20 minutes without equipping the lasso
hidden moss
what about the legend of the west or is it just in rdr1
John can get legend of the west without glitches and bugs
sinful knot
Micah when he can't hit John after firing all 12 shots with revolver at 5 feet a...
but boy he can aim from cover
major plot armor
hushed flare
Drag a perfect moose from annesburg to tumbleweed in 20 minutes without equippin...
Horseman 11
pure tusk
John can get legend of the west without glitches and bugs
is legend of the east better than the legend of west?
hushed flare
but boy he can aim from cover
You also can't kill Micah either since I managed to shoot him in the face but the bullet had no effect #plotarmor
hidden moss
is legend of the east better than the legend of west?
It doesn't matter tbh
Legend of the west is from RDR1 only lol
hidden moss
Legend of the middle east
hushed flare
legend of the all directions
latent plover
Compass master
hushed flare
yes
hidden moss
Legend of Arthur Marston
frigid cloud
In rdr2 you cant go to where john can go in rdr1
In rdr1 you can't go to where Arthur can go in rdr2
hushed flare
legend of the reversed swanson
uncut topaz
Killed the two Murfrees who loot the campers they killed and their backups spawned inside the lake and had to swim far as hell to me 😂
vast elk
sinful knot
You also can't kill Micah either since I managed to shoot him in the face but th...
More plot armor before we get to micah, somehow sadie stabbed with a bowie knife in her ribs bleeding out like crazy, manages to get to john and micah's location, walk all that way and shes bleeding out
hidden moss
In rdr2 you cant go to where john can go in rdr1
In rdr1 you can't go to where A...
Technically RDR2 map didn't exist and designed lol
So In rdr2 John can go anywhere he wants
hushed flare
More plot armor before we get to micah, somehow sadie stabbed with a bowie knife...
Because if Sadie died then fans would cry again
vast elk
Fuck is this spoilers hour?
sinful knot
But shes stronk woman!!!
vast elk
frigid cloud
Micah should've killed her in first mission
hidden moss
Fuck is this spoilers hour?
What do u mean man?
hushed flare
I feel like Micah in gameplay would just one shot Sadie in John in 0.0001 seconds
sinful knot
Micah should've killed her in first mission
fax
hidden moss
He just dyed his hair
sinful knot
he has no problem killing innocents so why shouldnt he shoot sadie in the face in the first mission
candid walrus
I feel like Micah in gameplay would just one shot Sadie in John in 0.0001 second...
yep
candid walrus
Micah should've killed her in first mission
100%
sinful knot
I feel like Micah in gameplay would just one shot Sadie in John in 0.0001 second...
RDR1 john could probably shoot him though
hushed flare
remove Arthur update when
sinful knot
badass
frigid cloud
In rdr3 we play as Micah and get to kill Arthur
hidden moss
remove Arthur update when
Make all npcs John Marston update
candid walrus
yesyesyes
hushed flare
Add Gavin update tho
sinful knot
Replace arthur with micah update
candid walrus
hidden moss
You know what's funny?
hushed flare
Replace arthur with micah update
Yellow alive damnation
candid walrus
Me
sinful knot
They gave John's hair to mufree gangs
and del lobo gangs
but no hair for player_three
LOL
sinful knot
I wouldnt be surprised if they gave some npcs most of johns hairstyles
hushed flare
I wish Johns equipment wasn't clipping so much
Knife holster and left holster clipping through coats
sinful knot
Make JMRP into an update for consoles
hidden moss
Take every John Marston mods and make it official update
hushed flare
Replace John with micah update
hidden moss
Replace all npcs with John update 😳
hushed flare
there we go
sinful knot
Replace sadie with feminist in saint denis update 
frigid cloud
I wonder if anyone died to Micah in fistfight
frigid cloud
You can't see your health also probably makes you invincible
hushed flare
Micah will eventually pull out his cheating moves like hortensia in saint denis
frigid cloud
Lol
hushed flare
Whoretensia
frigid cloud
Can you use Evans repeater on Micah during final mission
hushed flare
It forces u to revolver
sinful knot
pretty sure micah knocks all your guns off the cliff when he tackles arthur
hushed flare
Go back for the money ending
frigid cloud
I wonder if on pc could force to use repeater
hushed flare
Shooting Micah 26 times with explosive repeater ammo
frigid cloud
woah
pure tusk
arthur is better shot than john
hidden moss
arthur is better shot than john
Wrong
hushed flare
meh
hidden moss
RDR1 John would destroy Arthur.
hushed flare
it depends on the player
pure tusk
john wasnt even holding his gun right
hidden moss
john wasnt even holding his gun right
He does lol
frigid cloud
When Arthur starts the game with cattleman revolver
pure tusk
later in rdr1 yes
hidden moss
Rockstar actually gave John's actual character to Arthur
hushed flare
When Arthur starts the game with cattleman revolver
Arthur starting with lemat when
latent plover
In 5 playthroughs ive never gone back for the money, just can’t do it
hidden moss
In rdr1 John said he was ruthless, right hand of Dutch, and most skillful of Dutch
hushed flare
Go back for the money high honor
hidden moss
But they gave that character to Arthur sadly
frigid cloud
Ive returned to muneh and got gold medal
latent plover
I think it seems natural for Arthur to return for the money
pure tusk
In rdr1 John said he was ruthless, right hand of Dutch, and most skillful of Dut...
arthur is the best shot in rdr2
hushed flare
Low honor
hidden moss
arthur is the best shot in rdr2
Like i said, They gave John's rdr1 character to Arthur.
hushed flare
arthur is the best shot in rdr2
U forgot gavin
hidden moss
Downgrading John's character
pure tusk
plus john was giving up on the life of the gunslinger or an outlaw, john trained a bit with the best gunslinger but it was not enough lol
latent plover
I always shoot Nigel now
latent plover
hidden moss
plus john was giving up on the life of the gunslinger or an outlaw, john trained...
John said to Abraham that John is right hand of Dutch, most skillful
but in RDR2
All John does is stay in camp
it just retcons of Rockstar
hushed flare
so was Arthur left hand
hidden moss
Every returning characters gets downgraded in Rockstar games.
hushed flare
And Micah was the middle hand
latent plover
John said to Abraham that John is right hand of Dutch, most skillful
Why does this sound like an extract from the bible
frigid cloud
Next game we'll get Arthur with John's hair
pure tusk
John said to Abraham that John is right hand of Dutch, most skillful
yeah but shit aint chaning that john didnt even hold his gun right
hushed flare
Next game we'll get Arthur with John's hair
We play as Davey and then Arthur gets Davey's hair in the epilogue
hidden moss
Rexental says that John can't hold his gun right
pure tusk
Rexental says that John can't hold his gun right
yes he doesnt hold it right in rdr2
hidden moss
Because Rockstar cut his animations
hushed flare
John's running animation dies from cringe
hidden moss
John's actual animations holds the gun right
sinful knot
John had rdr1 run, walk aim, etc everything from rdr1
pure tusk
John's actual animations holds the gun right
its not that...
sinful knot
but they cut that in rdr2
hushed flare
I wish we had John's puking animation
hidden moss
its not that...
It's a retcon then.
latent plover
It does seem like R* just cba with rdr2 John
hidden moss
R* Just forgot to write John how he was meant to be
pure tusk
It's a retcon then.
i just said that johns trainer (in the story) tought john how to hold it right
latent plover
I wish we had John's puking animation
That’s so weird right
He pukes with Arthur’s voice
hidden moss
Just more proof that R* Ruined John a lot
Like srsly
Epilogue John's antagonizes and greets
sinful knot
imo i dont like arthurs final ingame outfit much
why didnt they give Arthur his badass cover outfit
hidden moss
Epilogue John's dialogues and antagonizes sounds like he learned it from a kindergarten children
But Npc John can insult good
Rdr1 John insults way better than Arthur
It's just Epilogue John that got ruined a lot
sinful knot
yea
random thunder
hello cool kids
pure tusk
It's just Epilogue John that got ruined a lot
yeah he didnt use the guns that much
which means he slightly lost his aim
hidden moss
yeah he didnt use the guns that much
No. John's epilogue writting sucks
sinful knot
epilogue john sucks overall
hidden moss
He doesn't act like Npc John or Rdr1 John
pure tusk
No. John's epilogue writting sucks
yeah but it impacts the story a lot
hidden moss
His antagonizes and dialogues are cringe.
sinful knot
he isnt the badass man we see in rdr1
hidden moss
yeah but it impacts the story a lot
John was a bitch in the epilogue. The whole epilogue was just sucking Arthur's cock and John getting roasted by uncle. I feel like 1899 had RDR John as reference, and epilogue John had 1899 John as reference. People say "character development", then tell me how John went from a little socially awkward bitch who can't get over Arthur's death in the epilogue, to the guy he was in rdr1
sinful knot
exactly, epilogue john in rdr2 always handed his balls to women
frigid cloud
How tf you typed that so fast
hidden moss
How tf you typed that so fast
😎
random thunder
How tf you typed that so fast
fr holy hell my man typed a whole bible in 5 seconds
hidden moss
fr holy hell my man typed a whole bible in 5 seconds
I have typed something way longer than this
Ah come on
They don't allow it
pure tusk
John was a bitch in the epilogue. The whole epilogue was just sucking Arthur's c...
Yeah john was a family man in the epilogue, but it does not mean he is still a good shot rockstar fucked john up, which made arthur a better shot
random thunder
what the hell HAHHA
pure tusk
I have typed something way longer than this
i have 70 wpm :(
hidden moss
Yeah john was a family man in the epilogue, but it does not mean he is still a ...
At the end It's R* doing character downgrade
random thunder
pure tusk
At the end It's R* doing character downgrade
yeah, epilogue didnt even feel like a cowboy game
it was just family shit
frigid cloud
Farming simulator
random thunder
Farming simulator
HAHHA yes
hidden moss
it was just family shit
And Epilogue John's character getting fucked
random thunder
From pew pew pew to 👨🌾
sinful knot
Farming simulator
get roasted by uncle and hand your balls to women simulator
frigid cloud
Shit shovelling
pure tusk
am i the only one who hates epilogue jack?
frigid cloud
Dutch was right, they should've gone to tahiti
hidden moss
Epilogue is just lack of content tbh
They cut lots of shit from epilogue
And they lost so many potential to add stuff to epilogue
Og John, RDR1 map actually was meant to look like RDR1 map
frigid cloud
Algernon exotic hat store when
pure tusk
Epilogue is just lack of content tbh
tbh they rushed it too much, all they wanted is to connect the rdr2 to rdr 1 and epilogue was rushed af
hidden moss
More story
hidden moss
tbh they rushed it too much, all they wanted is to connect the rdr2 to rdr 1 and...
Yeah
Epilogue was meant to look more like RDR1
In 1.00 version
Manzanita post map has train station
pure tusk
DUDE THEY MADE ME FIX THE FENCE
hidden moss
but in later patches they removed that from map
pure tusk
AND CALM DOWN A BULL
trail hull
Veteran players also think online mode has lack of content as well and I agree
hidden moss
DUDE THEY MADE ME FIX THE FENCE
It's not about that
It's lack of content
OG Real John Marston look and animations
Actual 1907 map
More story missions
frigid cloud
Meanwhile armadillo revives itself and tumbleweed dies
pure tusk
i mean there is the New Austlin if thats the name
trail hull
#JusticeforGuarma
hidden moss
#JusticeforGuarma
#JusticeforEpilogueJohn, #JusticeforGuarma, #justiceforreal1907map, #justiceforstorymode
hidden moss
oof
pure tusk
BRUH
hidden moss
Got ghost pinged
random thunder
hidden moss
Slurs?
trail hull
Lmao
hidden moss
They didn't give proper story to Epilogue John
pure tusk
#JusticeforEpilogueJohn, #JusticeforGuarma, #justiceforreal1907map, #justicefors...
guarma was kinda an useless chapter too
didnt have that high impact to the main story
hidden moss
I'd prefer Mexico tbh
Like Arthur and gang lands at Mexico
helps Allende win a fight
Which Allende welcomes Bill and Javier in RDR1
pure tusk
I'd prefer Mexico tbh
i would perfer the gang going west
frigid cloud
They should've taken over guarma
sinful knot
They should've taken over guarma
most of the gang probably were on mainland
latent plover
Plan
Faith
Muneh
Noise
Tahiti
Need to count how many times Dutch says each of those words
quick ferry
Hello
latent plover
It’s me
quick ferry
Do you guys know how I can get deleted saves back in rdr2 I deleted all of them
round hedge
epilogue was just mad boring
and wacky ass john wasn't even near as fun compared to RDR john
frigid cloud
I quit for a day after I was in epilogue for the first time
latent plover
Do you guys know how I can get deleted saves back in rdr2 I deleted all of them
I don’t think you can
Maybe within your consol settings or something but I doubt it
round hedge
I quit for a day after I was in epilogue for the first time
if john had his RDR personality, epilogue would've been a lot more fun to play imo
hidden moss
Do you guys know how I can get deleted saves back in rdr2 I deleted all of them
If it hasn’t synced yet, it’s possible by deleting RDR2, installing it & then selecting “Sync with cloud”
pure tusk
u have a program that can give u back your deleted files
hidden moss
If it had been synced already, it’s gone
hidden moss
u have a program that can give u back your deleted files
On xbox?
hidden moss
Ye
quick ferry
If it hasn’t synced yet, it’s possible by deleting RDR2, installing it & then se...
Oh damn
hidden moss
Lets hope it hasn’t synced then😄
quick ferry
I really hope so
hidden moss
Just select “Cloud Saves” after reinstalling
quick ferry
So just delete it and install it again?
hidden moss
Yup
hidden moss
Sure thing, hope it works💖 I had the same thing with GTA story mode, so quickly closed game so it wouldn’t sync, and reinstalled😄
quick ferry
I closed it quick but I started the game again couple of times to check the reloads
hidden moss
Hmm, well let’s hope for the best. I think it’ll have cloud saves, since there’s nothing to replace them yet
quick ferry
I hope so
latent plover
It’s crazy that rains fall and his people were driven out of their own home
For oil that wasn’t even there
Well driven out or killed I guess
hidden moss
Well driven out or killed I guess
Ye, I hate that Dutch made it so much worse
latent plover
hidden moss
That really hit me, when he was mourning his son. And in the end credits scene, when Rain Falls is looking at an eagle flying over ;(
latent plover
Yeah crazy symbolism
quick ferry
What kind of horse do you guys use
hidden moss
Shire
latent plover
I only noticed the Eagle flies reference on my 3rd playthrough
quick ferry
I use Turkoman black bay
latent plover
What kind of horse do you guys use
Turkoman
latent plover
I switch between that, mustang, Arabian
latent plover
You can get a free Turkoman in chapter 3
How?
quick ferry
I don’t like the Arabian that much
hidden moss
You can get a free Turkoman in chapter 3
Ye the braithwaith horse
keen birchBOT
Read if Arthur sucks.
latent plover
Yeah
hidden moss
Read if Arthur sucks.
No u suck
frigid cloud
hidden moss
Smh
quick ferry
When you get the horses and you go to that peaceful place you can brush the horse and give him treats and when it turns lvl 1 it’s yours when u finish the mission u can come back and get it
That’s how I got a free Turkoman black bay
hidden moss
Did yall know Lumbago is real? I thought Uncle made it up, till today, when I got diagnosed with it😄
latent plover
Ahh I seee
hidden moss
Luckily it can’t be terminal xD
hidden moss
Ye im fr
frigid cloud
Wow
latent plover
It’s very serious
frigid cloud
We should never underestimate lumbago
hidden moss
Ye it hurts like heck😄
quick ferry
Damn
hidden moss
Can’t even walk
quick ferry
Ohh hope you’ll feel better
hidden moss
Yup😅 ya know. I thought my doc was joking, I asked them if they were for real xD
Never knew it was a real thing
frigid cloud
You'd think game wouldn't have irl sicknesses
frigid cloud
Tuberculosis was a shock for me though
hidden moss
So that’s good😄
hidden moss
Tuberculosis was a shock for me though
Ooh that hurt ye. I had no clue what was happening when Arthur fell from his horse
frigid cloud
They were all red in my first playthrough
hidden moss
He looks badass
hidden moss
They were all red in my first playthrough
Ouch, I eat when it’s not fully white anymore, like the top turns a bit grey, and I feed him ;p
I rly dislike low cores😄
frigid cloud
They were all red in my first playthrough
Cause I didn't understand what they did so left it like that nowadays even if it's just a little bit low I still eat
hidden moss
Haha yup xD
uncut topaz
Wow you can see Saint Denis from “the loft” at the very top of the map, crazy
latent plover
I remember I used to think “this is so unnecessary why do I need to clean my guns and feed my character jeez”
Tbf I still think cleaning guns is a chore
But I understand Arthur’s gotta eat
hidden moss
Tbf I still think cleaning guns is a chore
Eh it only takes a few secs😄
hushed flare
Man I feel like I clean my guns every spec of dust
hidden moss
Same, I clean em as soon as they lose 1/4th of the bar
hushed flare
Trinkets + wraps
hidden moss
Just feels better, you can get gun oil from any NPC by killing em anyway
hushed flare
Jup?
tidal raptor
But I understand Arthur’s gotta eat
Not only that there’s the weight system I think it’s neat how it works
latent plover
Yeah details
hushed flare
The weight system is sort of unexplained
Especially how there is like 3 different perfect weight levels and stuff and I still don't know how to maintain a weight
hidden moss
obese = more health less stamina
anorexic = less health more stamina
becoming anorexic is easy, just barely eat anything and fill your health core with minor things like biscuits instead of big game meat
golden storm
I havent eat anything lol
hidden moss
as for becoming obese, just eat alot
hushed flare
Perfect weight gives -15% core drain rate in every core but it's so weird to maintain
hidden moss
Weight system shouldn't exist lol
hushed flare
Not really broken just kind of unexplained
hidden moss
I understand how it works
hushed flare
They don't teach you how to really raise the weight because it's not just eat mindless and raise weight
And they never teach player calories
hidden moss
They just couldn't get it worked properly tbh
U lose weight in one day
After eating a whole big meat.
hushed flare
Im pretty sure you have to get that zing sound to raise weight
hidden moss
Yeah
hushed flare
Like you filled a core up sound
fierce cave
What does the short barrel for the schofield do
hushed flare
Nothing
golden storm
mmm that meat is so tender 
candid walrus
ok
round hedge
Perfect weight gives -15% core drain rate in every core but it's so weird to mai...
it's bugged
they broke the weight system after 1.00
mighty pecan
i don’t think my weights ever been anything other than ‘average’ on both Arthur and John
round hedge
wish there were mods to get rid of useless or annoying mechanics
cleaning guns, taking care of horses and weight system
now that would be pog
also getting rid of temperature system for characters
rocky wren
I was playing single player and found the sheep that’s in the shed at that one farm with the bow and the rigs alive and moving and I killed it
Kinda weird
fierce cave
Nothing<:kek:853319794416680960>
Whats the point of it then
hushed flare
Nothing
odd cape
steep epoch
What does the short barrel for the schofield do
makes it a snubnose.
pastel rampart
Show ur henta mr morgan
hidden moss
Can someome please help me, i am trying to remove my gloves, on my horse, but no option is showing up to in the wheel
some threads on google said u can
steep epoch
go to the second wheel page
bottom left
you can't be moving on the horse though
you need to stop moving
please not hentai Arthur
steep epoch
are you in chapter 1 rn?
hidden moss
nope in 3
steep epoch
hmm
reload the game if the damn gloves bother ya so much
or go to a tailor/clothing change
vast elk
can u eat snakemeat?
frigid cloud
Eat the snake itself 
steep epoch
I just burn snakes cause they annoy me.
frigid cloud
Average white arabian user
warped root
Average white arabian user
I just tamed it lmao
warped root
Ready to get bucked off over a snake? <:cowboykekw:712116098748907564>
always has been
frigid cloud
Is white the worst out of all Arabians
warped root
no brown is i think
warped root
google it lmao idk
frigid cloud
Rose gray is best right
warped root
oh ok
frigid cloud
I think so at least
warped root
as in prettyness or stats?
frigid cloud
Stats
warped root
hmmm
frigid cloud
Health and stamina can be maxed if fully bonded
Meanwhile black Arabian level 9-8 for health and stamina
warped root
yes my new one is at lvl 1 and already has more health and stamina than my previous lvl 4 horse
gentle dew
Anyone encountered crashing with latest nvidia drivers? My game won't start, not sure whether to downgrade.
latent plover
A zombie apocalypse would be good for Rdr2
Oh well. No use dreaming about the impossible
warped root
less gooo
golden storm
just broke john out of jail
dutch villain arc?
ope now we're banned from the east nice
no
warped root
meaning good job
golden storm
no the internet spoiled it bc I looked stuff up for help and it was like "oh yeah arthur? he dies lol. dead. totally dead. rip in pieces I guess."
faint thistle
Question
warped root
what you smoking bro i need some of that
faint thistle
Do deadeye hits count for your accuracy even when your target should be dead?
Like if a dude dies from 3 repeater shots but I paint him a dozen times with deadeye, will that count against me even if they all hit?
Say I shoot someone with a gun that kills them in 3 hits
But I shoot them using deadeye tags about 7 times
Do the extra shots that come after they're technically dead count against my accuracy or not?
So I can offset crappy prior accuracy by marking someone with 20 shots?
So like, an npc dies in x amounts of hits
Ohhh, I get you
warped root
they dont i guess think of it like if the game you aimbot would it give you accuracy
latent plover
Nah they don’t count
faint thistle
Oh, thanks yall
Was wondering if I could offset missed shots by filling npcs with bullets in deadeye
Nice
Which one?
He's a beast
Iirc they shouldnt
The deed has u keep em anyway right
The toughest ones are pestilence and death
Yeah 😂
None of them are
Also they steer south
If you snag death he instakills zombies
Pops heads
Rdr2 has better horse balance 😂
I actually didnt know they could go at a gallop for actual minutes
No clue
golden storm
wait Milton died
why is he in the Cornwall mission then
he died in chapter 5
oh
oh
I thought he died in the fight after guarma
yeah I thought he was dead lol
this game has so many missions lol 😅
oh my goodness
okokoo
do I have to do my active stranger missions
like before im john
frigid cloud
No
golden storm
ok cool
frigid cloud
You still can continue doing them as john
golden storm
good
frigid cloud
Hall donation, Mrs downes and what else
golden storm
yeah what's up with arthur running into Mrs Downes like all the time
yes
he gave me tb
nope
he died later
and gave me tb
yes
I wonder who else arthur infected
latent plover
Mr Downes a noob
Didn’t have the decency to tell Arthur to stay away or he’ll be sick too
red pond
I have a question about trapper please, do i have to sale him animal skins first so can craft clothes with it ? Normal ones, not legendary
frigid cloud
You have to sell it first then you'll be able to craft
hidden moss
I left a group in RDO because i was fucking lonely without a mic lmao
analog oyster
I left a group in RDO because i was fucking lonely without a mic lmao
That's why mic is a priority these days
analog oyster
Ah. Well I did. We have 1 that hasn't got a mic but said he'd get one soon. So we let him in
hidden moss
Those people made me feel like I don't have friends
analog oyster
Well I can be your friend
hidden moss
Thanks for your service.
analog oyster
🧑✈️
hidden moss
Me too
Wait no. He's too old for WW2
Good god. A WW2 Rockstar Game
Nah. I prefer Adult Jack in 1916 WW1
Making his Pa proud in WW1
He dosen't even need to scream for his mother. He has deadeye
golden storm
red dead redemption 2? more like train robbing simulator
analog oyster
👏
golden storm
could rdr and gta be in the same universe
analog oyster
🤔
vast elk
Jack dies in WW1
golden storm
ughhh chapter 6 is so long lol
it's 19 missions
I mean missions
I have done 5 in the last 3 hours what
I'm kinda taking my time though
WOAH
that's quick
I started on June 22nd
I havent played it lol
faint thistle
How long does being drunk last on rdr2
vast elk
How do I continue? @hidden moss
Im losing the urge
This game
I hate doing challenges & fishing
Should I just play the missions?
faint thistle
The braithwaite raid is a classic
frigid cloud
There's no force to do challenges early on
hushed flare
Average bandit challenges in chapter 3 enjoyers
frigid cloud
Average bandit challenges in chapter 3 enjoyers
Where's average herbalist challenges in chapter 2 enjoyers
hushed flare
braithwaite manor probably
hushed flare
Where's average herbalist challenges in chapter 2 enjoyers
Average herbalist 9 in chapter 2 enthusiast
frigid cloud
Can you avoid sniper hitting you if you're in first person mode
Or he'll hit you eventually
hushed flare
Wagon glitch maybe
frigid cloud
He said it OMG
vast elk
are the satchels worth the trouble?
frigid cloud
No
frigid cloud
Feel like they could've added a trophy for crafting it as arthur
hushed flare
chapter 2 legend of the east satchel owners
hidden moss
Average modder chp1 all items unlocked enjoyers 
sinful knot
Can you disable NA sniper somehow?
Yea
Either way you can just put yourself into godmode
frigid cloud
No wonder why we don't have an invincibility cheat code
rocky wren
What if micahs name is micah because irl Micah is a rock that looks like gold it has the nick name of fools gold so Micah made us believe he was fine until chapter 6
heady anchor
amber portal
For horseman 10 does it give u a checklist of which horses u have left
So u have to keep track urself damn
latent plover
For horseman 10 does it give u a checklist of which horses u have left
Yes
When you click whatever button it is to look at your challenges, click into it again and it gives you a list
Well yes you probably just didn’t see it, it wouldn’t disappear for you
Hmm only if you want 100% otherwise forget it
Well you get a satisfying cutscene and an achievement
I think that’s it
It could be somewhere in the settings instead
hushed flare
30/90
Hope your ready for gambler challenges
Also mission replays help with challenges like weapon expert
round hedge
if we got an outfit as good as legend of the west
I'd definitely tryhard on the challenges
challenges in RDR2 are boring as fuck
and way too hard
frigid cloud
If you complete a challenge in a replay and finish the mission and it carries over if that's what you're asking
frigid cloud
Eh I just did 100% for platinum trophy otherwise I would have not bothered
hushed flare
There's some challenges like kill people with crafted shotgun ammo and you can use mission replay to kill enemies and keep the shotgun ammo
And there's one that's "kill 9 enemies from behind stealthily with a bow"
frigid cloud
Yeah use the mission where you save eagle flies
Might need to replay twice not sure
Yes
As long as you finish the mission
Nope fortunately
huh
Could you replay the debt mission to keep getting consistent cougars?
Or is that unreplayable
The one near strawberry
In chapter 3 lol
It has one white cougar but probably unreplayable
latent plover
Probably
vast elk
I can't believe I just spent like 30 min finding squirrels
hushed flare
Man I feel like I find squirrels everywhere
vast elk
Yes unless u want perfect variant
lean hedge
ok
remote wave
Horse balls
frigid cloud
Flying horse
Next dlc: animations are sped up in singleplayer
What'd be the best looking game?
does it get graphical updates every week?
turbid ore
frigid cloud
A lot changes between 1899-1907
Even though the only difference I know is saint denis trolley doesn't have Cornwall name anymore in 1907
I forgot npcs change too
Is 1899 tumbleweed sheriff and 1907 tumbleweed sheriff the same?
round hedge
does it get graphical updates every week?
RDR2 gets downgraded over updates lol
graphics downgraded
round hedge
Is 1899 tumbleweed sheriff and 1907 tumbleweed sheriff the same?
new austin doesn't have a 1907 version
frigid cloud
oh
round hedge
they didn't give a shit into making it accurate
armadillo is still stuck in 1899 and macfarlane's barn is nowhere to be seen
The amount of effort they put in the game and mfs are moaning 🤓 🤓 🤓 🤓
the effort and details of epilogue 😩😩
rockstar spent 8 years and mfs moaning 🤓
because it's legit in their first game dumbass lmao
arctic wren
Dude why’re you being an arsehole
hushed flare
round hedge
Dude why’re you being an arsehole
why not
arctic wren
Cause there’s no need
hushed hatch
Hello
hushed flare
Lovely pfp sir
People liked it so much someone in this server copied it(except they have a different hat)
hushed flare
meh they aren't impersonating so idc
arctic wren
I actually like Micah Bell up until after Guarma
Like he was one of my favourite characters
dire sentinel
Did you get revenge
john marston moment
arctic wren
If only John listened to Arthur when he told him to not look back
hushed flare
me riding up to profile copiers house killing 15 of his gang just to kill him/sarcasm
arctic wren
Rdr1’s story wouldnt have happened
dire sentinel
me riding up to profile copiers house killing 15 of his gang just to kill him/sa...
then edgar ross comes to your house :)
hushed flare
then edgar ross comes to your house :)
sad
round hedge
Rdr1’s story wouldnt have happened
it would
dire sentinel
Not really
john bought the house with his name tho
round hedge
micah was retconned but john would still get fucked up, the FBI received orders from Nate Johns to get rid of all outlaws
and John was on the list
arctic wren
john bought the house with his name tho
Ah forgot about that
hushed flare
was John just forgotten until he killed micah
round hedge
so he'd get fucked up anyway
hushed flare
assuming John didn't commit a 1500 bounty massacre in every state
arctic wren
I think they thought he was dead until they found Micah
round hedge
was John just forgotten until he killed micah
in RDR at least he was "arrested" because of his bad deeds during the van der linde gang time
arctic wren
Shot in a robbery gone wrong at the end of rdr2, didn’t see him again
round hedge
in rdr2 tho they made it because of revenge = bad
hushed hatch
Can anyone help me?
arctic wren
Can anyone help me?
What’s up
hushed hatch
It was working fine one day the next it’s buggered
arctic wren
Getting mad FPS lag not too sure why
Ah I don’t know how to help with that sorry
arctic wren
Not really, sorry
hushed flare
is your ram clogged
round hedge
It was working fine one day the next it’s buggered
typical rdr2
hushed hatch
typical rdr2
Yup
arctic wren
Maybe it’s your wifi
hushed flare
when you go into saint Denis and your fps drops 20 frames - average pc user
arctic wren
Thats a joke
frigid cloud
Who's the imposter
hushed flare
your red name
dire sentinel
i just finished a fisher of fish 
mighty pecan
guys guys, so i spent about 15 minutes straight in a shop buying all the cigarette cards and i got them all but i got no achievement saying i did even though it clearly said 144 out of 144
help?
frigid cloud
Did you visit the guy
dire sentinel
and did u mail them?
frigid cloud
Post them
mighty pecan
wait im supposed to post them?
mighty pecan
uhh maybe lemme check
frigid cloud
When you check logs it says mailed them and empty box
For that quest
When you mail them it's over I think
sand apex
LOL
frigid cloud
A few days later you get your awards
mighty pecan
bruh
sand apex
imagine having all cards after AGES and just selling then
thats painfuk
u got an autosave or sum?
hushed flare
YOU SOLD ALL 144 CARDS LOL
mighty pecan
u got an autosave or sum?
yeah im just loading up the game
sand apex
good
mighty pecan
YOU SOLD ALL 144 CARDS LOL
I DID AND ITS SO PAINFUL
dire sentinel
I DID AND ITS SO PAINFUL
well, not as painful as searching in the wild for the 144 cards
but yeah, i didn’t run around the states for them
mighty pecan
im loading back to a save rn i can’t remember if its right
dire sentinel
good luck
frigid cloud
Doesn't the game tell to post them at a post office
frigid cloud
Wtf
frigid cloud
Next time that blog will tell you to sell the herbs you collected for herbalist 7
frigid cloud
Herbalist was fun compared to gambler
dire sentinel
oh dude im doing the herbalist stuff last
same
mighty pecan
im omw to saint denis rn to start the process again
hushed flare
Herbalist is pretty easy imo
dire sentinel
go to rhodes, i think someone told me the prices there are cheaper for cigs
hushed flare
Herbalist is pretty easy imo
Unless your arthur
mighty pecan
go to rhodes, i think someone told me the prices there are cheaper for cigs
Its fine, im playing as John
frigid cloud
Unless your arthur<:kek:853319794416680960>
Chapter 2 lote satchel owners be like: excuse me?
ripe wolf
Hey can anyone help me when I started the trader role I was in the middle of meeting cripps when my power went out and now I have no idea how to start the role. I don’t have a prompt or anything. What should I do.
hushed flare
Chapter 2 lote satchel owners be like: excuse me?
New Austin smh
ripe wolf
<#507661753497288704>
Sorry
mighty pecan
okay, starting now, wish me luck 😭
hushed flare
Covered wagon <:dutchsmart:644244986900119572>
War wagon in sp when
frigid cloud
New Austin smh
Tbh I thought you were talking about 7 not 9
Pearson sells cigarette cards cheaper for John
frigid cloud
In singleplayer eagle eye feels slow after returning from online
frigid cloud
Can you sell them at doctor
hushed flare
sell
old pond
I think you can send them to someone
hushed flare
As arthur
frigid cloud
Can you sell them anywhere
hushed flare
Can't sell them to trappers for some reason
frigid cloud
Hm, fence maybe?
keen birchBOT
Read if Arthur sucks.
frigid cloud
latent plover
Can't sell them to trappers for some reason<:pepw:796651677289021470>
Can you discard them
golden storm
rip my horse
mighty pecan
ok i finally got all the sets of cards and i went to post them but the option to post mail was greyed out??
native thunder
ok i finally got all the sets of cards and i went to post them but the option to...
you sure u got a full set?
frigid cloud
Check from logs
frigid cloud
Did you visit the guy at flatneck station?
That happened to me, tried to post everything without visiting the requester
native thunder
not entirely sure tbh
native thunder
there's some glitches with arthur and john stuff
mighty pecan
yeah im going to flatneck station rn to check
wraith panther
Is there a way to rob a gunsmith without them pulling a gun on you?
like in St. Dennis
wraith panther
vey simple ty
hidden moss
<:sadart:512820686859927562> <:revolverleft:752651324100706424> <:micah:66173846...
Love it
shy mulch
man horseman 9 sucks as arthur
frigid cloud
Is there a way to rob a gunsmith without them pulling a gun on you?
While doing bandit 3,I noticed if he shoots you once and you knock him out and no law
Oddly enough it works
shy mulch
ma horse started pathfinding near a rock and all those bitch ass pinkertons shot me up
frigid cloud
Potent health cure
frigid cloud
noice
hidden moss
I wasted 10 health cures because of the diamond opportunity in Blood Money
frigid cloud
Wish we had madam Nazar in sp so we could buy plants quickly and craft things quicker
hidden moss
True true
Or maybe that herbalist guy
I forgot his name but he gives you a special miracle tonic
shy mulch
doesn't matter if u pop a health cure if they all collectively aimbot you since your horse stopped sprinting
frigid cloud
Do it as john then simply
shy mulch
nah im saying fuck the pinkertons and the dev who decided to give lawmen aimbot and grinding that shit
shy mulch
I literally made it to beecher's hope the other attempt
just that windy path is annoying near the river
frigid cloud
I used that broken bridge near Riggs station
shy mulch
I was watching this video and the dude sped past the forest just before all the lawmen spawned he must have gotten lucky because whenever I'm that close to a bunch of lawmen they'll just rip through my cores in a second
frigid cloud
What video are you watching?
shy mulch
believe it was the first spawn
frigid cloud
Tell the name
shy mulch
guide by dylan quitoriano
hidden moss
Seeing the exotics list makes me want to go to a RDO gang and just sit there alone listening to people having fun in the party while i'm there not having a goddamn mic.
red helm
Yea I was rewatching
I've tried doing Horseman 9 as Arthur. Ouf. It's hugely luck based on where the Lawmen spawn in that windy path just south of the Owanjila Dam. Which you obviously already guessed.
frigid cloud
Average broken bridge enjoyers