#red-dead-singleplayer
1 messages · Page 360 of 1
i need 2 perfect pelts and i need to study the Florida Panther to get the Zoology Achievement
lmao
lol bored?
Nooooooooooo
what
Horse ded
o
yea it was the free iron grey Ardennes
it was taking up stable space >.>
but i can get it back so ye
alright now i have an empty stall
much better
WHAT THE FUCK DID I JUST FIND
How are you guys always killing your horses? 😂
Bank robbery is a crime but you can’t rob the bank?
o-o
@ben10 why did u leave
I finished rdr2 8 times
I strart to get bored from the game
I m not intersed in online
And i have nothing to do

What’s wrong with online ? @strange fox
I dont like it that much
You have to pay for almost everything
And everything is expensive
Are there shark card equivalents ?
Ye
Gold bars
Online is super fun once you get into it, I enjoy it much more than GTAO but everyone has their preferences.
If you have muneh its fun
What console are you on?
Ps4
Did you get all the achievements, every greet / antagonize dialogue line, every camp request, full compendium (each item bar full as well) every point of interest, every secret encounter, and most importantly, FIND GAVIN??
Those are just a few things to do 
Also, I cant think of a single situation where anyone would use half of these server emojis



Damn thats addicted
Thats nolive
I'm trying to do it, I call it 1000% completion, I'd say I'm about 500% there

Mega no life
Bruhh you re wasting you time
I play for fun
Don't you have a life
Nope
I’m hurt
I’m finishing up rdr2 story mode
My Foxtrotter I had ever since chapter 2 died on me when saving John. :((
I had that horse for a year
You cannot find gavin
oops
Fools, you can find Gavin, he's up in Canada, that's the real reason Charles went there.
bruh Arthur is Gavin
the online player is gavin and since the online player isn't in the story, it's why gavin is never found
yes
But I named Gavin Warner McAllen.....wait a second DOUBLE LIVES
I named mine The LUMBAGO Gunslinger

L U M B A G O
ugh running around collecting pelts for the tracker is exhausting. Tryna buy every piece of clothing he's got 💫
L u m b a g o
really hope we get a rdr3 so we can play the blackwater mission
If there ever another rdr3 I want it to be a completely new story
i think either way is good. i just want more content
Hi
With how frequently they talk about blackwater and the dead members like the callander bros and jenny in chapter 1 and 2 it makes eager to experience blackwater and to meet/play the people who died in blackwater
But im also cool with a new story
blackwater should never be a new game
it'd be cool as a dlc
a failure as a full game
it could be dutch bringing the gang together
i'd also like to do it but
i have lumbago, the terminal kind im afraid
its a slow and painful death my brother

Indeed
I once 100%ed rdr2 I didn't even know there were guides
does the hermit with the rare shotgun respawn? i went to his house and he killed me and when i came back he wasnt there
Has mods fixed the issues with rdr2 that people gave bad reviews for such as bad combat and long animations?
what
I killed him first time and got the rare shotgun, Idk how much later but he respawned with a double barrel shotgun.
I really want to play rdr2 rn, but i can't because my exams start in 19 days

sad
are the veteran side quests still available in the Epilouge? I want to get Buelle as John when the time comes
lmao Javier and Arthur arguing about how to pronounce Lannahechee is hilarious
Yes
You can do that one as John or Arthur
awesome
Rdr2 soundtrack in the background while ploughing through work is a real mood
ynneL!
Lennie?
lenneh
Lennay
Lenny? I’m Clyde you got the wrong feller
Do i look like a Lenny to u?
Well, yes
Yes, you can do the first three veteran missions as Arthur and come back in the epilogue as John to finish the last/fourth mission of the veteran. Dont forgot Buell, he's a one of a kind horse and dont forget the giants boar tusk
The giants boar tusk is a missable item
The veteran shows up in chapter 6 yea
The veteran missions can be started as Arthur and completed by Arthur, but can also be finished as john
idk if john can start the first veteran mission
ok. good to know
bai
im back John can also start the veteran mission, but then hamish wont be friends with arthur
sad
Best one is still walking in on the lady in the middle of conducting her business lmao. No shame 
But if you do it as arthur I guess you don't get to have the horse very long 
missed opportunity for a "join in" option 
dangit
Hey
Can someone clarify if I get to keep my original horse on the hunting trip with Hosea
Yes
He can
Oh sorry
You answered already haha
You can if you decide to stable it
He means the horse you dont sell I assume?
If that’s the case, yeah it just stays at camp
Oooh, yeah sorry about that
I wish they did away with the having to buy a horse while you're on that mission ngl
mhm
Waste of $15 having to buy a Morgan when you've got a horse at camp 

precious muneh
m u n e h
dollars even
thats why you do the first three as arthur and the last mission as john
stable it its a one of a kind
don't forget the quarter. - arthur morgan
I've seen that in my first playtrough and I couldnt stop laughing
the special and ultimate edition had the option to select the free horse option. I remember I named that horse Travis Scott
oops i talk too much
me with a precious free thoughrobred 😎
i got a free thoughrobred, and 2 arabians the black and white
I just ended up giving myself John's horse from thr epilogue lol. My headcannon is that Arthur leaves it for him along with all the muneh at the pig farm 
rachel is a nice horse ngl
Yeah its a beautiful coat
Much nicer than the brindle thoroughbred I got off the random encounter where the guy gets kicked in the face trying to change a horse shoe

ewww arabians
yea but dont forget im in chapter 2
pretty decent
arabians are the "fastest" horses but wait
is that a TURTLE?!!! 700 kilos away? imma buck u off
and run 100 miles away
so
stats really do not matter
at all
apart from stamina
and health
true
My Rachel got hit by a train in the first 10 minutes of epilogue free roam
@hidden moss when i finished the epilogue
i went to mount hagen with rachel to take micahs revolver and shoot his cold body
i didnt remember where was was at
so i was on a cliff with rachel
i fell
i called for it and he fell and died
so i was in the mountains
no horse and no fast travel
Oof
You take the pelt
I guess
What are you gonna do lasso the carcass half way across the map?
The carcass isn't needed for crafting
Just need pelt

You can't take the carcass
large animals like elk, moose, bears, black bears, etc can't be put on your horse
Can you not skin carcass put it on your horse then skin it later?
you can take the carcass of smaller animals, like the beaver etc.
^
your choice
but it would be sad if you died then the carcass is gone and you have a uncompleted compendium entree of a legendary animal
But what if you save
idk about that
Cuz I save alot
it doesnt stay there forever i think
yes thats good
One time I save scummed and my wolf carcass disappeared one time
how? I don't know
died in o driscoll gang camp In freee roam loaded a save and wolf carcass is gone
animal carcasses decay tho
its best to skin them while you kill them, what else are you gonna do with it?
oh you talking new austin legendary animals
ehh its possible to get them with arthur but its hard
very hard
I heard of the buggy thing but that's a bit too much
Having to drive from saint denis to new austin
yeah the buggy thing is hard
Screw rockstar
there is another buggy that spawns around the map thats usable too
but idk it lasts so long cuz too many shots at it and there is a hole in it and you still die
Sniper can shoot through wood for some reason
yes
near lakay
the hosea map
West of Lakay at the other side of the lake
Can it be done in chapter 4
Crap
it was only a scripted event in chapter 4 of the legendary alligator
In urban pleasures I've noticed my m199 pistol gets auto equipped
why
When the trolley ride starts for some reason I'm using an m1899 even though it's in weapon locker
sometimes the game swaps to the best weapon the player has, it does the same in other missons. idk if its the same for urban pleasures
M1899 best weapon
when I played american venom i also had a m199 and i before that i never even equipped it
What's next i auto equip sawed off in american venom
idk
also sometimes switches my semi auto shotgun for some random landcaster
someone who knows how to use rampage trainer how do i change my player back to arthur
i cannot find arthurs player model
@honest drum ?
i wanna mess around in 1907 as arthur
so errr I have 75% on one of the animal progress, how do I get the last 25%? do I just have to kill another one? I haven't played in a long time so that's why I'm asking
any specific animal or?
Whitetail buck
In order to 100% a animal. You need to track an animal thats 25% kill a animal thats also 25% and skin
but it depends on the animal
track, kill and skin
just look in the compendium what your missing
Welp, time to play mailman 
remove tuberculosis cheat code when
I just jumped off the hotel roof in strawberry and Arthur landed on his horse and get on lol
How did you even get up there
Howdy fellers 
yeah you can do that
What shenanigans y'all up to today? 
hi, how ya doing?
you don't wanna know
st denis
massacre
1899
😳
i just saw a video about how much content was cut from guarma
so much
its sad
i have audio of a cut treasure map side mission
i would've liked a longer story of guarma
i think i sent it before
i wanna hear it pls
I wish the new austin herbs were on guarma and we can like buy a ticket to guarma
can't get legend of the east as arthur without having to do complicated glitch
there was cut content for a ticket to guarma. the ticket would've cost a 100 dollars
yeah its sad
Wtf
Hur durr durr
The reason was probably you would see the black guy again and lore break or something
Also law enforcement?
?
Can I commit massacre and there's law on guarma
But they cut out TAHITI
still waiting on the day i can go to TAHITI
I want to go to tahiti pay for passage and get land for when we get there
that's what ditch wanted
c'mon I have like more then 20k
how much did the saint denis bank have
I would like a mod that added all cut content to rdr2 from whats recoverable from the game files. Sadly i dont know how to make mods for rdr2
I feel like if we ripped stuff from the game files shenanigans would happen
Like since it wasn't finished development it would probably feel weird
I wonder if they tested the ticket system at all
mmm idk
also have to kill the sniper on guarma
where do i find the talismans i bought? i dont see them in the satchel. i see the trinkets
wardrobe
thank you
np
You have to equip them?
y e s
nope thats not how it works
All this time I didn't have my 10% health core bonus thingy
trinkets do work from the moment you get them
@honest drum how do I install rdr2 mods, just drop the .asi file into the installation folder or how does it work?
is there a max amount of weapons your horse can carry?
even the pistols?
you can carry all weapons on your horse
revolvers, to pistols, to repeaters, to your bow, dynamite, etc.
every weapon in the game is stored on your horse
every weapon you have unlocked*
I should be able to carry 8 shotguns smh
i went around gathering all the unique hats and weapons. it wont let me in new austin to get the remaining items i guess i gotta do more story first
Dynamite bow vs legendary bear
i wanna get all the unique clothing from the trapper but i feel tryna hunt down every animal for a perfect pelt is gonna take forever
"vanity all is vanity" cheat with angelo bronte and save the game
Big brain
is it only pelts for these unique items cause i wont even bother gathering the carcass if thats the case
are unique outfits needed for 100%
no
its fun tho
ahhh i see so many cool mods to try. this is gonna be fun
For fun I got all my outfits and a rose gray with angelo bronte glitch
dont forget to save the wittemore
oh
during that gamble mission on that boat in st denis
Wittemore I don't have
after the mission its temporily stored as an outfit on your horse
it wont be there if your horse outfits are full
no I had it stored but then I cleared it for some dumb miner outfit
fun fact: the wittemore has two different outfits: the one with the blue tie = high honour and the red tie = low honour
can I have blue tie seperate
I wish I can change LOE outift without degrading temperature buff
but i forgot the wittemore myself too
thats an awesome detail
Even changing the LOE equipment to bandit equipment changes it to "withstand hot temp"
instead of withstand all temp
Too bad it's too easy to get high honor unless you deliberately commit genocide
I 100% rdr2 and yet I keep hearing arent you cold dressed like that
i h a t e t h a t
"yOur gOnna fReEze yO dEath mR moRgan"
for me its difficult to get high honor. takes forever
wait
Bitch I have the damn legend of east outfit on
do the honorable missions, like helping penelope braithwaite, charlotte the widows, helping hamish the veteran etc.
I just did bandit challenge 1 - 8 and my honor is like 60%
do the bandit challnges before the honorable missions
For the stagecoach ones I used alden so I didn't get a crap ton of bounty and loss of honor
im on bandit challenge 4 i think
Rains fall and strauss absolve debts give a ton of honor
you lose honour if you dont absolve a debt
They had to make bandit the best looking equipment
why lol
Your getting a debt
unless there's something weird
like killing braithwaires after mansion burns down
in chapter 6 arthur realizes strauss is stealing from the poor
thats why
arthur is near visiting his old friends at that point

im trying not to spoil the game
I wanted to shoot downes
I already did my first playthrough on my second except this one is 100%
i did the same
According to your best of the west role you already 100%?
And you somehow studied like 1000 animals
took me 3/4 months
ehh im addicted
like when i saw i already had 140 of 179 animals i thought why not finish it
I see
now im just messing around in old saves with mods
Can you beat the game with only sawed off shotgun
no, i already know a few scripted events where your forced to use different weapons
aren't those like final chapter 6 mission and urban pleasures
That's the only ones I can think of
off the top of my head
chapter 2, leviticus cornwall mission, john at gunpoint, chapter 5 on guarma every mision there there you cannot have sawed off shotgun. colm hanging mission forced to use sniper
i can name a few more examples
can you duel with sawed off because I never tried
idk, i didnt encounter a lot of duels in my 100%
Like duel jim boy callaway with sawed off
Ok
I also need to make sure I DON'T buy the m1899 next playthrough
i should try it
i like it
in american venom i was forced to use an m199
well shit
im thinking of a third playtrough in the future with mods
Rdr2 but you go 999 miles per hour
Can someone help me?
You know the hermit cave thing ?
Can john get up to the guy??
its possible, but its a hard jump to get to the hermit
yeahh, I got up as Arthur. But john can't for some reason
Lmao
Underweight john probably
I'm surprised I have average weight arthur in chapter 4
I've been eaten cheese wedges
I heard also passing out to being drunk increases weight
never tried tho
yes
u need scripthook too
same process
u know a site for good rdr2 mods, there arent a lot of mods on nexusmods
You look on the Steam workshops? I haven't tried but I'd see if there's any there
i dont have steam version
Oh ok
Ah I got it on steam when it was on sale Christmas 2019
got in first lockdown last year
Nexus mods
But ya I never looked into mods. When I've done everything I possibly can on the story I'm going back to Online
no
Not how mods work for rockstar games

send invite
im already in a modding rdr2 idk if its the same server
it looks like we're talking about the same server
on your profile it says we're in the same server
yeah i noticed that
I feel like horses are way too sensitive and when they get really scared they just ignore my inputs even if what I'm trying to do is more beneficial than standing still next to multiple predators.
It’s realistic
Depends on their Temperment.
I hate that argument. If the game was "realistic", everything should be realistic, not the majority and then leave the rest of the mechanics to rot.
Sorry what lol
I said that the horses was realistic
And that argument is completely invalid
Not everything has to be realistic/unrealistic
Tell that to Rockstar
If it was realistic, we would have to stop to find an outhouse every few minutes.
When going for gold medals - if i pause the game does it pause the timer?
I hope so.

having trouble finding cougars for master hunter 6; if you know cougar spawns ping me
can’t ping
Hey @wild dune are you playing as John?
I have a map in new austin that will useful if you are john
what you guys would think if rdr 2 online gives you the option of being a pinkerton?
it would be cool
I have a question about random encounters
If you just ride by without interacting will they reappear?
I’m worried I’ve missed a lot because I play with minimum HUD
Encounters respawn even if you already did them. But not all encounters like the appleseed wood company house...
Some encounters have stages
Okay cool thanks
For example if someone challenged you to a shooting challenge they will respawn
Like the union railroad company or the appleseed timber company those are staged encounters.
Cain just arrived at camp
Deckard cain... the rogue camp?
clemens point
Sorry, I'll leave.
having trouble finding cougars for master hunter 6; if you know cougar spawns ping me (playing as arthur, chapter 2) or dm me
@wild dune u have to kill 50 cougars using a shotgun
no i have to kill them with bow nerd
Nah shotgun preservers the pelt
bet
There is a cougar spawn near blackbone forest. check #red-dead-media
shotgun ruins pelt
Killing cougars with a bow is part of a challenge.
Nahhh not with incendiarys
And a shotgun does ruin the pelt. I've tried.
not sure if i want to scroll for hours looking for the map, just dm me it
k
I got a cougar to spawn near the trapper near blackbone forest, but only once.
As John north or ridgewood farm I couldn't get away from the cougars.
At least backbone forest is a static spawn for the cougar so you can just farm it by placing a camp nearby and sleeping until the corpse has despawned
Took me about five tries to get a 3 star cougar to spawn for my satchel 
xd
Annoyingly I ran into a cougar at the beginning of chapter 2, there's a random event right near horseshoe overlook where you have to save a guy in a tree from a cougar, but your weapons aren't good enough to preserve the pelt 
yea, ive run into him a few times haha
@worldly gulch I never found that spot I guess. I should have tried harder. Story of my life 😛
Tbf most of it is just running around like a nutter until something happens 
wow
lmao


I got lumbago
No, lumbago no

Working hard?
Didn't capcom make a really shitty version of Red dead revolver then sold the rights to an early stage R*
yeah i think you can still find images of the original game covers with the capcom logo in the corner instead of rockstar’s
If capcom didn't decide to make red dead revolver then we wouldn't be here rn
I was honestly surprised it was capcom and not a R* idea
lumbago would still be taken seriously
it is very serious
I wonder who’s the real rip van winkle
John Marston is not rip van winkle
And Jim Milton is not rip van winkle
So who is rip van winkle





What do y’all consider rich in both online and single player?
Why is it sometimes I can't cut horses free
The game wants me to blow up the banking coach and kill 4 horses
bullshit
Fml
Honor is actually hard to lose
I've done bandit 1 - 8 and haven't even dropped to neutral
No
Story
I just robbed a banking coach and I can't cut horses free so the game wants me to blow up 4 horses
honor.exe
You can shoot the lock
Or use a rifle butt to smash the lock siliently
Equip lancaster and you press X to smash
lol
I helped marry for 100%
I don't want to miss missions
if I was not going for 100% I wouldn't have helped mary
Why
based
me with 12 health cures for some reason
was it those mr black and mr white prisoners
After getting legend of the east satchel I have attained 99 cheese wedges
Those are getaways
"chain gang"
tbf they wouldn’t really survive as long as they did if they were alone
but by the end that could definitely be a possibility lol
shoot out the wheel spokes.
Spokes?
Yeah, the Bars giving the wheel it's shape?
Mhm.
It's a way to disconnect the horses in the event of not being able to free them by cutting the tack.
tf is that thing
I just found out banking coaches have heavy armored wheels
Welp
Gaflavvity
"Oh Darling Abigail, I've Changed! Come live with me in an outhouse, I wouldn't ask my worst enemy to take a shit in!"
If it's the Laramie Gang Leader, he's confirmed that ain't him.
that’s the laramie gang leader
Yeah, Ogg's confirmed that wasn't him in that role.
At best someone did a real good impression of Ogg.
Or he's playing coy.
when you read laramie’s lines written it sounds like some shit you’d hear in red dead revolver lmao
are you downloading rdr2 itself
Good morning! New here, finished the story and started new one 😄
Slightly related does anyone else think that Alden Carruthers sounds like Bruce from Family Guy 
Arthur must have superhuman metabolism cause five days on the trot now he's been having 6-7 meals per day and he's still underweight 
oh no.. why? what happened
oh god ... i got stabbed by micah for the ending...
You mean stabbed by Mikey
i mean stabbed by a bastard named raty boi 76
I play Vermintide 2, and Micah makes these rats look like honorable warriors
whats vermintide
A game like Left 4 dead with Warhammer's lore
but you fight Rats, Chaos mobs and beastmen, depending on map
Idk, now that I can freeroam. Doesn't feel right to just speed through the game
I'll finish it for sure, but it won't be the same.
The freeroaming is the best thing for me tbh. I've spent six days on this new save now, good 5-6 hours a day and I'm still only halfway through chapter 3

I spent 1 week in valentine, taking baths at the hotel, going to saloon for drinks and playing poker
I spent a lot of that time farming all the materials for the satchel and the camp upgrades too to be fair
This game is so alive, so the side stuff for me is mostly the world interracting
I loved upgrading the camp
Me too, but it will make Dutch having more plans
Yeah but I doesn't feel the same with only a couple weapons to choose from
I WANT to freeroam but it's tough when you need to do something
Ah yeah you went and did a Charles didnt you with your new save

cooking lesson
Never search "It's just a video game" on yt
As a psychology student, i ll add a new disorder : Post red dead redemption depression/red dead depression
I have that. can't recover. I think i wont ever..
Post Traumatic Redemption Disorder, PTRD
You may have it if the first ten notes of thats the way it is make you well up in tears

😭 😭 😭
My only wish is that I played it sooner to avoid spoilers
Arthur death wasn't what made me depressed it was really the lead up
This mission really tried to rip your soul out of you
-Horse death
-Goodbye to the ladies
-"You are my brother"
-Give away your hat
-That's the way it is
-Arthur dies
-Dutch being a douche and leaving you behind
-"May i stand unshaken"
I think the one time I was really close to crying was with the nun and how that was
Mine was during the ending credits, when Pearson looked at the old gang picture on the wall, and "see the fire in your eyes" was playing in the back, I couldn't hold it anymore.. tears were falling
That woman could pull my heartstrings with anything
is Amish guy or whats his name from Veteran side quest blind?
his eyes are empty blue grey as if he was blind
but he doesnt act like he is
For me it was the final horse.
Horses in this game in general leave me awestruck and have given me a new appreciation for these sensitive creatures.
I have no appreciation for dominoes. 😏
lol
same, my friend(a switch player) spolied the game for me on purpose but even tho I knew Arthur was gonna die I still shed a tear or two at the end
but I cried like a bitch when I saw epilogue John
It was torture seeing john look like my ass
Yeah I knew in advance arthur was going to die cause someone showed me the epilogue with John but I didn't know how he'd die and I broke down man
At least when i visit arthur's grave, i see an eagle
I get way too invested in my characters and rdr2 was the first game I've ever played where your character dies lol
Ma boah was honorable
As in: canonically dies
do u play on pc
Rdr2 early day yt vids were like kill mr downes early? Prevent tB
I'm also physically incapable of not wearing John's rdr1 outfit onwards 
yeeep lmao
Fun fact: if you do not have level 4 bond with your horse, Arthur will say "Thank you", otherwise i think he doesn't say that
it's not his rdr1 outfit
they scuffed it
Infinite gold limphany glitch
If you have level 4 bond*
Arabian horse is small
i think it's only if u have a level 1 bond he won't say it
Yeah I think with John at level 4 bond he says "I love you girl"
I don't think I've ever not had level 4 bonding by that point, might test that out
Really? I thought you need 4level bond in order to say it. Tbh i bought the cheapest horse because i had no money, i bought him the best saddle and the best stuff later, and i saw it die in front of my eyes 😦
Yeah that was always my issue with Arabians too.
My arabian bucks me off the second it sees a snake
Yeah I'm going to have to steal a horse when I get to that point. I'm using a mod that gives me John's epilogue horse and my headcannon is that Arthur left it for him ... can't do that when its ded 
Arthur ghost left it


So guys, do you believe that Micah was the only rat in the gang?
Dutch bad
Idk but saint denis job absolutely stinks of abigail being a rat
plot twist john was working for edgar ross from the start

I think he was yeah, think everyone else was genuinely loyal to the gang. I'm sure micah was too up to a certain point but I think he was offered freedom to bring the gang in like arthur was in chapter 2
I thought it was Micah's fault there too. If you pay close attention, you see the gang members all wearing dark clothes but Micah is wearing white.. something smells here
He should have told them fake info and kill ross and milton early 
I mean arthur could have just shot them there and then

Or when they came back in chapter 3 
I wanted to quick draw milton and ross in chapter 2
Still weird how John got arrested (while hosea and lenny were killed) and abigail managed to slip away when they got hosea
I think Milton killed Hosea because he knew that it would make the gang mad and lead them out. Lenny was armed and followed by the gang when he got killed, they couldn't arrest him, i think John was captured alone, this is why they arrested him. Not sure about Abigail tho, since she kills Milton later
Pinkerton's don't shoot girls

Nah cause when John says dutch couldve helped him they would've been together and actively shooting lawmen
I don't think any of the girls are necessarily as high profile as Dutch, hosea and Arthur
Karen is the only one who joins the robberies i think?
And she's got distracting assets 
Karen did the drunken harlot
these are not the fellers you're looking for
Yes, he saw him doing nothing, doesn't mean they were as close as Lenny was with the others when he got killed
Karen would like to speak to the bank manager

Alden is free money
Not free idiot 😡😡😡
Rob alden
full on rat yes, but i believe abigail gave a tip
on the st denis bank
maybe abigail got eavesdropped?
Ah, a man of great intelligence I see
arthur was the rat the whole time 
fuck micah
Ok
arabian horse is tiny
arthur and john look dumb on a arabian horse
Hosea knew something was going wrong so he most likely urged Abigail to get away.
Fuck Dutch, he was worse than Micah if you ask me
Cain was the rat
Even tho i antagonize Micah everytime
"Who made you Shepherd to these lost souls you've led horribly astray?"
The true rat was the horse you stole at the beginning
True rat was the deer you kill in the hunting mission in chapter 1
During my 100% playtrough I only kept antagonizing Micah at camp lol
Charles was the rat, let's face it
Joking of course, i love Charles, he is the true brother
The legendary bear from hunting with Hosea was the rat
Fuck that Bear btw, gave me heart attack
Mrbossftw is the rat
Actually we are the rats, we knew Micah was the rat, and we didn't kill him earlier
100% true
The rat outside Micah's camp was the rat
John's Shitshack at Beecher's hope was the Rat
no
if I did I wouldn't play rdo and I would use mods like crazy
time to witness Arthur’s death soon
Talking about mods, is there any mod for Nitro gun in offline mod?
Uncle was the rat. The one time he gives you a robbery lead and you get in an ambush with Cornwall's men
uncle is just an idiot
lol
what
nitro?
Elephant gun, the one from online
hello chat
Seriously? Does it have the model too? Cause i play on first person
well ye it's just the model atm
well u could use lenny's simple trainer to get the sounds and everything, but that also breaks some stuff
like the gunsmith
i made a navy revolver mod too
and a javier revolver mod
dang I’m at the last mission again
If you have the original edition and then get the special edition of rdr2, do you have to start a new game?
bruh
why deleye
then re semd
lol
Were can i find gun mods?
nexus mods
same as every other mod
also joun the rdr2 modding discord
for nexus
60k members
Strange, cause i looked up there and didn't find anything regarding to guns
Wanna get this game but I think pc is better as on ps4 can’t use mods and mods prolly fixed a lot of the games problems
your wayyyyyyyy better off ther
what
Because I'm being ignored
I ll check again, since you say they are there, i think i missed them
no u aint
but to answer ur question, yes probably
micah: pulls out gun
me: Q Q Q Q Q Q
I'm gonna see if there is a way to make deputy archibalds hat obtainable so that it saves in your inventory. It matches my outfit perfectly and I want it kek
Kill milton for milton's hat
Just finished American Venom last night and wow that was a way to end a game

You have chosen death
Uncle is a better gunslinger than Arthur and could handle negative effects like a true legend. Arthur died from TB and Uncle lived a full life and had the deadly lumbago.
this game make me depressed
Working hard uncle?
Kieran got spelt wrong
rip :(
lol
Micah's a little bitch and his balls were too
o'driscoll
HOW MANY TIMES DO I HAVE TO TELL YOU, I'M NO O'DRISCOLL
That's what an O'Driscoll would say
Yo yo
Well in some ways he is
He's probably a better shot than Arthur with revolvers. If not I'd put him at the same place as Arthur.
Micah does not have deadeye
he doesnt need it
He didn't need it
he's just simply good
He also is a badass
exactly
He is unloyal, but in some ways he was right.
He was a survivor
He wasn't loyal to anyone
Not in American venom 😂😂😂
He probably would've shot Milton and ross if he got what he wanted
mhm
micah can kill 3 people in 3 shots in like 1 second but in american venom he just shoots the box with 99999 bullets
Yeah hahahahaha
Well I mean I fucking shot his balls off so I think he wasn't exactly a good shot
Well the mission wasn't made to kill John
The real question is do you let micah die with his hat on
I think prime arthur is so much better than prime micah
It was meant to make John get his redemption, and looking great
micah is a badass
Definitely
micah only went after arthur because arthur was weak
not exactly
Did you see the magnificent 7 rdr2 trailer?
Micah needed daddy dutch to save him against a man breathing his final breaths
I've seen the magnificent 7
what rdr2 trailer
You have turned into my daddyyy
Of course his hair is a monstrosity
Well it's a fan made "trailer"
Check #red-dead-media
but with irl people
Uh i don't think it's that one @vivid umbra
no
what is the best gun type for the scorpion revolver in single player
will the legend of the east satchel go to marston after arturh's death?
Yes
Micah : Shoots Miss Grimshaw
Dutch : Who is betraying me?
Me : 
h m m
I think even one character said "dutch has a soft spot for grimshaw"
Before chapter 5
Yeah arthur said that to tilly
"do you think dutch would mind if I killed miss grimshaw"
One thing that irritated me is that Arthur didn't shoot Micah. He draws his gun faster, before Micah even pull out his revolvers. I know it is "plot" but Arthur could kill Micah easily there
He could, but what would the gang think?
Things didnt even get cleared up then. With Dutch continuing to go along with Micah, and less with Arthur. It would feel to Dutch that Arthur is trying to cover himself while making himself looking like a rat.
Dutch didn't even react on Micah killing Grimshaw. Unless he was that stupid... I wish i could shoot them both tbh
He was dying anyway
Dutch went crazy, he pretty much only believed Micah. He could've thought everyone was a traitor.
And, he only believed Micah because Micah agreed to everything he said.
I know, if i was Arthur i would kill this guy even if i got shoot in the end by everyone
it feels like almost by the end of chapter 6, deep down he knew he needed to trust arthur but due to his personality he can’t, because that would be admitting he was wrong which he never wants to be
dutch is one strange fella
👆 👆
it’s definitely shown by when he agreed to not save abigail, he says everything he can to be right. “it’s not like that arthur!” while he’s sweating and most likely shitting his pants
His constant talking about "a plan". He always wants to think he's right and has it under control.
Unrelated question, but why did uncle leave the gang and then return with Molly?
had to go to Ireland for his lumbago treatment
restock on booze
maybe even rob the bank successfully and uncle was secretly a legendary gunslinger and is true to be red harlow idk
Yknow before he was called the One Shot Kid
When do you think was the earliest point Arthur actually started doubting Dutch?
chapter 2
he doubts him
with john
in 'the sheep and the goats'
he still has faith of course
but he's starting to wise up a bit
It’s cool replaying the game and seeing all the foreshadow
You know the Dialogue with Charles in the mission where the 2 check out Dewberry creek?
Pretty good foreshadowing
Arthur says something like :"Dutch wouldn't just... hide out in a cave somewhere, it goes against everything he stands for. That'd just be admitting were all just low down criminals."
I was impatient XD and when I was looking up something in the game I saw the title of a video “does Arthur Morgan die” and once I saw that I was devastated. Rdr2 has the best story line of any game I have played so far. (A amazing game but sad and depressing but it’s a game with lots of death so that’s to be expected)
I want to kill Dutch but also feel bad for him. You can clearly see as the storyline folds out he is losing himself and getting worn out. Dutch even says so in chapter 4 (forget the exact line but Dutch does admit he is worn down)
^
Why do gambler challenges exist
I’ve spent at least 2 or 3 hours on challenge 8 and I only got one so far
i agree 
Micah would shoot dutch in the foot and still be like wHo is bEttaYing mE
does any body know were the naval watch is?
What do you do in the first Mary mission
recover a family heirloom from her dad or something
Bring back Jamie to her
That's the 2nd one I think
The first one, you need to go to those chelonians to try and bring Jamie, her son, back to her. @cerulean edge
"He keeps saying it's a disgrace that a man of his standing has to ride around on some old nag"
"Standing? He's usually falling down..."
I love the passive aggressive shit he gives Mary in the second mission too lmao
"We'll just follow the smell."
....
"Either he's waiting on a woman of dubious morals or he's trying to sell something"
...
"Looks like he's selling."
I remember so many jokes in rdr2 missions since I got nothing better to do
Oh my god I just noticed that the picture you take with Abigail is visible above the fireplace in Beechers hope
This game will never stop amazing me
Oh wow
Does it I live combat
Involvr*
If one more person in camp tells me I stopped paying into the box I swear I'm going over to the Pinkertons and hand them in myself 
No
It's a horseback chase and then you shoot the gun out of Jamie's hand
That's it
can yall help me install mods the vids arn't working
They tell u to donate yet they donate a used tooth pick
We will simply ignore the fact I bought all of pearsons camp upgrades and everything but the chicken coop out of my own pocket 
i just hate the bug where they say it's too cold out in chapters 2 and 3 no matter what you wear
Honestly its a meme at this point, I don't even bother interacting with them anymore
im just trying to get into the world for muh immersion :((
Y'know, it'd only make sense if it were further north like near little creek river in Big Valley in the hours before the sunrise.
IT isnt just chapter 2 and 3, its all chapters 1 until epilogue part 2
😐
Abigail, Jack and Uncle are still screaming at me that im too cold dressed like that
Yeah gets goofy and irritating.
Thankfully Beecher's Hope never gets over 72 Fahrenheit
During my entire 100% playtrough I've been told that im too cold dressed like that
I know it doesn't help when you actually do dress warmly.
do all stables sell the same horses?
No, you can find the best in Blackwater.
If you're still wanted in Blackwater, I reccommend the Black Arabian you can buy from the Saint Denis stables.
Just use whatever horse you like the best.
Doesn’t it not matter too much if you upgrade the saddle and get full bonding
Stat wise I mean
there are some horses exclusive to one area of the map, I generally prefer those cuz they are one of a kind.
I’ve been using an Appaloosa most of my new play through, I like the pattern on them
The Raven Black Shire is a good horse.
I had a Missouri pinto dapple foxtrotter as my main horse
She and Arthur died I’m in the epilogue now 
how'd you guys get it that early? was it using the photographer mission
i just stole a horse from a dude’s camp and kept it forever
moment
