wow!
#red-dead-singleplayer
candid walrus
upper fox
im little addicted to rdr2
i want more content
i dont wanna finish my playtrough, but there is almost nothing left for me
upper fox
probally the three horses you only get at a stable
upper fox
you going for 100%?
yes
candid walrus
ah, ok
upper fox
98% done
candid walrus
wow
upper fox
If I finish the last three legendary fish and pay my last respects to the last few fallen gang members I will have my 100%
candid walrus
that is a ton of time
upper fox
60 hours are from my first playtrough, this is my second playtrough
candid walrus
o
unique garnet
lucky for you, that snake is easy to find in new austin
upper fox
i've been struggling for an hour to find that snake
lost quartz
finally finished Algernons quest
candid walrus
awesome
lost quartz
jesus that was annoying
upper fox
congrats
lost hollow
yeee hooo finished herbalist 9
upper fox
jesus that was annoying
yeah
lost quartz
dope hat tho
upper fox
yeee hooo finished herbalist 9
congrats
upper fox
dope hat tho
yeah the revolver is cool tho
lost quartz
alot
upper fox
a lot of collecting herbs and hunting
candid walrus
Ive been getting bird plumes anytime i see them. is that a good idea..?
lost quartz
yep
upper fox
specific feathers, plants and when you hunt them its like they went extinct
candid walrus
oof
lost quartz
spoonbill and egret are what you want
candid walrus
ah, ok
unique garnet
gator eggs are easy imo
upper fox
eggs were the easiest
candid walrus
how do you get gator eggs?
upper fox
they have nest and you can take them
lost quartz
there are nests you can find
upper fox
near shady bale and bayou nya
lost quartz
easy to get
candid walrus
ok!
upper fox
just near the water side
lost quartz
egrets and spoonbills was the worst part for me
no reliable spawn location and spawn in small numbers
candid walrus
i finished the dreamcatchers this morning
upper fox
in a hunting event with pearson. PEarson will learn you that too
lost quartz
nice
upper fox
that event is in chapter 4
lost quartz
yeah he shows you gator eggs and crayfish
upper fox
jup
candid walrus
oo
upper fox
when i was in chapter 4 that was one of my first events
candid walrus
is it a companion activity type of thing?
lost quartz
yeah
upper fox
all my extra event missions I completed from the moment C4 started
lost quartz
like hunting or robbing homesteads
candid walrus
ah, ok
lost quartz
i do all of them when they spawn
upper fox
Mine all spawned at once
candid walrus
that will be good for the trophy 
lost quartz
most boring one was Uncles
upper fox
true
lost quartz
just steal some cows
upper fox
collecting bulls or something
lost quartz
shoot 2 guys
candid walrus
lol
lost quartz
that was it
upper fox
yeah
candid walrus
which chapter?
upper fox
chapter 4
lost quartz
shady belle
candid walrus
ok
lost quartz
im at the end near the bank mission and i cba to do it
candid walrus
any companion activities in c3?
candid walrus
oh wow
upper fox
any companion activities in c3?
Chapter III
Five Finger Fillet with Micah Bell
Dominoes with Tilly Jackson
Home Robbery with Sean MacGuire
Fishing with Javier Escuella
Fishing with Kieran Duffy
Coach Robbery with Bill Williamson
Coach Robbery with Sean MacGuire
lost quartz
theres Companion stuff in each chapter
candid walrus
thanks!
candid walrus
lol
upper fox
i've learnt a lot of new stuff in my second playtrough
lost quartz
poker was easy and so are blackjack and FFF but dominoes is awful
upper fox
Golden rule: Do white missions and events before main story missions.
upper fox
Also a golden rule: ALWAYS take the longest route or might else you fall of a cliff and your horse dies.
lost quartz
they dissapear
candid walrus
oooh
lost quartz
when yu go to the next chapter they dissapear
upper fox
The camp companions are specific for that chapter
candid walrus
yea
candid walrus
lol
upper fox
and some side quests become unavailable in some chapters, example the missions for helping penelope braithwaite and that other dude will become unavailable in the epilogue
candid walrus
ah, ok
honest drum
Oh brother, chapter 4
upper fox
a lot of side quests are available in the epilogue
lost quartz
Oh brother can be done in epilogue i think
upper fox
oh brother is available in the epilogue right?
honest drum
Ye my bad
I thought you meant side missions that are unlocked in different chapters
Lol
lost quartz
the penelope and that guys missions are awful
honest drum
But ye there’s a few, mainly just the honour ones though
upper fox
Stranger Missions
Chapter II
"Fundraiser" (Unavailable in the epilogue)
"Arcadia for Amateurs" (Part 3 of this mission will be skipped if done with John Marston)
Chapter IV
"The Mercies of Knowledge"
Chapter V
"The Widow of Willard's Rest":
All encounters can only be seen by visiting Charlotte Balfour 3 times with Arthur Morgan, and then visiting her once as John Marston in the epilogue
If the player never meets Charlotte as Arthur, only the first 2 encounters will be available in the epilogue.
If the player meets Charlotte as Arthur but doesn't complete all encounters, she cannot be encountered in the epilogue as she has passed away before 1907.
Chapter VI
"Of Men and Angels I & II"
lost quartz
so boring to me
upper fox
all misssable
honest drum
Part 3 of Arcadia for amateurs?
upper fox
the nun in st denis
honest drum
I’ve always done them as John
lost quartz
oh yeah
honest drum
I mainly do all the collectibles as John tbh
upper fox
i did everything i could with arthur and did the remaining stuff as john
also some side quests are needed for 100% and can be missed
lost quartz
yeah i probably wont do much in epilogue cos ive already got dreamcatchers, cig cards, most of the bones, most of the Leg' fish and animals
ill just finish off some challenges
like herbalist and horseman
and bandit
candid walrus
are you kidding?! i got silver again! i swear I got 12 headshots. smh
upper fox
You can do every challenge until herbalist 9
lost quartz
yeah thats what im on
upper fox
Herbalist 9 will be the only remaining as Arthur
lost quartz
i have to get 43 species
upper fox
4 herbs are in new austin
lost quartz
i have like 30 i think
upper fox
you have a checklist
lost quartz
does it?
lost quartz
yeah they give you one for survivalist 10 but not herb 9
upper fox
i made a document that i had as a checklist
lost quartz
annoying
upper fox
ahhhhhhhhh i cant find a black tailed rattle snake
the last animal remaining for the zoologist achievement
honest drum
I wish for herbalist 9 we got a checklist in the challenges section like horseman 10
candid walrus
yea
honest drum
Like I have to have a notepad open on my pc whilst doing it and ticking them off every time I get one, very annoyijg
upper fox
i did the same
candid walrus
i was also doing that and then I forgot to enter one so I have to do them all over again. :')
lost quartz
what is horseman 10, im still on 9 as arthur lol
upper fox
what is horseman 10, im still on 9 as arthur lol
tame every horse species
candid walrus
what is horseman 10, im still on 9 as arthur lol
i think its tame a bunch of different wild horses
upper fox
i remember
lost quartz
oof
upper fox
i had trouble finding hungarian halfbred, the game bullied me and when i got it i instantly i found 3 more of them
lost quartz
always the way
upper fox
every time you try to find an animal its like they went extinct
lost quartz
couldnt find a snowy egret then found 5 flying together after i finished the side quest
lost quartz
still killed them tho
upper fox
same
lost quartz
out of principle
upper fox
i did out of anger
lost quartz
i find it funny how after like 2 chapters deer become completely useless
candid walrus
o-O
lost quartz
they give ok meat and useless pelts
upper fox
Cool fact there is a bird in this game called carolina parkeet and there are only 25 of them in the game total and if you kill them all they go extinct. there is a secret side miissions for that.
lost quartz
venison is awful compared to big game
candid walrus
oh wow. thats interesting
upper fox
that secret side mission is only for the carolina parkeet
you get no reward
just the feeling you made a bird extinct
candid walrus
oop
dire glade
What's the easiest way to get myself dirty?
upper fox
riding through new austin
unique garnet
ahhhhhhhhh i cant find a black tailed rattle snake
ride off the trail in cholla springs
i see em all the time
unique garnet
where armadillo is lol
upper fox
i've riding through and near the area of armadillo for two hours
unique garnet
you'd be better of sleeping or reloading the file then
upper fox
you'd be better of sleeping or reloading the file then
any recommended time? i've trying to find them in noon
unique garnet
mid day is prob best, but idk if there is a "best time"
upper fox
i only keep finding dessert iguagna's, black tailed rabbits and american badgers
i've found it!
oh fuck, i never studied the timber wolf
but atleast I got the skin deep achievement!
candid walrus
wow!! awesome!
delicate sparrow
congrats
upper fox
im going for perfect animal compendium, so study, track, kill and skin so I still need to do three animals
for zoologist achievement
delicate sparrow
nice
upper fox
I need to track northern water snake, pluck eastern turkey vulture and study and track timberwolf
candid walrus
this whole time ive been rowing around flat iron lake thinking it gave me stamina experience >.>
upper fox
just run around and you will gain stamina
delicate sparrow
oof
upper fox
also do the challenges getting the reinforced equipemtn will get you max health, stamina and dead eye
candid walrus
kk
upper fox
the challenges are required for max health, stamina and dead eye, the reinforced equipemtn you can buy at a trapper
hidden moss
Bonnie McFarland is best girl
upper fox
true
huh, i just found a new animal that I didnt study and that isnt in the compendium an mangy red american squirrel
candid walrus
m a n g y
stable citrus
So pumped to have tiger mustang as arthur 
delicate sparrow
yes
stable citrus
Is there anything I should do before I leave new austin
upper fox
are you there as arthur?
delicate sparrow
hunt the legendary animals
stable citrus
Yes
upper fox
New Austin: Dinosaur bones, four herbs exclusive: special treasure map, legendary animals, legendary fish, Arthur special journel drawings. Thats about it
John and Arthur have both different drawings in New Austin.
Arthur has a lot of detail. John his drawing looks like a child drawing.
stable citrus
John draws like a child. Wonder why Arthur has drawings there anyway
Since you have to bug to get here
bronze pumice
I once heard someone say that he would’ve been able to go there at one point
upper fox
Even the dinosaur mission has a own cutscene with Arthur with dialogue at the end if you colected them all
stable citrus
Lame. I never played rdr1 so I don't care to play as John so much. And arthur is great
bronze pumice
I have never played RDR1 but still like John
upper fox
Rdr1 is worth playing tho. I would recommend it
bronze pumice
I guess you just get attached to a character if you play with them for thousands of hours, even if they aren’t saying barely anything
upper fox
YES I GOT THE ZOOLOGIST ACHIEVEMENT LETTSS GOOO
stable citrus
Gz what's that
upper fox
study every animal in the game
delicate sparrow
nice
stable citrus
Lot of animals in the game to boot. Studying birds can be a pain
upper fox
When I started going for zoologist I already had 145 done of the 178
so I was like why not finish it?
stable citrus
Very Finnish of you
upper fox
finnish? ah yes ice mountains
native willow
Rdr1 is worth playing tho. I would recommend it
Facts
Playing 2 then 1 (what I did) felt like a great experience
upper fox
Playing 2 then 1 (what I did) felt like a great experience
same
native willow
Onto undead nightmare, then a replay of 2 
upper fox
imma play undead nightmare soon
native willow
Would be cool for 2 to get a similar wacky, non canon expansion
Although I think that ship has sailed
strange dragon
If we got an Undead 2 which camp would you like to be the camp for the story
upper fox
Would be cool for 2 to get a similar wacky, non canon expansion
My english isnt that good, i dont understand a single word of what you just said
strange dragon
I would like Horseshoe or Rhodes
native willow
My english isnt that good, i dont understand a single word of what you just said
It would be cool to get a similar DLC to undead nightmare for 2
upper fox
that would be cool
native willow
Non canon meaning it’s not the “true” story
upper fox
i've seen a few video's about undead nightmare. it would be fun and cool for rdr2 too
native willow
Imagine Arthur Morgan, vampire hunter 
strange dragon
Imagine Arthur Morgan, vampire hunter <:DaveHahaYes:792492389080104960>
only in our dreams sadly
Arthur would be a great monster hunter
native willow
Totally
upper fox
I would love another experience with Arthur
native willow
Pre TB Arthur would beat the fuck out of Vampires
upper fox
Yes
strange dragon
I wanna see a zombie version of Arthur
upper fox
Wtf, Just completed entire animal compendium and within 20 min I already got 4 out of 5 animals for hunting request 5
bronze ibex
becomes bull when people hack/mod brings you to him blow up your stuff kills your mounts just to ruing your game to where you would quit the game from dum Ass hackers
inner raptor
If we got an Undead 2 which camp would you like to be the camp for the story
Shady Belle.
strange dragon
Shady Belle.
not a bad choice
maybe Beaver Hollow and Dutch and the boys can board up the cave
inner raptor
Beaver Hollow is right where the gang was about to end, nah.
strange dragon
true
I definitely wouldn't want to be john again, but I feel like R* would do that
strange dragon
Yeah, I think that is a good choice
They would have the mansion plus there could be zombie gators
maybe under the mansion there were vampire coffins and they woke up and you have to defend the gang
something
upper fox
i have 420 hours in rdr2, hehe funny number
strange dragon
I like John and Arthur equally but c'mon Arthur would be a bad ass zombie slayer
Plus we already have John's zombie story
It's time for either the LUMBAGO gunslinger or the TB gunslinger
Each of them are very likable that is why I can't choose one over the other, but I want more Arthur stuff too
That's why I kinda hate gta v a bit cuz R* just loves milking it
Gta v stands in the way of more good rdr2 content
yes but still it sucks big O'Driscoll balls
hidden moss
gta so boring
strange dragon
It is not boring it gets too much attention
hidden moss
i find it boring
free roam is like the most boring thing ever and only some missions are fun
strange dragon
I would honestly love a new GTA game set in the 80s
hidden moss
the story is okay but not half as good as rdr2
strange dragon
Yeah RDR2 is way better
Trevor is the best part of GTA v
but that is one character
RDR2 has way more likable characters
strange dragon
me too but then Micah
hidden moss
ye
i thought micah was cool at first when we rescued him from the jail
like i knew he was an asshole but i didn’t hate him
until the end
strange dragon
yeah same, tho some people say they hated him from the very start which I don't believe at all unless they knew what happened
strange dragon
Imagine giving GTA v another remaster
hidden moss
that’s when i started disliking him
strange dragon
I still can't believe it
hidden moss
lol
strange dragon
why not san andreas
I want to play that game again but with better graphics and smoother gameplay
Also, why did R* make rdr2 if they were just gonna leave it unfinished for some parts then leave it all behind for gta v
They could easily milk the shit out of RDR2
hidden moss
ikr
there’s soooo much more content they could’ve added
they could’ve addressed the blackwater massacre more in depth, they could’ve shown the backstories of some of the gang members (like sadie and charles) could’ve done something with the mystery man
the list goes on
The issue is that Rockstar made this to win awards and once it did that it was over for the game
strange dragon
The issue is that Rockstar made this to win awards and once it did that it was o...
Sad as hell
hidden moss
Thats just how the gaming industry is
strange dragon
Online can be fun but it could be one of the best online games if R* would actually do something with it
hidden moss
The issue is that Rockstar knows that no child will pay 500 dollars irl to buy gold teeth and lanterns on your horse
But it will happen in gta with cars and shark cards
strange dragon
Jesus why are children even playing this stuff
ik I sound like a parent but still
strange dragon
The issue is that Rockstar knows that no child will pay 500 dollars irl to buy g...
Plus if that is the case well idk what to say
Did they even respond to the outraged marston fans when they freaked out over the hair
Still I cannot wrapped my mind around this, even if a child is playing this I bet they would enjoy fighting vampires or any kind of monster
There is no reason not to give rdr2 more attention
It is still ready to be milked
hidden moss
But that's the thing they know people love the cars and rpgs in gta rather than a horse and revolver which is sad to say
strange dragon
I mean I don't cuz revolver and a horse is something different from my life rn
I want to be in a new world not the same fucked up world
Gta is fun but still I prefer rdr way more
hidden moss
Exactly
strange dragon
Also why can't they have one group work on gta and another on rdr
it is a win win for everyone
r* gets muneh and the fans for both games get more content
strange dragon
nah we understand
R* is Dutch and RDR2 is John yelling to R* "you left me to die"
But the fans are Arthur trying our best to save it
Gta V is MIcah
sorry to gat v fans but it's the truth
native willow
they could’ve addressed the blackwater massacre more in depth, they could’ve sho...
honestly, if Red Dead 3 is a prequel (again) I'd like to follow Landon Ricketts through the height of the old west, and finish off with his participation in the blackwater raid/massacre
so we could see what his involvement was, as well as what actually went down
hidden moss
ye
native willow
and yeah I'm not so sure
I'm 50/50 on if the series will continue
def not for a long time if it is
probably another 5-10 years
native willow
ye just a tad off
hidden moss
still a while tho
native willow
although RDR holds up surprisingly well
2 is like
wowza
prettier than irl sometimes, haha
native willow
I just played recently
can't recommend enough
it makes 2's story so much more powerful/impactful and crushing
native willow
I had a lot of plot points spoiled for both games, but it's still gone on to be one of my favorite series
strange dragon
If there is another Redemption story I think it should be Arthur's dad and throughout the story he teaches Arthur many things including revenge is a fools game and how to be a better person and then by the end we see his dad die. Then we can play as Arthur and witness him trying to raise his family but then he sees the aftermath of the robbery and goes to get revenge leaving Arthur down the wrong path
native willow
well less so "spoiled" and more so just exposed to it on the web and such
strange dragon
That is just my thoughts
native willow
didn't care much at the time, and both stories still wrecked me emotionally haha
hidden moss
i didn’t know anything about rdr2 when i played it
so everything was a complete surprise
which made the ending crush me even mor e
native willow
idk if I'm into the Arthur's dad idea, but i suppose it's just the execution of the idea that matters
my preferred 3 is either Rickett's story or Jack's story continuing
strange dragon
yeah, I am trying to think of possible ways to give the fans that want to play as Arthur again but also not involve too much of the van der linde gang along with the Black water massacre
native willow
so is the original Red Dead Redemption lol
strange dragon
I would prefer Jack's story or just a completely new story with new charcters and no more van der linde gang
hidden moss
if they remaster rdr1 to have rdr2’s graphics ima get that right away
strange dragon
Or a new Red Harlow game
hidden moss
same
native willow
Or a new Red Harlow game
you mean uncle? /s
strange dragon
you mean uncle? /s
yeah the LUMABAGO gunslinger
native willow
I don't really see your point, Red Dead 1 has cars in multiple missions, we just can't drive them
strange dragon
Yeah but I'm talking about it's main character with a new story
native willow
sure they weren't wide spread, but that also applies to 1914
yes
it's only a 3 year difference
hidden moss
“enjoy your fishing while you can, kid”
native willow
although I will admit the idea of Jack fighting in WW1 is fucking cringe to me
native willow
he wasn't fishing
he was hunting duck
along the river
shooting birds=fishing
big brain
evidently
native willow
who cares if it was finishing or not
it's just a mandela effect type thing where people remember it wrong
but yeah it's not really a big deal
he gets shot so hard he back flips into a river
hidden moss
yeah
aight well i’m probably gonna go cry to some of the ending parts of rdr2 for like the hundredth time so ye i’ll see you guys
gn
bronze zenith
I would not want rdr3 to follow Jack into the early and mid 20th century
That would be weird and out of place for the red dead series
bronze zenith
True, but I like red dead a lot, as is evident by me being here lol
And of course I want another game
at some point
strange dragon
yeah I think it would be cool but there is still stuff I would want to see happen with RDR2
plus I still haven't even beaten yet lol
bronze zenith
yeah there’s no way it’ll happen any time soon, if it ever happens at all
strange dragon
well 100%
strange dragon
yeah there’s no way it’ll happen any time soon, if it ever happens at all
yeah it seems GTA is R*'s main concern
paper peak
They could always make a gta prequel set in the old west
strange dragon
Jesus who knows where I will be in 20 years
lucid lake
i know its cheesy but id love another undead nightmare
bronze zenith
Another La Noire would be cool tho
lucid lake
that was awesome
bronze zenith
I never played the first La Noire but it looks good
paper peak
R* gets their gta, we get our rootin' and tootin'
strange dragon
i know its cheesy but id love another undead nightmare
I think almost everyone does
bronze zenith
Jesus who knows where I will be in 20 years
Same
native willow
I would not want rdr3 to follow Jack into the early and mid 20th century
I somewhat agree, but I think it could be done
like the epilogue of 2 and the main story of 1 already take place when the west was effectively dead
but once you go past something like...1918 or so, it would be pushing it
bronze zenith
I would hope they’d just either stay within the same time period (1899-1911) or go further back in history (like 1860s-1880s or something)
native willow
like...Jack becoming a gangster or a soldier are dogshit ideas imo
but a game with him could work
I do agree with you though
a game at the height of the west would be perfect
1870's or so
strange dragon
1870's or so
That is why I kinda suggested Arthur's dad or we could just have a brand new character
bronze zenith
I would honestly just like a brand new character
strange dragon
Still I would take a new character over Arthur's dad
native willow
my vote is sealed for Landon Ricketts
wanna know what he did at the blackwater massacre
also he's the fastest hand in the west...he has to be, he's the last one left 😉
strange dragon
The brothers that died in rdr2 is almost everyone's ideas for rdr3 that I see the most of are them being able to play in the Blackwater massacre then play as Arthur which are terrible ideas
bronze zenith
I’d even be down to see the game from a different gang’s (or solo person’s) perspective and how they interact with the Van der Linde gang in its earlier stages. e.g. you play as a character from outside of Dutch’s gang. Although that might not fit the red dead theme
native willow
yeah i think that idea works for 2 and 1, but idk if the dying/replaced protag should become a series staple haha
bronze zenith
The brothers that died in rdr2 is almost everyone's ideas for rdr3 that I see th...
Yea I mostly see people suggesting the people who died in blackwater
strange dragon
It's dumb to me cuz why devote a full game just for that idea
Plus it is just rdr2 if Arthur is the epilogue character
native willow
Yea I mostly see people suggesting the people who died in blackwater
this is why i prefer the ricketts idea
he was involved, on the other side and doesn't die
could be interesting
bronze zenith
Like I said, my personal favorite idea would for it to just be a completely new character who isn’t in the Van der Linde gang but still ends up interacting with them in some way. That way it could still stick to the “Van der Linde story” but R* could have a ton of freedom on what story to make
strange dragon
or if they go with Jack they can do Red Dead Sperm and have you be a sperm version of Jack and fight all the other sperms off and the epilogue is 5 year old jack
native willow
sand apex
That is why I kinda suggested Arthur's dad or we could just have a brand new cha...
we only see 1 picture of him i think
bronze zenith
this is why i prefer the ricketts idea
Sorry I haven’t finished rdr so I had to look him up, but yeah that could be cool
sand apex
only know that his name is luke morgan
strange dragon
we only see 1 picture of him i think
yeah it is in Arthur's tent
native willow
Sorry I haven’t finished rdr so I had to look him up, but yeah that could be coo...
no problem friend, haha
but he's a cool character
bronze zenith
or if they go with Jack they can do Red Dead Sperm and have you be a sperm versi...
Lmao
native willow
the mexico portion of RDR1 felt really special since Mexico isn't in 2
def hoping parts of mexico return in a future entry
sand apex
why rockstar give no mexico
native willow
well it wouldn't make sense story wise
sand apex
mexico dope
native willow
ye
strange dragon
I wanna see Javier make the guy poop himself
native willow
Javier is such a cunt in 1
bronze zenith
Exclusive land for the rdr players
native willow
he's so different in 1
strange dragon
Javier is such a cunt in 1
yes he is
bronze zenith
Javier is cool in RDR2
native willow
RDR2 javier has drip
RDR2 Javier has STD's
i mean 1
lol
also RDR Bill is fuckin' rough
not that Bill was ever a looker
bronze zenith
And I really liked Dutch in RDR2, so I’m scared to see how far he’s fallen in rdr
native willow
if you've seen how he is at the end of 2, it's pretty similar
bronze zenith
I liked Sean
native willow
just less emotionally distraught/messed up over his gang being destroyed
strange dragon
And I really liked Dutch in RDR2, so I’m scared to see how far he’s fallen in rd...
When he saw john in the epilogue he got scared cuz he was wondering how john manage to claim Arthur's hair
bronze zenith
just less emotionally distraught/messed up over his gang being destroyed
Aight
sand apex
sean was exactly how arthur described him
native willow
friendship with the van der linde gang is over, impressionable young native men are my best friends now - Dutch, 1911, probably
sand apex
an annoying little brother
native willow
I have a soft spot for Irish characters
bronze zenith
Sean’s death surprised me the most of any death in RDR2, but it was probably cuz he was one of the only characters I didn’t know would die before playing
bronze zenith
friendship with the van der linde gang is over, impressionable young native men ...
Oof
sand apex
everything goes wrong when micah leads
strange dragon
Sean’s death surprised me the most of any death in RDR2, but it was probably cuz...
Sean, Hosea and Lenny's deaths were sad as fuck
sand apex
dutch ruined the gang
strange dragon
I remember pausing the game after sean died cuz it was so sudden
native willow
Oof
yeah without spoilers, the first game expands on his using of Native Americans to further his own goals
like he does in 2, towards the end
sand apex
i loved hosea dn lenny
bronze zenith
I remember pausing the game after sean died cuz it was so sudden
Yup lol
sand apex
hosea is that one cool grandpa
sand apex
hosea was never wrong
bronze zenith
They were just walking down the street in Rhodes and then BOOM- Sean dead
sand apex
if dutch listened to hosea
native willow
Hosea was a smart fuckin' cookie
probably the smartest gang member, if not up there
sand apex
the gang would be in tahiti right know harvesting mangoes
bronze zenith
I wish they got to farm those mangoes
native willow
considering Arthur got a lot of his teaching from Hosea(iirc) I'm inclined to believe he was the smartest actually
Jack ends up pretty intelligent though
bronze zenith
but then the games wouldn’t have been as cool
native willow
cause he's a fuckin' nerd
strange dragon
Jack in the epilogue is annoying as hell
sand apex
5 year old jack in rdr2 is so fucking cute
mental hinge
arthur is intelligent in different ways
native willow
I don't think i ever found Jack super annoying
like sometimes, but only in the way it's designed to be
he wasn't that bad
mental hinge
he's not good at academics but he's creative and talented in arts
strange dragon
He was such a good kid in the main story but in the epilogue I wanted to hogtie him and give him to the skinner brother s
sand apex
i hate how john looks in the epilogue
native willow
valid
sand apex
i want young john master
native willow
it doesn't bother me that much, but it's pretty dumb
sand apex
john marston LOL
mental hinge
adolescent jack makes me wanna punch him
native willow
John should be a bit skinner/raggedy
strange dragon
i hate how john looks in the epilogue
I wish they fixed his hair
sand apex
yea
strange dragon
Johns epilogue face is fine
native willow
eh I give Jack slack in the RDR epilogue cause his life was shit
don't remember him being annoying in 2
personally
hidden moss
in the epilogue and the first game i like him tho
native willow
ye
sand apex
i love him during the story
hidden moss
his voice is just annoying
hidden moss
ye fuck strauss
sand apex
if arthur didnt do that mission he woulda lived
hidden moss
he’s pretty much the reason arthur died
native willow
he's so done with the world after the epilogue, it's kinda sad
sand apex
and micah would be in hell
sand apex
how is he arthurs kid though
hidden moss
no it wasn’t lol
strange dragon
who
hidden moss
it was confirmed that he’s john’s son
sand apex
by what? mrboss?
native willow
you're full of shit lol
mental hinge
reading back in the 1900's was equivalent to playing video games in the 21st century
native willow
he's John's son
strange dragon
MrBossftw confirmed this
native willow
it's obvious
hidden moss
exactly
native willow
plus Jack doesn't even look like Javier
mental hinge
related or not jack is still john's kid
native willow
he looks like abigail when he's younger
strange dragon
I hate when people try to relate everything to Arthur
hidden moss
plus Jack doesn't even look like Javier
he looks a lil like him when he’s grown up in rdr1
native willow
and is kinda the spitting image of his dad imo in the epilogue
hidden moss
he looks more like john tho
sand apex
"WASSUP GUYSYSYSYSYSY MRBOSS FOR THE LOSE HERE AND ARTHUR IS SUPER NICE TO JACK AND JACK IS CUTE AND ARTHUR IS COOL SO IT IS CONFIRMED HE IS ARTHURS SON NOW LETS WATCH THE ENTIRE TITANIC MOVIE FOR THEM ADS 🤑 "
native willow
mental hinge
if u read arthur's journal he actually would've married abigail if linton and marston weren't around
native willow
Jack is the best RDR protag cause he declines sleeping with a prostitute cause he doesn't want "crotch rot"
sand apex
im sure im not the only one who finds young jack to be super cute
native willow
that line made me roll
golden vector
(mangoes)
native willow
im sure im not the only one who finds young jack to be super cute
ye he's cute
"HAVE YOU EVER HAD SPAGHETTI"
sand apex
"let me know if you find candy"
mental hinge
"PAPA BRONTE TAUGHT ME LOTS OF ITALIAN WORDS"
native willow
"STOP CALLING HIM PAPA"
mental hinge
"DID YOU KNOW CAVALLO MEANS HORSE IN ITALIAN"
sand apex
i wish i could have jack as my kid irl
hidden moss
the saddest part of the ending of rdr1 is that john never got to learn what spaghetti is :(
golden vector
honestly
jack was so much better off with bronte wellbeing-wise
hidden moss
fr
sand apex
yeah dude
golden vector
society
native willow
we live in one
golden vector
fr fr
golden vector
even past the grave he leaves and comes back yet again
hidden moss
john coming back to life is like the dumbest thing ever
golden vector
how many times marston
hidden moss
takes all the realism out of rdr1
strange dragon
takes all the realism out of rdr1
Undead nightmare is just a fun game to play who cares about the story when Undead is not even canon
sand apex
can u even play undead before finishing the story
golden vector
if it was canon you would’ve seen it in the marston ranch chapter
hidden moss
ohh i thought it was a part of rdr1
sand apex
well would it still show him getting out of his grave
native willow
Undead nightmare is just a fun game to play who cares about the story when Undea...
this
hidden moss
my bad
native willow
nah ur good
but UN doesn't factor into the story at all
like, a zombie apoc didn't happen in the RDR world
golden vector
the only problem here is that there is no UN2
native willow
john isn't roaming around post 1911 as a shambling corpse
strange dragon
Zombie Marston vs Zombie Morgan
native willow
I guess you could think of UN as it's own timeline/separate thing
sand apex
arthur is better than john idc
sand apex
list of things john CANT do
native willow
I don't see a point in comparing
strange dragon
Arthur=John imo
native willow
facts
golden vector
if you take a closer analysis of john’s character, he’s just as complex and interesting as Arthur is
golden vector
Jarther Marston
hushed geyser
I just antagonized Susan and Arthur said: "Who you gonna shoot next?"
hexed wren
Jarther Marston
Jarther morston
golden vector
at least the dude becomes a writer at the end
native willow
ye
strange dragon
But The LUMBAGO Gunslinger is better than both Marston and Morgan
native willow
I like that idea/theory, although i know GTA is considered a different universe or whatever
sand apex
john cannot:
swim
parent
run properly
hexed wren
But The LUMBAGO Gunslinger is better than both Marston and Morgan
uncle "lumbago"
native willow
still consider it legit though
hexed wren
john cannot:
swim
parent
run properly
Yes
native willow
Jack becoming a writer just makes too much sense
golden vector
yeah
native willow
L U M B A G O
strange dragon
I like that idea/theory, although i know GTA is considered a different universe ...
There is solid evidence that they exist in the same universe
native willow
interesting
sand apex
los santos
golden vector
it’s an easter egg in a different universe but an easter egg that still confirms
sand apex
san andreas
spark shard
Jack's clothing looks like arthurs clothes and johns hat
native willow
I thought it was commonly accepted that they aren't
hushed geyser
Mary-Beth is one of the best camp members with some of the best events
sand apex
rdr2: new york, australia
golden vector
or maybe just a reference to rdr1 all together idfk
hushed geyser
Jack's clothing looks like arthurs clothes and johns hat
It's because it is.
native willow
Jack's clothing looks like arthurs clothes and johns hat
yeah that's one of my few headcanons in fiction
even if it isn't
I still want it to be
I still think of it as that
doubt it would ever get confirmed or denied
unless a remake/remaster made the coats the same
hushed geyser
Btw I threw dynamite in camp and blew up Micah
sand apex
i really loved charles
sand apex
yeah
golden vector
i actually who would win a fight hand-to-hand between arthur and charles
native willow
them leaving after the epilogue makes me very sad
golden vector
my money’s on charles
hexed wren
charles is buff
Charles is native american
sand apex
yeah i know
hexed wren
he is a street fighter what can u say
No, arthur is masscare soldier
golden vector
he’s half native half black
hexed wren
Because he masscare valentine
native willow
my money’s on charles
Charles physically or with a bow/stealth
gun fight to Arthur
hexed wren
strawberry
yes
hidden moss
if you didn’t kill micah wearing arthur’s hat you didn’t kill micah properly
sand apex
i really wanna see the blackwater massacare but at the same time its impossible cause
after that whats gonna happen
native willow
if you didn’t kill micah wearing arthur’s hat you didn’t kill micah properly
if you didn't put all 6 shots into his head or his dick, did you really kill him
golden vector
i really wanna see the blackwater massacare but at the same time its impossible ...
we can only assume it was like the St Denis bank job, something bad happens then the gang gets fired on by a shit ton of pinkertons
hidden moss
if you didn't put all 6 shots into his head or his dick, did you really kill him
no, you didn’t
sand apex
if you didn't put all 6 shots into his head or his dick, did you really kill him
shoots his lungs "hey there no-lungs"
hidden moss
bill says during the saint denis bank robbery that it’s worse than blackwater
hexed wren
we can only assume it was like the St Denis bank job, something bad happens then...
Fun weird fact:pinkerton is real life security contractor
golden vector
i think on my 2nd or 3rd run i accidentally set a sawed-off shotgun as my primary holster so when i shot micah he was just this bloody standing meat walking
hidden moss
i really wish arthur spit in micah’s mouth right before dying so instead of shooting micah in american venom you can just beat him up and watch him die slowly and painfully of tuberculosis
hidden moss
ye i don’t get that
sand apex
💀
hidden moss
micah had like 5 holes in his head when i killed him and he just walked away casually and fell over and died
golden vector
Fun weird fact:pinkerton is real life security contractor
yeah i knew that, they were one of if not the very first national detective agency in the U.S
sand apex
imagine he actually died cause the snow was too cold and he couldnt handle it
native willow
Even though I didn’t do the ending where Micah loses his eye, him calling John Scarface while looking like that is
Comedy gold
golden vector
micah had like 5 holes in his head when i killed him and he just walked away cas...
adrenaline and shock is probably the only explanation we have for that, and people have survived getting shot in the head before
other than that it’s mostly bs lol
native willow
Well irl Micah’s brains would be out
sand apex
but did those survivers get shot 6 times in the head
hidden moss
people have survived getting shot in the head once
native willow
Answer is it’s a game and the cut scene has to trigger that way
hidden moss
and probably not in the brain
native willow
Exploding his head would have been amazing
golden vector
but did those survivers get shot 6 times in the head
some people have survived several bullets to the head yeah
native willow
Just POP and fall
sand apex
well apparently old micah didnt
sand apex
is horseback 9 even possible for arthur
native willow
His body is still there after the epilogue?
hidden moss
ye
sand apex
or would i have to do it as john cause im doing 100%
golden vector
yes
native willow
Wild
sand apex
yea
hidden moss
oh nice
sand apex
so u can empty your pockets full of molotovs on his ass daily or weekly
hidden moss
i also spend like 10 minutes stabbing and shooting him
golden vector
good man
sand apex
imma show u guys my outfit for arthur tomorrow i think its sick
sand apex
double action
golden vector
yep
native willow
Nice
native willow
I find it awesome that you can still cock the double action manually each shot
The little details
sand apex
imma go now
hidden moss
there’s sooo many tiny details in rdr2 that rockstar didn’t need to add but still did
sand apex
good night fellas
native willow
Night
sand apex
as hosea would say 😔
native willow
Yeah the little details add up
golden vector
gambler revolver and micahs revolver
you forgot Algernon’s revolver
sand apex
i dont know what that is but do u mind telling me where that is tomorrow?
i might need it for 100%
sand apex
oh
sand apex
ok ty
red helm
Exotic's side Missions.... worst side mission there is.
golden vector
yes
red helm
Fragging Orchids. Forget the Plumes they are actually the easy part.
native willow
Oh fuck that lol
sand apex
ok gn
hidden moss
hol up for some reason when i see a bounty poster on the map and go to the bounty poster it disappears when i arrive in the town it’s in
why
golden vector
still better than the herding missions ngl
red helm
Why do people have so much problems with Herding? It's really simple.
hidden moss
hol up for some reason when i see a bounty poster on the map and go to the bount...
is it bc of my bounty?
red helm
There is like, 2 missions to herd, though....
and one is just a small side mission that isn't even required.
golden vector
it’s just to me but they feel boring as hell
golden vector
to explain it in the best way i can:
i simply do not find directing 15 animals to a location for 6 minutes fun, perhaps not boring at times but not fun
to me at least
red helm
Alright. It's one of the biggest things actual cowboys do, so, I'm actually surprised there aren't a lot more herding missions. Not that I actually Want to do more of them, but, they aren't hard.
golden vector
i mean when you first do them it’s fun
hidden moss
am i the only one that enjoys hog tying strangers and drowning them or burning them alive
golden vector
for other further runs they feel much more slow, like chapter 1 kinda
hidden moss
once i burned so many people alive in armadillo that as soon as i lassoed a guy he said “you’re gonna burn me alive, aren’t you?” and he was correct
that was a nice thing rockstar added tho
i didn’t know ai was like that
golden vector
wait fr?
hidden moss
ye
hidden moss
lmfao
spark shard
Fragging Orchids. Forget the Plumes they are actually the easy part.
I found the orchids to be easier 😏
red helm
I found the orchids to be easier 😏
I only find this answer acceptable if you didn't look them up online.
spark shard
Well guess what I did 😏 saved and loaded
red helm
What does that do?
covert lintel
Sorry if I sound like a child but gore really makes me feel weird
Wish there was a way to disable that
covert lintel
I see
native willow
would be nice for people to have that option
covert lintel
I'm fine with gore but in red dead 2 it's a bit extreme
native willow
but i find it makes the game more realistic and weighty
native willow
totally
like i said, i get it, although i personally enjoy it
anything to get more people into the story and stuff
and exploring the world or whatever
covert lintel
What guns mainly cause gore?
native willow
shotguns
covert lintel
Ik shotguns do
native willow
explosives
covert lintel
I see
native willow
high powered sniper rifles with headshots
if you stick to stuff like pistols/revolvers, and repeaters it shouldn't be that bad
covert lintel
Yeah im fine with blood
native willow
or perhaps try to go for more center mass shots
you can't blow peoples bodies up haha
covert lintel
I don't like nudity either but it's not their from what I heard
covert lintel
you can't blow peoples bodies up haha
Yeah lol
covert lintel
I don't like nudity either but it's not their from what I heard
Or at least not much
native willow
that i understand but like... it's the old west, there's prostitutes and stuff around
a boob or two is inevitable
although again, i can understand not liking it
native willow
but I do think it makes the world feel more alive/realistic, and it isn't too excessive in RDR2
covert lintel
Ah that's good
native willow
yeah i really don't remember a lot
it's mostly just violence
like there's some shit in a bar in a mission, but like...prostitutes hang around there, it makes sense
covert lintel
I see
native willow
I suppose the point I'm trying to make is, they don't use it excessively
and when it's used it's not just like HAHA TITTY
covert lintel
That's fine
native willow
it's something that makes sense for the world or story
I think the bigger issue would be violence
but i don't remember a lot of gore in cutscenes
covert lintel
Yeah nudity isn't too bad imo
native willow
def some gunshots and people suffering though
covert lintel
def some gunshots and people suffering though
I see
native willow
like overall, i think the story def has moments of all those things, but that's just cause of the world it's portraying
the wild west was fucked
but the game also has moments of beauty
that's probably one of it's greatest strengths
game puts you through a lot of emotions and feelings
sorry this has gone way on a tangent haha
covert lintel
like overall, i think the story def has moments of all those things, but that's ...
Yeah
If the gore was optional then I would be fine
But irs not so I'm gonna have to watch out on that
native willow
yeah just stick to center mass shots and not super powerful guns
deadeye can help that
covert lintel
I usually don't care about the esrb rating since it depends on how mature a person is
covert lintel
idk how far into the game you are
I haven't gotten it yet
I played it at a friend's house
native willow
ah i see
covert lintel
And had a lot of fun
Didn't notice much gore but mainly since we were doing fist to fist
hidden moss
tbh if they made a game where you’re john and you just take care of the farm and hang out with jack and abigail in beecher’s hope i would play it
pretty much just the epilogue but the length of a full game
hidden moss
morning fellers
sinful hound
Wadduppp
verbal prairie
ahh man I just clicked on an rdr2 soundtrack on my recommended and slowly but surely got goosebumps
sinful hound
Is it the one with that's the Way it is in the beginning as the first song?
hidden moss
the soundtrack gives me the feels 
verbal prairie
no lol, that ones too strong for me
I tend to avoid super emotional/ super intense soundtracks or scenes after I finish something for a while
I couldn't replay the breaking bad ending on YouTube for weeks for example
it wss Angelo Bronte's theme
hidden moss
same dude, I still cant listen to thats the way it is. its too much
sinful hound
That's the way it is is a powerful song but it didn't make me cry, just think about rdr2. The other songs tho... 😭
worldly gulch
Howdy fellers 
olive notch
That's the way it is is a powerful song but it didn't make me cry, just think ab...
Deadman's gun.
sinful hound
Howdy fellers <a:hattip2:748043742774296607>
I like you mister you have a kiiind face
worldly gulch
That reminds me of that disabled vet in valentine lol, the one who wanted a hug having only ever said hi to him 
flat oriole
The kind I like to PUNCH
:O da baby brrr brrr less go
undone fog
Wassup cowpokes
sinful hound
Sup black lung
mental merlin
hello peoples
candid walrus
hey
mental merlin
That reminds me of that disabled vet in valentine lol, the one who wanted a hug ...
I have ran into him
candid walrus
Mickey?
worldly gulch
Thats the one yeah
candid walrus
He's a cool guy. I saw a video where someone shot him once >.>
mental merlin
sad
candid walrus
yea
golden vector
s
candid walrus
all he wants is some muneh
mighty hemlock
I would know
strange dragon
Muneh
hidden moss
all he wants is some muneh
and faitftftfthhh
candid walrus
lol