I misread sorry
#red-dead-singleplayer
frigid cloud
wraith panther
nice
frigid cloud
Actually there are multiple maps and only final location has gold bars
hidden moss
had a theory i was testing if anyone wants to check it out
when you grab someone and drown them underwater if you hit square (i spammed it to make sure it was pressed no matter what) you'll only drown them to the point of a knockout where as if you press circle (spammed it same as last time to be sure) you'll drown them and kill them from it
the game brings up no indicators when its happening
i think thats how it works but im not sure so if anyone wants to test it that would be really cool
native thunder
what do you mean
how do you grab an npc and use square to drown? isn't square to throw them some distance away
latent plover
Yeah when you tackle them into water you automatically move to drowning them
latent plover
Yeah
empty mist
like
when u tackle someone in shallow water
instead of chocking them
you just shove their face in it
latent plover
Yeah exactly, try it in butchers creek
empty mist
Thats sum attention to detial
latent plover
You can’t stop it either
late laurel
!pbrename
hushed flare
Reject lasso tackle become drown tackle
gilded grove
Hullo there ! Just joined the community. Nice to meet ya 😌
hidden moss
You can’t stop it either
Thats why I had my theory of using square to only knock them out with it
I think its correct as I did it but had to hop off before I could do it over and over to be 100% sure
hidden moss
Hullo there ! Just joined the community. Nice to meet ya 😌
If it'd yiur first time playing just be aware spoilers are allowed in this chat and untagged so use at ur own caution
gilded grove
Would anyone kindly tell me if it is actually possible to free a prisonner from wagon driven by law officers without getting a bounty or wanted ? Even when wearing mask and different clothes i'm recognized. This is getting annoying because i'm trying to get robberies location clues and it seems you cant get them otherwise than doing low honor stuff
hidden moss
The law sees through the mask
hushed flare
Well shoot the lock and kill the guards
hidden moss
Only npcs don't
gilded grove
Lmao. Even if i shoot them without anyone around i get wanted and bounty lol
hidden moss
Mhm
hushed flare
Kill 2 lawman in the middle of who knows and get a 30$ bounty because a ant saw your crime
gilded grove
So true. Seems wanted logic is broken in this game
hidden moss
Thebgame has such weird moments of realism and immersion and this shit is broken af
gilded grove
Lol
hidden moss
When someone witnesses their own assault
hushed flare
And gun smiths are understandable ig
It would be funny if all gun smiths were just Uber powerful with guns and could one shot you
gilded grove
Yes. I love the game so far this is my first playthrough. World is perfect and all but wtf did they do with law system. You get magically wanted even alone in a desert
hushed flare
When someone witnesses their own assault
The game will have people come back from the dead to report their own death if you give it enough time
hidden moss
How
hushed flare
Respawning npcs are annoying
hidden moss
When the games so broke u can't tell thats a joke
hidden moss
My game has been so stuttery and freezing lately
And rofkstar 100 percent degraded graphics from day 1
gilded grove
Or you get weapon seller that lock people in his cave to replace his lost son then goes back to work the following day telling you he dont trust you and watches you. Lmao
hushed flare
At least you get arguably the best repeater in the game
hidden moss
Bolt action rifle is my favourite gun
hushed flare
Have you tried carcano
hidden moss
I dont remember when or why but it just is
hushed flare
One shots people in the chest from across the world
hidden moss
Lol
frigid cloud
get it early with uncle's companion activity in chapter 4
frigid cloud
What else can you collect
gilded grove
So far, while i'm satisfied with the game, story and world, i'm finding difficulty with the grinding hunting system. Basically all upgrades, clothes, camp stuff have to be acquired with perfect pelt. Its really putting me off sometimes. Im at chapter 4 and i dont even have 10% of camp upgrades. Soooo boring apart from legendary animals hunt
hushed flare
What else can you collect
You can do all the challenges (including herbalist 9 with a trick) and you can get all guns and your still Arthur and still have a camp idfk
frigid cloud
That trick doesn't work anymore does it
frigid cloud
So far, while i'm satisfied with the game, story and world, i'm finding difficul...
It'd not make any sense if you needed poor pelt for something
frigid cloud
Carcasses then 
frigid cloud
I think hunting is fun.
gilded grove
In the end arthur is pretty much slaughtering the whole eco system to get anything.
It is at first
frigid cloud
except when you need to get perfect opossum 
gilded grove
But after 100 dead animals its not
frigid cloud
well difficulty is at top when you're doing hunting requests lol
hushed flare
Hunting gets annoying when it takes 8 flipping bullfrogs to get a perfect one because all of them kept spawning 2 stars
modern minnow
Rockstars unmatched game design
ikr
wraith panther
At least you get arguably the best repeater in the game
The Lancaster Repeater?
hushed flare
Ye
heady anchor
Altleast I get to use lemat and carcano in chapter 4 earliest
How do you get the carcano early?
frigid cloud
do the companion activity with uncle for rustling when you scare away the other rustlers shoot the lock and go into the homestead then wake up the rancher he carries a carcano
hidden moss
The Lancaster Repeater?
I don't get why it's good asf
Accuracy? I've seen Carbine with better stats
hidden moss
No. It's cleaned
wraith panther
I compared it to Carbine, and it's worse than Carbine
hushed flare
How lol
wraith panther
Damage and a few other stata
hidden moss
Me too
hidden moss
I got scammed when i bought it when folks told me it's the best repeater
hushed flare
Why would you need damage
wraith panther
You bought it?
hidden moss
Yeah
hushed flare
Especially so small
hidden moss
In Online
hushed flare
7 ammo
frigid cloud
use dead eye to reload 
frigid cloud
no but activating dead eye reloads your gun
frigid cloud
yes
wraith panther
Bruh
hushed flare
use dead eye to reload <:dutchsmart:644244986900119572>
lemat revolver moment
wraith panther
Is there anyway to get the LeMat revolver before Chapter 4?
hushed flare
nah
hushed flare
well I say it's better then the schofield
hidden moss
no but activating dead eye reloads your gun
Oh
No wonder fuckers in Online keeps finishing me off with those
hushed flare
Schofield feels like the Arabian of revolvers
hidden moss
Schofield feels like the Arabian of revolvers
True
wraith panther
Why is there so much hate for Arabians smh
hidden moss
Why is there so much hate for Arabians smh
Too stupid
frigid cloud
In online it doesn't work
Ive tried it and no activating dead eye in online doesn't reload your gun
hidden moss
True
hushed flare
Oh and also they are small asf
hidden moss
And they jump off a cliff for no reason
hushed flare
So
wraith panther
Fair
unborn iron
The hecK?
Uncle just took off his pants
And
his B*tt was exposed
hidden moss
And they buck the fuck outta you when you're trying to get a escaping bounty
hushed flare
Just use a MFT, has very similar stats but no elite handling like it actually does a damn thing
wraith panther
Uncle wants private time
hushed flare
MFT or Turkoman
hidden moss
The hecK?
Uncle just took off his pants
And
his B*tt was exposed
I've seen Bill with those pajamas
wraith panther
MFT or Turkoman
Ty
hushed flare
Same with lemat
Also what's up with navy
Why is it so "good"
besides it's looks
hidden moss
Because of the accuracy
It's fast asf for headshots
I have it as a starter revolver
wraith panther
Because it has the word navy in it
hidden moss
And later become my secondary revolver for my off-hand holster
Variant Schofield as my main one
hidden moss
Spinning the Navy Revolver is fucking satisfying
wraith panther
I only wish that we could upgrade ammo capacity or something
hidden moss
It really made it look big
wraith panther
How do you spin on pc?
hushed flare
when you spin the sawed off shotgun and shoot yourself with incendiary
hidden moss
I only wish that we could upgrade ammo capacity or something
True. I want to upgrade the capacity to my Springfield and Pump-Action Shotgun
wraith panther
That's what I call a big brain move
frigid cloud
Springfield is deadly with express ammo
hidden moss
I agree
hushed flare
I only wish that we could upgrade ammo capacity or something
I wish we could upgrade ammo space
wraith panther
when you spin the sawed off shotgun and shoot yourself with incendiary<:troll:85...
Kill yourself so that the cops can't kill you
hushed flare
Springfield is deadly with express ammo
Carcano also
hidden moss
Kill yourself so that the cops can't kill you
They tried.
frigid cloud
Carcano also
Yep
wraith panther
50 round Revolver
hushed flare
Carcano bad because it auto scopes so no ooga booga auto aim noooo!!!!!
wraith panther
Take out an army in dead eye
hidden moss
Take out an army in dead eye
hushed flare
does anyone actually use scopes on repeaters
frigid cloud
no
hidden moss
no
wraith panther
You can put a scope on a repeater?
hasty totem
hi
wraith panther
I need to start upgrading stuff
hushed flare
You can put a scope on a repeater?
yes but it's so unnecessary
wraith panther
Scoped shotgun
hushed flare
Evans repeater with a scope
wraith panther
Is a 20x Zoom thermal scope a good investment for a sawed off shotgun?
frigid cloud
There's no scope on shotguns as far as I know
wraith panther
My immersion is ruined
I'm sure that I could've attached a scope to my shotgun in the 1890s
It's definitely highly practical
hushed flare
Scoped bow when
hidden moss
Also add a shoulder handle for a revolver
wraith panther
They need to embrace the gta shotgun style
hidden moss
Would be cool tho. Reminds me of that scene in "For A Few Dollars More"
wraith panther
Silenced scoped automatic shotgun
hushed flare
For some reason wrap makes weapons wear down slower
wraith panther
Wrap?
hidden moss
For some reason wrap makes weapons wear down slower
I love putting cloth wrap in my weapons
wraith panther
What's that
hidden moss
It looks so badass
hidden moss
I am lvl. 39 and still use cloth wraps
wraith panther
I've been playing rdr2 for like 4 days ok
unborn rose
And sawed off shotgun
wraith panther
It does sadden me that there's only one sidearm main shotgun
frigid cloud
y tf are you so obsessed with shotguns
hidden moss
y tf are you so obsessed with shotguns
It's fucking great
frigid cloud
when someone pulls out a carcano
wraith panther
Because you go pew pew pew pew pew and their Head, arms and legs are gone
frigid cloud
you should try executing people with shotgun 
hidden moss
you should try executing people with shotgun <:neghonor:512094734605615104>
I did that to a bunch of O'Driscolls
I tied one up and made him watch his friends get their heads blown off
And he still screams mom jokes on Arthur
wraith panther
My only problem is how to tie multiple people up
hidden moss
My only problem is how to tie multiple people up
Lasso
frigid cloud
Lasso
hidden moss
Press Circle
wraith panther
Since while I'm tying one person up, the rest are going to murder me
frigid cloud
I swear lasso animations are SO SLOW compared to online
wraith panther
I'm on pc
hidden moss
I prefer tackling them and tying them up
hidden moss
I swear lasso animations are SO SLOW compared to online
I agree. I got so fucking tired of it in Singleplayer
wraith panther
How much faster are they in online?
frigid cloud
2x
hidden moss
Nothing. They just don't tie the legs
hushed flare
Online reload animations be like
frigid cloud
Nothing. They just don't tie the legs
Yes and they still become tied
hidden moss
Weird how fast asf you can parkour in Online fast compared to Young Johnny Marston
frigid cloud
in sp he puts their hands together and goes to tie up the legs much longer
wraith panther
Also btw, who are some terrible people who I can kill in sp? Except for the Aberdeens and Sonny
frigid cloud
Also btw, who are some terrible people who I can kill in sp? Except for the Aber...
Murfree brood gang
wraith panther
Justice calls then, thank you
hushed flare
Murfree brood gang
Me raiding beaver hollow for the 81722882828th time
hidden moss
Me raiding beaver hollow for the 81722882828th time
Same with Shady Bell
frigid cloud
Do gang hideouts respawn
wraith panther
Also for the Killer Prostitute, can I help her get rid of the bodies and then tie her up and deliver her to the Sheriff?
hidden moss
I just tied a Bounty Hunter and go to the exact location where Arthur and Micah fought and cut his ropes
frigid cloud
Phew, I was leaving a few enemies alive before leaving it so it respawns
hushed flare
Also.murfreess drop burdock root and ginseng alot. But I've seen violet snowdrops and yarrow
Murfrees are accidentally a plant farm
frigid cloud
Could be useful for herbalist 7 maybe
frigid cloud
yes
frigid cloud
I think only fills up the core
hushed flare
No it's for health stuff
frigid cloud
But doesn't give health xp
hushed flare
Like tonics
But then again potent miracle tonic exists
So special health cure and snake oil isnt that practical
wraith panther
I must say the stuff that fills your cores up completely and fortifies them are really easy to come by
frigid cloud
You can't carry much with regular satchel
hushed flare
Well. LOTE satchel exists
hushed flare
Very worth it
slate badger
guys is there anything wrong with my game I want to do some hunting requests for 100% completion but the posters don't spawn
frigid cloud
I got it in chapter 2 early on
hushed flare
man
frigid cloud
guys is there anything wrong with my game I want to do some hunting requests for...
Maybe because you already picked it up
Check your log to see if hunting request is active
red helm
guys is there anything wrong with my game I want to do some hunting requests for...
The poster isn't marked by a mission, you literally have to find it hanging on a post office or train station wall.
hushed flare
may rdr2 Jesus spawn perfect quality birds
red helm
Fragging birds...
frigid cloud
Is it possible to do it without dead eye?
hushed flare
Probably with varmint rifle + buck trinket
hushed flare
I coulnt be fucked though to no deadeye a robin with a bow
red helm
Thor, Zeus, Ra, Make this bird carcass perfect!
hushed flare
What's stupid is on another playthrough save file I found a robin on a bridge when as John i never did
Arthur chapter 2
John is Robin repellant
frigid cloud
Is dominoes rng based
hushed flare
Gambling
red helm
most gambling is rng based.
hushed flare
most
red helm
Well, Five Finger Filet really isn't.
frigid cloud
Blackjack is worst
red helm
It's technically gambling..
frigid cloud
Poker is meh
hushed flare
win blackjack with 3 hits or more 3 times
frigid cloud
It's not as bad as blackjack
wraith panther
Btw does Five Finger Filet just go until you can't pay anymore?
red helm
Btw does Five Finger Filet just go until you can't pay anymore?
I guess, I've never bothered going past the third guy though.
frigid cloud
I never beaten the second opponent in five finger fillet
Can't be bothered to press multiple buttons
hushed flare
Button combos go from A X X X X to A X Y B Z after like 1 second
red helm
Yeah, the third round is yicks...
hushed flare
In FFF
red helm
Far easier ways to make money, than that.
hushed flare
just bet all 5$ in blackjack and win 5$
somehow it works
I've even gotten blackjacks with more then 5$ bets
red helm
They really needed a higher stakes for those.
red helm
Indeed, the game on the boat was sweet.
hushed flare
Can't have the community complaining that some arse pulled a royal flush
In 300$ pot
When you had a straight flush
red helm
Yes, a legit game, for $10's, or $100's. would've been cool.
red helm
This 15 cents or whatever, just is a joke.
red helm
Yeap, nuts to that.
frigid cloud
I got robbed on purpose in saint Denis because I saw a video where you could go back and kill the guy who robbed you but didn't work so I lost 1000+$
red helm
That special encounter?
hushed flare
I mean what the heck did people was going to happen
Shady guy leads you to dark alley at 2 am
In promise of navy revolver in story mode
frigid cloud
I mean what the heck did people was going to happen
Get 1000$
frigid cloud
and I did the serial killer mission with Arthur but didn't kill him when he grabbed sheriff so I didn't get the 20$
hushed flare
Mission failed sheriff died
frigid cloud
you probably know this but sheriff kills him eventually
wraith panther
Sheriff kills who?
hushed flare
he kills dn
wraith panther
Danny Nerworker?
hushed flare
No Deez nuts
frigid cloud
Sheriff kills who?
Serial killer.
wraith panther
Makes sense
frigid cloud
I think I prefer 70 gold medals over 100%
hushed flare
Nah.
frigid cloud
y
hushed flare
It's only the last 10% that's the worry
70 gold medals would take much longer especially some tedious missions making you replay it way more times then needed
Stupid timed missions
wraith panther
Are there any rewards for getting a gold medal?
frigid cloud
It counts towards the trophy
Nothing in game
Unless you like the look of a gold medal
Imagine there are like 120 or 150 challenges in rdr3
wraith panther
I wonder what RDR3 will be like
frigid cloud
we'll never know
hidden moss
I wonder what RDR3 will be like
It's a mystery
It's either gonna be a completely new story, Young Hosea and Dutch or Jack in WW1
frigid cloud
or they make it an actual irl game
wraith panther
tbf I doubt that Rockstar has any plans to actually release any new games this century.
hidden moss
I'm expecting Bully 2
wraith panther
Was Bully made by Rockstar?
hidden moss
Because RDR2 had alot of Bully references
frigid cloud
Ofc
hidden moss
Yeah
wraith panther
bruh
frigid cloud
Or we play as charles when he leaves John's ranch
wraith panther
I never played Bully
hidden moss
Or we play as charles when he leaves John's ranch
He defends his home from Pinkertons in Canada
hushed flare
Imagine there are like 120 or 150 challenges in rdr3
Can't wait for "win blackjack with 8 hits or more 20 times in a row while on no cores and while In a gunfight with Landon rickets ghost"
hidden moss
I never played Bully
Play it
frigid cloud
lmao
hidden moss
It's a goddamn masterpiece
wraith panther
Is it GTA as a kid?
frigid cloud
Kind of
hidden moss
Kinda
hushed flare
Meh
hidden moss
But it has a unique style
It ain't a GTA Clone. I hate it when people call open world games with driving and laws "GTA Clones"
hushed flare
All I know about bully is 2 headed human so
frigid cloud
Can't wait for "win blackjack with 8 hits or more 20 times in a row while on no ...
They'll definitely make it in a row this time if it ever comes out
wraith panther
It ain't a GTA Clone. I hate it when people call open world games with driving a...
Someone once called Watchdogs 2 a GTA clone
hidden moss
Someone once called Watchdogs 2 a GTA clone
Fuck him
hushed flare
And then we will have hunting requests ending up with perfect ant pelt
hidden moss
I literally just wanna play Sleeping Dogs without people calling it a GTA Clone
hushed flare
And there spawn is broken like moose and they spawn with 1-2 star 99% of the time
hidden moss
I literally just wanna play Sleeping Dogs without people calling it a GTA Clone
And yes it's a masterpiece hidden gem
hushed flare
And yes it's a masterpiece hidden gem
I assume sleeping dogs is about dogs sleeping right
Press X to sleep
frigid cloud
wraith panther
Put a dog to sleep by punching it unconscious
hushed flare
frigid cloud
Do you have to do something to be able to buy M1889
I don't think I saw it in the catalogue
red helm
I think it's just at the Saint Denis Gunsmith in Chapter 4.
Or, at least, after chapter 4.
red helm
I also have seen Bronte's men drop it, during missions. But, that's also in Chapter 4, so...
wraith panther
coolness
frigid cloud
hushed flare
well
red helm
It's quite a good gun.
hushed flare
It feels like a semi auto pistol but cooler and less fire rate
Maybe that's the point
red helm
You're either aiming for the head, or just using Deadeye. So, fire rate is usually not that big of a deal with Pistols.
hushed flare
why aim for the head when you can use carcano
Good thing deadeye removes bloom with pistols
red helm
When they are to close...
hushed flare
Well. Hipfire Carano then
Even though the bloom is more crazy then Mauser/semi auto in some cases
red helm
Yeah, generally. I liked the M1899 more than the Midnight and Semi Auto. so, up to the player.
wraith panther
also what gets transferred from Arthur to John?
hushed flare
So is the meta then just m1899 with split point ammo
hushed flare
I wish gold bars got transferred
red helm
also what gets transferred from Arthur to John?
Guns, cloths, unique items..
red helm
To bad you can't wear the Reutlinger.
hushed flare
Well u can use it
frigid cloud
I swear liveries get removed once you're in epilogue
wraith panther
and stats?
red helm
They give you all these fancy clothes options, but then you can't add a pocket watch....
hushed flare
Lote vest is like the closest thing
wraith panther
like Deadeye, Health and stamina?
hushed flare
For me my John started with like level 5 health and stanima and level 8 deadeye
I think
frigid cloud
I never got maximum honor as john
red helm
No, John has all 7 stats, you only have to get them up to 8.
hidden moss
Yeah, generally. I liked the M1899 more than the Midnight and Semi Auto. so, up ...
Me too
hushed flare
Probably I got jacked on valerian root then
hidden moss
Having it dual wielded made me feel like Dante
frigid cloud
Can you max your stats out without buying gears?
hushed flare
No
wraith panther
I never got maximum honor as john
Imagine trying to get max honor
hushed flare
Just no
red helm
Can you max your stats out without buying gears?
You still need the challenge stuffs.
hushed flare
The game forces you to win blackjack 3 times with 3 hits or more and poker and dominos 3 times in a row before letting you have level 10 stanima
frigid cloud
hushed flare
red helm
The gambling challenges should've been for Deadeye level. I found that odd.
hushed flare
At least they left the most tedious challenge set for the least important core
hidden moss
Mightnight -looks- cooler, but, stat wise, I switched.
I came for the fire rate
frigid cloud
which ones
hushed flare
Who needs a lot of stamina when you almost die from going knee deep into water
frigid cloud
Oh yeah also challenges give dead eye, stamina and health xp
red helm
I came for the fire rate
Of course, I just meant, looks wise, Midnight is nice. But... oh well.
hushed flare
And who runs for so much time they deplete a level 9-10 core
frigid cloud
Does honor make a dialogue difference in epilogue
where
lol
Are you talking about the mission where Charles talks about arthur
No I mean in missions
Ah
Well that was Arthur's honor
I'm talking about John's honor
If his honor makes a difference in missions
ah okay seems like there's not much honor can do in epilogue other than discounts
Bet
vast elk
Can u get max honor?
frigid cloud
Not till chapter 6
vast elk
How
frigid cloud
Greet people
vast elk
Do u not do missions
frigid cloud
That's y fishing is best
vast elk
Bandit challenges fucked up my mediocre honor
wraith panther
Donating to the camp fucks up my bad honor
vast elk
Greet people
"how do u do mister?"
"Now give me all you got!"
frigid cloud
Could you do first bandit challenge in armadillo without any worry about law
wraith panther
Wtf does Grimshaw actually do there?
frigid cloud
"how do u do mister?"
"Now give me all you got!"
Lol
wraith panther
"how do u do mister?"
"Now give me all you got!"
accurate
frigid cloud
Sometimes npcs deserve to be antagonized
wraith panther
and lassoed
frigid cloud
Run
hidden moss
And killed with a knife
frigid cloud
Lassoing nah
vast elk
When I first started I got in so much trouble cos the accidental presses of takedown button
hidden moss
Lol
wraith panther
lassoed and dragged into a river
frigid cloud
frigid cloud
"how do u do mister?"
"Now give me all you got!"
You should do the hidden stranger mission in swamps if you've ran out of stranger missions to do @hidden moss
hushed flare
Robbing armadillo is very honorable
hushed flare
Huh
vast elk
There isnt really much to do in st Denis is there?
frigid cloud
If you encounter one of the night folk's ambush you get a hidden mission
wraith panther
There isnt really much to do in st Denis is there?
kill everyone
vast elk
frigid cloud
Rob everyone in alleyways
save a man from being robbed then Rob him
Visit mr. Vampire
Kill that racist
Play poker
Go to theater
Take a bath
frigid cloud
wraith panther
Like I do when I save someone and immediately kill them
wraith panther
Even more money
wraith panther
Precisely
frigid cloud
And sell his body
frigid cloud
yes
wraith panther
sounds legit
frigid cloud
Very legit 100%%%%
wraith panther
just gonna ride around with a human carcass on my horse
frigid cloud
If you visit the bank first John says 'send the money to bank for me' to sadie but if you didn't visit it he says 'hold onto it for me I need to visit the manager over by the blackwater and get a loan for the property' instead
hushed flare
just gonna ride around with a human carcass on my horse
Make sure to have a skull mask also and while holding a dynamite arrow
vast elk
I havent yet met the vampire
rigid crane
i bought rdr2 today and i can't get past the loading screen cuz it says social club is down or smthn
any help
?
vast elk
Use vpn
rigid crane
don't have one
vast elk
U shouldn't need vpn
rigid crane
it says that i need to sign into social club to get it to work
but im already signed in
rigid crane
its weird cuz i can play gta v just fine
upbeat cradle
Guys what happened to Pearson I forgot
subtle knoll
he owns a shop and is married in rhodes
hushed harbor
robbed catfish jackson's, only knocked out algie and nate's acting like i killed him
the reticle was still red when i pointed a gun at him so he's still alive, maybe nate's just jumping to conclusions
wraith panther
Probably
native thunder
kill him too :)
wraith panther
Nate should learn to take a pulse
hushed harbor
i killed algie last playthrough and felt bad, i just knocked the gun out his hands and then socked him in the face
wraith panther
imagine having human emotions in rdr2
hushed harbor
i also felt bad when i collected algie's debt later and the house was just empty
wraith panther
hm
Max Honour playthrough?
tbf I felt bad for like 5 seconds after shooting the old woman in the head
but then had a lot of fun with my new shotgun
hidden moss
Max Honour playthrough?
Try it
wraith panther
never
hidden moss
A negative honor playthrough is fun no doubt, but shallow
vast elk
i killed algie last playthrough and felt bad, i just knocked the gun out his han...
Can u just lassoo the father?
hushed harbor
probably but i didnt really think of that
vast elk
dire sentinel
I like the guns I get on low honor play through
what guns?
opaque aurora
what’s the best way to get money fast legally
dire sentinel
treasure hunting, doing side quests with the gang, side missions, bounties, and uhh...
opaque aurora
what about the fastest way to get honor
dire sentinel
choosing honorable story mission options, helping strangers, greeting people, yeah yeah yeah
opaque aurora
k thanks
hidden moss
The amount of times I tried to get rid of the guy looking for Gavin-
vast elk
Tie him up
hidden moss
I do, and throw him in water- but he always comes back
odd cape
Maybe Gavin isn’t real
Maybe Nigel isn’t real
Maybe they’re both imagined by Arthur and John
Maybe Gavin was the friends we made along the way
or maybe
ARTHUR IS GAVIN?
prisma orchid
#FIXEPILOGUERDR2
little condor
Why
little condor
I put it, it's not even 2 hours old and it's a couple with gf
quick whale
K
little condor
before was andrew's spider man
opaque aurora
Maybe Gavin isn’t real
if you kill nigel and loot his body, he has a note that says Gavin is a split personality
red helm
You don't have to kill Nigel, you can hogtie and rob him, for the note.
prisma orchid
John morgan
arthur marston*
dire sentinel
arthur marston*
*jim milton
odd cape
if you kill nigel and loot his body, he has a note that says Gavin is a split pe...
It’s hinted at
limber palm
Hi
hidden moss
Hey
elfin kiln
Yknow
Sometimes I wanna shoot Susan
I put nearly 120 dollars of cash in the box
And then head out for a good week, treasure hunting, looting, fighting, making thousands for the gang. And of course, all that work and money just to head back to camp and “MR MoRgaN yOuvE StoPpEd PaYiNg In tHe BOXcshshhdhd”
prisma orchid
*jim milton
arthur marston*
dire sentinel
finally, i got all the carcasses for ms hobbs
hushed flare
And then head out for a good week, treasure hunting, looting, fighting, making t...
checks last donations
Arthur: 120 dollars
Charles: 2 chicken feathers
John: poor rabbit pet
Reverend: 5 whole cents
Sean: his own shit probably
vast elk
*checks last donations*
Arthur: 120 dollars
Charles: 2 chicken feathers
John: po...
Dont forget Micah
hushed flare
Micah donates once and I think it's like 20-50$ in some random event
hushed flare
Only 25 cents
dusky vault
Do i need full compendium in game to get the 100% completion role or just 100% on my game save?
hushed flare
Look at 100 percent requirements
vast elk
Imagine 100% ing rockstar game
dusky vault
where is that qwerty?
vast elk
Good thing thers no yoga shit in this game
hushed flare
where is that qwerty?
In progress smh
hushed flare
Wtf
dusky vault
ik in game u need 50 animals
hushed flare
No you just need 100 percent completion
hushed flare
If you do need 50 animals. Those are easy to get naturally in 100 percent
I don't
Remember that requirement tho
dusky vault
If you do need 50 animals. Those are easy to get naturally in 100 percent
I have everything I need besides the god damn dinosaurs bones
haven’t found a single fucking one
hushed flare
Well. Rdr2map helps
dire sentinel
o
hushed flare
meh
dusky vault
takes like 9 hours or so
hushed flare
There's a 100% Speedrun category
dire sentinel
The world record is like 12:59:00 any%
HUH
elfin kiln
*checks last donations*
Arthur: 120 dollars
Charles: 2 chicken feathers
John: po...
Let’s be realistic, Dutch tells Javier or Bill to maybe put some money in the box they’ll probably fuckin climb in themselves
noble grail
*checks last donations*
Arthur: 120 dollars
Charles: 2 chicken feathers
John: po...
Arthur: His home, lungs and life savings.
elfin kiln
Hosea drops a grizzly bear for light savings
elfin kiln
Arthur: His home, lungs and life savings.
Not to mention his poor wife and child
dire sentinel
arthur has voice lines to go to blackwater on a stagecoach 
jolly dragon
He has voice lines for talking to the sick people in Armadillo too
hidden moss
It's pretty interesting that originally Arthur was suppose to go to New Austin at some point in the story. Makes me wonder if he was never gonna die in the game? unless it was during a few cut missions that possibly open New Austin?
vast elk
I dont really care about john
hidden moss
arthur is an evil person
Did you even play through the story?
frigid cloud
It's pretty interesting that originally Arthur was suppose to go to New Austin a...
Definitely he was allowed to go into new austin
Then got cut
hidden moss
Definitely he was allowed to go into new austin
He also had a few dialogue lines once you do that stranger mission finding all the dinosaur bones
oblique rose
Man whenever I replay red dead I hate having to do the Thomas downes mission
frigid cloud
You've played before?
frigid cloud
Well probably he hates it cause Arthur gets tb
dusky vault
Well probably he hates it cause Arthur gets tb
Tbh. I enjoy playing as john a lot more
he’s cooler
imo
frigid cloud
Epilogue is a break from gunslinging and robbing
hidden moss
of course, you are gonna enjoy him more.
frigid cloud
yeah
hidden moss
cuz the honor won't make a difference with the story.
you can do whatever you want with john.
twilit swallow
👉 👌
summer lily
i laughed when arthur met the chelonians on the mountain and when they jumped off , if you jumped off he would scream chelonian or somet like that 
tidal raptor
So does anyone got a solution with the whole your guns unequip when getting off of your horse
summer lily
whenever i do story mode idc about him getting tb i just don’t do the mission before they go to the mountain
summer lily
So does anyone got a solution with the whole your guns unequip when getting off ...
No idea
it just happens and i accepted it
tidal raptor
it just happens and i accepted it
Alright I just get tired of being stuck with my revolvers i appreciate your help
summer lily
Have you tried reddit?
summer lily
Alright I just get tired of being stuck with my revolvers i appreciate your help
make sure to equip them before i learned to do that
was hard while playing online and then dtory
tidal raptor
was hard while playing online and then dtory
Yeah it’s frustrating because they care more about online like come on R* give the single players a bone
tidal raptor
Yeah like glitches are immersive I had to restart from chapter 3 because of a glitch that makes it to where you can’t save outfits
I probably saved em to quickly I dunno exactly
hidden moss
Why does my tomahawk always go low even when I deadeye with it
Trying to do sharpshooter 4 and its killing me
tidal raptor
Trying to do sharpshooter 4 and its killing me
The throwing knife one was annoying to me now you’ve got my questioning if I want to go for all of them
hidden moss
I always forget to feed john and he gets underweight and no matter how much I buy and feed him it doesn't change
Is it something specific that I have to give him-
tidal raptor
Just keep feeding him not sure if this helps but plain big game gets my online character fat so try feed John as much big game as you can
faint thistle
Why does my tomahawk always go low even when I deadeye with it
Throwing weapons charge when you hold the trigger
frigid cloud
The throwing knife one was annoying to me now you’ve got my questioning if I wan...
Nah it's easy
hidden moss
Throwing weapons charge when you hold the trigger
I thought this was quite intuitive
granite tangle
yo
arthur dies
?!
i just did the mission im acc sooo sad
do i have to play as john now for the rest of the game
glass isle
meh, i mean you have the epilogue
granite tangle
whats that tho
glass isle
the epilogue?
granite tangle
yea
glass isle
ohhh just some missions ig
glass isle
ye
granite tangle
do we ever get redemption
glass isle
idrk
winged stirrup
his death was his redemption
winged stirrup
yes
granite tangle
oh nice
frigid cloud
no do i ever get to kill micah
Spoilers if you didn't finish yet
granite tangle
how far in
frigid cloud
End
winged stirrup
yeah
granite tangle
brooo this is gunna take ages
winged stirrup
American Venom
frigid cloud
Ok bye
winged stirrup
the epilogue isn't that long
granite tangle
im a little confused...
winged stirrup
unless you take your time to explore
winged stirrup
no
granite tangle
dutch walked off
granite tangle
did dutch betray arthur
granite tangle
did dutch know micah was with pinkerton
winged stirrup
no
granite tangle
oh he never believed arthur
winged stirrup
ye
frigid cloud
He did at the end I think
granite tangle
bro im acc mad.
winged stirrup
idk
winged stirrup
dutch is kind of insane
winged stirrup
never thought i would cry because of a game
winged stirrup
because arthur told him he can't go any further
and that he has to face micah
which means certain death considering his tb
granite tangle
true
and now its literally impossible for arthur to make a return
in rdr3 if there is one
winged stirrup
ye
i would imagine rd3 being before everything
like the inception of the gang
idk
hidden moss
all of them
granite tangle
am i the only one that thinks its so dumb
winged stirrup
what
winged stirrup
k
latent plover
am i the only one that thinks its so dumb
Plot armor
hidden moss
dutch letting arthur die
a littlle bit but they did dutch really good and it all related with dutch behavior
winged stirrup
you mean they wrote dutch really well
hidden moss
you mean they wrote dutch really well
yea
winged stirrup
all the characters are meticulously crafted
granite tangle
yes]
hidden moss
but i cant be the only one who doesnt hate micah
winged stirrup
micah is a complicated character
I dont think anybody has really cracked him yet
was he greedy?
did he want to be the good guy?
did he have some kind of hate for arthur?
granite tangle
there is way too many interpriations of his actions
PLOT TWIST
ARTHUR DID SOMETING WORSE
hidden moss
micah is a complicated character
i know but in my oppinion hes one of the best written characters in the game
winged stirrup
i know but in my oppinion hes one of the best written characters in the game
exactly he is so complex, even more so than arthur
hidden moss
yea thats why i like him
winged stirrup
because we never find out what micah's motif really was
hidden moss
because we never find out what micah's motif really was
i hope we will in rdr 3
hidden moss
i hope we will in rdr 3
if there will be one
winged stirrup
i hope we will in rdr 3
if we are getting a 3, like i said, it will probably the inception of the game
gang
hidden moss
if we are getting a 3, like i said, it will probably the inception of the game
yea but i hope they dont explain anything because then its hard to really have a opinion about the game
hidden moss
yea but i hope they dont explain anything because then its hard to really have a...
everything*
winged stirrup
idk i would like to have some type of backstory for each of the characters
granite tangle
but
dutch and micah
must have worked together
because on the train job they left john
to die
NOT TO MENTION DUTCH LEFT ARTHUR NEARLY GOT STABBED
winged stirrup
but then again even with just these two games i think it is enough to satisfy me if we don't get any more
granite tangle
AND LET JOHN GET ARRESTED
winged stirrup
yeah that factory scene confused me when i first saw it
hidden moss
but then again even with just these two games i think it is enough to satisfy me...
same iguess
i think i just want to know more but not everything
granite tangle
same
mint urchin
I sneezed
slim oak
So happy gonna meet the voice actor for Arthur Morgan today
rustic dawn
@red crypt hobnob
hidden moss
So happy gonna meet the voice actor for Arthur Morgan today
Congrats
sturdy kite
How tf do i get rid of suspenders as arthur
hidden moss
I wanna get rid of John's suspenders
hushed harbor
dont say suspenders without the penders
worst mistake of my life
winged stirrup
I wanna get rid of John's suspenders
change clothes
wraith panther
dont say suspenders without the penders
worst mistake of my life
Excuse me
how to get rid of the sus
sturdy kite
Any way to get rid of a bounty for free
frigid cloud
Surrendering might be but still takes away your money
sturdy kite
then how is it free
red helm
Best advice I can give is to not get a bounty in the first place.
red helm
That wouldn't help with your $ bounty.
red helm
It does make Lawmen Despawn. But...
wraith panther
but then I need to pay money
and I'd much rather lose $500 dying to lawmen than paying $150 to get rid of my bounty
red helm
$150 is the max you lose to dying to someone.
wraith panther
Nice
frigid cloud
Get 1500$ bounty in every state as arthur before the last mission
red helm
I completely spaced going for the Bountiful trophy, before finishing chapter 6...
frigid cloud
Btw I think you can do bandit 7 challenge with one of those random events where you get robbed and if you loot the thief it counts for it
red helm
Yes, it counted for me. I got lucky, wasn't even trying for it.
frigid cloud
A bandit challenge where you don't lose honor 
Links are not allowed whoever's trying
west condor
i realised
red helm
hushed flare
Btw I think you can do bandit 7 challenge with one of those random events where ...
Or you could just rob a train and Rob passnegers
Oops, pinging
wraith panther
is the bandit 7 challenge to loot a few people?
red helm
Rob $50 total from Towns people and Travelers.
red helm
If you don't know the tricks, it's annoying... but..
wraith panther
whattricks?
red helm
Trains, or the Pick pockets in Saint Denis/Van Horn.
frigid cloud
They also work for looting 250$ trophy I forgot its name
fossil shoal
does anyone feel bad for strauss
frigid cloud
hushed flare
x
hidden moss
Ayo
Any rd2 zoologist online atm?
I got lonely in RDO and it's great to be back with John taking care of his family all over again.
weak socket
if I choose to go back for the money, will John still get Arthur’s hat in the epilogue or not
wraith panther
The money from the Aberdeens?
weak socket
no in the last mission
hushed flare
I wish hat accessories weren't only on Arthur's hat
weak socket
I want to do go back for the money but I don’t have the heart to leave John
hidden moss
I wish hat accessories weren't only on Arthur's hat
True
hushed flare
I got all 4 endings in mission replay and the high honor go back for money is pretty cool
weak socket
Yeah the high honor go back for money is cool, it’s just the low honor
I was crying for low honor go with John
And I will get low honor go back
hushed flare
low honor go with John feels more natural for Micah to do
weak socket
Arthur is about to go back to camp I don’t know what to choose
lilac tendon
I beat the game 7 times
weak socket
lilac tendon
weak socket
hushed flare
I beat the game 7 times
Wait so you beat the game 7 times but 86% completion?
according to Xbox achievements atleast
wraith panther
Is it fun
wraith panther
oof
hidden moss
Hm
I have between 900 and 1k hrs in rdr2 but only 2 or 3 completions and no significant trophies
hushed flare
i got 100 percent on one playthrough on my xbox
Now my "second" playthrough is abandoned
hidden moss
I have abandoned far too many playthroughs
wraith panther
smh
hidden moss
This game may be too long
wraith panther
Does your ability to win fights change from Arthur to John?
wraith panther
So he weighs less than Arthur?
hidden moss
normal weight John looks like slightly underweight Arthur
hidden moss
No
wraith panther
Weight only effects cores
Doesn't it only affect Stamina and maybe Health?
hushed flare
Doesn't it only affect Stamina and maybe Health?
Yes unless it's perfect weight
Perfect weight gives 15% core drain to all cores
wraith panther
you mean -15%?
hushed flare
yes
wraith panther
Nice
hushed flare
very hard to maintain
wraith panther
Constantly eatin
hushed flare
I keep flipping from perfect weight and average