red-dead-singleplayer

[dire sentinel]

i mean, john said in rdr he never went to new austin

[red helm]

Assuming they cut a bunch of content for New Austin, people have talked about there being random files for voice stuff with Mexico border guards, and Arthur talking to the Stagecoach guy about taking him to Armidillo, etc etc.

[granite axle]

I can't help but think if the gang just fled to New Austin instead of heading North, they'd be better off.

[candid walrus]

Interesting

[candid walrus]

They would have to get past the Great Plains and Blackwater first, so I don't think they would have been able to

[granite axle]

They'd be in The Great Plains anyway

[red helm]

Lot of "what if's" in this game...

[granite axle]

They would just head south

Also

Has anyone seen the RDR2 iceberg?

[red helm]

Ice berg? no...

[delicate sparrow]

i don't think there are icebergs in the western United States

[granite axle]

Nah like the image

[delicate sparrow]

oh idk

[granite axle]

Not a literal iceberg lol

[red helm]

Umm... Glacier?

[narrow jetty]

Well yeah you can also go to armadillo as Arthur via mods and there's specific greet and analogize lines for the sick people there. Arthur also has dialogue with Herbert Moon

[dim adder]

Can any of you fellers get into the room to see the mutant an PC? I can see it, but I can't get through that window.

[narrow jetty]

They had Roger record like all the same lines that Rob did for New Austin

yet he can't go there without mods

weird

There's even a custom journal drawing for Arthur in New Austin

[upper fox]

That weird house near Van Horn?

RDR2 has too much content, its sad. It would’ve make the game so much better

[dim adder]

Yup, that one

[hushed flare]

rdr2 feels like it has so much content and none at all

[dim adder]

I almost feel like it's just the right amount of content for the map size and general scope of the game. Guarma is a sad feature that didn't make the deadline...

[hushed flare]

guarma felt small af

[dim adder]

It's quite small, even if you return and voyage around the areas that are otherwise inaccessible without the donkey glitch.

but the unique animals are nice and it offers a unique area, along with it's own secret content.

The cost to return to guarma is even in the dang game code... it seems like the thing was relatively feature-complete so it drives me crazy any time I find a reason to return to that place.

[warped arrow]

Guarma was pretty boring

and you couldn't really get around anywhere

[dim adder]

I've explored all of guarma and picked up every unique guarma animal (study/track/collect).

It's the only place you'll see the green turtle, shark, or a few others. Also a great place to get "exotic" bird meat.

[warped arrow]

dang

I did all of the missions and didn't express because being on feet and a lack of ammo was driving me nuts

[dim adder]

you should always express

never don't not express... you'll not regret it every other time

but, yeah, I assume you meant 'explore.' It's tough to explore in that chapter... you /can/, but it's so much more fun to revisit and take your sweet time.
I felt like that chapter was exceptionally rushed and not that much fun.

[warped arrow]

Agreed

And

[warped arrow]

Yeah my auto correct keeps going crazy

[hushed harbor]

trying to find an opossum now, every time i find one they're either 1 or 2 star

[dim adder]

did you try south of that one place?

[hushed harbor]

"that one place" being...?

[dim adder]

between the water and the land? 😛

Between Rigg's Station and the peninsula south of there. (not quite to the tip, but to the corner of the fence)

[hushed harbor]

no i havent, i'll try that

[jovial sundial]

Hey guys

Don’t you love waking up to go to school on 3 hour sleep

[hushed harbor]

...found another 1 star one 😐

[dim adder]

trying to get 3-star animals is a pain. I've been searching for a 3-star bull moose for weeks

[jovial sundial]

It’s a lot easier finding 3-stars animals in online

Which make no sense

[primal flare]

@true drift pong

[true drift]

You fackr

[dim adder]

@jovial sundial It makes perfect sense... rockstar raises their finger to offline players.

[deep cypress]

and to online

its so painfully grindy

[dire sentinel]

i love hunting 3 star bear pelts lol

[dim adder]

bears are pretty common and easy to hunt

[grim lotus]

How do you revisit Guarma?

[dim adder]

out of map glitch

[hushed harbor]

found a couple 2-star opossums... getting there.

[marble shard]

hey guys i just strated play rdr2 is their a guide how i should do things

[grim lotus]

Way to do it on Xbox?

[latent plover]

YouTube

[grim lotus]

Yeah, leave this server

Minor Spoilers are thrown around easily here cuz there's no rule against them and some people will give you Major Spoilers on purpose

[whole lantern]

yes

[grim lotus]

Oh right ok

[hushed flare]

iS 50k beTtEr tHeN a GoLd bAr

[tired wigeon]

Money > Goldbars

Prove me wrong

[wanton cove]

All that money in Arthurs pocket sometimes makes me feel like I am cheating on the gang every time Dutch goes "We need money!" like I guess we could all be on Thaiti already if I actually could throw my cash at 'em

[spiral laurel]

After my first playthrough im gonna go on a cruel and evil playthrough

But to be honest

I barley have the heart to antagonize Hozea, Jack, Lenny, Sadie and etc

[latent plover]

Yeah easily, it’d be good if there was an ending where you can go to Tahiti

All the treasures are probably enough

[latent plover]

I did an evil playthrough but I too couldn’t antagonise certain characters and certain random events

It’s tough

[hidden moss]

hi yall

[hidden moss]

Hello

[latent plover]

Hey there mister

[spiral laurel]

So I never even noticed this, but Apparently if Arthur doesn't get a proper nap in a while, his idle animation changes

[hidden moss]

How?

[latent plover]

I’ve not heard of that

[hidden moss]

Neither have i

[latent plover]

My Arthur rarely sleeps and seems the same always

[hidden moss]

I sleep at night all the time

With Arthur and John

[spiral laurel]

Ok so, Arthur if he doesn't get the proper amount of sleep in my game, will look like he's struggling to stay awake

[latent plover]

When a core is empty (red) he’ll have his head down and look tired maybe that’s it. I remember thinking he needed sleep but turns out he just needed to eat.

[spiral laurel]

his eyes will be squinted and what not

[hidden moss]

Oh i do notice that, but id did not think that that was the reason

[latent plover]

Check if you have an empty core it might be that instead

[hidden moss]

Or the game is broken

[latent plover]

I used to sleep at night too because I literally couldn’t see where I was going it was too dark

[hidden moss]

But Vee's is the most likely

[latent plover]

But there’s a few random events only at night so I stayed awake for that and hunting nocturnal animals

[hidden moss]

Or i would go to Tumbleweed and just relax

And deal with that annoying sheriff

[latent plover]

Him and sheriff Malloy are always my victims

[hidden moss]

Same

How long did it take you to finish the game?

[latent plover]

The story took me 40-60 hours I can’t remember exactly it was a while ago

[hidden moss]

For me like 200

Because i focused on the mysteries a lot

[latent plover]

My first playthrough I missed basically every side mission bc I was rushing through the main missions

Then I realised how much more to the game there was

[hidden moss]

The Side missions are the best in my opinion

Like Giants and Serial Killers and Vampires and Ghosts

[latent plover]

Yeah a variety of interesting stuff

[hidden moss]

Have you dealt with this cult roaming around lemoyne

[grim lotus]

Yeah his eyes start closing and he sways slightly

[hidden moss]

And The Heartlands

[grim lotus]

Sherrif Malloy pisses me off lol

[latent plover]

Kkk? Yeah

[hidden moss]

I just watch

[latent plover]

He’s a murderer

[hidden moss]

RESPECT THE LAW AND WE WILL TREAT YOU LIKE FAMILY, DISOBEY AND WE WILL SLAUGHTER YOU LIKE A HOG

[grim lotus]

Wearing white robes?

I only saw them in Chapter 2 once and then never saw them again

Burned them but still

[hidden moss]

Haha i do the same, you can find some near valentine

[grim lotus]

He is? I didn't know that he just annoys me

His moustache does not suit him

[grim lotus]

Where ish?

[latent plover]

Yeah there’s YouTube video you can watch, he kills Moira, that girl he was having an affair with

[grim lotus]

Oh lord

Typical

[latent plover]

You can hear it in the game after your first bounty mission

[hidden moss]

Have you solved the mystery of the Giant of the North (Thats my nickname for him)

[grim lotus]

OH YEAH I remember that somewhat

[grim lotus]

I've never done any of the mysteries lol

[hidden moss]

WHAT

Dude your missing out

[latent plover]

Not personally but StrangeMan has

[grim lotus]

Imma end up having a hard time in the Epilogue

[hidden moss]

I did on my own

[grim lotus]

How so?

Do u need them for 100% btw

[hidden moss]

Theres vampires, ghosts,

Giants

Cults

Serial Killers

[grim lotus]

I got, like, 2 of the serial killer clues but now I'm on CH6 and I can't find him

Ik about that one

[hidden moss]

Oh he is over near Annesburg

In like a basment

Don't go in there

There is a lot of things that you cant unsee

[grim lotus]

How do you find the 3rd clue

[hidden moss]

What are your clues?

[grim lotus]

I've probably seen worse

[hidden moss]

There is one in Valentine, Near Braithwaite Manor

Etc.

[grim lotus]

Can't remember

Was one in the Heartlands under the rails and one in Rhodes

Idk wut the specific details were

[hidden moss]

Uh i forgot the others

[latent plover]

There’ll be a location for it you can probably google and it’ll show you on a map or something

[hidden moss]

Do you guys know about the Night Folk?

[grim lotus]

True, I'll probably start doing that as John

[hidden moss]

Over in the Bayou

[grim lotus]

Isn't that an RDR1 thing?

[hidden moss]

No thats at RDR2

[latent plover]

Yeah they’re quite spooky

[hidden moss]

Who are the gang over at Roanoke?

The Butchers

[grim lotus]

No, I don't

[latent plover]

Murfee

[hidden moss]

Yes the Murfee Brood

[grim lotus]

Murfree Brood

The ones you drive out of Beaver Hollow

In Ch6

[hidden moss]

Who would win The Murfees or the Night Folk? Which side are you on?

[grim lotus]

I've never seen the Night Folk but the Murfrees can't shoot for shit

[hidden moss]

Dude The Night Folk are scary as Fck

Search them

[grim lotus]

I got ambushed and ran a loose circle around a couple to hit them from behind, guy on the other side of the ridge popped 7 shots at me and hit 2 or 3

Oh God all the pictures remind me of DbD

[hidden moss]

Mhm

[grim lotus]

Wait so are they in the Lagras-Lakay area?

[hidden moss]

They are scary

If you stay out of Saint Denis for too long you can see folks hanging then you will be ambushed

[latent plover]

Murfee would easily win I think

[hidden moss]

And killed brutaly by a machete

[latent plover]

Since the night folk don’t use guns

[hidden moss]

Thats a good hypothesis

[grim lotus]

So southern Marsh Basin Area?

[hidden moss]

Basically

[grim lotus]

I might have to set up camp and hang around a bit lol

[hidden moss]

But after i head there i just head over to the north and just go on top of a mountain and i just watch the Sun rise and set

[grim lotus]

If they were stealthy and tactful, they could win Murfrees can shoot as well as John after getting Mauled by wolves

[hidden moss]

True Leays call it a tie

[grim lotus]

Yeah Y not

O'Driscolls or Lemoyne Raiders tho

That's the question

[hidden moss]

I was just gonna type that

[grim lotus]

So what's your opinion?

[hidden moss]

Lets look at this from different points in the battle

If it is an ambush on Shady belle from the O'Driscolls

Then the O'Driscolls will win

Since they are good at that

The Lemoyne Raiders will be completly outnumberd on all sides

Putting an End to their gang

But if it is an head on war

It will obviously be the Lemoyne Raiders

[hushed flare]

wonder why every gang has like 20298302 members and then vanderlindes max number was like 15

[hidden moss]

Because the Gang consists of War Veterans still raging on the Civil War

Uh because The Van Der Linde gang consists of amazing Gunslingers and Profesionalls?

[grim lotus]

If they were on equal ground at equal distance?

[hushed flare]

I must have killed half the population of del lobos at this point, I raided fort Mercer and thieves landing for like the third time

[last pier]

I can’t bring myself to finish story mode.

[hidden moss]

Like Dutch said "If you can ride a horse and kill without thought the O'Drisscolls will let you in"

And "Colm cares about numbers"

[hushed flare]

wonder why Arthur and John can tank like 2000 bullets

[hidden moss]

Uh because there is something called Plot Armor

And they are the main protagonists

[hushed flare]

If you get shot 3 times in the head and 8 times in the chest just drink a moonshine

[hidden moss]

So they cant die untill the end of the story

[hidden moss]

That's Red Dead Logic for you

[hushed flare]

They should have gave uncle a moonshine

[hidden moss]

Uh that guy

He is useless

[hushed flare]

I saw him work before

[hidden moss]

Arthur GAY

[hushed flare]

Carrying some random sack

[hidden moss]

Thats all he does

[grim lotus]

O'Driscolls: being payed for working, many join for easy money, none are particularly Loyal or honourable
Lemoyne Raiders: Vets that were on the losing side of the war trying to grip on to something that isn't there
Night Folk: well, it's a cult, so I'm not surprised
Murfree brood: I feel like there isn't actually that many but they're just Bums who don't care for society

[hidden moss]

#Johnhasconstipation

[hushed flare]

where skinners and del lobos

[grim lotus]

Idk about Other Gangs I'm on Ch6

[hushed flare]

I wish nitefolk was a part of the main story

Lakay

[hidden moss]

Angelo Bronte's Gang vs The Braithwaites vs the Grays

[grim lotus]

But in terms of O'Driscolls

Colm probs had a close circle and they were kinda like the true gang in the same sense as the Van Der Lindes

[hidden moss]

Whou would win?

[grim lotus]

When in the story

[hidden moss]

Keiran Hit Differently

[hushed flare]

Angelo Bronte has cops

[grim lotus]

B4 or after the mansion burned down

[hidden moss]

And Saint Denis on his side, the most advanced

B4

[grim lotus]

He has the Police in his pocket, but he has a bunch of GunsForHire at his mansion

[grim lotus]

Probably still Angelos but Braithwaites would put up a good fight

Idk about Grays there's not many compared to other Factions so they're probably losing

[hidden moss]

The Braithwaites and the Grays vs Angelo Bronte's Gang, Seems fair now?

[grim lotus]

That's gonna be a Slaughter-until-surrender Scenario

The B&Gs wouldn't team up for anything but still, they would all kill until both sides just give up

[hushed flare]

What's it with people keeping their cores empty, no hats, dirty guns, all gold guns, and deadeye abusing

Every damn playthrough

[hidden moss]

Catherine's exceuce: YOU KILLED MY SONS

[grim lotus]

People just don't understand the game

And the detailed system

[hidden moss]

I only use hipfire and people are either too poor or they just dont know how to maintain them

[hushed flare]

hipfire kind of aims for you

[hidden moss]

HATS COULD SAVE YOUR LIFE

[grim lotus]

Also they probably were playing Online so bought story (in terms of gold guns and deadeye abusing)

[hidden moss]

AND THEY MAKE GREAT FASION

[hushed flare]

I hate getting my hat shot off in a big gunfight

[grim lotus]

Me too but it's cinematic as fuck

[hushed flare]

Feels like it takes 999 years to pick it up and I go from full health and health core to no health meter and half health core

[hidden moss]

I just pick'em up after like a total badass

[grim lotus]

I wait until after

[grim lotus]

Same

[hidden moss]

While in cinematic

Oh i look awesome

[grim lotus]

If you're getting peppered with bullets you're not exactly gonna think "Shit I need to pick up my hat" are you

[hidden moss]

Uh....dont judge

[hushed flare]

Meanwhilegetting sprayed by 2000 bullets and a Gatling gun and trying to pickup my hat For some reason

[grim lotus]

Bruuh

[hushed flare]

I mean I can deadeye abuse right

[grim lotus]

I don't but you'd waste your health

[hidden moss]

I would just run

If there is too many LAW

[grim lotus]

What does Deadeye abuse mean

Same

[hidden moss]

It means using it way to much

[hushed flare]

Use deadeye for every kill for x amount of time

[hidden moss]

Like just spamming it

[grim lotus]

Ew why bother

[hushed flare]

Beastys rdr2 playthrough be like

[hidden moss]

Imagine winning Rdr2 without dead eye

[grim lotus]

No point unless you're speedrunning

[hushed flare]

I want to do that

[grim lotus]

You can probably do that excepting the times when you get forced into it

[hushed flare]

People still use it in Speedrunnijg because no bloom and also it refills ammo instantly

[hidden moss]

Yeah thats an exeption

But the pain and rage tho

[grim lotus]

That's what I meant

[hidden moss]

AND THE HIPFIRE THO

[grim lotus]

Just let the auto aimlock hold your hand

[hushed flare]

Hipfire = auto aim central

[hidden moss]

What if there was no aimbot in the game

[grim lotus]

My hipfire doesn't auto aim much

[hidden moss]

OOH THE STRESS THO

[grim lotus]

We would all be absolutely fucked

Repeatedly

[hushed flare]

wide aim is trash tho

[hidden moss]

wE WOULD BE FUCKed HARD

[hushed flare]

normal aim should have been the default

[grim lotus]

What does that mean

[hidden moss]

In shotguns?

Because shotguns are overpowerd

[hushed flare]

It's a lock on mode

Wide means it locks on to nearest enemy in what feels like a 9999 meter radius normal is like 10 meters and haven't used narrow

[grim lotus]

Oh the one where you press Aim and it sweeps you 70 degrees to the nearest person

Yeah I agree

[hidden moss]

I hate that

[hushed flare]

How to abuse wide aim to the fullest
1: a one shot rifle
2: express ammo

[grim lotus]

No

[hidden moss]

What if you could widen your duals

[hushed flare]

explosive ammo or slug shotguns also work

[grim lotus]

Bow

[hushed flare]

Tomahawk

[grim lotus]

Chest up one shot

No not enough ammo

You can carry, like, 9 max

[hushed flare]

Springfield rifle with express

then

[grim lotus]

Agreed

[hidden moss]

So you can hit two people at the same time like a mexican standoff

[grim lotus]

Although slow ass reload

[hushed flare]

bolt action with express sometimes does the job also

but less consistent?

[hidden moss]

Double action with explosive ammo

[hushed flare]

not enough bullets

[grim lotus]

That would be absolutely sick

Especially if you entered a Rival Gang Building and two people aim at you

[grim lotus]

agreed

[hushed flare]

only time I used explosive ammo was with nite folk and I had explosive ammo already loaded so I accidentally wasted like 5 on one guy

Not only time

[grim lotus]

I mean, if it's a Chest-Up OneShot then it works consistently

AutoAim aims at chest so

[hushed flare]

that's why one shot chest weapons are a thing

[grim lotus]

I barely use explosive I don't see the point

[hushed flare]

explosive is just fun in replay missions

[grim lotus]

I'm more a Split Point guy a lot of the time

[grim lotus]

Yeah fair enough

[hushed flare]

I'm more of a high velocity

[hidden moss]

What if you micah and dutch just had a standoff for hours

And just talking about arthur

[grim lotus]

How would that work

Imagine John and Charles noticed halfway through and went on Arthur's side

[hidden moss]

JOHN: DAMN YOU DUTCH YOU JUST LEFT ARTHUR
DUTCH: I...I...
MICAH: ARTHUR IS DEAD AND HE WAS WEAK AND GAY

[hushed flare]

Charles stayed with the indians

[grim lotus]

Micah tried to Bum Arthur once so he insults him like that

[grim lotus]

Spoiler ;w;

[hidden moss]

Yeah

[hushed flare]

no

[hidden moss]

The Reason for Micah's survival: Dutch is my fucker

[grim lotus]

Nah Micah gave good head so he was allowed in to the gang

That's the real reason Molly went Insane

[hidden moss]

If Charles John and Abigail and Sadie was with him at the ending, it would have ended up differently

[grim lotus]

Don't spoil it ;w;

[hushed flare]

"if I head down there I'm dead in 5 minutes"

no you wouldnt

[hidden moss]

No they would have died

Arthur Survied and lived with john

[hushed flare]

Charles couldn't go because indians and Sadie was already helping with jack

[hidden moss]

Yeah Arthur just beat the shit out of Micah

THATS TOTALLY WHAT HAPPENED

[hushed flare]

no Arthur threw Micah off cliff the end

[hidden moss]

NOT SPOILING ANYTHING

AHAHHA

[hidden moss]

YES CORRECT I FORGOT TO MENTION

[hushed flare]

No rules against spoiling unless it's intentional to ruin someones experience

Plus they don't even allow damn spoiler tags lololl

[hidden moss]

YES

And Arthur was cured of tb

and him and john and abigail and jack lived happily ever after

HAHAHA

AND CHARLES WANT TO CANADA

AND SADIE WENT TO SOUTH AMERICA

[hushed flare]

and we gave Hosea some Moonshine to heal up the bullet wounds

[hidden moss]

Yeah

And we glued Keirans head back

[hushed flare]

No, we made Kieran use horse reviver

[hidden moss]

And we got karen back

And lenny went back to shady belle

And lived his life

[hidden moss]

Best message of the day

[reef hollow]

Hello guys do you know the mission with serial in valentine because i killed her by mistake.

?

Please help!!!!!

[latent plover]

The one in the saloon?

[grim lotus]

Honestly you either kill her or tell Sheriff Malfoy about her

[reef hollow]

Yep

[grim lotus]

I helped her our once then declined second time and had to kill her cause she attacked me

[latent plover]

Yeah she dead

[grim lotus]

Dw about killing her she's not innocent

She'll get hanged anyway

[latent plover]

Provided you take her to the sheriff ^

[reef hollow]

I saw that because i kicked her when sheriff was walking around me

[grim lotus]

And then what?

[reef hollow]

I did not get bounty

Can I rerive her?

[grim lotus]

You don't get payed anyway

You just inform Malfoy then she gets publicly hanged

About 2 in-game days later

[hushed flare]

I feel like all hangings just happen randomly

I had Elias green hanging what felt like 999 in-game days later

[grim lotus]

Hmm

Maybe it's the next time you enter the town

[orchid plank]

Bruh I can’t find the goddamn Californian horned owl

[hushed flare]

I saw some just sitting on the barn at emerald ranch at night time

I dont know if it's guaranteed

But it's how I found my first owls

[orchid plank]

It’s not that kind

They are exclusively near tumbleweed I’m pretty sure

[latent plover]

I spent hours searching for this one

Found it in the desert somewhere near a small ranch

[orchid plank]

I only need 6 more animals and it’s causing me physical pain

[latent plover]

Yeah that owl was my last

[hushed flare]

what is this online

[latent plover]

But I guess the spawn is random so maybe you’ll find it soon

[hushed flare]

animals are the reason why I'm never gonna get 100%

[latent plover]

Why not?

Anyone can do it so you can too

[orchid plank]

The most painful thing by far is going to be 70 gold missions

[latent plover]

Indeed

You’ll know the script of the mission in some cases

[hushed flare]

I don't have the energy to do it ya know

[orchid plank]

I have 8 😭

[latent plover]

Ah yes haha that’s understandable

[hushed flare]

I've done 5 challenge lists, and first part of duchess and other animals, test of faith, dream catchers, graves, rock carvings

[latent plover]

Nice

Those aren’t so bad since you can follow a guide for their locations

Just takes a long time

[orchid plank]

Duchess and other animals took me 2 whole days of playing

[hushed flare]

I mean fuck animals in rdr2

Jacked up spawns

at least the plants and other stuff don't move

[orchid plank]

Holy shit I got it

Thank god

[latent plover]

[grim lotus]

Noice

[candid walrus]

Sounds epic

[latent plover]

Photo op!

[grizzled pivot]

I wanna get the game and play it again

Maybe when it goes on sale on PlayStation

Being in this chat has made me miss it lmao

[hidden moss]

Lol, till the end of chap 3 I take everything super slow, now that I’m in chap 4 I rush all missions. Can’t wait for that mess to be over😅

Took 4 weeks to get to chap 4 this time, it’s so nice to take it so slow💖

Ye, that’s why I take things slow xD I prefer Arthur from chap 1 to 3, after that I just rush to get to John

[hushed hatch]

Any clue where support is

?

Helps

[hidden moss]

I don’t hate it, I just don’t like it, kieran, lenny & hosea :/

Nah it will😄 whole gang starts to suck after chap 4

Always happy when that’s over

Eh I have uncle & Abigail at the ranch, good enough😄🥲

:o monster

[grizzled pivot]

I didn’t, I got a new console tho

Played it on previous Gen

[hidden moss]

Doesn’t PS save ur purchases on account?

[grizzled pivot]

Went from Xbox to PS

[hidden moss]

Ah ic😄

[grizzled pivot]

How many play throughs has everyone done?

[hidden moss]

4 complete

6 total, tried low honour Arthur

But didn’t like that, so gave those up😄

I’m on my 5th now, full replay

[hidden moss]

Wbu?

[grizzled pivot]

I’ve only done 1 full play through

As soon as I can get the game again I’ll do a full second

There’s so much content in the game my first play through was like 85 hours

[hidden moss]

Haha nice😄

[grizzled pivot]

Like total play time

[hidden moss]

Oooh a week playtime?

[grizzled pivot]

But how many hours?

[hidden moss]

That’s not rushing nope

[grizzled pivot]

Oh wow

[hidden moss]

Nice😄

I’m at the Eagle Flies mission rn, where you steal those documents from the oil fields. This mission reminds me of Assassins Creed so much xD 1 of my favs😄

[grizzled pivot]

Yea it’s my favorite single player experience of all time too

[hidden moss]

Do I have to accept the Mary Linton missions to 100% the game

She's kind of a bitch and I don't wanna help her

[grizzled pivot]

Not sure

[hidden moss]

I accepted and I regret it

I think I hate her more than Micah

[candid walrus]

Sad

[placid inlet]

welp

[hidden moss]

True antagonist of the game is her

[placid inlet]

nah

[candid walrus]

Why

[hidden moss]

Guess she’s played me for a fool as well, I like her😄

[grizzled pivot]

I forget who / what she does

[candid walrus]

She was Arthur's girlfriend (?)

[grizzled pivot]

Oh yes okay

[hidden moss]

Ye

[grizzled pivot]

I thought so

But couldn’t remember for sure

[hidden moss]

She's the bitch that only sends u a letter when she needs something

[grizzled pivot]

HAHA

[hidden moss]

And then constantly nags u throughout ur mission

[candid walrus]

I don't remember her nagging

[hidden moss]

Only happens with clean/underweight Arthur

Like she called Arthur a pompous asshole AFTER I FUCKING AGREED TO HELP HER

Like the audacity

[grizzled pivot]

Yea I remember all that now lmao

Ah man I wanna get back on the game lmao

[hidden moss]

Also she says "oh Arthur" every other fucking sentence

[candid walrus]

What's wrong with that

[hidden moss]

Like comparing her to Micah I think michah is a swell guy

[hidden moss]

After she's said it for the 50th time it gets annoying

[candid walrus]

Understandable

[placid inlet]

oh orthurr

[native willow]

Bruh

Micah is a murdering rapist

[placid inlet]

[hidden moss]

And her dad's a complete fucking asshole who is an hollow shell of a man and whenever u make a light hearted joke she gets all offended

[grizzled pivot]

[native willow]

Manz kills dogs and shit

Mary is just kind of a bitch, but not even wrong

[hidden moss]

Better than Mary Linton

[native willow]

Arthur is an outlaw after all

Nah Chief lmao

[candid walrus]

[native willow]

If you actually like micah, seek help

[hidden moss]

Only when compared to Mary

[hidden moss]

He called me Brother

How can you not like him

[placid inlet]

sob

[native willow]

Pain

[hidden moss]

We killed 2 entire towns together

How can u not feel the bond

[native willow]

[timber elk]

micah's death was the saddest one in rdr2

[placid inlet]

[spiral laurel]

I haven't seen it yet but

I knew he had to die at one point

Since I played RDR1 and he obviously isn't there

[native willow]

His death is hilarious

[spiral laurel]

I don't wanna know much about it

if thats fine

Sorry for being a buzz kill...

Still 2

I'm taking my time

Btw, I love the improved poker in this game

the only issue I have

is that the bets are way too fricken low

like...5 Dollar pay out at max?

you kidding me?

No I mean

if you Win

I could go out, Kill a Deer, and even in bad condition get close enough to 5 Dollars

Poker isn't worth the time for money collecting

but it's still fun

Thats fine with me

I didn't really like Cheating anyways

Well, in this game I wouldn't at least

since the payout is so low it wouldn't be worth it

maybe if we could bet a lot of money

ok maybe

but a lot of the fun for me comes from Playing the game

I love Poker

and I killed chat...

[timber elk]

shoot an old lady, get a semi-auto shotgun

[spiral laurel]

hey btw while on the topic of Money

what's a good way to accumulate money in single player

[timber elk]

just do the missions

[native willow]

Yeah the missions give serious money after a while

[spiral laurel]

Well yeah I know

but I try not to do too many missions

but treasure hunts run out eventually right?

well, I guess I mean a safe way then

what do you mean there is none?

I mean, theres Hunting, Fishing, Camps

I'm just asking whats best

[native willow]

Yeah not massive amounts anyway

[timber elk]

there's some side quests that give you money too

fishing is boring

[native willow]

Fishing/hunting for money sounds boring as fuck

I just loot corpses and sell shit at the fence

And do missions

[timber elk]

you don't really need to grind if you just play the game

since the missions gives you a lot of money

[native willow]

Ya

[spiral laurel]

guess I'll just look around the world then

see if any other opportunities come by

[timber elk]

you're in chapter 2 right

[spiral laurel]

see, I'm just trying to maximize my time in each chapter

[timber elk]

javier has a side mission where you rob some gang hideout

i think that gives you a decent amount for where you are now

yeah

[spiral laurel]

I mean

I do just want to buy some things that I want

clothes, guns

things like that

[timber elk]

you can find really good guns in the world

for where you are rn at least

[spiral laurel]

Alright

[candid turret]

you can get a couple 100 dollars by doing secret robberies

like the valentine doctor

[timber elk]

the valentine doctor has a backroom that you can rob to get a schofield, it's a solid ass gun

[candid turret]

in ch3 you can get a double action revolver with sean

[spiral laurel]

Yeah I'm waiting to get a fence open to get a lock breaker

I wanted to do it

[candid turret]

sean home robbery

[spiral laurel]

I tried

[timber elk]

in ch 2 you can get a lancaster repeater with micah

[carmine mica]

there is another way

[timber elk]

you can rob some old lady's house at watson's cabin and get a semi-auto shotgun

[carmine mica]

go to rhoades

[timber elk]

that thing shreds people

[carmine mica]

go to gun store

dual wield sawed off

[candid turret]

thats creepy af

[timber elk]

pretty sure you can also get a pump action from the homestead that javier robs with you

[spiral laurel]

No like

for the safe

in the back

Theres a safe

[timber elk]

@spiral laurelyou don't need the safe for the schofield

[spiral laurel]

how

[timber elk]

it's a box on the table

[spiral laurel]

No like, I wanted the Fifty from the safe

[timber elk]

loot the box on the table

[spiral laurel]

how do you open it then

I didn't get it

I researched

and it said I needed a lock breaker

[candid turret]

you can also rob the strawberry general store

[timber elk]

he can't buy any good guns rn

we did

[candid turret]

no im sure you can do it with arthur as well

[timber elk]

@spiral laureldid you get the semiauto shotgun yet

[candid turret]

if you havent done it yet

money

so with john it aint worth it

i dont know around a 100

200 maybe

saint denis gunsmith is a worth a look too

[green wave]

i always feel so bad

[timber elk]

i love catching rival gang members and cooking them over a campfire

[candid turret]

same

[timber elk]

or the guys that are camping and they start waving their guns around when you go near them

[candid turret]

gang hideouts are the best

[timber elk]

@candid turret pov: you're a skinner brother and you see john sprinting at you with a lasso

[candid turret]

lmao

[reef hollow]

What is the best bounty target?

Most funny

[timber elk]

@reef hollowthere's this serial killer that you have to find through a puzzle

you find the first piece near valentine under a railroad where there's a torso handing and a head impaled onto a beam witha knife

idk the rest

[reef hollow]

How do I get to the side bussines under doctor’s in valentine?

[stable hornet]

I remember you had to point the feller with a gun and then you should have an option to make him guide you to the door

He should ask one person behind the door to open it

and then good luck, no way to do it sneaky even if you use a bow and you end up with an expensive bounty and a couple of dollars + a schofield revolver

[warped arrow]

I like it when lawmen who are speeding towards you on horses and you kill their horses and they go flying, two bounty hunters where riding towards me(between me and them was a big crevas) and they were about to stop but I was able to kill both of their horses in time and they both got flung into the crevas and fucking died

[stoic narwhal]

stop right there criminal scum

thats animal cruelty

[dire sentinel]

i was driving a train while being chased by the law, and i shot one of the law's horses and they flung in front of the train and yes

[warped arrow]

I hate how the train slows down as you go to kill people while its moving

[dire sentinel]

yeah

in the story, when u kill the driver or smt the train doesnt stop but in free roam its different

[spiral laurel]

Just did the Bear Trap Side Event

Saved the guy, Gave him some Whiskey, and let him keep his stuff

just wanted to help him out

[barren comet]

i blew his head off

im so evil

[wanton cove]

After 3 real life days of camping and baiting and riding from one spawn point to another I finally got that god damn Panther Pelt, gosh I am still shaking bc that thing almost killed me but I am so glad the hunt is finally over. Back to the story

[candid walrus]

Very nice

[barren comet]

whats that for?

[wanton cove]

For the satchel

[barren comet]

nice

[grizzled pivot]

Legendary panther?

[wanton cove]

Using every minute I can as Arthur

[wanton cove]

Ah nope, regular one

[warped arrow]

I suggest throwing a dynamite at it, or using the dynamite arrows and shoot it at the drivers cabin

[grizzled pivot]

Word

[hushed harbor]

i havent found a 3 star opossum in like 3 irl days. when will the pain end.

[hushed harbor]

fucking FINALLY found one

[warped arrow]

Where

[hushed harbor]

out by lone mule stead

[warped arrow]

Ohh

I forgot where the mule sted is

[hushed harbor]

due north of blackwater across the upper montana

[warped arrow]

thanks

[hushed harbor]

arthur gets sent there when captured by the o'driscolls in chp 3, so that should give u an idea

[warped arrow]

I see

[jovial sundial]

am going to have such a "fun time" getting dinosaur bones

[hushed harbor]

i looked them up and it was honestly ezpz

[candid walrus]

Dinosaur bones suck

I hate them with all my being

[jovial sundial]

ik but its annoying riding to diffent places for itte things

*little

[hushed harbor]

i went for all the new austin ones first and went northeast as i went

[candid walrus]

I only have a few more I need to get

But I haven't completed story yet so I can't get them

[shut stone]

Panthers stopped spawning for me i had to quit

[jovial sundial]

how meny dinosaur bones are there

[hushed harbor]

for the outfit, yeah

[jovial sundial]

nvm i found out

[hushed harbor]

you dont get the achievement, no, but u get the outfit for completing all 90 challenges

[candid walrus]

Only 90 challenges for what

^

[wanton cove]

Panthers never spawned for me before as well and I am in Ch6. I just gave it all my free time I had the last days but it really drains you, so I can totally understand you

[candid walrus]

Yeah, they're pretty annoying..

[hushed harbor]

i managed to do them

but i dont think the outfit looks that good

[candid walrus]

I'm stuck on gambler 5

I should probably do the next bandit challenge

[hidden moss]

There is an easy way to spawn a panther

just put bait

in a road

[wanton cove]

You dont know how much bait i wasted and in the end I only found the panther through an ambush.

You dont find pathers. They find you.

[shut stone]

Yep panthers see you yoh dont see them

Getting gritty fish neat is one hassle

Then hoping a panther is in the area is another hassle

Getting in a spot to get a clean shot is an even harder hassle

[candid walrus]

I guess I'm lucky. I kept finding a bunch perfect panthers

[shut stone]

After that its just skin it😅

[wanton cove]

You dont have to find a spot when you are laying on the ground about to get torn apart

[shut stone]

Im terrible at those types of fights

[wanton cove]

I can mostly make it out alive when bears/wolves attack but those sneaky felines just one-snack you

[candid walrus]

I need to kill a bear when it attacks me 17 more times then I get the Grin and Bear it achievement

It's gonna take forever

You let it attack you and then when you're on your back, get your knife out and spam the stab button (I can't remember if I pressed R2 or O) then when it backs off, shoot it with the gun you automatically pull out

That's what I did

[shut stone]

Imma send a vid to media showing my lack of skill against animals maulling me

[candid walrus]

You could also look it up

[shut stone]

Its sending it was funny rewatching it

[red helm]

Which one is that?

[candid walrus]

I can't remember.. Something about dominoes

[red helm]

Beat people without drawing, or some such?

[candid walrus]

I think so

I'll look it up

This is what it is

"Win Three Rounds of Dominoes Without Drawing Any Tiles Against Two or Fewer Opponents"

[red helm]

Okay, yeah, that one was fairly rough, Just need some luck.

Are you having problems actually understanding the game, or is it just being annoying?

[wanton cove]

It already started great with that horse I actually like dogs, seems like they just dont like you boah

[candid walrus]

Both. I mean, I haven't tried it yet, but the dominoes in game is kind of different than what I know how to play

[red helm]

Well, my advice is to try it at the Emerald Ranch, they play the 'Draw' Version there, which in my opinion, is the simplest version, over the 5 and 3's. But, whatever you find easiest.

[candid walrus]

Ok, thank you! I'll try that once I can log on

[red helm]

5's and 3's is usually quicker, though, once you learn the game, better. However.

But, yeah, Draw is easier if you are still learning.

[candid walrus]

Ah, alright

The version I'm used to is the one where you can only play on your own line unless someone has a penny on their line, then you can play on it if you want

idk if there's a name for that kind

[red helm]

Yes, I played a version like that as well. We called it "Train Wreck", but I'm sure there is some other names for it.

[candid walrus]

I'll ask my grandma, maybe she knows

[red helm]

My Family was from Texas, and maybe that's just what they called it around that area. But, don't know.

[candid walrus]

Maybe

[astral bone]

Should I go for more frames or better quality?

[red helm]

You should go for what your gut is telling you is best.

[astral bone]

Guess I'm going to get some taco Bell then

I'm fresh off witcher 3, let's see how rdr 2 stacks

[upper fox]

I prefer better quality over more frames

[upper fox]

Even Gavins Location?!?!?! r* is really on fire damnnnnnn

[orchid plank]

What about the location of the goddamn Tahitian MANGOES

[red helm]

RDR3 is just going to be a Mango Farm Sim.

[hidden moss]

Oof, at the end of chap 4 Arthur was overweight, at the end of chap 5, he’s down to average

Will miss overweight Arthur, man he’s a beast😄

[hushed harbor]

now i need to find a skunk, where are the more common skunk spawn places?

[orchid plank]

Near the abandoned fort by the river in west Elizabeth

Directly south of strawberry and north of beechers hope

[hushed harbor]

fort riggs?

[orchid plank]

I think that’s what its called

I can’t remember it’s name

Yeah fort riggs, just east of that

[red helm]

Night time for Skunks, and yeah Fort Riggs and Riggs train station is good places.

Or Eris Field, south of Emerald Ranch, if you're over in that area.

[red helm]

Did you sneeze while you were typing in your Username?

[orchid plank]

No

Just had a fit on the keyboard

[hushed harbor]

ive seen skunks in the same place ive seen opossums (like southeast of the second "O" in rio bravo)

[red helm]

Definitely, Skunks and Opossums like to hang out in the same spots.

Badgers as well.

[upper fox]

Near the river near the trapper near strawberry there is a skunk spawn

i had a headache trying to make that sentence

[covert osprey]

I have a question

[red helm]

North of Owanjila? Yeap, another good spot. Skunks are in a lot of places, Probably anywhere with lots of trees.

[covert osprey]

In red dead 2 I have the flaxen chestnut Hungarian half bred horse and I've had it the whole game so far I'm only in chapter 2. I was trying to kill the legendary white bison and came across the white Arabian that was there. The Arabian is faster that the Hungarian half bred but the halfbred is a war horse and won't kick you off at the sound of a gunshot. Should I replace my Hungarian halfbred for the Arabian?

Also my halfbred is fully bonded

[orchid plank]

Or have no horse 😎

[red helm]

Depends what you are doing. For stuff like Horse challenges, Arabians are nice. But, if you are doing missions with a lot of fighting, or hunting predators, you may not want the hassle of the Arabian.

[covert osprey]

Like I said I'm only in chapter 2 and I'm trying to do as many side quests as possible and kill all legendary animals

The stats on my halfbred are 5 for both speed and acceleration

And 7/10 for health and 6/10 for stamina

[upper fox]

More legendary animals will be unlocked when you continue playing

[red helm]

Honestly, stats of horses aren't a huge deal. 80% of which horse to use is Looks.

Like, a 2 speed VS a 10 speed, yeah, you'll see a difference, but, a 7 VS a 10... Eh, not really.

[orchid plank]

My horse died because it gave up on life

Just swam into the sea and drowned for no reason

[red helm]

ha... nice.

[covert osprey]

But I also like my current horse but I also want a really fast one and I can't decide.

[red helm]

You have 4 slots in your stables for a reason, switch around for different situations.

[covert osprey]

But then again the Arabian will go nuts at the sign of a predator or gunshot

I also don't really switch horses around. I usually stay with one horse for the entire game.

So what should I do?

[red helm]

Well... flip a coin then.

A white arabian at 4 bond will sale for like $200.

[grizzled pivot]

Legendary animals and fish were my favorite parts of the game

Loved doing that

[orchid plank]

Fishing was tedious

Hunting was better

[hushed harbor]

finding a lot of coyotes and raccoons, but no skunks...

[red helm]

Fishing was the suck, until I learned you can change the reeling in settings.

[grizzled pivot]

Both had their advantages and disadvantages for sure

Did you complete all of them?

[orchid plank]

Yeah

[orchid plank]

I wish I knew that 😫

[red helm]

Yeap, you can change it to just holding down the button. Magnitudes easier.

[orchid plank]

Motherfucker

Why isn’t that the goddamn default

[warped arrow]

man is it worth going for legend of the east aster the epilauge

[red helm]

I get that the spinning thing is realistic, but blah..

[grizzled pivot]

Didn’t know you could do that

[orchid plank]

Why not

[red helm]

It's buried in all those settings.

[warped arrow]

E

[covert osprey]

So I've decided to keep both horses and for right now I'm going to try out the Arabian. It's a good girl. Any name suggestions?

[candid walrus]

Hmm

Aphrodite

She's the goddess of beauty, and the white Arabian is very pretty, soo..

[ember anvil]

bruhhhhh

i got ambushed and my horse died and i couldnt revive it since i also died

[gaunt lintel]

Steven name it Steven

[bronze sundial]

eden

[candid walrus]

That is very sad

[ember anvil]

rip deez

[hushed flare]

[ember anvil]

atleast it was the special edition horse so i can get it back

[timber elk]

i name all my horses Micah Bell

[warped arrow]

Slowly on my way to obtain the legend of the east outfit

[jade saddle]

Hi, I have a question

If I start a new game do I maintain all my completion progress?

[coral pike]

guys i think i encountered a bug

i started a stranger mission and then the cutscene never initiated

and now the dudes are just standing there

[shut stone]

L

[candid walrus]

Interesting

[coral pike]

i posted a pic in #red-dead-media

just did oh, brother

what a strange mission

[candid walrus]

Which one is that again?

[coral pike]

shooting the bottles off the peoples heads

[candid walrus]

Oh, the stranger mission where the two brothers are competing for the girl?

[coral pike]

yeah

[hidden moss]

do i have to kill all the legendary animals for 100%

[coral pike]

bro why all these stranger missions just be sending me somewhere else to do something

this shit is annoying as fuck

maybe i should do a story mission to vary the pace cuz i been doing a lot of stranger missions

[candid walrus]

That's a good idea

[hidden moss]

1. talk to this guy

2. talk to this other guy

3. gunfight or something cool happens

4. done

id prefer it if you could teleport to waypoint again

[coral pike]

i like how stranger missions were done better in gta v

or rdr1

[candid walrus]

I usually do something along the lines of: Continue a stranger mission (Hunting request, Dinosaur Bones, Duchess and Other Animals, etc.) Do some hunting for compendium and trapper, do a story mission, explore, then repeat. Just so I don't get bored

[coral pike]

i havent been doing any of the collectathon stranger missions lol

[candid walrus]

lol

[coral pike]

way 2 lazy for that

i did enjoy the albert mason stranger missions

think those might be my favorite from this game so far

[candid walrus]

I love those

Probably my favorite also

[coral pike]

hes such a nice fellow

[hidden moss]

what about the gunslinger ones

id prefer it if you did it as john in new austin

[candid walrus]

Haven't finished them yet

[coral pike]

i like charles chatiner or however u spell it stranger mission as well

the french art guy

chatenay*

god i love charles chatenay hes so crazy

[coral pike]

omg the area north of annesburg with the waterfalls is so pretty

[upper fox]

jup

[warped arrow]

Yes

Jumo

You will survive because of the wayer

[jovial sundial]

i only need 11 more weapons for the compendium

they are mostly stuff you pick up from side quests and story missons

[coral pike]

i like these marco dragic missions

[spiral laurel]

Ok so I have a question

whats the point of the Mask if your just gonna get a bounty anyways?

like, what Benefit does it even provide?

[candid walrus]

If you wear a mask/bandanna while commiting a crime, the law and/or citizens will take longer to recognize you if you don't have one on. Same goes with outfits. Hence why it's a good idea to wear different outfits when you commit crimes. Of course, this doesn't mean your crimes will be forgotten. They will still be able to recognize you after a while.

[spiral laurel]

Well, if I pay off my Bounty, since mine is very low thanks to the fact that no one saw me commit any murders and I didn't murder any lawmen

Will people still treat me the same?

[covert osprey]

Update, I hated the Arabian because it was getting spooked by a gust of wind.

[candid walrus]

They won't treat you badly, they should be the same if you paid it off.

[covert osprey]

I now have broken the perino Andalusian

It's a good boy and I need a name.

Any suggestions?

[candid walrus]

Hmmmmmmm

Dionysus

or Poseidon

[covert osprey]

Why dionysus

[native willow]

I always give my horses pretty simple names

[covert osprey]

Poseidon would kinda make sense because I found the horse next to brandywine drop

[native willow]

Big Jim

[candid walrus]

I dunno. I just think it's an interesting name. And I feel like Dionysus pairs well with the perlino, but Poseidon is also pretty good as you pointed out

[covert osprey]

Dionysus is the Greek god of vegetation and fruitfulness.

[candid walrus]

Yes

[covert osprey]

So it could make sense too as I found the horse next to brandywine drop where there was a lot of vegetation.

[candid walrus]

Yeah

Either one could work

[covert osprey]

Dionysus it is.

[candid walrus]

Awesome

[covert osprey]

Thank you :)

[candid walrus]

Np ^^ I enjoy naming horses

[green wave]

i literally named my horse “horse”

[candid walrus]

lol

[green wave]

my current horse is named tex

she’s a pretty girl

lived through a lot

i’ve literally let myself die to save her like bro she’s so special to me

[candid walrus]

Which horse is it?

[green wave]

just a basic american standardbred

not the best, but has worked super well for me

[covert osprey]

What about ares since the Andalusian is a war horse

[candid walrus]

Which coat?

[candid walrus]

Oh, yes I quite like that name.

[green wave]

idk the name but it’s just a beige horse with white on it

[candid walrus]

Hmm

[green wave]

i really want a horse like hoseah has

[candid walrus]

The silver Turkoman? Yeah, it's very pretty

[green wave]

idk where to buy one if u can

[candid walrus]

It isn't buyable in story, but in online it is.

[green wave]

ohhhh

can u find them wild?

[candid walrus]

No

[green wave]

danggggg

so you can’t get any of them even with different coats in story?

[candid walrus]

Any of what?

[green wave]

the turkomans

[candid walrus]

I don't think Turkomans are in the wild.

Let me check.

No, they aren't found in the wild.

[green wave]

aw man, that sucks

i don’t rlly play online mode often so i won’t be able to get one either way

[candid walrus]

Sad

[covert osprey]

You can buy the gold Turkoman in chapter four in Saint Denis

[candid walrus]

Mhm

[green wave]

WHAT OKFG THABK YOU SO MUCH

I CANT SOELL

[dire sentinel]

?

[hidden moss]

Come here pretty boy!!!

Micah is right btw

[hushed harbor]

found a 3 star skunk but it despawned because wolves spawned where it was going (at least i assume thats what happened)
are you fucking kidding me

[hushed harbor]

god damnit game stop spawning fucking coyotes and turkeys

[coral pike]

oh boy time for the bank job

banking, an old american art

its been interesting to see how john has grown disillusioned of dutch's grandiose ideas

[barren comet]

“pLaN”

[coral pike]

HOSEA

LENNY

THIS GAME

[hidden moss]

the coward, the killer, that shot Mr. Miller
has laid ol' otis in his grave
YAH

[coral pike]

oh boy im in chapter 5 now

[warped arrow]

How do you execute people where you do something and you pistol whip them and you can either shoot or hit them again

[jovial sundial]

I had a grate experience last night

I went up to big valley To get a owl I needed and I got it but my horse fell down the hill and I had no revices

Revives

I thought I did

I never got that horse downed so I thought I never used my revives

Guess I never had any

😐

[coral pike]

guys i think i have a photo mode addiction

[fringe trellis]

Red dead is so cute

What

Am I wrong?

[barren comet]

what horse?

if it’s the white arabian that’s sad

[long plume]

I've been having this very concurring issue where the bounty mission in Tumbleweed never wants to spawn, I know there is supposed to be an event where the Sherrif of the town shoots a Del lobo but I've never had that spawn yet. Quite literally the last thing I need to finish off all the gangs!

Any help would be appreciated

[barren comet]

re load the save?

[upper fox]

Does Arthur have a wanted poster in the game?

Cuz I didnt remember and I found it in the game files

I posted it in #red-dead-media

[wide pivot]

alright i’m doing horseman challenge 4 in story mode but i never manage to catch anyone with my lasso from horseback, and i don’t know if this is because i’m absolute trash or if it might be some kind of setting. PLEASE help me out

[upper fox]

just lasso a npc and go ride until your goal is reached

[wide pivot]

yeah i know i know but i never manage to catch someone from the horseback

[upper fox]

once you lassoed him just ride away

[hushed harbor]

just get closer lol

[wide pivot]

I GOT ONE YEAH

[upper fox]

nice

[latent plover]

I’ve always thought with these wanted posters in the 1800s, couldn’t you just change your hairstyle and beard and then you wouldn’t be recognised?

[wide pivot]

uh the Bandit challenge is going to be the end of me, ugh all for some nice equipment

[clear swallow]

Does it count as doing a random free mode encounter

If you kill the person

For example Maximo the treasure hunter

[latent plover]

Yeah

Pretty sure it does. I’ve accidentally killed random encounters and tried to reload to the point just before the encounter but the game autosaves straight away. So I guess it counts

[clear swallow]

To get 100% do you have to do all random encounters @latent plover

Or just 25

Im trying to get platinum

[latent plover]

It says in the game pause menu

I think its progress > total completion