red-dead-singleplayer

[crimson orchid]

quick question so you can have two different saddles on each of your owned horses right?

but the thing is everytime i saddle a horse up it always switches it with the one i had previously

cause i have more than one saddle but idk how to put the other one on my new horse

[slate night]

so what town is rhodes even based off of?

as a Louisiana native, I can't say that we have an abundance of reddish sand here

[delicate sparrow]

i don't like that one either

[hidden moss]

Woh I just realised there are allot more treasure maps then I thought. I got the poison trails, jack hall & high stakes. But there’s also Landmarks of Riches, The Elemental Trail & the Torn Treasure Maps

[delicate sparrow]

there's lots of them

[hidden moss]

Where John keeps trampling the sheep?😄

[hidden moss]

Yup. I had no clue xD

[slate night]

I liked after it

the bigass shootout in valentine

the mission I hate the most are those indian ones towards the end of the game, they just get boring

it also ruins my max honor, which was slightly difficult to maintain on my run

[safe nebula]

what do i do

with legendary bear pelt

[delicate sparrow]

sell to trapper

[safe nebula]

wheres he

[delicate sparrow]

go to saint denis

do NOT sell it to the butcher though

only trapper

[safe nebula]

ok

saint denis isnt on my map

[delicate sparrow]

get a train

[safe nebula]

theres one in valentine

right

[delicate sparrow]

every town has one

[safe nebula]

ok

[delicate sparrow]

get a train

and just look up directions

[red helm]

Rhodes confuses me too, there is a lot of red sand in Oklahoma, so, maybe they meant it to be like there... but then Lemoyne is supposed to be a southern state.... oddness.

[slate night]

yeah I'm in Louisiana, and we have no reddish sand here, so I'm not even sure where that town is based off of

[hidden moss]

Hi everyone

[red helm]

Perhaps it's supposed to feel like a way stop, from coming out of the plains of the west.... but still, it's to close to the Bayou's and plantations... so, doesn't fit.

Evening.

[delicate sparrow]

howdy

[hidden moss]

I really want rockstar to make a single player dlc for rdr2

[delicate sparrow]

not gonna happen, rockstar doesn't care about singleplayer

[hidden moss]

Yh ik sadly they just care about milking gta online

[delicate sparrow]

ye

[mental hinge]

they say it's a mix of missouri, luisiana and alabama

[hidden moss]

Whats your favourite mission from the game

Mine is the st denis bank robbery

[delicate sparrow]

idk tbh

[lost hollow]

that grind to get 70 gold medals is rough

[delicate sparrow]

ikr

[safe nebula]

are all clothes the same

[cerulean edge]

Are there any comprehensive guides out there that tell you how to do all possible things in each chapter so you don’t miss out on anything ?

Like stuff that would disappear if you continued with the story

[devout niche]

For the weapons expert where you have to kill enemies with throwing knives within 10 seconds - do bounty hunters count?

and or can you use improved throwing knives?

[delicate sparrow]

no, there's so many different clothes

[safe nebula]

no i mean

do they effect gameplay

[delicate sparrow]

yeah bounty hunters count, and yeah, im pretty sure improved knives are fine

[delicate sparrow]

yes and no

if ur in a cold area, like a mountain, you'll lose health core if you're not wearing warm clothing

however, the same will happen if you wear warm clothing in a hot area like rhodes

[devout niche]

But no, its not like clothes giving you an armor boost or anything like that

[delicate sparrow]

yeah

no armor boost lol

[safe nebula]

why are the missions greyed out and locked

[delicate sparrow]

cause you committed a crime in the area

wait till shit cools down or pay off your bounty

[bronze zenith]

There’s a lot of red clay in the Southern states. Doesn’t mean it’s necessarily reddish where you are, just that it’s more common in the South East than in the north

I’m sure they just used it as a way to make a distinction from Lemoyne/Rhodes to the rest of the map

[red helm]

Sure, but I've visited places in western Oklahoma, and the dirt there is quite red, like it is in Rhodes.

[bronze zenith]

Oklahoma is still somewhat Southern

[red helm]

Wouldn't really call it that...

[lost hollow]

holy! i gotta kill a grizzly bear with throwing knives without taking damage for Weapons Expert 10?!

oh ima have a rough time

[red helm]

Poison Knives...

[lost hollow]

smart

[bronze zenith]

It’s below the Mason Dixie Line, so I would call it sort of Southern

[red helm]

It's also West of the Mississippi.

[bronze zenith]

And?

So is Texas

Texas is certainly Southern

[red helm]

Texas is not a Southern State, Texas is Texas.

[bronze zenith]

Yes, Texas is a Southern state lol

Even some of Louisiana is west of the Mississippi

[red helm]

Are we going to call New Mexico a Southern state too? or Hawaii? it's south of the Dixie line.

[bronze zenith]

Yes, New Mexico is a Southern state lol

[red helm]

Mkay.....

[bronze zenith]

Idk about Hawaii cuz it’s way out in the Pacific. It’s not part of the contiguous 48 states

[red helm]

Technically the only states that should be calling themselves "The South" are the ones that were in the Civil War.

[bronze zenith]

Ehh

[delicate sparrow]

not necessarily ranava

[hexed wren]

Micah bell is atonement

[lost hollow]

I'm on Gambler 3: win 3 fillet matches but im on Chapter 6 as Arthur and the gang doesn't have games to play anymore. I went to Van horn and the game is available but there's no one to versus...

[lost hollow]

Same in Valentine. No NPCs to play with at the table

nvm guide said to walk out the saloon and back in until someone spawns

worked

[hexed wren]

Btw.. kill people on van horn to lead world war 3

[scenic oak]

I just lassoed some guy shooting at me with a shotgun but when he fell, he accidentally shot his own leg off

This game still amazes me

[hearty ledge]

I accidentally bumped one with my horse the whole town came after me

[hexed wren]

RIP

Advice:Go to bar and killing people will give defense and offense

[lost hollow]

on gambler 4 now. Gambler 3 was a pain. never playing finger fillet again

poker easy

[umbral kayak]

Hey all is there any way to rob shady businesses in the back of the store without being wanted?

[sinful hound]

I mean I know of one place where you don't get wanted if you don't fire a bullet

The st. Denis gunsmith

Go to the right of him and you'll find a steel Door. You know the rest.

After you open the door threaten the guy but don't shoot him

Then go up and knock out the guard

And then feel free to do whatever. Don't shhot the people as they'll give you the safe combination. If you wanna knock Tha players out too to get their stuff.

[pine sparrow]

Legit just finished the gamble 9 challenge to then see my fully bonded horse dead when I leave the table that I was sat at for like 4weeks straight to do this dumb fk ass challenge

[umbral kayak]

Ah okay cool ty. I just robbed a medicine store in the back in Valentine LOL

[sinful hound]

That's cool.

[umbral kayak]

I pointed my gun at the cashier/doctor and he took my in the back

Pretty neat

[pine sparrow]

sounds kinky

[umbral kayak]

Lol

[sinful hound]

Ooh

[forest blaze]

how did you take 4 weeks to finish it

damn it wrong message

[sinful hound]

You're too old to row...

And you're too dumb for anything else

[lost hollow]

Is the Saint Denis poker game rigged?

can't win

[sinful hound]

Which one?

[forest blaze]

poker

saint denis

[forest blaze]

no just go all in

they will either fold or be brave

the first time they will probably fold

[lost hollow]

well i can win sometimes but im tryna bust someone for the challenge. it's been 2 hours.....

they are ridiculous

[hidden moss]

gambler challenges dont test your skill at all. they test your patience.. who designed these

i wish dominoes didnt exist

trying to win a dominoes game:

[lost hollow]

Yay gambler 4 is finally done..... Now I gotta play Dominoes

[lost hollow]

I don't understand how to play dominoes

[pine sparrow]

it depends which one you're playing because I'm pretty sure theres 3 different "modes"

and hf with gambler 9 xd

think it took me 3-4 hrs

easiest dominoe is at emerald ranch btw

imo

[sinful hound]

Damn @pine sparrow is like the third person I saw here with a Thomas Shelby avatar lmfao

Don't mind it tho, great actor and great performance.

[pine sparrow]

true

[worldly gulch]

Took me a fair while to get the hang of lol, I usually play the all fives mode cause its much faster, cause you score points for each multiple of five that's on the ends on the table as you go along

[forest blaze]

people dont know how to play dominoes?

[lost hollow]

nope. when i was a kid i stacked the dominoes and knocked them over. was never taught there was an actual game xD

But i beat the challenge!

[hidden moss]

me playing dominoes:

[sinful hound]

Dominoes here are completely differently played

[hidden moss]

I'd rather play 10 Poker challenges than one dominoes

[forest blaze]

id rather do the gambler 8 than 9

honestly

[pine sparrow]

its crazy how long it took me to do 9

when it took me like 2 minutes to do gambler 10

[lost quartz]

my tiny brain could never

i struggle playing poker let alone dominoes lol

[sinful hound]

I just finished Bandit 10!

[lost quartz]

nice

[sinful hound]

Finally I can rest

It wasn't that hard I just wasted a lot of ammo

[lost quartz]

i havent tried the bandit challenges since my first run are they hard?

[sinful hound]

No,they're fun. You're just gonna lose a lot of honor.

Emerald Ranch helped me with almost every challenge.

[lost quartz]

yeah imma wait til john to do them

[sinful hound]

Stick around there

[lost quartz]

idc about honour in prologue really

[sinful hound]

I did the same thing! Arthur is never a bad guy

[lost quartz]

i prefer doing more sand boxy stuff with john

[gaunt scarab]

You can't send spoilers here right?

[lost quartz]

more realistic stuff with arthur

sure

we all do

[sinful hound]

Challenges are kinda repetitive. The hardest challenge was the third. Deliver 3 coaches to Seamus in one day

[lost quartz]

just dont tell people who say they dont want spoilers

[sinful hound]

^

[gaunt scarab]

oh good then I'm safe

[lost quartz]

doing a stagecoach robbery might be handy there

you get 2 coaches sometimes

for the final ones

[sinful hound]

Huh?

[gaunt scarab]

And is there any money penalty or something when you load a game?

[sinful hound]

Uhh

What do you mean?

[lost quartz]

yeah what does that mean lol

[sinful hound]

The stupid thing : when you steal 3 or 4 coaches for Seamus and deliver only 1,after the cutscene all the other coaches despawn

Sometimes not a single wagon comes out in emerald ranch

[lost quartz]

damn thats annoying

[sinful hound]

Mostly they're there though.

[lost quartz]

just gotta pray for good odds

[sinful hound]

Just look around the roads.

[gaunt scarab]

load save

[sinful hound]

That won't work I think

[lost quartz]

?

[sinful hound]

Resetting save will just repeat everything that'll happen that "day"

[lost quartz]

^

no money penalties or anything lol

[sinful hound]

Yeah lol

For real tho bandit challenges are great!

Explorer too

[lost quartz]

explorer was dead easy

easiest challenge by far imo

herbalist seems really annoying

[sinful hound]

I'll try to do herbalist as John

[sinful hound]

Yeah mostly it's just find a treasure map and find a treasure

[lost quartz]

good to do early game cos you get around 2k in total

then go to limpany and get the gold

[sinful hound]

It was fun collecting em

Because I found the lack hall game treasure with my father without looking at guides

First time he ever played rdr2 with me

[lost quartz]

nice

i gave up after a while and used the guides

[sinful hound]

Lmfao I need to do herbalist 2

[lost quartz]

is that the berries?

[sinful hound]

Yeah

4

Don't know where to find em

[lost quartz]

ive got 3 but cant find a 4th

[sinful hound]

I found ome

Oh I think I already ate that one

[lost quartz]

ive got evergreen huckleberry, raspberry and currant but cant finad another

use the interactive map thats what imma do when i get to it

[sinful hound]

I found the raspberry and another. I forgot which I did

Do you use the regular rdr2 map!

[lost quartz]

i use the rdr2 interactive one when finding stuff

dino bones, dreamcatchers etc

[sinful hound]

Yeah, the one from the app store or?

[lost quartz]

check red dead media

i use that one

just use the filters on there and its really simple and accurate

[sinful hound]

WHAT

NOOIIII

I DIDN'T SAVE AND NOW I NEED TO DO BANDIT AGAIN

[lost quartz]

[sinful hound]

At least it was fun ig

[pine sparrow]

btw to do gambler 10 easily just spam all in

usually most of the table will fold and its just rng at that point

[lost quartz]

Thanks

[sinful hound]

Wtf I can't find the plants it's still 2/4

I don't even know which ones I need

I ate like 5 different plants and still its the same

[hidden moss]

Blackberries, Evergreen Huckleberries, Raspberries and Wintergreen Berries

[candid walrus]

^

[sinful hound]

Yes but I can't find them anywhere 😫 😫

I checked on the maps and stuff, still nothing

Finally found the huckleberries

No wintergreen tho

[worldly gulch]

How does that one run versus the jean ropke one? I find that one to be quite bulky and slow sometimes so any strong alternative I'll take it

[lost quartz]

The one i linked is great cos you can turn on and off the things you wanna search, mark off ones you've found and each one comes with a small description about where it is

I've also had 0 problems with it running badly its been smooth and 100 percent accurate on the places

[hidden moss]

yeah and rdomap is also good cuz it has everything and free. well, not everything, but you can search every animal and plant for free.

[strange dragon]

Is there anyway I can make either Arthur or John pee, without any mods?

[hidden moss]

well for Arthur just get drunk with LENNEEEH

[sinful hound]

Replay that scene in a quiet time

Infinite p e e

[strange dragon]

yeah, Ik that but I want to pee on Beecher's hope

[strange dragon]

can you use your mod to pee on micah's dead body?

[strange dragon]

what do you think I do with that quiet time?

[sinful hound]

Ahahahahahah

No

A mission called "A Quiet Time"

The one LENNEHHHH

[hidden moss]

yeees lol

[upper fox]

Guys what stuff do you lose between the transion fgrom chapter 6 and epilogue part 1, Just got my stuff back and I lost three gold bars...

[azure cairn]

You lose everything except guns I think

[upper fox]

Where the hell did my medical tonics go and gold bars then?

[azure cairn]

They disappear

[upper fox]

Well I lost 1500 dollars rip

[azure cairn]

Finish the story and you get a big stack of cash

[upper fox]

but stil it was extra munnehh

[hidden moss]

I used to be the prize pony but now I'm the work horse

Thats a good quote

[strange dragon]

I hate when people say that Arthur's TB is deadlier than Uncle's LUMBAGO

Arthur had a quick death while as Uncle had a long painful death/life

[sinful hound]

Still can't find those wintergreens

[candid walrus]

i found the wintergreen berries near the trapper by blackbone forest, right where the cougar comes running at you. did you try there?

[sinful hound]

I didn't. I was looking in Annesburg.

Thanks for the tip!

[worldly gulch]

Semi related i guess but what disease does Hosea have? Couple of times in camp ive noticed he mentions being sick to Arthur and he coughs a lot, does he have tb too?

[candid walrus]

np! i also posted a picture in red dead media

nvm picture wont work -,-

[strange dragon]

I actually never encountered any of that, but who knows.

He was working on medicine at horseshoe

[sinful hound]

I think he had lung cancer maybe a bit over but idk.

Maybe even early tb

It was very big at that time.

It was widely known I mean

[worldly gulch]

I ran into one random bit with him and Sean where he's literally bent over coughing and throwing up so wondered what he's supposed to have. Granted I never noticed it in my first playthrough but I kinda rushed through the story

[strange dragon]

it is possible he could've had black lung disease but i doubt it

it literally could be anything

[honest drum]

there's a audio file named 'hosea_sick' and it's full of him coughing

so he was sick

it's not old age

what it was tho IDK

maybe TB

maybe arthur didn't even get it off thomas downes, TB is usually spread to someone over a prolonged period of time

[candid walrus]

odd

[honest drum]

not direct contact

[candid walrus]

o, maybe

[mental merlin]

do I have permission to blow your wall with a bomb

[mental merlin]

don’t you mean old boy

[honest drum]

what?

[mental merlin]

he’s old

probably

[wild spoke]

if i didn't did the quest of the aberden pig farm can i still get my mony back?

[honest drum]

what yes u just go back

[mental merlin]

uh

I don’t even know

[honest drum]

there isn't a second quest

u just run back

it's behind the painting

[honest drum]

...

hosea_sick

[mental merlin]

if I need money I will rob a home stand in chapter 3

[wild spoke]

yes but I didn't did it when I was Arthur can i still get it?

[honest drum]

what?

u want arthurs money?

as john?

[wild spoke]

yes

[honest drum]

no

[mental merlin]

you can’t

[honest drum]

u get like 20k when u finish the game anyway

[strange dragon]

don't you mean old boah

[mental merlin]

sure

[wild spoke]

didn't you say it's buying the painting?

[mental merlin]

what

[honest drum]

what

i meant if u did the quest

obviously lmao

[wild spoke]

oh

ok

[mental merlin]

I still have half of the 20 k left

and it’s been almost 2 weeks

[sinful hound]

Can plants respawn?

[mental merlin]

prob why

[sinful hound]

Nothing

[mental merlin]

totally

[sinful hound]

Off to herbalist 4

Herbalist 5!

[candid walrus]

awesome! that one is pretty easy if you know where to look

[sinful hound]

Good thing I have like 4 tobacco alteafy

I find em in the heartlands usually

[candid walrus]

thats good

[sinful hound]

Thanks again for the location!

[candid walrus]

no problem, glad i could help out ^^

[mental merlin]

[candid walrus]

smol arms

[mental merlin]

LYEENH

[candid walrus]

YNNEL

[mental merlin]

ynnel

neeley

[candid walrus]

lyenn

[mental merlin]

jenny Lenny

is Jenny’s lennys sister

[candid walrus]

A r t h u r a n d M a r t h a

O_O

[mental merlin]

they both have similar names

[sinful hound]

Or

[candid walrus]

or?

[sinful hound]

BiLl aNd pHiL

[mental merlin]

Sean and bean

[candid walrus]

B e a n

[sinful hound]

That would pronounce Sean like sheen

[crimson orchid]

There a photo mode channel anywhere?

[mental merlin]

yes

RDR2 media

[sinful hound]

#community-content ig

[crimson orchid]

Oh nice

Thanks

[sinful hound]

Nw

[spring sluice]

Or been like bohn

[sinful hound]

Ahahah

[misty nebula]

#red-dead-media #red-dead-fashion #general-media

[sinful hound]

Herbalist 5 finished!

Oh god what is herbalist 6

Oh my god

[spring sluice]

?

[sinful hound]

It's hard

[honest drum]

thats what she said

😉

[sinful hound]

I imagine it has gotta be annoying af

[spring sluice]

"collect 15 plants in 10 seconds"

[sinful hound]

Out

[sinful hound]

Almost

Only Collect 15 different plants

[mental merlin]

that’s like hard

[sinful hound]

You can't even do that

[candid walrus]

ah I hated that one

[spring sluice]

Yea he said it was hard

[honest drum]

it's not 10 seconds lmao that would be impossible

[candid walrus]

wait until herbalist 9... 🥲

[sinful hound]

Considering the time needed for the animation to finish

[mental merlin]

yea it’s impossible

[sinful hound]

Don't spoil

[candid walrus]

i wont lol

[sinful hound]

Thanks

[mental merlin]

I hate the train bird one

[sinful hound]

Huh

[mental merlin]

used a train in Rhodes

got wanted for robbing a train when I was shooting birds that were flying

worst part train goes into saint denis

[honest drum]

thats so easy lol

[mental merlin]

but I got out

[honest drum]

jump on a train from valentine

vuala

[mental merlin]

Not when you get wanted

[honest drum]

about 50 crows

[mental merlin]

where does it bring you

[honest drum]

through the heartlands

if u stay on it long enough u go through cornwall's oil thing

[mental merlin]

oh hell

[honest drum]

but it's ez for the challenge

[mental merlin]

I don’t like when you have to get oil

for the train rob

shit

because it’s too easy to die

they shoot the oil

you go KA BOOM

[candid walrus]

yea

[honest drum]

u know u don't have to get it from the refinery

[candid walrus]

the gold medal for that mission is difficult

[honest drum]

they travel around the map

[mental merlin]

Wait

[candid walrus]

what?! you dont? for me there were only ones at the refinery

[honest drum]

on the map too

[honest drum]

no

there's one in valentine

[mental merlin]

You get gold medals from doing all the challenges in the mission???

[candid walrus]

gosh dang it..

[honest drum]

at around midday that comes through

[candid walrus]

ye

[honest drum]

they all have different schedules

[sinful hound]

Can anyone tell me where to find most different plants at one place or is it just rng

[mental merlin]

I didn’t know

[honest drum]

one of them stops at valentine for a break in the saloon

[mental merlin]

uh forest

[candid walrus]

painted sky is a great place

that's where i completed the challenge

[mental merlin]

yes

[honest drum]

just ride around the map tbh

ez

[sinful hound]

Wow thank you bro

[mental merlin]

what mission do you all hate

[sinful hound]

So helpful

[candid walrus]

lmao

[honest drum]

ikr lmao

[sinful hound]

That gator missiom

[honest drum]

same

[sinful hound]

Hate it so much

[mental merlin]

yea it’s quite boring

[candid walrus]

uhhhh. not quite sure

[honest drum]

charles hunting chapter 1

[candid walrus]

ugh i hate that

and saving john in chapter 1. super boring -,-

[mental merlin]

when I did that one first IT TOOK ME LIKE 20 MINUTES

[honest drum]

why 20 mins

[mental merlin]

because it was my first time playing

[sinful hound]

My boy couldn't shhot with a bow smh

[mental merlin]

then my second time took me like 10 minutes

[honest drum]

as it is for everyone lol

took me about 10

first try

[sinful hound]

^

Don't know why but I hated the snow

[honest drum]

i like ch1

overhated

imo

except for charles hunting

[mental merlin]

chapter 2 and 3 are like the best tbh

[honest drum]

ye

[mental merlin]

so much good missions

[honest drum]

not story telling best tho

chapter 4-6

for that

[mental merlin]

I like the first mission in chapter 3

[sinful hound]

👈 for chapter 2,👉 for chapter 3

[mental merlin]

chasing a train

[honest drum]

👈

[sinful hound]

👉

[mental merlin]

🖕

👎

[honest drum]

[candid walrus]

o-o

[crimson orchid]

In terms of good mood between the gang? For sure. But in terms of storytelling it gets heavy as the game progresses

[mental merlin]

well yea

[pine sparrow]

[sinful hound]

4 plants found

[mental merlin]

chapter 2 and 3 are good missions

[mental merlin]

wow

[honest drum]

i have no idea how the rdr2 modding server has double the members in this server

i thought this server would of had more ngl

[sinful hound]

10 more plants to go

[mental merlin]

yesterday or the day before a bunch of people joined tbh

[mental merlin]

noice don’t take a year

[sinful hound]

Hope not

[crimson orchid]

Oof links don’t work here?

[mental merlin]

N o

[crimson orchid]

Got it

[sinful hound]

Try #red-dead-media

[crimson orchid]

The talismans aren’t very helpful are they

[mental merlin]

this is Arthur on the toliet

[sinful hound]

Holy cow try dead eye emptying the whole magazine while dusk wielding m1899 pistols

Dual *

[mental merlin]

ded eye

🪦

👁️

dead eye

[honest drum]

which one was ur first

playthrough

[sinful hound]

6 more plants to go

[honest drum]

for me

[sinful hound]

to me

[hidden moss]

gang

[mental merlin]

same

[crimson orchid]

I was a little low starting off but people told me honor was really important for the ending you got so I got it up

[honest drum]

👀

[sinful hound]

6 more plants to goo

Oh wait I already said that lol

[crimson orchid]

You can’t f*ck rats it’s humanly impossible

[sinful hound]

Speaking from experience?

Desperate eh?

[crimson orchid]

Let’s just say it wasn’t possible

[mental merlin]

and my second run is

[candid walrus]

O_O

wtf did I walk in on

[crimson orchid]

I can’t play low honor I just can’t after playing for the first time

[mental merlin]

why

[crimson orchid]

I was like ok ima do a low honor playthrough

But Arthur doesn’t hit the same as just a bad man

As a degenerate

It don’t feel right

[mental merlin]

okay

[crimson orchid]

Alright?

[mental merlin]

John and Arthur are very very cool

[sinful hound]

There are like 2 different ginseng right

[mental merlin]

I think

[sinful hound]

American ginseng and the other one that doesn't say it's ginseng but really is

[hidden moss]

alaskan

[candid walrus]

alaskan

[mental merlin]

it just says PLANT

[sinful hound]

Will both count towards herbalist 6

[mental merlin]

prob

[sinful hound]

Are they different plants

[hidden moss]

yes

[mental hinge]

yes

theyre 2 different species apparently lol

[sinful hound]

Oh ok, kinda weird

Thanks y'all.

[mental merlin]

Arthur be like take my hat John and leave

[sinful hound]

🫂

[mental merlin]

and then Micah is like

🤜

and Arthur goes

[sinful hound]

Me traveling from valentine to New Austin

[mental merlin]

🌄

and Arthur be

🪦

[hidden moss]

🦌

[mental merlin]

[hidden moss]

authurs death scene was sad

[strange dragon]

Micah Bell

[mental merlin]

sad

Sad

[hidden moss]

sad

I'm afraid

[mental merlin]

MICAH evil

Micah in hell when he died I think

and Arthur go to heaven

with high honour

[strange dragon]

Atleast Arthur can be with his ho and son along with the other fallen gang members

[mental merlin]

AND JOHN BE LIKE

and Dutch go

now

Dutch when goes be like

🚶‍♀️⬛

he walk into the dark abyss

uh every ded

[mental merlin]

and colm

[strange dragon]

colm

gives them some berries

[sinful hound]

Hmm

Only 1 plant left!

[honest drum]

wait until herbalist 9.........

[sinful hound]

Don't spoil

Pls

I can't wait!

[strange dragon]

im in chapter 2 and i'm trying to do the bandit challenge 2, what's the best way to find and rob stage coach

[sinful hound]

Go to emerald ranch

Quite remote and there's wagons everywhere

And you get money when you sell to Seamus

[strange dragon]

i did, and i didn't find anything

but thanks

[hidden moss]

did you do the mission with hosea

spines of america

[sinful hound]

I DID IT!

[mental merlin]

good for you

[sinful hound]

Make 5 tonics and use em? Pff

[hidden moss]

I cant do that one cuz i dont have the recipe

[strange dragon]

No I do not think so

[sinful hound]

You can do any tonic I believe

[honest drum]

oh you can...

[sinful hound]

Oh wait no

You need special wonder tonics

[hidden moss]

no dude i need the recipe first

[sinful hound]

Yeah I saw that now

[hidden moss]

maybe it unlocks with story. idk im stuck at that challenge for now. rip

[candid walrus]

what do you need? the special miracle tonic?

[sinful hound]

I think so, yeah

Make 5 and use em

Yarrow, burdock root and something else I forgot

[candid walrus]

i know where you can get the free recipe pamphlet. i cant remember the exact location but it's near little creek river behind the cabin in the woods. let me find a picture and i'll send it in #red-dead-media

[hidden moss]

i dont wanna know. i want to find myself but thank you

[honest drum]

fence

rip

[mental merlin]

[candid walrus]

lol

[honest drum]

currant

im doing it rn]

[upper fox]

Are there any epilogue part 1 exclusive items? So yes which one So no imma gonna go to part 2

[mental merlin]

[hidden moss]

hello

i installed trainer for rdr2

this not make ban me yes?

[mental merlin]

what trainer

[hidden moss]

from nexusmod

Red Dead Trainer
By iJamesss

[mental merlin]

I don’t know

[hidden moss]

i got a ram error

now it works

and it works nice

what if i accidently press on online?

i read theres a function that instant closes the game then

[mental merlin]

I don’t know

[sinful hound]

Wait for me dawg

I can't play anymore😭 😭

[delicate sparrow]

which challenge

[hidden moss]

Craft 5 special health tonic. But dont tell me where to find it please

[mental merlin]

why

[sinful hound]

I don't wanna

I'll be on later

[mental merlin]

I know how to get the recipe

[hidden moss]

Don’t use it online

[sinful hound]

I just need the stuff for the tonic. Already bought the pamphlet

[hidden moss]

Don’t say it bro

[mental merlin]

I won’t

not hard to get it though

[hidden moss]

Thanks mister

[sinful hound]

I can't wait for herbalist 9 and 10

Idc if it's hard

[hidden moss]

Herbalist 11 : harvest 5 mangoes

[mental merlin]

Mangoes?

[hidden moss]

Man goes

[sinful hound]

Moon walks sometimes

Ba dum tss

You love it

What's the hardest herbalist challenge

Just say its number

[candid walrus]

9

[delicate sparrow]

herbalist 69: hold micah at gunpoint and have him pick herbs for you

[sinful hound]

Ahahah

[candid walrus]

LOL

[sinful hound]

Herbalist 9 got something to do with new Austin?

Don't know if that's true

[delicate sparrow]

yes

[sinful hound]

How much does it have to do with it?

A lot of traveling I presume

[dawn bone]

I got a question and i was wondering if someone could help me

[strange dragon]

yeah

[dawn bone]

Okay so you know the Saint Denis Night Time Black Arabian Horse quest thingy? I tried stealing the horse but a lawman saw me and then i died ( with autosave on ) and now im wondering if i could re-do the quest

[strange dragon]

yeah, you can re do the quest.

If for some reason you can't just go to your save file and load up a game file that doesn't have that quest progress on there

idk cuz that hasn't happened to me before

[dawn bone]

Thats the problem, i only got 1 file

So imma cri

I never claimed the horse, i just died in the middle of the quest

And it didn't work since

[strange dragon]

did you fail the quest?

or did you complete it

after you died of course

[dawn bone]

i think i failed? a lawman got mad at me cuz i didnt move along but the horse, man and dead wife dissapeared

and after that i died

[strange dragon]

You should be able to do the quest again

[dawn patio]

Has anyone tried seeing what happens if you shoot Benjamin lazerus, the guy in the theater that let's you shoot him in the mouth and bites the bullet, in the chest instead of the mouth ? Does he die?

[inner raptor]

"If I murder a man, does he die?"

[river edge]

hey

[strange dragon]

No, he doesn't die

[dawn patio]

No I mean like, he survives if you shoot him in the mouth, because he claims he bites the bullet, but if you shoot him in the chest will the game just pretend you shot him in the mouth

[river edge]

"If I die will i really die?"

[dawn patio]

So he bites the bullet even if you shoot him in the leg?

[dawn patio]

Not the metaphor literally

[strange dragon]

nah

[mental merlin]

uh do you just find bones random holes in the ground

because I’m doing a side mission where I have to find 30 bones

[dawn bone]

How tho

it never respawned

[dawn patio]

No, you can look up the locations for all of them

[mental merlin]

so some of them are on land?

not underground

[dawn bone]

Does anyone have spicy locations for spicy horses? in storymode?

[dawn patio]

By lake Isabella theres the best horse in the game

[dawn bone]

I already have that one :3

[dawn patio]

I cant think of any other horses besides arabian lol

[floral jasper]

I met Rains fall

Precious man

[dawn patio]

I tested it and shot him in the leg he falls down and gets mad at u but doesnt die

[delicate sparrow]

great dude

[floral jasper]

Indeed

I'm tracking down all the former gang members and peeps from side missions

Is there a location for Trelawny? After completing the game

[upper fox]

I just tried swimming to an island in New austin, but I forgot John cant swim...

[delicate sparrow]

lol

[floral jasper]

[inner raptor]

His horse can.

[hidden moss]

That isnt where the foxtrotter spawns?

[dawn patio]

Isnt the arabian the best in singleplayer

[misty nebula]

the white has the best stats

[dawn patio]

Ya

[misty nebula]

but it also is scared very easily

turks are good

[dawn patio]

Ya but I personally care more about health stamina speed acceleration than all the other minor factors like fear

[mental merlin]

I think I glitched into johns tent when he was sleeping

[dawn patio]

[strange dragon]

idk, if you go far enough or do another mission it should be there again.

[dawn bone]

ZI hope, thanks for the advice!

[blazing thorn]

I dislike myself for losing 4 horses during my second playthrough

[delicate sparrow]

don't you carry horse reviver?

[hidden moss]

I have an idea for the rdr3 story, You play Mac and you and the gang just got to blackwater where you do heist that range from banks to robbing Colom and it ends with the Blackwater job. you go to different camps four times you start at blackwater then go to strawberry then you go a much my populated Tumbleweed then move back to Blackwater for the final heist you play a very short time as the three who were sent scouting ahead and get to witness John get his scars. It would add in three new members that die before Blackwater Jamey, Roney, and sam. This I feel like could wrap up the story of the Van Der Linde game and then the next game could start a whole new story. If they make rdr3 I hope its somewhat like this

[chilly bough]

Nothing beats playing RDR2 for the first time

[delicate sparrow]

it won't happen

[chilly bough]

The first run through of the story

[delicate sparrow]

rockstar confirmed that we will never find out what happened in blackwater

[delicate sparrow]

ikr

[hidden moss]

damn

I felt like that could really be a good game

[chilly bough]

wait, how do i get my correct roles?

[delicate sparrow]

go to #roles

[hidden moss]

I just want a red dead with more Sean

[chilly bough]

Alr

there we go

[delicate sparrow]

ye

[chilly bough]

it doesn't have a PS5 role :/

[delicate sparrow]

we all miss him

[misty nebula]

yes

[delicate sparrow]

get the ps4 role, cause ps4/5 are cross platform

[chilly bough]

hm

yeah

[hidden moss]

I shot every Gray after that mission while in a Sean outfit because of his death

[delicate sparrow]

yeah sean was amazing

[hidden moss]

only reason i got the bad honor ending

[verbal prairie]

the blackwater idea is pretty popular

it sounds great but

it doesn't really work out

[unique garnet]

Black is better than White... Rose Grey is better than the Black

[mental merlin]

white

[forest blaze]

war horse

[lost hollow]

I like the Champagne Missouri Fox Trotter

That's what I got Arthur using right now

Great stats

[inner raptor]

White costs 0 dollars btw.

👍

[lost hollow]

White horse so cliche though 😂

[mental merlin]

Anyone know where the hell I can get wild mint from?

like where can I find it

[lost hollow]

Just about anywhere. Looks a little like the tobacco plant.

[delicate sparrow]

yeah

[hidden moss]

mildly infuriating: i hunted and skinned a 3 star moose but there was already a pelt on my horse. so I left the pelt on the ground near my horse and went to find another horse. when i tamed a new horse and returned, the moose pelt was gone. why?? i was mad

[lost hollow]

Hmmm think it's normal for pelts to disappear if you leave that despawn radius. Bodies usually stay but think pelts always disappear

[hidden moss]

but WHY.. why.. it should stay there. i wasnt even too far away.

[lost hollow]

Think bodies stay because they decay over time. Wouldn't make sense to leave dropped items on the map forever

[mental merlin]

can you find wild mint in forests

[lost hollow]

I have found mint by the tree lines

[delicate sparrow]

yeah, check #rdo-compendium

[devout niche]

I cast my Lake lure into aurora basin 10 times and didn't get a bite. That normal?

[lost hollow]

What are you fishing for?

Did you try tapping the reel to slowly reel in the lure? That usually attracts the larger fish.

Think the smaller ones prefer bait

[devout niche]

I'm trying to catch a legendary. I think it's rock bass. I just hold down the reel button on slow. I don't tap it.

[lost hollow]

If you use your eagle eye you should be able to spot the legendary. It'll look noticeably larger than it's normal counterparts. Also when it's swimming around the water will look more disturbed. Once you see it cast out near it.

Make sure you're using the Special Lake Lure

[devout niche]

Tapping reel seemed to make a difference. Special lake lure, not just lake lure?

[candid walrus]

Yep. You need special one for legendaries

[lost hollow]

Yup

[devout niche]

ugh. Ty 🙂

[lost hollow]

You're welcome

[devout niche]

So far fishing is making me not want to go for 100

[lost hollow]

Haha 😂

Ya it's a grind

It's been taking me forever to get 100% completion

Takes 10x longer than just getting the story done. I played the story through my first time playing. A year later I decided to get all the achievements. Think I started my 2nd play through 2 months ago.

Like while trying to get other achievements done too so I don't miss anything along the way.

[devout niche]

Yep, its all a grind. Trying to kill birds of prey with a tomahawk

[lost hollow]

Think I'm at 73% completion right now

[hidden moss]

Does anyone know how to get ponchos. Please I’ve spent so much time on the game and I still can’t find any

[crimson bronze]

Ravens count.

Still

I think

[hidden moss]

I’m on 89% completion

[crimson bronze]

So a lot easier to just kill something, wait for ravens then mark them in dead eye and chuck the tomahawk.

[unique garnet]

ponchos only exist in red dead online

[hidden moss]

WHY THE HELL ROCKSTAR

[floral jasper]

LUMBAGO

[slate night]

it's weird going to places I am familiar with in RDR2

like I know some landmarks from New Orleans and the other smallers towns are super familiar to me

[quaint warren]

Hello

[mental merlin]

Jesus Christ I’m drunk in RDR2 and it’s making me want to puke and commit die

is there a way to get more storage

[wary oasis]

Satchel storage?

[mental merlin]

y e s

[wary oasis]

Upgrade it via Pearson at the camp

[mental merlin]

how will I do it if I beat the game

[wary oasis]

Sorry?

[mental merlin]

bruh nvm

[wary oasis]

Could just explain your question more?

You finished the SP missions basically?

[mental merlin]

the what

[wary oasis]

single player

[mental merlin]

y e s

I beat the game

[crimson bronze]

You mean playing as John? Buy the Satchels at the fence.

[mental merlin]

a fence

I don’t even think they sell them

[wary oasis]

Check r/reddeadredemption there is people asking in there and the fence is the answer

[lost hollow]

Ya go get your satchel and anything else that will make your game life easier cause if you wait until after you beat the game, then are you really gonna keep playing the story?

[wary oasis]

I upgraded all mine by CH6

But I'm aiming to collect and complete everything

[lost hollow]

I also want to collect everything too

[wary oasis]

I made my own list of everything and just scratched stuff off when I got them

[red helm]

Collecting everything is boring, I am just standing on a road, shoting every bird I see. Damn birds.

[lost hollow]

I do the same thing 😂

[wary oasis]

I've spent the last 10 hours just trying to find hats I've not collected

😁

[red helm]

I'm actually only slightly exaggerating. I've been hunting for a Perfect Woodpecker carcass for the last several hours....

[lost hollow]

Ya those perfect birds are hard to get

[red helm]

Indeed, I got a Perfect Cardinal really quickly, but the Woodpecker is just refusing. I've killed a few, but they keep going to 2 star.....

[lost hollow]

Using small game arrows?

Think that's what they need

[red helm]

Yeap..

[lost hollow]

Ya then just gotta try to get a head shot if you see them chilling on a rock or fence

[devout niche]

Do I keep a legendary fish if its less than 10 lbs?

[red helm]

Very hard to find them just sitting somewhere, I usually find them flying around.

[red helm]

I know that guy that wants the Leg fish talks about only wanting high weight, but I just sent the fish, regardless of what it weighed, and never had any trouble...

He never sent them back or anything..

[devout niche]

I wondered if that rule was just for non-legendary fish

[red helm]

Don't worry about it, as annoy as a few of them are to fish up. Just send them and move on.

[upper fox]

Does anyone know something about the dead chelonians camp in New Austin?

Im looking for loot and I could only find a small jewellery bag

[red helm]

I don't remember one...

[upper fox]

I send a ss in media

[red helm]

It was like October or something when I was exploring there in my first play through, so, I'm sure someone else would be more helpful.

[upper fox]

couldnt find anything online

[red helm]

Some camps just have suck-o for loot, though.

[upper fox]

im currently and slowly making the whole new austin map for myself visisble and i came across that

[red helm]

I found a camp, up on a cliff in the Big Valley area, that was really hard to get to, but all that was in it, was a silver pocket watch and a money clip with, like $5. Super disappointing.

[upper fox]

sad

i once accidnetly found some fluorite and something else that ended with rite dunno what its used for

[red helm]

Indeed.

[upper fox]

some weird gem stones

or something

[red helm]

Meteorite?

[upper fox]

no

[red helm]

Oh, darn...

[upper fox]

It's called ammolite and fluorite I've found it in a eagle's nest

[red helm]

There are 2 known Meteorite pieces but they say 2 out of 3 when you look at them. Yet, no one has every found a third.

Oh, interesting.

[upper fox]

So far I've found two meteorites. One in a house and one meteorite crash area

[red helm]

Yeap, those are the two known.

[upper fox]

Where does it say 2 out of 3 meteorites? Im kinda curious

[red helm]

In the Satchel inventory, or at a Fence when selling.

[upper fox]

Wth one of my meteorites is missing

[red helm]

Just, all items have a limit you can carry. Might not mean anything.

[upper fox]

I swear I feel like I lost a lot of collectable items during the transition from chapter 6 to epilogue

Three gold bars gone

[red helm]

Surely the collectible/special items won't have disappeared, that would be lame.

[upper fox]

My preparation for hunting request 5 is gone

[red helm]

Carcasses indeed go away.

[upper fox]

so I've have to hunt them again

all my tonics

all my fishing stuff

[red helm]

Lures or just worms/crawdads/etc?

[upper fox]

Lures and specific food for some fish

both

[red helm]

Huh, lame, but.. oh well.

[mental merlin]

wow legend of the east satchel is so god damn good

[red helm]

Yes, it is.

[upper fox]

I've spent 1500 dollars to get everyhting back

[upper fox]

jup its good and looks good as well

[mental merlin]

now I finally won’t run out of god damn food

and heals

[red helm]

Yeah, it looks neat, but doesn't quite fit with some outfits... I made a all black outfit to go with my Dishonorable ways. So the Satchel of the East kind of stands out.

[mental merlin]

wait can I catch 99 of each fish now?

[upper fox]

Almost everything is max 99

[red helm]

You could...

[mental merlin]

amazing

[red helm]

Bullets are obviously more than 99.

[upper fox]

Yeah thats why I said almost

[red helm]

But, yes you can have 99 meats and such

[upper fox]

Just saw a random house in New Austin blow up

wtf

[mental merlin]

Lol

[red helm]

Ha, yeah, I remember that happening. Interesting encounter thingie. North of Gaptooth.

[upper fox]

I never explored New Austin in my first playtrough, so its a interesting experience rn

[mental merlin]

jeez I spent a lot of money on items

[red helm]

That's what money is for.

[upper fox]

I've found and seen some weird shit in New Austin some kind of lady with a animal head or something

[mental merlin]

time to do bounty’s or some other shit

what the hell

[red helm]

The 'Donkey Lady' ?

[mental merlin]

is cigarettes still 20

[upper fox]

idk might be

you could get a drawing from it

[red helm]

"Donkey Lady" is some f'd up shit, and made me really love to shot up the Del Lobos.

[red helm]

Cig's can go to 99. Just assume everything can go to 99.

[upper fox]

Yeah

Meteorites cannot go 99, the colectable stuff cant

rare collectible

[red helm]

Well, yeah, certain things are just hard to get more than a few of.

[mental merlin]

just saved someone from getting robbed and then they gave me money for saving them

makes sense

Jesus Christ so much cigarettes

[wary oasis]

Few around Lake Owanjila

[devout niche]

I saved a wife from the skinner bros. They killed the guy she was with. If I had acted faster could I have saved them both?

[upper fox]

I've found an perfect woodpecker around little creek river near hanging dog ranch it took me 35 min

[upper fox]

Guys I'm curious Im now in epilogue part 2 and got a loan from the bank, does my money frequently go away or does it go away after certain missions after i worked for that money?

I dont want my johnny marston broke again

[worldly sequoia]

just got 100% last night

[devout niche]

@upper fox don't go out of your way to accumulate money in the epilogue

[hidden moss]

Niceee

[worldly sequoia]

@upper fox yea don't worry about it

[lost hollow]

Oh I have a hard time finding those carolina parakeets. I found them on accident and I haven't been able to find them since.

[worldly sequoia]

@lost hollow They mainly spawn in the bayou i know of three locations. I've killed 23 out of 25 lmao

[lost hollow]

What 3 locations? Any info I've looked up on them don't work for me.

[worldly sequoia]

just be patient every now and then just check up on a location you know of

[lost hollow]

Fine then. Keep your secrets.

[worldly sequoia]

no secrets it's just a rare animal lol

[lost hollow]

Excuses

[dawn patio]

I like how if you kill the racist guy in saint Denis there are no witnesses even if theres people right next to u

[worldly sequoia]

rockstar knew what they were doing lol

[lost hollow]

😂

[dusk socket]

Who are you? Aiden, O'Malley. What are you doing Mr. O'Malley? We were lost at sea. Arthur: What are we gonna do (Aiden?) I completely forget that the fake name Dutch used in Guarma, was the name of a character in the GTA 4 storyline.

[delicate sparrow]

oh yeah

[dusk socket]

I'm in shock of how I overlooked this after so long.

[mental merlin]

what happened to Susan and all the other girls at the end

[red helm]

Grimshaw is rather obvious.... ?

[mental merlin]

well yes

and tilly

[red helm]

You can find Tilly in Saint Denis, like just east of the Tailor across from one of the Saloons. Mary Beth is in Valentine waiting for a train.

[mental merlin]

so all the other members just left or they just died?

[delicate sparrow]

sadie's a bounty hunter

[red helm]

Karen is the only Question Mark. After you talk to Tilly she sends a letter, that says she thinks Karen drunk herself to death.

[delicate sparrow]

she's in the epilogue

[mental merlin]

I know I know

[red helm]

I figured her knew where Sadie was, and Abigail, Obvie.

[mental merlin]

but did like bill and all the other members die or just disappear

[red helm]

Bill isn't a girl..... lol..

[mental merlin]

I said all the other members

[red helm]

Ahem...

[mental merlin]

that was before the message

after

[red helm]

Sure, sure... Bill and Javier are dealt with in RDR1, same as Dutch

[mental merlin]

did John kill em?

[red helm]

Bill yes, Javier you get a choice to gun down or let go, but he gets caught and hung, immediately afterwards, so... meh.

[mental merlin]

and then there were no more boys left in the gang

[red helm]

Started with a bunch, but yeah, it gets whittled down pretty quick.

[lost hollow]

wth Gambler 8.....

how

[delicate sparrow]

yeah ik

the last few gambler challenges are so damn hard

[dawn patio]

[lost hollow]

[forest blaze]

i mean every single person that owns the legend of east outfit will shoot a poker table or a domino one

every time the see it

maybe not shoot on sight

but shooting after losing

[molten pelican]

HELLO

[hidden moss]

was dutch always crazy? or did he end up turning into a carzy person
\

[hearty ledge]

After black water he started gradually going down then after what happened to hosea he lost himself and his voice of reason

[verbal prairie]

Saint Denis is the generally agreed upon date for the start of dutch's downfall

however there are varying theories which you are as welcome to believe as any others

[hidden moss]

okay/

do you have xbox series x