#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 408 of 1

hidden moss
#

dunno how smart comes into play but it just shows john never had a journal to draw in throughout his adventures

spiral laurel
#

Ok maybe I should have said something like that

#

it's not that he isn't smart

hidden moss
#

its alright

spiral laurel
#

he's just not as Experienced

hidden moss
#

yeah

#

i find arthur being the better character overall though

spiral laurel
#

but Yeah, I do like how John seems to have his own thoughts about things in his Journal while still sharing similar thoughts as Arthur

#

I like John so far man

native thunder
#

i would have more fun playing as john if he could swim or draw better lol

spiral laurel
#

I played RDR1 first recently

#

then I moved onto RDR2

hushed flare
#

if only john actually used the right puking animation

#

and sound

hidden moss
#

I played rdr1 when i was young

spiral laurel
#

RDR has always been to me an Anthology, sorta like Star Wars

hidden moss
#

couldnt remember anything moving into rdr2

#

Uncle should have killed Micah

#

took me a while to realize John was the dude from the first game

hushed flare
hidden moss
#

Fr

#

both of them are cool characters tho

spiral laurel
#

btw, did you guys wanna hear a Fun fact about Uncle

hidden moss
#

Yes

hushed flare
hidden moss
#

uhm

#

He has lumbago

spiral laurel
#

Uncle had Two actors, his first one during RDR2's development died and they needed a new one, however they kept some of his lines in and even kept all of his singing in

hidden moss
#

u mean rip van wrinkle?

#

or whatever he called himself

hushed flare
spiral laurel
#

Also, A lake in the game, Ocreaghs run I believe is named after the first actor

hidden moss
#

Uncle van der linde

#

thats cool

wintry pike
spiral laurel
#

I can btw show you guys some of the cut uncle voice lines, they are a bit choppy byt they were found

#

posted it in Media

#

I believe the reason they are so Choppy is because they were extracted from the back ground version of Conversations

#

You may notice conversations going on around the camp that aren't actually happening, well some are added into the background, and I believe those lines are from those

frigid cloud
#

John's angry at uncle why is that in first game

spiral laurel
#

Because uncle was always very Lazy

#

also he comes in demanding for Jack not to blame him

#

so yes, I'd be kinda Angry at uncle lol

#

doesn't mean he doesn't love him

frigid cloud
#

I never paid attention in epilogue, most say john is skinny

#

Is it true

spiral laurel
#

John's body in Epilogue is about the same as Arthurs

hidden moss
#

wait did they actually finally fix the cold bug?

half marsh
#

from what I’ve heard they have

hidden moss
#

let's fucking goooo

spiral laurel
#

THEY HAVE???

hidden moss
#

i hope so

spiral laurel
#

FFS FINALLY I GOTTA UNINSTALL THIS MOD NOW

frigid cloud
#

Cap

half marsh
#

people have said they haven’t had it since the update ¯_(ツ)_/¯

spiral laurel
#

YOUR GONNA CATCH A CHEEL DRESSED LIKE THAT

hidden moss
#

hold on, gotta undress my pile of animal pelts that is arthur

spiral laurel
#

lol

hidden moss
#

may iiiiii stand unfrozen

little roost
hidden moss
#

name one person that has played through RDR2 and managed to keep both arthur and john on average weight

frigid cloud
#

None

dire sentinel
#

wait no

hidden moss
#

bullshit

dire sentinel
#

when arthur got tb i ate a bunch yet still failed

frigid cloud
#

I never eat food unless my cores are low

dire sentinel
#

i was keeping john perfect weight until i left it cuz i tried to make RDR1 john marston

#

anyways

hidden moss
#

how do you even manage their weight lol

#

it just goes down

dire sentinel
#

just like irl, ig

frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

Imagine if uncle didnt get Lumbago

dire sentinel
#

i ate like five or six meals from the bar with tb and no improvement

frigid cloud
#

He'd be one shotting everyone

hidden moss
#

rdr3 will explain how uncle got lumbago

#

Fr

#

Play as uncle

#

Gang leader

#

Kills Dutch

hidden moss
frigid cloud
#

Saloon foods fixes

#

Or does it

dire sentinel
#

whats funny is that the food itself from bars cost more than a night in a hotel

frigid cloud
#

1$

dire sentinel
#

bar food - $5.00

#

hotel night - $1.00

hidden moss
#

thats some five star meals youre getting dude

dire sentinel
#

as well as the hotels

frigid cloud
spiral laurel
#

Well I gotta Admit, the Food and Rooms in RDR2 looks great

#

I'd gladly Eat Lambs fry for example

hidden moss
#

i recently watched a video of the npcs eating food in bars

#

and that must be the most detailed eating ive seen in a game

#

lol

spiral laurel
#

It feels like everyone has a real path and plan for the day

hidden moss
#

^^ i think thats cause they do

dire sentinel
#

there is always smt to do in red dead

hidden moss
#

no?

dire sentinel
#

wdym?

#

but still, why keep the npcs and the whole map loaded even if you're not looking?

#

there will be tons of lag, and doesn't affect realism

hidden moss
#

thats how games work

dire sentinel
#

oh yeah

#

thats what u mean

#

i see

#

i've seen an npc spawn in before

#

i was drinking in valentine alone, and looked behind me to see a guy fade into existence behind me

hidden moss
#

mrboss ftw makes a video about god showing up in saloon

#

Yeah

dire sentinel
sturdy frost
#

Is it just me who can actually maintain the perfect weight or what?

hidden moss
#

do you know who he is?

#

mrboss ftw

#

I had a epic battle with the mountain man for stealing his hat

frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

There were chairs breaking everywhere he bumps

#

yeah thats what i mean, he would've made a video about a npcs fading into existance claiming its god or something

hidden moss
frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

the guy went from like a million views per video when rdr2 came out to barely 10,000 i think

sturdy frost
#

MrBossFTW, more like MrLoseFTL.

candid walrus
#

MrTrashForTheBin

hidden moss
#

I was waiting for that

#

A well deserved name.

#

did michaels voice actor comment about it?

#

thats funny

#

Yeah

dire sentinel
#

does mrbossftw even know that the community dislikes him?

sturdy frost
#

MrTrashForTheBin is even worse than Morgz when it comes to clickbait.

hidden moss
#

I mean most of the people who like him are kids

sturdy frost
#

Yes.

#

I liked him at first, then I realized.

hidden moss
#

i think most people liked him at first

#

then he started milking rdr2

#

I've hated him since he starts those GTA 6 leaks clickbait

#

" what happens if you follow this squirrel at 3am ( ALMOST DIED ) "

sturdy frost
#

Yeah, but by the time I liked him, I was very new to RDR2 so yeah.

dire sentinel
hidden moss
#

Thank god when i was new to RDR2 i didn't trust his videos because of what he did back then with GTA V

sturdy frost
#

Strange Man is the 🐐 though.

hidden moss
#

True

#

he made some informative videos before

#

then it went downhill

dire sentinel
hidden moss
#

yeah

hidden moss
candid walrus
#

Strange Man is amazing

#

He deserves more subscribers

sturdy frost
#

Sure.

#

He makes his videos so much more exciting and all by adding all this creepy music etc.

red helm
#

@candid walrus stop changing your pfp, oddball.

candid walrus
dire sentinel
#

strange man deservers mrbossftw's subs

red helm
candid walrus
#

Fine

#

I'll go cry in general

dire sentinel
#

waAahhHhAHahhAHahH!!1!11!!

hidden moss
#

watches arthur die to the sunset

dire sentinel
#

sobs

hidden moss
red helm
#

Arthur's Horse dying scene?

hidden moss
#

fr

hidden moss
sturdy frost
#

Am I the only one who kept his horse from the first mission till the end?

hidden moss
#

i used the white arabian

dire sentinel
hidden moss
#

on my first playthrough i used the horse you get from preordering the gaem

candid walrus
#

I rode the first horse off a cliff as soon as possible
cowboykekw

sturdy frost
#

Dude, what the fuck is wrong with you?

candid walrus
#

Everything

red helm
#

And then there is Storm the Psycho.

frigid cloud
#

Don't think so

hidden moss
#

yeah

frigid cloud
#

I didn't see it in stables

hidden moss
#

i think so at least

sturdy frost
#

You should be able to get that thoroughbred after the main story.

frigid cloud
#

Or Arthur exclusive

hidden moss
#

i always had that preorder horse in my stable if thats the same horse idk

#

I hate the fact that i got Buell in Chapter 6

sturdy frost
#

Same.

dire sentinel
hidden moss
#

I treated him like a son when i got him

#

godbless buell

frigid cloud
#

I don't find buell special I've got it twice and and I didn't take it

hidden moss
#

godbless hamish

hidden moss
frigid cloud
#

You don't need those for 100%

candid walrus
#

You don't need the Guarma animals for 100%.

hidden moss
#

Really?

#

Cool.

dire sentinel
#

u don't need it for trophies, or 100%

frigid cloud
#

yep

hidden moss
#

I guess i'll go continue my 100% journey by doing the challenges

sturdy frost
#

Gambler 8.

hidden moss
#

I was planning

frigid cloud
#

Challenges 🤢 can't stand them anymore

dire sentinel
hidden moss
frigid cloud
#

Dominoes and blackjack bs was enough for me

hidden moss
#

That took me hours because i got wanted for disturbing the peace

frigid cloud
sturdy frost
#

Dominoes, sheesh.

hidden moss
#

I escaped with a train and decide to shoot while it's moving

#

And then i got lost in the middle of nowhere. My horse was too far away

frigid cloud
#

For me, train wasn't moving at all

dire sentinel
#

the poker ones were easy, and the dominoes gave me time to relax imo

frigid cloud
#

Dominoes was stressful

hidden moss
#

the amount of boardgames ive learnt to play through games is insane

frigid cloud
#

Not knowing how to play dominoes just sucks

red helm
hidden moss
frigid cloud
sturdy frost
#

“It ain’t that simple.”

hidden moss
#

I lost my honor for those

red helm
#

Don't worry about honor, when doing challenge.

#

Also, getting honor up is very easy.

hidden moss
#

Plus don't worry about honor. I'm playing as John now

#

i cant be bothered trying to 100%

#

And i beat the story with all tears sacrificed

hushed flare
#

i hate how its the only vest that does that

glossy belfry
#

why do people keep mentioning the cold bug?
i've never encountered it, and i've finished the game 3 times on pc
i know it's been patched in this update though so that's good

hushed flare
#

i want a blue or black one that isnt online

dire sentinel
#

that vest is amazing even tho i havent got my hands on it yet

hidden moss
#

I've always wondered why Jewelry is useable in this game

dire sentinel
#

that pocket watch is gorgeous

red helm
#

When learning domino's. make sure you are playing the "Draw" version(Emerald Ranch station). It's easiest to learn.

hidden moss
#

you get a pocket watch for doing 100%?

hushed flare
#

reutlinger pocket watch is a godly watch

frigid cloud
hushed flare
#

the actual legend of the east outfit i dont like

#

the neckwear and weapon equipment is kind of weird

frigid cloud
#

You get micahs hat

hidden moss
hushed flare
frigid cloud
hidden moss
#

Is it for online?

frigid cloud
#

No

hushed flare
#

its similiar

hidden moss
#

Good

hushed flare
#

its not micahs hat

hidden moss
#

Something rewarding

hushed flare
#

good big valley hat

frigid cloud
#

Obviously it won't be named Micah's hat

hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

hmm

#

Ok then

hushed flare
#

micahs brim is a like a rope kind of thing

#

like arthurs

hidden moss
#

I didn't notice that rope on his hat

frigid cloud
#

How to get an exclusive hat
Complete the exotics quest and you'll get one

hushed flare
#

exotic hat is so cool

#

only the gambler ones

frigid cloud
#

Rest is alright

#

Still I don't like master hunter 6

#

Herbalist fineee

hushed flare
#

wait

#

i thought master hunter 5 was the cougar one

frigid cloud
#

6 is the cougar one

hushed flare
#

ok yeah

#

kill 5 cougars with a bow and skin them

#

it took me 3 real life days

#

i wasnt doing it nonstop though

#

i did other challenges while i progressed through it

frigid cloud
#

I think it's longer with arthur

hushed flare
#

i did bandit as arthur so fast

#

becasue as john i wouldnt need to worry

frigid cloud
#

That's panther

hushed flare
#

thats a panther

frigid cloud
#

No?

#

Yes

hushed flare
#

very useful for the saddle and LOTE satchel

dire sentinel
#

qwerty, that challenge is easy. do u need a video?

hushed flare
dire sentinel
#

it helped do it quickly

frigid cloud
#

New Austin has more cougar spawns I think

dire sentinel
#

o

hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

where

hushed flare
#

perfect panther for the saddle and another one for the satchel

#

the one near braithwaite manor atleast

#

if you bait it

#

every baited animal always spawns with no stars

#

o

frigid cloud
#

I found a boar in heartlands

#

During master hunter 7

hushed flare
#

next thing i know im gonna find some in new austin

hidden moss
#

I am the only one here who goes to Fort Mercer everytime i get bored in the game

hushed flare
hidden moss
hushed flare
#

from beaver hollow to fort mercer

#

del lobos have an insane amount of member because i swore i killed there hideouts like 9999 times

hidden moss
#

I roped one Del Lobo left to lasso him and shoot him with the goddamn gatling gun

hushed flare
#

i made a pile of del lobos and lit fire

hidden moss
#

Me too

hushed flare
#

free loot

frigid cloud
#

Playing online and returning to story feels so slow especially hogtie animations

hidden moss
#

Yeah. Free 200$

hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

lol

hushed flare
#

if onlywe got the enamels in story mode

hidden moss
#

PONCHOS

hushed flare
#

is this irldoggy2

#

lol

#

whats next your gonna feed a beaver for 4 days and then you realize its a grizzly bearkekmonka

red helm
#

It's the best Single player saddle, but barely. Really any of the Trapper saddles are fine.

hushed flare
#

it merges with other saddles

#

i hate it

red helm
#

Glitchy?

#

Merge? What do you mean?

hidden moss
hushed flare
#

if you have it crafted

red helm
hushed flare
#

no just equpping it then exiting the saddles and then the stable just merges itpepw

red helm
#

Huh...

#

I've kept on the Panther for like half a year, so..

hushed flare
red helm
#

I still need one more panther for the coat, but.. eventually..

hushed flare
#

coat

#

what

red helm
#

Or....

hushed flare
#

or is it cloak

red helm
#

hrm... whatever the other thing is. I have the vest.

hushed flare
#

can you die in camp

red helm
#

I know the trapper needs 2 Panther pelts. and I made one of the things. so..

hushed flare
#

only obstacle is master hunter 6 but everything else is pretty easy even master hunter 9

red helm
dire sentinel
frigid cloud
#

Yup

#

Mh 10 is to kill legendary panther anyway

hushed flare
#

master hunter 10 looks intimidating but was very easy

frigid cloud
#

I died once

#

But always make a save before attempting

hushed flare
#

i cheated and used my turkoman

#

didnt get bucked off

red helm
#

Yeah, the panther wasn't that bad, just luck where it spawns after the clues.

hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

Not as bad as the hunting requests

hushed flare
#

riggs station at night i always find an opposum there

hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

Fuck them

hushed flare
#

i hunted like 8 bullfrogs that were 2 star and then i found 2 two star robins when i was doing them

red helm
#

The only hard part about the Opposum is just finding one.

hushed flare
red helm
#

For the challenge? It isn't relevant the stars.

hushed flare
#

trolling

frigid cloud
#

It wouldn't go that specific

hushed flare
#

im suprised hunting requests didnt put a fucking moose in it

red helm
#

Master hunter 9? It's just to kill a Oppossum when it is playing dead. Doesn't matter what the pelt quality is.

frigid cloud
#

Animal spawn rate drops when you get the list

dire sentinel
#

rly?

red helm
#

Yes

hushed flare
#

i could have sworn when i needed a robin i found EVERY other bird in perfect quality needed for hunting requests when i was camping at fort brennand

#

woodpecker, like 5000 cardinals, bluejays, sparrows

frigid cloud
red helm
#

When you are the a mission/challenge to find something, it's not even fake, it's very much real that the spawn rate is lowered.

hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

yea at least

#

It's just long and tedious

hushed flare
#

and atleast you dont have to hunt and find 3 star birds

#

3 star spoonbills kekmonka

red helm
#

Oh, yeah, when I was looking for wood peckers, no where to be found, but all the other birds, like locusts. then when I needed a robin. Wood peckers all over the place..

hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

Buck antler barely had a use for me never worked almost

hushed flare
#

arent rabbits like everywhere i just find perfect rabbits when going on any road

frigid cloud
#

Fr I struggled with mh2 too

hushed flare
#

idk i always thought that challenge was easy

frigid cloud
#

I don't like that track 10 animals with binoculars

hushed flare
#

yes

#

you have to use memory

#

i cant imagine being that guy with 42/43 herbs to pick and not remembering any of the herbs he pickedkekmonka

frigid cloud
#

Me neither

#

That must suck

hushed flare
#

its most likely a black currant or a wild feverfew i bet

#

ive literally never seen those 2 plants in my life

#

until herbalist 9

frigid cloud
#

When I got 37 I was sweating because I thought I missed one

hushed flare
#

good thing rdo map helped

#

you can always mark the nearest plant then check it off the list

frigid cloud
#

Yea surprisingly rdo map works for plants in sp

#

I used it for 7

hushed flare
hidden moss
#

Trying to get the last legendary fish but i can literally not find a single boat to get there

#

:(

hushed flare
#

thats how i got mine atleast

frigid cloud
#

Survivalist 9 was kinda hard because I kept getting 14-18 lbs fishes

hidden moss
#

Dont think i have enough stamina to swim that far

frigid cloud
#

Use your horse to get close to it

hushed flare
#

i used the legendary muskie

frigid cloud
#

Finally got a 19 lbs muskie doe

#

Shortly after that

hushed flare
#

lol

#

"she married a postmannnnn"

#

oh

#

it feels like an eternity since i did that mission chain

#

welli did it as orthur

frigid cloud
#

🦓

hushed flare
#

"it could have been a goose for all i know"

frigid cloud
#

moose

hushed flare
#

loose

#

lol what

#

reloads save

frigid cloud
#

What's that

#

Is 'best in the west' the hardest trophy for rdr2

#

Which one is it

#

It's art?

#

I forgot

#

I wonder

hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

Gold rush was meh

#

I skipped lots in chapter 6

#

But if you're in a replay it's definitely harder

hushed flare
#

all i know is that moonshine doesnt count as healing you according to gold medal requirements

#

and you get 3

frigid cloud
#

And dead eye level 3-4

hushed flare
#

unless its chapter 1

frigid cloud
#

I've started new playthrough just for gold rush

#

you can

#

But couldn't be bothered

hushed flare
#

if only i didnt use a glitch that disabled my achievements

frigid cloud
#

How

hushed flare
#

its a use cheats and be able to save glitch

frigid cloud
#

Ah

#

Still it's for that playthrough so you're not locked from doing trophies forever

hushed flare
#

i have 100 percent completion and all that jazz according to social club but on xbox it says "48% complete" and apparently never completed chapter 4

frigid cloud
#

Wtf lol

hushed flare
#

karma for me i guess

hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

Imagine you're at 99.8% and forgot you used a cheat

hushed flare
frigid cloud
hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

I know

#

I've got all the trophies so cheats make no difference to me

boreal goblet
#

Wrong chat

hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

Cause I am

hushed flare
frigid cloud
#

I like how all lemoyne raiders has unique interactions in shady belle

#

First one's gun's jammed and Arthur lets him go and john kills him thinking he was trying to flee and upstairs second one asks to fight without guns and third one trash talks and suicides

hidden moss
#

Finally caught all the fishes

#

has the update fixed anything in singleplayer or nah

#

supposedly fixed the cold bug thingy

#

not having too much clothes on or whatever

soft jewel
#

@frigid cloud what a coincidence lol

frigid cloud
#

indeed

#

Didn't know you were in

soft jewel
#

Same

#

Inet

spiral laurel
#

I love all the Details in this game

#

one of the coolest ones I've found has to do with the Prisoners

#

now I'm sure you all know you can find escaped Prisoners and what not, but did you know you can sometimes find 2 Officers with a small group of Prisoners outside of towns? the officers overlook them as they mine down large stone rocks

frigid cloud
#

I did

spiral laurel
#

I love the little details related to the time period and the political stuff going on

#

while still not being overly serious

soft jewel
#

I killed the officer’s

#

When it was my first playthrough

spiral laurel
#

Like we have references to the Racial issues, Womens rights, the KKK, and all kinds of other issues that existed around this time and it's all handled very well

#

it never finds itself being too serious, nor is it too humorous

soft jewel
#

Imagine rdr3

spiral laurel
#

An RDR3 sounds like a cool idea but there are only two Directions we could go now

#

forwards and backwards

candid walrus
#

Mhm.

spiral laurel
#

If we go Forwards we will have to either tell the story of a new character or Jack, however as much as I like this idea with Jack, I don't think it will work

#

it's pretty clear by the end of RDR1 that the world is starting to become more modern

#

if we were to have another game with Jack, it would practically be during the Prohibition Era

#

not a bad timezone keep in mind, but also not very western inspired

#

If Rockstars gonna do anything else with the Red Dead Series, I have three ideas

#

A new game set in the past before RDR2, a remake of Red Dead Revolver, or a Remake of Red Dead Redemption

tacit ledge
#

Heard they finally fixed the cold camp glitch so awesome

spiral laurel
#

WHY ARE YOU WEARING THAT YOU'LL FREEZE TO DEATH

tacit ledge
#

Yeah it was annoying

hidden moss
alpine axle
#

its not true

#

the bug is still thare

green pine
#

What should I do if I 100% the game already

native thunder
#

not play the game and do something else lol

green pine
#

ok

#

Ill find something to buy on steam then

rose oar
#

ill be wearing a long sleeve and jeans and they yell at me when its like 40°c

olive mango
#

Does the game let you sell/discard unique items made for crafting talismans? I don't want to make a mistake and accidentally sell an item I may need

covert verge
#

Unless you turn autoaim off like i do

eager dawn
#

hello is it possible to downgrade to 1.26 for trainers?

round flower
#

Misouri fox troter or silver tail standerbred

hybrid valley
#

I loooooove Standardbreds

dire sentinel
round flower
#

Which one is better

#

Like which one should be my main

#

I know fox troter is better

#

Just what would u have

dire sentinel
#

missouri fox trotters are brave, and have great stats.

#

although, the american silver tail standardbred is a beautiful horse imo, and are pure race horses. yet the standardbred aren't very brave from my experience

stone salmon
#

Guys overall what’s the best horse?

warped arrow
#

Ur mom but shes really hard to ride at times cause shes too fat, but at least thats extra health, the speed is decent but in my opinion it could be faster but thats how the devs did what they did

languid perch
#

shes gunshot resistant tho

#

thats a plus

#

and tanks all fall damage

languid perch
stone salmon
#

Lol I use both

languid perch
#

oh nice

hushed flare
#

Arabians are cowards

serene crane
#

can anyone tell me easy ways of making money with high honor? i used to rob hella trains but i had the lowest honor bc of it lmao

warped arrow
hushed flare
#

Use Google and YT

#

it's almost like cheating though

quick whale
#

Man, this companion gang bug is fun as hell

hidden moss
#

the wolf heart talisman/trinket either one sucks

#

makes it so annoying to get drunk

visual pumice
#

they sell for liek 300 a pop

#

o

hidden moss
#

Nice,

#

I mean, for me who drinks heavily,

#

That may be a good investment

#

Because my crew always bitching about how I have good aim even while drunk with the screen blurred

hushed flare
#

I'd say it's unlikely

quick whale
#

You wanna know how to do it?

hidden moss
#

is it weird that in my first playthrough ever where i had fully high honour i dressed arthur as a dirty outlaw with a level 10 beard and now im doing a low honour i have him in an elegant suit with a nice moustache and well kept haircut

languid perch
#

nah its more normal tbh

#

hagrid looked like a lovecraftian creature dulled down in harry potter but he was cool

hidden moss
#

grinding my honour for the gamler outfit in rhodes just for some goddamn black fancy pants

glossy belfry
#

are the cloth physics being at 30fps fixed?

lunar creek
#

Is it possible to change default loadout in singleplayer? Everytime i get on a new quest now they equip me with one of my rifles, and i dont ever want to use that rifle but once the mission starts my horse is nowhere to be found and i cant change it

versed hound
lunar creek
#

Oh nice, gonna check that out. Thanks! 😄

spiral laurel
#

Me Playing Chapter 1 Again
Hosea: "Get us out the Stream!"
Also Me: Drives off the Waterfall and dies

#

Ok real talk, whats with Rockstars Insistence upon giving us some Unskippable chapter or Prologue

versed hound
spiral laurel
#

I disagree

#

but I also believe that for those who have played it, we should have the option to sKip

versed hound
#

it gives a fare amount of lore but not much

#

and also sets the base for the game

spiral laurel
#

No I mean

#

I think Chapter 1 is good for the story

#

but once you know the story, one times enough

versed hound
#

Well basiclly job goes bad and they confused why there friends dead and they are wanted dead or alive in lower montana river and have huge price on head aka arthurs infamous line of his 5k bounty and leviticus cornwall's train was robbed by them so he hires pinkertons to hunt them down

spiral laurel
#

so let us just skip it

#

He's Associated with the Van der lin gang, most likely the bounty was made once they found out who he was

#

and what he did

versed hound
#

Train robbery of leviticus cornwall

spiral laurel
#

ok let me explain the Criminal system

#

Most did not know who arthur was at first

#

however once they found his Identity, and what he was linked to as the right hand man of Dutch

versed hound
#

nvm

spiral laurel
#

he was given a big Bounty

#

do I need to explain this in further detail

hidden moss
#

how big was the new update

#

i didnt get time to do it yet

versed hound
hidden moss
#

there goes my whole night plans

spiral laurel
#

Where does it say

hidden moss
#

thank you though

spiral laurel
#

Arthur in New Austin and Black Water has a 5000 Dollar one

#

Dutch only has 1000?

#

thats dumb

#

I'd say it should have been 10,000

#

that would make sense

#

He's a big deal

versed hound
#

Ill be gone

spiral laurel
#

He was also probably ID’d at one point

#

he did have A friend in strawberry

#

Someone he wasn’t close to

#

So it’s possible he gave away his ID

#

Btw can I just say what would be cool to see in Some thing RDR related

#

Imagine if there was a Fame or notoriety system that dictated how fast people saw you

#

And if you checked your own poster, the picture would get better quality as you became more famous

#

Sorta like in hitman blood money

#

Well not fame in the sense of RDR

#

But rather just Notarized for crimes

#

Like the more crimes you did, the more people would recognize you as a criminal

#

Well

hidden moss
#

Ps4 takes so long to do system software updates and ontop I got the rdr update to do I can't play my ps4 at all tonight :(

spiral laurel
#

The more people spot you, the more people see your face

#

The more detailed wanted posters and their drawings could be

hidden moss
#

Interest idea

spiral laurel
#

the easier people recognize you then

hidden moss
#

Imagine rather than just be able to actively see your bounty you'd have to find a poster of it

#

So that you would know how much it costs and to get rid of it

spiral laurel
#

that would be kinda cool as well, but I see why that’s not the case

hidden moss
#

Too annoying

spiral laurel
#

But it would be cool to see how detailed your description becomes

#

Like if the more crimes you did, the better people recognized you thanks to more detailed letters

hidden moss
#

more of an imagine kind of thing excluding the actuality of gameplay and realism collision

spiral laurel
#

Well a pardon wouldn’t make sense in RDR2

#

In terms of the story

#

It would just as easy nullify the idea of them being on the run

hidden moss
#

Neither do bounties state to state though

versed hound
#

I mean your wanted dead or dead in the bounty hunters eyes

spiral laurel
#

I do wish RDR2 didn’t do one thing

#

The dead or alive lock down areas

#

I was just saying how I didn’t like them

#

I get their purpose

#

But I still don’t like them in terms of what we could have got

#

Dead or alive imo should have just meant that you can’t go into towns or what ever in that area

#

Not that you’d be swarmed as soon as you entered

#

I mean the lock down

#

Oh my gosh, I mean like at the start of the game

#

When you can’t enter black water

#

Because your wanted dead or alive

#

I just mean in terms of when your playing as Arthur

#

I wish we could freely roam the area close to blackwater, since I think it would have made more sense if you can’t enter the town without being spotted

#

Instead, no matter where you go, your always being swarmed by officers

#

yes but for that one missions only

#

Exactly

#

That’s what I find dumb

#

You either do or don’t

#

Exactly

#

Plus fun fact about black water by the way

#

Despite there being mentioned that it has a train station , in game it actually doesn’t

#

But there’s an unused train station worker in the files

#

With a young and old look

versed hound
#

I think their should be patrols around but when you in NA your free to enjoy there

spiral laurel
#

Yes that’s what I meant

#

The guys in RDR1 with an 1899 and 1907 model

#

Funnily enough, pretty much everyone in black water has the same models despite not being able to visit it properly as Arthur

#

Yes exactly lol

hidden moss
#

Thats because Arthur was meant to be able to go there

#

Thats why

spiral laurel
#

We know

#

with all the cut lines of dialog, new Austin content and the Scarlett Fever, it’s blatantly obvious he was suppose to be able to visit the place

#

It’s such a shame man

hidden moss
#

Weird choice to cut it

#

But I assume it's because they wanted more to be available in the epilogue

spiral laurel
#

it’s funny because if a capable modder could do it, you could easily be able to beat everything in new Austin as Arthur

#

You could complete a test of faith and a fisher of fish as Arthur

#

He even had recorded lines for these missions

#

It is

#

But the thing is

#

The animations for John for strangers are almost always recycled from Arthur

#

Meaning that is technically Arthur’s animation

hidden moss
#

Didn't John originally have all his things

#

Then they just made him Arthur 2.0

spiral laurel
#

what do you mean

#

oh yeah sorta

#

To explain

hidden moss
#

Hair and facial shape an whatnot

spiral laurel
#

John in prerelease screen shots had his own look based off RDR1

#

At launch, he looked ok but there were obvious downgrades

#

then as updates came he got worse

#

lol

hidden moss
#

Didn't they have his normal look in the original game version

spiral laurel
#

In the prerelease beta

#

Yes

hidden moss
#

Then slowly morph him more with updates

spiral laurel
#

no not really ,

#

At launch he looked ok, but it wasn’t his prerelease version

hidden moss
#

oh

spiral laurel
#

It just got worse after that

hidden moss
#

Ye

#

Rdr2 undead nightmare wheb

#

I know

spiral laurel
#

I'm just gonna say this right now, Modders could find a way to make Arthur visit new austin, I can explain what they would need to do since it's already easy enough

hidden moss
#

Imagine the anguish people would feel if they had to brutally murder Arthur lol

#

His zombie

hidden moss
spiral laurel
#

Not just that

versed hound
#

Im just sayin why cant they add boat to take you to Guarma

hidden moss
#

Wasn't that one of the first things they did

versed hound
#

but not to Guarma

spiral laurel
#

Change how lockdown works, remove invisible Snipers, remove Cholera posters and replace them with Scarlett Fever, Allow Arthur to beat Fisher of Fish and a test of faith using possible unused animations

#

and there you go

#

Pretty much everything else is done

#

he has Journal Entries and Voice lines for things there already

#

so, yeah

#

Fun fact, Invisible snipers work in a funny way

#

they actually shoot from your Cross hair I believe

#

if you block it by getting inside a building and don't point the center of your screen to a window, you can avoid them all together from shooting you

#

Holding a body for example and pointing your cross hair towards the side arthurs carrying the body, the body can take every one of the shots

frigid cloud
#

John says he's got a bounty on his head in epilogue but there's no actual bounty or maybe he still thinks there's a bounty on him

#

I made him join them

hidden moss
#

Can you catch the legendary catfish that you see with the fisherman guy?

frigid cloud
#

No

#

Uncatchable

hidden moss
#

Oh ok weird

quick whale
hidden moss
#

theres game files of it but it’s technically not in the game and not catchable

cosmic sonnet
#

Hey so I know the doctors part is coming up where they tell him he has the illness where on the scale would I have to be to get the good version of that?

mental merlin
#

he

spiral laurel
#

Fun fact, in the Mission Polite Society, Valentine Style, if you Choose to help the guy who lost his horse, Uncle recommends you to buy some coffee to help keep you awake

mental merlin
#

e

spiral laurel
#

if you don't help him, he will recommend to buy a Cigar to calm yourself down

cosmic sonnet
#

Huh that is a cool detail

quick whale
wide pivot
#

AYO i just updated my game and loaded story game, to see that a new story has begun? bro i was chapter six- please help 😔

versed hound
wide pivot
#

i believe so, but why’s this happening? has anyone else encountered such?

versed hound
#

where are u and what time

#

Ladies and gentlemen we got it

frigid cloud
#

Yes unless you have the trinket

native thunder
#

pronghorn

#

which is in NA

frigid cloud
#

If you skin it it's not a problem

candid walrus
#

Mhm

frigid cloud
#

Skins don't rot

native thunder
#

yes they do lol

frigid cloud
#

Never happened to me

native thunder
#

oh wait

candid walrus
#

They do after a long period of time

native thunder
#

i think they do

#

but they just disappear from ur horse

frigid cloud
#

I guess the trinket is only for carcasses

spiral laurel
#

I’m about to say what I believe is the dumbest thing there is in this game atm

#

Special items can be sold

#

items like the meteor, the shrunken head, the arrow head

quick whale
#

Ofc pal

#

Lilian powell her name

#

*Lillian

tidal ruin
#

I drank like

#

50 whiskey shots

#

didnt get drunk

#

It took beer to get me drunk

quick whale
#

You can speak to her

quick whale
stable marten
#

does anyone have a epilouge part 1 save file on ps4 or ps5

#

btw story > online

pure stirrup
stable marten
#

damn for ps4?

quick whale
#

You have Wolf trinket?

hidden moss
#

Are melee weapons always on you

#

Such as the pirate sword

#

Like I won't have to worry about leaving it on my horse

stable marten
#

does anyone have save wizard that can give me a profile
i wanna edit story mode saves

sturdy frost
#

Alright, here’s the big question…

#

GTA or RDR?

warped arrow
#

Rdr

regal shale
#

gta if you want a comedic game rdr if you want a sad game

warped arrow
regal shale
#

what

warped arrow
regal shale
#

pls no

warped arrow
regal shale
#

NOT THE AGENT 47'S

warped arrow
regal shale
#

anybody know how to earn alot of honor quickly?

warped arrow
#

Skin bunch of animals

regal shale
#

that doesnt give you honor that gives you a pelt

quick whale
#

Don't overkilled animals, you'll lose honor

regal shale
#

yes

quick whale
#

The boots smells like Horse shit mow

regal shale
#

red dead 2 is packed full of easter eggs and thats why i love it

warped arrow
frigid cloud
warped arrow
#

Rip

frigid cloud
#

It says resourceful honor up

warped arrow
#

I finished it a while ago and I've been doing online DUDE

frigid cloud
#

Probably for getting meats

warped arrow
#

doing chores helps too

#

But in the epilauge they get reeeallllyyyy boring

spiral laurel
#

I heard that the Epilogue doesn’t have anything to buy or make in terms of decor

#

Which sucks imo, you could do it for every other Camp in the game but not the final home

regal shale
#

the real question is arthur john or jack?

spiral laurel
#

It’s a nice detail

#

What even is that question

frigid cloud
#

Would you prefer camp or Beecher's hope

candid walrus
#

Camp

spiral laurel
#

tbh here’s my thing

candid walrus
#

Better locations most of the time

regal shale
#

beechers

spiral laurel
#

I love the Camp and Beechers hope

#

But for me, the camp has more that’s interesting thanks to the crafting system, you can bring in pelts and actually decorate the place

#

there’s also the point of there being general upgrades you can buy

#

And as far as I’ve heard, there’s nothing to buy for Beechers hope

#

which is my problem

#

Beechers hope should be like the end game camp

#

Not a sub par camp

frigid cloud
#

I was disappointed when I realized there's no bath in Beecher's hope

#

I don't think I can change clothes either in Beecher's hope

spiral laurel
#

that’s the problem for me, it feels like there isn’t enough for it being the end game location, Beechers hope should have had decoration options, a map, a bath and so on

frigid cloud
#

I couldn't find it then

spiral laurel
#

In conclusion, Beechers hope should have had more since it basically is the end game camp

#

Imagine if it also had things like a donation box, but more of less an allowance for the home instead

#

So you could buy food, meds and ammo for the home to keep

#

Well come on, I mean in terms of a personal armory

#

plus, I’m sure they had to deal with Coyotes and what not

quick whale
#

Like a heifer? trollartistic

spiral laurel
hidden moss
#

I just tried RDR online, it’s fun for a lil bit, but man do I miss Arthur’s voice talking during missions, to horse, npc etc😄

#

Still preferring Story mode big time xD

spiral laurel
#

Which is why rockstar should have just shelved some of the content for online and actually made a real dlc…

#

Pls rockstar… pls

hidden moss
#

Oof ikr :(

quick whale
#

Hellclown reminded me of Hellfire

spiral laurel
#

it was made around 1899

#

Which is funny since the song named the telephone was also made then I believe

quick whale
#

May or what?

spiral laurel
#

Wait let me check on this

#

Ok so, the phone was invented in 1876

#

The song was made in 1899

#

yes

#

Well they weren’t common

#

This was the experimental phase

#

This was basically the birth of audio communication

regal shale
#

HOW DO I KEEP ACCIDENTALLY RUNNING OVER PEOPLE AND LOSING HONOR

#

AAAAAAAAA

quick whale
#

You didn't run over ppl in Saint Denis by incident

spiral laurel
#

There should have been some way for him to swim, still it would break continuity

bleak juniper
#

@hidden moss Nerd!

oblique rose
#

I’m such an idiot, I was riding with my horse and I got on a train and I let my horse follow me and then the train runs over my horse

candid walrus
#

Go to Pearson and press donate

oblique rose
#

Shouldn’t be

candid walrus
#

Then donate and pelts, carcasses, or meat you may have

frigid cloud
#

you can donate predator bait lol

#

yep

oblique rose
#

Tahiti

frigid cloud
#

They should've taken over guarma

oblique rose
#

when Dutch said we need more money I had about 35k

#

in the end he didn’t care

#

It’s all micah’s fault

frigid cloud
#

whoever played the first game probably knew he wasn't a nice dude

oblique rose
#

I thought he was gonna die or something at the beginning

#

And then Arthur has to lead the gang

hybrid valley
#

i think he was like that all along, personally

#

why else would he let micah get away with all the shit he does

frigid cloud
#

You can also buy supplies from the ledger and still keep the gang fed

warped arrow
#

hes really cool at the beggining

oblique rose
#

I miss Lenny

candid walrus
#

Micah is best boah

hybrid valley
#

he's not though, he shot a woman point blank right before the beginning

frigid cloud
#

I don't miss lenny

hybrid valley
#

on the Blackwater Massacre

oblique rose
#

Someone in the gang said Micah shot a lady

hybrid valley
#

But he still did it

frigid cloud
#

No that's dutch isn't it

quick whale
#

We need money, you dumb fool! MONEY or we all.... DEAD!

-Crazy Dutch Van Der linde 1899

hybrid valley
#

Oh I thought that's who we were talking about my bad

candid walrus
#

Dutch was the one that shot the girl. Heidi McCourt

#

A beautiful rat

oblique rose
#

That’s a little disrespectful to rats

frigid cloud
#

Strange man tells that dutch shot her on the ferry

#

In the head

#

Oh I'm cowboy now

warped arrow
#

No one knows what happend at the black water masicar

#

I can't spell

frigid cloud
#

Massacre

warped arrow
#

My wifi bad

hybrid valley
#

i love playing the epilogue and being like "yes good everything is gonna be okay for John"

#

and then Remembering

oblique rose
#

We need more money

hybrid valley
#

the barn

oblique rose
#

Have ya’ll played red dead 1

hybrid valley
#

yepp

oblique rose
#

why did I suddenly turn yellow

#

I haven’t

#

I think I will

#

Cause it’s on PlayStation now for free

hybrid valley
#

that was the first video game that really affected me emotionally

candid walrus
frigid cloud
#

No

oblique rose
#

Imagine If you could donate human limbs

frigid cloud
#

Chapter 1 feels so slow and boring

hybrid valley
#

anyone else obsessively spend like 2 days trying to get Pearson's scout jacket

oblique rose
#

I hated the snow

#

There’s a Pearson’s scout jacket?

quick whale
#

Pearson scout jacket is the rarest scout jacket in the game.

hybrid valley
#

it's denim and it looks cool af

oblique rose
#

can you still get it in the epilogue

hybrid valley
#

nope

#

Chapter 2 only

frigid cloud
#

No

oblique rose
#

damn

#

can I replay chapter 2 for it

frigid cloud
#

Is it specifically chapter 2

hybrid valley
#

Yes

quick whale
#

I get his Jacket

oblique rose
#

I wish I knew that

quick whale
#

Pretty dope jacket he had

hybrid valley
#

I personally don't think there's a special requirement to trigger it

frigid cloud
#

Is it the one where he wants rabbit carcass

oblique rose
#

well atleast Pearson has a job in Rhodes now

hybrid valley
#

I tried all the ways that were recommended on yt and reddit

#

and then one day i just strolled into camp and got the request

oblique rose
#

I wanted Pearson’s hat

#

Boah

quick whale
#

If you want that jacket, greet him while he drink some rum while he making stew at morning

hybrid valley
#

make sure you do the Kieran quest first

#

bc apparently it won't trigger when there's a quest too close

oblique rose
#

I actually liked Kieran

hybrid valley
#

love Kieran

oblique rose
#

his death made me sad

#

I killed everyone in that attack

hybrid valley
#

well as soon as it's available, i don't think it's available until after those first quests with javier and hosea and uncle

quick whale
#

After i get pearson jacket, i used it alot

oblique rose
#

I think you gotta go hunting with hosea first

hybrid valley
#

you have to watch him between 10am and when he puts the lunch stew out

#

if he puts the lunch stew out it's too late

quick whale
oblique rose
#

seems complicated

#

I wonder who found that out

hybrid valley
#

yeah, he'll be behind his counter on the side of the wagon, drinking rum

#

it's super complicated, no idea why

oblique rose
#

I don’t like how skinny John is

quick whale
#

Also stay away from him till there's only Greet option with him

oblique rose
#

he’s skinny compared too Arthur

hybrid valley
#

yeah but ARthur's a tank

oblique rose
#

sorry, I’m from Norway

#

I mix up the too and to

#

What’s the difference

hybrid valley
#

too is also

oblique rose
#

alright

hybrid valley
#

"I like that too"

oblique rose
#

thanks

hybrid valley
#

english is stupid

candid walrus
#

Just speak American

#

Way better than English

hybrid valley
#

y'all'd've

quick whale
#

I like the Nevada hat

delicate sparrow
#

ez
just speak Hindi

#

it's mad easy

oblique rose
#

I’ve wasted to much money on clothes in this game

#

Nah just speak the Tahitian language

#

I’m trying to find the old gang cause I know you can find them, but I’ve only found Mary-Beth and Pearson

candid walrus
#

Tilly is in Blackwater

rose oar
#

shes in saint denis on a bench near the tailors

oblique rose
#

Alright thanks

candid walrus
#

Oops, yeah. St. Denis I meant. I'm tired.

#

Sorry.

oblique rose
#

I can speak Dutch, MONEY TAHITI

rose oar
#

also this isnt a gang member but rains fall is at the train station in annesberg

candid walrus
#

Why you want to geld Tahiti

oblique rose
#

Alright, I’m gonna try and find the rest myself

rose oar
#

i remember i found mary beth and i tried chasing after her train but i ran beside a building at one point and i got hit by the train but i was playing for 3 hours and i had auto save off and my horse buell died

#

it was so disappointing

oblique rose
#

I also chased the train

rose oar
#

i lost 3 hrs of gameplay bc i had to go to an old save

oblique rose
#

It disappeared for me

#

I got on it

#

And then it disappeared

#

Mary Beth wasn’t on it

rose oar
#

in online the train tracks eventually stop and the train keeps going and it brings you through a forest

#

and it goes through trees

#

the trees hit you and you fall off and die

#

its so funny

oblique rose
#

Really?

#

I havent played online since my internet sucks

rose oar
#

yeah it might happen in story too

#

near emerald ranch

oblique rose
#

I wish we could go back to guarna

#

Cause there’s some exlusive animals there

rose oar
#

youcan study them but you dont rly need to

#

i tried studying a parrot and the law found me and i died

#

guarma was fun but it was scary ngl

#

i also wish that guy came with you

oblique rose
#

lemoyne at night is scarier

hybrid valley
#

god the night folk

#

and the ghost

oblique rose
#

I haven’t encountered the night folk yet

rose oar
#

i just realized ive been talking in single player lol

#

they are fucking terrifying

frigid cloud
rose oar
#

at the shady belle camp

#

i was riding into saint denis at night

#

and i saw a barrel full of body parts

#

i figured it was part of the game so i was like wtv

#

and this guy

#

my horse bucked me off

#

and i chased it into the swamps

#

and

#

a guy came

#

out

#

with a machete

#

and hit me with it and

#

he was like smiling

#

and ran off all creepy

hybrid valley
#

they one-shot you too

#

they can, anyway

rose oar
#

have you guys ever seen that ghost girl

#

i saw a yt video about it

hybrid valley
#

yeppp

rose oar
#

then i saw her

hybrid valley
#

i was riding through the swamps minding my own damn business

oblique rose
#

You guys know the woman in saint denis that go “ let me vote, let me vote“

rose oar
#

i got so scared i turned my game off

hybrid valley
#

and then she spoke and i about soiled myself

rose oar
#

i was just trying to get a fit

#

and she wouldnt stfu