red-dead-singleplayer

[misty nebula]

he does not

[hushed geyser]

Alright

[visual rose]

flaco will pull out another gun

and act like a normal enemy

i think he will charge you with a knife if you do it again

calloway will die regardless of what you do

i'm talking about after disarming him

you also gain honor for each disarm you do

[misty nebula]

dam

didnt know you could

[visual rose]

he was sort of difficult to disarm if i remember it correctly

[hushed geyser]

It's been a while since I duelled though

And I can't win against Mr midnight

[visual rose]

smash R2 for easy win

[hushed geyser]

I'm filling up the meter and I die

[visual rose]

if you don't wanna win the easy way

[hushed geyser]

I want to disarm him though

[visual rose]

don't try to fill the entire meter

[hushed geyser]

I tried that too

[visual rose]

i find it easier to disarm him before he crouches

[hushed geyser]

I pressed L2 and I pulled out my gun though

And accidently shot his face off

[visual rose]

oh lol

don't panic

there's no consequences if you fail

[hushed geyser]

I lost honor when I shot him

So Im reloading my save

[visual rose]

oh pain

i played before the lemat revolver and that pistol were added

are they any good?

[hidden moss]

Lemat is good but slow reload

[hushed geyser]

I still can't disarm him

He shoots me way too quickly

[hidden moss]

Idk if you can but try and use lemat shotgun mode

And just blast his arm

[visual rose]

you don't need to shoot his gun

only his hand maybe arm

[hidden moss]

Yeah i just used lemat shotgun

[hushed geyser]

I fill the meter up to max

But it doesn't give me time to even shoot him

[hidden moss]

Aim at his arm and spam r2 with the shotgun and no meter

[hushed geyser]

I don't have a shotgun on me

[hidden moss]

Do you have lemat

[hushed geyser]

I know how to do it now though

Oops I accidently shot his stomach

YES

I DID IT

I DISARMED HIM

I didn't even shoot his hand too

[visual rose]

nice

[dark stratus]

Anyway to get 144 cig cards no duplicates. I have roughly 3 of every cigarette card I already have

[misty nebula]

go to each location to gather them

[sinful hound]

Y'all still talking bout gunslingers?

[sinful hound]

Rdr2 map and find their location. It's always exact and it may take some time but you'll get em all. Just remember to sign up so you can mark locations as found

[candid walrus]

I've been meaning to get the cigarette cards >.>

[sinful hound]

They look cool

[crystal willow]

Who here has played Hunt Showdown?

I first played that game so when i played RDR2 i knew a lot about guns haha

[dark stratus]

Let's go finally did the smoking and other hobbies

turned in 8 sets

[sinful hound]

How hard was it? Was it fun?

[dark stratus]

Costed alot of money
It was fun to destroy 20 lemoyne raiders at shady bell for a few bucks and a cigarette card but other then that it was a lot of buying

Didn't want to put the money to waste

my next task looks is fisher of men

[sinful hound]

I find all my cig cards

I will try for 100% and I will do EVERYTHING aside gambler challenges

[dark stratus]

You do get your money back tho

they give you like a thousand dollars

[sinful hound]

I went around blackwater and found a couple

There was one on a roof

You can find secret spots that way lol

Found one in a chicken coop

[candid walrus]

I should really do the cig cards but I keep forgetting >.>

[dark stratus]

I've only found a handful of cigarette cards not bought

[sinful hound]

I like finding em because I wanna explore

Also I have like 7k atm so I don't wanna spend much

From the 15k I had I have 7k now and I still don't have everything

[dark stratus]

I had lots of money from treasure hunts and it's all going away

[sinful hound]

Well I did the treasure hunts too

[dark stratus]

I have about 12 stashed gold bars

after I found out you can make a camp and fast travel pretty much in every location I spedran the treasure hunts

[sinful hound]

I just sold them all xD

[dark stratus]

fast travel from arthur/john made camps alow you to fast travel and still keep camps

[sinful hound]

I didn't make a save before American venom tjo

I didn't understand what the load feature was so I just deleted every save like a idiot

[dark stratus]

I'm before the final mission as arthur rn

[sinful hound]

Now I'm stuck with evelyn miller

[dark stratus]

Who?

[sinful hound]

The writer

The one Dutch used to read

[dark stratus]

I literally don't remember any side characters names

[sinful hound]

He has a line of quests

You find him on a hill overlooking strawberry

[dark stratus]

Is it the gunslinger dood?

the book guy

[sinful hound]

No

Wait

[dark stratus]

G

[sinful hound]

G

[dark stratus]

good game

[devout niche]

Has anybody managed to use a windows macro to do cooking with some automation?

[dark stratus]

You could use an object

I used my toe before

[terse cape]

Pinkertons are pretty cool

[dark stratus]

What about the blueertons

[paper peak]

Silvertons

[dark stratus]

Blackertons

[paper peak]

Carillionertons

[candid walrus]

o-o

[nimble cosmos]

im kill micah 😄

[misty nebula]

good

[nimble cosmos]

he rat

[young ivy]

Can you save your game when your in guarma

[terse cape]

Yeah

[storm gate]

man

earning exp for moonshiner has to be the easiest thing ever

i earned level 20 in 2 days

doing my own deliveries

and moonshine story missions

[silver jungle]

sus

[devout niche]

Are the only night scented orchids over by the panthers in the south of rhodes?

[hidden moss]

why does rockstar like to show the characters of the Dutch gang as "revolutionaries"? we all know that they are villains but why insist on saying that all police officers in RDR 1 and 2 are racist? they claimed that edgar ross called native americans savages, then they said that Arthur and John were anti-racists, what was all that for? just to say that the protagonist is good and the civilization is bad?

[storm gate]

probavbly to give a politically correct story

idk

[hidden moss]

its cringe

[hidden moss]

The only non-racist policeman in rdr 1 is that sheriff in armadillo, but they made it VERY CLEAR that he hated the FBI, so it's kind of the game saying that civilization "corrupts" society, or something like that

[storm gate]

lmao

[prime estuary]

it was how it was back then

not everybody was racist but a lot of people were and still are

[hidden moss]

it wasn't that way either, they exaggerate too much, they showed as if every citizen who wanted modernization needed to hate natives

[deft wharf]

i mean you are almost done

[prime estuary]

they more wanted to assimilate for some others want them to go

[deft wharf]

i won't spoil anything

[hidden moss]

What?

[prime estuary]

force them to join our culture and live in our way of life

[devout niche]

When killing a bird for the plumes is it ever possible to get more than one plume per kill?

[upper fox]

im trying to show my custom made arthur morgan cig card in red dead media but the bot wont let me 😦

[north swan]

You can post image files in #red-dead-media or #red-dead-fashion

[upper fox]

i know but discord has hiccups atm

so it wont let me post it in the media channels

[devout niche]

Do you gain anything, information or otherwise, from having a lady help bathe you?

[grizzled sapphire]

Pretty sure, other than obv filling cores an putting a smile on Arthur's face, there's no gain.

[scenic oak]

Anyone know how to get the blackwater farrier outfit as Arthur in pc?

[devout niche]

You get extra cores filled if you get "help"? I thought maybe eventually one of the helpers might share a robbery tip

[hidden moss]

is rdr 1 divided in 3 history parts?

1--New austin
2-Mexico
3-Blackwater

[native willow]

4

Beechers Hope

[undone maple]

Um I want to ask that can you upgrade your bag when you play as john? If no,wat is the recipe of the best bag and how to get guarma animal matirials after you leave guarma

[gilded bramble]

Dutch's Mustache is glorious.

[thin girder]

Dose Arthur die he’s my fav character

[undone maple]

[undone maple]

Yes

[thin girder]

Lol nice joke

[hidden moss]

[worldly turret]

[thin girder]

No

[native willow]

[worldly turret]

[thin girder]

No you ya twat no one loves

🤴

[worldly turret]

i mean, you're not wrong

last person that told me they loved me lied

[thin girder]

Lol

Sucks to suck

[native willow]

[hidden moss]

that part is pretty much irrelevant

[native willow]

You asked a question and got an answer

[hidden moss]

what is the best pistoll in rdr1?

[hidden moss]

yes

[native willow]

The game is broken up into 4 chapters it doesn’t matter how short the last one is

[hidden moss]

oh now i undearsteand

[hidden moss]

so theres 3 main chapters, and the last one that is short?

[native willow]

Yes, and a short epilogue mission as Jack

[hidden moss]

I honestly think that Jack wouldn’t kill Ross if he hadn’t been so arrogant, for example if Ross said:

Boy, I was obliged to kill his father. It was not my choice.

and of course if he was less of an idiot and treated jack with respect

[native willow]

No, jack hates the government for what they did to his family, he’d still kill ross

[hidden moss]

I think if Ross had at least apologized or something, he could at least have lived a little longer

[native willow]

Jack is good at hiding how he feels In that mission but Ross clearly draws out how he truly feels

I disagree

Jack would kill the man who was responsible for his fathers death no matter what

John was betrayed, there’s no way to spin it where Jack isn’t pissed

[hidden moss]

I don't understand why Jack hates the government, it depends a lot on the Player, of course he hates Ross, but what if the player decides to play as a "man of law" following orders and helping the police

[native willow]

Also Jack killing Ross, looking at his gun somewhat in disgust/contempt and walking away is a fantastic ending

...the government killed his fucking dad dude

Why would he not hate them

You really don’t get this lmao

It’s not that deep

[hidden moss]

I wrote it wrong, Jack has reason to hate the government, but what if the player decides to help the government? after all you can complete 100% in the game without killing ANY innocent, it will only be WELL difficult

[native willow]

Tf does that even mean

You can do whatever you want, but the canon ending is jack killing Ross

I don’t understand why you ask these questions

[hidden moss]

I’m saying that Jack’s more likely to hate Ross than ALL the US government

[native willow]

Sure, I’m not acting like Jack is gonna become a dedicated anti government terrorist hell bent on destroying it, but it’s not like he’s gonna have anything to do with them

They used his father, and killed him. It’s not like Ross single handidly ordered John’s death

Many government officials would be involved with that

[hidden moss]

yes

[native willow]

Why would Jack have much love or respect for them

[hidden moss]

I seriously wonder if Jack would kill Ross if instead of sending Ross to kill John they send that sheriff in armadillo

[native willow]

They Wouldn’t send a sheriff to execute John

They sent a shit load of soldiers and government agents

That scenario just isn’t plausible

[hidden moss]

whatever, what would happen, just tell me that

[native willow]

No, go think up or write your own fan fiction bro

[hidden moss]

what do you think would happen if the sheriff in armadillo went with several government men to kill john?

[native willow]

Idc about what ifs

[north swan]

Says the person who made a giant "What if" scenario.

[native willow]

outside of something like an undead nightmare 2 which would be non canon anyway, when did i do that lol

well, anyways

is there a good reason to use schofields over cattlemans

didn't see much of a reason in my first playthrough

although they sound pretty nice

[mental hinge]

schofields do more damage at the cost of reload speed

they're also a lot more accurate

[native willow]

I’ll keep that in mind

They’re pretty guns

But I can never bring myself to bling out guns in this game

Just doesn’t really feel like Arthur or John would run around with gold guns

Actually Arthur’s gold/engraved double action is pretty nice

[gilded bramble]

i agree

[native willow]

I usually use blackened steel, iron or silver

Blued steel is pretty clean too

[crystal olive]

What’s the best horse I can get in chapter 6 rn I have a black Arabian

[mental hinge]

bad idea to get a horse in chapter 6 since you lose all of your horses at the end of chapter 6

but a turkoman, arabian and missouri fox trotter are one of the best choices

[crimson bronze]

Circling back just a little bit, anyone else find it just a little odd that the US. Marshal Outfit kinda looks like Jack's Rancher outfit from 1911?

[pine cipher]

I guess, the vest looks around the same

[crimson bronze]

I think it's a bit of the general look of it coupled with the vest, Yeah.

[hushed geyser]

you really asking for a horse IN CHAPTER 6?

[jade copper]

[native willow]

[dark stratus]

Buell best horse

It is the rarest horse

[sinful hound]

<644694680055054362>

OKthen

Howdy everyone

[dark stratus]

Lemat, Dynamite arrow, molotov

[sinful hound]

Hmmm

Cattleman+Lemat next play thru

[hidden moss]

I like gold on my pistol

[hidden moss]

Bruh I lost it in 5 mins

[undone maple]

Um how to found guarma animals in main island

[sinful hound]

Go around the camp, near the water

You should find the birds

Note that the guarma animals aren't necessary for 100% I think

[undone maple]

Um lizards?

[sinful hound]

The green iguana things?

You can find them outside guarma too

[undone maple]

Um I mean back to lamoren

[sinful hound]

Huh

Lamoren?

[undone maple]

Yes

There a place to found

them

but idk where

[sinful hound]

You can find most of them around the river

Just look around

[undone maple]

Ok

thx

[sinful hound]

I found the 2 birds there, the lizards too, and the snakes

Nw

[hidden moss]

do yo need all animals in the compendium for 100%?

or like ~40

[worldly gulch]

@undone maple the biggest island in flat iron lake next to clemens point, the chapter 3 camp, has lots of iguanas as it is a static spawn location

[sinful hound]

Yup. Wanted to say that too

[worldly gulch]

Also good spot for turtles, muskrat and raccoons

[undone maple]

Ok thx

[random sedge]

All

[worldly gulch]

Do you? Cause on the total progress checklist in the progress menu it says it completes at 50 i believe

[hidden moss]

ye

[crystal olive]

Yeah Ik that the horse dies but my other one died before I could use a reviver

[sacred thistle]

Legend Of The East Outfit

I'm doubting everything I've done til this point

on my 4th playthrough of the story, I start to focus on the challenges as early as chapter two.
Apparently, the game requires you to go to New Austin for a couple of these challenges and I doubt that can be done with Arthur, I'll have to play it til the end and get the Outfit with John, it's pretty stupid.

[candid walrus]

yeah its kinda annoying

[visual rose]

can you still go to new austin as arthur in the current patch?

i want to see arthur using that outfit

and herbalist 9 ain't gonna stop me

[candid walrus]

not sure

[visual rose]

there was a glitch with a chapter 4 mission that let you just walk into new austin as arthur

otherwise there's an invisible sniper

that one shots you

if you go too far

same thing in guarma if you try to go literally anywhere :/

[mental hinge]

the glitch has been patched

[visual rose]

sad

[mental hinge]

u can use an alternative method using a covered chuck wagon

legend of the east as arthur is still possible

though it's rather difficult

dinosaur bones is also possible

[visual rose]

covered chuck wagon

all legendary fish possible?

[mental hinge]

i dont think so

[visual rose]

why not?

[mental hinge]

since u have to be off ur wagon for too long to get it

the method revolves around using a certain camera angle in order for the wagon to cover arthur's head

[visual rose]

damn that sucks

[mental hinge]

once he gets off to pick flowers or inspect bones, u have to make sure the wagon cover is still covering him

[visual rose]

wasn't there also a method where you could use the valentine cornwall shootout mission

in chapter 2

[mental hinge]

using the buggies in st denis give u a lesser chance of being shot

[visual rose]

to get into new austin

[mental hinge]

but its not worth it since st denis and new austin are too far apart and the buggy is too brittle

[mental hinge]

havent heard of it

[visual rose]

i heard of it once

where you use the final part

where you have to escape the lawmen with wanted dead or alive

you can just stay wanted and go to new austin

then maybe when the mission ends the sniper won't be there to annoy you

maybe i will test it out

[worldly gulch]

I'm kinda disappointed there isn't more to do in NA with John. Apart from the few new things to collect, some legendary animals and a few bounties I think that's pretty much it right? Huge area of the map which just feels underused

Could have done with a couple more sadie missions or smth at least

[visual rose]

the west of the map is def underused in singleplayer but i think that's by design

though i really never feel encouraged to go to NA

as john at least

there just isn't much going on in there

[sinful hound]

Tbh j just go there for thieves landing and the challenges

It's bland

[strange dragon]

I wish you could go there as Arthur

[visual rose]

same

[strange dragon]

There are two outfits that I want to wear as Arthur but I can't since it is only available in tumbleweed

[visual rose]

i did some research, even if you manage to get all legendary fish as arthur the mission only shows up in the epilogue

legend of the east is arthur's outfit

i also kind of wish you could get john to have his 1899 hairstyle in epilogue

[strange dragon]

We do have it in one cut scene

[brave dagger]

What cutscene

I can’t remember

Sed

[visual rose]

even if that meant making it so there's hairstyles exclusive to arthur and other hairstyles exclusive to john which would be kinda sad for creating cursed images

[strange dragon]

I heard R* first started working on the epilogue so there is no reason why we shouldn't have it

[visual rose]

i saw a video that had john using that hairstyle in epilogue and it looks amazing

[strange dragon]

When John writes a letter to his ho, there is a cut scene of John and Charles looking up at the house and if you look at John's head his og hairstyle is there

[brave dagger]

Right

[visual rose]

i wonder if NA was an idea added late into development or if the devs just forgot/didn't bother fleshing it out

[brave dagger]

Idk

Ask rocksta- wait

They’re watching us

Every. Single. Move we do.

[visual rose]

D:

[strange dragon]

I like killing Del Lobos and shooting up both towns and fort mercer

[brave dagger]

I love going to fort mercer

[visual rose]

i remember rampaging armadillo

[brave dagger]

Just kill a buncha Del Lobos, boom free fort for you

[brave dagger]

Saaaaame

[visual rose]

targeting everyone who looked sick

[strange dragon]

I went to Armadillo then took the same path John takes in rdr1 to fort mercer

[brave dagger]

I have probably rampaged every city in the game tho

[visual rose]

i tried to get a bunch of people in that hole so i could throw a molotov in it with them in but that didn't worrk

i don't think i ever rampaged strawberry

every other city tho

[strange dragon]

I mean you have to

[brave dagger]

Blessed are the meek so they say

[strange dragon]

You don't have a choice

[visual rose]

van horn and saint denis especially

[brave dagger]

Well there was that one time where you got that rat out of jail

Idk how he couldn’t escape tho

[visual rose]

oh yeah

[brave dagger]

Rats are tiny

[visual rose]

he's too dumb

to even consider trying that

[brave dagger]

Idk why, but when i wear a bandana it becomes an 80$ bounty instead of 300$ in that mission

Either that or i kill less lawmen

[visual rose]

he wants his cheese back but of course he needs arthur to babysit him

[brave dagger]

Cause I remember in my first playthrough i got a 300$ bounty

[visual rose]

i always try to wear bandanas in crime missions

but lawmen recognize you on sight

somehow

[torn oar]

I always forget to put on my bandanna and I've k Ly been caught like 2 times

[strange dragon]

I still don't understand how Arthur gets recognized when going into Blackwater if you make his hair and beard look different wear a mask and a new set of clothes

[visual rose]

harbalist challenges are my least favorite

i prefer gambler challenges over them

[brave dagger]

Ikr

Unless they have control of the KGB and MI6 which is very unlikely

[visual rose]

exactly

[strange dragon]

It is also funny how even if you pay your bounty you will still get attacked but if you pay your bounty for other places then you are all good and nothing happens the next time you walk into that town

[brave dagger]

Except EVERYONE hating you

Or constantly saying: “Don’t cause trouble or you’re dead mothafucka”

[strange dragon]

yeah but it will still allow you to go in and get some stuff

[brave dagger]

Yeah

UNLESS

It’s on lockdown

[strange dragon]

yeah

[brave dagger]

New goal

Get a max bounty everywhere and have every single town in lockdown

Doable?

Idk

[strange dragon]

And the invisible sniper when you get pass the lawmen and shit is bs

We should be rewarded for getting pass the lawmen, just let us walk around NA

[visual rose]

funny how the pinkertons still keep their super soldiers in blackwater

during chapter 6

which is after the saint denis bank robbery

[strange dragon]

You can free roam up to Thieves landing but if you go pass that then you are done

[visual rose]

which is claimed to be worse than the blackwater one

[brave dagger]

Yeah

[strange dragon]

I mean it was

I think so at least

[dark stratus]

I hate how legend of the east arthur is blocked off by some dumbass sniper

4 herbs are heavily guarded

[strange dragon]

And Otis Miller revolver

[dark stratus]

otis miller is just a schofield?

[visual rose]

it's time for all of us give herbalist 9 and the blackwater/guarma sniper a fuck you

fuck you

[brave dagger]

For you Mr. Van Winkle? Yes. For Hosea? Yes. For Lenny? Yes. For Dutch? Oh no

[dark stratus]

is van winkle dead

[brave dagger]

Arrested

[dark stratus]

So rest in peace van winkle

[strange dragon]

Nah he was left behind in Rhodes while trying to find a place to piss

[brave dagger]

Hey you @strange dragon you look like Jim Milton

[visual rose]

he was never seen after the first time he was seen

[strange dragon]

I have a screenshot of him

[dark stratus]

Try marston, john marston

[strange dragon]

Jhon

[dark stratus]

Jhoooooon made it

[strange dragon]

No that was Jim Milton

[brave dagger]

“John Marston.”
”JOOOOOOOOOHN MAAAAAARRRRRSTOOOOON.”
Nope. Nothing here

[dark stratus]

Winkleeeeeeee made it

hes the only one

[strange dragon]

nah he lives in Rhodes

[dark stratus]

Ok nvm

[brave dagger]

You also look like a fella that killed a dude out by Roanoke

Hmmmmm

[strange dragon]

Pearson killed John

[brave dagger]

GASP

WOT

[strange dragon]

he needed more meat

[visual rose]

even in online new austin feels empty

that's one of those moments where you wish the devs had more time

and that their budget was bigger

[dark stratus]

Story mode is better then online

[visual rose]

yes

much better

lol

[dark stratus]

What is it gambler 8 that's the crap challenge

Win 3 blackjacks in a row doubling down

[visual rose]

yeah

[dark stratus]

in a row

[visual rose]

about blackjack

anyone noticed that you can't go above 15

in money you get i think

i forgot what it was but trying to get above 15 on something is impossible

[dark stratus]

I wish we can go on a river boat in free roam

Actually idk

I just want a high stakes poker game

Without having to replay fine night

[visual rose]

yeah

[dark stratus]

Rdo gambling sounds interesting tho

I can imagine sore losers just throwing a molotov on the table

[candid walrus]

lol

[brave dagger]

Finally

After so many years

I got a stache

Well

Part of one

I goin be like Teddy Roosevelt

[viral flicker]

i have an unknown collectible its above cigarette card sets. anyone know what chapter i get that one at?

[candid walrus]

i think it might be the graves

not exactly sure

[rigid nacelle]

here's a tip

NEVER insult a man in the factory area of saint denis

i've done it many times and i just had a bunch of factory workers beat me up

[candid walrus]

O_O

[rigid nacelle]

like they ALL turn against you

[candid walrus]

dang

-map becomes a sea of red dots-

[rigid nacelle]

i just beat up like 10 guys

and more guys just ran torwards me

they kept comin at me

[candid walrus]

oop

[worldly gulch]

Yeah I remember accidentally bumping into a worker with my horse trying to get it to stop and got rounded up by 4 of the bastards

[candid walrus]

o-o

[rigid nacelle]

i just did the smoothest train robbery ever

basically i jumped on the train

knocked out the only two guards on the train

so in the end i didn't kill them

robbed all of the people

then jumped off the train, THEN they woke up

and i was long gone

nobody knew it was me and no police came

no casualties

[candid walrus]

nice

[visual rose]

Damn that's clean

[visual rose]

I remember doing that and i ended up beating the whole factory up

Just barely survived

One of the workers was a big guy who was tough to take down

I tried to do it afain

Again*

And the law gets involved every time now :L

[hidden moss]

just gonna throw this out here but I'm so tired of "Micah bad" jokes it's painfully unfunny at this point man

[rigid nacelle]

man those factory workers don't mess around

micah bad

[hidden moss]

Micah bad

Micah greasy

[visual rose]

if i had to guess how many guys there were

it would be around 17

i saw a video of someone doing it too

but the fight lasted so long

some guys woke up

and got right back into the fight

[rigid nacelle]

LOL

[visual rose]

it was metal as fuck

[upper fox]

micah was bad

[rigid nacelle]

is*

[visual rose]

yeah i don't mind them nowadays but i can't find them funny anymore atleast 99% of the time

[upper fox]

unless its a original joke

[visual rose]

yeah

[rigid nacelle]

agreed

i just said micah bad to tease you

[worldly gulch]

You run a heist like that then you simply can't have a pfp of mr. Dutch

[rigid nacelle]

i like my pfp tho

[upper fox]

dutch is happy

[worldly gulch]

Yeah but he don't do smooth plans though

[rigid nacelle]

that's true

but if you need a plan he's yo man

either way he gets it done lol

[worldly gulch]

Like, Dutch would plan everything to the second and his horses ankle would break or smth

[upper fox]

hosea has the best and smooth plans

[rigid nacelle]

i don't remember if it was hosea or trelawney

but arthur did con a stagecoach

[visual rose]

that valentine robbery can go really smooth if you do things right

but it's not planned by dutch

[upper fox]

hosea and arthur has a real estate scam before chapter 1?

[rigid nacelle]

the valentine robbery was the best in terms of money

[visual rose]

the coach robbery with trewlawny might be the smoothest robbery in the game

[upper fox]

prob

[rigid nacelle]

nononono

you forgot the time at the poker table in that boat

[upper fox]

yeah that was best for sure

[rigid nacelle]

they stole everything, there was a firefight but arthur was never identified

[upper fox]

no one died and it was succesfull

[rigid nacelle]

like most robberies

[worldly gulch]

Smoothest robbery was the one with hosea

[visual rose]

oh yeah

there's that too

there's many smooth robberies

[rigid nacelle]

and all these weren't planned by dutch

so if we remove dutch

[visual rose]

none of them involve dutch or micah

[rigid nacelle]

and make hosea the leader

then the van der linde gang could of gone to tahiti

[visual rose]

but to be fair

the chapter 1 train robbery

[upper fox]

was cool too

[visual rose]

it wasn't dutch's fault that it didn't go smooth

[upper fox]

i like the ferry job better

[worldly gulch]

Yeah arthur fucked the train robbery up

[visual rose]

yeah

[upper fox]

goddamn bill

[visual rose]

though

[upper fox]

ruined it

[rigid nacelle]

but dutch didn't listen to hoseas warning

[visual rose]

can really any robbery that involves massive shootouts go smooth

[rigid nacelle]

which is why the pinkertons were after them besides the blackwater massacre

[worldly gulch]

Nah Bill set the charges right, arthur messed up with hooking them up to the detonator

[visual rose]

though to be rude to bill

he could have shot the dinamite

[rigid nacelle]

if they never robbed cornwall's train the pinkertons wouldn't have chased them

[visual rose]

yeah

[rigid nacelle]

leviticus had the pinkertons chase the gang

[visual rose]

but the robbery itself wasn't too bad compared to others

[rigid nacelle]

but they would still be hot in the water because of the massacre back in blackwater

[upper fox]

if they didnt rob anything it would've changed the entire story...

[visual rose]

i bet that arthur and hosea scam in blackwater would go amazingly well

to the point dutch would have no excuses left

to keep the madness going

[upper fox]

micah prob was a rat before the game. micah had dutch's his bounty poster at the camp he was after he escaped from the strawberry sheriffs office.

[visual rose]

unless the canon arthur is the one that screwed up every screwable robbery

[rigid nacelle]

i don't think micah was a rat before guarma

[visual rose]

lol

[rigid nacelle]

but i DO think he was plan on betraying them all along

[visual rose]

i'm still debating on who could be the rat

[upper fox]

why would he have dutch his bounty poster

[rigid nacelle]

in his camp after breaking him out

[rigid nacelle]

yeah

[worldly gulch]

Agreed, I think Milton spoke the truth about this

[rigid nacelle]

micah doesn't have to be a rat to turn dutch in

a rat means he's simply the informant in this case

[visual rose]

well that's only found in the epilogue iirc

[rigid nacelle]

maybe he wasn't workin for the pinkertons but to me he always had plans to turn em in

[upper fox]

no it can be found immidiantly after micah left that camp

[rigid nacelle]

you can even say that micah let john get arrested

or had a role

[visual rose]

what the fuck

[rigid nacelle]

because john had a bounty

[visual rose]

arthur you dumbass

[rigid nacelle]

don't call my boah a dumbass

call karen a dumbass when your riding to camp

[visual rose]

lol

[upper fox]

i can go back to my chapter 3 save and still find that scrap piece of dutch his bounty poster

[rigid nacelle]

karen:"who is it?!

arthur: it's arthur you DUMBASS

[hidden moss]

Why do people roleplay here

[rigid nacelle]

because people nerds

[visual rose]

i had arthur say that line once to sadie

felt out of character lol

[hidden moss]

Roleplay something interesting like space aliens vs cowboys

[visual rose]

since unless you antagonize her i don't think you ever see arthur insult her like that

[strange dragon]

i like that line the best when he says it to bill or john

[visual rose]

yeah it feels made for bill or john

does trewlanwy even have events in the camp

i really rarely see him there

especially at chapter 4

where does he even sleep

[worldly gulch]

Just that one stagecoach I think in chapter 3

[visual rose]

seeing him in camp is like the only moment you can see him wearing that red coat too iirc

[worldly gulch]

Does make me laugh everytime arthur calls him slippier than an eel in an oil slick

[visual rose]

that's the antagonize dialogue?

damn i'm missing out

[worldly gulch]

Nah he says that as part of the stagecoach mission dialogue

[visual rose]

i remember seeing a theory about trewlanwy being the rat

honestly makes a whole lot of sense

[worldly gulch]

Best antagonize from arthur I remember him doing was howdy madam, you remind me of a lady I once knew. Yeah, I loved that horse

[visual rose]

god yes

i love that

those greet then antagonize

[candid walrus]

i like the one where he goes
"howdy there ladies"
"nice of the asylum to let you folk out for a bit"

[worldly gulch]

Or when John goes why don't you go back in that hole you crawled out of, or aren't you welcome there anymore either

[candid walrus]

LOL

[visual rose]

i remember antagonizing someone as drunk arthur

[hushed geyser]

How tf do I trigger the secret jail breakout scenes

[visual rose]

then apologizing

arthur just said

"i love you"

[candid walrus]

I-

[hushed geyser]

#red-dead-media

[visual rose]

lol

[serene shoal]

People were talking about some boring ass shite in another chat so I came here

[bright sparrow]

I hate dutch

And I like him at the same time

[serene shoal]

It was something about “stride” or something

[sinful hound]

That's everyone

[serene shoal]

Micah is a good character, people hate him so much. Just like the actor planned. Same with Dutch, they both made people kinda like them then turned around and made everybody hate them, tbh I quite liked Micah until I found out he was the rat.... thanks Reddit

[hidden moss]

i always hated most of the criminnals

[crystal willow]

Hi everyone

Hate Micah as much as you want, but his outfits were amazing

[clever scarab]

hi

[daring yarrow]

Micah was an amazing revolver shooter

[crystal olive]

I’m starting to regret buying a 1000$ horse in chapter 6

[candid walrus]

😬

[silk current]

oof

[hidden moss]

Not in American venom

[native willow]

Micah had drip

[grizzled sapphire]

I want his horse

[dark stratus]

I want overweight john

[worldly gulch]

I want to buy Sadie a new horse, Hera just looks diseased

[native willow]

It’s blursed

John is fat and has a thicc mustache on my first save

I made him look like Mario

[dark stratus]

Red hat?

[native willow]

Nah, but he had strong Italian plumber energy

[worldly gulch]

Mango Mia

[golden vector]

he missed like the first 20 shots when john was 3 meters away from him in american venom tho lol

[reef lake]

i've been to prison on multiple occasions and i only had like one cut scene

[keen breach]

just go to lake issebella and get the snow horse

i forgot the name

but thats what i got

[worldly gulch]

X on xbox I believe

Same but i use controller kek

[keen breach]

oh that might help me in the future if its buggin im on pc too

im in chapter 4

whats the big city harbor called???

saint sum

[worldly gulch]

I've no idea what the keyboard default is, try pressing all of them xD

Denis

[keen breach]

saint denis is where im at

currently

[north swan]

Probably E

Maybe R

[keen breach]

im just after we got the boat to rob the harbor

but we havent robbed it yet

oh no wait

i dont remember

we might be rolling up on that italian guys mansion

[worldly gulch]

Ah yes Emily Bronte

[keen breach]

emily?

i swear that wasnt his first name

[worldly gulch]

Kek she was a famous author

Angelo

[keen breach]

ah yes

rdr2 story is straight fire

[north swan]

and that's a fact

I've said it before, I'll say it again, we need story-mode dlc, mexico, canada, SOMETHING.

[keen breach]

im not even past the first story

im in chapter 4 ;-;

[north swan]

I've been replaying and I'm also on chapter 4.

[keen breach]

ah

i see

can you answer a question for me then rq

i forgot what we are doing in this mission

i just picked up the boat from those people out in the swamp and we got the boat to either rob the harbor or roll up on angelo bronte for setting us up

but i cant remember which one

[north swan]

you use the boat to pull up on bronte

[keen breach]

thank god

hes a bitch

[north swan]

All I'm gonna say is that there are bigger ones.

[keen breach]

bigger bitches?

[north swan]

You'll agree with me later on in the story.

[keen breach]

ah

alright

[north swan]

Way bigger bitches.

[keen breach]

LOL

i hated how stuck up and condescending ole angelo bronte was at the party

[north swan]

Shame that dutch & crew didn't really notice either since they don't speak italian.

[keen breach]

for real

no subtitles for the italian either

so i had no idea what they were talking about

[north swan]

"They've bathed for the first time this month, no doubt." "Now that they've left, bring out the good wine." "I'm looking forward to watching you all die." etc. Cocky bastard of a character, but very well played.

Those are all things he had said in italian.

[keen breach]

tell me you didnt remember that off the top of your head

[north swan]

No I definitely did.

[keen breach]

wow

im impressed

actually

[north swan]

Did the mission only a couple days ago.

[keen breach]

oh so your ahead of me?

so you are in chapter 4

[north swan]

No, he said that all at the party.

[keen breach]

oh right i think after the party is chapter 4

[north swan]

I finished robbing the trolley and haven't played since.

[keen breach]

OH

right right

[sinful hound]

The things he says when first meeting him are

Who are these clowns

Then his guard says, They come for the boy

Then Bronte, with the money?

[keen breach]

shoutout to john for causing this mess

john rlly lost his kid tho

like

[north swan]

Shoutout to Catherine Brathwaite for giving Jack to Bronte.

[keen breach]

oh yeah thats true

[north swan]

John is a better father in rdr1

[keen breach]

never played 1

just 2

[sinful hound]

Shoutout to John for "letting fly on those sobs"

[north swan]

Me neither, but I've watched so many playthroughs I might as well have.

[keen breach]

is rdr1 and rdr2 chronological?

[north swan]

rdr1 takes place after rdr2

[keen breach]

so yes they are chronological

[native willow]

Yeah, although he and Jack still struggle to connect sadly

Their relationship is interesting

[north swan]

But play them in either order and it'll make sense either way.

[native willow]

Ye

[north swan]

Definitely.

[keen breach]

hes the baby daddy who hasnt seen his kid in awhile so its mad awkward

[native willow]

Jack is probably one of the saddest characters in the franchise imo

[north swan]

I hated hearing Jack call John "Sir" all the time instead of dad.

[keen breach]

on a unrelated note

what does "imo" mean

LOL

i feel like i should know this

[native willow]

In my opinion

[keen breach]

oh

then im actually not suprised i didnt know that

didnt realize their was an abbreviation for it

[north swan]

My rdr2 is redownloading :/ I'm gonna be waiting a while.

[keen breach]

didnt you say you played a few days ago?

why would it not be installed a few days later

lol

[north swan]

Yeah, I keep turning off my PC before I fully close it and it causes some error so steam has to redownload the files.

But it's way faster than the initial install.

[keen breach]

oh your just verifying riles

files*

[north swan]

The install took me like 7 hours, redownloading files and such takes like half an hour.

Halfway done, too.

[keen breach]

my internet is pretty fast

[sinful hound]

Rdr2 took 1/4 of my ps4 storage lmfao

[keen breach]

i got 2tb ssd

and 1tb hdd

0-o

[north swan]

I've got like 600 GB left B)

[sinful hound]

Damn

Gg

[keen breach]

pc tins

tings

[north swan]

Mhm

[sinful hound]

I've had 1tb of storage but my HD got burnt so they had to make it less

[north swan]

ooooooof

[sinful hound]

Now I have 480gb lol

[keen breach]

just get a external usb Toshiba hdd

[north swan]

Just sliced it and half and spat on your storage.

[sinful hound]

But they installed a sd card so at least it won't happen soon again

[keen breach]

also wdym it "burnt"

[sinful hound]

I wish they just threw the PS away

[keen breach]

like wtf

them consoles overheating

[north swan]

Yeah

[sinful hound]

I couldn't access my storage

Didnt really burn

Lol

I couldn't do anything

Ce-something

I couldn't access storage for some reason

[keen breach]

if your warranty assumingly expired there's no point in leaving the warranty screws in i would have just did some diy fixes

[sinful hound]

Tough being 15 and parents not caring at all

[keen breach]

watchu mean

[sinful hound]

I think they would have just thrown the PS away

They hate me playing

They almost forbid me using social media

[keen breach]

wtf

[sinful hound]

They think that people can hack me only by me saying hello

[north swan]

I don't have a credit card and my parents hate me playing, too, so I have to pay friends so they'll buy a game and gift me it.

[keen breach]

awwww damnnn

not those kinda parents

who think

[sinful hound]

tHeY cAn fInD yoUr nAmE aNd adDrEsss

[keen breach]

yeah LOL

[sinful hound]

Never talk to strangers

[keen breach]

im 15 as well so

i feel that

[north swan]

I know, they think you can say that your name is john and they'll nuke your entire neighborhood.

[keen breach]

but my parents arewnt like that

my parents are mad chill

[sinful hound]

Wtf I can't even talk to people irl just lemme be with internet people for a minute

[sinful hound]

And then they'll end up in prison because of me

[north swan]

mhm

[sinful hound]

For some reason not even they understand

[north swan]

I've heard that one before.

[sinful hound]

I'm underage so they have to pay for my shit

But at least they leave me be sometimes

[keen breach]

thats how my grandparents used to be until i just had my pc for a few years then they caught on

but my mom and dad are very young for me being 15

so its not like they are oblivious

[sinful hound]

Maybe #general

We should prolly switch there

[keen breach]

eh

[north swan]

yeah, we moved off the topic of rdr2

[keen breach]

the chat gonna be mad flooded

[north swan]

On that topic, though, what's y'all's favorite weapon/loadout?

[keen breach]

in general

im rocking dual volcanic atm

[sinful hound]

Cattleman, Lancaster repeater, pump action

With da fisherman's hat

[north swan]

Pistols are great but I use dual wield scholingers just 'cause revolvers are cooler to quick draw with.

[sinful hound]

Scholingers

[keen breach]

lmfaoo

[sinful hound]

You mean Schofields?

[north swan]

Yeah, I dunno what I was thinking.

[sinful hound]

Hahaha

[north swan]

My blood is cherry diet coke

Give me some credit

[sinful hound]

I love the cattlemans because they're the og revolvers to me

I love the way they sound

[north swan]

Yeah, but the schofields are just statistically better.

[sinful hound]

But I currently use Otis Miller's and Boy Calloway's revolvers

[north swan]

I'll respect that.

I wish you could get both of the guns some characters have.

[sinful hound]

I hate Micahs revolvers for some reason

[keen breach]

idk if im that far into the game yet those names sound familier but im unsure if i have been given a chance to pick those up yet

[mental hinge]

cattlemans literally define the wild west lol i can see why some people use em despite average stats

[north swan]

I ain't gonna say any names because I know peytonieus hasn't finished the story but...

[sinful hound]

They r part of the gunslinger quests

[sinful hound]

Definitely, the long barrel is a bit too long tho

Otis' is not a part

OKthen

[hidden moss]

The way they shoot annoys me

[north swan]

I didn't say that.

[sinful hound]

I never even used them

[hidden moss]

They're just a worse double action

[sinful hound]

I love the engravings on boy's revolver

[north swan]

You just equip Micah's revolver and you can smell the rat shit on it.

[keen breach]

theres a whole "fuck micah" thing??

[sinful hound]

#red-dead-media

[keen breach]

hmmmm spoiler???

[sinful hound]

Nah

Micah is weird in general

He is very hateable

[mental hinge]

micah is an example of the chaotic good character

[north swan]

There's a fuck arthur, and a fuck dutch

[sinful hound]

I mean, he technically, TECHNICALLY, is a good guy

[north swan]

and a fuck john

[mental hinge]

exactly

in one perspective he's the hero of the story

[nimble cosmos]

yes

[mental hinge]

he is just a total asshole

[hidden moss]

And that is a huge huge huge huge technically

[sinful hound]

He even said he's "a survivor"

He'll switch sides to stay alive

Not like it helped him but ok

[crystal olive]

I deeply regret buying an Arabian halfway through chapter 6

[sinful hound]

God due

[north swan]

Yeah

[sinful hound]

Dude

Bruh

[hidden moss]

Oh god

[crystal olive]

It’s my first time

[sinful hound]

What

[hidden moss]

That guy buying an arabian in ch6

[sinful hound]

Ah

[crystal olive]

Rip frank

[north swan]

The word "survivor" gives me flash backs to Micah yelling "I'm a survivor, black lung! That's all there is, winning... and losing."

I named all my horses Ace or Spades or Poker.

[sinful hound]

Yes, that's why I put it on "" 's

I like how he says it too

[crystal olive]

Well I just thought I’d tell you cause I paused my game when frank died and I wanna finish this mission

Idk what’s gonna happen

[north swan]

birds pull up and kill everyone

big beak bitches

[crystal olive]

Ah shit

[mint swan]

hi guys, one quick question. is there a limit on how many hats can you save in the wardrobe?

or how many stolen hats can you save?

[north swan]

Nope, only on how many fit on your horse.

[mental hinge]

there is

[north swan]

Oh really?

[mental hinge]

only certain stolen hats can be stored to your wardrobe

not every hat you can pick up gets saved

you can identify a saveable hat if it's glowing on the ground

[mint swan]

ye, but is there a limit on how many hats can i save in the wardrobe?

[mental hinge]

lol

[arctic wren]

Wish I could use Hamish’s hat 😔

[mental hinge]

yes

[north swan]

might want to press L, and abandon the mission to retry from the checkpoint.

Might be glitched

[arctic wren]

Try punch her

Might fail the mission

[devout niche]

Anybody know a secret spot for spoonbills?

I need 5 more and they are scarce

[crystal olive]

What does the deer mean

Arthur died and I got a deer cutscene

[devout niche]

@hidden moss did you get to the part where you go on the boat in the lake?

Maybe a bug

[north swan]

Press L. Alt, what does it say is the next part in the mission?

hmm

Screenshare in a VC.

Try steering the boat around, or taking it out further from land.

Hmph.

[devout niche]

Sounds bugged 🙂

[north swan]

You tried reloading the latest autosave?

[devout niche]

Have you reload..... ^^

[north swan]

I didn't want the nitro anyways, you didn't have to delete everything you said to hide it.

Makin' me seem like a crazy person talking to myself.

[arctic wren]

High honour

Good job

[mint swan]

hi, i have a question. if i buy the trapper's gambler equipment, wich give the player a bost in the stamina, will the bost remain in the player no matter if i wear the bandolier, holster and such? or i have the wear them so the bost remain active?

pardon my english, isnt my main language

[mint swan]

wich animal shows if you finish with low honor?

[arctic wren]

I think it’s a wolf or coyote, I’m not sure

Never had a low honour playthrough

[north swan]

It's a coyote.

[mental hinge]

yeah iit's a coyote

[arctic wren]

Thanks

[crystal olive]

Now I’m playing as John this is sick

[arctic wren]

Just wait until American venom

[crystal olive]

Is that at chapter 2 of epilogue?

At the end?

[worldly gulch]

i know the woman who's looking for donations in saint denis tells you you get your name memorialised if you do but until now i hadn't actually realised Arthur's name is in fact on the plaque

[undone maple]

No you don’t

but the bear claw one is the best

[rigid nacelle]

i'm listening to uh

some kid rant about a woman

throwing rocks

i shot him

i think he'll respawn

think i'm gonna reload the save

[undone maple]

Which kid?

Jack will throw rocks at Keran

[reef lake]

nite folk are so damn scary man

[undone maple]

Yes they are

so equip a sawed off in swamp

[reef lake]

i get scared to shoot the rope hanging up a body cuz i know they're gonna get me

[undone maple]

Equip a shotgun first

don’t aim

[mental hinge]

they're pretty easy to take down

i mean they just use knives

[undone maple]

and just press r2 torwards them

[reef lake]

ya they are but they still scare me

[chilly yoke]

i just began as john

lol

like what happened to all the gold i picked

ik arthur gave his shit to john

but its not in my inventory

[crystal olive]

What ending did u get Lito?

Luro*

[undone maple]

You will get those back later

[chilly yoke]

i got the one where i help john

i didnt go after the money

john dipped after arthur gives him his satchel

im tryna buy sum guns i look broke asf lmao

ik i got sum thousands in that satchel

@undone maple so i gotta keep doing the campiagn

[crystal olive]

But what cutscene did you get the coyote or the deer?

[chilly yoke]

oh shit

ummmmmmm

i think it was a coyote eating another coyote

thats what i saw

[hidden moss]

what happens if you are with "neutral honor" and make an ending?

[chilly yoke]

i had pretty bad honor

[crystal olive]

It goes to the closest region of honor

I don’t think it’s possible to have neutral honor

[heady oriole]

Is there anything to find in Guarma

Like an easter egg at least

[chilly yoke]

so i should keep doing the campaign to get my shit back? @crystal olive

[reef lake]

i had high honor both of my playthroughs but now i'm replaying it a 3rd time with low honor

but it's hard cuz i like being nice

[crystal olive]

Well it’s my first time doing it I’m at the same spot as you rn but You should keep playing it seems good don’t forget to equip Arthur’s hat

[heady oriole]

I never equipped arthur's hat in american venom

[chilly yoke]

wym arthurs hat

umm

[crystal olive]

Arthur gives John his hat in the last mission

[reef lake]

why not.... loser

[chilly yoke]

why should i equip it'

[heady oriole]

Because I decided not to

[crystal olive]

Idk just a nice hat

[reef lake]

u don't have to lol it was just my decision

[chilly yoke]

bruh lmao

[crystal olive]

Cause johns golf hat is ass