#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 411 of 1

spiral laurel
#

I'll be sure to lie to your face next time and call you a nice guy while I'm at it lol

native thunder
#

what's the point of arguing y'all

spiral laurel
#

Ah it's nothing any more

severe relic
#

Yeah

spiral laurel
#

anyways, the Sub Titles in this game are odd

severe relic
#

I just accidentally sent that sticker

#

:troll:

spiral laurel
#

they convey different points yet work with the same sentence they are suppose to be meaning

#

it's... weird

hidden moss
spiral laurel
#

Thats the Troll

severe relic
spiral laurel
#

I'm already over it Vincent don't worrry, there wasn't much to look at any ways

#

But yeah, now that Rockstars finally fixed the Cold Bug

#

I hope Subtitles can be next

severe relic
#

Sure

native thunder
#

we just need john to not look like an ogre

spiral laurel
#

OH yeah that too

native thunder
#

then story mode is nothing different from when it first released oh my god

hidden moss
native thunder
#

sp was decent, they downgraded it, and now our main wish is not a dlc or anything, but to be back to its previous state smh

spiral laurel
#

Then I wouldn't bother with him

severe relic
native thunder
#

the argument is over stop lmao

hidden moss
severe relic
#

I know

#

This argument is over

spiral laurel
#

thats... the troll

hidden moss
#

You bitch

native thunder
#

._.

severe relic
#

:troll:

native thunder
#

vincent please stop talking, the argument is over so no need to keep going on

spiral laurel
#

Vincent it's fine, people like this are everywhere

#

Cool your jets

native thunder
#

lol

hidden moss
#

Sure

spiral laurel
#

I usually just deal with them

hidden moss
#

Don’t mess with me again @severe relic

spiral laurel
#

Vincent... this is the internet

hidden moss
#

Peace

native thunder
spiral laurel
#

There won't be any real threats or fist fights

#

unless someone takes it too far

severe relic
spiral laurel
#

which I assume won't happen

#

at least... I hope

#

moving on, recently I've seen some guy complain about RDR2 about how bad it was and what not siting issues that are Fundamentally in every rockstar game

#

and you wanna hear the funniest part

#

this was commented on a GTA Speed Run Video

severe relic
#

Bruh

spiral laurel
#

Keep in mind, when I said "ISSUES" I mean

#

Nit Picks and needless complaints

native thunder
#

darkviperau?

spiral laurel
#

Of course

#

I didn't wanna say it but of course, look I love Dark Viper, I think he's a cool guy and all

#

but he makes too much of a deal about RDR2 being bad to him

#

to the point where his influence spears into his audiences mind

fossil shoal
#

is it above anti-aliasing or below tree testelation

native thunder
#

above taa

half marsh
spiral laurel
#

I just find it really funny, because people like that make me think they believe GTA 5 is Fundamentally better game than RDR2

#

when... Spoilers, it isn't

#

I know It's all objective

#

but come on

native thunder
#

rdr2's story is better, but missions are slow.

severe relic
#

Y'know, I think that fact is, they can't understand how the game actually has a good story, as it did in the start, and they're saying a game in development for more than 8 years is bad, meaning that they don't give half of a shit about the effort rockstar put into it, even though GTA has a better online servers, that doesn't mean red dead redemption 2 isn't half bad.

native thunder
#

for some ppl that's a real hard turn off

spiral laurel
#

The thing is about RDR2 is that it's very different

#

it's more of a Slow paced game

severe relic
#

GTA is more fast paced

spiral laurel
#

weirdly in line with games like Animal Crossing for example

fossil shoal
native thunder
#

some ppl like me dont mind the way rdr2 does things, in fact i like it, since it gives me time to understand game mechanics etc. but some people just want to get ahead with the game

severe relic
#

Rdr2 actually wants you to enjoy the game

spiral laurel
#

games that rather than jettison the player into new things all the time, RDR2 focuses on the world and character building

native thunder
#

it's very subjective to the player

severe relic
#

Well of course, the missions can be long

spiral laurel
#

it is subjective

fossil shoal
#

at least the tailing part shows you great horse animation and good landscape unlike assassin's creed

severe relic
#

RDR2 actually wants you to relate to the character in a few ways.

spiral laurel
#

but still, I think theres a clear difference between something when it comes to rating a game

Rating a game based on how bad it is
And Rating a game based on how it doesn't work for you, because the truth it, not everything you don't like is bad

#

lets be honest

severe relic
#

True

spiral laurel
#

if you don't like a game, sometimes you can still see how and where it's amazing to other people

fossil shoal
severe relic
spiral laurel
#

as a whole, RDR2 is slow paced

native thunder
#

walking on the cliffside during sean's rescue was so not needed lol

spiral laurel
#

but I don't think the pacing is too bad

#

now examples like that

fossil shoal
#

bruh no i am just asking how is that tied to what we are talking about

spiral laurel
#

yeah thats a little far

#

one thing I will complain about is this

severe relic
spiral laurel
#

if Rockstar ever needs to learn something, it's that not everything has to be gameplay, look I know they use cutscenes, but this isn't half life, you either make a Cutscene, or make complete gameplay

#

don't try to cram cutscenes IN GAMEPLAY

native thunder
#

i dont mind it, i feel indifferent abt button prompts in cutscenes.

#

but

spiral laurel
#

My issue is this

native thunder
#

to people who aren't super invested at the moment and use cutscene time to take a break, yea it's bad lol

spiral laurel
#

this isn't a half life game, this game has cutscenes and all

#

so why not make rides on the river like with Seans break out mission... a cutscene

#

instead of just PRESS W TO PROGRESS THE STORY

#

does that make sense?

hidden moss
#

We both have the same eye size and same hair and same spirit animal (wolf)

spiral laurel
#

Without counting Arthur, John or Jack since they are main characters of the Redemption series

severe relic
#

True

hidden moss
#

Yeah

spiral laurel
#

the characters I relate to the most are Hosea, Lenny and maybe Uncle

severe relic
#

They were the main characters in the original games

spiral laurel
#

Oh Abigail as well

severe relic
#

Of course, Jack is more after John dies

spiral laurel
#

You know, sometimes its more interesting to look into side characters than the main characters

#

the main three will always be great

#

but sometimes people seem to forget about other ones

hidden moss
#

Indeed

spiral laurel
#

Pearson and Miss Grimshaw for example are great ones

hidden moss
#

Pearson was the wholesome man of the gang next to Kieran

spiral laurel
#

Oh I like Kieran

hidden moss
#

He has that new kid feel

native thunder
#

grimshaw's annoying as hell in camp though

vivid blade
#

fr

spiral laurel
#

Miss Grimshaw feels like the tough love kinda mother, the one that acts like an Army Sargent sometimes, and a loving Family memeber the next

native thunder
#

yea that's her role

hidden moss
#

Indeed

native thunder
#

but during actual gameplay she's annoying

spiral laurel
#

yeah mostly

#

probably because shes gotta deal with some stupider people in the camp all the time...

#

Micah... Bill... even Dutch

#

trust me, I'd be cranky if I had to deal with people like them all day

#

Dutch is fine btw, just, well he has some weird spats

#

Sorry for killing chat

vivid blade
#

i hate chapt 3

spiral laurel
#

I haven't fully played it yet

native thunder
#

okay buddy

spiral laurel
#

whats it like

severe relic
native thunder
#

clemen's point

vivid blade
severe relic
#

Oh wait

#

My dumbass

vivid blade
#

clemens point sucks

severe relic
#

I can tell why

vivid blade
#

i just hate lemoyne

#

in general

native thunder
#

chapter 5 is the only bad chapter. after that in ch 6 i didnt feel like doing anything other than just do the story

#

ch1 is pretty slow too though

#

but only if u played already

severe relic
spiral laurel
#

heres another issue with Rockstar I have

native thunder
#

it does well for a tutorial

severe relic
#

I've played chapter one more than 5 times

native thunder
#

but to ppl like me, it's just annoying lol

severe relic
vivid blade
#

for than 0

#

20

#

for me

spiral laurel
#

Prologues, now look, Chapter 1 is actually a good chapter, but the issue is being forced to replay it, it's a bottle neck as soon as you start

#

and it gets old

#

real fast

vivid blade
#

quick

spiral laurel
#

thats my problem

#

I just wish people could get the option to skip it

#

then people would realize how, well good of a starting chapter it is

#

despite being the most linear part of the game

vivid blade
#

i hate wwhen after a mission

#

u have to go back to camp

#

to start a new one

severe relic
#

True

spiral laurel
#

Oh and one more thing I don't like about Rockstar games

#

let me lay out the situation

vivid blade
#

after 20+ times beaten

spiral laurel
#

your trying to beat a level in a certain way or whatever

vivid blade
#

its so boring at times

spiral laurel
#

and once you screw up something, you just wanna restart to the checkpoint right?

#

well guess what, you gotta find stupid and annoying ways to kill yourself

#

throw Dynamite on the floor, or jump off a high place

#

ffs just give me a restart button

vivid blade
#

fr

#

imagine arthur could just

#

like

#

fly

#

lmfao

#

horse takes forever

native thunder
#

uh, pretty sure u can press left on d pad to bring up mission menu on the left, then restart ur mission

#

idk what it is on pc

hidden moss
#

I studied a rat while it was in a cats mouth lol

spiral laurel
#

Cool

hidden moss
#

I've been wondering if they are gonna add automobiles in RDO

#

OH GOD NO

vivid blade
#

thatd be cool tho

#

like rdr1

#

but not time correct at all

hidden moss
#

Can't wait to get ran over by black coated tryhards

#

Or preform a drive by

vivid blade
#

fr

#

then gta kids finna be coming

#

but its a good idea

#

no drivebys

hidden moss
#

Yeah but the game takes place in 1898

vivid blade
#

yea

#

rdr1 1911

hidden moss
#

And there were automobiles in 1911

vivid blade
#

yea

hushed harbor
#

i love how when you antagonize someone again before they finish responding they get interrupted

hushed flare
#

"I'm talking"

spiral laurel
#

I'm convinced Rockstar hates Creativity

#

it's My way or the high way for some missions

#

to give a prime example of what I mean, you guys know the Second Money lending quest? where you go around and get three different Depts?

#

well the one with the guy who tries to escape on his Horse I tried to do differently this time, instead of talking to the guy on the log, I talked to chick himself, who obviously tried to say to talk to the guy on the log

hushed flare
#

When you fail the mission because you "abandoned it"

spiral laurel
#

of course I knew it was him, so I lasso'd him, tied him up, check his pockets

#

and I failed it

hushed flare
spiral laurel
#

I failed the mission because I knew who Chick Mathews was already

#

nothing actually

#

it's even more insulting since well

hushed flare
#

Just "failed"

spiral laurel
#

IT DIDN'T ACTUALLY FAIL

#

the mission just locked itself

#

which means I need to come back and do it again

#

how dumb is it that the devs are so fricken picky that they won't even give you the fun of catching him before he leaves

hushed flare
#

I like how you can kill the dude, lose honor and then find the treasure but you can't lasso him the first 5 seconds to loot himthestare

spiral laurel
#

oh whats worse

#

when I looted him while tied up

#

he didn't have the map

hushed flare
#

I mean kill the dude on the ride

spiral laurel
#

and I lost Honor

hushed flare
#

Like when he's riding away

spiral laurel
#

... rockstar please

#

let me have options

#

this is the dumbest thing I've ever seen

hushed flare
#

"mission failed, you abandoned (something)"

spiral laurel
#

Honestly, I love how Creative some missions are

#

but I hate the lack of player input Rockstar allows

#

It's their way or the high way

#

and the highway ain't got nothing

bitter echo
#

well clearly their approach to game design is working

hushed flare
#

I wish the low honor system had more benefit

spiral laurel
#

Yes, they ARE selling tons of Copies and making tons of money

#

but is the system ALWAYS AMAZING?

#

no

#

most of the time it actually isn't

bitter echo
halcyon dove
#

rdr1 on switch would cure my depression ChewieNut

hushed harbor
#

most people play rdr2 for the story

hushed flare
spiral laurel
chilly rapids
bitter echo
spiral laurel
#

I'm not saying that the Game ISN'T Inherently Creative

hushed flare
#

A free roam game with mostly linear missions

spiral laurel
#

I'm saying, the lack of player input is a Damper on the games focus on creativity

#

with missions especially

chilly rapids
#

I havent played the story enough times to name all of the missions that let you do things differently but

#

One mission is the one where you catch the kid in st denis

hushed flare
#

Yeah you have to jump over a wall

#

And camp the place he comes to

hushed harbor
#

maybe for low honor there could also be higher chances for rarer wild horse breeds and coats and stagecoaches with rarer items in them
or more money from robbed registers

spiral laurel
#

Low Honor should have definitely been focused on the Criminal side of the gameplay

#

In terms of Perks

#

since there are barley any

bitter echo
#

shrugs can't possibly please everyone, that's for sure

hushed flare
#

I remember in rdr1 if you were a douchebag enough witnesses wouldn't report for anything less then murder

spiral laurel
#

it's just a personal problem I have with games that promote lots of creativity, then when things start to turn into a mission or whatever, they decide to start Bottle necking out of no where

hushed flare
#

Also the camp donation stuff is semi flawed

spiral laurel
#

thats another thing I've been wanting to mention

hushed flare
#

You don't have to feed the camp or do any upgrades and stuff and the story just keeps going like nothing's wrong

spiral laurel
#

The Camp in this game can so easily be ignored, and when you finally beat the game, it's like it never even existed, what? giving money to your home to help feed your friends and family? making Decorations for your last location? NAAAAHHH Its the POST GAME!!!

turbid ore
#

but getting the fast travel upgrade is useful

hushed flare
#

agree

spiral laurel
#

my main issue is

hushed harbor
#

and for the rarer horse breeds at coats theyd be ridden by especially touchy NPCs thatd chase you to the ends of the earth to get their horse back if u just stole so youd probably have to kill em

spiral laurel
#

if you want a camp system, don't just drop it off at the end of the game

#

seriously, the system could have easily worked with Beechers

chilly rapids
#

Dude what

hushed flare
#

Feeding system at Beecher's hope would have been nice at least nothing more

chilly rapids
#

How would it have worked with epilogue

vivid blade
#

farming sim

hushed flare
chilly rapids
#

Its 1807 they can just buy from the shop

spiral laurel
vivid blade
#

1907*

hushed flare
#

1807doggy2

hushed harbor
#

i dont think theres a medicine or provisions wagon equivalent in beechers is there

spiral laurel
#

you can literally buy food to be shipped from stores to the camp

hushed flare
#

oh yeah I forgot you can't take a bath at Beecher's hopetrollcrying

spiral laurel
#

my issue is about why the system was dropped off at the end of the game, the part where you should have easy access to everything

#

Imagine if you could have had a Med Cabinet in your home stead

#

or a small locker of ammo

vivid blade
spiral laurel
vivid blade
#

ye

hushed harbor
#

theres no real reasin to go to beechers besides maybe wardrobe weapon locker and free shaving if u care abt that

spiral laurel
#

and again, thats my main issue

hushed flare
#

Or a fast travel if your too lazy to make a camp

spiral laurel
#

for the Final Permanent home in the game

#

it's arguably the worst

hushed harbor
#

and if ur gone for a long time the family just goes "oop johns back lol"

spiral laurel
#

a Fricken Hotel finds itself to provide more

vivid blade
#

u guys wana see some cool stuf

spiral laurel
#

I could easily just live in Saint Denis lol

vivid blade
#

saint denis sucks

spiral laurel
vivid blade
#

facts tho

#

lemoyne sucks aswell

hushed flare
#

Rhodes is cool

#

Or hot

vivid blade
#

citys like that (saint denis) werent really a thing

turbid ore
#

yeah you can find pearson in rhodes

vivid blade
#

in 1899

hushed harbor
#

tbh if i were to live in any town in the rdr2 map irl itd be either strawberry or 1907 rhodes

vivid blade
#

valentine or blackwater

hushed flare
#

valentine has horse poop streets

vivid blade
#

k?

chilly rapids
#

All of the towns do

hushed flare
#

At least thats where I see the most poop

chilly rapids
#

Its the late 1800s/early 1900s

vivid blade
#

execpt colter

chilly rapids
#

Colter is abandoned

hushed flare
#

Well that town is a bit deadtrollmask

vivid blade
#

yes

#

i like it tho

#

feels like the wild west

#

a ghost town

hushed flare
#

but snow

vivid blade
#

i hate snow in rdo

hushed flare
#

Only RDO?

hushed harbor
#

wish ambarino actually had towns and not only a native American rez and hamish's place

vivid blade
#

yea

chilly rapids
#

Ambarino is good for hunting

hushed flare
vivid blade
#

weird fact i learned

#

u guys know why its called

chilly rapids
#

Best views in rdr2 is mount hagen, the loft, and the first evelyn miller mission

vivid blade
#

O'Creaghs run

hushed flare
#

double tap RB to go backwards on horse

hushed harbor
#

if u had to choose would u rather live in 1907 armadillo or 1907 tumbleweed

hushed flare
#

Armadillo EW

vivid blade
#

becomes abonded

hushed harbor
#

pick ur poison

vivid blade
#

if u ever played rdr1

hushed flare
chilly rapids
hushed harbor
#

be nice to sheriff freeman he just wants order

hushed flare
#

Op npc.exe

chilly rapids
#

My favorite stranger is the photographer

vivid blade
#

mine is hamush

chilly rapids
#

Or Charles Chatenay

vivid blade
#

hamish

turbid ore
#

idk why

hushed flare
turbid ore
#

no

hushed flare
#

Only guns then

#

I thought he was similar to the vampire

hushed harbor
#

the stranger that i think is the most interesting is francis sinclair

vivid blade
#

never ask a man his salary
a woman her age
R* why the Navy Revolver is not in story

hushed harbor
#

because time travel is cool

turbid ore
#

i like marko dragic

#

the robot guy

vivid blade
#

yea

turbid ore
#

its interesting

vivid blade
#

the dino bone

hushed harbor
#

mr black and mr white, the two escaped convicts, are probably my fav

turbid ore
#

removing their bounty posters

#

i wish removing my bounty was that easy

hushed flare
#

kek

vivid blade
#

imagine they let u buy house in rdo

hushed flare
#

Getting bounty hunted at 15$ bounty meanwhile I think these guys have 80$ bounty combined(40$ each) and then they walk away from poster takedowns

turbid ore
#

rdo becomes gta online

vivid blade
#

ew

#

but like

#

rdr1

#

u can rent

hushed flare
#

buying Angelo Bronte's mansiontroll

hushed harbor
turbid ore
hushed harbor
#

i dont play r* online modes, i think they're boring
how does gtao do it

vivid blade
#

gtao got boring

#

its not really gta

#

anymore

chilly rapids
#

it wouldnt work with gtao because the apartments have multiple rooms and floors

hushed harbor
#

i dont have friends so im just stuck in rdo all alone

vivid blade
#

tru

chilly rapids
#

houses in the 1890s didnt have as much room as gtao apartments did

vivid blade
#

partly bc im lvl 5

#

25

hushed harbor
#

itd probably be more fun if i had friends who actually play the same games i do to dick around in the open world

#

with

turbid ore
#

my friends are too obsessed with gta

vivid blade
#

same

hushed harbor
#

i keep resetting my character appearance cuz im never satisfied with it

vivid blade
#

i dont got the gold for that 😭

hushed harbor
#

i delete the character instead cuz idrc

vivid blade
#

damn

#

i wouldnt do tht

hushed harbor
#

i never get very far so i dont lose much

vivid blade
#

how much gold u got now

hushed harbor
#

idk id have to check

vivid blade
#

i have less than 1

#

saving for arthurs outfit

turbid ore
#

i hated that

#

same here

#

now i am playing for the second time with lowest honor

hushed flare
fossil shoal
half marsh
fossil shoal
#

where can you see the directory?

hushed flare
#

he killed gang that do bad things so he's opplantRoyale

fossil shoal
half marsh
#

probably

turbid ore
#

but i get it

hushed flare
turbid ore
#

maybe. but he's an ass for me

fossil shoal
half marsh
fossil shoal
#

wait i got more fps from quality than ultra performance

half marsh
#

yeah, either because its cpu bottlenecked, or maybe because some scenes may have intensive effects independent from resolution? ¯_(ツ)_/¯

obsidian crown
#

Does anyone else have a lot of bugs on singleplayer after the online update???

#

Shopkeepers will take like a full minute to show me the catalogue option, pause menu takes like an hour to open

spiral laurel
obsidian crown
#

No, none

#

I'm on a console

spiral laurel
#

I see

#

Well I wouldn’t know what to do then

obsidian crown
#

Thanks anyway, I was just making sure if it was just a problem with my game

dire sentinel
#

where's a good location for perfect rat pelts?

#

i need it for hunting requests

chilly rapids
dire sentinel
#

with the lemoyne raiders?

chilly rapids
#

Yes

dire sentinel
#

oh, thank you

chilly rapids
#

It has a unique weapon I think

dire sentinel
#

yeah, and a hat too i'm pretty sure

quick whale
dire sentinel
#

ill check that out in a bit, sadly i already visited the saloon in saint denis for the perfect rat pelts already

quick whale
#

Or bolder glade

chilly rapids
#

You can do it twice

dire sentinel
#

so here i am haha

chilly rapids
#

Tuff

frigid cloud
#

You might've gotten it already but anyway

languid perch
#

give me stuff to do in the game other than the story

frigid cloud
#

Hunting requests

dapper lichen
#

Bruh I just learned that in the game the horses 🥜s shrink according to the temperature

#

And people still say Rdr2 is unrealistic

strange smelt
frail vessel
#

Yo I need help for the console display settings, would be glad if someone could help out

hidden moss
frail vessel
#

Horse ball enjoyer? whot

hidden moss
#

it was in every first " top 20 details in red dead redemption 2 " videos

candid walrus
#

Wow, my mom's boyfriend was so close to 100% completion..

undone maple
#

Your mom's boyfriend nearly get 100%

bitter echo
#

dang it I think the game glitched and didn't credit me for finding first treasurre

green pine
#

you mean your step father

candid walrus
#

No, he isn't my step dad yet

green pine
#

So what is the relationship between you and him

candid walrus
#

Idk honestly

#

They're going to get married in a few months

#

So then he'll be my step dad

green pine
#

Congrats

#

So like you rob banks with him?

candid walrus
#

No, lel

green pine
#

oh

#

BTW why do so many people simp for micah

candid walrus
#

Dunno

green pine
#

Its you and also @hushed flare

bitter echo
#

that moment when the challenge is done and you can fully unload on the hideout

green pine
#

ok?

night turtle
#

how do you hunt these small animals? have a hard time chasing them lol

frigid cloud
#

dead eye

#

On horseback

frigid cloud
#

Nastas and dutchs voice so similar do they have the same voice actor

fiery prawn
#

does someone know how to get perfect pelt for squirrels ? i use small game arrows and shoot their head (with dead eye) and it stills ruins the pelt

timid shoal
#

Try using a varmint rifle

fiery prawn
#

on the wiki it does say that small game arrow is the only way to go but i will try the varmint rifle

frigid cloud
#

No

#

Use small game arrows

timid shoal
fiery prawn
#

no i always make sure it's a three star animal

#

whatever i'll just keep on trying

timid shoal
#

actually now that I think about it, you should prob stay with small game arrows but it's worth a shot

languid perch
#

boah juice

frigid cloud
#

the only way to get perfect squirrel is small game arrows anyway

languid perch
#

and boah juice

hidden moss
#

i managed to get perfect wolf skin after shotgunning it to death. Dunno how that works

elfin kiln
frigid cloud
#

No

elfin kiln
#

Yes they are though

frigid cloud
#

No

#

It's small game arrows

elfin kiln
#

Squirrels are varmints

frigid cloud
#

No.

elfin kiln
#

Why wouldn’t the varmint rifle work

frigid cloud
#

Too much damage to the pelt

#

Small game arrow is the only way

candid walrus
#

You have to use small game arrows

#

Or else the pelt will be damaged

elfin kiln
#

You cant argue with facts, squirrels are varmints though aren’t they?

frigid cloud
#

No

elfin kiln
#

Yes they are

frigid cloud
#

They arent

frigid pier
#

Get the buck antler trinket

#

It helps

elfin kiln
#

K what they are varmints why are you saying no

frigid cloud
#

It's small game arrows

elfin kiln
#

Do you know what a varmint is?

frigid pier
#

They are varmints but they are also small game

#

And the game has decided you can only use small game arrows

elfin kiln
#

True, I’m just pointing out that that’s kinda inconsistent

frigid pier
#

Because logic

elfin kiln
#

Both should work since they are varmints

#

And small game

frigid cloud
#

Ok

#

Does it say varmint rifle and small game arrows on its info tab?

frigid pier
#

It does not cuz that’d make sense

frigid cloud
#

I never tried varmint rifle for squirrels

elfin kiln
#

Ive never used small game for them but I’ve only ever hunted two squirrels

frigid pier
#

I have but I had the deer antler trinket so I got a perfect pelt anyway

frigid cloud
#

Was it perfect when you shot it with varmint rifle

frigid pier
#

No, I don’t think so?

elfin kiln
#

I just had a stroke

#

Sorry

#

Yes, not the word varmint

frigid pier
#

I forget

elfin kiln
#

I got perfect pelts both time with varmint rifle

#

I also had the buck trinket

frigid pier
#

That’d be why

elfin kiln
#

My whole point here was squirrels are varmints

#

So both should work

frigid pier
#

It increases the pelt by one star

elfin kiln
#

I think I only had it the second time though

frigid cloud
#

Yeah probably trinket had a use

#

Don't think varmint rifle works for perfect squirrels

frigid pier
#

It doesn’t

elfin kiln
#

Is that actually how that trinket works?

frigid pier
#

I looked on the wiki

elfin kiln
#

Holy shit

frigid pier
#

It’s too powerful

elfin kiln
#

I thought it just increased the chances, I didn’t know it just automatically upped the rating

frigid pier
#

In reference to the varmint rifle for hunting “However, it is still too powerful for very small animals such as Squirrels, Chipmunk, Blue Jay etc. To hunt those animals, A bow with Small Game Arrows is the best choice.”

frigid cloud
#

yep

elfin kiln
#

That’s waaaaay to powerful for an animal that takes five seconds to kill

frigid cloud
#

Varmint rifle is for skunks, rabbits, beavers and opossum

elfin kiln
#

Sorry for the argument

#

I apologize if I was a jerk

frigid pier
#

I’m not sure if it actually increases it by one, but that’s what my experience has shown. Except for one star animals it didn’t seem to? But that might have been cause I killed it with a shotgun

#

Shotgun best hunting weapon

frigid cloud
#

I skinned a bear that was poor and I got good bear pelt

frigid pier
#

Yeah

frigid cloud
#

With the trinket being active

frigid pier
#

Shotgun with flaming buckshot

elfin kiln
#

I’m just saying, squirrels are varmint, I don’t know why it would not let it be killed with a varmint

frigid pier
#

Best way to hunt

elfin kiln
frigid pier
#

It’s cuz the squirrel is so small it can’t handle a .22 round ig

frigid pier
elfin kiln
#

You just show the pulp left after the hunt the buck trinket and it just morphs back into a rabbit

frigid cloud
#

Buck antler trinket didn't have much use during hunting requests for me

elfin kiln
#

Really?

#

This game is great but it hurts my brain sometimes

frigid pier
#

Yeah

spring hedge
frigid cloud
frigid pier
#

One thing that bothers me is that quick drawing into dead eye has perfect accuracy when firing from the hip but firing from the hip normally doesn’t

elfin kiln
#

Most animals I hunt I get perfects without even checking the pelt type, and my friend says that they haven’t gotten a perfect yet in the last week, both of us have the trinket

frigid pier
#

I get why

#

But like consistence please

elfin kiln
#

Like I want to see Arthur just stopping mid air and shooting twelve people in a half second

frigid pier
#

Watch a cowboy three gun shooting match. It’s pretty damn close lol

elfin kiln
#

Ive just discovered my new favourite thing, thank you kind bord

frigid pier
#

Np lol

narrow jetty
#

I had the brilliant idea of hunting with explosive shotgun shells

#

needless to say there wasn't a single perfect pelt

torpid trail
#

IAM in chapter 2

#

Where r u now

narrow jetty
#

Welp I just started the epilogue of my 3rd playthrough lol

torpid trail
#

No cause every time I open it says save game damaged

hybrid hollow
#

eyo guys do u know anything fun after u finish the whole game

#

cuz ive hunted 10 legendary animals so far

red helm
#

Work on trophies?

hidden moss
#

i just beat rdr2

red helm
#

Nice

hidden moss
#

i think my favorite part was the first chapter tbh, especially being in the snow

#

i rlly liked the game

spiral laurel
weary verge
frigid cloud
#

challenges

red helm
#

Most of the challenges were enjoyable. But there are a couple that were just, wtf.

native thunder
#

i feel bandit and hunter challenges were the only ones that were fun and doable by yourself without guides

#

algernon is probably the hardest 100% requirement

red helm
#

Finding some of the orchids were just ugh, without internet help. Yes.

regal shale
#

any fast ways to earn honor as arthur, i wanna earn some quickly as arthur before the final mission of the main story

red helm
#

Walk around Saint Denis and greet everyone you see.

#

Tedious, but it gets the job done.

frigid cloud
#

5 cougars take so long to find

native thunder
#

uh not really

#

maybe difficult if you have no idea where to find them

frigid cloud
#

Well I only used two spawn points

native thunder
#

their spawns are pretty consistent

frigid cloud
#

So maybe that's why

red helm
#

If you don't really know where to look for the Cougars, that one can be ugh, but once you do know where to look..

native thunder
#

i use one most of the time lol

frigid cloud
#

Other than cougar one I enjoyed it

spiral laurel
#

You know I’ve noticed something about the Challenges

#

They aren’t fun, they are out of the way and don’t feel streamlined enough

#

I mean some work well, some don’t

#

Some just feel like a check list to follow off the beaten path

red helm
#

In RDR1, the challenges kind of were aligned with the story, if you did them right.

#

But, yeah, I do see what you mean.

spiral laurel
#

The challenges just feel very stupid at times especially with how specific they could be

#

Take the one that forces you to hunt down 3 perfect rabbits, why not just say 3 perfect medium game?

#

It’s a huge nit pick and maybe not the best example

spiral laurel
#

but it should give you a general idea

frigid cloud
#

That one took me long enough, barely 3 star rabbits were spawning

spiral laurel
#

And I love Poker

frigid cloud
#

Poker easy

frigid pier
#

The poker ones are easy

frigid cloud
#

Blackjack is rigged

native thunder
#

the only bad ones are dominoes and blackjack

spiral laurel
#

Black Jack and poker

#

I love them

frigid pier
#

It’s the fucking blackjack gotta hit 3 times and win thing

native thunder
#

dominoes only if u dont know how to play like me

frigid pier
#

Like that’s just luck

red helm
#

Maybe if the dollar value's were-n't- so damn low, Gambling wouldn't be so lame.

native thunder
#

gambler 8 is over hated.

frigid cloud
frigid pier
#

And I used mods to beat it because I spent hours and couldn’t do it

heady anchor
#

The only one I don’t like is dominos.

native thunder
#

^

#

8 just takes time

frigid pier
heady anchor
#

I love the blackjack challenges quite a bit.

native thunder
#

learning how to play dominoes or another game is way harder than just spamming x on gambler 8 lol

frigid cloud
#

10 is easiest probably

red helm
#

Gambler 8 took me 4 and a half hours.

native thunder
#

ouch lmao

#

i think ps4 took me 2 hours and pc took me 1

red helm
#

All basically wasted time, since I won such little amounts of money.

frigid pier
#

Rn I’m working on the horse 10. Trying to avoid a guide so finding each horse type is take a while

red helm
#

Horse 10 is pretty easy, a lot of the horses are around Tumbleweed and the Blackbone forest.

heady anchor
#

That sounds fun to me.

#

Mainly because you get to explore.

frigid cloud
#

Big valley also has the most of the horses you need

red helm
#

Blackbone forest is in the Big Valley.

frigid cloud
#

right my bad.

frigid pier
#

Good to know

sullen spade
#

Hey, I just wanted to ask if anyone else has been having issues with performing actions on horseback after the newest update? I'm on PC btw

#

When I try to interact with NPCs while riding on horseback the prompt only appears for a split second before then closing again by itself, I can spam right-click but it still doesn't let me pick any option, I also have a similar issue with lassos on horseback as when I try to swing it, it automatically stops. This issue only appears while being mounted on a horse, on foot the game works perfectly fine.

torpid trail
#

You thinking someone will read all this:🤡

narrow jetty
#

Everytime I'm sad I just think of the fact that Arthur once said "Vamos" to a German man and I feel all better

red helm
#

I read it, I just didn't have a answer for him.

narrow jetty
#

Yeah I don't know lol

sullen spade
#

It's only started happening after the update to Online

narrow jetty
#

well is it an issue online or single player?

red helm
#

Updates tend to bring glitchy non-sense, so.... foopie.

narrow jetty
#

or both

sullen spade
sullen spade
torpid trail
#

I don't have even ps plus

red helm
#

They are the -Suck- at addressing bugs..

torpid trail
#

They said that sp had free ps plus for a month

#

They chose them Randomly

red helm
#

Don't think they said that. I think they just said you didn't 'need' it to play Online, for a month.

prime estuary
#

yeah

#

you don't need it for single player

torpid trail
#

I would rather play Fifa on a pc without paying money to play

#

Or any game

#

But the community 😪

supple nymph
#

Xeron..

sullen spade
#

No thanks

supple nymph
#

Alright,

hidden moss
#

are chapter 5 and 6 long

#

cuz im on 50% and im chapter 5

#

wtf

sullen spade
#

Sorry I meant to spoiler tag that

hidden moss
#

no worries

#

so story ends when its 100%

sullen spade
hidden moss
#

fuck

#

so i have to tryhard side missions

#

great

#

so that means rdr2 general story aint that long

sullen spade
#

Sorry, is there a bot just auto-deleting messages? I spoiler tagged that one

hidden moss
#

probably

candid walrus
sullen spade
#

Oh, I see

vivid blade
#

ijjitjihr

astral bone
#

Yo what's this Gavin memr

#

I have no idea about it

hidden moss
#

Rd

#

More like LD

covert verge
#

Sometimes I think that this game can read you mind when you’re hunting

#

You’ll ride past like five perfect animals but the moment you start looking for them, they just cease to exist

hidden moss
#

can you reach honor level 7 in chapter 4?

fiery prawn
#

i have encountered the feral man several times now and i have not yet been able to talk to him because i keep getting attacked by his wolf

#

what am i suppose to do ?

odd cape
#

istg I just found a perfect ram and shot it and then my horse got scared for some reasons and threw me off and ran over it now it’s a poor ram.

#

I fucking hate my horse sometimes.

chilly rapids
spiral laurel
#

bro I feel like giving up on hunting completely

#

I hit the animal with a small game arrow? they don't die and I damage them

#

I hit them with a normal or improved? they die but I get a 2 star

native thunder
#

you gotta pull the bow more

spiral laurel
#

your kidding me

native thunder
#

if you click immediately then it wont do as much damage lol

quick whale
#

Yeah

native thunder
#

i think it only does full dmg in immediately if u dead eye the target

spiral laurel
#

bro I also just wanna catch a rabbit for this fricken request

quick whale
#

The longer you pull, the bigger the damage

spiral laurel
#

I bet the game has altered it's spawning

#

BECAUSE THEY ARE BARLEY ANYWHERE NOW

native thunder
#

using varmint rifle is easier for rabbits

spiral laurel
#

well whats the best way to hunt these small animals?

#

Chase them down on a horse? look out from miles away then slowly sneak in? use Bait?

native thunder
#

bait is worst option

#

rabbits i just ride on a horse and shoot them when i see them

#

but that's bcs i have aim assist and dead eye so it's easier for me, idk abt pc

#

tbh whenever i hunt , it's always on a horse and with dead eye

spiral laurel
#

honestly I don't get this game

#

I'm convinced it lowers the spawn rate once you start one of these hunting things

#

I'm looking for one rabbit and one squirrel, and now they are as hard to find as the lost Ark

odd cape
spiral laurel
#

FRICKEN FINALLY

#

GOT A PERFECT RABBIT

vivid blade
#

hi

quick whale
#

Did "Catch a chill" bug is fixed?

spiral laurel
thick mortar
odd cape
thick mortar
#

Because I want some

#

He means 3 star animals btw

dire sentinel
#

???

#

legendary animals are quite easy actually imo

thick mortar
#

WHAT ARE YOU GUYS SMOKING

#

What premium platinum cigarettes are you smoking?

odd cape
#

They’re literally shown on the map

#

While you have to find perfect animals by chance

#

Maybe if you’re in the main story and it’s near blackwater

hushed flare
#

Legendary animals you can just empty a bolt action onto them and no pelt ruin

#

Hardest legendary animal would probably be legendary panther because grass but even then you can consume a tonic and survive if ambushed

pure stirrup
#

Just imagine what would happen if arthurt didnt save micah from the starwberry prison

coral garden
#

yeah I spent about an hour hunting today

#

only saw 5 perfect pelts/birds

#

oh wait, singleplayer not online. omegalul M&B

#

mb*

spiral laurel
#

Either A: you don’t understand how hunting works in this game
Or B: you haven’t even tried it or the game

serene cove
#

Red Dead 2 got me feeling somethin else trollsad

spiral laurel
#

seriously, I’d take a legendary over looking to find some perfect pelt

serene cove
#

What do I do post game? It basically turned into farming simulator cause I don't know what to do

spiral laurel
serene cove
#

Yeah

#

Hunted all legendaries too

spiral laurel
#

Alright well let me list off a few things you can do then

serene cove
#

I even got that stupid stuffed squirrel

spiral laurel
#

First off, treasure hunts are cool to do, next is searching the land for all encounters or special items and places

#

You can also try your hand at beating all the challenges

#

which will give you extra stats

#

You could also attempt to locate all animals

serene cove
#

Does anyone know where the squirrel gets off to? I found it a few times around beechers hope but its just gone now

spiral laurel
#

And on top of a mountain

serene cove
#

Ah that'd explain why I can't find it

#

Is it mount shann?

spiral laurel
#

I’m not joking btw, it’s the last location to find it

#

it’s so random

serene cove
#

That's real strange

spiral laurel
#

Search up which mountain

serene cove
#

I'll just check mount shann

spiral laurel
#

Also I think the explanation for it disappearing is that Abigail doesn’t like it

#

and she tries to hide it

#

didn’t think she’d go that far

serene cove
#

That explains the first two but I doubt shed go up to the top of a mountain

spiral laurel
#

Maybe she just got sick of John finding it so many times

serene cove
#

Oh that's the same mountain with the UFO Easter egg

spiral laurel
#

I will also say this Zen Ten

#

If you truly want to get everything and do everything I have some bad news

#

Your gonna have to probably restart the game and use a missable content guide and a intractable map online

#

Since there’s a lot to find

serene cove
#

I have the rare guns

#

I knew ahead of time those were missable so I made sure to grab them

spiral laurel
#

well what about all the other weird things like the missable hats, documents, Guarma animals, random events and missions

serene cove
#

I know a glitch to get back to Guarma

#

But I don't know the one to get back to mainland so I'm not gonna do that

spiral laurel
#

I’ll give you a good example of a missable hat in the game

serene cove
#

Probably will just restart tbh, the story missions were the best part

spiral laurel
#

You know Appleseed timber?

serene cove
#

Yeah

spiral laurel
#

And how it disappears at one point

serene cove
#

That's the place you can give supplies to, right?

spiral laurel
#

Not only are there 3 events related to it, there are also two missable items

#

The bucket hat and a letter from a body

#

once they leave, there’s no doing any of that

serene cove
#

I did a few events around there

#

They had me locate two missing guys

spiral laurel
#

the bucket hat is worn by the workers

#

It’s recommended you get it after their final quest with the wolves

serene cove
#

Yeah that was the one

#

I liked checking up on them and making sure they were all ok

#

Same with the homesteader you can give cash

spiral laurel
#

But yeah there’s a bunch of weird stuff that take strange requirements to get

serene cove
#

Also

#

I found this strange house in the swamp

spiral laurel
#

what was it

serene cove
#

Theres a painting in there and it looks really familiar

#

Is it a reference to something?

spiral laurel
#

oh… does it look like it’s sorta unfinished?

serene cove
#

No, I've been checking up on it

#

Its some well dressed guy

spiral laurel
#

Did you ever check the mirror

serene cove
#

Can't say I did

spiral laurel
#

Huh, well you should have when you last saw it

serene cove
#

I'm near there right now actually

#

I'm trying to get the crying woman encounter

spiral laurel
#

I don’t think it appears again if you face away from the mirror

#

You may need to either reload a save or look up what’s there

#

I can show you an image

serene cove
#

It looked kind of unfinished

#

But it looked like a guy in a suit and tophat

spiral laurel
#

oh well, If it isn’t done yet then come back some time

hidden moss
#

Playing this game for the first time on a big TV with a proper bass and speakers

#

I appreciate thebsound so much more

serene cove
#

The games a treat

spiral laurel
#

maybe try your luck in a few days

serene cove
#

I'm gonna go check on it right now actually give me a few minutes

hidden moss
#

The way the bass hits as the horse gallops and gunshots

#

The sound design is great

serene cove
#

The night folk are out being night folk-y

#

I love the Easter eggs in this game

spiral laurel
#

what did you find?

serene cove
#

The little alligator in the tophat is great

#

I'm not there yet

spiral laurel
#

I meant by Easter eggs lol

serene cove
#

Oh

#

Well I found two UFOs

#

Some weird nightmare creature in a house

spiral laurel
#

Nightmare creature? Where?

serene cove
#

Dead guy with a tiny arm

#

In the 2nd floor of a house near Annesburg I think

#

Had to climb up some boxes to get there

spiral laurel
#

Yeah that’s a sort of reference to Frankenstein

#

With all the stuff stitched together

serene cove
#

That whole place gave me the shivers

#

A lot of weird taxidermy

#

Ok I'm at the shack

#

Gimme a moment to check on it

#

The painting looks complete

#

Looks like the magician from the main story

spiral laurel
#

Well look at the mirror

#

Tell me what you see

serene cove
#

Oh that's creepy

#

Wait a second

#

That's the strange man from rdr1

spiral laurel
#

Yep

serene cove
#

That guy gave me the shivers

spiral laurel
#

the strange man is just this weird person who seems to follow John a lot

serene cove
#

Yea

spiral laurel
#

It’s also implied he did a deal with one of the residents in Armadillo, which resulted in what it looks like when you finally see it

serene cove
#

Yeah a painting of him is in one of the stores I think

spiral laurel
#

If you go to Armadillos general store it’s there alright, but also notice something weird

#

The guys the same guy from RDR1

#

Even though the whole towns infected, he’s not

#

And he’s arguably the most liable one to die

serene cove
#

Yeah from what I remember isn't he the only survivor??

spiral laurel
#

Yes

#

Not just from Cholera

#

But every other issue the town has faced

serene cove
#

Also the del lobos

spiral laurel
#

Even back when the game was in development and you were allowed to visit as Arthur

#

The Scarlet Fever was happening and it’s assumed he was still there

#

Along with that, thanks to some cryptic writing and what not theres a theory

#

a theory that the strange man offered this guy two things, 2 generations of survival, or happiness, it seems he didn’t take the latter

serene cove
#

He's miserable

#

I really don't like him

spiral laurel
#

Well it’s obvious then which one he chose lol

#

He seems to be either the survivor thanks to the strange man

#

Or possibly the cause of the towns downfall

serene cove
#

I played rdr1 after rdr2 personally

spiral laurel
#

Well here’s something interesting to note

#

The strange man actually mentions the boat robbery we don’t see in RDR2

#

About how Dutch apparently shot a girl through the head

serene cove
#

Heidi McCourt

#

The magician mentions her too

#

I think his name is Josiah

midnight hill
#

hi everyone BongoWave hope this is a good place to ask

I only started the game a week or so ago and trying to get a hang of hunting and collecting pelts and such

I just wanted to clarify, how does one purposefully lose a pelt lol..
I finally got a clear shot of a deer and don't want to lose a perfect pelt, but my camp is way far off as well as any trapper..

how can i lose my pelt on purpose to get it to a trapper automatically blobgiggle

quick whale
hybrid hollow
#

btw guys what is the mysterious hill house

spiral laurel
midnight hill
spiral laurel
#

They aren’t fast really

dire sentinel
#

exactly

midnight hill
#

oh 👀 that is good to know then
thank you! 😅 going to get it to the camp then

spiral laurel
#

you’d really be needing to go out of your way and wait for them to really rot

#

so yeah don’t worry

#

Also one more thing

midnight hill
#

cool cool, thank you ablobaww

dire sentinel
spiral laurel
#

If you have already encountered legendary animals let me just say this, don’t be afraid to use your best weapons as legendary pelts never get damaged

midnight hill
spiral laurel
#

And one uh, take your time btw, don’t rush through story missions since this game is different in the sense that each point in time on a chapter has different things going on

#

Some strangers may become available

#

Some may even not work any more

dire sentinel
#

hopefully you're deep enough into the game to get it, but pretty sure there is a trinket for animals sitting on your horse to not rot

midnight hill
#

ooh good to know 👀 i'll slow down.. blobgiggle i tend to rush through missions a lot in games indeed

dire sentinel
#

i don't recommend chatting here, you'll get spoilers

hybrid hollow
#

btw guys in master challenges how to kill animals but before u should call them

spiral laurel
#

Yeah that’s also a big thing, I haven’t beat the game yet I already got a good idea of what’s going to happen

#

Thanks to YouTube and this server

#

so yeah id be careful

midnight hill
#

haha yeah i'm going to not look here blobgiggle thank you very much, guys, you're all very helpful a_sparkles

spiral laurel
#

Your welcome

hushed flare
#

Just call the animal and kill it right after doggy2

tiny berry
#

do I ask questions about single player here?

hidden moss
#

The Rhodes genes store owner has a bandage and thinks I shot him

#

My third time there thosnplaythrough lol

noble grail
#

Guys

#

Can I get some help

old token
#

Sure : ) I can try to help

noble grail
#

Ok so,

#

I had this hat right

#

And

#

It was from legendary bear pelt n' what not

#

So

#

Pretty important

#

ANd

#

I was trying to tame a horse right

#

But accidently pulled my gun out, and the horse booted me

#

Is there a way to get my hat back?

#

Oh.

#

I am special.

#

Cheers.

old token
#

Pretty sure if you go into where you can change Arthur’s outfits you can just equip it or it should be on your horse I think

#

Wasn’t sure if it was in the horse though since I haven’t played campaign in months😅

noble grail
#

Don't I gotta save it to the horse

old token
#

Yup

turbid ore
#

i'm fine with it on ps4 somehow. It was troubling me for some days then i got the hang of it

#

epilogue 1

#

i dont like that part

#

gets better later near the end

#

3-4 hours at least

#

maybe 2

#

if you skip cutscenes

#

lol

#

you know it already

#

bye

cobalt ferry
#

Yo

#

I’m about to beat the game

#

And my question is

#

Is this game replaysble

#

Replayable

#

I mean

#

Is it fun in your second walkthrough

#

Or is it boring as hell in the second walkthrough

frigid cloud
#

Depends on the person

cobalt ferry
#

I’m the person

#

LOL jk

#

But wdym

primal scroll
#

It's pretty fun on the replay

#

The emotional moments don't hit as hard but you'll notice more cool details on the second playthrough

frigid cloud