red-dead-singleplayer

[upper fox]

damn

amazing story

[cobalt mantle]

I know right

[upper fox]

@hidden moss sus

[cobalt mantle]

Hes so sus bro

[upper fox]

sussy

bye

[cobalt mantle]

another no context

All I did was kick him in the groin. It was self defense but I ended up ending my entire bloodline.

[cobalt mantle]

Incredible isnt it?

[upper fox]

yeah

i got a little emotional

[cobalt mantle]

I'm gonna go now

[upper fox]

b-bye

[cobalt mantle]

shoots with sussy furry killer

Dies epicly

closes discord epicly

[upper fox]

nooooo

people are gonna scratch their heads reading our conversation

lmao

[quick whale]

What the?

[upper fox]

no

dong ding

[warm crown]

For some reason during the "social visit" mission every time I finish killing all the odriscols I fail the mission because I "abandoned the hideout"

[hidden moss]

I would probably purposely die so you can abandon the mission or restart the mission from the beginning

If you haven’t already

[warm crown]

why does it happen though

[hidden moss]

I’m not sure, the mission worked fine for me

[tawdry moon]

After burning Grey's field, in next mission they set up a trap for the gang

How did they knew it was the gang

[prime estuary]

voices plus a few saw their faces

[hidden moss]

Could you still steal horses from stables?

Or did they patch it

[dire sentinel]

not its not

i can still do it

[hidden moss]

Intriguing

What do you do?

[dire sentinel]

ill send u a dm

[hidden moss]

Alr

[dire sentinel]

anyways

[stark hare]

Hi

[pine dirge]

I was bored so I was watching someone from 🇯🇵 play the game and I found out something interesting

The line from Micah during the beginning of the game that goes something like "Why does Arthur get a root and I get a bunk bed next to Bill WIlliamson and a bunch of darkies?" doesn't translate very well into 🇯🇵 (at least the subtitles)

The 🇯🇵 translation is something like "Am I with Bill and the idiots?"

I was surprised cuz the person playing giggled a bit so I had my suspicions that the translation was different... well that's obvious but you know what I mean

or maybe they were laughing at Micah getting mad over the fact Arthur got his own room and he didn't? eh whatever I'm not gonna speculate too much, just wanted to share that piece of info

[hidden moss]

6 perfect squirrels were a pain to kill

[pine dirge]

for the trader?

honestly birds are difficult to take down IMO

except maybe turkeys

[hidden moss]

I finished all the bird accessories

I kept ruining the squirrel pelts tho

[pine dirge]

I finished the rock carvings quest

gonna hunt some more wild animals later today

it's late so I might go to sleep soon anyway

[versed geyser]

On console wait till they get into view then lock on

On PC you have to wait until they land

[hidden moss]

Don’t you get a secret if you follow the bird?

[past pasture]

hey guys

[hidden moss]

Hello

[past pasture]

sup XD

wanted to ask that i picked up the wide blade knife but now i dont have it with me...
at first it replaced my default knife but now i only have the default knife....
i went back to the mine but there's nothing now

[hidden moss]

For the horsemen 9 challenges I can’t fall off my horse right?

[hidden moss]

My stupid horse decided to trip over a small rock and ruined my whole run

Now I gotta go back to van horn

yesterday my horse just died being ran over by a train in saint denis

[rose oar]

AHAHAHAHA

that happened to me when i first got buell

lost 3 hrs of playtime

[hidden moss]

i kinda cried when i came up that he was died

he was with me since chapter 2

[rose oar]

i was smart and got him in the epilogue

which is funny bc i saw hamish as arthur

mans was in the same@spot for 8 years

[hidden moss]

no just do the first three missions with hamish as arthur

then go back with john

actually i did not play it yet

i was planning to play it tho

[rose oar]

when u find hamish hes against a rock bc buell got away with his leg

8 years later he was still stuck there

[hidden moss]

how did he survived then

ahaha

[rose oar]

idk 💀

i was playing rdr1 again a few days ago

bc my account was suspended for 3 days

it was fun but

[hidden moss]

must be good

[rose oar]

the graphics are so bad

😭

on ps4 theyre bad

[hidden moss]

what can you expect from a 11 yrs old game

[rose oar]

i mean it was ahead of its timeline

yes it is

bruh

[hidden moss]

Rdr1 graphics are pretty good considering the time it was released-

[rose oar]

do u not know what it means

for 11 years ago? it was

and it ison ps4

[hidden moss]

I rmemeber my rdr1 a bunch of people would spawn with no heads

[rose oar]

idk why ur trying to start an argument about it

its an opinion not a fact

ur acting like it is tho

[hidden moss]

or even acting like animals ahaha

[rose oar]

let me have my opinions gah dam

[hidden moss]

was kinda funny tho

[sturdy patrol]

I liked rdr1 graphics a lot when I played it but if I played it now I'd obviously find them sorta bad lmao but then I thought they were amazing

[rose oar]

wasthat also a glitch in undead nightmare? or were the npcs supposed to be headless

[hidden moss]

R* was never ahead of time back in the first decade of 2000

[rose oar]

they did p good physics

[sturdy patrol]

Rdr1 was really broken but so is most rockstar games. Still love them though

[rose oar]

except they didnt know how to make john swim 😭💀

they didnt

[hidden moss]

then how can CJ swim?

in gta san andreas

[rose oar]

whos cj

ohhh

OHHHHHH

i was so confused i thought u meant cj was in red dead 1

idk maybe programming it was different or smt

[hidden moss]

Horses use to just drown if you touch the water

[hidden moss]

ahahaa that'd be funny tho

[rose oar]

that glitch happened to me in rdr2

that one spot up in the grizzlies

with all the holes that shoot water

theres a big water pond

i brought my horse into it and it sunk to the bottom in a second

and died

[hidden moss]

i know but idk at least try to swim to the shore

no he like insta-kill

[sturdy patrol]

John's toe will touch water and your stamina will just decrease at rapid speeds

[hidden moss]

well in rdr2 its not that different

[rose oar]

bruh right

ur horse runs for 2 seconds and u go flying

i just realized

gta 5

online

u never hear ur character

when u fall it doesnt yell or scream

in rdo they do

[hidden moss]

even if they burn?

[sturdy patrol]

I'm pretty sure I've heard my character make a noise or I'm just hallucinating but tbh i might just be hallucinating

[hidden moss]

he learnt from the best one in 1911

[rose oar]

i think u might be thinking about rdo

maybe

idk ive never heard my character

neither have my friends 😭

maybe its just a ps4 thing

[sturdy patrol]

I might be because I haven't played gta in awhile

[rose oar]

its so funny bcs

u could be doing a story mission with other gang members

and theyll get shot 20 times

and theyre fine

but in a cutscene

[hidden moss]

still idk what changes in rdr1 with high/low honor

[rose oar]

1 shot and they die a brutal tragic death

[hidden moss]

sure is better in rdr2

then

i didnt mean that

[sturdy patrol]

Five finger fillet in rdr1 was the best

[hidden moss]

but there are side missions too

so its not that bad

[sturdy patrol]

I really loved seeing Jack grown up

He's really badass grown up

[hidden moss]

it it a 11 yrs old game tho

im not so sure

Omg I swear to god

Deadass

The game wants me to fail

Npcs spawned in with their daym horses and screwed over my horsemen 9 challenge

[hidden moss]

ahahaaha im sorry

Everything was going so smoothly

[hidden moss]

most of the time there's no one in the roads in rdr2

For real, I was looking Infront of me, then quickly looked sideways to see the route curves and I ran into a horse

I was passing tall trees area too 🤣

[frigid cloud]

Ouch

[hidden moss]

Yaaaas

Did the challenge

[hidden moss]

[hidden moss]

i accidentally pressed stand on a 4 in blackjack and won from the dealer breaking

[spiral laurel]

I didn’t want to really play RDR Online, but it’s cool that they actually included things that make sense to the story

Since RD Online takes place one year before the events of RDR2 you can find subtle changes to the world that reflect this

Like In one mission, you help Sadie Adler and her Husband Jake

[hidden moss]

And you meet Sean

And joe

[grim lotus]

I thought it was more than that

My friend reckons it's 8

I think it's 6

[barren comet]

its cool and all but it depends if you like zombie games

[barren comet]

what mission

[spiral laurel]

Don't know , I just saw a video of It

[barren comet]

she prolly just living her life

[tawdry pelican]

cmon boys

just one more job

[swift heath]

hi

just got rdr2 the other day and just started C2

and im really stuck on what im supposed to be doing atm.

im in Valentine and got arrested 6 times in the past 5 mins

just for standing next to a lawman

and every time someone on the streets attacks me, I get arrested for using self defence

i don't even kill them - i just tie them up

and then i get arrested for "kidnapping"

[spiral laurel]

Alright so

Missions are highlighted on the map

Jack shares the same fame are marston

probably because they are both technically named John Marston

and he may be mistaken for John

that would either be a bug

or an unfinished part of the game

maybe its not properly programmed for NPCs to say "Hello Marston" to jack

But yeah it makes sense why Jack shares Johns fame, like I said Jack could have easily been mistaken for John and people could have though that John dying was a myth because of that, in a way Jack is carrying on the Legend of John Marston

well exactly

John was very recluse with his life

I just said

Jack is easily mistakable for John Marston

Both Jack and John in Legal Terms have the same name

John Marston

Jack's real name is John

Let me explain

along with that, not many people knew about John, and a lot of info people got about john came from legends

Fame in a way, is a Legend status

which one?

I dunno

but continuing on

Continuing on, due to Jack's legal name being John, which would most likely then be shown in documents like News Papers and legals papers, as well as the fact that many people probably didn't know much about John, if he had a family or if he truly died

its then completely understandable that when people hear about a man named Marston, and see that the person known as Jack is Marston, the people will automatically think its the Marston from three years before

like I said, Fame is like a Legend Status

Jack in a way, is carrying on the legend of John Marston

it makes sense then that in a game about Cow boys, that fame would have to do with Jack and John the same way

Cow Boys themselves were born out of Fame

I just mean in terms of the games theme

being based around the old west even in a dying state

was it?

huh

either way, I'd say it makes sense why he kept his fame

well let me put it like this

John is a nobody by the time RDR1 starts because everyones forgotten about him

thats just how Legends work and information

it eventually is just forgotten to time

so, by john building a new rep in a new County, it makes sense then why people hold him in a different state of mind

but of course your fame changes depending on who you are

you could return to your outlaw ways and become the feared John Marston

or become a new man who lives by the law

No I'm talking about IRL

just because you start with no fame at the start of RDR1

which makes it seem like everyones forgotten about him

maybe

either that or they forgot to program it for him

since I don't remember people on the streets saying Johns name

just "Marston"

oh ok

so maybe it was just something they forgot

Oh yeah you could be right

it is a Disguise

[wide pivot]

HEY MY HORSE IS STILL ALIVE
buuut arthur’s hair is uncut, but i don’t dare making a visit ..

[spiral laurel]

I fricken love Arthurs voice acting

A Quiet Time just showcases how good his actor is

[barren comet]

saint denis:the best city to get a bounty and murder lawmen

[severe relic]

True

[fresh heron]

Is scripthook broken for SP mods?

[spiral laurel]

I sent you a link

those guys should help you

[fresh heron]

thanks

[versed geyser]

SPOILER : Free up Micah smoking that Arthur pack

Micah bell is my favourite character

[late prawn]

A very unpopular opinion

[versed geyser]

I had a sigh of relief when Arthur got shot

And I rage quit when Dutch killed Micah

[late prawn]

Good for you ig

[versed geyser]

Lol

[barren comet]

you are evil

[chrome halo]

Hey guys

I speedrun rdr2 for 5 times now

[hidden moss]

Uh

[wanton cove]

Arthur can actually get shot?

[hidden moss]

Why the fuck is chapter 5 so short

[hidden moss]

DO NOT SPOIL

PLESSE

ANYRTHING

I’m not done yet with the game

[wanton cove]

i legit just read 5 messages above me fellow

this chat is not spoiler-free, best avoid it if you are midgame

[hidden moss]

But there are no spoiler free servers

Unfortunately

And I wanna talk abt the game LOL

But yeah

[versed geyser]

Then don’t until you finish it

Or DM people if you need to ask a question

Lol it’s a literal minefield

[quick whale]

Tumbleweed town become ''Tumbleweed''

[fierce cave]

Bty

Ausu

Is the semi auto shotgun better than pump action

[quick whale]

Look at the gun states

[full hawk]

So I was playing booker and this guy got two winning cards of 6 of spades and a 9 of clubs

[spiral laurel]

I can barley forgive Rockstar for making such a stupid mistake with Johns hair in the epilogue

Throughout the game his NPC model had a dark brown hair while In the Epilogue it’s jet black

Dogs aren’t really in RDR1 that much

Also that could be an ambient sound

It’s a part of the ambiance in RDR1

You’ll hear creatures off in the distance

[quick whale]

It's a ghost

[spiral laurel]

lol

[quick whale]

You can also hear the ghost dog barking in rdr2 too

[spiral laurel]

there’s only one thing that changes on the map, that’s the Marston home

That’s it

I meant in terms of RDR1

[quick whale]

I like the mexico theme in rdr1

[spiral laurel]

After the three year time jump after the story

the home just has less

That’s all

Then there’s the grave stones

[quick whale]

At that time, ww1 already happened

[spiral laurel]

Also you know what’s even weirder

You can start a stranger quest as John, die, come back 3 years later as Jack, and complete it

The only exception is the strange man

But… like what

[quick whale]

Strange man is a accountant which is Grim Reaper job

[spiral laurel]

the Strange man btw also appeared to John in RDR2

They never spoke until RDR1

[quick whale]

Also if you read Arthur's journal, he write that he see someone familiar with Trelawny but Trelawny still at NY at that time

Yeah

[spiral laurel]

Speaking of Arthur’s journal, here’s a fun fact

Arthur has special journal entries for points of interest in New Austin

despite not being able to travel there

These can only be seen via glitches or mods

also, Arthur and John have different ways of writing

Arthur has a more clean form of writing and his drawings are more detailed

[quick whale]

John draw is shit

[spiral laurel]

While John is much more quick with his writing and his drawings more simple

however even with all these changes

I find it so weird they never wanted to change the dialog in stranger missions between Arthur and John

[quick whale]

He got a speed hand

[spiral laurel]

it’s so weird

like, playing the stranger missions available to Arthur as John is so weird

But John adopts pretty much every line and characteristic Arthur has

[candid walrus]

John's drawings suck

Besides then

[quick whale]

Levin mission with Arthur is much better

[candid walrus]

But the rest suck

[spiral laurel]

that’s the thing, the devs got lazy and instead of changing the dialog in stranger missions, they just reused Arthur’s

It makes no sense seeing how John normally speaks nothing like Arthur

that also makes no sense to me, yes there was a virus but how did the city raise back up only to start dying again in 1911

[quick whale]

Blame Herbert moon for making armadillo a dead town in 1907

[spiral laurel]

it’s clear Herbert is an odd fellow

[candid walrus]

^

[spiral laurel]

He could have had something to do with it

[candid walrus]

He made a deal with the Strange Man

[spiral laurel]

Especially since he himself has ties to the strange man

[candid walrus]

Mhm

[spiral laurel]

Weird how he isn’t named in RDR2 yet it’s still him

[quick whale]

Sean horse name is Ennis

[spiral laurel]

They should have either done two things

One: ACTUALLY FINISH THE GAME

Or two: accept their loss and cut what needs to be cut

No

Nothing changes after the time jump in RDR1 besides the ranch

[quick whale]

I wonder why there is no M1911 pistol in rdr1

[spiral laurel]

There was a 45 in RDR1

but I don’t remember that

[quick whale]

45 what?

Guns?

[spiral laurel]

The 45 caliber pistol

It’s in RDR1

[quick whale]

1911 Marstons ranch is shit

1907 ranch is better

[swift heath]

i got a free gun choice on some stranger's tab - what is the best gun?

[quick whale]

Also why they the barn walk animation in rdr2 is same in rdr1?

[spiral laurel]

If we ever get a RDR1 remake, I’d love some world changes between 1911 and 1914 as well as a real epilogue for Jack

[quick whale]

That's scary

[spiral laurel]

I swear, the first ending in RDR1 is so shocking to see

Like, you see death right in front of you

And all you gotta do is open the door

[quick whale]

Ross is bitch

[spiral laurel]

I’d say the only bad thing he did was attack John

Besides that, Ross was a decent law man

maybe not a good or bad person

But decent

[quick whale]

John should never look back like arthur said to him

[spiral laurel]

you know, I bet they used Jacks jacket for Arthur and retroactively made it Arthur’s jacket

it would make sense why they did that

[upper fox]

i also thought jack's jacket looked familiar to arthurs jacket

[spiral laurel]

Like I said, it may be that they retroactively made it Arthur’s jacket

By using the jacket from Jacks design

[quick whale]

Also Sadie should never tell John about Micah tho

[hidden moss]

Guys, i have a problem. In Chapter one, at the mountains, i need to complete Pearson's quest to continue the story but therefore i can't due to a bug i guess.

I walk toward him, he stands up and talks to me, the game tells me to press L2 to focus on him and talk but the game doesn't give me a choice to make such as "Talk".

[versed geyser]

Restart your game then

[swift heath]

smh

is the volcano pistol good

[cobalt mantle]

why

[quick whale]

Because micah death lead Ross to John and that what caused rdr1 to happened

[cobalt mantle]

Micah's dead isn't he?

[quick whale]

Yeah, that his death lead Agent Ross to found John

[cobalt mantle]

so, John did a good thing by killing Micah

[quick whale]

And the guy who micah where about is Sadie

[cobalt mantle]

He didn't die without revenge

[cobalt mantle]

I know Micah died

[quick whale]

Revenge is a fool game

[cobalt mantle]

I beat the game

[quick whale]

John should never look back

[cobalt mantle]

Arthur's calling John a fool in hell

[hidden moss]

I did, it doesn't work.

[versed geyser]

Lol then idk

[hidden moss]

Imma try and reinstall it someday

see if the problem gets fixed

Rdr2 > gta .

meh

[fresh heron]

I guess you cannot mod singleplayer with the latest update then?

[hushed flare]

Guess I'll forever be level 10 health level 9 stamina and level 10 deadeye

[boreal goblet]

Why do you like Micha qwerty

[quick whale]

Infinite

Infinite bounty mean infinite money and fun

[proven folio]

who likes Micah

No one likes Micah except for Micah himself

[candid walrus]

Quite a few people like Micah

[hidden moss]

can someone help me with the weapons expert challenge

the bow one

[frigid cloud]

Use gang hideouts take out one guy silently then leave till they stop pursuing you and make sure enemy dot appeared on the map so it counts for the challenge

[hidden moss]

i tried that with beaver hollow

somehow they hear all of my footsteps

[frigid cloud]

Kill only one guy a time

Then leave and return

I did it with hanging dog ranch

If you're in epilogue try to replay the mission called king's son

Make sure to get everyone with bow tho don't leave any for charles

You might need to replay it twice

[queen rampart]

h-hi

shit

[dapper lichen]

Hi

[queen rampart]

im hose

hosea matthews

[candid walrus]

What

[dapper lichen]

Nice

What's your favorite thing to do in rdr2 aside from missions

[queen rampart]

kill skinners

and murfrees

and blow them up with tnt

[dapper lichen]

Mine is to get a high bounty and then go hide in the cemetery in Saint Denis

[queen rampart]

ooh ion do that with arthur tho

i neve rkill people with arthur

only in the epilogue

thats my way to go

[dapper lichen]

I dome either

Don't*

[queen rampart]

the best thing to do imo in the epilogue is torture civillians

with john

i lasso them and take them to the swamps and feed them to gators

[dapper lichen]

Yh lmao

[queen rampart]

oh yea and that crying La llorana night folk lady

I was riding by her

as john right

I already knew what was gonna happen

So I threw 4 sticks of dynamite at her blowing her body apart

and none of the night folk attacked me they all ran

[dapper lichen]

Yikes

Lmao

[queen rampart]

I lost honor tho

[dapper lichen]

Yeah

[queen rampart]

but idc night folk deserve it

They some annoying bozos

[dapper lichen]

Yeah lmao

[queen rampart]

favorite part of the map?

[abstract fractal]

lemoyne

[queen rampart]

mine is roanoke ridge arguably the best spot

I love the scenery and the easter eggs there

[abstract fractal]

region wise though id say uhh

i like tall trees

[dapper lichen]

New Hanover is my favorite

[swift heath]

how do I accept bounty hunting missions if the Sheriff office in Valentine is locked?

[quick whale]

There's a lot of ways to spelled "Saint Denis"

[abstract fractal]

lemoyne in general is just super cool

saint denis, rhodes, caliga hall all look nice

[dapper lichen]

Yeah

[barren comet]

ikr

[quick whale]

Why i spell Lemoyne "Lemon"

[abstract fractal]

lemonye

[weary verge]

Hello

[dapper lichen]

Favorite town?

[weary verge]

Oh yal talking abot favorite towns

[abstract fractal]

van horn

[weary verge]

My fav town is arguably butchers creek

Idk if anyone agrees

[quick whale]

It's a village

[dapper lichen]

Mine is Valentine

Bc it has everything

[abstract fractal]

butchers creek is cool but they shouldve recognised that as a settlement in its own right

[swift heath]

👻

[weary verge]

Oh then i gotta say annesburg

[abstract fractal]

like emerald ranch and lagras

[weary verge]

Lakay is creepy

I went there at night and i saw voodoo shit and heard stuff

[dapper lichen]

I also like Annesburg bc the mine is fun to explore

[abstract fractal]

annesburg would be so good if you could do more in it

[dapper lichen]

Yeah

[weary verge]

You can i heard you can wear the miner hat and go into the mines

Without being attacked

[quick whale]

Saint Denis law is shit

[weary verge]

Fax

[abstract fractal]

yeah they're irritating

[dapper lichen]

Yes

[abstract fractal]

why i love van horn so much

[weary verge]

Best spot to kill civillians for fun is armadillo

Ik people can agree with me

[barren comet]

its too deserted

[quick whale]

Because there is no law in there?

[barren comet]

pun intended

[abstract fractal]

yeah.

instead you just get into a gunfight with the locals

[weary verge]

No law is the best place i hate van horn thho

The npcs are annoying

Armadillo on the other hand is free kills

[dapper lichen]

Yeah

[weary verge]

And they dont fight back

My favorite kinda place

[dapper lichen]

Van horn npcs are just mean

[abstract fractal]

armadillo is probably my least favourite town

[weary verge]

Hmm its a boring town

Aside from the strange man easter egg

[barren comet]

best place to get into a bar fight tho

[abstract fractal]

yeah definitely

[quick whale]

But Herbert moon make that town dead tho

[dapper lichen]

Yeah true. Speaking of, what's ur favorite saloon

[barren comet]

i like valentimes

[abstract fractal]

either the posh one in saint denis or the one in valentine

[barren comet]

and saint denis

[dapper lichen]

Mine is the one on the poor side of Saint Denis

[quick whale]

Valentine is good

[dapper lichen]

I accidentally discovered a stranger mission here

[abstract fractal]

the one with the frenchman?

[barren comet]

what was it

[quick whale]

In Valentine bar there's a guy who wearing a ridicoulous clothes

[barren comet]

(call me a horrible person) but i really liked fighting bertram

[dapper lichen]

This prostitute took me behind the saloon and made me get into a fight for making them lose the bet on Charles

[quick whale]

He's telling about his past and his dissapointment about Civilization and Society

[abstract fractal]

whenever i visited van horn and wanted to start a fight

[quick whale]

Chatenay you mean?

[abstract fractal]

i always killed bertram first

[abstract fractal]

yeah charles

[quick whale]

I like the wittemore outfit

[abstract fractal]

i think my favourite outfit you can buy from a store is uh

[dapper lichen]

I don't have one

Lmao I haven't changed my outfit since I first started online

[abstract fractal]

the donegal

[quick whale]

I used that in last Chapter 6 along with Buell

[abstract fractal]

im very conflicted with what style i wanna go with in red dead online

i either wanna go mafia or scotsman

[dapper lichen]

Yh

[quick whale]

Did you guys completed Hamish mission as Arthur or John?

[dapper lichen]

John

[abstract fractal]

arthur

[barren comet]

arthur

[quick whale]

Goddamn, using Buell in last mission in Chapter 6 is more deep

[barren comet]

oof

[abstract fractal]

my horse in chapter 6 i had since like

chapter 2

[barren comet]

same

[abstract fractal]

hosea gifted it to me

i went through a lot with that horse

[quick whale]

Black shire

[dapper lichen]

Yeah same

I named my epilogue horse Arthur

[quick whale]

I guess that black shire is rarest shire i supposed

[quick whale]

Same

[dapper lichen]

Who would win, Micah or Arthur

[abstract fractal]

arthur id say

[dapper lichen]

In a gunfight I would pick Micah

But otherwise Arthur 100%

[abstract fractal]

a gunfight it would be close but id say arthur wou ld prevail

[barren comet]

does any1 else have dead eye execpt for arthur and john

[abstract fractal]

micah and dutch do i think

[barren comet]

someone was telling me dutch and micah do

[quick whale]

I just realised that you can get Missiouri Fox Trotter horse in Chapter 2 using Albert Mason mission

[stiff gyro]

I LOVE ARTHUR!!!

[dapper lichen]

Same

[barren comet]

we all do

[stiff gyro]

NOOOOO

[dapper lichen]

The best written video game character ever imo

[barren comet]

same

[quick whale]

Same

[abstract fractal]

same

[stiff gyro]

[dapper lichen]

Favorite mission?

[quick whale]

Damn, saint denis robbery theme is good

[dapper lichen]

Mine is getting drunk with Lenny, obviously

LENNNYYYYYY

[barren comet]

i dont remember the name but its when your talking to sadie adler and the camp gets ambushed by o,driscolls

[abstract fractal]

horsemen, apocalypses

id say mine is

short walk in a pretty town

[quick whale]

A new jarusalem

[dapper lichen]

One of theost badass moments in the game is when the gang rolls up to Braithwaite Manor to rescue Jack

[barren comet]

that was good

[abstract fractal]

that was a legendary moment

[barren comet]

yessss and they burn it down

[dapper lichen]

Yep

[quick whale]

Mission where we get Bronte

[abstract fractal]

revenge is a dish best eaten is a close second imo

[barren comet]

and drown him and feed him to a gator

[abstract fractal]

the music was superb

[barren comet]

red dead redemption was really good for me even tho arthur died i really liked the mission

[quick whale]

Urban pleasures

[abstract fractal]

that was a great mission although it was slightly ruined for me as my brother was arguing with me during

[barren comet]

oof

[dapper lichen]

Oooof

[barren comet]

my room was dark and it was really raining

so it hit harder

[quick whale]

Hell Hath, no fury

Goddamn that mission is badass

[dapper lichen]

Yeah

[barren comet]

what was the train heist called where we got that cool shot of arthur cocking his repeater. that was a good1

[quick whale]

Chapter 2 mission i supposed

[candid walrus]

Crap... Can't remember the name..

[quick whale]

Our best selves

I guess only "Our best selves" mission where you can killed horse without losing honor tho

Did you guys killed the horse during "Our best selves" mission?

[abstract fractal]

yeah

killing horses is a great way to lose honour

and during my low honour playthrough

it was something i did casually

[candid walrus]

Which one is our best selves, again?

[quick whale]

Only this mission where you can killed horse

[abstract fractal]

its the last train robbery of the van der linde gang

[quick whale]

Without losing honor

[candid walrus]

Ah, ok.

Haven't reached it yet

[quick whale]

I tryed not to killed the horse well, i didn't kill any horse

[candid walrus]

I like throwing horses off cliffs if I'm bored

[barren comet]

evil

[candid walrus]

I am indeed evil

[abstract fractal]

i enjoy killing innocent civilians with a shotgun without warning

[barren comet]

i love dangaling people of cliffs with my lasso

[quick whale]

I killed npc if i'm bored or mad but before i saved my game first

[barren comet]

when i walk around valentime i wait till someone atagonises me and i blow their head off

[abstract fractal]

wait guys ive got a curious question

[candid walrus]

Sometimes I lead the horse to the cliff then turn slightly so they fall. It's pretty funny

[south epoch]

[abstract fractal]

so

[candid walrus]

Hm?

[abstract fractal]

do you use the same guns for both john and arthur

or do you use seperate guns

[quick whale]

Also i drowned npc when i'm bored

[candid walrus]

Idk, maybe I will once I reach Epilogue

[south epoch]

[quick whale]

With lasso

[south epoch]

[abstract fractal]

whenever an npc really pisses me off i either fire bottle or drown

[quick whale]

Both

I usually drowning

[barren comet]

i dismember them

[candid walrus]

I can't be the only one that's fire bottled a horse that kicked me

Right?

[quick whale]

It's fun drowning npc

[abstract fractal]

ive got a guilty confession

[south epoch]

yes

[barren comet]

tell

[abstract fractal]

because i was trying to be an evil arthur

i frequently punched my horse

[barren comet]

i did that my 7th playthrough i went full evil

[candid walrus]

I do that with high honor arthur

[abstract fractal]

thats so evil what the

[quick whale]

I already completed 6 bandit challenge

[candid walrus]

How is it evil

[quick whale]

Bandit challenge is easy

[abstract fractal]

YOU CANT PUNCH YOUR OWN HORSE

its like

your main companion in the game

it feels wrong

its like kicking a dog

[candid walrus]

👀 💧

Well

You see

[abstract fractal]

not even micah punched his horse

[barren comet]

YOU JUST TOLD US YOU HIT YOUR HORSE

[abstract fractal]

YEAH BUT THEY'RE PLAYING A HIGH HONOUR ARTHUR

IM PLAYING LOW HONOUR IVE GOT AN EXCUSE

[candid walrus]

lol

[barren comet]

TRUE

[candid walrus]

I don't like my horse. it crashes into trees too much

[barren comet]

im so evil even when i have horse reviver

i kill my horse

[candid walrus]

So i replaced it

[quick whale]

Bandit equipment is badass

[abstract fractal]

yeah

the gambler equipment is cool too imo

[quick whale]

But gambler challenge is hell

[abstract fractal]

true.

i had to play dominoes with hosea so many times

[quick whale]

Gambler 8 is annoying

By the time Gambler 8 is finished, your controller will be broken 🗿

[wanton cove]

Why does Epilogue Ch1 John look so much like Arthur

I mean I like the look but it aint John

[quick whale]

Rockstar reused arthur model for John

[wanton cove]

he looked more like john at the end of the main story wtf i dont get it

[quick whale]

Rockstar is too lazy to used Npc John model

So instead they mixed Arthur model to John in epilogue

[wanton cove]

after all the details and stuff they put in that game and then they fuck this one up

thats just

disappointing

[quick whale]

Trelawny and javier have some good clothes

[hot otter]

agreed

[silk nest]

if ur a low rank do u get a free horse coupon ?

[swift heath]

i got a "bounty hunting" icon on the map in Valentine. i go to the sheriff office and the bounty board is empty. am i supposed to wait or does it unlock after a mission?

thank you

what is the fastest horse you can capture in the wild?

[hidden moss]

The chestnut Hungarian is pretty rare

Can’t seem to locate it

[hollow urchin]

yo anyone want to do some bounty hunting

[astral bone]

I have this fucking glitch

Welcome to saint Denis and the game crashes

Already restarted and it still happens

Anyone know how to fix it?

[hidden moss]

Does it only happen in the mission, or also outside of the mission?

If it always happens, you’ll need to lower your graphics

If it’s just the mission, try game repair/verify integrity

Found the Hungarian half bred

[dire sentinel]

those r brave as heck

[swift heath]

any way to increase horse durability

[frigid cloud]

Doing horseman 10?

[swift heath]

like some kind of armour

[dire sentinel]

i realized if u killed javier in rdr1, u put his body in a car

wow

[hidden moss]

Yup yup

[dire sentinel]

i have four herbalist challenges left

and im done

:)

[astral bone]

It was just the mission, I found a way around it, thanks though

[hidden moss]

does john have any honor changes?

like dialogue changes

rdr2

[swift heath]

i got arabian

i was about to be thwarted by a group of bounty hunters on my way back but saw them before they saw me

[hidden moss]

Finished the horsemen challenges.

That challenge was prob the easiest-

[hidden moss]

There’s quite a few of them too.

Chestnut, Warped brindle, rose grey and black Arabian too.

[dire sentinel]

and white arabian

[swift heath]

and black arabian???? where

[hidden moss]

Saint denis

[swift heath]

thanks

[hidden moss]

It’s has better stats than all of em,

[swift heath]

Which has the best stats

[candid walrus]

Black Arabian.

[swift heath]

oh

oh read that wrong lol

Yea I'm gonna get that black one

[candid walrus]

Nice

It's a very nice horse

[swift heath]

i stabled my white arabian instantly because I'm too scared to take it out anywhere

[candid walrus]

lol

[swift heath]

my previous 3 horses all got killed and I couldn't afford reviver

[candid walrus]

Always have horse reviver

[swift heath]

and I spent like 20 mins getting this white arabian

I can't fast travel yet so I made the entire journey

[swift heath]

is 1 enough? also what is the fastest activity to make money? i just did a bounty hunting thing which "pays well" yet I only got $50 from it

was $50 a lot back in those days

[candid walrus]

Do the robbery in chapter 3

You get $250 I believe?

[swift heath]

oh wow

[candid walrus]

Oh, and treasure maps. Those help a ton

[swift heath]

need to finish C2 first

[candid walrus]

Each gold bar is worth $500

[fiery prawn]

anyone knows how to make the guy for the second treasure map appear ? i went back and forth for a few in game days to the location and the guy still isn't there

for the High Stakes at 5:40 in the RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2 · ALL TREASURE MAPS Locations Video Guide on youtube

i cant put links

[hidden moss]

What the heck

A lady lead me to an ambush in saint denis 🤣🤣

[hushed flare]

You followed the prostitute?

[hidden moss]

And angelo’s bronté’s men tried jumping me

[hushed flare]

noob moment

[hidden moss]

🤣🤣

[hushed flare]

couldn't be me

I'm pretty sure I killed her but then she respawned

Killed her got a 100$ bounty came back many days later and then she is back

[swift heath]

Does dead eye get drained by different amounts depending on how many shots you make?

[spiral laurel]

I think it depends simply on how long you use it

so if you wanna keep the most of it, you gotta be quick

[queen rampart]

Dead eye is a last resort imo

if ur gonnna drain the whole thing it takes about 10-20 seconds i think

so thats about 35 enemies if you're fast with using it

maybe 40

i killed 10 murfree in 5 seconds with dead eye

[spiral laurel]

See, my problem is that I spammed Dead Eye in RDR1

So I’m so use to using it in RDR2

[queen rampart]

I really dont spam dead eye that much

[spiral laurel]

Which basically makes me drain it a lot

[queen rampart]

i use free aim

without aim assist

its fun as hell without aim assist

because you genuinely need skill to kill enemies

[spiral laurel]

no no I understand that

[queen rampart]

only time i use dead eye is if im ambushed

[spiral laurel]

I love free aim on PC

[queen rampart]

PC free aim is prolly better than xbox

[spiral laurel]

But… it just feels awesome to take out multiple enemies

[queen rampart]

Fr

[spiral laurel]

… “PROLLY”?

it’s like

[queen rampart]

Nah it is loool

[spiral laurel]

Better

In all ways

console sucks for shooters imo

Change my mind

[queen rampart]

Nah it does suck but im always on console

so i have to aim differently

[spiral laurel]

oh, I’m so sorry

[queen rampart]

I aim to the right of their head and fire a second before

it works tho lol

[spiral laurel]

Anyways, yeah free aim on PC is so smooth man

I feel like a real gun slinger

[queen rampart]

Yea i 100 percent agree

its so satisfying too

if you use dual schoeffield revolver its the best line up imo

[spiral laurel]

I’m more of a double action fan

[queen rampart]

callaway's revolver and the golden revolver i forgot what it was called

[spiral laurel]

Double action to me is a good medium between damage and speed

plus, it’s a western classic

[queen rampart]

Double action isnt my fit but i can resonate with what you said

I use Calloway's Schoeffield and otis Miller's schoeffield

as my dual revolvers

[spiral laurel]

if I need damage, I simply use my larger weapons, I use revolvers for quick shooting

[queen rampart]

Yea I can agree with that. My favorite gun in the game is the bolt action

I love the sound and the overall fluidity of the bolt actio

n

as well as the customization that is involved with it

Favorite sidearm is the volcanic pistols

Thats m main loadout for hunting,missions,and etc.

[spiral laurel]

I think the main reason I use the double action so much is just because of the stats like I said, the way I use it, and I also prefer it over the scholfield or whatever that other revolvers called

It just looks better lol

[queen rampart]

Yea I can agree with that personally tho volcanic pistols are just better for me than revolvers

[spiral laurel]

plus I prefer the traditional revolver, it’s why I didn’t use the more modern weapons in RDR1

Yes a 45 is cool… but come one… it’s red dead redemption

[queen rampart]

Tryna stick with that wild west look

[spiral laurel]

same

[queen rampart]

As Arthur I always try to stay close with the time period

never wearing anything too weird

in saint denis i always wear a tophat and suit idk why but it feels right

[spiral laurel]

I mean it’s a high dollar town

[queen rampart]

I change my clothing based on the location

[queen rampart]

agreed

they always say some nasty stuff to you if you wear shitty clothes

I wore the bear hat and bear coat and they said some mean shit to me lol

[spiral laurel]

i only wish that Arthur was allowed to visit new Austin, he was planned to at one point

Yet they cut it because of the lack of dev time

[queen rampart]

Honestly wish they made the map at tall trees a bit wide for that tho

IF they made like a secret route behind dutch's hideout in rdr1

to get to new austin

that would have been really cool

[spiral laurel]

like, for example did you know Arthur has journal entries for points of interest in New Austin?

Despite not being able to visit it

[queen rampart]

Yea he probably does because John is a mirror copy of arthur

[spiral laurel]

Not really

[queen rampart]

Most of John's actions are just copy pastes of arthur imo

[spiral laurel]

John has different entries

[swift heath]

I have the Volcanic Pistol. Is that a good weapon for Dead Eye?

[queen rampart]

yes very good

[swift heath]

Great

[queen rampart]

keep using it its myt favorite sidearm

in the game

Also upgrade your hollster

[spiral laurel]

John has simpler drawings and handwriting not as good as Arthur’s

[queen rampart]

Yea I can tell with his drawing of buell lmao

[swift heath]

I got it for free after helping a stranger since he had some kind of animal bite and was dying from it.

[queen rampart]

Continue to use the volcanic

[swift heath]

What will this do?

[queen rampart]

150 to 200 ammo

[swift heath]

Ohh, nice

[queen rampart]

go to a trapper and do all the challenges to unlock the holster

upgraded

and the upgraded bandolier

[spiral laurel]

also, a lot of Johns stuff is actually made, but it’s just cut, for example John had a special player model and animations made for playing as him, however it was all cut

Lazy…

[swift heath]

Without upgrades, is it possible to get free pistol ammo from the camp?

[queen rampart]

Umm I think so but it will be regular ammo

not high velocity

[spiral laurel]

Instead they just copy and pasted Arthur

[swift heath]

Is high velocity worth the extra cash?

[queen rampart]

Thats the only part of rdr2 thats a mistake

[queen rampart]

Nah buy express ammp

ammo

[swift heath]

Ok

[queen rampart]

Express ammo is the best ammo in the game

[spiral laurel]

Well if you ever get a PC, install mods for that

There are mods to fix John, give him the proper model and animations

[queen rampart]

Yea definetly getting the john hairmod if i get a pc

[swift heath]

Why is high velocity more expensive if express is better?

[queen rampart]

Not too sure about that but express does more damage

whereas high velocity has more range

[swift heath]

Ah ok

[queen rampart]

but tbh the range isnt that much of a difference

id just get express ammo

[spiral laurel]

Get the full on restoration mod, it fixes pretty much everything besides animations

plus it also fixes his hair color

[queen rampart]

Yea I def will if I get a pc

[spiral laurel]

It’s not black any more

[queen rampart]

John's build should also be more lean

in rdr2

he's way too big for his build type

John was more of a runner rather than a brute like arthur

Wjhat are your favorite characters in rdr2 aside from arthur and john

Mine personally has got to be Charles or Sadie

[spiral laurel]

That’s a hard question but so far

I like Jack, not just in RDR2

[queen rampart]

Ahh rdr1 jack

Jack in rdr1 was a badass

especially when he punked Ross with his deadeye

Dude looked so cool

[spiral laurel]

Plus, Jack pretty much carried on Johns legend

[queen rampart]

Yea he really did

[hushed flare]

John should have just drank special health cure and ate minty big game smh

[swift heath]

Btw anyone know what the legendary animal is where the white arabian is found?

I got a msg saying I'm in the territory

[quick whale]

Legendary white bison you mean?

[swift heath]

Probably. I just got told that I'm in "legendary animal territory"

[quick whale]

It's legendary white bison

[swift heath]

Ah nice

[hazy gull]

Hey, trying to merge two incompatable RDR2 Mods. (Both have shop_items.ymt) Wondering if anyone here knew how to do that? Could give me a hand with it.

[hidden moss]

You gotta wait till night to hunt the legendary white bison.

[wet wharf]

so im guessing rifles are for hunting and repeaters are for combat?

is that correct?

[hazy gull]

Some animals use repeaters.

and the Bolt Action Rifle is great in combat.

[wet wharf]

i ment large game

like deer

[hazy gull]

Iirc you can use a repeater on a deer for a perfect pelt.

[wet wharf]

most of the time when i use a repeater on deer and get a headshot uh oh poor pelt

i use carbine in online tho so that might have something to do with it

[hushed flare]

Springfield is good at one shotting in the chest

with express ammo

[wet wharf]

wouldnt that be overkill?

im not experienced with hunting

[hushed flare]

Idk maybe you can be mr Wide aim assist and just LT RT instead of LT flick joystick up and RT

[wet wharf]

e

also whats good for alligators

[hushed flare]

Shotgun slugs and bolt action and higher rifles

But I think the shotgun has a chance of completely turning it to a one star

[wet wharf]

ok

[hushed flare]

Alligators = big game meat farm

[upper fox]

I just had an conversation with a gta kid. He told me rdr2 is boring and has bad graphics

bruh

[hazy gull]

Bruh

[upper fox]

He told me he played it twice

Once online and once story

[delicate sparrow]

tell him to stop the cap

[jolly dragon]

if hes a gta kid then he only cares about online

[dire sentinel]

express ammo isnt needed

from my experience, i guess.

[hushed flare]

For me it makes a difference

I wasnt able to one shot as often with high velocity which used to be my main ammo

[dire sentinel]

i use the springfield rifle usually on the face, or in places to cause a bleed-out.

(regular)

[hushed flare]

Very good hunting weapon

[dire sentinel]

yeah, its awesome. u can hunt three start bear pelts with it if u shoot it in the right spot

[hushed flare]

I got one shotted by some random lawman with a knife

a while ago

[dire sentinel]

were u low healthed?

[hushed flare]

no I had like a gold health core

And damaged ring

[dire sentinel]

did the stab u repeatedly before?

[hushed flare]

walked Infront of me then stabbed me where I assume is the heart and died

[dire sentinel]

just once?

[hushed flare]

when plot armour doesn't work out

he was very close to me

[dire sentinel]

o

[hushed flare]

there's a lot of things that can one shot u in the game

I'm pretty sure all nightfolk with melee weapons has a potential to one shot

[dire sentinel]

i think npcs and other stuff can do that too, i was doing a bounty and the bounty was about to one-shot stab me. i could tell because he held the knife in a certain way

[hushed flare]

I would assume it's pretty hard for it to happen

[dire sentinel]

yep

[hushed flare]

I remember this moment when a skinner brother one shotted me with a machete from the back

[dire sentinel]

the machetes have a higher chance of one-shotting from my gameplay

[hushed flare]

The way the npcs one shot you is very similar on how the player executes people with one shot melee weapons

[dire sentinel]

yeah

[hushed flare]

did u know the sheriff of tumbleweed can one shot you with all of their attacks

[dire sentinel]

yeah

one time i disarmed his shotgun for an experiment and i thought i won until he pulled out his revolver and executed me with a one-shot

[hushed flare]

yep

[cobalt mantle]

Sup Micah fan

[hushed flare]

sup online fan

level 50

[cobalt mantle]

p-p-pardon?

I beat the game 4 times

[hushed flare]

ok

Then rdr2 enjoyer

[cobalt mantle]

you stinker

[dire sentinel]

o

[hushed flare]

I'm stuck on the gambler challenges

all I have is hunting requests and gambler challenges

[cobalt mantle]

One of my favorite missions is a fine night of debauchery

[dire sentinel]

that was the first challenge i finished before doing the rest lol

[hushed flare]

gambler 8?

[dire sentinel]

i have four more herbalist challenges and im free :D

[cobalt mantle]

and american venom, red dead redemption