red-dead-singleplayer

[sinful hound]

I guess so,every other mission actually either did something to provide backstory to characters or explain or develop a certain part of the story. That mission did neither.

[undone python]

there's money in a shack on the left side of the house if you view it from the front. There's a door in the kitchen area that leads to it. There's at least $40 in there.

[hidden moss]

ill kill them before they can rob me

if I ever get to visit them

[candid walrus]

the people at Aberdeen Pig farm terrify me

[undone python]

Guarma was pointless too, because it felt like a short version of the Nuevo Paraiso section from rdr1.

[hidden moss]

they r prolly the most terrifying thing in the game

[candid walrus]

yea

[hidden moss]

forget night folk and crackheads

they r the real shit

[candid walrus]

Murfree brood isn't too terrifying, just plain weird

[hidden moss]

idk them

[sinful hound]

Well it did make a good follow-up to the "thing" . We couldn't just think they magically got away and found the rest of gang after.

[undone python]

their simple to kill

[hidden moss]

who r they

is it a spoiler

[undone python]

I believe Chapter 5 onwards has trouble pacing itself because it's more constant gun battles compared to chapter 2 through 4

[sinful hound]

Well we can see what the "gang" became after it.

That's why all that happened.

[undone python]

not really, they only appear once in the story to move camo location

camp

[hidden moss]

ok

[honest drum]

no they don'y

not just once

they're everywhere up there

if u make a camp you'll get a random encounter with them

they can ambush you

etc

basically like the o'driscolls

and lemoyne raiders

[undone python]

yeah but that's not part of the story, it's just free roam stuff

[honest drum]

ye but u said they only appear once

[undone python]

in the story, which is correct, only once in the story

[hidden moss]

i dont get the francis thing either

[undone python]

who is francis

[hidden moss]

rock carving guy

[candid walrus]

back

[undone python]

oh yeah, his encounter broke for me. I only got his first visit

[candid walrus]

apparently he's a time traveler

[hidden moss]

when u finish the stuff his wife holds him in her hands

as a baby

[candid walrus]

yea

[undone python]

mother*

[hidden moss]

she called him her husband huh

[candid walrus]

before I looked up what that mission meant i was like "w h a t"

[undone python]

her husband was dead, her son is francis

[hidden moss]

well i dont get why he turned into a baby

[undone python]

he's a time traveller

[hidden moss]

ik but i dont get it

[honest drum]

it's a connection to gta 5

i'll send a vid explaining it now one sec

[honest drum]

im surprised there wasn't a master hunter 10 kill all legendary animals ngl

[candid walrus]

that would make sense

i cant remember what master hunter challenge im on

im on number 4. just checked

[tawdry idol]

32 gb

Still not running smooth

[honest drum]

just finished Survivalist 10

[candid walrus]

nice! thats the one where you have to catch every type of fish right?

[honest drum]

ye

i've done it before

[candid walrus]

was it difficult?

[honest drum]

nah

just time consuming

[candid walrus]

ok. good to know

[honest drum]

catching fish is easy

[candid walrus]

yeah. I like it, it's quite relaxing if I have nothing to do in game

[brave hedge]

Why can't I wear the Custom Outfit's I saved as Arthur, As John?

[candid walrus]

anyone know what the largest percent of stuff you can get done in chapter 2 is? for 100% completion

[honest drum]

i finished chapter 2 with just over 40% completion, and i didn't do any of the challenges, so my guess is about 60%]

[candid walrus]

Ok, thank you! I'm at 42% percent so far

[honest drum]

nice

thats a good start

[candid walrus]

yea. I'll probably do rock carvings next

[honest drum]

ye

do those

they're easy and are a big part of the completion

[candid walrus]

yeah. dinosaur bones was difficult and i hated it

[honest drum]

you can't finish legendary fish and dino bones until the epilogue

[candid walrus]

too bad I lost all of them when i reloaded my other save :/

yeah

[honest drum]

make sure u do the 'fisher of fish' mission

side mission that is

with jeremy gill

u have to post the legendary fish if u didn't know

[candid walrus]

yep, i talked to him a while back but haven't caught any fish yet

[honest drum]

nice

[candid walrus]

which fish would you recommend to go after first?

I've got to stop by the bait store first

[honest drum]

doesn't really matter

tbh

just u can't finish it until the epilouge

[candid walrus]

yeah.

[brave hedge]

Why can't I wear the Custom Outfit's I saved as Arthur, As John?

[hallow pawn]

progress further in epilogue pretty sure you can

[candid walrus]

I want to go back down to our house and play rdr2 but I'm too lazy to walk back down the hill -,-

[honest drum]

i swear this game just knows which challenge your tryna do

like im tryna do horseman 10

and i can't find a single fucking wild horse

but when im not tryna do it it's horses galore

[candid walrus]

IKR? Every time I tried the Sharpshooter 4(?) I could never find birds while I was on a train. And then I tried hopping on a train at Valentine because it had stopped at the station. Well, the train didn't move for 30 minutes and there were NPCs and carts backed up almost all the way to the saloon. It was weird

[verbal prairie]

when I was walking home from van Gogh after guarma

there was not 1 single horse

nearly missed the song

[candid walrus]

van gogh?

[verbal prairie]

man

what's it called

[candid walrus]

Van Horn?

[verbal prairie]

van Gogh van winkle

same thing

[candid walrus]

lol

[verbal prairie]

I never go there anyway

never remember

the name

you could've told me it was van winkle I wouldn't raise an eyebrow

[candid walrus]

I don't go there much either. Everyone hates me at Van Horn :T

haha

[verbal prairie]

lol

[honest drum]

just finished horseman 10

finally

[candid walrus]

nice!

you going for 100% completion?

[honest drum]

yes

96.7% completion

[candid walrus]

wow!

[honest drum]

sooo close

[candid walrus]

what else do you have left to do?

[honest drum]

just exotics, hunting requests and 3 more sets of challenges which i've nearly done

[candid walrus]

are the hunting requests the ones where you have to get perfect animals for that lady?

[honest drum]

yes

they don't take long

[candid walrus]

ah, ok. can you only do those in the epilouge?

[honest drum]

not sure tbh

i just always have

in the epilouge

i know you can get them as arthur

just don't know if u can finish them]

just got to level 10 on my health too

[candid walrus]

ok, thanks

oo

does your health/stamina/dead eye reset when you start the epilouge?

[honest drum]

no

HOLY

[candid walrus]

O_O

[honest drum]

i just took out 2 deers with one arrow

wow

[candid walrus]

How-

[honest drum]

idek lolol

i just clipped it

[candid walrus]

n i c e

[delicate sparrow]

wow

[candid walrus]

logging on to rdr2 now

does anyone know if you go to the arcadia for armatures guy (Albert Mason) after Arthur gets sick, if he has any different dialouge?

[warm kelp]

Hi! Do you know why sometimes strangers have a number after their name like Stranger 4 or Stranger 2?

[candid walrus]

Probably because it's the second or fourth mission in their stranger mission strand. Could be wrong though

Is it something like (Just an example) Arcadia for Armatures II, IV, I, etc?

[hallow pawn]

to make it clear they are different people

if that is what you mean

[candid walrus]

ah, ok. nvm LOL

[atomic dome]

it's possible, just killed 2 while hunting for one.

though, it's probably a glitch

[candid walrus]

anyone know if there are any other missions from Albert mason after Arcadia for Armatures III?

[atomic dome]

considering some arrows goes through when shot at a person/animal

[verbal prairie]

pretty sure

that's probably something you can search up

actually now that I think about it I have had his mission for ages

he just disappeared on me

[candid walrus]

oof

i really like his missions

[verbal prairie]

he is definitely a cool guy

[candid walrus]

yea

[atomic dome]

i found myself replaying the story a bunch of times.

[verbal prairie]

one of my favourite strangers tbh idk why

[candid walrus]

agreed

I'm so close to being maximum honor nwfnewjfw

[spice rain]

You can't get max honor until chapter 6

[candid walrus]

wait really?

d a n g i t

[spice rain]

Yeah sadly

[candid walrus]

how come?

[spice rain]

Idk why

[atomic dome]

it sorta makes sense though.

[spice rain]

You just can't max it out until then

[candid walrus]

why is there just a random guy walking around with a bull

[atomic dome]

not gonna spoil it.

obviously.

[candid walrus]

yea

oh well xd

[atomic dome]

though, keep this in mind.

keep it up.

[spice rain]

Keep whut up

[atomic dome]

dat honor level doe.

[candid walrus]

ill try my best lol

[atomic dome]

Donate 2 the blind man you encounter

you get an achievement at chapter 6, once finally getting max honor.

cool stuff.

[spice rain]

You get the same achievement for getting lowest honor too

[candid walrus]

that's what I'm going for, the minimum or max honor trophy

[honest drum]

nah the arrow went through the neck and into the other one

crazy luck

[candid walrus]

woo

[atomic dome]

yeah, that's a hidden detail.

[candid walrus]

finally got master hunter 4 done

[atomic dome]

thought it was a glitch lol

[honest drum]

i killed 2 people with one bullet before, couldn't clip that tho

[atomic dome]

it's possible for that, too

[candid walrus]

time to skin 3 black or grizzly bears :')

[atomic dome]

@candid walrus goodluck

[candid walrus]

any places to recommend?

thanks xd

[atomic dome]

shoot it with a range weapon.

[delicate sparrow]

hi gab

[spice rain]

Between the owanjila lake and blackbone Forrest

Hey reaper, hru

[delicate sparrow]

good hbu?

[candid walrus]

thank you!

[spice rain]

V good, hungry

Mmmmm

[delicate sparrow]

i just ate

[honest drum]

also anyone else hate bandoliers?

they look so out of place

and ugly

[delicate sparrow]

i don't have a problem with bandoliers

[honest drum]

imo

[atomic dome]

@candid walrus i also recommend don't go full tactical mode, as in rushing that bear with a pump action shotty.

[delicate sparrow]

they're historically accurate

[honest drum]

ye but i just hate how they look

[atomic dome]

you'll get yourself eaten up pretty fast.

[candid walrus]

thanks! im gonna head over to the place near watsons cabin first

[delicate sparrow]

@candid walrus want bear hunting tips?

use cover scent

[spice rain]

I'd recommend just shooting the shit out of their face with a Springfield with express rounds

[honest drum]

potent predator bait

[delicate sparrow]

you don't even need express rounds

[olive notch]

Get a good rifle

[delicate sparrow]

i would use a bolt action or springfield and spam dead eye

[spice rain]

You don't but I've always used themn

[delicate sparrow]

use express if you want the perfect pelt though

[spice rain]

Always guaranteed kill

[candid walrus]

thanks all of you XD i dont mind not getting a perfect pelt, i just need it for the challenge :>

[spice rain]

But perfect bear pelts help get a very cool coat

[candid walrus]

from the trapper?

[delicate sparrow]

ye

[candid walrus]

ill keep that in mind! is it part of the legendary bear set?

[olive notch]

Are you hunting the legendary bear?

[candid walrus]

my brother got the hat and coat and now uses it on Arthur all the time lol

[spice rain]

Nah but bear and cougar pelts get the cougar Cutaway Coat

[candid walrus]

Nope, just a regular one for the survivalist challenge

[olive notch]

right.

[candid walrus]

good to know! thanks!

[delicate sparrow]

where are cougars

[honest drum]

the cougar saddle is great too

looks cool

[honest drum]

blackbone forest

[delicate sparrow]

ty

[honest drum]

sleep until morning

garanteed spawn

at least for me

[olive notch]

They're also sometimes near rhodes

in the forest

[spice rain]

That's the panther

[candid walrus]

there is almost always one at blackbone forest next to the creek

[honest drum]

thats panthers

[delicate sparrow]

panther my guy

[olive notch]

I think there's only one panther.

[honest drum]

no

[olive notch]

Doesn't despawn for me then.

[olive notch]

Also armadillo.

[candid walrus]

dang. just ran into the blind guy at the heartlands and he said "For loyalty is both your saving and your curse"

👀

[spice rain]

Panthers only spawn at Old Harry Fen, but cougars have quite a few spawns

[olive notch]

just play the game

[honest drum]

'your whole life you've followed the wrong star' or smth like that is the best line from cassidy imo

or

'enjoy today, because tomorrow, well tomorrow awaits us all' while speaking to john

[olive notch]

Expect spoilers here.

[candid walrus]

yeah. sadly i already know how it ends lol-

before i got the game i watched a full playthrough of it thinking i would never be able to play anyway so... yeah

[olive notch]

Understandable.

[spice rain]

😔

[candid walrus]

smh i was using auto ride and my horse went face first into a wagon

[honest drum]

if i ever get spoiled on a game i usually just wait 3 years then play it lmao

i forget everything

[candid walrus]

lol

[honest drum]

did that recently with marvel spider man 2018

[candid walrus]

me trying to avoid the thomas downes mission when i ride past it: 👀 💧

[hidden moss]

FUCK I'M NERVOUS as fuck, I HATE THE SHIT OF MY COMPUTER, LIKE A GAMES COMPUTER WITH 8G RAM CAN'T RUN GTA4? Damn it I understand that GTA 4 has a history of BUGS on the PC, BUT THIS IS NOT THE FIRST TIME THAT HAPPENS HAPPENS, I calmed down, and I am seriously thinking about exchanging my 2400 dollar gamer pc for a medium / weak computer. my plan is to sell this current pc to buy a ps4 and a weak computer for study

[olive notch]

That's unrelated.

Good luck.

[candid walrus]

my horse just got ran over by a wagon and it wont move but it still has a lot of health- why is this horse so obsessed with wagons

[atomic dome]

sexually attracted to wagons.

[candid walrus]

lol

[honest drum]

jesus wow

calm

#pc-technical-stuff

[tawdry idol]

Murderer

[bronze pumice]

What?

[tawdry idol]

Witness

[bronze pumice]

Oh

[candid walrus]

seems there isnt a bear here

[tawdry idol]

The moment

[candid walrus]

woo

came looking for a bear and i got a perfect cougar pelt

[bronze pumice]

How much money do you have in RDR2?

[candid walrus]

I have $1,359

[bronze pumice]

I have $1,700,000

[candid walrus]

wow

how did you get that much?

[bronze pumice]

Trains, wagons, stores, etc.

I’ve spent thousands of hours

[candid walrus]

nice

anything i can do with a perfect cougar carcass?

[bronze pumice]

Sell it

[candid walrus]

can i craft anything with it tho

[bronze pumice]

Maybe

Give it to the trapper just in case

[candid walrus]

will do

[indigo topaz]

No u can just sel it but the pelt u can use

[candid walrus]

ah, ok.

[bronze pumice]

I don’t do any crafting so I don’t really know what you can craft

[muted jetty]

hey guys can someone help me out? there's a problem with my graphics that I want to fix

[bronze pumice]

Computer or PS5?

[muted jetty]

pc

[bronze pumice]

I don’t play RDR2 on computer, sorry

[muted jetty]

basically the lighting is super flickery

[warm kelp]

what does "reticle messages" option exactly? I can't see any difference between On or OFF

[honest drum]

ye mines like that

have u updated the nvidia drivers?

[candid walrus]

lmao i just greet + greet + antagonized someone and he asked about bounty hunters. when the NPC replied Arthur just said 'thank for nothing, idiot"

one of my favorite ones

[honest drum]

#pc-technical-stuff @muted jetty

[honest drum]

ye lol

i love greet, greet, antagonise

some great lines

[candid walrus]

yep

my dog wont stop squirming everywhere

[honest drum]

'howdy'
'i like your face'
'reminds me of the last time i lifted my horses tail'

[candid walrus]

YES

I love that one LOL

[tawdry idol]

That moment a coyote kills a bear

Jk

[candid walrus]

o-o

[honest drum]

i love how bad john's drawings are compared to arthurs

[candid walrus]

lol i just did it again and this time arthur complimented someone's horse. then he said "I'm surprised it ain't bucked you off and kicked you in the face. I would" then the guy almost killed me. wtf

ikr

[honest drum]

lmao

i love how easy the explorer challenges are

literally just find treasure 10 times

they could of made them like 'find 3 treasure in 12hrs' or smth

[candid walrus]

i havent completed all of them yet because im too lazy-

[honest drum]

and it's not even treasure

just maps

count

[tawdry idol]

How does John not know how to swim lol?

[honest drum]

it's because of rdr1

in rdr1 you die instantly

if u touch water

so they wanted continuity

plus back then not many ppl knew how to swim

[bronze pumice]

It’s 1907, they didn’t have readily available swimming lessons

[honest drum]

ye

[candid walrus]

why is this one drawing of a duck by arthur so bad. the ones next to it are super detailed and then... duck

is this only in my game or is it in others too?

[bronze pumice]

I don’t know

I only play as John

[honest drum]

ye lol the duck is so bad

maybe it's a bug

maybe they put johns drawing

instead of arthurs

there

[candid walrus]

lol

also, do arthurs drawings get more detailed the more times you "interact" with the plant/animal? so for plants, the more you pick them the more detailed it gets?

[honest drum]

not rlly

he's just a really good drawer

[candid walrus]

because some of the plant drawings in arthurs journal are half really detailed, and then half sketched

ah, ok

[honest drum]

in general

i love how arthur wishes he'd married abigail

[candid walrus]

yea lol

[drifting star]

Really?

[honest drum]

it says in his journal

after the fishing trip with jack

[drifting star]

U mean Arthur wish he marrys Abigail or he wishes John merrier Abigail

Marry*

[honest drum]

he also doesn't know the difference between Italian and Spanish lolol

[candid walrus]

arthur wishes he had married abigail instead of john

[honest drum]

ye lol

'before she fell hard with MARSTON'

[drifting star]

Lol

[honest drum]

i love how he capitalises MARSTON

[drifting star]

I’ll have to check that out

[candid walrus]

M A R S T O N

is there any way to help the guy who gets mauled by a wolf near donner falls? or does he just die either way?

[honest drum]

i love how arthur doesn't know the difference between 'senor' in spanish and 'signor' in italian

when writing about bronte he says 'senor bronte'

[candid walrus]

lol

[honest drum]

arthur doesn't remember lenny's death correctly either

he writes 'lenny got himself shot in the head' when he comes back from guarma

when really he was shot in the stomach

[candid walrus]

do you think there's a reason why?

[verbal prairie]

it all happened so fast

[candid walrus]

true

[verbal prairie]

likely just wasnt thinking about the details and rather about how he might be next

[honest drum]

and it was a few weeks after he got his journal back

[verbal prairie]

I'm guessing the devs did it intentionally

which is actually really cool if so

[honest drum]

either that or lenny originally had a different death that was cut but rockstar didn't change arthur's journal

[fading shard]

@deep yacht hello

[candid walrus]

poor lenny ;-;

[verbal prairie]

nah tbh if multiple mistakes are in his journal I think it's more of a realism thing

[honest drum]

ye

[verbal prairie]

like señor instead of signor

[honest drum]

well Señor

[fading shard]

@north aurora hello

[candid walrus]

i cant find any bears so im just going to go fishing >:C

[verbal prairie]

fishing sucks

hunting all the way

[candid walrus]

oof

i like fishing better now because i changed the reel in option

i just hit a rock with my horse and i went flying at least 50 feet

wtf

whats the fastest way to get max health/stamina/dead eye?

[hallow pawn]

find ginseng elixirs pirate rums valerian roots and do challenges

[candid walrus]

ok! im currently out of all three of those. are they just chance finds?

[hallow pawn]

you can help moonshiners and give them herbs

they have an aged pirate rum

you can loot cabins out in wild

they have stuff

[candid walrus]

thats great! thank you!

[hallow pawn]

np

[indigo topaz]

Row a boat to boost up health bars and run like shit for stamania

[candid walrus]

LOL ok

[indigo topaz]

To improve dead eye u neet to shoot from long distances and do chores

But if u want it full...u have to finnish all of ure challenges

[hallow pawn]

yea

challenges are important

[candid walrus]

that's what im attempting to do. hopefully it doesnt take too long

[indigo topaz]

Only gambler and herbalist were in a pyn in the ass...but the rest are easy

[hallow pawn]

the blackjack challenge with 3 hits

[candid walrus]

yeah im at challenge 9 for herbalist. gotta wait until the epilogue to finish it tho

[hallow pawn]

that was a pain in the ass

[indigo topaz]

Bruh that blackjack one

Do it in rhodes

[hallow pawn]

both of them are really hard to me

[candid walrus]

which challenge was it?

[hallow pawn]

gambler 2 and 7 if I'm not wrong

[candid walrus]

ah, ok

[indigo topaz]

The herbalist just took really long to finish but the gambler was just pure luck to finish

[drifting star]

Did mine in Blackwater

Tried for 3hrs in Rhodes and got none

[hallow pawn]

blackwater is a good place to do gambling challenges

[drifting star]

Blackwater I got all the 3 in 30mins

[honest drum]

im about to say a huge spoiler so leave if u haven't finished the game

a very cool detail is that in a random encounter at camp in chapter 2, hosea and lenny say they want to be buried with friends, they're buried together, and arthur says he'd like to be buried facing the west, charles (who is present during the encounter) buries him facing the east, this symbolises how arthur changed

[drifting star]

Ahhh yes I remember that

He says he wants to die facing the sunset

[honest drum]

and he dies during sunrise

[drifting star]

Yeah I thought that was really cool when I found that

[indigo topaz]

Noice

[honest drum]

ye, little details like this is what makes rdr2 the best game of all time imo

[candid walrus]

oh man

[drifting star]

💯

[candid walrus]

thats an awesome detail

[dusty river]

rdr2 is the best game of all time 100%

[candid walrus]

yus

[drifting star]

Yeah sooo much to do

[dusty river]

ikr

[drifting star]

When I first started I thought there was too much to do lol

[candid walrus]

same lol

[dusty river]

the first time i completed the game only doing the missions then in my 2nd and 3rd playthrough i did a ton more

[candid walrus]

just had the incest couple at aberdeen pig farm invite me in for dinner 👁️ 👄 👁️

[candid walrus]

im trying to go for 100% my first playthrough

[dusty river]

oh god

[hallow pawn]

btw

about aberdeen

does that money transaction thing still work

[candid walrus]

i dont think so

[dusty river]

I dont think so

wow

[hallow pawn]

[dusty river]

same reply noice

[sinful hound]

Lol

[candid walrus]

LOL

[honest drum]

yes

if

u mean arthurs money as john

[hallow pawn]

yes

I mean that

nice then

[honest drum]

im 99% sure it does

[sinful hound]

It should

[hallow pawn]

bcs I'm finding all treasures and I dont wanna be poor until end of epilogue 2

[candid walrus]

going after the legendary gar

lets see how this goes lol

just stumbled across the rapists house thinking it was a random honorable encounter because of the circle thing on the map. noped the heck out of there

[honest drum]

easy

[candid walrus]

finally got the longnose gar! do i just immediately send it to the fish dude?

[hidden moss]

have you noticed that it seems that all online games are getting full of toxic players that kill you for whatever reason?

[sinful hound]

Yes

[candid walrus]

yep

[hidden moss]

it’s getting almost impossible to play them, or you’re just offline or you die and you can’t do anything online

[candid walrus]

yea

[signal timber]

Where do you do 5 finger fillet?

[hallow pawn]

strawberry

van horn

[candid walrus]

strawberry, van horn, and...

[hallow pawn]

valentine's other tavern

[candid walrus]

dunnno the last place

[lucid lake]

wow I just did that weird couple encounter blindly

the first thing the dude said to me made me suspicious

[candid walrus]

incest couple?

[lucid lake]

yeah!

[candid walrus]

did the same thing to me earlier lol

[lucid lake]

so i just snuck in the side stole some shit, and then killed them both

gruesomely

[candid walrus]

i just steer clear of them.

LOL

[lucid lake]

and then threw a molotov in and carried on my merry way

[candid walrus]

lmao

what fish should I go after next 🤔

[honest drum]

Go to a post office

Then send it

[candid walrus]

just did, thanks :)

[honest drum]

Whichever one is closest lol

There’s one just outside of St Denis

[hidden moss]

do i have to complete a specific mission to unlock a fence? i just unlocked chapter 2 btw

[honest drum]

On the train track bridge thing

And there’s one on sisika

So get a boat and go to sisika

[candid walrus]

lake sturgeon?

[honest drum]

Idk

[honest drum]

No

Well

You need to do a mission to unlock the fence at emerald ranch

But

All the other ones you get straight away

There’s one in Rhodes

[lucid lake]

LOL i was wondering who i sent a fish to

i had the option to mail a fish so i did

but had no idea why

[honest drum]

You can send any fish to him

[candid walrus]

lol

[lucid lake]

i dont remember ever meeting a fish guy

[candid walrus]

fish guy

[honest drum]

Even after you finish all the legendary ones but uhhh that’s a bit strange if you know what happens

[candid walrus]

his new name

[honest drum]

Jeremy Gill

[hidden moss]

so i just unlocked chapter 2, where is the nearest fence?

[candid walrus]

Emerald ranch fence

if you've unlocked it

[honest drum]

Rhodes

[lucid lake]

oh man i think i killed him

[hidden moss]

and i dont need to do any missions to unlock it?

[lucid lake]

i remember the spot

[hidden moss]

its already there?

[honest drum]

Not the one in Rhodes no

There is a mission for the one at emerald ranch

But all the others no

[candid walrus]

how do i get the legendary fish in st. denis without getting hit by a train lol

[honest drum]

Trains are very rare in that track

If I was you

Do it in the evening

[candid walrus]

ooh

[honest drum]

Sisika is harder

[hidden moss]

ok

[honest drum]

As you can’t get seen

By the guards

Why rockstar put a fish there I’ll never know lol

[candid walrus]

ok! i'll go after the St. Denis one first

[honest drum]

A treasure map would of been better on Sisika or smth

Prisoners stash

[candid walrus]

yea

[honest drum]

Or a convict that hid all the gold from a bank robbery he got arrested for

[candid walrus]

foosh

thats a good idea

[drifting star]

Where’s Sisika?

[lucid lake]

can I do anything with the wolf picture from mr mason?

[candid walrus]

not really

just a picture

[lucid lake]

ah well

thought i could put it up in camp or something

[candid walrus]

sadly no

[lucid lake]

love the missions with that guy, the back and fourth between him and arthur is amazing

[candid walrus]

ikr?? i love them

are you kidding

i just got the legendary sturgeon on the line and then a fricking train comes

i stg

finally got the strugeon

[sinful hound]

It's the island penitentiary, left of st. Denis and annesburg

[candid walrus]

debating on weather or not i should get another fish or go after a legendary animal

[dawn patio]

Hey some of the things I need to get full the compendium are guarma exclusive is there any way to get them like go repeat a guarma story mission and find them or???

[honest drum]

It’s the prison

[drifting star]

Ahhhh the prison

[honest drum]

Island off St Denis

[drifting star]

Yeah I remember now

Is there a way to there?

[honest drum]

Boat

Steal a boat off someone

[drifting star]

Ohhh ok

[honest drum]

Then row there

Or use a steam boat

Lol

[drifting star]

Thanks I can get the fish now

[honest drum]

I did it in the epilogue so it was hard getting a boat

[drifting star]

I’m doing it in epilogue too

[honest drum]

I had to like shoot the boat driver, use my horse, get off it right by the boat and jump on quickly so I didn’t drown

[drifting star]

Lol forgot about drowning

[honest drum]

If you wanna get back without rowing, the fish goes into your satchel so you don’t have to carry it, just get killed by the guards

You’ll respawn at mainland

With the fish

In your satchel

Ngl I really wanna do a permadeath play through for my YT channel

[drifting star]

Ahhhh ok cheers

[honest drum]

Everytime I die make a new game

That would be painful

But

Would get a lot of views

Soooo 👀

[drifting star]

That sounds fun tbh

Red dead redemption mission tho

[honest drum]

It would be, until you die in red dead redemption (the last mission as Arthur) 🤣

[drifting star]

I watched your vid on Johns daughter, never knew he has one tbh

[honest drum]

Ye it’s a good detail

[drifting star]

Had*

[honest drum]

Well mystery

[drifting star]

Yeah

[candid walrus]

The animals from guarma don't count towards 100% completion, so don't worry about them.

[dawn patio]

I already have 100 percent completion

I just want a full compendium

[candid walrus]

ah, well then you can't go back

[red helm]

There is a Artist stranger you do some mission for in Saint Denis, that those pictures are used for. FYI.

[candid walrus]

sorry

[dawn patio]

[candid walrus]

sorry ;-;

[drifting star]

Pain

[honest drum]

They’re in the art gallery in st Denis

As well as a pic of Arthur

U can go there anytime

[hidden moss]

You can find all guarma species on the islands in flat iron lake.

[dawn patio]

Are you sure about that?

I've never heard of anything like that...

[hidden moss]

Never checked, read it somewhere tho

Might be a myth🤷😄

[lucid lake]

love to hear that thanks guys

[honest drum]

It’s true

Well

Idk about the birds

I know everything else is

[dawn patio]

Ya in pretty sure th e birds I'd what I need

[honest drum]

The theory is that the crashed boat on the island was transporting those animals to America, but it crashed and they escaped on the island

[honest drum]

There might be the birds

I swear I’ve seen them

Idk 100%

[candid walrus]

just got the legendary boar 🥳

[dawn patio]

I'll have a look when I can

[dawn patio]

Pog

[candid walrus]

lol

[verbal prairie]

who do you guys think would've sided with Arthur at the end

had they survived

or not left the gang

[candid walrus]

hmm

[verbal prairie]

one I know 100% is if Charles was there he would've

[candid walrus]

I say Lenny, Hosea, Sean, Javier, Kieran, Susan, Charles... Think that's it

[verbal prairie]

I know itd be dumb if no one died before that

but all I'm saying is

...imagine a confrontation like that

Micah, Dutch and their supporters Vs Arthur, John and their supporters

[candid walrus]

that would be interesting

What do you think about Bill?

[verbal prairie]

oh bill was there ig you didn't know I won't tell you who he sides with though

[candid walrus]

Ah, ok

I feel like he would side with Dutch but idk

Oh we forgot reverend and strauss

they aren't too important tho

[verbal prairie]

they're interesting ones

yeah..

idk

Strauss had a more personal connection with Arthur

[candid walrus]

yea

[verbal prairie]

idk about reverend though

[candid walrus]

Personal 👀

[verbal prairie]

lol

trelawny?

[unique garnet]

not the birds and snakes.. those are only on guarma

[candid walrus]

ooh yeah forgot about him

probably Arthur

although he's a very come and go type of person

[verbal prairie]

looking back at your list idk about Javier

[hidden moss]

Ah rip, nvm then😄

[verbal prairie]

I mean he seems like a good friend to Arthur he's not in it for himself

[candid walrus]

yeah

[verbal prairie]

but his loyalty could overcloud his judgement

[candid walrus]

thats true

[honest drum]

Literally everyone

[verbal prairie]

do you think Javier would?

[honest drum]

Wdym

[candid walrus]

im half and half about Javier

i feel like he would side with him but at the same time he wouldn't

[honest drum]

Javier is there

[verbal prairie]

wait

wtf

really?

[candid walrus]

?

[honest drum]

What

[dawn patio]

Ya lol was about to say

[verbal prairie]

I swear he was not there

[honest drum]

Javier is there

[dawn patio]

He was on Dutch side but had his gun in the air

[honest drum]

He doesn’t side with anyone

[candid walrus]

where

[honest drum]

He aims his gun in the air

[dawn patio]

Pointing to the sky

[candid walrus]

o

[verbal prairie]

oh that might be why I don't remember it

[dawn patio]

So he kinda sided with dutch

[honest drum]

And him and bill leave Dutch as soon as they can

[verbal prairie]

the others where more blatantly sided

were*

[dawn patio]

Bill was hesitant

Although he did point his gun at them

[honest drum]

They leave Micah and Dutch as soon as they can

[verbal prairie]

bill always hurts lol

I liked bill

[dawn patio]

Really lol

[honest drum]

In the scene were they’re on horses shooting at Arthur and John, bill and javier aren’t there

[candid walrus]

Bill was ok imo

[dawn patio]

Hes one of the more unlikable ones imo

[honest drum]

No I feel bad for bill

He was basically bullied

Even by Dutch

Which explains in rdr1 why he’s so obsessed with leading a gang

[verbal prairie]

bill was always just a nice lovable person to me personally

[honest drum]

He finally felt like he was worth something

[verbal prairie]

I think the bonding in the parties helped

[honest drum]

In rdr1

[dawn patio]

I guess my thought process is messed up by the piece of garbage he is in rdr1

[honest drum]

‘I’m in charge now John! No more Dutch, and no more you!’

He was finally worth something

[dawn patio]

I just keep thinking about what he did at I think ridgewood farms

Like raped and killed pretty much everyone there

[delicate sparrow]

who?

[candid walrus]

Bill Williamson I believe

[honest drum]

He didn’t

His men did

[candid walrus]

how come i cant craft the legendary boar trinket? i skinned it and everything but it isnt showing up in the crafting area for Seamus

nvm! figured it out

[hidden moss]

one thing I noticed in the "factions" of rdr2 if only one member infiltrates there, it can do a lot of damage, imagine if a pinkerton secretly infiltrates the DUtch gang and starts causing the death of several members

[dawn patio]

Which is pretty much what happened

[hidden moss]

Serious?

[verbal prairie]

Micah?

he worked with the Pinkertons and caused the death of pretty much everyone

pretty similar

[hidden moss]

i heard a story that micah was an infiltrator of the pinkertons, does that continue?

[dawn patio]

....

[verbal prairie]

huh

[dawn patio]

Did you even play through the story lol???

[hidden moss]

I dont have money

to buy rdr 2

[hidden moss]

thanks for the reply, funny that rdr2 sometimes seems more like "villains killing villains" of course there are some characters that are debatable if they are heroes like Ross, but most of the time yes it is villain killing villain, mica was not a hero idealistic or something

[dawn patio]

Oh

Ya..

In chapter 6 milton reveals micah helped the pinkertons

[verbal prairie]

wtf

[hidden moss]

Why did he help them? I read on the wiki that even before he helped the Dutch he was a thief, he only did it for the money?

[verbal prairie]

if you don't think you'll ever play it wouldn't it be a good idea to watch a summary lol

[dawn patio]

I dont remember but prolly money

[hidden moss]

i'm thinking of exchanging my pc for a worse computer so i can have money to buy a ps4 and then be able to play rdr 2

[muted sierra]

I'm almost done everything u can do as Arthur. All I have to do is kill the few Carolina Parakeet (keeping a perfect as a trophy) and get one more horse

[hidden moss]

can someone for the love of god explain to me how a computer from 14 years ago can run gta 4 BUT MY 2018 NO?

[candid walrus]

just reached 43% completion 🥲

[hidden moss]

I got 88 then started a new save

[candid walrus]

nice

[tawdry idol]

Sniper

[delicate sparrow]

?

[delicate sparrow]

your computer is broken

actually i need to know one thing

do you have your game installed on an SSD or HDD

[hidden moss]

i dont know

[muted sierra]

nvm I need to find weapons

[delicate sparrow]

Then nobody can help you, sorry

[hidden moss]

How do I find this out? because then I don't have heavy games, all my games are very light

things with less than 10 gigs

[spark shard]

I love that hose say yuh

[drifting axle]

Can someone tell@me if laptop can play this game on low or potatoe mode with decent FPS no lag I have acer nitro 5 with 1050ti

[tawdry idol]

You guys are smokers

Helps with your core

[delicate sparrow]

you'll be fine

[delicate sparrow]

you have windows 10 right? press the hotkey windows key + r

a menu will pop up

type the command dfrgui

it'll show you

[hidden moss]

i will send a photo

[delicate sparrow]

ok

put it in media

[spark shard]

My guess is hes either in saint denis or on a boat to italy

[delicate sparrow]

@spark shard congrats on 100%

[tawdry idol]

German guns but no Russian guns, makes sense

Or it doesn't

[spark shard]

Already got 100% in 2018

[delicate sparrow]

congrats on red name

[spark shard]

Just did it again on a run where I wasnt dishonorable arthur 😈

[delicate sparrow]

wow

2 100%s

i can't even get 1 lol

[dawn patio]

What are you stuck on

[hidden moss]

one night when I was frisky

[dawn patio]

Ok

[delicate sparrow]

Exotics

[dawn patio]

I feel so bad for you

[delicate sparrow]

im really not interested in 100%

[sacred mirage]

I wanna get my hair passed level 7. I've tried using hair tonics, even tried stacking them. Then went to sleep for several days, nothing happened. I've been playing for another couple of hours now and I'm still at lvl 7. What am I doing wrong.

It's for my beard to be precise. I've been trimming my hair. Is that the issue? I mean I don't think it is because I literally haven't touched my beard but you never know

[prime jewel]

wish i could've helped

[hidden moss]

Lv 7 is max for hair

[sinful hound]

He just said it's for his beard

[sacred mirage]

It's for my beard but I already figured it out. It's tied to story progression. Now that I'm in chapter 4, it started growing again. Thanks though

[hidden moss]

Oh sorry i just read ur first phrase

[sacred mirage]

No worries :)

[hidden moss]

Try lv 10 moustache and lv 3 beard

Micah moment

[velvet mauve]

I swear some people hear a fucken rude

[sinful hound]

Why what's up?

[velvet mauve]

I swear I join a video chat for a second and then they start swearing at me bro my
Microphone was even mute

[spark shard]

I finally killed edgar ross

[velvet mauve]

Idk tho

Idc

Tho

@spark shard nice

[spark shard]

Time for some good ole red dead undead nightmare

[hidden moss]

I didnt like it

[velvet mauve]

Never played it is it worthet

[hidden moss]

Undead?

[velvet mauve]

Yeah

[hidden moss]

I didnt like it but it was fine

[velvet mauve]

Ok

[spark shard]

You say that because you're afraid of zombies

God damned coward

[hidden moss]

Sure dude

They were anoying

The on 4 legs guys

Repetitive

[spark shard]

You could literally say that about all rdr2 human enemies. Guy with a gun.

[hidden moss]

If undead rdr2 came (it doesnt) i would play it tho

[spark shard]

If rdr2 storymode got any updates or dlc's (never will) I would pay top dollar for it

If rdo was good (never will be) I'd play more often

[hidden moss]

I bought rdt2 for 33 euros and i have played it 2 times i think a third time so i know it will be worth it

[winged python]

Crossing a railroad bridge with your horse must be one of the most terrifying experiences

[sinful hound]

That legendary sturgeon tho

Even worse imo

[hidden moss]

My horse once got stuck on a train in saint denis, and i didnt know if it would survive it did but it was a long as train

[hidden moss]

Thats why i like horses in rdr2 better then cars in gta5 i care about my horse

[winged python]

i mean you can't really put an insurance on your horse

[inner raptor]

Next to robbing a train.

[winged python]

robbing trains is so bad, the bounty you get is more expensive than the payout

[inner raptor]

Your horse is stupid so it'll probably run into the train

[winged python]

that's how my beloved arabian died

[hidden moss]

Exacly, and your honor gets lower

[winged python]

is there a way to make money/have fun after u finished the game

apart treasure hunts

[hidden moss]

I cant enjoy myself after the story

I did the treasur in beginning chapter 2 and had more then 10.000

[winged python]

i had 3500$ after the bank robbery, i spend 2000$ and bought all the camp upgrades, which i think might've been a waste

[hidden moss]

What chapter are you?

[winged python]

i already finished the game, rn im replaying it and im at chapter 3 rn

[hidden moss]

O yea

From gold bars you can get 24 max

[winged python]

24k?

[hidden moss]

500 for 1 gold bar

[winged python]

so 24 bars

[hidden moss]

24 max bars

[winged python]

damn

disappointing

[hidden moss]

Why

[winged python]

ain't enough

[mild burrow]

where can i catch the biggest fish?

[hidden moss]

After a while you dont know where to spend your money

[winged python]

water, idk tho

[mild burrow]

Why spend? Just save

[hidden moss]

For what

[mild burrow]

Nothing

[winged python]

act poor stay rich you wouldn't get it

[pearl scarab]

nashville

[mild burrow]

Like irl, don’t need to act rich to be rich

[hidden moss]

Should i replay rdr2 for the thrid time

I dont wanna get depressed

[pearl scarab]

Yes you should

[winged python]

do it lmao

no balls

[mild burrow]

Yes, everytime you replay the story, always choose a different route

[hidden moss]

Im playing another game but when its finished ill play rdr2 again

[pearl scarab]

What game

[hidden moss]

I cant

[mild burrow]

Why?

[winged python]

my 2nd replay im killin every mf that looks at me the wrong way

[hidden moss]

I wanna see him die in peace and somewhat how he wanted

[mild burrow]

I got low honor for the first time, i’m trying to get ultra high honor and actually playing the side missions this time

[hidden moss]

Tip donate 20 at camp

[pearl scarab]

canonically arthur would not kill anybody at cold blood

[mild burrow]

Have to replay it anyway, i lost thr autosave

[sinful hound]

Finished the game twice and I'm in chapter 2 now what should I do gimme advice

[winged python]

commit a hate crime

join the kkk

[sinful hound]

Ok

[hidden moss]

Do treasur hunts

[sinful hound]

Why not I never was a bad guy

[sinful hound]

Already did em 😔 😔

[hidden moss]

It took me like 3 days

[sinful hound]

It took me around the same since I didn't play much

[hidden moss]

Me nether

2 or 3 hours max

[sinful hound]

I need to make a save in chapter 3

Always forget it

Best soundtrack in rdr2?

@hidden moss

[hidden moss]

What

[pearl scarab]

May I stand unshaken

[sinful hound]

Best soundtack in rdr2

To me it's cruel cruel world or little Liza Jane

[pearl scarab]

Build a little house together

[formal pilot]

Why do I get so many black dots in my face?

[sinful hound]

YES that one too!

[hidden moss]

Thatd just the way it is

And venom

[pearl scarab]

That song was made to cure our cowboy depression

[sinful hound]

And bring it back after

[hidden moss]

Was fun for 3 minutes

Then back to red dead depression

[sinful hound]

Ring dang doo is epic too

[drifting star]

Ring dang doo is my favourite camp song

[sinful hound]

What's the Ring dang doo tho

[formal pilot]

Best settings to make the game less blurry?

[prime jewel]

i hate beaver hollow

[sinful hound]

Who doesn't

[prime jewel]

yeah

the location ew

but horseshoe overlook

delicious

[drifting star]

I like the chapter 3 one

[prime jewel]

clements point is nice too

it has the summer ambiance and feels good

[hidden moss]

Chapter 2 is the best chapter cant change my mind

Everything is the best in it

[drifting star]

Chapter 3 is my favourite personally

Sneaking between the manors and then destroying them was fun for me idk why

Chapter 2 is my second favourite

And chapter 1 was my least favourite

[dire glade]

Chapter 2 I think was with valentine camp was good

[prime jewel]

yeah

[dire glade]

Lake Isabella in the north you can try to get that red fish

[prime jewel]

1. Chapter 2
2. Chapter 3
3. Chapter 4
   4.Chapter 1
4. Chapter 5
5. Chapter 6

[dire glade]

You need special lake lure though

[prime jewel]

owanjila one is bigger i think

[dire glade]

Idk where that is

I only know the biggest fish I know in lake Isabella

[prime jewel]

owanjila, the lake near strawberry

a big one

there is a red arabian near

and some beavers

[dire glade]

Red Arabian?

[prime jewel]

yeah?

[dire glade]

I like my horses a bit white so Isabella is good for me tyvm

But ngl the white Arabian in the north looks good

[prime jewel]

i don't like arabians but i love the red one

[dire glade]

Arabians are fast so

That's what matters

[prime jewel]

skittish as a beaver 😦

[dire glade]

Idk if they are the fastest in the story but

[prime jewel]

spped doesn't affect that much

only a few second

[dire glade]

Yeah a few seconds can be precious you know

Still better then nothing

[prime jewel]

nah

[dire glade]

Imo

[floral jasper]

This game makes me cry

[prime jewel]

i'd prefer riding a morgan rather an arabian

arabians just sucks

[floral jasper]

I don't like small horses

Looks stupid

[prime jewel]

me too

pony

[dire glade]

I respect your opinion but for me personally I like the look and stats of Arabian

[prime jewel]

i don't like the stats

[dire glade]

And it also fits with my nationality 😝

[prime jewel]

ur an arabian?

[dire glade]

Yep

By blood I'm Arabic so

[prime jewel]

i use a turkoman cause of my nationality

not kidding 😄

[dire glade]

A hahaha you're turkish?

[prime jewel]

yep

[dire glade]

That's good anwyays

[prime jewel]

turkomans are good

[dire glade]

On topic don't wanna get warned lol

[prime jewel]

coats, stats

[dire glade]

I've never seen one before

How're they like in rdr2

[prime jewel]

u gotta be kidding

[dire glade]

No

[prime jewel]

i'll post wait a sec

[dire glade]

Only in multiplayer I've seen it in the catalogue