red-dead-singleplayer

[obtuse zodiac]

Ok

"Micah is a dick because he killed people"

[rough kelp]

ok

[obtuse zodiac]

Ok yes aj we know u don't know what outlaw means

Ur still engaging which is funny

[supple trout]

Are you done yet

[obtuse zodiac]

Nah bit more

[rough kelp]

ok

[simple tangle]

i love you aj

[rough kelp]

i love u too

[lost meadow]

Damn i just finished the main story

[stiff summit]

Guys for those that play on pc,do yall have a problem whenever ur riding a horse and the horse just randomly starts going in circles?

[agile wharf]

Playing rdr mobile and its very lagy somtimes but its stable kind of lagy bc it just slows down game any tips?

[stiff summit]

How do u even play rd2 on mobile??

[amber tinsel]

You cant play rdr2 on mobile

I think so

[stiff summit]

Then why did he say playing rdr mobile

Or maybe he means rdr1

[amber tinsel]

You can play rdr1 on mobile

[stiff summit]

Ik

[amber tinsel]

Through Netflix games

[stiff summit]

I tried it on my phone

Didnt even start

[amber tinsel]

But thats all i know

Yeah I just play rdr on ps5

Even if you could play rdr2 on mobile it would be laggy as hell

[zinc oxide]

i will NEVER use camp quicktravel

ngl adding it wasnt the best idea

[thorny cargo]

why

i use it all the time personally

[zinc oxide]

it just kills a lot of the games experience

long horse rides with occasional encounters

[agile wharf]

Yes

[oblique bramble]

WHAT

[agile wharf]

Free too😉

[agile wharf]

Yes its the 1st one

[agile wharf]

Although i have played rdr2 on mobile

[agile wharf]

I can send working link if u want

[stiff summit]

The problem is my phone i thing

[agile wharf]

What phone?

[stiff summit]

Cuz when i start it u know like the first thing u see is the netflix logo and it just keep repeating over and over

[agile wharf]

Yeah worked fine for my samsung a15 and a55

It's AMAZING on a55

Though laggy on a15 but still playable

[agile wharf]

Where did u downlad it from?

[stiff summit]

Idk i tried from 2 sites but same result

[agile wharf]

I used apkvision

Worked well

6gigs

And instaled it with zarchiver

[granite peak]

Rule #14 | Piracy - Any type of pirated or illegally obtained content is prohibited. This includes suggesting to pirate or jailbreak any games/media/services/products, or explaining how to do so.

[zinc oxide]

how do i get a kanu? im tryna fetch some iguanas rn

[thorny cargo]

just swim with your horse

[thin elbow]

What will happen if I rob a trapper? Will I be able to use it again later on to sell stuff, or does that one then permanently closes?

[zinc oxide]

its too far for that

[thorny cargo]

ive done it millions of times, are you on the edge of the shore closest to the island?

if you go with your horse and just calm it whenever you can youll be able to

[thorny cargo]

you can use it again later on

[zinc oxide]

wdym

yh

[thin elbow]

Is it profitable?

[thorny cargo]

youre going to the island with the broken ship, right?

[thorny cargo]

stealing from the trapper? no

[zinc oxide]

no

[thorny cargo]

then where are you going?

[zinc oxide]

left of rhodes

that island

[thorny cargo]

yes, that is the island with the broken ship

and the tricorn hat

[zinc oxide]

ah

[thorny cargo]

you should be able to make it there with your horse

[zinc oxide]

hang on a dude with a canoe is on his way here

ima slime him

[zinc oxide]

its not the best horse

[thorny cargo]

oh

[fast warren]

I was going to the trapper (the one near emerald ranch) and I saw a girl in a wagon being taken by the murfee bloods or whatever and I followed her a bit then I saw a tree and it to old me I could inspect and it was the trail trees and as I was doing it a buck/deer ran into me- does that mean anything

[thorny cargo]

no, bucks will attack you anytime

[fast warren]

oh okayy

[empty patio]

It's worse when you're minding your business and then suddenly you're flying across the ground

[rough kelp]

one time i was collecting a perfect pronghorn pelt and a buck ran into me while i was skinning it then it went down to a poor pelt

i was so fucking mad

[ivory pumice]

Oh makes sense I thought since i skinned them it bypassed it

[obtuse zodiac]

U need it if ur doing 100% I mean there's no way ur travelling all the way to the edge of the map for a cigarette card lol

[zinc oxide]

if

But like for my first playthrough I really dislike it

After that I’ll use it

[rough kelp]

i love fast travel especially when ur grinding

[zinc oxide]

question

do I keep my total progress and challenges when starting a new run

[thorny cargo]

no

or wdym

you keep it for that run, but in your new one you have to start over

[zinc oxide]

nooooo

i just lost my will to live

god no please

ughh

is it possible to miss something and then not being able to do 100%

idk how the total completion % works

[thorny cargo]

no

there are no missables for 100%

but there are missables for platinum/all achievements

[zinc oxide]

ok good

the fact you lose everything once the run is finished hurts me

[thorny cargo]

well you dont lose it? you still keep your save

you just make a new one

[zinc oxide]

true

is your total prog lost once youre john

or how does that work

[thorny cargo]

no

you still have your progress once youre john because you need to be him to get 100%

since some stuff is in new austin

[zinc oxide]

ah

[ocean perch]

hi

[thorny cargo]

howdy

[zinc oxide]

hey partner

[dusky remnant]

howdy!

[zinc oxide]

how do yall study animals such as cougars and panthers

[thorny cargo]

from far away but its hard

get on a rock

they cant go on them

[zinc oxide]

alr

shit man I shouldve helped mary out shouldnt I

[sharp bison]

Wdym when your John? I’m on chapter 3

[thorny cargo]

its spoilers

youll find oiut later

[sharp bison]

How may chapters are there anyways

[thorny cargo]

6

[sharp bison]

Do you switch like in gow ragnarok between kratos and Atreus

[thorny cargo]

again, its spoilers. youll see

[obtuse zodiac]

nah its just a mod

[zinc oxide]

holy I got 0.5% progression just from watching a show

[slim wharf]

I finally caught the kid in st denis

The one who tries to rob you

[zinc oxide]

can you slime him

i hate these goddamn panthers

they just dont spawn for some reason

[slim wharf]

Unfortunately no

You can only tackle him which triggers a cutscene where Arthur threatens him and he gives his shit back and tells him where Bronte is

[zinc oxide]

smh

dawg genuinely why arent my panthers spawning

Im at that crossroad and he just isnt appearing

[thorny cargo]

are you going into the forest

part

[zinc oxide]

yk those rocks]

[thorny cargo]

you sometimes have to go further than that. into the forest. the spawn wont trigger if you arent close enough

and some of the spawns are closer and some are farther

[zinc oxide]

you mean placing the bait more in the forest?

uhh would it be a bad idea to clear out the part 4 camp bandits

Im near it and I wanna kill them

[thorny cargo]

baits only work if the animal is already spawned

theyre useless

[zinc oxide]

how do I get it to spawn without being killed tho 😭

[thorny cargo]

spawn it and then run onto the rock

[simple tangle]

i just spent like 3 hours just dying and losing money because suddenly every horse and wagon in the entire red dead universe wanna bump into me and knock me off my own horse

oh my god stupid shit like this ragebaits me so good sometimes

i went from like $1350 to $930

[hollow stirrup]

W game ♥️

[valid birch]

i can relate

badly

[warm galleon]

Still got lumbago

[hollow stirrup]

Yep

A slow and painful death

[warm galleon]

How do we know that you have lumbago…

You could lie

[valid birch]

fr

[hollow stirrup]

uhh

[valid birch]

getting out of barn work eh

[hollow stirrup]

Because…

[zinc oxide]

yh but like

[hollow stirrup]

uhm

[zinc oxide]

how do I spawn

[hollow stirrup]

I’m hurt

[warm galleon]

Skinners again?

[hollow stirrup]

Yeah

[valid birch]

we know for i fact u aint not got lumbago

[hollow stirrup]

They uhh

[hollow stirrup]

Shhh

HUSH!

[valid birch]

did they hang you in strawberry this time

[warm galleon]

gonna kill Micah with bling

Calloway and Otis Miller

[valid birch]

otis miller is a just a fancy schofield

but otis with my aim assist setting i miss nothing

its crazy

[warm galleon]

Made the Rip van Winkle outfit an hour ago

Had to get to tumbleweed

[hollow stirrup]

Yes

And they beat me 😔

[valid birch]

so its not the fire on your back this time

[hollow stirrup]

No its bruises

[thorny cargo]

run around in the forest and eventually youll see a red dot

[valid birch]

are we talking about leopard saddle?

[thorny cargo]

leopard saddle?

you mean panther?

theyre just trying to get the panther to spawn in general

iirc to study it

[valid birch]

i cant get it for the life of me

4 playthroughs and have never got it

[thorny cargo]

how

[valid birch]

i dont know

it just never spawns

ive tried litterally everything

[thorny cargo]

just walk around in the forest area southeast of old harry fen huh

no idea why it doesnt spawn for you

just bad luck

[valid birch]

i think its because i waste my luck on getting red and white arabian every time

[thorny cargo]

why would u go for the arabians 😭😭😭

[warm galleon]

I had a male white Arabian in my current playthrough as Arthur

[valid birch]

its cool

[thorny cargo]

i hate arabians

[warm galleon]

got it by feeding the braithwaite white Arabian

[valid birch]

same

i just like to flex it to my friends lowk

[thorny cargo]

hows it a flex

its one of the easiest horses to get

i guess for its stats

[valid birch]

idk atp

it just looks cool

its looked at me with a smile

so i kept getting it

[warm galleon]

What was y’all’s reaction to Hamish‘s death

[zinc oxide]

why tf do I net get a reward for the most disturbing killer in rdr2

ngl there are some pretty unsettling things in this game

[zinc oxide]

theyre fast

[thorny cargo]

there are other horses at the same speed, some even more (aside from the rose gray arabian)

[zinc oxide]

like?

[thorny cargo]

missouri fox trotters

[zinc oxide]

those r fast?

[thorny cargo]

yes...?

[zinc oxide]

am I mistaking smth or have I seen that horse like 1023 times

[zinc oxide]

well Im omw to get the white arabian, should I not bother

[thorny cargo]

actually

[tight turret]

the platinum is making controler's x suffer

[thorny cargo]

in terms of speed, the fox trotters are THE fastest

rose gray is the best for all stats in general

[thorny cargo]

well

as much as i dont like arabians, the white arabian is the easiest to attain early-game

[zinc oxide]

i dont like arabians aswell but I want the horse challenges done asap

[thorny cargo]

you could do the albert mason trick to get the silver dapple pinto mft but thats only if you have the patience for it

[zinc oxide]

oh no please dont tell me

I finished that quest tdy

[thorny cargo]

all of them?

[zinc oxide]

Im on the 5th one

rn

[thorny cargo]

then nvm

[zinc oxide]

yeah it was during the 4th one

or 3rd

i dont remember

[thorny cargo]

3rd

[zinc oxide]

well what should I go for now

[thorny cargo]

the arabian if youre just looking for a good horse fast ig

only some good horses are available early-game

[zinc oxide]

what chapter are the missouri fox trotters

[thorny cargo]

epilogue

unless you get the silver in alberts mission

or do the trick to get it from that one lady random encounter

[zinc oxide]

wdym?

[zinc oxide]

damn this sucks

[thorny cargo]

i dont know how to do it but ive heard of a way to get it from that lady you find limping away from her dead silver mft

what chapter are you in

theres two horses better than the white arabian you can get in the main chapters, but it depends on what chapter youre in

[zinc oxide]

2, 16% (😔)

[thorny cargo]

then you cant get either nvm

just get the arabian i guess

[zinc oxide]

ive seen it abt twice

[zinc oxide]

buell?

[thorny cargo]

no

buell's stats suck

[zinc oxide]

any good horses in ch3?

typo

[thorny cargo]

yes

the brindle thoroughbred

which is one of the ones i was gonna recommend

fastest horses in the game are fox trotters (epilogue), brindle thoroughbred (ch3), and reverse dappled nokota (ch4)

those are alternatives to arabians. i will never bond with an arabian

[zinc oxide]

ive been using the thoroughbred from valentine since like 5h playtime

whats the brindle thoroughbred

[zinc oxide]

how come you dislike arabians THIS much gng

[thorny cargo]

do you mean the american standardbred you can buy from the valentine stables?

[zinc oxide]

I think so

no its a thoroughbred

[thorny cargo]

rockstar made them look absolutely pathetic in the game. they arent like that irl

[zinc oxide]

I got rdr2 ultimate if that says anything

[thorny cargo]

oh

it does

you can get that horse to max speed

10 bars

the white arabian is worse than that horse bro

[zinc oxide]

how

[thorny cargo]

just get hooded stirrups and complete 2 random encounter races (although it might be a while until you get this random encounter)

[zinc oxide]

Ive maxed out everything except the panther pelt

[thorny cargo]

hooded stirrups bumps the speed up 2 points, and then by winning two races you get another point

7+3 = 10

[zinc oxide]

hooded stirrups?

[thorny cargo]

yes

buy them

[zinc oxide]

current stats are 7 spd 5 acc

[thorny cargo]

yes

thats the base stats

[zinc oxide]

i suppose theyre at the valentine stable

or any

?

[thorny cargo]

any

[zinc oxide]

are they chapter locked by any chance

[thorny cargo]

no

[zinc oxide]

I just saw a man get hanged in valentine and I feel bad for not stopping it

@thorny cargo I cant click on stirrups

is there something I have to do?

[thorny cargo]

what saddle are you using

[cedar quiver]

Hey I tried posting images of my Arthur in both media channels but they were removed instantly.

[zinc oxide]

crocodile one from trapper

[thorny cargo]

cant upload more than 4 images at a time

[thorny cargo]

cant put stirrups on that one

[zinc oxide]

does that go for all trappers?

[thorny cargo]

no

[cedar quiver]

Ah. Thanks

[zinc oxide]

which ones can use hooded stirrups

[cedar quiver]

Since the images are of Arthur which channel is more appropriate for it?

[thorny cargo]

#red-dead-media or #red-dead-fashion

[cedar quiver]

Thanks

[thorny cargo]

no idea, i just know a few have their own special stirrups

not the panther saddle though

[zinc oxide]

which ones do you use

[thorny cargo]

i use the panther saddle and hooded stirrups

cuz its the best combo in. the entire story-mode

[zinc oxide]

question

ik theres a hunter quest taht involves killing panthers

should I wait with bag of the east and panther saddle for then?

[thorny cargo]

master hunter 5 has you killing cougars. you kill the legendary panther in master hunter 10

so... no

because you dont get a panther pelt from either

[zinc oxide]

oh mb

[jade river]

There aren’t cougars in missions!

[thorny cargo]

wdym?

[jade river]

I’m referencing a meme mb

[thorny cargo]

oh 😭

[zinc oxide]

W rdr2 for crashing while Im on an annoying ass challenge mission!!

welp

NDakw

[obtuse zodiac]

Only the white one is cool because the colour shinies

I do also believe the ultimate edition horse has the same stats as the Arabian

It's also a lot bigger and taller

[zinc oxide]

what animals count as predators

[empty patio]

Bears, wolves, cougars, panthers, coyotes

[acoustic moss]

anyone know what mods cause the game to crash when in combat

[keen remnant]

Sh

[slim wharf]

A carnivore

Any animal that eats other animals is a predator

[zinc oxide]

so this includes foxes and shi

[slim wharf]

By real life standards yes but by rdr2 standards idk

[zinc oxide]

i will burn this earth to the ground if its only animals that attack you

[jade river]

I’d argue foxes aren’t predators

[slate wing]

there ominovores if i remember correctly

like they eat both berries and meat

[zinc oxide]

why the fuck does my gun auto reload

[empty patio]

Yes foxes are omnivores, their diet consists of berries as well

[jade river]

We eat berries and mushrooms, you fool!

[jade river]

Cus

[zinc oxide]

how do I stop my gun from auto reloading cus Ive messed up sharpshooter 5 a dozen times now

[thorny cargo]

dont use deadeye

[slate wing]

dont use deadeye

[slim wharf]

Why not?

[thorny cargo]

foxes are predators

opportunistic omnivores

[jade river]

I mean they’re kinda just opportunistic hunters I feel like

[jade river]

Was literally typing the same thing

[thorny cargo]

still makes em predators tho, considering therye hunters

[jade river]

Are we calling dogs predators now?

[thorny cargo]

dogs are instinctually predators, yes.

theyve been trained to control that side of them

[jade river]

Like you can definitely argue dogs and cats are

[empty patio]

To be fair anything that eats meat as a source of their main diet whether they also eat berries or not are considered predators

Size doesn't matter

[thorny cargo]

unless theyre a scavenger

[empty patio]

Yes

Then those are considered necrovores

Like vultures

[slate wing]

weird question but what would rats be labeled as

[thorny cargo]

foxes will scavenge but they do still hunt, making them predators

[empty patio]

Mhm

[thorny cargo]

rats are omnivores

[slate wing]

ohhh ok

[zinc oxide]

you are the goat tysm

[empty patio]

Yeah rats are also known to be cannibalistic as well

[slate wing]

didint know that part lol

[thorny cargo]

ya

brutal

talking about rats is making me think about rat kings

[slate wing]

oh those things lmao

[slate wing]

the only rat king i respect is master splinter the literal king of rats

[slim wharf]

Yes but they hunt other animals so to those animals they’re predators

[slim wharf]

Domestic dogs eat dog food only for the most part so no but wild dogs absolutely yes

[jade river]

Yeah, but we don’t traditionally think of them as such

Autocorrect

[slate wing]

i hate auto correct

im listening to Evanescence

[empty patio]

BRINGGG MEEE TOO LIIFEE

[slate wing]

exactlly lol

[empty patio]

I LOVE going under

The music video was so weird

[slate wing]

im litterly listening to that rn lmao

i also like linkin park three days grace slipknot i grow up with linkin park basiclly cause of transformers one and two lol

[empty patio]

Omg Linkin Park mentioned

[slate wing]

one of my favourites is papercut

[empty patio]

In The End, Numb and Burn It Down are my favorites

[slate wing]

i love in the end

[empty patio]

Oh and Catalyst

[slate wing]

i dont think ive hear of catalyst yet is it from the new signer

singer

[empty patio]

Nope! The main singer made it not the new one

[slate wing]

ohhh ok

[thorny cargo]

you guys might want to take this to general or dms if it continues

[slate wing]

yeah true

[empty patio]

OH HELP I thought this was General LOL

[slate wing]

lol

[slim wharf]

Based baseder and basedest

[steep tendon]

a

[zinc oxide]

@thorny cargo sorry for the ping but I remember selling cigarette cards, does this mean I cant get 100%? Ik you said there arent any missables but Im unsure

[obtuse zodiac]

What mods do u even have

[thorny cargo]

why does that make you worry that you cant get 100%

[acoustic moss]

a whole lot

[obtuse zodiac]

Do u use any mods for guns, combat or shooting or anything

[acoustic moss]

yes

[obtuse zodiac]

Like which ones

[thorny cargo]

even if you sold all the cigarette cards in the game you can still get them back by buying cigarettes

just loads of packs

so no, not missable

[acoustic moss]

all the ones in the immersive modpack reimagined

[zinc oxide]

Bc I want to get 100%

[zinc oxide]

Ah

Ima js get lung cancer

[midnight ocean]

lol

its actually faster to discard the cigarettes anyway

[obtuse zodiac]

So like what's the issue your dealing with?

[acoustic moss]

i start shooting and my game freezes completely, it might be when i go into deadeye i cant tell

[zinc oxide]

I agree but its less fun

[haughty bramble]

Hi

[lapis sable]

Cigarette cards are the best thing in this game. Every time i wanna collect them and not pay in a general store or find them in the wild, I go to a train or a general store and murder folks for it

It's so fun to cause chaos all for those cigarette cards

[copper folio]

ayo anyone know if its possible to get the legendary pronghorn coat as arthur?

tried going to new austin during the bronte mission just to find the thing didnt spawn and the buggy exploit is nigh impossible

[dusk comet]

hellooo

is the word mod banned

huh

spoilers

why is the spoiler tag banned

thats weird

epilouge spoilers no tag i guess but i wanted to mod rdr2 (this is my first playthrough) since it bothered me so bad john barely looks like john playing as him but im worried it might mess up cutscenes or any other animations

what do yall think?

[tall radish]

yea the NPC model seems different from the player model

[empty patio]

[dusk comet]

i mean, is it worth modding it?

i havent seen one showcase of any of these mods with a cutscene playing

that worries me

[marsh flint]

I should play more rdr2

110ish hours and I still want MORE

[severe tangle]

I hit 2,300 before I started playing something else. lol

[final grove]

Dang it the random encounter race rich guy bumped into me in the second race
Now he said he won't race me ever again
Won't he? Or will the encounter trigger again?

[pallid kayak]

What your guys horses?

[old pike]

War horse idk

[pallid kayak]

No name?

[old pike]

Idk i got in mission

[pallid kayak]

Which one

[old pike]

White one

[pallid kayak]

Good

[old pike]

In veteran guy

[pallid kayak]

Good

[old pike]

Yeah

You?

[mental jungle]

Oh buel

[thorny cargo]

buell

[tawny yew]

Buell the buddy

[hidden tartan]

I sometimes forget how intense rdr2 gets now replaying it

Like Caribbean wars!

👀

I mean kinda badass ngl

Didn’t know I would be shooting cannons again and fighting literal soldiers

[sharp bison]

Can someone help me out? I’m in chapter 3 and I dont want to rush the story but I don’t really know what else to do

[ember ridge]

Have you got your legend of the east satchel

Or was it west

Whatever the satchel is with 99 spaces for items

[sharp bison]

I don’t have any extra satchels

[ember ridge]

Talk to Pearson

You need to buy him leather working tools at the ledger though

[sharp bison]

I did but it won’t let me make anything

[potent loom]

Good too

[warm galleon]

on my 5th playthrough now

It’s getting cold again

[pulsar ruin]

You guys think Arthur ever found the people who did in Eliza and Isaac?

[umbral condor]

just killed ross

[pulsar ruin]

I understand, I couldn't finish any of his Mario Maker levels either

[valid meteor]

I shot thomas downes and the mission wasnt cancelled💔

[zinc oxide]

Yall remember that creep somewhere in Lemoyne that knocks you out

And does weird things to Arthur

I burnt him alive in his home and I feel great

[valid meteor]

W

[warm galleon]

real W

[sharp bison]

which combo of revolvers should i go for

[midnight ocean]

you mean like you wanna dual wield two different revolvers?

[sharp bison]

yeah im in chapter 3 rn and micah gave me the extra holster some time back

[midnight ocean]

i like to go with two of the same

but if you want two totally different ones you could go schofield and double action

[sharp bison]

which two

same ones

[midnight ocean]

you need pelts, it should show what you need when you hover over each satchel

schofields is my pick

you can buy them in rhodes

you can also get a free one in valentine by doing the secret doctors office robbery

[sharp bison]

how do i get him to open the door

[midnight ocean]

aim your gun at him

there should be an option for it

if not then i guess you didnt get the tip somehow

i think you can knock on the back door to trigger it

[ancient pagoda]

When where you able to get the satchel with 99 space?

[midnight ocean]

you can get this as early as chapter 2

[ancient pagoda]

What I didn’t even know it existed until late epilogue

[midnight ocean]

when you buy the leather working tools in camp it gives pearson a satchel crafting menu

you just need to bring him the pelts for each satchel

[ancient pagoda]

Huh ok 👍

[snow ferry]

bro I've wasted so much time trying to find blackberries for the pick and eat 4 different berries challenge

But I finally found them 😁

[midnight ocean]

excellent

just wait til you get herbalist 9 tho

[snow ferry]

can't wait 💀

[midnight ocean]

if you're actually trying to do em all, start collecting all the different meat types now

so youll be ready

[snow ferry]

gotcha, I'm following the 100% completion guide from gtaforums, eventually I'd like to aim for the platinum trophy tho

[midnight ocean]

good stuff, i used that same guide

[snow ferry]

I've been trying to study and skin as many animals as possible as I go

the guide definitely saves me a lot of headache

[midnight ocean]

yeah that guide saves you a lot of trouble by having stuff overlap and get done ahead of time

[zinc oxide]

should I wait until i play john for horseman 9? i gotta ride to blackwater without touching water

[river goblet]

Guys! I need help with finding a perfect horse for Arthur. Im looking for large horse (not like shire or ardeens just like thoroughbred or dutch). Any ideas?

[zinc oxide]

there arent that many large horses in rdr2 I think

[midnight ocean]

whats wrong with thoroughbreds and dutch warmbloods

[river goblet]

In red dead wiki thoroughbred are marked large

[empty patio]

They're more tall than large

[river goblet]

They arent barve

[zinc oxide]

they arent that big

[midnight ocean]

no such thing as horse bravery

[river goblet]

They are big

[zinc oxide]

yall is there an effective way to upgrade deadeye

[zinc oxide]

i have one, it seems like the avg horse

[midnight ocean]

wdym upgrade

[river goblet]

Shooting headshoots

[zinc oxide]

like seeing vital spots n stuff

ion have that for some reasobn

[midnight ocean]

you just need to progress the story

[zinc oxide]

ight

[river goblet]

Yea

In chapter 4 robbing a train station you ll get penultimate upgarde

Or last

I dont remember good

[midnight ocean]

last upgrade is in chapter 6

[river goblet]

K

[zinc oxide]

why is this damn panther not spawning

in every video Ive watched he spawns when the predator bait near

[midnight ocean]

i dont think bait spawns animals

i think they need to already be in the area

[zinc oxide]

is yt lying to me

[midnight ocean]

best way to get one to spawn is go to that area, save your game and load the save

this refreshes animal spawns

unless you just killed one in the area then you might need to wait a day

[zinc oxide]

he isnt spawning either way

I saw him once and then he never came back

[midnight ocean]

where are you

[zinc oxide]

yk that crossing near rhodes I think

[midnight ocean]

told ya lol

[zinc oxide]

so I got away

placed bait at the optimal spot

now he isnt appearing

[midnight ocean]

dont bother with bait

[thorny cargo]

bait doesnt work if its not spawned

i told u

[zinc oxide]

read what I said

it literally spawned and I placed bait just a couple m away

now hes gone

[thorny cargo]

if you ran away its possible he despawned

[zinc oxide]

they can despawn like that?

[thorny cargo]

yes

[zinc oxide]

ts generationally useless

[thorny cargo]

animals can despawn veerryy easily

[zinc oxide]

then whats the point of bait

[thorny cargo]

useless

ive only ever actually used bait for the challenge

[midnight ocean]

you need it for that one challenge but otherwise i never used it

[thorny cargo]

yeah

[zinc oxide]

i can hear it

[midnight ocean]

get on your horse and equip your rifle

safest way to deal with predators

[zinc oxide]

my deadeye always marks something that isnt his head

and I wanna study it

[midnight ocean]

what chapter are you in

[zinc oxide]

2

[midnight ocean]

2?

ohh

yeah you might want to progress to the end of the chapter before doing a lot of hunting

so you can get the manual targeting

[zinc oxide]

i can hear it

[zinc oxide]

its the only pelt I need for satchel of the east

[midnight ocean]

keep trying then i guess

[zinc oxide]

hes here

but I cant study him

[midnight ocean]

if he doesnt see you yet use binoculars

[zinc oxide]

hes staring at me with murderous intent

uhh should I reload the save to study?

or do I js slime him

[thorny cargo]

you cant study him?

[zinc oxide]

as soon as I did he ran away and despawned

dudeee this is so annoying

[thorny cargo]

if you kill it youll have to wait a few ingame days or smt so i suggest saving since you studied it and then reloading until u get a 3 star

[zinc oxide]

he was 3 star 😭

[thorny cargo]

youll find another 3 star, dont worry, its pretty common

[zinc oxide]

for some reason when I load a save I dont spawn in the forest

anymore

shi he killed me

as soon as I found him

[thorny cargo]

are you using a bow?

[zinc oxide]

yup

[thorny cargo]

thats good

without manual tagging its kinda hard

[zinc oxide]

so reliable

[zinc oxide]

?

[thorny cargo]

with where youre in in the story, you have automatic tagging

meaning when you deadeye it selects where you tag for you

[zinc oxide]

YO

he jumped onto the rock I was on

[thorny cargo]

was it a big enough rock

[zinc oxide]

yes

[thorny cargo]

bad luck then

[zinc oxide]

this game cant be serious

time to load a save I suppose

[midnight ocean]

studying predators is already kinda hard with a controller

must really suck on kbm

[zinc oxide]

oh my god I finally got his ahh

[violet nova]

Can I get help

my game is loading going past the scenic loading screen and then ‘not responding’

[zinc oxide]

wait I dont even have to study

[zinc oxide]

close and reopen I suppose

[violet nova]

I already

[zinc oxide]

I skinned it and it was added to my compendium

[zinc oxide]

restart ur device then

[violet nova]

Did that too

[zinc oxide]

then idk man

[midnight ocean]

well there's your problem

[zinc oxide]

where do I find shotgun recipes?

alright arthur just slepts for 36 hours

when is bro gonna respawn

[thorny cargo]

incendiary is at copperhead landing, explosive is at the exploding moonshine shack (in new austin. u cant get it yet)

slug and regular ammo gotta be purchased, cant be crafted

[zinc oxide]

thx

uh how do I get a panther off me

I spam e and nothing happens

[midnight ocean]

you dont

thats why i told you to stay on your horse

[zinc oxide]

got a 2nd one

thats all I need right?

[midnight ocean]

2nd what

panther pelt?

well you need one for the satchel and one for the saddle but the trapper can use two more for outfits

and if you're trying to do skin deep or zoologist then you might want to get both types of panther, regular and floridian

[zinc oxide]

ye

[zinc oxide]

all of this needed for 100% isnt it

[midnight ocean]

none of it is

[zinc oxide]

what do I exactly need for 100%

[midnight ocean]

check progress tab in game

progress > total completion

or check out the most recent pin in here, everything needed is listed in that link near the top

[zinc oxide]

alr

are stirrups chapter locked cus Ive equipped the panther saddle and I still cant buy any

[midnight ocean]

i think you can only get them for purchased saddles not crafted ones

but the effect is built in to the crafted saddles anyway

[zinc oxide]

crow said that they use panther and some sort of special stirrup

[zinc oxide]

are the stirrup bars yellow?

[midnight ocean]

thats weird bc im looking at a screenshot of someone at the stables with the panther saddle and the stirrups option is grayed out

[midnight ocean]

oh okay apparently you can put on a normal saddle, equip the stirrups, then switch to the panther saddle and keep the stirrups

[zinc oxide]

oh alr

[zinc oxide]

are they cus the stirrup disappeared

[midnight ocean]

yellow is whatever boost is given by the equipment

[zinc oxide]

ok good I have that

my horse has 9 speed and a gray bar with 7 acceleration

[zinc oxide]

@midnight ocean sry for the ping but yk how if you save an npcs life from a snakebite you get a free item

i could wait until I unlock the carcano rifle, should I do that?

[midnight ocean]

i'm actually not sure if you can save it like that

[zinc oxide]

oh alr

but when do I unlock the carcano

[midnight ocean]

chapter 6 i think

but rolling block is basically the same anyway

[zinc oxide]

do you reckon I should run double schofield

[midnight ocean]

yes

[zinc oxide]

schofield revolver so tuff

[midnight ocean]

theyre my fav

and you can use em to get the challenge for kills will long barreled revolvers without having to modify them

since they are long barreled by default

[zinc oxide]

money isnt an issue

man I found a cougar but dont have the hunter quest yet

also when do I get the rolling block

Im on springfield rn

[oblique quiver]

schofield or cattleman

[midnight ocean]

dawg

just look it up lol

[zinc oxide]

cattleman

[zinc oxide]

answers here are more direct and more info

[midnight ocean]

you know why they're more direct

because half the time we're googling the answer for you

[obtuse zodiac]

Watch him die

[midnight ocean]

if you go on the wiki page for any gun in the game it will say "you can get this gun during this misson or purchase it during this chapter"

doesnt get much more direct than that

[obtuse zodiac]

Everything in the game is low-key cheap

[oblique quiver]

cattleman has better fire rate but schofield has better range and accuracy

[zinc oxide]

dont you see Im letting you grind

[midnight ocean]

save your questions in here for stuff thats more complex or hard to find the answer to lol

[obtuse zodiac]

There's a vid for everything on YouTube

[zinc oxide]

how do I play as arthur morgan

[zinc oxide]

youtube is my best fried

[midnight ocean]

i mean i kinda hate videos because you gotta sit through the whole thing

but so much info is available on the wiki

[random imp]

Hello can i ask questions here? I just started playing and still on chapter 2, my question is for the rock carvings, do you need the do it one by one and send mail or you can check them all before sending the mail?

[midnight ocean]

you can mail them whenever

[random imp]

ohh cool thank you partner

[zinc oxide]

does this question pass: I found a house near van horn and and annesburg and theres a green light in it

can I get in somehow

its completely nailed shut

[midnight ocean]

think its related to an easter egg

[zinc oxide]

wdym?

[midnight ocean]

i think its related to an easter egg

i havent done it

[zinc oxide]

alr

lowk theres barely any point to legend of the east fit

cus by the time you can properly finish it youre in the epilogue

[midnight ocean]

yeah its just for the flex

but i mean they gotta have some kind of cool reward for beating every challenge

[zinc oxide]

yo I found cave paintings

DAWG i dont have the quest

[midnight ocean]

wut

[zinc oxide]

I thought cave paintings was a quest

[midnight ocean]

i think thats the dreamcatcher one

[empty patio]

Yeah the dream catchers has cave painting for the last part of the quest

[empty patio]

Is it inside Elysian cave?

[zinc oxide]

yea

[empty patio]

Yeah that's part of Dreamcatcher quest

[midnight ocean]

i dont think anyone gives you that i think you just go out and start finding em

[zinc oxide]

how bears feel after making the loudest noise throughout the entire forest just to never ever be seen

[empty patio]

Yeah it's just a random side quest you can start on your own, only reason it's a quest is because you get a small prize at the end

[midnight ocean]

if you want a grizzly i would just go to that spot northwest of wallace station

[thorny cargo]

that spawn is so guaranteed its crazy

[midnight ocean]

ive seldom seen them anywhere else

one time near the owanjila trapper

[zinc oxide]

alr

also ive maxed out everything from my guns but it says theres still something that could be better

[zinc oxide]

wdym tho

[thorny cargo]

northwest of wallace station

[zinc oxide]

how far

[thorny cargo]

just that path thats going into the woods

a bear usually spawns along the side or nearby

[zinc oxide]

holy since when were bears this scary

[cedar quiver]

I just found two dead sheep near emerald ranch

[zinc oxide]

So?

[cedar quiver]

Is this linked to a side quest?

[zinc oxide]

prob noit

cooking all the meat I have now that I got the east satchel is pain

[thorny cargo]

its an easter egg

[zinc oxide]

dumb question but where is copperhead landing? i cant find ir

[thorny cargo]

along the shore south of van horn. not van horn mansion, its past that

[zinc oxide]

found it, thanks

[thorny cargo]

yw

[zinc oxide]

i find it very unpleasing that arthur cant sit in the train properly

nvm

[pulsar ruin]

What if Micheal De Santas and Arthur met

[zinc oxide]

hell yeah my horse has 10 speed

genuinely fed arthur 15 big games and hes still underweight

@thorny cargo i came across the woman with the dead horse what do I do now

you said something about getting the fox trotter early

[thorny cargo]

no idea, like i said i dont know how to do it

most likely its been patched, since i believe its older

[zinc oxide]

oh alr

[lapis sable]

In my older pc, the train usually despawns after it's been robbed :/

With all dead peds falling to the tracks

[ivory pumice]

Any mods that let you skin people?

[acoustic moss]

game freezing when in a gun fight sometimes in deadeye sometimes just randomly, music still plays though

[zinc oxide]

oh shit Im gonna have to learn how to play poker

[lapis sable]

we used to be able to skin horses and dogs

in RDR1

[zinc oxide]

alright my compendium says Ive obtained every cigarette card

in the quest it says I didnt send the dude the cards

when I did

now Im gonna have to slave away for those cards again

[lapis sable]

Just go to the post and mail them

Also, you can do it all over again and he'll keep sending you stuff. My inspiration to go rob stores and trains for premium cigs

[zinc oxide]

yes I know I did

and it didnt count

[lapis sable]

Wait a few ingame days

[zinc oxide]

god this is so fucking annoying

[zinc oxide]

no like I mailed him all cards at once

and it didnt register 2 sets

[zinc oxide]

atleast my money isnt being wasted rn

[lapis sable]

Have faith.

[zinc oxide]

I am going to slaughter somebody

went from 5k to 4k real quick

and still dont have those 2 sets

[lapis sable]

Please slaughter a train

[zinc oxide]

Irl

[lapis sable]

Uhhh no. In game yes

[zinc oxide]

Also!! The missing cards are the ones Im getting least of

Love this game sm

[zinc oxide]

every time I use quick travel I feel guilty for not experiencing the ride itself

[lapis sable]

i don't really use quick travel since in low honor playthoughs, i don't hesitate to shoot folk in the head

[simple tangle]

[late pecan]

I’m streaming rdr2 and trying to 100% the game if anyone's interested

[zinc oxide]

How much prog you got

[zinc oxide]

yall Im in a theater rn

would it be a shame if I threw 8 molotovs everywhere

[crude basalt]

security be like : You are a DEAD MAN !! I will send you straight down to HELL!!😂

[zinc oxide]

boi...

[zinc oxide]

yo sry for the ping but wdym by this

please speed I need this

[flint flint]

i swear the blackjack dealer at Rhodes is cheating ! 😤

[flint flint]

makes me wonder if there's a prostitution mod lol

[crude basalt]

bruh

[zinc oxide]

do cigarette cards respawn after a time? youtubes not helping

[viscid plover]

👍🏻

[zinc oxide]

thanks Biney

[viscid plover]

Of course pal

[zinc oxide]

about how long does it take? cus I collected them a while ago and they still havent appeared

[viscid plover]

Try saving the game or fast travel or sleep

[zinc oxide]

oki dokes

[zinc oxide]

reloading didnt help

[viscid plover]

I guees

[late pecan]

Just started

Chapter 2 rn

Gonna get the dream catchers, bones and rock carvings

[lapis sable]

Low honor gameplay being a terrorist

[zinc oxide]

real

Ive been in chapter two

16% story

95 hours on the game

for about 46% completion

[flint flint]

i'ts a 18+ game isn't it ? 👀

can i abuse Save / Reload to make enemies / whatever respawn etc ?

what if I wanna like do clean robbery will this work ?

Like actually able to get away without being caught for who I'm doing the robbery

[crude basalt]

yupp

[zinc oxide]

my horse died and I killed about 80 lawmen

and then I loaded my save

[flint flint]

and as if nothing happened then ?

[zinc oxide]

had to, I used everything I had and it got boring

[obtuse zodiac]

Ye

[zinc oxide]

endless killing

[obtuse zodiac]

Arthur not the type to do that even John

[flint flint]

damn i assume this game has like a permanent auto save of every actions

i forgot but i think it's the same with GTA V? But in GTA V it's really no big deal

not as if you hvae like bounty, honor or even matters if your car blow up

[obtuse zodiac]

U can rob trains and stores without bounty I mean I think that's pretty good

[flint flint]

im no expert but I thought it's actually a quite respected profession back then 🤔

[obtuse zodiac]

No lol

[flint flint]

they rob kill but that is crossing the line 😅

weird times.. 😗

[obtuse zodiac]

I thought u meant prostitution

[flint flint]

but i just completed an interesting side quest it seems Arthur is really disgusted bout slavery i think or something, it's one of the stranger in Rhodes but I don't really understand the mission's context

i assume the person sold slaves or something

[flint flint]

yes i was, but i don't mean by arthur doing it but rather receiving the service

[obtuse zodiac]

No

That was never a good profession

[zinc oxide]

my horse is so fucking annoying

as soon as the situation is desperate she just bucks me off

and dies

[flint flint]

mine runs in circle

[zinc oxide]

i have a moral issue

yk catfish jackson?

[flint flint]

no

[zinc oxide]

ah

[ember ridge]

Yes

[zinc oxide]

man do cigarette cards deadass not respawn cus Im losing hella cash rn

i got a set twice before my final one please

[vale osprey]

Yes, cigarette cards do not respond once picked up.

[zinc oxide]

i have a full on gambling addiction

[vale osprey]

You can get them through purchasing Premium Cigarettes from General Stores

[zinc oxide]

im aware

but getting 1 is near impossible

[vale osprey]

Nah just need have money, time, and patience. Thats how I collected all the cigarette cards, never picked up one when I 100% the game.

[zinc oxide]

im doing this a 2nd and 3rd time for some reason

[viral socket]

It's my birthday.

[marsh shore]

yo guys how many horse race is in the game?

you when theres npcs that want race and then when you win you get a passive

[modern bobcat]

I want to gain in real life, but do I have to greet 3 people to get or one is enough?

[unborn imp]

Hi guys, I'm 40% into the game and i wanted to ask if I should add visual/graphic mods to the game (I have a RTX 5050 laptop)

[sharp bison]

is there any other way to get rid of bounties except paying for them

[marsh shore]

3

[modern bobcat]

I wonder why is that

[marsh shore]

or else it would be too easy to get max honor

[modern bobcat]

Okay, and how can I know my honor level?

[midnight ocean]

took me like ten minutes to complete every set after i had like half the cards lol

don't smoke the cigarettes to get rid of them, discarding is faster

[marsh shore]

press alt

[modern bobcat]

But there's no alt in real life

[marsh shore]

then wait for the last mission you might be in heaven

[modern bobcat]

But what if I didn't have enough honor? I can't risk it, I want to make sure I have enough honor to play the last mission

[zinc oxide]

Ik but my luck is abhorrent

[fair sentinel]

are there actually behavioral difference between horse breeds? the wiki doesn't seem to have any infos on this, but I've seen posts claiming that arabians are better at detecting snakes or a yt short claiming appaloosas are fearless

[tidal slate]

@midnight ocean damn man you got a Sherrif Star?

[midnight ocean]

i dont think there are

[midnight ocean]

lol just the helper star

kinda like sheriff jr

[tidal slate]

Jezz i was scared see that glowing Name

[fair sentinel]

yeah, maybe it's just ai slop/content farm

[midnight ocean]

well it is a hotly debated topic within the community

a lot of people genuinely believe in horse bravery

ive seen a few different explanations for it

[fair sentinel]

maybe I'll grab an appaloosa in ride into an aligators jaw, but I doubt that is actually a feature 🤔

[midnight ocean]

lol

well ive seen videos of people riding an arabian right up to a grizzly and a cougar without getting thrown

[fair sentinel]

yeah, that doesn't seem right

[midnight ocean]

its like rockstar wanted to confuse us on purpose

if you go to the descriptions for some horses itll say like "doesnt spook easily from gunfire" and stuff like that

which makes you think oh bravery is a thing

but then some other descriptions will say "good for farmwork"

like wtf does that mean in the context of gameplay? nothing

which makes me think we can just disregard what those descriptions say about each breed

[fair sentinel]

I mean, that is lore at least xD and you could extrapolate like.. better stamina from it.

I just completed my second play-through and feel kinda bummed that it's over

[grizzled haven]

the description matches of what horses were used in the irl 1800s not like gameplay.

Usually the horse has higher stamina and health rather than speed

[fair sentinel]

also managed to kill my first horse with a train as is tradition

i still don't get if horses in the same breed can just have different stats like better speed or stamina. or is it all set?

[midnight ocean]

yeah but some people get confused and think theyre describing gameplay

which i dont really blame them for

[grizzled haven]

mm yeah understandable

[midnight ocean]

in a game where theres horses and gunfire and horses can get spooked by gunfire its a strange choice to write text that says some horses scare more easily than others just for flavor lol

[fair sentinel]

some things seem to agitate horses like predators and riding fast for a long time, but it doesn't really do anything other than throw you off or cause horsie to run

[midnight ocean]

i mean horses do experience agitation

the thing people get wrong is thinking different horses experience agitation differently

it all depends on bond level and what their state of agitation was prior to the encounter

other than that its all external factors

[fair sentinel]

that's probably it

[trim hamlet]

now I would understand if people were like "Oh my Arabian is so skittish while my (other horse breed) is brave!" if they had done the same stuff to bond with the Arabian as they did with their other breed (since Arabians take longer to bond)

but even then, it's not cause it's an Arabian, it's cause you didn't get it to the same bonding level

[midnight ocean]

do they actually take longer to bond

it seems people tend to report this stuff based completely on vibes

[trim hamlet]

well

i looked in the horse tab in pause menu

and it said like 218 (or whatever)/500

and i was level 1

so i assume it takes 500 points to get to level 2

that was for an arabian

i checked with uhh
i think it was an ardennes

and it was x/250 when i was level 1

[thorny cargo]

yes, horses with better stats take more xp to bond with

it's in the official guide

[snow smelt]

I've redownloaded rdr2 again cause i miss everything

[heady sluice]

should i buy rdr2 ive watched a few videos abt it but im not so sure

[flint flint]

if i kill random NPC like say a ranch i come across, will they respawn or they be lost forever ?

[snow smelt]

I'd say buy it

it's really fun

[heady sluice]

ok ill buy it soon

[snow smelt]

Buy it for me as well

[heady sluice]

i only have enough for one game

[snow smelt]

Tuff

[worldly saffron]

Is getting wanted during a mission normal?

[thorny cargo]

its supposed to happen in some missions

[flint flint]

lol i stacked up over 400 + $ bounty during the prison break at Strawberry

that mission bankrupt me....what do you want me to do just dodge through all the lawmen ?

[midnight ocean]

i think you get like $300 no matter what

[worldly saffron]

Is nothing supposed to happen from the drunk mission?

I got no charges somehow

[midnight ocean]

i think you can get arrested during it but idk if it has an effect on anything besides not getting the gold medal

[boreal vale]

And who doesn't want the gold medal?

Gold Rush here we come

[tame storm]

hii

im at 99.1%

i need 1 fish for the challenge 10

but idk which one is it, i did all the legendary ones

is there any way to know which one is it?

fish compendium is completed so it doesnt help at all xd

[midnight ocean]

nope!

[thorny cargo]

thats why u mark off which fish u get when u getthem lol, only solution is going through a list and catching them all again until u get the one u missed

[long goblet]

I used the mask and even dodged the lawmen but still got the bounty anyway

[obtuse zodiac]

Once lawmen see u it's over

Also in missions you gonna get bounty regardless

[long goblet]

Yupp they saw me right away when the mission started...ig it was supposed to happen

[obtuse zodiac]

Even if u put on a mask

[long goblet]

Yes you're right

[obtuse zodiac]

And u commit a crime and the law see ur face then yeah u get bounty

Masks work if u have no bounty and u do a crime without he spotted by the law

[long goblet]

Ohhh

[jade river]

If I turn up the sharpness too much everything starts to look all shimmery n shit lol

[obtuse zodiac]

But if civilians see u in masks that's fine they won't recognize, commit a crime with mask, then quickly run away and take ur mask off to be less suspicious

Just make sure the law doesn't see u

[jade river]

I didn’t even notice at first cus I usually use that same amount of sharpening and it works fine normally

[obtuse zodiac]

With or without mask

[long goblet]

Thanks for that...I was interpreting it wrong all along thinking mask won't get me a bounty

[obtuse zodiac]

Yeah np

[midnight ocean]

also youll automatically get a bounty on trains i think

idk if law has to see you

[jade river]

4K makes the volumetric lighting look so good ngl

[clever heart]

Is it normal to execute all the law men if they kill my horse?

[obtuse zodiac]

Gotta get away from the red circle before it's too late

Around lol 5-10 seconds I believe

[fair sentinel]

is there an event for getting arrested in strawberry while micah is in jail?

[rich stream]

hey, ive tried improved arrows, regular rifle rounds, express, i only get 2 star cougar pelts. suggestions?

[fair sentinel]

poison arrows in the head work

[rich stream]

damn, i dont have the poison arrow recipe quite yet