It gives you a list of what’s needed
#red-dead-singleplayer
latent plover
clear swallow
yeah 25
latent plover
Cool
You don’t really have to think much about getting those, they come naturally throughout the game
clear swallow
Yep
Let me pop this motherfucker and see if it counts
Yep it counted as complete
Might be different for some others though
deep cypress
what are you taling about
clear swallow
scroll up???
sick wave
barren comet
yea
wary oasis
If I don't complete the Lending a Hand achievement at end of game is there a mod so I can play them?
Or have to play the story all again...
barren comet
you can replay missions i swear
wary oasis
You can reply story ones
barren comet
not strangers
wary oasis
Not sure about optional
Got a few left to do, it's at 40/100 at the moment so maybe I can still get it
wary oasis
The steam progress bar is in % so 40% isn't half yet
Got a few more to go
Can't remember if I've completed all by name if I was to look them up...
wary oasis
I'd imagine the biggest ball ache to get Best in the West is the cigarette cards...
Just keep buying and discarding until you get them all?
Might just roam the map and find them lol
I know
But doesn't bother me actually
Now I know...
Yep
But there is maps of them online
Which is what I meant, I'll do it that way
I've got loads already, just need to find the missing ones
astral bone
Bruh my fps in the snow 😭
green wave
didnt know that
ty
grizzled pivot
How long do your play throughs usually take you hour wise
How many hours a day did you play
Solid
hidden moss
question
if you dont do the indian missions
does a cutscene with dutch not happen
there was a cutscene that rains fall asks for arthurs help with eagle flies
and he doesnt like it that arthur does stuff behind his back
dusky vault
question
is there any like easy way to find treasure from treasure maps?
cus i have like 3 treasure maps
but i cant set a waypoint
and idk how to use a map
._.
ping me plz if u have an answer lol
shy mist
Been trying to climb this mountain north west of calumet ravine, and it seems like my character no matter what, slides down whenever its close enough to the top, is there some kind of barrier or anything? or am i doing anything wrong
latent plover
is there any like easy way to find treasure from treasure maps?
YouTube
Or you if want to find it yourself
You have to view the treasure maps in your satchel and work it out from there
shy mist
thats messed up, kind of a turn off tbh, thank you!
latent plover
Once you’re really familiar with the map you’ll find it easier
dusky vault
okie
thank u
im on chapter 3
but its my second time making it to chapter 3
cus my game save got deleted
latent plover
upper fox
I heared that is a difficult one to trigger
coral pike
just finished chapter 5 i think
that was interesting
when tf do i get my horse back
prime estuary
Umm
coral pike
i spent 1000 on my horse
prime estuary
You get it when you get to the cabins
coral pike
glad to know the game doesnt just like
whisk the horse away from me
wtf the subtitles stopped appearing randomly halfway thru this cutscene
ok game
dire sentinel
i spent 1000 on my horse
theres a glitch to get free horses from a stable
console works too
i always do it
coral pike
theres a glitch to get free horses from a stable
its ok i have my horse back now
dire sentinel
don't discuss glitches please
wait huh y
sharp citrus
hushed flare
don't discuss glitches please
Weirdest rule ever
prime estuary
Tos
signal steeple
wtf the subtitles stopped appearing randomly halfway thru this cutscene
Happened to me too. Apparently I pressed R3 (or L3. Not sure). It toggles subtitles.
long plume
you can lasso a corpse and it still counts
hushed harbor
ive yet to find any skunks at ringneck creek, even at night 
red helm
ive yet to find any skunks at ringneck creek, even at night <:suffering:61096817...
I found lots of them in the Eris Field at night.
cinder pulsar
Hello, so I need a little help with storymode. It´s more or less unplayble. it started with annoying bugs such as arthur freezing on the spot when i went to pick up an item. to frustrating ones, such as the game crashing everytime i went to Rhodes, or falling tough the ground when i fast traveled.
ive followed a lot of advice, such as clean the ps4, do a system update, rebuild system database, i even uninstalled rdr2 and reinstalled it, and it honesly made it worse lol. now the game wont even load.( stuck in an infinite loading screen )
And no, im not having these bad issues with my other games, just long load times, but my other games do WORK. rdr2 does not anymore, and im out of ideas, so im asking if anybody has any ideas here that i haven´t tried?
hushed harbor
just get a new ps4 lol
cinder pulsar
you think the issue is the ps4?
like, a new one? i rather not, but worst case scenario then sure
but for now i wanna try other things, cause it´s only rdr2 i can´t play propelry
red helm
Or the play disc is bad? I don't know...
cinder pulsar
Or the play disc is bad? I don't know...
thats the funny thing, it´s not. its as clean as the day i got it
hushed harbor
idk how to help because i use ps4 and it works on my machine
dire sentinel
welp im in chapter 6 now
not recommended to talk abt chapters if u havent finished the game
spoilers exist
red helm
thats the funny thing, it´s not. its as clean as the day i got it
I don't mean, that it's dirty, that the disc itself is bad.
cinder pulsar
i get asking here may not be the best idea lol, but i am sort of desperate, so apolagies
hushed harbor
I found lots of them in the Eris Field at night.
like by compson's stead?
cinder pulsar
I don't mean, that it's dirty, that the disc itself is bad.
oh
red helm
like by compson's stead?
It's between Emerald Ranch and Rhodes, in the Scarlett Meadows.
hushed harbor
i know where it is im just asking for a specific location lol
red helm
Just make a circle around that pond and go around the river until you hit the road, then go back up to the pond.
hushed harbor
because im desperate just to get a 3 star skunk after being cucked from one yesterday
red helm
That's what I did to get a Opposum, then a Skunk, for the Hunting Requests. Didn't take very long for either.
hushed harbor
wait wtf one just spawned right in front of me as i was leaving my campsite to go to the pond 
red helm
Nice. Good luck
hushed harbor
managed to bag a bullfrog too so now i have all the stuff for request 4
red helm
Very nice.
prime estuary
thats the funny thing, it´s not. its as clean as the day i got it
Blueray discs can have damages that you can't see like a invisible mark or something
hushed flare
hunting requests
cinder pulsar
Blueray discs can have damages that you can't see like a invisible mark or somet...
i didn´t know that, guess i could buy a new disc and see if that is the problem
prime estuary
If a friend has it see if you could use theres
If they both don't work then the disc drive may be damaged
cinder pulsar
i dont have any friends who play rdr2 anymore sadly, only friend who played it thought the game was ass and gave it away
hushed flare
Maybe cuz finished story mode
dire sentinel
hunting requests<:PES_SadGe:814280618959568896>
i'm prepared for hunting requests
is it supposed to be hard or
because i heard lots of people annoyed
upper fox
just watch out you dont run over the perfect pelt animal with your horse
happend to me way to much
Also sometimes it could take a lot of time to find a specific animal
hushed harbor
it certainly feels like the spawn chances of the animals you need get reduced when the request is active
upper fox
i felt the same
hushed harbor
though no one really cares to check if that's really the case
red helm
If you look up what animals you need beforehand, and get a lot of them, like the Song Birds and such...
Yes, the spawn chance gets lowered, It's pretty lame.
upper fox
Also you need to use specific weapons for specific animals to get perfect pelts.
dire sentinel
just watch out you dont run over the perfect pelt animal with your horse
when i was doing the hunting challenges or whatever its called, i had to hunt a cougar with a bow and my horse killed one of the cougars
great
thats war horses in a nutshell
upper fox
You cant get a perfect rabbit pelt while using a shotgun
dire sentinel
varmint rifle works bets imo
hushed harbor
hafta use a varmint rifle
upper fox
Small birds: small game arrows
rabbits, squirrels: varmint
deer: sniper or carbine rifle
correct me if im wrong
dire sentinel
i dont remember, does the varmint rifle ruin bird pelts?
upper fox
its been a while since i hunted
upper fox
i dont remember, does the varmint rifle ruin bird pelts?
not sure
its been a while
oh yeah always headshots
red helm
Birds are tricky, if they are in the air, you can't use a bow very well, because of the angle, so you kind of have to use a Varmint rifle in that situation.
upper fox
use dead eye
upper fox
then your arrows are like homing rockets
red helm
Eh... Dead eye on a tiny dot, in the distant...
upper fox
thats easy
red helm
Sure, give it a try, but.. Cross your fingers, either way.
dire sentinel
the arrow isnt as fast, causing it to probs miss shots on birds
the bullets are yea
upper fox
Hunting requests 1 tm 4 are 1899, hunting request 5 is epilogue/1907
upper fox
yes
hushed harbor
you can do basically everything for 100% completion as john
red helm
Song birds suck to hunt, pretty much no matter what you do. See one on a rock with your binoculars, really far away, Crouch with Scent cover on, sneak up from far off. and they still might take off for No apparent reason...
upper fox
in 1899 you cant complete hunting request 5
dire sentinel
have u gotten 100%?
red helm
Indeed, Arthur can't do the last set.
upper fox
in 1899 after you did hunting request 4 you receive a letter that says your help wasnt needed anymore
hushed harbor
im real close to 100%, yeah. i actually need to get to request 5 myself, gonna get the animals before collecting the paper for it
dire sentinel
Song birds suck to hunt, pretty much no matter what you do. See one on a rock wi...
for the exotics, just find a jolly family of birds and dead eye them all
(with a varmint)
red helm
That's my plan, I'm in the middle of part 2 of the Epilogue, and I know the 5th Hunting Request letter is at the Post Office, but I want to get the Birds/bat before I go get it.
red helm
for the exotics, just find a jolly family of birds and dead eye them all
Exotic birds aren't nearly as bad as Song birds, in my opinion. Even the Spoonbills weren't that bad as looking for Woodpeckers and Robins and such.
dire sentinel
they arent very small
hushed harbor
wheres a good blue jay location btw
dire sentinel
which makes it easier at least
upper fox
that duchness mission was more annoying then hunting request
dire sentinel
that duchness mission was more annoying then hunting request
it took me a lotta reloading saves
red helm
wheres a good blue jay location btw
Kamassa River, just south of Brandywine Drop, or there is a little Cabin just north of Pronghorn ranch.. I can't remember the name.
upper fox
it felt like all animals went extinct
red helm
Duchess mission, the Orchids were more annoying than the plumes, sort of.
hushed harbor
for me they were fine, they always appear in set locations
upper fox
the birds were annoying
red helm
Eh, I was already killing all the birds way before I started looking for the Orchids, so.. eh.
upper fox
orchids were ok
hushed harbor
Kamassa River, just south of Brandywine Drop, or there is a little Cabin just no...
ill try the river first, just hope i dont get ambushed again by a god damn cougar
but first im gonna collect the bat at the elysian pool cave
hushed harbor
what really ticked me off was when i attacked by one while teaching charlotte balfour how to shoot properly
red helm
Ouf, that sucks. I've never had troubles with Predator animals during missions.
red helm
Wow Charlotte got old in the Epilogue. All gray haired and wrinkles, that was shocking, she was super hot in chapter 6...
candid walrus
Lol
dire sentinel
Wow Charlotte got old in the Epilogue. All gray haired and wrinkles, that was sh...
LOL
upper fox
I think its weird during any point of the first charlotte mission you can scare her with pointing your gun. I didnt want her to die and then my last save was from hours ago
warped arrow
I gave up on obtaining the legebd if the eaat
red helm
I mean, it looked like she aged like 20 years... Well, maybe not that many, but still... Was shocking.
warped arrow
dire sentinel
but still, arthur seemed like an honorable character when she was talking abt him
but really u cant really make him one
candid walrus
My pony
upper fox
cool
red helm
O-0
I am seeing, like, a pair of black leather(?) chaps with like a sandy beige background. So, like a man's legs or something..
dire sentinel
oh there
dire sentinel
ye
red helm
Okay, yes, that's a horse in a stable paddock.
coral pike
that moment when ur in cinematic cam following someone else and then ur horse rams straight into a tree
red helm
Last time I tried to Cinematic camera somewhere, my horse tried to jump down a bunch of cliffs... Ouf, Ding Dong...
15 yards from the road, but no, let's jump down these cliffs and nearly die... Yeah, good idea.
upper fox
cinematic camera is auto walk so dont touch your controller then
coral pike
i didnt
hushed harbor
why are horses so fuckin stupid
candid walrus
Idk
red helm
All I was doing was pushing the X button, while eating dinner.
I had to quickly put down my fork, and take control...
hushed harbor
that random encounter in tall trees with the guy laying by a wagon after a skinner ambush is surprisingly sad
red helm
I feel bad for the horses that are left tied to the Wagon's after those skinner ambushes. Just like pulling the Wagon's along, and the drivers are peppered with arrows.
hushed harbor
try to find blue jay at brandywine drop after sleeping at camp
immediate cougar
i swear to fucking god
red helm
Bad kitties.
hushed flare
big cat
hushed flare
I feel bad for the horses that are left tied to the Wagon's after those skinner ...
Even the horses have arrows in them
red helm
Sometimes.
coral pike
out of all the immoral things you do in this game, i think the stuff that makes me feel the worst are the money lending and other sins missions
somber trellis
i had a white arabian horse and it died; anyway to get a new one ?
coral pike
rip horse
somber trellis
aw
candid walrus
You should be able to find the same one at the lake again.
hidden moss
i had a white arabian horse and it died; anyway to get a new one ?
Ye, it respawns after a few in-game days
coral pike
u telling me i couldve found an arabian horse in the wild instead of spending 1000 on it
granted the one i bought is a black arabian horse
but still
hidden moss
Yup
I prefer dark bay turkoman/shire tho
They don’t get spooked as easily, are big, look great & have good stats
candid walrus
No. You can't find the black Arabian in the wild. Only the white (it's actually gray but whatever), red chestnut (actually a bay), and the warped brindle.
hidden moss
They don’t get spooked as easily, are big, look great & have good stats
Well shire stats are a bit low, but with custom saddle that’s an easy fix
red helm
Black arabian has a few more stat points, than the white. But yes, those others are free.
candid walrus
Mhm
copper niche
What do u guys think is the best shotgun for rdr2 story
hidden moss
What do u guys think is the best shotgun for rdr2 story
I always use pump action shotgun, or the LeMat revolvers
LeMat can be both shotgun & revolver, they’re pretty much my main guns😄
coral pike
how do u get em
hidden moss
Gunsmith
coral pike
ima do that
warped arrow
In saint denis
somber trellis
my black arabian horse just dissapeared and replaced wiith a Tennessee walker wtf?
hidden moss
my black arabian horse just dissapeared and replaced wiith a Tennessee walker wt...
That can happen when your horse is dead & you die
Did you fall of a cliff with ur horse, get hit by a train?
Cus horses can insta die, I’m pretty sure they also die if they’re wounded (in need of reviving) at the time when you die
warped arrow
Hope you had a save
somber trellis
That can happen when your horse is dead & you die
nope
somber trellis
Hope you had a save
nope
warped arrow
Rip
somber trellis
rip 1k ig
somber trellis
unfortunate
delicate sparrow
wait huh y
against discord TOS for game servers, I got no fucking clue why
spiral laurel
This is gonna sound weird to ask but, why is everyone in both RDR 1 and 2 so accepting of everyone?
I mean, I know there are a few references of people who don’t like a certain type of person
But to my knowledge a time like this in history basically had most people against the idea of a diverse society if that makes sense
It just seemed odd to me that The RD franchise which is set in a odd time period didn’t really touch on these issues much
hidden moss
Dutch's gang are the only accepting ones that I saw in RDR2. Nearly everyone else was racist or something.
analog rune
guys im on an honest days labour mission with sadie and its bugged she is behind a rock but cant do anything , any fix? i uninstalled all mods
hidden moss
I'd say just restart the mission
warped arrow
the chinese people in rdr2 are funny
clear swallow
If u play the story more u get enough money to buy a thousand black arabians@somber trellis
coral pike
i quite like this stranger mission with the widow
upper fox
treasure maps is the ez money
spiral laurel
Question, does Honor change anything about John in RDR2?
I haven’t got to play as him yet, but I was wondering if the things that applied to Arthur like dialog changes and what not also applied to John
west mulch
where can I go to upgrade bow arrows?
coral pike
just finished do not seek absolution ii
what a potent mission
and i can see now why there was an honor threshold to access the mission
are u fucking kidding me i just got robbed by a stranger in saint denis and lost 232 dollars
red helm
I haven’t got to play as him yet, but I was wondering if the things that applied...
There seemed to be a couple dialog differences in the epilogue , yes, if you played Arthur high or low honor.
west mulch
where can I go to upgrade bow arrows?
?
red helm
?
You either find the recipes hidden around the world, or buy them from the fence, remember to recipe the pamphlets after purchasing.
hushed harbor
managed to get a blue jay, now just for a beaver and a crow
candid walrus
Nice
delicate sparrow
nice
candid walrus
Hope you can find them
warped arrow
hushed harbor
Hope you can find them
i doubt it but ty
potent mortar
hey guys is their a way to play as arthur in the epilogue without save wizard
hushed harbor
no
candid walrus
No
potent mortar
ok thanks
west mulch
where do I get feathers?
hushed harbor
managed to get them all in advance, received the fifth one and then sent it
felt so good after the stress of hunting a blue jay
delicate sparrow
nice
coral pike
i like these last moneylending missions
i can absolve the debts
and make up for all the shit that was the earlier missions
those missions also gave me a shit ton of honor
narrow quest
warped arrow
i hit my horse and it died
spiral laurel
I’m gonna rephrase my last question because I don’t think anyone understood it
Just like how dialog changes for Arthur depending on Honor, like his combat voice lines, responses and what not
Does John also have different dialog for his personal Honor as well?
red helm
Just like how dialog changes for Arthur depending on Honor, like his combat voic...
Arthur definitely says different things depending if he is high or low. Totally.
spiral laurel
Yes, of course, my question is if this mechanic is applied to John as well
red helm
Unsure about John, I've been working him up to High for the store Discount. You'll have to ask someone else.
spiral laurel
hmm
This is interesting since John actually did have different dialog based on honor in the first game
red helm
I mean, I'd assume John has different dialogs, since Arthur does.
coral pike
are you fucking kidding me
i did the last penelope mission
finish it
then i notice on my map it says
"arthur's saddle" instead of arthurs horse
i run over like a while
to find my horse is dead somehow
im guessing it got hit by the train?
stupid fucking horse
that thing costed me $1000
was such a good horse too
my temporary horse has shit stamina
turbid oar
those kind of things happen i let my lil bro play for a while with my horse which i had bonding of level 4 with and he runs off a cliff
guess im stuck with the tenesse for now
coral pike
i might spend my remaining 400 dollars or so on a new horse
cuz this temporary horse fuckin sucks
coral pike
theres like
nothing available to me rn
besides main story missions
but those probably get me good money
turbid oar
did you complete the game ?
coral pike
rob what
turbid oar
the people
coral pike
but my honor
turbid oar
some are quite rich
hmm
watch this video then
really nice
wait im sending it
WHERE TO FIND THE LEGENDARY BROKEN PIRATE SWORD [RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2]
search this video
click on the channel called zenogaming
he has good tips on these kind of things
coral pike
i dont like how buddy buddy micah and dutch are being
why does dutch trust micah
micah fucking sucks
dutch has been getting harder and harder to root for lately
coral pike
o fuck my temporary horse died
i decided to be nosy and see what blackwater is like
not a good idea
o i get a new temp horse
sweet
warped arrow
lol
I campped on top of a building and killed half of the population and booked it the second I got onto the floor
clear swallow
How can i study birds easily
I get as close I can get get right under them and it wont let me study em
crimson bronze
Binoculars.
coral pike
i quite enjoy the hamish sinclair missions
hushed harbor
do any gold bars respawn in the epilogue
hushed harbor
😔
west tide
dire sentinel
im guessing it got hit by the train?
i once left my horse on the tracks, and bought a train ticket. apparently my horse died from the train and then i learned to never leave your horse sitting on the tracks
i even saw it in the little cutscene when on the train
my horse got smashed
worldly gulch
do any gold bars respawn in the epilogue
Yes any gold bars that aren't rewards from treasure hunts respawn. The one at limpany, Braithwaite Manor and the two at the train crash site respawned for me
coral pike
u see i was doing the last penelope mission which involves arthur shooting people from the train
and my horse was following me
and after the mission
my horse was dead
so
i can only guess that the horse got hit by the train
long plume
Is there anyway to get unique events to trigger more often maybe specific routes and such? I know this is a stupid question but I've been trying to get a unique encounter with the tumbleweed sherrif for ages as I need the bounties he gives off
Its so very tiring
To get the tumbleweed ones you need to get a unique encounter with the Sherrif of Tumbleweed
If that's the case than I've visited it for the first time 72 times as I've attempted for so long for it to work
So clearly it's not or my save is corrupt somehow
hushed flare
Or maybe u have bad memory
keen birchBOT
See this message if Arthur sucks.
onyx hollow
hearty venture
hello , the game can run with rtx 2060 in full grafic seting??
inner tartan
Hi guys. Does anyone know how to avoid using Rockstars trashy launcher? I now for some reason cant connect to Rockstars Games Library Services after 200+ hours of playing.
turbid phoenix
i just play in the ps4 and its been good so far
green pine
Ps4 is the best platform RDR2 runs on
clear swallow
yeppy
candid walrus
Mhm
hushed flare
Console in general is good anyway
clear swallow
played on ps4 and now on ps5
hushed flare
I want to play on PC just so I can mod
green pine
But tbh im more used to R* games on pc
delicate sparrow
PC
green pine
ok
upper fox
no reason to have xbox
green pine
But my pc doesnt have disk function so I cant insert a rdr1 disk for xbox 360 into it even if it would be supported
upper fox
backwards compatibility is the only thing i think is cool about the xbox
green pine
But PS5 has backward compatibility
upper fox
rdr1 doesnt have a pc port
green pine
rdr1 doesnt have a pc port
maybe we insert the disk and use xbox controller
upper fox
xbox has backwards compatibility with orginal xbox , xbox 360, xbox one
upper fox
I heared ps now sucks
green pine
Yeah bc its a streaming service so It will require a lot of internet
upper fox
jup
green pine
But you'd still use it if you really cant find a PS3 or just a huge fan of the red dead redemption series
upper fox
I still have my first xbox 360 and I found rdr1 in a drift store for 5 bucks
keen birchBOT
Keep it on topic.
hidden moss
I now have $13,403.71 in chapter 2 👍
marble juniper
hello i have 300$ and i just started what should i buy
delicate sparrow
hello i have 300$ and i just started what should i buy
what do you have so far?
like what horse, what guns
tiny berry
I now have $13,403.71 in chapter 2 👍
wtf did you do lol
hidden moss
gold
hushed flare
Low honor playthrough
timber elk
you eat babies
grim lotus
you eat babies
You're getting payed for that?
timber elk
You're getting payed for that?
what
marble juniper
like what horse, what guns
nothing
grim lotus
I'm not getting payed for that what am I doing with my life :,(
marble juniper
i have the cattlemen revolver
grim lotus
$300... Idk what's for $300 but what's the latest mission you remember doing
marble juniper
like what horse, what guns
and the horse was just some random horse i found because my other one died
marble juniper
$300... Idk what's for $300 but what's the latest mission you remember doing
released micah from prison
grim lotus
You might wanna get a nice horse but tbh you will in a Ch2 mission
Oh
Probably a nice horse then
marble juniper
Probably a nice horse then
i got one for 50$ but it died lol
grim lotus
Or maybe a rifle but you don't need them that much right now
grim lotus
i got one for 50$ but it died lol
Did you do that mission with Hosea where you go into Town and buy a new horse?
marble juniper
Did you do that mission with Hosea where you go into Town and buy a new horse?
and give them a black one?
marble juniper
Did you do that mission with Hosea where you go into Town and buy a new horse?
i think so because i had to give them a black horse and buy a new one
marble juniper
oh i could keep it? i wanted it but when i bought the new horse the black one disapeared
marble juniper
Did you do that mission with Hosea where you go into Town and buy a new horse?
anyways yes i bought a horse but it died because some bounty hunters attacked me
grim lotus
oh i could keep it? i wanted it but when i bought the new horse the black one di...
Yeah that happens I think I declined the offer
marble juniper
If you save often then you can reload Old Saves
well it is just a horse + i could already buy a new one but i want to buy something i need but idk what i need
grim lotus
If you've just got the Dual Holster from Micah, you're gonna want another Sidearm
Dual Wielding a Sawn-off Shotgun adds 2 big shots and that's it
marble juniper
If you've just got the Dual Holster from Micah, you're gonna want another Sidear...
yea i got it
grim lotus
It's practically useless
marble juniper
If you've just got the Dual Holster from Micah, you're gonna want another Sidear...
which side arm should i get
i have 300$
grim lotus
One of the slightly better revolvers could work
grim lotus
i have 300$
It depends on your taste
If you want to be matching, Cattleman
If you want raw power, look for the one with the highest stats
marble juniper
but shouldnt i save some money for a horse or smth
because my horse is pretty shit 3 speed 3 acceleration
grim lotus
Cattleman is nice and reliable at your level, since you've been using it for a while
Double Action has a faster fire rate but is less accurate
Idk about Schofield cuz tbh I upgrade loads on all my guns by habit so they're almost the same
grim lotus
because my horse is pretty shit 3 speed 3 acceleration
That's actually alright
The Shire (black horse) has 4S-2A I think
It might be more
I can't rlly remember I got upgraded Saddle and stuff
grim lotus
because my horse is pretty shit 3 speed 3 acceleration
Tbh if you buy higher level Equipment for that horse it could work rlly well
I don't know what kind of things you can afford but Stirrups are important
I think they heighten stats
And Saddles decrease Core Drain rate
marble juniper
i had the american standardbred i believe
marble juniper
Alright so buy a sidearm and upgrade horse stuff
timber elk
Alright so buy a sidearm and upgrade horse stuff
just go get the schofield revolver from the valentine doctor and the semiauto shotgun from the watson's cabin, and later you'll get a lancaster repeater from micah, those are the only guns you need through the game
hollow comet
When kkk doesn’t spawn
dire sentinel
just go get the schofield revolver from the valentine doctor and the semiauto sh...
i grabbed the rhodes lancaster repeater and micah gave me it too, so im stuck with 2 lancasters lol
timber elk
i grabbed the rhodes lancaster repeater and micah gave me it too, so im stuck wi...
it's a good rifle
timber elk
i use lancaster and semi-auto shotgun
candid walrus
Should I try and get all the trapper clothing
Also, how do I get to Siska to get the legendary fish there?
Nvm
made it
marble juniper
oo ty
candid walrus
lmfao
My horse got hit by a trolley but it didn't fall
It's like it was in slow motion
upper fox
I remember in my first playtrough my horse died because of the trolley in the mission where arthurs stuff got stolen by the kids
candid walrus
yikes
upper fox
horses are dumb
timber elk
pov: you're a bounty hunter who brought 5 of your friends and 2 dogs to hunt down the player who has a bounty of 5 bucks
deep fox
my horse sied
died
it got tickled by a train and now its lungs have imploded apparently
hushed flare
Just revive Arthur with special horse reviver
coral pike
im trying to buy hair tonics and it says i cant carry any more even tho im 99% certain i dont own any
why is this
i just want my hair to grow fast
ive checked my tonic inventory and theres no hair tonics there
coral pike
can i stack hair tonics
coral pike
i mean like does the effect stack
hushed flare
Very worth it when you get LOTE satchel
hushed flare
Let's you carry 99 of everything
coral pike
🤔 maybe ill grind for satchel after all
coral pike
bruh this yt vid says this gonna take 6 hours
candid walrus
Sometimes it can take shorter
Sometimes longer
All depends on the animal spawns and their quality
coral pike
cant wait to hunt for a couple hours
jovial sundial
does anybody know where the poster for the squirell statue
coral pike
i feel like this woulda been more worth if i had gone for the satchel earlier in the game
im in ch6 so if i can rly just buy it as john i might just do that lol
jovial sundial
same am in ch6 but am holding off playing as johm for abit just trying to get things done before i move on
full garnet
I just found my first fence in St Denis. Are there any must have Documents?
hushed flare
Why would u want to do that carrying 3 cheese wedges only is painful
well in the epilogue you really don't need satchels anymore 
That's why they make it purchase
jovial sundial
what satchel is it?
hushed flare
legend of the east
jovial sundial
oh
hushed flare
such a logic breaking satchel
jovial sundial
i mean am half way through ch6 so amma just buy it in epilouge
hushed harbor
Abigail: "how many times i gotta bury you john marston"
John: "you aint never burying me"
candid walrus
👀
coral pike
i mean am half way through ch6 so amma just buy it in epilouge
same lol
hushed flare
Abigail: "how many times i gotta bury you john marston"
John: "you aint never bu...
This is why John should have just chugged a bunch of moonshine and tobacco on the barn thing
red helm
RDR1 was quite cool, back when they made it. Maybe not "Ground Breaking" but, I quite enjoyed it.
serene rivet
dumb question.. the animal icons we get in the map, are those random? or we have choices on what animals we see first and thats the one ill see on the map? or i can have my map actually full of animal icons?
upper fox
most game developers back then didnt bother to add in those little details.
even old r* games have more detail then last year released games
kuch cyberpunk kuch
hidden moss
dutch just wanted to eat tahiti's mangoes because he heard it is insane 😔
red helm
dumb question.. the animal icons we get in the map, are those random? or we have...
Unsure.. I'm thinking it's not random, but... Don't know..
serene rivet
can you show me your map?
red helm
I'm on PS4, so, unfortunately not.
serene rivet
full garnet
Is there a way to lock those Cigarette cards? I accidentally sold one to a fence. -.-
red helm
Don't think so, but it's alright, you can always buy Premium Cig packs, for random cards. They aren't unique.
full garnet
okie good... idk where to get those but I won't worry as much then! Thanks 🙂
red helm
General store. You may have to discard them from your satchel, if you are full.
full garnet
Ok! Thanks very much
red helm
No problem.
hidden moss
i like to call my horse while running so it chases me
I played so much MGSV with D-Horse that i thought my horse would just teleport on me
hollow comet
a few weeks ago i came here mad because i lost a save
I am now close to where i lost the save
So uhm
WOHOOO
fuck you
I’m sorry
that was rude
I’m just anti dutch and anti micah
“there’s nothing wrong with dutch”
Dutch can go end his lafe
nobody likes dotch
he can end his ugly, disgusting, lafe
I am a verry verry verry veerry
hollow comet
oaky
i had to redo story mode
the last part as arthur
and i realized that i didnt cry at a single death except for hosea’s
jovial sundial
and i realized that i didnt cry at a single death except for hosea’s
lennys were sad but it happend so quick so you kinda didnt feel it
hollow comet
the last ride to camp, when hosea’s words echo through your head
and the song
that was just
jovial sundial
true the last ride is emotional as fuck
red helm
The quotes on the Last Ride actually change depending if you are High or Low honor.
marble juniper
how do i stop being wanted from a city?
hollow comet
train station
red helm
how do i stop being wanted from a city?
Pay your bounty.
hollow comet
unless its dead or alive
red helm
Yes, there are certain times/places that the plot have you always Wanted.
jovial sundial
how do i stop being wanted from a city?
pay bounty
marble juniper
cant i just let the bounty hunters kill me?
red helm
If the Bounty is at a $$ then you either have to pay OR you can surrender to lawmen and go to jail.
jovial sundial
hell nah its 300 and its all i have
i think if you just surrender to the police i think the bounty goes
red helm
If you go to Jail, the bounty goes, and a Fellow Gang member will come to break you out.
marble juniper
and how long will i be in prison
jovial sundial
cant i just let the bounty hunters kill me?
even if you let the bounty hunter kill you it wont get rid of the bounty
jovial sundial
and how long will i be in prison
like a min and sometimes the gang will break you out
candid walrus
Other times Arthur/John bribes them
jovial sundial
and how long will i be in prison
yea
red helm
Lame that if you die to a Bounty hunter, You lose a bunch of money, but the bounty $$ doesn't go down... Pffft.
jovial sundial
Lame that if you die to a Bounty hunter, You lose a bunch of money, but the boun...
its pretty dumb tbh
red helm
I've actually never surrendered. I rarely have a bounty, even on my low honor play through.
red helm
Whenever I'd want to lower my honor, I'd do it smart. Kill the witnesses to my crimes, then ride off when done, so I couldn't get anymore people to report me.
Depends what platform you are on. PS4 you press the Down arrow.
marble juniper
Whenever I'd want to lower my honor, I'd do it smart. Kill the witnesses to my c...
i threatened someone in a town lol
hushed flare
to bad I can't kill the witnesses to my train robbery
serene rivet
i manage to spawn 2 cougars in a row.. and now i cant find 1 again
marble juniper
what stirrups should i buy
hushed flare
Hooded
candid walrus
Hooded stirrups
red helm
i threatened someone in a town lol
Well, yeah, don't mess around in the cities. That's just trouble.
jovial sundial
what stirrups should i buy
make sure to always to keep horse revives
serene rivet
i mean yes but im just collecting perfect pelts for the camp stuff
red helm
Moose Antler..... blarg.
hushed flare
If only camp customizations did stuff
serene rivet
is it bc my camp is too close to the spawn point? its driving me crazy lol
red helm
is it bc my camp is too close to the spawn point? its driving me crazy lol
Yes, don't camp near where you want a animal to spawn.
usually..
hushed flare
If that's driving you crazy good luck on trying to get 5 snowy 5 red and 5 little egrets to spawn
red helm
I know a bunch of places for Egrets...
hushed flare
Maybe I just had bad luck then I kept finding everything but red egrets
hushed flare
Yes
jovial sundial
i cant wait to get michas revolvers
hushed flare
Revolver*
hushed flare
jovial sundial
its dumb you cant get both even tho he's literally shooting both at john
hushed flare
When you make someone use 2 revolver for the entire game but then when they die they only drop one and the other magically dissapears
My only logic explanation is that Pinkerton took one
But it's still not logical
warped arrow
E
jovial sundial
imagine they took michas revolver as evidence
red helm
Rockstar and their foolish logic.
jovial sundial
yea
hushed flare
Not dual wielding double actions
hushed flare
Michael gun fires fast as heck
Isn't that just double action revolvers anyway
jovial sundial
ngl I've been using the cattleman recently and its so fun
hushed flare
Double actions have kind of trash accuracy
jovial sundial
i think lemat is best revolver
hushed harbor
i dual wield schofield revolvers
red helm
I did American Venom last night, and Micah was reloading way to fast, either that or he had like 30 bullets in each of his guns. Cheating twirp.
jovial sundial
i dual wield schofield revolvers
you have calloways schofield?
hushed flare
I did American Venom last night, and Micah was reloading way to fast, either tha...
Maybe he used deadeye but he misses because deadeye instantly refills ammo
hushed harbor
you have calloways schofield?
yeah but i dont use it, just normal schofield
red helm
Maybe he used deadeye but he misses because deadeye instantly refills ammo
Might've been, and aiming at barrels, because he only hit me like once.
hushed flare
I mean I've missed people when I marked them in deadeye before
jovial sundial
it would be cool if dutch dropped his revolver he shot micah with
hushed flare
Dutchs revolvers can be recreated pretty much
jovial sundial
true
red helm
I was barely moving from that box/barrel stuff, because he was shoting so much. I never could get a good opening. But, for using 6 shoters, he was definitely shoting a whole lot of bullets.
hushed flare
12 shots tho
And they are double actions so he doesn't have to use hammers
It's like semi auto pistol but budget
red helm
I never once really saw him reloading.
hushed flare
He's using deadeye obv
red helm
Clearly.
hushed flare
Deadeye to refill ammo
hushed harbor
playing the epilogue makes me "forget" about arthur in a "moving on" sort of way
hushed flare
Deadeye but it's online deadeye
red helm
And why doesn't Sadie just shot Micah? Why does she try to Capture him? Pffft, Sadie...
hushed flare
I feel like Micah could have just shot Sadie super fast lol
red helm
Yeah...
hushed harbor
westerns
hushed flare
Gotta make sure YouTubers don't cry before killing micah
hushed harbor
imagine if they killed off sadie too
hidden moss
Cool
jovial sundial
its dumb that sadie and charles were never spoke of during rdr1
red helm
Would've sucked if Sadie died then.
marble juniper
make sure to always to keep horse revives
where do i buy em
red helm
Eh, a bunch of characters weren't mentioned in RDR1.
jovial sundial
where do i buy em
genral stores in horse section
hidden moss
Eh, a bunch of characters weren't mentioned in RDR1.
Yeah. Let's just wait for RDR1 remake
jovial sundial
Yeah. Let's just wait for RDR1 remake
tbh i dont think a rdr1 remake would be good
red helm
It would only be good if they add a lot of content. If it's just graphics update, then whoop.
hidden moss
If it involves RDR2's map for extra missions then yeah
hidden moss
I agree
jovial sundial
some people want it be in the prohibition era
hushed harbor
would the RDR2 map be inaccessible to the RDR3 protag until the epilogue where you play as arthur
jovial sundial
but if they ever did it should be a backstory and how the gang rised to what it was before blackwater
red helm
Eh, I don't think I'd want it to go up to the Blackwater massacre and then play as Arthur...
jovial sundial
would the RDR2 map be inaccessible to the RDR3 protag until the epilogue where y...
maybe like rdr1 a certain part would be
jovial sundial
Eh, I don't think I'd want it to go up to the Blackwater massacre and then play ...
maybe play as hosea
red helm
Better to leave that as a "Mystery" thing.
jovial sundial
Better to leave that as a "Mystery" thing.
true say
red helm
Indeed, Like play as Hosea or some such..
jovial sundial
maybe the game would end when the gang picks up micah
hushed harbor
rdr3 but the map is stretched to be accurate to real life states (like ambarino is changed to be as big as irl montana)
jovial sundial
and the final scene is micah looking down then looks up with a grin on his face with his hat tilted down
jovial sundial
rdr3 but the map is stretched to be accurate to real life states (like ambarino ...
but think how long it would take to design the whole map
red helm
If they were as big as the real states, think how long the game would be the load and such... ouf.
jovial sundial
If they were as big as the real states, think how long the game would be the loa...
and plus they would have to put double the random events and side quests
hushed harbor
also since there's 45 states in rdr2 during its time just like real life that means theres 5 states that dont exist in the rdr universe that were repalced by the states in rdr2
hidden moss
When i first met the man with a toy boat i immediately got GTA SA Zero mission flashbacks
marble juniper
i have a question why doesnt the doctor in valetine open?
jovial sundial
i still need to finish marko dragics missions
red helm
That damn RC airplane....
hidden moss
i have a question why doesnt the doctor in valetine open?
You have to look in the back
And interact with it
And go rob the doctor from Valentine ( Left D-Pad)
jovial sundial
i have a question why doesnt the doctor in valetine open?
quick note for you go to the back of the store you will see a black door knock on it then point the gun at the the doctor and order him to open it and you will have a small shootout and get abit of money
marble juniper
ik but the doctor isnt open
delicate sparrow
wait till he opens
jovial sundial
i have a question why doesnt the doctor in valetine open?
and you can do this at the strawberry genral store,rhodes gunstore and saint denis gunstore
delicate sparrow
in the morning
hidden moss
I did that in a stealth approach but i quickly got caught and only steal the revolver and money clips. Didn't even bother the safe
red helm
Eh, bring your Bow, and try to silent kill the O'driscols, then when the law does come, Use your Lasso and Hogtie them. for a lower Bounty.
hidden moss
I hogtied the store owner when it opened
marble juniper
wait till he opens
its been 2 day in rdr2 days
hidden moss
And run underground and dead eye bow them
red helm
and yeah. Only go for the Gun, money on the table, and the safe. then once that is done, run run to your horse and go.
jovial sundial
its been 2 day in rdr2 days
did you rob him?
marble juniper
did you rob him?
jovial sundial
<a:CB_awkwardkid:595322840560173057>
thats why
marble juniper
hes writing smth in the back
jovial sundial
<a:CB_awkwardkid:595322840560173057>
gotta get out the area and go back later
marble juniper
oh ok then imma go do a mission and return
jovial sundial
i just had a spicy chip go doen the wrong hole and yea you get the rest
jovial sundial
so not sicko mode
delicate sparrow
indeed not sicko mode
jovial sundial
everytime i breath i feel the heat rising up
delicate sparrow
does it actually work like that?
jovial sundial
i guess so
delicate sparrow
well, you experienced it, I can't question it
jovial sundial
we really went from talking about robbing a doctor to me becoming a fire breather
serene rivet
1 more perfect cougar pelt left 
jovial sundial
1 more perfect cougar pelt left <a:9519_Pepe_Hype:611364060935749632>
i know a good cougar spot up near marko dragics lab and near the legendary animal
serene rivet
yes im near the legendary uh deer buck i think it is
jovial sundial
yea
serene rivet
but i trust myself -0 so every time i get a pelt i go back to the camp LMAO ive lost my pelts when dying.. and cougars are a thing
jovial sundial
i think my horse was downed and my ps4 turned off
are you going for the squirrel statue
serene rivet
right now im just completing the camp stuff
jovial sundial
right now im just completing the camp stuff
ah do you know were the poster for it is
gaunt jackal
Hey I need some help
jovial sundial
Hey I need some help
sure
jovial sundial
yea
serene rivet
mhm
gaunt jackal
For some reason I don’t have any missions I’m in chapter 6
serene rivet
im in the 3rd one i believe
jovial sundial
nvm my horse all good
delicate sparrow
For some reason I don’t have any missions I’m in chapter 6
which one did you just finish?
jovial sundial
For some reason I don’t have any missions I’m in chapter 6
you gotta do the "murfee country" misson
gaunt jackal
Um don’t know put I know I’m in the last 3 missions
jovial sundial
do you have a letter at camp?
gaunt jackal
No
jovial sundial
like when you go on the map it dosent show one
jovial sundial
you did that misson?
gaunt jackal
Ya
jovial sundial
hmm did you do the mary side quest?
jovial sundial
no the girl arthur used to date
gaunt jackal
No not yet
gaunt jackal
Ok thank you
jovial sundial
np
marble juniper
make sure to always to keep horse revives
it died 
jovial sundial
oof
hidden moss
I have 99 horse revivers just in case-
hidden moss
it died <:CB_angery_cry:407262705041276929>
Thats rough 
hidden moss
I’m on the train mission in chap 6 now
jovial sundial
all goes bad after that
hidden moss
I’m on the train mission in chap 6 now <:sadart:512820686859927562>
Everything goes to shit after Saint Denis bank job
True true true
It killed the voice (Hosea) and the future (Lenny)
jovial sundial
Everything goes to shit after Saint Denis bank job
i think a soon as hosea died things really went baf
hidden moss
i think a soon as hosea died things really went baf
hosea..
jovial sundial
dutch lost his right hand man and the man he knew for a long time and i guess micah took advantage of the open spot hosea left
hidden moss
Also he lost his future
Micah shouldn’t have ever even been allowed in the gang
Smh
jovial sundial
lost his thinking
micah was only accepted into the gang is because he saved dutchs life
marble juniper
Thats rough <:sadart:512820686859927562>
yea the horse decided to ram someone and bounty hunters killed it and me
jovial sundial
quick thing if you go back to micahs camp in strawberry he has a photo of dutchs wanted poster you can take
hidden moss
yea the horse decided to ram someone and bounty hunters killed it and me
damn.
hidden moss
quick thing if you go back to micahs camp in strawberry he has a photo of dutchs...
Isn't javiers in online in the bounty hunter theme max tent too?
hidden moss
Dutch is an asshole but joining Micah again made me absolutely despise him
jovial sundial
Dutch is an asshole but joining Micah again made me absolutely despise him
he only went back to micah because they needed the money they left in blackwater
hidden moss
he only went back to micah because they needed the money they left in blackwater
I still don't see why they couldn't send josiah to get the money or somebody else
jovial sundial
Dutch is an asshole but joining Micah again made me absolutely despise him
atleast he assisted in michas death
hidden moss
Is it known how long Dutch and Micah were together in the epilogue
hidden moss
Welp Arthur is dead
hollow comet
Is it known how long Dutch and Micah were together in the epilogue
I’d say maybe a few years
candid walrus
Sad. But he had to die
hollow comet
They need to make a game where you play as a black man during slavery
Controversial but the gameplay will be good
Fighting your way to freedom
hidden moss
They need to make a game where you play as a black man during slavery
transatlantic slave trade?
jovial sundial
I still don't see why they couldn't send josiah to get the money or somebody els...
i think dutch didnt wanted to go back for it michah was the one who kept suggesting it and they had 42k in the end but they lost that money so they thought it was best to get that money and eventually leave each other
jovial sundial
Django unchained as a red dead game
could be a good game
hidden moss
i think dutch didnt wanted to go back for it michah was the one who kept sugges...
Yeah...I just guess it doesn't make sense that josiah literally walked in and out of blackwater as he pleased and nobody thought to use him for the money
To me atlesast
hollow comet
Or life as a Pinkerton
hidden moss
They need to make a game where you play as a black man during slavery
He escapes Manhunt style?
Would be awesome
marble juniper
so i made the doctor open the backroom and killed the people where can i find the gun
hidden moss
Or life as a Pinkerton
Until you get shot by notorious outlaws arthur callahan, aidan o'mally and rip van winkle.
delicate sparrow
They need to make a game where you play as a black man during slavery
na, American Revolution game
hidden moss
so i made the doctor open the backroom and killed the people where can i find th...
The chest on the table
jovial sundial
Yeah...I just guess it doesn't make sense that josiah literally walked in and ou...
i guess it would be to strange a man walking out of town that went through a blood massacre with a fat bag of money
delicate sparrow
we don't have any American Revolution games
candid walrus
na, American Revolution game
Yes, yes, yes
hidden moss
we don't have any American Revolution games
AC 3?
delicate sparrow
there's a French Revolution AC game, but no american revolution game
hidden moss
i guess it would be to strange a man walking out of town that went through a bl...
True..
hollow comet
Yall think rdr3 will happen ?
Probably
candid walrus
No
hollow comet
Oh
hidden moss
Yall think rdr3 will happen ?
Nope, not at all
candid walrus
I doubt it will
delicate sparrow
it's the american revolution
jovial sundial
it should not happen
hidden moss
it's the american revolution
Yep. I was about to correct you
delicate sparrow
but it's an AC game, so it's shit
hollow comet
What
jovial sundial
a rdr3 would ruin the games
delicate sparrow
we don't need a rdr3, make a whole new historical universe
hollow comet
Rdr3 no but red dead redemption: something something
delicate sparrow
we don't need more GTA-style games
spiral laurel
I’m gonna be honest
delicate sparrow
ok
spiral laurel
RDR3 can work, anything can work
marble juniper
so i just take the money and gun then dip?
hollow comet
Yes
spiral laurel
With enough effort RDR3 is possible
hushed harbor
i did it. i got 100% completion
ended it with the grave. you know the one.
hidden moss
so i just take the money and gun then dip?
Yep
hidden moss
Rdr3 no but red dead redemption: something something
something about sadies time in SA or charles in canada would be real nice tbh
I really wanna see a rdr game where we see the rise of the gang
jovial sundial
and plus they cant even get round to update there dying online mode never mind another red dead gane
spiral laurel
I really wanna see a rdr game where we see the rise of the gang
That would be nice
Or an RDR1 remake
hollow comet
I really wanna see a rdr game where we see the rise of the gang
Black water?
spiral laurel
With all the features from RDR2
hollow comet
They could make a alt reality
delicate sparrow
I really wanna see a rdr game where we see the rise of the gang
we know the rise of the gang
dutch had a drunkard dad or something, ran away from home
candid walrus
There is nothing left to tell. It's over.
delicate sparrow
met Hosea at a party when they tried to pickpocket each other, became friends
spiral laurel
There is nothing left to tell. It's over.
This is not even said at all
jovial sundial
dutchs mother is buried in blackwater
spiral laurel
If RD was over they’d say it is
delicate sparrow
started an insurance fraud thing, got caught, went to jail
spiral laurel
We don’t know if they will make another
delicate sparrow
they escaped and found Arthur
hidden moss
There is nothing left to tell. It's over.
Sadie or charles, they left their stories open for speculation.
candid walrus
No
marble juniper
i took the gun how do i change it to my sidearm
spiral laurel
But let’s not say they will or will not
delicate sparrow
and started adding more and more people till the gang reached the point in the game
spiral laurel
Let’s just think about it right now
candid walrus
I don't think a game with either of them would work
delicate sparrow
game
spiral laurel
All I’m saying is
hidden moss
I don't think a game with either of them would work
How comes?
hollow comet
Johns dumb
spiral laurel
RDR1 remake would be awesome
spiral laurel
Johns dumb
At first yes
hollow comet
Bro nearly drowns in the water at strawberry
spiral laurel
But he gets better
marble juniper
i took the gun how do i change it to my sidearm
.