red-dead-singleplayer

[oblique rose]

I shot her so many times cause every time in saint denis near the tailor she wouldn’t shut up

[hybrid valley]

she's at the mayor's party too

[oblique rose]

I haven’t seen her since

[rose oar]

omgggg

she was so annoying

like now you will never vote lady

[oblique rose]

Have you guys been in the incest pig farmer place

[hybrid valley]

unfortunately

[rose oar]

yeah i saw a yt video about it so i went there

[oblique rose]

idk why I trusted them

[rose oar]

thsts actually how i kept my@money in the epilogue

[oblique rose]

I wish I went there as Arthur

So I could do that

[rose oar]

but it was so dumb bc

[hybrid valley]

i usually just keep all the unique valuables, and they transfer to john

[rose oar]

in the epilogue i thought they would still be there

so i waited until i had guns

and i showed up there

and the place was abandoned

[oblique rose]

Where on about is tilly

[rose oar]

it was funny bc john had like $5k and he was so desperate for money

[oblique rose]

What if you don’t kill them

Will they still be there

[hybrid valley]

yes

wait

if you don't meet them?

or if you meet them and don't kill them?

[oblique rose]

if you go in there as Arthur

[hybrid valley]

oh that idk

[frigid cloud]

you cant

[oblique rose]

Get your money stolen

And don’t kill them

[frigid cloud]

nvm

[oblique rose]

And you come back as John

Will they be there?

[rose oar]

i didnt kill them

they just leave the place

after they rob arthur

in the epilogue theyre gone

[oblique rose]

I tried shooting the guys head off but it wouldn’t come off

[rose oar]

LMFAOO

i burnt him but

his fat protected him

[hybrid valley]

what made me mad is that i didn't know they have a stash room

[rose oar]

he survived

[oblique rose]

I shot his wife in the head and then choked him

t took so long

[hybrid valley]

so i was always like "why did i come here"

[hidden moss]

His sister u mean

[hybrid valley]

sisterwife

[hidden moss]

😄

[oblique rose]

it’s both

[rose oar]

his sister girlfriendlmfao

yeah

[hybrid valley]

have you guys been to the Strange Man's hut?

[rose oar]

yeah i watched a whole video on him

[frigid cloud]

try choking that guy with raccoon hat in valentine saloon

[rose oar]

oh also alot of ppl dont know this but

[oblique rose]

when I read on YouTube it was incest pig farmer I thought it would be a farmer that breeds pigs with its own family

[hybrid valley]

lmao!

[rose oar]

after trelawny leaves

[hidden moss]

I haven’t, I killed poor jimmy tho

[rose oar]

you can go to his house

as arthur

in saint denis

you can hear him inside his house with his family

and then arthur was like

trelawny??

[hybrid valley]

i think you can do that before he leaves? bc i had it happen in chapter 4

[rose oar]

and he was like arthur is that you

yeah

i think so

[oblique rose]

what about the debt German guy

[rose oar]

strauss?

[oblique rose]

I tried following him when he left

[rose oar]

he died

[oblique rose]

I wanted to shoot hi-

[hybrid valley]

yup

[oblique rose]

Oh

[rose oar]

charles talks to john about it

[oblique rose]

lmao what a noob

[hybrid valley]

Charles tells John in St Denis

[rose oar]

i never finished the debts

[hybrid valley]

he got tortured for info abt the gang

and he never said a word

[rose oar]

sad bc thats what happened to sean except sean made it out tho

didnt survive long after that 😬😬

[oblique rose]

I can’t find Tilly

[hybrid valley]

She's by the Dominoes

Sitting on a bench waiting for a trolly

[rose oar]

look up her location online

[frigid cloud]

Near tailor

[oblique rose]

Sean’s death made me jump since it was so unexpected

[rose oar]

yeah near the tailor at the trolly

[frigid cloud]

dominoes 💩

[rose oar]

i never did that

or poker

[hybrid valley]

still don't know how to play that game lmao

[frigid cloud]

Me neither

My opponent always draws

[hybrid valley]

i got really good at poker in the game and then tried to play it in real life and realized there was no game giving me prompts on what to do

[rose oar]

LMFAOOO

i didnt know how to play poker

[candid walrus]

Dominoes

[rose oar]

omg i forgot about the javier trelawny arthur mission

with the poker

thats what made me love javier

[hybrid valley]

i looooove that mission

[oblique rose]

The boat)

?

[frigid cloud]

yes

[hybrid valley]

i love when javier murders people for calling him slurs

[rose oar]

yeah

[frigid cloud]

Ferry

[oblique rose]

yeah same

Wasn’t it Strauss that gave you directions in the poker game

[hybrid valley]

yes

[rose oar]

yeah

i was so scared for that mission

idk why

j thought i would somehow mess up

[oblique rose]

Arthur was drippy in that mission

[hybrid valley]

what was y'all's hardest missions?

[rose oar]

omg

the one with charles where

[frigid cloud]

You're scripted to win I think

[hybrid valley]

like the ones you messed up the most

[rose oar]

you had to clear out

the chapter 6 camp

charles kept running in there and dying

[oblique rose]

What camp was rhat

[rose oar]

and i would play it at like 3 am

[hybrid valley]

beaver hollow

[frigid cloud]

Beaver hollow

[rose oar]

yeah

[oblique rose]

oh

[rose oar]

i played at 3 am so i was too scared

didnt play it for like

a week after that

[hybrid valley]

the Murfrees creep me out too

[rose oar]

i ended up skipping that part

[oblique rose]

I was camping once and the Murfrees showed up

[rose oar]

in my second playthrough i cleared out the place and i was so happy

omg that happens to me sometimes

then when it gives me the option to kill them

i kill them

[hybrid valley]

have you ever had the creepy woman show up at your camp?

[oblique rose]

And then one of them tried stealing my horse

no

[rose oar]

the paranoid one?

[hybrid valley]

yes

[rose oar]

like 4 times lmfao

[frigid cloud]

She talks about butcher creek

[hybrid valley]

ugh i hate butcher creek man

[rose oar]

same

that one mission with the dogs

[hybrid valley]

but i love to watch that dude run around screaming

[oblique rose]

I haven’t met her

[frigid cloud]

It's random anyway

[hybrid valley]

the banjo guy at butcher creek scared the bejeezus out of me

[frigid cloud]

Funny how you have option to kill that widow in chapter 6

[rose oar]

i never rly go there

omg i always see people doing that mission but

i never did it

[hybrid valley]

i love that mission

Charlotte is so good

[rose oar]

are there missions i have to do as arthur to get 100%?

[frigid cloud]

No

[hybrid valley]

no

[oblique rose]

Have you guys ever went into a store and then you bump into a guy that steals your money

[rose oar]

bc im on my 3rd playthrough now

[frigid cloud]

You only need 10 stranger missions for 100%

Doesn't matter which ones

[rose oar]

yeah and then u loot him and get twice the money he stole

wait actually

[hybrid valley]

you have to do all the challenges though

[rose oar]

omg 😭

[oblique rose]

wait WHAT

you can loot him

[rose oar]

ive done basically all the stranger missions

YES LMFAO

[oblique rose]

I just threaten him

[rose oar]

you hogtie him

and then loot him

[oblique rose]

And let him fin

[frigid cloud]

I didn't hogtie

[rose oar]

and u get like 1.2k

[oblique rose]

bruh

[hybrid valley]

dammit i didn't know that

[frigid cloud]

I tackled him

[oblique rose]

I’ve been robbed like 4 times

[hybrid valley]

lmao!!!

[frigid cloud]

It also happens in van horn saloon

[oblique rose]

are you serious right now

[frigid cloud]

Bartender warns you

[oblique rose]

iwisjsjwiwiss

[rose oar]

the law might getmad tho

for hogtying

worth it tho

[frigid cloud]

Nah

[hybrid valley]

did you guys know there's a lady in the small saloon in st denis who propositions you and you can say yes

[frigid cloud]

Game knows he's a thief

So you don't get wanted

[rose oar]

the law usually gets mad at me

[oblique rose]

and then she leads you too a gang?

[hybrid valley]

yeah lmfao

[oblique rose]

yeah

[hybrid valley]

and if you say yes as john you lose honor

[oblique rose]

I thought I could fuck

[frigid cloud]

Never happened I usually threaten and beat him up

[rose oar]

did youguys ever beat up that guy in the van horn saloon

i felt bad about that omg

[oblique rose]

The big guy

[hybrid valley]

me too omg

[frigid cloud]

who

[rose oar]

the one in the circus

[oblique rose]

I forgot his name

Bertram?

[frigid cloud]

Oh yeah

[hybrid valley]

Bertram

[rose oar]

bertram

yes

[frigid cloud]

I thought you were talking about the guy in valentine saloon

[oblique rose]

and that little dwarf was annoting as hell

[rose oar]

LMFAOO

having to chase hik

as he disappeared

with his smoke

[hybrid valley]

it was p cool though

i'm a sucker for pretty colors

[oblique rose]

I wanted to pick him up and kick him like a ball

[rose oar]

HAHAHAHHA

[oblique rose]

I tried shooting him

[rose oar]

then it said you could see them perform in saint denis but i never checked it out

right

[frigid cloud]

fr

[oblique rose]

I miss the horshoe overlook whatever it was called

[rose oar]

i always play music when i play the game

[oblique rose]

I liked that place

[rose oar]

my favourite camp

was colter

[hybrid valley]

mine is shady belle

[rose oar]

lmfao when the game first came out i didnt know how to read cursive and

[frigid cloud]

lakay best

[rose oar]

i thought it was colten

[oblique rose]

Shady belle is the mansion right

[frigid cloud]

yes

[rose oar]

yeah

[oblique rose]

I hate that place only cause of kierans death

[rose oar]

same

that was sad

[frigid cloud]

I dont

[hybrid valley]

and the glitched Raiders yelling in the distance

[rose oar]

my first playthrough i didnt know who anybody was

like when we saved sean

i thought it was a random guy

and when we saved john

and dropped him off at camp

[oblique rose]

ironic it’s an Irish guy named sean

[hybrid valley]

omg i was losing it when we saved john

[rose oar]

i thought we were saving a random ladies husband

[hybrid valley]

i was like "SHOW ME THE BOY"

[rose oar]

and i literally played rdr1

LMFAOOOO

[oblique rose]

John is in red dead 1?

[rose oar]

i finished rdr1 but that was like 4 years ago

you play as him-

[oblique rose]

I haven’t played it

[frigid cloud]

[hybrid valley]

John is the protagonist of RDR1

[rose oar]

ohhh if your on ps4 its on playstation now

[oblique rose]

is he?

[hybrid valley]

and it takes place after rdr2

[rose oar]

wait

in rdr2

you play as artuur right

[oblique rose]

I’m gonna play it after I 100% rdr2

[hybrid valley]

yes

[void pine]

How long is the epilogue

[rose oar]

and turn into john

[rose oar]

a few hrs long

then

[frigid cloud]

3 hours max

[rose oar]

in rdr1

you play as john

[void pine]

ok thx

[frigid cloud]

Or 4

[rose oar]

and turn into jack

if there would be an rdr3

i wonder if you would play as jack

[oblique rose]

you can play as jack in red dead 1? That’s badass

[hybrid valley]

i want a game about the van der linde gang in the old days

[rose oar]

yeah hes grown up

[oblique rose]

o

[rose oar]

sameeee

[hybrid valley]

yo spoilers

[oblique rose]

fr

[rose oar]

and the blackwater massacre

[oblique rose]

e

[rose oar]

lmao imagine some weird gta red dead crossover

[oblique rose]

Aren’t they in the same universe

[hybrid valley]

there's GTA stuff in red dead

the Chelonians

[rose oar]

and red dead stuff in gta

like in online

[hybrid valley]

turn into that weird cult in GTA

[rose oar]

your arcade door is madam nazar from online

also in gta

[oblique rose]

did you guys know in the Spider-Man game if you climb a building you can find nico Bellec’s apartment and he’s planning a heist

[rose oar]

you get an email from vanderlinde

[void pine]

when does rdr2 take place

[frigid cloud]

1899

[oblique rose]

If they make red dead 3 there better be Tahiti

[rose oar]

1899

[frigid cloud]

And 1907 later on

[void pine]

Oh ok

[oblique rose]

1899 and 1907

[rose oar]

epilogue is 8 years after the story

tbh i dont like epilogue jack

i only like him bc its jack

[oblique rose]

I hated his voice

[rose oar]

when you take him on a horse ride

i get him bucked on purpose

[oblique rose]

I wanted the tiny little child that walks around with no shoes again, not the 12 year old that calls you sir

[rose oar]

but then i felt bad and let him win the race

LMFAOOO

right

[frigid cloud]

I never let him win

[void pine]

rdr2 is probably my favorite game of all time now. there’s just so much to do and it’s so difficult to get bored

[oblique rose]

There’s probably still stuff we haven’t discovered

[candid walrus]

Yep.

[oblique rose]

I liked going fishing with jack as Arthur

[languid perch]

sea of thieves got dethroned by rdr2

for me

[rose oar]

i stopped playing red dead for like months

bc i was so busy on gta

when i got back on

[oblique rose]

I hate not being able to swim

As John

[rose oar]

the pass had just came out

same

[oblique rose]

Cause I loved jumping off mountains into water

[rose oar]

i had to do stuff that required me to swim

[hybrid valley]

maybe he shouldn't be such a little baby

[frigid cloud]

And learn how to swim

[rose oar]

they couldnt make him swim since rdr1

it was too much forthe game to handle

so they said he couldnt swim

[frigid cloud]

'Can't herd, can't swim'

[hybrid valley]

stinky weasel boy

[oblique rose]

Should of been a point where Arthur teaches him

[rose oar]

they couldnt

bc rdr1 is after rdr2

[oblique rose]

You know what Would make sense

when John is escaping prison

That halfway when their on the boat the guards shoot it down

And that’s when John learns too swim

[rose oar]

they couldnt do that

[oblique rose]

it would be better

[rose oar]

in rdr1 he canr swim

[oblique rose]

oh

[rose oar]

so then it would be

he couldnt swim then he could

[oblique rose]

Give him floaters

[rose oar]

then he couldnt again

LMFAOOO

[hybrid valley]

lmfao john with arm floaties

and a ducky ring

[rose oar]

usually when i go into story

[oblique rose]

it was invented in 1931

[rose oar]

it shows a picture of colter

[oblique rose]

that’s like 20 years

[rose oar]

but now its been rotating pictures

LMFAOOO

[oblique rose]

oh

[rose oar]

HAHAHAHA

its ok im not good at@math either

[oblique rose]

Just ditch the 12 years

[rose oar]

shouldve seen me trying to figure out how much money i would make if i got $14 an hour for 8 hours

[oblique rose]

John could invent it

[rose oar]

i had to use a calculator on my phone

omg i just realized

if im going to work in a few months

i need to know math

[hidden moss]

Duh silly!

[rose oar]

i cant do division or subtraction or multiplication

[candid walrus]

Tf

[rose oar]

ima use my phone calculator

i cant do any math

i cant do basic 4th grade math

its sad

[oblique rose]

fr

[hidden moss]

F

[oblique rose]

I used to be in special ed lmao

My ass couldnt do math

Still cant

[rose oar]

i have adhd so i couldnt focus in class

[oblique rose]

i have anxiety

And school made it Worse

Damn bro

guys where can i Get a good horse

I spent like 950$ on a horse

It was an arabian

And then that was the horse that got run over

Sad

[rose oar]

HAHAAHAHAHAHA

[oblique rose]

I cried when the horse i had as Arthur died in the end, cause it was the horse you got at the beginning of the game

i cried over a fucking fictional horse

[rose oar]

i usually sold that horse right away

[oblique rose]

im such s loser

[rose oar]

i kept it this time

[hybrid valley]

yo SAME though

[rose oar]

omg i accidentallykilled a horse

and cried

[oblique rose]

I had no horse reviver once

and i couldnt kill my horse

I didnt have the balls

[hidden moss]

I kept that same horse the entire game, afterwards I decied to go up to the mountains and get the white arabian

[rose oar]

i sold it

nvm i didnt

[hidden moss]

when i got buell as john i took him down to the stables to sell my other horse. On my way there i manage to kill him LOL

[oblique rose]

My horse died s couple minutes ago

[rose oar]

AHAHHAHA

[hidden moss]

i was quick to load a previous save though

[frigid cloud]

How to kill your horse;
Meet mary-beth in valentine station
Leave your horse on train track

[oblique rose]

I see everyone talking about buell

How do i Get it

[rose oar]

im using the horse you get at the adler ranch

[hidden moss]

You do the veteran missions

[rose oar]

the hamish mission

[oblique rose]

No spilers just location

plez

[rose oar]

near o creaghs run

[hidden moss]

dunno what its called

[frigid cloud]

Only in chapter 6

[oblique rose]

its only in chapter 6?

[rose oar]

dont do it before the epilogue

no

[hidden moss]

you can do the three first missions with him

[oblique rose]

i havent done it

[rose oar]

its not just in chapter 6

[hybrid valley]

yeah if you do it as arthur you won't have buell in the epilogue

[oblique rose]

But i heard about the veteran missions

[frigid cloud]

Well I meant you can't do his missions before chapter 6

[rose oar]

go up to o’creaghs run

ohhh

[hybrid valley]

there are 3 or 4 parts to the veteran missions

[rose oar]

4 parts

yes

[oblique rose]

when my horse died about 30 minutes ago i just stole a horse of some guys cargo carrier idk what the name is

[rose oar]

you can do the first 3 as arthur if u want to

[hidden moss]

ugh tell me about it

[oblique rose]

Uncle complained to me about lumbago while i had tubercolosis

[hidden moss]

I'm pretty sure I was able to meet mr black and white both as arthur and john

[oblique rose]

Same here

[hidden moss]

pretty weird

[oblique rose]

I fid their mission as John a couple hours ago

[hybrid valley]

you can do most of the stranger missions as john

[hidden moss]

yes i know

but i did them as arthur

and then i did them again as john

[frigid cloud]

Except chapter exclusive ones

[hybrid valley]

OH yeah i had that happen too

[hidden moss]

weird

[oblique rose]

Have ya’ll done the oh brother missions

[hybrid valley]

i love those two

[hidden moss]

probably

[hybrid valley]

they're so stupid

[oblique rose]

i just stole a random horse and it has 5 in speed

[hybrid valley]

is it a standardbred

[oblique rose]

Its a heavy

[hybrid valley]

huh

halfbred?

[oblique rose]

wagon ride in chapter 1?

[hybrid valley]

i like it'

it has charles

[oblique rose]

it was calm

it had Charles and hosea wasnt it

[frigid cloud]

why don't you skip the mission

Fail 3 times

[oblique rose]

What do i name the horse

[frigid cloud]

Horse

[hidden moss]

Bastard

[oblique rose]

Its a belgian

should i name it waffle

[hybrid valley]

omg yes

[hidden moss]

you should name is bastard

[oblique rose]

Do u guys still have rachel

[hybrid valley]

i LOVE rachel

but that's bc I'm a slut for thoroughbreds

[oblique rose]

I had an arabian the same colours as rachel

[rose oar]

i hated rachel

[crimson bronze]

Rachel is a nice horse, I just wish that they had better stats.

[oblique rose]

So i wanted to name it rachel but on steroids

[rose oar]

i sold her immediately

[crimson bronze]

@oblique rose Was it the warped Brindle?

[hybrid valley]

i personally have never needed my horses to be super fast

[oblique rose]

idk it died a couple minutes after i for it

Got it*

[hybrid valley]

yeah rachel has some of the best stats in game

and she's not a pony

i can't get over how silly arthur looks on those tiny arabians

[oblique rose]

guys i keep finding gavin’s friend

[hybrid valley]

yeah he gets around

[oblique rose]

Im gonna run him over

[frigid cloud]

kill him

[hidden moss]

i wonder how gavin's doing

[hybrid valley]

i think he got abducted by the UFO

[hidden moss]

isnt there some video

[oblique rose]

Hes probably one of the murders Victims

[frigid cloud]

He's the invisible sniper

[hidden moss]

that a guy get abducted outside of valentine

during a thunderstorm?

[oblique rose]

I love valentine

[hidden moss]

me too

people thought the dude was michael from gta or something

or played by the same actor at least

[crimson bronze]

Health and Stamina is more of what I mean.

[oblique rose]

worst city what is it

Armadillo

Are you already in chapter 2

[frigid cloud]

Missed it I bet

[oblique rose]

When did you start

[frigid cloud]

Now craft legend of the east satchel

[oblique rose]

it took me 4 hours just for chapter 1 in my original playthrougj

[oblique rose]

I love that satchel but hate how it looks

[frigid cloud]

You can use others

And still keep the expansion

[hybrid valley]

if y'all are trying to be completionist i recommend rdr2map.com

[oblique rose]

what

fr?

[frigid cloud]

Yup

[oblique rose]

So i can like use the tonics satchel

[hybrid valley]

yep

[frigid cloud]

I switched to Arthur's and it still said carrying 55 out of 99

[oblique rose]

alright going to change now

I hate when you run over some guy

By accident

Did chat just die

[hybrid valley]

this chat?

hey who is y'all's favorite gang member

besides arthur and john

[candid walrus]

Micah

[hidden moss]

pearson i think

its really sad seeing him in chapter 6

well on second thought

[hybrid valley]

have you seen him sing that song

[hidden moss]

i dont actually know

oh yeah

[hybrid valley]

and arthur can join in

[hidden moss]

yeah

[hybrid valley]

that got me bad

[hidden moss]

that was very sad

mhm

[hybrid valley]

but also arthur has a very nice singing voice

[hidden moss]

yeah

but idk whos my favourite

i like all of them

[hybrid valley]

it's a hard choice

mine is charles

[hidden moss]

rockstar really made all loveable

except micah

[hybrid valley]

every time I hear Nosh's voice i die inside

[hidden moss]

whos nosh?

[hybrid valley]

Noshir Dalal

Charles's va

[frigid cloud]

Neither

I can't decide

[hidden moss]

ahh

i really do like the whole gang though

[hybrid valley]

me too

except Dutch and Grimshaw

[hidden moss]

i love dutch

[frigid cloud]

Y grimshaw

[hybrid valley]

i think Dutch is a great character, well-written

[frigid cloud]

What's wrong with her

[hybrid valley]

I hate the way she treats the women

she's super nice to the men

[hidden moss]

i find dutch has the best potential story wise

[hybrid valley]

but she basically expects the women to whore themselves out

and tried to force abigail to go back to prostitution

[frigid cloud]

when

[hybrid valley]

there's an ambient convo

where she and abigail are yelling at each other

and she says abigail is having thoughts above her station

and abigail says she isn't, she just isn't going to do that anymore

[frigid cloud]

what chapter

[hidden moss]

if there ever comes a rdr3 i hope it shows more of dutch's story

[hybrid valley]

i wish i could link a video

it's in ch 2

in front of john's tent

[frigid cloud]

I found one

She really said she could discuss the matter with dutch lol

[hybrid valley]

she also has a rant at the campfire

about how the girls are all useless because they think they're too good to be whores

[frigid cloud]

I think once she forced me to have a bath during the debt missions

[hidden moss]

what mission

[hybrid valley]

it's when he's tied to the tree

you do the first few missions and then a K shows up

[hidden moss]

oh

[candid walrus]

They try and geld him

[hybrid valley]

i think you have to go hunting with Hosea

[candid walrus]

Yeah, you do

[hybrid valley]

anyone else think Bill has a crush on Kieran

[frigid cloud]

no

[hidden moss]

i think bill has a crush on himself

[hybrid valley]

yes it's the one with the horse

[frigid cloud]

Yes going to stable first

[idle pike]

It's hinted that Bills sexuality is for men indeed.

[hybrid valley]

yep!

[hybrid valley]

thank you! yeah he was discharged for deviancy

[hidden moss]

at 10am

[hybrid valley]

it's between 10 am and like 12:45

basically, when he starts preparing the stew and before he puts the pot on the fire

stay away from him, go hang around at the square table

he'll go between chopping rabbit, take the bowl over to the side table, then he'll stop and drink from his flask (that's not when to approach him)

it's a crapshoot

[spiral laurel]

Bill has been well... he's been referenced a lot in Homosexual ways, now I dunno if its to tease his masculinity or actually poking fun at a fact

but it's still a thought

however I don't think Kieran wants to be anywhere near him

[hybrid valley]

@hidden moss he does a few different animations besides drinking

[frigid cloud]

after he tried to geld him

[hybrid valley]

he'll be preparing the stew, and then SOMETIMES he'll go stand behind the side table, chop some things, and then stop and take a drink

you approach him then and Greet him

[spiral laurel]

You talking about Pearson?

yeah he has a whole Routine

[idle pike]

He literally knows that the rapist in the swamp 'did things' to Arthur

[spiral laurel]

Yeah exactly

[hybrid valley]

You greet him when you see him drinking from a tall bottle

[hidden moss]

the rapist in the swamp?

[spiral laurel]

Yes

[hybrid valley]

yo the fact that he teased arthur about that was fuckt up

[idle pike]

Yep

[spiral laurel]

if a man offers you food from a cabin, take a walk inside

[hidden moss]

OHH

wait you got raped?

[spiral laurel]

Its IMPLIED

[idle pike]

[hybrid valley]

heavily

[hidden moss]

Oop

[hybrid valley]

arthur even walks funny

[spiral laurel]

It's not actually said if you are or not

but it's IMPLIED

[spiral laurel]

thats because all of his cores are gone when you leave

[hidden moss]

I just thought he got robbed and thrown out

[spiral laurel]

it's not to Imply that he has been, it's because his cores are gone

[hybrid valley]

there are videos on youtube that'll show you exactly what it looks like

[spiral laurel]

Arthur has different walks depending on his Health or Stamina

what are you talking about?

[hybrid valley]

okay so

he'll be holding the drink in his hand

and you go up and greet him

[hidden moss]

isnt it better if you just watch a youtube video about this?

then you can see exactly what to do

[hybrid valley]

when he's standing behind the cutting board on the side of the wagon

holding a tall bottle in his hand

sometimes he'll be whistling

[oblique rose]

which camp is this

[hybrid valley]

Horseshoe

[frigid cloud]

Horseshoe overlook

[hybrid valley]

Sometimes you talk to him while he's drinking and nothing happens

it's stupid

[oblique rose]

i saw him drinking at a table once

I just walked past him

[hybrid valley]

yeah

and sometimes it doesn't work

i don't know why

[viscid trout]

Hey, does anyone knows where can I find the music of this scene? At 2:53

[hybrid valley]

nobody really knows the EXACTLY conditions

like i said, it's hard

it took me like 2 days

[viscid trout]

youtube com/watch?v=5gjVpYQ9DWQ

[hidden moss]

according to the video i just found. He jumps off the cliff at like 10am and then after that he goes back to camp and sits at the poker table

until he takes up a bottle

[hybrid valley]

that never worked for me

the cliff

[hidden moss]

meanwhile you need to get your stamina core to red

by smoking or something

and then he will call you peaky

[narrow salmon]

my mods for singleplayer have all of a sudden stopped working, i have uninstalled the game and reinstalled about 3 times now. If anyone has a solution that would be super useful

[hybrid valley]

oh well there you go

it's even more unknowable

[oblique rose]

now i wanna replay story mode

[hybrid valley]

i'm on my 5th playthrough 😳

agreed

esp bc i don't want any of the valentine horses

[native thunder]

i heard the new update screwed up any mods

[hidden moss]

you need to buy a horse during that mission?

[native thunder]

yes

[narrow salmon]

oh really?

[hidden moss]

ah

i probably just got the special edition one

[hybrid valley]

love that horse

[native thunder]

yea u can get the free black throughbred if u have ultimate

[hidden moss]

yeah

[frigid cloud]

It's nice

[native thunder]

but otherwise it forces u to buy one

[hybrid valley]

i always use a black standardbred

[hidden moss]

i see

[hybrid valley]

i got really attached to it

[hidden moss]

i just go and get the white arabian as soon as i can

[hybrid valley]

have you checked the RDR2 soundtrack?

[hidden moss]

then i use that until it dies in chapter 6

[frigid cloud]

I only catched white Arabian once

[hybrid valley]

i like the red chestnut arabian better

[hidden moss]

i just find it being all white is awesome

so thats why i use it

same as dutch's

[oblique rose]

Have you guys encountered the Kkk in the game

[hidden moss]

although his is albino

[hidden moss]

yes

[hybrid valley]

horse girl fact
dutch's arabian is white, not albino
and the white arabian is actually gray

[oblique rose]

I got good honor for killing them

[candid walrus]

Finally someone understands

[hybrid valley]

it drives me nuts man

[candid walrus]

Albinos don't exist

[candid walrus]

Samee

[hybrid valley]

i love white horses

they're so pretty

it's why i love the few spotted appy so much

it's so close

it never worked for me but it's worked for others, i know

[oblique rose]

I havent killed a legendary animal yet

[hidden moss]

im fairly sure dutch's horse is albino

[hybrid valley]

the game says it is, but it isn't

horses aren't albino

[candid walrus]

Albinos don't exist irl, but the game says they do.

[hidden moss]

oh ok

[oblique rose]

I mean

Guarma doesnt exist either

[candid walrus]

Just like 'white' horses don't really exist
They're actually a type of gray :)

[hybrid valley]

it's all about the skin color

[candid walrus]

Rockstar didn't seem to research coats much

[native thunder]

an island and the color of a horse is different lol

[candid walrus]

Ye

[hybrid valley]

got some of the horse coats drive me nuts

[hidden moss]

so

[hybrid valley]

"mahogany bay" it's an overo bay shut up

[hidden moss]

white horses are grey horses

and albino horses are white horses

[oblique rose]

Did you guys rob dutch while drunk

[hybrid valley]

yep!

[hidden moss]

according to the article i just read

[frigid cloud]

Isn't that a mod

[oblique rose]

no

i dont think so

I saw someone rob Jack

[hidden moss]

what do you get out of it

[oblique rose]

Jack calls you a Meanie

[hybrid valley]

@hidden moss i went out and did a mission every now and then and then tried again

finally got it when i was coming back into camp after a mission, went straight to pearson, and he gave the request

lmfaoooo

[oblique rose]

buy fast travel

[hybrid valley]

i'm glad i'm not the only one who worked this hard for a damn jacket

[oblique rose]

Or Get on a train to valentine

[hybrid valley]

it's just such a sexy jacket

[hidden moss]

i never really used jackets

[oblique rose]

Same

[hidden moss]

only coat i really used was the montana one

cause that looks swaggy as hell

[hybrid valley]

i have a mod that adds temperature cores

[oblique rose]

No collar shirt and vest is what i wear

[hybrid valley]

so i use them more now than i did first playthrough

[hidden moss]

i just dont find them good looking

except for the gunslinger jacket or whatever its called

[hybrid valley]

i only use the scout jacket and the ram coat for winter

i want the ram coat in real life so i can pimp walk

[oblique rose]

They wasted the snow biome

[hybrid valley]

oh my god right??

[hidden moss]

how

[oblique rose]

not Even a snow village

[hybrid valley]

the ONLY time i go up there is if i'm desperate for meese

[oblique rose]

I like camping up there

[hybrid valley]

i like walking on the ice and hearing the boings

[oblique rose]

I found the frozen couple at night

[hybrid valley]

did you go back to sadie's house and get the jewelry

[oblique rose]

no

[hidden moss]

nope

[frigid cloud]

It's burnt down isnt it

[hidden moss]

i was going to go back there to see if there is something to get but i never did

[hybrid valley]

yeah but there's a lockbox

[oblique rose]

Is it an item request

[hybrid valley]

just like the gold bar at the braithwaite manor

[oblique rose]

How much is a gold bar worth

[hybrid valley]

500

[native thunder]

500

[hidden moss]

500

[frigid cloud]

500

[native thunder]

lol

[oblique rose]

oj

[hidden moss]

wasnt it 300 originally?

[native thunder]

300 is ingot

[hybrid valley]

yes

[native thunder]

whatre you doing?

[hybrid valley]

yeah just sit and creep on him

doesn't matter

[hidden moss]

dont thinii tmatters

[hybrid valley]

if you guys haven't done the entire explorer challenge set i highly recommend it

big money

[oblique rose]

How much

[native thunder]

explorer challenges were the easiest

[hybrid valley]

i always go and get all the gold bars right out the gate

[hidden moss]

i just watched a youtube video for all the gold locations

[oblique rose]

How much money

[hidden moss]

lots

[hybrid valley]

like 3k

[candid walrus]

Armless Arthur

[frigid cloud]

And most boring probably

[hidden moss]

i love how dutch always complained about money and there i was sitting at like 6k

[native thunder]

not rlyt boring, its quick as hell

[hybrid valley]

he goes at like 9:45

[native thunder]

every challenge is just find a treasure

[hybrid valley]

there's also the statue gold bars

like 2 or 3 of them

[oblique rose]

20k is nothing in gta but alot in red dead

[hybrid valley]

and the limpany gold bar

[hidden moss]

because back then 20k was A LOT of money

[hybrid valley]

basically multiply money by 30 for rdr

so 20k was like 600k

[oblique rose]

Dang

[hybrid valley]

the blackwater ferry was carrying 150k

which tells you why the VDL gang is so wanted

[hidden moss]

how did they manage to waste 130k

[frigid cloud]

If Micah got the blackwater money why john gets 20k at the end

[hybrid valley]

they didn't

they hid it

because dutch spent a lot

[frigid cloud]

How big was the bank debt

[oblique rose]

im so glad i didnt go back for the money

[hybrid valley]

i have a theory

that dutch buried the money in his mother's grave

in Blackwater

[hidden moss]

that would make sense

[hybrid valley]

he tells hosea "my mother is buried in blackwater, did i ever tell you that?"

[oblique rose]

nah he bought a boat to Tahiti but it was a scam

[hybrid valley]

i don't think so

[frigid cloud]

So he lied

[hybrid valley]

nope

[hidden moss]

you can find her grvae

[hybrid valley]

you can find his mother's grave

[frigid cloud]

nvm

I know

Thought of something else

[hybrid valley]

just wait

[oblique rose]

Did anyone Else wear Arthurs hat a lot more when he passed away

[hybrid valley]

he'll be there

i NEVER changed hats for arthur or john

[frigid cloud]

Nah IT'S worse on john

[hidden moss]

i always wore arthurs hat

it just looks dope af

[oblique rose]

same

[hybrid valley]

i told you man it's tough

[oblique rose]

looks to good

[hybrid valley]

he's not a reliable man

i always wore john's hat as john though

bc i missed it so much from rdr1

[hidden moss]

oh i wore arthurs as john too

[frigid cloud]

Johns hat better

I like it more

[halcyon dove]

anybody here remember jolly from the server

[oblique rose]

Idk i joined today

[hybrid valley]

same

yeah! he started cooking, now just keep an eye on him

sit at the poker table

yes

or you can sit at the square table and still see him

[oblique rose]

I wanna play red dead online so bad but my internet sucks

[hybrid valley]

yeah ignore that

[hidden moss]

i find online extremely boring

[hybrid valley]

if it's the flask that's not it

i've only played online for like 5 hours max

yes it's normal

he has several animations that he does while preparing lunch

agreed!

feels more lifelike

he'll take the bowl over to the side table

and then he MIGHT stay there, or he might go back to the butcher table

go get drunk on the whisky by hosea's bed

[hidden moss]

have you studied every corner of this game or something?

[hybrid valley]

it'll empty health core

me? yes

[hidden moss]

i can tell

[hybrid valley]

i just hit 1000 hrs

and it's all in story mode

it's a sickness

[hidden moss]

wtf

[frigid cloud]

well done

I've got like 900 hours but stopped playing recently

[hidden moss]

how do you people manage

[hybrid valley]

i have no friends

:)

[hidden moss]

neither do i

[hybrid valley]

and i don't leave my house

[hidden moss]

but playing a game for 1000 hours is extremely boring IMO

[hybrid valley]

and i have OCD

[hidden moss]

i dont leave my house either partner

[hybrid valley]

sometimes he straight up won't

and you'll have to try again the next day

it sucks

[native thunder]

why do you guys think having an empty core will aid you in getting pearson's jacket

[hybrid valley]

some ppl say it does

didn't work for me

[native thunder]

i dont think it's that complicated

[hidden moss]

anyway imma go back and play some more

[native thunder]

also try not to stalk him, you can also turn the camera away from him, and soemtimes the animation will change

[hybrid valley]

ohhhh i never tried that

[native thunder]

reload ur save

his animation will be him cutting meat on the table with the tent over it

[hybrid valley]

lmfao

[native thunder]

imagine arthur just staring and following pearson lol

[oblique rose]

Pearson wouldnt care

[hybrid valley]

he'd just start talking about the navy

[oblique rose]

lumbago

[hybrid valley]

yeah, it'll loop

i recommend doing what Sheep said

[native thunder]

i got mine pretty quickly on pc, but on ps4, i just loaded saves at around 9am to 3pm. i stayed on the right of dutch's tent facing away from the poker table. then turned my camera away from where pearson is. then ocassionally checked back

"i stayed on the right of dutch's tent facing away from the poker table", by that i mean where he usually stands holding a cigar during the day time. at evening he stands facing the poker table

what tiem is it

well, i htink you have until 2-3pm

but dont stare at him lol

do some other stuff in camp without looking at him, or just reload ur save rn

uh yea.

[oblique rose]

I had a knife finger game with Lenny once

It was fun

man i miss Lenny

[native thunder]

reloading saves is singleplayer's cheat code, like i said before

[hybrid valley]

^ true

like when you're horse gets downed and you're about to die so you slam the start menu and get out before it's too late

[native thunder]

i got pearsons request on pc just by waking up in noon, and then i walked up to him and boom arthur becomes 'peaky'

okay?

spawn by the fire and ?

[hybrid valley]

nothing is guaranteed

[oblique rose]

i thought pearson would become a butcher

Not a general store guy

[native thunder]

cool

tbh, you can just wait as long as you want until maybe 6pm

[hybrid valley]

the tennessee whiskey

[native thunder]

he will hold the animation for a decent amount

[hybrid valley]

the tall bottle

[native thunder]

rip lol

[hybrid valley]

ah shit

i forgot that the update would break my mods

[native thunder]

again, ur stalking him right?

lol what

[hybrid valley]

you have until the very last mission of ch 2 to do it

[native thunder]

what why

lol

[hushed flare]

Because it worked for some peoppe

[native thunder]

oh nvm his animation is just holding the bottle for way too long for a normal person

maybe sleep , click noon option, check, if not then leave camp do some stuff maybe for an in game hour, then come back

[frigid cloud]

nice

How does the jacket look like

[hybrid valley]

NICE

when you bring the rabbit, donate it like any other animal

[frigid cloud]

I know I was asking to someone else

[native thunder]

DENIM

[hybrid valley]

it's the scout jacket, but denim with tan fur on the collar

[frigid cloud]

I think you need to press give request and you donate

[hybrid valley]

not for this one, it doesn't have the give request option

so you just donate it to camp like normal

[native thunder]

i held the rabbit, walked to pearson, pressed give request, he said to bring it to the table, and then i donated it

[frigid cloud]

Yes he does

[hybrid valley]

fair enough

[native thunder]

but yea i think u can jsut donate it

just run around the entirety of twin stack pass and the heartlands area

[frigid cloud]

I looked up, you press give request and he tells to leave it on the table and you donate if you don't press give request it might just be a donation

NO

[native thunder]

carcass

oh no

HAHA

[frigid cloud]

Just rabbit

Not pelt

[hybrid valley]

sdfhjkhsdfajk;lfa

hahahaha

oh no

god i can't ride my horse on the road into camp without hitting a rabbit normally

but whenever i need one suddenly they're extinct

i downloaded a mod that turned the boar talisman into Blondie's poncho and it doesn't work

this sucks

try just walking around

i've noticed that if you go really slow, stuff starts to spawn more

could be in my head but

[frigid cloud]

Hosea's mission had consistent perfect rabbit carcasses but you did it already

[spare oar]

@hybrid valley damn I got the same wallpaper on my phone (love it so much))

[hybrid valley]

yessss it's my destop wallpaper too

i think so?

[frigid cloud]

They do

I'm sure

[turbid ore]

if i use my legendary bear pelt to craft a jacket, then can i use it later for crafting other items?

[hybrid valley]

you'll only need it for the items you can craft with the trapper

there's no other use

[turbid ore]

ok

so i cant craft the whole set

[hybrid valley]

oh! yes you can

you can craft all the items that require it

[turbid ore]

ok

[hybrid valley]

since you just saved