#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 377 of 1

native willow
#

nah lol

errant meteor
#

literally just said their trash

sinful hound
#

I can't find the actual word

native willow
#

they're good, but not the best

native willow
#

balanced

sinful hound
#

Yeah that's it

#

Balanced

native willow
#

that I agree with

errant meteor
#

golden standard

native willow
#

but that doesn't make it "the best"

#

that's subjective anyway

#

I don't think there is a best

sinful hound
#

I can MAYBE make an exception for the Calloway and Miller revolver

native willow
#

double actions suck though

errant meteor
#

yes

sinful hound
errant meteor
#

double is bad

sinful hound
native willow
#

Granger's revolver is my favorite cattleman

#

that shit is sexy

sinful hound
#

Double = no

sinful hound
native willow
#

John's is kinda cool too

sinful hound
#

Flaco's sucks

#

Literally no engravings

native willow
#

yeah Flaco's is lame

#

nah it's got some skulls I think?

#

just very

#

little

errant meteor
#

schofeild tho

native willow
#

yeah Schofields are hot

#

I have two with brass frames, they look good

errant meteor
#

schfeild with express are a two tap

sinful hound
native willow
#

I almost always run splitpoint on revolvers

sinful hound
#

Calloway's or Miller's

native willow
#

or high velocity

#

for range

native willow
#

Calloway's is clean though

sinful hound
#

I love the cattleman because it's the first gun you get and you grow with it

errant meteor
#

bro like bounty hunter schofeild

native willow
#

I just wish the cattleman was called the single action army instead

#

idk why RDR sometimes makes names up for guns

vital isle
#

Basic cattleman work regular rounds can be a oneshot to the body depends where you hit

native willow
#

but sometimes they don't

#

lol

vital isle
#

With*

sinful hound
native willow
#

yup

errant meteor
#

yea like the heart

vital isle
#

True lmao

native willow
#

headshots, or bleedout shots

sinful hound
#

Like a shot to the neck will always kill someone

#

Or to the head lmao

errant meteor
#

heart is also a one shot kill zone

vital isle
#

Evans repeater or Lancaster?

sinful hound
#

Lancaster

errant meteor
#

lan

sinful hound
#

All to the way

errant meteor
#

yep

#

no doubt

sinful hound
#

Best repeater imo

#

Litchfield suckd

vital isle
sinful hound
#

S

vital isle
errant meteor
#

springfield best rifle

sinful hound
#

Yes

echo girder
#

i prefer evans over lancaster

vital isle
#

I say bolt is best rifle

native willow
#

I use the Bolt Action

echo girder
#

because of higher ammo capacity and higher fire rate

#

and the sound

native willow
#

Springfield is cool, but can't beat 4 more rounds lol

errant meteor
#

springfield plus express equal one shot chest shot

native willow
#

can you put a scope on the springfield

sinful hound
#

Gtg

errant meteor
#

yes

sinful hound
#

Okay I'll catch you later then

echo girder
#

obviously can

native willow
#

honestly guns having scopes at this time is so weird

vital isle
native willow
#

I get why they did it, but it's kinda goofy

vital isle
echo girder
native willow
vital isle
native willow
#

I think the only stuff I put scopes on are the Bolt Action

#

and obviously the rifles that you can't take scopes off of

vital isle
#

Or the rolling block

native willow
#

yea

#

I'd take it off if i could lmao

vital isle
#

Is the rare even very much different than the standard rolling block?

native willow
#

I wish you could aim the rolling block without the scope

#

just engravings I think

echo girder
#

i think

native willow
#

I use that over the standard though

#

just cause it's rare

echo girder
#

i use it until i upgrade

#

mine

vital isle
#

You can modify the regular rolling block

native willow
#

yea

#

I rarely use it though

#

so not much of a factor in my case

vital isle
#

If you play the offline story mode In chapter 2 go to limphany and you can find a gold bar and get an easy 500 bucks

native willow
#

already did that way back, I'm on chapter 6 now

#

did have a thought though

#

would be cool to see some of those burned out towns in a game set further back in the past

#

if they ever do another game

vital isle
#

Ye I’ve beat the story 3 or 4 times I get bored with the free roam and restart

noble vale
vital isle
#

At least Arthur can swim lmfao

noble vale
#

Although i loved witcher 3 bec i played it 8 times

#

But rdr2 is nowhere boring

#

Imo

vital isle
#

Rdr2 the story is just so awesome I can’t get enough of it

noble vale
#

Yeah although its missions are far from the best thing in the game

#

Do you have the platinum trophy?

#

If ur from ps4

vital isle
#

No

noble vale
#

Oh

native willow
vital isle
#

I’m on PS4 but can’t get platinum

noble vale
#

Do you have the 100% completion zoologist skin deep

native willow
#

the story is great, but actually playing some of the missions isn't super fun

noble vale
#

Because i have them

native willow
#

some are very linear

noble vale
#

I have them but

#

How can I

native willow
#

yeah the overall experience is great

noble vale
#

Send them to alden

#

And get my rewards

#

I send ps app screenshoys

vital isle
#

Everybody found all the old gang members graves?

noble vale
#

Yeah I agree with the linear part, also some of them are a bit boring

noble vale
vital isle
#

I have with YouTube help

noble vale
#

M2

vital isle
#

Rip Arthur

noble vale
#

Rip

#

How do I sent proof to the bot

vital isle
#

Arthur Is better than John in every aspect tbh

noble vale
#

Agreed

vital isle
#

He can swim he can shoot and is just way much of a nicer person in the end

noble vale
#

Yeah

native willow
#

I think they're both great

#

one isn't really great without the other

vital isle
#

Same here just Arthur Is slightly better

native willow
#

Arthur changes and he sacrifices a shit load for John, John goes on to live a better life because of Arthur

#

they enhance eachother in my eyes

vital isle
#

Playing with John is like omg swim it’s not hard

native willow
#

Arthur is def a bit more Empathetic/Dynamic in a lot of ways

noble vale
#

Do u know how I send proof that i have the achivements

native willow
#

but i like John a lot too

#

we know

#

yeah we know

#

I don't care

vital isle
#

They are both badass for sure

native willow
#

yup

#

both go out like legends

vital isle
#

Ye

#

John took like 8 bullets from the Pinkertons in rdr1

native willow
vital isle
#

Arthur’s lungs pretty much gave out but he died peacefully depending if you played him honorably or not

vital isle
native willow
vital isle
#

You don’t know how bad I wanted to blow Thomas Downes head off the 2nd time I played through the story

native willow
#

oop

#

idk I find him more

#

pathetic than anything

vital isle
#

Ye fr

#

Have you heard the theory that Arthur could’ve got TB from Guarma?

native willow
#

nah

#

I mean it's clear as day that he got it from Downes

#

dude coughs blood in his mouth

vital isle
#

Ye ik

native willow
#

what's the theory

noble vale
native willow
#

I've also heard that Hosea could have given it to him, but I don't buy into that either

native willow
noble vale
native willow
#

it starts before guarma

vital isle
#

Ye

noble vale
#

Yeah

native willow
#

but yeah I agree

#

it's a pretty flimsy theory

noble vale
#

Explain something to me

#

Why did dutch kill micah

#

I know the obvious answer i just want ur opinions

vital isle
#

Cause he’s a piece of shit

native willow
#

trying to understand Dutch is difficult honestly

noble vale
#

Fair enough

vital isle
#

Also John killed him

noble vale
#

Yeah but dutch clearly shot him

vital isle
#

Dutch just wounded him

noble vale
#

And assisted John

native willow
#

true but Dutch did shoot him, he would have been willing to

boreal goblet
#

hello

native willow
noble vale
#

Hi

vital isle
native willow
#

I also think Dutch does have some guilt over what happened to Arthur, although he'd never say that, especially after the events of 2

noble vale
#

Yeah

native willow
#

Dutch became a real fucking lunatic by the time of RDR1

noble vale
#

And he maybe realised that micah is a traitor

#

On the other hand why did he stay with him for 7 years

vital isle
noble vale
#

Also yeah he helped John but why did he antagonize him in rdr1

native willow
#

for the Government

#

Dutch was still an outlaw

noble vale
#

Yea i know that

native willow
#

rounding up natives and shit to fight the army

#

oh

noble vale
#

I have rdr1

native willow
#

you mean like

#

why did he say that shit to him?

noble vale
#

But havent finished it yet

vital isle
#

Dutch killed himself tho

native willow
#

I'm confused at what you're asking lol

noble vale
#

He actually helped him but then they were enemies

native willow
#

he was also clearly still angry at John after

vital isle
#

Ye

native willow
#

he doesn't say anything to him and just leaves

noble vale
#

Yeah but no reason for it

native willow
#

and John falls out of the life

#

no reason for what

noble vale
#

For being angrt

#

Y

#

Also at the start of the encounter dutch said the same reason as you I suppose

#

When john asked him why is he here

vital isle
#

Arthur and John were the good guys in the end of rdr2 and weren’t in the wrong of betraying Dutch

native willow
#

yeah

#

Dutch still thinks John "betrayed" him

noble vale
noble vale
native willow
#

obviously

vital isle
#

You would think Javier would go with Arthur and John

native willow
#

nah

#

Javier is a dick at the end of 2

noble vale
#

No

native willow
#

and he's kinda Dutch's bitch

#

he always talks about how they just need to stick with dutch

#

in chapter 6

boreal goblet
#

and that sucks cause i liked him

vital isle
#

Ye same here

noble vale
#

The best time of rdr2 was at the start of chapter 2 until sean died

#

It was heaven

#

Imo

boreal goblet
#

seans death still hurts

noble vale
#

Yeah and it all went downhill

odd urchin
#

Hi

noble vale
#

I dont like saint denis as a town

#

Valentine and rhodes have that western feeling

boreal goblet
#

saint denis is just a representation of what the gang hates so you probably should hate it

native willow
#

yerp

vital isle
#

None of the good people like Abigail, John, Jack, Charles oh yeah and Tilly uncle and Pearson etc. Would’ve survived without Arthur and Sadie

boreal goblet
#

yeah

vital isle
#

They helped everybody escape and they all started better lives

#

Saint denis sucks

boreal goblet
#

black water eventually will be as bad as saint denis

#

its probably the closest to industrialization

young dragon
noble vale
#

Yeah whatever they have that modern feeling that I dont like

#

Western wasnt the correct word

boreal goblet
#

hello john are you a fisherman

#

wow

arctic wren
#

How did you manage that

boreal goblet
#

john is it art?

arctic wren
#

Yeah I always thought that was a bit overkill

#

I like how they don’t care if you beat up the racist tho

hidden moss
#

damn, seeing arthur's death scene still hits me so hard that i start crying, fucking hell

#

oh wait, i didnt even know theres a "darker" arthur death, does that scene change based on ur honor?

placid inlet
#

Yeah there’s 4 endings

hidden moss
#

damn

quaint sage
#

I thought there was only 2??

#

Dang, might need to experience them all if there’s 4

boreal goblet
#

bad ending treasure chest good ending treasure chest bad ending john good ending john

arctic wren
#

I’m on my second playthrough, doing a bad honour help John

#

Then I’ll do good honour go for the money, then the bad honour equivalent

boreal goblet
#

i want to do that but buells my horse...

#

so i cant

#

i dont wanna see him die

hidden moss
#

Hey.

#

Anybody alive?

boreal goblet
#

yes

#

wdym by that

arctic wren
boreal goblet
#

yeah

hidden moss
#

Can anybody help with graphics? I am wanting my graphics kinda better then console graphics on my PC. dont say put all of them on ultra i dont have that good of a PC. If you dont want to help thats fine but if you do DM me or something i really dont know

#

and I dont mean like 4k i mean the normal legit graphics on a console

boreal goblet
#

i play on console so idk

hidden moss
#

oof

arctic wren
#

I tried it on pc, I didn’t have a good enough pc to even have it full screen

hidden moss
#

damn

arctic wren
#

I could play it decently, but it was just a square in the middle of the screen

#

Hated that cause I could see everything else around it and it bothered me

hidden moss
#

Do you mean crash issues

#

Or like lag

arctic wren
#

Didn’t have either

hidden moss
#

FPS issues?

arctic wren
#

Never really had any

#

Just didn’t have enough video memory to go full screen

prime estuary
obsidian shell
#

On chapter 6 with my 7th run. My mind still cant handle it lol

prime estuary
#

Its going to look better at at least 60fps

sinful hound
#

Am back

obsidian shell
#

Trelawny, am i popular in Blackwater yet?

sinful hound
#

Depends

#

How many friends did you make, aaarfEr

obsidian shell
#

Well its goin good have this guy named Tommy nice enough feller and a guy named Jimmy Brooks, he knew us when we had a "party" in Blackwater

#

gtg Trelawny, ill see u in Blackwater rescuin Sean

sinful hound
#

Ohh, see you ;)

hidden moss
#

it looks way worse then a console

#

but also only having 1080p on the console

#

so i dont accidently think its better

#

over 4k

prime estuary
#

Its a decent pc

#

You wont get something better then console

hidden moss
#

ok sure

prime estuary
#

If you want it playable as is

hidden moss
#

"just do medium" is a bit vague imo, a lot of graphical options have big impact on visual quality and a small performance impact, while other options are vice versa

#

2000 dollar PC vs a console. go ahead.

#

I dont have a 2000 dollar PC of course

#

but appearantly a console is better.

prime estuary
#

I said decent pc

hidden moss
#

AMD 5060 XT.

#

not the best

#

but also not bad.

prime estuary
#

You wont get better graphics on console is what I said

hidden moss
#

oh.

#

AMD 5060 should be enough to get me atleast slightly better

#

is what im saying.

#

not very high tho

#

like everyone

#

sad.

prime estuary
#

So you would get something similar to a console

#

But not better

hidden moss
#

Well idk if its because of crashes

#

It can run the textures on ultra

#

and the rest on high.

#

but the game crashes

#

i think it does it still

#

even on medium.

#

menu crashes

#

and shit

prime estuary
#

Hmm

hidden moss
#

someone told me

#

to replace the menu

#

that can cause frame rate drops

#

but doubt it

#

the current menu

#

he said the current menu causes frame rate rops

#

DROPS*

#

but i doubt that is it.

prime estuary
#

I have no clue

hidden moss
#

Like if I open my menu

#

it crashes

#

and wont let me open.

#

Is what im saying.

#

It could just be crash problems ngl.

#

When I do the benchmark test

#

when they test robbing a place and stuff running from gaurds

#

sometimes arthur

#

cant ride the horse and just

#

stands there

#

doing nothing

#

idk if other people have that glitch to.

hidden moss
#

I dont like low frames tho so i lowered it until i reached 60.

prime estuary
#

Thats playable

hidden moss
#

Yeah its console frames and it was fine i guess

#

but i like 60 frames

#

more then graphics

#

I lowered them till i reached 60

#

All im having is crash problems I think or something idk how to fix it

blissful heart
#

which single player comes close to rdr2 which i can play?

#

already finished rdr2

hidden moss
#

what ending u got

hoary heron
#

Y'know the legendary panther cloak you can get from the Trapper

#

There's some other variants right made from different animals

#

Are any of them a black sort of colour

scenic oak
#

I never noticed how good the lip sync is

shut stone
red helm
#

I've been playing Witcher 3 for the last few months, and quite enjoy it.

shut stone
#

I finished it through gamepass but want to own it

red helm
#

Nice. I beat the main game a few weeks ago, Playing through the 2 Expansions now, though.

shut stone
#

I need to get on those💯

red helm
#

The first one was, interesting... err wish I could remember the names and which one is which...

#

I beat the Blue one, but it was a little, eh at times. Mostly fine though. The second one, the red one is much better though. But, I'm only just starting it.

wanton cove
#

Man, I really hate to see Arthur getting worse and worse health wise with each main quest I do. It's the small things - the coughs in between, the red eyes.. I really dont want to continue the game further because that just cant end well cowboy_sad

red helm
#

It is indeed, rough.

wanton cove
#

But that music scene in chapter 5, boi what a feeling

#

You could really feel how everything is on its deepest point right now

red helm
#

Just wait, it gets a bit lower.

wanton cove
#

Just when you thought it prolly couldnt get worse..

#

Time to go pelt hunting to shove the miserable feelings off a bit more :')

red helm
#

That will probably help.

shut stone
#

Is there a certain time i have to wait beforw hunting another legendary animal?

upper fox
#

everything is so dark and sad after chapter 4

red helm
#

Legendary animal's are one time only. In Single player.

upper fox
#

Yes

potent mauve
#

E

shut stone
upper fox
#

legendary animals unlock after certain chapters

red helm
placid inlet
#

Pretty sure there’s no cooldown with them

upper fox
#

example you cant hunt the legendary gator in chapter 3, cuz its something from chapter 4

shut stone
shut stone
red helm
#

Yes, a couple of the legendary's only show up after certain conditions, but most are available as soon as you are in Chapter 2.

upper fox
#

cant remember from what chapter the elk is from

#

wait wait i remember something about the elk

red helm
#

Elk shouldn't have any conditions.

upper fox
#

his location isnt exactly on the map where his icon is

wanton cove
red helm
#

Yeah, don't 100% trust the map Hosea gives you.

shut stone
#

Ok i will search around till i get the notification

red helm
#

Or even sometimes when you get the Notification. The Coyote is actually a bit off..

upper fox
hidden moss
#

anyone here wish they could forget about the story and replay the game again?

blissful heart
upper fox
hoary heron
hoary heron
hidden moss
#

can someone help my crash issues?

autumn verge
#

Where the admins at

#

And when are we going get duh uhh

#

Unicorn roadstar horsebread

boreal goblet
#

whos death hit the hardest to you guys? except Arthur and John

serene rivet
#

Lenny

boreal goblet
#

for me it was lenny

#

same

serene rivet
#

8321_pepecry Lenny is my fav from the whole bunch

#

Hosea was sad too.. he was a cool guy

hidden moss
#

anyone alive/

native willow
#

no

boreal goblet
#

Hosea isnt lmao

native willow
#

f

hushed harbor
#

how should i do weapons expert 6? the 4 kills with a stick of dynamite one

candid walrus
#

go to a gang hideout

serene rivet
#

i liked Hosea

hushed harbor
hidden moss
#

red dead endings make no sense

candid walrus
hidden moss
#

@hidden moss

hidden moss
#

yeah ?

hushed harbor
hidden moss
#

i wonder if DIRECT 12 will solve my freezing issues

narrow jetty
#

wasn't expecting my horse to go

#

and when Arthur said thank you I was like alright rockstar I hate you assholes

native willow
#

That shit made me feel the feels

hidden moss
#

why is it so easy to hit 30 fps for me at night but i get like 20-25 in the day lol

#

is it cuz of shadows

shut stone
#

Is there anyway to get perfect sheephide without losing honor?

candid walrus
#

nope

#

just gotta do it

shut stone
#

Damn dropped alot of honor for 1 sheep that's terrible

shut stone
#

Do i have to go to black water to get the little bois book?

obsidian shell
#

No

whole pine
#

does more events open up to arthur?

#

im on chapter 3 and ive only had a few bounties and just wondering

#

if more activities open up to you later in the game

obsidian shell
#

@shut stone Their is a place between Emerald Station and the Kamassa River, it is between 2 roads.

native willow
#

Certain quests are tied to certain chapters

#

You’ll get more stuff to do

obsidian shell
#

@whole pine If you didnt know their are fishing, hunting, robbing home steads that you can in the camp. Their will be a white circle like stranger missions around the camp starting somewhere in chapter 3, A home for robbing, animal for hunting, and a fish for fishing around ur camp. Hope this Helped

red helm
shut stone
obsidian shell
#

@shut stone np, its abandoned house with a dead women and kid

hushed harbor
#

idk how im going to do the hunt 5 cougars master hunter challenges, hunting 1 for the lote satchel was already stressful

red helm
#

A lot of people have been asking about this the last few days.

#

Where cougar's are..

hushed harbor
#

im not asking about its location im just saying that hunting 5 of them is gonna be super stressful because of how scary they are

red helm
#

Make sure to use Improved arrows, or Poisoned.

#

And yeah, Cougar's are the meanies.

hushed harbor
#

i used a rifle last time i hunted one and got a perfect pelt so idk maybe i could use that?

red helm
#

the challenge is to use a bow.

hushed harbor
#

oh yeah

red helm
#

Definitely don't forget to skin afterwards though.

hushed harbor
#

also is there a way to check specific facial hair lengths in the pause menu? i dont wanna have to go back to camp or the barber (of which there are only 2 as arthur) to check when im trying to get lvl 10 beard

red helm
#

Umm... I've never thought to look..

hushed harbor
#

it just tells you generic "short medium long" type stuff in the statistic section

narrow jetty
#

Red Dead 2 is the breaking bad of video games

hushed harbor
#

now for the tomahawk weapons expert challenge, the one where you kill 4 enemies with the same tomahawk

#

im sure the ancient tomahawk counts? since its a special weapon im just unsure if its still classified in the code as a "tomahawk"

red helm
#

Probably not, use the basic ones.

hushed harbor
#

i tried it and it worked

red helm
#

Oh, okay then.

#

I just killed a whole barnyard full of cows. Poor cows. Always fun bringing your honor down.

cunning siren
#

Is there a way to look at my honor rank?

hidden moss
#

anybody having these problems and got them solved DM me? Problems: Sometimes fighting, grabbing, riding your horse takes like a min before it works. The longer u wait till pausing to the menu the more it freezes

shut stone
cunning siren
#

I play on pc lol. But ive figured it out. Thank you anyways :P

rugged nacelle
#

Can someone Recommend me good Graphics settings for my PC?

Specifications: -
Processor: - AMD Ryzen 5 3550H
RAM: - 8GB DDR4
GPU: - NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1650

noble vale
#

Medium

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

so yeah, a medium/high combination should work fine

hidden moss
#

guys i wanted to say something

#

I hate Red Dead Redemption this game sucks.

#

-Greatings your mom

obtuse halo
#

anyone know a fix to stop the game from launching into a black screen? I use Epic and R* launcher. I get the intro, like the shotgun loading, but when it reaches the actual menu, black screen

hushed harbor
#

try to do weapons expert 10
immediately get bumrushed by the bear before i can even do anything
okay

#

imma see if i can get that cairn lodge random encounter

hidden moss
#

is there any differnce between the satchels or does it just change the looks of it ?

candid walrus
#

Yes, there is a difference

#

LOTE satchel is the best you can get. It allows you to carry almost 99 of every tem

hidden moss
candid walrus
#

Np

spring sluice
#

Wow I just found a cool duologue in game

#

when you rob that old lady's house and come back some time later her sons are actually there

#

they frickin scared me when they knocked me down

#

Idk I just use a sniper and headshot the huge animals

sinful hound
#

@hidden moss just go all in with a Evans repeater

#

Although I killed the bear Revenant style

noble shuttle
#

find a different one

#

huh

#

then look up a video of where the animal is

#

oh

#

thats rockstar for you

#

i mean look at undead nightmare

#

theres a glitch that causes the zombies to have invisible heads

#

sometimes making it so you cant kill them with guns

#

and rockstar hasnt decided to go back and fix it

#

nice

#

was that your first legendary animal?

#

ok

#

ive only killed 3

#

the bear, the elk, and the white bison

#

but i plan on killing them all before i beat the game for the third time

#

i havent made any trinkets

#

will do that next time i visit the trapper

#

isnt there one for the lion paw?

#

because i have that

#

yea

#

in a side mission

#

you can kill it and make a trophy out of it

#

which is the paw

#

in between Rhodes and Valentine somewhere theres a guy dressed up as a queen named margret and he sends you to get a zebra, tiger and lion for his show

#

after the mission you get an emerald

#

worth 50 bucks at the fence

candid walrus
#

yep, there is a lion paw trinket.

#

although the emerald Margret gives you is a fake

candid walrus
#

are you kidding

#

i found a perfect cow moose but not a bull

#

smh

#

this game hates me

hidden moss
#

i just found a perfect black bear pelt is there anything good i can do with it ?

delicate sparrow
#

yeah

#

sell it to the trapper

#

you could probably use it to craft something

hidden moss
#

ok

noble shuttle
#

yea and the gold can be sold for $500

flat sable
#

Is it just me or how come stagecoaches catch on Fire when I shoot them with the Pump-Action Shotgun?

hidden moss
#

Aw man, I was trying to get to san luis river for the legendary fish as Arthur, by boat, somehow the snipers were still able to find me ;p

#

I got to thieves landing tho, furthest I ever got

hidden moss
#

wtf
WHY IS THE ATTACKERS INVISIBLE\

sinful hound
#

Wdym

hidden moss
#

bro this game on PC..

#

the characters turned invisible

#

with a gun

#

i cant even handle it

#

this port was really bad on PC

noble shuttle
#

honestly most rockstar games should be made for console

#

when they put it on pc it usually is a buggy mess

#

and after a month hackers infest online modes and rockstar does nothing about it

boreal goblet
#

rockstar banned one hacking software atleast

noble shuttle
#

they force money drops and they dont ban the hacker, they ban the victim

noble shuttle
#

out of hundreds

vestal horizon
#

At what mission do you discover Saint Denis? I really want to do that poker room robbery.

boreal goblet
#

actually they just remove the money from your account you dont get banned

#

i can find where they say it

noble shuttle
#

and that mission is really good

vestal horizon
#

A Quiet time?

noble shuttle
#

no not at all

#

thats chapter 2

#

san denis is chapter 4

vestal horizon
#

Guess I'm not getting my secret robbery.

boreal goblet
#

you can go there any time btw

vestal horizon
#

I know but I can't see the path.

noble shuttle
vestal horizon
#

I have no idea how people see you the windows are boarded up.

boreal goblet
#

how far are you? like what chapter

vestal horizon
#

Chapter 2

noble shuttle
vestal horizon
#

The rest of the map is blurred out

boreal goblet
#

near the ocean

noble shuttle
#

basically just put a waypoint at the bottom right and follow it, you should end up there soon enough

vestal horizon
#

Alright thanks

noble shuttle
#

and it will reveal some more of the map

vestal horizon
#

Also the Valentine saloon reopened at LAST

#

As soon as Jon spawned in I killed him and took my hat

boreal goblet
#

coolio city

vestal horizon
#

I got a instant wanted level

#

Even though Jon is a annoying ass

noble shuttle
#

who's Jon?

vestal horizon
#

Jon:* You ain't worth two shi-* dies *

vestal horizon
#

If you kill him you get a amazing hat

sinful hound
#

Oh

#

That guy

#

Yeha fuck him

vestal horizon
#

I killed him using a gun I stole from the Doctor but I should have burned him alive.

noble shuttle
#

is it the guy with the animal hat?

vestal horizon
#

Yea

noble shuttle
#

i remember that guy

#

i just beat the shit out of him and took it

vestal horizon
#

Or load up on tonics then freeze time and mark targets on him. Unfreeze time and hit all your targets and Jons body will have holes all over it. * Insert JoJo music here *

noble shuttle
#

i like how if you walk into the doctor sometimes he will say "Snake oil is hard to get" or something...mate you buy it from the general store for like $3

boreal goblet
#

and homeless people give it for 50 cents

noble shuttle
#

ikr

#

i got max potent snake oil i dont need it

#

honestly i feel that opened snake oil is more useful than regular snake oil

boreal goblet
#

why?

sinful hound
#

Does the same effect

#

And is easier to find

#

Imo

#

lol

#

Yeah lol

noble shuttle
# boreal goblet why?

because the effects of regular snake oil seem to go out super fast so really whats the point

#

they just say you look stupid

boreal goblet
#

then you kill em

noble shuttle
#

i had a cool outfit but i stopped wearing it because every time i walked by hosea he said i looked stupid

boreal goblet
#

Hostess mean

#

hosea

latent plover
#

Mean Hosea

boreal goblet
#

is there a reason you can't go to NA with arthur? other than the animal bones

noble shuttle
#

oh wait

#

new austin

latent plover
#

Thats the way it is

#

Lol but nah you can’t because pinkertons

boreal goblet
#

i know that

#

but why did they do that

noble shuttle
#

hes wanted

latent plover
#

That’s just how the story starts

noble shuttle
#

the black water massacre of 1899

boreal goblet
#

but like if you can go there, why would they go out of there way to make it impossible to stay there

noble shuttle
#

this is why you listen to the dialogue

boreal goblet
#

except for john

noble shuttle
latent plover
#

Just to show you that there are pinkertons all over the place there

#

So you can try but you will die

boreal goblet
#

i guess

sinful hound
#

Arthur can't go because he's wanted there

latent plover
#

Invisible sniper is always watching

sinful hound
#

Pinkertons and stuff

sinful hound
boreal goblet
#

i understand storywise. but why would they make it impossible to go there while your arthur. maybe it is just because of the story but just wierd

noble shuttle
#

most likely to make it so you have something to explore after the epilogue

boreal goblet
#

i guess that makes sence

night turtle
#

lol rack up bounty, spend all money, antagonize lawman, go to jail, profit?

noble shuttle
#

what?

boreal goblet
#

yeah but he is pretending to be jim milton

noble shuttle
#

then how did he get the house after his work with the pinkertons in rdr1

#

hm?

latent plover
#

His house is in WE

noble shuttle
#

technically you have a point

#

but also john didn’t tell bonnie a lot of things

boreal goblet
#

wait wheres WE again

latent plover
#

It could just be a plot hole

noble shuttle
#

he would have been in NA for the events prior to rdr2

latent plover
#

Oh yeah lol I think that’s right

noble shuttle
#

because john and arthur have been in the gang for over 15 years

latent plover
#

Unless he rejoined them in blackwater since he was away for a year

noble shuttle
#

you’d think they would have been in NA quite a few times

noble shuttle
#

in rdr2 i think he’s 6 during the main game and 14 in the epilogue

sinful hound
boreal goblet
#

oh

noble shuttle
#

close enough

#

that still shows that there was at least 3 years prior to rdr2 that john could have been in NA

#

with the fact that john didn’t tell bonnie a lot of things at first

red helm
#

I've seen him in there after the Epilogue.

#

Well, it is a Random encounter.

hidden moss
#

oh i also only today discovered that u can meet rains fall in annesburg

red helm
#

Mary Beth is at the Valentine train station, and Tilly is in the middle of Saint Denis, fyi.

upper fox
#

Pearson is the general store owner in Rhodes

#

The widow aka Charlotte is meetable in the epilogue if Arthur helped her

vestal horizon
#

What happens if you lure Jon back to camp? I've already killed him so i can't test this expirement out for myself.

upper fox
#

If Arthur didnt help she either dies or she young again and John can help her

#

instead of Arthur

upper fox
vestal horizon
#

In the Valentine saloon

#

Have you killed him? Cause he gives you a free hat.

upper fox
#

If you lead enemies to camp you lose honor

#

and yes I have his hat

vestal horizon
#

What does Dutch do if you lead him to your camp though?

#

Does he start brawling with him?

upper fox
#

Idk I once brought a dead body to camp I lost honor and the game despawnt the dead body

vestal horizon
#

Oh alright

upper fox
#

The dead body was the opponent from the gambler 9 challenge

#

You can bring meat/food into camp and gang members will respond. You cant bring dead bodies of npc's into camp.

slender gull
#

Yes the gang members dont allow you

hidden moss
latent plover
ruby seal
hushed flare
native willow
#

PLAN

undone maple
#

The God Damn Plan

tribal quartz
#

@worthy hatch @hidden moss me WHEB I have plan.

finite jolt
#

I love Dutch’s character so much I wish he didn’t go insane

#

That’s the thing about a prequel

native willow
#

I mean he's certainly an interesting character, but I def don't love him

#

seeing him manipulate people kinda sucks

verbal portal
#

Anyone just keep restarting play throughs without finishing them

#

I don’t want it to end so I just keep restarting

hushed harbor
#

imagine if francis sinclair was someone from our time rather than the 1920s

green pine
#

And got the worst ending which is Micah stabbing me on the back

#

God Damn rat

narrow jetty
#

Arthur Morgan is based

#

dude literally took the reins on a woman's suffrage march

placid inlet
#

King

hushed harbor
#

completed the survivalist challenges ArthurSip

bronze pumice
#

Why they sending over 10 dogs to kill me?

sinful hound
forest blaze
#

just go to a post office to pay it off

#

or get arrested if you want

sinful hound
forest blaze
#

isnt it more of a pussy move just paying off your arson that you committed in saint denis in another state

#

or you were saying that just getting rid of it and not living with 1,500$ bounty in every state is a pussy move

sinful hound
#

both are pussy moves

#

Just don't pay it off and fight off BH like a boss

#

😤 😤 😎

#

I'm just joking man

forest blaze
#

yeah but they have an endless supply of lawmen

sinful hound
#

Still

forest blaze
#

going down one way or another

sinful hound
#

If your bounty is over 500$ already it's gonna be a lot of money spent on paying off

#

I'd pay off anything below 100$ because BH annoy me sometimes

forest blaze
#

oh yeah forgot what it was using my money carefully

sinful hound
#

Lmaooo

#

I finished the bill and Karen robbery and got like 2.5k

#

Spent it on the fast travel thing and the boat

forest blaze
#

you probably wasted your money on that boat

sinful hound
#

Nah I love to explore

forest blaze
#

dont think you are gonna be close to water for long

sinful hound
#

I won't leave ch 3

#

Ever

#

That's why

#

I wanna do the trelawny mission so I have him at camp and after that I'm just gonna be in Clemens Point doing chores and listening to random events at camp

forest blaze
#

alright alright

#

if you want you can get gold bars

#

but with the bank mission you can buy plenty of stuff

#

so it doesnt matter that much

sinful hound
#

Yup

arctic wren
#

Lum-bay-go or Lum-bag-oh?

#

I’m telling my friend it’s lum-bay-go

#

He wont listen

hidden moss
sinful hound
#

Although some people do say lum bag oh

#

In my country it was called lum bah goh

hidden moss
# green pine I was too good at avoiding spoilers so I didnt know arthur dies

i "accidentally" (more intentionally, but like i couldnt be bothered to play the game at that time) spoiled myself with a few seconds of the last scene with the sunrise and stuff, still didnt wanna play the game, but then i saw like 2 seconds of a clip seeing arthur crawl on that rock and i instantly closed my browser, started up the game and played for several days and yeah 2 days ago i just completed it and even tho i knew arthur would die, just not how, i still sobbed for 10 minutes, it just goes to see how attachment to anything in this world is unforgiving in emotion

#

and im glad i got to enjoy that experience myself, and not spoiling myself with videos, because thats a hell of a difference, being able to control your decisions vs watching a vid where someone does something stupid or some other shit i dont like

#

altho i barely did any side quests as arthur, i just grinded the story cuz i was so desperate to see the ending, i was so desperate that i started having thoughts i should go watch a vid on yt about the ending, but i kept convincing myself to play the game myself and experience it

green pine
#

wow

hidden moss
#

lol

ruby seal
#

I just would like to say FMicah

dusky vault
#

theres some new players on this server

candid walrus
#

they shouldn't be on the server, then. since spoilers are allowed here. unless you're doing it to ruin someone elses gameplay

hidden moss
#

^

dusky vault
#

okie

#

🤷‍♂️

grizzled sapphire
#

Tbf, the games almost 3 yrs old too. Pretty tuff to not know how it ends at this point.

candid walrus
#

^

hidden moss
#

well there are certainly people like me who only upgrade from intel hd in god dam 2021 lol, so its understandable

delicate sparrow
dusky vault
#

o

#

it doesnt

#

nice

#

mb

hidden moss
#

also the graphics settings are hell to adjust... it took me maybe around 10-15 hours in total, all of these months, for me to fiddle with the settings and remain where im at right now, and im still switching settings around occasionally

#

sometimes my fps drops too much so im unhappy, but when i get higher fps, im also unhappy about the graphics and turn them higher again, its like i have some sort of crisis lmao

delicate sparrow
#

what are your specs?

hidden moss
#

im currently on a 2200g with integrated vega 8 and 8gb ram

#

i want 900p because it looks so much sharper than something like 750p, but at the same time i want 30 fps as well, and also good graphics, like my mind is just having a crisis picking one or the other

delicate sparrow
#

yeah that's why

dusky vault
#

just get a console cus it doesnt lag on them ez pz 🥱

delicate sparrow
#

you're not gonna get much fps with those specs

#

in your case, just get a console

#

you'll get a consistent 30 fps on a ps4 at 1080p

#

and cheaper than a pc

hidden moss
#

i upgraded to this pc only 6 years after being stuck with intel hd, i cant be bothered to buy a console when i can buy a 970 for cheaper and also upgrade the cpu later lol

dusky vault
#

lol

delicate sparrow
#

a ps4 has better graphics then a 970

#

and look at the pc market right now

#

you have 2070 supers selling for about $1k usd

hidden moss
# delicate sparrow you're not gonna get much fps with those specs

i can get locked 30 fps (drops to 28 sometimes which isnt too much of a problem) on 720p at medium-ish settings, but the graphics look awful, and especially the resolution and all of the TAA ghosting, so i'd rather stick with lower fps and better graphics which is what im doing rn, i dont need 30 fps to play the game :P

#

and also yeah ure right, the pc market is fked but 970s are pretty cheap in my country, second hand at least

#

i'd say 150$ for a 970 is a good deal considering what is going on right now

#

and im fine with a 970, as far as i saw, it can do 1080p medium/high at 40 fps

delicate sparrow
#

your choice

hidden moss
#

ive tried an xbox one before when my older bro had one, but i just dont like controllers when it comes to games, and dont like the fact that i have to buy a game which i cant play on pc later if i ever get a good one, and also isnt the console market fked too? pretty much everything hardware related like cpus, gpus, basically anything that has a chip is just overpriced as shit now

#

sup

candid walrus
#

general store

hidden moss
#

holy fuck, theres a hidden special option for texture quality that loads all of the game textures at once and requires over 24gb of vram... LMAO

halcyon dove
hidden moss
#

does anyone have a comparison between water SSR off and on?

#

wanna see if turning it off is worth it or not, as water kills my fps even when its not on my screen lul, disabling water with a mod menu gives me 5 fps (at least on guarma), even when im not facing the water

native willow
#

that's why you always carry max horse revivers

#

lmao

minor skiff
#

I had $1500 bounty in 3 states

#

Feel like an outlaw

narrow jetty
#

Edgar Ross might honestly even be worse than Micah

#

Micah was a piece of shit but at least he was like, up front and blunt

#

Micah was more of an outward prick but Edgar Ross was a two faced bitch

minor skiff
#

Cowpokes Ross was the real monster in rdr

hidden moss
minor skiff
#

Agent Milton was nothing but Ross he is 10× worse

#

@hidden moss not in story mode the highest bounty in story mode is 1500

hidden moss
#

In Saint Denis

#

With John and Dutch

minor skiff
#

U can't have more then 1500 in story

#

It stop after 1500

hidden moss
#

Okay

#

I’m gonna test it soon

minor skiff
#

I have tried with mods and without mods and its allways stop at 1500

#

Should wish we could get atleast $5000

hidden moss
#

Managed to get 21 with 5 cards in bj, I'm hella proud

#

: )

latent plover
#

“Almost blackjack with a twenty!”

#

You must’ve heard that line a few times?

candid walrus
#

Yep

#

You need to complete them

#

What's master hunter 2 again?

#

Oh, that's not too bad

#

Wait until the later ones...

#

you will

#

sadly no

hidden moss
#

Can't do gambler 2?

candid walrus
#

🤷‍♀️

hidden moss
#

Try gambler 7.

#

You'll be crying.

#

I'm 1/3 through it

#

because the gods smiled upon me

#

and i got 21 with 5 cards

candid walrus
#

nice

hidden moss
#

Oi storm

#

U in the epilogue?

candid walrus
hidden moss
#

I dont believe

#

i have like

#

half of the animals

#

and it says i have enough

#

u only gotta get like 50

candid walrus
#

you dont need everything for 100%

#

just some things

hidden moss
#

well then it's not really 100% is it?

candid walrus
#

guess not

hidden moss
#

its more like

#

uhhhhhhhhh

#

...

candid walrus
#

what

hidden moss
#

how is that not fair

#

do you understand math

#

a real 100% would be full compendium, all things discovered

#

full journal

candid walrus
#

mhm

hidden moss
#

story completed

#

everything

candid walrus
#

all side missions completed too probably

hidden moss
#

so by saying we did 100% by not actually doing 100%

#

wait

#

i just got wooshed

#

kill me

latent plover
#

Literally everything you can possibly do is technically 100%

hidden moss
#

42069 weeb street

latent plover
#

But r* gave us some mercy

hidden moss
#

milwaukee, florida

minor skiff
#

Gambler challenge is like hell

candid walrus
#

No, it IS hell

narrow jetty
#

Hot take: Whether your Arthur has low or high honor, Micah should have killed him

#

Makes a lot more sense and makes American Venom make a lot more sense

#

and satisfying

#

him dying naturally of the tb at that exact moment is a little to perfect and unrealistic imo

placid inlet
#

i mean-

#

he also had tooons of injuries lmfao

narrow jetty
#

Fair, but it's still a little far fetched

#

Micah should have killed him regardless of honor, sure maybe they can be different deaths, like with high honor its less brutal, but It just makes a lot more sense for Micah to kill Arthur

hidden moss
#

does anyone know how to quickfire without deadeye

#

i mean

#

i saw alot of these youtube videos doing it

#

seems pretty cool

narrow jetty
#

mods?

#

idk

hidden moss
#

idk man

#

if it would be

#

id be pissed

#

because im shit at installing mods

#

for controller, just tap RT, for mouse, hold right click, tap left click while also letting go of right click and it should start quickfiring

#

its harder on mouse and takes a bit to get used to but yea

#

tap once only?

#

tap as many times as u wanna quickfire, obviously

#

okay thanks

hidden moss
narrow jetty
#

I just think its unrealistic. There is absolutely no reason why Micah would let him die peacefully. Arthur, even though the good man beat the giant in the end to use Mary's phrase, lived a live of savagery, as did John. The whole point of the story in John's case was that despite his redemption, he still lived a bad life and got killed violently. The beauty of it is that even though he had to pay for his sins and die savagely, he still redeemed himself in the end

red helm
#

Eh, Maybe Micah didn't think he didn't need to bother shooting him?

candid walrus
#

probably

red helm
#

Course, I've only seen 2 endings now, so.... eh.

narrow jetty
#

I know this might be uncomfortable to hear, but Arthur did not deserve a peaceful death. He was a good man at heart, but he killed hundreds of people in his life, many innocent people as well. Selflessly saving his friend in the end doesn't wipe that all way

red helm
narrow jetty
#

He got redemption though

candid walrus
red helm
candid walrus
red helm
#

Yeap, he got Redemption. I'm getting my honor back down to -100% now, So that I can see the two Dishonor Endings. But I was killing cattle for pelts that I still needed for the Trapper clothes, Almost there though.... Efficiency.

narrow jetty
#

lol

#

nice

red helm
narrow jetty
#

Hell, I don't even know if i'd describe Arthur as a good man. He had good in his heart, more than most outlaws which made him special, but in his actions, for like 99% of his life, he was a stone cold killer

red helm
#

Yeah, I figured instead of just killing a bunch of rando's on the road, I may as well gather up some sheep pelts and what nots.

candid walrus
red helm
#

If all you know for most of your life is Crime and Killing, it's hard to tear your way out of it. Like Hosea says.

candid walrus
hidden moss
#

isnt that what his redemption is about?

red helm
#

Pretty much.

candid walrus
#

I now begin the search for a moose

#

again

red helm
#

Darn Moose

narrow jetty
# hidden moss isnt that what his redemption is about?

People don't change, they just become more who they really are. Arthur has always had a good heart and been a good man deep down, but he lived the life of a bad man. As a result, he was a bad man for most of his life

#

He was a good man who lived the life of a bad man

#

his whole life he was living against his nature

hushed harbor
#

wheres a good spot to wait for wagons for bandit 8

narrow jetty
#

when I say he wasn't good man, I mean he lived his life as a bad man

hidden moss
red helm
hidden moss
#

yes he lived a bad life for a long time but he eventually became who he really was, a good man, and he saw this MUCH more clearly because of TB

narrow jetty
#

at the very end, yes, but it doesn't absolve him of his sins

red helm
hidden moss
narrow jetty
#

that's what the story is all about. John for example deserved the death he got because he lived a bad mans life, but the beauty is despite all that, he redeemed himself

#

They become good, but were not absolved of their sins

#

It's a life lesson, Becoming a good person doesn't mean you are absolved of the sins you committed when you were a bad person

red helm
#

Good and Evil are points of view.

narrow jetty
#

but the best thing you can do is redeem yourself

red helm
#

There are certain things that can be catagorized as bad or good, but there is a whole lot of gray area in between, It's very hard to straight up judge things.

narrow jetty
#

Well of course every concept like that is subjective, but there's a general understanding of wrong and right.

hidden moss
#

sex bad, virgin good

red helm
#

Now we are just moving into Ethics and Morals, which is tricky.

narrow jetty
#

I'm not saying dutch's gang didn't have good intentions, their intentions were admirable, but they also did a lot of bad things and killed innocent people

red helm
red helm
narrow jetty
#

I actually don't even mind that part lmao. It's just that it was still a gang of outlaws and killed innocent people.

red helm
#

I mean, all those guards and lawmen, protecting the banks and trains and wagons, that get shot up. Those are just people trying to earn a living, sure they knew what they signed up for, but, at the end of the day, they just wanted a pay check, and to have a wife and children. Same as the farmers and the Store clerks. So..

narrow jetty
#

Ya know what I love about the story? It's central theme is people ultimately getting what they deserved. Arthur got sick because he beat a dying poor sick man to death. He deserved TB. And the beautiful thing is, fate punishing him for his sins, (TB) is ultimately the very thing that led to his redemption

red helm
#

Yeah, all the layers to the game.

narrow jetty
#

It's bad people getting punished for the bad lives they lived, and those punishments leading them to their redemption

#

John's death holds so much more weight after rdr2

safe torrent
#

It's a really beautiful story, both in the first and second game

red helm
#

You mostly get Explorer challenges for finding Map chests.

#

Get a new map.. ?

narrow jetty
#

John was originally a shitty kid who walked out on his family for a year and wanted nothing to do with them. He later died so that they could live. His punishment, being killed, was also his redemption, saving the family he once walked out on

red helm
#

Which ones do you have?

#

Huh... that's weird, are you should you've only done one map? THey usually only have 3 chests each...

safe torrent
red helm
#

Well... There is several, so I kind of need names...

safe torrent
red helm
#

There is a bunch of maps, way more than you need to finish Explorer 10.

#

Okay. Riggs station is due east of Strawberry, there is a Trapper just north of it. The guy with the Cursed Treasure map is on some large rocks in the Diablo bluffs(Think thats the name) north of the trapper.

#

He is just a encounter, You'll either have to rob him or kill him, for the map.

#

Then yeah the Poison trail map is where Flaco(The Gunslinger) is by that ice lake.

#

Collect the map, then find the treasure chests.

narrow jetty
#

Think about the development of John Marston. He was a terrible father and a terrible husband/boyfriend to abigail, pushing jack and Abigail away all the time, His ultimate Redemption wasn't just dying for his family, it was dying for the family he wronged before. That's the theme of both games. Both Arthur and John's fates were simultaneously punishment for the bad lives they lived and also the very things that redeemed them

#

Christ I love the whole story

red helm
#

Yeah, easy, as long as you know where to find the maps and where to go. If you don't use the internet,it can be a bit of a challenge.

hushed harbor
#

once u do em once its easy to remember the locations

red helm
#

Nah, After I found the map, I only used the internet once.

#

The treasure chest at the last point of the Poison trail map is in a odd spot, that I had to look up..... Meh

hidden moss
#

ya know whats even more weirder about the story? its that it genuinely made us care and sob about an outlaw at the end

hushed harbor
#

well, outlaws are human too