#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 362 of 1

native willow
#

He still dies if you don’t kill him as john

#

He gets executed

hidden moss
#

when I talk about the police I mean Ross and that skinny sidekick, how I liked that guy

upper fox
#

you dont see javier die on screen if you capture him alive tho

#

so thats why i said it was optional

native willow
hidden moss
hidden moss
native willow
#

Nah he’s def dead I don’t think there’s much room to debate

upper fox
#

jup

native willow
#

If they killed John they def hung Javier

upper fox
#

but it depends on the player, but both ways he dies

native willow
#

Yerp

upper fox
#

one way quicker then the other

native willow
#

I killed him

#

Javier is a dick in 1 lmao

upper fox
#

i captured him alive

#

true

#

i like rdr1 javier better

#

rdr1 story was very short tho

#

but it was great

native willow
#

Yeah it’s great

#

Glad I played it

upper fox
#

i played it on xbox 360 2 months ago and i was impressed how good of a game it was. It was definitly the best game of its time when it was released

native willow
#

It holds up surprisingly well

upper fox
#

After my exams im gonna play undead nightmare

native willow
#

Nice

#

It’s fun

#

Very short though

#

Unless you go for everything

upper fox
#

I was kinda expecting that compared to the main story

hidden moss
#

i dont remenber

#

if i killed him, probably yes

#

at that time i just liked killing NPCS

upper fox
#

if you capture Javier alive he spits on you during the scene where john hands him over to edgar ross

honest drum
#

aka red dead cringe

hidden moss
honest drum
#

lol im jk

clever scarab
#

hi all

#

im kimda new to discord and new to rdr2

pine dirge
#

I just got arrested for "kidnapping" a Del Lobo

#

I was gonna drop him off at the sheriff's but they drew their guns on me

#

I knew I should have shot him

lament gyro
#

oof

devout niche
#

Are vanilla flowers used in any quests/achievements?

clever scarab
#

btw my avatar is Rock group Rush...my nick comes from lotr books

devout niche
#

rip neil peart

clever scarab
#

cool yes ...probably end up listen to Rush now tonight

hidden moss
#

Rdr1 has aged really well

#

I just finished it and wow was it good

clever scarab
#

should I go to general chat room?

hidden moss
#

in rdr 1 if i hunt ALL the buffaloes have any chance of them not coming back? like in real life when they were wiped out?

#

I found a rare brindle coat and the stats are high, but I can only switch it out with my mustang idk which to choose

#

I have the mustang because of the stamina and health

#

For combat

#

But I also want the brindle coat idk which to choose

#

Someone tell me which one

devout niche
#

I think the general consensus is that stats don't matter too much. Go with what feels good.

hidden moss
#

Ok

jaunty ravine
#

So does anyone know how to get boats easily as John?

#

Because I just had one and it randomly sank and I died

iron sentinel
#

I am so glad rockstar did rdr right

#

Thank god they didn’t add the satire aspect from GTA V

hidden moss
#

I really love gta 5 is my favorite game

strange dragon
#

I will try and get them, my power went off as soon as I finished the mission so it didn't save

upper fox
#

cool

#

there area lot of videos about getting micah's revolver early

#

according to a video about the mission just have a gray icon and you should use micah's left foot with a fire arrow

#

@strange dragon

#

ehh just go and see the vid i send in media

strange dragon
#

ok thanks

north swan
#

What can I do with large legendary fish? I can't mail them, and I can't sell them, either.

upper fox
#

you can send all legendary fish, but you gotta unlock the side mission for that

#

search up the location a fisher of fish

#

its a cabin near chapter 3 camp near the lake

#

so just beaware of spoilers if you search it up

#

wait i'll send a screenshot of the locatioon in media channel

regal kestrel
#

Josiah kinda looks like the strange man

#

Pretty sure there’s already theories about him

viral flicker
#

finally finished buying all the outfits from the trapper and all upgrades from pearson except the ones locked of from new austin

#

now to finish chapter 3 lmao

bright wind
#

What ones are locked from New Austin?

#

You can get Iguanas as Arthur

#

from that Island near Clemens' point

#

Oh you mean trapper ones, I read that wrong

worldly gulch
#

I think its the pronghorn, cougar and tatanka bison that are locked until the epilogue

#

And the panther is locked behind the hunter challenges

bright wind
#

What?

#

There's lots of Pronghorn in New Hanover/West Elizabeth

#

Cougars are down south of Braithwaite manor

#

and in other foresty areas

worldly gulch
#

Oh I thought we were talking about the legendary ones

#

Cause I read trapper

bright wind
#

ohhhh that makes more sense sorry lol

#

I thought we were talking about Pearson still for some reason

#

Is there another legendary Bison? The one I know is up in the snowy mountains

worldly gulch
#

Yeah the tatanka which is up near mcfarlanes ranch somewhere I believe

bright wind
#

Oh okay

devout niche
#

Where should one sell vanilla flowers?

#

or can they only be traded to Algenon guy

bright wind
#

They can be crafted into health items and I don't know about selling but the wiki states they're worth 25 cents

devout niche
#

Thanks

grizzled sapphire
hidden moss
#

Anybody just go around straw berry with ram shotgun coat, and other only crafted outfit, with pagen mask and start deleting people with a bow

#

Are Legend of the East with Pegan mask

hushed harbor
#

which talisman is the one that increases the chance of getting perfect pelts

devout niche
#

buck

north swan
#

buck

young dragon
#

F*ck

dawn patio
golden vector
#

holy shit fellas

#

i found a perfect moose and sold the pelt to a trapper

#

my faith in humanity has been restored

sinful hound
#

Howdy fellers

restive hearth
#

Heller

sinful hound
#

Fowdy

restive hearth
#

xD

warm vigil
#

do I have to complete the challenges to get 100 % completion?

tall yoke
#

Yes

#

All 90 of them

austere gyro
#

Where is these damn cougars. I need bow huntings.

tall yoke
#

Im doing the same to get 100%

austere gyro
#

Master hunter?

spice rain
warm vigil
west parrot
#

y i k e s

clever scarab
#

good morning

mental merlin
#

m o r n I n g

mighty pecan
#

Mornin to ya

mental merlin
#

I feel like Dutch finished Arthur at the end by stepping on his hand

worldly gulch
#

Time to get Mr. Marston's inheritance sorted, to the pig farm we go

hushed geyser
#

Mary-Beth is a sweetheart

#

Have you seen her encounter with Kieren at Horseshoe Overlook?

honest drum
#

ye

torn oar
#

I was minding my own business, going to bring my catch to the trader and a horse with a saddle and reigns just barreled into me. I don't know where she came from because there's no people around me; I'm in the middle of the forest

hushed geyser
#

When I go near the woods I see people with arrows into their back dead on horseback

#

Probably the skinners

torn oar
#

Interesting, thank you!

bright wind
#

Challenges

#

Or just going for 100% in general

#

maybe even achievements

#

Honestly not sure

#

I'm figuring it put as I go

#

I only beat it a few days ago

#

Wow only with the story or 90% of the whole game?

#

Either way that's impressive

#

On social club it says I have like 88-89%

#

Oh okay

summer depot
#

4 days 100%? I dont believe it

bright wind
#

Only the story sure I can believe that

summer depot
#

Robbing a bank is part of completing 100% so i know you lieing now lol

bright wind
#

Any% speedruns are about 12 hours

#

He means like in free roam

#

Ofc you rob banks in missions

summer depot
#

Anyways im in guarma n i found a deae rainbow boa. Is it only located here? So i can move on

#

Yes

#

All the missions and side quest dont add up to 100% thatl just give you 80% or so. You gota kill and fish legendary. Collect items and draw on notepad etc.

#

I found a green turtle in the beach of guarma. I studied it and tracked it. When i tried killing it a sniper got me. Its not marked on my animals. Any help?

worldly gulch
#

Hmm, found a colour scheme for my guns that I possibly like even more than the dark walnut/nickel combo PES_Heart

vale crown
#

Arthur: But I ain't much of a dancer

Dutch:HAVE SOME GODDAMN FAITH!

native willow
#

pretty sure you can only rob stores, people and stagecoaches

#

and homes if you can get into them i suppose, lol

hushed geyser
vale crown
cerulean edge
#

Uh guys

#

So in the hotel in valentine who the fuck is the one making those crying moaning noises

#

And how do I stop it

prime estuary
#

Theres a sick guy there

#

You can't

cerulean edge
#

Is he the one who’s room you can into

prime estuary
#

Yes

crystal willow
#

Hey there misters

brazen lark
#

Anyone wanna grind lvls

olive notch
#

Wrong channel

brazen lark
#

Where do I go sir

#

Ian been on the chat in a while

sinful hound
#

Go to roles, pick your role and go to #yourrole-lfg

#

@brazen lark

brazen lark
#

Thank you

sinful hound
#

Fs

bright wind
#

"sent too many spoiler tags" I sent one

delicate sparrow
#

yeah, you aren't allowed to use any spoiler tags

#

spoiler tags are banned here

bright wind
#

Okay well anyway I went to horseshoe overlook as JOHN and heard feint voices of the camp women singing some song

honest drum
#

ye it;s for all camps

bright wind
#

Only in the epilogue I imagine

#

actually I didn't hear any in Beaver Hollow

#

but the sound of gunfire might've drowned it out

olive notch
#

Try clearing Beaver hollow first.

#

Then wait.

bright wind
#

Maybe when I come back to it. I did clear it but I didn't stay that long

olive notch
#

Yeah you gotta stay there for like 3+ minutes I think.

#

Or just get 100%

cerulean edge
#

Hey in the hosea bear mission what happens if you decide to track the bear

honest drum
#

what

#

stay?

cerulean edge
#

Yeah

#

How long does it take

honest drum
#

nothing u can just kill the bear

#

the mission ends

cerulean edge
#

Is he like right up the road

honest drum
#

ye

#

it's easy

cerulean edge
#

Ight coo

#

oh also

#

Hunting confuses me

#

What’s the difference between skinning the animal in the wild and putting the whole carcass on your horse ?

hushed geyser
sinful hound
#

Did John participate in the ferry job?

#

Was Arthur there?

candid walrus
#

Pretty sure John participated

#

Arthur wasn't there. He went with Hosea to do their own scam

#

Alright so I'm about to do the mission with John where you steal the Braithwate horses
I saw someone post something a while ago that said if you fed the horses when you steal them after the mission ends you could whistle and appear as temporary horses

#

Is that true or no?

honest drum
#

he just arrived later

candid walrus
#

ye

honest drum
#

when it was all chaos

candid walrus
#

he just wasn't there at first

honest drum
#

ye

sinful hound
#

Then why can't we go to NA as Arthur?

#

Don't think it's because of blackwater.

haughty whale
#

yo

sinful hound
#

Yo

cerulean edge
#

Yo

hidden moss
#

Yo

cerulean edge
#

Besides Mexico is the whole map from rdr in rdr 2?

#

??

honest drum
#

yes

#

just dead af

#

hardly anything to do apart from collectibles

lament gyro
#

What are some good ways to get my Honor up, I have been very Outlawish

candid walrus
#

catching fish and throwing them back in the water

#

aight so I found the crashed ship on the island near Clemens point

#

isn't there a sword here or something?

worldly gulch
#

Tricorn hat

light stream
#

or greeting everyone in Saint Denis @lament gyro

lament gyro
#

ok

sinful hound
#

Just outta St. Denis

worldly gulch
#

Yeah the usual thousand hey misters will atone you of any sin

candid walrus
#

got a nice hat tho

hushed geyser
#

Although you never really go into it until the epilogue

#

You only go there for like one mission as Arthur

candid walrus
#

Finally got the take from the rich trophy

#

woo and I got the rare rolling block rifle

crystal willow
#

Am i the only one who avoids playing the game when in bad mood? I think that i will make the NPCs bad haha

#

sad*

formal flame
#

Killing people in this game is so damn satisfying

hidden moss
#

Can someone explain to me why the feds take so much time to kill dutch? like he was basically trying to DESTROY blackwater in rdr1, is so hard to just take 1 thousand US soldiers and invade his base?

verbal prairie
#

because this isn't a movie and its grounded in reality. at the start there was absolutely 0 reason to send us soldiers

#

he was just some ordinary outlaw

hidden moss
verbal prairie
#

because they're clever?

hidden moss
#

what?

native willow
#

Blackwater really ain’t that big in either games lol

verbal prairie
#

how do the most modern banks in this day and age get robber???

#

robbed*

#

you're making no sense

native willow
#

It’s advanced for the time but it’s not some super secret fortress

verbal prairie
#

lmfao yeah

hidden moss
#

their pistols alone can kill at least 10 Dutch men(High power pistoll)

verbal prairie
#

no???

native willow
#

Dude what are you smoking

#

And where can I get some

verbal prairie
#

do you even know what happened at blackwater

#

multiple gang members got killed

native willow
#

He doesn’t seem to know much

verbal prairie
#

some wounded

native willow
hidden moss
#

What the fuck is radagast smoking jesus christ

native willow
#

Not that what he’s saying makes any sense lmao

hidden moss
#

I'm not smoking, I played rdr 1 for the last time in 3 years and I don't remember certain things, what I'm asking is: How did Dutch manage to invade the most modern bank on the map without leaving "any" trace?

#

like how did the blackwater police get in this situation? when they completely invaded the bank?

native willow
hidden moss
#

@native willow undearsteand me now?

native willow
#

No

verbal prairie
#

lol

hidden moss
native willow
hidden moss
# hidden moss Have I had a stroke trying to read this

I'm wondering how Dutch completely broke into the blackwater bank without attracting attention. Of course after a while the protagonist and some policemen arrive. but and before that? At the exact moment of the invasion? where he and his indigenous henchmen arrive and invade the place, where was the police? did they let that happen? I didn't see any dead bodies or sign of shootings in place before the protagonist appeared

#

Well it was 1911 you could probably walk into a bank carrying a gun... why aren't you asking this about any of the other bank robberies in either game 😂

hidden moss
verbal prairie
#

he's right, the 1900s weren't exactly too well known for their brilliance in policing

hidden moss
verbal prairie
#

what?

hidden moss
#

translator problems give me some minutes

native willow
#

Do you not understand that they ride into town and rush the bank

#

Blackwater is small

hidden moss
#

They don't just have a stroll around for a bit and stand outside the bank thinking for a wee while

#

Then ask the police if they can rob the bank

native willow
hidden moss
#

._.

verbal prairie
#

I'm so confused lmao

hidden moss
#

Same hahahah

native willow
#

Master of charisma

hidden moss
#

ok i understood Dutch and his men got on horseback but there was NO ONE to stop them? When I played rdr 1 blackwater it was FULL of police, even if there was no one near the bank at the time, after 30 minutes no police officer passed by and thought: I'm going to take a look at the bank.

#

and i may be wrong but, isn't blackwater territorially one of the biggest cities in the game?

#

What an amazing plan! I hope it doesn't lead to the gang falling apart with numerous influential members! Then a rat influenced the leader into disregarding everyone for money, resulting in the death of one of the longest serving gang members!

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

I wasnt talking to you

#

you are confusing me, can someone explain to me WHAT WAS THE DUTCH'S PLAN?

native willow
hidden moss
#

to break into the blackwater bank on rdr 1?

hidden moss
#

was it simply going there with 20 soldiers and shooting anyone who opposed them?

native willow
hidden moss
#

Wtf is this guy on

hidden moss
# hidden moss Wtf is this guy on

i will make the same question again:

when dutch invades the blackwater's bank in rdr 1, did he have any plan for that? or he just take 20 natives and shoot whoever was oposing him?

#

undearsteand me now?

#

Not really

#

THIS IS THE LAST TIME I WILL ASK:

in rdr 1 Dutch invades the blackwater bank in the mission: "great men are not always wise" when he invades that bank, before the invasion did he have any plans? because it implies that he just got there and invaded without any planning.

#

@hidden moss

native willow
#

Maybe you should stop asking

hidden moss
#

Nobody is "playing with you"

#

im just a kid

#

._.

#

We literally do not know what the fuck you are talking about

#

._.

#

this mission on the video:

#

oh i cant send links

native willow
hidden moss
#

😂😂😂

#

@hidden moss explain this to us like we are 5 years old

undone maple
#

Um guys I was on the end of chepter 6 and I have few things want to ask

#

first when will I get beck arther’s stuff?

#

secound dose the pig farm still work to save money?

native willow
#

Pretty sure you get all of the weapons and outfits back after John starts setting up Beecher’s hope

#

Forgot exactly when

undone maple
#

Ok

#

thx

worldly gulch
hidden moss
#

how can i get Easy money on rdr 1? without killing innocents

golden vector
#

hunt a shit ton of animals and sell them in mexico

undone maple
#

Suddently found I was full of all valuanles and food so I got only money while lootiogpeepotf

#

Poor little john can have all thatihaveaplan

#

Also the O’driscol hidout have a lot of things like 100 dollers in a lootbox and tons of dead guy to loot

hidden moss
golden vector
#

just realized

#

depends what you’re selling

#

mexico takes majority of the best sell price, but north (west elizabeth) takes up a chunk of it too

hidden moss
#

makes sense

golden vector
#

a lot of the hunting animals are better to sell in mexico

hidden moss
#

in the past i ussualy sell all of my itens on blackwater

hidden moss
#

fillet

golden vector
#

yeah but that’s harder and you can most definitely lose money if you lose

hidden moss
#

so the problem with this method is that it is only good if you are a professional in it? and have trained a lot?

golden vector
#

also if you hunt long enough to get a shit ton of pelts that can total like 200+ dollars it’s easy

#

so five finger fillet is fast but risky and hunting takes time but is guaranteed to give you a great payroll

hidden moss
#

i undearsteand now

hidden moss
#

Bro I just blew up Sean and mission failed..

#

Bro he die anyway

undone maple
#

This is the game

#

Die in mission:fail
Die in cutscean:No F given

#

Also take midnight’s gun in the gunslinger side mission

#

it’s op

#

and I confused,how you blew up himthonkhaw

devout niche
#

Is there anything I can do with the chained outhouse in braithwaite?

obtuse venture
#

Yeah throw a molotov at it

devout niche
#

You yankin my chain, mister?

obtuse venture
#

Bomb it?

hidden moss
#

So what exactly was Molly's role in gang aside from being Dutch's mistress?

#

She didn't seem to have done anything for the gang, was never part is any robbery, never involved in a shootout and never stole anything.

undone maple
#

thonkhaw So what a girlfriend do besides to spend your money

mental hinge
#

idk she kept dutch in check i guess

#

then again she just stands around putting on make uo

#

jack is a more useful membner

undone maple
#

Yes jack make us unlock fishing,gave a chocolate bar after we gave him the book

#

Molly?Just wandering around a get money

hushed harbor
#

not even a single companion activity

hushed geyser
#

A rdr2 undead nightmare where we play as Abigail would be epic

#

A female Protagonist after almost 12 years of the rdr series

undone maple
#

Uncle : L U M B A G O

#

I think ot will be saidy because that will be strange that it will did’t match UN 1

#

Maybe she was defending the gold mine

#

Or her bounty target was infected

hushed geyser
#

I tried playing American Venom without shooting Micah and he killed both Dutch and Sadie

#

It was hard to not shoot Micah

undone maple
#

Why the hack will you did’t shoot a piece of shit?realmicah

#

Just shoot him ! Shoot his head ! shoot his balls! Shoot his heart ! wait he don’t have a heart..

golden vector
#

nor balls

sinful hound
#

Yo yo

crystal willow
#

Took away my frustration from chapter 6

undone maple
#

Noice

#

BURN IT

crystal willow
#

Fuck Micah

undone maple
crystal willow
#

Actually, there are people who think Micah isn't the rat

#

and try to defend him

hidden moss
#

there are people who made fk arthur emote and have the audacity to use it

vital plover
half sage
#

Can you craft at camp in chapter 3?

worldly gulch
#

You can craft at camp from chapter 2 onwards yeah, you need to find the scout camp fire

#

I always go to pearsons camp upgrades and select the scout camp fire so it reminds me where it is cowboykekw

sinful hound
#

When can you fast travel from the wilderness camp? Does it unlock after a chapter or?

worldly gulch
#

Unlocks once you upgrade Arthur's tent with the map

sinful hound
#

Ah

#

I thought it was only for his tent at camp

#

Thanks

prime jewel
worldly gulch
rotund wave
#

literally no one:
not a single soul in the universe:
uncle: I gOt LuMBaGo

candid walrus
#

IT's a veRy SeriOus ilLneSs

rotund wave
#

John: GET UP

candid walrus
#

If I work too hard I'll get a RELAPSE

hidden moss
#

Can ANYONE explain to me why Rockstar created rdr undead nightmare? That DLC isn’t even a cannon, nothing makes sense there, it’s totally weird.

#

I don't even know if the community liked the DLC. I remember that when I played rdr 1 on my PS3 I always ignored this DLC, because I had nothing to do with it

crystal willow
hidden moss
#

I would appreciate it

rotund wave
#

I read your name as radstag and thought you were referencing fallout lol

hidden moss
#

no

#

its a lords of the rings character

honest drum
#

not everything has to be canon

#

it's a great DLC

#

fun af

#

it's a nightmare john has

#

while sleeping

hidden moss
#

ok but could you explain to me how it ends? is there at least an end? in which case you would kill ALL the zombies

hidden moss
#

serious?

honest drum
#

ye

#

hence why it's called 'undead NIGHTMARE'

hidden moss
#

so is it "cannon"? after all even if it’s just a dream, it happened, of course it doesn’t affect the real world because it was a nightmare, but that means that even in the main campaign John had that dream

honest drum
#

what happens in the dream obvs isn't canon because it's a dream, but that he had the dream is canon

#

afaik

hidden moss
iron sentinel
#

Is there a trainer or something that lets me teleport to guarma in the epilogue? Please tag me 🙂

mental hinge
#

i like rampage since it's a bit more diverse

worldly gulch
iron sentinel
#

Oh awesome. I’ll be using scripthook for a couple of cool scripts I found anyway

candid walrus
sinful hound
#

Back to my playthrough again

#

Didn't play in a week or so

honest drum
#

rampage trainer or scripthook
@mental hinge scripthook is just the hook, not a mod, also i don't think the scripthook trainer comes with a teleport to guarma option as it's an extremely basic trainer

tall sail
mental merlin
#

chat

#

da chat

sinful hound
#

Da Chat⁉️

mental merlin
#

yes DA CHAT

minor skiff
#

People who play rdr on pc do u use controller when u fishing?

#

I tried once with mouse and was hard

native willow
#

I use a controller for everything on PC

#

I don’t enjoy rockstar games on keyboard usually

#

There’s also a setting you can change to make fishing easier iirc

minor skiff
#

Play gta t with keyboard but rdr2 is impossible to play with keyboard

#

Feel like its not relaxing

native willow
#

Agreed

#

Although on GTA I still usually kept a controller for flying planes/helicopters lol

mental merlin
#

Just explore

visual rose
#

a friend of mine made me start playing red dead online but that got me encouraged to get back into singleplayer too

#

missed this game

mental merlin
#

no

delicate sparrow
#

yeah

#

compendium

mental merlin
delicate sparrow
#

fuck

#

ur right

#

just look up complete list of animals in rdr2

mental merlin
#

you need 3

#

not 2

#

I don’t know maybe check new Austin for the tiger

#

and like swamps and water places for the turtle

#

@hidden moss

sinful hound
#

I don't think that it is entried as a tiger

#

Because it's not a tiger

candid walrus
#

it's a cougar disguised as a tiger

sinful hound
#

Yes

mental merlin
#

have you messed up the cattleman only yet? @sinful hound

sinful hound
#

Nope

#

I lost a save so I'm back to the start

#

I went with uncle and da girls to valentine

mental merlin
#

your on chapter2 still it’s been like a week

sinful hound
#

Yeah I like to explore

#

Probably won't leave chapter 2 after a month 😂

mental merlin
#

your never gonna finish it

mental hinge
#

chapter 2 is the most chill chapter

strange dragon
#

I wished I stretched mine out to a year

sinful hound
#

I'll speed through ch 6

mental merlin
#

so you can be depressed

sinful hound
#

Can't *

mental merlin
#

you don’t cry when Arthur dies

sinful hound
#

I do

hushed geyser
#

If Kieran survived Mary-Beth and Kieren would have probably gotten together

candid walrus
#

yeah

hushed geyser
#

You can see how much Mary-Beth cares for Kieren in the campsite hidden events

#

Especially when she gives Kieran water and food without him even asking

#

And who was the one who was terrified when Kieran died?

#

Mary-Beth.

crimson bronze
#

I honestly think Kieran would've been a Stablehand at Beecher's Hope if he had survived.

hushed geyser
#

Wait wrong chapters

#

Kieren didn't deserve to watch Sadie starve him but I'm not mad at Sadie for that

#

She had her reasons

#

I'd honestly do the same if his gang killed someone I love

visual rose
#

i still feel bad for kieran

#

i guilt tripped myself in my firstplaythrough because i thought i could have saved him

hushed geyser
#

It would be nice if you could find Kieren in Emerald Ranch like Mary-Beth in Valentine and Tilly in Saint Denis

#

And if you have high honor Kieren would ride the train to Riggs station and move into Beechers as a stablehand

#

If he survived

fierce crow
#

yeah

#

honestly kieran didn't deserve what he got. He was a pretty good dude despite being a goddamn odriscoll.

candid walrus
#

yeah

crystal willow
#

Agree

#

I was shocked when i saw Kieran dead

fierce crow
#

yeah me too

candid walrus
#

He deserved better

crystal willow
#

Poor guy was trying to get their trust

fierce crow
#

I was like WHAT THE FUCK.

candid walrus
#

mhm

fierce crow
#

yeah

hushed geyser
crimson bronze
#

I shudder to think what Colm did to the poor kid.

fierce crow
#

lol

#

why

#

he was a goddamn odriscoll.

#

lol

crystal willow
#

I actually thought that Kieran would kill Colm

#

When i first started playing the game

fierce crow
#

that would be dope but I love how he went

hushed geyser
#

You don't want to know how many times I shot Colm in the crotch during the hanging of Colm O'driscoll when I remembered he killed Kieran

crystal willow
#

Too bad you fail the mission if you do it

fierce crow
#

fucking swinged

hushed geyser
crystal willow
#

I shoot him before they hung him

#

even if i failed

#

i shoot him 3-4 times

#

and i got 4 "Mission failed"

#

Wish Rockstar gave us a little more freedom with the missions

hushed geyser
fierce crow
#

yeah I know

#

I was just playing around

hushed geyser
#

Kieren is severely underrated though

crystal willow
#

Guess they stricted the missions this design because the game is a prequel

hushed geyser
#

He doesn't even get one of those character arts in rdr2 with the quote things

fierce crow
#

yeah smh

crystal willow
#

Dude it was Micah's fault Kieran died

hushed geyser
#

I'd gladly replace Micah with Kieran

candid walrus
fierce crow
#

He wasn't one of my favorites but he was a good character

#

I should of went fishing with him

tall yoke
#

Do you lose your gold bars, if you finish the "main" story?

crystal willow
#

My favorite after Arthur was Charles

hushed geyser
crystal willow
#

i f** loved Charles

fierce crow
#

I regret not doing that cause I was like "I'll do it later"

candid walrus
#

Lenny was probably my second favorite
loved the quiet time mission lol

fierce crow
#

smh

#

my dumb ass

crystal willow
#

Lenny too

#

But Charles was a brother

tall yoke
#

Micah was the boy

fierce crow
#

Charles is probably in my top three alongside Arthur and John Marshton tbh

sinful hound
#

Uncle

crystal willow
#

He respected nature
He brutally murdered someone because he killed Bisons
He went back and burried Arthur
He helped John with the house and never demanding a thing and in the end he left like a badass

candid walrus
sinful hound
#

Uncle is cool

hushed geyser
#

Kieran didn't deserve to die but he did have one of the most epic death scenes

tall yoke
#

Lumbargo

#

Trivago

fierce crow
#

uncle is cool as well but would have been better if it weren't for his lumbago haha lmao.

native willow
fierce crow
#

definitely

hushed geyser
#

Charles is epic

fierce crow
#

charles is based as fuck

candid walrus
#

what if uncle actually had Lumbago but no one believed him

native willow
#

Chad energy

tall yoke
#

Charles is bae

hushed geyser
#

Charles is hot

tall yoke
#

Charles 9inch

fierce crow
#

lmao

tall yoke
#

Micah is underrated

native willow
crystal willow
#

Nah, micah gets what he deserved

fierce crow
#

honestly one of my favorite scenes is where arthur morgan just came back from Guarma and kicks open the double doors and goes ham on the pinkertons. Fucking hell.

hushed geyser
crystal willow
#

Fun fact is that i like Micah

#

i love when characters make me "feel"

#

Micah literally filled me with rage

fierce crow
#

thats how I imagine it at least

native willow
#

So you love to hate him

hushed geyser
#

Micah as a character is a hell no but Micah as an antagonist is a hell yeah

crystal willow
#

He is in my top5 best character

tall yoke
#

No jokes now..

Hosea is the boy

crystal willow
native willow
#

That’s valid

#

But actually “liking” micah is cring

candid walrus
native willow
#

Like people who think he’s right

#

Hosea was a G

#

Didn’t deserve to go out that way

candid walrus
#

mhm

crystal willow
#

He is not a cliche villain that you hate because "he looks like stupid" like i did with Umbridge from Harry Potter or Eredin from Witcher 3

#

He has his own philosophy and he shows his nature

hushed geyser
#

When you think about it Dutch was technically the one who killed Hosea

fierce crow
#

Hosea is definitely up there. I was hoping he would survive all the shit but nope. damn.

hushed geyser
#

Dutch planned the robbery but Hosea told Dutch it was an extremely bad idea

crystal willow
#

I think they intentionally killed Hosea

#

Imagine if you had to hunt down Hosea in RDR1

#

would be so depressing and frustrating

hushed geyser
#

And he didn't even "get out there" when Hosea was being held at gunpoint

native willow
candid walrus
hushed geyser
#

Hosea's a king

#

He sacrificed himself so John could have a happy family

crystal willow
native willow
#

Literally no redeeming traits when it comes to micah besides being a good draw/shot

crystal willow
#

His quotes reflect his character and actions

native willow
#

Right but there’s isn’t really a deep philosophy or thought process like Dutch or someone else

crystal willow
#

He isn't the guy who claims that we must help the poor and on the other side he shoots people down because they ask him from money

native willow
#

Micah is just willing to do anything for himself

crystal willow
#

Yeah it isn't, by philosophy i mean "a way of life"

native willow
#

Fair enough

fierce crow
#

yeah, hes a true outlaw, he doesn't give a shit. No need for Philosophy there, IMO.

crystal willow
#

For me Dutch was the true villain in this game

native willow
#

Well yeah

crystal willow
#

Not Micah

native willow
#

Dutch is a POS

hushed geyser
#

Bronte was the one who made Dutch all crazy

crystal willow
#

I don't understand why Dutch didn't suspect Micah when Micah told me to go back to Blackwater by himself

native willow
#

Maybe he was “good” but that time had long passed

native willow
hushed geyser
#

Bronte made Dutch and the gang rob the post office and escape on the trolly

native willow
#

Actions of RDR2 just accelerated it

hushed geyser
#

And the trolly crash was what made Dutch crazy

tall yoke
#

Rockstar should focus on a diffrent era Red Dead game.

Maybe Pirates era? That would be really refreshing.. The potential it have

A open world Pirate Game (just like Black Flag & Sea of Thieves)
But from Rockstar. . called

Red Dead Seas

hushed geyser
#

You can clearly see the changes of acts in Dutch after the crash

crystal willow
#

and he kept trying to persuading Dutch to go back there even when the entire Pinkerton army was swamping Blackwater

native willow
#

I don’t think a single head bonk set Dutch down that path, he had already massacred people in blackwater

fierce crow
#

lol pinkerton army

#

I like it

native willow
#

It probably made shit worse though

crystal willow
#

Hosea's death destroyed Dutch. He was the one who kept his shit together

native willow
#

That I won’t deny

hushed geyser
native willow
tall yoke
#

Leopald Strauss was the one who got caught and didnt say a word with torture

candid walrus
#

I think the combination of Hosea's death + trolley crash + Micha kind of made Dutch go crazy

native willow
#

I don’t see the crash as the catalyst

#

Just a factor

hushed geyser
crystal willow
#

Not only that, Hosea died, Lenny died, Arthur was doubting him, John was doubting him..

native willow
crystal willow
native willow
#

And just the kind of person he was imo

candid walrus
#

yea

#

He started showing his true nature once he went a little crazy

tall yoke
#

I would say one of the loyals. We dont know the ones who did not got arrested

crystal willow
#

I started hating Dutch when he killed that woman at Guarma

#

He started suffering from paranoia and saw traitors everywhere

spice rain
#

Tbf that was mean

tall yoke
#

Yh that was clapped

hushed geyser
#

Rockstar only killed off Hosea, Lenny, Sean, Molly, Susan, and Kieren because they would all have sided with Arthur and John

tall yoke
#

Lmao i was like bruh dutch wtf

candid walrus
#

Yeah killing the old lady was not justified

crystal willow
#

Rockstar actually wouldn't like us to hunt these people down

verbal prairie
#

wasn't the old lady gonna rat them out lol

spice rain
#

No

#

And to who?

candid walrus
#

no she wasn't

verbal prairie
#

I don't think that's anywhere near the most detestable thing he's done

hushed geyser
#

Btw when I went back for the money after getting the ending where you help John I looted Miss Grimshaw

tall yoke
#

No it was the fancy irish woman

native willow
#

All the deaths also make for a powerful/compelling story

tall yoke
#

Dutch gf

crystal willow
#

For Dutch, everyone was a rat, but he didn't realised that the true vermin was Micah

native willow
#

Some of them are pretty crushing

native willow
verbal prairie
#

I don't remember properly but I swear he had a good reason

hushed geyser
verbal prairie
#

no I mean the women in guarma

native willow
#

Pretty sure Molly is Scottish

verbal prairie
#

woman*

crystal willow
#

He didn't, he literally killed her because he "thought" that she will betray them

tall yoke
#

Mad

hushed geyser
crystal willow
#

and Milton stated that Molly didn't give any information

spice rain
#

Molly O'Shea is the most Irish name

verbal prairie
#

oh I see

native willow
crystal willow
#

I also like Milton

candid walrus
#

Molly was just drunk

tall yoke
#

Milton

crystal willow
#

Not sure if i am the only one

tall yoke
#

Milton i did that mission yesterday. On my platinum hunt

verbal prairie
#

Milton was the good guy in the story, however I wanted to kill him very badly

hushed geyser
crystal willow
candid walrus
#

yea

verbal prairie
#

to me dutch's scariest moment was killing bronte

crystal willow
#

This game's character quality was astonishing

tall yoke
#

What if it was all Cains master plan to destroy the gang?

verbal prairie
#

as much as I wanted to kill him it was such an intense moment

native willow
#

Idk, saying “HEY GUYS I SOLD US OUT” to the stressed and tired outlaws was just not a good choice lmao

verbal prairie
#

it was really heavy

candid walrus
native willow
#

So it’s hard for me to feel for her

candid walrus
#

plus Molly didn't really help out at all so..

crystal willow
candid walrus
#

I didn't exactly feel bad about it

hushed geyser
#

Because before the mission where you see Molly die you can greet Tilly and Arthur asks where Molly is, Tilly replies with "She hasn't been back in a while, all I know is that she's drinking at the Saint Denis Saloon"

tall yoke
#

It was Cain im telling ya

crystal willow
spice rain
hushed geyser
tall yoke
#

It was Cain trust me

native willow
#

Cain slander

#

Tf

crystal willow
#

I have proof

verbal prairie
#

why does it have to be some obscure idea like Cain destroying the gang lol. why cant it just be what the game tells us it is for once

native willow
#

He’s a good boi

#

Well

#

Was

crystal willow
#

He ratted the gang and went to blackwater because Micah told the rat that the gold bar was cheese

spice rain
#

I see the joke flying over some people's heads

crystal willow
#

So Micah ratted the rat too

native willow
#

Jokes are usually funny

hushed geyser
#

I love how when you study Rufus in the epilogue his description is just "Rufus is a good boy"

native willow
#

Cause he is

crystal willow
#

He is

native willow
#

The best

crystal willow
#

Nah, best boah was my horse

#

who died in the end

native willow
#

Red Dead Rufus when

tall yoke
#

Rockstar should focus on a diffrent era Red Dead game.

Maybe Pirates era? That would be really refreshing.. The potential it have

A open world Pirate Game (just like Black Flag & Sea of Thieves)
But from Rockstar. . called

Red Dead Seas

crystal willow
native willow
crystal willow
native willow
#

Just make a new franchise

spice rain
#

We don't need another red dead game

native willow
#

That id be down for

spice rain
#

New title would be better

hushed geyser
crystal willow
#

I would like a RDR1 remake

native willow
#

I’d be down for another red dead

hushed geyser
#

We need Red Dead Sadie

native willow
#

Not another redemption though

crystal willow
#

Or at least a DLC

candid walrus
#

a rdr1 remake would be good

native willow
#

Yea

tall yoke
#

Not a cowboy game cuz RDR2 is done with cowboy era. Everything is in that game

fierce crow
#

RDR1 PC port

#

instant buy

crystal willow
#

We need a RDR3 where you play as McCallander

half sage
#

How many weapons can I buy? I thougt was one of each but seems you can buy multiple pistols?

native willow
#

Why would you want a red dead game that’s not based off westerns/cowboys

tall yoke
#

Pirates

native willow
#

That’s the point

fierce crow
#

no

crystal willow
#

Yeah red dead without western will be really bad

candid walrus
#

ye

native willow
#

Facts

fierce crow
#

red dead needs to be western. rootin tootin shootin. thats the main theme of the series.

native willow
#

Yep

crystal willow
#

I actually want Rockstar to work on a cyberpunk game

candid walrus
#

Or we could get Blue Alive Resurrection

crystal willow
#

A good one

candid walrus
#

.>

spice rain
native willow
fierce crow
#

thats like stripping guns from Call of Duty.

native willow
#

A futuristic game

#

From Rockstar

crystal willow
#

After the huge failure from CDPR

hushed geyser
#

be kind

fierce crow
#

yes

crystal willow
#

i was so hyped about a Cyberpunk game

fierce crow
#

be kind

crystal willow
#

and myself still wants to experience it

native willow
#

I had fun with itt but it failed hard

#

The base consoles versions were shameful lmao

tall yoke
native willow
#

And all the bugs and cut shit

hushed geyser
#

How the heck do I start the Valentine duel

native willow
#

That’s a bad take, it’s literally a game that’s a homage to westerns

crystal willow
#

Miyazaki (the creator of dark souls series for anyone who doesn't know) wants to make a game that has RDR2 storytelling

native willow
#

But yeah, Let’s be pirates

crystal willow
#

Maybe FromSoft + Rockstar will work on an open-world sandbox ARPG souls-like game

fierce crow
#

yeah if its not gonna be western it should not be named anything remotely close to the red dead series

tall yoke
#

Do you want a new RDR game in the next 10 years Tbone?

native willow
#

^

fierce crow
#

that would be a disservice to the franchise.

native willow
#

Not really a priority but sure

tall yoke
#

Why not something new and refreshing

crystal willow
#

Nah, imho, a new RDR game will just be a fanservice game

native willow
#

Why not make a new franchise then

fierce crow
#

yeah

#

exactly

native willow
#

Why make a cowboy game about pirates

#

That makes no fucking sense dawg

crystal willow
#

RDR ended, it was amazing journey that i won't forget anytime soon

fierce crow
#

I agree with Tbone here

crystal willow
#

i don't want them to ruin it with a new copy-paste game

fierce crow
#

no offense

tall yoke
#

Red Dead can be used for era open world games.

fierce crow
#

but there is little logic in your argument. We don't wanna do a battlefield V here.

tall yoke
crystal willow
#

Rockstar makes quality games guys

native willow
crystal willow
#

I am sure they know what they are doing

tall yoke
#

GTA6

fierce crow
#

yeah they do make good singleplayer campaigns for sure

#

amazing ones

native willow
#

^

crystal willow
native willow
#

Online needs some work kekwahahaha

fierce crow
#

Online I can't really say, but I been playing RDO a bit a month or so after I beat the main game

native willow
#

I just don’t enjoy grinding/the monetization

crystal willow
fierce crow
#

Its not too bad

native willow
#

It’s okay

#

It has its issues

#

I liked it more than GTAO

tall yoke
#

RDO needs better content and no reskin buisness like GTAO has

fierce crow
#

but its definitely not the best, but so far I been enjoying it.

native willow
#

Nothing beats single player though

fierce crow
#

I agree

crystal willow
#

Tbh, i would prefer a DLC for RDR2

fierce crow
#

and yeah the story reigns surpreme

tall yoke
#

Foundation is there on RDO

crystal willow
#

but i can't think any setting for it..

native willow
#

I’d love an undead nightmare type expansion

fierce crow
#

I want story DLC too damn it

tall yoke
#

Only needs good content

fierce crow
#

YES

tall yoke
#

Y3Ω

fierce crow
#

UNDEAD NIGHTMARE 2.0

tall yoke
#

Yes

native willow
#

Arthur Morgan, Vampire Hunter

#

Please

fierce crow
#

that be dope

tall yoke
#

But it would be uncle

native willow
#

I wanna use the vamps knife to kill other vamps

crystal willow
#

Arthur Morgan finding Trevor, Big Smoke and Micah in hell

tall yoke
#

Protagonist

crystal willow
#

God sent him in hell to get rid of them because even hell was too good for them

fierce crow
#

lmao

crystal willow
#

Well of course this is a joke xD

#

Arthur Morgan as a legend in apex legend

#

plz Rockstar give them the permission 😦

#

Jokes aside, i want a DLC where you play as Micah/McCallander/Dutch

high parrot
#

pc just crashed and i didnt save ugh

#

gotta go replay about 4-5 missions

crystal willow
high parrot
#

my smartass turned it off

fierce crow
#

That's a fucking F

crystal willow
fierce crow
#

Damn man

high parrot
#

fr, thank god skip checkpoint is a feature

fierce crow
#

Indeed

crystal willow
#

Off topic

#

Anyone wanted a mission or a story about Black Belle?

#

This woman was so freaking badass

high parrot
visual rose
#

wa

#

GEASLLOJFHSL

#

sorry

#

accidentally

#

clicked reply on that

#

and forgot to unclick

#

lol

native willow
#

By far

visual rose
hushed geyser
#

I like the fact that Rockstar only included 11 duels in rdr2

fierce crow
#

Yeah the other ones sucked

#

Including Calloway

hushed geyser
#

Since duels back then were actually really rare

native willow
fierce crow
#

Imo

crystal willow
#

I didn't like how the duels ended..

native willow
#

I loved the amount in RDR

#

And how people would challenge you randomly

#

Way more chances to shoot someone eight times in the head and watch them backflip

crystal willow
#

At least with the legendary gunslingers (except Granger who was a freaking ratshit), i didn't want to kill Midnight

fierce crow
#

Lmao

native willow
#

Midnight was a weirdo

#

Although I guess they’re all strange people

#

Fuck Granger though

candid walrus
#

ye

native willow
#

Killing him felt good and his pistol has drip

sinful hound
#

Fuck granger

#

Flaco was ok

#

Billy 2nd

native willow
#

Yeah he wasn’t terrible

sinful hound
#

Belle 1st all the way

native willow
#

Black Belle the best

#

Ye ye

crystal willow
#

yeah excluding belle

sinful hound
#

Calloway had cool Dialogue

native willow
#

I love Arthur’s journal entry about her

crystal willow
#

I am talking about Midnight, Flaco and Granger

native willow
#

He was so impressed by her

crystal willow
#

I fell in love with her

sinful hound
#

"Draw."
"Why?"
"I said draw goddammit."
"No."
"Yeeeeees"

crystal willow
#

Black Belle > Lady Dimitrescu

sinful hound
#

Yes

candid walrus
#

Black Belle was badass

sinful hound
#

Blowing up those folk was fun

candid walrus
#

yeah

sinful hound
#

Imo, Black Belle=Calloway because you could duel him and his gun is beautiful

#

Canis Canem Edit

crystal willow
#

Oh, another thing i wanted in this game

#

I really would like a Lucky Luke easter egg

#

I grew up with Lucky Luke comics and i would really love an easter egg, with Daltons or Rantaplan

native willow
#

Who/what’s Lucky Luke?

#

Western comic character?

crystal willow
#

An old (really old iirc) comic character about a cowboy (who is named Lucky Luke) who can shoot faster than his shadow

native willow
#

Interesting

crystal willow
#

And has 100% accuracy every time

native willow
#

Only cowboy comics I’ve read are DC

#

Jonah Hex is my guy

crystal willow
#

Check them out if you want

#

They are somehow old and you may find them cliche

#

But i read them again and again when i was like 10

#

i kept reading*

native willow
#

I can get down with older comics if there’s some draw like great art or weird characters

#

I’ll try to look into it

crystal willow
#

I like the draw of it, if you remember the old Marvel comics about Beyonder (my first ones)

#

It has similiar art

#

I can't send you a link for some reason, discord won't allow me to

mental merlin
#

why the hell did I just see people in suits and one person is in black at night

#

and then they burned a cross

#

and then someone died

#

?

fierce crow
#

Pretty sure that's the KKK

#

Actually

#

One hundred percent sure that is

#

Make sure to shoot all of them

mental merlin
#

shoot all of em?

fierce crow
#

Kill em all

mental merlin
#

where can I see em again?

misty nebula
#

blow em all

#

em

fierce crow
#

It's random

misty nebula
#

fuck

fierce crow
#

Nice

#

Lmao

misty nebula
crystal willow
#

Dafuq, i never encoutered KKK members

#

and i roamed a lot at night

fierce crow
#

Yes the kkk will sometimes burn people on a cross

mental merlin
#

THE HELL

fierce crow
#

I only encountered it twice

golden vector
#

yeah i saw that encounter once

mental merlin
#

ALL THE BODYS AND THE CROSS DISAPPEAR

golden vector
#

i’ve had it multiple times

crystal willow
#

Back on track now

golden vector
#

each and every time i have killed all of the members

fierce crow
#

I killed them all the second time lol

crystal willow
#

Tbh once i grabbed a poor guy and threw him on rails because he wanted to report me to the officers

visual rose
#

they burn people on the cross

crystal willow
#

This is the only thing i did at night

visual rose
#

? i never saw that

crystal willow
#

and kill some o'driscols

misty nebula
#

they can be encountered randomly in day and night. the time depends on the place

visual rose
#

every single event of theirs i saw was them being humiliated

misty nebula
#

like strawberry, you can find them right outside of strawberry during the day, but the one at Rhodes is during the night

visual rose
#

the cross one has them adding a new someone into their ranks

misty nebula
#

same with a valentine one

visual rose
#

but the new guy accidentally burns himself with the cross

#

another one was 2 guys being crushed by a cross while another just gets sad and calls himself a failure

crystal willow
#

Man i can't even go back to Strawberry because the asshat called Micah put 100$ bounty on me

visual rose
#

and another was i think 2 of them getting lost in the woods

crystal willow
#

Hope they catch him and burn him on a cross too

fierce crow
#

You can go back eventually

crystal willow
#

I need to pay bounties

fierce crow
#

After a while through the story

visual rose
#

i never saw kkk outside of roanoke or lemoyne lol

fierce crow
#

My first time was near valentine I think

visual rose
#

wonder if they can spawn in new austin

hushed geyser
#

What happens if you disarm the legendary gunslingers

misty nebula
hushed geyser
visual rose
#

billy will kill himself

misty nebula
#

he throws it