#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 383 of 1

spiral laurel
#

I played through RDR

#

And I gotta say, it’s very lack luster at times

#

it needs some sort of improvement

upper fox
#

rdr1 has too short story

#

they have to add exlcusive content for jack

spiral laurel
#

actually, I feel very differently

#

I think the story was too drawn out

#

it felt like you were just herded around the map being forced to do random and sometimes tedious tasks

upper fox
#

idk

spiral laurel
#

No I don’t wanna move cattle, no I don’t wanna use a canon, NO I DON’T WANNA HELP YOU

#

plus, I hated aiming with an Xbox controller, look I’m fine with the controller but if you give me a shooter game give me a mouse man

upper fox
#

rdr1 was made by r* san francisco if i remember correctly

spiral laurel
#

I feel like I’m asking a lot, but at the same time there’s a lot I felt could be fixed

#

It’s still a good game

candid walrus
#

I just hope that it's added to PS4.

upper fox
spiral laurel
#

it just has a lot of little issues that form into one big one

#

like for example, I’m gonna be honest, the stranger missions sorta sucked

#

It barley ran on my Xbox 360

#

of course it is

#

But yeah, strangers in RDR1 sucked for me, a lot of it felt like just a bunch of cut scene triggering

#

With very linear paths to take

#

Or little gameplay

#

are the Strangers in RDR2 better?

candid walrus
#

For sure.

#

YES

#

FINALLY

upper fox
#

nice

candid walrus
#

Only step closer to Legend of the West

spiral laurel
#

But yeah, when I played RDR1, I was just so focused on finishing the story

upper fox
#

i have the cowboy role for too long

spiral laurel
#

I just stopped caring about most other things half way through

#

even without the side tasks it still felt like a slight slog

#

I feel bad for really ripping on RDR1, because I know a lot of people liked it

#

Maybe I’ll like it more after RDR2, but in my experience RDR1 just isn’t a game I really wanna return to, about half way through I just wanted to get it over with and that’s what I did

upper fox
#

some people prefer rdr1 over rdr2

spiral laurel
#

that’s insane

#

all RDR1 made me wanna do is play RDR2

#

doesn’t bother me

#

still doesn’t bother me much

ruby apex
#

sad

spiral laurel
#

it all felt like a bunch of naked land

ruby apex
#

did the game reveal what dutch's grand plan is

spiral laurel
#

yes I did, I saw that it was too big

#

I’m just bothered by RDR1, I wanted to leave it saying I loved it

#

But I just, felt like the game was leading you on with bread crumbs the whole time, giving you constant long rides and everything

#

I can get a cool outfit in many other games, I don’t hate RDR1, but I’m not gonna play it again for a long time

#

I guess because my patience ran thin

#

I just didn’t have as much fun as I thought I would, it felt sorta lack luster

#

I still think it’s a good game

#

it’s just, yeah, age has really slowed it down

#

Coupled with using a controller, the horrible performance on Xbox

#

And old design issues

#

Yeah, it wasn’t exactly fun the whole way through

#

It’s a good game imo

#

And keep in mind

#

This is all my opinion, maybe you’ll enjoy it

#

As for me, I think I just need to sit on it for a while

#

I still think that rockstar did a great job building off of the very loose narrative

#

as it seems to tie very well into RDR2

#

Oh also

#

RDR1 has very exaggerated characters

#

to the point where I’m just asking myself “ok how is this person even able to dress themselves in the morning.”

warped arrow
#

Damn

grim lotus
#

You Racist motherfucker~

#

Yeah I shut my phone down whilst it was sending

#

Earlier

#

Whoops

ruby apex
#

whats the benefit of a repeater if u can just use dead eye with pistol to 1 hit kill

grim lotus
#

Also the Descendants theory

ruby apex
#

also this game has no damage falloff, making rifle redudent, just use repeater or revolver

grim lotus
candid walrus
#

Mhm

grim lotus
#

Obviously Dead Eye renders accuracy useless

#

But still

#

Tf is wrong with you

ruby apex
#

wtf

grim lotus
#

No, why would you kill a dog

ruby apex
#

u r a monster

#

holy

grim lotus
#

So

#

That's fuckin' wrong

ruby apex
#

who would shoot a dog

candid walrus
#

What's worse
Killing a dog, or a horse

grim lotus
#

Would you kill your Horse?

ruby apex
#

we have a monster here

candid walrus
grim lotus
#

Idk in story

candid walrus
grim lotus
#

If it's a Wolf it's different but what did a dog ever do to you

grim lotus
candid walrus
#

Yeah

#

By killing it I meant running it off cliffs

grim lotus
#

Oh, yeah I've done that by mistakes a few times

candid walrus
#

Stuff like that

grim lotus
#

If you did it on purpose something fuckin' wrong with you

#

Wdym

candid walrus
#

Yeah there are quite a few things wrong with me

ruby apex
#

whats the diference of the effect of new and opened bourbon

grim lotus
#

You did?

LMAO

grim lotus
candid walrus
#

Yeah

grim lotus
#

That's such bull lmao

ruby apex
grim lotus
#

🎵 I'm falling flying through the air🎵

grim lotus
#

I love how Arhur (and John I think)

#

Just

candid walrus
grim lotus
#

Completely waste your money with Cigs and Drink

#

You literally spent a $ on a bottle and he takes one swig

#

And then proceeds to YEET the 95% full bottle to the floor

#

Seriously? I never knew that

#

It's a ✨miracle✨

candid walrus
#

Have any of you ever become a fireball

grim lotus
#

Once or twice~

#

OH YOU MEANT IN RDR2

candid walrus
#

lol

grim lotus
#

No I try to avoid it

#

NO

candid walrus
#

I'm not sure if it works in story but I want to try now

grim lotus
#

WTF

#

STOP

#

Arthur's scream as he falls is fuckin' hilarious

#

Roger Clark didn't have to put so much effort into it

#

But he did

#

And it sounds amazing

#

FUCK OFF

#

Stop it

#

Please

#

It's not funni

#

What you get up to in game is up to you

#

But plz don't make me suffer

candid walrus
#

Yes, it's hilarious when he does that lol

ruby apex
#

is dead eye the unique skill of authur in the gang?

#

what skill does hosea, dutch have other than intelligence

#

stfu

#

rude

#

is rare block rifle good

#

no u

candid walrus
#

Yes

ruby apex
warped arrow
#

you cant go to a gun shop and eddit that rare gun

ruby apex
warped arrow
#

and its a bit more powerful

candid walrus
ruby apex
#

btw are the cigarette cards real?

#

who collect those anyway

candid walrus
#

Wdym?

ruby apex
candid walrus
#

Yeah

ruby apex
#

but its a lot of em

ruby apex
candid walrus
#

Hmm. Maybe. I'm not sure

ruby apex
#

i think ppl wont collect em

#

it sucks, so many cards

#

what do i get for collecting em

warped arrow
#

how much

candid walrus
#

Money and items

warped arrow
#

how much monmey

#

can you get the cards by smoking them

candid walrus
#

You can get the cards by buying them then discarding them

warped arrow
#

what

#

why discarding them

candid walrus
#

It's quicker

ruby apex
#

when do u lose the deputy job in rdr2

#

do they find out u r outlaw eventully?

#

chap 3 or 4

candid walrus
#

Probably once Chapter 3 ends

ruby apex
#

okay

#

dutch was trying to be the good guy joining the lawmen and it doesnt worked in the end lol

candid walrus
#

He wasn't really trying to be a good guy. It was more to earn their trust and then to backstab them. Since they were trying to play both families

ruby apex
candid walrus
#

Yeah

ruby apex
#

since they could have researched about the background of dutch and other

warped arrow
#

sort of

candid walrus
#

Mhm

#

That's how Chapter 3 ended. They got found out

warped arrow
#

how many stranger missions are in single player

ruby apex
#

also i want to know does anyone in the gang also know howt o use dead eye or it is just an innate skill of authur only?

candid walrus
#

Probably just a skill for Arthur only. Although it's really only a gameplay mechanic, not a super power or something.

ruby apex
candid walrus
#

Ah

hidden moss
ruby apex
#

hes smart like hosea, i think other cant plan that well and manipulate ppl

candid walrus
hidden moss
#

I got lumbago

#

Feels the same imo

#

Oh yh

ruby apex
#

impossible, authur is older and should be more skilled

#

Beware of an old man in a profession where men usually die young

hidden moss
#

Dutch 🐍

#

I like johns run

#

He runs like he shit himself

ruby apex
#

i hate this game missions, always have to move with the gang

#

they are so slow af

hidden moss
warped arrow
#

the marking of the targets has a different soundc

ruby apex
#

yup

warped arrow
#

s

ruby apex
#

damnit

#

cant control myself in mission that need to act normally

warped arrow
#

i like replaying missions and then having 2 or one powerful gun and a whole aresenal to mess around with

hidden moss
#

I disagree

ruby apex
#

i shot a few shots and the mission fails

warped arrow
#

i've been slaughtering people with cheats as i dont have anything to do

hidden moss
#

Yes but your telling me you would rather play as John

#

Very strange

warped arrow
#

I like both of them

hidden moss
#

It’s called an opinion dummy fuck

#

My opinion on your opinion is strange

#

Why in the fuck is my name yellow

warped arrow
#

lol

#

what role did you have before

candid walrus
#

You're a cattle rustler

hidden moss
#

Most people prefer Arthur to John

hidden moss
warped arrow
#

probs because of the playstation role

hidden moss
#

Yh

warped arrow
#

i like john a bit more

hidden moss
#

Maybe

hidden moss
warped arrow
#

hes got different voice ques for talking to horses

#

i think

hidden moss
#

Didn’t like him in rdr 2

spiral laurel
#

Fun fact

#

Jack Marston has been voiced by Three different Actors, one of them being a Female Actress

hidden moss
#

I had to go around greeting people to get food honour to get the good ending

warped arrow
#

dang

spiral laurel
#

just thought it was cool for people to find out

hidden moss
warped arrow
#

what was the good ending

hidden moss
#

Him dying with the sunset

warped arrow
#

i had the low honor one because i killed random people that walked past me

hidden moss
#

Bad ending Micah shoots him

warped arrow
#

oh\

#

oh well

#

live by the gun die by the gun

#

theres a netural honor ending???

candid walrus
#

I'm not sure

warped arrow
#

i chose to help john but i still got bad ending

#

lol

candid walrus
#

lol

warped arrow
#

might be because my honor was way down there

#

lol

keen birchBOT
barren dagger
#

john

ruby apex
#

when do i get litchfield

#

man i hate micah so much

warped arrow
#

i like micha

#

micah

ruby apex
#

which gang is largest/most powerful in rdr universe

candid walrus
#

Probably the O'Driscolls

#

Size wise

ruby apex
candid walrus
#

I have no idea honestly. But it's quite a lot

ruby apex
#

when u do clean ur gun btw?

candid walrus
#

When do i clean it as in how often, or...?

ruby apex
candid walrus
#

I clean it when it'd about halfway empty

#

Or before missions if it's low

warped arrow
#

what do i do since i've finished the story stuff for single player

somber trellis
#

can you get riid of guns?

warped arrow
#

no

candid walrus
#

Blow up everyone

warped arrow
#

it got really boring

#

i even go to areas and start stealth killing for fun

candid walrus
#

Blow up animals then

#

Or

#

hmm

warped arrow
#

pain

ruby apex
#

i wish there is a sniping mission

candid walrus
#

There is

warped arrow
#

i once went to that place with the mining area and theres a huge tower you can climb and i got a 1.5k bounty by sniping everyone including horses from it

#

i also figured out npcs can die from falling

candid walrus
#

Sounds fun

#

Where is it at?

warped arrow
#

yk the uh

#

the town up north from van horn

#

that one town

candid walrus
#

Annesburg?

warped arrow
#

yeah

#

its a big wooden tower near those mining builkdings

candid walrus
#

I'll have to head over there

ruby apex
#

damn

#

got captured by colm

#

am i going to die

warped arrow
#

yes

ruby apex
#

is this the bad ending

candid walrus
#

no

warped arrow
#

yes, now keep playing

#

lol

candid walrus
#

You still got a ways to go

cobalt mantle
#

I'm replaying rdr2 again

warped arrow
#

im to lazy to replay it

#

apparebtky there are 26 stranger quests

cobalt mantle
#

big game

warped arrow
#

kinda

#

well it is

#

it just gets boring once you have no quests and you have to actually search for them

#

i like finding ones where some guy gets robbed in blackwater, as you can just walk up to the guy and shoot him in the head lol

#

how many gold bars are there in single player

ruby apex
#

THIS GAME IS SO LONG

#

I HAVE BEEN PLAYING FOR SO MANY DAYS AND THE STORY IS ONLY AROUND 40%

warped arrow
#

same

#

it took me 4 weeks

#

well

#

2

#

i think

#

why cant there be more clothes in single player than in multiplayer

#

i call bs

#

:/

worldly turret
#

rushing through story still took me about 4-5 days, it's a long story especially chapter 6

warped arrow
#

dang

ruby apex
#

WHY CANT I SHAVE IN CAMP

warped arrow
#

so you can shave

#

oh

ruby apex
#

cant find the shaving place

worldly turret
#

also i assume there's more clothes online than story because Arthur is probably picky and because it's just a normal thing for games to have more clothes for online than story

warped arrow
#

near your bed

warped arrow
worldly turret
#

story characters are picky with what they were, online would have more diversity

warped arrow
#

i see

ruby apex
#

how long can the facial hair be

warped arrow
#

long

candid walrus
#

The max is level 10 length

stuck plaza
#

Need a mod for 20 length

#

Someone make it

warped arrow
#

no

wide pivot
#

hey hey is it worth buying that fast horse at Strawberry? unlocked chapter 3. it’s ugly but it’s fast, help me out

warped arrow
#

being fast is usless

#

if it looks good get it

#

to you

#

idk its your decision

#

i just stuck with that tenese walker horse

wide pivot
#

lmao same

late wigeon
#

I have a feeling that using dead eye to shoot 15 shots into the head of a legendary animal probably isn't the most accepted way of hunting but it'll do ¯_(ツ)_/¯

sand harbor
#

its one method i guess

ruby apex
#

wtf

#

sean just died suderly

#

does gang member start to die from chap 3?

sand harbor
#

oh no

#

yep

#

sean is the the only chap 3 death

#

trust me, chap 4 is even worse

warped arrow
#

fr

ruby apex
#

woah

#

damn

#

the gang has been lucky in the first few chap

warped arrow
#

all because dutch has a god damn plan

ruby apex
#

also i forgot to loot so many greys before progressing in the mission

warped arrow
#

yes

#

sssssss

ruby apex
#

is looting worth it? now have 5k cash and i dont know what to buy

sand harbor
#

what im planning is just leaving micah in the cell in chap 2

#

fuck micah

warped arrow
ruby apex
warped arrow
#

and dont get the money back

sand harbor
ruby apex
warped arrow
#

same

#

i like to save money though

#

even though i spent hundreds of dollars just for some tonics

ruby apex
sand harbor
#

i legit went crazy with buying shit

ruby apex
#

the sean death is so sudden

sand harbor
#

its the saddest

ruby apex
#

before chap 3 no one in gang dies

sand harbor
#

imo

#

well

#

in chap 1 it is revealed that davey and jenny die and in chap 2 it is revealed that mac dies

warped arrow
#

because it acts as like a second health bar

#

and once that gets depelted it goes to your regular white healtj

ruby apex
#

sad godfather vibes, everyone around authur dies one by one

sand harbor
#

well

ruby apex
#

like michael corleone

sand harbor
#

except charles, sadie, john

#

who tf is michael

ruby apex
sand harbor
#

o

ruby apex
#

if u dont know godfather then we dont talk anymore

sand harbor
#

i dont rlly go into godfather

warped arrow
#

i kn ow what a godfather is

#

you got the regular

sand harbor
#

also

warped arrow
#

and then you got the mafia esc

ruby apex
#

jk

sand harbor
#

that fucking white cougar side mission

warped arrow
#

?

ruby apex
#

no its a movie

warped arrow
#

where white cougar\

sand harbor
#

its a debt collection mission with some feller who gets fucked decked by that white cougar in the cave

ruby apex
#

which chap hosea and lenny die

sand harbor
#

4

#

end of chap 4

late wigeon
#

what about that mission?

sand harbor
#

in the saint denis bank robbery failure

ruby apex
#

sad\

sand harbor
#

the cougar mission is fucking scary

#

i shat myself

ruby apex
#

i think hosea is the smartest in the gang

sand harbor
#

it fucking came OUT OF NOWHERE

late wigeon
#

lol

sand harbor
#

if hosea didnt go, nor would the gang

delicate sparrow
sand harbor
#

fucking love hosea

candid walrus
sand harbor
worldly turret
#

HoseaBank.gif

sand harbor
#

srsly has anyone here done that white cougar side mission

#

okay

late wigeon
#

I have yeah

#

I didn't find it scary idk

sand harbor
#

it jumped at me

#

i'll never do that mission in 1st person again

candid walrus
#

I did it

#

I tried using photo mode to find the cougar cowboykekw

sand harbor
#

the balls on this man/woman

warped arrow
#

what

#

whawt cougar

candid walrus
#

The white one

ruby apex
#

man

#

dutch is savage af

#

almost wiped the braithwhite family out and didnt spare the women sons

candid walrus
#

Mhm

#

That's probably Dutch's best mission

#

Anyone have some tips for gambler 4

#

I've been stuck on this one for ages

sand harbor
#

gambler 4?

candid walrus
#

Yeah

ruby apex
#

so is grey or braithwhite more powerful?

upper fox
#

just keep playing until a opponent gives up

candid walrus
#

Alright

#

I did know that

#

I'm just not good at poker

sand harbor
#

oh yeah should probably mention the braithwaites losing catherine

warped arrow
upper fox
candid walrus
upper fox
#

damn

candid walrus
warped arrow
ruby apex
warped arrow
#

Im stuck on the double down and win 5 times for blackjack

upper fox
#

I did all gambler challenges and yet i still dont know how poker or blackjack works

candid walrus
#

I'm having my mom's boyfriend teach me how to play. lol.

sand harbor
ruby apex
#

also lemonye are they good ppl

#

the leader shot himself in the mission

sand harbor
#

its the only area where you can come across the night folk and kkk

#

its def the most racist state

ruby apex
#

what

warped arrow
#

Never ran int9 tbe night folk yet lol

ruby apex
#

lol

sand harbor
#

same

warped arrow
#

And im in the epulague

sand harbor
#

i just stay away from the marshes

#

and you heard me right

warped arrow
#

I litterwlly ride through them

sand harbor
#

the KKK is in lemonye

#

oops its spelled lemoyne

ruby apex
#

is the gang declining from chap 4

#

also when is the peak of the gang

candid walrus
#

I would say before the Blackwater Massacre

sand harbor
#

hmmm

candid walrus
#

But play wise, probably Chapter 2

sand harbor
#

the gang does peak in chap 2

#

after saving sean

#

also the gang declines somewhere in chap 4 maybe even chap 3

#

but the rapid downward spiral happens after the saint denis bank robbery

#

with john being captured and hosea and lenny being dieded

candid walrus
#

Mhm

sand harbor
#

and also Bill, Micah, Javier, Arthur and Dutch being seperated from the remains of the gang for all of chap 5 basically

#

basically having Sadie and Charles as the only good armed ones remaining

ruby apex
#

sad

candid walrus
#

HAHA

#

YES

#

FINALLY

#

Now on to Valentine

sand harbor
#

btw

#

nvm

ruby apex
#

how do i get litchfield asap

#

already in saint denis

ruby apex
#

this game has so many cutscene

#

wtf

#

just jump into the action already

serene rivet
#

are we gonna be jack in rdr3? :o

candid walrus
#

I doubt there will be a RDR3, not gonna lie

#

The story is pretty much done

serene rivet
#

well.. if it makes money, theyll make it

candid walrus
#

Maybe

serene rivet
#

or maybe a remastered rdr1

candid walrus
#

I would rather have that than a part 3 ngl

#

I at least want it on PS4, remastered or not

serene rivet
#

tbh i just want a good, long game

#

like rdr2, idk what ill play after i finish it 8321_pepecry

queen arch
#

rdr3 is definitely possible, they can just make a brand new story with jack as the lead, pretty sure it'll come out after many years doe

#

or after they finish milking gta online

candid walrus
#

But if Jack was the lead... What would they do? It would just turn into a WW1 game

queen arch
#

Rockstar got extremely talented writers, if rdr3 existed pretty sure they can come up with something interesting, who knows

#

However what I would love right now is for rockstar to make a rdr1 PC port, I have no idea why the game isn't released on PC yet

candid walrus
#

I wish they would add RDR1 to all the platforms. I don't own a PS3 or an Xbox 360 so I can't play it

queen arch
#

Barely anyone got a PS3 or an Xbox 360, these consoles were made like 14 years ago

candid walrus
#

Mhm

serene rivet
#

i mean..

#

i got both lol

queen arch
#

I actually got a Ps3, but shit's so old and broken, keeps shutting itself off, I tried fixing it many many times but it just keeps breaking Spongino

#

my cousin also got an xbox 360, but same case, too old and broken

serene rivet
#

mines are good to use

queen arch
#

Lucky goaWAAAH

serene rivet
#

also got a ps4 but i dont play on consoles tbh.. my wrists hurt, i rather play on my pc

red helm
#

I'm going to hook up my PS3 at some point and try to play RDR1. Hoping it'll be okay.

#

Trying to finish the Witcher 3 expansions, and also my second play through of this, first though...

#

Don't you need to hold down the button to sale? That's the suck.

serene rivet
#

u can go tame her again

#

how so

red helm
#

Sounds like a crappy glitch. Use the Clemen's brother's. You get better prices to sale to them, anyway. and Shouldn't have a problem with double selling.

#

Kind of hard to go back and tame + Rebond up a horse again.

#

Turko's don't spook very easily. Black arabian should have better stats than a White

queen arch
#

Oh btw, there's a stranger mission i'm doing that's supposed to have like 4 encounters, I did the first 2 but the 3rd one is refusing to show up, I slept like 3000 times, and I made sure wither or not it shows up during the day or during the night, I've been trying to make it appear for more than a week and i'm losing my mind

red helm
queen arch
red helm
#

I mean, all horses are like 80% your preference with looks. But, if one cares about stats, more is more.

red helm
queen arch
#

ohh

#

yeah i am

red helm
#

Get it up to like -60% and see if it shows up?

queen arch
#

Kk

red helm
#

I know that Hamish wasn't showing up with -100%. and I -think- Charlotte wasn't either.

candid walrus
#

FINALLY

#

Busted out an opponent in Valentine

#

On to St. Denis

dim adder
#

I feel like taking one of the murfree brood to a sherriff's office, even though I'm expecting to get accused of kidnapping at some point.

candid walrus
#

"Oh, so you brought in a crazy cannibal that regularly kidnaps people and deserves to die? Kidnapper!"

dim adder
#

(and was presently engaged in said cannibalism)

candid walrus
#

lol

dim adder
#

yup... witness

#

I guess if the law don't wanna do what the law's meant to do, then the law has to get done some other way...

#

$10 bounty because I didn't have my face covered

candid walrus
#

Geez

#

I'm just not really good at it

dim adder
#

oh, ooops... mister murfee took a tumble down a steep cliff. He seems to no longer be fighting against the ropes.

red helm
#

Aww, that's a crying shame.

dim adder
#

the cave hermit?

red helm
#

I almost ran over Nigel last night in Blackwater..

candid walrus
#

Yikes

red helm
#

and considering the last time I saw Nigel, I hogtied him and robbed him(For the note). That would've been pretty funny to trample him...

dim adder
#

cripes... I have apparently memorized the location/appearance of a large number of plants.

#

woah....

#

I was trying to see what type of horse I was looking at with binos, but the horse was too far away. I took out the rifle and Study came up as an option. I have horsemanship 10, but this is a breed I haven't studied yet and it's too far away for me to study/ride/tame/anything.

red helm
#

Interesting.

dim adder
#

whew!

#

That was the MOST stressful taming ever.

red helm
#

Which breed was it?

dim adder
#

Andalusian/Perlino

red helm
#

Oh nice. Was it just because it was next to the ledges of the Waterfall areas?

dim adder
#

I /think/ this is the spot on the cliff where the corrupt sheriff got shot.

#

yeah

red helm
#

Calloway Gunslinger side mission. Yeap. That's the only place that horse appears.

dim adder
#

It kept retreating further and further into the narrower and narrower area and kept trying to run off the edge when we were riding it out.

#

and I just ran into it while I was roaming around. neat 😄

red helm
#

Very nice. Also where a Moose can spawn.

dim adder
#

I may not have found a robin, perfect bull elk, or anything else in a million years, but at least I found this.

red helm
#

If you go due south along the river, you'll see a bunch of rocks with birds on them. Robins can spawn on those.

dim adder
#

I seem to have lost the horse. :/

#

A cougar attacked, I got bucked off, and now I can't find it (or tracks)

red helm
#

D'oh. Bad kitty!

dim adder
#

What action is "analog stick up and down"?

red helm
#

And yes, this is also a good spot for cougar's...

dim adder
#

ah, my own horses don't leave tracks... I eventually found it. 🙂

#

I think I'm going to have to give up the white arabian to keep this fella; return him to the wild to be retrieved at a later date.

#

now I'm feeling lucky and I want to try for those robins 😄

west mulch
#

I bought like a bandana but its not in my horse

#

I bought it in like the tapper

dim adder
#

I'm kinda tempted to go ahead and sell Rachel too. She's not a particularly good horse and I only keep her because she's the end-of-the-game horse.

west mulch
#

It says they are stored in horse but they aren't

dim adder
#

clothing locker?

#

heh... "Female Fertility Statue" ... "You can't carry any more of this item."
I have a funny feeling that, if I sell the one I have, this one will also disappear.

red helm
# west mulch I bought like a bandana but its not in my horse

I'm not sure there are Bandana's at the Trapper. Well, if you don't see it in the Hat's on the horse Wheel. You can go to either the Camp and check your Clothing Wardrobe There, Or if you are John you can go to Beecher's Hope, in the Bathroom is the Wardrobe. Or just go to a Hotel.

dim adder
#

OMG!

#

I went back to the same place that this horse was and there it was! A bull moose!!!

#

(only two stars, but hey... closer than I've been)

red helm
#

There are some Fancy Vest's at the Tailor. You can add pocket watchs to it.

red helm
warped arrow
red helm
dim adder
#

I can't scare it away and then hope I bait a better one with potent herbivore bait, can I?

warped arrow
#

Thats cool

#

Idk

red helm
red helm
dim adder
#

oh... I didn't realize the trinket was that strong. I thought it only worked on pelts you knocked down from 3

#

well then... I'll take the shot

red helm
#

I've had it make it one better before. Just make sure you one-shot it.

dim adder
#

I didn't one-shot it... how?!

red helm
#

Foo!

#

Did you use a good bullet?

dim adder
#

I had all the time in the world to make an absolutely perfect shot with springfield/express

red helm
#

Darn then...

dim adder
#

that was right smack dab in the middle of the red
I feel robbed

red helm
#

Yeah, that should've done it. Cheated.

dim adder
#

Is the trinket just a random star increaser?

red helm
#

I'm actually not 100%, I haven't actually cared about pocket watches, and I may just be thinking of the trinket's now.

#

Okay then. That's to bad.

#

There are a whole bunch of fancy clothes at the Tailor's (Ties and such), so, if one was to make their own Rich Dude outfit, it would be lame to not have a pocket watch included.

upper fox
#

There are missable trinkets so beaware of that

#

it isnt needed for 100%

#

In that mission with rains falls where his shit got stolen by the us army

#

rain falls asks arthur not to kill anyone

#

if arthur doesnt kill anyone he gets a trinket

#

if arthur does kill arthur doesnt get the trinket

#

the trinket adds 15% stamina, dead eye and health

#

specially great for arthur

hushed flare
#

I think it's like 15%

upper fox
#

oh yeah ur right

hushed flare
#

15% slower drain speed

upper fox
#

still great for arthur

hushed flare
#

Why not for john

#

John has no tb

upper fox
#

tb drains cores way faster

hushed flare
#

and that's supposed to helppepw

upper fox
#

15% isnt much, but it helps

hushed flare
#

Well it's alot

#

probably best trinket in the game

#

boar and buck trinket could be second

upper fox
#

I collected all equipment ingame but yet idk what all trinkets do

#

lmao

hushed flare
#

they just give you boosts

upper fox
#

i know that

#

but what individually trinket does

#

idk for every trinket i have what they all do

dim adder
#

buck is hands down my favorite

hushed flare
#

I think you can use kit in satchel

upper fox
#

i only knew the owl feather trinket

hushed flare
#

And you can see trinkets

#

I think trinkets and talismans are somewhwre in compendium but me can't find

upper fox
#

its under equipment

#

i have full completed compendium i have no life

hushed flare
#

yeah mr <@&540280464066215977>kekw

#

now we need gold rushpepega

upper fox
#

im too lazy for that.

hushed flare
#

"rare shotgun"

upper fox
#

john is also a reskin

#

lmao

hushed flare
#

his hair is a reskin

upper fox
#

body too

hushed flare
#

Arthur's hair but blackpepw

upper fox
#

facial expressions too

hushed flare
upper fox
#

i once tried to recreate johns iconic pose of rdr1 cover and all i could see was arthur's facial expressions

somber trellis
#

After a train stops at a city or a town, how long does it take for it to get moving again?

hushed flare
#

Yeah because John doesn't go COUGH COUGH COUGH

upper fox
#

rdr2 cutscenes for example is the same for arthur and john, same movement and same dialogue. John is literally a arthur reskin

hushed flare
#

I mean what are they gonna do

upper fox
#

nothing

#

r* doesnt give a fuck

hushed flare
#

not like people are gonna, finish noblest of men and a women as john

#

jkk

upper fox
#

Puking animations for john and arthur are the same

hushed flare
#

wtf now we need puke animation changes when some dumbass player eats a oleander sage now

upper fox
#

they didnt bother to make every animation twice.

hushed flare
#

Ok but John's puking sound is weird

#

Exactly

#

I guess they didn't expect some dumbass to eat oleander sage 7 years laterpeeposhrug

upper fox
#

all i'm saying is that john is arthur in everyway.

hushed flare
#

also I don't think John sais sorry to his horse when the horse runs into a wagon and shot in the foot by the lawman he just sais "wElL doNe bOI"

grim lotus
#

2

somber trellis
#

how long does it take for a train to pull away from a station ?

grim lotus
#

6 foot 2

#

John is around 5"9 or 10

somber trellis
#

ok

grim lotus
#

Actually wait no I think he's shorter than that

keen birchBOT
hushed flare
#

Gaius bad

#

lol

#

chapter 2 is overrated

dim adder
#

I have...

hushed flare
#

Bruh

dim adder
#

Depending on where you're at, you might be preventing it from leaving.

hushed flare
#

if you sit in the train it won't move I think

dim adder
#

in front of the train and near the tracks can also keep it from leaving

somber trellis
#

can you only rob the secret poker room once?

upper fox
#

yes

somber trellis
#

aw

candid walrus
#

Finally finished gambler 4

dim adder
#

wait... isn't that the one where you just need to bet max every time?

#

yup, that's the one

#

(and remember you can walk away before the end of the hand...)

candid walrus
#

Ah

grim lotus
somber trellis
#

yeah, theres more than 1?

upper fox
#

no

grim lotus
#

No, I thought you might be talking about something in RDR1 cuz I haven't played it

upper fox
#

well other secrets room but not poker

grim lotus
#

That's all I've found so far lmao

upper fox
#

Moonshine business strawberry

spiral laurel
upper fox
#

Room in valanetine at the doctor

somber trellis
#

and why tf does the damn train take so long to get away from the station

dim adder
#

My favorite gambler challenges are the dominoes ones. The hardest of those is not drawing any tiles, but that's not /that/ difficult.

grim lotus
grim lotus
candid walrus
spiral laurel
#

So, I haven’t gotten far into RDR2 yet

#

But I gotta say, I was floored when I found out actual stage acts are in the game

grim lotus
#

IKR

spiral laurel
#

Since you don’t just watch them, you can also take part and even sabotage them

#

it’s so cool

dim adder
grim lotus
#

THE GUY WHO COULD CATCH A GENUINE BULLET IN HIS MOUTH

#

IN SAINT DENIS

spiral laurel
#

That’s the only one I watched

#

I loved it man

dim adder
#

The game provides a pretty helpful guide to winning the games

spiral laurel
#

it was like a real act

grim lotus
#

I WAS HAVING A PANIC ATTACK TRYING NOT TO SHOOT HIM ON THE NOSE OR CHIN/NECK

candid walrus
#

I want to watch that show and not shoot him in the mouth to see if he dies

spiral laurel
#

I actually was in complete awe at the act, I felt like I was in a real show

grim lotus
spiral laurel
#

I know it’s all a video game, but man it’s so immersive

grim lotus
#

"Call you on my tElEpHonE" I wanted to commit sexist homicide

spiral laurel
#

I can’t believe I actually felt amazed by the events of a video games play, but it was awesome

grim lotus
#

"The Pip Boy is awesome"

Ok but does fallout have 213 animal & fish species?

upper fox
#

its a cool feature

grim lotus
#

For tracking and Shooting?

upper fox
#

yes

grim lotus
#

No

#

Not without mods

grim lotus
#

Oh well

grim lotus
upper fox
#

we have atleast 3 tho

grim lotus
#

But is that Two Hundred and 13?

I swear there's five different species of snake

Of fuckin snakes

Depending on the environment they're in

Who puts that much effort into a videogame besides R*?

upper fox
#

if i add the number 210

#

yes

grim lotus
#

But that's 210 animals that don't exist

#

So ha

upper fox
#

im desperate for more rdr2 content

#

rp?

grim lotus
upper fox
#

except messing around, but that quickly turns boring

grim lotus
upper fox
#

yes

grim lotus
#

And 100%?

upper fox
#

yes

grim lotus
#

Wow

#

Yeah I can see how that would get boring pretty quickly

#

Kinda same but I wanna pace myself at the same time

grim lotus
# upper fox yes

Did it feel like a grind or was it fun? I don't want to get bored and quit one of my favourite games

upper fox
#

It was fun

#

When I was at 98% completion I was like I WANT MORE

#

So I decided to do the entire compendium

grim lotus
#

That's fair enough

#

It annoys me that they don't give hints at all as to what's missing form the compendium

upper fox
#

I just used youtube

grim lotus
#

Fair enough

upper fox
#

for example "rdr2 equipment compendium" then you find people scrolling through the compendium

grim lotus
#

It would be kinda awesome if there was some thing if you've passed a certain animal and Arthur mutters under his breath "wonder if I got that one written down?"

#

Just like John occasionally sings if you use the Alcohol in your satchel and get drunk whilst riding a horse

upper fox
#

I could go for gold rush achievement, but thats like playing the entire story again. Ikd if i wanna do that.

grim lotus
#

70 Story Missions with Gold?

upper fox
#

yeah

#

gold medals

grim lotus
#

I attempted to do that but on the second mission when you rescue John it's so fucking difficult to clear it with 0 damage

upper fox
#

Some are harder then others

#

There are missions that say complete within 5 or 6 min

grim lotus
#

Those are stupidly annoying

upper fox
#

They require to complete within a certain time

#

YEs

#

My aim also sucks and not having dead eye on the first few missions sucks

grim lotus
#

You don't?

dim adder
grim lotus
#

That's bullshit

upper fox
#

Dead Eye becomes available in the mission of raiding the o driscoll camp that old mining camp

upper fox
grim lotus
#

Did you not save at all?

dim adder
upper fox
#

I completed the entire game and the cold weather bug is still here

upper fox
upper fox
grim lotus
#

That sucks man

dim adder
#

I had to give a feather to charles to get the last item request, which required being able to complete chores for the day; I couldn't complete chores because the pitchfork wouldn't show up. Because I didn't do the granger mission before building the barn, the pitchfork that blew up was apparently /also/ the one used at the barn.

upper fox
#

everyone has

grim lotus
#

What was the nature of the bug

dim adder
#

No pitchfork -> no finishing chores -> no charles -> no item request fulfillment.

upper fox
#

Item requests arent required for 100% its optional

#

?

grim lotus
upper fox
dim adder
#

I don't keep one save per week...

upper fox
#

I save multiple times a day

grim lotus
dim adder
#

nor was I aware of the bug until weeks after triggering it

#

It /is/ complete progress blocking

upper fox
#

And I keep multiple saves of certain points of the game so I could easily go back to any chapter I want

grim lotus
grim lotus
dim adder
grim lotus
#

How?

upper fox
#

On pc that isnt a problem

#

enough storage

dim adder
#

I tend to keep major checkpoint saves, weekly saves, and then a few throughout gameplay

dim adder
upper fox
#

I didnt do that item request cause I couldnt trigger the request

dim adder
#

I play with autosave disabled

upper fox
#

I play with it enabled, cause my pc often crashes

#

Also I have this weird bug that all textures become extremely blurry and the game doesnt respond anymore

#

So for auto save to save for me is nice

dim adder
#

At this point, I basically play with four saves; one is updated 1x/{m,w,d}, and another any time I get a perfect pelt.

#

I also have a few older than that... just in case I run into yet another weird bug that requires me to go back weeks/months worth of gameplay to get around. 😠

upper fox
#

I save a lot too, cause sometimes I save and then I instantly I forgot I saved so then I save again

dim adder
#

It's annoying that the default response to blocking bugs is, "go to an older save."

#

that pretty much sums up why I won't buy a second rockstar game

candid walrus
#

Dang. Just got the camp encounter where Karen slaps Molly. LOL

candid walrus
#

Huh... I just checked the cigarette card quest thing and it hasn't shown I've completed it. I got every single card, sent them in, got the rewards, etc. But I just checked and it's saying I never sent the cards to the guy. Interesting..

dim adder
#

I had that. Sometimes just getting another card triggers re-completion.

candid walrus
#

That makes sense. I picked up some premium cigarettes and got a card. Does it still count as completed or did I screw everything up?

spiral laurel
#

So I wanna ask a few questions about how RDR2 works

random plover
#

Swag

spiral laurel
#

Since I’m fairly new and I don’t wanna let my gang down nor do I want little Jack to get hurt

#

So, food, how does it work for the gang

candid walrus
#

The gang won't die if you don't bring them food

#

But i think it just kind of.... Boosts their morale? Idk

dim adder
#

"or screw everything up?" doesn't quite track with me. Worst case, you lost that particular task and need to re-do it.

spiral laurel
#

I know they won’t die

#

But what I mean is just generally caring for the Van der lin gang as a whole

#

what’s important to know

candid walrus
#

Just give them food often and restock the ammo + medicine tents then you'll be good to go

dim adder
#

@candid walrus easiest way to get all the cards - legend of the east satchel, visit pearson, and then just hang out in his shop until you have them all

spiral laurel
#

Well what about MUNEH

#

I know there are achievements related to it

#

But what else does it help out with by donating to them

chrome spear
#

How do I restock the supplies in my camp, I know i need to bring animals for food but what about other things

#

Like meds

candid walrus
candid walrus
dim adder
#

you buy refills in the bottom of the ledger

chrome spear
#

Oh

#

So it’s just buying supplies?

dim adder
#

yup

chrome spear
#

What do the animals I bring do then

spiral laurel
#

Well, does donating money ever help in keeping the gang stocked at all? Like if I was to give them money or supplies to sell for profit, will that ever help them buy what they may need at that time

dim adder
#

personally, I prefer just go to town and get what I need

#

nope

candid walrus
spiral laurel
#

Bears, Deer, things like that

candid walrus
#

Donating money doesn't really do anything for the gang

#

You can just buy upgrades with it

spiral laurel
#

don’t bring in something dumb like a skunk or a cat

candid walrus
#

That's basically it

#

I've brought a skunk to camp before

chrome spear
#

TBH I got the game bc I saw people hunting bears

spiral laurel
#

It looks all so cool man

chrome spear
#

I underestimated the story

spiral laurel
#

I can’t wait to sink my teeth into the gang part of the game

#

I know it’s not a permanent part of the game

#

but it’s still cool to me

chrome spear
#

I literally got this game 3 days ago

candid walrus
#

Ah

#

Do you care about spoilers at all?

chrome spear
#

I mean

#

I’d rather not

#

But maybe small things

dim adder
#

My favorite activity is wandering through the mountains and hunting/fishing

#

mostly fishing

chrome spear
#

I prefer the grizzlies

candid walrus
#

Alright. If so then I would recommend you don't hang around here too much. People talk about spoilers freely here so just be prepared

chrome spear
#

Oh

candid walrus
#

But you can do whatever you want

dim adder
#

It still makes me sad that my favorite hunting buddy died. 😦

chrome spear
#

Oof

#

One question b4 I go tho

candid walrus
#

Yes?

spiral laurel
#

I already played RDR1

chrome spear
#

How do you get more legendary hunt on certain animals

spiral laurel
#

I got a good idea of what’s gonna happen

dim adder
#

"get more legendary hunt"??

candid walrus
#

You can only hunt legendary animals once

dim adder
#

ah

#

new game!

chrome spear
#

I saw a really good player hunting a legendary bear

candid walrus
#

Yeah, there's only one legendary bear.

chrome spear
#

And I’ve already completed the hunt with hoesea

#

Maybe they chose to go back to camp with him instead of staying to hunt it down

dim adder
#

I like how hunting legendaries becomes routine after the second or third but then throws a curveball at the end.

chrome spear
#

I’m tryna kill a bunch of people but I only have 60 ammo

#

Should I be worried

#

NVM they didn’t respawn after killing them the first time so I got the wagon ez

candid walrus
#

I'm convinced it's impossible to complete A Fisher of Men in under 7 minutes 20 seconds

dim adder
#

I decided I'm not interested in golds beyond getting 100%

candid walrus
#

I want to try and get gold rush so that's why I keep trying

warped arrow
#

Dude im so pissed

#

Yk the vetrian mission

candid walrus
#

Yeah

warped arrow
#

With the old man

#

I just found out that he dies

candid walrus
#

Ah

warped arrow
#

man that would of been an awesome time to spend hunting

#

god damn it

#

What i do eith thus damn horse niw

candid walrus
#

Keep it

warped arrow
#

Ok

west mulch
#

whats better racing or elite handling?

warped arrow
#

how y get elite handling

candid walrus
#

Arabians

west mulch
#

I have a horse with racing handling but I can buy a elite one

#

Not sure which is better

warped arrow
#

Oh

candid walrus
#

The handling doesn't really matter

west mulch
#

Oh ok

warped arrow
#

I'm still si angry that the damn old man died

#

That would of been so fun to just have so many things to do with the guy

dim adder
#

rose grey arabian > *

candid walrus
#

Epic. Just survived a bear attack

#

Now to do it 17 more times

warped arrow
#

Holy shit

#

I got myself from the red of low karma, im talkimg bright red, right into high honor

#

Idk how

#

Is there a way to check it

candid walrus
#

Down on the D-pad for PS4

#

So you'll have to find out the equivalent of that for whatever you play on

acoustic umbra
#

its honestly harder to be bad then good

warped arrow
#

Im on pc

#

Oh its alt

red helm
candid walrus
#

Yeah, it seems so

#

It's one of the 4 Chapter 2 missions I still need to get gold in and it's so annoying

red helm
#

There are a couple I have tried, and they are just... Nope.

#

There is one that a Kid steals the Sister's Crucifix, and you need to get to him in 19 seconds. Just.. not a clue how to do that one.

candid walrus
#

Doesn't sound fun

red helm
#

But.. yeah, avoid the timed missions, when redoing for Gold Rush, they are the ugh. A lot of people have complained about those.

candid walrus
#

I absolutely hate them. I'll probably just have to forget about trying to do them

red helm
#

I did try doing the Fisher of Men for gold, too, and yeah, Not a clue how to get it done that quick..

timber elk
#

easier to chase a dead person

hushed flare
#

I robbed a train and I went from 90% honor to like 60% honor

#

a few more trains and robbed passengers and I can probably be level 5 bad honor

timber elk
#

you can pretty much choose if you want to be bad or good from the last strauss missions

hushed flare
#

kinda wish there was more bad honor perks

#

you get more money and tobacco stuff from looting I think at level 1 and level 5 a different deadeye sound

timber elk
#

Micah's death made me cry

barren dagger
#

Yo

#

I'm on console and I haven't gotten the m1899

#

it's after shady belle

#

And I can't find it in the Sd gunsmith

hushed flare
#

you also can get the Turkoman also

barren dagger
hushed flare
hushed harbor
#

its one of the first missions

#

in ch 4

hybrid scroll
#

Can we get max honor in chap 3 ?

#

Ok thx a lot

dire sentinel
#

huh

#

i got max honor in chapter six tho-

#

umm

#

want me to send a ss?

#

i can go on my arthur save

#

k let me get on it a sec

#

y tho lol

#

u dont believe me

#

im on console

#

not pc

#

i cant mod

#

for honor

barren dagger
#

It ain't there

#

I finished gilded and stuff

#

It ain't thete

#

There

dim adder
dim adder
#

@dire sentinel You're mistake was not killing all of them in the same dead-eye. 🙂

barren dagger
#

I can't get my m1899's

abstract relic