Arabians succ
#red-dead-singleplayer
dire glade
Idk I just looked yt how to get fastest horse and I found Arabian
sinful hound
Speed isn't everything you don't even notice it
You need a horse that won't run off on every occasiln
But still fast enough.
I'd buy the Missouri fox trotter
It's a good mix on everything
Either it, or the gold turkoman
mild burrow
thanks
dire glade
Anytime
signal timber
I was trying 5 finger fillet in van Horne last night but it just kept saying it was a practise mode. So how do you get the actual game, where you win?
prime jewel
MFT, turkomans, Ardennes are better
and dutch warmblood
frank void
I went back to a previous save file before Arthur dies in chapter three just so I could see my horse that I saved from a crashed wagon and kept through the entire game this game pulls at you heart strings man
sinful hound
and dutch warmblood
Yes
hidden moss
I did like chapter 1, chapter 5 was boring to me
Chapter 4 house was anoying as fuck
frank void
I think the main problem with the epilogue is how you get all that money and then have basically nothing to do which is we’re a lot of people lose interest
hidden moss
Yes and i dont think if im going to replay that im going to play epilogue
frank void
Yeah they need to add a dlc already
hidden moss
Not the lose your stuff but epilogue 1 is kinda boring the second and third time
And i just wanna know WHERE WENT MY MONEY
frank void
You know the side mission with Jim boy Calloway
sinful hound
Yeah
drifting star
I did like chapter 1, chapter 5 was boring to me
Chapter 5 was ok for me I guess but it was easy to rush through
hidden moss
Chapter 5 was ok for me I guess but it was easy to rush through
Yea could have bin more
frank void
I forgot to collect the money as Arthur so I go to the post office as john and get 300 bucks as soon and the 2 mission of the epilogue
hidden moss
Wish you could go in freeroam
drifting star
Wish you could go in freeroam
Same that would be awesome
sinful hound
Like Cayo perico in GTA online?
hidden moss
Idk gta online is dogshit
frank void
Better then rdr online
frank void
It’s pretty shit
hidden moss
its basically an open map and u have missions
AND NO GOAL
idk its like u play it with no purpose
frank void
Yeah the only good part is that you can see sadies husband
hidden moss
Rdr2 should have kept sean longer
hidden moss
Yeah the only good part is that you can see sadies husband
wait where did they meet sadie again in the story?
in the mountains?
Yes chapter 1
frank void
Yeah considering it’s set in 1998 rdo
frank void
K
frank void
I finished the game twice
hidden moss
but Ill leave
frank void
So I’m a normal person
hidden moss
just tell me where ur pfp is from haha
prime jewel
u shouldn't be here
hidden moss
are u guys all done wit the story?
frank void
Yeah
frank void
👎👎👍👎 is the basic reaction to toughs deaths
hidden moss
kieran,arthur,micah and lenny
MICAH IS NOT SAD
hidden moss
MICAH IS NOT SAD
i only know abt his betrayal no more
and that u kill him
Have you heard about charles dying or
hidden moss
DM if you need advice
its youtube too
frank void
He’s lying black lung
candid walrus
yuh
frank void
When you have enough money to buy Tahiti come on doootch
candid walrus
lol
We just need more muneh
"But Dutch we have $60,000-" "NO. We need more MUNEH"
frank void
The moment you realise in rdr3 micha might not be in the gang yet
And it’s in the glory days
👁👄👁
frank void
Rockstar I would like to be paid 69 dollars and 420 cents for the idea
candid walrus
LOL
frank void
Hey when I went to kill Micah a actual rat just walks across in front of the house
Put twenty holes in it mistook it for Micah
sinful hound
Yes
candid walrus
lol
frank void
Anyway I’ma hit the hay and remember I don’t need friends they disappoint me
candid walrus
lmao
hidden moss
Guys do you think can we play Blackwater Massacre in next RDR game ?
candid walrus
I hope so
Well, actually
if we were able to play the Blackwater massacre then it would probably end up in the gang "winning" because there would be an actual person (the player) on the gang's side instead of all just NPCs, if that makes sense
Idk what I'm rambling on about
Maybe it would end with the Blackwater massacre, as they're fleeing into the mountains.
hidden moss
I think so.
candid walrus
Since Arthur and Hosea weren't there because they weren't able to help.
hidden moss
I hope we can play as Arthur Morgan after the main character death.
candid walrus
Yea
But who would it be? And if it ends with them fleeing into the mountains, there wouldn't really be an epilogue/free roam
hidden moss
Yes I agree with you.
candid walrus
I do hope there is a RDR3 though
hidden moss
Maybe we can play as Jenny,Mac or Callander boys.
candid walrus
Yeah that would be interesting
Or maybe young John, Arthur, Dutch, and Hosea before everyone else joined the gang?
frank void
I feel like most people want to play Arthur
frank void
He is the best protagonist
candid walrus
yea
frank void
As he comes to term with his morality
hidden moss
I think that having a player would not help in the blackwater massacre, if the rockstar wants to just fill up with enemies in such a large amount that it is impossible to win, like at the end of rdr1
candid walrus
I think that having a player would not help in the blackwater massacre, if the r...
That's true, dunno why i didn't think of that
frank void
Plot
candid walrus
But what do you do after the Blackwater Massacre, if it's the "ending" mission? There won't really be any free roam since they're in the mountains
frank void
Hmmm
drifting star
Hmmmmmmmm
candid walrus
Hmmmmmmmmmmmm
frank void
Yeah but most people playing rdr3 would have rdr2
hidden moss
But what do you do after the Blackwater Massacre, if it's the "ending" mission? ...
yep
candid walrus
true
hidden moss
some continue to "play" around the map
drifting star
Yeah but people like to collect everything and if there’s nothing to collect at the end then they’ll think they’ve just wasted their time
frank void
Yeah
candid walrus
That's true
hidden moss
Yeah but people like to collect everything and if there’s nothing to collect at ...
unless it’s someone looking for 100%
candid walrus
I'm so glad I joined this Discord so I could finally talk to people about RDR2
frank void
Rockstar might combine the games so once you finish rdr3 you go onto rdr2
candid walrus
Yeah
drifting star
I'm so glad I joined this Discord so I could finally talk to people about RDR2
Same lol
drifting star
unless it’s someone looking for 100%
Tru
frank void
I mean they wouldn’t have to worry about the map when making the game
candid walrus
yeah
Or maybe, rdr3 won't end with the Blackwater Massacre? Perhaps something else? But I don't know if that would work
prime jewel
Guys do you think can we play Blackwater Massacre in next RDR game ?
i think we may, because in the last two games, we played other characters, like: we played red harlow in red dead revolver,but then we played john marston in rdr1, then we played arthur morgan in rdr2, learned about john's past. I think we'll play another guy in vdl gang then he'll die in blackwater massacre
candid walrus
i think we may, because in the last two games, we played other characters, like:...
I like your theory better lol...
prime jewel
there will be a important robbery before blackwater, then until blackwater, we'll play arthur morgan...
I HOPE
candid walrus
I hope so also
prime jewel
it'd be nice
but it'll take a long time
cause we have GTA6
but we don't even know are they going to launch that one
candid walrus
It took them 10 (?) years to make RDR2, so it might take even longer for RDR3
Hopefully it'll be worth it
candid walrus
Yeah
prime jewel
im thinkin of 8-9
candid walrus
Probably
And by then tech might be more advanced so it could take longer or shorter, who knows
prime jewel
actually, it has a nice algorithm, gta5 learned smh abt rdr1, then rdr2 learned smh by GTA, then GTA6 will learn smh by rdr2, then rdr3 will learn something from GTA6
imo
mental hinge
rdr2 is already an extremely detailed game, i reckon the next one would take more than 10 years to make
candid walrus
Yeah
prime jewel
rdr2 is already an extremely detailed game, i reckon the next one would take mor...
right, wish it won't
mental hinge
to produce a story and game that would top red dead 2 is a tall order
sharp oak
can you catch fish at little creek river?
candid walrus
I've never tried before, but you probably could. Not sure though.
spring sluice
It should tell you river bait if I'm not mistaken
candid walrus
^
hexed cove
guys i cant seem to help reverend sawney. i click rapidly but it always resets. the max it got to was a little bit more than half. which is weird cause i saved lenny first try. i avarage 5-5.6 cps
spring sluice
?
sharp oak
what bait should i use
im guessing there are only smaller fish in there, but what bait is good for small river fish?
candid walrus
Hmm. Are you clicking really quickly?
hexed cove
idk if this is the place for troubleshooting
hexed cove
Hmm. Are you clicking really quickly?
i am
candid walrus
Odd. Always works for me
hexed cove
or at least i think i am
candid walrus
im guessing there are only smaller fish in there, but what bait is good for smal...
Cheese is usually good for Bluegill/rock bass
spring sluice
5 clicks per second?
hexed cove
is the lenny one any different cause i got it first try
sharp oak
how do you kill snakes without ruining them?
hexed cove
weird
candid walrus
how do you kill snakes without ruining them?
Small game arrows with a shot to the head always keeps them perfect for me
sharp oak
ok thanks
candid walrus
Np
sharp oak
well i guess little creek river doesnt have any fish : (
hexed cove
welp i use right hand because of side mouse buttons
so it aint the best
max i can do right now is 5.8
now 6
verbal prairie
if it doesn't work try an autoclicker
hexed cove
do you know a good one?
verbal prairie
it's single player so there's no idea of it being cheating
idk any off the top of my head but you can easily find it
hexed cove
alright i have one
now lets se
e
bruh its not working
fuck it im skipping it
no this is not my fault
i tried it with 2 fingers
i got 11 cps with it
bruh
hidden moss
Guys in Epilogue can we see Mary Linton ?
candid walrus
No, I don't believe so
hidden moss
Okay,thanks !
candid walrus
No problem
lost quartz
she leaves at the end of her stranger missions i cant remember where tho
calm anvil
yeah @hidden moss
if you do all her missions and i think if you get the high honour help john ending
oh are you asking if you can actually meet her
no
prime jewel
Guys in Epilogue can we see Mary Linton ?
only credits
she has a black dress and pays her respects near athurs grave
lost quartz
yeah she moves away somewhere
candid walrus
wow i didn't know she visited his grave
sad level 100
how does she know where his grave is tho
hidden moss
Thanks again.
lost quartz
charles probably told her
candid walrus
ah, ok
upper fox
guys i have a question i never cared about this in my first playtrough, but does the trapper and fence reset from chapter 6 to the epilogue part 1?
upper fox
for example if i sold him something legendary animal part in chapter 6 and i go to the epilogue does it go away?
upper fox
aight thanks
lost quartz
np
formal wagon
Anyone know how to do the second part of the gunslingers
upper fox
i believe you have to go and examine the picture of the gunslingers to start it
formal wagon
I mean when you have done them
lost quartz
you have to wait but i cant remember how long for
candid walrus
What chapter are you in?
formal wagon
3
upper fox
Somewhere in chapter 5 or 6 is the second part i believe
candid walrus
You have to wait until Chapter 4 i think, then talk to the bartender in Valentine
formal wagon
Ok
candid walrus
They'll be on a boat in St.Denis
lost quartz
yeah then you go find them
upper fox
Chapter 4 is the second part
so is the third part
You can finish the noblest of men, and a women all in chapter 4
lost quartz
one of the best stranger missions imo
upper fox
I liked the exclusive revolvers and I loved the end
lost quartz
yeah shame you couldnt upgrade them though
upper fox
it would've been cool if we could customize them
lost quartz
yeah i just use dual schofields
hidden moss
do you think the plot of rdr 2 would change a lot if micah was a "hero" instead of working for pinkertons for money he works for them because he thinks they are the "right side" and that they are doing good?
upper fox
yeah i just use dual schofields
i use one volcanic pistol and one schofield
lost quartz
i used to use that but i just use 2 schofields now cos they look cooler
upper fox
but i like to change them every few weeks
lost quartz
do you think the plot of rdr 2 would change a lot if micah was a "hero" instead ...
it would take alot of the sting away from the ending because you couldnt be as mad at micah
upper fox
its sad to see Dutch break a 20 year old relationship or something close to that for a 6 month old rat
I recently I've found out when Micah was in the strawberry prison and he had his own camp for a while he was carrying Dutch's his wanted poster
lost quartz
yeah theres alot of foreshadowing
upper fox
Micah was proablly a rat or a goverment errand boy since the beginning, but he probaly started slowly betraying the gang
hidden moss
it would take alot of the sting away from the ending because you couldnt be as m...
just to remember i'm not saying that micah would not cause the death of several members, but instead of him being a crazy psychopath he would be a "good guy" he would not make racist jokes, or psychopathic phrases
upper fox
Milton said he was a rat since they came back from Guarma
lost quartz
milton tells Arthur that micah started helping after Guarma when you rescue Abigail
upper fox
Yeah, but Molly wasnt the saint denis bank rat so who was?
Molly didnt say anything to the pinkertons
lost quartz
was there a rat for that heist?
upper fox
When Molly was drunk at the beginning of chapter 6 she said she told the pinkertons about the bank heist while when MIlton said she didnt tell anyone and had to let her go
honest drum
Milton said he was a rat since they came back from Guarma
i doubt this is true
i think he was a rat wayyy before
upper fox
abigail
she wanted her little own little johnny marston
she didnt like to share
she was greedy
lost quartz
nah dont think abigail did lol
honest drum
that's why she did it, she wanted him safe
honest drum
nah dont think abigail did lol
there is a lot of evidence
honest drum
they shoot lenny and hosea in cold blood, but arrest john, abigail manages to 'slip away'
honest drum
abigail literally blowed milton's brain
she wasn't a rat
upper fox
Abigail slipped out of the pinkertons hands when the shooting started. You'd focus on the big bad gunslingers lighting you up, not some random woman.
Bill leads them back to the camp. He goes around asking everyone where the gang went, and that obviously ended up spreading to pinkerton ears.
You don't kill prisoners for no reason.
No wonder she hates Dutch. She stole the key because she wanted to steal the gang's money to go live out a nice life with John.
Micah is a survivor. He's not loyal to anyone but himself. He sticks with Dutch because Dutch is good at robbing people. He made a deal with the pinkertons because he wanted to live.
honest drum
just
upper fox
copied this from reddit
honest drum
gave a tip a robbery
lost quartz
nah doesnt make any sense to me
honest drum
nah doesnt make any sense to me
how?
lost quartz
she was always loyal to the gang whereas Micah wasnt
honest drum
Bill leads them back to the camp. He goes around asking everyone where the gang went, and that obviously ended up spreading to pinkerton ears.
this was micah lol
upper fox
I dont believe Abigail was the rat, but we will never know who was the second rat
honest drum
she was always loyal to the gang whereas Micah wasnt
she wanted john safe
lost quartz
yall found the civil war knife
yeah its cool
lost quartz
he was gonna be hanged in sisika
honest drum
he was gonna be hanged in sisika
no he weren't
lost quartz
if you and sadie didnt save him
honest drum
they would of did it
lost quartz
yeah he was
upper fox
he was gonna be hanged in sisika
sounds like abigail wanted john hanged instead of saved
lost quartz
thats why you save him
honest drum
mate it was weeks after the bank, he would of been hanged by then
honest drum
thats why you save him
no it's because he's in jail lol
lost quartz
yeah
upper fox
A few people on reddit really believe Abigail was the rat and was responsible for the death of Hosea and Lenny
honest drum
2 i believe that abigail gave a tip to secure john's safety
hence why he wasn't shot
hidden moss
can someone answer my question better? what would happen if micah were not a psychopath? Was he working with the pinkertons just because he thinks the Dutch gang is bad? this includes him stopping acting like an idiot, with mean jokes and etc.
honest drum
like lenny and hosea
lost quartz
reddit theories are usually awful
upper fox
sometimes
lost quartz
the ones ive seen anyway
honest drum
can someone answer my question better? what would happen if micah were not a psy...
mate u don't know the story
play the game or watch it
honest drum
reddit theories are usually awful
i didn't get this off reddit lol
just common sense
lost quartz
yeah i just dont agree with it thats all
honest drum
who else was the rat then, and why did john not get killed
hidden moss
play the game or watch it
i know the story, what i asked was: what do you think would happen if micah was infiltrated in the gang because he wanted to do good? and not for money (what happened in real life)
lost quartz
its a good theory i just dont believe it
honest drum
i know the story, what i asked was: what do you think would happen if micah was ...
what r u on about
lol
upper fox
I am reading one of the conspiracy theories about who was the rat, but why did Milton kidnap Abigail at the end of chapter 6? Im really wondering why. Milton shoudlt have known who was abigail she wasnt an outlaw
lost quartz
i know the story, what i asked was: what do you think would happen if micah was ...
then the whole story is different dude
lost quartz
i mean maybe but at the end of the day its a game and we'll never know
honest drum
and during chapter 4 is when john and abigail start to make an effort
honest drum
i mean maybe but at the end of the day its a game and we'll never know
ye lol
it's still fun tho
upper fox
it will always remain a mystery just like princess isabeau
lost quartz
i remember seeing that poster for the first time and got so confused when there wasnt a bounty mission
lost quartz
google it mate
honest drum
and cut voice lines
candid walrus
do anyone know where to find ram?
there's usually a few around Cattail pond
honest drum
cut side mission
upper fox
her grown up
yeah but birthmark on wrong side of the face
quaint warren
there's usually a few around Cattail pond
alright thx
honest drum
yeah but birthmark on wrong side of the face
what
candid walrus
Np :)
honest drum
im not on about time travel
just in general
there's a model of her grown up
you know she was kidnapped like 15 years before the game starts
upper fox
yeah it was cut but i remember reading shit like her npc model had a few mistakes
lost quartz
time travel is in the game for that weird rock carving guy (not related to isabeau)
honest drum
yeah it was cut but i remember reading shit like her npc model had a few mistake...
ye
honest drum
time travel is in the game for that weird rock carving guy (not related to isabe...
ye
epslion program
lost quartz
i hate missions like that
honest drum
i love thrm
lost quartz
find 400 carvings and 234 dino bones
upper fox
hamish and francis have the same surname
honest drum
find 400 carvings and 234 dino bones
no lol
10 rock carvings
30 dino bones
and you find parts of the map u never would of come across
like i find new places now
lost quartz
yeah just too tedious to find one then google the next one
upper fox
I really hate that you have too wait until the epilogue to complete the dinosaur bones, because there is a cutscene that proved Arthur could've finished it
candid walrus
ikr
upper fox
yeah
lost quartz
i hate that you cant get all the legendary fish and animals till you finish the game
upper fox
there are also cut audio content of arthur asking for a stagecoach to armodillo, tumbleweed and of that and even interactions with the shops around there
honest drum
ye
lost quartz
just annoying
upper fox
torture scene?!
honest drum
yes
lost quartz
i wish arthur could go south but i get why he cant tbh
upper fox
when arthur got tortured by the o driscolls?
lost quartz
it would make the epilogue boring
upper fox
probably one of cut money lending and other sins mission
honest drum
i wish arthur could go south but i get why he cant tbh
u mean west
honest drum
probably one of cut money lending and other sins mission
ye
honest drum
not rlly
lost quartz
well it is
lost quartz
ok the bottom of the map
delicate sparrow
you mean the one by strawberry?
upper fox
it was proablly cut because it sounds like arthur was torturing a teenager
lost quartz
jesus haha
honest drum
it was proablly cut because it sounds like arthur was torturing a teenager
ye
i have one of him shouting at bill
and the gang
arthur that is
upper fox
weird
willow acorn
Hi
drifting star
Hi
lost quartz
Hi
lost quartz
first playthrough?
willow acorn
Yes
drifting star
I wanna get 100% but I dont think I have the will to do all 9 challenges 😫
lost quartz
thats good
willow acorn
But I know it’s not good
lost quartz
dont look up anything
willow acorn
I haven’t
All I know is that I need to get my honor up if I want whatever the good ending is
lost quartz
ending got spoiled for me day after i got the game
honest drum
shouldn't have any
willow acorn
Damn that’s sad
I didn’t ever expect to buy the game when it came out so I didn’t care about spoilers or anything
candid walrus
same for me
i never thought i would be able to play the game so i watched a full playthrough of it lol
lost quartz
luckily it was just the ending and nothing else
upper fox
mrbossftw spoiled arthur death to me with his stupid thumbnails...
lost quartz
he is so shit
willow acorn
pain
upper fox
yeah
lost quartz
i watched a top ten starter tips video and first tip spoiled it
upper fox
my youtube recommendations must hate me
candid walrus
oof
upper fox
Strange Man has great videos
honest drum
omg i just found the best convo in the game files 🤣
limber oyster
Last weekend I spoilered me a lot with a video by zynxise
upper fox
omg i just found the best convo in the game files 🤣
apparantly Sean likes to fart alot
honest drum
lolol
chilly spruce
Where does pearson have his shop?
strange dragon
Rhodes
chilly spruce
Kk ty
strange dragon
np
lean sparrow
Should i complete the game for the third time
candid walrus
I say go for it if you want to!
lost quartz
yes
im on my 4th i think and still finding new things
just got ambushed by murfree and they led me into a pit trap
calm anvil
ending unironically got spoiled for me because i watched kek or cringe with dutch van der linde
lost quartz
hahahaha
olive notch
ending unironically got spoiled for me because i watched kek or cringe with dutc...
uh oh.
verbal prairie
imagine if Hosea led the van der lindes 😔
lost quartz
the Matthews
vivid umbra
then it would be called the matthews
candid walrus
The matthews gang
lost quartz
not as cool really
calm anvil
the van winkle gang
vivid umbra
rip van winkle gang
olive notch
marston gang
lost quartz
you need scars to be initiated
calm anvil
rip van winkle, hoagy macintosh, tacitus kilgore, and alfred lafonde
verbal prairie
they shouldve made Arthur's hat in rdr2 John's hat in rdr1
would've been an amazing detail and made the handoff so much more meaningful
upper fox
Arthur's hat design didnt exist yet. It would've been an cool detail
verbal prairie
I mean have Arthur's hat in rdr2 be John's hat in rdr1, not vice versa
calm anvil
if they had arthur wearing john's classic hat throughout all of rdr2 the reveal later on wouldn't be as impactful
being that you know
verbal prairie
I mean I think everyone expected it
because Arthur wasn't the type to run off anyway
calm anvil
yeah it would have been cool if arthur had john's classic hat but it was the right decision not to give it to him
candid walrus
Sean? yeah that was sad
wooden shoal
Yeeeeh
hidden moss
you can find his grave
candid walrus
Where is it at?
calm anvil
i think there's a grave for everyone except grimshaw
candid walrus
Why not Grimshaw?
calm anvil
i looked at all the possible cutscenes that take place at the train station when you help that captain with rains fall
on my playthrough i got the sister cutscene but i think the best one is honestly high honour reverend's
candid walrus
I thought reverend was only low honor?
calm anvil
he appears on high honour if you don't do all the missions with brother dorkins
and the cutscene changes
calm anvil
you miss the iconic "i'm afraid" line but it's pretty good
candid walrus
Does he say anything different for high honor vs. low honor?
calm anvil
it's like the one time he acts like an actual reverend
candid walrus
lol
calm anvil
when arthur said he was afraid was the only time in the entire game that got me to tear up
you don't expect him to admit to it
candid walrus
yeah, i watched the cutscene on youtube and ngl I did the same thing
upper fox
when arthur said he was afraid was the only time in the entire game that got me ...
i only cried when my horse died
in the mission "red dead redemption"
hidden moss
I'm trying not to get attached to my horse
candid walrus
Not looking forward to when my horse dies...
calm anvil
my horse during that mission was the white arabian
hidden moss
I have like 12 missions left
candid walrus
I have the white arabian and the White overo (?) American paint that people say is rare
upper fox
I have 5 missions left in chapter 6 and im trying to do so much as possible that I can do with Arthur
calm anvil
it's a nice touch how that scene only plays if your bonding with the horse is high enough
it'd feel a bit stupid if arthur did that with a horse you just got
hidden moss
I know a way to give all my money to John though so I'm happy
candid walrus
how
candid walrus
huh. thought that didn't work anymore
hidden moss
nah
upper fox
I've had my horse since chapter 2, I've spent 280 hours so far in my playtrough and I got attached to a horse named Kanye West
candid walrus
lmao
calm anvil
i named my white arabian after my dog
i like naming horses after pets i had or family members had
hidden moss
my horse is named big tommy because lil tommy died in chapter 2 🥲
candid walrus
O_O
hidden moss
and now big tommy is gonna die
candid walrus
...What happened to little tommy-
hidden moss
fell off a cliff
candid walrus
O
calm anvil
i didn't know horsed died permanently if you didn't revive them so literally the mission after i bought the scrawny nag with hosea
it got ran over by a train
and got permad
candid walrus
oof
upper fox
the horse you got from Hosea is apparantly a one of a kind
candid walrus
Wait really? The shire?
upper fox
It has a unique pelt or something
candid walrus
I almost sold it lol
upper fox
You cannot find it anywhere in the game
calm anvil
missouri fox trotters are the best horses
upper fox
You can only get it from Hosea
honest drum
her entire character goes against the games message
drifting star
I thought she was annoying
honest drum
she's a psychotic bitch
honest drum
if rdr3 continued with sadie
i fucking hope not
what is there to tell
and
it'd be boring as hell
calm anvil
i feel like it's the most likely if rdr3 had to be about a character we already know
candid walrus
yea
hidden moss
no
honest drum
anymore and it'll become old and boring imo
we've had 2 games
on the VDL gang
it could ruin it
we know the story
it's been told perfectly
hidden moss
nah
honest drum
a rdr2 DLC would be great
hidden moss
yes
hidden moss
nah
hidden moss
rdr3 sadie
hidden moss
South america
calm anvil
that's the point we don't know her story lol
honest drum
what the story
hidden moss
or before
honest drum
that's the point we don't know her story lol
it'd be boring
hidden moss
in snow
honest drum
ah yes ranch simulator
calm anvil
but out of all the characters we already know she would be the most likely to feature in rdr3
hidden moss
epilogue in a nutshell
calm anvil
because she actually has a redemption plot
honest drum
but out of all the characters we already know she would be the most likely to fe...
i don't mind her featuring
signal timber
What's the deal with 5 finger fillet? How do you get a win? It just kept saying I was in practise mode
drifting star
What's the deal with 5 finger fillet? How do you get a win? It just kept saying ...
Need someone to play against
honest drum
what do u like so much about her character? @hidden moss
signal timber
Need someone to play against
So just wait for an npc
drifting star
So just wait for an npc
Yeah just sleep or go to another place
hidden moss
she has redemption
honest drum
she has redemption
no she doesn't
hidden moss
yes
hidden moss
red dead revenge
honest drum
game
hidden moss
rdr
honest drum
red dead revenge
revenge is south america? lmao
drifting star
I hated her since the mission in chapter 3 where u go shopping with her
candid walrus
lol
honest drum
red dead revolver
red dead redemption
red dead redemption 2
red dead revenge
so basically... ruin both rdr games?
lmap
hidden moss
yes
honest drum
...
drifting star
:p
calm anvil
red dead renounce humanity return to monkey
i don't want rdr3 to be about sadie
i just said she's the most likely protagonist
which she really is
calm anvil
only gang member still acting as an outlaw
honest drum
which... is why we need a new story
honest drum
and i expect we'll get that
honest drum
and... that still makes her the most likely
what lmao
you know what new story means, right?
calm anvil
no i just don't think you get the point being made
honest drum
no i do
calm anvil
like you're intentionally misunderstanding
honest drum
you think because she's an outlaw (which she isn't) we'll play as her
calm anvil
it's not about whether or not we want a new story
calm anvil
i told you that if the game had to be about a character we know
she is THE MOST LIKELY
it's not hard to understand
honest drum
jesus
i KNOW
what your sayinf
but
she's deffo not the most likely
if it had to be like that
it could be a prequel
to rdr2
if they really went down that line
which i hope they don't
calm anvil
the last time someone suggested that you then proceeded to rant about how that's really stupid
honest drum
what?
im just disproving
im not ranting
like at all
lmao
plus red dead is a western series
a south america set game?
that's like GTA becoming a futuristic game
hidden moss
lol it is
verbal prairie
Sadie doesn't really fit in to red dead main characters
she's a great character but I just don't see her roaming around being an outlaw
honest drum
sadie haters <:frank:657414149105778709>
sadie realists
verbal prairie
I don't hate Sadie for the record
hidden moss
wee wee wee
verbal prairie
I just don't think it'd make sense
hidden moss
u have a hate boner for her gameroll. we know it. shes a great character
sadie hater
honest drum
u have a hate boner for her gameroll. we know it. shes a great character
no she just isn't a well written character imo
calm anvil
i think she's a good character but i wouldn't want to see an entire game focused around her
i just think she would be the most likely protagonist out of all the characters we know of
honest drum
and i've never seen anyone combat my points with a valid argument
hidden moss
true
bronze zenith
i think she's a good character but i wouldn't want to see an entire game focused...
I kinda agree
hidden moss
keep talking sadie hater
hidden moss
no
verbal prairie
I disagree with gameroll but at least make a valid point instead of spamming something jeez
honest drum
keep talking sadie hater
if u aint gonna contribute to the convo please just go
calm anvil
sadie bad or sadie good
hidden moss
ring dang doo
ebon bobcat
honestly Sadie has a unique back story but not diverse enough to make a game or even dlc for that matter about
indigo topaz
True
sinful hound
Yes
indigo topaz
A story of charles with rain fall and his tribe wont be bad
sinful hound
She'd be just a clichee character oh my God my huesband died anyway lemme kill some O'Driscolls
verbal prairie
that's what I'm saying she's not as criminal as Arthur and John and it wouldn't make sense to free roam with her and all
calm anvil
charles doesn't stick around the natives
honest drum
A story of charles with rain fall and his tribe wont be bad
what moving up north
then returning
calm anvil
after the epilogue he presumably goes to live in canada
indigo topaz
what moving up north
Yeah
calm anvil
he's not an outlaw anymore
ebon bobcat
im thinking more on the lines that her husband was shot and she was traumatized by the odriscolls , that along with the gangs mentality pushed her to become quite a badass
her character development is good
indigo topaz
Woah good point
ebon bobcat
unlike Abigail who just asks for favors all game
bronze zenith
I don’t think I’d want a third game to revolve around any of the existing gang members from RDR2 other than maybe Jack Marston
indigo topaz
I don’t think I’d want a third game to revolve around any of the existing gang m...
Now that l can agree with
sinful hound
I'd like them to be mentioned or something, but not to be played.
Especially not as a whole game character
verbal prairie
Jack still seems boring
hidden moss
yes
bronze zenith
Realistically I’d like someone new to play as
indigo topaz
But they should make the next game early like civil war times
calm anvil
a game about adult jack would just be rockstar making a mafia game
honest drum
i have 2 reasons for not liking her writing:
- she goes from suicidal to reading pearsons letter in a funny voice, while murdering raiders in a day
- her entire character goes against the message of the entire game and ends up fine
bronze zenith
Like one of the gang members who were mentioned but never seen in RDR2
honest drum
I don’t think I’d want a third game to revolve around any of the existing gang m...
i can't agree
west is dead
and there's again, no story
indigo topaz
Rdr2 is my fav game but the next game should be more western
ebon bobcat
jack after killing ross in rd1 is pretty much all jack was good for, after that a story spearheaded through him would be kinda boring ngl
honest drum
we need a 1860's or 1880's western
indigo topaz
we need a 1860's or 1880's western
There we go
honest drum
if it's in the 1880's we can have references to the VDL gang
hidden moss
yes
honest drum
newspapers etc
indigo topaz
Aweaome
hidden moss
nah
sinful hound
Imagine playing as young hosea pickpocketing people
indigo topaz
And this time they should ceep more of their easter eggs in the game
sinful hound
Not that I want it, just opinionating
honest drum
eh maybe
hidden moss
maybe
honest drum
idk tho
calm anvil
rdr3 isn't going to happen for another 7 years at least
indigo topaz
True
honest drum
i feel that the entire VDL should be left alone except for small appearences at best
15-20 years
more like
ebon bobcat
if they keep the same engine , ill take any game that isnt gta5
indigo topaz
Easy
calm anvil
gta 6's up next and i'd like a return to bully or la noire after that
ebon bobcat
the western theme feels so immersing and fun
indigo topaz
if they keep the same engine , ill take any game that isnt gta5
I would do the same
honest drum
T2 are at E3 this year
indigo topaz
the western theme feels so immersing and fun
I agree
calm anvil
i can't remember if rockstar has more open world games aside from those four
honest drum
but u never know
calm anvil
bully, red dead, la noire, gta
ebon bobcat
it really makes you want to keep playing, keep exploring, talking etc. no game has ever made me want to do that
honest drum
well
indigo topaz
I wish you could just rob banks in free time
honest drum
actually idk
verbal prairie
it's probably time for a new ip I mean the rdr story can go backwards but it'd be hard to write a unique story when it's already been written and it certainly can't go forward
honest drum
it's probably time for a new ip I mean the rdr story can go backwards but it'd b...
i'd love a new IP
indigo topaz
would not make sense
Why mn....hire some thugs and do a robbery
honest drum
cuz they're a big deal
calm anvil
rockstar makes a futuristic game just to shit on cd projekt red
hollow panther
cum
calm anvil
makes what cyberpunk should've been
honest drum
if we're like the leader of a gang
indigo topaz
Ahh true
calm anvil
wins three hundred goty awards
honest drum
planning heists could be cool
but not like a whenever we want thing
like oppurtunities
indigo topaz
How about atleast a pet like a dog...l would enjoy that...helping u hunt and stuff
honest drum
bit like how side businesses work in rdr2 but more random
honest drum
How about atleast a pet like a dog...l would enjoy that...helping u hunt and stu...
pretty sure that was cut
u could bring cain out hunting
originally
from what i know
indigo topaz
pretty sure that was cut
That l would be fun
ebon bobcat
yeah with almost the entire gang dead or moved away, dutch dead as well as ross, it's hard to see where they can go with rdr3 . just speaking theoretically
indigo topaz
Protecting ure dog from bears and stuff
honest drum
yeah with almost the entire gang dead or moved away, dutch dead as well as ross,...
new game. red dead smth
red dead revolution
indigo topaz
yeah with almost the entire gang dead or moved away, dutch dead as well as ross,...
New story l geuss
calm anvil
i wish they kept going with that naming scheme
red dead revolver
red dead redemption
verbal prairie
like oppurtunities
when you get tips in rdr2 from escaped prisoners
calm anvil
rdr2 should've been red dead retribution or something
indigo topaz
I say this again the story should take place in the civil war...
verbal prairie
could convert to tips for trains or stagecoaches
honest drum
rdr2 should've been red dead retribution or something
nah
indigo topaz
Why
ebon bobcat
is it just me or would another western without having anything to due with the gang feel idk, monotonous and bland?
hidden moss
Ooo rdr3
hidden moss
is it just me or would another western without having anything to due with the g...
Hm maybe
honest drum
because rdr2 is about redemption.....
ebon bobcat
maybe it's just me but that feels like beating a dead horse
indigo topaz
People say rockstar should make an rpg but tbh im tired of rpg
ebon bobcat
i think rdr2 was a good culmination of events, sums up the story nicely and did a great job with the western theme
indigo topaz
Like its fun but hel its everywhere
ebon bobcat
anything more on that genre would feel like overkill
honest drum
i think rdr2 was a good culmination of events, sums up the story nicely and did ...
it was more of an eastern
indigo topaz
Rdr2 is like a cowboy simulator
hidden moss
I hate RPGs
honest drum
it's the opposite imo
hidden moss
yeah
hidden moss
needs more desert
indigo topaz
Look l say they make one more game about the western atleadt
honest drum
i'd love that
calm anvil
dutch's gang of outlaws vs bronte's proto-mafia was one of the best parts of the game
ebon bobcat
but it is about the west either way you look at it, the gang dies off because they died along with the west. with teen jack in rdr1 being the final piece of the story
indigo topaz
Cause l love westerns and after she success of rdr2 imagine what they could do next.....yeah maybe the story will be difficult but the world and gameplay will be on another level
ebon bobcat
yeah the engine is great and they have plenty of capital to enhance it im sure
indigo topaz
too rushed
It was prettu long for me.....took my time there
ebon bobcat
thier story telling has always been on point too
indigo topaz
True
ebon bobcat
i trust them to take the franchise where it needs to go
the voice actors loved making rdr1 and 2
rdr2 undead nightmare when???? 
indigo topaz
But like whe will get the next gta over good few years and maybe the next rdr of decades
Man why is there not an undead nightmare for rdr2!!!!!
Hel man that maid me mad
ebon bobcat
who knows , they make so much money off gta online still they may postpone gta6 for who knows how long
indigo topaz
Damn
ebon bobcat
Man why is there not an undead nightmare for rdr2!!!!!
i know. we are all thinking it!! cmon rockstar
indigo topaz
Wtf yeah sure it will maybe be difficult to fit it in with die main story but we stil need one
Imagine the gang came back from guarma and everyone is zombies
That would be awesome
ebon bobcat
Although I did see a video of Dutch’s voice actor saying he “didn’t work on the 1st undead nightmare” maybe hinting there is a 2nd one in the works??
indigo topaz
Then u have to go figure out why
ebon bobcat
Who knows
calm anvil
i'd love it if in undead nightmare micah just inexplicably became a really nice guy
indigo topaz
It would be awesome
ebon bobcat
Zombie Micah .. hehehe
indigo topaz
Rockstars easter eggs are so good that l want more from it
ebon bobcat
Sounds like fun
indigo topaz
Do u guys think there are unsolved secrets in rdr2
calm anvil
gta 5 is 8 years old and there's still unresolved theories
ebon bobcat
Do u guys think there are unsolved secrets in rdr2
I certainly think so. The game has only been out a few years. Some Easter eggs go years , decades even without being solved or found
honest drum
Do u guys think there are unsolved secrets in rdr2
there's loads
panoramic map for one
and a few others
lost quartz
isnt that map unsolvable?
i swear a bunch of people have been trying since it was found
calm anvil
the general consensus is that it was cut along with a lot of stuff related to new austin
calm anvil
was it ever actually explained why dutch didn't have arthur involved in the blackwater heist
if he was there they probably wouldn't have failed so miserably
lost quartz
yeah him and hosea were doing another thing i cant remember what though
then the ferry thing fucked it all up
candid walrus
was it ever actually explained why dutch didn't have arthur involved in the blac...
Him and Hosea were going to carry out their own scam then they would meet up with the rest of the gang.
calm anvil
yeah but you'd think that like
seeing how much money they'd make off the boat heist
they'd just have everyone in on it
candid walrus
yea
calm anvil
dutch likes muneh though 💰 💰 💰 💰
candid walrus
m u n e h
honest drum
they'd just have everyone in on it
i mean they already had a lot of people
and
they didn't think it'd be that guarded
plus after hosea and arthur pulled off that scam they would be rich af
candid walrus
Yeah
lost quartz
that was the plan to be hella rich and then move somewhere far away
do we ever find out how much was on the ferry money wise
lost quartz
how much was it
delicate sparrow
$250k i think
lost quartz
way more i think
delicate sparrow
cause $250k back then is 8m today
honest drum
about $4,753,265.06 today
candid walrus
wow
delicate sparrow
yes
lost quartz
yeah
honest drum
rich boi
lost quartz
christ
calm anvil
the blackwater boat heist was 150k in total
that's excluding whatever hosea and arthur were planning
delicate sparrow
i always thought it was $250k lol
calm anvil
you can find newspaper scraps that mention how much money was on the boat
honest drum
thing is the law would of probably left them alone if they knew they never actually got the money
well
not left them alone
but wouldn't of pushed as hard
obviously the gang would still have cornwall
and the pinkertons
lost quartz
i always thought that how much money you put in the donation box should attribute to the money john gets at the epilogue
honest drum
but the funding from the government would dissapear
honest drum
i always thought that how much money you put in the donation box should attribut...
that'd make no sense
calm anvil
arthur puts 20 thousand dollars into the box
micah puts 25 dollars and some feathers
"who amongst you is betraying me"
honest drum
all john gets is a sack of money from the train robbery
lost quartz
the money john gets is the money from beavers hollow
calm anvil
you're talking about the money you get after american venom