oof well okay so, idk if ur aware but mooses are naturally rare to spawn, and a bull moose is even more complicated but
#red-dead-singleplayer
junior spruce
junior spruce
in my multiple playthroughs, my safe place to go get a bull moose (although it takes... sometimes a few retries, spawn is sure in that place, but not guaranteed) a bit northeast of colter
sand rain
I tried that one it’s the one on the cliff edge right?
junior spruce
yep its kind of a popular pick for people
he's sure to spawn there but not guaranteed he'll spawn
does that make sense?
sand rain
Yeah
junior spruce
so it can either take you 1 try or 10 tries, but seriously mooses are rare af
sand rain
I tried that place 3 times total
junior spruce
especially bull mooses
sand rain
Alr ima try again
junior spruce
I tried that place 3 times total
you know that quest that pearson gives you for a scout jacket? it took me 9 reloads once to get that quest triggered so
things happen, sometimes just take time...
sand rain
you know that quest that pearson gives you for a scout jacket? it took me 9 relo...
But if it doesn’t spawn should I reload my game or sleep?
junior spruce
reload, sleeep, ride away and come back, your choice
sand rain
reload, sleeep, ride away and come back, your choice
Alr ty
sand rain
Alr
junior spruce
also you mentioned owanjila, you'd have better luck following the river south, until it curves left (right if you're looking at the map instead)
their spawn rate is bigger in the section where the river splits in 3 and back into 1, and a few meters ahead of that as well
sand rain
I got it first try after retrying holy lol
junior spruce
im glad i was able to help!!
novel plaza
Who’s John Marston?
delicate cairn
Who’s John Marston?
Me
empty patio
You're Javier
novel plaza
Javier is a bad person tho
delicate cairn
Yea he just never had a redemption
his ending is unfortunate and sucky, but arthur and john are still like
bad people
novel plaza
his ending is unfortunate and sucky, but arthur and john are still like
not bad people
There morals were thrown out the window due to Dutch’s manipulation
Hence the name
Red dead redemption
delicate cairn
everyone there are technically bad people, they ARE outlaws for a reason
novel plaza
everyone there are technically bad people, they ARE outlaws for a reason
you can do bad things and not be a bad person at heart
novel plaza
Dutch manipulated them all
And when Dutch was out of the picture
Javier stayed doing bad shit and exploiting the poor
delicate cairn
Dutch manipulated them all
idk if i'd go there though i don't know..
delicate cairn
dutch went crazy
WELL DUH but i don't think he manipulated people
delicate cairn
WELL DUH but i don't think he manipulated people
when i say people i mean everyine* oops
girl wait no stop don't get me started i just told the other guy in DMs im extremely tired and can't talk about games rn 😅
hardy turtle
girl wait no stop don't get me started i just told the other guy in DMs im extre...
omf
blissful marten
versed nymph
Bill be robbing the funding box, infront of Dutch
harsh dome
Guys, a jerk just pushed me down and stole my horse. How am I going to get it back? How am I going to travel?
snow jacinth
Guys, a jerk just pushed me down and stole my horse. How am I going to get it ba...
whistle when your in range the horse will come back to you but when hes not in range i dont know
harsh dome
whistle when your in range the horse will come back to you but when hes not in r...
I loaded game and respawned. My horse is near me. I am now aware that some strangers who call for help/are 'side missions' are bad people
snow jacinth
I loaded game and respawned. My horse is near me. I am now aware that some stran...
some are some arent
mostly the females arent the theives
harsh dome
some are some arent
It's tricky to tell whether they are good or bad. Like this guy, was asking for help, then when I came near him, he pushed me down and stole my horse
olive ermine
It's tricky to tell whether they are good or bad. Like this guy, was asking for ...
i think if ur bond with ur horse is high enough, u can just call it over and ur horse will drop the npc off its back before getting back to u
torpid delta
I'm just starting chapter 4 and Arthur started coughing right away is he ok? Like he started coughing out of nowhere
versed nymph
I'm just starting chapter 4 and Arthur started coughing right away is he ok? Lik...
First playtrough?
torpid delta
Yeah
versed nymph
Hm don't worry bout it. Its normal always happens it's js because of the air that hangs around shady belle
torpid delta
Oh
versed nymph
He swallows a fly or smth
glad kettle
Yeah 🥹
glad kettle
Hello
harsh dome
I restarted checkpoint for the part 'Leave Penelope's place without being seen'. I have left the place. My horse is nowhere to be seen. How can my horse suddenly disappear? How am I going to travel?
snow jacinth
I restarted checkpoint for the part 'Leave Penelope's place without being seen'....
Walking
harsh dome
I had to load game to get my horse near me
torpid delta
Who changed my name I'm the real jack Marston
harsh dome
The Springfield rifle is good at shooting people
charred nest
The Springfield rifle is good at shooting people
its a good sniper but i prefer the bolt and later the carcano i hardly ever use the springfield
snow jacinth
how’s everyone doing
good u
earnest oasis
good u
awesome
i got the best gun in rdr2
look at the rdr2 media and see what i posted yesterday
snow jacinth
look at the rdr2 media and see what i posted yesterday
ok
snow jacinth
look at the rdr2 media and see what i posted yesterday
double action revolver is good for gunslinging
snow jacinth
i got the best gun in rdr2
oh wanna know a little trick for holstering ur revolver or pistol?
double click LB on Xbox when holding your revolver or pistol
snow jacinth
no barrel 💀
earnest oasis
and the craziest part is that i randomly got it after logging in
not playing for a while
harsh dome
Guys me and Charles rescued Trelawny. A few bounty hunters escaped and we shot a few. There's a few more missing. It says 'Search the cornfield'. I search the cornfield but I can't find the remaining bounty hunters...
spare forge
guys im new to this game how to play rdo?
glad igloo
guys im new to this game how to play rdo?
just start the tutorial it guides you
spare forge
just start the tutorial it guides you
i played that but like i want to play with people
glad igloo
i played that but like i want to play with people
you need to add people first to play with them i think
spare forge
you need to add people first to play with them i think
u wanna play?
glad igloo
u wanna play?
idk i got tests
spare forge
idk i got tests
aight good luck bro
glad igloo
aight good luck bro
btw you can't play with anyone from other platforms
earnest oasis
Guys me and Charles rescued Trelawny. A few bounty hunters escaped and we shot a...
they probably left
earnest oasis
guys im new to this game how to play rdo?
do the tutorial and missions, the tutorial gives u your own horse while the missions give you gold and dinero
but u need low honor for some missions
and high honor for some missions as well
harsh dome
they probably left
It still says 'Seach the cornfield'
glad igloo
and high honor for some missions as well
im kinda new, high honor or low honor is better?
spare forge
do the tutorial and missions, the tutorial gives u your own horse while the miss...
i mean i did the tutorial but like i cant find players to play with'
earnest oasis
It still says 'Seach the cornfield'
keep finding i think
earnest oasis
i mean i did the tutorial but like i cant find players to play with'
it’s cuz u did the tutorial
u can rejoin
the tutorial makes it private server sorta
or there’s just nobody near u
spare forge
the tutorial makes it private server sorta
oh
earnest oasis
It still says 'Seach the cornfield'
lemme see ur map rq
granite peakBOT
spare forge
i just finished the tutorial and jumped in RDO
earnest oasis
i just finished the tutorial and jumped in RDO
awesome
earnest oasis
i think u get money left over
it’s because nobody near you
and if ur like super duper upset about it or something like that
u can rejoin
by going to online, then press free roam
and it should put u in the same spot but with people
and if it doesn’t work
it’s because there’s no people near you so u gotta go somewhere populated
like valentine
i think u follow da yellow circle @harsh dome
and if it don’t work u can always restart the mission
harsh dome
i think u follow da yellow circle <@716304424703623198>
No! The yellow circle is where Charles is
thorny cargo
Guys me and Charles rescued Trelawny. A few bounty hunters escaped and we shot a...
they are there. youll see white indicators flash on your map to help you with finding the remaining ones. just approach the area with your gun
run around for a while in all of the sections
and just have patience
dreamy crystal
Panthers are always 3 star? Or do we have to be lucky to get a 3 star panther after each in game 3 days
thorny cargo
Panthers are always 3 star? Or do we have to be lucky to get a 3 star panther af...
panthers are not always 3 star
but frequently are since they rarely spawn
dreamy crystal
panthers are not always 3 star
That's why I was thinking I was doing something wrong, I got 2 one stars in a row. I wasn't able to look what they are before hunting, cause I just use my self as bait to hunt.
thorny cargo
That's why I was thinking I was doing something wrong, I got 2 one stars in a ro...
what gun are you using?
jaunty parrot
Old logo
versed nymph
That's why I was thinking I was doing something wrong, I got 2 one stars in a ro...
If you need a good gun to hunt, I always use springfield rifle. With a headshot it's done in one shot and won't lose stars. I do alway upgrade it but idk if that matters.
midnight spire
Yoo
harsh dome
they are there. youll see white indicators flash on your map to help you with fi...
There are no white indicators flashing on my map
thorny cargo
There are no white indicators flashing on my map
they will flash every like, minute or so. its to help people know where to go if they dont accomplish anything for a few seconds or so
go to the top right field (if youre approaching from where you initially ran into the fields) and run around, youre supposed to trigger a cutscene there if youve killed the other bounty hunters like you were supposed to
harsh dome
go to the top right field (if youre approaching from where you initially ran int...
I am at the top right field. Charles is squatted down. I don't see any remaining bounty hunters
thorny cargo
I am at the top right field. Charles is squatted down. I don't see any remaining...
just run around for a while in all of the fields and make sure you havent missed any bounty hunters, thats all i can tell you. the other option is getting the "mission failed" screen repeatedly until you get the option to skip the checkpoint
harsh dome
just run around for a while in all of the fields and make sure you havent missed...
How do I get the 'mission failed' screen repeatedly?
I triggered a cutscene where a bounty hunter caught Arthur, but Charles freed him
versed nymph
Anyone else obsessed with seeing your horse acting like an actual free wild horse. I love it
pulsar ruin
What's the difference between RDR1 Normal and Hardcore?
haughty summit
What's the difference between RDR1 Normal and Hardcore?
you only ahve 35 helath in hardcores modes
opaque quiver
lowkey the one who made ideas about red dead 1 stranger missions is a peak thinker
median jacinth
Somebody wanna play
versed nymph
Anyone have tips on how to get better at the controls in rdr1, i've been wanting to play but i can't get good w em
pulsar ruin
It's better with a controller, so I'd go get one.
thorny cargo
I triggered a cutscene where a bounty hunter caught Arthur, but Charles freed hi...
that was the cutscene i was talking about
pulsar ruin
How do duels work in RDR1?
floral crypt
I just logged onto my game and started trotting down a path and notice a subtle mark/square/dot on the map (not like a shack or house square, but smaller) and so I go to it, it turns out to be a chimney with gold hidden! cha ching!
pulsar ruin
Ohh
novel plaza
How do duels work in RDR1?
Fill the blue bar up higher than your opponents red bar by precisely marking shots
pulsar ruin
And how do I do that?
static imp
And how do I do that?
aim by using the right stick. aim for the head or the chest. then, mark your shot by pressing r1 after the reticle turns white and small. finally, press r2 to shoot.
pulsar kite
pulsar ruin
So don't just mash r1, got it.
static imp
can you help me with my bug
what bug?
novel plaza
only one slot for some reason
what point in the game are you at
rich lake
Can I even get high honour in chapter 3 yet?
molten talon
this flower mission is so buns in undead nightmare
olive ermine
I'm officially at chapter 5 now. I am NOT HAVING FUN 😊😊
novel plaza
I'm officially at chapter 5 now. I am NOT HAVING FUN 😊😊
Why not
errant yew
Anyone have any places to find an American paint? It's the last horse I need for the horseman 10 challenge
rich lake
Got kidnapped by O'Driscoll's
thorny pewter
Anyone have any places to find an American paint? It's the last horse I need for...
Behind the mountains at the Indian reservation, there is normally a herd of them
errant yew
Behind the mountains at the Indian reservation, there is normally a herd of them
I'll definitely try this, thankss
thorny pewter
Np
molten talon
do I just complete all the missions
yes
epilogue part 2 is very fun
part 1 is kinda like ranch sim tho
red vessel
part 1 is kinda like ranch sim tho
ye seems like it
what’s after the end of the epilogues
the end of the game?
olive ermine
technically, the rdr1 lol
idle charm
the end of the game?
free roam
ionic juniper
I think it's more fun to free roam freely with Arthur
Other than Rachel, I don’t have a special horse for John
red vessel
I think it's more fun to free roam freely with Arthur
Yeah me to glad I saved a file before doing the mission
ionic juniper
but Old Boy is a better horse
idle charm
Who do I play as
john in the epilogue and arthur chapter 1-6
ionic juniper
I'm on Chapter 6. There's a separate save file for John, but I don't really like it. I prefer riding around freely on a horse like Raven Black Shire, or I like it when enemies are constantly setting traps.
harsh dome
Hey guys, which store sells gun oil?
dense raptor
Hey guys, which store sells gun oil?
General and gun
harsh dome
General and gun
Thank you
harsh dome
It's an inconvenience when it reaches night, I have to ride somewhere in the field to sleep until next morning
idle charm
yall where do you think is the most prettiest place on the map? like somewhere where you can just relax or take photos and shit
idle charm
It's an inconvenience when it reaches night, I have to ride somewhere in the fie...
just use the camp feature or use lanterns
harsh dome
just use the camp feature or use lanterns
What 'camp feature'? I could use lantern but it's still difficult to play at night
idle charm
What 'camp feature'? I could use lantern but it's still difficult to play at nig...
hold tab, then press E or R (i forgot which but one of them) then look at the bottom, there should be a campfire icon... hosea teaches you to camp in the first mission with him did you not pay attention
harsh dome
hold tab, then press E or R (i forgot which but one of them) then look at the bo...
Oh that campfire! I know and use it. I'm afraid I don't remember
idle charm
fr no worries. as far as ik those 2 are the only ways to play at night. and towns arent too far either, buy a room there or gallop to the camp and sleep
mental edge
yall where do you think is the most prettiest place on the map? like somewhere w...
big valley and the surrounding areas
idle charm
big valley and the surrounding areas
which part? like the hanging dog ranch?
mental edge
which part? like the hanging dog ranch?
personally enjoy the lupine fields and black bone forest
idle charm
personally enjoy the lupine fields and black bone forest
where tf is black bone forest never heard of it
gloomy cipher
I recently booted rdr2 and my game is running at the usual 90fps average but feels like its at 20 fps its weird, and this happened randomly i play the game every day and no issues anyone have a fix or having this issue? I've tried the usual of re installing, checking the game files but still same, is the newest nvidia update bugged or what ? would appreciate any help!
mental edge
where tf is black bone forest never heard of it
oh idk if i can send media here but it’s the area above/north of owanjila
earnest oasis
what point in the game are you at
2
trim axle
i feel pretty dumb but i dont understand the ''sharpshooter 2'' challenge ''0 of 2 animal species Dead Eye kills'' i killed animals with deadeye.. nothing works. i dont get what I'm doing wrong
errant yew
Me neither lol
harsh dome
I completed the rob bank mission with Bill, Karen and Lenny and I received a share of $2,750. I am so happy! Is this the only mission where you get a large amount of money?
earnest oasis
I completed the rob bank mission with Bill, Karen and Lenny and I received a sha...
i think there’s more
I THINK
but not quite sure
errant yew
I completed the rob bank mission with Bill, Karen and Lenny and I received a sha...
yeah, you can get alot more from doing the cigarrette cards side missions tho
dense raptor
Taking a short walk in a quiet town rn 😭🙏🙏🙏
brave hedge
If I kill a Shop Keeper, is the Shop forever Closed, Will He Be Revived somehow or is someone else gonna work at the Shop?
hidden moss
If I kill a Shop Keeper, is the Shop forever Closed, Will He Be Revived somehow ...
He respawns after a while
hidden moss
But i don't have Xbox so that info is useless
For anyone that does play on xbox
latent lantern
Hi guys
I wanna know if there is any mod that can remove all npcs in the world
if there is, please ping me. Thank you :)
wary oasis
Anyone know how to view photos just taken with the handheld camera? None taken show up in the social club...
Nor via "G"
delicate sparrow
it should be in social club
wary oasis
Taken about 10 selfies, went to social club > photos but none appear apart from some ancient ones I accidentally took...
Filter = All
This is weird, when I look at the amount of photos in the photo screen 12/200 it goes to 13 then immediately back down to 12 again...
hidden moss
how long is the rdr2 online tutorial
I wanna start playing with others already its taking forever
wary oasis
So this appears to be an issue with selfies only, shots taken normally show straight up
verbal prairie
@wary oasis pretty sure you have to go into social club on the device you took the pictures on
if you upload them from there, you can then view on all platforms
blissful sandal
Sometimes selfies won’t show up at all, it’s weird
You do need to upload them to social club to do anything with them at all
verbal prairie
where are you trying to view them from
blissful sandal
Yeah this started being a huge issue after the naturalist update
Since social club photos became used more
wary oasis
With the camera > take selfie > Show Photos (G) > which launches social club
wary oasis
Yeah this started being a huge issue after the naturalist update
Annoying, wanting Arthur to pose lol
hallow wave
thats the way it is is the most emotional part of the game for me
shell thicket
rockstar wants to be so special making us all use social club for photos
verbal prairie
well tbf
social club makes it global so you can access it everywhere
whic might not be useful for pc players
but it is for us console playees
man I can't type today
brave hedge
How can I have 2 Different Save Files with both on Auto Save?
wind vortex
How can I have 2 Different Save Files with both on Auto Save?
İdk
delicate sparrow
How can I have 2 Different Save Files with both on Auto Save?
just make two different save files with both on autosave, whichever save is loaded is the one that'll autosave
brave hedge
no, she doesnt
hidden moss
alright thanks
verbal prairie
only the ones you kill give you a gun
worldly oriole
is it normal that everytime you play you use cheats now
brave hedge
What's the Best Saddle?
fringe pawn
what is the key to ride the horse?
crimson bronze
Best Saddle in Singleplayer?
brave hedge
obviously
crimson bronze
I've heard people say the Panther Trail Saddle is the best.
brave hedge
Whatever I'll just Buy a Good Looking Saddle with My Cheated Money and Put Infinite Stam and Invincibility on my Horse
devout niche
Anybody know if they patched the glitch in the Arcadia for beginners quest that let's you capture a fox trotter?
crimson bronze
Although there are other saddles at the trapper with good stats, really just depends on what you think looks best.
main root
ok
honest drum
with arthur u have to make them
honest drum
can you play the epilogue forever?
yes
brave hedge
I've made a New Game, but for some Reason I can't save it, why's that and how do i save it?
honest drum
u can't save in missions
brave hedge
Im not
When i turn Autosave on it says's "Do you want to overwrite ..... with your Current Game Progress" and If I press no, Autosave turns off
main root
why say no
fringe pawn
just overwrite
vague zinc
Lenny for president
brave hedge
All Micah's Fault
vague zinc
Yes fuck Micah
vague zinc
All my homies hate Micah
delicate sparrow
Best Saddle in Singleplayer?
beaver roping
it has the best stats
everyone who actually studies stats should agree on that
easy to get too
all you need is one perfect beaver skin
crimson bronze
This is true, Admittedly, I forgot about that one.
hidden moss
whats the key to see the time
sacred solstice
there is none
you just need a pocket watch
go in your satchel, equip it and in the select it in the inventory menu
hidden moss
ok thanks
versed pier
@hidden moss On the PC you can press Alt twice and you will see time and temp
hidden moss
thx
delicate sparrow
whats the key to see the time
PC? Left alt
hidden moss
👍
delicate sparrow
👍
hidden moss
shows money and "honor" but not the time
shell thicket
if you press alt + f4 it gives you more info
shell thicket
really? they must have changed it, that sounds amazing
wary oasis
really? they must have changed it, that sounds amazing
Give it a shot
shell thicket
will do
native dew
Do you have to skin ALL animals in game for that trophy?
spark shard
Why couldnt arthur just straight up kill micah in camp
hidden moss
if you press alt + f4 it gives you more info
yea sure
lucid lake
the ring dang doo, now what is that!? 🎵
lean sparrow
Can anyone recommend something to do in the game im burned out of the game
sinful hound
the ring dang doo, now what is that!? 🎵
Soft and round like a *****cat
verbal prairie
Can anyone recommend something to do in the game im burned out of the game
find a new game
prime jewel
YO
inner raptor
What the fuck is up with this random guy.
Oh he wants me to take him to the place I shot up.
lucid lake
I hate/love how after big shootouts in missions you only get so much time to loot the bodies before the boys show up
and I just watched them show up, and each one of them picked up a body put it on their horse and left
it was spooky
muted jetty
oh god the search for the white arabian is difficult as shit
it's a white colored horse
in snow
main root
where can i pay off my bounty in saint denis
prime estuary
no
spark shard
A carbine is a repeater
prime estuary
they are repeaters
spark shard
I just said that maroder us tupede
prime estuary
what
muted jetty
so when i hunt
since i don't have a rifle
if i used a repeater, it will harm the pelt?
prime estuary
it would yeah if it says use a rifle
muted jetty
also
are there any quest pre-reqs for the white arabian? i heard some people say you have to do the quest with hosea first but i'm not sure if that's true
prime estuary
I Dont think so
wary oasis
No just go to the location and wait, it should spawn most times.
inner raptor
Did you find the area it was in?
last sierra
Is the white Arabian better than the black Arabian
prime jewel
@honest drum why is he muted?
inner raptor
No.
muted jetty
@inner raptor i'm in the area, just can't find it
i haven't even spotted it to chase it
last sierra
but the best arabian is rose grey
Can you get the rose grey one in story mode
I assume you can
inner raptor
Huh.
inner raptor
It's probably hiding somewhere.
prime jewel
it's in blackwater so thats why
muted jetty
i don't even know if its' here
i mean
iit should be
but i can't really distinguish between white and white
no trail either
i'll just come back after teh hosea quest to see if that does it
since i don't think legendaries really spawn until after that quest
main root
where can i pay off my bounty in saint denis and what is the best horse in the game
last sierra
where can i pay off my bounty in saint denis and what is the best horse in the g...
At the post office, the Arabian horse
prime jewel
where can i pay off my bounty in saint denis and what is the best horse in the g...
there is not a "Best Horse"
main root
well a horse with the best stats
prime jewel
every horse has their bad and good things
last sierra
Probably the Arabian is the most balanced
prime jewel
the best horse is the horse you love
lucid lake
dude takes some SPILLS and just gets right back up
muted jetty
there's probably best horses for certain aspects
prime jewel
for example, if u love a suffolk punch, that's the best horse
shy mural
does anyone know how you quick draw or flourish (tricks, spinning etc) your revolver on PC controls?
civic helm
I was bringing Edith Downes back to Annesburg on my horse and on the first time I crashed into a tree and I had to retry the checkpoint because I “Attacked Edith Downes” and on the second time, I crashed into a rock
verbal prairie
hunting the white Arabian wasn't so hard for me
just took a bit of dead eye or whatever it's called without a weapon
inner raptor
Eagle eye.
verbal prairie
yeah that
last sierra
does anyone know how you quick draw or flourish (tricks, spinning etc) your revo...
Double press the holster button to do the spinny thing
shy mural
Double press the holster button to do the spinny thing
yeah, figured it out -- but for me I have to hold the first holster for a second before tapping again
upper fox
Guys I have a question. At what point in the story did Micah become the rat/the pinkerton errand boy/ I've seen video's that said after they came back from Guarma, but when Micah escaped from the jail in strawberry and had his own camp and you go back you can find that Micah had Dutch his wanted poster so what do you guys think of it?
calm anvil
micah was the first one back at the lakaye camp even before arthur and he tried blaming bill for the pinkertons showing up
verbal prairie
strawberry is when Micah truly turns into Heisenberg
calm anvil
i think micah ratting out the group is most likely to have happened after returning from guarma
but he was already causing their downfall way before that
not intentionally just through being incompetent
upper fox
yeah thats what milton said, but im wondering why after strawberry jail escape micah had dutch his bounty poster
that makes me think micah was a errand boy for the goverment just like how john was in rdr1
calm anvil
john didn't actively try to kill lawmen while being their errand boy
micah gunned down half of strawberry and killed a ton of lawmen in rhodes and saint denis
hidden moss
I think abigail ratted about saint denis
upper fox
yeah, but i dont think the pinkertons would've cared about that, because the pinkertons are a private national agency
they probaly didnt care about other law men
upper fox
I think abigail ratted about saint denis
100%
hidden moss
Why would they have arrested john who was shooting and killing lawman while he was with the gang but kill hosea and lenny who were unarmed at the time?
calm anvil
molly didn't tell the pinkertons about st denis and they say they only picked up micah after guarma so it's really just guesswork for what happened in denis
hidden moss
Why would they have arrested john who was shooting and killing lawman while he w...
And how did abigail get away when hosea got taken?
calm anvil
i think micah was working on betraying the gang from right after blackwater but he wasn't an informant until after guarma
he was planning on turning in dutch to get clemency for himself
and probably go back for the blackwater money on his own
upper fox
i think molly got so drunk and said she ratted while she didnt, but yet we dont know who was the rat about the st denis heist
but i think its possible molly and micah ratted
calm anvil
i think the most likely scenario is just that molly told them the gang was in st denis but didn't mention the heist
upper fox
yeah probaly and the pinkertons just guessed they were going to rob the bank
calm anvil
and hosea got picked up by a pinkerton patrol during the heist
upper fox
because what else is there to rob except the troley station
upper fox
and hosea got picked up by a pinkerton patrol during the heist
probally
calm anvil
if arthur had any foresight he would've just shot micah during their stagecoach robbery in the river
upper fox
arthur just could;ve said he died during the robbery and just walked off
devout niche
Does anybody know, on pc, using the Arcadia glitch to get the fox trotter - once you track and catch up to the fox trotter how do you mount /jump on to it?
upper fox
and the gang probally would've continued a few more years
calm anvil
honestly i disliked bill more than micah
i just thought micah was kind of cool
he was a dickhead but i still thought he was a cool character
upper fox
Bill is a idiot, micah his voice actor did a really good job
upper fox
abigail did it because she wanted a normal life
calm anvil
she just makes it out completely unharmed and dutch is right for being suspicious about how john was taken alive while lenny got gunned down
so yeah thinking about it now
i say micah was planning on betraying dutch ever since blackwater
only helped pinkertons since after guarma
abigail was the rat during the st denis heist
upper fox
abigail had a secret releationship with the pinkertons thats how she escaped unharmed
once a whore always a whore
i guess right
inner raptor
Seriously, how do I get this gun at Fort Brennand?
delicate sparrow
abigail was the rat during the st denis heist
really?
upper fox
r/youmissedthejoke
spark shard
row an oak rige
inner raptor
How do I get small game arrows?
upper fox
if you look down and press and hold e you get a craft menu
vague zinc
Lenny
upper fox
somewhere between ammunition there is a recipe for small game arrows
inner raptor
Can you put that in uhh...
upper fox
You cany buy small game arrows you need to craft them
inner raptor
Xbox terms?
upper fox
just look down and game at the bottem says it for you
or just setup a camp and you can do it also
it igves you the same craftting menu
inner raptor
Bah, I need flight feathers. Where are birds at?
upper fox
any bird gives flight feathers or ducks yeah
upper fox
just shoot a couple in the air and use deadeye
inner raptor
Think it'll be easier.
upper fox
ehhh
idk
in a video i just searched up somewhere around limpany
at the river side
are you doing the pearson camp upgrades?
@inner raptor
inner raptor
Yeah.
upper fox
Cool, i recommend doing all the satchels
the last one you unlock is super good
it gives you a lot of storage
almost every item 99 max
upper fox
Lemme give you a tip, just search up any animal and then perfect pelt, you will find a video that says which weapon is the best to use, a lot of animals you can kill with a varmint rifle. It spares you a lot of time, because small game arrows are expensive af
upper fox
pretty sure you can get perfect rabbit pelt with varmint rifle
delicate sparrow
yes
upper fox
i struggled a lot killing rabbits with small tip arrows
delicate sparrow
you can get perfect rabbit with varmint
however you can't get perfect squirrels with varmint though
upper fox
for squirrels you will need small tip arrows
delicate sparrow
yeah
upper fox
i've wasted too much small tip arrows trying to kill a rabbit
upper fox
i tried it with dead eye doesnt work you will just ruin the pelt it will go from 3 star to 1 star
i've learned a lot about hunting in rdr2 doing all the camp upgrades for pearson
i did all the camp upgrades and i still need to do all the hunting requests for 100% completion
@inner raptor good luck later trying to get a moose antler, because a western bull moose are harder to find then any legendary animal. I've spent 15+ hours just to get one...
inner raptor
So you need to get "It's Art" to get Best in the West?
inner raptor
The achievement.
upper fox
hunting requests are required for 100% completion, yes
inner raptor
So you need to get the squirrel statue?
upper fox
i think so, thats statue at beacher's hope right at house?
inner raptor
Yeah.
upper fox
probally
spiral cliff
I just started the single player what should I be putting money towards
upper fox
upgraded gun belt, volcanic pistol and maybe a personal created outfit for arthur
spiral cliff
Aye
hidden moss
And save the black horse that you got from Hosea, that is actually a one of a kind horse
Ok
Is it possible to break into fort wallace in the free roam
paper peak
upgraded gun belt, volcanic pistol and maybe a personal created outfit for arthu...
Not gonna lie the volcanic is probably my least favorite gun in the game, I'm loyal to the revolvers, particularly the Cattleman
But that's just me, Schofield is also great
hidden moss
sand apex
i personally main double wielded schofield
i mean the schofield is decent at most things
robust cosmos
I’m so sick of being told I’m cold when I’m wearing winter clothes
hidden moss
"You'll catch a chill wearing that arthur!"
verbal prairie
so sick of being told I'm hot when I'm wearing winter clothes
lemme look stylish in piece
robust cosmos
How have they not patched it out
paper peak
I don't remember getting the weird weather lines until my most recent playthrough, now I'll be using Summer Gunslinger in the middle of the day and get "aren't you cold in that Arturd?"
spark shard
"You'll catch a chill wearing that arthur!"
My gang even though it's 80°F:
tidal relic
I accidentally punched a guy and now for some reason I can't do certain missions, even though I don't have a bounty. Did I do something wrong?
hidden moss
I accidentally punched a guy and now for some reason I can't do certain missions...
It just says that: You cannot join this misssion because of your recent actions pls join later
You can see them running too
I killed someone in Rdr2 and i saw Dutch running
tidal relic
Oh, kk
hidden moss
killed everyone in van horn for fun
worldly oriole
killed everyone in van horn for fun
even the duels?
robust cosmos
Yeah I couldn’t collect one of Strauss’ debts off a guy because of that, he kept running away whenever I got close. Give it some time, maybe leave the state and come back
lucid lake
a gosh dang muskrat just bit me for no reason i was mindin my own business
am i gonna get sick
red helm
Ha, funny when they do that. No, Muskrat's are not poisonous, or diseased.
robust cosmos
Ask that guy to suck it out of your leg just in case
tidal relic
Am I remembering right? I heard that you can watch your bounties' executions.
grizzled sapphire
I was just watchin Arthur and Hamish hunting the boar on YouTube. Arthur says: "I'm afraid I lost sight of him". YouTube subtitles: "I'm afraid of sodom"
😂
hidden moss
Killed everyone in Armadillo for fun
Plague doctors when see infected individual
Bruh
hidden moss
Plague doctors when see infected individual
I didnt know they played rdr2 back then
prime jewel
Killed everyone in Armadillo for fun
yes
there is a guy who burns all plagued people
hidden moss
I think we will see how the gang is formed in the 3rd game
prime jewel
i hope
but we won't control arthur,
we'll control another one in the gang, and when he reaches his redemption, we'll control arthur
elfin musk
but we won't control arthur,
what if we control hosea
prime jewel
maybe
hidden moss
What if we control Dutch
If that happens I kill myself
sacred mirage
Okay please tell me I'm not screwed here... I got the Chick's Treasure Map but I didn't go get the treasure right away. People are now saying that the guy took the treasure himself. Does this mean there's no way to get it? I've already played hours after that mission. I'm trying to get 100%. If this screws my completionist playthrough, I'm probably gonna rage quit. Please tell me I can still find the guy and take the treasure or that it won't affect my 100%
thorn plinth
If I stow a legendary fish on my horse and use the wilderness camp to fast travel, will it remove the fish?
brave hedge
My 15% Save File got Deleted, anyway to get it back?
hidden moss
My 15% Save File got Deleted, anyway to get it back?
once a save file is completely deleted im pretty sure you cannot recover it, sorry.
warm kelp
Hi! What is the consequence of having empty stamina core?
spice rain
Death
honest drum
Hi! What is the consequence of having empty stamina core?
Why don’t you just eat lol
brave hedge
I empty my stramina core but I don't die
You don't but you walk Slower and Stamina takes longer to Regenerate
warm kelp
So the only utility of Stamina is running?
brave hedge
And Swimming
worldly oriole
eh
brave hedge
obviously
verbal prairie
oh wtf
I used to calm my horse 24/7 on horseback
to up my bonding
never noticed a stamina decrease
spice rain
I think he means when you're breaking the horse
grizzled sapphire
So the only utility of Stamina is running?
Pretty sure your aim is alot harder to stabilize too
hidden moss
also when you lasso an animal you need stamina
honest drum
Yes
Deffo
I feel really bad for Dutch
Especially in rdr1
He finally saw what he couldn’t
And he lives with the fact he let his son die
rose bison
Sort of odd to think about how John tried to turn him in even tho he basically saved his life
ionic apex
Okay please tell me I'm not screwed here... I got the Chick's Treasure Map but I...
did my man chick take the treasure?
delicate sparrow
So the only utility of Stamina is running?
running, swimming, climbing, jumping
sacred mirage
It doesn’t effect 100%
Thank god haha
honest drum
Sort of odd to think about how John tried to turn him in even tho he basically s...
He had too...
Do you not know the plot of rdr1 lmao
sacred mirage
did my man chick take the treasure?
Yes, he did. Should've killed that weasel
brave hedge
I took a Bath and now I have the Alligator Garment Set for Free for some Reason lol
calm anvil
what's your guys' favourite soundtrack from the game
i really like angelo bronte's theme and fleeting joy
brave hedge
That one Soundtrack when Arthur Takes his Last Ride
vague zinc
My favourite soundtrack is red dead redemption 2 house building sound track
honest drum
what's your guys' favourite soundtrack from the game
deadmans gun or red dead redemption theme
rose bison
He had too...
I know but still it would’ve been better if Dutch had remained the bad guy.
honest drum
ngl i love rdr1 soundtrack a lot more
rose bison
Now I get all sad when I think of rdr 1
honest drum
I know but still it would’ve been better if Dutch had remained the bad guy.
nah he never was the bad guy
honest drum
it's a strange one
calm anvil
i forgot that red dead came out after gta 4
rose bison
But he still let Arthur die, he left John twice and Lenny
honest drum
he was losing everything he worked so hard for and loved
muted jetty
dutch was an ideologically driven man who found himself played more times than he can count in the later part of his life
honest drum
But he still let Arthur die, he left John twice and Lenny
what about lenny?
dutch couldn't cope with the fact that the world was changing
muted jetty
his story is the story of the death of the freedom his ideology brought
calm anvil
dutch definitely wasn't a good guy
honest drum
he'd worked so hard to build a family and it was being taken away from him
calm anvil
he had all the chances to actually take the gang to safety during chapters 2-5
but he kept asking for one more score
calm anvil
they really didn't need one after the valentine bank
and after selling the cornwall bonds
muted jetty
the amount the gang functionally got from the valentine bank was significantly less than what the player got
calm anvil
dutch was vengeful and had no foresight
honest drum
they wouldn't of lasted long
calm anvil
no reason to have gone after bronte and cornwall
brave hedge
I hope RDR3 (If it comes out) We will play Jack Marston
honest drum
no reason to have gone after bronte and cornwall
ye he starts to lose his mind a bit
honest drum
I hope RDR3 (If it comes out) We will play Jack Marston
why tf does everyone say this
muted jetty
@brave hedge no
honest drum
we need a NEW story
muted jetty
dutch and how he got his feud with colm
calm anvil
if red dead 3 was about jack marston it'd take place during the prohibition era
honest drum
any more VDL gang and it'll come repetetive and boring
calm anvil
it'd really just be rockstar making a mafia game
honest drum
dutch and how he got his feud with colm
ah yes an entire game right here ppl...
we already know what happens
dutch killed colms brother and colm killed dutch's lover
calm anvil
you can literally say the same thing about red dead redemption
muted jetty
??? we already knew what happened at the end of red dead 2 back when red dead 1 happened
honest drum
60-70 hour story
calm anvil
we already knew what happened to the gang
muted jetty
because they kinda
calm anvil
but red dead 2 was still incredible
honest drum
we already knew what happened to the gang
exactly
muted jetty
and they pulled what
honest drum
??? we already knew what happened at the end of red dead 2 back when red dead 1 ...
no.. we didn't
muted jetty
a 100 hour story out of it
muted jetty
@honest drum we knew enough to expect
calm anvil
if red dead 3 is actually happening i'd just want a new story
honest drum
if they made a prequel to the prequel we know both
calm anvil
if it had to be about characters we already know
muted jetty
arthur wasn't mentioned at ALL during the first game
calm anvil
i'd rather a game about the gang being formed
muted jetty
so it doesn't take much deduction
honest drum
i'd rather a game about the gang being formed
even that would be shit
imo
we again, know exactly what happens
stuff like this is DLC material
not full game
honest drum
arthur wasn't mentioned at ALL during the first game
exactly lmao
calm anvil
you could absolutely make a game around that
honest drum
we didn't have a clue how the gang ended
calm anvil
there's 20 years of lore you can build around to make a third game about the gang
honest drum
you could absolutely make a game around that
how?
muted jetty
@honest drum what
calm anvil
doesn't have to be something they even mentioned
honest drum
explain what redemption and twists could be
muted jetty
arthur wasn't mentioned because arthur was DEAD
that's why we knew he would DIE
it's the shtick of red dead
main character dies
honest drum
that's why we knew he would DIE
your literally proving my point
rdr2 worked because we had no idea how the gang ended
brave hedge
arthur wasn't mentioned at ALL during the first game
because they probably didn't come up with the Character "Arthur Morgan" back than, they maybe never thought about making this exact character
verbal prairie
play as micah 👀
honest drum
play as micah 👀
again.. dlc material
verbal prairie
what do you suggest lol
muted jetty
@brave hedge still, rockstar knew that he'd have to die if they were going to introduce him
honest drum
references to the gang
verbal prairie
it would seem really weird to break away from this story, it might work but you get the idea right?
honest drum
<@!529992724754202654> still, rockstar knew that he'd have to die if they were g...
u rlly don't understand do you
muted jetty
I don't think you understand, to be frank
honest drum
no u don't understand me, i understand you perfectly fine
your trying to say rdr2 worked so why wouldn't rdr3
calm anvil
there's absolutely enough there to make a third game about the gang
honest drum
and im saying
we already KNOW how the gang was started
and what happened
we didnt KNOW how the gang ended
from rdr1
verbal prairie
he's got a point tbf
I'm sure it would be a fun game but you gotta think how much material they have to work with
brave hedge
we didnt KNOW how the gang ended
If you look at RDR2 and RDR1, either they went to Another Place (Like Saide to South America I'm pretty sure) or they died
honest drum
there's absolutely enough there to make a third game about the gang
yes robbing banks for 60 hours wow how such fun
verbal prairie
well
muted jetty
@honest drum sounds fun
verbal prairie
in all fairness
honest drum
where's the story
muted jetty
who doesn't like robbing banks
muted jetty
@honest drum and we know there's no dlc coming
honest drum
but in no way is there enough material for an entire game
muted jetty
so the only hope is a game
verbal prairie
when I started playing rdr2 I really hoped to be able to plan heists myself and pick members of the crew to come
verbal prairie
make it high risk so you have to put in a fair share of money
honest drum
so the only hope is a game
and im saying it wouldn't work
verbal prairie
and you lose it and get a bounty if you fail
would be possible with Dutch as a main character
honest drum
when I started playing rdr2 I really hoped to be able to plan heists myself and ...
this'd suit RDO more tbf
verbal prairie
yeah true but then again I've never liked rdo or gtao
honest drum
that would be sick tho
honest drum
yeah true but then again I've never liked rdo or gtao
same
brave hedge
would be possible with Dutch as a main character
Fuck Dutch, Fat Pearson is better
verbal prairie
lol
muted jetty
pearson game
honest drum
but honestly i'd love to plan a bank heist with my mates
verbal prairie
Pearson planning a huge bank heist
muted jetty
60 hours of cooking
spice rain
To be fair red dead is more of a story based game, random heists would probably feel awkward
verbal prairie
don't forget the leatherworking
brave hedge
60 Hour Game Material of Selling and Cooking
verbal prairie
To be fair red dead is more of a story based game, random heists would probably ...
could be post game in another game where it fits the story
such as a prequel
honest drum
forget five finger fillet, make arthurs satche;
spice rain
60 hours of cooking
I still to this day love Cooking Mama
sinful hound
Hunting for crayfish and running away from gators
muted jetty
cooking pearson
calm anvil
forget red dead redemption 3
muted jetty
the entire soundtrack is the build theme
honest drum
Hunting for crayfish and running away from gators
i never got this side quest
calm anvil
red dead revolver 2 🥶
honest drum
in 10+ playthroughs
sinful hound
i never got this side quest
You missed out lmfao that fat walrus runs pretty good
honest drum
red dead revolver 2 🥶
red dead new game 🥶
honest drum
with the other walrus's
spice rain
My wish is for them to leave it alone and make a gta 6 because I honestly want to just shoot the shit out of things
honest drum
With the other WALRUSES
this is one of my fav antagonise lines haha
honest drum
My wish is for them to leave it alone and make a gta 6 because I honestly want t...
ye gta 6 will be next
sinful hound
this is one of my fav antagonise lines haha
Top 5 definitely
honest drum
and it better be good
sinful hound
I like you mister you have a kiiind face
spice rain
I hope to god it's set on the 70s
verbal prairie
well this is rdr server
sinful hound
The kind I like to PUNCH
honest drum
im expecting a 2024/2025 release for gta 6
spice rain
They'd be able to be offensive as fuck and have 'the era' to fall back on
verbal prairie
it sucks they take so long to make the games lol but we gotta appreciate it
verbal prairie
obviously the development time calls for pure quality
honest drum
they poured basically everything in to it
calm anvil
they worked on red dead 2 and gta 5 at the same time
sinful hound
The kind I like to PUNCH
honest drum
they worked on red dead 2 and gta 5 at the same time
no gta 5 was the prioriry
my guess is that 2016 started semi-production for gta 6
calm anvil
yeah and i wouldn't be surprised if gta 6 has already been in development since around 2015
honest drum
and just after rdr2 released is when they went full production
calm anvil
and since rdr2's been out for 3 years they've shifted their focus primarily to gta 6
honest drum
yeah and i wouldn't be surprised if gta 6 has already been in development since ...
thats not how they work
sinful hound
The kind I like to punchh
honest drum
they'll be working on it
muted jetty
@calm anvil red dead 2's development time was 2013-2018, gta was RELEASED in 2013
honest drum
but at like hald if not less efficency
calm anvil
red dead 2 was already being planned during red dead redemption's development
honest drum
<@!155298189199671296> red dead 2's development time was 2013-2018, gta was RELE...
nah rdr2 dev started 2010
they've said that
not full production
but it was in the works
sinful hound
The kind I like to PUNCH
calm anvil
you think they'd ever return to la noire or max payne?
instead of just cycling between red dead and gta
verbal prairie
I mean r* aren't really afraid to take risks
honest drum
ngl i'd love a new IP
verbal prairie
deviate from the regular
calm anvil
i feel like max payne has a lot of potential if they turned it into it's own open world game but it'd be a bit too similar to gta at that point
honest drum
i feel like max payne has a lot of potential if they turned it into it's own ope...
ye it'd be gta 2.0 with some diff combat
i'd like a L.A Noire 2
imagine a pirate game tho
open world
calm anvil
in terms of open world games being compared to one another
i always felt like red dead was closer to assassins creed than gta
drifting star
imagine a pirate game tho
Now that would be pretty cool
verbal prairie
i always felt like red dead was closer to assassins creed than gta
in the sense you 'unlock' new parts of the map as the story progresses?
well in a sense your gang kinda discovers the places
as opposed to having access to it all
calm anvil
just the general style of the games feels similar
time period definitely adds to it
with gta being set in modern day
rigid nacelle
alright boahs
i'm starting my second playthrough
i'm gonna have good honor all the way through
drifting star
Started my second yesterday I’m going for low honor
rigid nacelle
sounds fun
the fun part is when you are replaying a game or rewatching a TV show or movie is that you notice things and small but special details you wouldn't have noticed in the first time
drifting star
I’m gonna 100% complete my first play through before I properly get into it
Yeahhhh I love when that happens
rigid nacelle
but chapter 2 is soo lengthy
drifting star
Chapter 3 is longest I think
rigid nacelle
i thought chapter 2 was
drifting star
Chapter 6 has most missions
rigid nacelle
i HATED chapter 1, they really did a good job making you feel like you were stuck in the snow
drifting star
Saaaame even when I replayed it yesterday I felt trapped all over again
rigid nacelle
like i hated playing chapter 1 but they really did a good job in making it feel immersive
drifting star
Yeah
brave hedge
Chapter 1 is pretty SHort cuz it's more like a Tutorial
rigid nacelle
^
sinful hound
Guarma was the 2nd shortest chapter imo
calm anvil
guarma was my least favourite chapter
brave hedge
Guarma is best
brave hedge
Epilogue 1 is boring aswell as Chapter 1
drifting star
I liked Guarma tbh
calm anvil
chapter 4 was my favourite in terms of how fun the missions were but chapter 3 was probably the best in terms of the story
drifting star
Chapter 3 was the braithwaite manor one right?
calm anvil
yeah
shell quiver
Epilogue 1 is boring aswell as Chapter 1
Epilogue is good, change my mind
rigid nacelle
ye
rigid nacelle
Epilogue is good, change my mind
it's okay, epilogue 2 is better. but i can never forget arthur's insults
brave hedge
Epilogue is good, change my mind
I hated the Farm
drifting star
The mission where you burn braithwaite in chapter 3 was badass
sinful hound
I hated chapter 6 the most
calm anvil
the gang walking up to the mansion looked pretty cool
shell quiver
I hated the Farm
You get to lIve the life of John as he's building his farm, you also get to get loans
calm anvil
micah was a rat but i still think he was a cool character
drifting star
I hated the start of epilogue 1
rigid nacelle
he's a GREAT but extremely hatable character
he's great in the sense that he's well written
calm anvil
i feel like rockstar intentionally made it so micah stood out as a skilled gunslinger during missions
rigid nacelle
that's because they were setting him up to be arthur's nemesis
calm anvil
he's meant to be comparable to john and arthur in skill but still completely hatable
drifting star
Anyone else leave Micah in jail as long as possible
rigid nacelle
i didn't because i didn't know what i was getting into
drifting star
My mate spoiled it all so I already knew 😞
calm anvil
i feel like inworld deadeye is basically just a representation of someone having insane reactions and skill
and the only 3 people who are capable of it would be john arthur and micah
rigid nacelle
wait micah has deadeye?
calm anvil
dude watch the clip of the shootout in rhodes with the sheriff
rigid nacelle
don't forget jack
calm anvil
the cutscene
rigid nacelle
jack has deadeye at the end of rdr1
calm anvil
and yeah adult jack
brave hedge
I wish you could get Dutches Acctual Scofield
verbal prairie
never understood deadeye actually in terms of realism
what's the explanation for it
calm anvil
insane reaction time and precision
borderline inhuman
rockstar loves using bullet time
dead eye, max payne, michael in gta
verbal prairie
was it always just down to skill lol
calm anvil
but yeah if you watch the cutscene before the rhodes shootout where sean dies
drifting star
i love how the plot of rdr2 is based off a true story
Never knew that
calm anvil
micah headshots like 4 people while arthur is still reacting to sean
brave hedge
Anybody using the Bank Robbery Mod and can Explain how to Properly set it up so it works in game?
drifting star
Is there a theatre in Saint Denis I need to visit one for 100
drifting star
Ok cheers
sinful hound
But tbh the theater is interesting
And dirt cheap too
I always wondered how they fit in the valentine one
calm anvil
i only went to the theatre for mary's missions
sinful hound
It's a cool addition
drifting star
I’m tryna find it rn
drifting star
I never did Mary’s mission
sinful hound
I’m tryna find it rn
Somewhere in the middle near the train station
calm anvil
there's that one strauss debter mission where you have to collect from a guy and his son near rhodes i think
that was like the most depressing thing
drifting star
Somewhere in the middle near the train station
Found it thank you
sinful hound
Found it thank you
No worries
drifting star
No shows rn tho so I’m gonna have to wait u too there is one
rigid nacelle
hol up