red-dead-singleplayer

[buoyant palm]

Hello chat

[agile marsh]

I'm taking my horse for a ride in new Hanover

[thorny cargo]

whats the issue?

[zenith zodiac]

What's the best duel revolvers to use

I'm currently using duel volcanos, they hit hard but shoot slow

[pulsar ruin]

I was thinking the same thing the other day, it's a very otherworldly vibe.

[harsh dome]

I am just after the cinematic where Arthur and Lenny got thrown in jail. What do I do now?

Which button is it to expand my mini map?

[molten talon]

double action i think

[molten talon]

Alt + X to expand

[harsh dome]

What about PS5 controls?

Guys I am dealing with WROBEL. Should I threaten, dismiss or beat?

Guys I just fell down a high surface and my horse has fainted. It says I need a Horse reviver. Horse revivers are sold at General store and I am far out here. Also, I can't ride. What should I do?

[tender hare]

Which is worse
Greeting micah
Or
Antagonizing Charles

[tender hare]

Horses can still live for multiple hours when they need a revive, as long as you keep running and dont sleep it off you can still save horse

You can also break a wild horse and ride towards a nearby city so you return faster and horse is less likely to die

Since its only a temporary horse

[harsh dome]

I have loaded game. I have respawn with the horse alive. I need to remember, one of the things I need to do next, is to go to the General store and buy Horse revivers

[tender hare]

Yea and then go back, also if the horse thing now says saddle that means horse is dead

[harsh dome]

Remind me, where is the General store? I am in the camp where Dutch and the gang are. Are there any shops here that sell Horse Revivers?

[tender hare]

Horseshoe overlook is your current camp?

[harsh dome]

I think so?

[tender hare]

If yes go to the valentine stable located at the upper left corner of the city, it sells horse provisions including revivers

[harsh dome]

I am struggling. Is there an easy way to find Valentine stable and mark as waypoint on the map or something?

[tender hare]

Use the map index and scroll down till you find stable and just use a waypoint, the game prioritizes the closest one , I was saying valentine stable since valentine is the closest city to horseshoe overlook

@harsh dome

[harsh dome]

I used the map but I am not finding stable

[tender hare]

Move to #red-dead-media to be able to see it

[burnt vapor]

Y'all know that lady we help north of ansburg?

If we visit her as John, well...
She dead

[hexed pollen]

Which one

[burnt vapor]

The one who lost her husband
Lived in a cabin
We taught her how to hunt

[hexed pollen]

Ohhh yeah

Ion remember

[burnt vapor]

You a low honor enjoyer ain't ya

[ember ridge]

Not if you visit her 3+ times as Arthur

You have visit her at least three times (i think)

And then she will be alive

[molten talon]

no idea never owned a console in my life

[near tiger]

I assume it's down on the d pad like it is on Xbox

[harsh dome]

What d pad?

Which button is to melee?

[urban quest]

You killed her bro 😭
You didn't do enough missions with her so she can survive on her own

[burnt vapor]

WHAT

I taught her how to hunt

What else was there

[urban quest]

You need to teach her how to shoot properly and maybe smth else

[burnt vapor]

Alr thx I'm just gonna go die in a corner now

Do high honor they said

Best ending it is they said

[urban quest]

Best ending for Arthur,
Not so much for poor Charlotte 😭

I think that's her name

[burnt vapor]

It is

Why help folk IF FOLK gonna die anyway

Gotta make sure rdr1 happens ig

[harsh dome]

Hey guys I am in the camp. Is there anywhere in the camp that sells Horse revivers? I rather not travel far just to get Horse revivers

[urban quest]

Check by the wagon that had medical shi, maybe it has horse revivers

[harsh dome]

Which wagon? Which wagon had medical shi?

[urban quest]

The one next to where Strauss usually is

[urban quest]

Has like a + symbol on the map

[harsh dome]

I am at the wagon but there is no Horse revivers

[urban quest]

You can also buy them from stables or doctors,

[harsh dome]

I am in the camp. Are there any stables or doctors in the camp?

[urban quest]

They're in town

[harsh dome]

Guys, what are the controls I need to use when the train is coming to Reverend Swanson? I am the part where Arthur needs to save Reverend Swanson on the traintracks

[urban quest]

I think you push the left stick up and spam A,

[harsh dome]

Thank you!!

[urban quest]

Ofc

[harsh dome]

It says 'Return Reverend Swanson to Horseshoe Overlook'. Horseshoe Overlook is the name of my camp. I have to carry him all the way to my camp??? Did I get it correct?

[urban quest]

Put him on your horse and ride there, sorry for so late a response

[harsh dome]

I didn't realize I could ride with him on my horse. I have arrived

[urban quest]

Did you walk there

[harsh dome]

No I rode on horse

[urban quest]

Ok, I was just making sure bc I took so long to respond

[hollow axle]

Hunter guy in valentine bar, had to rough him up, was ruining the vibe for everyone, took his racoon cap as a trophy. 3 days later im robbing the doctor's shady backroom business and im in a standoff inside the doctor's office with lawmen across the street, who comes barging into the lookin for a rematch and comletely rocks my shit? i give the man props for coming in for a fist fight to reclaim his hat. he almost got me this time

[snow jacinth]

that guy is so annoying he just spawns every time I enter the saloon 💀

and talks nonsense

im like "nope im going to the other saloon in valentine"

[deft otter]

playing singleplay is so sad

its not as enjoyable

[charred vessel]

does anyone know why i’m stuck at 90% on the lending a hand trophy even though i did literally ALL missions…?

[thorny cargo]

did you do them all in the same playthrough

there are a few that you might have missed, they dont pop up if you dont go into where they "spawn"

[charred vessel]

nope, I did a quick search and found out they all have to be done in the same playthrough, haven’t done sadie’s mission on this playthrough

[rapid tinsel]

Singabeena

[novel plaza]

Ngl I prefer single player on both the rdr and gta series

gta online is fun sometimes cus I get to shoot people but it’s too grindy

[warm nimbus]

Dang I've found 2 graves in armadillo for 2 dead macfarlanes in rdr1

[warm nimbus]

Agreed

I mostly play gta sa nowadays I like exploding things

[warm nimbus]

Nvm I found 4

Poor macfarlanes

[novel plaza]

Owen macfarlane died of chronic diarrhea

[deep oasis]

Theres no story in online

[ember ridge]

Yes there is

[deep oasis]

Its not as good tho

[onyx salmon]

Guys

Could somone tell me how on yt or tiktok there are special cutscenes at camp how do i do them

[olive ermine]

i went to that cute hill house, and is there really a gold bar in there? because i saw a video about it before (and im not talking about the one with the statues puzzle)

[hollow axle]

Bro, this guy is the fucking terminator, he has found me FOUR times now to rematch me for the hat back. I wont use weapons on him, fair fight is a fair fight but this fucker is relentless

[empty patio]

Not a gold bar but you'll find a map, you have to start the treasure hunt "Landmarks of Riches" to get the map though, it'll only spawn once the quest is activated

[near tiger]

There's also Red Dead Online but I think Rockstar abandoned it

[hollow axle]

im just so far behind at this point. i know it doesn't matter but ima just wait for gta6 when everyone is at 0 again. and for me personally i get bummed out about rdr2 online, the launch was a little messy and so my friends got out of it so i never really got to enjoy it cuz my friends make the online what it is for me lol

[olive ermine]

ooh thank u :>

[empty patio]

🫶

[near tiger]

I wonder if I put my bandana on before I head into town and commit a crime if someone can identify me

[hollow axle]

this is one of the things that upsets me the most about the game

[near tiger]

Cuz usually when I put my bandana on in town right before I commit a crime I get identified

[empty patio]

The law can, but citizens won't

[hollow axle]

if you're face is literally hidden, you should just pop a "dead or alive" but remain unknown when caught, and if you manage to escape then yeah, you escape all good.

[empty patio]

I've tried committing crimes in Saint Denis and Rhodes but they can always tell it's you, Citizens won't though

[hollow axle]

well it's like, it makes me wanna ask the devs how we're actually supposed to do some of this crap, like perfect example is the Shady business at the doctors in valentine, like the game clearly wants you to get caught doing that.

[sage matrix]

The lawmen have studied your every move so they instantly know omit was you of course

[empty patio]

Yeah

[empty patio]

Stealth

[hollow axle]

but how? you walk in and you immediately have to kill like 5 of them and it alerts the entire town

[near tiger]

Yeah interesting how they made the wanted system overall in RDR2

[empty patio]

You can stealthily commit crimes, but it can be hard in Saint Denis since law is everywhere

[sage matrix]

Dead eye throwing knife perhaps?

[hollow axle]

like, the only way to not get caught doing that robbery is literally to sweat your ass off and kill everyone before they can actually see your face, mask or not, it's insane, and it doesn't feel intended at all

[empty patio]

You're talking about robbing the gunsmith, correct?

[near tiger]

I mean hey if you want a low honor playthrough then by all means kill them all

[hollow axle]

but again, it's scripted that 3 lawmen come into the docotors office once you kill odriscles, and theres 3 lawmen on the balcony across the street. it's near impossible for them not to see your face, but at any rate, the mask should work either way

[hollow axle]

doctor in valentine

honestly , it's very interesting, i would look it up, because i truly think the devs want you to get caught doing that

[empty patio]

If you don't shoot him and just hold your gun at him, he will run out, then quickly rob the register and leave

[hollow axle]

So in valentine doctors office/store, there's a shady odriscle business in the back. Very similar to the other "bonus" robberies that take place within varies shops in the game. (Gunsmiths in rhodes and saint dennis for example) , well during the specific bonus robbery at the doctor in valentine, directly next door to the sheriff's station, there is a backroom shady odriscle business going on, there's no way to stealth this. as soon as you walk into the back room you are face to face with 5 odricles, you must kill them with dead eye.

Honestly like i said, it's kinda interesting and really makes me wonder how the devs wnated you to do this, because there's also a safe you can only open with dynamite

[empty patio]

Ah I never attempted to do that robbery actually, I have the quest for it but never started it, I should do it to see if I can find a way to stealthily kill them 🤔

[hollow axle]

cuz i looked up a video how to do it, and you have to time it perfectly and get really lucky with how the AI moves around. often times they'll just immediately go in the back room and see you no matter what.

But it is possible to kill all of them without them actually looking at you, but like i said, you have to wait for them to turn around completely in most cases, get those pixel-peak shots through windows at the guys across the street, this clearly isn't how rockstar wanted you to do this

it miiiiiiight be, or was supposed to be the tutorial "bonus" robbery, and getting caught is just a part of it. i do discover things all the time that feel extremely introductionary but i have missed for years.

[empty patio]

If there is no way to get away from the law when doing this robbery, then it is scripted, yes, and might also count for the Bandit Challenge as well

[hollow axle]

sorry to hot mic lol, just kinda nice to talk about it with people who actually know the game, my friends are like "idk dude it's been like 10 years, but cool tho" lol

[empty patio]

Yeah I've had this game since release date but I'm not 100% expert on it tbh LOL

Some things I've missed so when I hear someone explaining it I'm just like I'm sorry idk how to help but good luck? 😭

[hollow axle]

no for real, how could you be lol they put so much in the game, i wonder all the time how they managed to do all this and make the game look amazing as it did, i never saw snow physics that good before i remember on opening night being blown away lol.

im pretty resourceful too , lucky thing about a game this old is that there is more than likely a video or reddit post about what you're having an issue with. and often times it's finding out you're tryna do something youre not supposed to do yet lol

[empty patio]

Yeah, I try my best to be helpful though, unfortunately for PC or PS I'm not really good at figuring out how to tell someone which controls to use as I'm an Xbox player only but I do try to help people with things I've done

[snow jacinth]

fr took like 60 hits to pass out

[near tiger]

Can't you just kill him bro?

Or does he respawn when you come back after?

[snow jacinth]

he spawns back i tested it idk if its a bug

[hollow axle]

ehhhhhh yeah. i think he does respawn, but he's a drunk man, he doesnt really deserve to dieeeeeee extactly

more like just a mortal rival locked into an endless dual

hes not getting the hat back tho it's mine now

[near tiger]

I'm guessing the "important" NPCs like him and the shopkeepers can't truly die

[quiet rain]

dude rhodes is so underrated istg

[hollow axle]

like bro. the fucking ughhhhasahahhhhh you even do a mission with dutch and hosea where you go fishing and you even grab a boat to which hosea says "ooo we could keep this, would be useful" and dutch is like yeah, but you still gotta buy the boat for like 300 some. maaaaan

[quiet rain]

Dude i couldnt finish that mission cause dutch and hosea wouldnt sit down, they would just be standing there, which cause the mission to bug out...

[coarse vale]

Hey guys can someone help me

I wanna 100% the game but i am stuck with some challanges

[feral bobcat]

Currently in Mexico and just met Landon Ricketts

[coarse vale]

Mostly herbalist

Idk but i cant find berries at all

And its nice to talk to someone while playing some story yk

[wooden kestrel]

Is there a way to set eagle eye to toggle instead of hold on PC?

[signal sedge]

Yes

[twin idol]

where to get the best horses in red dead redempton

any idea

i have shieee horses

[brisk pasture]

any nvidia peeps here?

[twilit zephyr]

@twin idol

White Arabian

Western shores of lake isabella

[idle charm]

guys is it possible to get the carolina parakeet journal entry without wiping out the species?

[twilit zephyr]

No unfortunately

You have to wipe out all the parakeets

[novel plaza]

I fuckin hate that glitch where u walk In a circle

Taht shit always happens at the worst time

[novel plaza]

I finally got my first 3 star rabbit tho

2 more to go

[pine creek]

busting a cap in every lemoyne raider's ass u see is so damn good...

[wooden kestrel]

Is there something wrong with the butcher in Strawberry? His face is covered in blood and he's twitching

The twitching might be a bug for me though

[empty patio]

Yeah the twitching is a bug for you, it's normal for the Butchers to be covered in blood, the one in Valentine has the same thing every now and then

[lapis panther]

You always get a bounty for that robbery. I do think it's worth it though as you can get the schofield revolver early, send some O'Driscolls to hell and make money

[olive ermine]

Y'all, is it better if I leave the treasure hunt for John later on in the game? I kinda don't need any more money as Arthur

[sage matrix]

I did it like that too

[novel plaza]

It will forever bother me how they didn’t just use or atleast build off of John’s model pre epilogue

He doesn’t look the same at all

RDR2 was almost a perfect game, sometimes I wish they worked on it for atleast another year

There’s also many inconsistencies from rdr1 to rdr2 like the macfarlane ranch, half the buildings such as the barn are not there despite Bonnie stating that her father built the barn when she was a little girl in the first game, this goes for places like thieves landing as well

Don’t get me started on guarma.

[novel plaza]

Rdr2 is a great game in itself but it’s hard not to notice the inconsistency as a rdr1 fan

[winged prawn]

Can anyone please help me to fix rdr2 fff error

[winged prawn]

Error fff

Idk i just installed cracked rdr2 u can dm me i can share u picture of my files

[fast hornet]

guarma is meant to be a contrast to the rest of the game. its supposed to show how even if the gang does get the tropical escape dutch planned, the law and their actions will still follow them

sure its disliked but it makes sense

[fast hornet]

and the ranch could very well have buildings added after bonnie was a kid, especially with how many people would realistically come and go. many places in the epilouge change from the main game, its not a stretch to think that the same could happen between rdr1 and the epilouge of rdr2.

[novel plaza]

I meant it was supposed to be a way bigger part of the game

[novel plaza]

well given it’s like a 4 year difference I find that hard to believe

1907-1911

no way they would have time to build the barn and all the buildings that are in hennigans stead in rdr1 in 4 years

It’s just developer oversight

[molten talon]

we need a guarma heist in rdo

[novel plaza]

there was supposed to be a lot more to do in guarma

like a whole island with two beaches with a dead pirate and a treasure hunt and stuff

Cus u were supposed to be able to come back but they cut it

I personally was disappointed by guarma I liked the jungle environment

I wish they worked on it a little longer instead of cutting it

[novel plaza]

And u were supposed to be able to take the pirates coat

U were also supposed to be able to wear overalls

[wicked cedar]

high or low have done both

[wicked cedar]

honor

[harsh dome]

I am in the camp. Where is the nearest place to buy Horse revivers? I don't want to travel far to get them

[dense raptor]

Which camp

[harsh dome]

Horseshoe overlook

[dense raptor]

K

Valentine

[harsh dome]

Am I correct that the name of the camp is Horseshoe overlook?

[dense raptor]

Yes

[harsh dome]

So, where is the nearest place to buy Horse revivers? Remember, I prefer not to travel far to get them

[dense raptor]

Yeah, Valentine is the closest

[harsh dome]

You mean Valentine saloon?

One of my items, Potent Bitters say 'Fully restores stamina and fortifies moderately'. What does 'fortifies' mean?

[dense raptor]

Valentine stable

[dense raptor]

Gold ring

[harsh dome]

Idk where is Valentine stable on the map

[harsh dome]

No, I don't think 'fortifies' mean Gold ring. What is the true meaning?

[dense raptor]

The the gold ring didn’t deplete temporarily

[dense raptor]

Dawg

Check rdr media

[harsh dome]

It's so dark. Can I get any flashlights in the game? Or can I sleep and wake up at a later time so I can play in daytime

[dense raptor]

Lantern

[harsh dome]

Idk what are you saying

[snow valve]

How did arthur get tuborculios

[harsh dome]

I checked Rdr media but I still don't know where is Valentine stable on the map

[harsh dome]

How can I get a lantern?

It's so dark. It's difficult to see

[lime bramble]

Hello y’all I’m new

[harsh dome]

If you die, does your money get deducted? I just died and I think a certain amount of my money has been deducted

How can I sleep? I want to sleep and wake up in daytime

[river idol]

I think you need to set up camp

[harsh dome]

What do you mean 'set up camp'? I am already in my camp. Do you mean set up a tent?

[river idol]

Yeah, sorry i meant the tent

[harsh dome]

Ok so, how do I set up a tent?

[river idol]

You know the wheel that pops up for your weapons and items? It’s in there.

[lime bramble]

What is your favorite town in rdr2 btw yall

[silk mason]

how do you get the missouri fox trotter? i failed to get it in the arcadia for amateurs mission

[lime bramble]

I do not know

[silk mason]

and im pretty sure the glitch where you shoot the lady and then wait for the horse to respawn alive is patched

[silk mason]

then why reply?

[lime bramble]

I don’t know

[dense raptor]

Thomas downes coughs on him

[snow valve]

Dang

[harsh dome]

I tried to set up a tent but it says 'Cannot set up camp while in the caravan'. What should be done?

[river idol]

You need to be in an area where that’s close to the road but on the grass

And then set up your tent

[dense raptor]

Dawg caravan is like end of chap 1 😭

No wonder you don’t have Valentine stable

You don’t unlock Valentine stable till Hosea gives you black shire

Does anyone else have the red Arabian and name it Boadicea?

[harsh dome]

Thank you very much! I was able to set up my tent and sleep. Btw, is there no way to sleep together with your gang?

[harsh dome]

Do you mean I am at end of chap 1?
When will Hosea give me black shire?

[dense raptor]

You prob arnt in chap one

He will give it like the first mission with him I think

[harsh dome]

Then what chap am I in?
I have done a few missions with Hosea

[dense raptor]

Hmmmm

What was your last mission

[harsh dome]

Shit! I don't remember. Is there a way to check what my last mission is?

[dense raptor]

The log

[harsh dome]

How do I check the log?

[dense raptor]

Shit

Idk fir pc

L

Click L

[harsh dome]

Next?

[dense raptor]

What was ur last mission

Should be there

[harsh dome]

Leopold Strauss. Money Lending and other sins - III

[dense raptor]

K

Yeah you should have unlocked the stable

[harsh dome]

I am trying to find for animals to hunt near the camp but there aren't any!

I want to hunt a large animal such as a deer etc.

There is no more arrow and bow in my Weapons wheel. How can I get arrow and bow?

[limpid summit]

You got a bow, and if you don't it's probably in your weapon locker or on your horse. And you can get arrows from any general store or gun store

Hunting? You'll need to ask someone else, I'm sorry

[harsh dome]

Ok, I found the bow. It was in my horse

[limpid summit]

That's good

[harsh dome]

Thank you

[lament coyote]

anyone know if the lion in the mission about the british circus is rare? I had a friend tell me he got a cougar painted white.

[limpid summit]

I'm pretty sure it isn't rare, you'll track it down either way

[lament coyote]

Noice thanks

[harsh dome]

Guys how do I hunt for large animals? Eagle eye is not showing me any tracks

[limpid summit]

What kind? There are many large animals

I'm pretty sure eagle eye should work either way. Hunting or finding something

[harsh dome]

Deer, bear and fish. What other large animals are there?

[harsh dome]

But it's not showing me any tracks

[limpid summit]

Moose's, eagles, and legendary animals ofc

[harsh dome]

Why are they called 'legendary animals' ?

[limpid summit]

Well, from my knowledge it's because they're bigger, harder to find, and sell more

[empty patio]

They're called Legendary because of their unique coat colors and rareness, and they can be harder to track

[harsh dome]

How do I get Eagle eye to show me tracks?

[empty patio]

Just random tracks, or the legendary tracks? I'm not sure how on PC

[limpid summit]

I don't know either, I have a controller when playing. Also thank you for helping me out, I'll leave you be

You too ML

[empty patio]

You're welcome

[harsh dome]

Tracks of any animal. Also one thing, can I get Eagle eye to show me tracks of a specific animal? For example, if I want to hunt a deer, it will show me tracks of deers

[empty patio]

Yes you can get Eagle Eye to show you specific tracks, as long as you have already studied said animal, it will tell you the specie's of the animal you're tracking
If you haven't studied the animal, it'll say Unknown, but will still show you the direction the animal is going

[harsh dome]

Ok let's try a deer. I want to hunt a deer, how do I get it to show me specific tracks of deers? How do I know whether I have already studied said animal?

[empty patio]

So on PC I'm not sure how to tell you on that one
But to study an animal, you can use your binoculars. Skinning the animal also unlocks the species name but it won't unlock the "Study" option until you actually study it with your binoculars. Make sure you're not too close to spook the animal

[harsh dome]

So, who can help me to get it to show specific tracks of deers?

[empty patio]

Possibly other PC players, perhaps?, some PC players use a controller and others use the keys, you'll just have to keep asking PC players in here if they know how to do that

[limpid summit]

Well, for me like Chronella said I usually just study any animal a far but for me to find out what animal I am tracking, I just look at the bottom right. Shouldn't it tell you what animal you are tracking? Even when you're in eagle eye it should tell you even before like as you said, either that or "unknown animal"

Also thank you Chronella for helping me, you have a great day

[harsh dome]

Why you look at the bottom right?? When I turn on Eagle eye, it does not show me any tracks.
Are you a PC or Xbox player?

[limpid summit]

I play on PC, but I play with a controller. It tells me what animal I am tracking or around in the area

[harsh dome]

It doesn't tell me what animal I am tracking

[limpid summit]

Well, I'm not sure, I'm sorry

Maybe ask someone else?

I don't know, sorry

[harsh dome]

I am at the drug store. I am looking at the catalogue. Tonics, Stimulants or Horse Care. Which one do I choose? I want to buy Horse revivers

[empty patio]

Get the Horse Reviver

Always good to have that on hand

[harsh dome]

I was only allowed to buy 3 Horse revivers. It didn't allow me to buy more than 3. It says 'You can't carry any more of this item'

Is there anything else I should get while I am still at the drug store? Otherwise I will be leaving

[thorny cargo]

if you havent studied the animal itll say "unknown animal"

[quiet rain]

shi just finished it for the second time

[harsh dome]

I am in grass. I tried setting my tent but it says 'Camp can only be set up in the wilderness'

[thorny cargo]

you arent in the wilderness. ride around a while

[lament coyote]

Whats the biggest fish you guys have got?

legendarys not included

[urban quest]

I caught like an 18 pound catfish**(?)** once

[empty patio]

A fish catching a fish

Now that's skill

[sly zephyr]

Finished my 4th playthrough today got my first low honor ending

[pulsar ruin]

Dawg, I somehow died twice in RDR1 in less than 5 minutes

Some bandits came to Armadillo, I tried taking care of them, died, respawned, had a shopkeeper ask for help with a robber, the robber ended up shooting me. Sigh.

[lime bramble]

Fr

[harsh dome]

Sometimes while I am out in the wilderness, I bump into strangers that have a 'side mission'. Like they will ask me to take them to town. Is it recommended to do these 'side missions' or don't do them?

[pulsar ruin]

It really depends on how you want to play.

So there's rumors Tumbleweed may be haunted, but I've explored it pretty well, and it just seems to be an abandoned town.

I saw a video of someone claiming to find the ghost of a random woman, but I'm 100% certain they just spawned in an NPC.

[harsh dome]

Why is the lantern not available in my wheel anymore?

How do I change clothes?

I have arrived in Strawberry to rescue Micah out of jail. I had a talk with the sheriff. It says 'Locate and speak to Micah'. But how the heck do I find for Micah?

It says 'Find a way to free Micah'. How do I free him?

[dense raptor]

Steam donkey

[runic iron]

Blow up the window with dynamite.

[novel plaza]

Tumbleweed isn’t haunted

[pulsar ruin]

It does feel pretty creepy, though.

[gaunt shell]

Hey guys!!! Does anyone know how to find Dutch warm blood's across the map? :3

[thorny cargo]

gold panner's horse. they spawn in a few locations

[gaunt shell]

Thank you!

[pulsar ruin]

How is it RDR1 Dutch looks better then RDR2 epilogue Dutch?

I can't post images here to show, but you all have access to Google.

[empty patio]

#general-media

[pulsar ruin]

Rating every Red Dead 1 character

Bonnie MacFarlane, S+.

Seth, A tier.

Charlie, S+

The snake oil guy who's name I can never remember right, B tier.

[modern bobcat]

Whose, not who's

[novel plaza]

Sematary listens to bladee

[novel plaza]

Quit being a a nerd

[novel plaza]

West dickens

[modern bobcat]

You mean quit righteousness? How could I

[quiet rain]

My first playthrough was low honor and the second one was high honor

[modern bobcat]

To the one who gave me that role, shall the LORD above forgive you

[novel plaza]

You should be a strangers and freaks mission

[modern bobcat]

Of course, pal. Whatever you think is best, I will see to it.

[mystic meteor]

Do you guys have tips for new players? I just downloaded the game a few days ago and it's been addictive ngl🔥

[lime bramble]

Wsp homies

[hollow axle]

Wow iron bay roan is actually amazing I love this horse

[zenith zodiac]

Anyone on xbox been able to do the new clothing glitch in Valentine

[granite peak]

Rule #15 | Exploits/Glitches/Hacks/Mods -
For singleplayer, we neither condone nor punish the use of mods.
For multiplayer, any and all modding, or content including it, is prohibited.
Discussions on how to do or find exploits/glitches/hacks/mods, or distributing any of these, is prohibited for both singleplayer and multiplayer.

[empty patio]

No glitches allowed to be discussed

[lime bramble]

Wsp

[hollow axle]

I’m fine w the rule , but can I ask why? I assume it’s so you folks aren’t inundated with “well it’s not working for me like you said, what the fuck man !”

[empty patio]

It breaks the game

[hollow axle]

Ah okay gotcha cool

[quiet pine]

Whats y'all's favorite rdr2 story mission(excluding red dead redemption and American venom)

[zenith zodiac]

I know now. Sorry

[zenith zodiac]

But how does unlocking clothing break the game

[empty patio]

Because you're not meant to, over time they break the game

[zenith zodiac]

Yeah okay I still don't understand. It's a solo single player game nothing can break the game

[empty patio]

It is very possible to break single player. It has happened before with other people.

This discussion is done with 👍🏻

[zenith zodiac]

This discussion is done with? You sound like a dictator trying to control a situation

There's nothing wrong with wanting to know why things aren't allowed

[ember ridge]

Because it's against the rules

Thats all you need to know.

If you have a problem with how this server is run message @fervent apex

[harsh dome]

I have a mission, 'The first shall be last', I have to rescue Sean from the bounty hunters holding him in Blackwater. Earlier when I reached a river, it says 'You are not allowed in Blackwater and a red area otherwise lawmen will be alerted. I don't remember fully what it says. Shortly after passing the river, a stranger shot me and the WANTED sign on top right flash. I think this likely has to do with the warning not to be in Blackwater and red area. I need to follow the waypoint to Javier Escuella yellow blip, what should be done?

[ember ridge]

Go around the edges of the cliff

[harsh dome]

It's happening again! 'WANTED. Dead or alive' at the top right

[harsh dome]

What about the waypoint? I need to follow the waypoint

[ember ridge]

Yes, you will be wanted as you're in blackwater territory. But if you skirt around the edges of the cliffs, youll come up to where javier and charles are

[harsh dome]

The part of my map covering Javier yellow blip has become blank

They shot me again

I have respawned and I am somewhere in the map near Javier yellow blip

I am travelling with Trelawny and Javier. I was following the waypoint to 'find the boat'. It says FAILED. Cover was blown'

[buoyant solar]

anyone have that bug with gurma navy mission when HUD isnt popping up?

[warm galleon]

Is Dutch Warmblood good?

Currently riding the shire Hosea gave me

[limpid summit]

It's a rare horse so yes it is

[warm galleon]

Found the gold guy

Gonna steal his gold nugget and horse

[limpid summit]

Nice 👍

[warm galleon]

He just..

Despawned

[limpid summit]

Oh

[warm galleon]

free Horse then

[limpid summit]

Cool 😎👍

[warm galleon]

Gonna call it Dutch

[harsh dome]

How do I get lanterns?

OMG!!! I only have $71.54 now! Does surrendering to lawmen cause your money to be deducted? I remember I had $300+

I need to gain more money. What's the fastest way to gain more money?

The money deduction is a bad impact...
Maybe next time I shouldn't surrender to lawmen

Some items in the catalogue are locked. How do you get them unlocked?

Can someone please explain to me what does 'fortifies' mean? For example, Potent horse medicine, it says 'Fully restores horse health and fortifies moderately'

[pulsar ruin]

Should have one in your inventory by default.

And "fortifies" just pretty much means "makes better" so in that context it just gives your horse more health.

And the fastest way to get money is to get treasure from looting corpses and selling it to fences.

[harsh dome]

It's not there. Idk why

[pulsar ruin]

Should be in the same slot as your knife, you just have to swap it.

[mental edge]

buffs your/your horse’s cores so that it doesn’t drain for a set amount of time

[harsh dome]

Why doesn't Google show this definition? I Googled 'fortify meaning' but did not come across this meaning

[ornate coyote]

Because English is weird

[pulsar ruin]

I like how many ways RDR1 has for you to make money over 2.

[harsh dome]

What are 'fences'? Where are they located?

[pulsar ruin]

They're guys who buy treasures and stuff, and there's a few across the map.

I usually go to Seamus or the one in St Denis.

[mental edge]

seamus gets nervy if you sell too much hot goods lol id recommend the one in st denis

[pulsar ruin]

I think there's also one in Rhodes.

[harsh dome]

Got it, thank you. But it's not lightning up

[mental edge]

should light up automatically if you’re in a dark area

[pulsar ruin]

Is it day time in your game?

[harsh dome]

Yes it is

[pulsar ruin]

It won't light up until night time or unless you're in a dark area, like Bunny said.

[harsh dome]

How do you put the lantern away?

[pulsar ruin]

Same as you do a weapon.

[harsh dome]

Idk what that is

[pulsar ruin]

L1

Oh wait

I forget what it is on PC

[harsh dome]

Nvm, just tell me cause I am using a PS5 controller

[pulsar ruin]

Oh, L1

Same button you use for the weapon wheel, but you just tap it.

[harsh dome]

It worked. Thank you

[pulsar ruin]

No problem. Need help with anything else?

[harsh dome]

I posted a pic in RD media

[harsh dome]

How do I know which one is 'treasure'?

Guys I only have $31.29 left! I need to gain more money

It says 'The gang are celebrating Sean's return and will be unavailable for other activities for a while'

[pulsar ruin]

Yeah, they're throwing a party to celebrate Sean being not in captivity.

[river idol]

Do some bounty hunting. You won’t have missions for a bit because of sean being back

[pulsar ruin]

And treasure is just anything super valuable, like pocket watches and necklaces

[river idol]

Bounty hunting’ll get you some money

[harsh dome]

What is 'bounty hunting'? How do I do it?

[indigo patrol]

When available go to the sheriffs office in Rhodes, Valentine, St Denis or Strawberry and check the posters

[indigo patrol]

I didnt read whole history, what chapter your in?

[warm galleon]

Yo guys what is the bravest horse? I’m in chapter 3 rn

[harsh dome]

Idk. How do I check what chapter I am in?

[indigo patrol]

Game progress I guess

[indigo patrol]

Try the get the MFT from the Albert Mason mission, and the Turkoman from the Brathwaite mission. Best horses in the game and brave also

[harsh dome]

I am in chapter 2

[indigo patrol]

Okay then u need to go to Valentine, first poster is outside next to sheriffs office.

[indigo patrol]

Did u alreacy unlock the Emerald Ranch Fence? Cause there are a few easy gold bars, u can sell them for 500 each

[harsh dome]

I am not sure

Why does it say 'Cannot set up camp right now'?

[urban quest]

Have you done the mission with Hosea where you rob a house?

[harsh dome]

I am not sure

[urban quest]

You may not have unlocked the mission yet

[urban quest]

Are you near a town or near the camp?
You can tell if you're too close to a town to set up a camp by looking at whether you're inside the faint spotted line around towns

[harsh dome]

I might have been 'near' the camp. I had to go far away from the camp to set up camp. Ridiculous!

[urban quest]

Camps are weird

[dense raptor]

Why does the double action get so much hate?

[urban quest]

Fr

I love it so much

[dense raptor]

Its goated

Especially High roller and Micah

[harsh dome]

I am running out of provisions. I only have 3 Plain venison left

[dense raptor]

Stock up at General store

[urban quest]

It's because of "the damage", when high velocity and express ammo are literally right there

[dense raptor]

Also like this might just be me but the Mauser is one of those hated on things but it’s actually tuff

[indigo patrol]

Go hunting!

[harsh dome]

I am low of finances. I only have $31.29 left

[indigo patrol]

Go to Limpany, get the gold bar and sell it and u have 500. Besides that, hunting is free. So are the treasure maps

[harsh dome]

I still don't know how to get Eagle eye to show tracks of a specific animal

[harsh dome]

Where is Limpany?

[urban quest]

Press both L3 and R3

[urban quest]

It's a burnt down town, south of Valentine,

[indigo patrol]

U got the varmint already? Or the Springfield? They are perfect for hunting. If not, use your bow.

[urban quest]

Look for a cluster of buildings on the map

[harsh dome]

I don't see Limpany on the map

[urban quest]

It doesn't have it's name on the map, look for a cluster of buildings

[indigo patrol]

Prob cause u havent been there yet

[urban quest]

I forgot abt that ngl

[harsh dome]

What is varmint and Springfield?

[twilit zephyr]

Rifle and repeater

[urban quest]

Both of them are rifles

[indigo patrol]

Also go to Cotorra Spings, on the map the point right below where the train track cross each other. 2 gold bars are waiting there for u

[twilit zephyr]

My fault been a while since I hopped on rdr2 fish

[harsh dome]

Idk where is Cotorra Springs and Idk how to go there

[urban quest]

It's a little complicated

[twilit zephyr]

Up north mount

[indigo patrol]

U really need to use google for things like this, makes it so much easier

Its north of Valentine but with that info alone u will prob wander around for days 😁

[harsh dome]

I don't see it north of Valentine on the map

[twilit zephyr]

Located in ambarino territory specifically grizzlies west directly northwest of valentine and just northwest of fort wallace

@harsh dome

[wooden kestrel]

Ride South out of the Wapiti Reservation and keep to the right. It's off the road right near the border between Grizzlies West and Grizzlies East in Ambarino

[warm galleon]

Happy Birthday to RDR i guess

[astral goblet]

if i take the train, how do i get my horse back?

[hollow axle]

it should "follow" behind the train to your destination, if it doesn't then it's either a small bug or the horse was like stuck somewhere somehow

[astral goblet]

oh :(

can i use a stable to get it quickly? is that a thing?

[hollow axle]

the fast travel system should be pretty robust/forgiving, which leads me to believe it's a bug when the horse doesn't actually travel with you.

I have seen trains completely demolish my silver dapple pinto in the cutscene, killing it completely, but it will be okay and spawn with me at my destination.

[hollow axle]

oh yeah for sure, you go to the stable, select "managed horses" then there's a "retrieve" button somewhere

[astral goblet]

any stable?

[hollow axle]

yep any stable, you get 4 horse slots and the stables act as a roaming bank for all of them.

Only the horses that a specific stable sells should be unique, you're stored/already owned horses are universal storage across stables

[astral goblet]

bro my horse is just there on the map not moving

and he isnt even close to the train station i left from

[hollow axle]

yeah if he's out of ear shot he aint doin shit.

[astral goblet]

L horse

[hollow axle]

but running to a stable and retrieving it is exactly what i do.

I have been stranded a few times by coincidence but that's when the game gets really interesting hahaha

Also huge pro tip, if you go to an island and your boat despawns (this has happened to me lol) all you gotta do is set up camp and arthur will teleport to the mainland automatically, i actually just do this when i want to leave the island anyway sometimes lol

[minor karma]

Guys I just started chapter two like 2 days ago and I’m stuck like I have hunted and brought herbs and stuff but I’m not progressing and the little icons are still red

[empty patio]

The camp supplies?

[minor karma]

Yes!

[empty patio]

Try bringing full carcasses, as many as you can, sometimes it takes a while

[minor karma]

Alr thank you! So when I bring the full carcass do I have to carry it to Pearson or am I able to donate the whole thing, or does it still need skinned

Sorry I’m struggling lmao

[empty patio]

You can donate the whole animal to Pearson without skinning it

[minor karma]

Okay thank you so much!!

[empty patio]

No problem

[stable zephyr]

Got the legen of the east satchel

Actually was pretty easy or maybe im just better at hunting than I used to be

[hollow axle]

99 max storage is so nice lol

[stable zephyr]

Im hyped im gonna be able to loot literally all the things now

[stable zephyr]

Watching Thomas Downes cough blood into arthurs mouth is so fucking rough

Genius of r* that we see and are at fault for the exact moment arthur gets tb

[nova mango]

Whats the coolest looking revolver

[pearl sequoia]

The revolver

The one that looks cool and badasss

It’s in the shop

[cosmic sky]

I jist finished my first playthrough including Epilogue. Ive never felt so accomplished in my life. This is the best and most emotional game i have ever played in my life

[keen narwhal]

so glad u enjoyed it :))

[cosmic sky]

Thanks

[keen narwhal]

ur welcomeee

what platform do u play on??

[molten talon]

you should do one more playthrough of the opposite honor, like if u did high then do low and vice versa

[cosmic sky]

Ok

[cosmic sky]

Xbox

[molten talon]

and try to get 100% if u can coz this game 100% is absolutely worth the time

[keen narwhal]

i’m actually trying to platinum the game rn

[cosmic sky]

Thats what I've heard

[cosmic sky]

Nice. How do you do so?

[keen narwhal]

rn i’m trying to get the best of the west trophy but i also need to try out rdr online to 100%

do u plan on 100% the game??

[charred vessel]

genuine question, is the legendary channel catfish even catcheable? I assume it’s not since it doesn’t say you need to catch it in the compendium but then, what would be the whole point of the rare lure—to make it easier to catch bigger fishes or…

[thorny cargo]

its not catcheable

[charred vessel]

that’s a shame, man… why do they keep scrapping cool concepts

[cosmic sky]

I plan on iy

It*

[azure spindle]

Random question

But

Is gta v any good

I just thought rockstar games

It’s probably like a newer version of rdr (as in timeline not when it was made)

[lapis hornet]

GTA V is a great game if you like driving around and shooting and killing people. It has a good story too

[azure spindle]

Oooh really thanks man

[lapis hornet]

There are a lot of good reasons that gta v is a great game. Just search them up on google or youtube. Theyll give a bunch of good reasons to play gta v

[olive ermine]

Are Arabian horses weak as shit? Because I found one by the deadboot creek, and it fucking died after falling ONCE from like a two or three ft height

[thorny cargo]

some tend to have a lower health, yes

also depends on bonding, low bonding = low health

[olive ermine]

Man 😞 And I thought it was my lucky day

[azure spindle]

Does anyone know what the best horse is I'm using the mustang right now i want the leopard Appaloosa for looks but mustangs stamina is pretty good .

[molten talon]

yes

arabians are over rated

[molten talon]

fastest one is the Missouri Fox Trotter

[azure spindle]

Ooh okay

[molten talon]

Yes GTA 5 is very fun and the story is not so depressing like rdr games

[azure spindle]

Hah okay then ima get it

[molten talon]

Just saying always pick C ending

coz its the cannon one

[azure spindle]

Yeaa isnt it the one where everyone survives

Without spoiling it

[empty patio]

All endings are cannon

If they weren't cannon they wouldn't be in-game

[molten talon]

no like its the most cannon choice after gta online dlcs released

[molten talon]

yes

coz the story mode characters are in online

of some major dlcs

like trevor appears, michael and franklin aswell

[empty patio]

Also you guys might wanna move to a different channel to discuss GTA, this is a Red Dead Franchise channel only

[limpid spindle]

gta is so mid

[open hearth]

white arabian

[azure spindle]

Its really fragile and bucks alot though

[lapis panther]

Missouri Fox Trotter.

[lapis panther]

V was garbage.

[azure spindle]

Better than mustang ?

[lapis panther]

MFT? Yes.

[azure spindle]

Ooh ok

[lapis panther]

I do like Mustangs though. Good horses

[limpid spindle]

Best horse imo is Buell

from the Hamish stranger mission

I've been maining it since i got it and never used another one

[lapis panther]

I made the mistake of getting Buell with Arthur in my first playthrough. Never again haha

I just do the first three Hamish missions as Arthur and the last one as John

[limpid spindle]

Yh i completed the first 3 parts as Arthur and the last one as John

first thing i did after getting free roam in epilogue

[lapis panther]

Buell and Rachel are good horses for John

[limpid spindle]

I sold Rachel i wasnt planning on using it

[lapis panther]

With Arthur, I usually keep his Tennessee Walker, but also buy a Dutch Warmblood and a MFT

[limpid spindle]

wasnt the most beautiul horse either

[lapis panther]

I never use the same horse

I alternate

[limpid spindle]

Oh lol, Buell is a Dutch Warmblood btw

[lapis panther]

With Arthur, I buy the one in Valetine

Chocolate Roan DWB. For some reason, I think it suits him haha

[limpid spindle]

As Arthur i've been using the horse the game gives you

Or rather Hosea mission when you go to the stables sell a horse and buy yourself one

[lapis panther]

Tennessee Walker?

[limpid spindle]

Idk what was the race in English cuz my game is Polish but it came free with Ultimate Edition

[lapis panther]

I always keep that one as secondary horse

[lapis panther]

Thoroughbred

I have the pre order Ardennes too

[limpid spindle]

Yea that. I think

[naive turtle]

I need help with something.

[lapis panther]

Help with what?

[naive turtle]

Mr. Black Mr. White bounty poster bug

[limpid spindle]

Whats the bug

[naive turtle]

I'm collecting posters, but the character director isn't taking the poster, and I have five posters in my bag.

[lapis panther]

Never had that problem before, I cannot help you on that

[naive turtle]

I put the video in the media folder.

Many people are experiencing this problem, and everyone has shared their issue, but I haven't seen anyone claim to have solved it.

[west hawk]

i was trying to do the give the flowers to william mission

but after a while when i went he was dead

[pulsar ruin]

I just let John get hit by a train in RDR1 and it's entirely my fault.

[harsh dome]

Idk how to ride south of the Wapiti Reservation. Idk how to reach Cotorra Springs using your directions

[harsh dome]

I left Valentine's sheriff office. I am at the river. It says 'Locate the bounty'. How do I locate the bounty?

The river is pushing me. Which button is to swim/swim fast?

I am at the part where bounty Benedict flows through the river. I have to catch him. But as I am riding on the horse keep going down, I don't see him in the river. How the heck am I going to catch him?

I failed the mission AGAIN! It says 'FAILED. You lost the bounty'

Somebody please help me!!! It keeps saying 'FAILED. You lost the bounty'

My R2 (RT) button isn't working! I can't lasso the bounty

[novel plaza]

Shoot him

[harsh dome]

I received $50 for capturing bounty Benedict. Isn't that a low amount?

Can't do that. He has to be captured alive!

Guys help me get more gold bars! Don't tell me Cotorra Springs because it's difficult to reach there

I came back to Valentine with Hungarian halfbred. Is there any way to get my horse to me fast or do I have to travel all the way to the same place I left him to get him?

[harsh dome]

Guys???

[mental edge]

treating my arthur so well he got a little chubby 😭🥺

[harsh dome]

I am in Valentine's sheriff office. Where are the posters for bounties? I can't seem to find them

[pulsar ruin]

I have killed 16 wolves in RDR1.

At least I have 16 wolf pelts.

[pulsar ruin]

Look for a skull icon.

[pulsar ruin]

And yeah, if you're too far away from your horse in RDR2, you do have to walk back to it or wait for it to come to you.

[harsh dome]

On the map or where?

[pulsar ruin]

Yeah, on the map.

[harsh dome]

There is no skull icon over the Valentine area

[pulsar ruin]

Then it doesn't have any bounties currently.

[harsh dome]

So, bounties aren't always available?

[pulsar ruin]

And as for gold bars, there aren't a ton in the game unless you do treasure hunts, but those can take time.

[frosty raft]

Just go to Tahiti Bru 💔

[pulsar ruin]

And nah, there's a finite amount of bounties in 2.

[harsh dome]

So, are there other ways I can gain money besides bounty hunting and gold bars?

[pulsar ruin]

Selling valuables is pretty good.

[wooden kestrel]

Do you know where Fort Wallace and Bacchus Station are?

[plain hull]

treasure hunts

[pulsar ruin]

Who's death is sadder, Arthur or John's?

[empty patio]

My horse

[hollow axle]

sean

also, does anyone know the firm number of ox pelts needed for all crafting total? im getting mixed answers when searching between 4 and 5, but peirson only took 2 and will now just sell the rest so im all confused now lol

[mental edge]

johns, abigail and jack seeing the aftermath of it is tragic

[pulsar ruin]

Plus the fact he was shot like a dog in the street.

[mental edge]

yes

[pulsar ruin]

At least Arthur went out with some dignity.

[hollow axle]

idk how yall saw John die, the way i saw him die he took down damn near the entire group that showed up to kill him, he almost got them all, went out like a beast

[pulsar ruin]

How do you think Abigail died? Some people seem to think it was old age, which makes less than no sense.

I think she died from a broken heart, which is a real thing that can happen.

[mental edge]

john’s death also made everything that arthur did and had hoped for fruitless

[mental edge]

i think the same!

[pulsar ruin]

Or to be more accurate, the grief and sadness weakened her heart severely and she passed from a cardiac episode

[hollow axle]

i thought this at first, but then realized arthur's story and character arc coming full circle was about arthur and his journey, not johns

[pulsar ruin]

And the only reason it didn't kill her sooner is because she was being strong for Jack, but once he reached proper adult age, she no longer saw any reason to carry on.

[hollow axle]

arthur needed to save john at the end for the sake of arthur's soul, its kind of a tie in to the big conversation he has with the nun at emerald ranch

[mental edge]

yeah his entire arc is very sobering, i really enjoy that about the rdr franchise is having these polarizing characters where we can’t really stake any moral claim on any of them. arthur especially. to me he’s more of a cautionary tale at best

[pulsar ruin]

"The thing is, I'm afraid, sister....."

[mental edge]

yesss he did what he could, with what he had and that’s about enough in the end i guess

[hollow axle]

as far as john goes, also very sobering and real, John, for all his flaws, at the very end of the day, he kept abby and jack alive, which is the sole main purpose of a husband and father, which is basically what he fought tooth and nail to prevent becoming in rdr2 - thats what i get from the story in retrospect

from "im not this kids dad, leave me alone abby" to basically dying for them in the end

[mental edge]

they portrayed the deadbeat trope so well with john in rdr2 that it felt like whiplash! and i find him so atrocious in the early chapters 😭 but that was the intention of the devs/story

[mental edge]

yeah 😔💔

[hollow axle]

i agree 100% it's so good to watch it all unfold over rdr2 and see how they all change. i think the deaths of basically everyone in the crew really effected john in the after math, which is why he's so stone cold by the time of rd1 and not kind of a silly idiot like in the beginning of rdr2

[mental edge]

oh I can’t send gifs here either </3

anyway cat nodding head in agreement gif to everything you’ve said

[hollow axle]

i have been burned by this too. i also can't change my name lol

[mental edge]

the entire franchise challenges our proclivity to put things into black&white boxes, ppl will hate any number of characters because they started off awful and unseemly and won’t consider them beyond the past. it’s kind of like a litmus test for empathy in a way, like yes i think john was so intolerable and gross for leaving abigail and jack but he also came around. of course it isn’t picture perfect but nothing ever is. it’s a very human trait to want a happy idyllic ending with anything

and sorry if that’s all over the place, i hope i make sense

[mental edge]

you’re telling me you weren’t always evilweener haha

[hollow axle]

i was going to make my name "fake evilweener" since i see alot of "fake" names everywhere hahah

[hollow axle]

no i get what you're saying and i think i agree, what i hope people take away from the story is that no human being is all good or all bad. There's alot of grey in life and what's most important is being good to your family friends and neighbors

[pulsar ruin]

What's the max amount of a single pelt you can have in RDR1?

[buoyant solar]

I think maybe she got sick

Does anyone know to " the outlaws return mod" in nexunods for the game

[granite peak]

Rule #15 | Exploits/Glitches/Hacks/Mods -
For singleplayer, we neither condone nor punish the use of mods.
For multiplayer, any and all modding, or content including it, is prohibited.
Discussions on how to do or find exploits/glitches/hacks/mods, or distributing any of these, is prohibited for both singleplayer and multiplayer.

[marble nebula]

Could anyone do some of my gold medals in share play ?

[charred vessel]

how hard to find is the rio grande turkey? cuz I can’t find any, can someone recommend spots to hunt this bird?

[tall radish]

[formal furnace]

It’s a pain but you’ll find it in southern new Austin

[charred vessel]

yeah i noticed, i kept reloading n reloading for like 2 hours and no luck

[nova aspen]

Even where they are you’d be pretty lucky to find one because of how rare they are

It’ll take a while but you’ll get there

[split edge]

What are some missables in chapter 2

I need all the missables

I don't think rdr2 is set in America

The borders are way to round

[ember ridge]

It is set in America, but a Fictional America. There is no one state it is based of

[warm nimbus]

There should be a rdr1 and rdr2 singleplayer channel not both mixed togheter

[warm nimbus]

I think new austin is only inspired by Texas

[cursive bramble]

Theory: Guarma is actually Tahiti and Dutch was hallucinating that someone told him otherwise because he felt that he couldn't make it there until he "earned it" with another heist

Don't ask how that would work geographically

[delicate cairn]

How would that work geographically?

[empty patio]

Cumberland is based off Wisconsin Cumberland State Forest
Blackwater is based off Blackwater Missouri, Bayou is based off Louisiana, Ambarino is based off a mix of all the Rocky Mountain states, Rhodes is based off of Arizona

[ember ridge]

That is more then one state

[empty patio]

Yeah I know CJAJXNFB

Oh and also, Black Bone forest is based off of Yosemite National Park in California

[rose gust]

how do i rob people without them trying to fight back? everytime ive tried ive had to shoot them after they pulled a gun on me

[harsh dome]

No I don't

[wooden kestrel]

You still need to get to Cotorra Springs?

[harsh dome]

Yes, I need to get the gold bars there

[wooden kestrel]

If you're looking for stuff like that I recommend looking up the RDR2 interactive map

Otherwise, try following the Dakota River (the one West of Valentine) North and then Northeast until you reach a place called Bacchus Station. From there, follow the train tracks West until you reach an open field to your right with hot springs, that's Cotorra Springs

[prisma minnow]

does anyone have any tips on my new rdr2 run? i played low honor my first time and i beat the main story (not teh epilouges) yesterday. and i feel like it would be fun to try high honor this time. im not a pro or anything tho so im jus wondering :)

[empty zinc]

This might not help or maybe you already know this, but when you play high honor everything at all stores cost a little bit less and you'll just get better deals on most things

[pulsar ruin]

Ok, John just got ripped off.

[bronze river]

I love the story so far, it's been so good

[pulsar ruin]

I went after a bounty, they were offering $240 for alive, so of course I go through all the trouble of bringing him back as such, only got $185.

[bronze river]

High honor is definitely the way to go

[empty zinc]

💔

[empty zinc]

TRUE

[bronze river]

damn...

[empty zinc]

When ever I get a bounty on me in rdr2 and I see the bounty people on the map looking for me it makes me so scared

For no reason

[bronze river]

Ngl, I keep forgetting to put on my mask whenever I wanna do a crime or smth

But yeah, that's scary

Especially when it's night time

[empty zinc]

[pulsar ruin]

Keeping the money from the Mr Tollets mission is the morally right thing to do, right?

[mental edge]

not me discovering the in-game california quail is in fact a bobwhite. NO wonder i was stumped trying to find them initially!! they aren’t using the right model or the right call

it probs sounds like im being pedantic lmao but it’s fun finding these lil errors

[indigo patrol]

Dont even know him, is that RDR1?

[mental edge]

never heard of mr toilet

[pulsar ruin]

Yeah, he's a stranger mission in it.

Makes you deliver opium.

Purely to keep certain railroad workers happy or something.

[mental edge]

deliver opium for medicinal purposes or nefarious purposes

[mental edge]

ohhh

keep the money

imo the “morally correct” thing would’ve been to refrain from helping but ig you gotta do what you gotta do

[indigo patrol]

I've never played RDR1, I'm pretty bummed about that, but playing it after RDR2 can only be a disappointment, right?

[pulsar ruin]

Yeah, I shot him and ended up keeping the money.

Nah, it's a great game.

Kinda wish I'd shot the guy who gave me the package too, but I did rob his safe.

[mental edge]

love how the games open us up to moral dilemmas

maybe ill play rdr1

[harsh dome]

I have arrived in Cotorra Springs. Where are all the gold bar locations?

[reef ether]

I thought beating the story again wouldn't be as peak I was wrong

[pallid plaza]

Its always peak

[rancid arrow]

[twin root]

Yooo is anyone alive

[open seal]

Yeah. Unfortunately my horse didn't make the cliff though...

[twin root]

Close the game

And launch it again

Or load old auto save

[open seal]

You mean I don't have to walk caring this stupid saddle for an hour in the rain. Hahaha

[pulsar ruin]

If you could add any song to either RDR1 or 2's soundtrack, what would it be?

[buoyant solar]

If you want to get high honor, go fishing and throw the fish back, best and easiest method.

[buoyant solar]

[lapis panther]

Derailed train?

[lapis panther]

It's easy as the clue is in the name on where to find it lol

[lapis panther]

High honour? Only kill when you need to and help those who need help.

[pearl carbon]

Oof i’m suck on the racing mission how do I complete it

[charred vessel]

it’s everything BUT easy mate, i’ve been there multiple times and STILL not there

spend 4 hours on resets and they refuse to spawn

i’ll keep trying as i got no other choice

[prisma minnow]

Oo thanks

[prisma minnow]

Kk

[empty zinc]

🍕

[narrow relic]

yo guys im doing my 4th or 5th playthrough rn and im on chapter 6, im high honour so what tips do you recommend for me?

[hazy cairn]

Finally finished rdr2. Why tf did micah look like he aged 20 years

[narrow relic]

idk lmao

[empty zinc]

Because he's just ugly like that

[onyx magnet]

I should've done high honor I regret everything now

[lapis hornet]

Just enjoy the last moments before finishing the story. Take a ride around a map with arthur one last time

[split edge]

Go to the nearest stable your saddle will teleport there

[dense raptor]

Funny because it’s only 8 years 😭✌🏼

[solid flicker]

guys

i need help

how to get Jacks book near Blackwater

i am scared i will die there

[dense raptor]

It’s actually in Lemoyne

[solid flicker]

i am in chapter 3 rn

i wanna help him out if i still got a chance

[dense raptor]

When did he ask for it

[fickle flicker]

guys wasnt there an optionon to be able to go to that one ahopkeepers basement and then find a kid in his basement and a gun

[solid flicker]

chapter 2

[dense raptor]

Alr

Give me a sec

[crisp oxide]

You can also get it in a homestead near Roanoke ridge or southeast of emerald ranch in Osmans grove

The penny dreadful book thing

[dense raptor]

Check media

[dense raptor]

I put it in media for you

[solid flicker]

ty

[trim hamlet]

ya
in Rhodes

[solid flicker]

can i fast traver there

@dense raptor

[silk tide]

yo some missions arent actually triggering idk why

Oh brother 2
and Chin gang part 2
aswell as the doctor’s robbery I finished it and its still in my log

[fickle flicker]

alr

[harsh dome]

Anyone???

[agile saffron]

Just picked up rdr2 ultimate edition yesterday as it's on sale

[harsh dome]

Why isn't anyone replying???

[solid flicker]

@dense raptor tysm bro i got chocolate bar from Jack

[pulsar ruin]

Do we know what happens to all the surviving gang members after RDR2?

[blazing smelt]

hello, im new to rdr2 and i need to know whats the goal of this game

[pulsar ruin]

The goal is to antagonize Micah and Dutch as much as possible.

[ember ridge]

Some you find out yeah

[blazing smelt]

explain a lil more plz

[pulsar ruin]

I think Reverend Swanson kept being sober and eventually got a job at a good church.

Charles went to Canada, where he found a native tribe and eventually a beautiful wife.

Sadie, well, probably went to Mexico and became a well-respected bounty hunter.

[ember ridge]

He went to africa I think to spread the word of the bible??

[pulsar ruin]

Oh, that makes sense.

And Pearson, the GOAT, of course got his own shop.

[pulsar ruin]

And man, you may as well ask what the goal of the sun is.

RDR2 doesn't have one specific goal in mind.

[ember ridge]

Tilly married a rich man and started a family

Mary-beth became an Author

Karen died suspected, Struass died under being tortured for info about the gang, Trelawny just continued being himself, Bill and Javier do stuff in rdr1...

Uhhh who else is there

[pulsar ruin]

I do kind of hope Sadie changed her mind about civilized society and settled down.

[ember ridge]

Nah she wouldn't have

She lost the true love of her life

Nobody can compare to Jake

[pulsar ruin]

Yeah, she just suffers so much, she deserves a happy ending.

[lyric chasm]

wassup

first up
im not the real john
at night im john
at day im créu

[empty zinc]

I remember going to Rhodes and going to the general store and seeing Mr. Pearson🥹

[turbid rampart]

Where do those green parrots in the swamps spawn, I'm on my second playthrough and havent found a single one yet

[river warren]

Well i tried to blow up the general store before

[empty zinc]

💔

[river warren]

I'm serious

[cold hill]

Yoo

[river warren]

And i tried to kill downes

With some dynamite

[wooden kestrel]

I sort of rushed to chapter 5 and I feel like I missed a lot. Should I start a second playthrough?

[empty patio]

Finish this playthrough then restart, yeah, there's a lot

[wooden kestrel]

When should I stop? My first instinct is a few missions into chapter 3

[harsh dome]

Hey @wooden kestrel, I have reached Cotorra Springs. Where are the locations of all the gold bars?

[wooden kestrel]

There are only two, and they are not at Cotorra Springs exactly, they are west along the tracks in a crashed train car below a bridge. I had assumed you were there for the Jack Hall map or the legendary wolf

[harsh dome]

@indigo patrol said to go to Cotorra Springs, on the map the point right below where the train track cross each other. 2 gold bars are waiting there for me. Where is the bridge?

[wooden kestrel]

It's west along the tracks after a tunnel I think

[pulsar ruin]

Finally finished with Mexico.

[cursive bramble]

Is it possible to get the last veteran mission as Arthur?

I did it as John in my first playthrough but I wanna have Buell as Arthur

[empty patio]

Yes

It's possible

[unique jungle]

strangest thing js happened

the captive boy in basement random event triggered for me in rhodes chapter 3, i freed him and then sheriffs started attacking randomly and i apparently killed sheriff gray like what??????????????

[pulsar ruin]

How does dueling in RDR1 even work?

Feels like sometimes I do it perfectly and others I just keep failing.

Oh, I think I get it now. I draw with R2 and have to quickly fill my meter more then my opponent does theirs, right?

[crisp oxide]

Should I get rid of the black raven shire?

[thorny cargo]

no

[mental edge]

yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

wait i read that wrong

im crying dotnt get rid of it plsss

[crisp oxide]

Such an enthusiastic yes

[mental edge]

NO

DONT get rid of it (all caps, very urgent)

[pulsar ruin]

I feel bad for Jack.

He became what his mother feared he would, not out of desire but necessity.

[hollow axle]

oooo just found a few spotted in the wild, this is a good horse

[forest schooner]

HORSE

I love horse

[hollow axle]

i wish they put an impossibly difficult easter egg in the game that leads to a unicorn.

[eternal estuary]

Crazy how rdr2 became the 3rd best selling game oat without any re releases

[hollow axle]

good writing

[pulsar ruin]

Just want through the most BS I ever had in RDR1

Went to get a bounty, and I couldn't put him on my horse, so bandits just kept coming

I'm so frustrated someone DM me funny John Marston pictures

[near tiger]

I am sad that it took RDR1 like 14 years to get a PC port tho

I know the code was like spaghetti code but it's also partly kinda Rockstar's fault for putting it off this many years

[pulsar ruin]

Ok, why can't I pay my bounty?

[novel plaza]

The Pinkertons were right

[sinful wyvern]

Gay

[sinful wyvern]

Go jump

[sinful wyvern]

Fatahh

[novel plaza]

Quit acting like a 13 year old

[sinful wyvern]

Nah

[novel plaza]

That’s why ur moms a whore

[supple trout]

[pulsar ruin]

Imagine John is running around in Undead Nightmare, having a great time dealing with the undead, when he suddenly sees Arthur.

[near tiger]

I did always think that Undead Nightmare was either an alternate universe/reality, John's purgatory or John is literally actually dreaming hence it being called a nightmare

[pulsar ruin]

I think the actual canon explanation for it is that it's a dream John has while recovering from his injuries at MacFarlane Ranch.

I also read a Creepypasta where it turns out the whole zombie thing is in his head and he's gone crazy and tied up Abigail and Jack before they starved to death.

[tough isle]

Guys I bought myself a Controller for PC

How do you guys makes the horse RUN??

Do you guys keep like smashing the A button for the whole journey

It is painful is there an easier way to do it

[pulsar ruin]

Just hold it down, the horse should go pretty fast, but not super fast.

[narrow relic]

search on youtube all controls for controller, try to get used to it.

[near tiger]

I need to see that creepypasta

Don't think I read that one

[near tiger]

I don't think that explanation holds up tho since John literally knows Professor MacDougal and Nastas in that DLC

The dream had to be at a certain point in the main game, maybe right before Nastas was killed

[pulsar ruin]

Well, maybe they messed up there.

[near tiger]

I think the DLC takes place sometime after the at Home with Dutch mission

[tidal slate]

If the Cat raises the Claws on someone... The joy of the Morning routine

[vagrant lily]

The damned wheel

[modern saddle]

Who's yall favorite character? (mine personally is Lenny Summers)

[harsh dome]

It's difficult to find my way with your directions. Can you tell me a place on the map to mark as waypoint? It will be easier to find my way there

[opaque quiver]

do you think a red dead 3 MIGHT release?

[ember ridge]

Tomorrow 12pm gmt

[harsh dome]

I am out of food

[pulsar ruin]

Go hunting

[harsh dome]

I am in Cumberland forest. There aren't a lot of animals here

[stable cove]

Idk if right place but anyone know why can't just press windows to tab out of rdr2

[harsh dome]

There are a few Cornwall Oil Wagon yellow blips in different places on the map. What do they mean? I am near a Cornwall Oil Wagon and Idk what should I do with it

[manic anchor]

wheres the content

[dense gate]

Take it

And run

[harsh dome]

The objective says 'Get on the wagon'

[river idol]

It means to steal the wagon, so you’ve got to get on the wagon

[harsh dome]

There is a guard in front of the wagon. When I get on the wagon, he immediately starts shooting at me. He has killed me many times

[river idol]

Before you get on the wagon take down the guards and then take the wagon

[harsh dome]

I killed the guard and after that only realize the wagon has moved. It says 'FAILED. The oil wagon was abandoned'

I killed the guard then the lawmen arrived and shot me

[chrome heron]

@ mountlady you trying to play together

[harsh dome]

How can we play together?

It says 'Drive the wagon to the drop off location'. Where is the drop off location? How do I find my way there?

[dense gate]

Yes get on the wagon

[dense gate]

Try to get on the wagon without killing anyone

And while u leave kill everyone

[harsh dome]

I have arrived somewhere near Dewberry Creek. I marked a yellow spot as waypoint and followed the way here. There doesn't seem to be anyone to interact about the wagon. What should be done?

Where is the drop off location??? How do I find my way there???

I have left the wagon at the drop off location. Now I have to walk so far to my horse!

[pulsar ruin]

Ok, I think I understand RDR1 dueling now.

[harsh dome]

Can I steal someone's horse? So that I can ride to my horse. Will there be any bad consequences?

[pulsar ruin]

You need to make sure the markers on your target are white and tight, so you're able to fill your meter faster.

[pulsar ruin]

Yes, you'll get in trouble for horse theft.

[harsh dome]

So the only way is for me to walk to my horse!?

[pulsar ruin]

Well, you can just steal a horse and deal with the consequences.

Or you can just walk until you're close enough for whistling to work.

[harsh dome]

How do I whistle?

[pulsar ruin]

Up on the d-pad, I think.

[harsh dome]

What is the control for PS5 controller?

[pulsar ruin]

Same thing.

[harsh dome]

I have just accepted a side mission to take a stranger back home. She lives in Valentine

She said 'We'll need to go on a horse. My leg can't handle the walk'. I am wondering how am I going to take her home!! What should I do guys?

She says 'Never mind, I'll find my own way'

[pulsar ruin]

Yeah, you obviously need a horse for that.

[harsh dome]

I had to leave my horse parked because I had to ride the wagon. Why do they give you missions where you will be separated from your horse?

Hunting is difficult. The animals keep running away from you

I tried to steal horse from a man but he rode away

[urban quest]

you need to crouch to not scare them, you can also use cover scent lotion so they don't smell you

[modern saddle]

If you want to steal a horse from someone than I suggest killing the person riding the horse and then following the horse and taming it (if your doing high honor then tie up the person with your lasso)

[harsh dome]

Where can I buy cover scent lotion?

[urban quest]

general stores

[harsh dome]

If I kill the person riding the horse, I will become WANTED and the lawmen will come after me.
What does high honor mean?

[wooden kestrel]

Try looking up the rdr2 interactive map, it has everything marked including a lot of good loot

[harsh dome]

What do you mean by 'rdr2 interactive map'?

[granite peak]

Interactive Maps for Red Dead Online -
RDO Map: (https://jeanropke.github.io/RDOMap/)
RDO Collector's Map: (https://jeanropke.github.io/RDR2CollectorsMap/)

[wooden kestrel]

I mean the RDR2 interactive map, you can just google it and it should be the first result

[shy hollow]

i guess i

im afraid...

[harsh dome]

I searched 'gold bar' and 1st result says '2X GOLD BAR, AGED PIRATE RUM & VALERIAN ROOT. Location: Inside the vertical train car. You'll need to drop down into the train car above, by climbing a small rock passage nearby the carriage'

How do I check how many items I have left? I want to check how many Horse revivers I have left

It's dark and the lantern doesn't seem to be available

[harsh dome]

Is there a limit to how many items I can carry? I am at the General Store in Valentines. It says 'Horse Reviver. Sold out'. When I press buy, it says 'You can't carry any more of this item'

[fierce dust]

yes

for horse revivers there is a limit

[harsh dome]

I used the 'Predator bait' but nothing seems to happen. Are the animals coming?

How do I attract the animals to me?

[delicate cairn]

Where are you placing it,

and how long are you waiting

and WHERE are you waiting

[harsh dome]

In the grass
Just for a while
The place I used the Predator bait

[empty patio]

You have to place it in specific locations where predators usually spawn every time, not just random locations

[delicate cairn]

so there's a problem, don't wait where you placed it

^ and following up with chron, when you place it walk away and use a scope/bow

[empty patio]

If you place it in random spots where predators don't spawn, the only thing you're going to get is a fox, boar, raccoon or coyotes

[harsh dome]

Oh I see. How am I supposed to know what are the 'specific locations' where predators usually spawn?

[harsh dome]

I can't wait far from where I placed it, in case an animal shows up, so my arrows can reach them

[empty patio]

So south of Braithe Waite there is a panther that spawns by the water
Left side of the map in Big Valley West Elizabeth there will be some wolves and bears that spawn there as well as a cougar
Top right of the map there will be a cougar that spawns up there in Roanoke Ridge
Top left in Ambarino near the lake there will be some wolves
Top middle of Ambarino there will be some wolves and on occasions, a grizzly

[harsh dome]

Thank you for the list. I will take my time to go through it

[empty patio]

Of course!

[pulsar ruin]

Started playing without a HUD, good fun.

Makes things a lot more cinematic and challenging.